electrical and i&c codes and inspection · implementation of design requirements numark...

111
ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION 1 Numark Associates, Inc. Day 7

Upload: others

Post on 27-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

ELECTRICAL AND I&CCODES AND INSPECTION

1Numark Associates, Inc.

Day 7

Page 2: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

DAY 7

Sessions:15. Digital I&C Standards

Student Activity: Mapping the Standards

2Numark Associates, Inc.

16. Instrument Setpoints/Standards

Student Activity: Sources of Uncertainty

17. Fiber Optic Standards

Page 3: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

15. Digital I&C Standards

3Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 4: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

15. Digital I&C StandardsObjectives

• Identify the major digital I&C standards

Pro ide a general o er ie of the

4Numark Associates, Inc.

• Provide a general overview of the purpose of these standards

• Discuss how these standards relate to new reactor inspection

Page 5: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

15. Digital I&C Standards

• IEEE Std 603 Safety Systems

• IEEE Std 7-4 3 2 Digital Computers in

5Numark Associates, Inc.

• IEEE Std 7-4.3.2 Digital Computers in Safety Systems

Page 6: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

15. Digital I&C Standards

IEEE Stds:• 828 Software Configuration Management

Plans

• 830 Software Requirements Specification

6Numark Associates, Inc.

q p

• 829 Software Test Documentation

• 1012 Software Verification & Validation

• 12207 Software Life Cycle Processes

Page 7: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Digital I&C Standards - Introduction

• The performance of analog systems can typically be predicted by the use of engineering models.

• These models can also be used to predict the regions over which an analog system exhibits continuous performance

7Numark Associates, Inc.

continuous performance.

• The abilities to analyze design using models based on physics principles and to use these models to establish a reasonable expectation of continuous performance over substantial ranges of input conditions are important factors in the qualification of analog systems design.

Page 8: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Digital I&C Standards - Introduction

• These factors enable extensive use of type testing, acceptance testing, and inspection of design outputs in qualifying the design of analog systems and components.

• If the design process assures continuous behavior

8Numark Associates, Inc.

• If the design process assures continuous behavior over a fixed range of inputs, and testing at a finite sample of input conditions in each of the continuous ranges demonstrates acceptable performance, performance at intermediate input values between the sampled test points can be inferred to be acceptable with a high degree of confidence.

Page 9: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Digital I&C Standards - Introduction

• Digital I&C systems are fundamentally different from analog I&C systems in that minor errors in design and implementation can cause them to exhibit unexpected behavior.

• Consequently the performance of digital systems

9Numark Associates, Inc.

Consequently, the performance of digital systems over the entire range of input conditions cannot generally be inferred from testing at a sample of input conditions.

• Inspections, type testing, and acceptance testing of digital systems and components do not alone accomplish design qualification at high confidence levels.

Page 10: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Digital I&C Standards - Introduction

• To address this issue, the review of design qualification for digital systems focuses to a large extent on confirming that the applicant/licensee employed a high-quality development process that incorporated disciplined specification and implementation of design requirements

10Numark Associates, Inc.

implementation of design requirements.

• Inspection and testing are used to verify correct implementation and to validate desired functionality of the final product, but confidence that isolated, discontinuous point failures will not occur derives from the discipline of the development process.

Page 11: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Digital I&C Standards - Introduction

• In digital I&C safety systems, code, data transmission, data, and hardware may be common to several functions to a greater degree than is

11Numark Associates, Inc.

g gtypical in analog systems.

• This commonality is the basis for many of the advantages of digital systems.

Page 12: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Digital I&C Standards - Introduction

• However, the commonality introduces a CCF concern: a design using shared data or code has the potential to propagate a CCF via software errors, thus defeating the redundancy achieved by the hardware architectural structure.

12Numark Associates, Inc.

• Greater commonality or sharing of hardware among functions within a channel increases the consequences of the failure of a single hardware module and reduces the amount of diversity available within a single safety channel.

