environmental adjudication in queensland: optimizing use ... · •longest hearing in 120 year...

43
Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use of ADR and Expert Evidence President Fleur Y Kingham Land Court of Queensland (AUSTRALIA) Tuesday 17 October 2017 Presented by the National University of Singapore & APCEL

Upload: others

Post on 09-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

Environmental Adjudication in Queensland:

Optimizing Use of ADR and Expert Evidence

President Fleur Y Kingham

Land Court of Queensland (AUSTRALIA)

Tuesday 17 October 2017

Presented by the National University of Singapore & APCEL

Page 2: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

Overview

•The Court’s jurisdiction and function

•An adversarial approach

•A different approach

Page 4: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 5: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 6: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 7: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 9: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 10: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 11: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 12: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 13: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 14: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 15: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 16: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

Objections

Environmental

Social and health

Economic

Suitabiity

Page 17: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 18: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 19: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 21: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 26: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

An adversarial approach

Page 27: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

• Longest hearing in 120 year history

• 98 days of hearing

• 14 active objectors (more inactive)

• 65 witnesses – 28 experts

• E-trial - 2,000 exhibits

• 800 pages of Member’s hand written notes

• 2,000 pages of written submissions

• 459 page decision

• Recommendation not decision

Page 28: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

NEW OAKLEIGH MINING AND REHABILITATION

Page 29: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

NEW OAKLEIGH MINING AND REHABILITATION

Page 30: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

NEW OAKLEIGH MINING AND REHABILITATION

Page 31: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

NEW OAKLEIGH MINING AND REHABILITATION

Page 32: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

ADR+

Page 33: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

New Acland Progressive Rehabilitation

Page 34: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 35: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 36: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 37: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

Court Managed Expert Evidence

Page 38: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 39: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 40: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 41: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 42: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses
Page 43: Environmental Adjudication in Queensland: Optimizing Use ... · •Longest hearing in 120 year history •98 days of hearing •14 active objectors (more inactive) •65 witnesses

Thank you