Download - The IMR Summit - ISA
The IMR Summit
February 19, 2018 11:00 AM to 3:00 PMFort Myers, Florida
Discussion Leaders
J. Michael Marks, Indian River Consulting GroupAbe Walton PhD., Ivory Bridge Consulting Group
Attention Participants
This deck contains materials that will take approximately 8 hours to properly cover and we only have three hours. Our intent is to tailor the material on the fly based on audience
feedback. You get the entire deck for future reference.
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
3Download This Deck At www.isapartners.org/educationFor Your Convenience
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
4Agenda
Morning Session 11:00 to 12:30• Crossing the chasm: birth to ownership exit
• Growth through adjacencies
• Workshop: Valuing the Ideal End Result
Lunch 12:30 to 1:30Afternoon Session 1:30 to 3:00• Strategic alternatives & intentional growth
• Process creation and achieving scale
• Workshop: Prioritizing Value Propositions
You may think that you are just a really talented sales
rep but your success is defined more by your
business model than your talent
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
5Peter Drucker
He passed away on November 11, 2005
I had the great fortune as having many classes and dinners with him at Claremont Graduate School and the book’s principles include:
1. Ensure your capacity for survival with enough strength to weather a blow
2. Ensure your ability to recognize needed change and adapt quickly
3. Ensure the boldness necessary to exploit emerging opportunities
His writings contributed to the philosophical and practical foundations of the modern business corporation. He was also a leader in the development of management education, he invented the
concept known as management by objectives and he has been described as "the founder of modern management"
http://smile.amazon.com/Managing-Turbulent-Times-Peter-Drucker-ebook/dp/B000FC12QE/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1424706401&sr=8-
1&keywords=managing+in+turbulent+times
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
6Sustained Competitive Advantage
Resource-based competitive advantage • Valuable• Rare• Inimitable• Non-Substitutable
• Culture wins over process - Southwest Airlines
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
7Idealized Final Result
How can you possibly know what you would do while under constraints, if you don’t know what you would do with out any constraints.
Start with WHY? or How Might We?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
8Getting Unstuck: Solving The Perfect ProblemThe only problems you have left are the perfect ones. The imperfect ones, the ones with a clearly evident solution, well, if they were important, you've solved them already.
It's the perfect problems that keep us stuck.
Perfect because they have constraints, unbendable constraints, constraints that keep us trapped.
There's no way to solve the perfect problem because every solution involves breaking an unbreakable constraint.
And there's your solution.
The way to solve the perfect problem is to make it imperfect. Don't just bend one of the constraints, eliminate it.
If the only alternative is slow and painful failure, the way to get unstuck is to blow up a constraint, deal with the pain and then run forward. Fast.
http://sethgodin.typepad.com/seths_blog/2010
/07/getting-unstuck-solving-the-perfect-
proble.html
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
9
Problem Finding = Different Models of Thinking
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
10Ideal Final Result - Exercise
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
11
Effective Rep Firms Keep Both Sides Honest Or At Least Equally Irritated
Your Multi-Sided Value PropositionDownstream- End Users &
DistributorsA rep-discovered sales opportunity creates significant pull through revenue for a distributorThe balance of direct and distributor lines creates linkage with other channel partners who bring opportunities to the rep’s firmThe rep firm provides the technical expertise so the distributor or end user doesn’t need to invest in it
Upstream- PrincipalsRep firms are good at 2 out of these 3 activities, so be clear and choose wisely based on the needs of your principals1. Getting products spec’ed with specifiers2. Managing projects3. Managing flow businessDemand creation or making markets for distributors to serveProviding principals with competitive insight and new market opportunities
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
12Network Effects (Apple’s I-Tunes)Every business model has two components, how to add value to a market and then how to extract valueMost businesses started with a virtuous circle, but when it breaks they plateau• It spools up just like a turbocharger when
it works• Sticky customers are both high margin
and happyThe key is knowing your tribe• Remember that your principals have high
switching costs and just deny it
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
13Crossing the ChasmBusiness models that don’t evolve will experience declining growth rates down to
core economic levels, excluding share shift
All of you started with a founder entrepreneur who was the lead sales manager, then you hired sales reps, and when absolutely necessary, finally hired some administrative support besides a spouse• To meet minimum W-2 or T-4 requirements you paid a high percentage of the
factory paid commissions to attract reps in the beginning• As you develop network effects the rep share declines while their income rises
Many firms get stuck here if you fail to change your comp plan as reps become over paid, complacent, and age out in annuity territories
• You evolve into a thirds model (1/3 each to compensation, overhead, and partner profits) while W-2’s grow rapidly at or above market
This is what funds the specialized marketing and operations functions thatdramatically increasing sales rep productivity by typically 4 to 8 times
Over 20 of the 21 Million US Firms Are Lifestyle Businesses
Potential Action Step
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
14Today’s Core B2B Challenges1. The accelerating trend away from relationship
buying to advantaged players & rabbits
2. The internet buffet of choice and transparent race to the bottom