Page 13: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Digital I&C Standards - Introduction

• Because of this CCF concern, review of digital I&C protection systems emphasizes quality, diversity, and defense-in-depth as protection against propagation of CCFs

ithi d b t f ti

13Numark Associates, Inc.

within and between functions.

• Additional guidance on assessment of diversity and defense-in-depth is provided in SRP BTP 7-19.

Page 14: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software Review Process

14Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 15: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software Review Process

• Audits of design outputs confirm that functional requirements are traceablethrough all intermediate design products to the final product.

15Numark Associates, Inc.

• Audits of design outputs also confirm that the software development process characteristics and the required software functional characteristics are present.

Page 16: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software Review Process

• The conformance of the hardware and software to the functional and process requirements derived from the design bases is audited.

• A sample of software design outputs should be reviewed to confirm that they address the functional requirements allocated to the software, and that the expected software development process characteristics are evident in the design

16Numark Associates, Inc.

goutputs.

• The review of validation and installation activities should include confirmation of the adequacy of the system test procedures and test results (validation tests, site acceptance tests, pre-operational and start-up tests) that provide assurance that the system functions as intended.

• SRP BTP 7-14, subsection B.3.3, describes functional characteristics and software development process characteristics that are verified by these audits.

Page 17: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software Life Cycle Activities

17Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 18: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software - Definitions

• Software: Computer programs, procedures, and associated documentation and data pertaining to the operation of a computer system.

• Software Maintenance: (1) Modification of a f f f

18Numark Associates, Inc.

software product after delivery to correct faults, to improve performance or other attributes, or to adapt the product to a modified environment. (2) The set of activities that takes place to ensure that software installed for operational use continues to perform as intended and fulfill its intended role in system operation. Software maintenance includes improvements, aid to users, and related activities.

Page 19: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software - Definitions

• Hazard Analysis: A process that explores and identifies conditions that are not identified by the normal design review and testing process. The scope of hazard analysis extends beyond plant design basis

19Numark Associates, Inc.

y y p gevents by including abnormal events and plant operations with degraded equipment and plant systems. Hazard analysis focuses on system failure mechanisms rather than verifying correct system operation.

Page 20: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software - Definitions

• Verification: (1) The process of evaluating a system or component to determine whether the products of a given development phase satisfy the conditions imposed at the start of that phase. (2) Formal proof of program correctness.

• Validation: The process of evaluating a system or

20Numark Associates, Inc.

p g ycomponent during or at the end of the development process to determine whether it satisfies specified requirements.

• Verification and Validation (V&V): The process of determining whether the requirements for a system or component are complete and correct, the products of each development phase fulfill the requirements or conditions imposed by the previous phase, and the final system or component complies with specified requirements.

Page 21: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 603 Safety Systems

21Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 22: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 603 Safety Systems

• Minimum functional and design criteria for the power, instrumentation, and control

• Systems required to mitigate the consequences of design basis events

22Numark Associates, Inc.

• Promote safety system performance and reliability

• Also applicable to equipment provided for safe shutdown, post accident monitoring display instrumentation, preventive interlock features, and other systems, structures, or components related to safety

Page 23: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 7-4.3.2 Digital Computers in Safety Systems

23Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 24: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 7-4.3.2 Digital Computers in Safety Systems

• Computer specific requirements to supplement IEEE Std 603-1998

• Scope: Computer hardware, software, firmware,

24Numark Associates, Inc.

and interfaces

• Minimum functional and design requirements for computers used as components of a safety system

• RG 1.152 (with exceptions & clarifications)

Page 25: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

25Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 26: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 7-4.3.2 Digital Computers in Safety Systems

26Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 27: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 7-4.3.2 Digital Computers in Safety Systems

• The use of software quality metrics shall be considered throughout the software life cycle to assess whether software quality requirements are being met. When software quality metrics are used, the following life cycle phase characteristics should be considered:

— Correctness/Completeness (Requirements phase)

27Numark Associates, Inc.

— Compliance with requirements (Design phase)

— Compliance with design (Implementation phase)

Page 28: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 7-4.3.2 Digital Computers in Safety Systems

— Functional compliance with requirements (Test and Integration phase)

— Onsite functional compliance with requirements (Installation and Checkout phase)

28Numark Associates, Inc.

