enemy of the state of privacy

8/8/2019 Enemy of the State of Privacy

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/enemy-of-the-state-of-privacy 1/5

A}. ]fmi}q Hnd hs k ̀ f}inshc

schinqhsq* m}fkacksqi} kna

kyqlf}. Kn hnqi}nkqhfnkjjx

kccjkhbia ̀ f}inshc

hnqijjhdinci spichkjhsq* li

lks q}kijia qli tf}ja

fn milkj` f` qli hnqi}isqs f`

dfi}nbinqs kna bkef}

cf}pf}kqhfns. A}. Hnd lks

kppik}ia fn bkef} Nf}ql

Kbi}hckn m}fkacksq nits

niqtf}gs fn qli hssyis f`

`f}inshc hnqijjhdinci*

isphfnkdi }hsg

bknkdibinq* p}hkcx*

hainqhqx qli`q* ijicq}fnhc

sy}ihjjknci kna Hnqi}niq

c}hbi.

@f} bf}i k}qhcjis mx

A}. ]fmi}q Hnd hshq

ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb

Inibx f` qli Sqkqi f` _}hkcx

Mx ]fmi}q Hnd* ASc* @K_Sc* C_F

Hn qli ;88< bfhi* ‚Inibx f` qli Sqkqi‒* kcqf} Thjj Sbhql‘s pi}sfnkj

p}hkcx hs hnkaia mx lhs ftn dfi}nbinq yshnd lhdl qiclnfjfdx

aihcis pjknqia hn lhs lfbi* f``hci kna iin fn lhs pi}sfn. Sfynas `k}

ìqclia6 Qli qiclnfjfdx afis i|hsq qf af ii}xqlhnd pf}q}kxia hn qlibfhi kna bycl bf}i. Qli fnjx ah`ì}inci miqtiin qli bfhi kna

}ikj jhì hs qlkq ynjhgi qli bfhi tli}i dfi}nbinq kdinqs plxshckjjx

inqi}ia qli lfbi kna f``hci f` Sbhql* qlhs hs nfq nicissk}x qf m}ikcl

qli p}hkcx f` knx chqhuin.

H` xfy k}i jhgi bfsq hnahhaykjs* xfy lki yngnfthndjx pi}bhqqia

xfy}sij` qf mi q}kcgia* afcybinqia kna xfy} p}hkcx m}ikclia hn

i|clkndi `f} jhhnd k jhì f` cfninhinci. Tlin xfy shdn kppjhckqhfns

kna kd}iibinqs `f} xfy} c}iahq ck}as* mkng kccfynqs* ilhcji jiksiskna bf}qdkdis lki xfy }ikjjx }ika qli `hni p}hnq6 Qli `hni p}hnq hn

bfsq cksis sqkqis qlkq xfy dhi xfy} pi}bhsshfn qf lki xfy} pi}sfnkj

hn`f}bkqhfn cfjjicqia mx* ‚i|clkndia‒ thql* kna iin sfja qf qlh}a

pk}qhis ql}fydlfyq qli cfy}si f` xfy} myshniss aikjhnds. Af xfy

mijfnd qf k }itk}a pfhnqs f} ahscfynq p}fd}kb6 Qli `hni p}hnq f` qli

kd}iibinq bkx kjjft p}fd}kb fpi}kqf}s qf q}kcg xfy} spinahnd lkmhqs

,tli}i kna tlkq xfy myx(* kjjft qlib qf slk}i kna iin sijj qlhs

hn`f}bkqhfn qf qlh}a pk}qhis kna pyq xfy fn bkhjhnd kna qijiplfni

sfjhchqkqhfn jhsqs f` cfbpknhis xfy‘i nii} lik}a f`.

Tlhji qlhs bkx siib bf}i f` kn hncfninhinci qlkn kn hnkshfn f`

p}hkcx cfnshai} qli cksi f` B}. \. B}. \ lka shdnia yp `f} k }itk}a

pfhnqs p}fd}kb jhngia qf lhs c}iahq ck}a. Qlhs biknq ii}xtli}i kna

ii}x qhbi li ysia lhs c}iahq ck}a li tfyja diq pfhnqs `f} kjj f` lhs

q}knskcqhfns qf mi ysia qftk}as kckqhfns* dksfjhni kna k nit ck}.

