![Page 1: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
© The Bulletproof Executive 2013
Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve – #264”
Bulletproof Radio podcast #264
![Page 2: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
2
Warning and Disclaimer
The statements in this report have not been evaluated by the FDA (U.S. Food & Drug Administration). Information provided here and products sold on bulletproofexec.com and/or upgradedself.com and/or betterbabybook.com are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure, or prevent any disease. The information provided by these sites and/or by this report is not a substitute for a face-to-face consultation with your physician, and should not be construed as medical advice of any sort. It is a list of resources for further self-research and work with your physician. We certify that at least one statement on the above-mentioned web sites and/or in this report is wrong. By using any of this information, or reading it, you are accepting responsibility for your own health and health decisions and expressly release The Bulletproof Executive and its employees, partners, and vendors from from any and all liability whatsoever, including that arising from negligence. Do not run with scissors. Hot drinks may be hot and burn you.
If you do not agree to the above conditions, please do not read further and delete this document.
![Page 3: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
3
Dave: Hey,it'sDaveAsprey.Beforewegetstartedwithtoday'sshowlet'stalkaboutCasperMattresses.ThestartupguidetoCasperarewinningdesignawards,gettingpropsforreinventingthehumblemattressandturningtheindustryupsidedown.Theystartedwithasimplemission,tocreateaperfectlyengineeredmattressthatyoucouldtryinthecomfortofyourownhome.Caspershipsthemattresstoyouforfreeandgivesyou100nightstotryit,againriskfree.They'llcomepickitupifyoudon'tloveitandrefundyoueverythingnoquestionsasked.UpgradingyoursleepisoneofthemoreimportantthingsyoucandotoincreaseyouroverallperformanceandCasperhascreatedaninexpensivewaytohackyourrestlessnights.Here'swhatelseIlikeaboutCasperMattresses.AllofthefoamsusedinCasperhaveenvironmentalcertificationsthatensurethey'rehealthytobearound.TheirmaterialsareSertaPurecertifiedmeaningthey'remadewithoutozonedepletersorPVDEflameretardants.
They'remadewithoutmercury,lead,andotherheavymetals.There'snoformaldehydeorthalatesandthey'reregulatedbytheConsumerProductSafetyCommissionaslowVOC.Takethemupontheir100nightriskfreetriallikeIdid.UpgradetoaCasperwithfreeshippingatcasper.com.UsemypersonalreferralcodeBULLETPROOFtoget$50offyourmattress.That'scodeBULLETPROOFfor$50offyourmattressatcasper.com.Termsandconditionsapply.
Audio: Bulletproofradio,astateofhighperformance.
Dave: Hey,it'sDaveAspreywithBulletproofradio.Today'scoolfactofthedayisthatifyoudon'tlikethesoundofpeoplebreathingorchewingyou'renotalone.Youmayactuallyhaveadisordercalledmisophoniawhichiswhenyouhaveanextremenegativeemotionalresponsetoauditorystimuli.Wedon'treallyknowwhetherthat'sbecauseofdysfunctionalsignalsintheneuronsoftheanteriorsinguletcortexandinsularcortex.ThosearerelatedtoTourette'ssyndrome,orwhetherit'sfromsomethingelsebutsomepeoplereally,reallydon'tlikeitwhenyoupopyourgumsoifyou'redoingthatmaybeyoushouldjustnotchewthegumbecauseit'sbadforyourtrigeminalnerveanyway.
![Page 4: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
4
It'stimetotalkaboutsomethingthatI'vebeenwaitingforallsummerlongandthatisthatwehavethenewchocolatefuelbarsthathavecomeout.Nowthatit'scoolenoughformetoshipyouchocolatewe'veenrichedthisstuffwithbrainoctaneoil,zerosugarchocolate.Thechocolate'slabtestedformoldtoxinsasyouwouldexpectandthisisthebestchocolateformulawe'vecomeupwithyet.Eachyearwetweakandtwistandyouaregoingtobeamazedatthenewchocolatefuelbars.Checkthemoutifyouhaven'thadachancetogiveitatry.Today'sguestissomeoneI'mreallyexcitedtohaveontheshow.He'sadistinguisheduniversityscientistatIndianaUniversitywhereherunsthetraumaresearchcenterintheKenzieInstitute.HisnameisDr.StevenPorgess.He'saprofessorofpsychiatryattheUniversityofNorthCarolina,aprofessoremeritusattheUniversityofIllinoisatChicago,andthereheranthebrainbodycenterandthedepartmentofpsychiatry,andhechairedthedepartmentofhumandevelopmentanddirectedtheinstituteforchildstudy.
Inotherwords,thisguy'sbeenstudyingthingsthatmakeusgoatvery,veryfinelevelsofdetailforprettymuchhiswholecareerandhe'shadavery,verydistinguishedone.Steven,welcometotheshow.
Steven: Thankyou,David.
Dave: Ionlyreadlike10%ofthecoolstuffyou'vedoneherebutyouwerepresidentofthepsychophysiologicalresearchandactuallyI'mnotevengoingtoreadallthatstuff,ahugebodyof20,000behavioralscientistsandyou'rethepresidentofthataswell.Forpeoplethatdon'tknowyou'resortoflikeoneoftheknownpeopleinyourfieldyoucouldsay.
Steven: Actually,that'sinthepastsoIdon'tdothattodaybutyes,myworkbasicallycrossesmanydisciplines,notmerelythebehavioralsciencesbutalsomanyoftheneurobiologicalsciences.
Dave: ThereasonIwantedtotalktoyoutodaywasthatyouaretheoriginalguywhoproposedsomethingcalledpolyvagaltheorywhichlinkedsortofhowourautomaticnervoussystem,orautonomicnervoussystemtiestosocialbehaviorsandIjustwouldloveforeveryonelisteningto
![Page 5: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
5
hearwhatispolyvagaltheoryandwhyshouldtheycareaboutit?That'sprobablyagreatwaytostarttheinterview.
Steven: Well,it'sprobablyagoodwaybutitcouldtakethewholeinterviewsoletmejustkindof,it'saquestionthatI'malwaysaskedandsurprisinglyIneverknowhowI'mgoingtoanswerit.Let'sbasicallybreakitdowntosomethingquitesimple.Whatcanwelearnfromtheevolutionofourspecies?Whatcanwelearnfromhowotheranimals,othervertebratesthatprecededusbehavedandfunctioned?Especiallyfromtheirautonomicnervoussystem.Whatcanwelearn?Whatwelearnedreallyisthatneurocircuitswereusedbymoreprimitivevertebratestobasicallyshutdown,tomakethemselvesappearinanimate.Itbecameadefensesystemandthenasvertebratesevolvedtheydevelopedsystemstomobilizeandweknowthisintermsofourownwordsasfightorflight.Thenwhathappenedwithmammalsisthattheyhadaneuroautonomicnervoussystemthatfunctionallygotlinkedtothenervesthatregulatetheirfaceandtheirvoice.
Basicallytheyweartheirheartintheirvoiceandontheirfaceandtheycommunicatethosequeuestoothers.OncewestartunderstandingaboutthesechangesintheautonomicnervoussystemwestartunderstandingwhatliterallyareneuroplatformsareforbehaviorandIjustwanttobasicallygivethemainpunchlinehereandthatiswhatweare,weactuallyareaproductofevolutionandthroughevolutionwedidn'tthrowouteverything.Werepurposeditandweuseditfordifferentpurposesandwechangeditslightly.Wehaveinourbodycircuitsthatcanbeusedfordefenseandcircuitsthatcanbeusedforsocialinteractionalbehaviors.Thosecircuitsfordefenseunfortunatelyhavebeenmisunderstoodbymostofbehavioralscientists,mostoftheclinicalscientistsaswellbecauseweliterallyhave2circuitsofdefense.
