8/9/2019 E. Phelps Gay Review of Louisiana Legal Ethics E-Book by Dane S. Ciolino

1/3

8/9/2019 E. Phelps Gay Review of Louisiana Legal Ethics E-Book by Dane S. Ciolino

2/3

nce uon a time, eple

Obught hings caled bks.Authrs wrked ard t wie

hem Pubishes se ney rin an auh's wds nice-okngae ad t bind he ined ages betwee ard cvers Smetmes tee wasa dus jcket with styis at and ciments frm er auhs abu the wk

beng ubshed ele pad mney tbuy ese bks rea hem and ut themn the sheves The ut was amney by he bshe, and then, i tebk dd wel, te ath eceived yaltes Reads lked wad t hldighese becs i hei hands and shwing

them at hmeBut I wite as a cnessed dinsau

Yeas ag, wen I hd he viege fsev ng as Lusian Stae Bar Assciain(LSBA) pesidet, thugt i wd bea gd idea f he LSBA ubish an

tdate bk n u Rues f Pfessina Cnduct We wud t eac edescbe is isty, te hw difeed (fa al) f he B Mde e give

te reader ifrmain hw he Rulehas been itepeted and advse lawyersf te kind f dsclinay tuble heycd ge in f vlaig the Rule

Wh beer tn f this ect tght, than the taened yng awess at Lya University namedDane S Cilin He was smat fearess,

enegetic and seeed t say yes t just

abt anying S he agreedIn the middle f my e (Januay

200 I), r Cii nished and theSBA ubished, a bk caled Loui-

siana Pfessional Responsibii Law

and Practie. I was d f it ahughmy w conibuti t t was virtalyni, and bagged bt t t my Barceagues n the sates A handselybsed aerback cs ie eyt rduce ad a ie ney uchaset was we-eceived and (J hink aiy

fequeny cnsulte Time asse n2004 Cin wte, and the SBAubished an daed editin and yetanthe in 2007 Ths s the beate andbaered versin f the bk a I ave nmy cedeza s beaen u, i act thatit is encirced by tw ubbe bands

A s, hose edtis ae gne with thewnd Why? Bcause he aest vesin,

which eaty ecoend t al LSBAembers udges an awyers aike) isan "ebk Yu can read i at wlalegalethis.o. at f Pf Cisweblg caled Luisana Lega Ehcs tis -t-dae, infrave wewebok abut r crrent Res, d t sthe distnct advtage f beig fee Nrntg, ages, bndng burbs

n at n k We, thees a ittle ata dawng a eican wse beak isking away a he scaes f justice) Tbbihiles ike me ths is a ne stte faas In fac, faced wih the sec freading this e-bk nlne (it's but 140ages) I did wha any 57yead, tfdate unc guy wud d: rintd itout I ten hed it i my hands and read iThe vedict, yu wi n be suprsed thear, s he same The bk is gd andis essentia eadng membes f theega fessio in Lisiana lus, yu

can beat te rceThe fmat emains he same e

an inteesng ening discussin f thestica devemen f isaa ethcsules, rf Cino rvides he tex feach current Rue, backgud infrmatin n is adoi by he LuisianaSure Cut AB Cmments n hecesdig del Rule ad msvauaby) anntatins ctng Luisanacse w iterreting each Rue. sefuland use-fiedy, the maea is cearyganzed and cncisey witten Oneew feate s that at e end f each Rulediscussin, Pr. Cin vides tes,giving us the vey atest inmain nhe Re and dvsing wen he age wasas udaed n the wds ne desnthave wait f the nex editin pcketat (emebe hse?) newsete;udates ae iseted it the e-bk ghaer he evet (e.g, a new case r Ruechange) ccus Rubbing sand i the facefnntecies lie e te fess adshs page is wii ediabe cick ee

t edit this ageGiven te engh and cmexity fhe es, nt mentin the fac that aswe knw) hey are vgousy enfcedt ges wthu saying that we al need tkw them at least have the neabys we ca navigate ur way thrughtbed ethica waters, which see toise u js ab evey day Just cck

n the Luisiana Lega thcs Web siteand it's a hee

S here are a ew uesins D yuneed w he deais ermissble anca ssstce t clens? xacty what

ki awyer advetising cmlies withnew Re 7 ad wat crsses the line? Hwabut te test imtin f cnctsf interest t ter wyes n yu m

(and s is ideed changg)? Hw shdy esnd t emais eceved by, bt inened f, yu? When can a awyerals be witness? Can yu cmmcte

wt fme emlyees f a catrepresented by cunsel? Pecsely whenae y duty-bd t ert wat yuerceve t be rfessina scduct?

