ecr international · 2009-02-28 · 4 climate energy micro-cogen consortium today darpa / us army...

42
1 ECR International Climate Energy Green Power from America’s Home Heating Industry

Upload: others

Post on 16-Apr-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

1

ECR InternationalClimate Energy

Green Power from America’s Home Heating Industry

Page 2: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

2

OUTLINEOverview/Background

Micro-CHP

Technology

Product

Key Issues

Page 3: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

3

Who we are…

Page 4: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

4

Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today

DARPA / US Army

Climate Energy

Duke Solar Energy(North Carolina)

Massachuetts RenewableEnergy Trust

New York State EnergyRes. and Dev. Authority

USCHPA

Yankee ScientificECR International, IncHeating Appliance Industry Leaders

Government

Renewable Energy Partners

Page 5: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

5

Overview“Case” for co-generation has been amply made for yearsResidential level cogen (Micro-CHP) has lacked adequate technology solutions…until now.New Technology

residential level applicability

consumer friendly

90%+ efficiencies

Environmentally sound

Wishful R&D? … No!!!

Page 6: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

6

What we’re doing…Developing patented space and water heating appliances that…

Cogenerate electric power

Are “customer-friendly” (…look and work like today’s appliances…),

Can be commercialized through existing industry infrastructure

Achieve near term product introduction through evolutionary technology

=Micro-CHP

Page 7: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

7

Over the last 10 years the US space heating appliance industry produced about 1,000,000 Megawatts of Thermal Capacity

Total USA Installed Electric Capacity ~ 600,000 Megawatts

Page 8: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

8

Why Micro-CHP Now …CHP has fundamental energy and environmental value, if done right

Improved understanding of the opportunity and emergence of good business model

Evolutionary technology solutions exist

Electric industry developments and national agenda have made Micro-CHP relevant

Page 9: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

9

Micro-CHP uses up to 95% of the Available Fuel Energy

85%HeatSurplus

Power to Grid 5% Flue Loss

10%ElectricPower100% Fuel to

Heating SystemCogen

Unit

Page 10: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

10

What’s really required for Micro-CHP

Economical PracticalThe right capacityLow emissionsGrid connectionBackup-power

Page 11: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

11

The Technology

Page 12: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

12

Liquid-Injected CogenEvolutionary hydronic heating technology

Synthesizes new technology with old

Compare to “hybrid” automobile

Page 13: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

13

Liquid-Injected CogenerationSimplified “Steam” power cycle made possible by modern materials, manufacturing and electro-mechanical technology

Cycle configured to specific needs of Micro-CHPInstantaneous water heating with only partial vaporizationPower from two-phase, oil-free expander

Page 14: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

14

Liquid-Injected Cogen FurnaceOil-Free ExpanderTwo-Phase

MixtureFuel Generator

LiquidHeater

Feed-Water Pump

Exhaust

3 kW electric30 kW heat

WarmAirTo Building

VaporCondenser

Return Air

Page 15: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

15

Why Use Water ?(and not “refrigerants”)

Best thermodynamic properties for Cogeneration (Most or our electric power

is from “steam” plants)

Thermal stability (can’t burn, can use direct fired heat exchangers)

Non-Toxic, No costCan tolerate significant leakageVery high heat transfer rates means compact heat exchangers(compared to refrigerants and organics)

Page 16: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

16

Rankine vs. LIC Cycles

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

0 0.5 1 1.5 2

Entropy, Btu/lb-F

Tem

pera

ture

, F

LIC

RankineRankine shown with ~200 F superheatLIC shown with 50% steam quality

Page 17: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

17

Potential Output of L-I Cogen Unit

0

1

2

3

4

5

150 250 350 450 550Pressure at Expander Inlet - psia

Mec

hani

cal P

ower

- ki

low

atts

Atmospheric Pressure Condenser

Per 100,000 Btu/hr Heat input

60% Efficient Expander

Steam

50/50

Liquid

Page 18: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

18

Advantages of Liquid-Injected Cogen

Appropriate heat/power ratio for homesLow hot water inventory – intrinsically safeUses compact, lightweight, high performance components Expander rotation matches generator speedExternal combustion - low emissionsQuality heat provided at up to 200 FBuilds on existing heating industry technology and business base

Page 19: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

19

(M1) Hydronic LICConcept Demo

Input:120,000 Btu/hrOil free scroll expander Produces 2 kW shaft power

Page 20: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

20

The Oil-free, Steam/water Scroll Expander –Why?

Need to keep oil out of high-performance heat transfer components Oil-free technology is emergingHandles two-phase over wide mixture rangeNo valvesSelf-starting, smooth-running, quiet

Page 21: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

21

Scroll Expander – Creating the Power

Mixture enters at center, expands spirally-outward

Scroll technology now preferred design for refrigerant compressors

No valves, oil-free, quiet

Page 22: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

12/8/2003

Scroll Devices for Fluid-Pressure Work Conversion

A century old principle for positive displacement machine

Recent commercialization enabledby advanced manufacturing capability

2000 US patents in last two decades 22Millions of compressors manufactured

annually (Copeland, Carrier, Hitachi)Many desirable features relative to

reciprocating pistons

Page 23: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

23

Scroll-Expander Requirements

Oil-freeCorrosion/erosion resistant to water/steam/air environmentVolume Expansion ratio of about 5Up to 200 psig inlet, 0 psig outletIsentropic expansion efficiency about 50% or moreLimited leakage (< 0.2 lbs/hr)10,000 –20,000 hour life, 5,000 hour service interval

