PUZZLE OF A DOWNFALL CHILD 1970lecinemadreams.blogspot.com/2013/02/puzzle-of-downfall-child-1970.html

I've a feeling an individual can easily gauge what his or her overall response to this film is likely to be simply basedupon how one reacts to its title. If Puzzle of a Downfall Child strikes you as a potentially profound, enigmaticallypoetic title conjuring up images of Paradise Lost and existential disillusion, you’re likely to fall in love with this long-considered-lost exemplar of European-influenced, '70s “personal statement” cinema. On the other hand, if the titlereeks of self-serious pretentiousness and needlessly arty ambiguity…well, little about the film itself is likely to alterthat perception.

Me, I fall a little into both camps. For one, I've always been crazy about the title. Perhaps that's because I was 13years-old when the movie came out and the title sounded just gloomily cryptic enough to appeal to my adolescenttaste for high-flown self-dramatization. (In an interview, director Jerry Schatzberg has stated that the title alludes to aplot element involving an abortion that was deleted in an early draft of the screenplay.) I adore Puzzle of a DownfallChild for its introspective examination of the elusiveness of happiness and the human desire to connect in the faceof reality-distorting conceptions of image, sexuality, self-worth, and success. In the telling, few of the film’s insightsare very acute, but there’s a psychological authenticity to the screenplay and performances which significantlymitigate the sometimes arthouse excesses of the film’s visual style.

Which leads to camp #2. As much as I love Puzzle of a Downfall Child and believe it to be both a beautiful andmoving film, I’m the first to admit that at times it can feel like a parody of a '70s art film. The debut effort ofphotographer turned-director Jerry Schatzberg, Puzzle of a Downfall Child falls prey to the minor sin of over-determined significance. There’s a kind of naïve foolhardiness to be found in acts of absolute sincerity, and if Puzzle

1/9

of a Downfall Child suffers from anything, it’s from a heartfelt conviction it is saying something “important” about thehuman condition. To some, such ponderousness can come off as pretentious, humorless, or just plain exasperating.But me, I’ll take a self-serious film that tries to be about something over today’s cynical, eye-on-the-boxoffice,market-research product any day.

Faye Dunaway as Lou Andreas Sand

Barry Primus as Aaron Reinhardt

Viveca Lindfors as Pauline Galba

2/9

Roy Scheider as Mark

Faye Dunaway plays Lou Andreas Sand (nee Emily Mercine), an emotionally fragile former high-fashion model whohas retreated to a solitary beach house on Fire Island following a crippling nervous breakdown. Visited by long-timephotographer friend and former lover Aaron Reinhardt (Barry Primus), Lou recounts her troubled life in a tapedconversation Reinhardt hopes to fashion into a film. With her life revealed in flashbacks that come at us in stylizedand realistic non-linear stretches devoid of obvious hints as to their veracity as memory, fantasy or both; Lou revealsherself to be the most unreliable of narrators. Yet the tone of these mental images, playing out like scrapbook pagestorn from an album and reassembled, expose the truth of the woman, if not always the truth of the eventsthemselves. It's a fascinating narrative path made all the more so due to Puzzle of a Downfall Child being a filmcontructed in much the same manner. That the movie creates for us a sense that we are watching just the sort offilm Primus' character is likely to constrcut from his talks with Lous is just one more piece of Puzzle of a DownfallChild 's continually self-referential puzzle.

Two magazine covers photographed by Jerry SchatzbergLeft: Anne St.Marie -1956 / Right: Faye Dunaway - 1968

Director Jerry Schatzberg, who had worked for more than 20 years as a photographer for magazines like Vogue,Esquire, and McCall's, based Puzzle of a Downfall Child on taped interviews he conducted with one of his favoritesubjects, 1950s supermodel Anne St. Marie. St.Marie, like her film counterpart, retired from modeling after sufferinga nervous breakdown. To further the whole wormhole effect of this enterprise, Schatzberg, who was rumored tohave had an affair with St. Marie (as does his screen doppelganger, photographer Aaron Reinhardt with Dunaway'sLou Andreas Sand) in real life photographed Dunaway for many fashion magazines, and for a time the two wereengaged to be married. Their relationship had already dissolved before Puzzle of a Downfall Child went before the

3/9

cameras.

