engg.service m. narayana swamy, 1069664, 281 to tsnpdcl.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · southern power...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M. Narayana Swamy, EMP.ID.No. 1069664, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.281 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 2: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 3: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 4: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M. Narayana
Swamy (EMP ID No.1069664),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M. Narayana Swamy,(EMPID
No.1069664) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M. Narayana Swamy,(1069664) ADE/EL./Transformers-2/Gooty
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 5: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M. Venkata Rangaiah, EMP.ID.No. 1065210, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.282 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 6: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 7: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 8: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M. Venkata
Rangaiah (EMP ID No.1065210),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to
serve basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M. Venkata Rangaiah,(EMPID
No.1065210) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M. Venkata Rangaiah,(1065210) ADE/EL./STANDS PROMATED AS EE/ADONI
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 9: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.D. Chenna Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 1068025, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.283 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 10: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 11: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 12: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. D. Chenna Reddy
(EMP ID No.1068025),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.D. Chenna Reddy,(EMPID
No.1068025) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.D. Chenna Reddy,(1068025) ADE/EL./STORES/ATP
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 13: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.K. Srinivasulu Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 1060333, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.284 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 14: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 15: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 16: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. K. Srinivasulu
Reddy (EMP ID No.1060333),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.K. Srinivasulu Reddy,(EMPID
No.1060333) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.K. Srinivasulu Reddy,(1060333) ADE/EL./Kurnool
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 17: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.V. Raja Sekhar, EMP.ID.No. 1067949, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.285 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 18: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 19: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 20: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. V. Raja Sekhar
(EMP ID No.1067949),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.V. Raja Sekhar,(EMPID
No.1067949) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.V. Raja Sekhar,(1067949) ADE/EL./Opn/ Rurals- EAST/ ATP
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 21: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.B. Veeresha, EMP.ID.No. 1065209, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.286 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 22: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 23: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 24: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. B. Veeresha (EMP
ID No.1065209),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.B. Veeresha,(EMPID No.1065209)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.B. Veeresha,(1065209) ADE/EL./Opn./ Yemmiganur
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 25: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.K. Nagaraju, EMP.ID.No. 1065864, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.287 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 26: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 27: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 28: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. K. Nagaraju (EMP
ID No.1065864),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.K. Nagaraju,(EMPID No.1065864)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.K. Nagaraju,(1065864) ADE/EL./Opn./Town-1/nandyal
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 29: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.K. Kalidas, EMP.ID.No. 1067108, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.288 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 30: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 31: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 32: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. K. Kalidas (EMP ID
No.1067108),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date, now
stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.K. Kalidas,(EMPID No.1067108)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.K. Kalidas,(1067108) ADE/EL./Opn./ Puttaparthy
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 33: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M. Hari Prasad, EMP.ID.No. 1065198, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.289 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 34: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 35: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 36: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M. Hari Prasad
(EMP ID No.1065198),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M. Hari Prasad,(EMPID
No.1065198) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M. Hari Prasad,(1065198) ADE/EL./Tech./CO/ Kurnool
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 37: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M. Hanumantha Raidu, EMP.ID.No. 1061485, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.290 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 38: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 39: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 40: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M. Hanumantha
Raidu (EMP ID No.1061485),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M. Hanumantha Raidu,(EMPID
No.1061485) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M. Hanumantha Raidu,(1061485) ADE/EL./Transformers-1/ anantapur
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 41: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.Ch.Nagaraju, EMP.ID.No. 1060464, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.291 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 42: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 43: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 44: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. Ch.Nagaraju (EMP
ID No.1060464),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.Ch.Nagaraju,(EMPID No.1060464)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.Ch.Nagaraju,(1060464) ADE/EL./Opn./ uravakonda
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 45: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.Y. Chandra Sekhar, EMP.ID.No. 1061287, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.292 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 46: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 47: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 48: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. Y. Chandra Sekhar
(EMP ID No.1061287),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.Y. Chandra Sekhar,(EMPID
No.1061287) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.Y. Chandra Sekhar,(1061287) ADE/EL./HT/CT-Meters-II/Ananthapur
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 49: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.K. V. Raja Sekhara Rao, EMP.ID.No. 1061047, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.293 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 50: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 51: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 52: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. K. V. Raja Sekhara
Rao (EMP ID No.1061047),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis
till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.K. V. Raja Sekhara Rao,(EMPID
No.1061047) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.K. V. Raja Sekhara Rao,(1061047) ADE/EL./Opn./ Rurals- EAST/ ATP
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 53: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.U.Prabhakar, EMP.ID.No. 1061488, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.294 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 54: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 55: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 56: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. U.Prabhakar (EMP
ID No.1061488),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.U.Prabhakar,(EMPID No.1061488)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.U.Prabhakar,(1061488) ADE/EL./HTM-1/KNL (ADE/M & P/Kurnool)
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 57: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M.Lakshmi Narayana Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 1061303, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the
Supplementary Report dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief
Orders- Issued. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.295 Dt.14-03-2020 Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt.
