2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.1
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Lecture 3: A brief background to Lecture 3: A brief background to multivariate statisticsmultivariate statistics
Lecture 3: A brief background to Lecture 3: A brief background to multivariate statisticsmultivariate statistics
Univariate versus multivariate statistics The material of multivariate analysis Displaying multivariate data The uses of multivariate statistics A refresher of matrix algebra Displaying multivariate data
Univariate versus multivariate statistics The material of multivariate analysis Displaying multivariate data The uses of multivariate statistics A refresher of matrix algebra Displaying multivariate data
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.2
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Multivariate versus univariate Multivariate versus univariate statisticsstatistics
Multivariate versus univariate Multivariate versus univariate statisticsstatistics
In univariate statistical analysis, we are concerned with analyzing variation in a single random variable.
In multivariate statistical analysis, we are concerned with analyzing variation in several random variables which may or may not be related.
In univariate statistical analysis, we are concerned with analyzing variation in a single random variable.
In multivariate statistical analysis, we are concerned with analyzing variation in several random variables which may or may not be related.
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.3
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
The material of multivariate analysisThe material of multivariate analysisThe material of multivariate analysisThe material of multivariate analysis
Multivariate data consists of a set of measurements (usually related) of P variables X1, X2, …, XP on n sample units.
The variables Xj may be ratio, ordinal, or nominal.
Multivariate data consists of a set of measurements (usually related) of P variables X1, X2, …, XP on n sample units.
The variables Xj may be ratio, ordinal, or nominal.
Sample Variable1
Variable2
VariableP
1 X11 X21 XP1
2 X12 X22 XP2
n X1n X2n XPn
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.4
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Example 1: Bumpus’ sparrow dataExample 1: Bumpus’ sparrow dataExample 1: Bumpus’ sparrow dataExample 1: Bumpus’ sparrow data
5 morphological measurements (in mm) of 49 sparrows recovered from a storm in 1898.
5 morphological measurements (in mm) of 49 sparrows recovered from a storm in 1898.
Bird Length AlarExtent
HeadLength
Humeruslength
Keellength
1 156 245 31.6 18.5 20.5
2 154 240 30.4 17.9 19.6
49 164 248 32.3 18.8 20.9
... ... ...... ... ...
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.5
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Example 2: Example 2: Biodiversity of SE Biodiversity of SE Ontario wetlandsOntario wetlands
Example 2: Example 2: Biodiversity of SE Biodiversity of SE Ontario wetlandsOntario wetlands
Species richness (number of species) of 5 different taxa in 57 wetlands in southeastern Ontario.
Species richness (number of species) of 5 different taxa in 57 wetlands in southeastern Ontario.
Wetland Birds Amphibians Reptiles Mammals Plants
1 82 7 4 9 223
2 36 2 1 3 119
57 61 4 2 6 173
... ... ...... ... ...
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.6
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
The material of The material of multivariate multivariate
analysisanalysis
The material of The material of multivariate multivariate
analysisanalysis
In some applications, the measured variables comprise both dependent (X) and independent (Y) variables.
In some applications, the measured variables comprise both dependent (X) and independent (Y) variables.
Sample Independentvariable
1
Independentvariable
2
Dependentvariable
1
Dependentvariable
2
1 X11 X21 Y11 Y21
2 X12 X22 Y12 Y22
n X1n X2n Y1n Y2n
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.7
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Example 1: Pgi frequencies in Example 1: Pgi frequencies in California California Euphydras edithaEuphydras editha
colonies in relation to colonies in relation to environmental factorsenvironmental factors..
Example 1: Pgi frequencies in Example 1: Pgi frequencies in California California Euphydras edithaEuphydras editha
colonies in relation to colonies in relation to environmental factorsenvironmental factors..
Colony PgiI Pgi2 Annualprecip.
(in.)
Altitude(ft)
Annualmax.temp.
SS .22 .57 43 500 98
SB .20 .38 20 800 92
GL .01 .92 50 10,500 81
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.8
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Example 2: Anurans in SE Example 2: Anurans in SE Ontario wetlands in Ontario wetlands in relation to surrounding relation to surrounding forest cover and road forest cover and road densitiesdensities
Example 2: Anurans in SE Example 2: Anurans in SE Ontario wetlands in Ontario wetlands in relation to surrounding relation to surrounding forest cover and road forest cover and road densitiesdensities
Wetland LF GTF MF Road density(1 km)
Forestcover (1 km)
1 1 0 0 20.2 0.10
2 1 1 0 6.2 0.90
3 1 0 0 12.6 0.35
4 1 1 1 0.02 0.95
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.9
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Multivariate LS Multivariate LS estimatorsestimators
Multivariate LS Multivariate LS estimatorsestimators
The vector of sample means, variances and covariances is an estimate of the true (“population”) means, variances and covariances.
