energy performance of heterogeneous lte networks...energy performance of heterogeneous lte networks...

23
Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third ETSI Workshop on ICT Energy Efficiency and Environmental Sustainability 3-5 June 2015 Sophia Antipolis

Upload: others

Post on 28-Feb-2021

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE NetworksHenrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel DianatEricsson ABStockholm, Sweden

Third ETSI Workshop on ICT Energy Efficiency and Environmental Sustainability3-5 June 2015Sophia Antipolis

Page 2: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

–Problem formulation–EARTH base station power model

Outline

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 2

–Scenario–Simulation results–Conclusion

Page 3: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Macro

Consumed Power

Macro

Het Net Scenario

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 3

Indoor Small Cell

Load

Small Cell

Page 4: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

• How does het net deployment affect the energy performance?

• Elaborate trade-off between small cell

Problem Formulation

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 4

between small cell transmit power and node density?

• What is the potential for energy savings using sleep modes?

Page 5: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Energy Performance Assessment Methodology

Post Processing

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 5

Power Consumption Models

Energy Saving techniques

Page 6: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

EARTH Base Station Power Model

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 6

Load dependent part

Fixed constant part

Resource utilization [%]0 100

Page 7: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Discontinuous Transmission

Resource utilization [%]

Power saving

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 7

Radio-frame 10ms

On

Time

Sleep

Page 8: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Discontinuous Transmission

• Micro DTX• MBSFN DTX• Lean Carrier

DTX

CRS

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 8

100%

OnSleep

41%59%59%

41%

MBSFN sub-frames

Radio-frame 10ms

on

DTX

on

MBSFN

MBSFN: Multi-cast and Broadcast Single Frequency Network

Page 9: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Small Cell Sleep Modes

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 9

Macro

Traffic load: High

Page 10: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Small Cell Sleep Modes

Sleep Sleep

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 10

Macro

Traffic load: Low

Page 11: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Simulation Scenario

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 11

Page 12: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

› Asian Scenario– Dense urban (inspired by Tokyo and

Seoul)Macro deployment (3-sector sites)

– Surrounding macro ISD = 400m– Center macro ISD = 200m

Simulation Scenario

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 12

– Center macro ISD = 200m

› 10 largest buildings– Small cell deployment

Page 13: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Small Cell Deployment

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 13

Deployment Type Sparse

Coverage area per node 1000 m2

Number of nodes x

Page 14: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Small Cell Deployment

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 14

Deployment Type Dense

Coverage area per node 600 m2

Number of nodes x

Page 15: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Result Evaluation

› Center area polygon– Area: 1 km2

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 15

– Area: 1 km– Contains high-rise center area

Page 16: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Simulation Results

10th percentile DL user throughput

Deployment Sparse Pico

Transmit power 100, 200 and 500mW

Capacity 285-388 Mbps

Total power consumption

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 16

10 Mbps

2x Capacity

+ Small Cell Increase

- Macro Offload

Page 17: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Simulation ResultsDeployment Sparse Pico

Transmit power 100, 200 and 500mW

Capacity 285-388 Mbps

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 17

2x Peak Throughput

Page 18: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

DTX Energy Savings

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 18

Page 19: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Sleep Mode Energy Savings

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 19

Page 20: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

Sleep Mode Energy Savings

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 20

Page 21: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

› The deployment of small cells increases the performance of the network, but without energy saving techniques the power consumption is up to 3x higher than that of the macro reference.

› With energy saving techniques such as DTX and small cell

Conclusion

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 21

› With energy saving techniques such as DTX and small cell sleep modes, the energy consumption of the HetNets can be reduced.

› From an energy performance perspective, dense low power pico deployment vs a sparse high power pico deployment are equally efficient. Micro DAS however, have shown to be a deployment of poor energy efficiency due to high feeder losses in the cables

Page 22: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third

› The results also show that the total daily energy consumption of the HetNets can be reduced by 10-20% with DTX.

› Introducing longer sleep periods also show potential for energy savings. The result shows that with a sparse pico

Conclusion

HetNet Energy Efficiency | Public | © Ericsson AB 2015 | 2015-05-25 | Page 22

energy savings. The result shows that with a sparse pico deployment, the power consumption at low traffic loads can be reduced by 33%.

Page 23: Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks...Energy Performance of Heterogeneous LTE Networks Henrik Forssell, Gunther Auer, Daniel Dianat Ericsson AB Stockholm, Sweden Third