dynamic asset allocation - aist mr4 1030-1130 chevrier - dynamic... · dynamic asset allocation...
TRANSCRIPT
Dynamic Asset Allocation
Thomas Chevrier, Ph.D.Head of State Street Associates, Asia Pacific
State Street Global Markets
Outline• Introduction to Dynamic Asset Allocation
– Why DAA
– What is DAA
– Allocation Strategies and Constraints
• Results– Model Performance
– Betting Returns
• Methodology– Dynamic Equities and Bonds Asset Allocation
– Dynamic Currency Asset Allocation
– Quality of Alpha
• Conclusion
• Appendix– Futures Basket
– Cost
2
-7%
-2%
3%
8%
13%
18%
23%
Jun-99 May-01 Apr-03 Mar-05 Feb-07 Jan-09 Dec-10
Annualized 2 Year Rolling Returns
High Turbulence SAA
Typical Australian Investor Performance Through Time
• Preserving Portfolio Value Is a Constant Challenge
3
Strategic Asset Allocation (December 2010)*
Asset Class Weight
Australian Equities 30%International Equities 15%Emerging Market Equities 5%Property 10%Alternatives 15%Australian Composite Bonds 5%Australian Sovereign Bonds 5%International Bonds 5%Cash 10%
Total Weight of Dynamic Assets 80%* Quarter 2010 Rainmaker Roundup Industry Funds Turbulence is determined using Global Asset Turbulence Index
Source: State Street Bank Europe Limited
Why Dynamic Asset Allocation ?
4
-7%
-2%
3%
8%
13%
18%
23%
Jun-99 May-01 Apr-03 Mar-05 Feb-07 Jan-09 Dec-10
Annualized 2 Year Rolling Returns
High Turbulence SAA DAA
Statistics Over Crisis Periods
November 2000 - February 2003 Total Return
Standard Deviation
Average Monthly Return
October 2008 - February 2009 Total Return
Standard Deviation
Average Monthly Return
SAA -3.50% 5.45% -0.12% SAA -9.78% 6.39% -2.04%DAA 2.79% 4.18% 0.11% DAA -6.13% 4.94% -1.26%
What is Dynamic Asset Allocation ?• Take advantage of specific market environments
Dynamic Asset
Allocation
Asset Allocation
Model
Carry Trade
on/off?
Stock / Bonds
Cheap?
Currency Turbulence
Index
Strategic Asset Allocation5
Individual Bet Size <5%
Total Bets in any direction <15%
Short Selling Allowed X
Short Currencies X
Leverage X
Long / Short Strategy X
3 Allocation Strategies
Currencies
Sample Constraints
6
Equities
Bonds
Equities
Bonds
Currencies
Results
• Betting on Equities, Bonds, and Currencies:– Out-of-sample information ratio of 0.89
– Worst drawdown reduced from over 17% to less than 15%
– Reduced probability of a loss and Value-at-Risk
– Takes bets 97% of the months
– Average monthly turnover of 8%
7
July 1997 - December 2010 Backtest (%)
SAAPublication Lag Out of Sample In Sample
Bets on Equities and Bonds Information Ratio - 0.64 1.23 1.56 Sharpe Ratio* 0.47 0.68 0.79 0.89 Return-to-Risk Ratio 1.15 1.37 1.47 1.56 Largest Drawdown -17.53 -13.20 -10.44 -11.88
Bets on Currencies Information Ratio - 0.64 0.75 1.60 Sharpe Ratio* 0.47 0.56 0.54 0.63 Return-to-Risk Ratio 1.15 1.24 1.22 1.29 Largest Drawdown -17.53 -18.40 -18.09 -17.74
Bets on Equities, Bonds, and Currencies Information Ratio - 0.89 1.46 2.04 Sharpe Ratio* 0.47 0.76 0.88 1.04 Return-to-Risk Ratio 1.15 1.43 1.56 1.69 Largest Drawdown -17.53 -14.11 -11.04 -12.09
* Riskless return = 4.5%
DAA
Model Performance
8
Betting Returns
-2.0%
-1.5%
-1.0%
-0.5%
0.0%
0.5%
1.0%
1.5%
2.0%
Jul-97 Jul-99 May-01 May-03 Mar-05 Mar-07 Jan-09 Dec-10
Publication Lag Average
9
• Batting average is 61.25%
Dynamic Equities & Bonds Allocation Model