— Performance history (Operation and Maintenance phase)

The basis for the metrics selected to evaluate software quality characteristics should be included in the software development documentation.

Page 29: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 828 Software Configuration Management Plans

29Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 30: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 828 Software Configuration Management Plans

• Minimum required contents of plan

• Defines activities and requirements for

30Numark Associates, Inc.

• Defines activities and requirements for any portion of a software products life cycle

• RG 1.169 (with exceptions & clarifications)

Page 31: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 828 Software Configuration Management Plans

31Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 32: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 830 Software Requirements

Specifications

32Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 33: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 830 Software Requirements Specifications

• Qualities of a good software requirements specification (SRS)

33Numark Associates, Inc.

• Software requirements specifications outlines

• Commercial or in-house software products

• RG 1.170 (with exceptions & clarifications)

Page 34: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 830 Software Requirements Specifications

• software requirements specification (SRS): Documentation of the essential requirements (functions, performance, design constraints, and attributes) of the software and its external interfaces

34Numark Associates, Inc.

• software design description (SDD): A representation of software created to facilitate analysis, planning, implementation, and decision-making. The software design description is used as a medium for communicating software design information and may be thought of as a blueprint or model of the system.

Page 35: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 830 Software Requirements Specifications

• An SRS should:

– Correctly define all of the software requirements. A software requirement may exist because of the nature of the task to be solved or because of a special characteristic of the project.

– Not describe any design or implementation details; these

35Numark Associates, Inc.

y g p ;should be described in the design stage of the project.

– Not impose additional constraints on the software; these are properly specified in other documents such as a software quality assurance plan.

• Therefore, a properly written SRS limits the range of valid designs, but does not specify any particular design.

Page 36: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 830 Software Requirements Specifications

• An SRS should be:

– Correct

– Unambiguous

– Complete

36Numark Associates, Inc.

– Consistent

– Ranked for importance and/or stability

– Verifiable

– Modifiable

– Traceable

Page 37: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 829 Software Test Documentation

37Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 38: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 829 Software Test Documentation

• Basic test documents associated with software testing

38Numark Associates, Inc.

• Defines the purpose, outline and content of each basic document

• RG 1.170 (with exceptions & clarifications)

Page 39: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 829 Software Test Documentation

• Test Design Specification: A document specifying the details of the test approach for a software feature or combination of software features and identifying the associated tests.

39Numark Associates, Inc.

• Test Case Specification: A document specifying inputs, predicted results, and a set of execution conditions for a test item

• Test Procedure Specification: A document specifying a sequence of actions for the execution of the test

Page 40: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 829 Software Test Documentation

• Test Plan • Test-Design Specification• Test-Case Specification• Test Procedure Specification

40Numark Associates, Inc.

• Test-Procedure Specification• Test-Item Transmittal Report• Test Log• Test-Incident Report• Test-Summary Report

Page 41: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 829 Software Test Plan Outline

1. Test Plan Identifier2. Introduction3. Test Items4 Features Tested

41Numark Associates, Inc.

4. Features Tested5. Features not Tested6. Approach7. Pass/Fail Criteria8. Suspension Criteria & Resumption

Requirements

Page 42: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 829 SoftwareTest Plan Outline

9. Test Deliverables10. Testing Tasks11. Environmental Needs

42Numark Associates, Inc.

12. Responsibilities13. Staffing and Training Needs14. Schedule15. Risks and Contingencies16. Approvals

Page 43: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1012 Software Verification and Validation

43Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 44: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1012 Software Verification and Validation

• Software V&V life cycle process requirements for different integrity levels

44Numark Associates, Inc.

levels

• The scope encompasses software-based systems, computer software, hardware, and interfaces.

Page 45: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1012 Software Verification and Validation

• Software development, maintenance, or reuse

Includes firmware microcode and

45Numark Associates, Inc.

• Includes firmware, microcode, and documentation

• Includes analysis, evaluation, review, inspection, assessment, and testing

Page 46: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1012 Software Verification and Validation - Definitions

• Independent Verification and Validation (IV&V): V&V performed by an organization

46Numark Associates, Inc.

