emergencylagoonmouth restorationat ......emergencylagoonmouth restorationat(lospeÑasquitoslagoon...

27
EMERGENCY LAGOON MOUTH RESTORATION AT LOS PEÑASQUITOS LAGOON 2015 SUMMARY REPORT Prepared by: Los Peñasquitos Lagoon Foundation ACOE Permit Number: SPL200701134RRS Coastal Development Permit No. 6.07.021.A1 401 Water Quality Cert. No. 07C094 February 12, 2016

Upload: others

Post on 01-Mar-2021

13 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

   

EMERGENCY  LAGOON  MOUTH  RESTORATION  AT    

LOS  PEÑASQUITOS  LAGOON    

2015  SUMMARY  REPORT    

   

               

Prepared  by:  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  Foundation      ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐‑2007-­‐‑01134-­‐‑RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

 February  12,  2016  

Page 2: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

1  

1   EXECUTIVE  SUMMARY  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  (LPL)  is  a  relatively  small  coastal  salt  marsh  (510  acres)  located  in  the  northern  portion   of   San   Diego   County   and   is   part   of   the   Torrey   Pines   State   Reserve.     LPL   receives   perennial  freshwater   flows  and  storm  runoff   from  a  60,000-­‐acre  watershed  comprised  of   three  sub-­‐watersheds:    Carmel  Valley,  Los  Peñasquitos  Canyon  and  Carroll  Canyon.    Listed  as  a  Marsh  Preserve  within  the  Torrey  Pines   State   Reserve,   LPL   is   afforded   the   highest   level   of   protection   by   the   State   of   California.       LPL  provides  critical  habitat  to  Federally  and  State  Listed  Species  that  include  the  Light-­‐footed  Clapper  Rail  (Rallus   Longirostris   Levipes),   Western   Snowy   Plover   (Charadrius   alexandrinus   nivosus),   Belding’s  savannah  sparrow  (Passerculus  sandwichensis  beldingi),  Nuttall’s  Lotus  (Lotus  nutallianus)  and  Coulter’s  goldfields  (Laesthenia  glabrata  ssp  coulteri).    LPL  also  serves  as  an  important  refuge  for  migratory  bird  species   using   the   Pacific   Flyway,   while   also   providing   habitat   to   other   marine,   terrestrial   and   avian  species  native   to  coastal   salt  marshes  along   the  Southern  California  Bight.     LPL  contains  Essential   Fish  Habitats  and  is  the  closest  coastal  lagoon  to  the  only  two  Areas  of  Special  Biological  Significance  (ASBS)  located   offshore   of   San   Diego   County.     LPL   also   serves   as   a   natural   system   for   flood   control   for  surrounding  urban  areas  and  provides  water  quality  improvements  for  the  coastal  waters.        

 

Large,  fast-­‐moving  waves  generated  by  winter  storms  in  the  North  Pacific  move  sand  and  cobbles   into  the  Lagoon’s   inlet  area  via  storm  surge,  wave  activity  and  high  tides.    While  the   initial  deposit  of  sand  can   be   removed   by   outflows   from   the   lagoon,   the   cobbles   remain.     These   cobbles   form   a   sill   that  facilitates  future  sediment  deposition  in  the  lagoon  inlet  during  subsequent  winter  swells  and  high  tides.    Evidence   indicates   that   the   LPL’s   inlet   to   the   ocean   had   remained   open   year   round   historically.    However,  land  use  change,  including  urban  encroachment,  during  the  last  two  centuries  has  reduced  the  lagoon’s  ability  to  flush  out  sediment  after  storm  events,  constrained  the  lagoon  inlet  to  a  fixed  location  south  of   its  historic   location,  and   introduced  perennial   freshwater   input   from  the  watershed.    Though  tidal  exchange  has  improved  with  the  construction  of  the  new  lower  bridge  at  North  Torrey  Pines  Road  (a.k.a.  Historic  Highway  101),  reductions  in  the  LPL’s  tidal  prism  and  closures  still  occur  as  large  volumes  of  marine  sediment  are  still  deposited  within  the  inlet  area  and  lagoon  channels.  

 

Decreased   tidal   prism   and   extended   inlet   closures   at   LPL   can   impact   both   aquatic   and   terrestrial  habitats,  impact  native  and  migratory  species,  pose  risks  to  nearshore  coastal  water  quality,  impair  the  Lagoon’s   Beneficial   Uses,   and   threaten   nearby   urban   infrastructure   vulnerable   to   flooding.     Water  quality  parameters  (e.g.  dissolved  oxygen  and  salinity)  degrade  during  extended  inlet  closures  once  they  are  no   longer  exposed   to   tidal  mixing   from  ocean  waters.     Impacts   to  water  quality   can  occur   rapidly  during   periods   of   warm   temperatures   typical   of   summer   months,   resulting   in   fish   kills   and   loss   of  invertebrate   communities.     Since   1995   all   three   of   the   Lagoon’s   three   main   tributaries   became  perennial,  providing  a  new  type  of   impact  to  Lagoon  environs  during  extended  closures  as   impounded  water  becomes  hyposaline.    As  a  result,  LPL  has  experienced  rapid  habitat  conversion  as  areas  of  historic  salt  marsh  located  in  the  eastern  portion  of  the  Lagoon  have  been  displaced  by  brackish  and  freshwater  

