energy commission agenda - berkeley, california...2017/07/26 · ordinance (item 10), and shared...
TRANSCRIPT
Berkeley Energy Commission
ENERGY COMMISSION AGENDA Wednesday, July 26, 2017 North Berkeley Senior Center
1901 Hearst Street 6:30 P.M.
Preliminary Matters:
1. Call to Order and Roll Call 2. Public Comments and Announcements 3. Approval of Minutes from Last Meeting (June 28, 2017)
Discussion and Action Items:
4. Prioritization of Council Referrals to Staff 5. Council Referral on Wind Turbines 6. Discussion on Reach Codes - Low-Carbon Water Heating and Solar PV 7. Report from Natural Gas Phase Out Subcommittee (Commissioner Leger) 8. Report from Potential Revenue Sources Subcommittee 9. Discuss Proposal to Recommend Action on Clean Renewable Energy Bonds
(Commissioner Jiang) 10. BESO Report (Staff) 11. Reports from Council Members:
Mayor Arreguin (Commissioner Stromberg) Councilmember Maio (Commissioner Bernhardt) Councilmember Davila (Commissioner Bell) Councilmember Bartlett (Commissioner Luce) Councilmember Harrison (Commissioner Weems) Councilmember Droste (Commissioner Johnston) Councilmember Worthington (Commissioner Jiang) Councilmember Wengraf (Commissioner Schlachter) Councilmember Hahn (Commissioner Leger)
12. Items for Next Month’s Agenda: East Bay Community Energy CAP inventory Update
Communications: None Late Communications from Previous Meeting: EC 2017-06-28 Presentation on Heat Pump Water Heaters
Adjournment
Page 2 Energy Commission Agenda July 26, 2017
Meeting Access: This meeting is being held in a wheelchair accessible location. To request a disability-related accommodation(s) to participate in the meeting, including auxiliary aids or services, please contact the Disability Services Specialist, at 981-6418 (V) or 981-6347 (TDD), at least three business days before the meeting date. Please refrain from wearing scented products to this meeting. Communications are Public Records: Communications to Berkeley boards, commis-sions, or committees are public record and will become part of the City’s electronic records, which are accessible through the City’s website. Please note: e-mail addresses, names, addresses, and other contact information are not required, but if included in any communication to a City board, commission, or committee, will become part of the public record. If you do not want your e-mail address or any other contact information to be made public, you may deliver communications via U.S. Postal Service, or in person, to the secretary of the relevant board, commission, or committee. If you do not want your contact information included in the public record, please do not include that information in your communication. Please contact the commission secretary, Billi Romain, for further information, at 1947 Center St., 1st Floor, Berkeley, CA, 94704, Telephone: (510) 981-7432, Email: [email protected]. Any writings or documents provided to a majority of the Commission regarding any item on this agenda will be made available for public inspection at the Office of Energy and Sustainable Development, located at 1947 Center, during regular business hours. The Commission Agenda packets and Minutes may be viewed on the City of Berkeley website: http://www.cityofberkeley.info/commissions.
Item 3 July 26, 2017
Berkeley Energy Commission
ENERGY COMMISSION MINUTES Wednesday, June 28, 2017
1. Call to Order and Roll Call The meeting was called to order by Chair Bell at 6:37 p.m.
Commissioners Present: Bell, Johnston, Leger, Luce, Stromberg, Jiang, and Weems. Commissioners Absent: Bernhardt, Schlachter Staff: Katie Van Dyke Guest: Rachel Golden Public: Six members of the public including Luis Amezcua of the Sierra Club and members of the League of Women Voters.
2. Public Comments and Announcements: Luis Amezcua shared that on July 6 East Bay Clean Energy (EBCE) Community Advisory
Committee will be meeting for the first time on July 6 (more information at http://ebce.org/public-meetings/). He also expressed support for the EV Charging Ordinance (Item 10), and shared that the Sierra Club has supported similar ordinances in Oakland and San Francisco.
3. Approval of Minutes from Last Meeting (May 24, 2017)
Motion/second to approve the minutes from the previous Energy Commission meeting (Leger, Stromberg). The motion carried 7-0-0-2 (Ayes: Bell, Jiang, Johnston, Leger, Luce, Stromberg, and Weems. Noes: None. Abstain: None. Absent: Bernhardt, Schlachter).
4. Presentation on Heat Pump Water Heaters
Rachel Golden, Senior Campaign Representative of the Sierra Club provided an overview of heat pump water heaters and the model renewable water heating ordinance developed by the Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC). This topic will be discussed further in
the next meeting.
5. Report from the Community Environmental Advisory Committee (CEAC)/Energy
Commission Joint Subcommittee on Natural Gas Phase-out Commissioner Leger reported on the joint subcommittee meeting which included a presentation from Pierre Delforge of the Natural Resources Defense Council on reach code model ordinance developed by NRDC for low-carbon water heating.
6. Update on Berkeley Energy Assurance Transformation (BEAT) Project
Katie Van Dyke provided an update on the BEAT microgrid project, including the completion of the regulatory, technical, and financial feasibility analyses as well as the convening of the first Technical Advisory Committee on June 22.
Energy Commission Minutes from June 28, 2017 Item 3
Page 2 of 3 July 26, 2017
7. Potential climate action funding sources for incentives Katie Van Dyke provided an overview of different options that exist for funding climate action plan programs such as Deep Green. The Commission moved to develop a subcommittee to evaluate funding options for decarbonization efforts. The subcommittee would include Commissioners Stromberg, Leger, Weems and Bell. Motion/second to create a Subcommittee to evaluate funding options for decarbonization efforts (Stromberg, Weems). The motion carried 7-0-0-2 (Ayes: Bell, Jiang, Johnston, Leger, Luce, Stromberg, and Weems. Noes: None. Abstain: None. Absent: Bernhardt, Schlachter).
8. Clean Air Plan Commissioner Stromberg provided an update on the Bay Area Air Quality Management District (BAAQMD)’s Clean Air Plan. The primary areas of focus in the plan are around efficiency in industrial sources, transportation, and building decarbonization.
9. Energy Use Requirements for Medical Cannabis Cultivation
Commissioner Bell provided an update on proposed ordinance to that would amend the energy use requirements for cannabis cultivation locations that allows cultivators to purchase energy from 100% renewable energy (e.g. through Community Choice Energy).
10. Council Referral for a Reach Code on Electric Vehicles Commissioner Bell provided an update on a referral from Council to the Energy
Commission and City Manager to develop an electric vehicle charging ordinance. This topic will be discussed further in September.
11. Reports from Other Commissions:
Planning Commission – Commissioner Bell reported that the Planning commission is looking at setbacks and other requirements for auxiliary dwelling units.
Parks & Waterfront Commission – Commissioner Weems reported that the Disaster & Fire Commission wrote to the Parks & Waterfront Commission regarding interest in installing charging stations in parks in the event of a disaster, and this was a recommendation submitted to the Parks & Waterfront Commission for T1 funds.
Public Works Commission – None CEAC – Commissioner Johnston reported that the committee is focused on cigarette
butt waste, the natural gas phase-out subcommittee, greenwater infrastructure, and climate change impacts on biodiversity.
Zero Waste Commission – Commissioer Luce reported the committee is focused on a ban on plastic straws.
Transportation Commission – Commissioner Leger reported that the City passed the updated Bike Plan.
12. Discussion on Work Plan and Mission Commissioner Bell provided an update that both the Energy Commmission work plan
and a resolution upcoming items for council (on the Utility User’s Tax (UUT) and work plan?) are scheduled to be on the agenda for the July 26, 2017 Council meeting.
Energy Commission Minutes from June 28, 2017 Item 3
Page 3 of 3 July 26, 2017
13. Items for Next Month’s Agenda: Council Prioritization Process BESO Update NRDC Model Ordinance & Cost Effectiveness Study PV Reach Codes East Bay Clean Energy (September) EV Readiness Referral Natural Gas Phase-Out Potential climate action funding sources for incentives
Communications: None Late Communications:
Adjournment Motion/second to adjourn at 8:46 (Jiang, Johnston). The motion carried 7-0-0-2 (Ayes: Bell, Jiang, Johnston, Leger, Luce, Stromberg, and Weems. Noes: None. Abstain: None. Absent: Bernhardt, Schlachter).
Berk
ele
y C
ity
Council
Refe
rral P
rioritization a
ppro
ved M
ay
30,
2017
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
4/2
5/2
01
74
1Sm
all
Bu
sin
ess
Su
pp
ort
Pa
cka
ge
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
the
de
velo
pm
en
t o
f a
pa
cka
ge
of
po
licie
s a
nd
pro
gra
ms
to s
up
po
rt t
he
est
ab
lish
me
nt
of
ne
w,
an
d s
ust
ain
ab
ility
of
exi
stin
g s
ma
ll a
nd
/or
loca
lly o
wn
ed
bu
sin
ess
es.
Me
asu
res
to e
xplo
re,
eva
lua
te a
nd
re
po
rt b
ack
on
as
pa
rt o
f th
e p
ack
ag
e in
clu
de
, b
ut
are
no
t
limit
ed
to
: 1
. A
pro
gra
m t
o p
rovi
de
fin
an
cia
l an
d o
the
r fo
rms
of
sup
po
rt
to s
ma
ll/lo
cally
ow
ne
d b
usi
ne
sse
s a
nd
no
t-fo
r-p
rofi
ts im
pa
cte
d b
y
de
velo
pm
en
t p
roje
cts,
eit
he
r d
ue
to
dir
ect
dis
pla
cem
en
t o
r to
dir
ect
or
ind
ire
ct b
usi
ne
ss in
terf
ere
nce
or
inte
rru
pti
on
; 2
. A
pro
gra
m t
o r
ea
ch o
ut
to,
wo
rk w
ith
, h
elp
de
velo
p a
nd
att
ract
sm
all/
loca
l bu
sin
ess
es
to
est
ab
lish
th
em
selv
es
in B
erk
ele
y a
nd
to
ass
ist
exi
stin
g s
ma
ll/lo
cal
bu
sin
ess
es
to r
em
ain
in B
erk
ele
y w
ith
a f
ocu
s o
n w
om
en
an
d m
ino
rity
ow
ne
rs;
3.
Ta
xes
an
d/o
r fe
es
on
va
can
t st
ore
fro
nts
, b
uild
ing
s a
nd
/or
em
pty
lots
; 4
. A
On
e-S
top
Sm
all/
Loca
l Bu
sin
ess
Ad
voca
cy C
en
ter
to
coo
rdin
ate
, fa
cilit
ate
an
d e
xpe
dit
e p
erm
itti
ng
, lic
en
sin
g,
pa
yme
nt
of
Ha
hn
OE
D1
4/4
/20
17
26
Re
ferr
al R
esp
on
se:
Ge
nd
er
Pa
y E
qu
ity
2.
Co
mp
lete
a p
ay
au
dit
on
th
e s
ala
rie
s o
f C
ity
of
Be
rke
ley
em
plo
yee
s to
inve
stig
ate
po
ten
tia
l ge
nd
er
pa
y g
ap
s w
ith
in t
he
cit
y w
ork
forc
e
CO
SOW
Au
dit
or
2
7/1
9/2
01
62
4P
erm
it S
erv
ice
Ce
nte
r Im
pro
vem
en
tsR
efe
r to
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
incl
ud
e in
cu
rre
nt
eff
ort
s to
imp
rove
th
e
Lan
d U
se P
erm
itti
ng
pro
cess
th
e f
ollo
win
g p
rop
osa
ls t
o in
cre
ase
th
e
eff
icie
ncy
an
d o
utr
ea
ch o
f th
e P
erm
it S
erv
ice
Ce
nte
r, m
aki
ng
th
e
pe
rmit
tin
g p
roce
ss e
asi
er
for
sta
ff a
nd
ap
plic
an
ts a
like
. Sp
eci
fic
pro
po
sals
to c
on
sid
er
incl
ud
e:
1.
We
bsi
te im
pro
vem
en
ts f
or
tra
ckin
g o
f p
erm
its,
calc
ula
tin
g p
erm
it f
ee
s, a
nd
ap
ply
ing
on
line
; 2
. C
ase
Ma
na
ge
rs f
or
coo
rdin
ate
d in
take
of
pe
rmit
ap
plic
ati
on
s a
nd
ma
teri
als
; 3
. In
form
ati
on
al
ma
teri
als
incl
ud
ing
an
imp
rove
d u
ser
gu
ide
an
d in
fog
rap
hic
s m
od
ele
d
aft
er
Biz
Gri
d;
4.
