environmental impact assessement report - phase …jmvp.nic.in/sites/default/files/draft eia report...
TRANSCRIPT
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 1
Prepared by:
EQMS -AIAID – IRGSSA JV
DRAFT ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT REPORT - PHASE 1A OF MULTIMODAL RIVER WATER TERMINAL AT RAMNAGAR, VARANASI, U.P. INDIA
33333333333
INLAND WATERWAYS AUTHORITY OF INDIA
Ministry of Shipping, Government of India
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 2
Table of Contents
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ........................................................................................................ 6 1.1. Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 6
1.2. Project Background ........................................................................................................................ 6
1.3. Project Description ......................................................................................................................... 6
1.4. Connectivity, Surroundings & Sensitivity of the Project Site .................................................... 8
1.5. Project Activities and Area Statement ......................................................................................... 8
1.6. Resources and Utilities Demand for Off-Site Developments ................................................... 9
1.7. Baseline and Social Environment .............................................................................................. 11
1.8. Environment and Social Impacts of the Proposed Project ..................................................... 14
1.9. Environmental Management Plan .............................................................................................. 14
2. INTRODUCTION ..................................................................................................................41 2.1. Prelude ........................................................................................................................................... 41
2.2. Project Background ...................................................................................................................... 42
2.3. Project Brief ................................................................................................................................... 43
2.4. Need for the Proposed Project ................................................................................................... 45
2.5. Need of Study................................................................................................................................ 46
2.6. Scope and Methodology of the Study ....................................................................................... 47
2.7. Limitation of the Study ................................................................................................................. 47
2.8. Structure of the Report ................................................................................................................ 48
2.9. References .................................................................................................................................... 49
3. LEGISLATIVE, REGULATION AND POLICY CONSIDERATION .........................................51 3.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 51
3.1.1. Overview of Indian Environmental Legislation and Administrative Framework ............... 51
3.1.2. Applicable Environmental Legislation .................................................................................... 52
3.2. International Best Practices & Guidelines................................................................................. 60
3.2.1. Operational Policies of World Bank ........................................................................................ 60
3.2.2. Relevant International Environmental Convention ............................................................... 62
3.2.2.1. International Maritime Organization Conventions ............................................................. 62
3.2.2.2. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Montego Bay, (1982): .................. 63
3.2.2.3. International Maritime Dangerous Goods Code (IMDG-code) ........................................ 64
3.3. Environmental Standards & Guidelines .................................................................................... 64
3.3.1. Guideline, Standard and recommendations as published by Environmental Committee
of PIANC ................................................................................................................................................ 65
4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION ....................................................................................................66 4.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................... 66
4.2. Location, Access and Layout of the Project ............................................................................. 66
4.3. Proposed Development ............................................................................................................... 67
4.4 Capacity and features of the project ...................................................................................... 75
4.5 Material handling and other Facilities.................................................................................... 78
4.7 Waste management ................................................................................................................. 78
4.8 Other features ........................................................................................................................... 78
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 3
5. : DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT (EVIRONMENT AND SOCIAL BASELINE) .......79 5.1. Prelude ........................................................................................................................................... 79
5.2. Site Description and Its Environs ............................................................................................... 80
5.3. Geology, Topgraphy & Drainage, Hydrology, Hydrogeology ................................................. 81
5.4. Meteorology ................................................................................................................................... 88
5.5. Ambient Air Quality ....................................................................................................................... 90
5.5.1. Analysis of Ambient Air Quality ........................................................................................... 93
5.6. Ambient Noise Quality ................................................................................................................. 94
5.6.1. Analysis of Ambient Noise Quality ..................................................................................... 95
5.7. Trafic Assessment & Site Connectvity ...................................................................................... 95
5.8. Surface and Ground Water Quality ............................................................................................ 95
5.9. Soil Quality ..................................................................................................................................... 98
5.10. Land Use ................................................................................................................................... 100
5.11. Biological Environment ............................................................................................................ 102
5.11.1. Flora .................................................................................................................................... 102
5.11.2. Fauna .................................................................................................................................. 109
5.11.3. Kashi Turtle Sanctuary ..................................................................................................... 112
5.11.4. Aquatic Ecosystem ........................................................................................................... 116
5.12. Social Impact Assessment ...................................................................................................... 124
5.12.1. Tourism and Heritage ....................................................................................................... 132
6. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS ............................................................................................ 137 6.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 137
6.2. Impact Identification ................................................................................................................... 137
6.3. Impact on Climate ....................................................................................................................... 139
6.4. Impact Due to Natural Disaster ................................................................................................ 140
6.5. Impact on Air Environment ........................................................................................................ 140
6.6. Impact on Noise Environment .................................................................................................. 143
6.7. Impacts on Water Resources ................................................................................................... 144
6.8. Impact on Land Environment .................................................................................................... 148
6.9. Impacts on Biological Environment .......................................................................................... 152
6.10. Impacts on Socio-Economy .................................................................................................... 155
7. PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS AND DISCLOSURE................................................................ 161 7.1. Methods of Public Consultation ................................................................................................ 161
7.2. Institutional Consultation ........................................................................................................... 164
7.3. Affected Person‟s (Land Acquisition) Consultation ............................................................... 166
7.4. Direct/Indirect Affected Person‟s Consultation ....................................................................... 167
7.5. Conclusion: .................................................................................................................................. 167
8. ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN AND MONITORING INDICATORS .................. 170 8.1. Introduction .................................................................................................................................. 170
8.2. The Environmental Management Plan .................................................................................... 170
8.3. Institutional Arrangement .......................................................................................................... 194
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 4
8.3.1. Environmental Management Cell ..................................................................................... 194
8.4. Environmental Standards .......................................................................................................... 196
8.5. Environment Monitoring Plan .................................................................................................... 196
8.6. Reporting Requirement .............................................................................................................. 200
8.7. Grievance Redress Mechanism ............................................................................................... 200
List of Tables
Table 1.1: Details of building to be constructed .......................................................................... 8 Table 1.2: Details of Roads ........................................................................................................ 9 Table 1.3 Design Vessel Sizes ..................................................................................................10 Table 1.4: Type of luminaires ....................................................................................................10 Table 1.5: Water level of River Ganga ......................................................................................12 Table 2.1: Geographical Coordinates of Project Site .................................................................43 Table 2.2: Reference Used for EIA Study..................................................................................49 Table 3.1: Summary of Environmental and Other Legislation with Applicability Screeening ......52 Table 3.2: Regulations Applicable on Vessels/Barges Plying in Inland Waterways (However,
these will be applicable for operation stage only) ...............................................................60 Table 3.3: World Banks Operational Policies - Environmental & Social Safeguard ....................61 Table 4.1: Type of commodity, volume estimated preliminary growth projections, preliminary