(IV&V): V&V performed by an organization that is technically, managerially, and financially independent of the development organization.

Page 47: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

47Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 48: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 12207 Software Life Cycle

Processes

48Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 49: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 12207 Software Life Cycle Processes

• Common Framework

• Applications:– Acquisition of systems and software products

d i

49Numark Associates, Inc.

and services– Supply, development operation, maintenance,

and disposal of software products– Software portion of a system

• Joint project of IEEE/EIA and ISO/IEC

Page 50: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 12207 Software Life Cycle Processes

• The purpose of this International Standard is to provide a defined set of processes to facilitate communication among acquirers, suppliers, and other stakeholders in the life cycle of a software product

50Numark Associates, Inc.

cycle of a software product.

• Written for acquirers of systems and software products and services and for suppliers, developers, operators, maintainers, managers, quality assurance managers, and users of software products.

Page 51: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 12207 Software Life Cycle Processes

• Provides over 50 definitions of terms used in commercial agreements and documentation

• Provides detailed definition of various

51Numark Associates, Inc.

Provides detailed definition of various processes associated with software life cycle activities

• Does not detail documentation in terms of name, format, explicit content, and recording media

Page 52: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Inspection of Digital I&C

52Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 53: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Inspection of Digital I&C

Inspection Procedure 52003, “Digital Instrumentation And Control Modification Inspection”

• NRR evaluates the applicant’s design (vendor design) as part of the safety evaluation process

53Numark Associates, Inc.

design) as part of the safety evaluation process

• Regional inspectors perform documentation and functionality reviews after the system leaves the vendor

• Regional inspectors review specific documentation to gain familiarity with the system, but should not duplicate NRR review efforts

Page 54: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Inspection of Digital I&C

• Verify that the as-installed digital modification is in accordance with the NRC SER, design drawings, and licensee commitments

• Verify that surveillance, abnormal operating, emergency operating and alarm response procedures have been updated and correctly reflect the new system attributes

54Numark Associates, Inc.

updated, and correctly reflect the new system attributes

• Verify that plant drawings, the UFSAR [FSAR], and other relevant documentation have been updated to reflect the replacement system. In those cases where the update to the UFSAR and other relevant documentation has not been completed, ensure that the process is underway, and is properly planned and proceeding in a timely manner.

Page 55: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Inspection of Digital I&C

• Adequacy and quality of the power and grounding system

• Electrostatic discharge (ESD) precautions and considerations have been incorporated into relevant procedures, and are followed.

B tt i b dd d i th t h ld b

55Numark Associates, Inc.

• Batteries embedded in the system should be on a periodic replacement schedule, if recommended by the battery manufacturer. This includes batteries used for battery backed random access memory (RAM).

• The handling and storage requirements of spare system parts are consistent with manufacturer and licensee requirements (periodic power-up, battery life, etc.).

Page 56: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Inspection of Digital I&C

• Determine if the licensee implemented any special procedures for ensuring that stored parts will be correctly handled (such as ensuring stored chips with embedded software are the correct revision).

• Inspect the installation environment and verify that

56Numark Associates, Inc.

p ythe licensee-specified environmental parameters accurately reflect the installation environment.

• Review the software test plan in accordance with BTP 7-14, Section B.3.1.12, and determine if the software test plan is sufficiently detailed to provide site acceptance tests, installation tests, and startup tests for the digital system.

Page 57: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Inspection of Digital I&C

• Review the procedures for the SAT, installation test, and start-up tests; and review the final V&V reports on these test procedures.

• Determine if the SAT will adequately test the licensee (not vendor) system specification and that

57Numark Associates, Inc.

licensee (not vendor) system specification, and that the test procedures are sufficiently detailed, clear, and unambiguous to allow site personnel to perform this test.