Cu
sto
me
r se
rvic
e im
pro
vem
en
ts a
t th
e C
en
ter
incl
ud
ing
a f
ast
tra
ck li
ne
, ki
osk
s, a
nd
an
on
line
ap
po
intm
en
t b
oo
kin
g s
yste
m.
Arr
eg
uin
(D
4)
Pla
nn
ing
3
2/2
8/2
01
72
7B
erk
ele
y D
ee
p G
ree
n B
uild
ing
Init
iati
ve (
Co
nti
nu
ed
fro
m N
ove
mb
er
15
, 2
01
6)
Re
vise
d m
ate
ria
ls
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
an
d E
ne
rgy
Co
mm
issi
on
th
e d
eve
lop
me
nt
of
po
licie
s a
nd
pro
gra
ms
to im
pro
ve t
he
en
erg
y e
ffic
ien
cy a
nd
su
sta
ina
bili
ty
of
bu
ildin
gs
ba
sed
on
th
e B
erk
ele
y D
ee
p G
ree
n B
uild
ing
pro
po
sal.
Arr
eg
uin
Pla
nn
ing
4
3/1
4/2
01
72
3P
ote
nti
al R
ecr
ea
tio
na
l Op
po
rtu
nit
ies
at
Will
ard
Pa
rk a
nd
Po
ol
Re
fer
the
issu
e o
f re
cre
ati
on
al o
pp
ort
un
itie
s in
th
e v
icin
ity
of
Will
ard
Pa
rk t
o t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er,
Pa
rks
an
d W
ate
rfro
nt
Co
mm
issi
on
an
d t
he
2X
2
Co
mm
itte
e o
f th
e C
ity
Co
un
cil a
nd
th
e B
oa
rd o
f E
du
cati
on
to
de
term
ine
the
be
st c
ou
rse
of
act
ion
fo
r in
cre
ase
d r
ecr
ea
tio
na
l eq
uit
y in
So
uth
Be
rke
ley,
incl
ud
ing
bu
t n
ot
limit
ed
to
th
e r
e-o
pe
nin
g o
f W
illa
rd P
oo
l.
Au
tho
rize
sta
ff t
o d
eve
lop
co
st e
stim
ate
s fo
r a
min
ima
l le
vel o
f re
pa
irs
to
ge
t W
illa
rd P
oo
l op
era
tio
na
l.
Dro
ste
Pa
rks,
Re
c, W
ate
rfro
nt
5
Item 4 July 26, 2017
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
4/2
5/2
01
74
2 C
om
pre
he
nsi
ve S
tud
y o
f E
me
rge
ncy
Serv
ice
s C
all
Ce
nte
r, S
taff
ing
an
dD
eve
lop
me
nt
Syst
em
s
Re
vise
d M
ate
ria
ls
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
an
d t
he
Dis
ast
er
an
d F
ire
Sa
fety
Co
mm
issi
on
to w
ork
wit
h t
he
Be
rke
ley
Fire
De
pa
rtm
en
t a
nd
Be
rke
ley
Fire
fig
hte
rs
Ass
oci
ati
on
to
inve
stig
ate
th
e D
ep
art
me
nt’
s cu
rre
nt
pra
ctic
es
an
d
de
term
ine
th
e f
ea
sib
ility
of
imp
lem
en
tin
g a
cri
teri
a-b
ase
d d
isp
atc
hin
g
syst
em
th
at
allo
cate
s st
aff
ing
ba
sed
on
ne
ed
an
d r
isk,
en
sure
s th
at
calls
are
pri
ori
tize
d b
ase
d o
n a
cuit
y, a
nd
mo
re e
ffic
ien
tly
de
live
rs t
he
ap
pro
pri
ate
allo
cati
on
of
reso
urc
es
to e
very
91
1 c
all.
In
clu
de
Alt
a B
ate
s
ER
clo
sure
in a
na
lysi
s.
Ha
hn
Fire
6
4/4
/20
17
21
Re
ferr
al t
o t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
to
Allo
w N
on
-co
mm
erc
ial U
se o
n G
rou
nd
Flo
or
Re
fer
to t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
an
am
en
dm
en
t to
th
e Z
on
ing
Ord
ina
nce
to
cre
ate
a u
se p
erm
it p
roce
ss t
o a
llow
no
n-c
om
me
rcia
l use
on
th
e g
rou
nd
flo
or
in a
pp
rop
ria
te lo
cati
on
s, w
he
re c
om
me
rcia
l mig
ht
oth
erw
ise
be
re
qu
ire
d.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
Pla
nn
ing
7
4/4
/20
17
26
Re
ferr
al R
esp
on
se:
Ge
nd
er
Pa
y E
qu
ity
1.
Dir
ect
sta
ff t
o d
raft
an
ord
ina
nce
re
late
d t
o a
n e
qu
al p
ay
ven
do
r
pre
fere
nce
fo
r ci
ty c
on
tra
cto
rs w
ho
de
mo
nst
rate
eq
ua
l pa
y fo
r m
ale
an
d
fem
ale
em
plo
yee
s (g
en
de
r b
ase
d o
n s
elf
-id
en
tifi
cati
on
)
CO
SOW
Fin
an
ce8
4/2
6/2
01
65
1R
efe
rra
l to
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
: C
ity-
Wid
e G
ree
n D
eve
lop
me
nt
Re
qu
ire
me
nts
Re
fer
to t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
, E
ne
rgy
Co
mm
issi
on
, a
nd
th
e
Co
mm
un
ity
En
viro
nm
en
tal A
dvi
sory
Co
mm
issi
on
to
co
nsi
de
r re
qu
irin
g
the
sa
me
Gre
en
Bu
ildin
g a
nd
Tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
De
ma
nd
Ma
na
ge
me
nt
(TD
M)
me
asu
res
req
uir
ed
in t
he
Co
mm
erc
ial D
ow
nto
wn
Mix
ed
Use
Dis
tric
t (C
-DM
U)
for
pro
ject
s o
f 7
5 u
nit
s o
r m
ore
th
rou
gh
ou
t th
e C
ity
of
Be
rke
ley’
s co
mm
erc
ial z
on
ing
dis
tric
ts.
Th
e c
om
mis
sio
ns
are
to
co
nsi
de
r
the
sta
nd
ard
s a
s o
utl
ine
d in
th
e r
ep
ort
wh
ich
wo
uld
ap
ply
to
larg
er
pro
ject
s ci
ty-w
ide
an
d p
ert
ain
to
: b
icyc
le p
ark
ing
sp
ace
s, v
eh
icle
sh
ari
ng
spa
ces,
Re
sid
en
tia
l Pa
rkin
g P
erm
its,
re
qu
ire
d p
ark
ing
sp
ace
s, L
EE
D r
ati
ng
,
Sto
pw
ast
e S
ma
ll C
om
me
rcia
l Ch
eck
list
sta
nd
ard
s, a
nd
tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
be
ne
fits
. I
n a
dd
itio
n,
the
co
mm
issi
on
s a
re t
o a
lso
co
nsi
de
r th
e f
ollo
win
g
1.
tha
t tr
an
sit
pa
sse
s w
ou
ld o
nly
be
re
qu
ire
d f
or
pro
ject
s w
ith
in a
qu
art
er
of
a m
ile o
f a
bu
s st
op
; 2
. a
sq
ua
re-f
oo
tag
e t
hre
sho
ld,
in a
dd
itio
n t
o t
he
un
it t
hre
sho
ld,
for
pro
ject
s to
wh
ich
th
e r
eq
uir
em
en
ts w
ou
ld a
pp
ly,
3.
the
va
lidit
y o
f th
e L
EE
D c
ert
ific
ati
on
; a
nd
4.
the
imp
act
on
th
e f
ina
nci
al
fea
sib
ility
of
pro
po
sed
re
qu
ire
me
nts
on
th
e d
eve
lop
me
nt
of
ho
usi
ng
an
d
aff
ord
ab
le h
ou
sin
g in
pa
rtic
ula
r.
4P
lan
nin
g9
20
16
-15
10
/6/2
01
51
2R
efe
rra
l to
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r: P
rio
riti
ze
Clim
ate
Act
ion
Pla
n’s
Po
licy
to
Re
de
sig
n/R
eb
uild
th
e B
erk
ele
y T
ran
sfe
r
Sta
tio
n a
nd
Ma
teri
al R
eco
very
Fa
cilit
y
into
a S
tate
of
the
Art
Ze
ro W
ast
e
Faci
lity
Re
ferr
al t
o t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er:
Pri
ori
tize
th
e C
ity
of
Be
rke
ley'
s C
lima
te
Act
ion
Pla
n's
po
licy
to r
ed
esi
gn
/re
bu
ild t
he
Be
rke
ley
Tra
nsf
er
Sta
tio
n a
nd
the
ma
teri
al r
eco
very
fa
cilit
y in
to a
sta
te o
f th
e a
rt Z
ero
Wa
ste
fa
cilit
y.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(Dis
t. 7
)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
10
2
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
20
16
-52
7/8
/20
14
14
Ele
ctri
c V
eh
icle
s fo
r th
e C
ity
Fle
et
Re
qu
est
th
at
the
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
retu
rn t
o t
he
Co
un
cil w
ith
a F
lee
t C
lima
te
Act
ion
Pla
n f
or
tra
nsi
tio
n t
o a
ll-e
lect
ric
veh
icle
s (E
Vs)
or
plu
g-h
ybri
ds
for
the
Cit
y fl
ee
t. T
he
pla
n c
ou
ld:
1.
set
an
nu
al t
arg
ets
fo
r g
ree
nh
ou
se g
as
(GH
G)
red
uct
ion
s fr
om
Cit
y fl
ee
t
op
era
tio
ns
in s
up
po
rt o
f th
e C
ity’
s C
lima
te A
ctio
n P
lan
;
2.
req
uir
e r
ep
laci
ng
all
no
n-e
me
rge
ncy
ve
hic
les
an
d a
ll p
oss
ible
em
erg
en
cy v
eh
icle
s w
ith
EV
s o
r p
lug
-in
hyb
rid
s b
y A
pri
l 1,
20
25
, w
ith
an
inte
rim
go
al o
f a
ce
rta
in p
erc
en
t b
y A
pri
l 1,
20
18
;
3.
req
uir
e c
on
vers
ion
wh
ere
ver
po
ssib
le t
o h
ybri
d v
eh
icle
s in
ca
ses
wh
ere
EV
s o
r p
lug
-in
hyb
rid
s a
re n
ot
yet
fea
sib
le;
an
d
4.
con
sid
er
the
Ad
dit
ion
al M
ea
sure
s a
s d
esc
rib
ed
in t
he
re
po
rt.
Ma
yor
Ba
tes,
We
ng
raf
(Dis
t. 6
)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
11
12
/13
/20
16
41
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al:
Su
pp
ort
Be
rke
ley
No
n-P
rofi
t Se
rvic
e P
rovi
de
rs t
o
Ass
ist
Pla
nn
ing
fo
r C
ap
ita
l Re
no
vati
on
,
Re
ha
bili
tati
on
an
d/o
r R
elo
cati
on
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to s
up
po
rt B
erk
ele
y n
on
-pro
fit
serv
ice
pro
vid
ers
by
exa
min
ing
me
tho
ds
to a
ssis
t p
lan
nin
g f
or
cap
ita
l re
no
vati
on
,
reh
ab
ilita
tio
n a
nd
/or
relo
cati
on
.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(D7
)
OE
D1
2
20
16
-11
7/1
4/2
01
53
7R
efe
rra
l to
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
:
Gu
idin
g D
eve
lop
me
nt
on
Sa
n P
ab
lo
Ave
nu
e
Re
fer
to t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
th
e d
eve
lop
me
nt
of
a P
lan
to
gu
ide
de
velo
pm
en
t o
n S
an
Pa
blo
Ave
nu
e.
Ma
io (
Dis
t. 1
),
Mo
ore
(D
ist.
2)
Pla
nn
ing
13
7/1
2/2
01
64
1C
om
mu
nit
y C
on
tro
l of
Surv
eill
an
ce
Eq
uip
me
nt
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er,
th
e P
olic
e R
evi
ew
Co
mm
issi
on
, a
nd
th
e P
ea
ce
an
d J
ust
ice
Co
mm
issi
on
to
co
nsi
de
r a
do
pti
ng
a c
om
mu
nit
y co
ntr
ol o
f
surv
eill
an
ce m
ea
sure
sim
ilar
to t
ha
t o
f O
rdin
an
ce N
o.