7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee
headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee
dated 26.12.2019. 9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of
2020 in CANo.11435/2018 10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man
Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019. 11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 58: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 59: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 60: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M.Lakshmi
Narayana Reddy (EMP ID No.1061303),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order
to serve basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M.Lakshmi Narayana
Reddy,(EMPID No.1061303) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to
TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from
14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is
directed to report to the Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to
get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To Sri/Smt.M.Lakshmi Narayana Reddy,(1061303) ADE/EL./Construction-2/ ATP
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL.
Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 61: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.Momin Mohd. Khasier, EMP.ID.No. 1060724, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.296 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 62: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 63: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 64: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/64.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. Momin Mohd.
Khasier (EMP ID No.1060724),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.Momin Mohd. Khasier,(EMPID
No.1060724) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.Momin Mohd. Khasier,(1060724) ADE/EL./Protection/ kurnool
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 65: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/65.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.D.Naga Raju, EMP.ID.No. 1061464, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.297 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 66: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/66.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 67: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/67.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 68: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/68.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. D.Naga Raju (EMP
ID No.1061464),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.D.Naga Raju,(EMPID No.1061464)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.D.Naga Raju,(1061464) ADE/EL./Construction/Kadapa
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 69: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/69.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.B.Srinivasulu, EMP.ID.No. 1061291, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.298 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 70: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/70.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 71: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/71.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 72: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/72.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. B.Srinivasulu (EMP
ID No.1061291),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.B.Srinivasulu,(EMPID No.1061291)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.B.Srinivasulu,(1061291) ADE/EL./HT Meters/Ananapuram
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 73: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/73.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.D.Vivekananda Swamy, EMP.ID.No. 1062228, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.299 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 74: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/74.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 75: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/75.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 76: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/76.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. D.Vivekananda
Swamy (EMP ID No.1062228),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.D.Vivekananda Swamy,(EMPID
No.1062228) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.D.Vivekananda Swamy,(1062228) ADE/EL./Opn/ Rurals- WEST/ ATP
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 77: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/77.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.P.S.V.S.Nandaiah, EMP.ID.No. 1066418, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.300 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 78: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/78.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 79: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/79.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 80: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/80.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. P.S.V.S.Nandaiah
(EMP ID No.1066418),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.P.S.V.S.Nandaiah,(EMPID
No.1066418) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.P.S.V.S.Nandaiah,(1066418) ADE/EL./Transformers/Nandyal
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 81: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/81.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.V. Sudhakaru, EMP.ID.No. 1066794, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.301 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 82: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/82.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 83: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/83.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 84: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/84.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. V. Sudhakaru (EMP
ID No.1066794),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.V. Sudhakaru,(EMPID No.1066794)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.V. Sudhakaru,(1066794) ADE/EL./LMC
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 85: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/85.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.B. Jeeva Ratnam, EMP.ID.No. 1055903, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.302 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 86: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/86.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 87: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/87.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 88: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/88.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. B. Jeeva Ratnam
(EMP ID No.1055903),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.B. Jeeva Ratnam,(EMPID
No.1055903) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.B. Jeeva Ratnam,(1055903) ADE/EL./Transformers/Adoni
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 89: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/89.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.G.Ranga Swamy, EMP.ID.No. 1052358, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.303 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 90: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/90.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 91: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/91.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 92: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/92.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. G.Ranga Swamy
(EMP ID No.1052358),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.G.Ranga Swamy,(EMPID
No.1052358) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.G.Ranga Swamy,(1052358) ADE/EL./Protection/Dhone (ADE/M & P/ Dhone)
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 93: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/93.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M.Ramasubba Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 1069013, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.304 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 94: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/94.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 95: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/95.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 96: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/96.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M.Ramasubba
Reddy (EMP ID No.1069013),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M.Ramasubba Reddy,(EMPID
No.1069013) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M.Ramasubba Reddy,(1069013) ADE/EL./CCO/ Nandikotkur
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 97: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/97.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.O.Venkateswarlu, EMP.ID.No. 1067992, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.305 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 98: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/98.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 99: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/99.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 100: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/100.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. O.Venkateswarlu
(EMP ID No.1067992),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.O.Venkateswarlu,(EMPID