Turnover Volume per day and required storage capacity ...................................................75 Table 5.1: Environmental Setting ..............................................................................................80 Table 5.3: Meteorological Conditions of Varanasi (30 years average) .......................................88 Table 5.5: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Locations .................................................................91 Table 5.6: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results (24-hour average) .......................................91 Table 5.7 Ambient Air Quality of Varanasi (March 2015) ...........................................................92 Table 5.8 : Ambient Noise Quality in Study Area .......................................................................94 Table 5.9 Name of Water Sampling Locations ..........................................................................95 Table 5.10: Surface Water Quality ............................................................................................96 Table 5.11: Ground Water Quality .............................................................................................96 Table 5.11 : continue… Ground Water Quality ..........................................................................96 Table 5.12: Soil Sampling Locations .........................................................................................98 Table 5.13: Physicochemical Characteristics of Soil .................................................................99 Table 5.14 : Land use of the Study Area ................................................................................. 101 Table 5.15 : List of Common Plant Species Present in Study Area ......................................... 104 Table 5.15: List of Wildlife Found in Study Area ...................................................................... 109 Table 5.16 : List of the Birds Surveyed / Recorded in the Study Area ..................................... 110 Table 5.17 Year wise details of Turtle Released in the Sanctuary ........................................... 114 Table -5.18: Details of Aquatic Sampling Locations ................................................................ 117 Table 5.19: List of Phytoplankton‟s Observed in Sampling Locations ...................................... 118 Table-5.20 List of Zooplanktons Observed in Ganga River: At Ramnagar site ...................... 119 Table-3.21: Zoo-benthic fauna at Ramnagar. ......................................................................... 120 Table-5.22 List of Fishes observed in Study Area during Study Period ................................... 121 Table 5.23: Uttar Pradesh State Population ............................................................................ 125 Table 5.24: Uttar Pradesh State Literacy Level ...................................................................... 125 Table 5.25: Uttar Pradesh State Population SC and ST ......................................................... 126 Table 5.26: Uttar Pradesh State Worker Population ................................................................ 126 Table 5.27: Population of the District ....................................................................................... 129 Table 5.28: Literacy in the District .......................................................................................... 129
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 5
Table 5.29: SC and ST population of the District ..................................................................... 129 Table 5.30: Work population of the District .............................................................................. 130 Table 5.31: Tehsil Wise Population of district .......................................................................... 130 Table 5.32: Tehsil wise literacy population of District .............................................................. 130 Table 5.33: Tehsil wise SC and ST population of District ........................................................ 130 Table 5.34: Tehsil wise work population of District .................................................................. 131 Table 5.35 : Town where the Terminal is to be located along NW-1 - Population .................... 131 Table 5.36: Town where the Terminal is to be located along NW-1- SC and ST population .... 131 Table 5.37: Town where the Terminal is to be located along NW-1 - Literacy and work
population ........................................................................................................................ 132 Table 5.36: Important festivals and the venue in Varanasi city ................................................ 135 Table 6.1: Impact Matrix for Proposed Off-site Infrastructure ................................................. 137 Table 6.2: Emissions produced in movement of 1 ton of Cargo for 1000 miles by tow boat, truck
and train ........................................................................................................................... 143 Table 7.1: Detail of the contacts during the Stakeholder Consultations ................................... 163 Table 7.2: Environment Issues discussed with stockholders ................................................... 164 Table 8.1: Environment Management Plan ............................................................................. 171 Table 8.2: Environment Monitoring Plan.................................................................................. 198
List of Figures
Figure 1.1: Location map of Terminal Site at Ramnagar ............................................................ 7 Figure 2.1 : Google Map Showing the Alignment of NW-1 ........................................................42 Figure 2.2: Google Map Showing Site Location.........................................................................44 Figure 2.3: Location Map of Varanasi Terminal .........................................................................45 Figure 4.1: Layout of Ramnagar Terminal, Stage 1 ...................................................................71 Figure 4.2: general arrangement of Jetty (Middle level), Ramnagar ..........................................72 Figure 4.3: Typical section of jetty, Ramnagar...........................................................................73 Figure 4.4: Details of stone pitching works ................................................................................74 Figure 5.1: Map Showing Environmental Monitoring Locations ................................................79 Figure 5.2 : Map Showing Plant Site & Seismic Zones .of India ................................................82 Figure 5.3 : Contour Map of Study Area ....................................................................................83 Figure 5.4 DEM of Study Area ..................................................................................................84 Figure 5.5 Drainage Map of Study Area ....................................................................................85 Figure 5.6: Windrose Diagram of IMD Varanasi (Summer Season) ...........................................90 Figure 5.7 : Photographs of Ambient Air Quality Monitoring .....................................................94 Figure 5.9 Land use/ Land Cover Map of Study Area .............................................................. 101 Figure 5.12 : Location of Turtle Sanctuary and Other Environment Features .......................... 113 Figure 5.13: Turtle Breeding Center Sarnath ........................................................................... 116 Figure 8.1: Institutional Framework ......................................................................................... 195 Figure 8.2: Grievance Redressal Cell ...................................................................................... 201
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 6
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
1.1. Introduction
IWAI, mandated to develop the inland water transportation system in country has proposed a
project “Capacity Augmentation of the Nation Waterway 1 (1620 kms, with minimum water
depth of 2.5-3 m) between Haldia and Allahabad”. National Waterway 1(NW 1) has the
potential to develop into a most economic, reliable, safe and environmentally friendly form of
transport.
Under this project, IWAI has proposed to develop a multimodal inland water terminal at
Ramnagar, on river Ganga in Varanasi district in Uttar Pradesh. This terminal will provide the
berthing facility for ships and loading and unloading facility for the goods. The construction and
operation of this facility will have associated social and environmental impacts, requiring
effective mitigation measures for its elimination and minimization. Thus, a detailed
environmental& social impact assessment study has been carried out for assessing the impacts
associated with development and operation of the proposed terminal. EIA report covers in detail
the environmental and social aspects of the proposed terminal during both
construction/development and operation stage. IWAI has appointed EQMS-IRG-ABNAKI
Consortium to carry out the detailed environmental impact assessment study for proposed
multimodal inland water terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi.
1.2. Project Background
IWAI has planned to develop a multimodal terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P. As per
planning, this terminal will be connected to rest of the city vide roads and railways both. An
access road will be developed to connect the terminal with national highway 7. Internal road of
12 m width will be developed within the terminal to facilitate smooth movement. Terminal will
also be connected to the DFC corridor from Mugalsarai to Bhaupur (under planning of DFCCIL).
The terminal will be developed in phases. At present phase 1A is being progressed. In the
phase 1A the terminal shall handle about 4,000 to 5,000 Tonne per day which is expected to
grow to 3.5 MTPA by 2018. Material to be handled will be coal, cement, stone chips, and
fertilizer and food grains.
1.3. Project Description
The proposed project site falls in Ramnagar Municipal Board of Varanasi district. The proposed
terminal is along Ramanagar Bridge, which is approximately 700 m from National Highway -7.
Ganga River flows in the West direction and a stream called Gurha Nallah flows into the river
and surrounds the site in East and South direction. Project is surrounded by open land. Location
map of the project site is given below in Figure 1.1.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 7
Figure 1.1: Location map of Terminal Site at Ramnagar
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 8
1.4. Connectivity, Surroundings & Sensitivity of the
Project Site
At present, proposed project site is accessible through existing kachha road, which connects to
NH-7 through village road (pakka). For transportation of men and material during construction
phase, a temporary access road of 600 m is proposed to be used. In future, an approach road
will connect the site to NH-7 for which land measuring 0.592 ha will be acquired. Nearest
railway station in Jeonathpur which is at 4.0 kms distance from terminal site in SE direction.
Connectivity will be made from proposed terminal to existing IR track and proposed DFC track
in future. Nearest airport is Lal Bahadur Shastri Airport located at a distance of app. 30 km in
NW direction.
Site is not a part of any forest land or any eco-sensitive/notified area. Project site is surrounded
by open land. No forest land, national park, migratory route of birds is present within 10 km
radius of terminal site. Kashi Turtle Sanctuary is located in downstream direction from terminal
site and is located at 2.3 km towards in North direction from terminal site. Ramnagar fort is
located at distance of 2.0 km from terminal site in north direction.
1.5. Project Activities and Area Statement
Proposed development
Proposed Terminal site for phase 1A covers an area of app. 5.685 ha. It was a private land,
which has been acquired by IWAI by paying compensation to land owners as per the law of
land. Facilities proposed at the site are 2 nos of berths for the cargo (100 m wide each), loading
& unloading bay, passenger jetty, Electrical sub-station (ESS), power back up and sanitation
facility.
Stone pitching works
Stone pitching works shall be carried out at the site to protect the riverbank from current &
waves. The stone pitching works shall protect a length of 200m behind the jetty. Stability of the
slopes shall be carried out in accordance with the Indian standards & guidelines.
Buildings
The following buildings described in Table 1.1 shall be constructed as part of Phase 1A:
Table 1.1: Details of building to be constructed
S. No.
Building Type Total Built up Area (Sqm)
1. Substation Building Single Storied Building 400 sqm
2. Toilet Block Single Storied Building 30 sqm
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 9
Pontoons
A steel pontoon deck of the size 20 m X 10 m shall be constructed at the location
Gangway
A gangway having walkway of 1.2 m width shall be provided to access the pontoon deck from
the shore.
Roads
Details of roads planned to be constructed are given below in Table 1.2. Any culverts required
at the crossing of the drains and drainage system shall be provided.
Table 1.2: Details of Roads
Road Type
Overall Width
Carriageway Width
Width of Paved
Shoulders on either side of
Carriageway
Width of Treated
Shoulders on either side of Carriageway
Approximate length
Type R1
22 m 7.5 m 1 m 1 m 650 m
Type R2
12m 5 m 0.75 m 0.75 m 365 m
1.6. Resources and Utilities Demand for Off-Site
Developments
Water supply
Water supply distribution system will be designed, installed and commissioned within the project
area including the supply of potable water to the buildings.
