The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting 153
Draft Minutes
THE UNITED CHURCH OF CANADA
MEETING OF THE EXECUTIVE OF THE GENERAL COUNCIL
Draft MINUTES
Saturday, March 3, 2018
The Executive of the General Council of The United Church of Canada met electronically from
11:00 am on Saturday, March 3, 2018 until 6:40 p.m. EST. The Moderator, Jordan Cantwell,
presided.
Attendance
Cathy Anderson, Miriam Bowlby, Sue Brodrick, Jean Brown, Wendy Brown, Janice Brownlee,
Graham Brownmiller, Russel Burns, Jordan Cantwell, Brian Cornelius, Brenda Curtis, Ken
DeLisle, Larry Doyle, David Fines, Paula Gale, Vilvan Gunasingham, Cathy Hamilton, Sean
Handcock, Dan Hayward, SungMin Jung, Debra Kigar, Bev Kostichuk, Aidan Legault, Jean
Macdonald, Jim McKibbin, Gary Paterson, Tim Reaburn, Mary Royal-Duczek, Nora Sanders,
Lawrence Sankey, Norm Seli, Miriam Spies, Anna Stewart, Norma Thompson, Erin Todd,
Donalee Williams, Sybil Wilson, Doug Wright
Corresponding Members
David Allen, Michael Blair, Shirley Cleave, Bill Doyle, Doug Goodwin, Alan Hall, Laura
Hallman, Peter Hartmans, David Hewitt, Lauren Hodgson, Cheryl Jourdain, Will Kunder,
Rosemary Lambie, Jody Maltby, Faith March-MacCuish, Erik Mathiesen, Shannon McCarthy,
Bill Smith, Cheryl-Ann Stadelbauer-Sampa, Nancy Sutherland
Regrets
Janice Asiimwe, Félix Bigirimana, Judith Evenden, Gabrielle Lamouche, Marlene Lightning,
George Montour, Donna Rumpel, Phil Schuyler, Janet Sigurdson, Pauline Walker, Peggy
Mulambya Kabonde (Global Partner)
Saturday, March 3, 2018 – Session 1
Welcome The Moderator constituted the meeting in English and French.
The Moderator welcomed the Executive and invited members to acknowledge the land and First
Nations territory where they were situated.
Worship
Worship was led by Japhet Ndhlovu, Church in Mission Unit, who opened with a prayer. Japhet
offered a reflection on the history of King Shaka, leader of the Zulu people from 1816 to 1828,
and the understanding of God on the cross. The scripture reading was 1 Corinthians 1:25.
The Moderator noted that Bill Smith, Executive Secretary of Bay of Quinte Conference, would
be the theological reflector for this meeting. The Facilitation Group for this meeting comprised
Allan Buckingham, Hewitt Holmes, and Betty Kelly.
154 The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting
Draft Minutes
Remembering Rick Balson
Rosemary Lambie, Executive Secretary of Montreal and Ottawa Conference, shared
remembrances of Rick Balson, who passed away in January. Rick had been a member of the
Executive since 2015 and was also a member of the Committee on Indigenous Justice and
Residential Schools, in addition to having been a long-time volunteer in Montreal and Ottawa
Conference.
The In Memoriam bulletin had been shared with the Executive before the meeting. (Addendum
A) The Moderator invited the group to take time during this meeting to hold these folks in prayer
and gratitude for the legacy they have left.
The General Secretary introduced the following two motions.
GS 77 Opening and Procedural Motions
Motion: Nora Sanders/Bev Kostichuk 2018-03-03-181
The General Secretary, General Council proposes:
Agenda
That the Executive of the General Council adopt the agenda for this meeting and that changes to
the agenda, which may be necessary as the meeting evolves, be made on the recommendation of
the Agenda Table.
Worship and Theological Reflection
That the worship leadership for this meeting be provided by Japhet Ndhlovu, and that theological
reflection be offered by Bill Smith.
Corresponding
That Shirley Cleave be named a corresponding member for this meeting.
Resource People
That resource people for this meeting be the Executive Ministers and Officers, David Allen,
Diane Bosman and Cynthia Gunn. That the Facilitation Group for this meeting be Allan
Buckingham, Hewitt Holmes and Betty Kelly.