No.1067992) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.O.Venkateswarlu,(1067992) ADE/EL./Dist.Stores/Ongole
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 101: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/101.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.B.Kalyana Chakravarthy, EMP.ID.No. 1064928, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.306 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 102: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/102.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 103: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/103.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 104: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/104.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. B.Kalyana
Chakravarthy (EMP ID No.1064928),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to
serve basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.B.Kalyana Chakravarthy,(EMPID
No.1064928) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.B.Kalyana Chakravarthy,(1064928) ADE/EL./CONSTRUCTION/ KURNOOL
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 105: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/105.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.Y.Vijaya Sarathy, EMP.ID.No. 1064926, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.307 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 106: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/106.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 107: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/107.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 108: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/108.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. Y.Vijaya Sarathy
(EMP ID No.1064926),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.Y.Vijaya Sarathy,(EMPID
No.1064926) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.Y.Vijaya Sarathy,(1064926) ADE/EL./OPN./GUDUR/ KURNOOL
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 109: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/109.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.D.Srinivasulu, EMP.ID.No. 1065474, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.308 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 110: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/110.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 111: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/111.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 112: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/112.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. D.Srinivasulu (EMP
ID No.1065474),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.D.Srinivasulu,(EMPID No.1065474)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.D.Srinivasulu,(1065474) ADE/EL./ZONE/ KURNOOL
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 113: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/113.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M.Purushotham, EMP.ID.No. 1065203, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.309 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 114: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/114.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 115: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/115.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 116: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/116.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M.Purushotham
(EMP ID No.1065203),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M.Purushotham,(EMPID
No.1065203) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M.Purushotham,(1065203) ADE/EL./Construction/ Adoni
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 117: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/117.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.N.Mahesh Kumar, EMP.ID.No. 1067939, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.310 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 118: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/118.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 119: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/119.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 120: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/120.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. N.Mahesh Kumar
(EMP ID No.1067939),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.N.Mahesh Kumar,(EMPID
No.1067939) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.N.Mahesh Kumar,(1067939) ADE/EL./Construction-1/ ATP
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 121: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/121.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.S.Ravi Prasad, EMP.ID.No. 1068877, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.311 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 122: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/122.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 123: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/123.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 124: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/124.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. S.Ravi Prasad (EMP
ID No.1068877),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.S.Ravi Prasad,(EMPID No.1068877)
who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.S.Ravi Prasad,(1068877) ADE/EL./Opn./Madakasira
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 125: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/125.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.T.Chandra Sekhar, EMP.ID.No. 1070930, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.312 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 126: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/126.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 127: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/127.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 128: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/128.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. T.Chandra Sekhar
(EMP ID No.1070930),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.T.Chandra Sekhar,(EMPID
No.1070930) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.T.Chandra Sekhar,(1070930) ADE/EL./Opn./ West/ Kadiri
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 129: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/129.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.B. Adi Seshaiah, EMP.ID.No. 1072030, ADE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.313 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 130: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/130.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 131: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/131.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 132: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/132.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. B. Adi Seshaiah
(EMP ID No.1072030),ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.B. Adi Seshaiah,(EMPID
No.1072030) who now, ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.B. Adi Seshaiah,(1072030) ADE/EL./Opn./ Gooty
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 133: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/133.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.J. Sandhya, EMP.ID.No. 18020, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.318 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 134: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/134.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 135: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/135.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 136: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/136.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. J. Sandhya (EMP
ID No.18020),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date, now
stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.J. Sandhya,(EMPID No.18020) who
now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.J. Sandhya,(18020) AE/EL./Indoor Stores/D.S/ Anantapur
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 137: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/137.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.T.Sindur Sharma, EMP.ID.No. 15277, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.319 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 138: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/138.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 139: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/139.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 140: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/140.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. T.Sindur Sharma
(EMP ID No.15277),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.T.Sindur Sharma,(EMPID
No.15277) who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.T.Sindur Sharma,(15277) AE/EL./SECRETARY TO CGRF
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 141: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/141.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.P.Sundara Kumar, EMP.ID.No. 18670, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.320 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 142: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/142.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 143: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/143.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 144: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/144.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. P.Sundara Kumar
