-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
1/90
USAID REGIONAL PROGRAM FOR THE MANAGEMENTOF AQUATIC RESOURCES AND ECONOMIC ALTERNATIVES
VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATECHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTSOF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
This publication was produced or review by the United States Agency or International Development. It was prepared by The Center Tropical Agricultural Research and Higher Education (CATIE) and The Nature Conservancy (TNC).
Central America, 2012
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
2/90
Carlos Roberto HasbnEnvironment and Natural Resources Regional Advisor Mexico and Central America.
Contract Technical Ocer. United States Agency or International Development, USAID.
Nstor Windevoxhel
Chie o Party. USAID Regional Program or the Management o Aquatic Resources and Economic [email protected]
Prime Contract No.EPP 1-05 -04 00020 00 TNC
Deliverable Number 5.3.
This document was elaborated by:
Climate Change and Watersheds Program, Tropical Agricultural Research and Higher Education Center. (CATIE)
Lenin Corrales, Pablo Imbach, Claudia Bouroncle, Juan Carlos Zamora, Daniel Ballestero
Mesoamerican Ree Program, The Nature Conservancy, (TNC)Fernando Secaira, Hernando Cabral, Ignacio March, James Rieger
Review by: Juan Carlos Villagrn & Zulma de Mendoza, Helena Miranda (Regional Sta members).
Photography: Fernando Secaira, Calina Zepeda
Graphic Design: Mauricio Ponce
This publication was produced or review by the United States Agency or International Development. It was prepared by The Center
or Tropical Agricultural Research and Higher Education (CATIE) and The Nature Conservancy (TNC).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
3/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
4/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
5/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
The objective o the USAID Regional Program or theManagement o Aquatic Resources and Economic Alternatives
is to reinorce the management o resources along the CentralAmerican coast, reduce threats related to unsustainable
shing and coastal development practices, support biodiversityconservation and improve the liestyles o communities in theregion. Climate change will have a serious eect on coral rees,
sea beds, beaches and coastal wetlands, all ecosystems thatsustain sheries and tourism, the main means o living or the
population; and it will likewise severely aect the inrastructureo the countries communities, cities and businesses. The
implementation o methods or climate change adaptation is
thereore a key element o the Regional Program, in order tomaintain unctionality o the ecosystems that sustain shing and
tourism and to improve the communities adaptive capacity.
The Program has 4 transboundary ocus sites: the Gulo Honduras, the Gul o Fonseca, the Mosquitia Coast o
Honduras and Nicaragua, and the area between Punta Cahuita,Costa Rica and Bocas del Toro, Panama. In 2011, the RegionalProgram developed the ollowing bases or implementing
adaptation methods in the Gul o Honduras:
1. As a rst step, the development o a Climate Change
Vulnerability Analysis and a Climate Change AdaptationPlan was coordinated, to be prepared by the dierentagencies o the Governments o Belize, Nicaragua
and Honduras responsible or managing shing andprotected areas, and or establishing and managing
government agendas on climate change. The purpose orthis coordinated eort was to include the government
entities in this process, and to assure the subsequentimplementation o the recommended adaptation methods.The dierent agencies involved were the Belizean
Department o Fisheries, the Coastal Zone ManagementAuthority and the Ministry o the Environment Oce o
Climate Change; the Guatemalan UNIPESCA, CONAPand Ministry o the Environment and Natural Resources
Oces or Climate Change and Coastal Management;and the Honduran DIGEPESCA, Forestry Conservation
Institute Protected Areas Oce and Department o theEnvironment and Natural Resources oce or ClimateChange. The personnel rom these institutions were
present at the national consultations described here.
THE USAID REGIONAL PROGRAM FOR THE MANAGEMENT OF
AQUATIC RESOURCES AND ECONOMIC ALTERNATIVES AND
ADAPTATION TO CLIMATE CHANGE
2. A Vulnerability to Climate Change analysiswas prepared or the Caribbean Coasts o
Belize, Guatemala and Honduras (USAID,2012b), to determine potential impacts to
the area and estimate the adaptive capacityo the coastal communities identiyingthe most relevant areas and the most
vulnerable municipalities.
3. National discussions were held with keystakeholders about the results o the
vulnerability analysis and jointly identiyied
the required adaptation strategies. Theseconerences were held rom August 22nd
to the 28th, 2011 in Belize City, Belize,La Ceiba, Honduras and Guatemala City,
Guatemala (USAID, 2012c).
4. A series o Proposed Climate ChangeAdaptation Strategies were developedor the Caribbean Regions o Belizea,
Guatemala and Honduras, with strategicrecommendations and specic actions
given or each country.
Envisioned or the next phase:
1. Conversion o the Proposed Climate Change
Adaptation Strategies into two nationalplans or adaptation along the marine and
coastalmarine and coastal; one or Hondurasand the other or Guatemala, and the
incorporation o recommendations in theNational Plan or Belize.
2. Development o climate change adaptationmethods to be used in the management o
protected areas in the Gul o Honduras andthe Bay Islands.
3. Support or the adaptation methods selected
during the implementation o the RegionalProgram rom 2012 to 2015.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
6/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
TABLE OF CONTENTS
FOREWORD 3
1. INTRODUCTION 7
Indicators o climate change and their eect on the coast-marine
environment 7
Dening the vulnerability o natural systems and human communities to climate change 10
II. OBJECTIVES 13
General objective 13
Specic objectives 13
III. METHODOLOGY 14
Denition the study area 14
Denition o the analysis period 17
Focal issues or targets 17
Hypothesis o climate change on target natural systems 18
Hypothesis o climate change impacts on social system targets 22
Methodology or measuring potential impact and vulnerability 23
Rise in sea surace temperature 24
Increase in hurricane intensity 27
Rise in sea level and risks to the coast 28
Changes in rainall patterns and air temperature 31
Estimating the adaptive capacity o human communities 36
Integrating vulnerability data 38
IV.POTENTIAL IMPACT OF CLIMATE CHANGE 40
Rise in sea surace temperature 40
Exposure 40
Sensitivity 46
Frequency and intensity o hurricanes in the Caribbean 48
Rise in sea level 51
Exposure 55
Sensitivity 56
Changes in air temperature and rainall patterns 59
Exposure 59
Sensitivity 64
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
7/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
V. VULNERABILITY TO CLIMATE CHANGE 68
Results o the adaptive capacity analysis 68
Vulnerability to a potential rise in sea level 70
Vulnerability to a potential rise in temperature and drop in rainall 72
Comprehensive vulnerability to the eects o climate change 75
VI. CONCLUSIONS 77
REFERENCES 78
APPENDICES 81
Appendix A: Vulnerability Results by Municipality 81
Belize 81
Guatemala 81
Honduras 82
Appendix B: Protected Area Vulnerability and Sensitivity 83
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
8/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
ACRONYMS
CATIE Centro Agronmico Tropical de Investigacin y Enseanza
CC Climate Change
CMIP3 Coupled Model Intercomparison Project phase 3
CONAP Consejo Nacional de Areas Protegidas (Guatemala)
CRISP Coral Ree Initiative or the South Pacic
CRW Coral Ree Watch (NOAA)
DHW Degree Heat Week
DIGEPESCA Direccin General de Pesca (Honduras)
GEI Green House Gases
ICF Instituto de Conservacin Forestal de Honduras (Honduras)
IPCC Intergovernmental Panel o Experts on Climate Change
MARN Ministerio de Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (Guatemala)
MASL Meters above sea level
NOAA National Oceanographic Atmospheric Administration (USA)
SERNA Secretara de Recursos Naturales
SSH Sea surace height
SST Sea surace temperature
TNC The Nature Conservancy
UNIPESCA Unidad de Pesca (Guatemala)
USAID United States Agency or International Development
WCRP World climate Research Program
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
9/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
I. Introduction
The communities located along the Caribbean coastso Belize, Guatemala and Honduras depend strongly on
shing and tourism or their livelihoods. These activitiesin turn are based on the use o goods and services rom
dierent types o coastal and marine habitats includingrees, sea grasses, lagoons and mangroves, among
others. Additionally, housing, urban, transportation and
recreational inrastructure has also been built along thecoast and on the coastal plains, making them vulnerable
to storms, hurricanes and foods. However, coral rees,mangroves and coastal lagoons reduce their eects,
providing a key service to reduce vulnerability.
