economic growth in the united states of america a county-level analysis
DESCRIPTION
Economic Growth IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA A County-level Analysis. April Harris Elana Kaufman Sohair Omar Elizabeth Pearson. Objective. To explore the factors driving differences in regional economic growth across the United States. - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Economic GrowthIN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
A County-level Analysis
April HarrisElana Kaufman
Sohair OmarElizabeth Pearson
Objective•To explore the factors driving differences in regional economic growth across the United States.
•To replicate the analysis in the OECD paper, “The Sources of Economic Growth in OECD Regions: A Parametric Analysis,” (December 2008) for the U.S. case.
Agenda
1. Theory 2. Data3. Summary Statistics4. Results5. Findings/Conclusion6. Future research/Recommendations7. Questions
What explains economic growth?
1. Neo-Classical Theory 2. Endogenous Growth Theory 3. New Economic Geography
(NEG)
Neo-Classical Theory• Long-run growth is the result of continuous technological progress, which is determined exogenously• Key implications
• Conditional convergence—if country starts from lower level of per capita output, it’s expected to have a higher growth rate
• Problems• Predicts economic convergence, which hasn’t been seen
empirically (limited empirical evidence)• Leaves technological progress out of the model—technology
is modeled as an exogenously determined constant rate
Endogenous Growth Theory•Internal factors are the main sources of economic growth
•Investing in human capital the development of new forms of technology & efficient and effective means of production economic growth
•Developed in the 1980s as a response to criticism of the neo-classical growth model
Endogenous Growth Theory
•An economic theory which argues that economic growth is generated from within a system as a direct result of internal processes. •More specifically, the theory notes that the enhancement of a nation's human capital will lead to economic growth by means of the development of new forms of technology and efficient and effective means of production.•Theory emphasizes that private investment in R&D is the central source of technical progress•Protection of property rights and patents can provide the incentive to engage in R&D•Investment in human capital (education and training of the workforce) is an essential ingredient of growth
Endogenous Growth TheoryArrow and Sheshinksi
Knowledge is non-rival, therefore discoveries spillover to the entire economy
Romer and LucasCompetitive assumptions can be maintained and determine an equilibrium rate of technological progress but the growth rate is not Pareto optimal. At the end, growth and knowledge can increase boundlessly. No convergence is predicted.
Romer, Aghion and HowittR&D activities reward firms through monopolistic power. The equilibrium is not Pareto optimal, but rather one with monopolistic competition. The stock of human capital determines growth, but too little human capital will be devoted to R&D. Also, integration into world markets increases growth rates, and large populations are not sufficient to generate growth.
New Economic Geography• What is economic geography?
– Economic geography is the location of factors of production in space
• (Krugman 1991)
New Economic Geography• What does NEG seek to answer?
– Why and when does manufacturing become concentrated in a few regions, leaving others relatively undeveloped?
– In order to realize scale economies while minimizing transport costs, manufacturing firms tend to locate in the region with larger demand, but the location of demand itself depends on the distribution of manufacturing. Emergence of a core-periphery pattern depends on transportation costs, economies of scale, and the share of manufacturing in national income.
New Economic Geography• How does NEG theory answers these questions?
– Through a model of geographical concentration of manufacturing based on the interaction of economies of scale with transportation costs
– Concentration of manufacturing in one location need not always happen and that whether it does depends in an interesting way on a few key parameters
New Economic GeographyGeneral Model:
• Two industrial sectors– Agriculture and manufacturing; agriculture fixed while
manufacturing is mobile• Transport costs:
– low • benefits manufacturing to aggregate
– High• does not benefit manufacturing to aggregate
– Technology (specifically transportation technology) lowers transport costs
– There exists tipping point between high and low transport costs
New Economic Geography• What is the tipping point?
– Low transport costs and external economies of scale increase the income of the core (urban) region relative to its periphery.
– Agglomeration raises wages in the core region relative to the periphery.
– If costs fall far enough (wages increase enough), the wage differential will induce firms to relocate back to peripheral regions.
New Economic Geography• If one region has right mix of key factors before - even just slightly
before - another similar region, the leading region takes off and the other may not grow.
• Thus despite early similarity regions can become quite different.
• Key factors are:– transport costs– proportion of economy in manufacturing
(affects ability to take advantage of economies of scale)– population
New Economic GeographyBasis for regional divergence:
• 1st - the concentration of several firms in a single location offers a pooled market for workers with industry-specific skills, ensuring both a lower probability of unemployment and a lower probability of labor shortage.
• 2nd - localized industries can support the production of nontradable specialized inputs.
• 3rd - informational spillovers can give clustered firms a better production function than isolated producers.
New Economic GeographyRe-statement of general model:
• Agricultural production is characterized both by constant returns to scale and by intensive use of immobile land. The geographical distribution of this production will therefore be determined largely by the exogenous distribution of suitable land.