Power Requirement
Power requirement has been estimated to be 130 KV during construction phase. An Electrical
Sub-Station (ESS) and power back up system has been proposed for the terminal.
Construction Materials Sourcing
Construction material will be sourced from nearest authorized & licensed quarry and dealers
Drainage
During construction phase, temporary drainage and pumping facilities will be provided to keep
the adjoining areas of work site free from water logging and flooding. A drainage system for
carrying the storm water run-off from the port area will be designed and provided. The design
rainfall intensity shall be taken as 50 mm/hr for the purpose of design of drainage system at site.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 10
Design Vessel Sizes
The design vessel sizes range and characteristics to be considered for design of jetty is given in Table 1.3:
Table 1.3 Design Vessel Sizes
Jetty Type DWT LOA (m) Beam (m) Loaded Draft (m)
Multi Modal Jetty
Maximum Ship Size 2000 80 11 3.5
Minimum Ship Size 200 18 5 1.0
The design bed level at the Jetty shall be taken as +3.5 m.
Earthing and Lightning Protection System
The complete earthing system shall conform to the provisions of Indian Electricity Rules, and applicable code of practice for earthing IS: 3043. All non-conducting structures shall be provided with Lightning protection consisting of Air termination network at the top and down conductors as per IS:2309. All structures made of conducting material shall be protected by adequate earthing arrangements and air terminations at the top as per IS:2309. Conductors shall be Galvanized Iron (GI) of suitable size as per IS:2309. Buried lightning grid conductors of 75mm x 8mm size shall be provided for interconnection of the lightning earth pits around individual building. The same shall also be connected with the main plant earth grid at places through isolating link installed in Earth pits.
Lighting System
The nominal voltage of the distribution system shall be 3 phase 4 wire (415/240 ± 10% volts). All the equipment and materials shall be suitable for the system voltage. All materials and works shall comply with IS code of practices, Indian Electricity Rules and regulations. The lighting system of particular area whether indoor or outdoor shall be designed in such a way that uniform illumination is achieved. The type of lighting adopted shall provide adequate level of glare-free illumination, without creating undesirable shadows. Design of lighting layout shall be based on the minimum lighting intensities at the working plane and the type of luminaire specified in Table 1.4.
Table 1.4: Type of luminaires
Location Intensity of Illumination
Type of Luminaire
Substation/DG room/ Transformer Room / Pump House
200 Industrial type fluorescent fixture with SS reflector and 2x36 watt fluorescent lamp
High Mast 20 HPSV flood lighting fixtures on Raise /
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 11
lowering high mast.
As required -- Fully vermin and weather proof integral street light fixture with die cast aluminium housing and 1 x 70 / 150 W HPSV lamp with integral control gear
Luminaires
All luminaires shall be of industrial/decorative type as specified. The number of different type of luminaires and their wattages shall be minimum consistent with the lighting requirements. While using discharge lamps, stroboscopic effect shall be minimized by various methods. All fluorescent fittings shall be of rapid start type and shall be so arranged that the power factor will be 90% or higher. All luminaries alongwith its terminal boxes shall have IP56 degree of enclosure protection for internal areas and IP65 degree of enclosure protection for external areas and battery room.
Emergency Lighting
For safety and protection of personnel and for shutdown of the equipment, battery operated lighting units shall be installed as a part of fixed wiring system. Battery operated lighting unit shall consist of compact fluorescent lamps. Sealed batteries, fully automatic solid state charger, transfer switch to automatically transfer from main supply to the battery and vice versa, fuses etc. shall also form part of the supply. The charger shall be capable of recharging fully in 12 hours. The incandescent fixtures shall be mounted on the box containing batteries and battery charger. The unit shall operate on 1 Ph 240 V 50 Hz.
Green Belt Development
Green buffer should be developed all along the terminal site and also compensatory plantation should be carried out at least as per state forest policy. Tree planted should be of native type.
Waste Management
Provision of septic tank is proposed onsite. Municipal Solid waste will be disposed off in
designated dumping site of concerned Municipal body. Excavated earth, C&D waste will be
reutilized to the extent possible or disposed of in designated dumping site of concerned
municipal body/PWD.
1.7. Baseline and Social Environment
Baseline environmental data generation was carried out during the period from 1st April 2015 to
30th June 2015. Data has been generated by following the approved procedures of the Ministry
of Environment & Forests and climate change and the Central Pollution Control Board. Study
area of 10 km radial distance around the Terminal site has been considered for the EIA study.
Meteorology: Meteorological data for summer season has been collected from India
Meteorological Department - Varanasi. The predominant wind direction is from Northwest. The
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 12
average wind speed ranges from 1.8 to 5.0 kmph. Daily mean temperature varied from 22.1oC
to 40.4oC. The relative humidity varied from 25% to 51%. The annual rainfall is1000 mm.
Ambient Air Quality: - PM2.5, PM10, SO2, NO2 and CO levels were monitored at six locations in
the study area. Predominant downwind direction, population zone and location where maximum
GLC is anticipated have been selected for measurement. The 24-hour average PM2.5 level in the
study area vary from 20 to 58 µg/m3, PM10 level from 53 to 145 µg/m3, SO2 level from 13.4 to
35.6 μg/m3 and NO2 level from 17.4 to 46.8 μg/m3. Concentration of CO varied from 250 to 690
μg/m3. Overall, the ambient air quality of the study area is meeting the prescribed National
Ambient Air Quality Standard at all locations except Ramnagar location, where the RSPM
values are high in terms of NAAQS. This is mainly due to the heavy traffic load on SH-7 and
other commercial activities in Ramnagar
Ambient Noise Quality: - Noise quality has been monitored at eight locations within the study
area. The observed noise level (Leq) in all residential monitoring locations ranges from 43.5 dB
(A) to 48.8 dB (A) during day time and 40.2 dB (A) to 43.0 dB (A) during the night time. The
observed noise level (Leq) in Ramnagar locations (Commercial) is 64.5 dB (A) during day time
and 54.8 dB (A) during the night time. The noise levels in the study area were found to be within
the national standards for residential area (45 dBA during night time and 55 dBA during day
time,) and commercial area (55 dBA during night time and 65 dBA during day time,)
Water Quality: - Eight samples of ground water and three samples of surface water have been
collected from the study area. Surface water quality of the Ganga River in upstream and
downstream point of project site was found to meet the Best Designated Use – „C‟ Criteria of
CPCB (fit for drinking after conventional treatment). Surface water quality of Nala is not meeting
any of the category of Best Designated Use – „C‟ Criteria of CPCB.
The pH value of ground water samples at all locations varies from 7.17 – 7.50 and are within
permissible limit. The conductivity values were found to be in the range of 462 – 1012
μmhos/cm. The chloride level was found to vary from 7 – 168mg/l; within permissible limit. The
total hardness values were found to vary from 152 – 420 mg/l; within permissible limit. Calcium
and Magnesium values were within the permissible limit. Zinc and Fe levels were found to be
within the permissible limit. All the parameters in ground water sample were well within the
permissible limit prescribed in Indian Standard IS: 10500-2012.
Hydrography: The water levels with reference to the India Naval Hydrographic Chart Datum
are given in Table 1.5 below
Table 1.5: Water level of River Ganga
High Water Level RL +73.90 m
Low Water Level RL +58.22 m
Current: The currents in the river are significant and vary season to season.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 13
Topographic Information: The study area, forms a part of Ganga river basin. The city of
Varanasi is located in the middle Ganges valley of North India, in the Eastern part of the state of
Uttar Pradesh, along the left crescent-shaped bank of the River Ganges. The river system
consists of the mighty Ganga highly revered by Hindus since ages. Varuna, Assi, Banganga,
Chandra Prabha and Karmnasa are tributaries of the Ganga, that drain the area. Being located
in the Indo-Gangetic Plains of North India, the land is very fertile because low level floods in the
Ganges continually replenish the soil. The topography survey of terminal site indicated that the
ground levels in the site broadly vary from RL +74.0 to RL +77.0 m.