Coastal and marine habitats are seriously disturbed byhuman activities through overshing, contamination,sedimentation and tourism activities; and weather
variability and climate change will substantially worsenthese conditions. Given the strong dependence o
coastal communities and national economies on theseecosystems, adaptation actions must be implemented to:
1. Improve the resilience o coastal ecosystems to
climate change and extreme weather events tocontinue to providing the goods and services that
assist the longterm sustenance o the communitiesand biodiversity.
2. Build the capacity o human coastal communities toadapt to the changes and extreme events that will
inevitably occur.
3. Finally, improve adaptive capacity and reduce thesensitivity o coastal inrastructure ports, uel
discharge areas, roads and airports all o keyimportance to the three national economies.
INDICATORS OF CLIMATE CHANGE
AND THEIR EFFECT ON THE COAST-
MARINE ENVIRONMENT.
The ocean perorms key unctions that are critical or
the climate through its close link with the atmosphereby storing heat, carrying it to all dierent regions o
the planet, evaporating masses o water, reezing andthawing polar regions, and storing and exchanging gases
such as carbon dioxide (CO2) (Herr and Galland 2009).
Increased concentrations o greenhouse gases without
precedent in human history (IPCC 2007), are creatingnegative changes to the oceans, threatening their ser-vices to ecosystems and human populations (Herr and
Galland 2009). Figure 1 shows the physical and chemicalchanges that the increase in greenhouse gases produces
in the coastal and ocean environment.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
10/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure 1. Important abiotic changes associated with cimate change (modied Hare 2006).
These changes are interrelated and create synergies that increase the strength o their eects and subsequent impactson ecosystems and people. For example, higher air temperatures and direct sunlight increase sea surace and seacolumn temperature which in turn change rainall patterns, increase hurricanes strength, expand water volumes and
raise sea level. These eects nally increase the strength o the marine currents, tides, waves, rainall and winds thataect the coast, producing coastal erosion, fooding, salt water intrusion, the destruction o vegetation and human
inrastructure as well as important changes to the ecosystems (USAID et al. 2009). Table 1 shows the eects o climatechange and their potential impacts on marine systems and habitats.
Precipitationchange Increased air
temperature
Intensified atmosphericpreassure gradients
Increased stormfrequency
Increasedwatertemperature
Sea levelrise
Increased UV
Increased CO2
DecreasedpH
Increase greenhouse gas concentrations
Intensifiedupwelling ?
Humanactivities
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
11/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Tabe 1. Possibe eects o cimate change on the marine and coasta environment (prepared b the
authors based on CRRH 1996; Hare 2006; IPCC 2007; Kokot 2004; Nichos et a, 2007; Orr et a. 2009;
UICN 2003; USAID et a. 2009).
Eects o cimate change Impacts
Increased CO2
in the atmosphereOcean acidication
Ocean acidication Decrease in the growth o coral and invertebrates that require calcium
carbonate to develop.
Increase in the air temperature Ocean warming: temperature o the surace water and water column.Changes in wind currents.Changes in rainall patterns,
Local weather anomalies.
Ocean warmingThermal expansion o the sea, raising the sea level.
Increased thermal stratication.Changes in marine currents.Reduction and changes in upwelling.
Thermal stress on ecosystems and species.
Rise in sea levelPermanent fooding o coastal zones and loss o coastal ecosystems and
inrastructure.Changes in estuarine salinization levels and tidal residence times.
Changes in fooding levels and patterns.Coastal erosion and loss o beaches.Saltwater intrusion in the coastal aquiers.
Rainall changes Increase in torrential rainalls, causing fooding and changes in estuarine salinelevels.Longer dry periods that change estuarine saline levels.
Changes in ocean currentsChanges in larval dispersion patterns.
Increased beach erosion.Changes in rainall and wind patterns.Changes in marine surgence.
Increase in storms intensity Destructive winds and fooding o the ecosystems and inrastructure.Coastal fooding and erosion.
Flooding in coastal zones, plains and riverbeds, and impact on vulnerablemountain areas.
Ocean acidication is an ongoing phenomenon. Records or the Northern Pacic dating back to 1990 (UNESCO 2009)
show a correlation with the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide (Figure 2).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
12/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
0
Figure 2. Ocean acidication and its correation to atmospheric CO2
in the Pacic (UNESCO 2009).
DEFINING THE VULNERABILITY
OF NATURAL SYSTEMS AND HUMAN
COMMUNITIES TO CLIMATECHANGE
Current and uture eects o climate change areconstantly more complex, creating more pressure on
ecosystems and aecting the liestyles o the people whodepend on natural resources under constantly changingconditions. For this reason coastal communities need
to anticipate and prepare or change, and institutionsmust promote and acilitate planning and preparation
or the uture (Marshall et al. 2009). The time or thispreparation is now; consequently the vulnerability
assessment considers current adaptive capacity to acetodays and uture impacts o climate change eects.
Climate change is a global process over which localcommunities have little infuence. However communities
can ace climate change through the adoption o keymeasures designed to reduce their vulnerability, decrease
the impacts and allow more time or better adaptation(Marshall et al. 2009).
Marshall et al. (2009) declared that vulnerabilityassessments should cover both the individual as well as
community scale, as interactions between the dierentscales are important. In this sense the community is
ormed o individuals; however individual responses are
requently determined by community standards, makingit impossible to understand vulnerability on an individual
scale alone.
People will also have to ace direct impacts o climate
change such as changes in drinking water availability,coastal erosion, salt water inltrations, fooding o
residential and agricultural lands and underground watersources (CRISP 2011).
People will also have to ace impacts o climate change inthe ecosystems. Fishing and recreational activities will be
impacted (Marshall et al. 2009) through the degradationo sh habitats such as coral rees and mangroves, loss
o beaches, and snorkeling and diving areas. The coastalprotection provided by barrier rees and mangroves will
be undermined. The eects o climate change will havesignicant eects on the social and cultural lie o manysocieties (CRISP 2011).
The concept o vulnerability was dened by the
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change1
(IPCC2001) Group o Experts as: The degree to which a systemis susceptible to, or unable to cope with, adverse eects o
climate change, including climate variability and extremes.
1 UNEP (United Nations Environmental Program) andthe WMO (World Meteorological Organization) ormed
in 1988 the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Changeand the United Nations Framework Convention on
Climate Change (UNFCCC).
Year
CO2Atmospheric (ppmv)
pCO2Seawater (atm)
pH Seawater
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
13/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Vulnerability is comprised o three components: exposure,
sensitivity and adaptive capacity.
1. Exposure reers to the presence o an eect oclimate change that can have negative repercussions.
It is measured by the extent o the anomaly inclimate or biophysical aspects; or example, how manydegrees the average temperature will change or how
many centimeters will the sea level rise, and the areathat will be aected.
2. Sensitivity reers to the presence o an object that issusceptible or sensitive to climate risks. For example,
i agriculture exists today or in the uture in areasthat will be subject to increased temperature and/or
fooding as a result o sea level rise.
3. Adaptive capacity reers to the capacity o a system
to change to better conront adverse impacts orrecover rom them. It assesses the capacities o
human communities and individuals, companiesand national economies. For example, it assesses i
armers have the capacity to change crops, increaseirrigation (to cope with increase temperature) or
move to another area (i fooding is the threat).
In a social context, the terms exposure, sensitivity and
adaptive capacity are dened as ollows:
1. Exposure is dened as the degree to which acommunity is in contact with weather phenomena
or specic climate impacts. This specically includesresidential areas and resources that are exposedto dierent impacts and weather phenomena. For
example, houses located close to the high tideline have higher exposure to sea level rise. Coastal
plantations have higher exposure to inltrationso salt water and fooding. Shallow rees that are
ully exposed to sunlight in areas with little windhave higher exposure to a rise in surace watertemperatures (CRISP 2011).