NS-
30
0.8
97
of
San
ta C
lara
Co
un
ty.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(D7
)
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
14
20
16
-54
2/1
0/2
01
51
8B
. A
me
nd
ing
BM
C C
ha
pte
r 1
1.6
0 f
or
Co
mp
ost
ab
le o
r R
ecy
cla
ble
Fo
od
wa
re
Dir
ect
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
an
aly
ze t
he
Ze
ro W
ast
e C
om
mis
sio
n's
reco
mm
en
da
tio
n;
refe
r th
e f
isca
l im
pa
cts
of
the
re
com
me
nd
ati
on
to
th
e
bu
dg
et
pro
cess
; a
nd
re
po
rt b
ack
on
th
e im
pa
ct t
o t
he
Cit
y's
Ze
ro W
ast
e
op
era
tio
ns
of
imp
lem
en
tin
g t
he
re
qu
ire
me
nt
for
com
po
sta
ble
or
recy
cla
ble
fo
od
wa
re.
Ze
ro W
ast
eP
ub
lic W
ork
s1
5
4/4
/20
17
18
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al;
Exp
an
sio
n o
f th
e
Go
Be
rke
ley
Tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
Pro
gra
m b
y
Inst
alli
ng
Str
ee
tlin
e H
ybri
d S
ma
rt
Pa
rkin
g
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al;
Exp
an
sio
n o
f th
e G
oB
erk
ele
y T
ran
spo
rta
tio
n
Pro
gra
m t
o in
clu
de
th
e in
sta
llme
nt
of
Stre
etl
ine
Hyb
rid
Sm
art
Pa
rkin
g o
n
a n
on
-exc
lusi
ve b
asi
s.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
16
9/2
7/2
01
61
7C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r R
efe
rra
l: I
mp
rove
me
nts
to B
erk
ele
y’s
Ve
ry L
ow
In
com
e T
ax
Re
lief
Re
fun
d P
rog
ram
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to m
ake
imp
rove
me
nts
to
Be
rke
ley’
s V
ery
Lo
w
Inco
me
Re
fun
d P
rog
ram
.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(D7
)
Fin
an
ce1
7
20
16
-19
2/9
/20
16
13
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al:
Exp
an
din
g G
un
Safe
ty M
ea
sure
s in
Be
rke
ley
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to c
on
sid
er
the
fo
llow
ing
ord
ina
nce
s: 1
.
Ba
nn
ing
Un
secu
red
Fir
ea
rms
An
d A
mm
un
itio
n L
oca
ted
In
Un
att
en
de
d
Ve
hic
les
In T
he
Pu
blic
Rig
ht
Of
Wa
y A
nd
"P
ub
lic P
lace
s" A
s D
efi
ne
d I
n T
he
Ord
ina
nce
; a
nd
2.
Re
qu
irin
g T
ha
t C
ity-
Issu
ed
Fir
ea
rms
In U
na
tte
nd
ed
Ve
hic
les
Be
Se
cure
d.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(Dis
t. 7
),
We
ng
raf
(Dis
t.6
)
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
18
3
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
2/1
4/2
01
72
0D
ire
ct C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
Acc
ep
t La
te
Ap
plic
ati
on
s fo
r 2
01
7-2
01
9 B
ud
ge
t
Cyc
le C
om
mu
nit
y A
ge
ncy
Gra
nts
, a
nd
to
Pro
vid
e E
nh
an
ced
In
form
ati
on
an
d
Sup
po
rt f
or
Co
mm
un
ity
Ag
en
cie
s
Du
rin
g t
he
Ap
plic
ati
on
Pro
cess
3.
De
velo
p p
roto
cols
fo
r e
nh
an
ced
ou
tre
ach
to
co
mm
un
ity
org
an
iza
tio
ns
reg
ard
ing
Co
mm
un
ity
Ag
en
cy G
ran
t a
pp
lica
tio
n s
ub
mis
sio
n d
ea
dlin
es
an
d t
o in
form
ap
plic
an
ts o
f re
sou
rce
s a
vaila
ble
to
ass
ist
in p
rep
ari
ng
an
d
sub
mit
tin
g t
ime
ly a
pp
lica
tio
ns.
4.
De
velo
p a
ha
rdsh
ip e
xem
pti
on
po
licy
for
late
ap
plic
ati
on
su
bm
issi
on
s
for
rea
son
s in
clu
din
g,
bu
t n
ot
limit
ed
to
, ch
an
ge
s in
ke
y o
rga
niz
ati
on
al
sta
ff,
tech
nic
al c
ha
llen
ge
s w
ith
su
bm
issi
on
s, a
nd
oth
er
sig
nif
ica
nt
or
un
fore
see
n b
arr
iers
to
tim
ely
su
bm
issi
on
s.
Ha
hn
HH
CS
19
20
16
-43
2/9
/20
16
27
Sup
po
rtin
g W
ork
er
Co
op
era
tive
s a
nd
Re
ferr
al t
o C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
De
velo
p a
Wo
rke
r C
oo
pe
rati
ve O
rdin
an
ce
(Co
nti
nu
ed
fro
m J
an
ua
ry 1
2,
20
16
–
Ite
m in
clu
de
s re
vise
d m
ate
ria
ls.)
Ad
op
t a
Re
solu
tio
n t
o s
up
po
rt w
ork
er
coo
pe
rati
ves,
an
d r
efe
r to
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
de
velo
p a
Wo
rke
r C
oo
pe
rati
ve O
rdin
an
ce,
wh
ich
incl
ud
es:
1.
Re
visi
ng
th
e e
xist
ing
Bu
y Lo
cal c
on
tra
ctin
g p
refe
ren
ce a
nd
ad
din
g a
wo
rke
r co
op
era
tive
pre
fere
nce
; 2
. R
evi
sin
g t
he
bu
sin
ess
pe
rmit
ap
plic
ati
on
; 3
. In
cen
tivi
zin
g e
xist
ing
bu
sin
ess
es
to c
on
vert
to
coo
pe
rati
ves;
4.
Cre
ati
ng
bu
sin
ess
ta
x a
nd
lan
d u
se in
cen
tive
s, a
nd
5.
De
velo
pin
g e
du
cati
on
al m
ate
ria
ls.
Arr
eg
uin
(D
ist.
4)
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
20
20
16
-31
7/8
/20
14
31
31
. C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r R
efe
rra
l: R
efe
r C
PT
ED
Stre
ets
cap
e f
or
Act
ion
an
d E
xplo
rati
on
of
Gra
nt
or
Oth
er
Fun
din
g
Op
po
rtu
nit
ies
to F
ind
th
e F
un
ds
to
Co
nst
ruct
th
e P
rop
ose
d I
mp
rove
me
nts
Re
fer
the
Cri
me
Pre
ven
tio
n T
hro
ug
h E
nvi
ron
me
nta
l De
sig
n (
CP
TE
D)
stre
ets
cap
e t
o t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
for
act
ion
an
d e
xplo
rati
on
of
gra
nt
or
oth
er
fun
din
g o
pp
ort
un
itie
s to
fin
d t
he
fu
nd
s to
co
nst
ruct
th
e p
rop
ose
d
imp
rove
me
nts
.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(Dis
t. 7
),
Wo
znia
k (D
ist.
8)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
21
4/4
/20
17
26
Re
ferr
al R
esp
on
se:
Ge
nd
er
Pa
y E
qu
ity
3.
De
velo
p a
n e
qu
al p
ay
cert
ific
ati
on
pro
gra
m f
or
city
co
ntr
act
ors
.C
OSO
WO
ED
22
6/2
8/2
01
64
3B
an
-th
e-B
ox
for
Em
plo
yers
Do
ing
Bu
sin
ess
wit
h t
he
Cit
y o
f B
erk
ele
y
Re
qu
est
th
at
the
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
dra
ft la
ng
ua
ge
re
qu
irin
g b
usi
ne
sse
s d
oin
g
bu
sin
ess
wit
h t
he
Cit
y o
f B
erk
ele
y to
elim
ina
te d
iscl
osu
re o
f co
nvi
ctio
n
his
tory
pri
or
to r
ece
ivin
g a
co
nd
itio
na
l off
er
of
em
plo
yme
nt.
Mo
ore
(D
2)
Fin
an
ce2
3
10
/18
/20
16
24
Exp
an
din
g t
he
Do
wn
tow
n A
rts
Dis
tric
t1
. R
eq
ue
st t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
exa
min
e e
xpa
nd
ing
th
e b
ou
nd
ari
es
of
the
cu
rre
nt
Do
wn
tow
n A
rts
Dis
tric
t O
verl
ay
as
we
ll a
s th
e a
llow
ab
le
act
ive
gro
un
d-f
loo
r u
ses.
2.
Re
qu
est
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r co
nsi
de
r th
e D
ow
nto
wn
Art
s D
istr
ict
as
pa
rt o
f th
e u
pd
ate
to
th
e B
erk
ele
y A
rts
an
d C
ult
ure
Pla
n.
Ma
yor
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
24
6/1
4/2
01
64
5a
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al:
Cre
ate
a
Pa
thw
ay
for
Cit
y E
mp
loye
es
to E
arn
a
Livi
ng
Wa
ge
Wit
hin
Tw
o Y
ea
rs
Ite
m 4
5.a
. a
me
nd
ed
to
re
ad
, “R
efe
r to
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
co
nsi
de
r a
pa
thw
ay
for
Cit
y fu
ll-ti
me
an
d p
art
tim
e e
mp
loye
es
to e
arn
a li
vin
g w
ag
e
wit
hin
tw
o y
ea
rs.”
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(D7
)
HR
25
20
16
-61
10
/21
/20
14
23
We
stb
rae
Tra
ffic
Pla
n
Re
fer
to t
he
Tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
Co
mm
issi
on
an
d C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r th
e
de
velo
pm
en
t o
f a
tra
ffic
ma
na
ge
me
nt
pla
n f
or
the
We
stb
rae
Are
a.
Ma
io (
Dis
t. 1
)P
ub
lic W
ork
s2
6
4
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
4/4
/20
17
16
Cre
ati
on
an
d A
do
pti
on
of
a T
ran
sit
Stre
ets
Co
op
era
tive
Ag
ree
me
nt
wit
h
the
Ala
me
da
-Co
ntr
a C
ost
a (
AC
) T
ran
sit
Dis
tric
t
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
the
Cre
ati
on
an
d A
do
pti
on
of
a T
ran
sit
Stre
ets
Co
op
era
tive
Ag
ree
me
nt
wit
h t
he
Ala
me
da
-Co
ntr
a C
ost
a (
AC
) T
ran
sit
Dis
tric
t.
Ha
hn
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
27
20
16
-69
3/1
5/2
01
62
1R
efe
rra
l to
Cit
y M
an
ag
er:
Do
na
tio
n o
f
Un
sold
Fo
od
to
Ch
ari
tie
s (C
on
tin
ue
d
fro
m F
eb
rua
ry 2
3,
20
16
)
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
an
d Z
ero
Wa
ste
Co
mm
issi
on
to
de
velo
p a
n
ord
ina
nce
fo
r C
ou
nci
l co
nsi
de
rati
on
re
qu
irin
g s
up
erm
ark
ets
in B
erk
ele
y
to d
on
ate
th
eir
un
sold
fo
od
to
ch
ari
ty.
If n
o lo
ng
er
ed
ible
fo
r h
um
an
con
sum
pti
on
re
qu
ire
th
at
it b
e d
on
ate
d f
or
an
ima
l fe
ed
or
com
po
st.
Arr
eg
uin
(D
ist.
4)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
28
4/4
/20
17
19
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al;
Exp
an
sio
n o
f th
e
Go
Be
rke
ley
Tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
Pro
gra
m t
o
Incr
ea
se P
ark
ing
Eff
icie
ncy
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al;
Exp
an
sio
n o
f th
e G
oB
erk
ele
y T
ran
spo
rta
tio
n
Pro
gra
m t
o a
llow
pri
vate
pa
rkin
g v
en
do
rs t
o c
ha
rge
ad
just
ab
le r
ate
s fo
r
pa
rkin
g s
pa
ces
Wo
rth
ing
ton
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
29
11
/29
/20
16
22
Urb
an
Ag
ricu
ltu
re P
ack
ag
eR
efe
r to
th
e P
lan
nin
g C
om
mis
sio
n t
o d
eve
lop
re
gu
lati
on
s to
fa
cilit
ate
urb
an
ag
ricu
ltu
re,
taki
ng
into
co
nsi
de
rati
on
th
e f
ollo
win
g c
on
cep
ts:
1.