• Manufacturing is characterized by increasing returns to scale and modest use of land.
New Economic GeographyRe-statement of general model: (cont’d)
• Because of economies of scale, production of each manufactured good will take place at only a limited number of sites.
– Other things equal, the preferred sites will be those with relatively large nearby demand, since producing near one's main market minimizes transportation costs. Other locations will then be served from these centrally located sites.
New Economic GeographyRe-statement of general model: (cont’d)
• As transportation costs decrease and economies of scale are present, a region with a relatively large non-rural population (or larger initial production) will be an attractive place to produce because of the large local market and because of the availability of goods and services produced there.
– This will allow the larger initial region to grow while the smaller initial region does not - or does so to a lesser degree and at a slower rate.
New Economic Geography• How does NEG relate to this research?
– NEG seeks to explain concentration and dispersion of economic activity
– Restated, NEG seeks to explain differentials in economic activity – this is precisely what we want to know!
New Economic Geography• How does NEG differ from Neo-Classical and Endogenous growth
theories?
– NEG takes scale into account
– Neo-Classical and Endogenous growth theories are only concerned with what happens at the margins
– NEG models propose that external increasing returns to scale incentivize agglomeration
– Agglomeration captures, via scale effects, how small initial differences cause large growth differentials over time
DataSources•Description•Frequency•Timing (1998-2008)•Sample Size (Special Cases)
Dependent variable: •Annualized per capita personal income growth (real in 1998)
Independent variables:•Log of income in the initial year (1998)•Physical capital/infrastructure•Education rates•Innovation Index•Employment rate •Employment specialization •Accessibility to Markets/Distance to Markets
Per Capita Personal Income• Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis
• Ranges from $8,579 in Loup County, NE to $132,728 in Teton County, WY• Used to create three variables:
• Dependent variable: annualized per capita personal income growth1/10 * ln(income in 2007) – ln(income in 1998)
• Highest: 7% in Sublette, WY • Lowest: -3% in Crowley, CO• Mean: 1%
• Independent variable: log of income in the initial year, 1998• Highest: $76,450 in New York, NY• Lowest: $7,756 in Loup, NE
• Independent variable: per capita personal income in nearby counties, weighted by distance and other spatial measures
Physical Capital/Infrastructure•Source: ESRI Data and Maps 9.3 Media Kit (2008)
•Density of major roads by county
•Airports by county
(Visual representation? Example: Frequency table of airports)
Physical Capital/Infrastructure
Education Rates• Source: 2000 Census • Percent of population with less than high school degree
• Highest: 62.5% in Starr, TX• Lowest: 4.4% in Douglas, CO• Median: 21.6%
• Percent of population with a high school diploma• Highest: 53.5% in Carroll, OH• Lowest: 12.4% in Arlington, VA• Median: 34.7%
• Percent of population with more than a high school degree• Highest: 82.1% in Los Alamos, NM• Lowest: 17.2% in McDowell, WV• Median: 41.4%
• These three variables add up to 1
(Capture above info in bar graph)
Innovation Index
[COMING SOON]
Employment Rate• Source: 2000 Census (for cross-section)• Youth employment rate: population aged 16 – 20 that is working divided by total population 16 – 20
• Highest: 100% in Loving, TX• Lowest: 8.78% in Shannon, SD• Median: 46.2%
• Working age employment rate: population aged 21 – 65 that is working divided by total population 21 – 65
• Highest: 88.4% in Stanley, SD• Lowest: 35.9% in McDowell, WV• Median: 73%
• Total employment rate• Highest: 86.7% in Stanley, SD• Lowest: 33.6% in McDowell, WV• Median: 69.9%
(NEED BAR GRAPH!)
Employment Specialization• What is it?
– Measure of industrial concentration of a region (county)
• What is it meant to capture?– Meant to capture notion of agglomeration
Employment SpecializationAgglomeration:
• What is it?– The spatial concentration of industry– A determinant of economic growth in NEG growth theory
• How is it modeled?– Employment specialization proxies for agglomeration
Employment SpecializationReturning to employment specialization:
• How is it modeled?– Specialization indices
• Herfindahl Index• Krugman Index
Employment SpecializationHerfindahl Index (HI):
• Definition:– The Herfindahl index is the sum across industrial sectors of the
square of that sector’s share of employment
Employment SpecializationHerfindahl Index (HI):
• Features:– Ranges from 0 to 1.0
– 0 = large number of very small firms (perfect competition)
– 1 = a single monopolistic producer (complete monopoly by a single firm)
• FYI:– Used in determinations of market share in regulation of
monopolistic activity(Replace text with math!)