(EMP ID No.18670),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.P.Sundara Kumar,(EMPID
No.18670) who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.P.Sundara Kumar,(18670) AE/EL./Opn./Madhura Nagar
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 145: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/145.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.B.Appala Naidu, EMP.ID.No. 17335, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.321 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 146: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/146.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 147: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/147.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 148: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/148.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. B.Appala Naidu
(EMP ID No.17335),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.B.Appala Naidu,(EMPID No.17335)
who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.B.Appala Naidu,(17335) AE/EL./Opn/Vissannapet
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 149: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/149.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.Shiak Khaja Babu, EMP.ID.No. 18706, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.322 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 150: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/150.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 151: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/151.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 152: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/152.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. Shiak Khaja Babu
(EMP ID No.18706),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.Shiak Khaja Babu,(EMPID
No.18706) who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.Shiak Khaja Babu,(18706) AE/EL./Opn./D-3/Narasaraopet
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 153: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/153.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.T.Ranga Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 17253, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.323 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 154: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/154.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 155: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/155.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 156: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/156.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. T.Ranga Reddy
(EMP ID No.17253),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.T.Ranga Reddy,(EMPID No.17253)
who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.T.Ranga Reddy,(17253) AE/EL./Opn./Kasinayana
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 157: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/157.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.K.Jaya Krishna, EMP.ID.No. 17989, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.324 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 158: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/158.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 159: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/159.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 160: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/160.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. K.Jaya Krishna
(EMP ID No.17989),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.K.Jaya Krishna,(EMPID No.17989)
who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.K.Jaya Krishna,(17989) AE/EL./Opn./Town/ Venkatagiri
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 161: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/161.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M.Abdul Haq, EMP.ID.No. 15492, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.325 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 162: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/162.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 163: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/163.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 164: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/164.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M.Abdul Haq (EMP
ID No.15492),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date, now
stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M.Abdul Haq,(EMPID No.15492)
who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M.Abdul Haq,(15492) AE/EL./MEDICAL INVALIDATION
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 165: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/165.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.P.Yuva Bharathi, EMP.ID.No. 18666, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.326 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 166: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/166.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 167: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/167.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 168: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/168.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. P.Yuva Bharathi
(EMP ID No.18666),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.P.Yuva Bharathi,(EMPID No.18666)
who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.P.Yuva Bharathi,(18666) AE/EL./Comml/D.O./Chirala
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 169: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/169.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.M.Lakshmi Prasanna, EMP.ID.No. 18103, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.327 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 170: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/170.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 171: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/171.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 172: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/172.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. M.Lakshmi
Prasanna (EMP ID No.18103),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.M.Lakshmi Prasanna,(EMPID
No.18103) who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.M.Lakshmi Prasanna,(18103) AE/EL./Planning/Corp.Off
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 173: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/173.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.B.Ramanjanamma, EMP.ID.No. 17285, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.328 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 174: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/174.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 175: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/175.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 176: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/176.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. B.Ramanjanamma
(EMP ID No.17285),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.B.Ramanjanamma,(EMPID
No.17285) who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.B.Ramanjanamma,(17285) AE/EL./T&P/ Circle Office/ Anantapur
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 177: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/177.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.R.Bhanu Chandhar, EMP.ID.No. 18673, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.329 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 178: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/178.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 179: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/179.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 180: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/180.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. R.Bhanu Chandhar
(EMP ID No.18673),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date,
now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.R.Bhanu Chandhar,(EMPID
No.18673) who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.R.Bhanu Chandhar,(18673) AE/EL./Camps Section/ Kurnool
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 181: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/181.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.G.Rama Devi, EMP.ID.No. 18102, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.330 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 182: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/182.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 183: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/183.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 184: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/184.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. G.Rama Devi (EMP
ID No.18102),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date, now
stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.G.Rama Devi,(EMPID No.18102)
who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.G.Rama Devi,(18102) AE/EL./Tech/Construction/DO/Kurnool
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 185: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/185.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.V.C.Shravan Kumar Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 19148, AE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary
Report dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.331 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 186: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/186.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 187: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/187.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 188: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/188.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. V.C.Shravan
Kumar Reddy (EMP ID No.19148),AE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve
basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.V.C.Shravan Kumar Reddy,(EMPID
No.19148) who now, AE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.V.C.Shravan Kumar Reddy,(19148) AE/EL./Opn. Section/ Orvakal
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 189: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/189.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.Y.N.Prasad Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 16949, AAE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.332 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 190: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/190.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 191: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/191.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 192: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/192.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. Y.N.Prasad Reddy
(EMP ID No.16949),AAE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis till
date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.Y.N.Prasad Reddy,(EMPID
No.16949) who now, AAE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.Y.N.Prasad Reddy,(16949) AAE/EL./Opn./ Devanakonda
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 193: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/193.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.C.Ramakrishna Reddy, EMP.ID.No. 20377, AAE/EL.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report
dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.333 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 194: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/194.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 195: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/195.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 196: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/196.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. C.Ramakrishna
Reddy (EMP ID No.20377),AAE/EL. working in APSPDCL on order to serve basis
till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.C.Ramakrishna Reddy,(EMPID
No.20377) who now, AAE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.C.Ramakrishna Reddy,(20377) AAE/EL./Anathapur(Expired)
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 197: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/197.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Accts.Service - Sri/Smt.Veera Hanumantha Rao Vurimi, EMP.ID.No. 1057985, GM/ACCTS.,Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the
Supplementary Report dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief
Orders- Issued. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.334 Dt.14-03-2020 Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt.
7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee
headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee
dated 26.12.2019. 9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of
2020 in CANo.11435/2018 10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man
Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019. 11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 198: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/198.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 199: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/199.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 200: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/200.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. Veera
Hanumantha Rao Vurimi (EMP ID No.1057985),GM/ACCTS. working in
APSPDCL on order to serve basis till date, now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.Veera Hanumantha Rao
Vurimi,(EMPID No.1057985) who now, GM/ACCTS. stands finally allotted to
TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from
14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is
directed to report to the Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to
get posting orders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To Sri/Smt.Veera Hanumantha Rao Vurimi,(1057985) GM/ACCTS./GM/ costing
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal - As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL.
Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 201: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/201.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.T. SAI SUDHAKAR, EMP.ID.No. 3837, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary
Report dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.314 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 202: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/202.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 203: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/203.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 204: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/204.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. T. SAI SUDHAKAR
(EMP ID No.3837),AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL is now stands
finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.T. SAI SUDHAKAR,(EMPID No.3837)
who now, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.T. SAI SUDHAKAR,(3837) AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL./DPE/Tirupati
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 205: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/205.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.T. SATYANARAYANA, EMP.ID.No. 6564, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the
Supplementary Report dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief
Orders- Issued. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.315 Dt.14-03-2020 Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt.
7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee
headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee
dated 26.12.2019. 9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of
2020 in CANo.11435/2018 10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man
Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019. 11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 206: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/206.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 207: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/207.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 208: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/208.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. T.
SATYANARAYANA (EMP ID No.6564),AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. working in
APSPDCL is now stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.T. SATYANARAYANA,(EMPID
No.6564) who now, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL,
is hereby relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN
and he is ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to
the Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.T. SATYANARAYANA,(6564) AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL./Opn./Vetapalem
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 209: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/209.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.U. L. NARASIMHA REDDY, EMP.ID.No. 6554, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the
Supplementary Report dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief
Orders- Issued. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.316 Dt.14-03-2020 Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt.
7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee
headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee
dated 26.12.2019. 9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of
2020 in CANo.11435/2018 10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man
Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019. 11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 210: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/210.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 211: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/211.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 212: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/212.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. U. L. NARASIMHA
REDDY (EMP ID No.6554),AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL is now
stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.U. L. NARASIMHA REDDY,(EMPID
No.6554) who now, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL,
is hereby relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN
and he is ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to
the Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.U. L. NARASIMHA REDDY,(6554) AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL./Opn./Giddalur
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 213: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/213.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service - Sri/Smt.SYED KHADAR BASHA, EMP.ID.No. 6540, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the
Supplementary Report dt.11-03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief
Orders- Issued. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.317 Dt.14-03-2020 Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt.
