educational research presentation
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
1/38
Basics of Educational Research
Dr. Muhammad Najam ul Kashif
Department of Education
NCBA&E(Multan Campus)
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
2/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 2
Session One Objectives
• Why Conduct Research?
• Thesis, a Presentation of Research Findings
• Problems with modern research
– How research was and is conducted
• Research Cycle
• Examining the Steps of the Research Cycle
• Categories of Research
• Quantitative Methods
• When Should I Use a Quantitative Method?
• A Quantitative Research Plan
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
3/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 3
Why Conduct Research?
1. Fills in blanks in our knowledge2. Expands our own understanding of issues
3. Reproduce knowledge, to validate other’s work
4. Add other perspectives to the knowledge base
5. Improves Practice
• Learn about new practices
(new ways of doing)
• Evaluate existing practices
(why are we doing this?)
6. Informs about important policy issues
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
4/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 4
Presentation of Findings
• A thesis is a formal method of sharingthe results of research.
• It is common requirement in highereducation for those completing post-
masters degrees.• A thesis should Not be confused
with a dissertation.
• Three important differences:
a) Lengthb) Rigor
c) Uniqueness of the research
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
5/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 5
Problems With Modern Research
• Conflicting results
• Vague findings
• Questionable data• Inaccurate• Small sample size
• Poorly constructed surveys
Key: Just because it’s publisheddoesn’t make it
“good research.”
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
6/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 6
How Research Was Conducted
“Scientific Method”
4 Steps of Inquiry
1. Observation
• Defines goal of research2. Make a prediction
• If confirmed, resolves problem
3. Gather Data
• Relevant to prediction4. Analyze & Interpret Data
• Determine if it supports prediction
S e q u e n
t i
a l
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
7/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 7
What Is Research Today?
“Research is a cyclical process ofsteps that typically begins withidentifying a research problem or issueof study. It then involves reviewing the
literature, specifying a purpose for thestudy, collecting and analyzing data,and forming an interpretation of theinformation. This process culminates in
a report, disseminated to audiences,that is evaluated and used in theeducational community.”
(Cresswell, 2002)
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
8/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 8
Identifying A ResearchProblem Specifying a problemJustifying itWhy do we need to study it?
Reviewing theLiterature
Locating ResourcesSelecting
Summarizing
Purpose andMethodologyPurpose StatementsFunneling/Narrowingto research questions
or hypothesis
Collecting Data Study Groups/Control &TreatmentPermissionGathering Information
Analysis/InterpretationBreaking down dataDepicting DataExplaining Data
Reporting & EvaluatingWhat does this mean?Which audienceStructuring report
Research Process Cycle
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
9/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 9
Research Cycle & Thesis ChaptersIdentifying A Research
Problem Specifying a problemJustifying itWhy do we need to study it?
Reviewing theLiterature
Locating ResourcesSelecting
Summarizing
Purpose andMethodologyPurpose StatementsFunneling/Narrowing toresearch questions or
hypothesis
Chapter One
Chapter Two
Chapter Three
Collecting Data Study Groups/Control &TreatmentPermissionGathering Information
Analysis/InterpretationBreaking down dataDepicting DataExplaining Data
Reporting & EvaluatingWhat does this mean?Which audienceStructuring report
Chapter Four
Chapter Five
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
10/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 10
Let’s Look at the Steps Individually
•Identify a problem or issue
•One that needs to be resolved
How?
•Specify the topic Justify why it needs tobe studied
•Suggest the importance of this topic to aspecific group
Why Specify?•Specifying limits broad topics makes themeasier to research.
Introduction also called the Statement of theProblem
Chapter One
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
11/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 11
Let’s Look at the Steps Individually
Literature Review Defined:Locating summaries, books, journals, andindexed publications on a topic, selectivelychoosing which literature is relevant, andthen writing a report that summarizes thatliterature.
Both Faculty and Students have fears aboutresearch
Faculty: the research won’t build on
existing knowledge.
Student: after planning and conductingresearch that it will merely replicate priorresearch.
Chapter Two
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
12/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 12
Let’s Look at the Steps Individually
Defining the MethodologyKey Chapter: Introduces the entire study,signals the procedures to be used(research methodologies, e.g.Ethnographic), and points to the resultsto be found.
This chapter must be crafted carefully.
Your explanation of how you are going to goabout collecting data so that others couldreplicate your study.
Collecting Data: identifying and selectingindividuals for a study; obtaining theirpermission to be studied; and gatheringinformation by administering instruments,through asking people questions orobserving their behavior.
Chapter Three
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
13/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 13
Let’s Look at the Steps Individually
Analyzing and Interpreting the Data
Analysis Means: taking the data apart to see individualresponses and putting it back together to summarize it.
Presentation of findings, no explanation.
Charts and Graphs Important to this chapter.
Reporting and Evaluating Research
Determining the audience and structuring
the report in a format that is acceptable tothis audience.
