-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
1/152
\FO[LK Y[C[LY IN\][
NB
CUULCJY BN] [AL YLINFK IO]I\O[
[aurgnnk
Dcrsacjj \.Y. Inurtanusl
;5
Bnjly Yqucrl,
Flw
_nr`,
F_ 35557
[ljlpanfl8 =3=-1
~ _ l s K Fn (rlqulsts bnr nrcj crgudlft wojj fnt flilsscrojy ml grcftlk)
i8
O .H
( b O
:480
8z8
-Wl
r -
8885
r0>rrHn
. 0 , 8)
8.8-IHi8
D
rf
n .^.
888H888
("')
\3
8833
8 { ~ 8 ~ 8 ~
'>
. ' ~ ' 3
-5
NH''''
- ..
:8
88i
,
^.
rf
-..H
5
5-
"
O
W
-..H
,
NUUNYOFG
UC][_8 Wojjocd Dnrros Lfklcvnr
Lftlrtcofdlft
lt cj.
NUUNYOFG
C[[N]FL_8 Doiaclj
U.
Xwlog Iarostocf Icrmnfl
BN]
LDL]GLFI_
DN[ONFY,
DN[ONFY
BN]
Y[C_Y CFK
OFH\FI[ONFY
ULFKOFG CUULCJ8
Acs rlqulst bnr rljolb mllf dckl mljnw>
~ _ l s K F n
Acs taos rljolb mllf prlvonusjy snugat of taos Inurt> _ls K Fn
]lqulstlk rlturf kctl cfk lxpjcfctonf
nb
ldlrglfiy8 Mltwllf Ylptldmlr =5
cfk Hufl =53=, O
sumdottlk
bnur dntonfs/pltotonfs sll`ofg tn
vcictl
t
tal
Hujy
=5,=533 Ytcy
Nrklr
nb
U. @lvof
Icstlj
waoia ogfnrlk dy
crgudlfts, ndottlk plrtoflft bcits
cfk
rlbuslk tn cppjy cftokosirodofc
jcw tn kltlrdofl cpprnproctl huroskoitonf bnr taos icsl. Ycdl ossuls rc
Acs crgudlft kctl nb cpplcj mllf slt>
K _ls ~ F n Ob yls, lftlr kctl8 ^
Y j g f c ~ t u r l Z b ^ ~ D N
.jJ. b 8 t S r ~ ~ t t y y 8 8
^ 3tn`
rt"'- Kctl8 Klildmlr 3
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
2/152
Fn. 3;-;9=1 IR
4
BN] [AL YLINFK IO]I\O[
X
(b
O . . 0 )
.4
i0i.ff
88t8 3 In
-4.3
00H
-3 H
i.8
5 -
I.3 j
8.88
b [3
f
rf
n
DC]I\Y OYCOCA WCYAOFG[NF,
Ujcoftobb-Cppljjcft
v.
~ I 8 O
.
58.
) .8.88
, () 888
'.
. ~ .
t ~ j ~ . ~
.
,
-
- -30-0
\3
- 5
88x
-.H
rf
:
333
IH
- - ' ,
^ o ~
I,..)
-.H
WOJJOCD DN]]OY LFKLCRN] LF[L][COFDLF[, JJI0 bnrdlrjy tal WOJJOCD DN]]OY
CGLFI_0 HLBB DLCKL cfk YC]CA WOFOC]Y@O,
Klblfkcfts-Cppljjlls
Cpplcj brnd tal \Y.
Kostroit Inurt
bnr tal Ynutalrf Kostroit
nb
Flw _nr`
Fn. 35 Iov. ?2;7 (U@I) (HIB)
CUUJJCF['Y
]LUJ_ [N LQULKO[LK DN[ONF [N ]LY[N]L OF BN]DC UC\UL]OY
Y[C[\Y, Y\YULFK BOJOFG OFH\FI[ONF CFK ]LDNRL CJJ U]LH\KOIL ULFKOFG
GNNK
BCO[A
CUULCJ, N]
OF [AL
CJ[FL]C[ORL, RO[OC[L CJJ N]KL]Y ]LFKL]LK
M_
U. @LROF
ICY[LJ
CFK [AL CDL]OICF C]MO[]C[ONF CYYNIOC[ONF K\L [N
B]C\K \UNF [AL
IN\][
CFK B]C\K \UNF [AL IN\][, M_ [AL INOj][.
]LS\LY[ [N []CFYBL] ICYL [N
CFN[AL]
IO]I\O[.
Dr. Dcrius Oscoca Wcsaofgtnf
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
3/152
Bnr tal bnjjnwofg rlcsnfs mljnw, O - pr
s
Cppljjcft Dcrius Oscoca Wcsaofgtnf - rlsplitbujjy sumdot taos
]lpjy Dntonf
of
lxtrldl gnnk bcota
tn cs`
tal cppljjctl inurt
tn8
(3.) trcfsblr taos cpplcj
tn
cfntalr ioriuot
nr (=.) klfy tal strcwdcf crgudlfts
3
rcoslk tarnuganut tal Cppljjlls' Klildmlr
;,
=53; Nppnsotonfcj Dntonf
cfk grcft tal lxtrcnrkofcry rljolb snugat of dy Fnvldmlr =3,=53; Lx. Dntonf bnr Lxtrcnrkofcry ]ljolb'= of
bcvnr
nb
tal Cppljjcft.
c s a o ~ g t n f v.
Wojjocd Dnrros Lfklcvnr Lftlrtcofdlft lt cj.8 C Suoftlsslftocj Icsl
nb c ]cil-Mcslk Infsporciy tn Inddot Brcuk \pnf tal Inurt Mjci` ]nml
Inrruptonf.
Nf Fnvldmlr
=3,
=53;, O rlsplitbujjy sumdottlk c =5 pcgl Lxplkotlk Dntonf tn tal \fotlk Ytctls Inurt
nb
Cpplcjs bnr
.tal
Ylinfk .Ioriuot-pursucft tn Blk.
]
Cpp.U..1,
=; cfk
;2 sll`ofg lxtrcnrkofcry rljolb ufklr tal
inurt's ofalrlft pnwlrs tn votoctl tal kliosonfs rlfklrlk my ]lpumjoicf cppnoftlk blklrcj hukgl U. @lvof Icstlj
cfk tal cjjlglkjy flutrcj, provctozlk, qucso-hukoiocj bnrud `fnwf
cs
tal Cdlroicf Crmotrctonf Cssnioctonf
( CCC ). Of tal Cppljjlls' Klildmlr
;,
=53; Nppnsotonf Dntonf, Jnlm Jnlm JJU cttnrfly Doiaclj
U.
Xwlog inftofulk tn pjcy tal rnjl
nb
tal voitod, flvlr rlbutofg tal vcronus jlgcj crgudlfts cfk pyrcdok nb
lvoklfil waoia prnvls tact
cjj nb
Icstlj's jlgcj infijusonfs tarnuganut taos icsl crl lrrnflnus cs mnta c dcttlr
nbjcw cfk pumjoi pnjoiy cfk tact tal nfjy rlcsnf Wojjocd Dnrros acs nmtcoflk ots bcvnrcmjl vlrkoits, os tarnuga
injjusonf, infsporciy, rci`ltllrofg cfk
brcuk. Cs
kosiusslk, alrl crl sndl
nb
tal rlcsnfs way cjj
nb
Icstlj's
kliosonfs sanujk ml votoctlk8
Pp. @lvof Icstlj Lrrlk My Infijukofg
tact
Crmotrctnr Grlgnry's Ucrtocj Bofcj Cwcrk Wcs Fnt
]lvolwcmjlT [al icsl jcw infilrfofg tal rlvolwcmojoty
nb
oftlrod, pcrtocj bofcj cfk ntalr typls
nb
oftlrjniutnry
crmotrcj cwcrks os prnmcmjy dnst klvljnplk tal Ylinfk Ioriuot. Mcslk nf cjj
nb
tal bcits cfk ioriudstcfils
nb
taos icsl, Doiacljs v. Dcrobnrud Yaoppofg. Y.C., 2=;
B.= ;33
(=k
Ior.
3?15) os fnt inftrnjjofg cfk Icstlj flw
3
[al
crgudlfts rcoslk of dy Fnvldmlr =3,=53; wlrl c
infklfslk
vlrsonf nb tal jcst tarll Dntonfs tact wlrl sumdottlk
tn U. @lvof
Icstlj mltwllf
Dcria 37,=53; cfk Nitnmlr 9,=53;. tal
ljotl
jcw bord Jnlm Jnlm
JJU cfk ots
cttnrflys
Doiaclj
U.
Xwlog,
Iarostocf K.
Icrmnfl
cfk Doiaclj Mcrfltt
ack
tarll nppnrtufotols tn rlbutl
tal
pyrcdok nb lvoklfil
prlslftlk tn suppnrt
cjj
nb dy jlgcj crgudlfts,
mut
taly iansl tn rldcof sojlft.
Icstlj, citofg cs
talor cttnrfly, kok tal
scdl cfk
ossulk
c bofcj hukgdlft of
bcvnr
nbWo oo ocd
Dnrros,
cs wljj cs
ossulk
c
bojofg ofhufitonf
cgcofst
dl.
= Citucj Fcdl8 Lxplkotlk Dntonf tn ]lstnrl
Of
Bnrdc Ucuplros Ytctus, Yusplfk Bojofg Ofhufitonf cfk ]ldnvl Cjj
Urlhukoil Ulfkofg Gnnk Bcota Cpplcj, Nr of tal Cjtlrfctovl, Rotoctl
Cjj
Nrklrs ]lfklrlk my
U. @lvof
Icstlj cfk tal
Cdlroicf
Crmotrctonf Cssnioctonf Kul tn Brcuk upnf
tal
Inurt cfk Brcuk \pnf tal
Inurt,
My
tal
Inurt.
-
3-
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
4/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
5/152
dlftonf
Crmotrctnr Grlgnry's kliosonf
tn ckdot
infilcjlk lvoklfil `fnwf
cs
Lxaomot 93 oftn tal lvoklfil
n rlinrk nr tact Wojjocd
Dnrros
Lfklcvnr wlrl indpljjlk tn pcy tal insts n acvofg
dy
l-kosinvlry lxplrt
rltrolvl tal ufklrjyofg l-dcojs tn taos
kniudlft
cfk prnkuil ntalr tcfgomjl lvoklfil plrtcofofg tn l-kosinvlry
of
]nwl.
Jctl
jcst
wll`, tal rciost l-dcoj lxiacfgl mltwllf YNF_ Uoiturls In-iacorwndcf Cdy Ucsicj cfk
bojd prnkuilr Yintt
]ukof
infilrfofg Urlsoklft
Mcrci` Nmcdc
wlrl
dckl
pumjoi.
ll
Lxaomot I.
f
kosiussofg taos ldmcrrcssofg bocsin, J C
odls
wrotlr Kcfolj Dojjlr wrntl8
Ossuls n rcil
acvl jnfg
mlklvojlk
Anjjywnnk, waoia
acs mllf irotoiozlk bnr fnt govofg dofnrotols lfnuga
nppnrtufotols
bnr wnr`, cfk
bnr fnt
knofg
lfnuga
tn
rlprlslft Cbroicf
Cdlroicfs,
Jctofns
cfk
ntalrs of
bojds
cfk
tljlvosonf sanws.
Kcrfljj
Auft,
c snionjngy prnblssnr ct
\IJC,
scok al wcs fnt surproslk
my
tal fcturl
n
tal ldcojs [aos
os walrl
wl crl of
Anjjywnnk,
scok
Auft,
wan
os korlitnr
n
tal
]cjpa H. Mufial
Ilftlr
bnr Cbroicf
Cdlroicf
Ytukols, waoia prnkuils tal cffucj Anjjywnnk Kovlrsoty ]lpnrt. Wl
acvl
c kovlrsoty prnmjld
... tal
bcit
tact ynu
icf acvl
talsl plrilptonfs
tact
crl dckl hn`ofgjy govl us c pll` oftn tal ufklrjyofg
iujturl
n tal
ofkustry.
Ot sanujk ml fntlk
tact
talsl twn flvlr uslk rciocjjy klrngctnry tlffs jo`l fogglr of rlblrlfil tn Nmcdc.
Anwlvlr, ot stojj knlsf't
iacfgl
tal
bcit
tact talor rciocjjy ofslfsotovl
inddlfts cmnut
tal Urlsoklft
crl
lxtrldljy rciost. O'd
surl tact
pronr tn tal rljlcsl n talor provctl infvlrsctonfs,
Ucsicj
cfk ]ukof, jo`l dnst
waotlsj Hlws,
wnujk
ml
tal borst
tn klfy
mlofg rciost, mut tal l-dcojs sugglst ntalrwosl.
Waojl sndl
mljolvl
tact
Ynfy crl tal trul voitods of taos sotuctonf kul tn tal
bcit
tact talor provctl l-dcojs wlrl aci`lk, Wojjocd
Dnrros wcs indpljjlk
tn prnkuil tal
ufklrjyofg l-dcojs
tn
Lxaomot 93 my Crmotrctnr Grlgnry nf Ylptldmlr
=
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
6/152
Icstlj cjsn bcojlk tn cklquctljy rlsnjvl tal bcit tact Iarostocf Icrmnfl rlbuslk tn kosijnsl
tn
dysljb,
tal Ynutalrf Kostroit nb Flw _nr` cfk/nr tal Ylinfk Ioriuot tact al wcs dcrrolk tn cf lxliutovl bnr tal
Cdlroicf Crmotrctonf Cssnioctonf - Ycsac Cfgljoqul Icrmnfl. [al CCC wcs cwcrl nb taos ofbnrdctonf cfk
scok fntaofg tn dl. Icrmnfl acs rldcoflk sojlft cmnut taos ofbnrdctonf bnr fofl dnftas cfk rlbuslk tn sumdot
cf Cbbokcvot infboffofg
nr
klfyofg taos ofbnrdctonf cs rlqulstlk of dy Fnvldmlr =3 =53; Dntonf. O jlcrflk
nb
taos ofbnrdctonf tarll ylcrs cbtlr jotogctofg taos icsl. Yofil Icstlj rlbuslk tn ckkrlss dy ijcods nb brcuk
upnf tal Inurt, acvl Jnlm Jnlm JJU cfk
ots
vcronus cttnrflys citlk ltaoicjjy tarnuganut taos lftorl
jotogctonf>2 Ob tal cppljjctl inurt 's cfswlr os yls, talf O cs` tact tal cppljjctl inurt pjlcsl lxpjcof anw sn sofil
ot
os ijlcr tact talsl `ofgs
nb
klilptonf cfk dcstlrbuj dcfopujctnrs sanujk ml kosmcrrlk.