Employment SpecializationHerfindahl Index (HI):
• Pros:– Captures industrial specialization
• Cons:– Is an absolute measure; Does not take neighbors into account
Employment SpecializationKrugman Index (KI):
• Definition:– KI = ∑j|aij-b-ij|
• a = the share of industry j in county i’s total employment • b = the share of the same industry in the employment of all
other counties, -i• KI = the absolute values of the difference between these
shares, summed over all industries
Employment SpecializationKrugman Index (KI):
• Features:– Ranges from 0 to 2.0 – 0 = county i has industrial composition identical to its
comparison counties – 2 = county i has industrial composition without any similarity
(no common industries) to its comparison counties
Employment SpecializationKrugman Index (KI):
• Pros:– Captures industrial specialization
– Is a relative measure; Compares to one’s neighbors
Employment SpecializationKrugman Index (KI):
• Cons:– Whether agglomeration economies can be fully captured by
relative concentration measures, or whether the absolute size of economic clusters is best for understanding the effects of geographical concentration on economic growth is debatable.
– Argued that the absolute size of clusters should be the basis for calculating the level of specialization.
– Objections hold that this level is systematically underestimated for larger metropolitan areas when relative levels of concentration are used.
Employment SpecializationKrugman Index (KI):
• Cons: (cont’d)• For a review/discussion of the literature on this point:
– Drennan, M. and Lobo, J. (2007) Specialization Matters: the Knowledge Economy and United States Cities.” Los Angeles: UCLA School of Public Affairs, unpublished manuscript.
– Duranton J. and Puga D. (2003) Micro-foundation of urban agglomeration economies in Henderson V. J. and Thisse JF. (eds) Handbook of Regional and Urban Economics Vol.4 Cities and Geography, Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Employment SpecializationWe chose…
Because of our specific interest in why regions grow at different rates relative to one another, the comparative nature of the Krugman Index seems better suited to our needs than the Herfindahl Index.
Accessibility to Markets/Distance to Markets
[PENDING]
OLS Results
_cons .0447189 .008105 5.52 0.000 .0288272 .0606106lninitiali~e -.003361 .0008151 -4.12 0.000 -.0049592 -.0017628 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00976 Adj R-squared = 0.0052 Residual .293232788 3077 .000095298 R-squared = 0.0055 Model .001620368 1 .001620368 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 1, 3077) = 17.00 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth lninitialincome
Scatter Plot
-.05
0.0
5.1
tota
lpcp
igro
wth
9 9.5 10 10.5 11 11.5lninitialincome
OLS Results
_cons .0107438 .0002969 36.18 0.000 .0101616 .0113261high_lengt~s 1.48e-06 6.28e-07 2.35 0.019 2.46e-07 2.71e-06 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00978 Adj R-squared = 0.0015 Residual .294323761 3077 .000095653 R-squared = 0.0018 Model .000529396 1 .000529396 Prob > F = 0.0187 F( 1, 3077) = 5.53 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth high_length_miles
OLS Results
_cons .0973624 .0104257 9.34 0.000 .0769203 .1178044percentmor~s .0401284 .0028069 14.30 0.000 .0346248 .0456319percenthsd~a (dropped)percentles~s .0231712 .0035923 6.45 0.000 .0161277 .0302147lninitiali~e -.0109003 .0010488 -10.39 0.000 -.0129567 -.0088438 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00942 Adj R-squared = 0.0737 Residual .272867456 3075 .000088737 R-squared = 0.0746 Model .0219857 3 .007328567 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 3, 3075) = 82.59 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth lninitialincome percentlessthanhs percenthsdiploma percentmorethanhs
OLS Results
_cons .0109692 .00019 57.74 0.000 .0105968 .0113417 airports .0016204 .0003464 4.68 0.000 .0009412 .0022995 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00975 Adj R-squared = 0.0067 Residual .292771168 3077 .000095148 R-squared = 0.0071 Model .002081988 1 .002081988 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 1, 3077) = 21.88 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth airports
OLS Results
