edwin alexander jandres-aguiluz, a073 674 189 (bia nov. 13, 2014)
TRANSCRIPT
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
1/13
Kelie MacDonaldCAIR Coalition1612 K St., NW Ste. 204Washington, D 20006
Executive Ofce r Immigraton Review
oard of mmigrtion ppealsOce of the Clerk
507 eesbug ike Suit 000als huch Vgiia 50
OHS/ICE ice of Chief Counsel - BAL31 Hopkins Paza, Room 1600Baltimore, M 2201
ame: JANDRS - AGUIUZ, EDWIN A... A 07-67 4189
ate o tis notice: /1/014
nclosed is a copy o the Board's decsion and order in he above-rerenced case.
ncose
mbullne, ug GGree, nne JPule, ger
Snceely,
D cDoa Cr
Che Clek
m e
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
Cite as: Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
2/13
.
U.S rtmnt of JuticExecutive Oce r Immiation Review
Decision of e Bod ommiation Appeals
Fs Church, Virgini 20530
File A073 674 189 Batimore, MD Dat:
In re: EDWI ALEXDER JDRS-AGUILUZ a.k.a. Edw Hdre
I ROVAL PROCEEDGS
APEAL TION
O BL OF SPONDEN Kellie MaDonald, Law SdentHeidi ltm Superviing Aoey
CRGE
NOV 13204
Notice: Sec. 237(a)()A)(iii), I&N Act [8 U.S.C. 27(a)(2)(A)iii)] -
Covicted o aggravated lony a deed der ection 10a)(4)(G))
37a)(2)A)ii), I& Act [8 U.S.C. 1227)(2)(A)(ii)] -Conviced o wo or more rime inolvig mora urpitude
237(a(2)A)i), I& Act 8 .S.C. 1227a(2)(A(i -Covicted o rie nvolvin moral tuiude
APPLICATION Teition
The repodent apea te Mch 4, 204, d ch 26, 0, eciion of theIigration udge ndig him removable denying i otion to tinate The Deparmentof Hod Secity a not responded. During te endecy of e appeal, e respondentmoved e Bod accet a uplemen brief. The reondent's motin will be grted ereord w be remded
W revi ig of ct r cle eor, but qeo of la, dicrtio, and jdgmnt, dal or iu i appea, de no .F.R 03.()()i), ii).
The reponde, a native and ctizen o El Salvador, a gred law eaent reidentt i Sepembe 1996. O April , 1998, he reondent wa convicted, prut to a gilty
plea, of a violatio o MARYLAND CODE RTLE CA) 27 45c(, credit d te rwich he wa entencd to 18 on' inceration, uended; ne; n retition(e coviction recrd r reponde le Sept. 03). On ch 26, 203, e repondentwas id, 2 ps t a , ts o ioati MARYAND CODE,CIINAL LAW -202, bgla in the rt degree, r which he wa senteced 364 day'
I hi ction i w codied at MRYLAND CODE, CRINAL LAw 8-204(a)( ).
2 ere i o dispute at e rodt' 203 onvictio doe not cotitute agravatedly, bt i a CIT J at 8).
Cite as: Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
3/13
A073 674 189
coduct that falls outside the generic the oense or that dos no involve moal rpitude.Se United States v. Henriquez, 757 F.3d 44, 19 (4th ir. 204); Matter of Silva-Trevino,24 I&N Dec. 687, 690 (A.G. 2008). This realisic probability c be established by sowigh, in a leas one other case, te state cos n fac did apply the statute in he spcial(nongeneric) mer[.]" Nunez oler, 594 F.3d 1124, 1129 9 Cir. 200) (inealquoaton mk omied.