• Review any hardware and software failures that have occurred to determine if they were properly resolved or if there are system weaknesses that require correction

Page 58: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Inspection of Digital I&C

• Verify that setpoints and related uncertainty terms have been adequately evaluated and reflect the system requirements, and have been accurately installed in the software. Request the licensee to download the current system setpoints and coefficients to a selected sample and compare

58Numark Associates, Inc.

coefficients to a selected sample and compare these to the system requirements documentation.

Page 59: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Student Activity

Student Activity: Mapping the Digital I&C Standards to Software Life Cycle Activities

59Numark Associates, Inc.

Activities

Page 60: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Software Life Cycle Activities

60Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 61: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

15. Digital I&C StandardsObjectives Review

• Identified the major digital I&C standards

61Numark Associates, Inc.

• Provided a general overview of the purpose of these standards

• Discussed how these standards relate to new reactor inspection

Page 62: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

16. Instrument Setpoints

62Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 63: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

16. Instrument Setpoints Objectives

• Identify setpoint standards and guidance

63Numark Associates, Inc.

• Provide a general overview of the purpose of the setpoint standards

• Discuss how these standards relate to new reactor inspection

Page 64: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

16. Instrument Setpoints – Standards & Practices

• International Society of Automation (ISA) (formerly Instrument Society of America)

• ANSI/ISA-67.04.01, Setpoints for Nuclear Safety R l t d I t t ti (A t d b RG 1 105 ith

64Numark Associates, Inc.

Related Instrumentation (Accepted by RG 1.105 with some exceptions/clarifications)

• ISA-RP67.04.02, Methodologies for the Determination of Setpoints for Nuclear Safety-Related Instrumentation (Guidance/background)

Page 65: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Definitions

• Limiting Safety System Settings (LSSS) for nuclear reactors are settings for automatic protective devices related to those variables having significant safety functions. Where a limiting safety system setting is specified for a variable on which a safety

65Numark Associates, Inc.

g p ylimit has been placed, the setting must be so chosen that automatic protective action will correct the abnormal situation before a safety limit is exceeded (10 CFR 50.36-2002).

Page 66: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Definitions

• Uncertainty: The amount to which an instrument channel’s output is in doubt (or the allowance made for such doubt) due to possible errors, either random or

66Numark Associates, Inc.

systematic. The uncertainty is generally identified within a probability and confidence level.

Page 67: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints - Relationships

67Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 68: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints –More Definitions

• Safety Limit (SL): A limit on an important process variable that is necessary to reasonably protect the integrity of physical barriers that guard against the uncontrolled release of radioactivity. (See 10 CFR 50.36[c][1][i][A].)

• Analytical limit (AL): limit of a measured or calculated variable established by the safety analysis to ensure that a safety limit is

68Numark Associates, Inc.

y y y ynot exceeded.

• Trip Setpoint - Trip setpoints are chosen to assure that a trip or safety actuation occurs before the process reaches the AL. Trip setpoints are also chosen to assure that the plant can operate and experience expected operational transients without unnecessary trips or safeguards actuations.

Page 69: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints –More Definitions

• Limiting Trip setpoint (LTSP): The limiting value for the nominal trip setpoint so that the trip or actuation will occur before the AL is reached, regardless of the process or environmental conditions affecting the instrumentation.

69Numark Associates, Inc.

g

• Nominal Trip setpoint (NTSP): A predetermined value for actuation of a final setpoint device to initiate a protective action.

Page 70: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – More Definitions

• The choice of a LTSP requires determining the Total Loop Uncertainty (TLU).

• The TLU represents the expected performance of the instrumentation under any applicable process and environmental conditions.

70Numark Associates, Inc.

• The trip or actuation is only required to mitigate certain postulated events; therefore, only the process and environmental conditions that occur during the postulated events (e.g., LOCA) need be considered.

Page 71: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – More Definitions

• The LTSP and NTSP for a trip or actuation on an increasingprocess variable would be:

LTSP = AL – TLU

NTSP = AL – TLU – Margin

71Numark Associates, Inc.

• “Margin” is discretionary or may be chosen based on the methodology applied.