Wehavetheverypopularone,fightandflight,butwealsohaveamoreancientonewhichisashutdownimmobilization,becomeinanimate,deathfeigningandthisistheonethatistriggeredinindividualswhoarerestrainedandhavenooptiontogetout.Thesebecomeresponsestolifethreatandwhatthepolyvagaltheorydoes,itexplainsalotofthesebehaviorsandphysiologicalconsequenceswhichareanamazingnumberofphysicalhealthailmentswhichwewilldiscussthatco-occur
![Page 6: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
6
withshiftingintothesedifferentphysiologicalstates.PolyvagaltheoryinformsustounderstandournativebiologicalreactionstosafetycuesandtodangercuesandI'mgoingtocategorizeanotherone,lifethreateningcues.
Dave: Allright,thisisexciting.Anyonewho'slistenedtotheshowforawhileknowsItalkalotaboutautonomicnervoussystemactivation,heartratevariabilitytraining,essentiallyturningoffthefightorflightwhenit'snotservingyou.Whatyou'reteachingusandwhatyouproposedalittlebitmorethan20yearsagonowisthatthere's2systems,right?Canyougoalittlebitdeeperonthesecondsystemthatdoesn'thelpyourunawayfromtigers?
Steven: Thesecondsystemiswhatyouseeinpetstoresifyoulookatreptiles.Theyimmobilize.Theyjustdon'tmove.Theyinasensearetryingtobecomeinanimateandreptileshavethiscapacityandtheywilldefecateandtheywillstopbreathingandtheycandothisforlongperiodsoftimebecausetheirmetabolicdemandsareverylowandtheydon'tneedmuchoxygen.Theproblemiswhenmammalsdothisourmetabolicdemandsaregreat.Weneedlotsofoxygenandthiscanbepotentiallylethalsothemetaphorortheurbanmyththatthepersondiedoutoffearisthattheperson'sheartstoppedwiththismechanismwhichisthroughavagalpathway.WhatIdidn'tquiteexplainwasthatbasicallythepolyvagaltheorygotitsnamebecausetherewere2differentvagalpathwaysandthedifferentvagalpathwayshaddifferentfunctionaladaptivecapacities.
Theonethatyou'rereallyaskingmeisimmobilizationasadefensebutit'snotimmobilizationwithvoluntaryI'mgoingtositstillsoIwon'tbeeatenbythetiger.Mybodygoesthere.Idon'ttellittogothereandIdon'twantittogothereoftenandthisisreallytheconsequencesofpeoplewhohavesufferedveryseveretraumaexperiencesorabuseexperiences.Theirbodyjustshutsdownandpsychologicallythepartthatremainswiththemfordecadesisdissociation.Theygosomeplaceelse.
Dave: Howcommonisthatphenomenainthegeneralpopulation?
![Page 7: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
7
Steven: WellasIstarttouseinasensethetheorytodecodethebehaviorsofpeopleIamtotallyshockedatthenumberofpeoplewhofunctionallyhavelivedagoodportionoftheirlivesindissociativestatesandhavebeenunawareofit.Ofcoursethey'reunawarebecausethey'redissociated.Theissueispartofoursocietyhastodealwithtellingpeoplenottofeeltheirbody,to"getoverit,""livewithit,""proceedwithit,"andalsoalotofthemedicaltreatmentmodelsarereallymodelsofdampeningthefeedbackloopsfromourautonomicnervoussystemthatsupportourhealth,growth,andrestorationbecausesometimesthosesignalsaretellingusthere'sbadstuffgoingon.
Ithinkit'squitecommonandwhatIoftensayinmytalks,IsaywhatifDakarwasmisinterpreted?Whatifhedidn'treallysay“jepensedoncjesuis”.Nowyou'regoingtohearmyhorribleFrenchaccentbutyou'reinCanada,youprobablyarticulateitbetter,buthesaysIthinkthereforeIam.Whatifhehadsaid“Jemesensdoncjesuis”?Ifeelmybody,IfeelmyselfthereforeIam.IfyouknowFrenchIselectedthereflexiveverbwhichisnottofeeltotouchbuttofeelone'sselfandthatisevenmissingfromourlanguageinEnglish.Wedon'thaveadifferentworkforfeelingobjectversusfeelingourselvessowegetconfusedwithouruseofwords.
WhatifhehadsaidIfeelmyself,thereforeIam.Nowaskanyonewhohassufferedfromseveretraumaexperiencesorabuse,theydon'tfeeltheirbodies.Thatiswhatgoes.
Dave: I'mgoingtoaskyoutodoanarmchairdiagnosiswhichyouevergetateverycocktailparty,butnotreallyanarmchairdiagnosisbutI'lljustrelayapersonalanecdotethatIthinksupportsthisbutjusttellmeifitdoes.Ididapersonalgrowthseminaralongtimeago,morethan15yearsago,andIwasworkingwithaverytalentedtranspersonalkindofpsychologistandIwasfeelingreally,reallyuncomfortableaboutthewholething.BasicallyshesaidyouhavetobefeelingsomethingandIsaidyeah,I'mfeelingprettyangryaboutthiswholethingsoI'mfeelingjustfinethankyouverymuch.Shesaidthenwhydoyouwanttoleavetheroom,whyareyouuncomfortable?IsaidIdon'treallyknowbutit'sjustbecauseI'mpissedoff.Afteradayofthiskindofarguingwithme
![Page 8: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
8
finallyshesaidistheresomeotherfeelinginyourbody?Isaidyeah,mystomachfeelsalittleweird.
Shelooksatmeandshegoesyeah,thatfeeling?That'scalledfear.I'mlikereally?BecauseIhadinternalizedthatwhilethereisnoreasontobeafraidthereforeI'mnotafraidthereforeI'lljustignoreallthatstuff.SincethenI'velearnednottoignorethosethingsbecausethere'sactuallyvalueinthesignal.Isthiswhatwe'retalkingaboutoristhatsomethingelse?
Steven: Well,it'spartofit.Inmymodelingthere'saconceptthatIcallneuroceptionandthat'sthedetectionofriskordangerintheenvironment.Thisisnotperception.Perceptionisacognitionandthat'swhatyouwereinvolvedin.Youweren'tcognitivelyperceivinganythingbutyourbodywasrespondingsothat'sneuroceptioninmyterminology.Yournervousnessmadeyouevaluateriskandsaidokay,somethingnotgoodishappeningsoyouhavethesebodilyfeelings.ThewordI'mtendingtousenowisthatthesearenowimplicitfeelingsandnowyou'restuckintheworldofhowdoyoudealwithimplicitfeelings?Wellyoutrytogetexplicitlanguageandactivity.Inasensethatbecomesthewholethemeofalltraumatherapiesthataresuccessfulandthatishavingpeoplelearntounderstandtheirimplicitfeelingsandtocontainthemandtokindofregulatethemwithexplicitorvoluntarybehavior.We'llseethisinothertypesoftherapieswhichI'msureyou'llaskmebutwhatyouhad,somewhereinthatroomyourbodywaspickingupcues,yournervoussystem.