Explains what this research means
Chapter Four
Chapter Five
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
14/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 14
Classification of Research
by
Purpose• Basic Research: Develop or Refine a Theory
• Applied Research: Applying or Testing aTheory to see if useful in solving a problem
• Evaluation Research: Collecting &Analyzing data about the quality, effectivenessof programs, products, or practices
• Research & Development: Researchingneeds and Developing products to meet the
needs.
• Action Research: Systematic approach ofinquiry within a particular school for the purposeof solving localized problems not contributing toscience.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
15/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 15
Classifying Researchby
Research Method
• Quantitative Research: Collection of
numerical data for the purpose of – Explaining
– Predicting and/or – Controlling a phenomenon of interest
• Qualitative Research: Collection,
analysis of non-numerical data for thepurpose of gaining insights into aparticular phenomenon of interest
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
16/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 16
There are many methods of
conducting research
Experimental
Correlational
Narrative
Ethnographic
Case Study
DescriptiveSurvey
Grounded Theory
Mixed Causal-Comparative
Single Subject
Qualitative Quantitative
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
17/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 17
When Should I Use A
Quantitative Research Method?• When the research problem is a
description of trends or anexplanation of the relationship among
variables.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
18/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 18
Quantitative Methods• Correlational: Collection of data to determine, if and to what
extent a relationship exists between to or more quantitative variables
– Ex. To what degree does parental involvement in school relate to
increased student achievement.
• Descriptive: Determines and reports on the way things are.Collects data to test hypotheses or answer questions about the
current status of the subject study. – Ex. Pre-election political poll or survey about public perceptions of their
schools
• Causal/Comparative: Attempt to determine the cause orreason for existing differences in the behavior or status of groups of
individuals. – Ex. The effect of preschool attendance on social maturity at the end of
first grade.
• Independent variable (cause) students attending preschool and not attending
• Dependent variable (effect) difference in social maturity between the groups
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
19/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 19
Quantitative Methods, cont.• Experimental: At least one independent variable is
manipulated, other relevant variables are controlled (impactreduced) and the effect on one or more dependent variablesis observed.
– Ex. The effect of positive reinforcement on attitude towards
school.• Independent variable: type of reinforcement
(positive, negative, no reinforcement)
• Dependent variable: attitude towards school
• Single-Subject: A design used to study the
behavior change that an individual or groupexperiences as a result of an intervention.
– Ex. The effects of weekly teacher and parentcommunication on the completion of homeworkof eighth-grade at-risk students.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
20/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 20
A Quantitative Research Plan• Introduction:
– Statement of the Topic
• Describes the variables of interest, the specific relationshipbetween those variables, and ideally the importantcharacteristics of the participants (gifted students, 4th graders
with learning disabilities)• Ex. “The topic to be investigated in the study is the effect of
positive reinforcement on the quality of 10th graders’ English compositions.”
– Variables: positive reinforcement and quality of
English compositions.
– Participants: 10th graders
– Background of the Topic
• Give the context:.
– Rationale for its Significance
• Why is this a problem
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
21/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 21
A Quantitative Research Plan• Review of Related Literature
– Provides an Overview of the topic
• Gives the big picture
– Informs the reader with References to What is Know aboutthe Topic
– Should Logically Result in a Testable Conclusion orHypothesis
• Ex. “Because of what we know about X,it is predicted that Y will occur.”
– Conclude with a Summary of the Literature and arestatement of the Implications for its Significance.
– Hypothesis is rooted in the literature
• There must be a logical reason for yourprediction and the Literature Review is the basis for it.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
22/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 22
A Quantitative Research Plan• Methods Section: Road map of your study
– Research Participants: description of the participants,demographic data, number, source,
• Should define the population from which the participants weredrawn
• Ex. “Participants will be selected from a population of 157 studentsenrolled in a Algebra I course at a large urban high school inMiami, Florida. The population is tri-cultural, being composed ofprimarily Caucasian non-Hispanic students, African-Americanstudents and Hispanic students from a variety of Latin Americanbackgrounds.”
– Research Instruments: description of the particular instrumentsto be used and how they will measure the variables.
• Instrument is a test or tool used for data collection.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
23/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 23
A Quantitative Research Plan
• Materials/Apparatus – If special materials (booklets, training manuals) are to bedeveloped for use in the study they should be described in theResearch Plan
• Design:
– General Plan for conducting the research study. – Indicates the basic structure of the study and the goals to be
achieved.
• Procedure:
– Detailed explanation of the steps that will be followed.
– This will allow others to replicate your study and get the same orsimilar results.
– Includes Assumptions (important fact presumed to be true but notverified) and Limitations (some aspect that may negatively effectthe study and over which the researcher has no control) Samplesize & Length of Study
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
24/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 24
A Quantitative Research Plan• Data Analysis:
– Description of the technique or techniques that will beused to analyze the study data.
– For some descriptive studies this may be nothing more thantabulating the responses.
– For most, it will usually involve one or more statistical tests.
– It is vital to provide a detailed description of your researchplan.