3. The erosion of selling service as a differentiator in the market
4. Increasing customer sophistication
5. Aging of old school sales reps and a limited pipeline of replacements
6. Markets are aligning by size where larges buy from larges
Many firms simply ride it down harvesting what they can
The punch line is that the old model is not a best practice for the future.http://blogs.hbr.org/cs/2012/07/the_game_buyers_play_with_vend.html?utm_source=fe
edburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+harvardbusiness+%28HBR.org%29
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
15Death of a Rep FirmThe most probable end to a rep firm is when the managing principal ages out and sells the business on a leveraged buyout to a younger firm member, who will default on part of the note, while feeling really bad for a host of market-based reasons• By definition, most are lifestyle entrepreneurial businesses as there is no
shareholder value outside of the relationships with the firm’s senior sales executives
There is nothing wrong with this as long as you don’t drink your own Kool-Aid• If you are old enough to ride it out then the best strategy is to put “lipstick on the
pig” and ride it down taking out as much money as possibleThis is often a best practice and there is a freedom when giving up the illusion of
building something that exists beyond you (Issue: getting others to invest)Some firms go on to create real shareholder value beyond the first founders when instead of waiting for a crisis, they start investing now (the afternoon session)
History Doesn’t Repeat Itself, But It Usually Rhymes
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
16A Rep Firm Is Worth Four Times Adjusted EBITDA EBITDA is Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation, & Amortization (think free
cash flow)
The four multiple is the median value for small professional service firms and your EBITDA is calculated by:ƩN(Principal Revenue X Commission Rate) = Total Rep Firm Revenue
less (Total Salary and Commission Compensation paid to owners*, sales reps, and support staff)
less (Other operating expenses except interest and taxes)
Equals the firm’s ~EBITDA
This value times four is the typical price that a willing seller pays to a willing buyer• This almost always requires the senior executive to stick around for two years to transfer
relationship equity with a sizable variable hold back based on transition success
* Does not include profit withdrawals
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
17Aging Out Exit Strategies for Life Style BusinessesYour value declines if you are within two years of exiting, don’t wait too
longScale back to become a Lone Ranger hanging on in retirementThis is often a viable alternative for non US principals who are skimming this marketReduce the compensation levels of existing staff capturing more for the owner• Replace aging loyal high paid reps with lower paid replacements• Change incentives to pay higher for growth than market servingSell out to remaining staff using 4X adjusted EBITDA• There is often a discount for limited marketability of 0% to 25% to an internal purchaser• Offering an additional large discount for cash within 30 days is always good moveSell out to an adjacent firm or to a senior leader at a supplier• The adjacent firm needs to share your top suppliers or your same customers
M&A Within Your Supplier Base May Create Valuable Exit Opportunities
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
18Worksheet: Rep Firm Exit Values
Calculation Element Value
A. Total Rep Firm Revenues (sum of all supplier and fee income)B. Total Salary and Commission Compensation paid to owners (not profit withdrawals), sales reps, and support staffC. Less: Other operating expenses except interest and taxesD. Firm EBITDA = A – (B+C)E. Add back expenses that would not exist in an arms length business (e.g. fancy offices, cars, or jets)F. Deduct expenses, like high rents, that would not exist in an arms length businessG. Adjusted EBITDA = D + E - FH. Typical Market Value of Firm is G X 4
Add one additional multiple if your largest supplier has extended termination notices, and subtract one multiple if your key line was just acquired, each situation is unique
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
19Group Discussion
Get into groups by non-competing firms and discuss the questions below making sure that everyone expresses their own views. Feel free
to give the boss suck up behavior if necessary.Choose a group leader by determining who has the most children and grandchildren
The role of the group leader is to ensure that everyone weighs in with their own views and that the group stays on track and consider these statements and questions
1. Share experiences in the group around firms that are no longer here, for whatever reason, and discuss your views on how well they managed their exits
2. Based on question one, what are the lessons for you going forward?
3. Given the uniqueness of each of these stories, are there any hypothetical examples you would like to get the take on from Mike and Abe?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
20Agenda
Morning Session 11:00 to 12:30• Crossing the chasm: birth to ownership exit
• Growth through adjacencies
Lunch 12:30 to 1:30
Afternoon Session 1:30 to 3:00• Strategic alternatives & intentional growth
• Process creation and achieving scaleFrom Patrick Carrol
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/6-ways-evolve-modern-sales-pro-patrick-carroll/
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
21The Truth For Non Glamorous B2B Space
Professional management requires growth faster than GDP and a 20% return on invested capital
• Lifestyle businesses have much lower expectations
Cost advantages come from scale, specialization, and performance management processes
Price advantages come from scale with suppliers, mass customization, and leveraging competitive intensity
• Long tail switching costs are the most valuable
Competitive advantage is not real unless you gain a significant cost advantage over your competitors or a significant price premium from your customers, either resulting in higher profits. Operational
execution is an activity, not a strategy.