Notnecessarilyyourconsciousawarenessandit'snotevenkinkybecauseaverysmallpartofoursensoryreactionsareactuallydealingwithconsciousawareness.Ourbrainisabigorganandit'sprocessinginformationevenathighlevels.Throughevolutionweevaluatedrisknotthroughaninternaldecisionofisthatdangerousorisitnotdangerous?ShouldIgetintothatcar?ShouldInotgetintothecar?Thosedecisionsweremadeveryrapidlywithabiologicalresponsethatwethenactedwith.Whathappenedtoyouisyougotabiologicalresponseandyouwantedtoactwithitornotactwithit.Yougotintothatdialogue.
![Page 9: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
9
Dave: TheworkingtheoryforwhathappenedisthatIwasactuallybornwiththeumbilicalcordaroundmyneckandIwasposteriorsoIhadsubstantialbirthtraumaandwhatwasgoingonintheroomwasotherpeopleintheworkshopweredealingwiththeirownbirthstuffanditmademynervoussystemanywayfeelreallyuncomfortablebecausetherewasasurvivallevelthreat,atleastitthoughtthat.Iknewtherewasn'tbutthefactyouknowitandyoufeelit,theydidn'tmatch.
Steven: Okay,yougavemeenoughinformationformetodeconstructit.Ratherthansaybirthtraumabecausethatcarrieswithitallkindsofpsychoanalyticdiscussions,let'ssayyouhadahypoxicresponse.Now,thebody'sresponsetohypoxiaislifethreat.It'sshuttingdown.Phylogeneticallyandalsodevelopmentallyhowdowedealifourbodystartstoshutdown?There'sonlyonethingwecando.Wemobilizebecauseifwemobilizesincetheautonomicnervoussystemishierarchicallyorganized,andwe'llgetbacktothat,aslongaswemobilizeournervoussystemcan'tshutdown.Youfindoutthatpeoplewhohavetraumaexperiencesareoftendoingrisktakingbehaviorsandhighactivitybehaviors.It'sbecausetheirbodyknowsthatiftheysitstillthey'renowvulnerabletoshuttingdown.
Dave: Wow.
Steven: Okay,yougotitalittlebecauseyouareamobilizer.
Dave: Justalittlebit.
Steven: Theissueis,infactifyoustartaskingquestionsaboutpeoplebaseduponthetraumahistorytherearetermsyoucanseeevenintheirbody,andthesearewordsthatyou'llprobablycomeupwithfromotherpeople,tightlywrappedintermsofthemusclesaretightandyoumightsayohthat'sananxioustypeperson,oryou'dhearintheirvoice.Theywouldbetakingveryfewslowexhalationsandthereasontheywouldn'tbeexhalingairslowlyisthatthatwouldputtheminamoreofthisvagalcalmstateandthey'rescaredofthat.
Dave: Let'stalkaboutthevagalnerveandthevagalresponsebecauseIthinkalotofpeoplelistening,mostpeopleareeitheratworkordrivingtheir
![Page 10: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
10
carsrightnow.Theymightnotunderstandwhatisthevagalnerve,whatisthevagaltones.Canyouwalkthroughthat,whereitcomesfrom?
Steven: Sure,okay.Thevagusisacranialnerve.Whatthatmeansisanervethatcomesoutofthebrain.Nowthereisawholeimportanthistoryherebecauseitgoesoutofthebrainbutitregulatesmany,manyorgansinourbody.Itisactuallyconveyinginformationfromthebraintoyourheart,toyourbronchi,toyourgutandsothesephysiologicalresponsesyouareoftengettingareoftendrivenbybrainsignals.Thisisveryimportanttounderstandbecausemostmedicinebasicallytreatsorgansastheareaofthediseaseandnotneuroregulationoftheorganasatleasttheantecedentforthediseasebecauseinmedicalschoolpeoplearenottrainedmuchaboutneuroregulationoforgans.Infact,thisisonequestionIalwaysaskphysicianswhoareinmyworkshops,Isayhowmuchtimedidyouspendstudyingthesensorypathwaysofthevagus?
Theansweristheymayhaveheardaboutitbuttheycertainlydidn'tstudyin.Nowthevagusisthisbigcranialnervethatleavesthebrain,comesoutofthebackofourheadandithas80%ofitsfibersaresensoryandthey'rebasicallyrunningasurveillanceteamofourinternalorgans.They'resendingthisinformationuptoourbrainstem.Ourbrainstemisdoingalittlebitofinterpretationandthesendingsignalsupwardtohigherbrainstructuresayingit'sokaytoattend,youdon'thavetobehypervigilant,youdon'thavetoruntothebathroom,youdon'thavetoeat.It'stellingyoucanIinteractordoIhavetoprotectmyself?Thesignalsarebeinginterpretedandthenthey'recreatingportalstoallowcognitiveandaffectivesystemstowork.
Nowwhatthepolyvagaltheorydoes,andI'mactuallygoingtogobacktoyourearlierquestionbecauseit'sveryimportanthereandI'mgoingtolinkitbacktoyouasababy.Ihavedoneworkinobstetricsandpediatrics.Ididabout20yearsofresearchinthatareameasuringtheheartratepatternsofbabiesandfetusesbecausetheheartratepatternsofthebabyandthefetuswasconveyinginformationaboutvagalfunction.Youcouldactuallystartassayingliterallywithaphysiologicalmarkerhowmuchvagalactivitywasoccurring.IreallyfeltIknewwhatIwasdoing,andthisgoesbackintotheearly1990sandIwasvery
![Page 11: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
11
pleasedwithhavingdevelopednewmethodstoextractfromheartratevariabilityanextraordinarilyreliableindexofthevagalinfluence.Ihavetotellyou,thisisprobablytheonepointyouprobablydon'tknowandthatisI'mthefirstpersontoeverquantifyheartratevariability.
Dave: Really?Idoitallthetimewithclients.I'manadvisortotheheartmathinstitute.Oh,mygoodness.Ididnotknowthat.Congratulations!
Steven: Well,that'sanotherstoryandthatwentbackintothe1960sanditwasaperiodoftimethatwhenIwastalkingaboutheartratevariabilitypeoplewouldsayyouhaveheartratevariabilityinyoursubjects,Steve,becauseyou'rejustabadscientist.Ifyouwereagoodscientisttheheartwouldjustbebeatingconstantlywaitingforastimulusandthenitwouldrespond.PeopleweresonaïveaboutneurofunctionandIwastryingtoexplainthatevenintheearly1900stheywereidentifyingvagalfibersthatwerecardioinhibitorywhetherornottheyhadarespiratoryrhythm.Thiswholefocusonrespiratorysciencearrhythmiaasafunctionalindexofthenewmyelinatedvagus,whichI'llgetto,isveryimportant.
Backtothebabywork.InIguessitwouldbethe1970s,80s,anduptoearly90sIwasstudyingbabies.Ifeltthatheartratevariabilityandrespiratorysciencearrhythmiawasthiswonderfulindexofhowhealthythebabywas.IpublishedapaperinamajorjournalcalledPediatricsshowingthatpre-termbabieshadlessrespiratorysciencearrhythmiawhichIcalledvagaltone,thanfulltermbabies.Thiswasreallywhatwasgoingon.Igotaletter,andthisisofcoursebeforethetimeofemail,andIgotaletteranditwasfromaneonatologistandtheneonatologistsaidIreallylikeyourpaper,howeverwhenIwasinmedicalschoolIwastaughtthatthevaguscankillyou.Perhapstoomuchofagoodthingisbad.IhadthatletterandIwasreallyperplexedbecauseIknewtoomuchofagoodthingwasn'tbad.Thatwasthewrongunderstanding.