Soil Quality: - Soil samples from surrounding agriculture fields were collected for analysis. pH
of the soil samples ranges from 6.9 to 7.7 indicating the soils are neutral to slightly alkaline in
nature. Texturally, the soils of study area are observed as Sandy Loam, & Clay Loam Soils. The
organic Carbon content of soil ranges from 0.44 to 0.52 % (as 0.76 to 0.90% Organic Matter),
thereby implying that soils are medium in organic content. Available Nitrogen content in the
surface soils ranges between 193.4 to 262.8-kg/ha. Available Phosphorus content ranges
between 11.5 & 16.2-kg/ha. Available potassium content in these soils ranges between168.8 to
245.7-kg/ha. Overall the soil of the study area is moderately fertile.
Land use: As per the land use based on satellite image about 57.87% of the land is under
cultivation. About 29.85% of the land is under settlement, about 6.2% land is under water bodies
and rest of the land is under other uses. Wheat, paddy, jowar and maize cultivation is done in
most of the agriculture land. Other crops grown in nearby villages are pulses, vegetables,
coriander, chilly and fruits.
Geology: Throughout Varanasi, the geological setting is quite similar: near surface are sandy
lenses surrounded by clay-silty deposits. This sandy lenses form the shallow aquifers (25-40 m
depth below surface, Shukla et al., 2008) with unconfined condition, which is the main water
supply of most part of the city. The lateral length of these lenses can be up to some 1000 m.
Below the clay-silty layer lie fine-coarse sand deposits, which represent the deeper aquifer (60-
70 m depth below surface, Shukla et al., 2008).
Seismicity: The proposed terminal site falls in Zone –III, which fall in moderate risk zone.
Contour Map: The contours in Toposheet have been digitized in the GIS environment and
assigned the respective elevation values in meters with reference to the mean sea level. Using
the SRTM (Shuttle Radar Topography Mission) data, the elevation values has been verified.
The range of elevation of this area varies from 55 – 95 m.
Biological Environment: The proposed site is devoid of any major plantation. Some agriculture
activities were taken up by nearby villagers within the land in the past but these activities have
been discontinued now. Now the land is categorized as fallow land. There are about 12 small
trees of Khajur (Phoenix sylvestris) and 8 trees of Babool shrubs (Acacia spp.) are present in
the identified land.
The access road to connect site crosses through the Ralhupur village. This road is pucca upto
the Ralhupur village. About 700 m stretch that connect terminal site to Rahlupur village need to
be some leveling and widening. Trees of Jamun, Peepal, Babul and Sisham etc are present
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 14
along this road. Houses and shops also exist along the access road. The access road (700 m
stretch that have to develop) is almost clear, only one or two trees of Jamun, is present along
the road alignment that may require to be removed. One big tree also requires some chopping
for clearing the passes. No significant flora or fauna was observed during the site visit except
nilgai wee spotted during site visit.
1.8. Environment and Social Impacts of the Proposed
Project
Impacts associated with construction phase of phase 1A are only discussed here. Impacts
during operation phase will be discussed in EIA study of phase 1B. No major impacts are
anticipated due to the project. Impacts are majorly anticipated on air quality, noise levels and
aquatic flora & fauna. Mitigation measures are proposed according to the magnitude and
significance of impact. Impacts can be reduced/minimized by adopting these mitigation measure
while implementation of project.
1.9. Environmental Management Plan
The Environmental Management Plan (EMP) is the synthesis of all proposed mitigation and
monitoring measures, set to a time frame with specific responsibility assigned and follow-up
actions defined. EMP is a plan of actions for avoidance, mitigation and management of the
negative impacts of the project. Environmental enhancement is also an important component of
EMP. A detailed set of mitigation measures have been compiled in view of the likely impacts
associated with the proposed phase 1A of the project.
Considering all the impacts identified for construction phase of terminal 1A, during the EIA
study, mitigation measures are proposed to prevent pollution. Impacts associated with operation
phase are not discussed here as the project will not be operationalized after construction of
phase 1A and same will be discussed in EIA study of phase 1B. Detailed EMP is given below in
table 1.6.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 15
Table 1.6: Environment Management Plan
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
1. Climate
1. Project is
unlikely to
cause
negative
effect on
climate.
However,
project can
contribute
positively for
climate
Avoid cutting any tree standing on the proposed terminal site or temporary accesses area of 600m length.
Prior permission shall be taken for cutting any tree.
Compensatory tree planation shall be carried out for any tree cut (as per state forest policy)
Addition plantation of local variety of tree ( 200 no one row of tree on three side of the terminal land) shall be carried out along boundary of the terminal site
Forest Conservation Act, 1980
Access road area and proposed terminal area
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Compensatory /Additional Plantation ( @ Rs 500 per tree for 200 tree) ) Rs 100000
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC1
2. Natural Hazard
2. Earthquake-
Seismic
Zone III i.e.,
Moderate
Adoption of Relevant IS codes while designing the civil structures to sustain the earthquake of moderate to high magnitude.
Applicable BIS Standards
Project area
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
1 It is proposed to set up Social and Environmental Management Unit (SEMU) in IWAI to manager social and environmental aspect of NW1 augmentation. PMC
( Project Management Consultants) anticipated to be appointed for project management and quality check.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 16
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
damage risk
zone2
3. Site Preparation : Access road, Construction Camp, Construction Site
3. Improvement
of Access
road :
pavement of
the road,
Disposal of
accumulated
Improvement of Access Road:
Access road route and alignment (for unpaved area) shall be finalized and submitted to PMC and IWAI for their concurrence.
Tree shall not be cut. Alignment shall be suitable adjusted to avoid cutting of the tree. If unavoidable,
Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000,
Social Impact Assessment
Juncture of Access road and Entrance phase 1A terminal site
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
2IS:1893 (Part 1): 2002 Indian Standard Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures Part 1 General Provisions and Buildings Fifth Revision divides
the Indian subcontinent into five seismic zones ( II to V) depending on the magnitude and damage intensity of seismic activity.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 17
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Municipal
Solid Waste3
: Loss of
Agricultural
land, loss of
tree, air and
noise
pollution
than tree shall be cut with due permission from concerned district/forests authorities.
Trimming of the large tree standing close to the site shall be done as minimum as possible.
Provision shall be made for dust suppression during its use.
Provision shall be made (safety boards, speed control, traffic guards) to prevent accident.
Survival rate of tree shall be regularly monitored. It is shall be minimum 70%.
Municipal Solid Waste Management :
requirements
3 Substantial municipal solid waste is disposed at the entrance and around the proposed terminal site requiring proper management of the same.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 18
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Arrangement shall be made for identifying the area for disposal of construction debris and notify to IWAI. The site should be minimum 1000 m distance from the river bank, residential area and sensitive areas like hospitals, school and temples.
Arrangement shall be made for segregation of waste generated from construction site into recyclable, compostable and non-compostable waste.
Resalable/recyclable waste shall be sold off to authorized agencies. Compostable waste will be composted in pits at site and non-compostable waste shall be disposed off to designated landfill site. If designated landfill site not available, then debris disposal site shall be identified
4. Setting of
Labor Camps
: Loss of
agriculture
land,
contaminatio
Location of Camp:
Agriculture land should not be used for development of construction labour camps. Barren/waste land should be used
Site identified by contractor should
The Building and Other Construction workers (Regulation of Employment
Labour Camp Locations
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Approximate Rs 500,000/- per camp for sanitation
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 19
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
n of land and
water
resources
from
municipal
waste from
Camps,
worker‟s
health,
Pressure on
natural
resources
due to
establishmen
t of labour
camps
be approved by the engineers of PMC/IWAI
Proper closure, stabilization and rehabilitation of the area should be carried out as soon as the activity is completed
No land should be used for above purpose without consent of land owner. Sanitation and Worker’s Health :
Camp shall be well ventilated. It should have adequate provision for illumination, kitchen and safe drinking water facility shall be provided at the camp
Adequate bathing and sanitation facilities to be provided at labour camp. Mobile Toilets shall be provided. Soak Pits can be provided only if labour camp is located away from river.
Proper drainage to be maintained around the sites to avoid water logging leading to disease
Preventive medical care to be provided to workers- six monthly medical check-up should be
and Conditions of Service) Act 1996 and Cess Act of 1996 and The Water (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and amendments thereof. Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000
an health facilities.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 20
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
organized
Waste will be collected & segregated within site into recyclable, compostable and inert waste. Recyclable waste will be sold off to authorized dealers. Compostable waste shall be pit composted and inert waste shall be sent for disposal to landfill or site identified for debris disposal.