Marketing is a force multiplier for everything above
http://www.amazon.com/Understanding-Michael-Porter-Essential-
Competition/dp/1422160599/ref=sr_1_1?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1360612888&sr=1-
1&keywords=understanding+michael+porter
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
22Stanford Idealized Redesign Exercise
How can you possibly know what you would do while under constraints, if you don’t know what you would do with out any constraints.
Start with WHY? or How Might We?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
23Changing The Risk/Reward EquationStart by knowing what you are selling and who is buying it
• Risk management is purchased by the CFO or Chief Legal Counsel, not the facility manager, senior project engineer, fleet manager, or the purchasing manager
What you need to be selling is lower risk backed by something tangible (hard for a competitor to duplicate) like a bond or insurance
A core competency must meet three criteria:
1. It must be valued by the customer
2. It must be expensive or hard for a competitor to duplicate
3. It must be transferable to other products or markets
Leveraging core competencies leverage your ability for increasing switching costs
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
24
Relative difficulty of sales execution
Customer Segment
Existing New
Products, Services
Existing Hard Harder
New Harder Hardest
Growing Into AdjacenciesCustomer penetrationprovides• Additional revenue• Higher relevancy• Better coverage to
protect existing business and intercept opportunities for new business
Large firms are not agile so they get the best returns by focusing on large scale customers with high risk avoidance
Business Models and Strategy
Distributors
leverage relationships
Manufacturersleverage brand
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
25
Relative difficulty of sales execution
Customer SegmentExisting New
Products, ServicesExisting Hard Harder
New Harder Hardest
Growing Into Your Three AdjacenciesA. New supplier principals
Do you have a strategic perfect line card?
B. New customers in same geographyYou used to call this prospecting
C. New servicesLook at Lowes
https://www.lowesforpros.com/articles/lowes-business-replenishment-program_a1749.html
Cost To Grow and Potential To Grow Define Your Priorities
It is very hard for a rep firm to develop a new customer base
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
26
A. Getting The Right Principals To Represent
What Do Your Supplier Principals Want?Balanced network of channel partners, both rep firms and distributors• Too many small ones are hard to manage and too few large
ones creates a concentration riskAlignment• Visible and attractive to their target customer segments (how
well do you know their analytical profile?)• Firms strongly motivated to invest in and promote their product
line (this means young guys investing for the future)• Manageable line conflicts, shared vision and values (are your’s
published and linked to theirs)Performance• Strong sales and marketing capabilities• Financially sound and capitalized to support investment
Num
ber O
f Rep
Firm
s
Annual Percentage Growth Rate
Target %
Setting this expectation is clearly the responsibility of
the rep firm
http://www.mdm.com/analyticsPotential Action Step
Your sweet
spot
Manage Expectations
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
27Considerations In Creating The Ideal Line Card1. Build a list of category leaders in primary, secondary, and tertiary products used by your core sweet
spot customers
2. Google dive each to determine if they use rep firms or just announced a major layoff or restructuring (big bet to get them to outsource their sales force)
3. Go see which complimentary lines are carried by their reps in other markets, look for combinations of lines that go together
4. Rank each potential line by both the number of other lines they coexist with their category leadership position and the high, medium, or low alignment between their target customers and yours
5. Break the list into three columns; acquirer, acquiree, uncertain (probability of being around in 5 years)
6. Develop your selection criteria and weighting to rank the lists (there will be multiple lists based on combinations)
A. Getting The Right Principals To Represent
% of Sales Commission Rate % Commission $$$ % of Sales Effort
Primary Products 60% Lowest 47% 68%
Secondary Products 30% Intermediate 37% 30%
Tertiary Products 10% Highest 16% 2%
Blended Total 100% NA 100% 100%
Your business is stronger with a mix
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
28So Why Should a Principal Choose Your Firm?1. You have access to their target
customers because of your existing bundle and relationships, not your selling skills (ante to play)
2. Your complimentary lines make you important to their target customers
3. You demonstrate local market knowledge far in excess of any potential factory principal (with data, not stories)
4. You are a professionally managed firm5. You generate consistently above
average growth
https://mrerf.orgAnnual Dues $250/yrCPMR ~$2,200/3 yrs
A. Getting The Right Principals To Represent
Potential Action Step
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
29
1. Protection: Ensuring that they retain all of the flow business that is bought and not sold, avoiding CSEs
2. Interception: Capturing business when a competitor CSE occurs
3. Disruption: Investing sales effort to disrupt a working sourcing relationship, usually driven by a product or programs
3 Ways That Reps Create Demand With Their CustomersA good Critical Selling Event (CSE) happens to a customer and is created by a failure of their
incumbent supplier, or a supplier of that distributor, meaning it is an external event and outside the control of your sales rep
B. Getting New Customers
*Repurchases of identical product
The secret of share growth is to never experience a CSE yourself and intercept the CSEs of your competitors
Your ability to set traps that intercept CSE’s is a major factor in capturing new customers & suppliers
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
30Critical Selling EventsKey market-timed events are often the basis for winning and keeping contracts
Ask yourself:
How much of your marketing budget is spent on broad marketing efforts vs. identifying and capitalizing on specific market making events?