Administrative Staff
That the administrative staff for this meeting be Shirley Welch, Stefanie Uyesugi-Cooper, Mary
Worrall, Stephen Fetter and Jamie Wilder. That the minute secretary for this meeting be Shirley
Welch.
Carried
Graham Brownmiller noted that there is a challenge with the wording of some of the proposals in
the consent docket, as many of them are not definitive, using words such as “could”. He also
noted some editing corrections. Nora confirmed that any editing will be corrected before the
proposals are brought to General Council.
GS 78 Consent Motions
Motion: Nora Sanders/Bev Kostichuk 2018-03-03-182
The General Secretary, General Council proposes that the Executive of the General Council:
The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting 155
Draft Minutes
1. Approve the minutes of the Executive of the General Council meeting held on November 18-
20, 2017.
2. Receive for information, the minutes of the meetings of the Sub-Executive of the General
Council held December 14, 2017, and January 25, 2018.
3. Receive for information the following:
Moderator’s Accountability Report
General Secretary’s Accountability Report
Permanent Committee on Finance Accountability Report
Permanent Committee on Governance and Agenda Accountability Report
Permanent Committee on Ministry and Employment Policies and Services Accountability
Report
Permanent Committee on Programs for Mission and Ministry Accountability Report
Aboriginal Ministries Council Accountability Report
Committee on Indigenous Justice and Residential Schools Report
Theology and Inter-Church Inter-Faith Committee Accountability Report
General Council 43 Planning Committee Report
Joint Grants Report
Nominations Committee Report
Pension Board Review Report and Recommendations
Theologies of Adoption Report
Report on Full Communion with the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)
Correspondence to the Executive of the General Council received since the last meeting
of the Executive (sent to the Executive by email and found online)
4. Approve the following proposals [text of these proposals found in Addendum B]:
AMC 3 – Extension of Aboriginal Ministries Council Appointments
G&A 28 – Comprehensive Renewal Evaluation
G&A 29 – Conflict of Interest Policy
G&A 30 – Nomination Committee: Mandate and Membership
G&A 31 – Judicial Committee Membership
G&A 32 – Reports and Proposals to the 43rd General Council
GS 80 – 2018 Operating Budget
GS 81 – Carbon Reduction
GS 82 – Pension Plan Governance Review Proposal
GS 83 – Full Communion Agreement with the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) in
the United States and Canada
GS 84 – Remit-Related Revisions to the Basis of Union
MEPS 26 – Calculation for Year of Credited Service
MEPS 27 – Change to Policy: Ministry Positions Accountable to the Governing Body
MEPS 28 – Manse Heating
MEPS 29 – New Compensation Model: Remote Manse Allowance
MEPS 30 – New Covenant Policy
MEPS 31 – Re-Engaging Retired Ministry Personnel
PMM 16 – Children’s Ministry Strategy
PMM 17 – LGBTIQ+ Two Spirit Pride Sunday
156 The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting
Draft Minutes
PMM 18 – LGBTQI2+ Communities and Human Rights
PMM 19 – Migrant Church – Migration
PMM 20 – Towards Peace in Palestine and Israel: A Call to Costly Solidarity
PMM 21 – The United Church of Canada Partner Council
5. Refer proposal LON 1 Mandatory Training for Ministry Personnel (TRC Call to Action #60)
to the General Secretary for consideration as the Office of Vocation is being developed.
Carried
Moderator’s Update
The Moderator spoke of her visit to the Red Sucker Lake First Nation in northern Manitoba and
the grief the community was going through at the time. To help the community one of the men
played music as his offering of support. It is important to offer support in whatever way you can.
She also updated the members about her visit to Kenya and the many partners she was able to
visit. Among the highlights were: the National Council of Churches of Kenya’s (www.ncck.org)
life-saving HIV/AIDS education program that has lifted much of the stigma for people in the
massive northern Kenya Kakuma refugee camp, reducing suicides among infected people and
encouraging people to come forward to be tested and treated; and a community for people with
disabilities who can now support themselves because of the vocation training provided by the
church’s partner, Pembizo Christian Council (Twitter @pembizo). Both the NCCK and Pembizo
are ecumenical bodies and collaborate extensively on their work. The Moderator also spoke
about a program for Christians and Muslims where the focus is de-radicalization for the isolated
and hopeless youth in slums who can be easily radicalized by organizations like Al-Shabaab.