Page 24: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

24

Liquid-Injected CogenWarm Air Space HeatingFurnace Demonstration Unit

Page 25: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

25

The Product

Page 26: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

26

Concept View of LICWarm-Air Furnace

Page 27: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

27

EconomicsRealistic target is around twice the cost of high efficiency (heat only) furnace

Reduced electric power costs result in good payback

Very attractive relative to alternative on-site power generators

Page 28: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

28

Cogen Heating System Monthly Electric Output*

0100200300400500600700800900

J A S O N D J F M A M J

Month

Range of TypicalMonthly Electric Usage for Gas Heated House

Cogen Monthly Electric Output kWhrs

*10% power to heat ratio, New York example

Page 29: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

29

The Market…

30+ Million Buildings in the US50+ Million Buildings Europe & Asia

US Market for Fuel-Fired Heating AppliancesSpace Heating ~ 4 million/yearWater Heating ~ 5 million/year

International market of similar size

Page 30: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

30

ISSUESRegulatory

UtilityEnvironmental

Legislative…Making it all work

Page 31: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

31

ISSUES Micro-CHP fits into the reality of today’s changing electric utility industry

Electric utilities will view CHP both as an opportunity and a challenge

Micro-CHP – more opportunity/less challenge

Key IssuesInterconnection PermittingFeesNet meteringTax credits

Page 32: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

32

Key Issues - Interconnection“…entry by all generators should be facilitated to the greatest extent

possible… and entry by distributed generation brings unique attributes to the market. Distributed resources are an effective check on the market power of incumbent utilities…”*

* ISO/RTO Interconnection Policy for Distributed GenerationWilliam Massey, Commissioner, FERC, April 2000

SafetyReliabilityFERC responsibility

States to follow guidelinesMicro CHP likely less controversial (environmental performance important!!!)

Interconnection rules must be fair and workable

Page 33: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

33

Key Issues – “Fees”Utility imposed “fees” (exit/entrance, stand-by/access) ADD to the costs of CHP!!!!Exit fees – means to recover future stranded costs associated with loss of customer States “all over the place” on fees

Six states with no feesFive states with conditional feesTwo states with broad fees on all self generationTwo states with conflicting legislative and administrative positions

Page 34: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

34

Key Issues – “Fees” (cont’d)Other “fee” issues that are not standardized

Grid connected vs. independentReduction in consumption from grid vs. complete avoidance “Hidden” exit fees

e.g. stand-by rates (MIT case in MA)“Bottom Line”

Regulatory treatment of “fees” driven by local regulators/legislators/utilities/perception of CHPSmaller sizes likely to receive better treatment

Page 35: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

35

Key Issues – Net MeteringNet-metering

Net total monthly electrical consumption or the difference between electricity “taken “ from the grid and the amount generated by the CHP appliance

Already in the “books” in many states (40+) as well as in several bills

S 1766 “mandates” net metering for systems <250 kW

Small systems favoredMost do not have “cash-back” provisions

Carry-over creditsYear-end round-upNet-negative flows to utility

Page 36: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

36

Key Issues – Taxes

House and Senate bills include tax credit language for CHP

Excludes systems < 50kW

Page 37: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

37

R&D

House-Senate Conference Committee

SEC. 201. DISTRIBUTED ENERGY AND ELECTRIC ENERGY SYSTEMS.(b) MICRO-COGENERATION ENERGY TECHNOLOGY.-From amounts

authorized under subsection 16(a), $2,000,000 for fiscal year 2003 and $20,000,000 for fiscal year 2004 shall be available for activities undersection 223.

SEC. 223. MICRO-COGENERATION ENERGY TECHNOLOGY. The Secretary shall make competitive, merit-based grants to consortia for the development of micro-cogeneration energy technology. The consortia shall explore the use of small-scale combined heat andpower in residential heating appliances.

Page 38: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

38

Bottom line…

Legislative and regulatory issues are important to the eventual success of Micro-CHP

Micro-CHP and intended market sector likely to yield more favorable treatment than some other technologies (size/application)

Page 39: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

39

Environment

Page 40: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

40

Annual Emissions Comparison(Per Million LIC Units)

0

1

2

3

LIC GTCC COALTechnology

CO

2 - M

TPY

NOx

- KTP

Y CO2

NOX

GTCC and Coal are Based on Equivalent kWhr Production

Page 41: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

41

Potential Impacts at the National Level(10 Million units)

Electric generation in the US -2000Coal - ~1900x109 kwhr

~600x109 kwhr for residential sector Gas - ~500x109 kwhrOil - ~100-110x109 kwhr

LIC Electrical Energy Contribution30x109 kwhr/year

~5% of coal generation for residential sector~30% of total fuel oil-based electrical generation!!!

Equivalent to:~30% of total Demand-Side Management (DSM) programs

Page 42: ECR International · 2009-02-28 · 4 Climate Energy Micro-Cogen Consortium Today DARPA / US Army Climate Energy Duke Solar Energy (North Carolina) Massachuetts Renewable Energy Trust

42

Carbon Dioxide Emissions from

Production of Electric Power

w/ MicroCHPw/o MicroCHP

4-5 tons C02

7 tons C02