• Data used to calculate the TLU should be obtained from appropriate sources, which may include: operating experience, equipment qualification tests, equipment specifications, engineering analysis, laboratory tests, and engineering drawings. The TLU shall account for the effects of all applicable design-basis events and process instrument uncertainties (unless they were included in the determination of the analytical limit).

Page 72: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints - Uncertainties

72Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 73: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Digital Uncertainties

• Sampling rate uncertainty: The sampling rate must be 2 X the analog signal bandwidth, to be a good representation of the analog input signal containing all of the

73Numark Associates, Inc.

g g gsignificant information.

- If the analog signal contains frequencies that are too high with respect to the sampling rate, aliasing uncertainty will be introduced. Anti-aliasing band-limiting filters can be used to minimize the aliasing uncertainty; otherwise, it must be accounted for in setpoint calculations.

Page 74: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Digital Uncertainties

• Signal reconstruction uncertainty: Some information is lost when the digitized signal is sampled and held for conversion back to analog form after digital manipulation. This uncertainty is typically linear and about ± 1/2 least significant bit (LSB).

74Numark Associates, Inc.

• Jitter Uncertainty: The samples of the input signal are taken at periodic intervals. If the sampling periods are not stable, an uncertainty corresponding to the sampled signal’s rate-of-change will be introduced. [Insignificant if the clock is crystal-controlled]

Page 75: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Digital Uncertainties

• Digitizing (or Quantizing) Uncertainty: When the input signal is sampled, a digital word is generated that represents the amplitude of the signal at that time. The signal voltage must be divided into a finite number of levels that can be defined by a digital word “n” bits long. This word will describe 2n different voltage steps.

The signal le els bet een these steps ill go

75Numark Associates, Inc.

- The signal levels between these steps will go undetected. The digitizing uncertainty can be expressed in terms of the total mean square error voltage between the exact and the quantized samples of the signal.

- An inherent digitizing uncertainty of ± 1/2 LSB typically exists. The higher the number of bits in the conversion process, the smaller the digitizing uncertainty.

Page 76: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Digital Uncertainties

• Computational uncertainties could also exist (e.g., curve fit using numerical methods for thermocouple characterization).

76Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 77: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – More Definitions

• Allowable Value (AV): A limiting value that the trip setpoint may have when tested periodically, beyond which appropriate action shall be taken.

• As Found (AF): The condition in which a channel, or portion of a channel, is found after a period of operation and before recalibration (if necessary).

77Numark Associates, Inc.

• As Left (AL): The condition in which a channel, or portion of a channel, is left after calibration or final setpoint device setpoint verification.

• Drift: A variation in sensor or instrument channel output that may occur between calibrations that cannot be related to changes in the process variable or environmental conditions.

Page 78: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Calculations

• Safety-related calculations must be performed to account for these uncertainties in determining specific setpoints.

• Calculations for RTS and ESFAS setpoints are t i ll f d b th NSSS d

78Numark Associates, Inc.

typically performed by the NSSS vendor.

• However, for all setpoint calculations, it must be assured that plant-specific calibration procedures and the installation conditions are consistent with the assumptions, design inputs, and results of the setpoint calculations.

Page 79: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Calculations

• Square-Root-of-the-Sum-of-Squares (SRSS) Method

It is acceptable to combine uncertainties that are random, normally distributed, and independent by the SRSS method.

When two independent uncertainties, (± a) and (± b), are combined by this method, the resulting uncertainty is (± c),

h

79Numark Associates, Inc.

where: • c = SQRT(a² + b²)

• Arithmetic Method

Combine uncertainties that are not random, not normally distributed, or are dependent by the arithmetic method.

In this method, the combination of two dependent uncertainties, (+a, -b) and (+c, -d), results in a third uncertainty distribution with limits + (a+c), - (b+d).

Page 80: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints – Attributes

Student Activity: Sources of Uncertainty

80Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 81: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

Instrument Setpoints - Uncertainties

81Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 82: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

16. Instrument SetpointsObjectives Review

• Identified the major setpoint standard

82Numark Associates, Inc.

