Download - Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
1/21
In this issueCost, quality and effort - the shiftingshopper trade offAre western economies down-and-out orwill they bounce?New frontiers in scienceHighlights from the IGD Convention
audience pollFour innovation trends for 2012Issue seven: Autumn 2011In this issueCost, quality and effort - the shiftingshopper trade offAre western economies down-and-out orwill they bounce?New frontiers in scienceHighlights from the IGD Conventionaudience pollFour innovation trends for 2012
Issue seven: Autumn 2011
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
2/21
ISSUE SEVEN AUTUMN 2011
Cost, quality and effort the shifting shopper trade-off
By IGDs shopper insight manager, Tim Maton
TThe latest financial squeeze is shiftingshopper behaviour once again. Itwould be far too simplistic to viewthis just in terms of trading down. Thereality is much more interesting and theresponses available to companies muchbroader.
The value prism
The shopper value equation has oftenbeen viewed as the balance of twofactors: cost and quality. Thats toosimple. Charting shoppers through recentturbulent times has reinforced our view ofthe importance of the third dimension tovalue: time and effort.
Weve been following how shoppers havemanaged a three-way trade off betweencost, quality (including ethics) and effort.Looking through this three cornered
prism not only helps us better understandthe decisions people have taken already,it also helps anticipate their next moves.
2008/09: Savvy shopping
In normal circumstances, most shoppersare creatures of habit. They buy mainlythe same products in the same stores atthe same time, each week. However, theglobal recession of 2008/09 jolted manyshoppers out of their habits, encouragingthem to economise.
Those thinking only in two-dimensionsat the time anticipated a big swingtowards budget ranges. There was somemovement in that direction but the effectwas muted. There was also no discernibledecline in ethical shopping.
Shoppers are always highly resistant tolowering their standards, viewing this as apersonal failure. When hit by an economicshock, their first resort is to seek ways to
save money without sacrificing quality.They can achieve this by trading time andeffort against expense. Its been called
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
3/21
savvy shopping.
HighExpenseGreaterEffortLower
QualityThe value prism 2010: Holding position2008-09:SavvyShopping2011: Return of thesavvy shopperHighExpenseGreaterEffortLowerQuality
HighExpenseGreaterEffortLowerQualityHighExpenseGreaterEffortLowerQuality2010: Holding position
During 2010, as the economy showedsome glimmers of recovery, shoppersstayed in a holding position. A sense ofuncertainty about the future remainedalthough there was a slight migrationback towards paying a premium forconvenience.
2011: Return of the savvyshopper
The current year has seen another waveof fuel and food inflation, governmentspending cutbacks, tax increases, rescuepackages for European economies andmuch speculation about a return torecession.
Almost four in ten (37%) British shoppersnow say they are trying to save moneyfrom their grocery shopping bill, up froma quarter (26%) in October last year.So the savvy shopper has re-emerged,returning to the tactics deployed in 2009,
only more so.
1.
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
4/21
Comparing prices. A greater numberof shoppers are making moreconsidered decisions scrutinisingprice and promotions. In fact 41%of British shoppers say theyretaking more time over shopping andchoosing products, up from 25% in
2008.2. Shopping around. Almost half(46%) of British shoppers claim to beshopping around more since the turnof the year, a marked increase fromthe 27% saying this three years ago.Our data confirms this fits a Europe-wide trend for shoppers expandingtheir repertoire of stores andchannels, flexing spend, dependingon where they find the best value.3.
Self sufficiency. Two-fifths (39%) ofBritish shoppers claim to be cookingmore from scratch up from 27% in2008. Over a quarter (27%) say theyhave been making more packedlunches, compared with 18% claimingthis three years ago.4.Seeking alternatives. Since thebeginning of the year, shoppers have
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
5/21
Hunting harder for value Hunting harder for valueshown a greater preparedness toexperiment with private label.More than a third (36%) of Britishshoppers say they intend to buy moremid-tier private label products in the
year ahead, up from 26% at the endof 2010. Shoppers only stick withprivate label when they are satisfiedwith the quality (except in desperatecircumstances) but 79% believequality has improved over the last twoyears.
2012: What next?
As the economic squeeze continues andpossibly intensifies, shoppers will find
it more difficult to save money withoutsacrificing quality. However, mostshoppers are still far from exhaustingtheir options and have highlighted twotactics in particular that they intend topursue further over the remainder of theyear.