On appe, e respondn gues tha MCA 27 145(c)() is divisible d e modidcaegorical yis is approprate under Descamps v. Unted States, _U. _,33 t. 2276, 223 (2013). The rsponden gues at he pase in MCA 2 145(c)()wi inen to use it or sell it or o sr i" modies only e immediately preceding clause.Ths, h gues, under Moncrie v. Hoer, _ _, 133 t. 1678, 1684 (2013), helest of h[e] acts criminalized" does not include he inent to depriv" lguge required r ggravted lony e oense or IMT. ee atter o GarciaMarga, supra atter ofGrley, 14 I&N Dec. 330, 333 (BIA 1973) (Ordiily, a conviction r he is considered oinvolv moral itude only when a peen ing is intended.) In oer words, eresondent gues tat MA 27 145(c)() does no necessly" each conduc a icudehe intent to deprive.
Assumig, rguendo, ht e rsponden's guen is coect, where a tate satue on isfe covers conduc hat is not punishabl der te generic dniton of he crime ere musbe realisti probbility that the ta would prosecute conduct under he sa tha fallsoutide e generic denition of the removable oense o defea a cge of removaility derhe caegorical aroh. See tter of Ferreia, 26 I&N Dec. 415 (BIA 2014). For
proceedings to be termnated based on he respondent's readig of th statute, Md musacly prosecute violations of MCA 27 145(c)() i cases in which individual taesa credi cd om othr . . without he consent of he cdholder" wihout ien to deprive
e cdholder of he us of the credt cd, e.g., whee a prson misenly es oher's cd.See Moncrie v. Holder, spra; Gonzales v. unasAlvarez, 549 U.. 183, 93 (2007)(holdng at a moion o rminate hould be graned if e respondent c a leas oin o hiso case or oter case in which e stae cos in fac did appl te stae in the special(nongneric) mer r which he gues").
The Immigration Judge did not apply he realic probability" est as of his categoricalinq. Becaus uch aplication requires fc-ding, we will red he reord o theImmiation Judg r pplcation of e rlistic proability test, as dscribd in ocriee duenAlvarez See Matter of erreira, supra, a 421. On remd, the paries may ubitaddional evdence d gumnt, wch may include evidence of yld prosecutions (or thlack ereo r e of a credit cd with or whou e inent to depive h coler.
: Te ecod s eded o e Igon Judge e poceedngsconsistn wi e reoing opnion d r e e of a new dcision.
3
Cite as: Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
4/13
Md igrao iic
weeey Maueen A
"'
UNIED SAS PARTM OF USTCE
XTIV O FO MMGO REEW
IMMGAIO COUR
HPKS LAZA, OOM 440BALTMO, MD 210
50 W alme St, Ste. 36aie MD 0
Date: Ma , 204
ie A07-489
he Mae JND AUZ, EDW EE
ached is a cp he e decs he ia dge
Ts decs s a ess a appea s ake e ad
iga ppeals. e ecsed cpes f OM EO 2,
ce ppeal ad OM EO 7, t ty as ey p ppey execed s be ed e a gat ppeas ee
Te appea s e accpaed y p pa ee ($1000)
Ecsed s a cpy e a decisi
Eclsed is a ascip e esy ecd
Y ae gaed ti t sbt a e ice i sppt apea
ng
csel s gaed ti st a
-
brief i psi te appeal.
Enclosed
i a cp e de /decs he ga ge
papes led e sal e accpaed y p
sevice p ppsg csel.