2. Sensitivit is the degree to which a community is
negatively aected by climate changes. For example,amilies or communities may be highly sensitive i
commercial coastal or subsistence plantations areexposed to changes in temperature, rainall and
foods derived rom climate change. I exposed reesorm the principal shing area that is the sourceo ood and income or a community, then that
community is highly sensitive to coral bleachingresulting rom raise o ocean temperatures (CRISP,
2011; Marshall et al., 2009).
3. Adaptive capacit is the potential o a community
to adapt, to ameliorate or to recuperate romthe impacts o climate change; it is determined
by knowledge and organizational, productive,social and institutional resources. For example a
wellinormed community with good organizations,cultural traditions and community participation maybe capable o developing good plans and making
decisions that help all members o the community.A household with sucient income rom diversied
sources is better able to adapt to climate change,in comparison with those that depend on oneactivity and/or are below the poverty level. Adaptive
capacity is the component o vulnerability that ismost susceptible to the infuence o social systems,
and consequently is an evident ocus or adaptation(CRISP 2011; Marshall et al. 2009).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
14/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
2
4. Figure 3. Co-dependence between ecoogica and socia sstems. The dierent eements cannot be
evauated without reerring to the others (Hobda et a. In revision: taken rom Marsha et a. 2009).
Exposure Sensitivity
Potentialimpracts
Ecologicalsystems
Socioeconomicsystems
Potential
impacts
Adaptativecapacity
Adaptative
capacity
Resourcedependency
Ecological vulnerability-
exposure social system
Vulnerability
socioeconomic
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
15/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
II. Objectives
3. To identiy the projected impacts o climate change
on the livelihoods o coastal communities thatdepend on the natural systems.
4. To identiy the priority areas or coastal ecosystemrestoration or conservation , to continue or
improve the provision o goods and services tothose communities.
GENERAL OBJECTIVE
To determine the level o climate change vulnerability o natural and social systems alongthe Carribbean coasts o Belizea, Guatemala and Hondura; and to identiy priority areas to
implement adaptation actions.
SPECIFIC OBJECTIVES
1. To present the scientic bases or climate change
trends, in increase availability or decision makers asthe basis o their adaptation policies and practices.
2. To identiy the impacts o climate change predictedor coastal and marine habitats that are the basis o
coastal communities livelihoods and which reducethe risk o extreme weather events.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
16/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
4
III. Methodology
This vulnerability analysis was conducted based on the
methodological ramework proposed by Schrter et al.(2005), and modied by the consultants:
DEFINITION OF THE STUDY AREA
The Exposure and sensitivity to climate change wereanalyzed using the boundaries o the watersheds o
the Mesoamerican Ree and the exclusive economiczones o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras (Figure4-A). Watersheds were originally included consideringthat changes in storms, hurricanes and rains derived
rom climate change determine the volume o waterand sediments aecting the availability o resh water,estuarine salinity, fooding and sedimentation in the
marine zone. However, only changes in terrestrialvegetation were considered in this analysis.
The coastal municipalities o Belize, Guatemala and
Honduras (Figure 4-B) were used to analyze the adaptivecapacity o human communities, as these were themost appropriate administrative units with statistical
inormation on social and economic aspects or thethree countries.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
17/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Exposure anaisis area
Terrestria Marine Kes and Isands
A
Figure 4. Stud area. Map A shows the stud area used in the exposure and sensitivit anasis.
Map B shows the stud area or the adaptive capacit anasis in the marine and coasta zone,
and consequent vunerabiit to CC.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
18/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
6
Vunerabiit anasis area
Terrestria Marine Kes and Isands
B
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
19/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
FOCAL ISSUES OR TARGETS
Climate change aects dierently every element othe social and natural systems. Banking may not be
as aected as sheries, and manatees less than corals.Similarly most adaptation measures can only be targeted
to specic elements. Thereore the analysis chooses themost relevant elements o the social and natural systemas ocal issues.
The ocal issues o this analysis are elements o the
natural systems (ecosystems, habitats, species, and keysites or species) that are considered important due totheir contribution o goods and services, and that could
be aected by climate change. Social ocal issues are keyelements o the social system that are critical or human
communities and the economy, and that are likely to beaected by climate change given the location or their
dependence on natural resources sensitive to climate
change.
NATURAl SySTEM ElEMENTS:
1. Coral rees and corals2. Fish spawning aggregation sites.
3. Sea grasses.4. Important shing sites.5. Sea turtle nesting sites.
6. Beaches.7. Mangroves and other coastal wetlands.
8. Coastal and migratory birds.
SOCIAl SySTEM OBjECTS:
1. Human populations: housing and service
buildings (schools, hospitals, shopping centers,etc.).
2. Artisanal and industrial shing.3. Tourism: hotels, restaurants, tourism attractions
and accesses.4. Coastal inrastructure: ports, marinas, piers,
roads, industrial installations and airports.
5. Commercial and subsistence agriculture.
DEFINITION OF THE ANALYSIS
PERIOD
The degree o exposure o natural and social systems toclimate change depends on the level o change in physical
and climate variables. Thereore we use climate changeprojections to determine the targets exposure.
Two temporal horizons were used or sea suracetemperature, rom 2030-2039 and rom 2090-2099; atemporal horizon o 2070-2099 was used to determine
change in rainall patterns and air temperature, due tothe high level o uncertainty or the period 2030-2039.
Historical inormation available up to 2010 was used todetermine past sea level rise. It was not projected in the
uture, but it considered areas that are below 8 metersabove sea level as potentially aected by sea level rise,
storms surges, and hurricane waves and foods.
The analysis included historical records o physical andclimate variables:
Air temperature: 1900-2010
Hurricanes and tropical storms: 1898-2010
Sea level: 1951-2010
Sea surace water thermal stress: 2006-2010
Future vulnerability depends on the evolution o
social systems such as human capacity, populationgrowth, change and growth o economic activities, and
inrastructure. These aspects were not projected in theuture; only current adaptive capacity and sensitivity wereestimated considering that the plan seeks to reduce
current vulnerability; and that governments, the privatesector, and individuals can and must take action now.
Future exposure helps us to plan or a less sensitivedevelopment and or societies with greater adaptive
capacity.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
20/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
8
HYPOTHESIS OF CLIMATE CHANGE ON TARGET NATURAL SYSTEMS
The analysis develops a hypothesis o the potential impact that climate change eects will have on ocal issues. They arebased on literature review and adapted rom Cambers et al. 2007. In this analysis we did not evaluate the likelihood and
certainty o the hypothesis.
Tabe 2. Hpothesis o impact on natura sstems.
Target CC eect Hpothesis o potentia impact on targets
Coral rees
and rees
Increase o sea suracetemperature.
Sea temperature increase will cause bleaching (zooxantelas algae whichlive in symbiosis with corals, leave the coral) and may cause coral
mortality i algae does not return. The longer the heating periods, thelesser the possibilities o recovery. Also, corals aected by other pressures
(contamination and overshing) are less resistant, becoming moresusceptible to bleaching and less apt to recover.
Increase o CO2
inseawater.
Oceans absorb CO2 rom the air, thereore an increase o atmosphericCO
2increases CO
2concentration in the water, which reduces the quantity
o ions needed or the ormation o calcium carbonate, urther reducinggrowth or bony shes, corals and other invertebrates.
Increase in theintensity o rains.
Increased precipitation will increase sediment discharge, reducing availablelight at the mouth o rivers causing reduced growth and increasedmortality, as well as complete destruction by sedimentation.
Increase in the
intensity o stormsand hurricanes.
Increase in the requency and intensity o storms will augment the
destruction o coral rees without allowing their recovery. In general,rees can recover in 10-15 years rom natural phenomena; the increased
requency o storms will allow less capacity or growth, so rees willdeteriorate.It will also increase the intensity o rains (see previous impact) increasing
run o and sedimentation.
Sea level rise.
Growth o healthy corals can be maintained despite the pace o sea level
rise unless changes occur so rapidly that the available light is reduced,hampering coral growth.
As sea levels rise, this reduces the capacity o ree crests to dissipate wavesand tides, reducing the unction o protecting the coast against extremeclimactic events.