De
sig
na
te “
urb
an
ag
ricu
ltu
re”
as
a p
rim
ary
an
d in
cid
en
tal u
se c
ate
go
ry
an
d d
efi
ne
as,
“th
e p
rod
uct
ion
of
foo
d o
r h
ort
icu
ltu
ral c
rop
s fo
r h
arv
est
,
sale
, a
nd
/or
do
na
tio
n,
no
t in
clu
din
g c
an
na
bis
”. 2
. A
dd
urb
an
ag
ricu
ltu
re
as
an
Ou
tdo
or
Use
in a
ll C
om
me
rcia
l zo
ne
s. 3
. P
erm
it u
rba
n a
gri
cult
ure
on
un
occ
up
ied
lots
in r
esi
de
nti
al z
on
es
(in
co
nte
xt o
f M
ea
sure
L).
4.
Co
nsi
de
r w
he
the
r to
pe
rmit
urb
an
ag
ricu
ltu
re in
lots
in t
he
Hill
sid
e
Ove
rla
y, a
nd
wh
eth
er
to p
erm
it u
rba
n a
gri
cult
ure
on
lots
of
a c
ert
ain
slo
pe
or
req
uir
ing
a g
eo
tech
nic
al s
tud
y. 5
. D
efi
ne
ro
oft
op
ga
rde
ns
an
d
de
velo
p r
eq
uir
em
en
ts t
ha
t co
mp
ly w
ith
exi
stin
g b
uild
ing
co
de
s. 6
. P
erm
it
acc
ess
ory
use
s, in
clu
din
g s
he
ds,
gre
en
ho
use
s, t
relli
ses,
pe
rgo
las
an
d
fen
ces
on
occ
up
ied
an
d v
aca
nt
lots
use
d f
or
urb
an
ag
ricu
ltu
re.
7.
Pe
rmit
gro
up
cla
ss in
stru
ctio
n,
com
mu
nit
y g
ath
eri
ng
s, a
nd
sa
les
as
an
acc
ess
ory
use
in c
om
me
rcia
l an
d r
esi
de
nti
al z
on
es
an
d e
sta
blis
h c
on
dit
ion
s fo
r
the
se u
ses
in r
esi
de
nti
al z
on
es
ba
sed
on
th
e r
eq
uir
em
en
ts in
Se
ctio
n
23
C.2
0.0
10
(B
), S
ale
s o
f N
on
-Pro
cess
ed
Ed
ible
s. 8
. P
erm
it s
ale
s o
f “v
alu
e-
ad
de
d”
pro
du
cts
or
pro
cess
ed
fo
od
pro
du
cts
to b
e s
old
on
sit
e d
uri
ng
th
e
sale
s o
f n
on
-pro
cess
ed
ed
ible
s o
r p
lan
ts,
in c
om
plia
nce
wit
h t
he
Sta
te o
f
Ca
lifo
rnia
Ho
me
ma
de
Fo
od
Act
. 9
. C
on
sid
er
the
leve
ls o
f d
iscr
eti
on
(pe
rmit
s re
qu
ire
d)
for
the
se v
ari
ou
s u
ses.
Arr
eg
uin
(D
4)
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
30
5
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
11
/15
/20
16
19
Bri
dg
e H
ou
sin
g S
tra
teg
ies
an
d
Ext
en
din
g t
he
Ho
usi
ng
Cri
sis
De
cla
rati
on
Re
vise
d m
ate
ria
ls
1)
Re
fer
to s
taff
th
e f
ollo
win
g a
me
nd
me
nts
of
the
Be
rke
ley
Mu
nic
ipa
l
Co
de
: A
me
nd
Se
ctio
n 2
3D
.08
.00
5 t
o c
lari
fy t
ha
t d
ep
en
de
nt,
no
-re
nt
ha
bit
ati
on
in a
cce
sso
ry b
uild
ing
s fo
r th
e p
urp
ose
of
bri
dg
e h
ou
sin
g is
allo
we
d a
s a
n a
cce
sso
ry u
se t
o a
n e
xist
ing
re
sid
en
tia
l use
. E
xpa
nd
th
e
de
fin
itio
n o
f “a
cce
sso
ry b
uild
ing
” to
incl
ud
e s
he
lte
rs o
n c
om
me
rcia
l an
d
relig
iou
s u
se lo
ts.
For
pro
pe
rtie
s o
wn
ed
by
fait
h-b
ase
d o
rga
niz
ati
on
s,
allo
w b
y-ri
gh
t d
eve
lop
me
nt
of
up
to
on
e a
cce
sso
ry u
nit
fo
r e
very
50
00
squ
are
fe
et
wit
h a
dd
itio
na
l un
its
pe
rmit
ted
th
rou
gh
th
e e
xist
ing
Ad
min
istr
ati
ve U
se P
erm
it (
AU
P)
pro
cess
. A
lso
re
fer
the
Co
un
cil
com
me
nts
fo
r co
nsi
de
rati
on
incl
ud
ing
a r
eq
uir
em
en
t th
at
the
bri
dg
e
ho
usi
ng
re
sid
en
t m
ust
be
re
gis
tere
d a
t th
e H
UB
or
wit
h a
se
rvic
e
pro
vid
er,
an
occ
up
an
cy li
mit
, a
nd
a p
roce
ss f
or
req
uir
ing
dis
cre
tio
na
ry
pe
rmit
s.
Arr
eg
uin
(D
4)
Pla
nn
ing
/ P
lan
nin
g
Co
mm
issi
on
30
X
4/2
5/2
01
74
3So
lan
o A
ven
ue
Eco
no
mic
De
velo
pm
en
t
Stu
dy
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to u
nd
ert
ake
a c
om
pre
he
nsi
ve s
tud
y o
f th
e
Sola
no
Ave
nu
e C
om
me
rcia
l Dis
tric
t, t
o p
rovi
de
ba
selin
e in
form
ati
on
fo
r
futu
re s
tra
teg
ic p
lan
nin
g a
nd
bu
sin
ess
de
velo
pm
en
t a
nd
init
iati
ves
tha
t
will
re
sult
in in
cre
ase
d t
ax
reve
nu
es
for
the
Cit
y o
f B
erk
ele
y, a
nd
to
rep
ort
to
th
e C
ou
nci
l on
a p
rio
rity
ba
sis,
at
an
up
com
ing
wo
rkse
ssio
n.
Ha
hn
OE
D3
1
20
16
-46
3/1
5/2
01
68
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ferr
al:
Pla
n f
or
Lig
hti
ng
an
d S
ign
ag
e a
t th
e O
hlo
ne
Gre
en
wa
y a
t
Ce
da
r, R
ose
, a
nd
Ho
pki
ns
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to d
eve
lop
a p
lan
to
imp
rove
th
e li
gh
tin
g a
nd
sig
na
ge
(e
.g.
sto
p s
ign
s) a
t th
e O
hlo
ne
Gre
en
wa
y cr
oss
ing
at
Ce
da
r, R
ose
,
an
d H
op
kin
s, p
art
icu
larl
y fo
r b
icyc
le t
ran
sit.
Ma
io (
Dis
t. 1
)P
ub
lic W
ork
s3
2
1/3
1/2
01
71
0M
ed
ica
l Ca
nn
ab
is O
rdin
an
ce R
evi
sio
ns
an
d C
ult
iva
tio
n A
pp
lica
tio
n P
roce
ss
Re
qu
est
th
at
the
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
pro
vid
e C
ou
nci
l wit
h a
na
lysi
s o
f th
e
qu
est
ion
s p
rese
nte
d b
y C
ou
nci
lme
mb
er
Ha
hn
.
All
Pla
nn
ing
33
4/4
/20
17
17
De
velo
pin
g a
Re
po
rt D
eta
ilin
g I
mp
act
s
of
Po
ten
tia
l Lo
ss o
f Fe
de
ral F
un
din
g o
n
the
Cit
y o
f B
erk
ele
y
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to p
rep
are
a p
relim
ina
ry c
on
cep
tua
l re
po
rt o
n
po
ssib
le s
cen
ari
os
of
loss
of
fed
era
l fu
nd
s, t
he
imp
act
s o
n t
he
Cit
y o
f
Be
rke
ley,
an
d p
ote
nti
al s
olu
tio
ns.
Ha
hn
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
34
2/2
8/2
01
71
6In
cre
asi
ng
th
e P
ark
ing
Pe
rmit
Gu
ide
line
s fo
r T
wo
BU
SD S
cho
ols
wit
h
Lim
ite
d A
cce
ss t
o P
ub
lic T
ran
sit
Re
qu
est
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
incr
ea
se t
he
gu
ide
line
s u
sed
to
gra
nt
resi
de
nti
al p
erm
it p
ark
ing
to
BU
SD s
cho
ols
fro
m 6
0%
to
70
% o
f th
e
nu
mb
er
of
BU
SD s
taff
(in
clu
de
s te
ach
ers
) fo
r sc
ho
ols
mo
re t
ha
n 1
/2 m
ile
fro
m a
BA
RT
Sta
tio
n,
or
1/4
mile
fro
m a
Ra
pid
Tra
nsi
t St
op
, o
r 1
/4 m
ile
fro
m t
wo
(2
) m
ajo
r tr
an
sit
line
s
Ma
ioP
ub
lic W
ork
s 3
5
6
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
5/1
0/2
01
63
7R
efe
rra
l to
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
:
Co
mm
un
ity
Ga
rde
n Z
on
ing
Re
fer
to t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
th
e f
ollo
win
g a
me
nd
me
nts
to
th
e
Zo
nin
g O
rdin
an
ce t
o d
efi
ne
Co
mm
un
ity
Ga
rde
ns
an
d p
erm
it t
he
m in
all
zon
ing
dis
tric
ts:
1.
Ad
d la
ng
ua
ge
to
Se
ctio
n 2
3F.
04
.01
0 (
De
fin
itio
ns)
to
de
fin
e C
om
mu
nit
y G
ard
en
s a
s a
ne
w z
on
ing
use
. 2
. E
sta
blis
h c
om
mu
nit
y
ga
rde
ns
an
d a
cce
sso
ry s
tru
ctu
res
incl
ud
ing
, b
ut
no
t lim
ite
d t
o t
oo
l sh
ed
s,
gre
en
ho
use
s, p
erg
ola
s a
nd
tre
llise
s a
s a
“b
y ri
gh
t” u
se in
all
zon
ing
dis
tric
ts r
eq
uir
ing
on
ly a
Zo
nin
g C
ert
ific
ate
. 3
. P
erm
it g
rou
p c
lass
inst
ruct
ion
, co
mm
un
ity
ga
the
rin
gs,
an
d s
ale
s a
s a
n e
xem
pt
acc
ess
ory
use
sub
ject
to
lim
ita
tio
ns
on
th
e n
um
be
r o
f p
ers
on
s, h
ou
rs,
sim
ilar
to t
he
req
uir
em
en
ts s
et
fort
h in
BM
C S
ect
ion
23
C.2
0.0
10
(B)
(Sa
le o
f N
on
-
Pro
cess
ed
Ed
ible
s in
Re
sid
en
tia
l Dis
tric
ts).
Re
vis
ed
to
in
clu
de
re
qu
est
s to
con
sid
er
lim
itin
g t
he
siz
e o
f th
e a
cce
sso
ry s
tru
ctu
re,
req
uir
ing
an
d A
UP
,
an
d i
mp
act
s o
f M
ea
sure
L.