As such, inferences to the latter based on the former assume random sampling.
The vector of sample means, variances and covariances is an estimate of the true (“population”) means, variances and covariances.
As such, inferences to the latter based on the former assume random sampling.
C
x
))((1
1
)(1
1
),,,(1
1
2
1
2
211
kkji
n
jijik
i
n
jiji
p
n
jiji
xxxxn
c
xxn
s
xxxxn
x
Cx,
Population
Sample
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.10
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
The sample The sample covariance matrixcovariance matrix
The sample The sample covariance matrixcovariance matrix
The sample covariance matrix is a square matrix whose diagonal elements give the sample variances for each measured variable (si
2), and whose off-diagonal elements are the sample covariances between pairs of variables (cik).
The sample covariance matrix is a square matrix whose diagonal elements give the sample variances for each measured variable (si
2), and whose off-diagonal elements are the sample covariances between pairs of variables (cik).
))((1
1
)(1
1
1
2
1
2
kkji
n
jijik
i
n
jiji
xxxxn
c
xxn
s
221
22221
11221
mmm
m
m
scc
csc
ccs
C
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.11
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
A review of matrix A review of matrix algebraalgebra
A review of matrix A review of matrix algebraalgebra
A matrix of size m x n is an array of numbers (either real or complex) with m rows and n columns.
Matrices with one column are column vectors, matrices with one row are row vectors.
A matrix of size m x n is an array of numbers (either real or complex) with m rows and n columns.
Matrices with one column are column vectors, matrices with one row are row vectors.
mnmm
n
n
aaa
aaa
aaa
21
22221
11211
A
mc
c
c
2
1
c ),,,( 21 nrrr r
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.12
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Special matricesSpecial matricesSpecial matricesSpecial matrices
A zero matrix 0 has all elements equal to zero.
A diagonal matrix T is a square matrix (m = n) with all elements equal to zero except the main diagonal.
An identity matrix I is a diagonal matrix with all diagonal terms equal to zero.
A zero matrix 0 has all elements equal to zero.
A diagonal matrix T is a square matrix (m = n) with all elements equal to zero except the main diagonal.
An identity matrix I is a diagonal matrix with all diagonal terms equal to zero.
000
000
000
0
nt
t
t
00
00
00
1
1
T
100
010
001
I
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.13
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Matrix Matrix operationsoperations
Matrix Matrix operationsoperations
The transpose of a matrix A (AT) is obtained by interchanging rows and columns.
The transpose of a row vector is a column vector, and the transpose of a column vector is a row vector.
The transpose of a matrix A (AT) is obtained by interchanging rows and columns.
The transpose of a row vector is a column vector, and the transpose of a column vector is a row vector.
mnmm
n
n
aaa
aaa
aaa
21
22221
11211
A
mnnn
m
m
T
aaa
aaa
aaa
21
22212
12111
A
mc
c
c
2
1
c ),,,( 21 nT ccc c
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.14
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
The trace of a matrixThe trace of a matrixThe trace of a matrixThe trace of a matrix
The trace of a matrix A, denoted tr(A), is the sum of the diagonal elements.
The trace is defined only for square matrices.
The trace of a matrix A, denoted tr(A), is the sum of the diagonal elements.
The trace is defined only for square matrices.
mnmm
n
n
aaa
aaa
aaa
21
22221
11211
A
n
iii
nn
a
aaaAtr
1
2211)(
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.15
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Matrix addition and subtractionMatrix addition and subtractionMatrix addition and subtractionMatrix addition and subtraction
Two matrices A and B are conformable for addition if they are of the same size (same numbers of rows and columns).
The resulting matrix A + B (A - B) is obtained by adding (subtracting) individual matrix elements.
Two matrices A and B are conformable for addition if they are of the same size (same numbers of rows and columns).
The resulting matrix A + B (A - B) is obtained by adding (subtracting) individual matrix elements.
22222121
12121111
22222121
12121111
2221
1211
2221
1211
,
,
baba
baba
baba
baba
bb
bb
aa
aa
BA
BA
BA
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.16
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Matrix multiplication by a scalarMatrix multiplication by a scalarMatrix multiplication by a scalarMatrix multiplication by a scalar
The multiplication of a matrix A by a scalar k involves multiplying each element of A by k.