(p.
@lvof Icstlj Cvnoks [otjl ROO, F_IA]J, Yalrdcf Cit cfk @u @jux @jcf Cit
nb
3173
Jo`l
tal
Ujcgul.T Yofil dy ofotocj ijcods ofijuklk oftlftonfcj pcttlrf cfk prcitoil kosirodofctonf, kospcrctl odpcit cfk
prl-aorofg ofkovokucj kospcrctl trlctdlft, O ack tn rljy nf aostnroicj cfk stctostoicj lvoklfil tn sanw tact
lxijukofg plnpjl nb injnr brnd aogalr-stctus, aogalr-pcyofg pnsotonfs wcs Wojjocd Dnrros' dnkus
nplrcfko O stcfkcrk nplrctofg prnilkurl cfk tact ot wcs fnt ciioklftcj nr kul tn iacfil tact talrl wlrl
zlrn Cbroicf Cdlroicf Cglfts, Innrkofctnrs nr Cglft [rcoflls ldpjnylk
f
tal Flw _nr` nbboil walf O
mlgcf tal Cglft [rcofll prngrcd of Ylptldmlr nb=55Y.7
ll
Lxaomot L.
Of
blklrcj inurt, Xwlog klfolk cjj
nb
2
Jnlm Jnlm
JJU's nvlrcjj pcttlrf
nb brcuk cfk
aogajy ufltaoicj citovoty icf
ml sllf my tal bcit
tact cjtanuga Doiaclj
U. Xwlog
acs
cjwcys mllf tal jlck cttnrfly of taos icsl, al flvlr sumdottlk c Fntoil nb Cpplcrcfil ( FNC )
walf
O
dckl tal borst slt nb
cttldpts
tn cpplcj
Icstlj's
Ytcy Nrklr. [aly acvl
trolk
tn dc`l ot
cpplcr tact
Icrmnfl os tal jlck
cttnrfly
nb
rlinrk of tal
icsl. Nf
Klildmlr ;,=53;, Iarostocf Icrmnfl sumdottlk
aos FNC,
waojl Xwlog sumdottlk c
FNC
bnr
Yumstotutl, Ckkotonfcj nr
Cdoius
Inufslj. O stctlk nmhlitonfs cfk
ot
knls
fnt
cpplcr
nf
tal rlinrk. ll Lxaomot
B. Nf
Ylptldmlr
39,
=539, Jnlm Jnlm JJU cttnrfly Doiaclj
Mcrfltt nbboiocjjy hnoflk tal crmotrctonf
cfk
sumdottlk c
Fntoil
nb Cpplcrcfil
wota tal Y.K.F._ nf
Dcria
9,
=53;.
(Kni`lt
Fn.
9
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
7/152
dy ijcods, scyofg tact dy jlgcj crgudlfts
wlrl
wotanut dlrot, jlgcjjy nr bcitucjjy.
Anwlvlr, Jnlm Jnlm
JJU
flvlr dlt talor alogatlflk murklf nbprnkuitonf cfk plrsucsonf tarnuganut taos lftorl jotogctonf. [aly
cjsn flvlr
prnvoklk c jlgotodctl, fnf-kosirodofctnry rlcsnf nr musoflss hustoboictonf
tn
lxpjcof way O
wcs
tal
nfjy Cbroicf Cdlroicf qucjobolk lfnuga
tn ml
aorlk
cfy
jlvlj
nb
tal Cglft
[rcofll prngrcd of Flw
_nr` Ioty.
Ofstlck,
taly trolk tn
klbcdl
dy iacrcitlr
my
scyofg tact O wcs cfto-Yldotoi cfk
bcjsljy
pnrtrcyofg
dl cs tal wnrst plrbnrdofg
ldpjnyll.
[al pyrcdok
nb lvoklfil
lstcmjosalk tact O lftlrlk oftn c
indpcfy
tact wcs
cjrlcky
vonjctofg
[otjl v
nb
tal Iovoj ]ogats
Cit nb
3?2;
ct
tal todl O sogflk talor dcfkctnry crmotrctonf
cgrlldlft. Kul tn
tal bcit tact
tal indpcfy acs cjwcys bcitnrlk rcil of ots ldpjnydlft kliosonfs cfk mljolvls tact rcil/iujturl os c
prlrlquosotl bnr mlofg aorlk cfkjnr prndntlk
tn Cglft,
Cbroicf Cdlroicf Cglft [rcoflls ack c zlrn plrilft
rctl nbprndntonf ( tal oflxnrcmjl zlrn ) tn Cglft mltwllf =555 cfk =535. Yll l.g. Groggs v. Ku`l Unwlr
In.,
;53
\.Y. ;=;
(3?73)0
Oftlrfctonfcj Mrntalrannk
nb
[lcdstlrs
v.
\fotlk Ytctls. ;93 \.Y. 9=; (3?77). O
wcs
dnrl qucjobolk tacf cjj nb dy sodojcrjy sotuctlk waotlj Hlwosa inuftlrpcrts of tal Cglft [rcofll prngrcd,
Yll
Lxaomot A,
cfk Wojjocd
Dnrros
cfk
Jnlm Jnlm JJU rlbuslk tn prnkuil
cfy
kniudlfts nr indpjy
wota
cfy nbdy
kosinvlry
rlqulsts mlicusl ot
wnujk
acvl
sanwf
tact talor stctldlfts
wlrl
prltlxtuc3.
Yll
Lxaomot
J [al pyrcdok
nb
lvoklfil sanws tact ack dy
rcil,
injnr cfkjnr plrilovlk fctonfcj nrogof pjcylk c dntovctofg
bcitnr of way O Pnr
sndlnfl nb
injnrT wcs fnt aorlk cfkjnr prndntlk tn Cglft
cfk
tact
ack
O mllf waotl cfkjnr
Hlwosa, O wnujk acvl mllf aorlk cfkjnr prndntlk tn Cglft my Wojjocd Dnrros.
1
Yofil tal prnmjld
nb
ofstotutonfcjozlk cfk struiturcj rciosd os fnt jodotlk
tn
Wojjocd Dnrros Y
Lxaomot H O ckkotonfcjjy rcoslk c fudmlr nb strnfg pumjoi oftlrlst crgudlfts wota tal Ylinfk Ioriuot tn
ofkovokucj nb ldpjnydlft nppnrtufotols nr ntalrwosl ckvlrsljy cbblit aos stctus cs cf ldpjnyll. mlicusl
nb
suia
ofkovokucj 's rcil. injnr. rljogonf. slx.
nr
fctonfcj nrogof,
;=
\.Y.I.
=555l-=(c) (ldpacsos ckklk).
1
Of
nr
crnufk tal todl
tact O
sumdottlk
dy
rlsudl,
tal indpcfy ack hust
prndntlk
c
waotl Cglft
[rcofll tn mnn`
urmcf
inftldpnrcry cits wan wcs fnt joilfslk ufklr tal [cjlft Cglfiy Cit [al crtost tact
O
in-dcfcglk mltwllf =552 cfk
=551 acs mllf
c ijolft nbWDL Lftlrtcofdlft
bnr
sox
ylcrs
cfk
os
fnw
cf
j3x
G]CDD_ fndofctlk
sofglr/snfgwrotlr.
Dchnroty
nb
dy waotl "Hlwosa" inuftlrpcrts ack cmsnjutljy fn pronr lxplrolfil wnr`ofg of
tal
lftlrtcofdlft ofkustry
cfk
wlrl
rlilft injjlgl grckuctls.
? Nvlr tal jcst bovl
ylcrs,
tal
Wojjocd Dnrros Cglfiy acs dlrglk wota twn prlkndofctljy cjj-waotl
Hlwosa tcjlft
spnrts
cglfiols
tact
rlprlslft
cfk
dc`l dojjonfs
nbb
nb Cbroicf Cdlroicfs
kul
tn
talor
rcil-mcslk dnfnpnjy8
Lfklcvnr
[cjlft Cglfiy cfk DG. Cjj nb
tal ntalr tcjlft
cglfiols, stukons, fltwnr`s, lti. ldpjny
sodojcr kosirodofctnry
ldpjnydlft
prcitoils,
pnjoiols
cfk
prnilkurls
cs Wojjocd Dnrros, alfil
tal
rlcsnf
way talor wnr`pjcils
cjsn acvl
zlrn
cfk/nr
c
grnss ufklrrlprlslftctonf nbqucjobolk Cbroicf Cdlroicfs ldpjnylk
cs Cglfts,
Innrkofctnrs
cfk Cglft [rcoflls.
-
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
8/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
9/152
Icstlj ossulk aos Ytcy Nrklr tn plrsnfcjjy sll` aos kosqucjoboictonf. Cbtlr al rlbuslk tn kosqucjoby aodsljb, al
inftofulk tn doscppjy tal jcw cfk ossul nfl-soklk Nrklrs of bcvnr nbWojjocd Dnrros cfk Jnlm Jnlm JJU.
Cjtanuga talrl os c strnfg blklrcj pnjoiy bcvnrofg crmotrctonf, talrl os
cf
lvlf strnfglr blklrcj pnjoiy
tn lrckoictl rciocj kosirodofctonf,
cs
wljj
cs
ntalr typls
nb
kosirodofctonf, tarnuganut tal Cdlroicf wnr`pjcil.
Cjtanuga Icstlj stctlk of aos Hujy =5, =533 Ytcy Nrklr tact O acPkT fnt sanwf tact Infgrlss oftlfklk
tn
prlijukl crmotrctonf bnr ijcods csslrtlk ufklr lotalr [otjl ROO nr ;= \.Y.I.
3?13, ot os ijlcr tact O acvl. PU@I
Ytcy Nrklr, 35.T Walf Wojjocd Dnrros'
aostNj_
nb oftlftonfcj rciocj kosirodofctonf
os
ci`fnwjlkglk my tal
odpcrtocj bofklr nb bcit, ot
os
ijlcr tact tal twn crmotrctonf cgrlldlfts O sogflk
cs
c infkotonf nb ldpjnydlft
wlrl mnta prnilkurcjjy cfk sumstcftovljy ufinfsionfcmjl, tcoftlk wota ojjlgcjoty cfk dcjud of sl. Yll l.g.
N']lgcf
v.
Crmotrctonf Bnruds. Ofi., =;2 B.9k
?7 Os
talrl
cfynfl
of
tal dnvol musoflss
wan acsf t mllf nf tal
mjostlrofg lfk nb cf
ldcoj
rcft
nfl kcy
cfk
c wlt `oss
tal
flxt>
Walrl s
tal
flws> Dy
injjlcgul Hlrldy Glrcrk cfk O
acvl
ack
niicsonf tn
alcr
brnd
]ukof of tal
alct nb
mcttjl cfk
bllj
mnta
aos stofg cfk aos
. prcosl0
taos
os flws> ( Al icjjlk
dl
c
koi` cfk cf cssanjl of
nfl
dldnrcmjl jofl, Glrcrk rlicjjs,
cfk
mrojjocft
tal
flxt kcy )
Yn
ot
stojj blljs tn dl tact ot s
jo`l sllofg sndlnfl
ufkrlssofg
tarnuga
c wofknw. Kn ynu
wctia nr turf cwcy cfk knls
lotalr citonf rlvlcj sndltaofg
cmnut
ynu>
0 ]LJC[LK
.
Ynfy's Doiaclj Jyftnf
Y`lks
COO
Acfks
Mrolbofg Nf
Aci`ofg Kcdcgl
Cf ldcoj wcs slft
tn
dl
cmnut
c polil wrottlf nf
taos
sumhlit
my Ljoycau Bof`,
tal
]cmmo
ct
tal Ucioboi Hlwosa Ilftlr. Ot
sllds jo`l c wnrtay ckkotonf
tn
at p8/Oklckjofl,indO=53;33=3snfy-aci`-cdy-pcsicj-l-dcjjs-3=5393
M=9;j#ind
dlfj-josj-
wrcpplr
;3=
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
40/152
3=33=3= 3;
Ynfy Aci`ofg ]lvlcjs L-Dcojs
b
LxliutovMY Korlitnrs8 ]lcitonfs
O
Klckjofl
cjj
tal kosiussonf
gnofg nf
of
taos ufprlilklftlk provciy
ofvcsonf tact
Ynfy os
lxplrolfiofg.
al
]cmmo
bniusls fnt sn duia
nf
tal
aci`lrs cs tansl wan lfgcgl
wota
tal
mcrlk
slirlts8
Ynfy Uoiturls wcs cttci`lk
my aci`lrs.
Cttci`lk
os tal
prnplr wnrk tn
klsiroml
aci`ofg of taos inftlxt. [al
aci`lrs oftlfklk
tn
acrd
Ynfy bofcfiocjjy
cfk
ofstojj
blcr oftn
tal alcrts nb tal
stukon's lxliutovls
cfk
ldpjnylls
bt
os
klstruitovl
cfk c
bnrd
nb
tlrrnrosd
Walf aci`lrs jlc` stnjlf
ofbnrdctonf, tal jlc`
os fnt
tal taofg
tact
aurts. [al
taofg
tact
aurts
os
tal pumjoi
odmomofg of tal jlc` [al
jlc`
aurts
sn duia mlicusl
bcr
tnn
dcfy
vnylurs
gjllbujjy klvnur tal
bnrmokklf bruot. [act's
nf
tal
vnylurs,
fnt
tal aci`lrs
[al rlst nb us crl
of
pnsslssonf
nb
stnjlf
prnplrty.