One is to apply greater budgetarydiscipline. Two-fifths (42%) of Britishshoppers intend to keep to a set budgetwhen shopping, which probably meanscutting down on discretionary impulse
purchases. This is an increase from the36% who have focused on it so far in2011.
The second tactic is to plan morecarefully and reduce waste. For example,39% intend to make better use ofleftovers, an increase from the 33% who
claim to have done so during the first halfof the year.
So shoppers can continue to trade effortagainst cost although not indefinitely.There is a limit to the effort shoppers arewilling and able to make. Eventually theywill begin to sacrifice quality and we haveseen more signs of this in recent months.
What does this mean forretailers?
Different companies specialise in servingdifferent parts of the value prism.However, the majority would like to see
lots of shoppers occupying the highexpense corner.
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
6/21
Unfortunately, a prolonged squeezewill force more people out of thiscorner. If so, most retailers would prefershoppers to head in the greater effortrather than the lower quality direction.Higher sales of ingredients would thenpartly compensate for falling sales of
convenience foods.
Retailers neednt be passive observersin this. They can exert a strong influenceby reducing the effort required to be asavvy shopper. For example:
Web-based, or better still,smartphone enabled services, suchas Leclercs Quiestlemonischer makecomparing prices easier
The Waitrose Quick Check serviceallows shoppers to keep a runningtotal of their bill while shopping
Weekly meal plans, such asSainsburys Feed the Family for 50per Week help shoppers to managetheir household budget and to reducefood waste
The Great Taste, Less Wasteprogramme at Morrisons is positionedas a campaign to help shoppers
get more meals for their money byreducing waste and making the mostof fresh food
Methods like these encourage shoppersto spend less. However, for retailers,thats much better than losing theircustom entirely. Theres plenty more thatretailers could and probably will do alongthese lines. The contest is on to establishthemselves as the savvy shoppers allyas they seek to save money withoutsacrificing quality.
What does it mean formanufacturers?
Branded manufacturers can also helpfamilies to economise. They can do so bymaking it less painful to trade down onquality, for instance through new entrylevel brands.
However, peering through the valueprism suggests some potentially more
attractive alternatives. For instance:
Introducing more semi-finished
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
7/21
branded products (such as a syrup or
cake mix)
New forms of packaging to cut waste
Participating with retailers to producefixed budget meal plans.
Shoppers will continue to trade off threefactors in their search for best value. Onlyby looking at all three will companies seethe full range of possibilities.
Note that all the data cited in this articlecomes from IGDs new ShopperTrackservice, unless otherwise stated. If youwould like to discuss the ideas in this
article further, please do contact theauthor.
Follow @IGDShopperNews on Twitter
visit: www.igd.com
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
8/21
ISSUE SEVEN Autumn 2011
Are western economies down-and-out or will they
bounce back?
By IGDs chief economist, James Walton
FFour years after the Credit Crunchand it is difficult to disputethat the Western world is livingthrough something much more than thedownward leg of a typical business cycle.
Debt continues to rise. Political unity
is crumbling. Power and influence isshifting. Critical resources are becomingincreasingly scarce. New technologiesare destabilising established businessmodels. These and other forces areeroding the foundations of the Westsprosperity.
The question facing America, Europeand Japan is no longer when will therecovery arrive but will there ever bea full recovery? Some are questioningwhether we might have passed the peak
of prosperity in developed countries.
In these conditions, what assumptionscan we make about the future of Westernmarkets and how should companiesprepare?
Cycles of history
To answer these questions we shouldlook back as well as forward. Todayscircumstances may feel unique butstability is historically rare; flux andchange are the norm. There have beennumerous examples of economic andpolitical structures which have emerged,prospered, failed and been replaced.
Some economists argue that businesscycles typically quite short are not theonly ones at play. There are also longerterm cycles which define whole eras inhuman development.
The Kondratiev Wave theory was
proposed in 1925 by Russian economistNikolai Kondratiev. He suggested thateconomic activity fluctuates along a
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
9/21
predictable path, with each cycle lasting40-60 years.
The wave articleAt certain stages these historical rhythmscan overpower the business cycle. TheVenezuelan economist Carlota Perez
believes this is what were experiencingnow.