She expressed her gratitude for the partnerships we have in the United Church of Canada where
we can bring both our gifts and needs, which is important in our relationships.
In closing, the Moderator thanked the entire Executive for the work they have done this
triennium, noting how she has been inspired by the leadership the group has offered in their
work.
Global Partner
Due to difficulties with technology and time differences between Zambia and Canada, Rev. Dr.
Peggy Mulambya Kabonde shared her greeting to the Executive via video.
Stretch break for 5 minutes.
General Secretary’s Update
The General Secretary reported that the United Church will be contributing to a Senate hearing
on adoptions. Executive member Dan Hayward will speak on behalf of the church on March 22,
supported by staff person Amy Crawford.
Remit 6 (One Order) did not pass, so the current system will continue and will transition into the
Office of Vocation. A staffing model for the new regional councils is taking shape, with one
Executive Minister covering several regional councils, supporting the program and
The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting 157
Draft Minutes
administrative regional council staff. Conversations between the General Secretary and regional
church leaders will be held next week to identify provisional Executive Ministers for each
region. Those recommendations for appointment will go to the Sub-Executive the week of March
19, and the provisional Executive Ministers will meet the week of March 26. They will work
with regional leadership and the General Council Office so regions can respond to their own
priorities, coordinating with the Office of Vocation. Diversity is a deep concern and as positions
become vacant, that will be a top priority.
With the full communion relationship with the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) the United
Church has been invited to name a person to sit on their board. Dan Hayward will be sitting in
that role, and will be attending their meeting in April.
April 4, 2018 will be the 50th anniversary of the assassination of Martin Luther King. We will be
sending a small delegation to Washington, DC to join the United Church of Christ and other
denominations in a rally.
The General Secretary reported on “the Indaba”, a gathering in February of this year, and shared
remarks on the event from Peggy Mulambya Kabonde. The gathering brought together partners
from Africa and Asia to share, and compare notes. In particular, Peggy spoke about revising the
way they do mission. Nora reported that she was in touch with Peggy recently and she plans to
be at General Council in July.
Plenary Listening Session
The Executive took time in a plenary listening session regarding proposal GS 79 2019 Budget
Assumptions. This session was led by Erik Mathiesen. During this time Erik noted that there was
an error in the preamble of the proposal: the cost of living factor should be noted as 1.6% rather
than 1.9% as had been circulated. There was time for clarifying questions at the end of the
presentation.
Mary Royal-Duczek, chair of the Permanent Committee on Programs, briefly explained the
change to the proposal PMM 15 Iridesce: the Living Apology Project. This change will extend
the project and move the apology to a later date on the request of Affirm United / S’affirmer
Ensemble.
Prior to the meeting, there were some questions regarding the proposal, MEPS 24 Admission
Policy and Procedures around the English language requirement for admissions. The Moderator
advised members to review the Appendix to the proposal for an explanation.
Lunch break at 1:14 p.m. EST.
Saturday, March 3, 2018 – Session 2
Welcome The Moderator welcomed the members of the Executive to the afternoon session of this meeting
of the Executive starting just after 2 p.m.
Discussion Session
Allan Buckingham reminded the Executive how decision-making will happen at this meeting.
158 The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting
Draft Minutes
The Executive broke into three discussion groups to consider the remaining proposals brought to
this meeting and to offer feedback for the Facilitation Group.
MEPS 24 – Admission Policy and Procedures
MEPS 25 – Board of Vocation and Candidacy Board
G&A 27 – Three Council Model Governance Requirements
GS 79 – 2019 Budget Assumptions
PMM 14 – Faith Formation Strategy (Spirit Awakening)
PMM 15 – Iridesce: the Living Apology Project
TICIF 4 – Theologies of Adoption
Once the Executive had reconvened from the discussion session, Bev Kostichuk advised that
following the in-camera session, the Executive would reconvene at 5:15 p.m. EST and continue
the meeting in the evening.