Wat language sh dinaiy be icuded in a cient egageme ee? Hwca y te f a fee is unreasnabe rn? Can yu citicze a udge? e yuas sevising awye ressible

he cduct f asscates ad aaegs?Must i-hse cse ut-f-satebti a iited icese t actice win Luisian? D yu have accet anen t seve as cnse f cimial defedan?

w sud add ta eve hgthis e-b sees y icky wadhe eien ue esdig t theseuesis, the answes i sme instancesreman eusive The ules, wic stilstem imaiy frm the AB MdelRues, aent always eectly clear nd

the cases and inns intepreting themca smeimes seem cvued (Takecn ics f inteesues 17 thrg. J as ne exame) But hugh sef hs e-b and cetan the resrces,1al Luisiana awyes adjdges have teptnity bece kwedgeabeabu u ethica es Suc kwegecan hel us cntend wit eveyday ethica isses and (hpely) kee s ftrube.

es y hink a tis is dy as dus

an, ets be hnest, sme f it is f Clino syy sces u the ext mtime t time. Cncening te anguage inRue .5(a) vidig that a lawyestrust acun mus be aiaed aban r sima insitutin, he fessrcmets is equreent asses halawyers d nt ttemt set u tust ccnts sng she bes t the ce

http:///reader/full/lalegalethics.orghttp:///reader/full/lalegalethics.org

8/9/2019 E. Phelps Gay Review of Louisiana Legal Ethics E-Book by Dane S. Ciolino

3/3

I commend the aforementione opening

essay on the history of our Rule. Among

ohe ibis Prof Ciolino noe th he

rs Loisana awyer-ehics code, pro

mgaed in 1899, was o based on he

Aabama code (wic os stes were

adoping) b isead on a 17 cenury

oa or Swiss awyersHe en egaes s

w e earlies reported case of lawyer

iscipine in Loisana nvoved PiereDormenon wo n 80 was sbared

aer beng ou "wearng a scar and

mac[ng] a e ea of e bigans

ring a 793 sae revo in Sano o

mngoTwo yeas laejusice prevaled

Monse Doenon was eaditted o

e Ba ae beig eleced o e Loisana

Hose o Repeetaies ad ceare by

tat body of any wrongdoing

So re up te computer cck your

mose and ae a loo a his boo Or

i you're a mserabe in-saned wrec

e me unconcened abo e wolesae

destrcion o rees pin e whoe ing

ou od i n yor ands spil a little

coee on i nrine cec and cice

watever yo wan and ive blssly

e pas Because e nex sop Iafaid is Kine.

FOOTNOTE

. To mentio two: Th Louisan AoreyDicpliry Bord Web ite t wladb.org;d te Loii Se Br ociion's Ehic

Adviory Service Wb sit a \lW Isa og or cll(504)566-1600.

E Phep Gy hrctifr 30yrt thm Chr/vch& Krn P H t th thmn rm ADRnc f e hunt rmPncnUnn 1975 n h JD

r' Tn LSch n 17 mmbr th LunStt 7) n Tx (3) Br AtnH as nt th un SttBr ct urn h 2000-2001 trm(St 0 61 Pyr St" N Orlen, L70130

There is always great satsfacton in being ale to help

someone who would not otherwise be able to aod legal

servces. A surprsing benet to taking pro bono cases as

been to help build my private practice as I have developeda network of referrals trough both y pro bono

clients and other attoreys I ave met in th

process of handling the cases.

- Paul "Woody Sot Fnn & t

n Vlt t Btn Ruge BAsociatol'r BO mjec/

http:///reader/full/wwwladb.orghttp:///reader/full/wwwladb.org