The multiplication of a matrix A by a scalar k involves multiplying each element of A by k.
2221
1211
2221
1211 ,kaka
kakak
aa
aaAA
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.17
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Matrix Matrix multiplicationmultiplication
Matrix Matrix multiplicationmultiplication
Two matrices A (m x n) and B (n x p) are conformable for multiplication (A • B) if the number of columns in A equals the number of rows in B.
A • B and B • A are both defined only when both A and B are square, but even when true, in general A • B B • A .
Two matrices A (m x n) and B (n x p) are conformable for multiplication (A • B) if the number of columns in A equals the number of rows in B.
A • B and B • A are both defined only when both A and B are square, but even when true, in general A • B B • A .
n
jjpmj
n
jjmj
n
jjpj
n
jjj
npn
p
mnm
n
baba
baba
ab
bb
aa
aa
111
11
111
1
111
1
111
BA
11
03,
21
12
10
11,
11
12
ABBA
BA
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.18
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Matrix inversionMatrix inversionMatrix inversionMatrix inversion The inverse of a matrix A,
denoted A-1, is the matrix solving the matrix equation
where I is the identity matrix.
Only square matrices are invertible, and some matrices cannot be inverted (“singular” matrices)
The inverse of a matrix A, denoted A-1, is the matrix solving the matrix equation
where I is the identity matrix.
Only square matrices are invertible, and some matrices cannot be inverted (“singular” matrices)
3/23/1
3/13/2,
21
12 1AA
I
AA
10
01
3/23/1
3/13/2
21
121
IAA 1
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.19
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
The covariance The covariance matrixmatrix
The covariance The covariance matrixmatrix
A multivariate sample is described by a covariance matrix, whose diagonal elements give the sample variances for each measured variable (si
2), and whose off-diagonal elements are the sample covariances between pairs of variables (cik).
A multivariate sample is described by a covariance matrix, whose diagonal elements give the sample variances for each measured variable (si
2), and whose off-diagonal elements are the sample covariances between pairs of variables (cik).
))((1
1
)(1
1
1
2
1
2
kkji
n
jijik
i
n
jiji
xxxxn
c
xxn
s
221
22221
11221
mmm
m
m
scc
csc
ccs
C
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.20
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Calculating the sample Calculating the sample covariance matrixcovariance matrix
Calculating the sample Calculating the sample covariance matrixcovariance matrix
X dT
LNM
OQP
1 1
3 0
0
3
SSCP X XSSCP
C LNM
OQPLNM
OQP
d d
SS CP
CP SS nT 1 12
21 2
2 3
3 18 1,
L OL OL OXd
NMMMQPPP
NMMM Q
PPP
NMMM Q
PP1
3
2
1
4
7
2
2
2
4
4
4
1
1
0
3
0
3
7
4
1
2
3
1
x x1 22 4 ,
x1 x2
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.21
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
The determinant of a matrix: 2 X 2 The determinant of a matrix: 2 X 2 matricesmatrices
The determinant of a matrix: 2 X 2 The determinant of a matrix: 2 X 2 matricesmatrices
The determinant of a matrix A, denoted det(A) or |A|, is a unique number associated with every square matrix.
In multivariate statistics, the determinant of the sample covariance matrix C plays a crucial role in hypothesis testing.
The determinant of a matrix A, denoted det(A) or |A|, is a unique number associated with every square matrix.
In multivariate statistics, the determinant of the sample covariance matrix C plays a crucial role in hypothesis testing.
A A
C C
LNM
OQP
LNMOQP
a a
a aa a a a11 12
21 2211 22 12 21
1 1
1 43
,
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.22
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Matrix inversion and the determinant: Matrix inversion and the determinant: 2 X 2 matrices2 X 2 matricesMatrix inversion and the determinant: Matrix inversion and the determinant: 2 X 2 matrices2 X 2 matrices
If a 2 X 2 matrix A is invertible, the elements of its inverse A-1 are obtained by dividing modified elements of A by |A|
Hence, if |A| = 0, the division is undefined and the matrix is non-invertible or singular.
If a 2 X 2 matrix A is invertible, the elements of its inverse A-1 are obtained by dividing modified elements of A by |A|
Hence, if |A| = 0, the division is undefined and the matrix is non-invertible or singular.
