e-journals pain points: dr. niso's prescriptions

31

Upload: nasig

Post on 25-May-2015

807 views

Category:

Education


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Overview of the in-progress PIE-J (Presentation and Identification of E-Journals) Recommended Practice. Presenter: Regina Reynolds, Library of Congress

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Page 2: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
Almost from the debut of e-journals, Serials librarians were in pain! Publishers seemed to forget all they know about publishing a journal when they went from print to online
Page 3: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Content listed under current titleContent listed under current title

Earlier journal titles: missing!Earlier journal titles: missing!

Page 4: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Page 5: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Students not finding articles Students not finding articles they needed!they needed!

Citations led to dead ends!Citations led to dead ends!

Page 6: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Missing numbering!Missing numbering!

No publishing statements!No publishing statements!

No dates!No dates!

Page 7: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Page 8: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Print ISSN used for ePrint ISSN used for e--version!version!

Page 9: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Page 10: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Digitized back content:Digitized back content: unpredictable,unpredictable,

incomplete,incomplete, unclear!unclear!

Presenter
Presentation Notes
Just when it seemed that things could not get worse, along came increased digitization of older content:
Page 11: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Page 12: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

ISSN either missing ISSN either missing or wrong!or wrong!

Presenter
Presentation Notes
The pain was almost unbearable!!
Page 13: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
Serials librarians collective nerves were raw and irritated
Page 14: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

CallingCallingDr. NISODr. NISO

Page 15: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
First: consciousness raising via an ISQ article
Page 16: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Information Standards Quarterly (ISQ)Spring 2009

Page 17: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
Then pie was offered….
Page 18: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
PIE-J, that is…
Page 19: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
A representative working group had to be assembled carefully
Page 20: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

PIEPIE--J Working Group RepresentationJ Working Group Representation

SpringerSpringerTaylor & FrancisTaylor & FrancisHarrassowitzHarrassowitzSerials SolutionsSerials SolutionsIEEEIEEEEBSCOEBSCOPublishing Publishing Technology plcTechnology plcAmerican American Psychological Assn.Psychological Assn.

Library of CongressLibrary of Congress(CONSER, ISSN)(CONSER, ISSN)

National Library of National Library of MedicineMedicineU WashingtonU WashingtonU BuffaloU BuffaloU Chicago (ref)U Chicago (ref)UCLA (ref)UCLA (ref)CrossRefCrossRefIthakaIthaka/JSTOR//JSTOR/PorticoPortico

20

Page 21: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
Endless conference calls
Page 22: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
Resulted in a draft
Page 23: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
The actual recommended practices only take 3 pages, and those pages might be summarized for publishers in conference handouts, attachments to ISSN assignments, etc. The bulk of the document consists of helpful appendices including 32 examples and appendices about topics such as determining title history, about ISSN, etc.
Page 24: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Key RecommendationsKey RecommendationsPresent all content under its original Present all content under its original titletitleInclude accurate and complete ISSN Include accurate and complete ISSN informationinformationInclude title historiesInclude title historiesUse numbering systemUse numbering systemRecommendations for digitized Recommendations for digitized contentcontentAppendices, including 32 examplesAppendices, including 32 examples

Page 25: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

http://www.niso.org/workrooms/piej/

Page 26: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Page 27: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Next StepsNext Steps

Public review of draft documentPublic review of draft document——until July 5, 2012until July 5, 2012Work with the commentsWork with the commentsFinalize and publish textFinalize and publish textArrange for ongoing maintenanceArrange for ongoing maintenancePublicize!!Publicize!!

Page 28: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Resources“In Search of Best Practices for the

Presentation of E-journals,” ISQ, spring 2009

“Journal Title Display and Citation Practices,” Serials Librarian, Jan. 2009

NISO workroom pagehttp://www.niso.org/workrooms/piej

28

Page 30: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions
Presenter
Presentation Notes
Publicity begins…!
Page 31: E-journals pain points: Dr. NISO's prescriptions

Thank You!Thank [email protected]@loc.gov