In-Camera Time
The voting members of the Executive moved to an in-camera session to hear the report of the
General Secretary’s Supervision Committee.
Motion: Bev Kostichuk/Norma Thompson 2018-03-03-183
That the Executive of the General Council move into an in camera session with the following
membership: voting members of the Executive of the General Council.
Carried
Saturday, March 3, 2018 – Session 3
Welcome The Moderator welcomed the members of the Executive to the evening session of this meeting of
the Executive.
Motion: Bev Kostichuk/Graham Brownmiller 2018-03-03-184
That the Executive of the General Council move out of the in-camera Session
Carried
Facilitation Group Overview
Allan Buckingham introduced and thanked Hewitt Holmes and Betty Kelly, co-members of the
Facilitation Group, for the work they did in compiling the feedback from the discussion sessions
conducted earlier today.
The Facilitation Group presented a summary and a suggested way of dealing with each of the
proposals based on the feedback provided.
Decision Making Session
MEPS 24 – Admission Policy and Procedures (including Admissions Task Group Report &
Appendix)
Facilitation Group’s remarks:
Concerns in all groups about English and/or French as language requirements
The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting 159
Draft Minutes
A note that Intercultural congregations need to be able to call someone speaking their
own language but these folks are being invited to be part of a church that is
predominantly English speaking
Recognition that it’s hard to find jobs in the United Church of Canada if you don’t speak
English
Could be short-sighted to stop gifts for ministry at the door because of language
restrictions
Need to protect congregations if the match is not good but appointment is 3 years
Concerns over length of work permits
General affirmations for the content of the proposal
Motion: Paula Gale/Debra Kigar 2018-03-03-185
The Executive of the General Council accepts the recommendation of the Permanent Committee
on Ministry and Employment, Policies and Services and requests implementation of the
following effective September 1, 2019:
1. That a definition of admission be added to the policy and that the procedures be
redesigned according to the recommendations below. An example of the process is
provided in Appendix B. The definition of admission is to enable ordered ministers from
other recognized denominations to transfer their ordination or commissioning into The
United Church of Canada.
2. That policies and procedures be established for ministers from other denominations who
apply to serve within The United Church of Canada but not be admitted, in order to
enable them to serve within the United Church. This includes ministers whose leadership
is required for short periods of time, ministers who serve ethno-linguistic specific
communities of faith and ministers from migrant church contexts.
3. That the process for admission be understood as distinct and separate from the process for
candidacy by ensuring that the Office of Vocation include a specialized and trained
committee to oversee and assess admission applicants. That the interview committee seek
to reflect the diversity of the Canadian reality and, where possible, include a member who
is from the country or denomination of origin of the applicant being interviewed and a
minister who was previously admitted to the order of ministry in the United Church.
4. That the implementation of the Office of Vocation ensure resources are available to
support admission applicants and pastoral charges for immigration.
5. That the application to enter the admission process include letters of reference and a letter
of standing, rather than contact information being provided and the General Council
Office being responsible for sending a request to obtain these items.
6. That the committee assessing applications to enter the admission process seek to include
diversity in terms of gender, age, race, cultural background and other related identity
groups such as orientation.
160 The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting
Draft Minutes
7. That proficiency in the English language be named as an eligibility requirement to enter
the admission process and that this requirement be assessed by conducting all interviews
with admission applicants in English. The English language proficiency continue to be
evaluated as we continue our work at being an Intercultural church.
8. That the first two components of the current process (Application and Credential
Clearance and Initial Interview) be streamlined into one component in which applications
will be assessed and, if eligible, applicants will be invited to an interview. Following the
interview, the applicant will receive a letter confirming acceptance into the admission
process and eligibility to seek an appointment or ministry employment in The United
Church of Canada.
9. That admission applicants who are interviewed using technology be interviewed in
person within the first 6 months of their ministry employment in Canada.
10. That the circulation of names be removed as a requirement of the admission process.
11. That the ministry employment be a minimum of one full calendar year in length and no
less than of half-time.