How much can you afford to pay for a market making event?
Do you know, or even really care, how many customers you have and how loyal they are?
Customer Retention and Repurchase RateRemember that the real goal is to increase shareholder value and the correlation to sales has gotten weakLoyalty and repurchase rate increase switching costs which always drive up profits
B. Getting New Customers
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
31Your Switching Cost ChallengeBid auctions are defined as perfect competition because all value accrues to the end user at the end of the value chain
• The dumbest or hungriest guy gets the business
• All bidders are fungible or interchangeable
We bank with Wells Fargo and we all hate them- but we won’t change
• The hassles (switching costs) are high and there is real uncertainty that we would end up any better, so we stay and they make high margin
You will not create any competitive advantage without changing your offering to increase customer switching costs
• Don’t expect anything to be driven from your sales function
• This is complex and time consuming for executives, it will require investment
• It will invariably require a business model change
B. Getting New Customers
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
32Green is
goodRed is
bad Potential to Grow Cost to Grow
$=10Millions, $$=100Millions, $$$=Billions, $$$$=10Billions
Market Size
Grow
th Rate
Selling Cycle
Ability to Expand M
arket
Current Share of
Custom
er Wallet
Level of Trust
Our Know
ledge of C
ustomers
Sales Force Fit (H
R investm
ent)
Mar-C
omm
Fit
Product Offering
Fit
Operational Fit
(CapX
required)
Com
petitive Intensity
Price Sensitivity
Switching C
ost
Segment 1 $$$$ H 1 – 2 yr H L L L L L M H M L H
Segment 2 $$$ H 6 – 18 mo
H L L L M M H M L L H
Segment 3 $$$$ M < 6 mo L L M H H H M H H H L
Segment 4 $$$$ L < 6 mo L H H H L H H L H H L
Customer Segment Attractiveness Example
Key conclusions:Segment 1 offers highest overall growth potential and a compelling opportunity for “imperfect
competition”: high barriers to entry and high switching cost. But accessing the market will take time, money and focus
Segment 2 offers lower long term opportunity but requires less up front investmentSegments 3 and 4 offer lower profit growth opportunities
Get the columns right first
B. Getting New Customers
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
33Territory Coverage Analysis Mixing New Data With Your Data
What is the role of your own sales reps?Is it OK that he or she spends no time at all visiting 36% of the total industrial spend in their territory?How would your principals look at this?Are there differences by product class?
B. Getting New Customers
Predicted Demand From MDM Analytics
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
34Unbundling for Increased Efficiency
Do what you do best and buy the rest
You must sell to users the way they want to buy- it is changing rapidly The Original Bundle
=Energy+Capital+Labor
+Materials
Why is this happening?