Page 3: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

2  

habitats.    In  addition  to  loss  of  salt  marsh  habitats,  year  round  inputs  of  freshwater  from  the  watershed  have  also  raised  serious  public  health  risks  due  to  vector-­‐borne  disease.    LPL  is  also  a  known  location  of  mosquito  breeding  habitat   for  Culex   tarsalis,   the   species  known   to   transmit  West  Nile  Virus   (WNV)   in  southern   California.     Documented   cases   of   WNV   have   occurred   in   both   wild   and   sentinel   avian  populations,  as  well  as  within  human  populations  located  near  the  Lagoon.    

 

Since   1985,   the   Los   Peñasquitos   Lagoon   Foundation   (LPLF)   has   performed   mechanized   lagoon   inlet  openings.     Through   adaptive  management   and   stakeholder   coordination,   LPLF   has   been   successful   in  maintaining  the   inlet  at  LPL  while  producing  multiple  benefits   in  a  cost  effective  manner.    The   inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos   Lagoon   closed  on  3/31/15  with   subsequent   inspections   indicating   that   it  would  most  likely  not  reopen  under  natural  conditions  (See  Figure  1-­‐1  to  Figure  1-­‐3).    The  inlet  remained  closed  until  it  was  breached  on  April  22nd.      Excavation  of  the  main  channel  and  inlet  area  commenced  on  4/23/15  and  continued  through  to  5/1/2015  with  no  work  occurring  over  the  weekend.  Water  quality  (dissolved  oxygen)  rebounded  quickly  once  tidal  circulation  was  restored.       It   is  estimated  that  more  than  30,000  cubic   yards   of   excavated  material   (i.e.   sand   and   cobbles)  was   hauled   to   Torrey   Pines   State   Beach   for  disposal  south  of  the  inlet.      

Figure  1-­‐1.    View  of  the  closed  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon,  looking  west  toward  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    Photo  taken  by  

M.  Hastings  on  4/9/15.  

Figure  1-­‐2.    View  of  the  closed  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  looking  southeast  from  the  lower  bridge  that  spans  the  inlet.    

Photo  taken  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/9/15.  

Page 4: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

3  

Figure  1-­‐3.    Panoramic  view  of  the  closed  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  taken  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/9/15.  

 

2   PERMIT  COMPLIANCE  Prior   to   excavation   and  disposal   activities,   LPLF   performed  monitoring   of  water   quality,   sensitive   bird  species  surveys,  and  grain  size  analysis  of  beach  spoils  pursuant  to  permit  requirements  and  conditions.    Beach   disposal   of   sand   was   performed   outside   of   grunion   spawning   dates   specified   by   California  Department  of  Fish  and  Wildlife.    

2.1     Water  Quality  Water  quality  data   indicated  decreasing  DO  levels  within  the  Lagoon  during  the  extended  closure  that  lasted   from   March   31st   until   the   inlet   was   mechanically   breached   on   April   22nd.     DO   levels   quickly  dropped  below  5  mg/l  on  April  1st  (See  Figure  2-­‐1),  indicating  stressful  conditions  for  aquatic  species  and  triggering  the  project’s  special  biological  conditions  set  by  its  Coastal  Development  Permit  (6-­‐07-­‐021-­‐A1)  that  allow   for  mechanical  excavation  of   the   inlet.    DO  dropped  below  2  mg/l   just  before  April  4th  and  remained   below   5mg/l,   for   the  most   part,   after   April   13th.   Once   tidal   circulation  was   restored  within  Lagoon  channels,  water  quality  parameters  quickly  improved  (See  Figure  2-­‐2).    Salinity  levels  also  were  affected  by  the  extended  inlet  closure  due  to  perennial  inputs  of  dry  weather  flows  of  freshwater  from  the  urbanized  watershed,  remaining  below  26  ppt  and  often  dropping  toward  23  ppt  (See  Figure  2-­‐3).    Salinity  levels  rebounded  quickly  to  30-­‐32  ppt  after  the  inlet  was  breached  and  even  increased  to  33  ppt  after  the  main  inlet  was  reconnected  to  the  ocean  (See  Figure  2-­‐4).          

Figure  2-­‐1.  DO  and  water  levels  within  LPL  after  inlet  closure  on  3/31/15.    Note  the  rising  water  levels  due  to  perennial  dry  

weather  inputs  of  freshwater  from  the  Lagoon’s  tributaries  in  conjunction  with  declining  DO  due  to  the  lack  of  tidal  mixing  from  ocean  waters.  Graphic  by  TRNERR.  