Perez associates long waves with theemergence, adoption, saturationand maturity of transformationaltechnologies, along with the social andcultural changes which accompany them.
She identifies five economic wavessince the 1770s, each driven by a set oftechnologies, as shown below. Cycle time
for the four completed waves varied butaveraged about 50 years.
According to Perez, each cycle dividesinto four phases:
1.Installation in which newtechnologies challenge the old andinvestors pour in capital to profit froma rising market, eventually creating aspeculative bubble.
2. Turning point the bubble burstscausing a shake-out. Althoughdestructive, this phase is essential toprogress.3. Deployment proven approaches inthe installation phase see widespreadadoption, creating new prosperity.4.Exhaustion technologiesbecome mature and the benefitsdwindle, causing a search for newbreakthroughs.Perezs idea is visualised by IGD in thechart above. The exact height of eachwave isnt important but notice that eachwave of technical development drivestwo pulses of economic growth before itis spent.
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
10/21
What next?
According to Perez, cheap energy andtransport (the foundations of the previousera) are giving way to cheap informationand its transmission. The Credit Crunch
marked the end of phase one of thedigital age and now were now livingthrough the turning point ahead of themass deployment phase.
This rollout could include: superfastbroadband across all developed
Technology alone is not enough toprogress the cycle. It requires technologyand capital to work in concert. A healthybanking system is required and yet todays
system is badly damaged, unable tosupport technology deployment at thepace required.
Political and social circumstances mustalso be conducive. Today, however,governments across the Western worldface a near-universal fiscal crisis asexpectations for social provision collide
sheet, pay close attention to staffmorale and otherwise build yourbusiness resilience.
3.Relinquish some of the old noteverything will be swept away but thevalue of some assets will erode as thecost of information falls and the costof fossil fuel rises. Anticipating thetrends early will allow you to divestat the right time, freeing funds forinvestment.4.Usher in the new the keycountries, affordable smartphones
worldwide, cloud based storage of data,
printed electronic tags, voice activated
with limited means, bringing sociodemographicgroups into conflict.
2005
characteristics of the next phase
will be digital, sustainable and
global development, so invest and
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
11/21
devices, automatic language translation,artificial intelligence automating manymore tasks and widespread use ofsensors to deliver live feedback.
Most industries will then undergo a
shake-out as new models supplantthe old. The media and entertainmentsectors are experiencing this alreadyand many others, including retail, arebecoming destabilised. Farming andmanufacturing are not immune asemerging technologies and rising energycosts upturn their financial equations.
However, we can expect great economicand social benefits from this process.Perez acknowledges that technology
is only part of the story and describesthe opportunity as using technology tohelp build a sustainable economy thatpromotes full global development.
Her vision is that the period from 2020 to2040 becomes the next golden era asthe information age promotes education,co-operation, democracy, health,efficiency and stability.
Whats holding us back?
This analysis is therefore cause for longterm optimism but there are also reasonsfor medium term pessimism.
Deployment is, therefore, on a go-slowuntil the financial and political systems arereformed and stabilised. Given the scaleof the challenge, this period will last someconsiderable time.
What it means forcompanies
Any model of change is only ever asimplification of reality but these ideashave the ring of truth.
Western markets are down and could staydown for a prolonged period but theyhavent been knocked out!
For business leaders, the task is to chart acourse through extended turbulence withthe aim of eventually capitalising on thenext era of prosperity.
What are the key principles that businessleaders should apply in setting that
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
12/21
course?
1.Play a long game set attainablegoals for the medium term andmanage expectations but set sightshigh for the long term.
2.Manage risk be sceptical abouteconomic forecasts, anticipatevolatility, maintain a healthy balanceencourage radical thinking in these
areas.
5.Remember the social factor consumers as well as companies willexperience dislocation and will need
reassurance from business that thesituation is under control so put astrong emphasis on building trust andtransparency.6.Watch for the upturn when theupswing finally arrives it will be morepowerful than a normal businesscycle. Recognising this early andresponding decisively will bring greatfirst-mover advantage.7.Get a head start the seeds of the
next techno-era are probably withus today and will likely involve acombination of renewable energy,biotechnology and nanotechnology.If you would like to discuss how the forcesdescribed in this article are likely to affectyour company, please dont hesitate tocontact the author.