• Analog to digital process transitions• Improved asset utilization• Lower cost to find buyers or sellers
1
2
3
4
C. New Services
Gen 1 Unbundler’sVISAUPSNBCEarly switchboards
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
35Get Ahead Of The Curve By Considering Investment1. Become a service business as soon as possible
− It starts with thinking about utility instead of products− The hard part is not designing a service based business model, the hard part is letting go of your
historyYour could provide warehousing and logistics service both upstream and downstream,
VMI, toolroom management, facility audits, pre or post sales value-added services, commissioning, reconditioning, end of life disposal, market insight, surveys, new product
evaluation services, application or certification training, value engineering, bonded inventory, or hundreds of other things that would be valued in your supply chain
2. Figure out how to get paid for the intellectual capital and information that you own
3. Invest to digitize analog processes both inside and outside the firmYou need to design and build your own digital roadmap for new capabilities
C. New Services
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
36Relative Service Attractiveness
It is not about what you can sell, or what you want to do, it is about how can you save money for your core valuable customers
Speak with your good customers discussing: where they have recurring pain-in-the-ass problems; the performance and cost of their other service providers; and any initiatives that they are considering for the futureExplain that your are gathering research and would like to come back when you have sized and cost-out the various opportunitiesThe value you provide is defined by the customer and often it is the difference between what they are paying for something now, and how much lower you can provide itYou speak with many core customers looking for patterns then you build out financial models for each common theme remembering the 1/3’s model
C. New Services
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
37The Business Model Canvas
1. An organization serves one or several Customer
Segments
3. Value propositions are delivered to customers
through communications, distribution, and sales
channels
2. It seeks to solve customer problems and satisfy customer needs with value propositions
4. Relationships are established and maintained
with each Customer Segment
5. Revenue streams results from value propositions successfully offered to
customers
6. Key resources are the assets required to offer and
deliver the previously described elements…
7…by providing a number of key activities8. Some activities are
outsourced and some resources are acquired outside the enterprise
9. The business model elements result in the cost structure
Value CreationEfficiency
C. New Services
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
38Value Proposition Development
Customer JobActivities, roles,responsibilities
PainsRisks, fears, hassles
GainsSuccess, fun, status
Pain RelieversWhat they know
they want
Gain CreatorsWhat they’d want
if they knew
Products andServicesWhat we
could offer
Methodology adapted from The Business Model Canvas, by Business Model Foundry GmbH, www.businessmodelgeneration.com
Segmentation Positioning
C. New Services
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
39Group Discussion
Get into the same groups but choose the group leader based on most years of education
The role of the group leader is to ensure that everyone weighs in with their own views and that the group stays on track and consider these statements and questions
1. In general, which of the three primary adjacencies, of suppliers, customers, or services, offers the most growth opportunity to the typical industrial rep firm?
2. Will the fact that most of today’s rep firms have little appetite for detailed analysis and making PowerPoint, have any real impact on those that prosper in the future?
3. While it is not necessary to share specifics, were there any new insights for you when looking at your business?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
40Agenda
Morning Session 11:00 to 12:30• Crossing the chasm: birth to ownership exit
• Growth through adjacencies
Lunch 12:30 to 1:30
Afternoon Session 1:30 to 3:00• Strategic alternatives & intentional growth
• Process creation and achieving scale Challenge: Learn something new from someone you don’t know well
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
41Agenda
Morning Session 11:00 to 12:30• Crossing the chasm: birth to ownership exit
• Growth through adjacencies
Lunch 12:30 to 1:30
Afternoon Session 1:30 to 3:00• Strategic alternatives & intentional growth
• Process creation and achieving scale
The punch line is that your old model is not a best practice for the future.
How strong is your web presence? Go Google, “manufacturer rep firm
websites” to see best in class examples
Potential Action Step
Trusted relationships have migrated to rabbits & advantaged players
Click the picture for the link
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
42Strategy Is Intentional and Based on InsightThis Is the Core Executive Responsibility
Tactics
Time
Gro
wth
and
Sha
re
End State
CurrentState
A clear end state is the best way to ensure that your investments
and priorities are additive
Success is often driven by what we
don’t do!
Kitting
Staging
PricingE-Commerce
Promotions
Market data
Warehousing
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
43Scenarios For ConsiderationMr. Phone, founded by “Trailerload Herbie” Goldstein (my old boss) built the first national rep firm in the automotive high performance aftermarket in 1975• It was acquired several years later by WR Grace and Herbie became a 1%erIt is common in the Heating Ventilation Air Conditioning and Refrigeration (HVAC/R) industry and the factory automation industry for Engineering Project and Construction (EP&C) firms to become manufacturers reps and for reps to migrate into EP&C firmsServicing the “last mile” in the building materials and liquor industry has created many replenishment rep firms• They don’t ever sell, but do all inventory replenishment to plan-o-grams
electronically with smart tablets in cars on routes for a service feeRep firms could have great data on product utilization that is saleable but most don’t spend the time or money to leverage this
You Earn Money By Taking Away Someone’s Pain