Page 5: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

4  

Figure  2-­‐2.    DO  and  water  levels  within  LPL  after  the  inlet  breach  on  4/22/15.    Note  the  quick  drop  in  water  surface  elevation  

followed  by  the  restoration  the  diurnal  tidal  signal  in  conjunction  with  DO  levels  that  shows  restored  tidal  mixing  within  Lagoon  channels.  Graphic  by  TRNERR.  

Figure  2-­‐3  View  of  surface  levels  (red  line)  and  salinity  (yellow  line)  captured  at  Monitoring  Station  W2,  located  at  the  railway  bridge  within  the  northern  channel.    Salinity  levels  decline  following  the  closure  on  3/31/15  due  to  dilution  from  continuous  

freshwater  inputs  from  the  watershed  and  lagoon  boundaries.    Graphic  by  TRNERR.  

Figure  2-­‐4.  View  of  surface  levels  (red  line)  and  salinity  (yellow  line)  captured  at  Monitoring  Station  W2,  located  at  the  railway  bridge  within  the  northern  channel.    Once  the  inlet  is  breached,  surface  levels  drop  and  eventually  follow  the  tidal  signal  of  low  

and  high  tides.    Salinity  rises  quickly  once  tidal  circulation  is  restored,  going  from  brackish  to  marine  with  regard  to  salinity  concentrations.    Graphic  by  TRNERR.  

 

Page 6: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

5  

2.2   Resource  Agency  Notification  &  Monitoring  Results  Notification  &  Submission  of  Pre-­‐  and  Post-­‐Activity  Sampling  Forms    Agency   notification   and   pre-­‐opening   and   post-­‐opening   monitoring   forms   were   submitted   to   the  regulatory   agencies   as   a   requirement   of   project   permits   (See   Appendix   1).       The   San   Diego   County  Department   of   Environmental   Health   (DEH),   California   State   Parks   (CSP)   Lifeguards,   and   CSP   Rangers  were  contacted  to  assure  that  beach  advisory  signage  would  be   in  place  and  that  the  necessary  water  quality  sampling  and  beach  safety  precautions  would  be  implemented.          Sensitive  Bird  Species  Surveys  Pre-­‐maintenance  surveys  for  sensitive  bird  species  indicated  that  no  listed  species  were  present  within  the   project   area   or   evidence   of   nesting   activity   adjacent   to   the   project   site.     This   was   most   likely  influenced   by   the   extended   closure   that   resulted   in   much   of   the   Lagoon’s   mudflats,   sand   bars,   high  marsh  and  transitional  areas  being  inundated  for  almost  a  month.    Surveys  were  conducted  on  April  9th  and  April  20th.    Monitoring   for   presence   of   sensitive   bird   species   was   also   conducted   daily   during   inlet   restoration  efforts   to   assure   that   there   would   not   be   “take”   or   other   impacts   to   sensitive   species.     Equipment  operators  were  briefed  on   limits  of   the  work  area  and  areas  of   sensitive  habitats   to  assure   that   there  would   be   no   impacts   to   vegetated   areas,   especially   those   used   for   nesting   by   Belding’s   savannah  sparrow  that  occur  adjacent  to  the  project  site.          Grain  Size  Analysis  Grain   size   analysis   was   performed   prior   emergency   maintenance   efforts   to   determine   suitability   for  beach   disposal   of   sediment   excavated   from   the   inlet   area.     Composite   samples   were   created   from  sediment  cores  taken  at  four  separate  locations  within  the  project  area  on  March  17th  (See  Figure  2-­‐5).  The   composite   samples  were   sent   an   outside   laboratory   to   determine   grain   size   analysis   and   sorting  using  laser  particle  analysis.    Results  were  provided  to  Army  Corps  of  Engineers  (ACOE)  on  April  9th  with  the   composition  of   all   four   samples   ranging   from  98.5%   -­‐   98.9%   sand  and  gravel   (See  Appendix   2   for  complete  results  and  statistics).      

Page 7: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

6  

Figure  2-­‐5.    Locations  of  sediment  samples  taken  within  the  project  area  and  submitted  for  grain  size  analysis.  

Graphic  developed  by  Coastal  Environments.  

   Turbidity  Monitoring    Beach  disposal   of   excavated  material   (i.e.   sand   and   cobbles)   is   performed   to   reduce  project   cost   and  provide   sand  nourishment   along   Torrey   Pines   State  Beach,  which   experiences   a   great   deal   of   erosion  due   to   large  wave   events   during  winter  months.     A  majority   of   the  material   spoiled   on   the   beach   is  placed   along   the   waterline   so   that   incoming   tides   can   disperse   the   sand   piles.     Sand   is   dispersed  horizontally  along  the  nearshore  area  usually  during  one  complete  tidal  cycle.          During   the  project,  photo  and  observational  monitoring  of   the  disposal   area  was  performed   from   the  coastal   bluff   near   Lifeguard   Tower   #4   and   on   the   lower   bridge   at   N.   Torrey   Pines   Road   to   assess  potential   water   quality   impacts   due   to   offshore   turbidity   from   an   elevated   viewpoint.     Monitoring  results   indicate   that   beach   disposal   activities   did   not   result   in   offshore   turbidity   beyond   levels   that  occurred  naturally   to  both   the  north  and  south  of   the  project  area  due   to  nearshore  currents  and   rip  tides  (See  Figure  2-­‐6  to  Figure  2-­‐8).    