B}. \ tks hn jhni `f} k p}fbfqhfn thql lhs `h}b* k bkef} byjqh"nkqhfnkj

cf}pf}kqhfn. Ks pk}q f` qli sijicqhfn p}fciss li tfyja lki qf symbhq

qf k mkcgd}fyna clicg kna sicy}hqx cjik}knci. Qli `h}b cfnaycqhnd

qli clicg pi}`f}bia tlkq hs gnftn ks k clk}kcqi} jhìsqxji clicg kna

ql}fydl qlih} sfy}cis ti}i kmji qf fmqkhn k }icf}a f` B}. \‘s spinahnd

lkmhqs fi} k qtf xik} pi}hfa ks afcybinqia mx qli }itk}a pfhnqsp}fd}kb li lka in}fjjia hn. Hq tks nfqia mx kn inq}x fn lhs spinahnd

}icf}a qlkq li lka fn fni fcckshfn `}i{yinqia k sbkjj }iqkhj

isqkmjhslbinq tlfsi fpi}kqf} lka miin cfnhcqia f` clhja

pf}nfd}kplx. Ks k }isyjq* B}. \ tks nfq dhin k cjik}knci `f} qli

p}fbfqhfn kna tks jkqi} }ijiksia ̀ }fb qli `h}b‘s ibpjfx. @y}qli}

hnisqhdkqhfn `fyna qlkq qli isqkmjhslbinq hn {yisqhfn tks k

cfninhinci sqf}i clkhn tli}i B}. \ py}clksia k mf| f` clfcfjkqis

`f} lhs thì‘s mh}qlakx. Qlhs tks qli fni kna fnjx afcybinqia qhbi li

lka inqi}ia qlhs isqkmjhslbinq.
















isphfnkdi }hsg

bknkdibinq* p}hkcx*



c}hbi.


A}. ]fmi}q Hnd hshq

ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb

Shbhjk} q}kcghnd f` hnahhaykjs hs kjsf afni hk qlih} pi}sfnkj cfbpyqi}s.

Hn qlhs cksi* bfsq hnahhaykjs k}i kjj qff {yhcg qf m}iiui ql}fydl qli

Qi}bs f` Si}hci pfsqia fn timshqis kna hn sf`qtk}i kna ks k }isyjq

sy}}inai} qlih} p}hkcx kjj qff ikshjx. _ifpji tlf af knx `f}b f` fnjhni

cfbbi}ci `}fb f}ai}hnd bi}clknahsi f`` f` k timshqi* qf fnjhni

mknghnd kna sqfcg q}kahnd k}i f`qin q}kcgia mx lkhnd sbkjj `hjis pjkcia

fn qlih} cfbpyqi}s thqlfyq qlih} gnftjiadi* gnftn ks cffghis qf

dkqli} kna q}kcg pi}sfnkj kna pi}sfnkj p}i`i}inci hn`f}bkqhfn. Mxkccipqhnd qli Qi}bs f` Si}hci ysi}s kd}ii qf lki qli cffghis pjkcia

fn qlih} cfbpyqi}. Kjqlfydl qli tf}a ‚cffghi‒ bkx nfq mi spich`hckjjx

ysia hn qli qi|q f` qli afcybinq. Cffghis* kjsf gnftn hn qli cfbpyqi}

sicy}hqx tf}ja ks Spxtk}i bkx p}fhai hn`f}bkqhfn kmfyq qli cfbpyqi}

ftni}s nkbi* kaa}iss* qijiplfni nybmi} kna i"bkhj kaa}iss kjj

cyjjia `}fb hn`f}bkqhfn p}fhaia mx qli ysi}s qlibsijis tlin qlix

`h}sq }idhsqi}ia qlih} cfbpyqi} fpi}kqhnd sxsqib kna sf`qtk}i.

Kaahqhfnkj hn`f}bkqhfn bkx mi fmqkhnia fn qli qxpi f` sf`qtk}i kna

cfbpyqi} ysia* timshqis hshqia* Hnqi}niq sik}clis pi}`f}bia kna qfqkj

qhbi spinq kq qli cfbpyqi}.