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
44Exit and Growth StrategiesThe most common growth strategy for a rep firm is a merger with adjacent geography (same lines) followed by a merger in the same geography with different products to the SAME customers
Two owners who both want out now is a disaster scenario
The ideal exit point for an owner is two years before you want to be done so you can effectively transfer relationship equity (you will leave some money on the table)
Remember that old men always stay too long, and death isn’t step two in this
The key bit of intelligence for acquisition and merger opportunities is the alignment of key strategic suppliers and their complimentary lines
Supplier acquisitions create both channel conflict and opportunities
There are real opportunities in adjacencies if it makes your customers or principals stickier (e.g. staging, kitting, VMI, 3PL, EP&C, selling consumption info back)
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
45The Cost Efficiency Of Scale – Go As Far As You WantThis is a worksheet to calculate the increase in your firm’s valuation if you grew large enough to maintain market compensation when you paid your sales reps 1/3 of your average commission rate from your principals• When built out ~50% of revenue
is providing services• You have 15 to 20 new support
staff and major technology supporting the same number of reps earning 10% more
• It could be the same geography, more lines or same lines, more geography, every mix is different
• The firm’s executives transition from selling to management
This takes years of hard work so don’t think about starting if you have less than ten more years
Most Successful Firm Owners Reach a Stage in Life That Scale Isn’t Worth It, Just Like a Millennial
Financial Elements Entrepreneurial Model Current State
Full Buildout With Scale and ~50% of revenue in services
A Rep Firm Total Commission Income 1,500,000$ 4,000,000$
B Average rep W-2 (T-4) 90,000$ 132,000$
C Number of reps including owner (No change as headcount is in support staff) 10.00 10.00
D Percent of commissions paid to rep 60% 33%
E Total rep compensation 900,000$ 1,320,000$
F Estimated support overhead at 33% of A 495,000$ 1,320,000$
G Firm EBITDA = A - (E + F) 105,000$ 1,360,000$
420,000$ 5,440,000$
5,020,000$
Times a 4X Multiple
Increase in Enterprise Value
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
46
The Sales Rep Of The Futureor how Johnny Unitas Lost Super Bowl III and the case for transparency
The rep firm marketing executive takes responsibility for business development using the sales force as an offensive weapon to gain and preserve shareGaining market scale is often not about selling stuff, rather it is about getting customers to choose your bundle as their supplier of choice
You may be selling a value proposition- not productsScorecards are public and real time• Performance discussions and best practice sharing become the norm
Geo-location services drive everything• Customer and market data is pushed to sales reps real time without asking (Google the
term SoLoMo)
• Everyone knows where the sales reps are- always
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
47
“People hire products to get jobs done”
Harvard Business Review
so start by asking:
what’s the job to be done?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
48
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
49
When we viewed innovation through a “jobs-to-be-done” lens, new possibilities emerged, inspiring us to rewrite the rules of innovation.
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
50Market Opportunity Scores - Circular Saw Client ExampleImportance + (Importance-Satisfaction) = Opportunity
Desired Outcomes Importance Satisfaction = Opportunity Scores1. Minimize Likelihood of going 9.5 3.2 = 15.8
off track at end of cut2. Minimize frequency of cutting 8.3 4.2 = 12.4
the cord3. Minimize the amount of 9.5 7.5 = 11.5
splintering4. Minimize time to make bevel 5.1 1.0 = 9.1
adjustments5. Minimize the likelihood of 9.0 9.2 = 9.0
cutting user
Sellers, take note: Stop
chattering about the attributes of
the product. Instead, be utterly clear about what it
does for those who buy it
Success comes from getting the job done 20 - 30 percent better
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
51
Group Discussion – Critical Selling Events
Get into the different groups (you already know what the other guys will say) but choose the group leader based on who has the most years of
experience as a manufacturers rep
The role of the group leader is to ensure that everyone weighs in with their own views and that the group stays on track and consider these statements and questions1. What are the jobs to be done for those who purchase commercial lawn
mowers?2. What could be the critical selling events?3. Are there new business models that could disrupt this industry?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
52The Large Scale TrendIn the beginning, sales reps were all self directed and told to look at their territories as their own businesses• Most were paid incentives on transaction revenue on receipt of funds (discounted
for price reductions) and the idea was they could eat what they killed• It was all about individual performance
What makes me unique is that I sell myself first and offer personal serviceAs market complexity increases the role transitions from being self directed to being management directed as an offensive weapon• The rep is provided with missions, tools, and rules of engagement• This is driven by scale, but small firms will never need to change
What would happen if a Navy Seal Team was put in charge of mall security with no mission defined or rules of engagement?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
53The Evolving Omnichannel Sales Model4. Punchouts & LOOP*Inside sales leads with
specialistsYou have sticky customers
with reliable serviceField sales is on call, as necessary, by your team
3. Field Sales LeadsExpand share of wallet
using team members and introducing specialists
along with special services
1. TelemarketingE-catalog or Amazon
Easy to buy & “once and done”Early alert opportunity tool
2. Field Sales LeadsProspect with provided
marketing analysis on cost to grow and potential to
growYour value proposition is
explicit and key
* Lights Out Order Processing (ERP or App)
What % of your sales calls are on the right side of the model?