Locations of four sediment samples.

Page 8: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

7  

Figure  2-­‐6.  Turbidity  monitoring  during  disposal  of  sand  on  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  4/29/15.  

   

Figure  2-­‐7.  Turbidity  monitoring  during  disposal  of  sand  on  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  4/29/15.  

 

 Figure  2-­‐8.  Turbidity  monitoring  during  disposal  of  sand  on  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  4/29/15.  

   Grunion  Monitoring    Disposal  of   sand  on  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach  occurred  outside  of   scheduled   (closed)  grunion   runs   for  April  2015.    Therefore,  monitoring  for  presence/absence  of  grunion  was  not  conducted.      

 

Page 9: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

8

3   SUMMARY  OF  WORK  PERFORMED  

3.1   Project  Footprint,  Equipment  Staging  Area  and  Access  Points  The  project’s  footprint  and  work  areas  are  provided  in  Figure  3-­‐1.    In  general,  excavation  and  stockpiling  of   spoils   occurred   between   Transect   A1   and   the   deep-­‐water   mark   located   between   Transect   D   and  Transect   E2   in   the   northern   channel.     Excavated   material   (i.e.   sand   and   cobbles)   was   loaded   onto  articulated   rock   trucks   and   hauled   out   to   Torrey   Pines   State   Beach   for   disposal   with   some   disposal  occurring  within  the  inlet  area  to  restore  a  remnant  dune  area.      

When  not  in  use,  heavy  equipment  was  staged  along  the  coastal  bluff  adjacent  to  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road  (See   Figure   3-­‐2   -­‐   Figure   3-­‐4)   as   required   by   project   permits   with   spill   prevention   tarps   and   buckets  placed  under  equipment  (See  Figure  3-­‐5).    Access  to  the  Lagoon  was  provided  by  a  sand  ramp  built  at  the   staging   area   that   allowed  equipment   to   descend   to   Torrey   Pines   State  Beach   and  enter   LPL   fromunder  the  lower  bridge  at  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road  (See  Figure  3-­‐6  and  Figure  3-­‐7).    

 

Figure  3-­‐1.  Project  Footprint.    Jones  &  Stokes  2007.

Page 10: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

9

Figure  3-­‐2.    Equipment  Staging  Area  and  Access  to  Project  Area.    Google  Earth  2010.

   

Figure  3-­‐3.    Equipment  Staging  Area  Project  Area,  viewing  north  along  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  4/22/15.  

Page 11: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

10

Figure  3-­‐4.    Equipment  Staging  Area  Project  Area,  viewing  south  along  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road.  Photo  by  M.  Hastings  4/22/15.  

Figure  3-­‐5.    Equipment  staging  area  with  spill  prevention  tarps  and  bucket.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  4/23/15.    

 Figure  3-­‐6.    Access  ramp  used  by  heavy  equipment  to  enter  and  exit  staging  area  along  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road.  Photo  by  M.  

Hastings  4/22/15.  

Page 12: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

11

Figure  3-­‐7.    Equipment  getting  ready  to  enter  LPL  under  the  lower  bridge  along  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road.  Photo  by  M.  Hastings  

4/22/15.  

3.2   Excavating  the  Inlet   Please  refer  to  Figure  3-­‐1  with  regard  to  locations  of  transects  referenced  in  this  sub-­‐section.      Work  began  on  4/22/15  and  consisted  of  cutting  a  channel  from  Transect  A1  to  Transect  A2  to  provide  a  conduit   for   lagoon   outflows   once   the   inlet   was   breached   and   breaching   of   the   inlet   at   9:38   am.    Equipment  worked  along  Transect  A2  until  lagoon  waters  drained  and  two  excavators  proceeded  to  the  deep-­‐water  mark  located  near  Transect  E2  and  began  to  excavate  the  main  channel.    Excavation  in  this  area  of  the  Lagoon  continued  through  to  4/24/15  with  spoils  stockpiled  for  loading  and  hauling  activities  that  would  commence  on  4/27/15.    Excavation  of  the  inlet  area  continued  on  4/27/15  through  to  5/1/15  with   heavy   equipment  working   from   Transect   E2   and   Transect   D   towards   Transect   A1   depending   on  water   levels  within  the  inlet  due  to  tides.    Efforts  from  4/27/15  -­‐  5/1/15  included  loading,  hauling  and  disposal  of  excavated  spoils  and  are  briefly  summarized  below.    