[act's cjsn lvoj
Aci`ofg wnujk ml
prcitoicjjy usljlss ob
wl
cjj
cgrllk
tn
ldmcrgn
cfytaofg
tact
os jlc`lk
my
tal aci`lrs.
Mut wl knf't
kn
tact. Yckjy,
talrl os kldcfkbnr aci`lk
kctc
[alrl os
nfjy
nfl
dnrcj ianoil8 Gcw`ofg os
c
iursl. Jnn`
cwcy
Walf
aci`lrs rljlcsl
porctlk
attp8//klckjofl.iidO=53;/3=3snfy-aci`-cdy-pcsicj-l-dcojs-3=53931=9;3 iiddlft-3ost-wrcpplr <
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
41/152
3=33=3=53;
Ynfy Aci`ofg ]lvlcjs
L-Dcjjs
Nb Lxliutovcs
Korlitnrs8
]lcitonfs
OKlckjofc
dnvols, ot's
nf us
tn gn tn tal
talctlr
cfk pcy
tn sll tal
bojd. Walf aci`lrs
wcft
tn
tljj
us
slirlts, ot's
nf us
tn
ogfnrl tald. Walf aci`lrs
jlc` oftodctl pantns
nb
iljlmrotols, ot's
nf
sniolty tn
jnn` tal ntalr wcy
Walf
wl
gcw` wl
stlp cirnss
tal dnrcj jofl
cfk
wl
mlindl tal aci`lrs. Jlt's
icrl dnrl
cmnut
tal voitods
nb
aci`ofg tacf
nur prurolft
iuronsoty.
[alrl os
lvlry
pnssomojoty
dnrl
kniudlfts
wojj surbcil
cfk tact taos
wojj glt ugjolr
mlbnrl ot s
nvlr. Ct
jlcst
nfl plrsnf
dlftonflk
of
tansl
l-dcojs trolk tn bofk
tal
audnr, cbtlr sal wcs
iacrcitlrozlk acrsajy of ldcoOs
flvlr dlcft bnr pumjoi
infsudptonf.
Cffcpurfc s
Dlgcf Ljjosnf twlltlk8
Mopnjcr =1 ylcr njk jufctoi > O
cjwcys tanugat nb dysljb dnrl
cs liilftroi.
]LJC[LK
.
Ynfy's Doiaclj Jyftnf
Y`lks
ACoj
Acfks
Mrolbofg
Nf Aci`ofg Kcdcgl
attp8//klckjofl.icfO=53;/3=3snfy-aci`-cdy-pcsicH-l-dcojs-3=53931=9;3 icfdlft-jost-wrcpplr
2 =
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
42/152
3=33=3=53;
Ynfy
Aci`ofg ]lvlcjs
L Dcjjs Nb
Lxliutjvcs
Korlitnrs8
]lcitonfs
O
Klckjofl
[al rcmmo s wnrks crl jo`ljy
sdcjj infsnjctonf tn Ucsicj,
Doiaclj Jyftnf,
cfk
irlctovls
jo`l ]ukof, wansl ufvcrfosalk
provctl npofonfs wlrl mcrlk cs
o taly wlrl tal Ulftcgnf
Ucplrs nr Lkwcrk Yfnwklf s
kcdfofg rlvljctonfs. [alsl
plnpjl crl prnmcmjy gnofg tn
acvl
tn
fjc`l ufindbnrtcmjl
panfl
icjjs, lvlf
tanuga
ot s
acrk
tn odcgofl cfynfl nf
tal
rlilovofg
lfk nb cf
cpnjngy
acsf t jo`ljy wrottlf
dcfy
provctl l-dcojs
tact
wnujk
icusl
pcof
cfk
rlgrlt
ob
dckl
pumjoi.
Yumsiroml tn Klckjofl Mrlc`ofg Flws
jlrts fk `llp ynur ofmnx acppy
. . ?2
nrl
Brnd Klckjofl
my
[cmnnjc
Cdy
Ucsicj Bnrdcjjy
Cpnjngozls
Bnr ]ciocjjy
Ofslfsotovl L-Dcoj
Ynfy
Uoiturls Dojjonf-Knjjcr Lxlis ]lvlcjlk
My Cjjlglk Aci`lr
Yintt ]ukof Cpnjngozls Cbtlr Jlc` b Ynfy s
Aci`lk ]ciocjjy Ofslfsotovl L-Dcjjs Nf Mcrci`
Nmcdc
nrl Brnd [al Wlm
Ypnfsnrlk
j f`s
[al [ruta Cmnut Cjtlrfctovl Ywlltlflrs
Fctonfcj Icfilr Ofstotutl
ajtp8jjklckjofl.indO=53;/3=3snfy-aci`-cdy-pcsicj-l-dcjjs-3=53931=9;3 inddlft-jost-wrcpplr
7
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
43/152
3=33=3= 3;
Ynfy Aci`ofg ]lvlcjs
L-Dcojs b lxliutovls Korlitnrs8
]lci\nfs OKlckjofl
[nd Iruosl's Hcw-Krnppofg Ckdossonf Os
Yiolftnjngy's
Wnrst
Fogatdcrl
Dcdcs Jctjfcs
Mruil Hlfflr Ytlps Nut Wota Kocdnfk
Lcrrofgs, Brlfia Dcfoiurl cfk Unfytcoj
(UAN[N)
YtorrofgKcojy
Hlffoblr Jcwrlfil's Mlvlrjy Aojjs Andl Os
Mlynfk Lxtrcvcgcft
JnffyDcg
=1 Iljlms Wan Acvl Ylvlrl Ojjflssls
UrlssrnndRjU
< Ucsswnrk [ops tn Urntlit _nursljb Cgcofst
Aci`lrs
Jjbljni`
?
Inddlfts
Lftlr
ynur
inddlft
alrl ..
]lcjjy
n Kli
35, =53;2829 cd
Ndg
taly rl cjj
audcf
cbtlr cjj wnw
]lpjy
Cfnfydnus nf
Kli
35, =53; 2829 cd
cfytaofg ot s ofsogat cs tn
anw
doslrcmjl
talsl plnpjl crl.
O d
nbtlf mcbbjlk way sn
dcfy suiilssbuj plnpjl
of
A -wnnk crl sn
cfgry cfk doslrcmjl. [alsl plnpjl tcj` cs
o b taly crl kliokofg
tal
bctl
nb tal wnrjk
...
Glt nvlr ynursljvls. Cjsn,
tal
nfl
todl
iljlms alcr anw
tal
plnpjl tact wnr` wota
ajtp8jjklckjofl.indO=53;/3=Hsnfy-aci`-cdy-pcsicj-l-dcojs-3=53931=9;j inddlfj-josj-wrcpplr
MO=
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
44/152
nwJnfg Icf Ynfy ]ldcof Yojlft f Bcil NbAci`ofg Cttci`> Klckjofl
Ucgl 3 nb 39
attp8//klckjofl.ind/=53;33=/snfy aci` cdy pcsicj sintt rukof mcrci` nmcdc 3=5393?19... 3= 3= =53;
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
45/152
Anw Jnfg Icf Ynfy ]ldcof Yojlft Of Bcil NbAci`ofg Cttci`> OKlckjofl
Ucgl =
nb 9
^Do`l Bjldofg8 Anw Jnfg
Icf
Ynfy Ytcy
Yojlft Of M r u t c A ^ ] O t j g ~ D O O O 3 4 \ j o j o c k l >
o
my
Do`l
bjldofg
Hr
Klildmlr 33, =53;
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
46/152
Anw Jnfg Icf
Ynfy
]ldcof Yojlft Of Bcil Nb Aci`ofg Cttci >
O
Klckjofl
Ucgl 9 nb39
'YNojOO Nb
Cfcrcjj_' BOfcOl8.jcx
[lflr
Lfks
AOjo Mjnnky]Od
Cjj
Ycd Irnw Jjjjjklr
Ynfy o-DcjOc
Ymni`jjb'8Cdy UcjjicO,
? Yintt
]ukOf
Acvl
AnOOywKODO-Yjzlu.
3
@lvjfAcrtBjrstCitnrjfYnfyLdcoO
AOOI`s [n
]lspnfk
Dnrl Brnd Bjldofg Hr
Cdy Ucsicj Bnffcjjy
Cpnjngozls
Bnr
]ciocjjy
Ofslfsotovl
L-Dcoj
Yintt ]ukof Cpnjngozls Cbtlr
H..lc` Ynfy's Aci`lk
]ciocjjy Ofslfsotovl ..
Do`l
B7ldofg8 Anw Jnfg
Icf Ynfy Ytcy Yojlft Of
Mrutcj Aci`lk L-Dcoj...
Y..' UnsotoRO Ypof
.
~
YNjj_
L-Dcojs Yani`lr8
Cdy
Ucsicj,
Yintt ]ukojj
Acvl
Anjjywnnk-1o8zl Lgns...
'Ynfs Sb
Cjjcriay'
BjjOcjl0
Hcx [ljjlr Lfks Aos Mjnnky
]ufCsYnd
Irnw
Jlcklr
DN]L
Dcr`ltpjcil
YLJDC
MLY[ KO]LI[N]
R K\RL]F _
Uicankv Cwcrks ~ . ~
Yt.R\A r b N \ j f ~ CFF\CJ j\JO'.A",.
ICJJ
BN]
LF
b]OLY 3.3 OC'.,
. 8
KLCKjoFL BN] O knf't `fnw,
mut
H
taof`
sal cfk
Ynfy ack
mlttlr
snnf bogurl
nut
c wcy
tn
infvly taly wnf't sot quoltjy
cfk ml
klboflk my taos fcstoflss, cfk taly ack mlttlr kn ot bcst.
Ulnpjl of tnwf crl wnfklrofg anw jnfg Ucsicj cfk tal stukon icf, ufklr tal guosl nb
fnt
kogfobyofg
tal
kcdcgl icuslk my talsl stnjlf kniudlfts, inftoful tn wlctalr cf
ufprlilklftlk dlkoc csscujt wotanu t scyofg cfytaofg> [nfogat's stnrols bnjjnwlk
lcrjolr rlpnrts
cmnut
l-dcojs brnd Yirllf Glds
prlsoklft
Ijoft Iujplpplr
cmnut
trrC
cglft
Hlrldy
Xoddlr's cs` bnr
lxtrc
dnfly mlynfk aos
$9
dojjonf pcyiali`
ob
ijolft
@lvojj Acrt wcs gnofg tn
tcp
aos vcs t sniocj dlkoc bnjjnwofg tn prndntl c bojd. Of tal
dossovls, Iujplpplr wrotls, "O 'd
fnt
scyofg
al's
c wanrl,
mut
al's c wanrl."
Fnw, Iujplpplr's scjty wot os s ndltaofg
al
wlcrs
nf
aos sjllvl,
cfk
O
ufklrstcfk
al
cfk Acrt spn`l cfk jcugalk ot nbb. [al rljctonfsaop taly acvl osf't rltjli8tlk
of
tal
jlc`lk rlpnrts,
cfk sn tal
rlpnrt, lspliocjjy walf tc`lf nut nb inftlxt, sllds jo`l c
votcjjy
odpnrtcft
rlvljctonf. Gulss wm ct> Ot
osf't. [al
bcit os, ot's
fnt ufinddnf bnr
tald tn tcj` tn lcia ntalr jo`l tact, nr bnr Iujplpplr tn tcj` tn dnst plnpjl of
Anjjywnnk jo`l tact. Acrt, c inrl rlcsnf bnr Yirllf Glds' suiilss,
osf't
gnofg
cfywalrl, brnd wact O'd rljocmjy tnjk.
[al
Ucsicj-]ukof lxiacfgl ofijuklk c tlsty strofg
nb
ldcojs walrl tal twn gn ct ot nvlr twosts cfk
turfs
of
tal
]ukof-prnkuilk Ytlvl Hnms dnvol
tact
lvlftucjjy dnvlk brnd Ynfy tn \fovlrscj, wota
Kcffy Mnyjl korlitofg Doiaclj Bc ssmlfklr cs
tal
Cppjl vosonfcry. [nfogat's Nmcdc k ospctia os
wofil-wnrtay cfk
sllds
kobboiujt tn klblfk.
t
wcs
cjsn c provctl infvlrsctonf tact sanujk flvlr acvl
mllf dckl pumjoi. [aly'rl fnt ljlitlk nbboiocjs
kltlrdofofg pnjoiy -
tal
mcftlr rlbjlits fnta ofg
dnrl tacf snpandnroi audnr rlgcrkofg sndlnfl
tn wand taly acvl prnvoklk dcssovl
cfk
lfkurofg suppnrt. Walrl's tal sicfkcj>
Ynfy tn taos pnoft
acsf't
klblfklk otsljb ct cjj, lvlf walf ot wcs ijlcr tmlsl l-dcojs
wlrl gnofg
tn ml
slrvlk up my
indputlr
mci`l rs wan'vl uslk sljlitlk hN\H3jcjostoi
nutjlts tn kn ots korty wnr` of icrryofg nut lcia suiilssovl stro`l. Ot's acrk tn mjcdl
cfy dlkoc nutjlt bnr fnt qulstonfofg tal aogalr purpnsl nb tc`ofg kosay, scjcionus
kniudlfts
cfk
pjcyofg
tald
bnr cjj taly'rl wnr ta, lvlf
ob
taly
crl
invlrofg njk
grnufk. Dnst nb
tal
kniudlft rlvlcjs acvl indl brnd dui`rc`ofg wlmsotls, mut
lvlf tal Wcjj Ytrllt Hnurfcj gnt oftn
tal cit
taos wll`, kovujgofg anw Ynfy
aolk tn
mlttlr lxpjnot Ynfy's Ypoklr-Dcf mrcfk, iujjlk brnd tal stnjlf l-dcojs.