Ialsoknewthatbabieswhohadthe...Ihavetobacktrackforamoment.IhavetotellyoufirstImorphedintohisperspectivebecauseneverarguewithpeopleunlessyouunderstandtheirperspectiveandhisperspectivewasthatasaneonatologistapneasandbradycardias,the
![Page 12: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
12
sensationofbreathingandtheslowingofheartratewereclinicalindicatorsorbadstuff,highrisk,andtheywerevagal.
Dave: Gotit.
Steven: Iwastalkingabouttheserhythmicitiesinheartratesupportinghomeostaticfunctionwhichwerealsovagal.
Dave: Whatwe'resayingthereisthatthere'sthese2differentthingsthatthevagusnervecando.
Steven: Wellthenervecandobutthatdoesn'tmakeanysense,doesit?Ibasicallysaidokay,thisisavagalparadox.NowIhavetofigurethisout.IfigureditoutbybasicallystudyingeverythingIcouldfindaboutthevagus.Thatdidn'thelpmeuntilIwentintostudyingcomparativeneuroanatomyandthattoldmeabouttheevolutionarytransitions.Whatyoufindoutisyoumayhaveonevagalnervebutit'saconduitwithdifferentfiberssotheconceptualizationwaswrong.Youhadtothinkthattherearedifferentfibersandtheycomefromdifferentpartsofthebrain.Theso-calledgoodvagalfibers,whichbythewayrepresentonly3%oftheentirevagalfibersinthevagus,aremyelinated,comefromtheareainthebrainstemcallednucleusambiguousandinteractinthebrainstemwiththeareathatcontrolsyourfacialmuscles,yourlaryngealmuscles.Theycontrolvocalizations,facialexpressivity,andeventhemusclesinyourmiddleearthatcontrollistening.
Dave: Forpeoplewhodon'tknowmyelination,myelinationiswhathappenswhenthebodyinsulatesnerveswithalayeroffatandthatallowsthenervestocarryelectricityfasterandwithlessresistancethannormalnerves.Whatyou'resayingisthatthepartofthevagusnervethatallowsustobasicallymoveourfaceandhearanddosomeotherkeycommunicationsisbetterorfasterthantherestofthenerve.AmIsayingthatright?
Steven: Wellclose.Let'sseparateandlet'sconceptualize.Inthebrainstemyouhaveacolumnandacolumnoffibersoracolumnofcellsthatarethesourceoriginforallthestriatedmusclesofthefaceandhead.Thatincludesmiddlehearmuscles,musclesofingestion,musclesoffacial
![Page 13: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
13
expressivity,musclesofthelarynxandthosearestriatedmusclesandtheycommunicateinthebrainstemwiththeareathatcontrolsthatmyelinatedvagus.They'renotvagalbutthey'repartofavagalcomplex.
Dave: Gotit,sotheyworktogether.
Steven: Theyworktogetherandnowletmegiveyoualittlesideviewonthat.IfyouthinkabouttheevolutionofmammalianspeciesIwasgoingtoaskyouthisquestionbecauseyoulikefactoidsandsothequestionisifyoufoundafossilhowwouldyouknowitwasamammal?
Dave: That'saninterestingquestion.IthinkwelookatbonestructureforthemostpartbutIdon'tknow,I'mnotafossilologist.
Steven: Thecriticalfeatureiswhetherthemiddleearboneshavebrokenoffthejawbone.
Dave: Really?Ididn'tknowthat.
Steven: Yes.Okay,nowthat'swhatmammalshave,middleearbonesbreakoffthejawbone.Theybecometheossiclechainthatenablesustohearlowvolume,higherfrequencyvoicesinbackgroundnoisesonlyifwehaveneuraltonetothosemiddleearstructures.Ifwedon'thaveneuraltonetothosemiddleearstructureswebecomehypersensitivetolowfrequencysoundsbecauselowfrequencysoundsgothroughboneconductionandtheysignalpredator.
Dave: Oh.
Steven: Okay?Whatyoustartseeingisifthismyelinatedvagusandthefacialmusclesaren'tworkingpeopletendtohaveauditoryhypersensitivitiesandhavedifficultyunderstandinghumanvoiceinbackgroundsettings.
Dave: Whatdoyoudoaboutthat?
Steven: Wellyoucanrehabilitateit.That'sactuallykindofwhatI'vebeenworkingonandIhaveacoupleclinicaltrialsonthatbutthecues,whatyouhavetodoisbasicallyusetheprinciplesofneuroceptionwhicharethatcuesofsafetyhavetotriggeraninhibitionofdefense.Whatare
![Page 14: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
14
cuesofsafety?I'lltellyou,they'renothavingteacherscarryingguns.Thosearenotcuesofsafety.Cuesofsafetyareintonationofvoice,prosodicvoices,mother-ese.Ifyouhaveadogorcatyouknowhowtotalktothem.Youuseaprosodicintonationofvoice.Ourneuroception,ournervoussystemdetectsthatasacueofsafetyandinhibitsthoselimbicreactivestructures.Talkingdoesn'talwayscalmpeopledownbuttalkinginaprosodicwayandlisteningwill.
Dave: Interestingsojustspeakinginthatwayandlisteningandbeingspokentointhatwaycanaffectyourverycorenervoussystem.Wow.
Steven: Absolutely.Oneofthelet'ssayfieldexperimentsthatIrunwhenItravelistowatchtoddlerswiththeirparentsandthekidsarealwaysscreamingwhenthefatherhasthetoddlerandthenthetoddler'sputovertothemotherandthemotherlooks,reaches,andsaysawordandthetoddler'sfine.
Dave: Right,andit'sthetoneofvoice?
Steven: Toneofvoice,thegesture.It'sthecomplexsetofcues,whilethefather'svoiceislower,especiallywhentheygetirritatedintheairport.Itgetslouderandlower,moremonotoneandthatinthebodyisatriggerofdefense.Itwilltriggerdefense.Theissueiswhydidthisoccurthroughevolution?Itoccurred,sothere'sabigsetofquestions.Peoplesaywellifyou'reanevolutionarypsychologistyoubasicallyfocusonselectiononbehaviorbutifyou'reanevolutionarybiologistyoudon'tcareaboutbehavior.Theissueisasthecerebrum,asthecortexinthebraingotlargeritputpressureonthejawboneandmiddleearbonesbrokeoff.
Dave: Wow.
Steven: Nowwhatdidthatdointermsofadaptivefunction?Itenabledmammalstohaveanacousticfrequencybandtointeractthatwouldnotbedetectedbythepredatorswhichwerereptiles.
Dave: Wow,okay.
Steven: Second,itenabledthemtodetectintheirconspecificoftheirownspecieswhethertheyweresafetocomeclosetoorweretheygoingto
![Page 15: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
15
haveafight?Nowweknowthissowhenpeopletalktousweknowwhetherthey'refriendlyornot.Youhaveenough,lookyoumakealivinginterviewingpeopleonspectrum.
Dave: It'sreallyfunny,mykidsareinaWaldorfschool.They're6and8andtheteacherswalkaroundtalkinglikethisanditdrivesmeinsane.InfactIthinkitdriveseverynormalparentinsanebutyoujustexplainedwhy.Theysaywellitmakesthekidscalm.Thisiswhatworksforkids.Thesethingsareenhancingthekid'svagaltonebyusingthosevoices.
Steven: Yeah,they'reenablingthevagaltonetocomebackonboardandthatwillsupportresilliancebecausethatvagaltone,thevagaltoneofthemyelinatedvagusenablesyoursympatheticnervoussystemandtheothervagalcircuit,whichisgoingbelowyourdiaphragm,nottoberecruitedfordefense.Theagendaincreatingahealthyworldorlifeistoenableyourautonomicnervoussystemtosupporthealth,growth,andrestorationandnottorecruititfordefense.