Day  1  -­‐  April  22nd    Two  PC-­‐400  excavators  and  a  wheeled   front   loader  were  brought   to   the  project   site  on  April  21st  and  staged  near   the  LPL   inlet.    Work  began  at  7:00  am  with   initial  efforts   consisting  of   cutting  an  outflow  channel  on  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach  at  Transect  A1  up  to  Transect  A2  within  the  Lagoon  (See  Figure  3-­‐8  and   Figure  3-­‐9).     This   channel  would  help   to  direct   the  discharge  of  water   impounded  within   the   LPL  once  the  inlet  was  breached  (See  Figure  3-­‐10).    Once  the  channel  was  completed,  the  inlet  was  breached  at  9:38  am,  releasing  impounded  waters  to  drain  the  Lagoon  (See  Figure  3-­‐10  -­‐  Figure  3-­‐13)  and  permit  access   of   heavy   equipment   back   to   Transect   E2.     Once   water   levels   dropped,   the   two   excavators  proceeded  to  the  deep-­‐water  mark  located  near  Transect  E2  and  began  to  excavate  the  main  channel.    Excavated   spoils   were   stockpiled   and   would   be   loaded   onto   trucks   the   following   week   to   haul   and  dispose  of  the  sand  on  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    

Page 13: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

12

Figure  3-­‐8.    Excavating  a  channel  west  of  the  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  to  direct  lagoon  outflows.    Photo  by  M.  

Hastings  on  4/22/15.  

Figure  3-­‐9.    Excavating  a  channel  toward  the  impounded  water  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/22/15.  

 

Figure  3-­‐10.    Getting  ready  to  release  impounded  water  within  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  by  breaching  the  inlet.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/22/15.  

Page 14: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

13

Figure  3-­‐11.    Breaching  the  inlet  to  release  impounded  water  within  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/22/15.  

Figure  3-­‐12.  View  of  water  exiting  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  shortly  after  the  inlet  was  breached.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  

4/22/15.  

Figure  3-­‐13.    View  of  water  exiting  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  later  in  the  day  after  the  inlet  was  breached.  Note  the  expanded  

with  as  channel  banks  erode  due  to  outflow.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/22/15.    

 

Page 15: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

14

Day  2  (April  23rd)  &  Day  3  (April  24th)  Day  2  and  Day  3  consisted  of  excavating  the  inlet  area  and  stockpiling  spoils  to  be  hauled  out  to  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach  the  following  week.     Initial  efforts  on  Day  2  focused  on  continued  excavation  of  the  deep  channel  near  Transect  E2  as  shown  in  Figure  3-­‐14  and  Figure  3-­‐15.    By  Day  3  excavation  continued  toward  Transect  D  in  both  the  north  and  southern  channels  (See  Figure  3-­‐16  and  Figure  3-­‐17).        

Figure  3-­‐14.  Excavating  at  the  deep-­‐water  mark  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  near  Transect  E2.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/23/15.  

Figure  3-­‐15.    Close  up  view  of  excavation  at  the  deep-­‐water  mark  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  near  Transect  E2.    Photo  by  M.  

Hastings  on  4/23/15.  

Figure  3-­‐16.   Excavating  in  the  northern  channel  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  near  Transect  D.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/24/15.  

Page 16: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

15

 Figure  3-­‐17.  Excavating  near  the  southern  channel  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  near  Transect  D.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  

4/24/15.  

 

Day  4  (April  27th)  -­‐  Day  8  (May  1st)  Additional   equipment   was   brought   in   over   the   weekend   to   facilitate   efforts   to   excavate   and   haul  sediments  out  of  the  inlet  area  at  LPL.    The  additional  equipment  consisted  of  three  45-­‐ton  articulated  rock  trucks  and  a  D6  Dozer.    Since  the  inlet  had  closed  to  tidal  circulation  on  Saturday  April  25th,  initial  efforts  on  Monday  (April  27th)  focused  on  clearing  the  inlet  area  between  Transect  A1  and  Transect  A2  to  release  impounded  waters  (See  Figure  3-­‐18  and  Figure  3-­‐19).    Once  the  water  levels  dropped  within  the  Lagoon,  excavation  continued  within  the  inlet  area  along  with  loading  of  excavated  spoils  from  the  previous   week   onto   the   rock   trucks   to   be   hauled   and   disposed   of   on   Torrey   Pines   State   Beach   (See  Figure  3-­‐20  and  Figure  3-­‐21).        

Figure  3-­‐18.  Excavating  the  inlet  area  near  the  bridge  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/27/15.

Page 17: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

16

Figure  3-­‐19.  Excavating  the  inlet  area  west  of  the  bridge  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/27/15.  

 

 

Figure  3-­‐20.    View  of  inlet  work  that  included  excavation  and  stockpiling  of  spoils  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.  Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/27/15.  