Provision shall be made for essential material supply like cooking fuel ( only LPG gas should be used, open burning of fuel should not be allowed)
Provision shall be made for day crèche for children
5. Setting up
construction
Camp:
Concert Mix
Plant, Hot
Mix Plant,
Mechanical
Workshop,
Fuel
storages,
All these facilities shall be installed at proposed terminal site itself. In case these are to be set up away from site than these shall be located at minimum distance of 500 m from habitation, water bodies and 1000 m from forest areas.
All maintenance facilities, hot mix plant and concrete missing plant shall be established with prior consent to establish to be obtained
Air (Prevention and Control of Water Pollution) Act, 1981 and Water (Prevention and Control of Water Pollution) Act, 1972
Site construction Camp
During design and Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Approximate Rs 500,000/- per camp for sanitation an health facilities.
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 21
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Lubricant
storages
from SPCB.
All such equipment/plant shall be fitted with air pollution control system and shall comply with condition of consent to establish.
Periodic monitoring shall be carried as per consent conditions.
4. Site Preparation : Power supply, Water Supply, Drainage and disposal of muck and debris
6. Power supply
and Energy
Conservation
: Air Pollution
, energy loss
Power shall be sourced from national/state grid. DG sets shall be used only during power failure.
Back-up power shall be set up with all provisions of containment for fuel leakages, air pollution control (stack height as per regulation), and with acoustic enclosure.
Solar energy shall be used in common lighting area on 1:2 basis.
Buildings designed should have green infrastructure. Measures should be taken to conserve energy as per ECBC norms as applicable.
Energy Conservation Building Code 2007
Construction Sites, Access road, and Labour Camp Locations
During design, Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
7. Water
Supply,
Drainage and
effluent
discharge
The Area is under safe category as per Central Ground Water Board. However, necessary permission shall be taken from district authorities as applicable before digging the bore well.
Central Ground Water Board, Local regulations.
Construction Sites, and Labour Camp Locations
Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Approx. Rs 300,000 for construction of
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 22
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Staff and visitors should be made aware about water conservation by displaying posters and signage
Garland storm water temporary drains shall be developed around the site to prevent any direct discharge of contaminated or soiled water to river. It shall be pass through di-siltation chamber and water collection pit. Collected water shall be used for construction purposes.
All washing and maintenance effluent from the workshop area of vehicle maintenance area should darin to separate collection areas fitted with oil and grease trap and de- siltation chamber. The treated water shall be used for dust suppression and green belt development. This water shall not be discharged to river at all.
grease traps and de-siltation chambers
8. Disposal of
piling earth,
muck and
debris:
uncontrolled
Provision shall be made for collection and draining of water for the piling earth. It shall be used for embankment protection or road construction depending on its
Terminal area River Bank along the terminal
Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 23
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
disposal may
leads to
increased
sedimentatio
n of the river.
suitability.
Provision shall be made for geo Synthetic Screen for arresting silt flowing down stream.
site
5. Embankment Design and Construction, Drainage Pattern and Fishermen’s Access to River.
9. River Bank
Erosion
Protection:
Construction
of
Embankment
and
construction
of jetty : may
lead to
accumulation
of sediments
on the updrift
side and
erosion of
the downdrift
side .
Contaminatio
n of river
Embankment protection measures (stone pitching) shall be made in both upstream and downstream to the extent that erosion is minimized.
Erosion monitoring shall be carried out periodically downstream as well.
River Bed material shall be tested for contaminants before its use or disposal for land fill site. If any level of heavy metal contamination is found than it shall be disposed off in a secure manner.
River Bank along the terminal site
During design, Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 24
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
water quality
and land may
happen due
to river bed
material
10. Drainage
Pattern
Natural Drainage pattern of area around shall be maintained. No waste shall be allowed to dumped to industrial effluent Nala flowing adjacent to the terminal site. Its opening to river shall not be obstructed in any manner.
Construction Sites, Access road, and Labour Camp Locations
Pre-Construction Stage and construction stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
11. Access to
river :
restricted
movement of
fisherman4
Fishing activities are seen in the river close to site. Arrangement shall be made to provide free access to river and undisturbed safe movement of the fishermen.
Terminal site and area around
Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
4 Fishing activities are seen. Local fisherman are seen fishing close to river areas. They access the river from small temporary access around the site.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 25
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
6. Construction Material Sourcing
12. Borrow areas
for sourcing
earth for
filling as
required
(erosion, loss
of productive
land, land
degradation,
air pollution)
Non-productive lands, barren lands, raised lands; wastelands shall be used for borrowing earth with the necessary permissions/consents.
Agricultural areas not to be used as borrow areas unless requested by the landowner for lowering the land for making it cultivable.
Excavation depth should not exceed 1.5 m bgl
Environmental Clearance from State Environmental Impact Assessment Authority and required permission from District Magistrate shall be obtained prior to excavation. Copy of this permission shall be submitted to IWAI before start of excavation.
Record of location, area, accessibility to the location and photograph of borrow area should be maintained prior to excavation
Site selected for borrow area should be approved by PMC & IWAI expert prior to excavation
IRC Guidelines on borrow areas and for quarries. EIA Notification 2006( under Environmental Protection Act and Rules, 1986; )
All Identified Borrow sites
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 26
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Ridges of not less than 8m width will be left at intervals not exceeding 300m. Small drains will be cut through the ridges, if necessary, to facilitate drainage.
The slope of the edges will be maintained not steeper than 1:4 (vertical: Horizontal).
Topsoil to be stockpiled and protected for use at the rehabilitation stage.
Rehabilitation shall be satisfactorily undertaken immediately after the use has ceased and at least three weeks prior to monsoon.
Unpaved surfaces used for the haulage of borrow materials to be maintained.
Transportation of earth materials shall be through covered vehicles.
Quarries for sourcing stone and aggregates (loss of productive land, land degradation, air pollution. Any
Aggregates required for embankment stone pitching and roads shall be procured from licensed quarries.
It shall be ensures that selected quarries are having requisite environment clearance, and comply with Air Pollution Control
EIA Notification 2006( under Environmental Protection Act and Rules, 1986; )
Quarry Site
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 27
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
illegal quarrying may lead to land use change, unstable rock formation)
and Noise level requirements as per the law.
Copy of Environmental Clearance letter and Consent to Operate and shall Be obtained and submitted to IWAI.
Material shall be transported under covered trucks only.
No new quarry shall be opened without due permissions.
Each Quarry shall be visited prior to its selection to ensure its compliance with lease conditions, EC and consent conditions.
Stone crushers, if required, shall be set up only after consent from SPCB and taking adequate measures for air pollution control
7. Protection of Flora and Fauna
13. Protection of
Tortoise :
Increased
sedimentatio
n
downstream
of
construction
Turtle Sanctuary is located at about 2.3 Km from site.
No movement of tortoise is reported upward to the site. No harm shall be caused to these tortoises in case any tortoise is sited. Necessary caution notice shall be displaced and conveyed to all construction workers and
Wild Life ( Protection ) Act, 1972
In and Around Project Site
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project costs
SEMU through DFO
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 28
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
site officers.
Geo-Textile synthetic sheet curtain shall be placed around pilling and construction area to prevent movement of sediments and construction waste.
14. Terrestrial
Fauna:
increase in
hunt
tendency5
Caution sign shall be placed to prevent hunting of wild animal and birds.
Provision shall be made for strict penalty for hunting these animals.
High noise construction work shall not be made in night.
Wild Life ( Protection ) Act, 1972
In and Around Project Site
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project costs
Contractor
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
15. Vegetation loss due to site preparation and construction activities
Tree shall not be cut as much as possible. Any tree cut shall be compensated with compensatory tree plantation as per state forest policy.
Tree plantation shall be made as feasible at site and around the site
Forest Conservation Act, 1980
In and Around Project Site and labour camp
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
5Peacock and Wild Neel Gai are sited next to project site.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 29
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
depending on land availability.
Provision of LPG shall be made in construction site camp and labour camp as fuel source to avoid tree cutting.