A A
AA
D D
D
LNM
OQP
LNM
OQP
LNMOQP
L
NMMM
O
QPPP
a a
a aa a a a
a a
a a
11 12
21 2211 22 21 12
1 22 12
21 11
1
1
4 2
2 64 6 2 2 20
6
20
2
202
20
4
20
,
, ,
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.23
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Multivariate variance: a geometric Multivariate variance: a geometric interpretationinterpretationMultivariate variance: a geometric Multivariate variance: a geometric interpretationinterpretation
Univariate variance is a measure of the “volume” occupied by sample points in one dimension.
Multivariate variance involving m variables is the volume occupied by sample points in an m -dimensional space.
Univariate variance is a measure of the “volume” occupied by sample points in one dimension.
Multivariate variance involving m variables is the volume occupied by sample points in an m -dimensional space.
X X
Largervariance
Smallervariance
X1
X2Occupiedvolume
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.24
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Multivariate variance: Multivariate variance: effects of correlations effects of correlations among variablesamong variables
Multivariate variance: Multivariate variance: effects of correlations effects of correlations among variablesamong variables
Correlations between pairs of variables reduce the volume occupied by sample points…
…and hence, reduce the multivariate variance.
Correlations between pairs of variables reduce the volume occupied by sample points…
…and hence, reduce the multivariate variance.
No correlation
X1
X2
X2
X1
Positivecorrelation
Negativecorrelation
Occupiedvolume
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.25
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
C and the generalized C and the generalized multivariate variancemultivariate varianceC and the generalized C and the generalized multivariate variancemultivariate variance The determinant of the
sample covariance matrix C is a generalized multivariate variance…
… because area2 of a parallelogram with sides given by the individual standard deviations and angle determined by the correlation between variables equals the determinant of C.
The determinant of the sample covariance matrix C is a generalized multivariate variance…
… because area2 of a parallelogram with sides given by the individual standard deviations and angle determined by the correlation between variables equals the determinant of C.
rc
s s1212
1 2
05 60 . cos , o
C CLNMOQP
1 1
1 43
2s
1s
h
2
sin 60 ; 3.2
3,
opposite hh
hypotenuse
Area Base Height Area
C
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.26
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
The use of The use of determinants in determinants in
multivariate analysismultivariate analysis
The use of The use of determinants in determinants in
multivariate analysismultivariate analysis For a univariate sample
variance sa2, the
multivariate analog is the determinant of the corresponding sample covariance matrix Ca, i.e., | Ca|…
… and these variances are often used in the calculation of multivariate test statistics, e.g., Wilk’s .
For a univariate sample variance sa
2, the multivariate analog is the determinant of the corresponding sample covariance matrix Ca, i.e., | Ca|…
… and these variances are often used in the calculation of multivariate test statistics, e.g., Wilk’s .
VariationSource
MS Teststatistic
Groups SSg/ k-1
Error SSe/ N-k F = MSg/MSe
Total SST/ N-1
Univariate single-classificationANOVA, k groups
Multivariate single-classificationANOVA (MANOVA)
VariationSource
C Teststatistic
Groups |Cg|
Error |Ce| = |Cg|/|CT|
Total |CT|
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.27
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
EigenvaluesEigenvaluesEigenvaluesEigenvalues The eigenvalues of a p X p
matrix A are the p solutions, some of which may be zero, to the equation |A - I| = 0.
The trace of a matrix is the sum of its eigenvalues…
… and the determinant of a matrix is the product of its eigenvalues.
The eigenvalues of a p X p matrix A are the p solutions, some of which may be zero, to the equation |A - I| = 0.
The trace of a matrix is the sum of its eigenvalues…
… and the determinant of a matrix is the product of its eigenvalues.
21
13A
21
13
0
0
21
13IA
055021
13 2
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.28
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Eigenvalues and Eigenvalues and eigenvectors Ieigenvectors I
Eigenvalues and Eigenvalues and eigenvectors Ieigenvectors I
Suppose v is a vector, and L a linear transformation. If L(v) = v, then v is an eigenvector of L associated with the eigenvalue .
e.g., if L is the reflection in the line y = mx, then is the eigenvector associated with eigenvalue 1, with -1.
Note that and are orthogonal!
Suppose v is a vector, and L a linear transformation. If L(v) = v, then v is an eigenvector of L associated with the eigenvalue .
e.g., if L is the reflection in the line y = mx, then is the eigenvector associated with eigenvalue 1, with -1.
Note that and are orthogonal!
mxy
)(L)( L
)(L
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.29
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Eigenvalues and Eigenvalues and eigenvectors of Ceigenvectors of CEigenvalues and Eigenvalues and eigenvectors of Ceigenvectors of C
Eigenvectors of the covariance matrix C are orthogonal directed line segments that “span” the variation in the data, and the corresponding (unsigned) eigenvalues are the length of these segments.