Dave: Let'ssaythatagoodportionofpeoplelisteningtothishavesomeproblem,somedegreeofproblemwiththeirvagaltone.I'mcertainlyoneofthemgivenjustmybirthhistoryandjustallthestuffthatI'vedealtwith.Iusedtoweigh300poundsandhadallkindsofotherlikeproblemsthatI'vehacked.Whatwouldyouadvisesomeonetodoiftheysaidallright,Iwantabettervagalresponse.I'dliketobehealthier,Iwanttobemoreresilient.HowdoIdothatasanadult?
Steven: Okay,butyou'rebasicallygivingmelotsofinformationthatIcanworkwithbeforeIgotothat.Ifyourvagalregulationisn'tworkingrightyouwillgravitatetotrytoregulatevagaltonethroughdifferentmechanismsandoneofthemisingestion.Ingestionutilizesthesamefeaturesorsamenervesthatsocialbehavioruses,butitdoesn'thavevocalizationswithitanddoesn'thavetouch,itdoesn'thavegesturebutit'sanattemptlikesuckingorchewinggumareattemptsforthebodytotrytorecruitthis,integrateit.Icallitintegratedsocialengagementsystemwhichincludesthatvagalactivity.Now,ifyouwanttodealwiththisfromamoreproactivewayaspectslikesinging,playingwindinstrumentswhichforceyoutoexhaleslowlyandthevagalefferentactionofthisnewermyelinatedvagushappensduringexhalationso
![Page 16: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
16
nowyouunderstandtheneuromechanismsunderlyingpranayamayoga.
Dave: Somethingthat'shelpedmeandsomethingIrecommendforalotofpeople.
Steven: Becauseduringexhalationthevagalefferent'sworkbutmorethanthatwhenyoupushthediaphragmdownthesensorypartofthevagusisstimulated,potentiallyit'sthosevagalmotorfibersworkingbetter.Whenyoudobreathingandpartofpranayamahastodowithstimulationofthefaceandthat'swheresensoryafferenceofthefacialmuscles,ofactuallyit'scranialnerve7whichisthefacialnerveandcranialnerve5whichistrigeminalwhichdealswithwhenyougotothedentistyouknowabouttrigeminal,thesensorypartofthatgoesintotheareaofthebrainstemthatregulatesthemyelinatedvagus.We'realwaystryingtogetthatsystemtoworkbecausethatsystemdownregulatesthedefensemodes,itdownregulatessympatheticactivityanditprotectsthatsubdiaphramaticothervagusfromgoingintodefense.Itenablesittosupporthealth,growth,andrestorationandinyourworldfacilitatedigestion.
Dave: OneoftheotherthingsthatIfirstlearnedaboutalmost10yearsagowasstickingyourfaceinicewaterforaminuteorsoasawaytobasicallycalmthevagalnerve.What'syourtakeonthat?
Steven: Okay,soyou'rerecruitinganancientdivereflexbutthere'saproblemwiththatbecausepartofthedivereflexrecruitstheunmyelinatedvagus.
Dave: Oh,interesting.
Steven: It'sbecauseincertainanimals,ithastodowiththeslopeofthebradycardia.Howfastdoestheheartrategodown?Somepeoplewhohavebeendrowningvictimswhohaven'treallydrowned,they'vebeenresuscitatedafterbeingincoldwaterformorethan20minutes,it'sbecausethebodywentintothatstate.Itwentintothisdeathfeigningstatesotheissueismaybe,maybenotwithyouricewater.Itmightbehelpfultomonitoryourheartratetoseehowmuchitdrops.Ifitdrops
![Page 17: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
17
downinto40beatsperminuteI'dbealittlebitconcerned.Ifyougetitdowntothelow60s...Youworkoutsowhat'syourbasalheartrate?
Dave: It'saround70.
Steven: Whenyouwakeupinthemorningdoyoumeasureitthen?Beforeyoustandup.
Dave: It'susuallyaround63.
Steven: Yeah,soandwhenyouwereheavywhatwasit?
Dave: Ididn'tmeasureitbackthen.
Steven: Yeah,butyoucanstartseeingtheshifts,especiallyearlymorning.Itwilldropdownandoneconcernisdoingtheicewaterearlymorning,like5or6inthemorning,mightbealittledangerousbecausetherearecircadianrhythmsandvulnerabilityforheartattackswhichagainaremisunderstoodbecausesomeoftheheartattacksmaybesuddendeathwhichispotentiallyavagalphenomenonandnotanarrhythmia.
Dave: Wow.Whatcouldwedotoreducetheincidenceofsuddendeathwiththisknowledge?PeoplelisteningarealllikeokaywhatcanIdoformeandsomeofthemhavevagalissuestheydon'tknowabout,othersdon't,buthowdowehackthat?
Steven: Thehackingofthisandactuallyit'sareasonablewordistounderstandwhatarethecuesthatournervoussystemcraves,reallycraves.Ournervoussystemcravescertainfeaturesofsafetyandtheyhappentobeawayfromlowfrequencybackgroundnoisesbecausethattriggerspredator.Weliketohearprosodicvoices.That'swhythe60swerewonderfulintermsoffolkmusicbecausetheyweresocialandpeoplewouldsingsongsaboutthemosthorriblethingsoccurringintheworldandeveryonewouldbesmilingbecauseofthearticulation,theprosodicfeaturesofthevoicebecausewewouldfeelgood.Itwasempowermentofbeingsocial.Thisisdifferentthanmusicthatusesmilitarymarchesandpatrioticactivitieswhicharemobilizingwithaffiliationandtheyareenergetic,butfolkmusicwithoutbasshasthefrequencybandsofafemaleandthattriggersustofeelcomfortableandsafe.
![Page 18: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
18
Acousticpropertiesareextremelyimportantandifyouwanttogobacktotheconceptofschools,schoolstendtobeverynoisybecauseofventilationsystems,highways,andavarietyofotherissues.Wearenotcreatingthecontextualenvironmentthatwillenabletheautonomicnervoussystemtofeelsafeenoughtodownregulatethedefensesystems.Imentiondefensesystems.Oneofthefight/flight,theotheroneisjustshuttingdown.Iwanttoemphasizeonepoint.Sinceyouhadthathistoryofhypoxiathethresholdforyoushuttingdownmighthavebeenlowerforyouthanotherpeopleandsothestrategiesthatyournervoussystemimplicitlytriedtoimplementmayhavebeenstrategiesofmoremobilizationtokeepyououtofthat.
Dave: Itwouldmakesense.NowthisisgoingtobemaybeaninflammatoryquestionandIapologizeinadvancebutwhatarewedoingwithCesareansectionwhenthatbecomesthemostcommonsurgeryperformedonwomen,whichitistoday?
Steven: Ithinkyouprobablyneedtoinvitemywifeonyourshow.MywifeisSueCarterandsheisthescientistwhodiscoveredtherelationshipbetweenoxytocinandsocialbehavior.
Dave: Okay,introduceus,please.Iwouldlovetotalkwithher.