4P
lan
nin
g3
6
20
16
-29
9/1
5/2
01
54
9R
efe
r to
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r, D
isa
bili
ty
Co
mm
issi
on
, a
nd
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
to D
eve
lop
an
Ord
ina
nce
Re
qu
irin
g N
ew
Re
sid
en
tia
l Bu
ildin
gs
to P
rovi
de
Au
to-
do
or
Op
en
ers
an
d R
oll-
in S
ho
we
rs
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er,
Dis
ab
ility
Co
mm
issi
on
, a
nd
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
to
re
qu
ire
ne
w r
esi
de
nti
al b
uild
ing
s in
Be
rke
ley
to in
clu
de
ess
en
tia
l wh
ee
lch
air
-acc
ess
ible
mo
dif
ica
tio
ns
such
as
au
to d
oo
r o
pe
ne
rs
an
d r
oll-
in s
ho
we
rs.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(Dis
t. 7
)
Pla
nn
ing
37
9/1
3/2
01
62
9C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r R
efe
rra
l: E
valu
ate
th
e
Eff
ect
ive
ne
ss o
f th
e C
ity
“Mo
ve-o
ut”
Pro
gra
m
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to e
xam
ine
th
e e
ffe
ctiv
en
ess
of
the
Cit
y
“Mo
ve-o
ut”
pro
gra
m a
nd
re
spo
nd
to
th
e f
ind
ing
s p
rio
r to
Ma
y 2
01
7.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(D7
)
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
38
20
16
-64
9/1
6/2
01
41
5C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r R
efe
rra
l: R
efo
rm
Be
rke
ley'
s 3
Str
ike
Ru
le,
Wh
ere
by
3
Pa
rkin
g T
icke
ts C
an
En
d A
n E
nti
re
Bu
sin
ess
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to lo
ok
into
th
e u
nin
ten
de
d c
on
seq
ue
nce
s o
f
the
3 s
trik
es
law
on
Be
rke
ley
taxi
ca
b o
wn
ers
, w
hic
h c
an
re
voke
a c
ab
com
pa
ny'
s b
usi
ne
ss li
cen
se a
fte
r re
ceiv
ing
3 p
ark
ing
tic
kets
.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(Dis
t. 7
)
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
39
20
16
-35
12
/17
/20
13
36
36
. R
evi
sin
g t
he
Be
rke
ley
Mu
nic
ipa
l
Co
de
to
Mo
re E
ffe
ctiv
ely
Ad
dre
ss I
lleg
al
Du
mp
ing
Dir
ect
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
pro
po
se p
ote
nti
al r
evi
sio
ns
to t
he
Be
rke
ley
Mu
nic
ipa
l Co
de
to
be
tte
r a
dd
ress
ille
ga
l du
mp
ing
in t
he
cit
y.
Mo
ore
(D
ist.
2)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
40
X
11
/1/2
01
61
8C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r R
efe
rra
l: C
on
sid
er
Mit
iga
tio
ns
for
Min
imu
m W
ag
e
Incr
ea
ses
to S
up
po
rt S
ma
ll B
usi
ne
sse
s
an
d N
on
-Pro
fits
by
Ad
dre
ssin
g P
ark
ing
,
Pe
rmit
an
d H
igh
Re
nts
Iss
ue
s
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to c
on
sid
er
mit
iga
tio
ns
for
min
imu
m w
ag
e
incr
ea
ses
to s
up
po
rt s
ma
ll b
usi
ne
sse
s a
nd
no
n-p
rofi
ts b
y a
tte
mp
tin
g t
o
ad
dre
ss p
ark
ing
an
d p
erm
its.
Re
qu
est
th
at
the
Off
ice
of
Eco
no
mic
De
velo
pm
en
t re
po
rt o
n o
the
r m
eth
od
s to
mit
iga
te t
he
imp
act
s o
f
min
imu
m w
ag
e in
cre
ase
s o
n s
ma
ll b
usi
ne
sse
s.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(D7
)
OE
D4
1
4/2
6/2
01
64
3E
xpe
dit
ing
Co
nsi
de
rati
on
of
a P
ote
nti
al
$3
mill
ion
Gra
nt
to B
uild
a M
ag
ica
l
Bri
dg
e P
layg
rou
nd
an
d s
en
din
g a
lett
er
of
inte
nt
(Co
nti
nu
ed
fro
m A
pri
l 5,
20
16
)
Re
qu
est
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
exp
ed
ite
co
nsi
de
rati
on
of
a p
ote
nti
al $
3
mill
ion
gra
nt
to b
uild
a M
ag
ica
l Bri
dg
e P
layg
rou
nd
, a
nd
se
nd
a le
tte
r o
f
inte
nt
to t
he
Ma
gic
al B
rid
ge
Fo
un
da
tio
n.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(Dis
t. 7
);
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
42
7
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
20
16
-63
11
/18
/20
14
42
Futu
re D
eve
lop
me
nt
of
the
4th
Str
ee
t
Are
a
Re
qu
est
th
at
the
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
re
turn
to
Co
un
cil w
ith
po
ssib
le
op
tio
ns
to e
nsu
re t
ha
t fu
ture
de
velo
pm
en
t o
f th
e 4
th S
tre
et
are
a is
ha
rmo
nio
us
wit
h t
he
su
cce
ssfu
l exi
stin
g r
eta
il d
istr
ict.
Ca
pit
elli
(D
ist.
5),
Ma
io (
Dis
t. 1
)
Pla
nn
ing
43
X
1/2
4/2
01
72
7Sp
eci
al R
PP
De
sig
na
tio
n,
Gra
nt
Stre
et
be
twe
en
Oh
lon
e P
ark
an
d D
ela
wa
re
Stre
et
Re
qu
est
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
de
sig
na
te a
sp
eci
al “
no
2-h
ou
r p
ark
ing
gra
ce p
eri
od
” re
sid
en
tia
l pe
rmit
pa
rkin
g z
on
e f
or
the
on
e c
ul-
de
-sa
c
blo
ck o
f G
ran
t St
ree
t b
etw
ee
n O
hlo
ne
Pa
rk a
nd
De
law
are
Str
ee
t. A
lso
,
req
ue
st t
o p
rovi
de
Co
un
cil w
ith
an
In
fo R
ep
ort
on
the
pro
cess
an
d
pe
rfo
rm in
cre
ase
d e
nfo
rce
me
nt.
Ma
io (
D1
)P
ub
lic W
ork
s4
4
20
16
-16
9/9
/20
14
29
Cre
ati
ng
Ad
dit
ion
al A
dm
inis
tra
tive
Po
we
rs o
f Z
on
ing
Off
ice
r to
Gra
nt
or
Re
com
me
nd
Ne
w P
erm
its
as
Re
late
d t
o
Co
de
En
forc
em
en
t
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
an
d B
erk
ele
y P
lan
nin
g C
om
mis
sio
n t
o e
xplo
re
the
cre
ati
on
of
a m
ech
an
ism
th
at
wo
uld
exp
licit
ly a
llow
sta
ff n
ew
dis
cre
tio
na
ry p
ow
ers
to
pre
ven
t a
pp
lica
nts
fro
m b
ein
g g
ran
ted
ne
w
resi
de
nti
al p
erm
its
un
til t
he
y h
ave
ab
ate
d o
uts
tan
din
g n
on
com
plia
nce
issu
es
or
cod
e v
iola
tio
ns
in o
the
r b
uild
ing
s th
ey
ow
n in
Be
rke
ley
wit
hin
a
rea
son
ab
le t
ime
fra
me
or
take
n g
oo
d f
ait
h m
ea
sure
s to
co
mm
en
ce d
oin
g
so.
HA
CP
lan
nin
g4
5
7/1
2/2
01
63
3E
xte
nd
ing
Op
era
tin
g H
ou
rs in
Co
mm
erc
ial D
istr
icts
Re
fer
to t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
to
re
vie
w a
nd
am
en
d t
he
Zo
nin
g
Ord
ina
nce
to
ext
en
d o
pe
rati
ng
ho
urs
of
bu
sin
ess
es
in c
om
me
rcia
l
dis
tric
ts t
hro
ug
ho
ut
Be
rke
ley
as
follo
ws:
24
ho
urs
in t
he
Do
wn
tow
n a
nd
No
rth
sid
e (
Eu
clid
Ave
nu
e b
etw
ee
n H
ea
rst
an
d R
idg
e)
com
me
rcia
l
dis
tric
ts s
eve
n d
ays
a w
ee
k, h
ow
eve
r p
urs
ua
nt
to s
tate
law
th
e s
ale
of
alc
oh
olic
be
vera
ge
s is
lim
ite
d t
o 2
a.m
.; F
rid
ay
an
d S
atu
rda
y to
2 a
.m.
in
the
Elm
wo
od
an
d N
ort
h S
ha
ttu
ck d
istr
icts
. H
ow
eve
r, s
ale
s a
nd
se
rvic
e o
f
alc
oh
olic
be
vera
ge
s is
lim
ite
d t
o f
ull-
serv
ice
re
sta
ura
nts
; Se
ven
da
ys a
we
ek
to 2
a.m
. a
t n
od
es
of
the
Sa
n P
ab
lo d
istr
ict.
Co
nsi
de
r a
pp
lyin
g in
th
ese
dis
tric
ts t
he
exi
stin
g r
eg
ula
tio
ns
in t
he
C-T
dis
tric
t o
n
off
-sa
le o
f a
lco
ho
lic b
eve
rag
es
an
d o
n p
rem
ise
co
nsu
mp
tio
n o
f d
isti
lled
alc
oh
olic
be
vera
ge
s a
t fu
ll-se
rvic
e r
est
au
ran
ts.
Sim
ilar
to t
he
exi
stin
g 2
4-h
ou
r zo
nin
g d
esi
gn
ati
on
in t
he
Te
leg
rap
h
Co
mm
erc
ial D
istr
ict,
th
ese
am
en
dm
en
ts w
ill a
llow
bu
sin
ess
es
in t
he
se
are
as
to r
em
ain
op
en
late
r w
ith
ou
t a
n a
dd
itio
na
l Use
Pe
rmit
.
Arr
eg
uin
(D
4)
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
46
20
16
-62
7/1
/20
14
18
18
. C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r R
efe
rra
l: U
pd
ati
ng
Gra
ffit
i Ord
ina
nce
an
d P
olic
ies
Ba
sed
on
a R
evi
ew
of
San
Fra
nci
sco
’s N
ew
Ord
ina
nce
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
an
d t
he
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
an
d P
ark
s a
nd
Re
cre
ati
on
Co
mm
issi
on
s to
cre
ate
an
ord
ina
nce
th
at
revi
ses
Be
rke
ley'
s
po
licie
s re
ga
rdin
g g
raff
iti,
fo
cusi
ng
on
pre
ven
tio
n a
nd
en
forc
em
en
t o
f
reg
ula
tio
ns.
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(Dis
t. 7
)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
47
8
Tra
ckin
g #
Me
eti
ng
Da
te
Ag
en
da
Ite
m
No
.
Tit
leR
eco
mm
en
da
tio
n
Sp
on
sori
ng
Co
un
cilm
em
be
r
/Co
mm
issi
on
Re
spo
nsi
ble
De
pa
rtm
en
t/D
ivis
ion
Ra
nk
Ma
rke
d f
or
Re
mo
va
l
20
16
-37
1/1
7/2
01
22
1R
efe
rra
l to
th
e C
om
mis
sio
n o
n t
he
Sta
tus
of
Wo
me
n (
PD
F)
Re
fer
to t
he
Co
mm
issi
on
on
th
e S
tatu
s o
f W
om
en
th
e a
lleg
ed
off
en
sive
tre
atm
en
t o
f w
om
en
in c
ust
od
y a
t Sa
nta
Rit
a J
ail,
as
rep
ort
ed
be
low
wit
h
the
aim
of
en
suri
ng
th
at
sea
rch
es
of
wo
me
n n
ot
be
co
nd
uct
ed
in t
he
pre
sen
ce o
f m
en
(b
e t
he
y m
ale
off
ice
rs o
r in
ma
tes)
an
d a
ny
oth
er
cha
ng
es
in p
roto
col t
ha
t m
igh
t b
e n
ee
de
d t
o e
nsu
re a
pp
rop
ria
te p
olic
ies
are
fo
llow
ed
du
rin
g s
ea
rch
es
of
wo
me
n in
cu
sto
dy.
Ma
io (
Dis
t. 1
)H
HC
S4
8
4/2
5/2
01
72
9D
og
Ow
ne
r E
du
cati
on
, C
esa
r C
ha
vez
Pa
rkR
eq
ue
st t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to lo
ok
into
th
e d
eve
lop
me
nt
of
a d
og
ow
ne
r
ed
uca
tio
n p
rog
ram
at
Ce
sar
Ch
ave
z P
ark
as
to t
he
de
sig
na
ted
on
-le
ash
an
d o
ff-l
ea
sh a
rea
s u
sin
g v
olu
nte
ers
wh
o w
ou
ld b
e e
ligib
le f
or
a s
ma
ll
stip
en
d.
Co
nsi
de
r p
art
ne
rin
g w
ith
th
e B
erk
ele
y H
um
an
e S
oci
ety
.