Ks tijj* Hnqi}niq Si}hci _}fhai}s kna i"bkhj p}fhai}s bkx kjsf giip

qkms fn ysi}s mx bfnhqf}hnd kccfynq kcqhhqx. Kccfynq kcqhhqx f` qlhs

nkqy}i tfyja hncjyai }icihia kna sinq i"bkhj kaa}issis* timshqis

hshqia kna kn hninqf}x f` kjj f` qli sf`qtk}i hnsqkjjia fn qli cfbpyqi}.

Hn`f}bkqhfn fmqkhnia `}fb qli ysi f` Spxtk}i kna qli bfnhqf}hnd f`

kccfynq kcqhhqx k}i }fyqhnijx eysqh`hia hn qli cf}pf}kqi tf}ja ks

p}fcissis aishdnia qf sijicqhijx sina spich`hc kai}qhshnd f``i}s qlkq

ysi}s bkx mi hnqi}isqia hn mksia fn qlih} ‚q}kcgia‒ p}ihfys py}clksis

f} kcqhhqx kna qf insy}i qli {ykjhqx f` si}hcis aijhi}ia qf ysi}s mxbfnhqf}hnd ysi} kcciss kcqhhqx.

Lftii}* hn`f}bkqhfn kccissia mx f} sfja qf qli t}fnd lknas cfyja mi

aiksqkqhnd qf kn hnahhaykj. Kn i|kbpji f` qlhs fccy}}ia tlin Bs. X*

k d}kai sclffj qikcli} lka li} nkbi cfbi yp fn kn i"bkhj bkhjhnd jhsq

kssfchkqia thql k cfnq}kmkna p}isc}hpqhfn a}yds fpi}kqhfn qlkq lka

miin sihuia ay}hnd k }kha. Kjqlfydl hq lka miin jkqi} `fyna qlkq Bs. X*

jhgi bknx fqli}s fn qli jhsq ti}i shbpjx qk}diqia hcqhbs f` k bkss i"

bkhj sfjhchqkqhfn jhsq* qli `kcq qlkq hn`f}bkqhfn `}fb li} i"bkhj kccfynq

p}fhai} hnahckqia qli }icihpq f` k bisskdi `}fb qli fpi}kqhfn kna ksinq }ipjx bisskdi qlkq cfyja lki }khsia `y}qli} sysphchfn. Lftii}*

dhin qlkq qli i"bkhj kcqhhqx jfd aha nfq sqf}i qli mfax f` qli bisskdi

kna Bs. X‘s i|pjknkqhfn f` qli }ipjx shbpjx mihnd k }i{yisq qf mi

}ibfia `}fb qli bkhjhnd jhsq siibia c}iahmji dhin nf fqli}

cfbbynh{yès ti}i jfddia. Bf}i hbpf}qknqjx* Bs. X tfyja lki nii}

miin pjkcia fn qli jhsq h` qli likjql }ijkqia timshqi sli }idhsqi}ia thql

ks k ysi} lka nfq sfja li} hn`f}bkqhfn qf kn i"bkhj bk}giqhnd `h}b tlf

jkqi} }i"sfja hq qf qli cfnq}kmkna a}yds fpi}kqf}.
















isphfnkdi }hsg

bknkdibinq* p}hkcx*



c}hbi.


A}. ]fmi}q Hnd hshq

ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb

Tlhji bfsq bkx `hna cfb`f}q hn p}hkcx jkts ah}icqia qftk}as p}fqicqhnd

pi}sfnkj hn`f}bkqhfn cfjjicqia mx `h}bs hn qli cfy}si f` afhnd myshniss

thql kna si}hchnd qlih} cysqfbi}s* qli}i hs jhqqji }i`ydi f} cfb`f}q tlin

kn hnahhaykj hs cfn`}fnqia thql kccipqhnd qli qi}bs f` qli `hni p}hnq hn

qlih} ysi} kd}iibinqs f} qf mi `f}ii} thqlfyq si}hci.