 Figure  3-­‐21.    Loading  of  excavated  spoils  near  Transect  E2  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.  Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/27/15  

     

Page 18: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

17

During  Day  5  through  to  Day  8,  efforts  continued  to  focus  on  excavating  the  inlet  area  and  hauling  spoils  to  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    While  work  areas  were  more  or   less  dictated  by  water   levels  within   the  Lagoon  due  to  high  tides  in  the  morning,  the  overall  progression  was  to  work  from  Transect  E2  toward  Transect  A1  as  summarized  in  Figure  3-­‐22  to  Figure  3-­‐33.  

Figure  3-­‐22.  Excavating  between  Transect  A2  and  Transect  B  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/28/15.  

 Figure  3-­‐23.    Loading  excavated  spoils  near  Transect  D  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/28/15.

Figure  3-­‐24.  Loading  excavated  spoils  near  Transect  D  at  the  southern  channel  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  

on  4/29/15.  

Page 19: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

18

 Figure  3-­‐25.    Loading  excavated  spoils  near  Transect  B  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/29/15.  

 Figure  3-­‐26.    Excavating  and  stockpiling  between  Transect  D  and  Transect  B  in  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.      Photo  by  M.  Hastings  

on  4/30/15.  

 Figure  3-­‐27.    Excavating  and  stockpiling  near  Transect  D  in  the  northern  and  southern  channels.    Loading  spoils  near  Transect  A.      

Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/30/15.  

Page 20: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

19

Figure  3-­‐28.  Panoramic  view  of  work  within  the  inlet  area  of  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/30/15.  

Figure  3-­‐29.    Loading  near  Transect  A1  during  high  tide  when  access  to  the  Lagoon  was  limited.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  

5/1/15.  

 Figure  3-­‐30.    Excavating  and  loading  near  Transect  B  within  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  5/1/15.

Figure  3-­‐31.    Panoramic  view  of  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  inlet  during  loading  of  excavated  spoils  to  be  hauled  to  disposed  on  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  5/1/15.  

Page 21: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

20

Figure  3-­‐32.    Finishing  up  excavation  of  the  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  near  Transect  A2.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  5/1/15.  

   

 Figure  3-­‐33.    Excavating  the  remainder  of  the  sand  spit  that  grows  off  the  southern  abutment  of  the  bridge  that  spans  the  inlet  

at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  5/1/15.  

3.3   Grain  Size  &  Sediment  Volume  Removed  from  the  Lagoon  Inlet  It   is  estimated  that  approximately  26,000  cubic  yards  of  sand  was  removed   from  the   inlet  area  at  LPL  with   an   estimated   25,575   cubic   yards   of   sand   hauled   to   Torrey   Pines   Beach   for   disposal.     Excavated  material  consisted  of  98.5%  to  98.9%  sand  based  on  the  results  of  grain  size  analysis  performed  in  the  project  area  prior  to  maintenance  activities.    As  shown  in  Table  3-­‐1,  grain  size  within  the  inlet  area  tends  to  be  greater  than  95%  sand.    Table  3-­‐2  provides  annual  amounts  of  sand  removed  from  LPL’s  inlet  from  2008  –  2015,  including  both  2013  and  2014  that  required  multiple  efforts  due  to  beach  nourishment  in  Solana  Beach  and  Encinitas  that  occurred  in  the  spring  of  2012  under  the  Regional  Beach  Sand  Project  II.    Please  refer  to  the  annual  summary  reports  for  2013  and  2014  for  more  information.    

Page 22: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

21

Table 3-1. Grain size analysis results at LPL inlet 2009-2015

Year   Core    Median  Grain  Size  (mm)  

%  Sand   %  Silt   %  Clay   Sample  Location  

2009

 

1   0.30   97.71   1.61   0.68   LPL  1.  Inlet    

2   0.27   98.38   1.10   0.52   LPL  2.  Western  Basin  on  Transect  B  

3   0.21   96.85   2.31   0.84   LPL  3.  Main  Channel  Near  Transect  D  

4   0.20   93.29   5.27   1.44   LPL  4.  Southern  Channel  Near  Transect  E2  

2010

 

1   0.35   98.67   0.91   0.41   LPL  1.  Inlet    

2   0.32   97.92   1.51   0.57   LPL  2.  Western  Basin  on  Transect  B  

3   0.28   98.14   1.3   1.66   LPL  3.  Main  Channel  Near  Transect  D  

4   0.24   97.73   0.56   0.62   LPL  4.  Southern  Channel  Near  Transect  E2  

2011

 

1   0.31   99.55   0.45   0.00   LPL  1.  Inlet    

2   0.29   99.01   0.53   0.38   LPL  2.  Western  Basin  on  Transect  B  

3   0.28   98.06   0.46   0.38   LPL  3.  Main  Channel  Near  Transect  D  

4   0.26   99.25   0.43   0.32   LPL  4.  Southern  Channel  Near  Transect  E2  

2012

 

1   0.25   96.47   2.62   0.91   LPL  1.  Inlet    

2   0.30   99.21   1.61   0.45   LPL  2.  Western  Basin  on  Transect  B  

3   0.23   97.33   1.98   0.69   LPL  3.  Main  Channel  Near  Transect  D  

4   0.21   95.22   3.81   0.97   LPL  4.  Southern  Channel  Near  Transect  E2  

2013

 