Ucc DH ICE, CE O THE
3 OS PLAZ 6TH FORO M 200000
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
5/13
r
\,
UNITED SAES DEPRTME OF SICE
XCIVE E O IGO VIEW
I SES IMGO COT
BLE, YAD
H OF: I EOA OCEDGS
dw exander JS-Z # 073-674
ES
GS
C
BLF F
Scio 27a2A of gaio Naoay A Ac or A, nd i a, an i ar dmsso, ou av b covcd of agava o dnd i scio 11a43)) of Ac a a rang o a os udng rcof son ro) or bg ons r wc of imrso a as was mosd;
Seci 27a(2Ai of c, as d, a, aan ime a dsso, ou v n conicd of ocis iovg mora tiud no sig o of a s
sc of cima scoduc
Scon 2(a(2(A( of Ac, as nd, a oav convcd of a cri ioving mor udcoi wit v ars a assio r ic asnnc of o y or logr ay b osd
Rsondn's Moo o Ta Pocdgs
CE
LF As L Pawe Lae G Se Aeses d c Law
e es ssss C Cos
Cnic fc, Sie 65 Ws Bamor
Blor, 20
3 o Pza, S 6Bor, M 22
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
6/13
EI EOADU O DECISO AD OE
I. Statemen e Case
rsod is m i d citin of Sdor Dmn of
omd Sc H) c im io rmo rocdigs ro issc of
oic o A, dad gs 6, A gs sod s
o ci o aio o Uid Ss; s d ciin of Sdo () as
admid o Ud Ss or Hoson, Ts, on or abo Ags 1, 99 as a 1
ii visior; ) adus is sas o of rsid o
Smb 2, 1996 dr scio 5 of Ac; (5) as, o Ari 1 1998 conid in
Disc Co a ogom Con, and ons of crdi cd , n vioio
of CO 7, 145c) isic Co Cs Nmb D56585; 7) r os, as sc o 8 mos iccraion; 8 was, o Mc 26, 21, covicd
Ciri Co a Mngomr Co d os of s d bg in
iion of CO C LW 62 Circi Co Cas Nmbr 12074C); and (9)
s crims dd is o of sg scm of min mscodc
Sm , sod did ca gios isd abov, d
Co, bsd coicio rcors s b DHS, ssnd cgs of
robili s o A 2a)2)A)i)iii A sr conincs o a sodn oni o sc cosl, rsod, o cons, consd
Cos nding i rsc o is rmoabii d so o m rocdgs condg
a s o rab s cg T Co nsrcd s o sbi bs o
iss of rovbii, c ac y sit ig rvid ms o
bo is, dc of rcor, d icbl l, Cors dcisin d od ow
o
II vence Psene
v
o docms rcd, o y dd io ic
DS Cocio cors r sod, c Sm 1, 2
1 D i c gio 6 ig o S , 2
2
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
7/13
om Rsod o o, v cob 8, 203
Rsons oo o Ac as S Aoys ad RsnaonaSa dad Jy 8, 204
Rsonns oo, d od i Suo of o da Pa a N Pa o Ta Pocdgs o, av, o S BgSc an ang o Roay, cvd aa 22 20
Rsos Padg, da ay 22, 20
o o d b Cos so, cv by 2, 2
DS Rsos o Rsods Moo o Ta Pocgs civd c 5201
Rsons S Mo i Suor of Tnag RovaPocdgs cvd Mc 5, 204
Rsodns R o HSs Rsos o Rsodn's Moo o Taocdngs cvd c 3, 20
I osio of h aes
Rpnden
sod cods a s o ob as an vcd of a aavad
oy os s Mylad cd cd covcon in 1998 2 T spongs a sa of convicio divisib as s caus o o id ici
l, was scon caus s spccay od b n o us, s o
sf o s son, sod oss Co s ay a odd cagoca
aoc ysis , gv DSs o sbm y cods byond c of
cocon s ons, t Co us assm mimm codc qd
convcon sau, aozd ing o i n ,
sod conds is ons s consis i sods dscio of c
dyig os
RsQon civ ss a a o a snc o caon s s d bgcto , i s cosd a is ons dos o consi agaa o
bl os e I 0(a)()()
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
8/13
,
ato rspo ges ta s 998 cit c coicto is ot a e
iolg ora p C bcase t statt of coctio oes ot re itt
respec to e st clas mc less oes t re tt to eetl te oe
o e se bet o te ei ca Give a Bo of ato Aps BAs tat te covco s CT oy w a pt g s tee," ar f
Graz I&N e , 33 B 9) eot ots at statte of
cvictio s ovebra ecomassig o CMT oCIMT oeses ter is o
ctgorcly a T. Acorigy, t spoe as at s 1998 ri c
cco coses ter aaate foy or a CMT, s tere o
roabl pst o A 27a2)A)-)
S cs a e resps 998 it coitio is
agavat flo e oese as e b A 1(a3)G Spcy S
es a te ets of et c e cotaie e l sta ol