7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee
headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee
dated 26.12.2019. 9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of
2020 in CANo.11435/2018 10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man
Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019. 11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 214: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/214.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 215: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/215.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 216: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/216.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. SYED KHADAR
BASHA (EMP ID No.6540),AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. working in APSPDCL is now
stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.SYED KHADAR BASHA,(EMPID
No.6540) who now, AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL,
is hereby relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN
and he is ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to
the Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.SYED KHADAR BASHA,(6540) AE/EL. (NOW ADE/EL./TOWN/ KALYANDURG
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 217: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/217.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Accts.Service - Sri/Smt.S.Ramesh, EMP.ID.No. 11624, JAO/ACCTS. Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-
03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.335 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 218: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/218.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 219: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/219.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 220: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/220.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. S.Ramesh (EMP ID
No.11624),JAO/ACCTS. working in APSPDCL is now stands finally allotted to
TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.S.Ramesh,(EMPID No.11624) who
now, JAO/ACCTS. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.S.Ramesh,(11624) JAO/ACCTS./JAO/CPR -3/ CO/ TPT
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 221: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/221.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—Accts.Service - Sri/Smt.K.Srinivas, EMP.ID.No. 11731, JAO/ACCTS. Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-
03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.336 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 222: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/222.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 223: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/223.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 224: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/224.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. K.Srinivas (EMP ID
No.11731),JAO/ACCTS. working in APSPDCL is now stands finally allotted to
TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.K.Srinivas,(EMPID No.11731) who
now, JAO/ACCTS. stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from the
services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be the
employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and Managing
Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.K.Srinivas,(11731) JAO/ACCTS./CPR/ CORP. OFFICE
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 225: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/225.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—P&G.Service - Sri/Smt.T. RAJESWARA RAO, EMP.ID.No. 2074, GM/HRD Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-03-
2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.337 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 226: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/226.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 227: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/227.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 228: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/228.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. T. RAJESWARA
RAO (EMP ID No.2074),GM/HRD working in APSPDCL is now stands finally
allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.T. RAJESWARA RAO,(EMPID
No.2074) who now, GM/HRD stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.T. RAJESWARA RAO,(2074) GM/HRD/GM/CORP. OFFICE
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 229: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/229.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—P&G.Service - Sri/Smt.N.CHINNAIAH, EMP.ID.No. 12572, DGM/HRD Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-
03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.338 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 230: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/230.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 231: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/231.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 232: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/232.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. N.CHINNAIAH
(EMP ID No.12572),DGM/HRD working in APSPDCL is now stands finally allotted
to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.N.CHINNAIAH,(EMPID No.12572)
who now, DGM/HRD stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby relieved from
the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is ceased to be
the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the Chairman and
Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.N.CHINNAIAH,(12572) DGM/HRD/DGM(IV)-Legal
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER
![Page 233: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/233.jpg)
SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED
CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI
ABSTRACT
Estt—APSPDCL—P&G.Service - Sri/Smt.K.SAHADEVA REDDY, EMP.ID.No. 4486, DGM/HRD Final Allotment to TSNPDCL as per the Supplementary Report dt.11-
03-2020 to the Final Report of One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Former Supreme Court Judge appointed by Hon’ble Supreme Court of India and further orders thereon—Relief Orders- Issued.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- S.O.O(CGM-HRD)MS.No.339 Dt.14-03-2020
Read the following:
1) A.P. Reorganization Act.
2) G.O.Ms.No.24 of Energy (CC) Department, dt.29-05-2014.
3) C. O. O. Ms. No. 318, dt.31-05-2014.
4) C. O. O. Ms. No. 319, dt.01-06-2014. 5) G. O. Ms. Nos: 32, Energy, I&I (OP.A2) Department,dt.30.11.2017.
6) W.P. No: 16330 of 2015 and batch cases – Common Judgement dated 02.02.2018 passed by Hon’ble HighCourt. 7) Orders dated 28.11.2018 in SLP (CA) Nos: 11435 of 2018 and batch
cases passed by Hon’ble Supreme Court appointing One Man Committee headed by Hon’ble Justice Dharmadhikari, former Judge of Supreme Court
ofIndia. 8) Final Report along with the final allocation lists of the One Man Committee dated 26.12.2019.
9) Hon’ble Supreme Court order dt. 24.1.2020 in MA No.60-62 of 2020 in CANo.11435/2018
10) Supplementary Report dt.11.3.2020 to Final report of One Man Committee of Justice Dharmadhikari, dt.26.12.2019.