12. That, where possible, the length of appointment for admission applicants who are subject
to the requirements of immigration be three years, rather than one-year renewable.
13. That the admission applicant consults with the Office of Vocation regarding opportunities
for employment to ensure gifts for ministry are a match with available ministry
vacancies.
14. That Search Committees receive training regarding intercultural interviewing.
15. That the Covenant Policy (previous Pastoral Relations policy) include a requirement that
communities of faith who covenant with an admission applicant must be oriented to the
admission policy and procedures and receive intercultural training and support for
immigration requirements (as applicable).
16. That mentorship be mandatory, resources for mentors be developed, mentors receive
training specific to the role, and mentors be assigned by the Office of Vocation once the
admission applicant has secured an appointment.
17. That specific Learning Outcomes for Admission Applicants be developed and used to
a. guide the creation of orientation resources and programming
b. assess an admission applicant’s understanding and knowledge of ministry leadership
within The United Church of Canada throughout the process, especially during the
interviews.
The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting 161
Draft Minutes
18. That orientation to the requirements of the admission process, ministry within The United
Church of Canada and the realities of life in Canada take place throughout the process as
follows:
a. Before submitting documentation for credential clearance, ministers from other
denominations who express an interest in being admitted will receive orientation to
The United Church of Canada, the realities of the Canadian context, the expectations
of the policy and procedures, immigration requirements (if applicable) and the
possible financial implications.
b. Following formal entry into the admission process, the Office of Vocation will
initiate a meeting with the applicant to provide orientation to employment in The
United Church of Canada including support in understanding appointment process or
other employment opportunities and preparing for interview(s). Included in this will
be an orientation to the various resources available, including financial assistance
loans and grants, minimum salary scale, pension and benefits, etc.
c. Once the admission applicant has secured employment, they will be oriented to
United Church polity, theology and history through a variety of learning methods, for
example, learning circles, one-on-one learning, workshops, etc. Assessment of this
learning will be done by the Office of Vocation using the Learning Outcomes for
Admission Applicants (see #17 above).
19. That the expertise inherent in the United Church theological schools be understood as a
valuable resource and that the Church endeavour to partner with the schools to develop
the orientation resources for admission applicants.
20. That ongoing networking and support for admission applicants be provided during their
process (for example, online cluster groups, regional gatherings, support groups for those
going through immigration, etc.) and that this be offered in collaboration between the
appropriate General Council units and Office of Vocation.
21. That funds be made available (by the Financial Assistance Committee or other sources)
to assist admission applicants in completing the mandatory trainings required of all
ministry personnel.
Motion to Amend: Cathy Hamilton/Dan Hayward
That in point #7 the words “or French” be added after each instance of the word “English” so
that point 7 would read as follows:
7. That proficiency in the English or French language be named as an eligibility
requirement to enter the admission process and that this requirement be assessed by
conducting all interviews with admission applicants in English or French. The English or
French language proficiency continue to be evaluated as we continue our work at being
an Intercultural church.
Carried
Motion as amended.
Carried
162 The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting
Draft Minutes
MEPS 25 – Board of Vocation and Candidacy Board
Facilitation Group’s remarks:
Affirmations of the work done
Some questions from group 3 were asked and answered
Motion: Wendy Brown/Norm Seli 2018-03-03-186
The Executive of the General Council recommends to the 43rd General Council that:
1. The Board of Vocation consists of 12 people with discretion to add another 2 to ensure
appropriate balance of intercultural, ordained, diaconal, designated lay ministry, and lay
members. The Indigenous Church would elect one Board member in addition to those
elected by the General Council.
2. The Board of Vocation is elected by the General Council as approved by GC42 and that
for 2018, should the General Council decide to enact the Office of Vocation remit, GC43
refer the election to GCE so the nomination process can be followed.
3. For 2018 the Conferences nominate five people to a pool to populate the Board, its
committees and candidacy boards. The nominations process of General Council would
provide the GCE a slate of 12-14 people for election to the Board of Vocation. This
would include naming the Chair of the Board of Vocation. The Indigenous Church would
elect a person to the Board of Vocation.
