downloaded from osteoporosis self-assessment tool (ost) [& osta for asians] a simple clinical...
TRANSCRIPT
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Osteoporosis Self-assessment Tool (OST)
[& OSTA for Asians]
A simple clinical tool to identify women with osteoporosis
Professor J-Y Reginster
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Background
• Cost and availability limit access to bone mineral density (BMD) in some communities
• A simple risk assessment tool could:– target BMD to high-risk women– reduce the need for BMD measurements
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Osteoporosis Self-assessment Tool for
Asians (OSTA)
Adapted from:
L. Koh, et al. A simple tool to identify Asian women at increased
risk of osteoporosis.
Osteoporos Int 12:699-705, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Objective
• Develop and assess a simple tool for predicting osteoporosis (femoral neck BMD T < -2.5) in postmenopausal Asian women, using risk factors obtained by questionnaire
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
InvestigatorsThe Osteoporosis Self-assessment Tool for Asia (OSTA) Research
Group
China : Huang Qi Ren, Zhang Wei Bin, Huang Gong Yi, Lou Si Quan, Luo Xian Zheng, Liu Gui Lin
South Korea : In-Kwon Han, Ki-Hyun Park, Moo-Il Kang, Hyong-Moo Park, Hyoung-Woo Lee
Taiwan : Chun S Shih, Li H Chen, Keh-Sung Tsai, Yang Bor-Yau
Hong Kong : Annie Kung
Philippines : Tito P Torralba
Thailand : Rajata Rajatanavin
Malaysia : Siew-Pheng Chan
Singapore : Siok Bee Chionh, Tang Ching Lau, Paul Ho, Leonard Koh
Belgium (WHO) : Jean-Yves Reginster, Wafa Ben Sedrine
Japan (validation sample) : Saeko Fujiwara
USA (MSD) : Philip Ross, Larry Radican
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Method
• Community-dwelling postmenopausal women– 21 clinics in 8 Asian countries– Consecutive subjects– Routine check-up or follow-up of medical
conditions– 860 subjects completed questionnaires– Study was performed under the auspices of
the World Health Organization (WHO)
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Recruitment Criteria
• Inclusion– Postmenopausal– Any race except Caucasian– Hip anatomy suitable for BMD– Willingness and ability to participate
• Exclusion– History/evidence of metabolic bone disease– Presence of cancer with known metastasis to bone– Evidence of significant renal impairment– One or both ovaries removed– Both hips previously fractured or replaced– History of bisphosphonate, fluoride or calcitonin use
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Risk Factors Assessed in Questionnaire
• Ethnicity• Weight • Height (present/past)• Physical activity• Sunlight exposure• Smoking• Dairy / soybean intake• Reproductive history
• Physical disability
• Rheumatoid arthritis
• Fracture history
• Family history of fracture
• Calcium supplements
• Postmenopausal estrogen
• Thyroid medication
• Corticosteroids
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Results: Study Population
• DemographicsChinese: 59% Korean: 18% Thai: 11%Filipino: 9% Other: 4%
• Age (years) 62 (6)
• Weight (kg) 57 (9)
• Height (cm) 154 (6)
• Femoral neck BMD (g/cm2) 0.71 (0.14)– 14% of women had T-scores < -2.5
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Multivariate Analysis• Multivariable model - “best fit”
– 11 variables:• age• weight • estrogen• thyroid medication• any fracture since 45• prior spine fracture• Chinese• Thai• 3 countries (Malaysia, Hong Kong, Taiwan)
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Simple Model (2 variables)Performs Well
11 Variables Age & weight
AUC 0.85 0.79
Sensitivity 95% 91%
Specificity 47% 45%
Koh L, et al. Osteoporos Int 12:699-705, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Calculation
Model with only 2 variables
(Weight - Age) x 0.2, drop decimal
example: Weight 59 kg, Age 72 yr
(59-72) x 0.2 = -2
Koh L, et al. Osteoporos Int 12:699-705, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Risk Stratification
Risk level
Low
Medium
High
% of all women
40%
52%
8%
% with osteoporosis
3%
15%
61%
Koh L, et al. Osteoporos Int 12:699-705, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation - JAPAN
• Adult Health Study, Hiroshima – Postmenopausal women in existing cohort– Ages 50 and older– N = 1123
• Sensitivity = 98%, specificity = 29%
Fujiwara S, et al. Curr Ther Res 62(8): 586-94, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation (Japan)
Risk level
Low
Medium
High
% of all women
40%
52%
8%
% with osteo-porosis
3%
15%
61%
% with osteo-porosis
1%
10%
44%
% of all women
25%
50%
25%
Development(Asian)
Fujiwara S, et al. Curr Ther Res 62(8): 586-94, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
