Walking the Tightrope of Risk In the Insurance Business
Rupert AtkinCEO, Talbot Underwriting
1
Houston Marine Insurance SeminarSeptember, 2014
Tightrope of Risk in Insurance
Starting a Lloyd’s business
- Posgate 127/126/700/701 1982
- Catlin 1003 1985-1990
- Atkin 1183 1990-today
1990 £6,000,000 capacity, 2 people 2014 £625,000,000 capacity, 300 people
What makes a successful Lloyd’s business?
Page 2
FEAR/SUCCESS
COMPLACENCY/FAILURE
FEAR/SUCCESS
COMPLACENCY/FAILURE
Tightrope of Access to and Management of Capital
Balance between investor return and capital adequacy for external constituencies
1991 Annual Venture, Individual Capital, Not paid up. Line size geared to credit at the bank. Only possible in Lloyd’s.
1997 Venture Capital, top line growth at wrong time in cycle. Solved one problem created another. Syndicate 1183 did not trade for 2000/2001, after 3 very difficult years of resisting merger.
2001 9/11 – Fell off tightrope, complacency had overcome fear, needed to recapitalise within 2.5 months.
$120m from the trade capital/private equity. Innovative layered structure. Again, only possible in Lloyd’s.
Page 3
INVESTOR,RISK APPETITE
RETURN ON CAPITAL
Tightrope of Access to and Management of Capital
Page 4
Dowling & Partners Securities LLC
Lloyd’s is better valued with divergence growing since end of 2010.
Tightrope of Access to and Management of Capital
Page 5
Only 3 non-Lloyd’s businesses break into the Lloyd’s valuation range.
Dowling & Partners Securities LLC
What Drives Value?
Value Generated by ROE, not Loss RatioLow correlation between longer term underwriting and market pricing.
Source : PWC Page 6
Acquisition of capital and management of return are key drivers of value.
Pricing multiples vs. combined ratios London Market combined ratios (five year average to 2013)
Lloyd’s Oversight
Outsized losses of the few, threaten viability of the whole.
Oversight of start ups – new rules.
PMD formed – Business Plan Challenge
- New Products
- Broker fees
Solvency II Capital Modelling.
“I work in Insurance vs I work in Lloyd’s.”
ENTREPRENURIAL FLAIR REGENERATION
REGULATORY OVERSIGHT STABLE PERFORMANCE
Page 8
Current Trading Conditions
OVERSUPPLY OF CAPITAL
WHERE ARE THE LOSSES
RISK SELECTION
Current conditions:
Capital Modelling has crushed the cycle and volatility.
Consequently the pricing freedom that comes with distressed opportunities will be hard to find – explains change in Berkshire Hathaway.
Modelling creates new risks- Enemies of judgement?- Systemic Risk as a result of limited
choice?- Patchy record of forecasting loss but
tool of rating agencies; still art as well as science.
CAPITAL MODEL
DISTRESSEDOPPORTUNITY
Page 8
Current Trading Conditions (2)
CAPITAL MODEL
DISTRESSEDOPPORTUNITY
Berkshire Hathaway/Aon transaction - Beginning of a new world or flawed
transaction? Innovation/Reinvention?
- Portfolio underwriting, Enemy of risk selection and Aggregate control- Portfolio underwriting because business
better controlled as a result of capital modelling.
- Risk selection among classes which are hard to model.
- ILS, Hedge Fund, Pension money can only play in modelable business. Will they ever meet a client?- Experts, individual decisions, client’s
needs and problems solved is Lloyd’s sweet spot.
Page 9
PORTFOLIO UNDERWRITING
RISK SELECTION
Distribution – The Brokers’ Tightrope
Lloyd’s Syndicate 1183 is Talbot’s only platform. 100% business through brokers. Who is the broker working for? Larger brokers seeking to generate
income from their underwriters as well as their clients – is this their tightrope?
Clients must pay for the value they derive from brokers.
- Fees must reflect this value. Tightrope for carriers as well – pay to play if yes - business withers if no? Paying for services we do not want to have access to business. Brokers have overtaken Underwriters in their management of technology and data (GRIP, WillPlace). Lloyd’s has a seam of gold, yet to be mined. Xchanging/Central Services Refresh. “Aon’s proposition is geared around creating tangible value for clients. Aon has invested
heavilyin recent years in developing the systems and tools to enable it to do this.”
CLIENT?
CARRIER?
BROKER AS AGENTFEES
FEES
Page 10
The Underwriting Tightrope
Lloyd’s Capital gearing, minimal investment return – underwriting decisions are key to profitability.
How to say “no” but still attract the best business is an art.
Past: Unfettered Judgement, Generalists. Present: Underwriting Authorities, Models, Specialists.
Onshore exposures drive need for modelling but not substitutes for judgement (Thai Floods).
Pricing and exposure models – vital tools and constantly improving, but remain imperfect.
Importance of Interpreting Models by peril/geography. Validus Research as a competitive tool. Restores expert judgement, avoids systemic risk.
NO, CAN’T HELPMR. BROKER
PLEASE SHOW MEALL YOUR BEST BUSINESS
BUSINESS PLAN,PRICING MODEL
FLAIR, EXPERTJUDGEMENT
UNDERWRITER
Page 11
The Regulatory Tightrope
Syndicates have 3 masters: Lloyd’s, PRA, FCA.
Fines no longer offset expenses, go straight to Exchequer.
Acknowledged duplication, accountable to different Masters – Bank of England and Government.
PWC: 72% costs increase; 41% Stifle Innovation; 49% prevented from
pursuing opportunity. Lloyd’s Performance Management
Directorate key to market revival. Regulator as enabler.
Conflict between caring for investors and caring for policyholders. Has Regulator given up?
Overseas Policyholders subject to UK expectations – to be changed?
PRA ADEQUATE PRICING FORSOLVENCY, NO UNDUE RISK.
FCAPOLICYHOLDER PROTECTIONTCF
UNDERWRITER
Page 12
Vision 2025
Attractive status quo, well priced business.London MarketBrokers
Increase High Growth Economies business to 25%. More competitive pricing. Local Brokers.
What can we be?
Page 13
Preservation: London based, subscription, International market, Central Fund, Global Licences, Rating, Broker P & C focused market.
Aspiration: Capital, people, Business attracted from High Growth Economies to reach 25%.
Broker sensitivity BUT focus on new business, help us find it!
Lloyd’s Market Association
Cross Membership of LMA Board with Council and Franchise Board. Helps communication between market and corporation on strategy and many other topics.
All managing and members agents are members.
2000 practitioners support panels.
4000 users of Lloyd’s Wordings Repositories.
Shared services: Credit control Coverholder Audits Exposure Data Standardisation/Data Cleansing Cat Modelling
Page 14
Marketing The Insurance Industry
Contribution to the economy: taxes, employment, investment management. Reputation is driven by reputation on settlement of claims, inevitable link with Personal lines. Claims free policy frees policyholder from uncertainty and fear.
- Claims free policy ensures ships sail, planes fly, cars are driven, buildings are built and money is lent.
- Claims free policy offers capital relief to banks.- Claims free policy can still benefit insured through Insurers/Surveyors/Engineers showing
their knowledge of other policyholders losses to prevent/reduce risk of loss, pre hurricane planning, business continuity.
Policy with claims can result in loss prevention measures for the future.
- Attack on Sri Lanka Airport
- Piracy in Malacca Straits and off Somalia, Well Control.
Page 15