2-9
The Big Pill Is That Field Sales Customer Assignments Are Episodic
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
54Specialized Selling Roles
FAMField Acct Mgr
IAMInside Acct Mgr
ISRInside Sales Rep
CSRCustomer Svc Rep
Specialist TSRTelesales Rep
Commontitles
SAM, AM, TM, FSR, OSR AM, IAM, Segment AM ISR, CSR CSR Many TMR, TSR
Primary SOS(1) Business solution “Relationship” =
reliability and trustTechnical and transactional Transactional Technical or
functional Awareness
Customers assigned? Yes, by dirt Yes, by dirt or segment Yes, by dirt or segment No Periodically, by need
or projectNo. Uses call list and
RFM(2) tickler
% in field >80%Own car
5% - 50%Shared car
<5%No car None >50%
Own car None
% demand creation >90% 5% - 50% <5% 0% >90% >90%
Customer relation role Primary Primary Primary but often
shared with FAMMaintenance
“first do no harm”
Support but Primary in peer to peer
situations
Generate and find CSEs(3) to pass to
other reps
Account capacity ~30 ~100 Hundreds Hundreds Hundreds
Usually a set of <1,000 changed
periodically
Median comp (vs. FAM) 100% 70% 60% 50% 80% - 120% 40%
When We Are Free to Do As We Please We Usually Imitate Each Other
(1) Service Outputs Supplied: the key elements of the customer value proposition(2) Recency, Frequency, Monetary (RFM): analysis to determine the optimum call frequency(3) Critical sales event: a sales opportunity driven by external circumstances
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
55Get Ahead Of The Curve By Considering Investment1. Become a service business as soon as possible
− It starts with thinking about utility instead of products− The hard part is not designing a service based business model, the hard part is letting go of
your history
2. Figure out how to get paid for the intellectual capital and information that you own
3. Fully embrace omni channel strategy (sales reps have transitory account relationships)
4. Realign resources around the life value of customers, not transactions
5. Find something to unbundle and become a marketshare challenger6. Invest to digitize analog processes both inside and outside the firm
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
56Group Discussion
Get into the different groups (you already know what the other guys will say) but choose the group leader based on who has the most years of
experience as a manufacturers rep
The role of the group leader is to ensure that everyone weighs in with their own views and that the group stays on track and consider these statements and questions1. Share experiences of any group members with any specialized selling roles2. Consider the mergers or acquisitions of independent rep firms and share any
observations on best of worst practices in post transaction integration3. What are the large scale disruptive trends that your principals face where they
lack a clear answer and how might the rep firm be able to help?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
57Agenda
Morning Session 11:00 to 12:30• Crossing the chasm: birth to ownership exit
• Growth through adjacencies
Lunch 12:30 to 1:30
Afternoon Session 1:30 to 3:00• Strategic alternatives & intentional growth
• Process creation and achieving scale
Whether you are a current or potential future owner of a rep firm
you are going to have a wind at your back with growth for the next decade
or so.
(There are several acquisition targets in this room today)
Success will be about doing new things, not doing the same old things better, so commit yourself to some
real self-development.
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
58
1.To improve a system, first understand the system
2.A system is a whole, which is defined by more than just the sum of the parts but rather the product of its interactions
3. If you only apply analysis to a system you take it apart and it loses all its essential properties, and so do its parts
Premises of Systems Thinking & Innovation
The Theory of SystemsUnderstand your firm as a system
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
59
Left to their own devices and without a systems approach, the result is sub-optimization
Human Nature is to value what we do and thus improve upon it via discretionary efforts
You would never improve the quality of one part of a system without also simultaneously improving the quality of the whole
Avoid Sub-OptimizationBeware of Independent Actors
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
60Picking Consolidation Packing Shipping
Maximum facility throughput
Pricing Customer Service Inventory Availability Delivery
Maximumsales
The Theory of Constraints
Either fix the constraint or manage the system around it
After you address one constraint a new one becomes critical
This is a fatal flaw analysis that must be part of your proposal
Travel Salary SupervisorRelationship
JobResponsibilities
retention
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
61Identify Your Critical Constraint
Attack it with non-recurring investment to gain recurring benefits
Sales Income
Symptoms:•Your biggest single frustration•What you apologize for the most•You talk about it all the time•You blame an entire department
Invest to build a process using technology to
decisively fix itYou pay the money once
and get the savings forever
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
62Amazon’s Innovation CycleDay 1 ‘vitality’ is like an organization’s startup and growth phases• they are delivering great value to their customers• In a perpetual state of change, flux, and liminality
Day 2 is the spiral of decline. “Day 2 is stasis”• Followed by irrelevance• Followed by excruciating, painful decline• Followed by death
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
63Stanford Idealized Redesign Exercise
How can you possibly know what you would do while under constraints, if you don’t know what you would do with out any
constraints.