Ma
ioP
ark
s, R
ec,
Wa
terf
ron
t4
9
6/1
4/2
01
64
5b
Livi
ng
Wa
ge
fo
r A
ll C
ity
of
Be
rke
ley
Em
plo
yee
s
Dir
ect
th
e C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r to
de
velo
p a
mo
re d
eta
iled
pla
n f
or
rais
ing
eig
ht
(8)
un
rep
rese
nte
d c
lass
ific
ati
on
s to
th
e L
ivin
g W
ag
e le
vel,
an
d t
o a
na
lyze
its
fisc
al i
mp
lica
tio
ns
city
wid
e.
Th
e p
lan
wo
uld
incl
ud
e a
dju
stm
en
ts t
o
the
cu
rre
nt
sala
ry p
ay
sch
ed
ule
fo
r th
e im
pa
cte
d c
lass
ific
ati
on
, a
nd
a
corr
esp
on
din
g b
ud
ge
t a
dju
stm
en
t fo
r th
ose
Cit
y d
ep
art
me
nts
th
at
ha
ve
em
plo
yee
s in
th
e im
pa
cte
d c
lass
ific
ati
on
s.
HR
50
10
/18
/20
16
37
Re
ferr
al R
esp
on
se:
Mo
dif
y N
um
eri
c
Lim
ita
tio
ns
(“Q
uo
tas”
) in
th
e E
lmw
oo
d
(C-E
) C
om
me
rcia
l Dis
tric
t; A
me
nd
ing
BM
C C
ha
pte
rs 2
3E
.44
an
d 2
3F.
04
2)
Re
qu
est
ed
th
at
the
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
revi
ew
th
e s
qu
are
fo
ota
ge
limit
ati
on
s in
Se
ctio
n 2
3E
.44
.04
0 a
nd
re
turn
wit
h o
pti
on
s fo
r
mo
dif
ica
tio
n
Ma
yor
an
d
Co
un
cil
Pla
nn
ing
51
20
16
-34
12
/16
/20
14
27
Re
ferr
al t
o P
lan
nin
g C
om
mis
sio
n a
nd
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
Re
ga
rdin
g t
he
Fe
asi
bili
ty
of
Re
qu
irin
g t
he
In
sta
llati
on
of
Wa
ter
Fou
nta
ins/
Filli
ng
Sta
tio
ns
for
Ne
w
Co
mm
erc
ial D
eve
lop
me
nt
Pro
ject
s
Re
fer
to t
he
Pla
nn
ing
Co
mm
issi
on
an
d t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
the
de
velo
pm
en
t o
f a
n o
rdin
an
ce r
eq
uir
ing
all
ne
w c
om
me
rcia
l de
velo
pm
en
t
pro
ject
s a
nd
re
mo
de
ls a
bo
ve a
sp
eci
fie
d a
mo
un
t to
inco
rpo
rate
a
pu
blic
ly a
vaila
ble
dri
nki
ng
fo
un
tain
an
d/o
r w
ate
r b
ott
le f
illin
g s
tati
on
or
loca
tio
ns
on
th
e p
rem
ise
s w
he
re o
ne
ma
y b
e in
sta
lled
wit
ho
ut
ad
dit
ion
al
cost
to
th
e c
ity
for
pip
ing
wa
ter
to t
he
loca
tio
n.
Re
po
rt b
ack
to
co
un
cil
wit
hin
6 m
on
ths.
Ca
pit
elli
(D
ist.
5)
Pla
nn
ing
52
7/1
9/2
01
62
5C
ity
Ma
na
ge
r R
efe
rra
l: E
xpa
nd
Sco
ote
r
an
d M
oto
rcyc
le P
ark
ing
in F
ron
t o
f th
e
Re
cre
ati
on
al S
po
rts
Faci
lity
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
to e
xam
ine
th
e f
ea
sib
ility
of
ad
din
g m
ore
pa
rkin
g a
nd
sco
ote
r p
ark
ing
sp
ace
s to
th
e R
ecr
ea
tio
na
l Sp
ort
s Fa
cilit
y
(RSF
).
Wo
rth
ing
ton
(D7
)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
53
20
16
-68
9/9
/20
14
39
Est
ab
lish
Pe
dic
ab
Po
licy
an
d R
eg
ula
tio
ns
Re
fer
to t
he
Cit
y M
an
ag
er
an
d T
ran
spo
rta
tio
n C
om
mis
sio
n t
he
cre
ati
on
of
an
ord
ina
nce
th
at
wo
uld
est
ab
lish
re
gu
lati
on
s fo
r p
ed
ica
b o
pe
rato
rs.
Mo
ore
(D
ist.
2)
Pu
blic
Wo
rks
54
X
9
Kathryn Harrison Councilmember District 4
Item 5
July 26, 2017
REVISED AGENDA MATERIAL
Meeting Date: June 27, 2017
Item Number: 37 Item Description: Referral to Community Environmental Advisory Commission and Energy Commission: Residential Wind Turbines
Submitted by: Councilmember Harrison
We would like to clarify that the Community Environmental Advisory Commission and Energy Commission create a joint subcommittee before returning to Council with a report and recommendation.
2180 Milvia Street, Berkeley, CA 94704 Tel: 510.981.7140 TDD: 510.981.6903 Fax: 510.981.7133 E-Mail: [email protected]
Kathryn Harrison Councilmember District 4
CONSENT CALENDAR June 27, 2017
To: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
From: Councilmember Harrison, Councilmember Bartlett, and Councilmember Hahn
Subject: Referral to Community Environmental Advisory Commission and Energy Commission: Residential Wind Turbines
RECOMMENDATION Refer to the Community Environmental Advisory Commission and the Energy Commission to study the efficiency, safety, and affordability of Residential Wind Turbines and request the Community Environmental Advisory Commission and the Energy Commission each create their own individual subcommittees that will meet and work together to and return to Council with a report and recommendation on whether Residential Wind Turbines are a viable alternative energy source for Berkeley residents, and a recommendation for a process to educate the public on this new renewable energy source. The Community Environmental Advisory Commission and the Energy Commission will each create their own subcommittees focused on studying this matter. These subcommittees will meet at the same time and work in conjunction with one another.
FINANCIAL IMPLICATIONS Unknown. Staff time will be involved in doing analysis and preparing reports for the Community Environmental Advisory Commission and Energy Commission discussion.
BACKGROUND In June 2007 the City of Berkeley became the first city in the nation to install a wind turbine for one of its buildings. As new improvements are being made in Wind Power, small Residential Wind Turbines are being touted as a cost-efficient and eco-friendly alternative means of generating power. Residential Wind Turbines sit on a vertical axis, allowing the turbine to operate and generate torque at very low wind speeds. Newer models of small wind turbines are lightweight, comprised of recyclable, highly resilient metal and can be assembled in less than one hour. When operating through an average wind speeds, these models generate little noise.
The United States Department of Energy states that small wind electric systems can:
Lower your electricity bills by 50%–90%
Help you avoid the high costs of having utility power lines extended to a remote location
Help uninterruptible power supplies ride through extended utility outages. The Commissions should consider the following questions when study the feasibility and scope of Residential Wind Turbines as an alternative means of energy generation in this report:
What Renewable Energy Companies are producing Residential Wind
Turbines across the globe? What is currently on the market? What prototypes are available?
Can Residential Wind turbines be an effective source of renewable energy
for Berkeley residents?
Do Berkeley homes have viable wind resources? What is the lowest wind speed these systems operate at and at what speeds do these systems generate the best results?
What is the ideal location for a Residential Wind Turbine? Where do local zoning guidelines allow for these structures? What local building and safety requirements must be met?
Will the noise made by these turbines be found objectionable by
Berkeley residents?
Can Residential Wind Turbines fit into a Home-Scale model? Can Residential Wind Turbines produce enough energy for one home?
Can Residential Wind Turbines fit into our Climate Action Plan? What
public safety concerns have been voiced regarding these new systems?
How can we educate the public and raise public awareness about this new renewable energy source? What are potential funding sources?
How affordable are residential wind turbine systems that are currently on
the market? What installation and maintenance requirements are expected?
ENVIRONMENTAL SUSTAINABILITY There are no identifiable environmental effects or opportunities associated with the preparation of this report and recommendation.
CONTACT PERSON Councilmember Kate Harrison Council District 4 510-981-7140
7/1
7/2
01
7 1
Ele
ctri
fyin
g B
uild
ing
s in
Ca
lifo
rnia
Be
rke
ley
En
erg
y C
om
mis
sio
n
Ra
che
l Go
lde
n,
Se
nio
r C
am
pa
ign
Re
pre
sen
tati
ve
Jun
e 2
8, 2
01
7
Tod
ay
’s P
rese
nta
tio
n
•B
rie
f p
rim
er
on
bu
ild
ing
ele
ctri
fica
tio
n
•B
arr
iers
to
ele
ctri
fica
tio
n in
Ca
lifo
rnia
•R
en
ew
ab
le W
ate
r H
ea
tin
g M
od
el O
rdin
an
ce
•Q
ue
stio
ns
an
d g
rou
p d
iscu
ssio
n
2
3
De
cre
asi
ng
ca
rbo
n in
ten
sity
of
CA
’s g
rid
-
10
0
20
0
30
0
40
0
50
0
60
0
70
0
80
0
90
0
20
15
20
20
20
25
20
30
20
35
20
40
20
45
20
50
0
10
0
20
0
30
0
40
0
50
0
60
0
70
0
80
0
90
0
20
01
20
03
20
05
20
07
20
09
20
11
20
13
20
15
lbsCO2/MWh So
urc
e:
EIA
CA
En
erg
y P
rofi
le 2
01
5 (
his
tori
cal)
an
d E
IA A
EO
20
17
(fo
reca
st)
His
tori
cal
carb
on
in
ten
sity
of
CA
’s
ele
ctri
city
se
cto
r
Fore
cast
of
carb
on
in
ten
sity
of
CA
’s
ele
ctri
city
se
cto
r
4
Co
mp
ari
ng
Th
erm
od
yna
mic
Eff
icie
ncy
Ele
ctri
c re
sist
an
ce w
ate
r h
ea
ter
(20
-ye
ars
ag
o;
CO
P =
0.9
6)
Ga
s g
en
era
tor
eff
icie
ncy
x w
ate
r h
ea
ter
eff
icie
ncy
= d
eli
vere
d h
ea
t p
er
ga
s co
mb
ust
ed
33
% x
.9
6%
= 3
2%
Ga
s ta
nk
less
wa
ter
he
ate
r (C
OP
= 0
.95
)9
5%
He
at
pu
mp
wa
ter
he
ate
r (C
OP
= 2
.5)
Ga
s g
en
era
tor
eff
icie
ncy
x w
ate
r h
ea
ter
eff
icie
ncy
= d
eli
vere
d h
ea
t p
er
ga
s co
mb
ust
ed
50
% x
25
0%
= 1
25
%
Wo
rst
case
sce
na
rio
–g
as
is t
he
ma
rgin
al u
nit
of
ele
ctri
city
pro
du
ctio
n
Late Communications Energy Commission
July 26, 2017
7/1
7/2
01
7 2
Ho
w g
rid
+ t
ech
imp
act
s G
HG
em
issi
on
s
0.0
0
0.0
2
0.0
4
0.0
6
0.0
8
0.1
0
0.1
2
0.1
4
0%
20%
40
%60
%80%
100
%
(tCO2/MMBTU delivered)
% R
en
ew
able
ele
ctrici
ty a
s m
arg
inal b
uild
Ele
ctr
ic r
es
ista
nc
e
(CO
P 0
.96
)
Gas
,s
tora
ge
ta
nk
(C
OP
0.6
)
Gas
,ta
nk
les
s c
on
de
ns
ing
(C
OP
0.9
5)
Ele
ctr
ic h
ea
t p
um
p
(CO
P2
.5)
No
te:
Ga
s u
sag
e d
oes
not
incl
ude
fu
giti
ve m
eth
an
e e
mis
sio
ns
Gra
ph
ic a
da
pte
d b
y N
RD
C b
ase
d o
n F
igu
re 3
(p
ag
e 9
-7)
fro
m “
Wh
at
if E
ffic
ien
cy G
oa
ls W
ere
Ca
rbo
n G
oa
ls?
” b
y M
ah
on
ee
t
al.