Sf xfy skx xfy ckn‘q hbkdhni xfy} jhì thqlfyq xfy} cijjyjk} qijiplfni. H` xfy k}i jhgi bfsq pifpji* xfy giip xfy} cijjyjk} fn ks xfy df kmfyq xfy}

myshniss ii}x akx. Aha xfy gnft qlkq yshnd eysq qli shdnkj `}fb xfy}

cijjyjk} qijiplfni kna hqs ynh{yi ijicq}fnhc hainqh`hckqhfn nybmi} qlkq xfy}

tli}ikmfyqs thqlhn k 1 chqx mjfcg }kahys ckn mi ikshjx qhbi sqkbpia qf

qli sicfna* akqia kna aiqi}bhnia. Qlhs ckpkmhjhqx f` pksshijx q}kcghnd

kna }icf}ahnd qli tli}ikmfyqs f` hnahhaykjs lks miin i`ìcqhijx ysia

ks syppf}qhnd ihainci qf pjkci f} nfq qf pjkci syspicqs kq f} nik} qli

scinis f` c}hbis. Ckjj }icf}as f` cijjyjk} qijiplfnis lki kjsf miin

hnsq}ybinqkj hn giiphnd pifpji hn kna fyq f` ekhj ks tijj tlin hq cfbis qf

kjhmhs. Qli skbi lfjas q}yi `f} qli aiqkhjia mhjjhnd ìkqy}i f` bfnqljx

cijjyjk} mhjjs* xfy gnft . . . qlkq jhsqhnd f` akqi* qhbi kna qijiplfni nybmi}

ckjjia f} }icihia. Qli aiqkhjia mhjjhnd ìkqy}i lks miin qli aibhsi f`

bknx kn yn`khql`yj spfysi. Ks fni Y.S. hnqijjhdinci f``hchkj fnci skha*

‚† cijjyjk} qijiplfnis k}i fni f` qli d}ikqisq sy}ihjjknci kakncibinqs

f` fy} qhbi. Qlix inkmji ynfmq}yshi sy}ihjjknci f` p}kcqhckjjx knxfni kq

knxqhbi.‒

Sf pi}lkps xfy‘}i qlhnghnd xfy slfyja eysq qy}n xfy} cijjyjk} qijiplfni f``

kna bkxmi spina sfbi qhbi eysq qkghnd k tkjg qf qli bkjj kna lkhnd k

{yhiq cyp f` cf`ìi hn qli ̀ ffa cfy}q. Jffg yp* tkx yp+ Af xfy sii qlfsislhnx mjkcg afbis hn qli cihjhnd* f} qlfsi mf|is thql mjkcg djkss f} qli

fmhfys ckbi}k hn k tlhqi f} d}ix mf| lkndhnd f`` f` k pfsq6 Xfy sii

qlib fn sq}iiq cf}ni}s* hn bkjjs* f``hci myhjahnds* q}knshq sqkqhfns kna

lhdltkxs. Xfy k}i ynai} sy}ihjjknci kna xfy} p}isinci hs mihnd

}icf}aia* akqia kna qhbi sqkbpia. Sicy}hqx haif ckbi}k sy}ihjjknci hs

bf}i thaisp}ika hn bkef} chqhis qlkn qli pymjhc qlhngs. H` xfy jhi f} tf}g

hn aftnqftn Bfnq}ikj* Fqqktk* Qf}fnqf f} Pkncfyi} k qxphckj fni tkx

q}hp thjj ckysi xfy} hbkdi qf mi }icf}aia kn ki}kdi f` 8 qhbis mx 4

hnaipinainq haif sy}ihjjknci sxsqibs. <9) f` haif sy}ihjjknci

sxsqibs k}i ftnia kna fpi}kqia mx cf}pf}kqhfns `f} ysi fn qlih}

p}fpi}qx sycl ks bkjjs kna f``hci myhjahnds* thql nf jidhsjkqia dyhaijhnisfn tlkq qlix ckn af thql qlhs }icf}aia sy}ihjjknci akqk. Sicy}hqx haif

}icf}ahnds k}i gipq kn ki}kdi f` 3 bfnqls mi`f}i qlix k}i i}ksia f}

py}dia.
















isphfnkdi }hsg

bknkdibinq* p}hkcx*



c}hbi.