Sea level rise will aect the coast, which may generate more sediments and
debris that will aect corals.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
21/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Target CC eect Hpothesis o potentia impact on targets
Coastalwetlands:
mangroves,lagoons,
savannas
Sea level rise.
Possible loss o mangrove area due to erosion at the edges or loss o
sandbars and lagoons that oer protection.Increase in mangrove surace by relocation and natural migration to the
interior where topography, soils and human use allows it.As sea levels rise, the salinity o coastal lagoons will increase, altering the
species composition (red mangrove is more tolerant to salinity than othermangrove species).Increase in salinity reduces the survival o seedlings, growth and the
photosynthetic capacity o less tolerant species (button, black and whitemangroves).
Increase in air
temperature.
Mangrove productivity, growth, litter production, and the expansion o
certain species are expected to increase in combination with high levels oatmospheric CO
2and the increase in temperatures.
I the water temperature reaches 35C or higher, it can cause thermal
stress to Rhizophora mangle. I the temperature goes over 38C, it canreduce the invertebrate diversity that live in the roots o the mangroves
and possibly prevent the establishment o seedlings.
Increase in oceanCO
2.
Increase in mangrove productivity.Stomatal conductance is reduced.
Increase in theintensity o rains.
Increased precipitation reduces salinity, exposes sulates and increasesnutrient availability.
Increase in droughtperiods.
The decrease in rainall and the increase in evaporation are expectedto cause a reduction in mangrove areas, especially in inland zones withhypersaline areas that will also suer a decline in growth rates.
Increase in the
intensity o stormsand hurricanes.
Mangrove coverage will be severely aected by the increase in the intensity
o hurricanes. Mangrove mortality rates caused by category 4 hurricanes inthe Caribbean are between 68 and 99% in the aected areas.
Beaches,coastal dunes,
low islandsand keys
Sea level rise.This will accelerate erosion o beaches and cays, eventually altering thecoastal topography, eliminating dunes and barriers between the sea and
interior lagoons or bays. It will also eliminate cays and small islands.
Increase in theintensity o storms
and hurricanes.
It will exacerbate beach erosion and erode sand barriers, cays and islands.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
22/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
0
Target CC eect Hpothesis o potentia impact on targets
Sea turtles
and nestingsites
Sea level rise.
Loss o habitats or nesting sea turtles and birds due to an increase in
erosion and the altered topography o beaches caused by sea level rise andmore requent and intense storms.
Increased tidal height will also food the eggs rom below. I the sand issaturated by the waves o the storms and the subsoil is fooded and doesnot drain properly, the embryos will drown.
Increase in the
intensity o stormsand hurricanes.
Further erosion and destruction o beaches and nests.
Increase in watertemperature.
Could alter migratory routes o turtles (studies indicate that migratoryroutes are heavily infuenced by sea surace temperature and chlorophyll
concentration).
Increase in airtemperature.
The sex is determined by the temperature in the middle third othe incubation period. Higher temperatures avor emales and lower
temperatures avor males within a thermal tolerance range o 25 to 35 C.Hypotheses have been stated that populations could sel-regulate i there
are more individuals rom one sex. Temperature could aect the severity oinections and could increase the outbreak o diseases o marine turtles.
Sea andcoastal birds
Increase in airtemperature.
Approximately 60% o the studies perormed on reproduction show that
at long term, the egg laying dates are changing according to the patterns oglobal warming.
Changes in wind
patterns.
Change in the migration patterns o birds due to changes in the
geographical displacement o winds and an increase in the requency andintensity o storms.
Increase in theintensity o storms
and hurricanes.
The increased requency o storms in the Caribbean may be the cause or
the reduction o some migratory birds. Mortality caused by winds, rainsand foods has been documented or aquatic birds such as the Brown
Pelican (Pelecanus occidentalis), and the Clapper Rail (Rallus longirostris).Hurricanes cause habitat loss or migratory birds like beaches, coastalwetlands, islands, keys and orests.
Sea level rise. Loss o habitats such as beaches, islands, keys and coastal wetlands.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
23/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Target CC eect Hpothesis o potentia impact on targets
Sea grasses
Sea level rise.
Studies have not dened its aect. Changes in light availability, wave energy,
type o substrate and herbivores will infuence marine prairies dependingon the species.
Increase in the
intensity o rains andlonger periods odrought.
More intense rains and storms will increase sediment transport that can
bury marine prairies and reduce light availability.Longer periods o drought will reduce the supply o resh water increasingsalinity, which can be a stress actor or sea grasses.
Increase in watertemperature.
Grasses could be aected by a change o 1.5 C, reducing their metabolism.Temperatures o 35 C or higher could inhibit root sprout o some species.
Increase in ocean
CO2.
Increase in CO2
will increase sea grass productivity. Together with a slight
rise in temperature, these chemical changes will augment biomass and
detritus.
Increase in theintensity o storms
and hurricanes.
The increase in storms and tidal waves, and the subsequent change in river
fow and sediment transport could destroy sea grasses. Their capacity orrecovery could diminish with storm requency. Marine prairies grow in low
energy environments and an increase in water turbulence could cause theirdisplacement or disappearance.
Coastal and
pelagic shes
Increase in watertemperature.
The rise in water temperature has caused coral bleaching and mortalityand a prolieration o algae, which has signicantly reduced sh density and
coral ree biomass. Data rom the Sabana-Camagey Archipelago, Cuba.Migration o diverse species to colder waters could cause mass extinctions
due to low dispersion capacity or lack o habitat.Changes in temperatures will impact the distribution and abundance o sh.
IIncrease in oceanCO
2.
There is convincing evidence that suggests that acidication aects
the calcication process, through which corals, mollusks and otherinvertebrates build their skeletons, shells and plates rom calcium
carbonate.
Increase in the
intensity o stormsand hurricanes.
Increase in storm intensity will degrade critical habitat or sh like rees,
mangroves and sea grasses, resulting in reduced the sh populations thatuse them.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
24/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
25/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
METHODOLOGY FOR MEASURING
POTENTIAL IMPACT
AND VULNERABILITY
Potential impacts and vulnerability were analyzed using
the our most critical climate change eects that canbe mapped or the study area. Then, we selected thosetargets with mapped inormation and which are sensitive
to those eects with a good degree o certainty. Theeects used to measure potential impact were:
Rise in sea surace temperature
Increase in storm intensity
Rise in sea level
Changes in rainall patterns and air temperature
Exposure and sensitivity indicators were dened or
each eect o climate change. Indicators were scored
using the methodology proposed by Preston et al.
Increase in sea suracetemperature
Increase in sea leveland coast risk
Change precipitationpatterns and air
temperature
V
R
Exposure Sensitivity Vulnerability
Following is a description o the methodology used to measure the potential impact o each climatic eect,
the indicators used and sources o inormation.
E S C
Exposure SensitivityAdaptiveCapacity
Figure 5. Conceptua approach to assess potentia impact and vunerabiit or each o the three eects
o cimate change and to integrate the vunerabiit o the stud area.
(2008), according to which indicators were given a score
rom 1 to 5, where 1 represents the lowest exposureor sensitivity, and 5 the greatest. The indicators wereestimated or three temporal scenarios: current, 2030-
2039 and 2090-99.
The adaptive capacity o human communities was thenestimated using 8 indicators, evaluated on the samescale with the lowest adaptive capacity 5, and the
greatest 1. In this analysis, which considered only currentconditions; the conditions measures by the indicators
were not projected in the uture. Then, the three typeso indicators (exposure, sensitivity and adaptive capacity)
were added to estimate the net vulnerability rom each
eect in the current scenario (Figure 5).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
26/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
27/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure 6. Causa mode used to measure the potentia impact o the rise in sea surace temperature.
Climate Topography
Sstems
Materia resources Socia resources
Adaptive
capacity
Sensitivity
Exposure
Natura sstem
Socia sstem
Sea surace temperature
Water colunmsupericial
Tourism
Ree coral
Fishing
PotentialImpact
Vulnerability
Natural Physical
Finance
Human Social
Cultural Political
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
28/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
6
The methodology used to analyze changes in sea suracetemperature (SST) was developed by the Coral Ree
Watch (CRW, http://coralreewatch.noaa.gov/), part othe National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
(NOAA), and consists o:
1. Nocturnal data selected rom the Coast Watchdatabase, to eliminate the eect o direct sunlightand to reduce variations in SST caused by solar
warming.2. Monthly mean SST calculations.