_nu wnfklr
ob
WY bs wojjofgflss tn muojk dcrgofcjjy oftlrlstofg stnrols nut
nbmci`lk
kctc
os rljctlk tn Ynfy sogfofg nf
tn dc`l
Glnrgl Ijnnfly's ckcptctonf nb tal Foi`
Kcvols lxpnsl Aci`Cttci`, waoia vojobols tal panfl-tcppo fg sicfkcj ct ]uplrt
Durknia's tcmjnoks (Durknia nwfs WYH . Fn dcttlr
tml
rlcsnf, tal rlsujt nb cjj taos
acs mllf
c sani`
cfk
cwl-icjomlr csscujt
nf
c Ynfy rlgodl tactwcs indofg
tn
tal
lfk nbc rnuga ylcr bojjlk wota rlstruiturofg
cfk
jcynbbs.
attp8//klckjofl.indH=53;/3=/snfy-aci`-cdy-pcsicj-sintt-rukof-mcrci`-nmcdc-3=5393?19 ... 3=33= =53;
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
47/152
Anw Jnfg Icf Ynfy ]ldcof Yojlft Of Bcil NbAci`ofg Cttci`>
O
Klckjofl Ucgl ; nb 39
Urnblssnrnb
tal
Musoflss nb Dlkoc
Hnaf Ucuj
tal
Grlct Ijjtan\i \fovlrsoty,
8 8 n ~ k j k n , Icjobnrfoc
^ flss Cbbcors Lxliutovl
D]I, Mlvlrjy Aojjs, Icjjbndjc
Klpcrtdlft Alck, Iofldc
jo
[ljlvosonf
Krlxlj \fovlrsoty. Uaojckljpaoc, Ulffsyjvcfoc
Korlitnr, Dcr`ltofg
Lftlrtco fdlft Nfl, Jns Cfgljls, Icjobnrfoc
Y DN]
H51Y
[al alct wnf t jlt up cfytodl snnf cs tal stukon prlpcr ls bnr [aurskcy s
JC
prldolrl
nbtal
Ylta ]nglf..Hcdls Brcfin indlky
[al
Oftlj Rolw, tal indlky cmnut tal
j b t h D p t . . l ~ ~ j k j j . t _ ~ O j O d t ~ d H n f g \f.
K l c k j o f ~ ' ~ ~ ~ ' ] n m m rlpnrtlk tnkcy tact Ynfy acs mnjstlrlk sliurotycfk [DX
rlpnrtlk
tact
tal stukon wnf t nbblr up ]nglf cfk Brcfin
tn
tal dlkoc.
Ynfy Mllbs \p YliurotyCalck
b
[al Oftlrvolw'
]LJC[LK
Urldolrl
Waltalr cfymnky splc`s nr fnt,
tal prlss volwofg
tal
dnvol wojj
ml muzzofg cfk surljy wrotofg
cmnut anw tal bojd lfks. Fnrta
@nrlc
acs
mllf spliujctlkcs
mlofg indpjoiot ojj tal aci`ofg nb
Ynfy nf Fnvldmlr =;. Ob
tact os
trul, tal dnvol s lfkofg wnf t aljp Ynfy. Woklsprlck muxz os tact taofgs knf t lfk
wljj bnr tal Fnrta @nrlcf jlcklr of tal bojd - O vl infbordlk tact Ynfy acs tnflk
knwf cf lfkofg kobblrlft brnd
tal
nfl cukolfils wojj sll tnfogat, bnr tal vlrsonf nb
tal bojd
tact
wojj
ml
sllf
of
talctlrs nvlrslcs -
mut
flotalr bofcjl os bjcttlrofg
tn
@od.
[aos mci` cfk bnrta nvlr tal bojd s lfkofg surbcilk, fcturcjjy, of ylt cfntalr slt nb
stnjlf l-dcoj inrrlspnfklfil wota Ynfy ILN @c=un Aorco.
Glnpnjotois
&
'[al Oftlrvolw'8 Fn Csocf ]ljlcsl
]LJC[LK
[al jost nb cwbuj taofgs tact acvl acpplflk tn Ynfy mlicusl nb taos
mrlcia - upindofg dnvols wlrl jlc`lk tn tal wlm, cjnfg wota plrsnfcj kctc cfk
Yniocj Yliuroty fudmlrs nb ldpjnylls - wojj pntlftocjjy irlctl bofcfiocj kcdcgl cfk
jcwsuots bnr Ynfy tact wojj ml bljt bnr ylcrs tn indl.
Cjj
mlicusl aci`lrs, pnssomjy wota
tal cssostcfil nb ofsokl aljp, bnufk c wcy of tarnuga tal mci` knnr tn wrlc`
ufprlilklftlk acvni tact ofijukls tal Anjjywnnk irlctovl inddufoty wnfklrofg ob
talor kctc
cfk
provctl infvlrsctonfs wojj
ml
sliurl
ob
taly kn musoflss wota tal stukon.
O odcgofl tact
ob
Ynfy s prnkuitonf tlcd ack ot mci`, taly wnujk lotalr acvl ofsostlk
tact tal Fnrta @nrlcf jlcklr ml boitonfcjozlk of [al Oftlj volw nr taly wnujk acvl
pcsslk nf dc`ofg
tal
bojd. [al indlky wnujkf t ml dnr l nr jlss buffy wota c
icroicturl ofstlck nb
tal
stcfkofg jlcklr nb c fuijlcr-icpcmjl inuftry. O ml t taly wosa
taly k flvlr
dckl
tal bojd.
Mut os taos tal todl bnr suia slinfk-gulssofg cfk acfk-wrofgofg> Ytukons cjjnvlr
tnwf crl wctiaofg lvlry klvljnpdlft of wact os turfof g
nut
tn ml tal mogglst bojd
stnry nb =53;. [aly crl rljolvlk ot o sf t talor l-dcojs mlofg dckl pumjoi, cfk ynu k
mlttlr mljolvl taly rl rlvolwofg talo r O[ systlds tn mcttlf tal actials cgcofst
mrlcials. Ynfy os rl-muojkofg ots sliuroty systlds brnd
tal grnufk up.
Ynpaostoictlk Ynfy Cttci` Wnujk Acvl Ulfltrctlk
]LJC[LK
Dnst Indpcfols BMO [ljjsInfgrlss
Anwlvlr, Ynfy lxliutovls jo`l Ucsicj, Jyftnf cfk ntalrs fllk tn kliokl waltalr taly
crl gnofg tn inftoful tn cmsnrm talsl cttci`s sojlftjy of anpls taly sumsokl (taly
wnf t), nr bofk c wcy
tn
splc` up cfk dc`l ot ijlcr tal y wojj fnt ml klboflk my
.-ymlr
tlrrnrosts (taly sanujk). Ot s ijlcr tmct rlstrcoft os nut tal wofknw, cfk tact lcia cfk
lvlry mrlcia wojj ml slrvlk up tn bulj flws rlpnrts tact wojj ml rlpnrtlk cs odpnrtcft
klvljnpdlfts, cfk slt tal infvlrsctonf of Anjjywnnk cfk
tal
dlkoc lvlry kcy.
attp8//klckjofl,ind/=53;/3=/snfy-aci`-cdy-pcsicj-sintt-rukof-mcrci`-nmcdc-3=5393?19... 3=33= =53;
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
48/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
49/152
xaomot
K
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
50/152
3=33 (lgJ[N-O,J[N-=,J[N-9
.. .
)
Wactcrl talsozl
nb
lciatcpl>
Wactmci`upsnbtwcrlcfkwactvlrsonf>
Oscfylfiryptonfsnbtwcrlmlofguslk>
Anwdcfytcpls>
Wacttyplnb kctcos nftaltcpls>
Lxiacfgl(UY['s)>
JntusFntls(FYB)>
Grnupwosl (fnt cs inddnf)>
Knynuacvlcprnhlitonf
nb
taltntcj
kctc
vnjudlnrtalplrilft
nbtal
tcpltactwcsuslk>
Anwdcfytcplsplrtcplslt>
Anwdcfymci` upslssonfscrlofvnjvlk>Nr wacttypl
nb
mci`upwojjml nf taltcpls>(o.ldnftajy/wlljky/kc\y/ylcrjy)
Wojjtalijolftmlcmjltn slfk
of
taltcpls>
Oacvlcfydnrlqulstonfs.Owojjslfktaldynurwcy.
f
taldlcftodl.pjlcslbnrwcrktalslqulstonfstnWojj ocdDnrros'
O[
klpcrtdlftbnrcfswlrs.Ocdanpofgtnrlilovlcrlspnfsl
fn
jctlr
tacf Wlkflskcy
Hujy
93,=539.
attps8jjdcoj.gnngjl.ind/dcoj/\/5O>uo4=&o`45cgl=lNkll&volw4pt&q4INDULJ =5KNI\DLF[Y =NXWlog&qs4trul&slcria4qulry&dsg43;5=33i7ikm=297...
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
51/152
3=33 O borst
cs`lk bnr taos ofbnffctonf nf Fnvldmlr =7
=53=
(sll l-dcoj mljnw) cfk ynu flvlr prnvoklk cf cfswlr.
Mlst,
Dcrius Wcsaofgtnf
INFBOKLF[OCJO[_ FNfIL8 [aos l-dcoj trcfsdossonf, cfk cfy kniudlfts, bojls nr prlvonus
l dcoj
dlsscgls cttcialk tn ot dcy
inftcof infboklftocj ofbnrdctonf tact os jlgcjjy provojlglk. O b ynu crl fnt tal oftlfklk rliopolft, nr c plrsnf rlspnfsomjl bnr
kljovlrofg
ot
tn tal oftlfklk rlIopolft, ynu crl alrlmy fntobolk tact cfy rlvolw, kosijnsurl, inpyofg, kostromutonf nr usl nb cfy nb
tal ofbnrdctonf inftcoflk of nr cttcialk tn taos trcfsdossonf os Y[]OI[J_ U]NAOMO[LK. O b ynu acvl rlilovlk taos trcfsdossonf
of lrrnr, pjlcsl oddlkoctljy fntoby tal slfklr. Ujlcsl klstrny tal nrogofcj trcfsdossonf cfk ots cttciadlfts wotanut rlckofg nr
scvofg of cfy dcfflr. [acf` ynu.
Brnd D.
Wcsaofgtnf
Pdcojtn8
audcfrogats.crlcdustEgdcoj.indT
Ylft [ulskcy, Fnvldmlr =7, =53= 358;= CD
[n dzwlogEjnlm.ind0
iicrmnflEjnlm.ind
Y\mhlit Jotogctonf Anjk
Doiaclj,
Cbtlr rlckofg Hukgl Ucttlrsnf's Fnvldmlr 1, =53= kliosonf infilrfofg Jlnfcrk
]nwl's
B]IU 25 Dntonf, ot icffnt
ml
kosputlk tact Wojjocd Dnrros cfk talor inufslj ack cfk sanujk stojj acvl of talor pnsslssonf tal citucj l-dcoHs tact wlrl
tn ciindpcfy Lxaomot
93
(tal l-dcoj slcria suddcry rlsujts kosinvlrlk of Hujy =55= waoia sanws
ynur
ijolft cfk
lxliutovls brnd ICC rlblrrofg tn Cbroicf Cdlroicfs cs fogglr, foggc, innf, dnf`ly,
\fijl
[nd cfk
ntalr rciocjjy klrngctnry tlrds aufkrlks
nb
todls) - cjtanuga ynu cfk ntalr nbboilrs ofvnjvlk of tact icsl acvl mllf
sldo-suiilssbuj of brcukujlftjy infilcHofg taos sdn`ofg guf lvoklfil brnd tal Ujcoftobbs cfk tal Inurt nvlr tal jcst
klickl.
_nu acvl mllf cwcrl tact O'vl ack Lxaomot 93 of dy pnsslssonf bnr tal jcs t bovl dnftas. Yofil O borst prlslftlk taos
acuftofg lvoklfil tn tal Ylinfk Ioriuot nf Hufl 2,=53=, ynu acvl ianslf tn rldcof sojlft cfk/nrrlblrrlk tn c
klilptovljy wrottlf hukoiocj npofonf prnkuilk tarnuga brcuk upnf tal Inurt mlicusl taos suppnrts dy inftlftonfs
tact taos icmcj acs dcoftcoflk ots kosirodofctnry cfk cftoindpltotovl ldpjnydlft prcitoils wota dcjoil cfkjnr rli jlss
ofkobblrlfil tn tal blklrcjjy prntlitlk rogats nbqucjobolk Cbroicf Cdlroicfs cfk plnpjl nb injnr bnr dnrl tacf c ilftury
tn dcoftcof ots dnfnpnjostoi inftrnj nvlr Anjjywnnk cfk tal dcr`ltpjcil nboklcs. Cs lvoklft my tal Flw _nr`'s
oflxnrcmjl zlrn of pnsotonfs
nb
Cglft, Innrkofctnr cfk Cglft [rcofll mlbnrl O mlgcf wnr`ofg ct tal indpcfy nf
Ylptldmlr =, =551, taos burtalr kldnfstrctls tact tal indpcfy acs oftlft onfcjjy brnzlf c wnr` iujturl ldmlkklk of
attps8jjdcoj.gnngOl.ind/dcot/ujNj>uo4=&o`45cgl=lNkll&volw4pO&q4INDULJ =5KNI\DLF[Y =5zwlog&qs4trul&sccria4qulry&dsg43;5=33i7ikm=297...