11) Clarification to supplementary Report dt.11.03.2020 of One Man Committee of JusticeDharmadhikari,dt.13.03.2020
*****
ORDER:- As per the provisions of AP Reorganisation Act, 2014, bifurcation of
employees has to be carried out. In this regard though modalities for division of
employees between two organizations was proposed by APTRANSCO, TSTRANSCO
did not agree and have unilaterally relieved 1157 employees from all TS Power
utilities stating those are natives of AP State, on 10-06-2015
2) Aggrieved by the act of TS Power Utilities, several cases were filed by
some employees and also A.P Power Utilities before Honourable High Court of AP.
3) During further course of time, the A.P High Court vide judgment
dt.02.02.2018 has set aside the orders dt.10-06-2015 issued byT.S.PowerUtilities
and directed Power Utilities of both the States to form a joint committee to
formulate modalities for division of employees.
4) Aggrieved by the judgment of Honourable High Court, TS Power Utilities
and TS Power Unions/Associations filed SLP in Honourable Supreme Court and
Supreme Court in the reference 8th read above issued orders constituting One Man
Committee with Hon’ble Mr. Justice D.M.Dharmadhikari, Retd., Supreme Court
Judge to decide the division of Power Utility employees of both theStates.
![Page 234: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/234.jpg)
5) The said One Man Committee conducted series of meetings with all
stakeholders including the Managements of T.S Power Utilities and A.P Power
Utilities and also with the employees Associations of both the States from 20-01-
2019 to 15-12-2019 and submitted its final report on26-12-2019.
6) Aggrieved by the report of the One Man Committee, AP Power Utilities
filed Miscellaneous Appeal No. 60-62/2020 (and other connected matters) before
the Honourable Supreme Court of India. The Honourable Supreme Court of India
by an order dt.24.01.2020 directed the said One Man committee to consider the
representations of A.P.Power utilities and to correct the mistakes if any in report
dt.26.12.2019.
7) As per the directions of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the One
Man Committee headed by Hon’bleJustice D M Dharmadhikari former Judge,
Supreme Court of India, has submitted supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 to
the final report dt.26-12-2019, wherein, in para 19 it has been ordered asfollows:
“On behalf of Andhra Pradesh, it has been contended that the Committee of Dr.
SheelaBhide, IAS (Retired) was constituted by the Government and allocation of
employees between APEPDCL & TSNPDCL was already made on 22.07.2017 and,
therefore, there is no necessity of reallocation of the employees between these
two Distribution Companies by the present Committee.
The Committee finds that, Dr. SheelaBhide Committee, was set-up in
accordance with Section 53 of the Andhra Pradesh Reorganization Act,2014 for
Appointment of Assets and Liabilities between two above mentioned Companies.
The decision with regard to the employees taken by Bhide Committee was pending
final allocation to be made, with consensus of the Companies in the two States in
accordance with Section 82 of the Act, of 2014. The allocation made in accordance
with Section 53 of the Act, has to be subject to the final allocation undertaken by
this Committee in accordance with Section 82 of theAct.
The present Committee, therefore, finds that allocation of employees between
APEPDCL and TSNPDCL on the Modalities fixed and approved by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court can bemade.”
The Committee has prepared a separate allocation lists, based on final modalities
dt.17-04-2019 containing names of employees Company-wise who are found
suitable for being allocated. Along with the Final Report dated 26.12.2019, a list
of 655 employees out of 1157 unilaterally relieved employees were identified and
allocated to the Andhra Pradesh power utilities out of which 69 have been
allocated to APEPDCL.
![Page 235: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/235.jpg)
8) As further directed in the Supplementary Report dated 11.3.2020, 71
employees have been identified by the committee itself as special cases covered
by Modality No. VIII to XIII to be allocated to Telangana State. Further, the Sub-
committee member of A.P Power Utilities was entrusted with the task of identifying
584 employees from the employees actually working with the A.P. Utilities on
“order to serve basis” from out of the list Annexed to the Supplementary Report
of the Committee to allocate them from A.P Power Utilities to TS PowerUtilities.
9) While identifying the said 584 employees to be allocated to Telangana
Power Utilities, it has been specifically directed that the identification of above
mentioned584employeesshouldbeotherthanthe655employeesallocatedtoA.P.