eivat o os f ge as se f aciaarg, 2 & ec 36
BA 28, e ese e e stae s categocaly agaae loy
a CMT respe to e S sms at t to erie a e e
o e oe xprss tes of e sate. Accorigl te S sbmts at e espo s
oale s cge
V nalysis Fidg
e or cose s of b pis r ecor cl
Te Co as r al ec f o spcy scss s cso
Base o e llowig, te Co s tat t respoet is oabe pst to al
ree gs of reoalit e A 27a)2Aii aie coict of
gava the e A 4G two CTs t sg o a
se se a sc a CT comd e years ar dission
3 s iefs e epode s e e C so cos s i eateoppose s e ot ecase e H ie t e a ely resoe 8C 32a wev v e cople e ega sss rase by e
rest's covos a i e ies of arig a ll a copete resoltio of tetter, o cce Ss tey espose
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
9/13
c
r wc a sc of on o ogr a iosd Fo rasons s bow
o s rsodns oion o Tia rocdig ad nd a is roa
a cg
Th so's 1998 rt r hevt n gra flony th ons dned bv A 10J4G rnden h reo so A 237((2(A)
T o n w rsods cd d concio s
aad fo nd cagoc aoach i aoac aows h Co o ook on
o of cia sa a iss and co m o s of r
d ofroa g Tayl i a495U.S 575 (1990). ra
d s aac o a no iqr ino facs f os b w x
ns rqd ss onio Dcap i S 133 S. 2276
2283 (203) f s is isb sc a cds cndc a s cndd
agaad f o mu s odd cagoca aroach S g i
a m60 F3d 14 4 ir 2012) P s aac Co a o o
o of conico d oh r dos t dn if os s aaad
on. S Shpad id Sa, 54 3, 00)
onn was coicd nd M COE 2, 14(c))4 wic is
cnica diisi w ons inoig a naoizd aing of a cdi c ados inon ci of a sn cri c ow oh nss ino coc
ha co aaad fon ons as dnd b NA 1(a(43G
a o aiaaga 24 N c a 3 (n s of a s
n INA 01((4(G);a oBaha c 381 30 (BIA 000) (sg
c dnon ofc of o wn A 10(a)(43)(G) Accod
o az h rso cno d cagorca aac S m
0 F at 20
COE A 4loi a a cois ci c wn
ak a m a pson r he pssessin c cnl foh wou e c w, w knowlg a as s ci ci i s i or o s o o sf a son o is r cho
M CO 27 c) is no coi a E A LW 82a(
5
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
10/13
A e w he ein o IA 01()(43)() cssts fe tng or xrce
o n ovr ppy wthut nsent d with e mal ent t v owner of e
rs d bet o oner dain s e t tta or pnt"
a of aciaadga 24 N D. a 36; alo Solma oal 49 F3276
83 4 C. 200) e May a py pbs aoer
wu nt or wy v a ed d a a be ten whut e
odr' nt w te tt ue el, or fer t r teeby dri e
tre cld h bene ownerhip rd. , crdt n
d nude f h elt en th r pse o IA 0(a)(43)(G).
Howv respd cond at e t cus a cred cd o
n r e esn cusdy r f h h e cod
cnt"lk a a pn M CO . 2 14()( ) (ms aded)
wrds e rendn es a e re it ne use t r t sel t r t trf
" mode onl e mmedael ecd cu, h knodg tha a be o
cv the ed " M COE A. 27 4()() (pha aded). e C
a w t pnen' tpreton
I Soima v. oa the o Crut inereted t Vra redt d e
a, te elt whc nt aterly drent om COE 2 5(c)()S F3d at 284; coma Va. Code 82192()) wh M CO 27
()(). Te r tte y dent to he Myd tatut nd provdes tha a
o is lty edt d e h e
ts obts or wh a credit cd r redt cd nmer m he ersnposs, utdy or ono oh wiout e dler cst r ho, nwee a i a ben o en, baned r whl eeves rdd or ed d ber tt e t or ell t, o trer to aps e e uer o he hoder
Va Coe n 921)) Noa, h o C intrt the nten t in the
Vr ae, hh ow a ia a a a of Mla tatt, ap to
woe ubeco Solima 9 3 at 284
Moreoe, h nie Sae Sr Co h mntrae a ron rrne r
din a arermen o lmen o t in a rn atue e he one
6
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
11/13
no xprssy iud. S O Sta, 724 Ad 43, 46-8 . 99) sg as
ang S Co's poiy of oin icso f a arqren n
irtg a cia tas also Moriss Uid Sas 34 US 26 202
(95; al id Sas 5 US 60 68- (1) s cl ae cns a n se ing s a e i r o vt
cming nnt onuc S Laoa i e 71 S , 45- (98.