Proper arrangement of lighting should be made at site and construction labour camp
Open burning of fuel for any purpose should not be allowed at the site
16. Effect on
Aquatic life
such as Fish,
Plankton6
No breeding ground is noticed around the project site. However, construction activity shall be restricted during spawning period of June to August.
Sedimentation and siltation shall be prevented/ controlled to maintain productivity of aquatic ecosystem and ensure availability of food for aquatic fauna & flora.
Terminal construction site
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
8. Air Quality
17. Fugitive Dust
Generation
due to
Transport of loose and fine materials through covered vehicles.
Loading and unloading of
Environmental Protection Act, 1986 and
Construction sites, Loading
During the Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
6The floodplain fisheries are dominated by major and minor carps viz, Labio rohita, Catla catla, Cirrhinus mrigala, L. bata, Puntius sps. and catfishes viz. H.
fossilis, Mystus sps, etc. and fishes of family Clupeidae, Notopteridae and a mix of many other families.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 30
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
construction
activities
construction materials in covered area.
Approach roads shall be paved and widened.
Water spraying on earthworks, unpaved haulage roads, other dust prone areas and construction yard.
Make Provision of PPEs like face mask to workers.
amendments thereof; The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 and amendments thereof
areas, storage areas,
18. Exhaust gas
emissions
from
machinery and
vehicular
traffic.
Regular maintenance shall be carried out of machinery and equipment.
Periodic Ambient air quality monitoring shall be carried out.
DG sets to be fitted with stacks of adequate height and low sulphur diesel to be used in DG sets as well as in machineries.
Monitoring of air quality for PM10, PM2.5, SOx, NOx, and CO shall be carried out quarterly at construction site. Stack monitoring shall be carried out every month at the site.
Environmental Protection Act, 1986 and amendments thereof; The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 and amendments thereof
Construction camps and sites, concrete mixing plant, DG sets locations
During the Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
19. Emissions at
access road :
Efforts shall be made to move construction material early morning and late evening period.
-do- Access road
During the Construction stage
- Do - Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 31
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
avoidance of
traffic Jams7
Traffic regulators ( Guard) shall be posted in habitat area and at key junction areas to avoid congestion
9. Noise and Vibration
20. Noise from
construction
vehicle,
equipment
and
machinery.
All equipment to be timely serviced and properly maintained to minimize its operational noise.
Construction equipment and machinery to be fitted with silencers and maintained properly.
Provision of temporary noise barrier near habitat areas during construction phase.
Protection devices (ear plugs or ear muffs) will be provided to the workers operating in the vicinity of high noise generating machines.
Speed control shall be enforced in habitat areas.
Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 and amendments thereof
Construction Site and accesses road.
During the Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
7 The roads connecting the proposed sites is narrow and also passes through habitat area. Traffic remains heavy.
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 32
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
The ambient noise level as per CPCB standard is 55 dB(A) and 45 db(A). Current noise level at habitat area meets the standard
Noise monitoring day and night at site, labour camp and access road area shall be carried quarterly to ensure the effectiveness of mitigation measures.
10. Land-use and Landscape
21. Land use
Change and
Loss of
productive/top
soil
Efforts shall be made to improve the aesthetic of the area. No construction waste or other wastes shall be dumped at unidentified areas. Caution board in local language shall be placed at different locations to prevent dumping of waste generated from construction site in the river and nearby areas
Compensatory tree plantation for loss of trees.
Top soil shall be preserved and laid over either on the embankment slope for growing vegetation to protect soil erosion or spread over in the proposed plantation areas.
Design requirement
Around project site area and borrow area
During construction Stage
Approximately Rs 25000 for five caution boards @ Rs 5000 per board
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 33
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Land earmarked for dumping of construction waste shall be free from any social and R&R issue and away from settlements.
22. Soil erosion
due to
construction
activities,
earthwork
Provision of cross drainage
structure shall be made in the
access road if required to maintain
the natural drainage pattern.
Provision of side drain shall be made in access road if required to prevent water logging.
Measures like building of scouring protection structures, protection by geo-textiles matting etc shall be made, if river bank erosion is found around the terminal area.
Bio-turfing of embankments shall be made enhance the slop stabilization.
Access road and river bank
Construction stage
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
23. Soil erosion
at earth
stockpiles
The earth stockpiles to be provided with gentle slopes to prevent soil erosion.
At earth stockpiles
Construction stage
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
24. Compaction
and
contamination
of soil due to
movement of
Fuel and lubricants to be stored at the predefined storage location.
Storage area shall be paved with gentle slope to a corner and connected with a chamber to collect
Terminal site
Pre construction and construction stage.
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 34
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
vehicles and
equipment
any spills of the oils.
Provision of “oil interceptors” at wash-down and re-fuelling areas.
Oil and grease spill and oil soaked materials are to be collected and stored in labelled containers (Labelled: WASTE OIL; and hazardous sign be displayed) and sold off to SPCB/ MoEF authorized vendors.
Movement of construction vehicles, machinery and equipment shall be restricted to the designated haulage route.
11. Water Resources
25. Depletion of
Groundwater
resources due
to unregulated
abstraction for
construction
purpose
Preference shall be given to source water from rivers wherever feasible in the project area with due permission from authorities.
Augmentation through incorporating water harvesting structures if technically feasible.
Construction of check dams in consultation with community to reduce burden on ground water resources.
Efforts to restrict water intensive activities during summer period
During
Constructio
n stage
Part of
project
costs
Contractor, IWAI/SEMU/PMC
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 35
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
(April, May, June)
26. Increase in
water Siltation
levels due to
construction of
terminal and
contamination
due to
disposal of
domestic
waste
The piling work shall be undertaken during low flow period.
Restoration of changes in the stream, if any, made during construction to its original level.
Precautions shall be made that no nala or canal is clogged.
Substructure construction should be limited to the dry season and cofferdams may be constructed and utilized to lift the spoil directly out of it and carried to the riverbank for land disposal.
Mobiel toilets with anaerobic digestion facility shall be fixed at construction site. No domestic waste shall be discharged to river.
Terminal
Site
During
Constructio
n stage
Part of
project
costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
12. Accident and Safety Risks
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 36
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
27. Accident risk
from
construction
activities
Contractors to adopt and maintain safe working practices.
Usage of fluorescent signage, in local language at the construction sites
Training shall be provided to workers, especially machinery operators, on safety procedures and precautions.
The contractors to appoint a safety officer mandatory.
At every work place, a readily available first aid unit including an adequate supply of dressing materials, a mode of transport (ambulance), nursing staff, and doctor to be provided.
Required PPE shall be provided to workers.
Half yearly medical check-up shall be carried of the workers and summary report shall be submitted to PMC
Central Motor
and Vehicle
Act 1988
EP Act 1986
Noise Rules 2002
Construction sites
Construction period
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
13. Shifting of Common Property Resources and other Utilities
DRAFT
EIA Report-Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 37
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Shifting of community properties and utilities
As per assessment no such shifting is involved. However, if any shifting is involved it shall done at suitable location with the concurrence from local authorities and community.
Project Area
Pre- Construction
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 38
1.10 Environment Monitoring Plan
A comprehensive monitoring plan has been prepared and described below in Table 1.7.
The objective of environmental monitoring during the construction and operation phases
is to compare the monitored data against the baseline condition collected during the
study period to assess the effectiveness of the mitigation measures and the protection of
the ambient environment based on national standards.
A monitoring schedule has also been prepared based on the environmental components
that may be affected during the construction phase of the project. Environmental
monitoring plan for operation stage will be discussed in EIA study to be carried out for
phase 1B of terminal.