_cons .0110871 .000308 36.00 0.000 .0104832 .0116909 airports .0017429 .0004284 4.07 0.000 .0009029 .0025829high_lengt~s -3.76e-07 7.74e-07 -0.49 0.627 -1.89e-06 1.14e-06 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00976 Adj R-squared = 0.0065 Residual .29274868 3076 .000095172 R-squared = 0.0071 Model .002104477 2 .001052238 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 2, 3076) = 11.06 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth high_length_miles airports
OLS Results
_cons .0188594 .0007721 24.43 0.000 .0173455 .0203734youthemprate -.0166641 .0016598 -10.04 0.000 -.0199186 -.0134096 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00963 Adj R-squared = 0.0314 Residual .285500966 3077 .000092785 R-squared = 0.0317 Model .00935219 1 .00935219 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 1, 3077) = 100.79 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth youthemprate
_cons .0206125 .0016478 12.51 0.000 .0173816 .0238434totalemprate -.0134318 .0023647 -5.68 0.000 -.0180683 -.0087952 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00974 Adj R-squared = 0.0101 Residual .291793528 3077 .000094831 R-squared = 0.0104 Model .003059628 1 .003059628 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 1, 3077) = 32.26 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth totalemprate
OLS Results
_cons .0119877 .0018895 6.34 0.000 .008283 .0156925totalemprate -.0228014 .0243243 -0.94 0.349 -.070495 .0248922workingage~e .033683 .0217282 1.55 0.121 -.0089204 .0762863youthemprate -.0204913 .0039113 -5.24 0.000 -.0281604 -.0128222 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00961 Adj R-squared = 0.0359 Residual .283988615 3075 .000092354 R-squared = 0.0368 Model .010864542 3 .003621514 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 3, 3075) = 39.21 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth youthemprate workingageemprate totalemprate
_cons .0191127 .0017728 10.78 0.000 .0156367 .0225888workingage~e -.0107746 .0024347 -4.43 0.000 -.0155485 -.0060007 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00976 Adj R-squared = 0.0060 Residual .292988405 3077 .000095219 R-squared = 0.0063 Model .001864752 1 .001864752 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 1, 3077) = 19.58 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth workingageemprate
OLS Results
_cons .0090671 .0004528 20.02 0.000 .0081792 .009955 ki .0027874 .0005197 5.36 0.000 .0017685 .0038063 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00974 Adj R-squared = 0.0089 Residual .29212165 3077 .000094937 R-squared = 0.0093 Model .002731506 1 .002731506 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 1, 3077) = 28.77 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth ki
_cons .0104854 .00032 32.76 0.000 .0098579 .0111128 hi .0034814 .0011334 3.07 0.002 .0012591 .0057037 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00977 Adj R-squared = 0.0027 Residual .29395184 3077 .000095532 R-squared = 0.0031 Model .000901317 1 .000901317 Prob > F = 0.0021 F( 1, 3077) = 9.43 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth hi
OLS Results
_cons .0173707 .0015157 11.46 0.000 .0143988 .0203426accessibil~y -.00061 .0001514 -4.03 0.000 -.000907 -.0003131 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00976 Adj R-squared = 0.0049 Residual .293306191 3077 .000095322 R-squared = 0.0052 Model .001546966 1 .001546966 Prob > F = 0.0001 F( 1, 3077) = 16.23 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth accessibility
OLS Results
_cons .0042186 .0006293 6.70 0.000 .0029846 .0054525distance_t~t 8.36e-14 7.14e-15 11.71 0.000 6.96e-14 9.76e-14 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00958 Adj R-squared = 0.0424 Residual .282271316 3077 .000091736 R-squared = 0.0427 Model .01258184 1 .01258184 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 1, 3077) = 137.15 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
. reg totalpcpigrowth distance_to_market
OLS Results