(A
CE
EE
Su
mm
er
Stu
dy
20
16
): h
ttp
://a
cee
e.o
rg/f
ile
s/p
roce
ed
ing
s/2
01
6/d
ata
/pa
pe
rs/9
_2
84
.pd
f5
Bu
ild
ing
s vs
Po
we
r P
lan
ts in
Ca
lifo
rnia
0
20
0,0
00
40
0,0
00
60
0,0
00
80
0,0
00
1,0
00
,00
0
1,2
00
,00
0
MMcf
Ga
s C
on
sum
pti
on
by
Se
cto
r
Ind
ust
ria
l
Ele
ctri
c P
ow
er
Co
mm
erc
ial
an
d R
esi
de
nti
al
So
urc
e:
EIA
20
17
an
d C
AR
B G
HG
In
ven
tory
6
Ele
ctri
city
Ge
ne
rati
on
(In
Sta
te)
11
%
Ele
ctri
city
Ge
ne
rati
on
(Im
po
rts)
9%
Bu
ild
ing
s
12
%
Ind
ust
ria
l
23
%
Ag
ricu
ltu
re
& F
ore
stry
8%
Ca
lifo
rnia
GH
G e
mis
sio
ns
(20
11
-20
15
)
Tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
37
%
Ga
s g
uzz
lers
in C
A h
om
es
Wa
ter
he
ate
r
49
%S
pa
ce
he
ati
ng
37
%
Sto
ve
7%
Po
ols
,
spa
s,
mis
c.
4%
Clo
the
s
dry
er
3%
7
2.1
2.0
2.3
1.0
0246
Ca
lifo
rnia
Ba
y A
rea
Metric tons CO2/year
Na
tura
l g
as
Ele
ctri
city
So
urc
e:
Jon
es
C.,
Ka
mm
en
D.,
“B
ay
Are
a C
on
sum
pti
on
-
Ba
sed
GH
G E
mis
sio
ns
Inve
nto
ry”,
Ja
n.
20
16
So
urc
e:
CA
Re
sid
en
tia
l Ap
plia
nce
Sa
tura
tio
n
Stu
dy
20
10
CA
Re
sid
en
tia
l Ga
s C
on
sum
pti
on
Re
sid
en
tia
l G
HG
by
So
urc
e
Tech
ava
ila
ble
to
da
y to
ele
ctri
fy h
om
es
8
7/1
7/2
01
7 3
Wh
at’
s a
he
at
pu
mp
? By
tran
sfer
rin
g h
eat
rath
er t
han
cre
atin
g it
,
hea
t p
um
ps
del
iver
ho
t w
ater
3-4
tim
es m
ore
effi
cien
tly
than
co
nve
nti
on
al w
ater
hea
ters
9
Be
ne
fits
of
ele
ctri
fica
tio
n
Air
qu
ali
ty
& h
ea
lth
Re
du
ced
me
tha
ne
lea
ks
Sa
fety
GH
Gsa
vin
gs
Job
sE
ne
rgy
eff
icie
ncy
Re
ne
wa
ble
inte
gra
tio
n
Sa
ve
mo
ne
y
Po
llu
ters
ou
t
of
po
liti
cs
10
Gro
win
g c
on
sen
sus
11
CP
UC
Pre
sid
en
t P
icke
r:“O
nly
20
pe
rce
nt
of
the
ca
rbo
n e
mis
sio
ns
bu
dg
et
in C
alif
orn
ia c
om
es
fro
m
the
ele
ctri
city
su
pp
ly;
30
pe
rce
nt
com
es
fro
m t
he
use
of
ga
s in
ho
me
s, b
usi
ne
ss a
nd
in
du
stry
, a
nd
40
pe
rce
nt
com
es
fro
m
tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
… I
he
ar
[a f
ocu
s o
n]
ren
ew
ab
le e
lect
rici
ty w
ith
ou
t
talk
ing
ab
ou
t th
is i
mp
ort
an
t ta
sk
of
fue
l sw
itch
ing
. W
e c
an
ge
t to
10
0 p
erc
en
t cl
ea
n e
lect
rici
ty a
cro
ss
the
sta
te,
bu
t w
e d
on
't g
et
to o
ur
gre
en
ho
use
ga
s g
oa
l u
nle
ss w
e
sta
rt t
o s
up
pla
nt
ga
s a
nd
tra
nsp
ort
ati
on
fu
el
wit
h c
lea
n
ele
ctri
city
as
ou
r fi
rst
fue
l.”
Th
e k
ey
to m
ee
tin
g
GH
G g
oa
ls is
“wid
esp
rea
d
ele
ctri
fica
tio
no
f
pa
sse
ng
er
veh
icle
s,
bu
ild
ing
he
ati
ng
,
an
d i
nd
ust
ry
he
ati
ng
.”
Ch
all
en
ge
s to
ele
ctri
fica
tio
n in
CA
Po
licy
bia
s to
wa
rd g
as
Lack
of
aw
are
ne
ss
$
12
7/1
7/2
01
7 4
Ne
ed
lea
de
rsh
ip f
rom
cit
ies
like
Be
rke
ley
13
Th
eo
ry o
f C
ha
ng
e:
Be
rke
ley
ad
op
ts
RE
wa
ter
he
ati
ng
o
rdin
an
ce
Ou
tre
ach
to
Ba
y A
rea
cit
ies
(20
%
of
CA
po
p.)
to
a
do
pt
ord
ina
nce
HP
WH
ma
rke
t d
eve
lop
me
nt
CE
C a
do
pts
in
20
22
co
de
cyc
le
Re
ne
wa
ble
Wa
ter
He
ati
ng
Ord
ina
nce
“Re
ne
wa
ble
Ho
t W
ate
r” M
od
el O
rdin
an
ce C
on
cep
t
Co
mb
ine
he
at
pu
mp
wa
ter
he
ate
r w
ith
so
lar
PV
, o
r u
se s
ola
r
the
rma
l, t
o h
ea
t w
ate
r w
ith
re
ne
wa
ble
en
erg
y:
Ap
ply
to
ne
w h
om
es
an
d m
ajo
r re
tro
fits
, no
t w
ate
r h
ea
ter
rep
lace
me
nts
in e
xist
ing
ho
me
s1
4
So
lar
PV
fo
r e
lect
ric
loa
ds
on
ly
•R
ed
uce
s u
tilit
y b
ills
an
d G
HG
s fr
om
ele
ctri
city
u
se:
•Li
gh
tin
g
•A
/C
•P
lug
lo
ad
s
So
lar
PV
fo
r e
lect
ric
loa
ds
an
d h
ot
wa
ter
•R
ed
uce
s u
tilit
y b
ills
an
d G
HG
s fr
om
ele
ctri
c lo
ad
s A
ND
n
atu
ral
gas
use
fo
r w
ate
r h
ea
tin
g
Ho
w d
oe
s th
e o
rdin
an
ce w
ork
?
15
Me
nu
of
3 o
pti
on
s:
�O
pti
on
1 -
He
at
pu
mp
wa
ter
he
ate
r +
so
lar
PV
�H
igh
-eff
icie
ncy
he
at
pu
mp
wa
ter
he
ate
r (H
PW
H):
NE
EA
Tie
r 3
-ce
rtif
ied
�E
no
ug
h P
V t
o o
ffse
t a
t le
ast
80
% o
f H
PW
H a
nn
ua
l e
lect
rici
ty u
se,
in
ad
dit
ion
to
an
y o
the
r so
lar
PV
re
qu
ire
me
nts
�O
pti
on
2 -
So
lar
the
rma
l w
ith
60
% s
ola
r fr
act
ion
�S
ola
r th
erm
al
cove
rin
g a
t le
ast
60
% o
f a
nn
ua
l ho
t w
ate
r n
ee
ds
+ g
as
or
ele
ctri
c b
ack
up
wa
ter
he
ate
r fo
r w
inte
r se
aso
n
�O
pti
on
3 -
CA
LGre
en
“PV
-Plu
s” p
ack
ag
e
�N
o s
pe
cifi
c re
ne
wa
ble
wa
ter
he
ati
ng
re
qu
ire
me
nt,
bu
t h
igh
er
bu
ild
ing
eff
icie
ncy
re
qu
ire
me
nts
(cl
ose
to
CA
LGre
en
Tie
r 2
)
�P
rovi
de
s fl
exi
bil
ity
op
tio
n f
or
bu
ild
ers
an
d h
om
e b
uye
rs w
ho
do
no
t
wa
nt
to u
se e
ith
er
op
tio
ns
1 o
r 2
�M
ust
co
mp
ly w
ith
20
16
bu
ild
ing
co
de
�S
ola
r P
V c
red
it h
elp
s o
verc
om
e H
PW
H p
en
alt
y in
co
de
�M
ust
be
co
st-e
ffe
ctiv
e
�P
ow
eri
ng
HP
WH
wit
h lo
w-c
ost
PV
ele
ctri
city
is v
ery
co
st-
eff
ect
ive
�M
ust
no
t vi
ola
te f
ed
era
l pre
em
pti
on
fo
r a
pp
lia
nce
eff
icie
ncy
sta
nd
ard
s
�S
ola
r th
erm
al a
nd
CA
LGre
en
“P
V-P
lus"
off
er
no
n-p
ree
mp
ted
op
tio
ns.
HP
WH
is a
n o
pti
on
, no
t m
an
da
tory
.
16
Me
ets
loca
l re
ach
co
de
re
qu
ire
me
nts
7/1
7/2
01
7 5
17
�5
0%
low
er
fue
l co
sts
/ u
tili
ty
bil
ls
13
% lo
we
r li
fe c
ycle
co
sts
30
% lo
we
r so
urc
e e
ne
rgy
50
% lo
we
r C
O2
*C
alif
orn
ia a
vera
ge
, cl
ima
te z
on
e-s
pe
cifi
c a
na
lysi
s a
vaila
ble
up
on
re
qu
est
Be
ne
fits
of
HP
WH
+P
V v
s ga
s ta
nkl
ess
18
$3
,51
6
$1
,51
1
$0
$5
00
$1
,00
0
$1
,50
0
$2
,00
0
$2
,50
0
$3
,00
0
$3
,50
0
$4
,00
0
Ga
s ta
nkl
ess
He
at
pu
mp
30
-Ye
ar
Fu
el
Co
sts
-57
%
•B
ase
d o
n a
vera
ge
Ca
lifo
rnia
co
sts.
A c
lima
te z
on
e-s
pe
cifi
c a
na
lysi
s ca
n b
e
pro
vid
ed
fo
r in
tere
ste
d c
itie
s
•3
% d
isco
un
t ra
te
•O
the
r d
ata
so
urc
es
an
d a
ssu
mp
tio
ns
in a
pp
en
dix
slid
es
HP
WH
+ P
V c
uts
uti
lity
bil
ls b
y 5
7%
19
•Li
fe C
ycle
co
sts
incl
ud
e e
qu
ipm
en
t, i
nst
alla
tio
n a
nd
op
era
tio
na
l
cost
s.
$5
,91
1
$5
,13
2
$0
$1
,00
0
$2
,00
0
$3
,00
0
$4
,00
0
$5
,00
0
$6
,00
0
$7
,00
0
Ga
s ta
nkl
ess
He
at
pu
mp
30
-Ye
ar
Life
Cy
cle
Co
st
-13
%
HP
WH
+P
V c
uts
life
cyc
le c
ost
s b
y 1
3%
20
0
10
0
20
0
30
0
40
0
50
0
60
0
Ga
s ta
nkl
ess
He
at
pu
mp
, h
igh
case
He
at
pu
mp
, m
id-
case
He
at
pu
mp
, lo
w
case
kg CO2e/y
An
nu
al G
HG
Em
issi
on
s
-23
%
-47
%
-71
%
Hig
h c
ase
: 8
0%
on
-pe
ak
op
era
tio
n
Low
ca
se:
80
% o
ff-p
ea
k
op
era
tio
n
Mid
ca
se:
50
% o
ff-p
ea
k
op
era
tio
n
GH
G s
avi
ng
s fr
om
HP
WH
+P
V
7/1
7/2
01
7 6
Sh
ed
on
pe
ak
Ch
arg
e o
ff p
ea
k
�N
RD
C e
t. a
l. s
tud
y i
n-p
rog
ress
to
qu
an
tify
th
e l
oa
d s
hif
tin
g c
ap
aci
ty a
nd
valu
e o
f H
PW
H,
resu
lts
pla
nn
ed
fo
r S
ep
. 2
01
7 21
HP
WH
pro
vid
es
ne
ed
ed
de
ma
nd
re
spo
nse
�La
rge
re
du
ctio
n in
uti
lity
bil
ls, c
ost
-eff
ect
ive
ove
r li
fe
tim
e
�La
rge
GH
G r
ed
uct
ion
op
po
rtu
nit
y
�T
he
rma
l sto
rag
e c
an
he
lp m
itig
ate
du
ck c
urv
e,
mo
ve
be
yon
d 5
0%
re
ne
wa
ble
ele
ctri
city
�O
pp
ort
un
ity
for
city
le
ad
ers
hip
--
citi
es
to p
ave
th
e
wa
y fo
r st
ate
wid
e b
uil
din
g c
od
e
22
Su
mm
ary
Th
an
k yo
u!