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
52/152
3=33
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
53/152
3=/3
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
54/152
3=33
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
55/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
56/152
3=33
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
57/152
3=33uo4=&o`4Scgl=lNkll&volw4pt&q4INDULJ =5KNI\DLF[Y =Nzwlog&qs4trul&slcria4qulry&dsg43;329m7;5m7mlm;...
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
58/152
3=33
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
59/152
Lxaomot L
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
60/152
]ciocj Kldngrcpaoi Mrlc`knwf ct tal F_I nbboil nb Wojjocd Dnrros Cglfiy (Ylptldmlr ?, =551).
[ntcj8
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
61/152
]ciocj Kldngrcpaoi Mrlc`knwf
ct
tal F_I nbboil nb
Wojjocd
Dnrr os Lfklcvnr Lft. (Cproj 35, =535).
[ntc 8Y
Waotl8 1,
355%
Cbroicf Cdlroicf8
5,
5
Aospcfoi8
5, 5
Csocf8
5,5
Innrkofctnr
[ntcj8
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
62/152
xaomot
B
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
63/152
FnfIL NBCUULC]CFILBN]Y\MY[O[\[L,CKNdNFCJ, N]CDOI\YIN\FYLJ
Yanrt [Okl8
Wcsaofgtnf v.
Wojjocd Dnrros Lfklcvnr
Lftlrtcofdlft. lt
cj.
Kni`lt
Fn.8
3;-;9=1-Ijv
Yumstotutl. Ckkotonfcj, nr
CdoIK!
Inufslj's Inftcit Ofbnrdctonf os u bnjjnws.
Fcdl8
Doiaclj
U.
Xwlog
Bord!Jnlm
&
Jnlm
JJU
Ckkrlss89;< Ucr` Cvlful, Flw _nr`. Flw _nr` 353
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
64/152
Lxaomot G
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
65/152
CDL]OICF
C]MO[]C[ONF CYYNIOC[ONF
-------------------------------------------------------- Q
DC]I\Y
O.
WCYAOFG[NF,
Ijcodcft,
-cgcofst-
WOJJOCD DN]]OY LFKLCRN]
CCC Icsl Fn. T9
32553;=23=
LF[L][COFDLF[, JJI, bnrdlrjy `fnwf cs
tal WOJJOCD
DN]]OY CGLFI_, OFI.,
HLBB]L_ DLCKL cfk YC]CA
WOFOC]Y@O,
]lspnfklfts.
-------------------------------------------------------- Q
KLIJC]C[ONF NB DOIACLJ U.
XWLOG OF
Y\UUN][ NB
CF CWC]K
NB
C[[N]FL_Y' BLLY
CGCOFY[
IJCODCF[
DC]I\Y WCYOKFG[NF
DOIACLJ U. XWLOG, cf cttnrfly ckdottlk tn prcitoil jcw of tal Inurts
nb
tal Ytctl
nb
Flw _nr`, klijcrls tal bnjjnwofg ufklr plfcjty
nb
plrhury pursucft tn =1 \.Y.I.
37;28
3 O cd c pcrtflr of tal jcw bord nb Jnlm Jnlm JJU ( Jnlm ), cttnrflys bnr
]lspnfklfts Wojjocd Dnrros Lfklcvnr Lftlrtcofdlft, JJI ( WDL ), Hlbbrly Dlckl cfk Ycrca
Rcf Anvlf (bnrdlrjy Wofocrs o). O cd bujjy bcdojocr wota tal bcits kosiusslk of taos klijcrctonf.
=. My Nrklr kctlk Cproj 31, =53;, Crmotrctnr Jlwos bnufk Ijcodcft Dcrius
Wcsaofgtnf tn acvl rlplctlkjy vonjctlk tal Crmotrctnr's prlvonusjy ossulk Infboklftocjoty Nrklr
cfk tact Wcsaofgtnf's mck bcota infkuit ack icuslk fllkjlss lxplfsl cfk kljcy. ;33133;
Nrklr nf Ycfitonfs ct ?-35. Crmotrctnr Jlwos scfitonflk Wcsaofgtnf
my
csslssofg cgcofst aod
twn-taorks nbWDL's blls cfk insts ofiurrlk of taos dcttlr brnd Blmrucry =3, =53;, tal kctl
nb
Crmotrctnr Jlwos's cppnoftdlft, tarnuga tal kctl nb tal Cpro331 Ycfitonfs Nrklr.
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
66/152
9. Of ciinrkcfil wota tal Ycfitonfs Nrklr, O rlsplitbujjy sumdot taos Klijcrctonf of
suppnrt nb cf cwcrk nb cttnrflys blls, my waoia WDL ciinufts bnr cfk sll`s tal blls
rlcsnfcmjy ofiurrlk of taos dcttlr mltwllf Blmrucry =3, =53; cfk Dcria 93, =53;. Waojl tal
Cproj
31
Nrklr plrdots WDL tn sll` ots blls cfk insts tarnuga Cproj 31 WDL cppjols alrlof
nfjy bnr cf cwcrk nb twn-taorks nbblls bnr tal plronk brnd Blmrucry
=3
tn Dcria 93. WDL
sll`s cf cwcrk nbY;9,757.25.
;. [al anurjy rctls cfk anurs
nb
Jnlm cttnrflys cfk pcrcjlgcjs wan acvl wnr`lk nf
taos dcttlr, cs iacrglk tn WDL, crl jostlk mljnw. [al rctls oklftobolk mljnw crl rlcsnfcmjl of
jogat
nb
tal lxplrolfil jlvlj, cfk mci`grnufks
nb
tal cttnrflys cfk pcrcjlgcjs cssogflk tn
rlprlslft WDL of taos dcttlr. O
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
67/152
jotogctonf lxplrolfil. [odntay Iuddofs os c pcrcjlgcj cfk tal dcfcgofg ijlr` of Jnlm's Flw
_nr` nbboil. Cftnoflttl Ulpplr os c slfonr pcrcjlgcj of Jnlm's Flw _nr` nbboil.
Uursucft tn
=1
\.Y.I. 37;2 3 klijcrl ufklr plfcjty n plrhury ufklr tal jcws nb tal
\fotlk
Ytctls n Cdlroic tact tal bnrlgnofg os trul cfk inrrlit.
Lxliutlk nf tal 1ta kcy
n
Dcy =53;.
9
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
68/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
69/152
Sucjoboictonfs nb Dysljb Yodojcrjy Yotuctlk WaotlH Hlwosm Cglft [rcoflls [act Mlgcf Wnr`ofg Ct tml Flw _nr` nbboil nb Wojjocd Dnrros
f
Ylptldmlr =551.
wnr`
lxplrolfil OY c
Infstruitovljy
dusoi
hnurfcjost
bnr
kosiacrglk of Cproj
gn DocdojYox
=535
cbtlr o ~ o p
Klgrlls
pumjoiost bnr
indpjcofts nbBciocj
dusoi prnkuilr
cialjnr s
of
Dlkoc
kosirodofcton f tn O Uplr
Kcfhcacfkz (Hustof
cfcgldlft
cfk
dcfcgldlft
cfk
Usyianjngy of Dcy =552 [odmlrjc`l, Fljjy
lptldmlr =3, 3?1;
Audcf
]lsnurii0s
wota
Burtckn, @lro Aojsnf),
crius Oscoca (=9,
gnofg nf
=;
cfk Dcstlr s
of Dusoi
rjcfkn cfk
fn citonf mlofg tc`lf
usoi
bro
icf
dcjl.
dlro
icf
Ylptldmlr =, =551
O
Musoflss
cfk twn ylcj3o
IN-jOjj\jcgofg
csaofgtnf Docdo,
BJ
ylcrs njk jctlr tact
my
nrgcfozctonf.
cfk lstcmjosaofg tal
nfta.) Lftlrtcofdlft Ofkustrols of
MOcijkostlk bnr
mjnwofg
icrllr
nb
H
]linrks'cy
=551, mnta bjud
tal
",ojostjl nf
icmcj s
\fovlj3ooty nb Docdo rlinrkofg crtost
ufjcwbujjy
Hczdofl Yujjovcf, cfk
kosirodofctnry
G]CDD_\
prcitoils. \flKjUjnylk
Ytuklft ]lp. bnr
bnr flcrjy tarll ylcrs.
Bjnrokc Iacptlr nb
[al
Fn
lxplrolfil tn
dy
`fnwjlkgl.
t
dnst,
nfjofl
hnurfcjostjmjngglr.
Rnjuftcrojy jlbt
tal
Cppjolk
cfk wcs
indpcfy
tn pursul
Hujy
=9, 3?1 Wact kn iurrlft lvlfts rlgcrkofg rcil rljctonfs of Cdlroic
kldnfstrctl>
Cjj ldpjnylr's rliruotdlft pnjoiols nr prcitoils dcy nvlrtjy lxijukl dofnroty cppjoicfts nr dcy acvl tal
lbblit nb lxijukofg dofnroty cppjoicfts. f ldpjnylr dogat cjsn rliruot my wnrk
nb
dnuta. Walrl suia rliruotdlft
tc`j Y pjcil cfk tal ofkovokucjs dc`ofg tal rlblrrcjs crl glflrcjjy dldmlrs nb nfl slx nr c splioboi rciocj grnup,
suia citonf dogat acvl tal lbblit
nb
lxijukofg ilrtcof grnups brnd ldpjnydlft.
Ob
talrl crl sumstcftocjjy blwlr
dofnroty cppjoicfts cfk ldpjnylls ta f talrl crl qucjobolk dofnroty dldmlrs of tal jcmnr dcr`lt, cf ofblrlfil
nb
kosirodofctonf dcy ml krcwf. [alrl crl jlss kosirodofctnry aorofg dltanks tacf rljyofg nf wnrk nb dnuta nr
flpntosd. [aos prnkuils cf oftrofsoicjjy kosirodofctnry indplfsctonf systld. glflrcj pnjoiy nb kosirodofctonf
Walf lvoklfil nb systldoi kospcrctl trlctdlft os prlslft
of
c icsl, tal lvoklfil os cjdnst cjwcys uslk cs tal
-2
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
102/152
prodcry dltank
nb
prnvofg jocmojoty rctalr tacf ct tal bdcj stcgl
nb
c DiKnffljj-Knugjcs icsl. [aos os trul lvlf
tanuga tal systldoi kospcrctl trlctdlft dnklj
os
duia tal scdl waltalr uslk (3) ct tal prltlxt stcgl nb cf
ofkovokucj kospcrctl trlctdlft icsl nr (=) cs tal prodcry dltank nb prnvofg jocmojoty.
Ilrtcof glflrcj profiopjls guokl inurts of sljlitofg cpprnproctl rldlkols bnr vonjctonfs
nb
blklrcj hnm
kosirodofctonf jcws. ]ljolb of kosirodofctonf os klsogflk mnta tn rldlky tal lbblits nb pcst kosirodofctonf cfk tn
prlvlft sodojcr kosirodofctonf
of
tal buturl.
Dnfltcry ]ljolb8
Mci` pcy wota prlhukgdlft oftlrlst ufklr Ylitonf 3?13 prl
cfk pnst-aorofg kospcrctl trlctdlft,
rltcjoctonf),
[otjl
vf (prl cfk pnst-aorofg kospcrctl trlctdlft, kospcrctl odpcit, rltcjoctonf),
F_YA]J
cfk
F_IA]J (prl cfk pnst-aorofg kospcrctl trlctdlft, kospcrctl odpcit, rltcjoctonf)T([O.O33.l r j Z d ~ 8 Y l p t l d m ~ r
3535 - Kctl
n
hukgdlftT
Brnd c dyrock nb kobblrlft cfgjls,
[
acvl kldnfstrctlk tact cmslft Wojjocd Dnrros' infsporciy tn oftlrblrl wota tal
audcf rogats nb Cbroicf Cdlroicfs cfk inftofulk lfgcgldlft of rcil-mcslk ldpjnydlft kosirodofctonf, [wnujk
acvl mllf aorlk cs cf Cglft of tal dusoi klpcrtdlft. O wcs ijlcrjy fcovl tn tal bcit tact mlicusl
nb
tal [cjlft
Cglfiy Cit, waoia stctls tact nfl dust ml joilfslk tn mlindl cf Cglft, O wcs stojj hust cs qucjobolk cs tal rlilftjy
prndntlk cfk dok-jlvlj Cglfts ct tal indpcfy. Ot tnn` dl wnr`ofg
of
tact lfvornfdlft cjnfgsokl tansl
prlkndofctljy cjj waotlj 3lwosa ofkovokucjs ct taos provctl cfk aogajy slirltovl indpcfy tn rlcjozl tact. cfk
taN\gat tact Nfil purpnslbuj hnm kosirodofctonf os prnvlk, tal voitods crl lftotjlk tn c prlsudptonf of bcvnr nb
cwcrkofg mci`pcy cfk ofhufitovl rljolb. Jll
v
Wcsaofstnf Inufty Mk. nb Lk., 2=< B.=k 3=9< (
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
103/152
bnrdlr INN nb tal Flw _nr` nbboil - tact talrl wnujk ml
fn
dnvldlft
of
dy lxprlsslk crlcs
nb
oftlrlst. Cbtlr O
bojlk c indpjcoft wota tal LLNI, tal indpcfy aorlk bovl mjci` plnpjl cfk nfl nb tal Cbroicf Cdlroicf Bjnctlrs
oddlkoctljy tnn` DG's cssostcft pnsotonf cfk DG wcs prndntlk tn Innrkofctnr. Cbtlr c blw dnftas, DG wcs
prndntlk tn Cglft of waoia
al
wcs cssogflk tn wnr` wota tal indpcfy's Jctof rnstlr bnr mrcfkofg cfk dcr`ltofg
nppnrtufotols. Lvlf cbtlr O wcs pcsslk nvlr bnr tal cssostcft pnsotonf, O stojj prlslftlk mrcfkofg cfk dcr`ltofg
prlslftctonfs bnr rlilftjy sogflk ijolft @lro Aojsnf cfk taos jlk tn lfknrsldlft klcjs bnr
alr.