_cons .0634634 .0111748 5.68 0.000 .0415525 .0853743 airports .0011786 .0004263 2.76 0.006 .0003428 .0020143workingage~e .0025639 .0043352 0.59 0.554 -.0059364 .0110642youthemprate -.0116003 .002529 -4.59 0.000 -.0165589 -.0066417 ki .0027824 .000657 4.23 0.000 .0014941 .0040706lninitiali~e -.0068983 .0011938 -5.78 0.000 -.0092391 -.0045576percentmor~s .0277121 .0031681 8.75 0.000 .0215003 .0339239percentles~s .0095969 .0041919 2.29 0.022 .0013777 .0178161high_lengt~s -4.46e-07 7.87e-07 -0.57 0.571 -1.99e-06 1.10e-06distance_t~t 4.25e-14 8.05e-15 5.28 0.000 2.67e-14 5.82e-14 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00926 Adj R-squared = 0.1052 Residual .263075644 3069 .00008572 R-squared = 0.1078 Model .031777513 9 .003530835 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 9, 3069) = 41.19 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
OLS Results
_cons .0631671 .0111864 5.65 0.000 .0412335 .0851007workingage~e .0020258 .0043356 0.47 0.640 -.0064751 .0105267youthemprate -.0117032 .0025314 -4.62 0.000 -.0166667 -.0067397 ki .0025355 .0006516 3.89 0.000 .0012577 .0038132lninitiali~e -.0068954 .0011951 -5.77 0.000 -.0092386 -.0045521percentmor~s .029272 .0031208 9.38 0.000 .0231529 .0353911percentles~s .010242 .0041899 2.44 0.015 .0020267 .0184573high_lengt~s 5.45e-07 7.02e-07 0.78 0.437 -8.31e-07 1.92e-06distance_t~t 4.20e-14 8.05e-15 5.22 0.000 2.62e-14 5.78e-14 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00927 Adj R-squared = 0.1032 Residual .263730976 3070 .000085906 R-squared = 0.1056 Model .031122181 8 .003890273 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 8, 3070) = 45.29 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
> i youthemprate workingageemprate
OLS Results
_cons .0762806 .0110451 6.91 0.000 .0546241 .0979372 airports .0009525 .0004248 2.24 0.025 .0001196 .0017853workingage~e .007201 .0043019 1.67 0.094 -.001234 .0156359youthemprate -.0144924 .0025074 -5.78 0.000 -.0194087 -.0095761 hi .0007522 .0012876 0.58 0.559 -.0017724 .0032769lninitiali~e -.0081632 .0011864 -6.88 0.000 -.0104894 -.0058371percentmor~s .0267372 .0031696 8.44 0.000 .0205225 .032952percentles~s .0102764 .0042013 2.45 0.015 .0020388 .018514high_lengt~s -1.22e-06 7.77e-07 -1.57 0.118 -2.74e-06 3.07e-07distance_t~t 4.67e-14 8.02e-15 5.82 0.000 3.10e-14 6.24e-14 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00929 Adj R-squared = 0.1000 Residual .264583407 3069 .000086212 R-squared = 0.1027 Model .030269749 9 .003363305 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 9, 3069) = 39.01 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
OLS Results
_cons .0635042 .0113212 5.61 0.000 .0413063 .085702 airports .0012035 .0004274 2.82 0.005 .0003654 .0020416totalemprate -.0089656 .0036322 -2.47 0.014 -.0160873 -.0018438 ki .0036642 .0006237 5.88 0.000 .0024413 .004887lninitiali~e -.0068724 .0012303 -5.59 0.000 -.0092848 -.0044601percentmor~s .0300993 .0031391 9.59 0.000 .0239443 .0362543percentles~s .0117685 .0042226 2.79 0.005 .0034891 .0200479high_lengt~s -3.64e-07 7.90e-07 -0.46 0.645 -1.91e-06 1.18e-06distance_t~t 4.55e-14 8.02e-15 5.67 0.000 2.98e-14 6.12e-14 totalpcpig~h Coef. Std. Err. t P>|t| [95% Conf. Interval]
Total .294853157 3078 .000095794 Root MSE = .00929 Adj R-squared = 0.0997 Residual .26478041 3070 .000086248 R-squared = 0.1020 Model .030072747 8 .003759093 Prob > F = 0.0000 F( 8, 3070) = 43.58 Source SS df MS Number of obs = 3079
Modeling Spatial Relationships
Inverse Distance…
K-Nearest Neighbor…
Contiguity…
Contiguous Counties
The average county has 5 to 6 neighbors (main point)How many neighbors does
the…
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 140
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Number of Contiguous Neighbors
Number of Neighbors
Num
ber
of C
ount
ies
Global Spatial Autocorrelation
Growth rates display spatial dependence…Moran’s I…Null hypothesis
*1-tail test totalpcpigrowth 0.432 -0.000 0.010 41.176 0.000 Variables I E(I) sd(I) z p-value* Moran's I
Row-standardized: NoType: Imported (binary)Name: W Weights matrix
Measures of global spatial autocorrelation
. spatgsa totalpcpigrowth, weights(W) moran
Own growth rates depend on neighbors (idea)
Moran scatterplot (Moran's I = 0.439)totalpcpigrowth
Wz
z-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
-3
-2
-1
0
1
2
3
4
5
228 2707
2287
2591
17722362
870
2668
2236323
2673
361
2586
1677
491
2066359254718582471711419
46424521861
424
1221
9251662
391
221265
2644
440
2098
17712902
691
277
564
2166
1721