• Provided a general overview of the purpose of the setpoint standard

• Discussed how this standard relates to new reactor inspection

Page 83: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

17. Fiber Optic Standards

83Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 84: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

17. Fiber Optic StandardsObjectives

• Identify the major fiber optic standards of interest to NRC

P id l i f th

84Numark Associates, Inc.

• Provide a general overview of the purpose of these standards

• Discuss how these standards relate to new reactor inspection

Page 85: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

17. Fiber Optic Standards

IEEE Stds:

• 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

85Numark Associates, Inc.

• 1590 Electrical Protection of Fiber Optic Communication Facilities

• P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

Page 86: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• All-dielectric, nonmetallic, self-supporting fiber optic (ADSS) cable.

• Scope:

86Numark Associates, Inc.

p– Construction, mechanical, electrical, and optical

performance

– Installation guidelines, acceptance criteria, test requirements, environmental considerations

– Dielectric capabilities of the cable components

– Maintenance of optical fiber integrity

Page 87: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

Cautions:– The standard does not purport to address

all of the safety issues associated with its

87Numark Associates, Inc.

use.

– It is the responsibility of the user to establish appropriate safety and health practices and to determine the applicability of regulatory limitations prior to use.

Page 88: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• The ADSS cable shall consist of coated glass optical fibers contained in a protective dielectric fiber optic unit surrounded by or attached to suitable dielectric strength members and jackets.

• The cable shall not contain metallic components

88Numark Associates, Inc.

• The cable shall not contain metallic components.

• The cable shall be designed to meet the design requirements of the optical cable under all installation conditions, operating temperatures, and environmental loading.

Page 89: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• Manufacturer Tests

– Cable Tests

89Numark Associates, Inc.

– Fiber Tests

Page 90: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• Cable Tests:– Water blocking– Seepage of filling/flooding compound– Electrical tests– Aeolian vibration (from crosswinds)– Galloping

90Numark Associates, Inc.

p g– Sheave– Crush– Impact– Creep– Stress/strain– Temperature cycle– Cable aging– Ultraviolet resistance

Page 91: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• Fiber Tests

– Attenuation

91Numark Associates, Inc.

– Water peak

– Temperature cycling

Page 92: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• Color coding is essential for identifying individual optical fibers and groups of

92Numark Associates, Inc.

individual optical fibers and groups of optical fibers. The colors shall be in accordance with TIA/EIA 598-A-1995

Page 93: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• The SOCC is a descriptive code that offers a relatively complete mechanical and optical definition in a minimum number of characters

• The SOCC characters are imprinted on the cable jacket The code has three fields:

93Numark Associates, Inc.

jacket. The code has three fields:

M1 M2 S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 N N N

• The first field, M1 M2, is a manufacturer codedefined by either the manufacturer or the user.

Page 94: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• The middle field, S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6, is a structural description where each alphanumeric character carries information about the cable structure.

S1 - type of fiber

94Numark Associates, Inc.

ypS2 - cable unit type S3 - cable structure unit; identifies the number of

working fibers per unit S4 - mechanical configuration S5 - maximum rated cable load (MRCL) S6 - defines the cable jacket suitable for

application in electrical fields

Page 95: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• The last field NNN, indicates the number of working fibers in the cable. Nonworking

95Numark Associates, Inc.

of working fibers in the cable. Nonworking fibers are not counted.

Page 96: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• The installation techniques and equipment for ADSS cable correspond to those normally used for overhead lines. It is recommended that the manufacturer’s

96Numark Associates, Inc.

recommended installation procedures be used for the installation of ADSS cable.

• Refer to IEEE Std 524TM-1980 [B15] for additional details on installation techniques.

Page 97: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1222 Self Supporting Fiber Optic Cable

• The strength of the electric field where ADSS cable is installed will have an effect on the performance of the cable.

• Where possible, ADSS cable should be located in areas of minimum electric field strengths.

• Electrical stress will contribute to the aging of the outer jacket, the electric field strengths must be taken into consideration

97Numark Associates, Inc.

the electric field strengths must be taken into consideration when determining the type of cable jacket which will be required.

• ADSS cables are designed with different type jackets for use in the varying electric fields, and the proper jacket must be used in order for the cable to provide the expected service life

.