Table 1.7: Environment Monitoring Plan
S. No.
Aspect Parameters to be monitored
No of sampling locations & frequency
Standard methods for smapling and analysis
Role & Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Construction Period
1. Air Quality (Ambient & Stack)
PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NO2,HC and CO
Four Sites including project site and 3 other sites within 2 km of terminal site Once in a month
Fine Particulate Samplers for PM2.5
Respirable Dust Sampler fitted PM10
Respirable Dust Sampler fitted withGaseous sampling arrangements forSO2 and NO2, CO analyser /portable CO meterfor COportable HC meter or tubes for HC;TO-14A, TO-15, USEPA method for sampling and analysis of VOCs in ambient air
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 39
2. Surface Water Quality
Physical, chemical and biological
River Ganga & Gurha Nallah Once a month
Grab sampling and analysis by using standard methods
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
3. Drinking water Quality
Physical, chemical and biological
Drinking water fro labour camps Once a month
Grab sampling and analysis by using standard methods
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
4. Noise Level
Day time and night time noise level (max, min & Leq levels)
Construction labour camp, construction siteand 2 locations within 2 km of terminal site Once a month
Noise meter Contractor
IWAI & PMC
5. Soil Quality
Soil texture, type, Electricalconductivity, pH, infiltration, porosity, etc.,
Construction site, labour camps and debris disposal site Once in 6 months
Collection and analysis of samples asper IS 2720
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
6. Soild & Hazardous Waste Management
Physical & Chemical characteristics
Construction site, labour camps and debris disposal site Daily
MSW Rules, 2000, Hazardous Waste & Management Rules, 2008
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
7. Wastewater Management
Physical, chemical and biological
Construction site & labour camps Once a month
-- Contractor
IWAI & PMC
8. Plantation Plantation survival rate
At plantation site (terminal site & afforestation site)
Survey, counting, recording & reporting
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 40
9. Soil Erosion
--- Upstream & downstream of terminal site
Survey & observation; Extent and degree of erosion; Structures for controlling soil erosion
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
10. Aquatic ecology
Phytoplankton, Zooplankton
River Ganga & Gurha Nallah Once a month
Plankton net of diameter of 0.35 m, No.25 mesh size 63 and analysis byusing standard methods.
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
11. Integrity of embankment
--- Upstream & downstream of terminal site
Survey & observation; Extent and degree of erosion; Structures for controlling soil erosion
Contractor
IWAI & PMC
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 41
2. INTRODUCTION
2.1. Prelude
The Inland Waterways Authority of India (IWAI) came into existence on 27th October
1986 for development and regulation of inland waterways for shipping and navigation.
The Authority primarily undertakes projects for development and maintenance of Inland
water transport (IWT) infrastructure on national waterways through grant received from
Ministry of Shipping. The head office of the Authority is at Noida. The Authority also has
its regional offices at Patna, Kolkata, Guwahati and Kochi and sub-offices at Allahabad,
Varanasi, Bhaglapur, Farakka, Hemnagar, Dibrugarh (Assam), Kollam, Chennai and
Vijayawada(A.P.).
Five waterways have been declared by IWAI for facilitating inland water transportation
and are listed below:
NW-1 -The Ganga (Haldia to Allahabad-1620 km)
NW-2- The Brahmaputra (Dhubri to Sadiya-891 km)
NW-3 The West Coast Canal (Kottampuram to Kollam with Udyogmandal and Champakara canals- 205 km)
NW-4- The Kakinda-Puducherry stretch of Canals with Godavari & Krishna Rivers (1078 km)
NW-5-The East CoastCanal with Brahami Rivet and Mahanadi Delta (588 km)
IWAI, to improve the inland water transportation system in country has proposed a
project “Capacity Augmentation of the Nation Waterway 1 (1620 kms, with
minimum water depth of 2.5-3 m) between Haldia and Allahabad”. National
Waterway 1 has the potential to form the most economic, reliable, safe and
environmentally friendly form of transport. Map showing national waterway 1 is given
below in figure 2.1.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 42
Figure 2.1 : Google Map Showing the Alignment of NW-1
Under this project, IWAI for improvement of navigation facilities has proposed to develop
a multimodal inland water terminal at Varanasi. This terminal will provide the berthing
facility for ship and loading and unloading facility for the goods. Each of this kind of
facility under this project will have associated social and environmental impacts,
requiring effective mitigation measures for its elimination and minimization. Thus a
detailed environmental social impact assessment study is carried out for assessing the
impacts associated with development and operation of the proposed terminal. EIA report
covers in detail the environmental and social aspects of the proposed terminal during
both construction/development stage and operation stage.
2.2. Project Background
IWAI has planned to develop a multimodal terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P. As per
planning, this terminal will be connected to rest of the city vide roads and railways both.
An access road will be developed to connect the terminal with national highway 7.
Internal road of 12 m width will be developed within the terminal to facilitate smooth
movement. Terminal will also be connected to the DFC corridor from Mugalsarai to
Bhaupur (under planning of DFCCIL). The terminal will be developed in phases. At
present phase 1A is being progressed. In the phase 1A the terminal shall handle
about 4,000 to 5,000T per day which is expected to grow to 3.5 MTPA by 2018. Material
to be handled will be coal, cement, stone chips, and fertilizer and food grains.
IWAI has appointed EQMS-IRG-ABNAKI Consortium to carry out the detailed
environmental impact assessment study for proposed multimodal inland water terminal
at Ramnagar, Varanasi.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 43
2.3. Project Brief
Multimodal Inland water terminal is proposed to be located at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P
along River Ganga. The terminal is proposed with the ambit to enhance the navigational
facility for NW-1 under project “Capacity Augmentation of the Nation Waterway 1 (1620
kms, with minimum water depth of 2.5-3 m) between Haldia and Allahabad”
The proposed project site falls in Ramnagar Municipal Board of Varanasi district. The
proposed terminal is along Ramanagar Bridge which is approximately 700 m from
National Highway -7. Terminal site for phase 1A covers area of app. 5.685 ha.
GangaRiver flows in the West direction and a stream called Gurha Nallah flows into the
river and surrounds the site in East and South direction. Project is surrounded by open
land. Geographical coordinates for the project is given in Table 2.1 below. Map showing
location of proposed terminal is given in Figure 2.2 & 2.3.
Table 2.1: Geographical Coordinates of Project Site
Point Longitude Latitude A 25°15'12.80"N 83° 1'49.33"E
B 25°15'13.99"N 83° 1'51.68"E
C 25°15'13.70"N 83° 1'56.68"E
D 25°15'7.90"N 83° 1'55.45"E
E 25°15'4.58"N 83° 1'57.32"E
F 25°15'3.38"N 83° 1'57.34"E
G 25°15'3.13"N 83° 1'53.82"E
H 25°15'1.59"N 83° 1'54.14"E
I 25°15'0.90"N 83° 1'51.59"E
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 44
Figure 2.2: Google Map Showing Site Location
At present, proposed project site is accessible through existing kachha road which
connects to NH-7 through village road (pakka). In future (later phases) an approach road
from the site will be developed which will be directly connected to NH-7 for which land
measuring 0.592 ha will be required to acquire. Nearest railway station in Jeonathpur
which is at 4.0 kms distance from terminal site in SE direction. Connectivity will be made
from terminal to connect to existing IR track and proposed DFC track in future at
Jeonathpur in later phases. Nearest airport is Lal Bahadur Shastri Airport at distance of
app. 30 km in NW direction. There are 2 fixed terminals at Farkka and Pakur, low & high
level jetty at Patna, GR jetty in Kolkata and 18 floating terminals enroute NW-1.
Facilities proposed at the site are 2 nos of berths for the cargo (100 m wide each),
loading & unloading bay, passenger jetty, Electrical sub-station (ESS), power back up
and sanitation facility.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 45
Figure 2.3: Location Map of Varanasi Terminal
2.4. Need for the Proposed Project
Inland Water Transport (IWT) offers a cost effective, environment friendly and fuel
efficient mode, especially for bulk cargo, hazardous goods and over dimensional cargo –
so vital for industrial development. Also as per report issued by European Conference of
ministry of transport (ECMT), social cost of air pollution, noise pollution, land coverage,
construction/maintenance and accidents for water transport is least when compared to
road and rail transport. Water transport has no or least impact in noise pollution,
accidents and land coverage.
Till middle of 20thcentury, IWT had been used as an important mode of transportation in
various parts of the country. However the IWT in an organized manner is significantly
seen today only in a few areas e.g. Goa, Assam, West Bengal and Mumbai, apart from
Ganga, Brahmaputra and Champakara and Udyogmandal canals. It is however,
heartening that transportation of goods by IWT mode in these regions has been steadily
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 46
increasing and has gone up to 70.00 million tonne (4.755 btkm) in 2011-12 from the level
of 32.48 million tonne (1.63 btkm) in 2003-04.