4. The nominees not on the slate for election to the Board would become part of a pool for
the Board of Vocation to populate the committees of the Board including the Candidacy
Boards whose responsibilities are identified in the Candidacy Pathway remit.
5. There will be up to six Candidacy Boards serving different geographies. One of these
Candidacy Boards will be named by the Indigenous Church and will serve the Indigenous
Church. Part of the responsibilities of the Office of Vocation ministers is to resource the
Candidacy Boards.
6. The Board of Vocation may appoint commissions to assist it in fulfilling its
responsibilities. Candidacy Boards are commissions of the Board of Vocation and would
have the responsibilities outlined in the Candidacy Pathway including, but not limited to,
naming candidates, terminating candidacy, and determining readiness for accreditation
for ordination, commissioning to the diaconal ministry and recognizing designated lay
ministers.
7. The regional councils have responsibility for ordaining, commissioning to the diaconal
ministry, and designating lay ministers. They decide on the basis of the determination of
readiness by the Board of Vocation through the appropriate Candidacy Board and
confirmation that the requirement for call or appointment has been fulfilled.
Amendment: Graham Brownmiller/Larry Doyle
That in point #4 the wording be changed to read:
The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting 163
Draft Minutes
“The nominees not on the slate for election to the Board be asked to become part of a pool for
the Board of Vocation to populate the committees of the Board including the Candidacy Boards
whose responsibilities are identified in the Candidacy Pathway remit.”
It was noted that in point #3 it is clear that the nominees are already part of a pool.
Defeated
Original motion as moved.
Carried
G&A 27 – Three Council Model Governance Requirements [original proposal and appendix
found at Addenda C]
Facilitation Group’s remarks:
Questions about specific French language membership of the Denominational Council
One group noted that the Executive had previously decided not to include specific groups
Concerns over using Proportional Representation for distributing Commissioners and
how it reflects the diversity of the church
Concerns over the size of the Executive and lack of Regional representation of Executive
(note: a proposal will be coming to GC43)
One group had a desire to change item 21 to say that the sub-Executive may make these
decisions at duly called meetings this would remove "or by signing written resolutions in
lieu of meetings as long as the resolutions are signed by all members of the sub-
Executive".
The same group noted: “If we are going to be bound by the way we have always done
things, we are not doing a new thing. If we are going to be dealing with a small sub-
Executive, then we need to trust that they will be able to establish trust together for a new
way of handling governance. We might be ready to move to this model in the future but it
is a lot to make the change to a smaller Denominational Structure and change the method
of decision-making at the same time.”
There was a question asked about whether there are guiding principles underlying the
policy about a balance of ministry personnel and lay members. This question would also
apply to the issue of there being diversity of voice.
Jim McKibbin spoke of concerns he had about this motion, but did not offer any amendments.
Motion: Sue Brodrick/Graham Brownmiller 2018-03-03-187
The Executive of the General Council approves the policies set out in the appendix, with the
following changes, for each of the three councils and recommends their approval to the 43rd
General Council.
From the Appendix:
7. Meetings:
The regional council will decide on the frequency, time, place of its meetings
provided it meets the minimum requirement set out in Remit 1 of meeting at least
annually as the full regional council or through its Executive. All meetings must be
called by the leading elder, presiding officer or secretary (or their equivalents within
164 The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting
Draft Minutes
the regional council structure). Special meetings may be called for urgent business.
Amendment: David Fines/Jean Macdonald
To add a new point after #9 f), to add four more members representing the francophone
constituency.
Defeated
Amendment: Bev Kostichuk/Graham Brownmiller
That in point #9 e) the words “...where possible” be added, so that the point reads: “204 members
elected by the regional councils, where possible, at least a year before the next regular in-person
meeting...”
Carried
Motion as amended.
Carried
Recorded Abstentions: David Fines and Jim McKibbin
GS 79 – 2019 Budget Assumptions [complete proposal with corrected background re: COLA
found at Addenda D]
Facilitation Group’s remarks:
This is the approval of budget assumptions but will the 260 commissioners feel
competent to make decisions. How deep will they want/need to dig?
One group asked for more clarity between M&S and assessments.