245320471243866
61123102196228224432029
1634
10526835114251694
906670
14312531
738
1723
12442019
2544434
1000
1226
17401068
432
1393
2631648
1643
1275
1197
4152025679
9981873388
1722
2901881
1627
513360
31310131406303530
376
2628
1240
2102
7039461890804405
69660710641044
1270
132224421350
458993384963
2369
494
2767
7145792018
2873
1246437
204110631254201116872583
661
1856
4033642061
6951204
6332427
50227659215171884969
1269
2027220453
1895
3892903
193114521637203714542912
39421091911
270
386
1657
2687126612551492
7191225900101
2094
9072031
479
1641
375430468
664
1327680
1705
961
1274
2086894694
246752373
1989
416
20289554451656
262
6711209
314
697
19082421
2869
123496743530382062
2747
1954
535
378186948024104562042
2482
454
12121054
515
2020
1562411
1242
2520
19381319
395
2776
2432
253
1357
1955400
1008362
2420
12051027
22005801479
1103
931
2093
366
978
16881201712
9641904
1725
2425301314011428966
1007510
146
1219
640569
358
25215142993
2620
2024
909
754
1860421431891
2078
976243118943652433392
1649
26992096
16691236915
1868
2577
369
913
20221217
1042751
2600
2526
2084
2734
674
9911222973851
1015
2551
2023
259
84
14512076
1272
60814972305
889706
147010021265
20143901507
312813
708
1284
1206
10591256
2054939
2468
8651073436
1278
12712043385
1344802
483
2478
2034
1257
1554877716583
1199
2298113
12286316671417
1277
315
1251
20801230
8681684
203
2063
2558486
1896
248
23646552180
15061286130512921026
1941
355
960615
2124
20691045473
136067
3242862
1258605256528252090678439
12032307
162048920744826061066
15471562051
2095
1505
2663
2056
933
663
922
1253
9322762486709
74228911885
1877
1049
1001
20606992304
1353
2068
1621
41341019002070
972
457
944
527
2408
823
7411235753
10242745
1010
2601
2172
1444
1943
2820
594
19401889
2898512
163914481645
5126
2087
1918
367
4984704901467
20822040
2207
12791216
2459
15222017276568520792178
2525
673735
239614491650
1259
339
549150
1437
2055
12312753575
208373088220771947
1820962
18671208
25
2233
1665
1245
734
2089
1386
29162754
2788
11987312896
5051878
2464
22511891
1857689
28531563
404
123914922296499231795604
1268
9902932
1528
1215
1288266371120
20652012628
1644196
8982617
902
317221570229008431489
1295
1384811712
14721719
598191924221043
402
19165872402492273
2715
24341202516
16523682316677
216
170
21955711930
2266
1934
1792
30362234155013371655
1112744
747
1543
12631250
426
14181819721859
896
2494
499
1549
23238401462
478
471
2497
878
622
497
852
2013
294
316
1358
6652285
17332269623983720
8851009
30141898
2608208
12491048
397
462
2444407
1892
1660
1527666
260
1917
968
1407
2838
2904658227022263050
2852
2982
4382048
444625
7809243049484995
143628291029
1252
6271371880
2050
707
2698
23941685
710
1812
1237
11926211840
90458212671935
24991037
2684
687
294730392438
1447
13432516629
1034
1485
2761
30221921491
1388
1762
13832415
503
2989892
2030
616
9812805
2450
4012010
2769617644
18509012449652
2203
73921001866
42213451661
2245
2268
1200
14422398
1913
2419292174
2619
210
1825874207
351
8113040
406
300183826361314
2399169129113012
548
14531843
442
1531
1213941
3008595
1936
299822301181545
2627
13652461
936341
2091
1481
2088
1511
568
2662
23955963024248022
382254
2038686298725514733032
723
2370
2770
1512
15912331
157570
18002649163117451004134919282292450
1355
5672801246782
2016
1312148729942387
129714583791503
163061413091556
13077581475
1915
13812847
2263
1518
1384
1767770
190
1561
127619392311746
47530271021
2085
1784
148812072039
954
2067
15411368
31
970810
3037
2379
22102460292919251831
2130
1674477
2560
74521751477276230071852380183020456192015
287
1214
286
3033
409
488
1224
2830
1247
1318
1899895305112801683
2072
1821
182321
399
65114962315
64711019483045105018882983
2851
562
2242
1864
717
11511754597872243
250025291700
2259
1987
15163011
529
2294
239
460
90
659
129817971315
2752
10497411471439672
469
3006145926
19063016
765
124131
68228261535
30202416414
5853035
2271
646418
1098
2823
18631887
555
14902568
2768
1875
1229
5866691509
220687
1273
22642261
938
24295911811
1699
2465182
2186
18011555578
2645
3004181
2771
172
2123
2075
2640
798137522832026
7751775
1530692
88
9454721378
1035512938
18748189
2036
29092273140
3
22313025
2957
1846781
2053
222184687520092248
352
3000164619331427219715042189
999
18721328953
1912
2071
2913
2058581
29672265
1945
21042905