1   0.30   98.56   0.96   0.48   LPL  1.  Inlet    

2   0.28   98.03   0.90   0.45   LPL  2.  Western  Basin  on  Transect  B  

3   0.39   99.15   0.32   0.69   LPL  3.  Main  Channel  Near  Transect  D  

4   0.25   99.09   0.51   0.97   LPL  4.  Southern  Channel  Near  Transect  E2  

2014

 

1   0.26   98.54   1.01   0.45   LPL  1.  Inlet    

2   0.34   99.02   0.64   0.34   LPL  2.  Western  Basin  on  Transect  B  

3   0.26   98.27   1.24   0.50   LPL  3.  Main  Channel  Near  Transect  D  

4   0.22   97.18   2.11   0.71   LPL  4.  Southern  Channel  Near  Transect  E2  

2015

 

1   0.22   98.6   0.98   0.47   LPL  1.  Inlet    

2   0.25   98.8   0.78   0.42   LPL  2.  Western  Basin  on  Transect  B  

3   0.22   98.5   1.06.   0.45   LPL  3.  Main  Channel  Near  Transect  D  

4   0.28   98.9   0.71   0.40   LPL  4.  Southern  Channel  Near  Transect  E2  

Page 23: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

22

Table 3-2. Cubic yards removed annually from the inlet at Los Peñasquitos Lagoon using heavy equipment.

Date  of  Inlet  Maintenance  

Type  of  Inlet  Maintenance  

Cubic  Yards  Removed  Annually  1  

Total  Cubic  Yards  Removed  to  Date    

4/30/08  –  5/09/08   Emergency  Opening   32,400   32,400  

5/16/09  –  5/26/09   Emergency  Opening   25,674   58,074  

5/03/10  –  5/08/10   Emergency  Opening   24,837   82,911  

5/06/11  –  5/13/11   Emergency  Opening   26,085   108,996  

5/14/12  –  5/18/12   Emergency  Opening   14,637   123,633  

5/13/13  –  5/17/13   Emergency  Breach   5,000   128,633  

6/12/13  –  6/21/13   Emergency  Opening   35,000   163,633  

4/7/14  –  4/11/14   Emergency  Opening   30,180   193,813  

4/21/14  –  4/25/14     Emergency  Opening   21,184   214,997  

 5/19/14  –  5/26/14     Emergency  Opening   4,170   219,167  

4/22/15  –  5/1/15   Emergency  Opening   25,575   244,742  

1 Estimates based on truck load counts with the average haul amount at 25 cubic yards per truck load.

4   RESULTS  AND  CONCLUSIONS  Benefits  to  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  and  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach  The   restoration   of   the   tidal   prism   at   LPL   provided   benefits   both  within   the   Lagoon   and   along   Torrey  Pines   State   Beach.     Within   the   Lagoon,   water   quality   (e.g.   dissolved   oxygen,   salinity,   pH   and  temperature)  was  restored  to  levels  required  for  the  health  and  survival  of  aquatic  species  that  include  fish  species  valuable  to  recreational  fisheries  (e.g.  California  halibut  and  anchovy)  and  invertebrates  that  provide  a  food  source  to  both  local  and  migratory  bird  species.    Restoring  the  tidal  prism  also  helped  to  protect  the  Belding’s  savannah  sparrow  (Passerculus  sandwichensis  beldingi),  a  State-­‐listed  endangered  species.    This  bird  nests  within  LPL’s  high  marsh  habitat,  defined  as  the  area  just  above  tidal  influence.    During   extended   inlet   closures,   rising   water   levels   caused   by   perennial   flows   of   freshwater   from   the  watershed   can   inundate   the   upper   marsh,   causing   nests   to   be   abandoned.     By   lowering   levels   of  freshwater  within   the  Lagoon,   the  project  was  also  successful   in  helping  protect  Nuttall’s   Lotus   (Lotus  nutallianus)   and   Coulter’s   goldfields   (Laesthenia   glabrata   ssp   coulteri),   two   1B   –   listed   plant   species  considered   by   the   California   Native   Plant   Society   to   be   rare,   threatened   or   endangered   in   California.    Lowered   water   levels   also   restored   valuable   foraging   habitat   for   two   federally   endangered   birds,  

Page 24: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

23

Ridgeway’s  rail   (Rallus  obsoletus   -­‐   formerly  referred  to  as  Light-­‐footed  Clapper  Rail   (Rallus  Longirostris  Levipes))  and  Western  Snowy  Plover  (Charadrius  alexandrinus  nivosus).    In  addition,  foredune  and  beach  habitat   is   restored  within   the   inlet   area   using   excavated   sand   that   is   placed   along   eroded   vegetation  banks  and  on   top  of  cobble  substrate  exposed  by  wave  propagation  and  surge  within   the   inlet  during  winter  months.        Project  benefits  along  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach  generated  by  beach  disposal  of  sand  excavated  from  the  LPL’s  inlet  include  the  following:  

•   Covering   of   exposed   riprap   located   along   an   eroded   bluff   that   separates   Torrey   Pines   State  Beach   and   public   parking   spaces   along   N.   Torrey   Pines   Road   to   improve   public   access   and  safety,  as  well  as   to  serve  as  a  soft  buffer   to  reduce  further  erosion  of   the  bluffs   from  winter  waves,  storm  surge  and  extreme  tide  events.      