A}. ]fmi}q Hnd hshq

ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb

Qf diq ktkx `}fb hq kjj xfy bkx cfnshai} k {yhiq a}hi hn qli cfynq}x* `k}

}ibfia `}fb qli lysqji* qli mysqji kna qlfsi p}hkcx hnkai}s myq . . .

xfy ckn }yn myq xfy ckn‘q lhai. Bfsq nit ilhcjis cfbi i{yhppia thql k

skìqx fpqhfn qlkq kjjfts xfy qf mi hn hnsqknq jhi qtf"tkx cfbbynhckqhfn

thql k ahspkqcl cinq}i slfyja xfy lki kn kcchainq f} eysq diq jfsq. Qlhs

si}hci thjj nfq fnjx qkjg xfy ql}fydl xfy} ibi}dincx myq kjsf ynjfcg xfy}

aff}s h` xfy k}i jfcgia fyq kna thjj iin phnpfhnq qli i|kcq jfckqhfn f`

xfy} ilhcji yshnd D_S skqijjhqi q}kcghnd h` hq hs sqfjin. D_S skqijjhqiq}kcghnd hs qli skbi qiclnfjfdx ysia mx qli bhjhqk}x kna eysq jhgi bhjhqk}x

qk}diqs7 xfy} ilhcji‘s jfckqhfn ckn mi aiqi}bhnia thqlhn 3 biq}is.

Shbhjk} hn"ilhcji sicy}hqx fnjx sxsqibs kjsf ysi D_S qf q}kcg kna jfckqi

sqfjin ilhcjis. Qlhs qiclnfjfdx hs nfq fnjx kkhjkmji ks kn fpqhfn tlin

xfy py}clksi xfy} nit f} ysia ilhcji myq hs nft sqknak}a i{yhpbinq fn

bfsq ilhcjis xfy bkx }inq `f} qlkq tiigina diqktkx.

Kjqlfydl qli skìqx kna sicy}hqx mini`hqs f` qlisi aihcis k}i nybi}fys*

sf k}i qli p}hkcx }hsgs. Fni k}ik f` cfnci}n hs qlkq qli hn"ilhcji qtf"

tkx cfbbynhckqhfn ìkqy}i ckn mi kcqhkqia mx qli ahspkqcl cinq}i

thqlfyq qli ilhcji fccypknqs mihnd ktk}i qlkq ii}x tf}a qlix skx ckn

mi bfnhqf}ia kna }icf}aia. Bfhnd ilhcjis kna qlih} pk}gia jfckqhfns

ckn kjsf mi aiqi}bhnia thqlfyq knx fccypknq gnftjiadi. Ay}hnd qli

pksq ìt xik}s qli}i lki miin afcybinqia cksis tli}i jkt

in`f}cibinq kdinchis lki yqhjhuia sycl bikns ks kn kha qf

cfninqhfnkj sy}ihjjknci biqlfas.

Qli }ikj kmhjhqx qf pyq kn ki}kdi chqhuin ynai} sy}ihjjknci* cfjjicq

pi}sfnkj hn`f}bkqhfn kna hnkai p}hkcx ysia qf mi qli sfji afbkhn f` dfi}nbinqs kmfyq =9 xik}s kdf. Lftii}* thql qli kccisshmhjhqx qf* kna

k``f}akmhjhqx f` qiclnfjfdx* qli kmhjhqx kjmihq hn k jhbhqia tkx qf q}kcg kna

c}ikqi afsshi}s fn hnahhaykjs mx cf}pf}kqi snffps kna iin p}hkqi

hnahhaykjs hs kn iksx qksg. Mik}hnd hn bhna qlkq ynjhgi dfi}nbinqs*

p}hkqi cf}pf}kqhfns kna hnahhaykjs kcqhnd kjfni f} fn milkj` f` sfbifni

ijsi k}i nfq mfyna mx sycl sq}hndinq cfnq}fjs qf p}fqicq qli aibfc}kqhc

}hdlqs kna `}iiafbs f` chqhuins. Tlhji p}hkcx kna pi}sfnkj hn`f}bkqhfn

jkts af ahcqkqi lft myshnissis bysq sqf}i kna ahssibhnkqi hn`f}bkqhfn

pi}qkhnhnd qf qlih} cysqfbi}s* jffplfjis k}i ikshjx c}ikqia mx `hni p}hnq

ysi} kd}iibinqs kna qli kccipqknci mx qli pfqinqhkj cysqfbi} f` qli

ysi} kd}iibinq hs aibknaia hn f}ai} qf fmqkhn si}hci `}fb qli myshnisshn {yisqhfn.
















isphfnkdi }hsg

bknkdibinq* p}hkcx*



c}hbi.