Steven: SheisalsodirectoroftheKinsieInstituteandthat'swhyI'mhereatKinsie,IndianaUniversity.BasicallytheCesareansaredisruptingthenormalbirthprocessandtheissuesarereallyinterms...Notthatthereisn'taplaceforCesareansbuttheissueofhavingthembeinasenseelectiveorvoluntaryorschedulingyourdelivery,itbecomesaseriousquestionabouthowweviewearlydevelopment.AsascientistwhatIhavelearned,andagainit'sacoupledecadessinceIstudiedtheliteratureinthis,wasthatifdeliverywasstarted,iftherewerecontractionsalreadystartingtooccurandtheprocessofdeliverywasstartingthenCesareanwaslessdisruptivetonormaldevelopmentalprocesses.
WhatSueismostinterestedinisnotmerelytheCesareanbuttheuseofsupplementaldrugs,artificialoxytocincalledPitocinthatincreaseduterinecontractilitywithoutsofteningthecervix.Thesearedrugsthat
![Page 19: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
19
arebeingusedandtheconsequenceondevelopmentaren'treallyunderstoodandactuallythat'swhatshestudies.She'sstudyingtheepigeneticeffectsofadministeringoxytocintoananimalmodel.
Dave: Wow,thatwouldbeafascinatinginterview.Myfirstbookwaswrittenwithmywifewho'sacaregiverstrainedphysician,hername'sDr.Lana,anditwasaboutwhatdoyoudobeforeandduringpregnancytohavehealthierkidsandlookingatthequalityofthebirthasafactorintheresilienceandeventheIQofyourkids.There'sstudiesonthatsoit'snotthatyoushouldn'thaveaCesareanit'sthatyoushouldn'tvoluntarilyhaveoneunlessthere'samedicalreasontoit.Ifthereisn'tamedicalreasondon'tdoit.
Steven: Yeah,wellitalldependsonwhatyouroutcomevariablesare.Ifyouroutcomevariableismortalitythenpeoplebuildthereasonableargument.Iftheoutcomevariableisthedevelopmentoftrajectorythenwehavealotofotherissuestodiscuss.Thesesamethingsoccurandthisisevenamoredelicatequestiontodiscussandthatisaboutpre-termbabies,howpre-termissurvivalbecausethey'redoingextraordinarilywellwithverysmallbabiesintermsofcognitivefunctionanddevelopment.They'renotdoingsowellwiththosesamekindsintermsofsocial,emotionalregulation.
Dave: Youthinkthat'salloratleastmostlyvagalnerverelated?
Steven: IthinksobecausewhenImeettheparentsandtheyareoftenprofessionalsandtheystarttellingmethesymptomatologyitsoundsverysimilarly.Auditoryhypersensitivitieswhichispartofthesocialengagementsystem,flatfacialaffectofteningestiveproblemsearlierinlife,difficultycoordinatingsucking,swallowing,andbreathing.Theseareallthepartsthatarelinkedtostimulatingthatmyelinatedvagustosootheandcalmus.It'snotlikethey'reindependentbuttheinformationisoutthere.SinceyourwifeisfromSweden,intheScandinaviancountriestheyhavewonderfuldatabases.Alotoftheseissuescanbestudiedthere.Inthiscountrywedon'thavetheselargenationalregistriessowecan'treallyevaluatewhattheycando.IknowintheUKandinDenmarkIknowtheydothisaswell.
![Page 20: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
20
Dave: It'soneofthebenefitsofhavinganationalregistryofwhat'sgoingon,that'sforsure.Speakingofwhat'sgoingon,we'vegotthingslikePTSD,autism,depression,anxietythatareallatrecordlevelsandyou'vetiedallthesebacktokindofanunknownvariationinthevagalnerve.Whataretheimplicationsofthisforsociety?
Steven: Theimplicationsarethattherearecoredysfunctionsthatresideorgetexpressedinmanytypesofdisordersanditdoesn'tmeanthatdealingwiththosecoredysfunctionswillinasensecurethedisorder.Itmeansthatwecanworkonthemtooptimizethequalityoflife.Virtuallyanytypeofmentaldisorder,anytypeofseverehealthdisordergetsmanifestedindepressedvagalactivitybutitalsogetsmanifestedindepressedregulationofthosestriatemusclesofthefaceandheadbecausethesearebrainstemstructuresandwhat'sontopofthebrainstemisthismassivearrayofneurocircuitsthatgetmanifestedinmanydifferentfunctionsandpathologies.IfwelookatautismoryoulookatschizophreniaandevenifyoulookatHIV,HIVhasaneuraltoxicityonthefacialnerveandactuallytheyhavelowervagaltoneandtheirfacesdon'tworkaswellandthisresultsintheconsequencethatcaregiverstoHIVfeelthattheirpatients,theirlovedonesdon'tlovethembecausetheirfacesarenotexpressiveandtheyfeelexploited.
Thisisthesamethingifyoutalktomanyparentswhohaveautisticchildren.TheysayIlovemychildbutmychilddoesn'tloveme.Whatthey'resayingisthechildisn'taskingaboutthem,notexpressive,notshowingempathybecausethefaceisnotworking.ThesearelowerbrainstemstructuresthatpotentiallycanbeoptimizedthroughprovidingwhatIcallcuesofsafetybuttheycanbeexercisedthroughthingslikesinging,breathcontrol,learninghowtobreathe,playingwindinstruments.Ifwethinkagainwhathappenedtoourschoolsystemsallthesethingswerepulledoutofit,theopportunitiesforsingingandevenplay.PlaybecomesthisreciprocityandonethingIdidn'tdiscussisthatwhenwehavethiswonderfulsocialengagementsystemwithamyelinatedvagusthenoursympatheticnervoussystemdoesgointofight/flightandwecanuseitforplay.
Dave: Wow.
![Page 21: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
21
Steven: Wecanmobilizebutthenwelookatapersonandwesayhey,that'safriendandyoucalmdown.Ifyouplayballoranythingandyouaccidentallyhitsomeone,throwanelbowandtheyfallontheground,ifyouturntopickupthepersontheysayitspartofthegame,I'mfine.Ifyouwalkawaytherepairdidn'toccur,thefacialinteractionwasn'ttheretoturnoffthatsympatheticdefense.
Dave: That'sprettyincrediblestuff.Giventhatthevagalnerveis,atleast3%ofit,issofundamentallyimportanttohumanresiliencewhichisatitscorewhatImeanwhenItalkaboutbulletproof,thesamehighperformance,IcantakewhatevertheworldisgoingtobringtomeandIcanhandleit,dowhatIwanttodo.HowdoIexercisethisasidefromsingingandplayingawindinstrument?CanIrunelectricityoverit?CanIshinelasersonit?
Steven: Igotprepared,yesterdayIlistenedtoyoutalkingtothepersonwhowasdoingTMSandsoyouhavemagnetsathome.Thebeautyofthiscircuitisit'snotdonethatway.
Dave: Darn.
Steven: Becauseyoucantriggeritthatwaybuttomaintainityouhavetomaintainitwithsocialinteraction.
Dave: MoreFacebookthen.
Steven: LessFacebook.
Dave: I'mjustkidding.
Steven: It'sbadenoughofSkypebutyeah,whatourbodyrequiresthepresenceofanother.That'swhoweare,that'swhomammalsare.Eventhoughtalkingonthephoneishelpful,Skypeishelpful;Facebookisprobablyhelpfulit'snotatotalreplacementfortheknowledgethatthatpersonistheretotouchandtocarefor.Againtheprinciplewehavetoalwaysemphasizeisthatweasmammalsdidnotevolvetotakecareofourselves,weevolvedwiththehelpofothersandwecontinuetoneedthehelpofotherstomaintainourlife.Eventhoughculturesaystakecareofyourself,doallthesethings,that'snotreallywhatourbodysays.