… so the product of the eigenvalues is the “volume” occupied by the data, i.e. the determinant of the covariance matrix.
Eigenvectors of the covariance matrix C are orthogonal directed line segments that “span” the variation in the data, and the corresponding (unsigned) eigenvalues are the length of these segments.
… so the product of the eigenvalues is the “volume” occupied by the data, i.e. the determinant of the covariance matrix.
No correlation
X1
X2
X2
X1
Positivecorrelation
Negativecorrelation
1
2
1
1
2
1
2
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.30
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
TOTLNGTH
TO
TLN
GT
H
ALAR HEAD HUMERUS
TO
TLN
GT
H
ALA
R
ALA
R
HE
AD
HE
AD
TOTLNGTH
HU
ME
RU
S
ALAR HEAD HUMERUS
HU
ME
RU
S
Displaying multivariate data I: Displaying multivariate data I: Draftman’s plots (SPLOM)Draftman’s plots (SPLOM)
Displaying multivariate data I: Displaying multivariate data I: Draftman’s plots (SPLOM)Draftman’s plots (SPLOM)
Plot pairs of variables against one another.
Advantages: need only 2 plotting dimensions, bivariate relationships among variables is clear.
Problems: no direct information on relationships in higher than 2 dimensions, relationships between objects unclear.
Plot pairs of variables against one another.
Advantages: need only 2 plotting dimensions, bivariate relationships among variables is clear.
Problems: no direct information on relationships in higher than 2 dimensions, relationships between objects unclear.
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.31
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Displaying multivariate data II: Displaying multivariate data II: multiple 3-D plotsmultiple 3-D plots
Displaying multivariate data II: Displaying multivariate data II: multiple 3-D plotsmultiple 3-D plots
Plot 3 variables against one another.
Advantages: trivariate relationships among variables is clear.
Problems: no direct information on relationships in higher than 3 dimensions, relationships between objects unclear.
Plot 3 variables against one another.
Advantages: trivariate relationships among variables is clear.
Problems: no direct information on relationships in higher than 3 dimensions, relationships between objects unclear.
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.32
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Displaying multivariate data III: Displaying multivariate data III: plotting index variablesplotting index variables
Displaying multivariate data III: Displaying multivariate data III: plotting index variablesplotting index variables
Generate index variables that combine information from several measured variables, then plot these variables.
Advantages: 2- D plots make relationships among variables clear.
Disadvantages: relationships among objects unclear, key information may be lost in data reduction
Generate index variables that combine information from several measured variables, then plot these variables.
Advantages: 2- D plots make relationships among variables clear.
Disadvantages: relationships among objects unclear, key information may be lost in data reduction -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3
FACTOR(2)
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
FAC
TO
R( 1
)
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.33
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Displaying Displaying multivariate data IV: multivariate data IV:
Icon plotsIcon plots
Displaying Displaying multivariate data IV: multivariate data IV:
Icon plotsIcon plots Used to visualize
relationships among objects, e.g. different canine groups.
Advantages: All variables displayed simultaneously.
Problems: order of display of variables arbitrary, and impressions may depend on order. Relationships among variables may be unclear.
Used to visualize relationships among objects, e.g. different canine groups.
Advantages: All variables displayed simultaneously.
Problems: order of display of variables arbitrary, and impressions may depend on order. Relationships among variables may be unclear.
Cuon Dingo Prehistoricdog
Chinesewolf
Goldenjackal
Moderndog
X3
X2
X1
X4
X5
X6
2001
Bio 8100s Applied Multivariate Biostatistics L3.34
Université d’Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Displaying Displaying multivariate data V: multivariate data V:
profile plotsprofile plots
Displaying Displaying multivariate data V: multivariate data V:
profile plotsprofile plots
Represent objects by lines, histograms or Fourier plots.
Advantages: All variables displayed simultaneously.
Problems: order of display of variables arbitrary, and impressions may depend on order. Relationships among variables may be unclear.
Represent objects by lines, histograms or Fourier plots.
Advantages: All variables displayed simultaneously.
Problems: order of display of variables arbitrary, and impressions may depend on order. Relationships among variables may be unclear.
-180 -90 0 90 180Degrees
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
Fou
rier
Co m
pone
n ts
CuonDingoPre_dogch_wolfgold_jackalmodern_dog
GROUP$