Begin with the 80/20 rule
Then ask WHY? or How Might We?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
64
http://www.mckinsey.com/insights/innovation/disrupting_beliefs_a_new_approach_to_business-model_innovation?cid=other-eml-ttn-mip-mck-oth-1509
Predator Or Prey
4 Areas Of Focus1. Innovating in customer relationships:
From loyalty to empowerment2. Innovating in activities: From efficient
to intelligent3. Innovating in resources: From
ownership to access4. Innovating in costs: From low cost to
no cost
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
65Leap of Faith Assumptions Exercise
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
66Potential Downstream Impact Areas1. Helping them make more money or spend less money• Integrated supply, outsourcing partner, value engineering, cost reduction commitments, indirect
and direct cost savings, strategic sourcing versus procurement
2. Getting them into new markets• Rep firms can lead from the middle and you probably sell to some of their competitors, or you can
lead them into an adjacent market niche
3. Making them more capital efficient• Consignment, spares management, date code management, end of life management processes
4. Education around one of their critical constraints• Succession, professional management, or use of analytics
Think About Distributor Channel Partners and End Users
How would your customers rate you on these factors?
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
67Potential Upstream Impact Areas1. Solid data-driven competitive insight on your geographical market patch where
you know 3 to 5 times more than your supplier principals2. Providing detail competitive and market data in real time, think confidential blogs
built on Google alerts and clipping servicesCall reports are the closest thing for a sales rep getting a Pulitzer prize in literature
3. The ability to provide recurring and valuable progress reporting data to supplier principals and downstream users
4. Providing qualitative and quantitative insight on new product positioning and competitive offerings
5. Lower recurring costs for market serving and higher for market making, think two tier commission rates, monthly retainer fees for services, & year 1 booster rates
90% Of Rep Firms Do Not Do This Well
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
68The Four Foundational RolesThe senior rep firm exec should first staff to their greatest personal weakness• If you have a strong line card but are too busy to improve, get operations first• If you could have a stronger line card and can’t find growth, do marketing firstAs you gain scale most tactical decisions are made horizontally with concurrence between any two functions and financeA significant portion of the incentive compensation for this group in on the results of the complete firm, not just their function and they have financial visibility into the firm
1- Sales 2 or 3- Marketing 2 or 3- Operations 4- FinanceResponsible for customer facing
activitiesResponsible for supplier facing
activitiesResponsible for rule making and all internal decisions around process
Responsible for defining when and how much and what will be generated
Outside sales, inside sales, product specialists, zone or market managers
Product marketing, supplier relationships, pricing, market analysis,
promotions
Order management, warehousing, IT, facilities, data and phone, logistics,
project management
Accounting, treasury, audit, investment analysis, policy and
procedures
Customer share of wallet growth and customer base broadening
Supplier market share growth, annual planning, building the best line card Warehousing, security, HSE, quality Policy compliance, cash controls,
effective planning and controls
All are responsible for revenue growth and net profit performance (each may have house accounts)
This Starting Point Helps You Get Clear On Who Owns Any Problem
They can all be partners with
various ownership percentages from
1% and up
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
69Key Take Aways
With less than 5 field sales reps per rep firm your options are limited, but…
1. You can define territories by assigned accounts instead of geographySome customers (think house accounts) only want an inside sales rep
2. When you have a vacant territory you don’t have to put another general line sales rep into it
Add a pure hunter or a specialist or any of the other roles
3. You can start to measure key activities around growth and share of walletMeasure and manage their growth responsibilities explicitly
4. You can change the way you compensate them and reduce the annuity effects of your sales management process
Perhaps territory size and tenure shouldn’t be the key income drivers
Your Size Is a Great Excuse to Do Nothing and Is the Most Common Choice
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
70Group Discussion
Get into the same group but choose the group leader based on who has the fewest years of experience as a manufacturers rep
The role of the group leader is to ensure that everyone weighs in with their own views and that the group stays on track and consider these statements and questions
1. What is your largest take away from these sessions?2. What advice would you have for ISA and the IMR group with respect
to additional training (you will be surveyed after this session)
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
71Do You Own Part Of a Manufacturer’s Representative Firm?None of us live forever and old men always stay too longIt is a great time to sell between now and 2019 to 2020 if you want out• If this is the answer, work hard to maximize EBITDA while
developing a good story and sell in 2019
If you always hit your growth targets, or at least are ahead of the other rep firms in the market, you remain strong at line extension introduction, AND you are an effective and valued partner in your principal’s change processes then
“…yours is the earth and everything that is in it”
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
72Next Week’s Homework Assignment
Discuss the questions below making sure that everyone on your team expresses their own views.
Everyone write down your assessment of your firm as it currently exists on a 1 to 10 scale with 1 being a pure lifestyle play with long tenured and loyal sales reps and a 10 being a professionally managed firm with high productivity and use of analytical data. Then give your score, folded up, to the least tenured member of your group.
1. The least tenured member provides the team with the low score, the high score, and the average
2. After a brief discussion everyone scores the firm again based on where you think it will be in five years if you don’t change anything and the least tenured member provides the same values
3. As a group discuss how you feel about the two sets of scores
WWW.IRCG.COM INDIAN RIVER CONSULTING GROUP
73Suggested Readings- Getting Out Of The Cat Box
These books are focused on improving where you are today
These books are focused on where you need to go