![Page 22: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
22
Ourbodysaysfindgoodfriends,haveagoodcommunity,havegoodsupportbecausethat'swhatourbody'sreallyaskingfor.
Dave: Theoldlinewegetbywithalittlehelpfromourfriendsisprettyaccurate.
Steven: True,yeah,yeah.
Dave: Allright,somoresocialengagementisprettyimportant...
Steven: Letmeinterrupt.Socialengagementifyouwantit.ForcedsocialengagementisthreatsotheissueisyouhavetoinviteitandwiththatIwanttochangeterms.Weusewordslikecaregiverimpliesthatit'saunidirectionaleventandcaregiver’sburnoutwhenitisunidirectional.ThatwastheexamplewiththeHIVorwiththeautismbecausecaregivingisbidirectional.Wegiveandweloveitwhenpeoplecanbegoodrecipients.Itcreatesareciprocitythatmakesusfeelgood.
Dave: It'sthatreciprocalloopthatsortofgetssetup.What'stheroleofgratitudeinallofthis?
Steven: Again,we'redealingwithwordsandI'mgoingtoactuallythrowitbacktoyouandIwantyoutotellmewhatyoumeanbygratitude?
Dave: Myunderstandingofgratitudeisthatit'sactuallyafeltstateandit'soneofthemechanismsthatIusetoturnoffwhatIperceiveisthefightorflightresponse.ItmaybeturningoffsomelowerleveldefensemechanismsbutwhenyoulookattheworldasI'mgratefulforallthisamazingstuffinitittendstomakeyousleepbetter,ittendstomakeyouhappier,ittendstomakeyounicer.
Steven: You'reinwhatIwouldcallaventralvagalstateandsothat'sthemyelinatedvagus.IactuallygaveatalkforcompassioncarewhichisagroupoutatStanfordanditwasonbasicallyancientpracticesasportalsofvagalregulation.
Dave: Wow,Ihavetohearthistalk.Isitonvideosomewhere?
Steven: Yeah,it'sonYouTube.
![Page 23: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
23
Dave: Okay,we'llfindthatandwe'lllinktoitintheshoutouts.
Steven: Basicallyitsaysthatthroughchantandprayerandevenpostureshiftswewererecruitingthisvagalsystemandthatwasinasensegivingpeoplestatesofcompassionorastatethatbufferedthemfrombeingdefensive.Letmeputacaponthisbecausewehavetounderstandthattheremovalofthreatisnotthesameassafetyandweliveinasocietythatsayswe'regoingtoremovethreatandyou'regoingtobesafewithoutprovidingwhatourbodyneedswhicharecuesofsafety.Whenyou'reinthisstateofgratitudeyouarebathedinasenseofthecuesofsafety.Whetheryou'regeneratingityourselforyou'reinanenvironmentwithothersandwhenyou'reinthatstateyou'renotrecruitinganyofthesedefenses.You'renotperceivingtheworlddifferently.Youperceivetheworlddifferentlybasedonyourphysiologicalstateandwhenyou'reinastatethatisbeingclearlyprotectedfromdefensebythismyelinatedvagusthenyouwon'trecruitthosedefensesignalsystems.
Dave: Apracticeofrecognizingandcultivatingthesensationofgratitudecantriggertheneurologicalexperiencethatit'sasafeworldwhichthenisgoingtokeepyououtofthesympathetic,thefightorflightandit'salsogoingtoenhancethemyelinationofyourvagusnervemaybe?
Steven: Wellitmightbutmoreimportantthanthatispotentiallyyoumaynotneedtomyelinateanymore.Youjustneedtoenablethatcircuittowork.Theissueishowdoyouoptimizewhatyouhave?Ithinkthat'spartofyourthemesoitdoesn'tmeanyouhavetorewire.Itmeansthatyoumayhavetoturnoffdefense.Themodelofpolyvagaltheoryisit'sahierarchicalmodel,andthisreallytherealtakehomepoint,it'sahierarchicalmodelthatarticulates3differentcircuitsthatoccurredthroughevolution.Oneisthismyelinatedvagusthat'slinkedtooursocialengagementsystem.Thesecondisasympatheticfightorflightsystem,mobilizationsystem,andthethirdisashuttingdownsystem.ThosesystemsthatItalkedaboutfordefensejustnowarenotsolelytherefordefense.Oursympatheticnervoussystemiswhatmakesusfeelgood,energetic.Oursubdiaphragmaticvagusisnotashutdownsystemwhenwe'resafe.Itenablesdigestiontooccurefficiently.Itenablesourbowelstoworkwellandthesymptomofcourseofwhatyou
![Page 24: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
24
knowalreadyisthatallthefeaturesofmodernsocietygetmanifestedinourbowels.
Whatthatissayingitgetsmanifestedinimmobilizationwithfearreaction.Ifwe'reimmobilizedweareconstipated.Ifwe'reimmobilizedwejustdefecateinappropriatelysothenotionofmaintainingtheseendogenousnormalrhythmsistheresponsibilityofthismyelinatedvagusthatenablesotherpartsoftheautonomicnervoussystemtoregulateourhomeostasis.
Dave: Wow,that'ssomepowerfulstuff.I'veseeninthebookOnCombat,whichisafamousbookstudyingfirstrespondersandpeopleinwar,wherepeopleattheWorldTradeCenter,thefirefighters,agoodportionofthemactuallyhadthatproblemofjustdefecationwithoutthatandfelthugeamountsofshamebecauseveryfewpeopleunderstandthiseventhoughit'snotaconsciousthingit'sthisresponse,right?
Steven: Ilinkthattorapevictimswhoalsofeelgreatshamebecauseit'sthesamecircuitthat'sgoingon,thesubdiaphragmaticvagusisimmobilizingthemunderrestraintorrapeandthephysiologicalinterpretationofthatimplicitfeelingendsupbeingshame.
Dave: Wow.
Steven: Okay?
Dave: It'scompletelywired.Ithasnothingtodowithourrationalthinkingatallyetwefeelitandwetrytorationalizeitanditgetsworse.
Steven: Yeah,thisiswhatItalkaboutourbigbraintryingtomakesenseoutofallthisinformation.Wehavetobeinformedbyourbiology.
Dave: I'velearnedalotinthisinterview.ThisisoneofmyfavoriteinterviewseverbutI'mstillstuckonokay,whatdoIdowithallthisamazingknowledge?I'llkeepdoingpranayamaorArtofLivingorsomesortofbreathingexercise.I'mnotsureI'mgoingtopickuptheflutebutwhoknows?Maybe.Icankeepcultivatinggratitude,whataretheotherthings?
![Page 25: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
25
Steven: Icangiveyouonebasicmetaphorandthatistofeelsafeinthearmsofanother.
Dave: Thereyougo.Thatisgreatadvice,okay.
Steven: NowIwouldmodifythattosaytofeelsafeinthearmsofanotherappropriatemammal.
Dave: Notaturtle,gotcha.
Steven: Rightandthereasonisthatsomepeoplereallydon'tfeelsafewithpeoplebuttheyfeelverysafewiththeirdogs.
Dave: Oh,thisexplainsthedogandmaybethecatthing,althoughwhoreallylikescats?I'mjustkidding.
Steven: I'vehad2phases.IwasacatpersoninitiallyandnowI'madogperson.Thedogpartisactuallylinkedtohavingrealchildrenbecauseoftheirneedinessandtheirreciprocity.Theyneedthesocialfeedbackfromyou.Catsareextraordinarilyindependent.
Dave: Veryperceptive.