For
mo
re i
nfo
rma
tio
n p
lea
se c
on
tact
:
Ra
che
l Go
lde
n,
Sie
rra
Clu
b
Ra
che
l.g
old
en
@si
err
acl
ub
.org
Pie
rre
De
lfo
rge
, N
RD
C
Pd
elf
org
e@
nrd
c.o
rg
Ext
ra S
lid
es
24
7/1
7/2
01
7 7
25
•U
sin
g D
OE
’s s
ou
rce
en
erg
y m
eth
od
olo
gy
fo
r re
ne
wa
ble
en
erg
y
•T
he
3 s
cen
ari
os
corr
esp
on
d t
o d
iffe
ren
t o
pe
rati
ng
pro
file
s: 8
0%
on
-pe
ak
, 5
0%
on
-
pe
ak
, 2
0%
on
-pe
ak
(co
ntr
oll
ed
)
0
1,0
00
2,0
00
3,0
00
4,0
00
5,0
00
6,0
00
7,0
00
8,0
00
9,0
00
10
,00
0
Ga
s ta
nk
less
He
at
pu
mp
, h
igh
case
He
at
pu
mp
, m
id-
case
He
at
pu
mp
, lo
w
case
kBTU/year
An
nu
al
Ca
ptu
red
So
urc
e E
ne
rgy
-14
%
-32
%
-49
%
Hig
h c
ase
:
80
% o
n-p
ea
k
op
era
tio
n
Low
ca
se:
80
% o
ff-p
ea
k
op
era
tio
n
Mid
ca
se:
50
% o
ff-p
ea
k
op
era
tio
n
En
erg
y sa
vin
gs
fro
m H
PW
H+
PV
�H
ea
t p
um
ps
can
als
o b
e u
sed
fo
r sp
ace
he
ati
ng
an
d c
oo
lin
g
�E
ven
mo
re c
ost
-eff
ect
ive
be
cau
se o
ne
he
at
pu
mp
re
pla
ces
two
ap
pli
an
ces
(fu
rna
ce a
nd
A/C
)
�A
ll-e
lect
ric
bu
ild
ing
s a
lso
avo
id g
as
con
ne
ctio
n c
ost
s ($
5,0
00
+
pe
r u
nit
)
�B
ut
all
-ele
ctri
c b
uil
din
gs
curr
en
tly
ha
ve l
ow
er
cust
om
er
acc
ep
tan
ce,
be
cau
se o
f p
refe
ren
ce f
or
ga
s co
oki
ng
an
d
fire
pla
ces
�Ta
ke-a
wa
y:
Wa
ter
he
ati
ng
is a
n e
asi
er
firs
t st
ep
. B
uil
din
g a
ll-
ele
ctri
c is
on
e o
f th
e m
ost
co
st-e
ffe
ctiv
e p
ath
wa
ys t
o a
chie
ve
the
wa
ter
he
ati
ng
re
qu
ire
me
nt,
bu
t it
do
es
no
t n
ece
ssa
rily
n
ee
d t
o b
e p
art
of
this
ord
ina
nce
26
Wh
y ju
st f
ocu
s o
n w
ate
r h
ea
tin
g?
Da
ta S
ou
rce
s a
nd
Ass
um
pti
on
s -
Co
sts
27
•D
isco
un
t ra
te: 3
%
•A
ve
rag
e C
A r
esi
de
nti
al g
as
rate
: $1
.28
/th
erm
(E
IA,
Jan
. 2
01
7,
htt
ps:
//w
ww
.eia
.go
v/d
na
v/n
g/h
ist/
n3
01
0ca
3m
.htm
)
•3
0-y
ea
r d
isco
un
ted
co
st o
f p
ho
tov
olt
aic
in s
ing
le f
am
ily
: $
0.1
14
/kW
h (
$3
.02
/wa
tt in
sta
lle
d),
Da
vis
En
erg
y G
rou
p,
En
erc
om
p,
Mis
tiB
ruce
ria
nd
Ass
., “
Loca
l P
V O
rdin
an
ce C
ost
Eff
ect
ive
ne
ss S
tud
y”,
htt
ps:
//fr
em
on
t.g
ov
/Do
cum
en
tCe
nte
r/V
iew
/33
14
6, u
pd
ate
d t
o f
ocu
s o
n n
ew
co
nst
ruct
ion
co
sts,
an
d t
o c
orr
ect
ov
erh
ea
d
an
d p
rofi
t co
sts.
•H
ot
wa
ter
usa
ge
: N
RD
C c
alc
ula
tio
n b
ase
d o
n K
ruis
et
al.
, C
ali
forn
ia R
esi
de
nti
al
Do
me
stic
Ho
t W
ate
r D
raw
Pro
file
s, M
ay
20
16
(Dra
ft),
htt
p:/
/ww
w.b
wil
cox.
com
/BE
ES
/do
cs/K
ruis
%2
0-%
20
Dh
w%
20
An
aly
sis%
20
5.d
ocx
•G
as
tan
kle
ss e
qu
ipm
en
t li
st p
rice
: $
1,0
42
fo
r 8
GP
M,
$1
,22
1 f
or
10
GP
M,
pe
r w
ww
.ho
me
de
po
t.co
mo
n 4
/14
/20
14
. En
erg
y
fact
or:
0.8
2 E
F
•G
as
tan
kle
ss in
sta
lla
tio
n c
ost
: G
as
sup
ply
lin
e:
$5
84
, w
ate
r h
ea
ter
inst
alla
tio
n:
$5
81
(htt
ps:
//w
ww
.ho
me
wy
se.c
om
/se
rvic
es/
cost
_to
_in
sta
ll_
gas_
lin
e.h
tml,
re
du
ced
by
30
% t
o a
cco
un
t fo
r n
ew
co
nst
ruct
ion
be
cau
se t
he
plu
mb
er
alr
ea
dy
in b
uild
ing
). C
om
bu
stio
n v
en
tin
g:
$5
0 e
qu
ipm
en
t a
nd
$1
78
eq
uip
me
nt
cost
pe
r 2
01
1 D
WH
CA
SE
re
po
rt.
Co
mb
ust
ion
te
stin
g c
ost
s n
ot
incl
ud
ed
.
•G
as
tan
kle
ss li
feti
me
an
d r
ep
lace
me
nts
: 20
ye
ars
(p
er
DO
E a
nd
20
16
DW
H C
AS
E r
ep
ort
). T
he
co
st o
f o
ne
re
pla
cem
en
t is
incl
ud
ed
in
th
e c
alc
ula
tio
n.
•H
PW
H e
qu
ipm
en
t li
st p
rice
: $
1,2
00
fo
r 5
0-g
al,
$1
,40
0 f
or
80
-ga
l, p
er
ww
w.l
ow
es.
com
on
4/1
4/2
01
7. E
ne
rgy
fa
cto
r 3
. 5
, C
OP
pe
r N
RD
C-E
coto
pe
20
16
stu
dy,
htt
ps:
//w
ww
.nrd
c.o
rg/e
xpe
rts/
pie
rre
-de
lfo
rge
/ve
ry-c
oo
l-h
ea
t-p
um
p-w
ate
r-h
ea
ters
-sa
ve
-
en
erg
y-a
nd
-mo
ne
y, s
cale
d b
y 7
% t
o a
cco
un
t fo
r p
erf
orm
an
ce i
mp
rov
em
en
ts s
ince
20
14
(ra
tio
of
3.5
EF
an
d 3
.25
EF
)
•H
PW
H i
nst
all
ati
on
: $4
97
(2
01
4 It
ron
Me
asu
re C
ost
stu
dy
ad
just
ed
fo
r in
fla
tio
n)
+ $
20
0 f
or
24
0V
co
nd
uit
co
st p
er
on
line
sea
rch
.
•H
PW
H l
ife
tim
e a
nd
re
pla
cem
en
ts: 1
3 y
ea
rs (
pe
r D
OE
an
d 2
01
6 D
WH
CA
SE
re
po
rt f
or
sto
rag
e w
ate
r h
ea
ters
). T
he
co
st o
f tw
o
rep
lace
me
nts
is
incl
ud
ed
in
th
e c
alc
ula
tio
n.
Da
ta S
ou
rce
s a
nd
Ass
um
pti
on
s –
En
erg
y a
nd
GH
Gs
28
•
Na
tura
l g
as
sou
rce
to
sit
e r
ati
o:
1.0
5,
En
erg
y S
tar
Po
rtfo
lio M
an
ag
er
- T
ech
nic
al R
efe
ren
ce,
htt
ps:
//p
ort
folio
ma
na
ge
r.e
ne
rgy
sta
r.g
ov/
pd
f/re
fere
nce
/So
urc
e%
20
En
erg
y.p
df
•
Ele
ctri
city
T&
D l
oss
es:
1.0
47
, E
IA,
20
15
, , h
ttp
://w
ww
.eia
.go
v/to
ols
/fa
qs/
faq
.cfm
?id
=1
05
&t=
3
•
Na
tura
l g
as
em
issi
on
s fa
cto
r: 5
.30
2,
kg
CO
2/t
h, ,
htt
p:/
/ww
w.e
pa
.go
v/e
ne
rgy
/gh
g-
eq
uiv
ale
nci
es-
calc
ula
tor-
calc
ula
tio
ns-
an
d-r
efe
ren
ces
•
Em
issi
on
s fa
cto
rs:
Ta
ble
10
, “C
EC
Dra
ft S
taff
Re
po
rt:
EST
IMA
TE
D C
OST
OF
NE
W R
EN
EW
AB
LE
AN
D F
OSS
IL G
EN
ER
AT
ION
IN
CA
LIFO
RN
IA (
Ma
y 2
01
4)”
,
htt
p:/
/ww
w.e
ne
rgy
.ca
.go
v/2
01
4p
ub
lica
tio
ns/
CE
C-2
00
-20
14
-00
3/C
EC
-20
0-2
01
4-0
03
-SD
.pd
f
lb
s/M
WH
k
g C
O2
/kW
h
Sin
gle
cy
cle
1
,23
9.3
0
.56
21
Co
mb
ine
d c
ycl
e
82
3.1
0
.37
34
•
So
urc
e-t
o-s
ite
ra
tio
s a
nd
he
at
rate
s: T
ab
le 3
9,
“CE
C D
raft
Sta
ff R
ep
ort
: E
STIM
AT
ED
CO
ST O
F
NE
W R
EN
EW
AB
LE A
ND
FO
SSIL
GE
NE
RA
TIO
N I
N C
ALI
FOR
NIA
(M
ay
20
14
)”,
htt
p:/
/ww
w.e
ne
rgy
.ca
.go
v/2
01
4p
ub
lica
tio
ns/
CE
C-2
00
-20
14
-00
3/C
EC
-20
0-2
01
4-0
03
-SD
.pd
f
H
ea
t ra
te
Btu
/kW
h
Th
erm
al
eff
icie
ncy
So
urc
e-
to-s
ite
Sin
gle
cy
cle
1
0,5
85
3
2%
3
.10
Co
mb
ine
d c
ycl
e
7,2
50
4
7%
2
.12
7/1
7/2
01
7 8
Pri
ori
ty o
pp
ort
un
itie
s fo
r e
lect
rifi
cati
on
Ne
w c
on
stru
ctio
n
•V
ery
co
st-e
ffe
ctiv
e
•S
ave
$ b
y n
ot
bu
ild
ing
ga
s in
fra
stru
ctu
re
Low
-in
com
e r
etr
ofi
ts
•C
ap
& T
rad
e f
un
ds
ava
ila
ble
•E
lect
rifi
cati
on
su
cce
ss w
ith
mu
lti-
fam
ily
re
tro
fits
a
lre
ad
y
•S
an
Jo
aq
uin
Va
lle
y
(CP
UC
)
Effi
cie
ncy
up
gra
de
s
•U
se E
ne
rgy
U
pg
rad
e C
A $
fo
r h
ea
t p
um
ps
if y
ou
h
ave
ele
ctri
c re
sist
an
ce
•C
ost
-eff
ect
ive
Ea
rly
a
do
pte
rs/”
gre
en
ies”
•P
rog
ress
ive
cit
ies,
m
un
is,
an
d C
CA
s
29