lvlf wrntl tal
glflroi potia jlttlr waoia wcs l-dcojlk tn vcronus indpcfols inftcoflk of Wojjocd Dnrros' kctcmcsl. Ijlcrjy, O
inujk plrbnrd tal hnm nb mnta dusoi cfk dcr`ltofg Cglft, mut wcs ufcmjl tn rosl cmnvl tal indpcfy's gjcss
ilojofg
fn
dcttlr anw acrk O trolk
tn
kldnfstrctl O wcs cf csslt
tn
tal indpcfy. Ack DG ack sodojcr rlsudl cfk
"NFJ_" cppjolk bnr tal Cglft [rcofll prngrcd, Wojjocd Dnrros wnujk acvl irlctlk c pnsotonf bnr aod cs cf Cglft,
cs taly kn bnr ntalr ofkovokucjs wan crl fnt "joilfslk" Cglfts mlbnrl hnofofg tal indpcfy. Waotls tact stcrtlk of
tal dcoOrnnd wota dl cfk wlrl lvlftucjjy prndntlk tn Cglft8 Dojls Gokcjy, Mrotnf Yialy, Yuzcffl Jynf,
Mlf Yodnfl, Hlffol Jlvofl, Grcad Hlcfoi`l, cfk glt c jost nb cjj ntalrs wan wlrl prndntlk. O wcftlk
tn `fnw
talor ijolft jost. Wact prnhlits
taly'vl
mllf ofvnjvlk of cfk tal cdnuft nb ofindl talor ijolfts acvl mrnugat
oftn tal indpcfy>
Wota dy cickldoi ciaolvldlfts fk rljlvcft
wnr`
lxplrolfil prl-kctofg dy ldpjnydlft ct Wojjocd
Dnrros, O wnujk acvl mllf aorlk
cs
cf Cglft
ob
wlrl Waotlb'Hlwosa" - lvlf
ob O'k
"NFJ_" cppjolk bnr tal Cglft
[rcofll prngrcd. Fn Waotlr'Hlwosa" Cglft [rcofll of tal aostnry acs mllf rlspnfsomjl bnr mrofgofg c ijolft
tn
tal
indpcfy tact wlft nf
tn
ml vlry suiilssbuj lbnrl hnofofg tal Cglft [rcofll prngrcd. Ob sn, Wojjocd Dnrros fllks
tn prnvokl talor fcdls, rlsudls cfk kctls
nb
ldpjnydlft. Yofil O acvl prnvlf prl-aorofg kosirodofctonf cfk tact O
sanujk acvl allf aorlk cs c dusoi Cglft,
[
cd lftotjlk tn mci` pcy
of
cdnuft lquovcjlft
tn
wact c stcrtofg Cglft
wnujk rlilovl. O wcs provy tn tal ldpjnydlft cgrlldlft nb Cglft Mrck Yallacf - tal ofkovokucj O acvl rlcsnf tn
mljolvl Wojjocd Dnrros trcfsblrrlk tn tal Flw _nr` nbboil
tn
wnr` cjnfgsokl Icrc Jlwos cbtlr O sumdottlk dy
rlsudl cfk wcs cjjnwlk tn mnn` Cbroicf Cdlroicf crtosts cjtanuga al ack
fn
oftlrlst of urmcf dusoi cfk wcs fnt c
"joilfslk" Cglft (c vonjctonf
nb
tal [cjlft Cglfiols Cit) -- kurofg nfl
nb
dy
hnm
cssogfdlfts
nb
ijlcfofg nut bojls
bnr bnrdlr in-INN, Wcyfl @cmc`. t wcs c bovl ylcr cgrlldlft, of waoia al wcs gucrcftllk cf lsicjctofg scjcry
lcia ylcr, inddossonfs cfk ckkotonfcj mlflbots. [al rlcsnf way dy prnhlitlk scjcry sanujk ml dnrl tacf wact Mrck
lcrflk, os mlicusl al kok fnt sogf tcjlft cfk al kokf't rlcjjy acvl cf oftlrlst nr jnvl bnr taos glfrl nbdusoi. Cbtlr al
wcs prndntlk
tn
Cglft of jctl =551/lcrjy =55?, al jlbt tal indpcfy sanrtjy talrlcbtlr. O rlinddlfklk dcfy crtosts
bnr Icrc Jlwos
tn
sogf cfk
ack
[ mllf cf Cglft, [wnujk acvl sogflk tansl crtosts dysljb. PIjcodcft ]lp. Yuddcry
Hukgdlft,
#.T
O wcs pcok my Wojjocd Dnrros brnd Ylptldmlr =551 uftoj Ylptldmlr =535. O'vl ofijuklk dy W-= bnrds
brnd WDC cfk WDL bnr tansl ylcrs. Mljnw
os
c iacrt O irlctlk
tn
prnvokl c rnuga lstodctl
nb
wact O cd nwlk bnr mci` pcy mcslk nf wcgls nfjy. Cjtanuga tal bogurls bnr lcia ylcr crl fnt ciiurctl, tal tntcj bnr
tal scjcry rlilovlk os. Cs bnr tal scjcry nwlk mcslk nf wcgls nfjy, O prnvoklk c gulstodctl
nb
wact MYA dckl cf
lftry jlvlj Cglft cfk klrovlk ct tal mci` pcy nwlk cdnuft my klkuitofg tal scjcry tact O dckl
cs
cf Cglft [rcofll
brnd tal scjcry O sanujk acvl rlilovlk cs cf Cglft.
_lcrs
nb
Ldpjnydlft Ycjcry ]lilovlk Ycjcry Nwlk*
Mci`
Ucy Nwlk
Ylpt. =551 - Ylpt. =55? $35,531.25 $2
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
104/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
105/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
106/152
Ior. =55?) (cpprnvofg grnsslk-up rlinvlry), wota Kcsafcw
v
Ulfc,
3=
B.9k 333=
K.i.
Ior. 3??;) (klfyofg
grnsslk-up rlinvlry).
[al slinfk infslqulfil, splioboicjjy infilrflk wota tal
CDb,
indls oftn pjcy nfjy
ob
cttnrfly's blls crl
ofijuklk of tal pjcoftobb's ofindl.
b
taly crl, taly wojj usucjjy icusl tal pjcoftobb's ofindl tn rosl cmnvl tal
tarlsanjk bnr cppjoictonf nb tal
CDb,
c indpjlx slt nb prnvosonfs tact, cdnfg ntalr taofgs, koscjjnw klkuitonfs tn
ofkovokucjs wota c aoga rcton
nb
klkuitomjl lxplfsl tn cffucj ofindl. Cdnfg tal klkuitonfs koscjjnwlk crl tansl
nrkofcrojy cvcojcmjl bnr cttnrfly's blls. Anwlvlr, Infgrlss cjjlvoctlk taos prnmjld of kosirodofctonf icsls,
ofijukofg tansl mrnugat ufklr tal profiopcj blklrcj jcws cgcofst ldpjnydlft kosirodofctonf, my c prnvosonf
of
tal
Cdlroicf Hnms Irlctonf Cit nb =55;. 331 Ytct. 3;31 (=55;), cdlfkofg =2 \.Y.i.
2=(c)(=5). [al lbblit nb taos
prnvosonf
os
tn plrdot c klkuitonf bnr cfy cttnrfly's blls cfk inurt insts cwcrklk nr lxplfklk of infflitonf
wota suia icsls, up tn tal cdnuft
nb
cfy hukgdlft nr slttjldlft ofijuklk of grnss ofindl, lvlf bnr tcxpcylrs
sumhlit tn tal
CDb.
\jtodctljy, mlbnrl dysljb cfk/nr lxplrt icf indputl mci` pcy cfk brnft pcy, O wojj fllk Wojjocd Dnrros tn
prnkuil vcronus Cglft ldpjnydlft cgrlldlfts, splioboicjjy brnd Cglfts tact wnr`(lk) tarnuganut tal dusoi
klpcrtdlft jo`l Icrc Jlwos, Ultlr GrnssJogat, Ycdcftac @ormy, Ylta Yolglj, cs wljj cs vcronus Cglfts tact crl
infsoklrlk tlfplrilftlrs tn prnhlit wact O wnujk acvl rlilovlk ack Wojjocd Dnrros fnt dcoftcoflk ots
kosirodofctnry wnr` lfvornfdlft wota dcjoil cfk/nr rli`jlss ofkobblrlfil tn tal blklrcjjy prntlitlk rogats
nb
Cbroicf Cdlroicfs cfk O trujy ack cf lqucj nppnrtufoty
tn
ckvcfil cfk ml dlftnrlk.
Of
Mlssolr
v
Urliosl [nnj
Lfgofllrofg In Ofi . 771
B
Yupp. 3
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
107/152
rlputctonf).
Cf
cwcrk
nb
jnst buturl lcrfofgs
os
c inddnf-jcw
tnrt
rldlky cfk c pjcoftobb dust sanw tact aos ofhurols
acvl icuslk c kodofutonf
of
aos
cmojoty tn lcd c jovofg. [al twn cwcrks indplfsctl tal pjcoftobb
bnr
kobblrlft
ofhurols cfk crl fnt kupjoictovl. Wojjocds
v.
Uacffcioc, 397 B.9k ?;; (7ta
Ior.
3??1). Of icjiujctofg brnft pcy,
tal
pjcoftobb dust sanw tal cdnuft nb tal prnpnslk cwcrk, tal cftoiopctlk jlfgta nbputctovl ldpjnydlft cfk cppjy
cf
cpprnproctl kosinuft rctl. Mrusn
v.
\fotlk Corjofls, Ofi., =9? B.9k
1;1
(7ta Ior. =55
O).
Brnft pcy os fnt sumhlit tn tal
icps
nf
[otjl
RO[
indplfsctnry kcdcgls. Unjjcrk
v.
L.[.
Kupnft kl Fldnurs
,
In.,
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
108/152
MFC)
37;1, 2? Ldpj.
Urci. Kli. (IIA) ,;;;59 (=k Ior. 3??2). Brnft pcy cwcrk
nb
$?=7,=97.27, rlprlslftofg
kobblrlfil mltwllf ;=-ylcr-njk borlbogatlr's rltorldlft ofindl cfk alr cffucj wcgls mlbnrl sal rltorlk cjjlglkjy
mlicusl nb kosirodofctonf uftoj alr fnrdcj rltorldlft cgl, wcs fnt lxilssovl0 fn lvoklfil of rlinrk sugglstlk tact
borlbogatlr wnujk
ml
cmjl tn bofk wnr` ct c scjcry jlvlj inddlfsurctl wota alr prl-tlffofctonf scjcry, alr
lkuictonfcj mci`grnufk wcs jodotlk
tn
nfjy sndl injjlgl ijcssls, cfk alr vnictonfcj lxplrolfil ack mllf jodotlk tn
wnr`
of
borlbogatofg
cfk
ldlrglfiy
rlsiul. Mrnckfcx
v.
Ioty
nb
Flw Acvlf,
3;3
Blk.
Cppx.
31
(=k
Ior.
=55
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
109/152
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
110/152
Kurofg nur Hujy 95, =539 infblrlfil icjj ynu sugglstlk mlofg rlofstctlk. O nppnslk. Fnw, of ynur taork
Oftlrod Kliosonf, ynu stctl tact O sanujk cfk iotl Bnrk Dntnr In.
v.
LLNI. Y1 \.Y. =3?,
=93 f.jY (3?1=) - tal nfjy icsl jcw dlftonflk of ynur odprnvoklft kliosonf. Bnr tal bnurta todl, O acvl tn
kldnfstrctl way ynur iotctonf nb tal jcw os lrrnflnus cfk fnt cppjoicmjl tn taos icsl. Walf O pujjlk tal citucj icsl
brnd WlstJcw, ot stctlk of tal oftrnkuitonf8
''[al Lqucj Ldpjnydlft Nppnrtufoty Inddossonf sulk cutndnmojl dcfubciturlr ijcodofg [otjl ROO vonjctonf
my rlbusofg tn aorl wndlf ct nfl nb ots wcrlanusls. [al \fotlk Ytctls Kostroit Inurt bnr tal Wlstlrf Kostroit nb
Fnrta Icrnjofc, Hcdls M. DiDojjcf, H. cwcrklk mci` pcy. [al Inurt
nb
Cpplcjs, 2;< B.=k 319, cbbordlk cfk
rldcfklk. Ilrtonrcro wcs grcftlk. [al Yuprldl Inurt, Hustoil N'Inffnr, aljk tact cf ldpjnylr iacrglk wota
kosirodofctonf of aorofg icf tnjj tal inftofuofg ciirucj nb mci` pcy jocmojoty my ufinfkotonfcjjy nbblrofg tal
ijcodcft tal hnm prlvonusjy klfolk cfk tal ldpjnylr os fnt rlquorlk tn nbblr slfonroty rltrncitovl tn kctl nb tal
cjjlglk kosirodofctonf, cfk tact cmslft spliocj ioriudstcfils, rlhlitonf nb tal ufinfkotonfcj hnm nbblr lfks tal
ciirucj nb pntlftocj mci` pcy jocmojoty. (ldpacsos ckklk)
_nu dust `llp of dy, ynu crl fnt dy bnrdlr ldpjnylr. [al ]lspnfklfts acvl flvlr ''ufinfkotonfcjjy
nb[lrPlkT PdlT tal hnm prlvonusjy klfolk - nfjy ynu acvl. [act cjnfl kldnfstrctls tact ynu knf't ufklrstcfk tal
jcw. [aly crl fnt nmhlitofg tn taos mlicusl
o
O wlrl tn ml rlofstctlk, O wnujk stojj ml tal nfjy Cbroicf Cdlroicf
Cglft ldpjnylk of tal Flw _nr` nbboil, Wojjocd Dnrros' kosirodofctnry wnr` lfvornfdlft wnujk stojj lxost cfk
tact's lsslftocjjy tal prnmjld alrl. Ulrblit lxcdpjl os tact nb Sulftof Ldmrll - tal ICC Cbroicf Cdlroicf
ldpjnyll wan wnr`lk of tal dcoOrnnd cfk sumdottlk cf Oftlrfcj Dldn kosiussofg aos cjjlgctonfs nb rciosd cfk
ldpjnydlft kosirodofctonf. ^ Cjsn, ynu crl iotofg c icsl infilrfofg mci` pcy, cjtanuga tal Iovoj
]ogats Cit wcs cdlfklk of 3??3 kul tn tal infslrvctovl citonfs nb tal hukoiocry of tal 3?15s. Nb inursl, taos
kliosonf wcs dckl of
3?1=,
of
waoia ]nfcjk ]lgcf wcs Urlsoklft.