256229451291125
6091310750
1672
21761461146911461653
7261465
732
20921162915
26141805
711
80829251932
1756693
2546
1602
3054
1552167561022671632
2854
15017731829
1946
1828621870
1859221779263424731033917
30997
408
14561546
417
2894
2476
1405
10702237
105725955893019
6391464
449
2389
2059
16732685
2498
65
65687385564132224405081560737
15151016
700
2057
2306764192
1826104118971261
2593
170724857448992257
951662834
217785297
2049
85
722
718
620190913912106909421352
193
56237943
1423
2033
558
1362
217745117
495
816
27934281626
1080
292214802798
236
532
2523
728
2679
9481382
387
1148
1468
2334821
433
1425
2235
1686
119
1484820
13211370307
34
952
244818222214244724267861841
2506
329
14783211689
2956
2935
346
13042044
2566
29818342222
2579912
8072868
2843
1060
805
1514
7135522803
2750736
507
1832
1074
911283527865422985
23201281
9351886
3010
39959
177314452828
1046
2534
2943
1486
30431081730
2664
2791
3001
2549
811676
2571
297362412992252
7761521
15367602333031
11552865
2227412
174
98824114472944
1121
1308
1540
1510137317603532258533
1670
9582204
1134
304712182216
363
5731814
29312145
1335
2286
246212231287
2372
302218362409
2742587769
2327
28561176
47683175
1051
1776357
2724293415252879
2585
81767522202472
1761
538
2604
725
930701
2313
208162627485842322635
888
1889751718
563
89
48466
1076
1084
7963048
17882190115029591012
2193
8492763
2247
1441
5882253
1606
2407192697
14991227715
1736143512
1625
2757
304305698
2897
14948542488654
192028112655
2405724
2841
992
8831929
193015
374
1072
2111882
50
1557
1638
2209
1283115776602441
2393
1695
18551804
1977
2199
1339
168039884787642
2941546890
2759
11658971799
1163248375768465715021815
2376
937
2584
2682899
26948481379
572
826784830
1532
1698
1731304679923832974
648561
2727
2046
950
166624513021642
2923
49169141
729
861155187914982021
2939
42916921377
129024241693
994103528135191330
29268032244
1326
2224643965
2073
1077
3026
2833
1953601
1463111221791724
254847
2819
2250
6
1952
23012182300228081047
2964
1313
2397
26722809
30552751544
16719491443381
2317
278
2700
705
3271851
1848
2910214
1727
6122194
28525536812795704
2991
7871061433242762
2484783
2148
833
105984839
250
2430169094914
1262
2643
8421359
2239
5662977
401542343
2714
26788932996
2513
1519
504
1177
4611455
271691
15246032812
1835920
1802
1862
92717141356932
1735
28162892
1880
790
13162335
1189
1482
147
292822462052
1416
1635
2712
1508146018061658
94
182728672751
459
17572857
14041765247772724061233005
1910
1421
175122972708247511582864
2380
806170865021832191
2677
187636
1781
1018
22413053330
103912481354302812324201137
9197941808630
539
1329
226
2676
8272403642
2469
1260
326
2656
11902228
41986
28931031
1834
2325
130
3052
1159393
2709
2818
131115731438
1457
79
311
2545
560
2035
28
2391
13461679
1710
347
222317385932143543
7406982445
204
27102933
1058
1167
2064
544
662
257
3017
2295
574
603542995299017941616
2463
789
22498191431548771
3182225
11522878
777139514711493
2519
17323029191122
1174
2417144
733
2691103025082232
190514465902458
5062318
3034
1990
1140
13031865298830217491143860180
768
106724542202
224017421803
74824142597191429862840844
814163
2669
761
220820978
2136
8562451
2659
17435286002181002827
660
17042275168
251
25032746
2284
982
6761529254
2969181723381474
2688
1629
10621809
1100
181313
2322162
599
6883371640
2812119
2925213482992
5412366
1440800
1331
283
309141514761220
252
2895
19011659
2609
2401
1601
304124711028
929
1951905
2115
8322446829266011727291739
2122
171161551
1921370
1755
13721937
1110
1483231224042821294
2961
857
838
2511
344162299
1424
1095222962764
28611737140945
174920
182324891334
129311259
1166
1183
1837
24123044
1759
926
1177288
1975
230284903
27381300
5509572181175102997
2810
1065
1612
618
2533
5312806
18182319
1014
28152790
12892722
1135
501
165303017472942
862
1603
2797427
1188
1500
2658
1325
2436
996
28591729
25222718
10362920
14202675
493
1611924
1085
987
214123
179241848713642243
2849
1391287624352509
202
2134
2848
2280
668
1180815
2760
2921825
2293
2832
2892958
2355
836
1324
1847
1845
467
28021414474
1744
21525762616
136124791154
910
2611
18103018134076328721513
1233
6427357797562799
29141351
2821
2487
98083
1779
940824
310
151
2654
338
2778
7661430345
2946114411
17962572
134228712682
2596
1764
788
21711780
1238
331
156710892720
15322963191534164728502212