Concern about the sharing of resources, and how that will happen. We can't insist, and in
some cases, suggestions are taken as merely that, "suggestions". How do we encourage a
spirit of generosity?
A concern was raised about funding levels, particularly of Regions, as well as capacity of
Regional staff to effectively support local communities of faith.
Recognition of the challenge of declining revenue trends and a desire to re-imagine more
streamlined ways to do things.
Motion: Debra Kigar/Sue Brodrick 2018-03-03-188
Approve the 2019 operating budget assumptions and principles as outlined.
Carried
PMM 14 – Faith Formation Strategy (Spirit Awakening)
Facilitation Group’s remarks:
General affirmations
Questions about how pilot congregations are chosen and their diversity
Question about funding which was answered, it will use existing budget
Motion: Sybil Wilson/SungMin Jung 2018-03-03-189
The Executive of the General Council
o Affirms the emphasis and need for strengthening faith formation in the denomination,
through a renewed culture of transformational faith and,
The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting 165
Draft Minutes
o Directs the General Secretary, General Council to develop pilot initiatives to activate the
Spirit Awakening Strategy for the 2018-2021 triennium in collaboration with Embracing
the Spirit.
Carried
PMM 15 – Iridesce: the Living Apology Project
Note that this motion had been updated by the Permanent Committee on Programs from what
had been circulated in the workbook.
Facilitation Group’s remarks:
Affirmations for the importance of the work
Sadness raised about delaying a formal apology from the church
Recognition of the reasons for delaying the timeline
Consensus to move forward
Motion: Ken DeLisle/Wendy Brown 2018-03-03-190
The Executive of the General Council:
a) Receives this proposal
b) Invites the 43rd General Council to:
i. Recommit The United Church of Canada to the full inclusion of all people.
ii. Extends The Living Apology Project, to report to the spring 2020 meeting of the
Executive of the General Council
iii. Requests the Executive / General Secretary to appoint a group to work with the
outcomes of The Living Apology Project, to offer an apology to the LGBTQ2+
community at the Denominational Council in 2021
iv. Reaffirms the church's endorsement of the Affirming Ministries Program and invites
all communities of faith to participate.
v. Directs the General Secretary, General Council to develop resources for ministers,
church leadership, and the wider church in their ministry with LGBTQ2+
communities that:
a. offers pastoral care
b. creates opportunities for healing and reconciliation c. demonstrates respectful
engagement in conflict/disagreement
Carried
TICIF 4 – Theologies of Adoption
Facilitation Group’s remarks:
Affirmations of the strength of the report
How much learning needs to happen before the church is ready to engage in An Act of
Repentance?
General desire for adoption and affirmation of the report
One group suggested encouraging more conversation to see if the further actions are
possible
Motion: Sean Handcock/Donalee Williams 2018-03-03-191
The Executive of the General Council:
166 The Executive of the General Council, March 3, 2018, Online Meeting
Draft Minutes
o Adopts the report and asks the General Secretary, General Council to place the report on
the United Church’s website;
o Commends the report to the Church for study and guidance for making decisions that
reflect ethical adoption practices;
o Repents for its part during the 1940 – 1980 period in the general societal shaming of
women who gave birth to children outside a marriage relationship;
o Consider doing further research into the policies and practices of United Church-run
maternity homes during the 1940 – 1980 period to determine whether residents were
coerced into placing their children for adoption.
Carried
Closing Procedural Motion
Authorizing the Sub-Executive of the General Council
Motion: Nora Sanders/SungMin Jung 2018-03-03-192
That the Executive of the General Council authorize its Sub-Executive to deal with the business
placed before it by this meeting of the Executive and any emergent business that may arise prior
to the next meeting of the Executive of the General Council.
Carried
The Moderator and General Secretary extended their thanks and courtesies to the staff and
volunteers who supported this meeting.
Theological Reflection
Bill Smith led a theological reflection.
The Moderator closed the meeting with a prayer and extinguished the Christ candle.
The meeting finished at 6:40 p.m. EST.
_______________________________ ____________________________________
Moderator, Jordan Cantwell General Secretary, Nora Sanders