Download - To Empower People
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 1/27
To Empower People: From StateTo Empower People: From State
to Civil Societyto Civil Society
Peter L. Berger and Richard John Peter L. Berger and Richard John
Neuhaus Neuhaus
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 2/27
Central ProblemCentral Problem
Desire for government servicesDesire for government services
Strong dislike of government and bureaucracyStrong dislike of government and bureaucracy
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 3/27
Societal ConceptionsSocietal Conceptions
MegastructuresMegastructures
Private ifePrivate ife
Mediating StructuresMediating Structures
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 4/27
E!amples of MegastructuresE!amples of Megastructures
T"e StateT"e State
Corporations# $ig $usinessCorporations# $ig $usiness
Educational $ureaucracyEducational $ureaucracy %rgani&ed Professions%rgani&ed Professions
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 5/27
Problems wit" t"e MegastructuresProblems wit" t"e Megastructures
'lienating to individuals('lienating to individuals(
)ot "elpful in providing meaning# fulfillment# )ot "elpful in providing meaning# fulfillment#
or identity to t"e individual(or identity to t"e individual(
*iewed as unreal or malignant*iewed as unreal or malignant
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 6/27
Problems wit" Private ifeProblems wit" Private ife
+solating+solating
Cannot be relied upon , unstableCannot be relied upon , unstable
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 7/27
E!amples of Mediating StructuresE!amples of Mediating Structures
)eig"bor"ood )eig"bor"ood
FamilyFamily
C"urc"C"urc" *oluntary 'ssociation*oluntary 'ssociation
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 8/27
*alue of Mediating Structures*alue of Mediating Structures
$ridge gap between private life and$ridge gap between private life and
megastructuresmegastructures
-ive stability to private life-ive stability to private life
Provide meaning and value to megastructures.Provide meaning and value to megastructures.
+f meaning is lost# democracy suffers(+f meaning is lost# democracy suffers(
Provide moral basis to political order# so orderProvide moral basis to political order# so order
is secured t"roug" consent not coercionis secured t"roug" consent not coercion
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 9/27
iberalismiberalism
Tends to be blind to t"e functions of mediatingTends to be blind to t"e functions of mediating
structuresstructures
-reater concern for t"e individual and a /ust-reater concern for t"e individual and a /ust
public order public order
Defends private rig"tsDefends private rig"ts from from t"e mediatingt"e mediating
structures 0"ostile to t"e idea t"at religion "asstructures 0"ostile to t"e idea t"at religion "as
public rig"ts and public functions1 public rig"ts and public functions1
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 10/27
ConservatismConservatism
2eld mediating structures in "ig" regard2eld mediating structures in "ig" regard
before t"e 34t" century before t"e 34t" century
)ow "as a tendency to revoke modernity )ow "as a tendency to revoke modernity
Sensitive to t"e alienations of big government#Sensitive to t"e alienations of big government#
but blind to t"e same effects of big business but blind to t"e same effects of big business
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 11/27
Proposition 3Proposition 3
Mediating structures are essential for a vitalMediating structures are essential for a vitaldemocracydemocracy +f mediating structures didn5t generate and+f mediating structures didn5t generate and
maintain values# t"e State would( 6"en values aremaintain values# t"e State would( 6"en values aredetermined top7down# t"e government isdetermined top7down# t"e government is
aut"oritarian# not democratic(aut"oritarian# not democratic(
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 12/27
Proposition 8Proposition 8
Public policy s"ould protect and fosterPublic policy s"ould protect and foster
mediating structures(mediating structures(
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 13/27
Proposition 9Proposition 9
Public policy s"ould utili&e mediatingPublic policy s"ould utili&e mediating
structures for t"e reali&ation of socialstructures for t"e reali&ation of social
purposes( purposes( isk of government cooption of mediatingisk of government cooption of mediating
structuresstructures
-oal is to e!pand government services wit"out-oal is to e!pand government services wit"outincreasing government oppressivenessincreasing government oppressiveness
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 14/27
EmpowermentEmpowerment
Feeling of powerlessness caused by facelessFeeling of powerlessness caused by facelesscontrolling institutions wit" different valuescontrolling institutions wit" different values
t"an t"e individualt"an t"e individual Easier for t"e affluent to resist t"eEasier for t"e affluent to resist t"e
encroac"ment of t"e megastructuresencroac"ment of t"e megastructures
Policy based on t"e mediating structures aimsPolicy based on t"e mediating structures aimsto empower poor people to do t"e t"ings t"eto empower poor people to do t"e t"ings t"emore affluent can already domore affluent can already do
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 15/27
NeighborhoodNeighborhood
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 16/27
-ood )eig"bor"oods-ood )eig"bor"oods
SafeSafe
SanitarySanitary
C"osen freelyC"osen freely
2ave varying degrees of social co"esion(2ave varying degrees of social co"esion(
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 17/27
$ad )eig"bor"oods$ad )eig"bor"oods
$ad neig"bor"oods can be:$ad neig"bor"oods can be:
+gnored+gnored
Dismantled and redistributedDismantled and redistributed T"reatening to non7poor T"reatening to non7poor
Doesn5t make poor less poor# /ust moves t"em aroundDoesn5t make poor less poor# /ust moves t"em around
May make t"e poor feel worse# since t"eir poverty willMay make t"e poor feel worse# since t"eir poverty will