• Nothing more frustrating than to collect data and learn
– There is no appropriate analysis method available
– The analysis required is beyond the capability of the researcher
– The data collected cannot provide an answer for the hypothesis
presented
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
25/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 25
A Quantitative Research Plan• Time Schedule:
– Important to have a realistic schedule in which tocomplete the research
– All too often, researchers do not have unlimited time tocomplete the study.
– Researchers tend to underestimate the time required tocomplete the study.
– Time schedule
• A listing of the major activities to be completed during theresearch study and an expected completion date.
• Ex.
– Surveys will be mailed to participants by June 30
– Surveys are to be returned by July 15
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
26/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 26
Let’s Review
• We conduct research to increase our knowledge orunderstanding and to improve our practice.
• Typically research is presented in a thesis format in highereducation but it can appear in journals as well.
• One of the major reasons why educators are concerned
about research is the conflicting results.• Modern research follows a cyclical process rather than the
sequential format of the Scientific Method.
• Research can be classified by purpose or method
– Purpose: Basic, Applied, Evaluation, R& D, Action
– Method: Quantitative or Qualitative
• Quantitative Research: A collection of data for the purpose ofexplaining, predicting, or controlling a phenomenon ofinterest.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
27/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 27
When Should I Use A
Qualitative research Method?• When the research problem is
an exploration and
understanding of a centralphenomenon.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
28/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 28
Qualitative Methods• Grounded Theory: systematic, qualitative procedure used
to generate a theory that explains, at a broad conceptuallevel, a process, an action, or interaction about a substantivetopic.
• Ethnographic: for describing, analyzing, and interpreting aculture.
– Culture: group’s shared patterns of behavior, beliefs,and language that develop over time.
– Example: Case Study
• Narrative: inquirers describe the lives of individuals, collectand tell stories about people’s lives and write narratives aboutindividuals experiences. This would include the documentationof events.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
29/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 29
Qualitative Ingredients
• Identifying the Topic: topic of interest.
• Reviewing the Literature: examines literature for usefulinformation and strategies for carrying out the study.
• Selecting Participants: selected to provide datacollection, purposely collected, not randomly selected, fewerin number than quantitative studies.
• Collecting the Data: collected from participants,interviews, observations and artifacts.
• Analyzing and Interpreting the Data: analyzes thethemes and results of collected data and providesinterpretations.
• Reporting and Evaluating the Research: summarizesand integrates the data into a narrative and visual form.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
30/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 30
Research Ethics
• RespectingParticipantRightsParticipant Bill of Rights
Right to be briefed about study
Know the purpose of the study andany social consequences
Right to refuse or withdraw from
study at any time
Right to anonymity
Right to gain something from the
study
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
31/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 31
Research Ethics• Honoring Research Sites
– Get permission first
– Don’t overly disturb operation
– Remember you may be a guest
• Reporting Research Fully & Honestly – Make sure your reporting is accurate.
– Report what you find even if it does not
support your hypothesis.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
32/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 32
But, I’ve Never Done This Before!
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
33/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 33
Necessary Skills• Problem Solving-Working Puzzles
– Research steps are like puzzle pieces. Your job is to putthem together.
– Critical Analysis
• Lengthened Attention Span – You are going to need to focus on materials for longer
periods of time.
– Your reading is for a different purpose so you will not beable to skim through articles.
• Using Libraries, Electronic and Brick Varieties – This process is going to require that you spend time in the
library.
• Writing, Editing, and More Writing!
• Reflection
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
34/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 34
Quantitative vs. Qualitative
Methods
• Description & explanationoriented
• Literature Review plays amajor role
• Purpose specific, andmeasurable
• Data CollectionPredetermined
instruments, numeric data• Statistical analysis
• Reporting, standard andfixed
• Exploratory &understanding oriented
• Literature review plays aminor role
• Purpose is general andbroad,
• Data Collection Emergingprotocols, text or image
data• Text analysis
• Reporting, flexible andemerging.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
35/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 35
Important Definitions
• Research Problem: an educational issue orproblem in a study.
• Research Topic: broad subject matter
being addressed in a study.
• Purpose: major intent or objective of thestudy.
• Research questions: questions theresearcher would like answered oraddressed in the study.
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
36/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 36
Should I Study this Topic?
• Contribute to Knowledge &Practice?
• Access to the people & sitesnecessary to the study?
• Time, resources, skills to study thetopic?
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
37/38
Dr Muhammad Najam ul Kashif 37
Flow of Ideas in a Statement of theProblem
TopicResearchProblem
Justification DeficienciesRelating toAudience
SubjectArea
• A concernor issue
• A problem
• Somethingthat needs asolution
• Evidence from theliterature
• Evidence frompractical experience
• What’s missing? • What do we needto know moreabout?
• How will addressingthis topic help others?
-
8/17/2019 Educational Research Presentation
38/38
D M h d N j l K hif 38
Examples, please…
Topic
ResearchProblem
PurposeStatement
ResearchQuestions
Distance learning
Lack of students indistance ed. Classes
To study whystudents do notattend distance ed.classes at acommunity college
Does the use of Website technology in the
classroom deterstudents fromenrolling in a distanceed. class?
General
Specific