3. Levels o thermal stress evaluated by comparingthe maximum monthly average rom the baseclimatology (MMM, 2001 2005) with the monthly
temperature or the study period (SST, 2006 2011). Table 5 shows the thermal stress evaluated
according to the dierent states that may ormay not produce sucient stress to cause coral
bleaching.
Tabe 5. Therma stress indicator or marine areas subect to a rise in sea surace temperature (NOAA
Cora Ree Watch 2011).
State Interpretation Denition
Without stress (1) No thermal stress Hotspot (1) equals 0
Attention (2) Low thermal stressHotspot (1) above zero but below the SSTthreshold or bleaching
Warning (3) Accumulating thermal stressOver the SST threshold or bleaching; DHW(2) above
0
Warning level 1 (4) Bleaching is expectedOver the SST threshold or bleaching; DHW(2) 4 or
above
Warning level 2 (5)Generalized bleaching and some
mortality is expected
Over the SST threshold or bleaching; DHW(2) 8
above
Notes: (1) Hotspot: areas where SST data exceed the average temperature observed in the hottest month o the year.(2) DHWs show the amount o stress rom heat accumulated in a certain area over the last 12 weeks (3 months). In
other words, Hotspot values are added when the temperature exceeds the bleaching threshold.
The base climatology data used in the analysis was takenrom the NOAA Coast Watch (http://coastwatch.
noaa.gov/ ) database which contains global Sea SuraceTemperature data at a spatial resolution o 5 km2.
Thermal stress was evaluated using scenarios o utureSST increases based on Donner (2009). The database
presents simulations or two emission scenarios (B1and A2); one or each scenario, and evaluates temporalthresholds such as those mentioned above (or 2030-
2039 and or 2090-2099), or a total o our simulationso uture climate.
Data is reported as SST anomalies, which are thedierence between current and uture temperatures.
The rst step was to add these to the base climatology(2001-2005), and then nd hotspots where there
is a rise in Sea Surace Temperature, using the samemethodology as the baseline data.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
29/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Increase in hurricane intensity
The question analyzed here is: What areas are historically more aected byhurricanes? What areas have more requent hurricanes, and which have been
struck by stronger hurricanes?
All the analysis targets are sensitive to hurricanes, especially human populations,rees and beaches. Hurricane Center has mapped hurricane trajectories or thelast 150 years with their intensity marked on the trajectory in the study area, and
then overlapped on the targets location.
Tabe 6. Hurricane exposure and sensitivit indicators.
Indicators Source o Data
Exposure indicators
Areas aected by hurricane intensity Historical data or tropical cyclones (NOAA, 2011)
Areas aected by increased requency o hurricanes Historical data or tropical cyclones (NOAA, 2011)
Sensitivit indicators or natura sstems
Agriculture exposed to more requent hurricanesCoral ree coverage (WRI, 2011) and areas aected by
increased requency o hurricanes
Agriculture exposed to higher intensity hurricanesCoral ree coverage (WRI, 2011) and areas aected by
hurricane intensity
Inrastructure exposed to more requenthurricanes Coral ree coverage (WRI, 2011) and areas aected byincreased requency o hurricanes
Urban and inhabitated areas exposed to higher
intensity hurricanes
Coral ree coverage (WRI, 2011) and areas aected by
hurricane intensity
Urban and inhabitated areas exposed to morerequent hurricanes
Coral ree coverage (WRI, 2011) and areas aected byincreased requency o hurricanes
Tabe 7. Hurricanes are cassied in 5 categories according to wind speed.
Category 1 2 3 4 5
Wind speed (km/h) 119153 154177 178209 210249 250
Tide height (m) 1.21.5 1.82.4 2.73.7 4.05.5 5,5
Pressure at the center o the hurricane (hPa) 980 965979 945964 920944
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
30/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
8
averaging SSH measurements o all the oceans on the
plant. Unlike the oceanographic measuring stationsthat measure relative sea level, the altimeter allows the
registry o absolute variations in global sea level, preciseto tenths o mm/year. These variations in global sea levelinclude: a) expansion or contraction due to variations in
water density (determined by changes in temperatureand salinity); b) exchanges o water with continents, the
atmosphere and polar caps: c) low requency variationsin ocean circulation.
In the conceptual model or coastal vulnerability to sealevel rises (Figure 7), exposure (in red) is driven by the
interaction between the weather system and coastaltopography. Sensitivity (in yellow) is a unction o the
ecosystems, productive activities and inrastructure
present on the coast. The combination o exposure andsensitivity creates the potential or an adverse eect.
Adaptive capacity (in green) is based on material andsocial capital used to address potential impacts and
vulnerability. The critical processes and interaction arerepresented by arrows.
Rise in sea level and risks
to the coast
This analysis was based on estimated relative (sea to
land) and absolute changes o sea level (SL). Relativemeasurements are based on tide gauges installed on
the land surace which are aected by changes in theirsurace position, thereby aecting their measurements.Absolute changes are measured using high precision
satellite instruments that were installed in the 1990s.
Ocean volume increases over very large geological timescales (109 years), while morphological changes to oceanwatersheds and tectonic plates that occur on temporal
sales o 107 108 years, could result in changes in sealevel o hundreds o meters. Sea level has changed over
temporal scales o hundreds o thousands o years asthe result o climate changes caused by the cyclical
exchanges o water between sheets o ice and the
ocean. In addition, changes in the elevation o the earthscrust (isostatic ice) continue to occur, and estimates
o changes in global sea level should be corrected or aconsideration made or this eect.
Global ocean volume changes due to climate change
also occur on temporal scales measured in decadesas a result o thermal dilation and exchanges o waterbetween the ocean and other reservoirs, including
the atmosphere. Global changes in sea level have beennoted on this scale, due to changes in ocean currents
and atmospheric pressure. Sea level can be modiedat the local and regional levels by tectonic, subsidence
and sedimentation processes. Regional processes maypredominate in the current scenarios o rising global sealevel (~ 3 mm/year), with regional variations ranging rom
-1 mm/year to 10 mm/year.
Sea level has been measured globally by NASA and theEuropean Space Agency since 1992 with a precision
o 5 mm at 10-day intervals, using altimeters aboardgeophysical observation satellites in polar orbits. Thealtimeters measure the distance between the satellite
and the surace using radar pulses, with sea suraceheight (SSH) calculated considering the precise position
o the satellite with respect to an ellipsoid surace oreerence (a model o the orm o the earths surace).
Global average sea height is altimetrically calculated,
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
31/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure 7. Conceptua mode or coasta vunerabiit to sea eve rise.
Material Resources Social Resources
Land use and development
Potential
Impact
Vulnerability
Naturalsystem
Social system
Tides
Climate Topography
CoastElevation
Cyclons Coastslope
Sea level rise Beach type
Adaptive
i t
Sensitivity
Exposure
Tourism Fishing Agriculture Inraestructure
Land use
Natural Physical
Finance
Human Social
Cultural Political
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
32/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
33/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
The data used to analyze sea level rise reerred to the relative rise (rom tide gauges) and absolute rise in sea level(rom remote sensors) in the Ports o Corts and Castilla in Honduras and Santo Toms in Guatemala. The ollowing
table lists the number o years o collecting data o each type.
Tabe 10. years o data compied per port and remote sensing station to cacuate reative and absoute
rise in sea eve.
Portyears o data
Reative increase
years o data
Absoute increaseTota ears
Corts 20 18 38
Castilla 13 18 31
Santo Toms 16 18 34
Changes in rainall patterns
and air temperatureThe ollowing databases and climate change scenarios
and models used to analyze projected temperature andrainall anomalies were used to analyze exposure:
Baseine cimate data: Changes in air temperature
and rainall were evaluated using the World Clim(Hijmans et al. 2005) climatological database, whichprovided a set o global weather data at a spatial
resolution o 1 km2 or the period o 1960-1990.