153715587972388
2437576
2674
2302
271
2936255025701741
271316821849772
2149258113321196153830091927
2365
2
234
86714138281020283786
2642
2831220528442368
2970
496
1387
2156
27327784611791184
443
500
10279318332507999711709
38224
1306
2622
134
2965
33
180728771893
10791770175228002213
637
27
1397
11642665
2845
1162
80
15391152125
1032
1211645
2543
2032
287524552517342226235
2496
2703
2927
2314638
2633452288429510062784
1341
1871
115352429632723
2428
521
21701964
16282667
1523
2105
2530
1118
29172188
918743
295529532952
13801883164
1609
812
1241
565
132322182937
1574
553
2359
1078
16331181
166710031450
2651
251857
104029481392
581333
21873289592306
22551671141018422951291
1768
137653292429810222701423114
1593
2439
1523241149280175017151092
44
1139
2169
613
2638
2374
8642392
1123
27742567166305
977
1566
136728831586
8871706
1285
1432
137417581056
23412299
1422
2775
9561716
250123501973
1950
1891798
1763
485
127
23601732966128214662870
2137
29992219
632
1526
18392889
21
75529495371053138520041958
547
1668
109521472780
229
17531580
1663
2238509
206545
1061
2466
51
1145
577
517
2167258
979
1994
2345
2400
209721162274249226812954871
1017
2919
632717
6362278
2326
1572
2789
18541071
2348
1697
297528392930
908
2794
13692281
914
2602
1995
2931400
21181138
1587
1296
25612117
21851005
1575
1363
1570
2309
853845
118713992787
1553
1971
349
2155
11562535
947
28632907
2737
2126
9282858
2743795
2817
148
27119677
2233023
24952940536221113216961336
2347
1038
240
396
340
2886
1853
24931161
2390
1681556
377
1992
1185
782
1793
1998
2846
1081
2866
2689
2144
1403
11912670
1600
2882112010831175
54
244
23522646
1942190325991495235
253610992515
1726
1195
1408
2384
2782
1963
1094
3003
1972
51828072755
1127
2984
10862514
1902222
2184
8691411
1194
2690
2288
1607
17772578
1182
3058
1142
822
23781841132
1169
1131
27412142
2542
2423540
2978
2695
1168
2610
205
1766
24742796
1664
2756
1608
916
348
53426351025
22918
2582
154
1320
801227
1595
2381985
1791
841
2615
1338
3722441135
1748
200
774
1986
2413133
2106
2772
272827772630
2874
2666
14121746
2888
2606
111915902971
158
197219448
201258812826321023
2976
187
159
559
1125
1703
2773759837
2161
2855
5261582
2120
2353
1564
1170
23812785
2481
43
1967
15851618
520226011152972
2128
227271
2457
1559212
1578
178779116542114
2541
3042
14292132781
129
333
1055
109716042692
554
1186297925101944
1565
2164
1264
249
256
2129
2885
2598455
2890
194
2740
1844850858
2730
2563
2159
2758
1171531421520
11732559
2731
2742
1734
159926212634
767
2792
247028871396
1651
2377
1713465
14261623
1019
23611991
11092860
281429682332
13662005279
2099
17202300
11932132
2290
2589
1376
1588
2631
46370
1301
1128
291837
1614
1113
2385
1091
886
835
2906
18242950
989
1783
1785
1419
2574
1108
1619
107
2107
23571087
2683
741347
25272328
12118529601602412783
2371
26051923
325
2256
1596
879
2580136
2343
1701921
2002
71782332
11172648
30642650
21683362133
1568
1088
1398210316112524
2491
2110
2556
27021571
2569
1584
3072
11111764
110228811106
145
2502
224
1788095252908
15792127
2980
19572
1317
1968
1597
2312354
2637
230322791105
1130
17891907
2006
158311262152
1075
21111778863
2344198
2836
308
2158
2962
21501160
2337
277923392590
1104
1589
2842335
2626
1981
2661
2824
1615
2804
253255
186
2157
2201
15771093
1636
1966
1390
2342
2594
23301728
2308
2113
1434
2112
1956
1581
1082
23861790199
18162456
2277
2696
152
2618
2624
6128222289
16102625
1786
16782880
25922528
1881
2346109615942375
21212657
2693
985
159821312512
170227051141272
1101
11722154
27212329
69
1999
1402
2686
2135
21082725
2373
1129
2160
1983
25641922
2140
2173
1969
1980
20032671
2336
2691613
2612
446
198427263070
356
2165
2653
30571957
73
2540
523
2153
1974
261
1982
27331178
2333
2539
1133
2340
301
1069320
1617290
2504306768
20002704
557
19962363
2623
183
2356
19652555
1576
2163
3063
260720072652
26132641
2367
2351
3075
21462382
2537
2557
934
21512554
1769
3078
1124383322603
2629
1979
264
1997
21012198884
26971107
350
1605
2671774
23492739
156926473071
1970
225
3060
30662719
2552
1988
200121392573
3061
307333424901960
196119763079
1136
2138
2749
2736
10902538
3065
1122
3069
2766
1962
3059
1592
15331624
2358306219933068
1717
20081959
1394
1116
30771978
1389
2639
1622
1114
2706
1011
2505
25753076
2680
3074
Main Findings
Future Research
Questions