Steven: Dogs,youchangethetoneofyourvoiceandthey'redownonthegroundbasicallysayingwhyareyouhurtingme?Thepointisthey'reexplainingtoyouintheirbehaviortheirneuroceptionofthevocalizationcuesthatthey'regetting.They'reteachingussomuchandsowhenwecanappreciatetheirvulnerabilityandlovethemandappreciatethevulnerabilityofourchildrenandlovethemandappreciatethevulnerabilityofourspousesandfriendsandlovethemthenwe'resafe.Thenwe'regood.
Dave: Wow,soitgoesrightdowntobeingvulnerableandacceptingvulnerabilityinothers.
Steven: Yeah.
Dave: Wow,that'ssomeprofoundstuff.Now,IsuspectyoumighthaveansweredoneofthesequestionsI'mabouttoask,oroneofthethings
![Page 26: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
26
I'mgoingtoaskyoubutgivenallthestuffyouknow,andthisisaquestionI'veaskedoneveryepisodeofBulletproofRadio,ifsomeonecametoyoutomorrowandyoudidn'tknowanythingabouttheirbackgroundandtheysaidlook,Iwanttoperformbetteratbeingahuman.IwanttokickassateverythingIdecideI'mgoingtodo.Whatarethe3mostimportantthingsIshouldknow?
Steven: Okay,we'lltrysomethingonthis.WhoknowswhatI'mgoingtosay?WellwhatIwouldstartoffbysaying,themostimportantthingwehavetounderstandisthatourautonomicnervoussystemfunctionsinahierarchicalwayandwhatthatmeansisthatsometimeswehavetounderstandhowourbody'sbeenchallengedincertainsituations.WhatIwouldsayiswehavetobecomeveryawareofwhatourbodyisdoing,ourbody'sresponses.Likeyourdescriptionofyourgutrespondinginthatroom,ifyouhadunderstooditfromapolyvagalmodel,fromthehierarchyofourautonomicnervoussystemandyoustartgettingasubdiaphragmaticgutresponseandyoureallywantedtomanageityouwouldthensaymaybemybodyshouldn'tbeinthisroomormaybeIneedtobenearsomeonewhomakesmefeelsafe.Maybemyspouse,maybesomeoneelse.
ThemostimportantthingIguessthewordsIwouldnowuseisyouneedtorespectyourbodymeaningthatyourbodyisreactingtosituationsandyouneedtounderstandthatit'sreactingit.Thisgoesbacktomoreoftheattributesofneuroception.Inneuroceptionwedon'tknowthecuesthatourbodyisrespondingtobutweknowthatourbodyhasrespondedandifwerespectthefactthatourbodyhasrespondedwecandogoodthingsforourbody.Wecanhonorourbody.Wecanmoveittoasaferplacebecauseweknowwhatcuesarenecessarysoweneedittobeaquieterplace,needtobewithsupportivepeople.
Dave: Okay.
Steven: IhavemoreIhavetoanswerorwasthatall?
Dave: Wasthat2orwasthat3?
![Page 27: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
27
Steven: Whoknows?Basicallyit'sgoingtobethisintegrationofunderstandingthehierarchyorourautonomicnervoussystem,realizingthatunderneuroceptionweareawareofourbody'sresponsesbutnotofthecuessoitbecomesmoreofabodyscanningandthethirdonewouldbetokindofhonorourbody'sresponsesandnottoinasensedenigratethemandsayit'snotimportant,I'llgetoverit.
Dave: Gotit,that'sagreatsummary.Wow.IcantellyouIdon'tthinkanyofthoseanswersI'veheardbeforeandthey'reallverywisesothankyouforsharingthat.Iwasexpectingsomethingunusualandyoudefinitelydeliveredit.
Steven: Thankyou.
Dave: Steven,thefatherofpolyvagaltheory,thankyouforbeingontheshow.Wherecanpeoplefindoutmoreabouteitheryourresearchoryourpractice?Isthereawaypeoplewhoareinterestedinlearningmoreaboutthiscanfindyou?
Steven: WellIhaveawebpageandit'sstevenporgess.com.Ithasalistofwheremytalkswillbeanditalsohaspublishedinterviewsandabibliographyandthere'salsogoingtobeawebpageatKinzie.Thereisonenowbutit'snotwelldevelopedwithmymaterialsonit.
Dave: Awesome,wewilllinktobothofthosepagesincludingtheKinzieoneifyou'dlikesopeoplecanjustcometotheshownotesorlookfortheemailwiththispodcast.
Steven: Okay,andactuallythereisquiteafewtalksonYouTubesopeoplemightiftheylikewantmoreofthistheycanfinditonYouTube.
Dave: Isuspectyou'llfindthattherearealotofpeoplewholistentoBulletProofRadiowhoarethinkingwait,thiseitherappliestomeoritappliestosomeoneintheworldveryclosetomesojusthavinganunderstandingofwhatourenvironmentdoestoournervoussystemisaverycorethingtobeingafullyfunctioninghumansoIthinkthatyou'llfindsomepeopleinterestedinyourworkbecauseit'sprettyinterestingstuff.
![Page 28: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
28
Steven: Wellthankyouverymuch,David.
Dave: ThanksforbeinginBulletproofRadioandIlookforwardtomaybemeetingyousomedayinperson.
Steven: Ilookforwardtoit.Thankyou,David.Bye,bye.
Dave: Ilearnedtocookinawaythatmostpeopledon't.Istartedlookingateverysinglemeal,designingandengineeringthemealnottomakemeloseweightorjusttotastereallygood,althoughthosewerepartoftheplan,itwastogivemeafoodhighsothatwhenIwasdoneeatingIwouldjustfeelamazing.Bulletproofispartlytheartabouthowtocookfoodthatmakesyouhavemorepower.It'sabouthavingenergydensefoods,nutrientdensefoodsthatdon'thavethingsinthemthatmakeyouweak.TheBulletproofroadmaptellsyouhowtodothisandBulletproofthecookbooktellsyouhowtomakeittasteamazingsoyoucanlearnhowtodothiscookinginyourownhome.There's125recipesthathelpyoukickmoreasseveryday.You'llfeelthedifferenceinyourbraininyourveryfirstmeal.Gotobulletproofcookbook.comandwe'llgiveyouabigdiscountandfreeshippingrightnow.Headonovertobulletproofcookbook.comtogetallofthisgoodnessandstartdoingittoday.Infact,ifyouhaveagardenI'lleventellyouhowtousethingsstraightoutofthegarden.
Featured Stephenporges.com A selection of Dr. Porges publications Talks by Dr. Porges on Youtube Resources Polyvagal Theory Autonomic nervous system Neuroception Hypoxia Phylogenetics Vagus nerve Heart rate variability
![Page 29: Transcript of “Stephen Porges: The Polyvagal Theory & The Vagal Nerve … · 2020. 2. 8. · Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges 3 Dave: Hey, it's Dave Asprey. Before](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022061005/60b30d4d19b759685f1aeff2/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Bulletproof Toolbox Podcast #264, Stephen Porges
29
Vagal tone Apnea Bradycardia Homeostatic functions Nucleus ambiguus Myelination Myelinated vagus nerve Pranayama yoga Cranial nerve 5 Cranial nerve 7 Dr. Sue Carter Dr. Lana Health registry database in Nordic countries HIV’s impact on vagal recognition Ventral vagal state The Center for Compassion and Altruism Research and Education On Combat Neuroception Bulletproof Heart rate variability training HeartMath Institute Bulletproof Road Map Bulletproof Cookbook