s"ow in starker contrast by new pro!imity to non7poor s"ow in starker contrast by new pro!imity to non7poor
TransformedTransformed
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 18/27
Policy -oalsPolicy -oals
Sustain diversity of neig"bor"oods(Sustain diversity of neig"bor"oods(
Counter destruction of neig"bor"oods causedCounter destruction of neig"bor"oods caused
by court /udgments t"at treat all communities by court /udgments t"at treat all communities
alikealike
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 19/27
C"allengesC"allenges
)eig"bor"oods empowered to impose t"eir )eig"bor"oods empowered to impose t"eir
values on individuals can be coercive and cruelvalues on individuals can be coercive and cruel -overnment intervention necessary to protect-overnment intervention necessary to protect
elementary "uman rig"ts 0race1(elementary "uman rig"ts 0race1(
Conflict between individual and communalConflict between individual and communalrig"ts due to t"e un/ust e!tension of policiesrig"ts due to t"e un/ust e!tension of policiesderiving from racial dilemma(deriving from racial dilemma(
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 20/27
acism as community c"aracteristicacism as community c"aracteristic
Focus public policy on neig"bor"ood7definedFocus public policy on neig"bor"ood7definedneig"bor"ood development to bring up poorneig"bor"ood development to bring up poorcommunities(communities( 's t"ey ac"ieve middle class goals# racism will be reduced's t"ey ac"ieve middle class goals# racism will be reduced
or separated from ot"er discrimination and will be moreor separated from ot"er discrimination and will be moreeasily prosecuted(easily prosecuted(
'c"ievement of individuals doesn5t necessarily mean'c"ievement of individuals doesn5t necessarily mean
t"ey5ll move out of poor neig"bor"oods(t"ey5ll move out of poor neig"bor"oods( Media# c"urc"es# sc"ools# government# etc( must continueMedia# c"urc"es# sc"ools# government# etc( must continue
and intensify efforts to educate against racial bias(and intensify efforts to educate against racial bias(
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 21/27
Specific ecommendationsSpecific ecommendations
eturn ta! money in non7categorical ways to be spent as neig"bor"oodseturn ta! money in non7categorical ways to be spent as neig"bor"oodsdeem necessarydeem necessary
Since we can5t force private financial institutions to make money availableSince we can5t force private financial institutions to make money availableto poor neig"bor"oods#to poor neig"bor"oods# 6e need a new version of t"e Federal 2ousing 'dministration6e need a new version of t"e Federal 2ousing 'dministration Property ta! regulations s"ould be c"anged to encourage "ome improvement(Property ta! regulations s"ould be c"anged to encourage "ome improvement(
Strengt"en neig"bor"oods by giving t"em more responsibility for lawStrengt"en neig"bor"oods by giving t"em more responsibility for lawenforcement(enforcement( Funding for part7time employment of parents to police sc"ools and publicFunding for part7time employment of parents to police sc"ools and public
places( places(
%pen up unused airwaves to regional# et"nic# and elective groups to fig"t%pen up unused airwaves to regional# et"nic# and elective groups to fig"tmedia "omogeni&ationmedia "omogeni&ation
Ta!ation policies and postal regulations s"ould support neig"bor"oodTa!ation policies and postal regulations s"ould support neig"bor"oodnewspapersnewspapers
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 22/27
FamilyFamily
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 23/27
edefined# but not in declineedefined# but not in decline
2ig" divorce rate# but also "ig" remarriage2ig" divorce rate# but also "ig" remarriage
raterate
+ncludes foster parents# lesbian and gay+ncludes foster parents# lesbian and gay
parents# etc( parents# etc(
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 24/27
Policy -oal 3Policy -oal 3
ecogni&e family as an institutionecogni&e family as an institution Society "as a vested interest in "ow values areSociety "as a vested interest in "ow values are
transmitted to t"e ne!t generation(transmitted to t"e ne!t generation( 6eak families produce uprooted individuals#6eak families produce uprooted individuals#
w"ic" make for ideal recruits for aut"oritarianw"ic" make for ideal recruits for aut"oritarian
movements(movements(
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 25/27
Policy -oal 8Policy -oal 8
%ppose policies t"at e!pose t"e c"ild directly%ppose policies t"at e!pose t"e c"ild directly
to state aut"ority wit"out t"e mediation of t"eto state aut"ority wit"out t"e mediation of t"e
familyfamily E!perts "ave relevant and "elpful e!pertiseE!perts "ave relevant and "elpful e!pertise
E!perts do not love or "ave long7term open endedE!perts do not love or "ave long7term open ended
commitment to individual c"ildrencommitment to individual c"ildren
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 26/27
Policy -oal 9Policy -oal 9
estore some control of education andestore some control of education and
economics t"at "as been stripped away byeconomics t"at "as been stripped away by
moderni&ationmoderni&ation
8/17/2019 To Empower People
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/to-empower-people 27/27
EducationEducation
State "as a coercive monopoly on education(State "as a coercive monopoly on education( ow7income parents "ave t"e least say about w"atow7income parents "ave t"e least say about w"at
"appens to t"eir kids in sc"ool("appens to t"eir kids in sc"ool( Personnel of t"e education establis"ment are upperPersonnel of t"e education establis"ment are upper
middle class(middle class( T"ey teac" t"eir upper middle class values(T"ey teac" t"eir upper middle class values(
Disparage t"e ways of life of t"e poor Disparage t"e ways of life of t"e poor Teac" contempt for t"e parents and self7contempt(Teac" contempt for t"e parents and self7contempt(
$est way to break up t"e monopoly is to allow c"oice$est way to break up t"e monopoly is to allow c"oice