Follow James on Twitter@jameswalton_IGD
visit: www.igd.com
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
13/21
ISSUE SEVEN Autumn 2011
New frontiers in science
By IGDs nutrition and scientific affairs manager, Rachel Hackett
WWe are still only part way throughthe digital revolution with manymore developments yet tocome. However, if these prove insufficientto regenerate economic growth, whereelse should we look for a technologybased boost?
Here IGD runs its rule over the maincandidates.
Energy
An energy revolution is beginning tounfold as we replace fossil fuels withrenewable sources. The solution is likelyto lie in a combination of technologiesrather than a single breakthrough.
Technologies to watch out for include:
More efficient ways to convert waste
to fuelNew fuel cells for small-scalelightweight applications: laptops,phones etc
Lower cost, more efficient solarenergy
Microbial fuels, e.g. algae
Geothermal energy (extracting heatfrom the earths crust)
Using artificial intelligence to manageenergy efficiently e.g. homeenergy management systems, smartelectricity grids
Nuclear fusion
Nanotechnology
Engineering at the nanoscale allowsthe development of new materials withsuperior properties some of which can be
used in novel ways. Everyday consumerproducts can be made lighter, stronger,cleaner, less expensive, more efficient
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
14/21
and more precise.
Nanoelectronics will prolong the trendfor miniaturisation meaning that moreinformation can be stored in ever smallerdevices.
Applications to look out for include:
Food ingredients delivering improvednutrition, safety and shelf life
Better performing portable fuel cells
for powering vehicles and appliances
Lightweight yet very strong materialsfor buildings, vehicles etc
Coatings for buildings, glass andmachines that reduce environmentalimpact, vibration, corrosion etc
Intelligent devices to monitorhealth, e.g. blood pressure, glucose,cholesterol
Medical devices for implantation
Genomics
Cost reductions and increasing speed
are making genome sequence data morereadily accessible both for humans andother life forms. This is generating anew branch of information technology:genomic information.
Applications to look out for include:
For humans: use of geneticinformation for medical markers,health diagnostics and personalisednutrition
Improved traceability andidentification of foods and otherbiological materials
More rapid selective breeding ofcrops for food and fuels (withoutusing GM techniques)
Further applications of GM for
animals, plants and microbes
Advances in understanding theinteraction between nutrition andother factors determining health
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
15/21
Synthetic biology
Eventually, we will be able to designand engineer forms of life fromscratch. New DNA sequences could beconstructed to create biological parts
and whole organisms to perform specificapplications.
The risks and ethics in this field willbe hotly debated but the potential isenormous and applications could include:
New processes for synthesisingchemicals and pharmaceutica
Highly efficient biofuels
Biosensors which flag any changesin biological fluids and tissue e.g. formonitoring human health or waterpollution
Bioremediation to removecontaminants, e.g. desalinating water
In vitro production of food e.g. meat
The dazzling potential of todays scientificleading edge suggests that if we can
repair the worlds financial system thenwe have the potential to enter anotherperiod of prolonged prosperity.
With digital technology grabbing somuch of the attention, far-sightedcompanies might be able to outflank thecompetition by casting their sights morebroadly and becoming early adopters ofother groundbreaking scientific fields.
Feel free to contact the author for furtherinsight.
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
16/21
ISSUE SEVEN AUTUMN 2011
Highlights from the IGD Convention audience poll
Over 700 directors and senior managers attended the 2011 IGD Convention on the t
heme ofbreakthrough innovation in October. Here are some of the highlights of the audience poll.
Which of these factors is currently causing you the
Whats happening to your R&D budget?
biggest headaches?
1Consumers/shoppers
1234On the increase
4%2 Rising input costs
35%
Holding steady
348%
Skill shortages39%
9%
45In decline
Changing regulations
4%
14%
A negative climate in the media
R&D budgets...those were the days
5%
6Tackling sustainability12%
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
17/21
1%
7Problems in raising capital1%
8Slow pace of consumer spending28%
Which part of the world is the biggest source ofinnovation in your market sector?
1UK
Whats been happening to innovation in your
29%
market sector?
2Rest of Europe
10%
1Theres been more of it3North America
30%
218%
Its been less frequent but in bigger steps44Asia
17%
319%53%
Its being squeezed5Nowhere stands out
24%
Whats happened to the pace of innovation in your What experience has your business had with phonebusiness? apps?