• Monthly publication
• 5 investor behavior signals
• 5 fundamental signals
• Customizable
Favors Stocks
Favors Bonds
Source: State Street Bank Europe Limited
10
Asset Allocation Model(as of 28 February 2011)
Signal Favors
Investor Behavior Regime Map Bonds Global Sector Risk Appetite Stocks Emerging Markets Flows Stocks Global Sovereign Bond Flows Neutral Global Dividend Yield Correlation Stocks
Fundamentals Relative Valuation Stocks US Earnings Growth Bonds Global Yield Curve Stocks Turbulence Indices Stocks Global Breadth Bonds
Model Favors Stocks
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100% Private Equity
International Property
Cash Plus 2%
Infrastructure
International Inflation-Linked Bonds
Specialist Credit
Australian Property
Diversity
Cash
Australian Sovereign Bonds
Australian Composite Bonds
Emerging Market Equities
International Equities
Australian Equities
Dynamic Equities & Bonds Allocation Model
11
Dynamic Currency Allocation Model
no active adjustment to exposure
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0
5
10
15
20
25
Jul-97 Nov-98 Mar-00 Jul-01 Nov-02 Mar-04 Jul-05 Nov-06 Apr-08 Aug-09 Dec-10
Mov
ing
Ave
rage
Turb
ulen
ce I
ndex
Currency Turbulence Index and 30-Day Moving Average
Turbulence Index
Moving Average SubprimeMortgage
Crisis
Ruble Crisis
Accounting Scandals
9-11
Dot-comBubble Burst
Source: State Street Bank Europe Limited (February 2011). Published Daily
Increases exposure to countries with interest rates higher than Australia & vice versa
12
-20%
-15%
-10%
-5%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
NZD
NOK
CHF
SEK
CAD
GBP
JPY
EUR
USD
Dynamic Currency Allocation Model
13
Currency Exposure (%)
CurrenciesExposure as % of Total Portfolio
CAD 1.99CHF 0.68EUR 3.10GBP 1.79JPY 2.50NOK 0.18NZD 0.08SEK 1.84USD 14.17
Total 26.34
• For Australian investors, currencies tend to diversify the portfolio, therefore taking currency bets may lead to greater portfolio risk in addition to generating potential alpha
• 26.34% is a small exposure which does not allow us to take large active bets
Quality of Alpha
14
Quality of Alpha
Percentage of Months with Bets
Mean Return of Bets
Batting Average
Average Win
Average Loss
Win/Loss Ratio
Information Ratio
# years confident
Bets on Equities and Bonds Publication Lag 91.88% 0.10% 56.05% 0.45% -0.36% 1.28 0.64 8.99Out of Sample 91.93% 0.18% 60.13% 0.49% -0.29% 1.51 1.23 2.41In Sample 91.98% 0.23% 65.41% 0.49% -0.28% 1.89 1.56 1.48
Bets on CurrenciesPublication Lag 50.63% 0.07% 50.96% 0.25% -0.13% 1.04 0.64 3.96Out of Sample 50.93% 0.07% 53.33% 0.24% -0.12% 1.14 0.75 2.91In Sample 51.23% 0.13% 60.38% 0.25% -0.06% 1.52 1.60 0.64
Bets on Equities, Bonds, and CurrenciesPublication Lag 96.88% 0.14% 61.25% 0.47% -0.38% 1.58 0.89 4.83Out of Sample 96.89% 0.22% 66.46% 0.51% -0.33% 1.98 1.46 1.75In Sample 96.91% 0.31% 71.60% 0.54% -0.28% 2.52 2.04 0.90
Conclusion
• Valuable information in SSGM indicators
• Can help to– Generate significant Information Ratio
– Reduce risks
• Even with a constrained, simple, yet realistic DAA model, the out-of-sample gains are impressive
15
Legal DisclaimerState Street Global Markets is a registered trademark of State Street Corporation (incorporated in Massachusetts).State Street Associates is a registered trademark of State Street Corporation.