Future cimate data: The climate change scenarios
used come rom the World Climate Research Program(WCRP), rom group CMIP3 (Coupled Model
Intercomparison Project phase 3), used in the IPCC AR4report. These scenarios have been scaled down (to a
resolution o 2.5 minutes, approximately 5 km) by TheNature Conservancy (TNC) Caliornia in three groupso radiative orcing (IPCC-SRES), B1 and A2 with 48, 52
and 36 scenarios respectively or the period 2070-2100,or a total o 136 uture climate simulations (Table 11).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
34/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
2
Tabe 11. Simuations used or Genera Atmospheric-Ocean Circuation Modes (GAOCM).
GAOCM 20th Cent low emissions (B1) High emissions (A2)
BCC-CM1 1 1 0BCCR-BCM2.0 1 1 1
CCSM3 8 8 4
CGCM3.1(T47) 5 5 5
CGCM3.1(T63) 1 1 0
CNRM-CM3 1 1 1
CSIRO-Mk3.0 1 1 1
ECHAM5/MPI-OM 4 3 3
ECHO-G 3 3 3
FGOALS-g1.0 3 3 0
GFDL-CM2.0 1 1 1
GFDL-CM2.1 1 1 1
GISS-AOM 2 2 0
GISS-EH 3 0 0
GISS-ER 5 1 1
INM-CM3.0 1 1 1
IPSL-CM4 1 1 1
MIROC3.2(hires) 1 1 0MIROC3.2(medres) 3 3 3
MRI-CGCM2.3.2 5 5 5
PCM 4 3 4
UKMO-HadCM3 2 1 1
UKMO-HadGEM1 1 1 0
Total 58 48 36
Cacuating exposure to changes in raina and air temperature: Exposure to rainall is measured according to
the number o simulations that predict a drop o over 50% in rain all based on the IPCC methodology on probabilityo change, which evaluates the amount rom simulations that exceed the established threshold (decrease in rainall over
50%). When
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
35/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Exposure to changes in temperature is measuredaccording to the amount o simulations that predict
a temperature rise in excess o 3 C. The samemethodology was used to evaluate exposure to changes
in rainall.
Changes in vegetation tpe according to theHodridge ie zones sstem: a simulation o theHoldridge lie zones system was developed to evaluate
the probabilities o change in vegetation type as aproduct o climate change. The Holdridge system
which is based on values o latitudinal region, altitudinalfoor and ground moisture, was used to construct themethodology proposed by Zamora-Pereira (2011), based
on the ollowing steps:
Denition o atitudina foors: Using WorldClim (Hijmans et al 2005) as the base climate data,
monthly average and annual biotemperatures were
calculated to dene the altitudinal foors, and nallyan average was obtained or the twelve months.
This is the mean annual biotemperature, which wasused to generate a layer o inormation that denes
the altitudinal foors, with the ranges separatedbetween 0-1.5, 1.5-3, 3-6, 6-12, 12-17, 17-24, and
24-30 degrees.
Denition o ground moisture: The second
variable calculated was monthly precipitation.When added, these values gave the total annual
precipitation or absolute annual precipitation.This layer o inormation was useul in obtaining
moisture provinces. Annual precipitation data wasreclassied in the ollowing ranges: 62.5-125, 125-250, 250-500, 500-1000, 1000-2000, 2000-4000,
4000-8000, and > 8000 mm.
Denition o atitudina region: The third andlast variable is biotemperature at sea level. This was
obtained by combining the average biotemperaturesor a site and at its elevation, thereby dening thelatitudinal region o the lie zone according to
geometric progression that indicates temperaturedecreases as elevation above sea level increases.
Construction o base ie zone maps: Finally
the current lie zones distribution map wasconstructed by overlapping layers o the above
inormation using a geographic analysis program(ArcGIS 9.3). This constitutes the map o reerenceor later analysis o changes in the distribution o lie
zones.
Future ie zones: The same methodology wasused to determine scenarios o uture lie zone
distribution, with a total o 136 uture distributionmaps constructed. Climate variable values are
reported as climate anomalies or each month; thatis, the dierence between current climatological
data (1961-1990) and uture simulated data (2070-2100).
Cacuating exposure uncertaint: Uncertaintyo uture climate results reers to the dierent
possibilities or dierent data in the proposeduture timerame. An analysis was run comparingchange between lie zones using current distribution
as the base and comparing it with each o the136 simulations; the IPCC (2005) uncertainty
methodology was then applied to reclassiy thearea according to the number o simulations that
indicated changes in orest type. Exposure was
determined to be Very Low when
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
36/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
37/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure 8. Conceptua mode or assessing vunerabiit to changes in raina and air temperature.
Material Resources Social Resources
Climate
Natural system
Social system Sistema social
Adaptive
Sensitivity
ExposureTemperaturevariability
Averagetemperature
Averagerainall
Rainallvariability
Wind Moisture
Temperature change Temperature changeWindchange
Moisturechange
PotentialImpact
Vulnerability
Vegetation Land use Elevation Slope
Tourism Fishing Agriculture Inraestructure
Natural Physical
Finance
Human Social
Cultural Political
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
38/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
6
ESTIMATING THE ADAPTIVE
CAPACITY OF HUMAN
COMMUNITIESAdaptive capacity can be estimated at the individual,community, sector and regional scale. Although an
estimation o the adaptive capacity o a communitymay derive rom the adaptive capacity o the individualsthat orm the community, an assessment o community
characteristics may oer inormation that better refectsthe capacity to respond to climate change (Marshall et al.
2009).
Dierent actors must be considered and evaluated using
a variety o methods, including the analysis o censusinormation, key inormant surveys rom businesses,
industry, government, research organizations, NGOs,indigenous groups and the public in general (Marshall etal. 2009).
Each site may have certain unique characteristics thatmake some indicators better than others or evaluating
vulnerability. A list o possible social indicators or eachactor that contributes to vulnerability may be extensive,especially when those indicators or adaptive capacity
depend on specic local situations, as these could covera wide range o social conditions (CRISP 2011). Thirteen
indicators were chosen or this project shown in Figure
9. However municipal level data available in the threecountries allowed the evaluation o only 6 indicators
(Table 13).
Figure 9. However municipa eve data avaiabe in the three countries aowed or the evauation
o on 6 indicators (Tabe 13).
ECOLOGICAL VULNERABILITY --->
EXPOSURE OF THE SOCIAL SYSTEM
SenstivitCC1. Demographic vulnerable groupsCC2. Dependence on the resources andservices vulnerable to the impacts o CC
Adaptive CapacitCC3. Actual livelihoods and home income diversity
CC4. Perception o alternative and complementarylivelihoods
CC5. Awareness o vulnerability to climate risksCC6. Access and use o available knowledge related
to the weatherCC7. Formal and inormal support networks or
the adaptation and risk reduction to the climate
CC8. Capacity o the community to organizeCC9. Leadership and governance
CC10. Equitable access to resourcesCC11. Cultural fexibility
CC12. Access to basic healthcareCC13. Access to basic inraestructure
POTENTIAL IMPACTS
VULNERABILITY
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
39/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Tabe 13. Criteria to anaze adaptive capacit at the regiona and oca eve, possibe data coection
methods and exampes o use (adapted rom Wongbusarakum and loper 2011).
Criteria Indicator Use o inormation
CC1. Demographic vulnerablegroups.
% o the population in poverty and extremepoverty
Identiy groups with higher risksassociated to CC and require the most
support.
CC2. Dependence on the
resources and services vulnerableto the impacts o CC.
% o the population whose principal livelihoods
(more than 50% o their income) dependon de natural resources: tourism, shing andagriculture
Predict impacts o CC in livelihoods, the
economy and ood security, points outthe livelihoods that are highly sensitive to
particular climate threats.
CC3. Actual livelihoods and home
income diversity.Number o local productive activities.
Identiy the economic sensitivity o thecommunities to CC and other external
threats.Identiy necessary options or livelihood
diversication.
CC4. Perception o alternative and
complementary livelihoods.
Quantity o existing skills in key activities
(shing, agriculture and tourism)
Identiy possibilities necessary resourcesor livelihoods adaptation to CC and
other external threats.
CC6. Access and use o availableknowledge related to the weather.
% illiteracy.