O vl
kosiusslk
nf
dcfy niicsonfs ]lcgcf cfk
tal ]lpumjoicf pcrty's infslrvctovl cglfkc tn bojj tal hukoiocry wota jo`l-dofklk blklrcj hukgls wan acvl mllf
ufbcvnrcmjl
tn
iovoj rogats.
Cfntalr rlcsnf way ynur sugglstonf
nb
rlofstctldlft os sanrtsogatlk os mlicusl ynu crl inftofunusjy usofg
icsl jcw plrtcofofg tn ijcods nb glfklr kosirodofctonf, of waoia tal ijcss nb pjcoftobbs dnrl tacf jo`ljy crl waotl
wndlf (pjurcj).3; [alrl wcs rlcjjy fn fllk tn rlck tal rlst nb tal jcw. Nfl taofg os ilrtcof8 Ob dy ijcods wlrl
brovnjnus nr pursulk of mck bcota, talrl wnujk ml fn rlcsnf bnr Crmotrctnr Grlgnry tn sugglst rlofstctldlft cbtlr
sottofg wota dntonfs tact spcf flcrjy tarll ylcrs. Way wnujk ynu ciiusl dl nb lfgcgofg of klbcdctonf, sjcfklr cfk
jomlj cgcofst dy bnrdlr ldpjnylr cfk talf sugglst tact O gn mci` cfk wnr` wota tal indpcfy O acvl klbcdlk> Way
wnujk Wojjocd Dnrros wcft tn aorl sndlnfl tact
acs
lxpnslk tald bnr mlofg c Hlwosa icmcj cfk lfgcgofg of
ofstotutonfcj rciosd bnr joY ylcrs> Fnt jngoicj.
C
kosirodofctonf voitod's prnhlitlk lcrfofgs tarnuganut tal kurctonf
nb
tal brnft pcy rlinvlry plronk acvl
ofijuklk tal bnjjnwofg typls nb dnfltcry indplfsctonf tact wnujk acvl ciirulk cmslft tal ufjcwbuj kosirodofctonf8
cftoiopctlk brofgl mlflbots, suia cs plfsonf mlflbots, pcok vcictonf, ldpjnylr inftromutonfs tn c scvofgs pjcf tact crl
fnt tnn ufilrtcof cfk spliujctovl, cfk ldpjnylr-pcok ofsurcfil prldouds, cftoiopctlk pcy ofirlcsls mcslk nf pronr
cffucj ofirlcsls,
ob
tal voitod jo`ljy wnujk acvl inftofulk tn rlilovl suia ofirlcsls, oftlrlst nf tal prnhlitlk
lcrfofgs. Mui`jly v. ]lyfnjks Dltcjs In., 2?5 B. Yupp. =33,
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
111/152
odpnslk my 3?13c(m)(9). Anwlvlr, tal Yuprldl Inurt inftlfks tact mlicusl brnft pcy os c rldlky cutanrozlk
ufklr 752(g) nb tal Iovoj ]ogats Cit nb 3?2; cfk Infgrlss kok fnt jodot tal cvcojcm ojoty nb suia rlwcrks ufklr
752(g), Infgrlss cjsn kok fnt jodot tal cvcojcmojoty nb brnft pcy cwcrks ufklr 3?13c. [al Inurt bnufk tact
Infgrlss snugat
tn
lxpcfk tal cvcojcmjl rldlkols my plrdottofg tal rlinvlry
nb
indplfsctnry cfk pufotovl kcdcgls
of ckkotonf tn prlvonusjy cvcojcmjl rldlkols suia cs brnft pcy. Mcslk nf tal bnjjnwofg rlcsnfs cmnvl, dy brnft pcy
scjcry sanujk ml tal indpcrcmjl tn wact c Waotl cfk/nr Hlwosa dok tn slfonr-jlvlj Cglft wnujk dc l ct _lcr 2
uftoj _lcr 95.
[alrl crl Cglfts ct Wojjocd Dnrros wan dc`l slvlf bogurls c ylcr.
Nf
Pofslrt kctlT, c
bcx
my Hnaf
Bngljdcf, bnrdlr in-alck nb Wojjocd Dnrros' dntonf-poiturl klpcrtdlft, jlc`lk nfjofl rlvlcjofg c dldn wrottlf
my IBN
rv
Wloftrcum, tal scjcrols cfk stni` cppnrtonfofg
nbWD
tnp cglfts, lxliutovls cfk
mncrk dldmlrs brnd =557. O mljolvl tact nvlr todl, O wnujk acvl mllf nfl nb tansl Cglfts mcslk
nf dy cmojoty tn oklftoby tcjlft cfk tal bcit tact Icrc Jlwos
os
fn jnfglr ldpjnylk ct tal cglfiy.
3 "Infstruitovl kosiacrgl niiurs walf tal ldpjnylr lstcmjosals c wnr`ofg
lfvornfdlft tact acs mllf dckl sn kobboiujt tact tal ldpjnyll os bnrilk oftn vnjuftcry rlsogfctonf
..Urnnb
nb
infstruitovl kosiacrgl knls fnt rlquorl prnnb nb oftlft, mut wojj rlquorl tal pjcoftobb tn prnvl dnrl tacf oflqucjoty of
pnjoiols. [al pjcoftobb dust lstcmjosa tal prlslfil nb infkotonfs sn oftnjlrcmjl talrl wcs fn ntalr ianoil tacf tn
rlsogf."3? Lcia kcy tact [ jotogctl taos icsl,
O'd
rldofklk nb wact [ cfk ntalrs wan jnn` jo`l dl, ack tn gn tarnuga
ct Wojjocd Dnrros.
Dy indplfsctnry kcdcgls sanujk ml cfywalrl mltwllf
$=
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
115/152
tlstodnfy mlbnrl ot, tal ckkotonf nb flw rldlkocj rljolb tn [otjl ROO wcs c irotoicj indpnflft nb kltlrrofg buturl
wrnfgbuj infkuit cfk lfinurcgofg ''provctl lfbnrildlft" nbtalstctutl.
=9
\frlbutlk aostnroicj lvoklfil waoia kldnfstrctls Wojjocd Dnrros'
33
[AL U]LYOKLF[8 O taof` cs jnfg cs taly'rl plcilbuj, O taof` taly'rl flilsscry.
Walf
taly tud vonjlft,
talf taly'rl inuftlrprnkuitovl. Mut -
S Mut wl icf ckdot tact tal vcst dchnroty nb talsl-
[AL U]LYOKLF[8 Cmsnjutljy.
S -
crc fnfvonjlft.
[AL
U]LYOKLF[8 Cmsnjutljy. Cfk tact's way O ack tald Of tal
Nvcj
Nbboil, sndl nb talsl bnj`s wan'vl
mllf nrglfozofg talsl prntlsts. Mlicusl tal njk
ckcgl,
pnwlr infilkls fntaofg wotanut c bogat - O taof`
tact's trul. Mut wact's cjsn trul os tact c inuftry's infsiolfil sndltodls acs tn ml trogglrlk my sndl
ofinfvlfolfil, mlicusl O taof` c jnt nb plnpjl
wan
scw
tal
Lroi Gcdlr vokln
crl
trnumjlk, lvlf ob taly
acvlf3
ack tact scdl lxplrolfil taldsljvls. Lvlf ob tacy'rl fnt Cbroicf Cdlroicf nr Jctofn.
O taof` talrl
crl
c jnt
nb gnnk,
wljj-dlcfofg plnpjl - O taof` talrl crl prnmcmjy c jnt nb pnjoil nbboilrs wan
dogat acvl jnn`lk ct tact cfk scok, tact
os
c trcglky wact
acpplflk, cfk
wl'vl gnt tn bogurl
nut
anw tn
mrofg
cf
lfk tn talsl `ofks nb trcglkols. Mut
talf
cttlftonf spcfs dnvl nf. [alrl's tal flxt taofg. [alrl's
sndl oftldctonfcj irosos. [alrl's sndltaofg tact
acpplfs alrl,
cfk iacfgl knlsf't rlcjjy niiur.
Cfk
tal vcjul nb plcilbuj prntlsts, citovosd, nrgcfozofg os ot rldofks tal sniolty taos os fnt ylt knfl. Cfk
pcrt nb
wact
O scok
walf
wl infvlflk c dlltofg
nf
Dnfkcy alrl ct tal Waotl Anusl wcs fnt nfjy tact O
wcs cffnufiofg c tcs` bnril tact acs tn rlpnrt of ?5 kcys wota splioboi, infirltl stlps crnufk trcofofg,
crnufk
anw wl crl lquoppofg pnjjll, anw wl'rl anjkofg pnjoil nbboilrs dnrl ciinuftcmjl, fnt nfjy
wlrl
wl
gnofg tn put dnrl bufkofg oftn sndl nb tal trcofofg cfk tliafnjngy tact icf prlvlft talsl taofgs brnd
acpplfofg, mut O'd gnofg tn stcy nf taos. Cfk fnt nfjy
cd
O gnofg tn stcy nf ot0 my vortul nb taos stcyofg of
tal flws mlicusl nb sndl nb talsc prntlsts, anplbujjy tal lftorl sniolty scys jlt's bofcjjy try tn dc`l sndl
rlcj prngrlss nf taos.
S Cfk prngrlss dlcfs kobblrlft taofgs tn kobblrlft plnpjl. Yn talrl crl tansl tact wcft mnky icdlrcs.
[alrl crl tansl wan wcft iovojocf rlvolw mncrks.
Cfk
duia nb taos os fnt c blklrcj dcfkctl.
[AL
U]LYOKLF[8 Dnst nb ot os fnt blklrcj, mut tal blklrcj gnvlrfdlft icf acvl cf ofbjulfil. Wl bufk c
jnt nb Huroskoitonfs cjj cirnss tal inuftry. Cfk ob
wl
icf oklftoby mlst prcitoils, talf bnr us tn ml cmjl tn
scy, ynu
fllk
tn cknpt talsl mlsj prcitoils, cfk Ob ynu knf't, talf plracps sndl nb tal bufkofg tact's
cvcojcmjl crnufk sndl taofgs tacO jcw lfbnrildlft icrls cmnut mlindl jlss cvcojcmjl. Wl'rl gnofg tn
prnvokl dnrl
35
bnj`s
wan crl
knofg tal rogat taofg cfk wl'rl gnofg tn
ml
ofvlstogctofg bnj`s
wan
crl fnt
knofg tal rogat taofg. O taof` tact mlindls
cf
odpnrtcft pcrt nb tal jlvlrcgl tact wl icf lxlrt.
S Cfk knls tact
acpplf
tarnuga blklrcj jlgosjctonf, Nb knls tact
acpplf
tarnuga utojozofg tal KNH cs c
wl scw Lroi Anjklr of Ijlvljcfk ylstlrkcy,
cfk
tal kliosonf, tal suplrvosonf cgrlldlft O taof` wcs c gnnk
nfl
tact scok tn tal ioty nb Ijcvljcfk, alrl's wact ynu'jol mllf knofg wrnfg, systldoicjjy. cfk fnw wl'rl
gnofg
tn
anjk
ynu ciinuftcmjl. Os tact
gnofg
tn mlindl tal
rujl,
Nb knls talrl ujtodctljy acojY
tn
ml blklrcj
attp8//www.mlt.ind/flws/fctonfcjO=53;33=33=3trcfsiropt-mlt-s-lxijusovl-oftlrvolF-wota-prlsoklft-nmcdc.atdO
Hcy X
cfk
Mlynfil8 C _lcr f
]lvolw
=53; acs mllf
c
augl
ylcr bnr dusoi's
borst
inupjl.
303/j5fNO;
Nut cfk Cmnut8 ]oacffc ]ni`s
tal Kocdnfk Mcjj
Ujus,
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
140/152
3=3393=53; [rcfsiropt
ML['s
Lxijusovl
Oftlrvolw Wota Urlsoklft
Nmcdc
OFlws OML[
pnjoiy>
[AL U]LYOKLF[8 Jlt's jnn` ct wact tal tcs` bnril glflrctls. O dlcf, O acvl infboklfil - wl'vl gnt c
pnjoil Iaolb, wl'vl gnt c irodofnjngost, wl'vl gnt iovoj rogats jlcklrs, wl'vl gnt citovosts cs pcrt nb taos tcs`
bnril prnilss. Jlt's sll tal spliobois tact taly glflrctl.
Mut O wojj tljj ynu tact tal Klpcrtdlft nb Husto il cjrlcky acs cutanroty.
Yn
Of tal Lroi Gcdlr icsl, Lroi
Anjklr, O taof` prnplrjy, scok wl'rl gnofg tn Ofotoctl c iovoj rogats ofRlstogctonf. [al Ijlvljcfk icsl ynu hust
dlftonflk. Wl cjrlcky acvl tal cmojoty tn tc`l c jnn`.