Page 98: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1590 Electrical Protection of Fiber Optic Communication Facilities

98Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 99: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1590 Electrical Protection of Fiber Optic Communication Facilities

• Engineering design of optical fiber communication facilities

99Numark Associates, Inc.

• Methods for providing telecommunication facilities serving electric supply locations

Page 100: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1590 Electrical Protection of Fiber Optic Communication Facilities

• During a power fault that occurs externally to an electric supply location, some portion of the fault current will return to the power systems source(s) of generating power in the network, through the electrical supply location grid impedance.

• This may cause a large increase in potential to be developed in and around the electric supply location i e

100Numark Associates, Inc.

developed in and around the electric supply location, i.e., ground potential rise (GPR) zone of influence (ZOI), with respect to remote earth locations.

• This GPR will result in current flowing into the wire-line networks or the power system neutral or any metallic infrastructures connected to the grid under study.

• For communication facilities, this creates a “transferred voltage” condition

Page 101: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1590 Electrical Protection of Fiber Optic Communication Facilities

• A properly engineered and installed all-dielectric optical fiber cable will provide

101Numark Associates, Inc.

immunity from the effects of fault-produced GPR and induction, as well as lightning-induced phenomena, at these locations.

Page 102: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std 1590 Electrical Protection of Fiber Optic Communication Facilities

• The optical fiber cable(s) shall be all-dielectric, i.e., the cable(s) do not contain metallic members, including copper pairs.

102Numark Associates, Inc.

• There shall not be any metallic wires placed along or near the optical fiber cable(s).

• The optical fiber cable shall be in conduit (PVC Schedule 80 minimum).

Page 103: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

103Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 104: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

• This Draft Standard is Not Publicly Available.

104Numark Associates, Inc.

Page 105: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

• Provides general requirements, directions, and methods for qualifying Class 1E fiber optic cables, terminations, field splices, and connectors [fusion or mechanical] for service in nuclear power generating stations

Cables optical fibers and splices within or integral to other

105Numark Associates, Inc.

• Cables, optical fibers and splices within or integral to other devices (e.g., instruments, panels, etc.) shall be qualified using the requirements in the applicable device standard or IEEE Std 323-2003, as appropriate.

• However, this standard’s requirements may be applied to the fiber optic cable, terminations, field splices, and connectors within these devices.

Page 106: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

• Primary objective of qualification

106Numark Associates, Inc.

– Demonstrate that the cables and components for which a qualified life has been established can perform its safety functions without experiencing CCF before, during, and after applicable design basis events

Page 107: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

• Principles of qualification

T t ti

107Numark Associates, Inc.

– Type testing

– Operating experience

– Analysis (analysis alone is not acceptable)

Page 108: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

• Analysis is used only as a supplement to type testing and / or operating experience

– Support test assumptions and results– Evaluate test data

108Numark Associates, Inc.

Evaluate test data– Evaluate operating experience data– Determine cause of test failure and justify qualification to

less severe service conditions / acceptance criteria– Apply type-test results for in-plant application– Augment generic test to demonstrate that performance

related physical properties are similar, materials are compatible, and materials interact in a similar manner

Page 109: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

IEEE Std P1682/D Qualification of Fiber Optic Cable

• The standard addresses, in part:

– Minimum specifications or descriptive information to be provided for the cables, field splices, and connectors

109Numark Associates, Inc.

– Test procedures for thermal aging, radiation aging, and synergistic effects

– Effects of radiation and temperature on attenuation

– Recovery from signal attenuation after radiation aging

Page 110: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

17. Fiber Optic StandardsObjectives Review

• Identified the major fiber optic standards of interest to NRC

P id d l i f th

110Numark Associates, Inc.

• Provided a general overview of the purpose of these standards

• Discussed how these standards relate to new reactor inspection

Page 111: ELECTRICAL AND I&C CODES AND INSPECTION · implementation of design requirements Numark Associates, Inc. 10 implementation of design requirements. • Inspection and testing are used

QUESTIONS ?

111Numark Associates, Inc.