Capacity o communities to understand
the impacts o CC and the need toeducate, identiy actual and potential uses
o inormation on CC.
CC7. Formal and inormal supportnetworks or the adaptation andrisk mitigation to the climate.
Number and type o existing networks.
Adjust extension and education programsto ace CC, and ll gaps in inormation
networks.
CC8. Capacity o the community
to organize.Number and type o community organizations.
Identiy potential networks that can
transer inormation related to CC andgive support, collaborate with existingnetworks that can support adaptation and
planning.
CC9. Leadership and governance.Number o coordination platorms withimpacts on resources or territories to CC.
Assessing whether a community is ableto restructure itsel ater suering an
impact, determine the level o condencewithin a community, identiy areas that
should be strengthened or adaptationwork, understand the level o stakeholder
participation in management and decisionmaking.
CC12. Access to basic healthcare. Lie expectancy at birth
Identiy vulnerable segments o the
population that could be less capable oadapting to CC.
CC13. Access to basic
inrastructure.Calories per capita
Identiy access to basic inrastructure,as greater adaptation is expected withgreater access.
CC13. Access to basicinrastructure.
Kilometers o roads (in relation to the suracewith 99% o population)
Identiy the access to basic inrastructurebecause more access is expected to bemore adaptive.
% population with access to drinking water
Indicators were applied per municipality and data was classied in 5 categories (1 major and 5 minor). These were then added togive the adaptive capacity or each municipality.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
40/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
8
INTEGRATING VULNERABILITY DATA
Vulnerability was estimated at the municipality level considering impact (exposure and sensitivity) in relation tothe adaptive capacity o human communities. Adaptive capacity reduces impact, and thereore reduces vulnerability.
Vulnerability was not calculated or rising sea temperatures, as it impacts only marine and not terrestrial targets.Following is a description o how the dierent indicators or exposure, sensitivity, and adaptive capacity were added to
determine vulnerability.
Exposure to changes in rainfall and temperature:maps showing potential changes in rainall ortemperature (two maps) under two emissions scenarios
(A2 and B1) were reclassied in ve categories accordingto the probability o change (with 5 the highest
probability).
Exposure to sea level rise: maps showing areasexposed to the rise in sea level. A digital elevationmodel was reclassied (90 m spatial resolution) in ve
categories (Very high: 0-1 meter above sea level; High:1-2 masl; Medium: 2-4 masl; Low: 4-8 masl; and Very low:
8-16 masl).
Mapping sensitivity of targets: the analysis considerednatural vegetation (mangroves), shing sites (coastallagoons), areas with potential or agricultural and
population use. The maps are binary and indicate targetspresence (1 or the areas where the element is present,
0 or sites where the element is absent). A summarizedmap was then constructed by adding and reclassiying
them using a logarithmic code instead o a binary codeto dierentiate each o the elements in the map (Coastallagoon: 10, Mangrove, 100, capacity or agricultural use:
1000). A logical order o elements present in the samespace was respected where areas overlapped, with
priority given to natural elements (coastal lagoons andmangroves), and nally potential elements (capacity or
soil use).
E S C V
R
Exposure SensitivityAdaptivecapacity
Vulnerability
Increase in sea surace
temperature
Increase in sea leveland coast risk
Change precipitationpatterns and air
temperature
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
41/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
In the case o temperature and rainall changes, thepotential vegetation map developed by CATIE using
Holdridge lie zones (Zamora-Pereira, JC; Molina, LG;Imbach, P. Pending publication) was added to areas with
natural vegetation cover (code 10000). The map projectsuture potential changes in vegetation according to
changes in rainall and temperature according to dierentscenarios.
Calculating sensitivity for each effect. A sensitivitymap was constructed by multiplying the exposure map o
one eect (categories 1 to 5) with the targets (presence)sensitivity map, resulting in a map with values between1 (very low) and 5 (very high). There was no need to
reclassiy the map.
Adaptive capacity: Determined as previously explainedor all coastal municipalities, classied in ve categories.
Important to note that categories are ranked inversely:
category 1 is very high capacity and 5 is very low.
Vulnerability to each impact: This was obtained bymutiping the nal sensitivity map (with categories
rom 1 to 5) by the adaptive capacity map (1 to 5).Vulnerability results vary rom very low (1) to very
high (25). The results were reclassied in ve classes inorder to obtain the relative vulnerability o the study
area. For example one pixel with sensitivity 4 (high) ina municipality with a capacity 2 (high), results in a pixel
with vulnerability 8 (low). The nal area maps cover onlythe coastal marine municipalities.
Vunerabiit CassResut rom mutiping
capacit b sensitivit
Very high 5 21-25
High 4 16-20
Medium 3 11-15
Low 2 6-10
Very low 1 1-5
Integrated vulnerability: The reclassied score (1 to 5)or vulnerability to changes in rainall and temperature
and vulnerability to sea level rise were added, and theresults reclassied in 5 categories.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
42/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
43/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Thermal stress was very marked rom 1998 to 2007, as can be seen by the ollowing map. A generalized bleachingthroughout the world occurred in 1998, seriously aecting the rees in the study area.
An assessment o the uture exposure to thermal stress o the study area shows that both emissions scenarios (B1 andA2) or the period 2030-2039 show a continued warming towards the Punta Manabique zone and towards the exterior
o the Gul o Honduras (Figure 12). However the results or the same emissions scenarios or the period 2090-2099show that the entire study area, the Carribbean sea territory o Belize, Guatemela and Honduras will be under thermalstress (Figure 13).
Figure 11. Therma stress eves, 1998-2007.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
44/90
2
Figure12.
Thermalstresslevelsfor2030-2039underemissionsscenariosB1(currentpage
)andA2(oppositepage).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
45/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
46/90
4
Figure13.
Thermalstresslevelsfor2090-2099underemissionsscenariosB1(currentpage)andA2(oppositepage).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
47/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
48/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
49/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure14.
Reefsensitivitytoseasurfacewarmingduring
theperiod2030-2039,underemissionsscenarioB1.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
50/90
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
51/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure17.
Hurricanefrequency,
1851-2009.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
52/90
0
Figure18.
Hurricaneintensity,
1851-2009.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
53/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure 19. Hurricane requenc b categor rom 1970 to 2004. Source Wikinson, C.,
and Souter, D. (2008).
Hurricane strength has increased over the last 150 years o recorded history.According to records, event categories 4 and 5 are now more requent, and
event categories 1 and 2 are less requent (see gure 19). Hurricane strength willcontinue to increase as sea surace temperatures increase according to climatechange projections.
According to the IPPC (2007a), the global sea level rose
at an average rate o 1.8 [1.3 a 2.3] mm per year rom1961 to 2003. Other authors (Domingues et al. 2007)
have estimated a rise o 1.5 0.4 mm yr-1 during thesame period, similar to the range managed by the IPPC
or that period. Sea level rise in the Southern FloridaKeys is estimated at 30 cm over the past 110 years, or
an average o almost 3 mm per year.
RISE IN SEA LEVELOne o the greatest consequences o climate change
is the rise in sea level, which intensies stress in manyareas, and particularly in areas with human activities
(Feenstra et al. 1998). Change in sea level is producedby global, regional and local actors such as changes
in sea surace temperature, salinity, winds, oceancurrents, contributions rom El Nio and La Nia
phenomena (IPCC 2007a), glacial isostatic adjustmentsand subsidence, and either natural or caused byhumans. Consequently the relative rise o sea level is a
consequence o climate change as well as many otheractors that vary rom place to place (Nicholls 2010).
50
40
30
20
10
0
70-74 75-79 80-84 85-89 90-94 95-99 00-04 05-09 10-14 14-19
Perce
ntageofhurricanespercategory
Categor 1
Categories 2 & 3
Categories 4 & 5
Five ears
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
54/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
2
I GHG are stabilized by 2100 at levels o scenario A1B (720 ppm), thermal expansion itsel would cause an additionalrise in sea level o 0.3 to 0.8 m in 2100 over that o 19801999 (IPCC 2007a). Other actors such as changes in
currents and ice thawing may also aggravate this impact. According to predictions or the Caribbean, sea level will riserom 0.18-0.59 m by 2099 (Cambers et al. 2007). Results obtained by other authors, such as Rahmstor (2007) with the
application o uture IPPC climate change scenarios (2010), hold that sea level could increase between 0.5 to 1.4 m overthe 1990 level (IPCC 2007a).