1Weve speeded it up
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
18/21
32%
21234
Theyre delivering measurable benefits for usWere working on speeding it up
11%
43%
3Weve dabbled but weve not seen a benefit yet
No change8%
24%4 Its deliberately slower as we focus on bigger steps8%
Were working on it5Unfortunately, its slowing down
46%7%
Were happy to let our competitors waste their time this way
6 Its ground to a halt
19%
2%
IGDs 2012 Convention will be held on 9 October and is now open for bookings at aspecial early birdrate. More information is available at igd.com/convention.
visit: www.igd.com
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
19/21
ISSUE SEVENAutumn 2011
Four innovation trends for 2012
By Jonathan Gunz, senior analyst - retail innovation
The parlous state of the world economy is forcing companies to return to the drawing board in search of new and sustainable modelsfor growth. Weve identified four trends in particular that are gaining momentum in response to this challenge.
3Trend 1: Collaborative consumptionWhats the idea?Instead of owning equipment (such as a drill) that you onlyuse very occasionally, why not form a community consortiumto buy and own it collectively? Such groups can also use theirbuying power to get better deals on various products and
services.ExamplesGroupon, LivingSocial and BuyaPowa connect people onlineto get better deals. Sobeys (Canada), Real (Germany) andMakro (Czech Republic) are amongst the first food retailersto encourage group promotions and buying techniques.Our VerdictIn many cultures, there has been a trend towardsindividualism but financial necessity and the ease ofconnecting online might now reverse this. Collaborativeconsumption is not about to become mainstream but willgrow in popularity.Trend 2: Pop-up paradise
Whats the idea?Why invest in expensive land, bricks and mortar if you canquickly and cheaply provide a temporary shop in locationswhere large groups are congregating? Digital technologyopens up new possibilities for this and manufacturers can get inon the act too.ExamplesTescos virtual store in a Korean subway is a potential landmarkevent and others are already testing the concept, includingOcado in London. Tesco also turned back the clock with a1950s vintage pop up store at Goodwood Races. Otherscreating temporary shops/exhibitions include Target, P&G,Unilever, Twinings, Danone and Coca-Cola.Our VerdictIt used to be said that retailing was about location, location,location. Taking stores to the people rather than attractingpeople to the stores is a powerful concept. If technology canmake this easier then retailing might never be the same again.Follow Jonathan on Twitter @gunz_IGDTrend 3: Customisation
Whats the idea?
People have always been willing to pay extra for certain productsor services if they are tailored to personal preference. The
problem has been to provide this economically. Now, newtechnologies are making customisation more affordable, not onlyfor production but marketing and communication too.
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
20/21
Examples
In the US, Wrigley consumers are able to design their ownpackaging whereas in Israel, they can print their photo on to a canof Coca Cola. The Sainsburys website includes a personalisedmeal planning service. Before long we will see personalised offers
delivered to shoppers via their phones when entering a store.
Our Verdict
Marketing has already become much more fragmented and theage of mass production is also gradually coming to an end. Theuptake of genetic profiling could accelerate customisation forfood by creating demand for personalised nutrition. Some of thetraditional economies of scale will eventually disappear whichcould be good news for small companies.
Trend 4: Cradle-to-cradle thinking
Whats the idea?
Why pay a rapidly rising fee to dispose of waste when you canconvert it into a new and valuable resource? If you take a zerotolerance approach to waste, right from the product designstage, then almost everything, including energy, water andmaterials can be recaptured and reused.
Examples
Cumbrian Seafoods is converting shells to cement. Unileverhas achieved its zero waste to landfill target across all 11 of its
UK manufacturing sites. Pepsico and Robert Wiseman are atthe leading edge of cleaning and reusing water. Sainsburys isrunning vehicles powered by food waste. There are countlessother examples.
Our Verdict
This concept is business critical. Any company failing to take acradle-to-cradle approach will be exposed both to rising costsand public condemnation.
If you would like to discuss any of these articles and their implications for your business in more detail,contact Adrian Williams, head of customised development, on [email protected].
IGD, Grange Lane, Letchmore Heath, Watford, Herts, WD25 8GD, UKPhone: +44 (0) 1923 857141 www.igd.com
-
8/3/2019 Thought Lines Autumn 2011[1]
21/21