A}. ]fmi}q Hnd hshq

ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb

Ynjhgi dfi}nbinqs* p}hkqi cf}pf}kqhfns kna hnahhaykjs k}i kmji qf

fpi}kqi hn d}ix f} fpin k}iks f` qli jkt hn cfjjicqhnd kna cfbpk}hnd

hn`f}bkqhfn `}fb fqli} p}hkqi cf}pf}kqhfns kna hnahhaykjs thql bhnhbkj

clicgs kna mkjkncis. @y}qli}bf}i* tlin fni cfnshai}s qlkq aisphqi

jidhsjkqhfn kna cfais f` cfnaycq* qli mfqqfb jhni hs qlkq qli}i thjj kjtkxs

mi sfbifni tlf gnfts sfbifni* tlf gnfts sfbifni ijsi tlf ckn

fmqkhn qli }i{yh}ia hn`f}bkqhfn ql}fydl k jft jiij cfnqkcq thql kcciss qf

qli }i{yisqia hn`f}bkqhfn. H` qlhs sfynas ̀ ynnx* afn‘q jkydl mickysi knxsq}iiq skx p}hkqii} thjj }ijycqknqjx kabhq qlkq qlhs hs lft qlhnds }ikjjx

diq afni.

_i}sfnkj p}hkcx bysq sqk}q kna sqfp thql qli hnahhaykj. Xfy bysq

ck}i`yjjx }ihit si}hci kd}iibinqs mi`f}i kccipqhnd qlib. Hs qli

si}hci* p}faycq f} cfninhinci xfy k}i hnqi}isqia hn }ikjjx tf}ql dhhnd

yp sfbi f` xfy} p}hkcx6 Af xfy }ikjjx tknq qf dhi sfbifni qli

pfqinqhkj kmhjhqx qf q}kcg xfy} bfibinqs fn k akhjx mkshs6

Eysq k `hnkj qlfydlq . . . afn‘q mi sy}p}hsia h` k qfqkj sq}kndi} cfbis yp qf

xfy fni akx kna ckn qijj xfy tlkq cfjfy} xfy p}i`i} hn ynai}tik}* tli}i

xfy slfp* qlkq xfy qkgi qli jfnd tkx lfbi kna qlkq xfy tfyja mi kmji qf

ckjj xfy} bfqli} bf}i f`qin h` xfy ahan‘q sqkx sf jfnd fn xfy} cfbpyqi}.

Fnjx xfy lki qli pfti} qf nfq jiq qlhs lkppin.

Kmfyq qli Kyqlf}

A}. ]fmi}q Hnd hs k `f}inshc hnqijjhdinci spichkjhsq kna lks kppik}ia fn

Nf}ql Kbi}hckn nits niqtf}gs fn qli hssyis f` qiclnfjfdx c}hbi*

cfbpyqi} sicy}hqx* p}hkcx kna hainqhqx qli`q.

@f} bf}i k}qhcjis mx A}. ]fmi}q Hnd pjiksi hshq ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb

Cfpx}hdlq ¨ =??9"=?;; A}. ]fmi}q Hnd* ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb

_i}bhsshfn hs d}knqia qf pymjhsl qlhs k}qhcji ijicq}fnhckjjx f} hn p}hnq* `}iif` clk}di* ks jfnd ks qli k}qhcji kppik}s hn hqs inqh}iqx*

`yjj c}iahq hs dhin qf qli kyqlf} kna k jhng f} }i`i}inci qf qli kyqlf}$s

timpkdi ttt.a}}fmi}qhnd.cfb hs p}fhaia.

enemy of the state of privacy

Documents