Figure 20. Methods or measuring sea eve: tide gauge (reative) and sateite (absoute).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
55/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Records rom tide gauges in 3 ports in the study areawere analyzed, as well as satellite measurements taken
since measurements began in 1992 (Figures 21, 22, 23).
It is a proven act that sea level has increased in absoluteterms at three dierent points in the study area, and in
relative terms in two points. Sea level in Puerto Cortsrose 9.2 mm per year rom 1945-1975 (Figure 22), andin Puerto Castilla 3.1 mm per year rom 1954-1970
(Figure 21), both relative to land. This is a total rise oalmost 30 mm, similar to data rom the keys o southern
Florida. Results measured by tide gauges in the PuertoSanto Toms in Guatemala (Figure 23) show a reversetrend rom 1962 to 1982, although not the absolute
measurements taken by satellite.
Figure 24 shows the results in absolute terms or analysisstations placed in ront o the ports or the period 1992-
2010. All cases show a clear rising trend. Data indicate
an increase o 8 cm in Puerto Castilla, 3.4 cm in PuertoCorts and 3.5 cm in Puerto Santo Toms.
Sealevel(mm)
pendiente = 3,1452 mm/ao
years
Sealevel(mm)
pendiente = -1,3841 mm/ao
years
Sealevel(mm
)
pendiente = -9,235 mm/ao
years
Figure 21. Reative change in sea eve in Santo
Toms.
Figure 22. Reative change in sea eve
in Puerto Castia.
Figure 23. Reative change in sea eve in Puerto
Corts.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
56/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
4
Puerto Corts
Puerto Castia
m= 1.764 mm/ao
m= 4.404 mm/ao
Santo Toms
m= 1.788 mm/ao
Sealevelanomaly(cm)
Sealevelanomaly(cm)
Sealevelanomaly(cm)
Figure 24. Absoute rise in sea eve in the Port o Santo Toms (Guatemaa), Corts and Castia
(Honduras) or periods o time between 1992 and 2009.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
57/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Exposure
Exposure to coastal hazards is dened by proximity
to the coast and the topography. Most o the territoryevaluated is at a suciently high altitude to avoid
exposure to sea level rise. The only aggravating actor isthat the population and inrastructure are concentratedwithin the rst kilometers o the coast.
Tabe 14. Assessment o exposure to the rise in sea eve.
Eevation
above sea eveGrading justication
< 1 meter Very highAreas highly exposed to fooding and erosion due to tides, extreme rains, andstorms o all categories with the actual sea level.
Areas covered with the oreseen sea level rise or 2090.
1 to 2 meters High
Areas exposed to fooding by storms at the current sea level.
Areas highly exposed to fooding and erosion due to tides, extreme rains, andstorms o all categories with the oreseen sea level rise or 2090.
2 - 4 meters Medium
Areas exposed to extreme events (3, 4, 5) under current conditions.
Areas exposed to fooding by storms and tides with the sea level rise predictedor 2090.
4 - 8 meters LowAreas exposed to extreme category 5 events under current conditions.Areas exposed to fooding by extreme events with the current sea level.
8 - 16 meters Very low Areas not currently exposed and not exposed with sea level rise.
Areas at 1, 2, 4, 8 and 16 meters above sea level were determined using the digital elevation model at 90 m ollowingthe scoring table, giving as a result the exposures stated in the map in Figure 25.
Areas with greater exposure are the Districts o Corozal
and Belize City in Belize, and the municipalities oTrujillo and Brus Laguna in Honduras. The municipality o
Livingston in Guatemala and the Honduran Municipalitieso Arizona, Esparta, La Masica, La Ceiba, Jutiapa and Utilainclude areas with signicant exposure (Figure 25).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
58/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
6
Sensitivity
Regional sensitivity to impacts is the use o their development patterns, such as their use or shing, agriculture,inrastructure, population, and their current altitude above sea level. One variable not considered in this study was
distance rom the coast and fooding zones. The population o coastal municipalities and districts in 2010 was 237,500 inBelize, 166,200 in Guatemala, and 733,600 in Honduras, or a total o 1,137,300 inhabitants.
More developed areas and those with a greater population are more sensitive, such as Belize City, Puerto Barrios,Puerto Corts, La Ceiba, and Trujillo (Figure 27). In comparison, the Municipality o Brus Laguna, with a signicant
exposure, is considered to have a relatively low sensitivity given its lack o development and low population density.
Figure 25. The impact o sea level rise is derived rom the magnitude o increase and presence o sensitive
ecosystems and inrastructure costs. The clear intrusion o sea level can be seen on local inrastructure in La
Ceiba, Honduras (let) and Livingston, Guatemala (right), which was originally built ar rom the shore (Photos
L.Corrales and Black Caribbean Nationa).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
59/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure26.
Coastalzoneex
posuretosealevelrise.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
60/90
8
Figure27.
Sensitivityof
coastalareasandBayIslandtosealevelrise.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
61/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
CHANGES IN AIR TEMPERATURE
AND RAINFALL PATTERNS
An analysis o a set o climate change indices taken in2005 or Central America and or the period 1961-2003
shows that the region is undergoing a general warmingtrend, with a greater occurrence o days with maximumextreme temperatures and a rise in the minimum
temperature, while low temperature events havedecreased.
Annual rainall indices indicate no signicant increase,although rains have been observed to be more intense.
That is, rainall patterns have changed, resulting in moreintense rains during a shorter period o time (Aguilar et
al. 2005).
ExposureThe mean annual global temperature has risen close to
one degree (0.6C) since 1888 (Figure 28). In CentralAmerica, the average annual temperature has risen
approximately 1o C since 1900; the number o hot daysand nights increased 2.5% and 1.7% respectively perdecade, while cold nights and days decreased -2.2% and
-2.4% respectively. Extreme temperatures have risen 0.2oC to 0.3o C per decade. (Aguilar et al. 2005).
The analysis considered changes in air temperature
according to emissions scenarios B1 and A2 or theperiod 2070-2099. Exposure was measured according
to the certainty that an increase o over 3C will ocurr,according to the dierent scenarios modeled. The IPCC
methodology species the ollowing categories:
Cassication % o scenarios that predict
a 3 0C
Very low
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
62/90
0
Figure29.
Exposureofs
tudyareatochangesinairtemperatureaccordingtoemissionssc
enariosB1(currentpage)
andA2(oppositepage)
for2070-2099.
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
63/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
64/90
2
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
65/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
Figure30.
Studyareaex
posuretochangesinrainfallfortheperiod2070-2099,accordingtoemissionsscenariosB1(page6
1)
andA2(currentpage).
-
7/28/2019 VULNERABILITY ANALYSIS TO CLIMATE CHANGE ALONG THE CARIBBEAN COASTS OF BELIZE, GUATEMALA AND HONDURAS
66/90
Evaluation o vulnerability to climate change along the Caribbean coasts o Belize, Guatemala and Honduras
4
Sensitivity
Agriculture is the most important sector that is sensitiveto increased temperature and reduced rainall. Projections
using scenario A2 show that most agricultural areas willbe highly aected.
Natural vegetations sensitivity to changes in temperatureand rainall was assessed by quantiying probability o
changes in Holdridge lie zones. Holdridge combinedtemperature, humidity, altitude and latitude to dene lie
zone, thereore predicting changes in tempereature, andhumidity will predict changes in lie zones as well. Each liezone is composed by a particular combination o species,
so a shit rom one lie zone to another caused by changesin temperature and humidity will change the species
composition.
Figure 31. Maps (gure 31) show the results obtained
using emissions scenarios B1 and A2 or the period 2090-2099. According to the results, most current lie zones
will change, with the greatest changes occurring in higherelevations (above 2,000 masl).
Figure 31. (next page). Changes in lie zones refect
vegetation sensitivity to changes in rainall andtemperature or the period 2070-2099, according to B1(above) and A