Fnw, tal stcfkcrks ct tal blklrcj jlvlj crl aogalr, cfk talrl crl sn d fy jnicj dufoiopcjotols, jnicj pnjoil
klpcrtdlfts tact knofg ot ct tal jnicjjlvlo, knofg ot ct tal stctl jlvlj os gnofg tn mc c jnt dnrl lbblitovl,
mlilusl tn mrofg blklrcj icsls, ot' s c aoga mcr. Ot's gnt tn ml fnt
hust
sndltaofg tact acpplflk
wjalrl
talrl's
sndl qulstonfs0 talrl's gnt tn ml c slfsl tact dcymc hustoil acs fnt mllf slrvlk my tal lxostofg prnilss
ct
tal stctl cfk jnicj jlvljs.
Mut O taof` tact lvlrymnky sanujk bllj infboklft tact taos Hustoil Klpcrtdlft os tc`ofg taos vlry slronusjy,
acs tc`lf ot vlry slronusjy. Wact O'k jo`l tn kn, tanuga,
os
tn iacfgl wact acpplfs nf tal grnufk, mlicusl
tact's gnofg tn ml dnrl jcstofg. Cfk O'jj hust govl ynu c inupjl lxcdpjls.
Walf O wcs of tal stctl jlgosjcturl Of Ojjofnos, wl ack prnmjlds wota rciocj prnbojofg walf ot icdl tn trcbboi
stnps, cfk wl ack prnmjlds rlplctckjy wota infblssonfs of irodls tact jctlr nf talrl wlrl sugglstonfs
dcyml taly ack mllf inlrilk.
Yn
twn
nb
tal taofgs O'd dnst prnuk
nb
wcs pcssofg c jcw rlquorofg
voklntcpofg nb oftlrrngctonfs sn tact - dy crgudlft wcs taos prntlitlk tal pnjoil cs wljj cs tal ciiuslk
mlicusl talrl's fnt gnofg tn ml cfy qulstonf. Ob taly infblsslk, ot's cjj talrl nf tcpl. Ob taly kokf't, talf
tal sugglstonf tact taly kok os fnt gnofg
tn
dc`l slfsl lotalr.
Nf rciocj prnbojofg, ot wcs c sodpjl dcttlr nb hus t `llpofg kctc. _nu acvl tn rlinrk Wan
ot
os tact ynu'rl
stnppofg. [al dofutl sndlmnky `fnws taly'rl mlofg wctialk, sndlmnky os jnn`ofg nvlr talor sanujklr,
talf taly'rl c jojjol dnrl oftlftonfcj
cmN\3
os taos c jlgotodctl stnp> Os taos c stnp tact O'd dc`ofg mlicusl
sndlmnky os rlcjjy mrlc`ofg tal jcw, nr mlicusl O
hust
knf't jo`l tal jnn`s nb tal plrsnf wjan s krovofg
tarnuga taos flogamnrannk>
Cfk wact wl scw wcs fnt nfjy c rlkuitonf of tal kospcroty nf trcbboi stnps, mut dy crgudlft, cgcof, tn
tal pnjoil klpcrtdlft wcs, taos wojj dc`l ynu c dnrl lbblitoRl pnjoil bnril, mlicusl ofstcck nb wcstofg ynur
todl wota bnj`s
wjan
sanujkf't ml stnpplk ynu icf bnius
nf
tal bnj`s
wjan
sanujk ml stnpplk.
Cfk nfl nb tal taofgs talt O wcft us tn dc`l surl wc ufklrstcfk os tact, inddufotols
nb
injnr fllk gnnk
jcwlfbnrildlft. O dlcf, talrl's c jnt nb irodl, cfk nfl nb tal taofgs tact wl tcj`lk cmnut nf Dnfkcy alrl
wcs ynu 'vl gnt ynufg plnpjl wan lfk up glttofg icugat mltwllf pnjoil tact taly knf't trust cfk bnj`s nf tal
strllts Rjan crl tryofg tn rnuga tald up. Cfk taly sanujk acvl infboklfil tact tal pnjoil crl nf talor sokl.
Cfk ob taly acvl tact infboklfil talf tal pnjoil crl gnofg tn acvl cf lcsolr todl knofg talor hnm, cfk taly'rl
dnrl jo`ljy tn indl andl scbl.
Cfk wjalf taly knf't acvl tact infboklfil - cfk wl'rl sllofg tact wota ynufg plnpjl cjj nvlr tal
inuftry.
[AL U]LYOKLF[8 ]ogat.
[alrl lrl c jnt nb plnpjl tact Of dcfy icsls knf't taOf` tact ynu'vl mllf cggrlssovl lfnuga of tcj`ofg
cmnut tal fudmlrs
nb
Cbroicf Cdlroicf dlf tact crl nvlrwaljdofgjy sant vlrsus wjaotl. Crl talrl lvlr
todls
wjalf
tal rlspnfsomojotols cfk nmjogctonfs
nb
Urlsoklft glt of tal wcy nb anw ynu wcft
tn
rlspnfk cs c
audcf>
[AL U]LYOKLF[8 Wljj, sndltodls plnpjl's infilds crl fnt mcslk nf bcit, mlicusl Ob ynu jnn` ct
cbtlr wjact acpplflk wota Doiaclj Mrnwf,
Ob
ynu jnn`lk ct wact acpplflk cbtlr [rcyvnf,
ob
ynu jnn`lk ct tal
kliosonf cbtlr Lroi Gcdlr, O'd mlofg prltty lxpjoiot cmnut
dy
infild, cfk mlofg prltty lxpjoiot cmnut tal bcit
tact taos os c systldoi prnmjld, tact mjci` bnj`s cfk Jctofns cfk ntalrs crl fnt hust dc`ofg taos up. O
klsiroml ot of vlry plrsnfcj tlrds.
O taof` wact sndltodls plnpjl crl brustrltlk my os dl fnt sodpjy scyofg, taos os wjact tal nutindl
sanujk acvl mllf. Cfk tact O icffnt kn, ofstotutonfcjjy.
Ot
os dy Hustoil Klpcrtdlft tact os ofvlstogctofg
talsl icsls. Cfk pcrt nb tal rujl
nb
jcw os tact O'd fnt puttofg dy bofglrs,
dy
taudm nf tal sictl
nb
hustoil. Cfk ot inujk indprndosl ofvlstogctonfs ob
Ot
cpplcrlk tact O wcs tryofg tn stllr tn c pcrtoiujcr
nutindl.
Yn O'd surl tact talrl's sndl bnj`s wjan hust wcft dl tn scy, of suia-cfk-suia c icsl, taos
Os
wjact O taof`
sanujk acvl acpplflk, cfk ob O ack mllf nf c grcfk hury t aos os
wjact
O wnujk acvl scok, cfk
sn
bnrta cfk
sn
nf. O'jj jlcvl ot
tn
plnpjl
tn
spliujctl
nf
wjactj'd scyofg tn dyslj b nr Doialjjl walf wlrl cjnfl ct fogat.
attp8//www.mct.ind/flws/fctonfcjO=53;33=33=3trcfsiropt-mlt-s-lxiousovl-oftlrvolw-wojjj-prlsoklft-nmcdc.atd 9
Icsl 3;-;9=1, Kniudlft =
-
8/10/2019 Washington v. William Morris Endeavor Entertainment LLC et al. (14-4328-CV) -- Appellant's Reply to Ex. Motion for Extraordinary Relief from the Second Circu
141/152
3=3393=53; [rcfsiropt8 ML['s Lxijusovl Oftlrvolw Wota Urlsoklft Nmcdc OFlws OML[
Mut
wact O icf
scy os
tact taos inuftry os ct
ots
mlst walf lvlrymnky
os
mlofg trlctlk bcorjy. Wl acvl c
aostnry cfk c jlgciy nb plnpjl fnt mlofg trlctlk bcorjy of cjj `ofks nb wcj`s nb jobl. Ot os pcrtoiujcrjy odpnrtcft
bnr plnpjl tn bllj
jo`l
taly'rl mlofg trlctlk bcorjy my jcw lfbnrildlft cfk pnjoil, mlicusl tal infslqulfils
walf taly'rl fnt trlctlk bcorjy icf ml klckjy.
Cfk O'vl scok ot mlbnrl8
[al vcst
dchnroty nb jcw lfbnrildlft nbboilrs crl knofg c rlcjjy tnuga hnm, cfk dnst
nb tald crl knofg ot wljj cfk crl tryofg
tn
kn tal rtgat taofg. Mut c indmofctonf nb mck trcofofg, Of sndl
icsls0 c indmofctonf of sndl
icsls
nb klpcrtdlfts
tact
rlcjjy crl fnt tryofg
tn
rnnt nut mocsls,
nr
tnjlrctl
sjnppy pnjoil wnr`0 c indmofctonf Of
sndl
icsls
nb
bnj`s hust fnt
`fn'nFofg
cfy mlttlr, cfk of c jnt nb icsls,
suminfsionus blcr nb bnj`s wan jnn` kobblrlft - 133 nb taos inftromutls tn c fctonfcj prnmjld tact's gnofg tn
rlquorl c fctonfcj snjutonf.
Cfk walf O tnjk tal ynufg plnpjl wan O dlt wota - cfk wl'rl gnofg tn acvl dnrl infvlrsctonfs jo`l taos
nvlr tal indofg dnftas - os taos osf't gnofg tn ml snjvlk nvldjgat. [aos os sndltaofg tact os kllpjy rnntlk
of nur sniolty0 ot's kllpoy rnntlk Of nur aostnry. Mut tal
twn taofgs tact crl gnofg tn cjjnw us
tn
snjvl Ot
fudmlr nfl os tal ufklrstcfkofg tact wl acvl dckl prngrlss. Cfk sn ot's odpnrtcft tn rlingfozl, cs pcofbuj
cs
talsl
ofioklfts crl,
wl
icf't lquctl wact os acpplfofg fnw tn wact wcs acpplfofg
[AL U]LYOKLF[8 O wcft dy iaojkrlf tn ml sllf cs tal ofkovokucjs tact taly crl, cfk O wcft tald tn ml
hukglk mcslk nf tal inftlft nb talor ialrcitlr lfk talor mlacvonr cfk talor tljlfts cfk talor gobts. O knf'
wcft tald tn ml nmhlits
nb
blcr
sodpjy
mlicusl
nb
dosguoklk cttotukls.
Ucrt nb wact O taof` os
sn
alcrtmrlc`ofg cfk brustrctofg
bnr
c jnt nb bnj`s walf taly wctia taos Os tal
rlingfotonf tact
sodpjy
my vortul
nb
injnr
ynu'vl
gnt jlss dcrgof
bnr
lrrnr. Cfk tact's pcrtoiujcrjy trul
bnr
mjci` mnys. _nufg dlf, tllfcgl mnys - sndltodls taly'rl gnofg tn kn stupok stubb. [act's trul waltalr
taly'rl waotl, mjci`, Aospcfoi. Ot knlsfj dcttlr. _nu kok stupok stubb. O kok stupok stubb. Dnst nb tal todl
ot's acrdjlss. Yndltodls Ot's icrljlss. Cfk talf
wl
grnw lfk wl prngrlss, cfk
wl
mlindl, anplbujjy,
snjok iotozlfs cfk dlf wan crl inftromutofg tn nur sniolty. Cfk sn ot's fnt sodpjy tact wl wlft tn dl`l surl
tact tal plrblit ynufg dcf os trlctlk n`cy. Wl cjsn wcft c mny wan's c mny, nr c ynufg dcf wan dcyml Os
c jo\jl infbuslk, dcyml dc`ls c dostc`l - wl wcft tald tn ml govlf tal scdl mlflbot nb tal knumt cs cfy
ntalr
dcf wnujk, nr cfy ntalr mny wnujk
ml
govlf.
Cfk tact O taof` os gnofg tn ml tal tlst nb waltalr nr fnt nur sniolty cfk nur jcw lfbnrildlft cfk nur
siannjs crl nplrctofg tal wcy taly sanujk ml.
Mlicusl
taos knlsf' hust mlgof nf tal strllts.
Wl'vl
mllf
wnr`ofg 'nFota tal Klpcrtdlft nb Lkuictonf nf tal bcit tact ynu'vl gnt mjci` `ofklrgcrtflrs mlofg `oi`lk nut
nb siann j ct sogfoboicftj y aogalr rctls. Fnw, talrl's nfjy sn duia acrd c bnur-
nr
bovl-ylcr-njk icf ml
knofg. My fcturl, taly crl kosruptovl. Cfk
ob
wl'rl cjrlcky dc`ofg hukgdlfts ct tact lcrjy cgl of c siannj
systld
talf wact icf wl
lxplit
walf tansl `oks glt njklr>
S Cfk taly'rl nf tal strllt.
[AL
U]LYOKLF[8 Cfk
taly'rl nf tal strllt.
Cfk
tact's tact cttotukl, tal dofkslt tact
wl'vl
gnt
tn
iacfgl.
Cfk cs O scok mlbnrl, O taof` Ot os iacfgofg. [al gnnk flws os, os tact walf ynu jnn` ct wan talsl
prntlstlrs crl, taly'rl fnt ljj mjci`. _nu'vl gnt - walf ynu tcj`
tn
tal waotl brolfks nb ynur kcugatlr nr dy
kcugatlr,
taly'vl
gnt c mlttlr cttotukl cfk c ijlcrlr dofkslt cfk c grlctlr ldpctay bnr wact's gnofg nf. Cfk
O taof` lcia
suiilssovl
glflrctonf, cs
ot
glts dnrl ufklrstcfkofg, dnrl bcdojocroty, dnrl indbnrt 'nFota
plnpjl nb ntalr rcils cfk ntalr iujturls, talf sndl nb taos kossopctls.
Mut wl icf't Hust wcot
bnr
tact prnilss tn acpplf nf ots nwf.
Ot
cjsn rlquorls pnjoiy iacfgls. Ot rlquorls
trcofofg.
Ot
rlquorls splioboi stlps my pnjoil klpcrtdlfts, stlrtofg brnd tal tnp, of nrklr tn ia