Power Utilities out of earlier relieved 1157 under the Final Report dated
26.12.2019 who were relieved by T.S in furtherance of the said report
dt.26.12.2019, and were awaiting orders of joining in AP Power Utilities. Thus,
theidentificationofthe584employeeshavetobemadefromtheemployeesactually
working in A.P. on “order to serve basis”. It is again clarified in the clarification
dated 13.03.2020 issued by the One Man Committee to the supplementary report
dated 11.03.2020.
10) The Hon’ble One Man Committee pleased to allocate 69 employees from
TSNPDCL to APEPDCL for the employees allotted from TSNPDCL opted to
APSPDCL. Hence mutual consensus in terms of the observations of Hon’ble One
Man Committee at para 28 and para (iv) of of the direction part of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020 which reads as follows:-
Para 28:- Despite all the care taker by this Committee (with the
assistance of the Sub-Committee, comprising one member of each side) if exceptional cases of certain employees are brought to the notice of the
concerned companies in the Two States, the concerned Companies on reciprocal basis, will be at liberty to make necessary additional allocations in mutual consultations and agreement between the Chief Executives of the
concerned Companies within the State or inter-se the Two States.
Direction part Para iv:- The employees allocated to a Company in
each State can be within the State, by the Managements of the concerned Companies, allocated or adjusted inter-se in the Companies falling within
their respective States.
The Distribution Companies falling within each State, with due regard
to individual option of the employee and the needs of the company, allocate and post them inter-se between the Distribution Companies within each State.
11) On mutual understanding of the APEPDCL & APSPDCL is proposed for
allocation of 59 employees from APSPDCL to TSNPDCL in lieu of the 69 employees
allotted to AP the balance 10 nos employees were adjusted in APEPDCL and said
employees were allotted from APEPDCL to TSNPDCL to arrive “financially
neutral”as discussed in para 16, para 27 and directions (IV) as of the
supplementary report dated:11.03.2020.
![Page 236: Engg.Service M. Narayana Swamy, 1069664, 281 to TSNPDCL.pdf · 2020. 3. 15. · SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF AP. LIMITED CORPORATE OFFICE::TIRUPATI ABSTRACT Estt—APSPDCL—Engg.Service](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022052008/601ce5a916bc6328bb1e4d57/html5/thumbnails/236.jpg)
12) As such, the process of identification of 584 employees to be allocated
to T.S.Power Utilities has been completed by the Sub-Committee member of A.P
Power Utilities in accordance with the Modalities and working modalities laid down
by the committee. A list of the said identified 584 employees has been submitted
to the Hon’ble One Man Committee in compliance of the directions contained in
Para 27 of the Supplementary Report dated11.3.2020.
13) Thus in compliance with the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of the
Honourable One Man Committee, the employee by name Sri. K.SAHADEVA
REDDY (EMP ID No.4486),DGM/HRD working in APSPDCL is now stands finally
allotted to TSNPDCL.
14) Therefore in compliance of the directions contained in Para 29(I) of the
supplementary report dated 11.3.2020, Sri.K.SAHADEVA REDDY,(EMPID
No.4486) who now, DGM/HRD stands finally allotted to TSNPDCL, is hereby
relieved from the services of APSPDCL with effect from 14.03.2020 AN and he is
ceased to be the employee of APSPDCL, and he is directed to report to the
Chairman and Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal to get postingorders.
(BY ORDER AND IN THE NAME OF THE SOUTHERN POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY OF A.P. LIMITED)
Sd/- H.HARANATHA RAO
CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR
To
Sri/Smt.K.SAHADEVA REDDY,(4486) DGM/HRD/DGM/Pension & IR
Through: The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati.
Copy to: The Chairman & Managing Director/TSNPDCL/Warangal. As per the Supplementary report dt.11-03-2020 of Honourable One Man Committee and further orders thereon, the above incumbent is finally allocated to TSNPDCL. Hence it is requested to issue posting orders to him/her. The Service Book, AARs, Property returns & LPC will be sent separately.
The Chief General Manager/HRD/APSPDCL/Tirupati. All the Superintending Engineers/Operation. The Pay Officer/APSPDCL/ Tirupati. All the Pay Drawing Officers, Tirupati. All Accounts Officers /Expenditure. The Chief Engineer/
(a) With a request to serve the copy of the proceedings to the employee, duly obtaining the dated acknowledgment. (b) Take steps to complete the formalities of relieving the employee in allrespects
on the date mentioned in para (14) above, and forward the report of compliance.
// FORWARDED :: BY ORDER //
PERSONNEL OFFICER