"If one can't keep some friends somewhere, then something is really wrong."

WHAT I LOVE ABOUT THIS FILMI think perhaps my favorite thing about Puzzle of a Downfall Child is that it combines two of my favorite film genres:the '70s trying-to-find-oneself character drama and the '40s suffering-in-mink women’s weepie. How perfect is that?When I first saw this film, Faye Dunaway’s too-sensitive-for-this-world fashion model was an oasis of estrogen ennuiin the testosterone-leaden desert of male-centric '70s films romanticizing male identity crises and masculineexistential moments-of-reckoning. To my taste, there was a decided oversupply of movies featuring the likes of JackNicholson, George Segal, Richard Benjamin, or Elliot Gould grappling with the meaning of life, while anuncomprehending female (usually a sweet-natured dumbbell, and almost always played by Karen Black) stoodaround on the sidelines. Aside from the vastly inferior (by comparison) Jacqueline Bisset drama, The Grasshopper(1969), Puzzle of a Downfall Child was one of the few films from this era to grant a female character an equivalentnavel-gazing opportunity.

To update Easy Rider's famous tagline, Puzzle of a Downfall Child could havebeen subtitled: "A woman went looking for America and couldn't find it

anywhere."

To its credit, Puzzle of a Downfall Child tries to find the common thread of humanity in the privileged-class despair ofLou Andreas Sand. And as embodied by Dunaway and captured by Schatzberg’s loving camera lens (actuallycinematographer Alex Holender of Midnight Cowboy), Lou may never look less than exquisite (even when in thethroes of a foaming-at-the-mouth nervous breakdown), but her pain is recognizable and real.

Have you ever seen an old detective movie or TV show and marveled at the perversity of cops and reporters at a

4/9

murder scene going on and on about how beautiful or desirable a female corpse was? I can't count the number offilms I've seen where men stand over a dead woman's body lamenting the "waste" of a beautiful woman and howparticularly tragic it is that said woman, so pretty or sexy in life, is now dead. It’s like there’s this overriding mentalitythat a woman’s looks and physical appeal matter even in death. Or worse, that one can be too beautiful to die...as ifthe loss of life is sad, but the tragedy is compounded if the corpse is attractive.

Beauty: Fetishism and Objectification

Puzzle of a Downfall Child sensitively addresses the high value we, as a culture, place on beauty, and the priceenacted on those who fall prey to it. In placing this character drama in the appearance-fixated world of fashionphotography, Schatzberg and screenwriter Carole Eastman take an insightful look at a woman whose entireexistence and sense of self-worth is tethered to her beauty. Whose need to please and always be seen as desirableunder the male gaze is both a desperate, deep-seated search for approval and a profound denial of self. The film'sdifinitive narrative thread calls attention to the pervasiveness of male exploitation and the vulnerability/susceptabilityof the female form.

Distorted ImageTroubled Catholic School girl Emily Mercine attempts to lose herself by adopting

a pretentious name (perhaps borrowed from Nietzschean psychoanalyst LouAndreas Salome) and engaging in casual sex with father-figure strangers. Like acharacter out of Damon Runyon, Lou Andreas Sand speaks in a mannered style

totally devoid of contractions, and compulsively re-imagines events of the past inorder to protect her fragile image of herself.

PERFORMANCESFaye Dunaway’s participation was instrumental in getting Puzzle of a Downfall Child to the screen, and her passionfor the project is evident in every frame. And it’s a good thing too, because to the best of my recollection there isn't asingle scene in which she does not appear. Mind you, I'm not complaining, for in much the manner that Liza

5/9

Minnelli's is so good in Cabaret that she makes you forget “Liza Minnelli: The Home Shopping Network Years”; FayeDunaway so thoroughly blows me away in Puzzle of a Downfall Child that I'm reminded of everything her careerpromised before the whole Mommie Dearest / voicemail meltdown thing. One of my favorite but most problematicactresses (you have to have a taste for her mannerisms), Dunaway has every reason to be very proud of her work inthis. After Bonnie & Clyde, Puzzle of a Downfall Child ranks as my all-time favorite Dunaway film. She isphenomenal in it.