•   Re-­‐contouring   of   sand   placed   along   the   upper   beach   to  mimic   the   profile   of   a   coastal   dune  extending  from  the   lower  beach  to  the  bluffs  to   increase  the  total  area  of  available  beach  for  public  use  and  improved  access  from  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road.  

•   Creation  of  potential  spawning  habitat  for  grunion  caused  by  sand  placement  along  portions  of  the  lower  beach  that  had  been  predominately  cobblestones.      

•   Improved  beachsafety  along  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach   through  the  creation  of  a  beach  access  ramp  for  emergency  vehicles  traveling  on  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road.  

Photo-­‐documentation   of   inlet   status   before   and   after   tidal   circulation   was   restored   is   provided  below:      

Figure  4-­‐1.    View  of  the  closed  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  on  4/9/15.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings.  

Page 25: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

24

Figure  4-­‐2.  View  of  the  closed  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  looking  southeast  from  the  lower  bridge  that  spans  the  inlet.    

Photo  taken  by  M.  Hastings  on  4/9/15.  

Figure  4-­‐3.    Panoramic  view  of  the  closed  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  on  4/9/15.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings.  

Figure  4-­‐4.    View  of  the  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  after  inlet  work  was  completed.    Looking  west  toward  the  ocean.    Photo  

by  M.  Hastings  on  5/1/15.  

 Figure  4-­‐5.    View  of  the  inlet  area  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  after  inlet  work  was  completed,  looking  southeast  from  the  lower  

bridge  along  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  5/1/15.  

Page 26: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

25

 

Figure  4-­‐6.    Panoramic  view  of  the  restored  inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon  on  5/1/15.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings.  

   

 Figure  4-­‐7.    View  from  the  north  parking  lot  of  eroded  remnant  dune  and  beach  habitat  scoured  by  incoming  swells  and  waves  

propagating  through  the  inlet  during  winter  months.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  2/3/15.  

 Figure  4-­‐8.    View  from  north  parking  lot  of  restored  beach  and  dune  habitat.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  on  5/1/15.  

Page 27: EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT ......EMERGENCYLAGOONMOUTH RESTORATIONAT(LOSPEÑASQUITOSLAGOON ((2015(SUMMARYREPORT(!!!!! Preparedby :! LosPeñasquitosLagoonFoundation !!! ACOE!Permit!Number:!SPL=2007

Summary  Report  2015-­‐  Restoration  of  the  Ocean  Inlet  at  Los  Peñasquitos  Lagoon    ACOE  Permit  Number:  SPL-­‐2007-­‐01134-­‐RRS  Coastal  Development  Permit  No.  6.07.021.A1  401  Water  Quality  Cert.  No.  07C-­‐094  

26

Figure  4-­‐9.    View  of  eroded  bluffs  adjacent  to  public  parking  along  N.  Torrey  Pines  Road  prior  to  the  project,  typical  after  winter  

months  that  erode  large  sections  of  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach.    Photo  by  M.  Hastings  4/21/15.  

Figure  4-­‐10.    View  of  the  same  section  of  bluffs  following  beach  nourishment  efforts  using  excavated  sand  from  the  inlet  area  hauled  to  Torrey  Pines  State  Beach  for  disposal  south  of  the  inlet  to  avoid  re-­‐introduction  into  the  inlet  area.    Photo  by  M.  

Hastings  5/11/15.  

 Reductions  in  Populations  of  Culex  tarsalis  -­‐  Freshwater  Mosquito  that  Transmits  West  Nile  Virus  The   project   was   successful   in   reducing   mosquito-­‐breeding   habitat   for   Culex   tarsalis   by   restoring   the  lagoon’s   ocean   inlet   and   tidal   prism,   achieved   through   breaching   of   the   inlet   and   re-­‐connecting   the  Lagoon’s   main   channel   with   the   ocean.   A   post-­‐project   site   inspection   indicated  that   surface   levels  within   the  eastern  portion  of  LPL  were  observed   to  be  below  the  bank  of   the   tidal  channels,   indicating  connectivity  with  the  ocean  and  adequate  drainage  for  the  eastern  portion  of  the  Lagoon.    Continuous  measures  of  water  levels  within  the  Lagoon’s  main  channel  also  indicated  that  the  tidal   influence  had  been   restored   as  measured   elevations   of  water   levels  within   LPL   corresponded   to  water  levels  indicative  of  the  low  and  high  range  indicative  of  the  corresponding  tidal  cycles.