Fr , i was n ren n cuabii ath the cr o r
c i Mad, h erso h ccd ck di a
dng resar o ayng r song a a ore, sg i r s r r ,
b l f d e the st Inreg the st i sc a m d
trre ad o a sd esl r e M Cor f As tt t []
rr t csd h cd wi cuabl se s o n
jrdnce" Gt a, 32 2 7, 80 (d. 193). i
M COD A 7 5(( inclve o n en cab o
nry of sbscon, v i e nn n ai on da
cn ca, h or n aoi o r nn a
sscon oa, 419 3d a 283 (stor oiio o b ra a o)
cod, e or a rson nvion r c s
avd on ons in meg INA a)(3(G) d e h
rob NA 37a)(2))()
e respondent 198 ci cr the cnvicn a T enerin him bleusuant INA 27aA and i)
rsode credi c onvcio s so cagorl a T BIAh
d t C re gna coduc a s inherly , l r a d
con a r o morai s owed bee ons o c in
ga a oao 24 & ec 2 33 (A 6); s ao a o a 2 N
c 2 292-3 BA 6 s e s a o cey o oe oa
a o, 24 N a 33 owv, rson onn a
con t c s o a e s o n er
peatly drve oer f s a e Co ises
7
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
12/13
c
e B in of Judoheld that the ae etal the Penyla i uh
at t is eae t aue t e ti i th te tet etni e echdie
netl." 2 N De at 3 s so a o V-ZS- 2 &N ec 33 30 IA
200) (tn tt pei ntent t peanenty eve ay be eued wee a punlawy e attet t te e oey te) ut te ae etal e s
h t it i enable t e e ti i it intent eet deve s e
e edi d e a t eaable t e whe e es eeie the credt
cd e iut oet e tent is t s etl til e ccll
te le w t s i util t sily er able t e se. .
le e rendt ted at the cts dl hi e ee e eult
iutd te e utupon
ductn a cate lys e
e de nt lk eyd e tatute vct. S Descmps 33 S Ct. t 2283 v
e a ie tec ah alsi the u wuld t cside exic evee
u e endent' ectt e ni cdut ud hi vct.
S odgo Hol 706 3 3 78 ( Ci 03
It well etalhed d the e t ute tht buy wt tt t
th i CI ae of T 2 &N ec t 2; a oFsc 8 IN
24 (BIA 8) The rt deee burly tatte i ld dvsle eee ee
ilin wth iet t it the d bula with itet t it a rie
vee. Se E ANN Lw 6202(a) Hee the idiet aiibe
Sar-apved duent ude te ded teal aaetalhe at te
Rendent victd e ivlvn ulay wth intent t it the. Se
S Cc Reod t 5e so Shd U.S. at 2 e the eset'
ul v a ttute a C Acdly e edt's ovtn eit
d te i CT red h vable ut t A 37(a)(2)(A(i (i).
V cs
in eeed a of h aalae d o n a hreoen' 8
yld edit d the cvictin i a aavat lny e vitn deed y A
0a)43G) edei vae puu t 23(a)((A(i eve the
d th te epndent' 8 aynd eit cd the ton i ne t C
vt onh red wc a te in ve yea ad endn
8
-
7/26/2019 Edwin Alexander Jandres-Aguiluz, A073 674 189 (BIA Nov. 13, 2014)
13/13
rov st to INA 27a2A Aon, rsond s
rov as h d oon o s
R
s by ord :
I ron oon o n s N
II sondnt s rovb o Savaor as h
9
lad
n Sts on Judo,