45-49
50-54
55-59
60-64
65-69
70-74
75-79
80-84
85-89
90-94
40-44
95-99
45-49 50-54 55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 85-89 90-9440-44
Osteoporosis Self-assessment Tool for Asia (OSTA)Weight (kg)
Age(yr)
LOW RISK
HIGH RISKmeasure BMD & treat
AT RISKmeasure BMD
History of prior non-violent fracture: consider BMD measurement and treatment
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation - KOREA
• Postmenopausal women– Ages > 55 – N = 1101
• Sensitivity = 87%, specificity = 67%
Ben Sedrine W, et al. Arth Rheum 44(9 Suppl):S260, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation (KOREA)
Risk level
Low
Medium
High
% of all women
40%
52%
8%
% with osteo-porosis
3%
15%
61%
% with osteo-porosis
2%
18%
64%
% of all women
61%
33%
5%
Development(Asian)
Fujiwara S, et al. Curr Ther Res 62(8): 586-94, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation - SINGAPORE
• 125 Postmenopausal women– Mean 60 ± 7.5 yr (range 50 - 89 yr)– Sensitivity = 94%, specificity = 64%– AUC = 0.83
• 98 Men– Mean 61 ± 8.8 yr (range 50 - 88 yr)– Sensitivity = 50%, specificity = 78%– AUC = 0.71
Koh L, et al. J Bone Miner Res 16(Suppl 1):S394 & S396, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
WOMEN
Risk level
Low
Medium
High
% of all men
72%
24%
4%
% with osteo-porosis
13%
26%
75%
% with osteo-porosis
2%
24%
80%
% of all women
53%
43%
4%
MEN
Koh L, et al. J Bone Miner Res 16(Suppl 1):S394 & S396, 2001.
RESULTS - SINGAPORE
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation (SINGAPORE)
Risk level
Low
Medium
High
% with osteo-porosis
13%
26%
75%
% of all men
72%
24%
4%
Koh L, et al. J Bone Miner Res 16(Suppl 1):S394 & S396, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation - CHINA
• 973 Postmenopausal women – Clinic in Shanghai
• 91 women (9%) had osteoporosis– 557 (57%) had osteopenia
• Sensitivity = 92%, specificity = 54%– AUC = 0.84
Ben Sedrine W, et al. Arth Rheum 44(9 Suppl):S258, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation (China)
Risk level
Low
Medium
High
% of all women
40%
52%
8%
% with osteo-porosis
3%
15%
61%
% with osteo-porosis
1%
13%
42%
% of all women
50%
43%
7%
Development(Asian)
Ben Sedrine W, et al. Arth Rheum 44(9 Suppl):S258, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Summary - OSTA• Age and weight alone performed well for
identifying osteoporosis– Consistent results among countries
• Including more variables did not substantially improve performance
• Using 3 categories may help to identify the highest and lowest risk groups– BMD measurements are probably unnecessary
in a substantial proportion of low risk women
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Osteoporosis Self-assessment Tool (OST)
Performance in Caucasians
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation - Caucasians
• Original “SCORE” population – Postmenopausal women in the US– Ages > 45 (mean = 61 yr)– N = 1102
• Sensitivity = 88%, specificity = 52%
• Adding other risk factors did not improve performance
Siris et al, J Bone Miner Res 16(Suppl 1):S341, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
Validation - Caucasians
• Screening for Fracture Intervention Trial – Postmenopausal women in the US– Mean age 68 yr (SD = 6)– N = 23,833
• Sensitivity = 95%, specificity = 34%
• Adding other risk factors did not improve performance
Hochberg et al, J Bone Miner Res 16(Suppl 1):S277, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
SCORE population
Risk level
Low (>1)
Medium
High (<-3)
% of all women
24%
67%
8%
% with osteo-porosis
4%
23%
57%
% with osteo-porosis
4%
18%
58%
% of all women
46%
48%
6%
FIT screenpopulation
Hochberg et al, J Bone Miner Res 16(Suppl 1):S277, 2001.Siris et al, J Bone Miner Res 16(Suppl 1):S341, 2001.
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
45-49
50-54
55-59
60-64
65-69
70-74
75-79
80-84
85-89
90-94
40-44
95-99
55-59 60-64 65-69 70-74 75-79 80-84 85-89 90-94 95-99 >9950-54
Osteoporosis Self-assessment Tool (OST)Weight (kg)
Age(yr)
LOW RISK
AT RISKmeasure BMD
HIGH RISKmeasure BMD & treat
History of prior non-violent fracture: consider BMD measurement and treatment
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
OST - CaucasiansSimple Rules
Risk Level Age minus weight*
High > 20
Medium -9 to 19
Low < -9
*Age in yr minus weight in kg
Downloaded from www.fosavance.ae
SUMMARY• Both OST and OSTA performed well
– Consistent results in different samples
• Using 3 categories may help to identify the highest and lowest risk groups– BMD measurements are probably unnecessary
in a substantial proportion of low risk women
• Category cut-points were slightly different in Caucasian versus Asian women