dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 welcome by chairman of phyics...

19
G.G. Ross, Z. Lalak, C. Muñoz, J.A.C. 1990 GrahamFest 2011 Dynamical determination of compactification parameters

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jul-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

G.G. Ross, Z. Lalak, C. Muñoz, J.A.C.

1990

GrahamFest 2011

Dynamical determination of compactification parameters

Page 2: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing
Page 3: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

GrahamFest Oxford

29 & 30 September 2011   MEETING INFORMATION Meeting Home General information Organizing committee Programme Accommodation Participants USEFUL INFORMATION Venue Getting here Eating out Relaxing

Programme Friday 30 September

The day begins at 9am 09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics

09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing out the

gluon 09:40-10:00 Mike Pennington (Jefferson Lab): Roads to freedom 10:00-10:20 Keith Ellis (Fermilab): Perturbation theory and the

parton Model in QCD 10:20-10:40 Alan Barr (Oxford): Invisible partciles at the LHC

10:40-11:15 Break

11:15-11:35 Bob Jaffe (MIT): Encounters with Voodoo QCD

11:35-11:55 Brian Pendleton (Edinburgh): Mass and mixing angle predictions from infrared fixed points

11:55-12:15 Luis Ibanez (Madrid): GGR, EWSB and DGS 12:15-12:35 Dick Roberts (RAL): An education

12:35-12:55 Alberto Casas (Madrid): Dynamical determination of compactification parameters

13:00-14:00 Lunch *Group photo at 13:45*

14:05-14:25 Zygmunt Lalak (Warsaw): Racetrack inflation

14:25-14:45 Pierre Ramond (Florida): Stitching the Yukawa quilt 14:45-15:05 Steve King (Southampton): Flavour and good taste

15:05-15:25 George Leontaris (Ioannina): Fermion Mass Textures: from family symmetries to ... F-theory

15:30-16:00 Break

16:00-16:20 Andy Lutken (Oslo): Duality in the quantum Hall system

16:20-16:40 Herbi Dreiner (Bonn): R-parity violation and discrete symmetries

16:40-17:00 Dumitru Ghilencea (Bucharest/ CERN): Naturalness, dark matter(s) and a last bet for a Susy Higgs

17:00-17:20 Alan Martin (Durham): Graham - his first research years and some stories

17:20-17:25 TBA

17:30-19:00 Reception

Page 4: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

F. del Aguila L. Ibáñez

C. Muñoz J.A.C.

80’s

A. Ibarra B. de Carlos

90’s

Page 5: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing
Page 6: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

imaginative

enthusiast

witty and sharp

friendly

informal

non-pretentious

direct

insightful

Page 7: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

rigorous

honest

Page 8: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing
Page 9: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing
Page 10: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

Dynamical determination of compactification parameters

Collaboration with Graham, Z. Lalak and C. Muñoz 1990

Page 11: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

“Historical” context

- No mechanism of SUSY breaking at the correct (~ E.W.) scale

- No mechanism to fix the dilaton, S (~ g-1 at MP), neither the moduli

Paradigm ≡ Heterotic String

Problems:

General believe: the physical vacuum should be “selected” dinamically

(circa 1990)

Page 12: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

Existing mechanisms of SUSY breaking:

Gaugino Condensation:

VEV for the antisymmetric tensor field:

Both problematic

Page 13: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

Our Work

First we showed that for any superpotential of the form

any SUSY breaking minimum must fulfill some conditions, like:

trilinear in the matter fields

Page 14: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

This is completely general, i.e. it does not depend on the explicit form of f(S). These conditions are very powerful.

Second, we showed that, when applied to one gaugino condensate, there is no realistic minimum, independently of the explicit form of WT.

Interesting, but frustrating....

(far too large gauge coupling)

Page 15: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

why just one condensate?

Page 16: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

Third, we showed that, when applied to several (e.g. 2) gaugino condensates, there can arise a realistic minimum (gGUT ~ 2), depending on the gauge groups involved and the matter content associated.

Moreover:

- At the same time, m3/2 can get a realistic value ~ TeV

- The moduli, which appear in the Yukawa couplings, get also stabilized.

- The presence of (hidden) matter is crucial.

- We illustrated all these points with examples in the Z3 orbifold.

Page 17: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

After sending the paper we discovered that the idea of multiple gaugino condensation had just been proposed by Dixon, Kaplunovsky and Peskin in a conference.

Then, all of us discovered that the idea of several condensates had been proposed before by Krasnikov.

However, he did not considered matter. As a result he found it impossible to stabilize the dilaton at a realistic value and to get the correct amount of SUSY breaking, corroborating our results.

Later, our formulation was refined by making it T-dual invariant. However our basic results were correct and have remained.

Page 18: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing

Remarks on the racetrack scheme

Racetrack models in theories from extra dimensions.

Building a better racetrack.

Racetrack inflation.

Moduli-mixing racetrack model.

Inflation in a refined racetrack.

D-term Uplifted Racetrack Inflation.

Patterns of supersymmetry breaking in (...) racetrack models.

..... etc.

The mechanism was later called “racetrack mechanism” and has been used in many papers

Page 19: Dynamical determination of compactification …...09:00-09:10 Welcome by Chairman of Phyics 09:10-09:20 Reading out of messages 09:20-09:40 John Ellis (King's College London): Sniffing