Issued by State Street Bank and Trust Company ABN 70 062 819 630, AFSL 239679 (State Street). This presentationis directed and made available only to institutional investors who are classified as wholesale clients under theCorporations Act 2001, and is not meant for the general public. The information contained in this presentation isobtained from a number of sources and its accuracy is not guaranteed by State Street nor is it a forecast of futurereturns. Past performance is no guarantee of future performance. This presentation contains general informationonly and is not intended to represent investment or professional advice. It is provided with the understandingthat the recipient will be responsible for making their own assessment and evaluation, and should seek the adviceof legal, tax and financial advisers before making any investment or trading decisions. State Street and its relatedcompanies and their directors and employees disclaim any liability for loss or damage howsoever caused by anyrecipient relying in any way on the contents of this presentation. Redistribution is prohibited without writtenconsent by State Street.
State Street Associates,
State Street Bank and Trust Company
One Lincoln Street
Boston MA 02111-2900
Appendix:
Considerations for Implementation
17
Futures Baskets
18
Futures Baskets (%)
Australian EquitiesInternational
EquitiesEmerging Market
EquitiesAustralian
Composite BondsAustralian
Sovereign Bonds
Equity FuturesAustralia 100Canada 3.59Europe 11.56Hong Kong 3.89 13.69Japan 16.92Singapore 2.63 9.09Switzerland 1.25UK 8.14US 55.60China 2.08India 15.44Mexico 19.81South Africa 11.20South Korea 6.50Taiwan 18.60
Bond FuturesAustralia 3 Year 94.29 87.43Australia 10 Year 5.71 12.57
Out-of-SampleTracking Error 1.59 1.90 8.13 2.15 2.47
Transaction Costs (bps) 0.54 0.79 1.30 0.50 0.50
Cost• For the most active DAA model, the Equities, Bonds, and Currencies model, we
observe an average annual cost of 16 bps
Cost (%)
Average Monthly Turnover
Standard Deviation of
TurnoverDAA on Equities and Bonds
Publication Lag 4.19 7.76Out of Sample 4.19 7.76In Sample 4.11 7.73
DAA on Currencies
Publication Lag 3.81 6.00Out of Sample 3.81 6.00In Sample 3.81 6.00
DAA on Equities, Bonds, and Currencies
Publication Lag 8.00 9.69Out of Sample 8.00 9.69In Sample 7.91 9.70
19
Futures Transaction Costs
Futures Transaction Costs (bps)
Country Future Cost Roll Frequency
Australia ASX SPI 200 Index Futures 0.54 QuarterlyCanada S&P/TSE 60 Index Futures 0.51 QuarterlyEurope DJ Eurostoxx 50 Index Futures 0.16 QuarterlyHong Kong Hang Seng Index Futures 0.58 MonthlyJapan Topix Index Futures 1.90 QuarterlySingapore STI Index Futures 0.99 MonthlySwitzerland SMI Index Futures 0.52 QuarterlyUK FTSE 100 Index Futures 0.33 QuarterlyUS S&P 500 Index E-Mini Futures 0.66 QuarterlyChina Hang Seng China Entreprises Index Futures 0.56 QuarterlyIndia SGX S&P CNX Nifty Index Futures 3.45 MonthlySouth Africa FTSE/JSE Top 40 Index Futures 1.41 QuarterlySouth Korea KOSPI 200 Futures 1.91 QuarterlyTaiwan MSCI Taiwan Stock Index Futures 1.53 Monthly
Australia 3 year Australian 3 Year Bonds Futures 0.50 QuarterlyAustralia 10 year Australian 10 Year Bonds Futures 0.50 Quarterly
20