THE STUFF OF FANTASYI tell everyone, even if you don't have the patience for the entire film, just watch the first 15 minutes. Thesequence chronicling Dunaway as a fledgling model navigating the battlefield of her first fashion shoot is cinemagold. Shot with an eye for detail only possible from knowing this world very well, Schatzberg peels back the illusionswe hold in our America's Next Top Model preoccupation the fashion industry and reveals the dehumanizing reality.Sure it's satirical, sure it's depicted from the overwrought perspective of the heroine; but from the performances, thedialogue (tellingly, Lou's voiceover describes the men on the set all looking at her as if they were sex maniacs. Thevisuals reveal her to have been largely ignored), and the stylish cinematography, this sequence is a great exampleof MY kind of moviemaking.

Dunaway reacts (I'll say) to being required to share her close-up with a livefalcon. This terrifying sequence recall actress Tippi Hedren's accounts of

working with Hitchcock on The Birds.

6/9

THE STUFF OF DREAMSOne of the good things about viewing an old film (and at 43 years-old Puzzle of a Downfall Child definitely qualifies)is that one gets to watch it in an environment entirely different from that in which it was created. Puzzle of aDownfall Child bombed in part because it came at a time when audiences were wearying of the glut of European-influenced, tarnished American Dream films that filled theaters after the breakthrough years of 1967. When viewedfrom the comic book / 3-D / blockbuster perspective of today, the film looks nothing short of miraculous.

Throughout her modeling career, Lou Andrea Sand compiles a list ofphotographers she refuses to ever work with again due to their abusive behavior.

Boldly written in red on this list is the name of the film's director, JerrySchatzberg. In her memoir, Looking for Gatsby, Faye Dunaway explains that thiswas an improvisational impulse on her part born of a particularly difficult time the

director gave her after actor Marcello Mastroianni (the man she left fianceSchatzberg for) visited her on the set. Schatzberg liked the touch and kept it in

the film.

As a culture, we’re guilty of attributing great profundity to the existential midlife traumas of male characters in films,while women undergoing the same are dismissed as merely neurotic. (I don’t know where I read it, but someoneonce observed that The Graduate missed the boat in focusing on the petulant Benjamin Braddock when the film'smost compelling story and most interesting character was Mrs. Robinson and her midlife dissatisfaction.) It’s difficultnot to think this subtle double-standard played into the critical response to Puzzle of a Downfall Child , but as goodas the film is (and I think it’s a really excellent film) there’s no ignoring that it falls into the usual traps that besetmovies that ask us to feel sorry for the beautiful people.

7/9

Film is a storytelling medium and all manner of human experience should be explored. But films like Puzzle of aDownfall Child seem to forget why movies exist and who attends them. No matter how masterful the film, it’s difficultto ask an audience to listen to a woman as breathtakingly beautiful as Faye Dunaway complaining about howunhappy she is in her (perceived glamorous) job as a fashion model, and how empty she finds her life (afteramassing enough wealth to live in financially independent solitude in a spacious beach house). We all know that therich and beautiful can suffer as much as the rest of us, but any film that attempts to dramatize a shared humanitywith people whose lives offer far more options than those of the average person has to walk a precarious tightrope.If the world is too glossy, the people too lacquered, it can actually end up glamorizing that which it's trying to vilify.Ultimately sending a message similar to the one expressed by those cops in the old movies bemoaning the fact thatcertain people are just “Too beautiful to suffer, too lovely to die.”

The DVD of Puzzle of a Downfall Child is currently only available in France (released Feb. 2012), but every yearmore and more obscure films are getting "made to order" releases, hopefully this will be one of them.

8/9

So, whether you take the film to your heart (as I did), or wish to wallow in its camptastic splendor (Puzzle of aDownfall Child is an exquisite, sumptuous-looking film that has a scene involving a toilet that is sure to sendMommie Dearest fans into wild ecstatics), this artifact from the days when movies sought to do more than makeVariety's Top Ten weekend boxoffice list, has a little of something for everybody.

No matter how you prefer your Dunaway, overdone and theatrical or touching and deeply affecting, Puzzle of aDownfall Child is a lost miracle of a film that is worth taking the time to discover (or rediscover).

"One only breaks oneself apart in order to put oneself back togetheragain...better."

To view some of Jerry Schatzberg's magnificent photographs, visit his website HERE

Copyright © Ken Anderson

9/9