Inland Water Transport (IWT) on NW-1 has the potential to form the most economic,
reliable, safe and environmentally friendly form of transport. Where developed for use by
modern inland water-way vessels operating on dependable rights of way, it can reduce
investment needs in rail and road infrastructure, promote greater complementarities in
the economic strategies the riparian states, enhance intra-regional trade and, through
increased economies of scale, significantly reduce transport costs for the benefit of the
entire economy and India‟s global trade competitiveness.
With increase in potential interest of shippers for transporting material including coal, fly-
ash, food grains, cement, stone chips, and edible oil via NW-1, there is an urgent need
for operationalizing the entire NW-1 stretch to meet this demand. At present, several
power companies have initiated action for setting up Thermal Power projects and
extensive movement of Over Dimensional Cargo (ODC), imported coal for NTPC
projects is planned to be done on NW-1 during the next 4 - 5 years.
With the objective of improving the navigation and navigation facility at NW-1, IWAI has
proposed project “Capacity Augmentation of the Nation Waterway 1 (1620 kms, with
minimum water depth of 2.5-3 m) between Haldia and Allahabad”. This will
significantly reduce transportation cost for shippers, reduces congestion and accidents
on highways and provide savings in carbon emissions for traffic on NW-1.
Permanent Multimodal Inland Water Terminal Project at Ramnagar, Varanasi is
proposed under this project and is proposed with an ambit to improve navigation facility
and infrastructure in NW-1. This multi-modal terminal will connect the major highways,
i.e. NH-7 & 2 and DFC track and will facilitate the transportation of goods in cost-
effective and green manner. Due to land constraints, terminal will be developed in
phases. At present 5.685 ha of land has been acquired thus phase 1A of the terminal is
being progressed.
2.5. Need of Study
The proposed multimodal inland water terminal project is highly beneficial and will
significantly contribute to the internal trade in the country. Rivers connects the major
ports to the hinterlands and facilitates the transportation of goods all across the country.
But the terminal project has associated environmental and social impacts requiring
effective mitigation measures for elimination and minimization. Thus a detailed
environment social impact assessment study has been carried out for the project to
assess the impacts of the project in the design stage so that adequate mitigation
measures can be proposed and implemented during the construction and operation
phase to ensure environmental and socially sound implementation of the project.
The project is being developed with financial aid of World Bank. Thus the EIA study has
been carried out in accordance with the operational policies of World Bank, Environment
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 47
Impact Assessment Guidance Manual on Ports and Harbours and Guidelines of MoEF
for carrying out EIA studies from time to time.
As per the World Bank Policy O.P.4.01, development of the terminal is classified as
„Category A‟ project which requires a detailed environment assessment study prior
development of zone to identify the potential threats of project to environment and to
frame mitigation and environment management plan to reduce the negative impact of
the project.
2.6. Scope and Methodology of the Study
For the purpose of environmental assessment, area within 10 km radial zone of the
proposed project have been studied and classified as Study Area. Following
methodology has been adopted for the EIA study:
Collection of primary and secondary baseline information
Analysis of project component and its activities with respect to environmental
aspects
Public consultation to identify their concern and acceptance to the project
Analysis of Alternatives
Impact assessment and identification of mitigation measures for elimination, or
minimisation of impacts
Assessment of institutional aspects, and development of Environmental
Management and Monitoring Plan.
Identification of sources of pollution during construction and operation phases of
the project at the proposed site
Identification of utilisation of resources obtained during construction and
operation phases of the project
Assessment of extent of pollution and resource utilisation in the proposed area
Recommend measures to optimise resource utilisation
Develop an environmental monitoring plan to ensure effective implementation of
the environmental management plan
2.7. Limitation of the Study
The present EIA Report has been prepared based on the Primary field investigations /
assessment, and secondary data from data collected from Inland Waterways Authority of
India, Uttar Pradesh Pollution Control Board, Indian Meteorological Department,
Banaras Hindu University, Public Works Department (PMGSY Department), Ganga
Pollution Unit, Kashi Turtle Sanctuary, Varanasi Development Authority, Sarnath Turtle
Research Institute, UP Jal Nigam, Public Health & Engineering Department, Jalkal
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 48
Vibhag, Irrigation Department, U.P., Collectorate, Statistic Department, Forest
Department and published journals, and books, public consultation and site
observations.
The environmental and social assessment is based on the information collected from the
various Agencies, community consultations and observations. Professional judgement
and subjective interpretation of facts and observations has been applied for the
preparation of the EIA Report. Since the project is under planning stage, final plans for
terminal, road and railway connectivity is under process.
2.8. Structure of the Report
The EIA report contains project features, baseline environmental conditions, assessment
of environmental impacts, and formulation of mitigation measures along with
environmental management and monitoring plan.
The report includes the following chapters:
Chapter 1: Executive Summary
The executive summary gives the synopsis of the EIA Report.
Chapter 2: Introduction
This chapter provides background information of the project proponent, need for the EIA
study as per prevailing legislation, Location and brief description of the project,
methodology adopted for EIA study and structure of the report.
Chapter 3: Legislative, regulation and policy consideration
This chapter deals with the details of the potential legal, administrative, planning and
policy framework which have been referred in the preparation of the EIA Report.
Chapter 4: Project Description
This chapter deals with the details of the proposed EZ such as location, connectivity,
project requirements, Infrastructure development, environmental consideration, project
cost, implementation schedule, etc.
Chapter 5: Environmental and Social Baseline
This Chapter describes the baseline environmental conditions around the project site for
various environmental attributes, viz. physical, biological and socio-economic, within the
10 km radial zone, which is termed as the study area. Topography, soil, water,
meteorology, air, noise, and land constitute the physical environment, whereas flora and
fauna constitute the biological environment. Demographic details and occupational
pattern in the study area constitute socio-economic environment. Baseline
environmental conditions are based on the information collected from the various
agencies and the secondary data collected from published sources.
Chapter 6: Environmental Impacts
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 49
This chapter details the inferences drawn from the environmental impact assessment of
the proposed project. It describes the overall impacts of the project activities and
underscores the areas of concern, which need mitigation measures.
Chapter 7: Public Consultation and Disclosure Meeting
This Chapter provides an insight into the process & methodology followed for carrying
out the public consultation meetings in study area and proceedings of pubic
consultations
Chapter 8: Environmental Management Plan and Monitoring Indicators
This Chapter provides mitigation and control measures to attenuate and/or eliminate
environmental impacts, which are likely to be caused by the proposed project. An
Environmental Management Plan (EMP) has been developed to mitigate the potential
adverse impacts and to strengthen the beneficial impacts. This chapter also provides the
environmental monitoring plan proposed for the project.
2.9. References
List of secondary data used for carrying out EIA study and preparation of EIA report is
given at table 2.2.
Table 2.2: Reference Used for EIA Study
S. No. Reference
Government Departments
1. Inland Waterways Authority of India
2. Uttar Pradesh Pollution Control Board
3. Indian Meteorological Department
4. Banaras Hindu University
5. Public Works Department (PMGSY Department)
6. Ganga Pollution Unit
7. Kashi Turtle Sanctuary
8. Varanasi Development Authority
9. Sarnath Turtle Research Institute
10. UP Jal Nigam
11. Public Health & Engineering Department
12. Jalkal Vibhag
13. Irrigation Department, U.P.
14. Collectorate
15. Statistic Department
16. Forest Department
Journals & Books
1. Singh A, Department of Botany, BHU “Observation on the vascular wall flora of Banaras Hindu University Campus, India”``
2. Current status of River Ganges – October 2008
3. Socio- economic Status of fishers of ganga river – November 2009
4. Ecology status and production dynamics of wetlands of uttar Pradesh – May 2004
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 50
5. Ecodynamics and fishery status of upper stretch of river Yamuna and associated canals – September 2003
6. Fisheries of the Hooghly-Matlah estuarine system – An appraisal – Feb 1997
7. Health of inland aquatic resources and its impact on fisheries – Feb 2014
8. The ecology and fishery status of river Yamuna – Feb 2014
9. The status of river ganges in the middle stretch – Nov 2008
10. Present status of hilsa in Hooghly-bhagirathi river – June 2012
11. Assessment of Water Quality of River Ganga along Ghats in Varanasi City, U. P., India. International Journal of Earth Sciences and Engineering ISSN 0974-5904, Vol. 04, No. 04, August 2011, pp. 698-711, Tarence Thomas, Meenu Mishra, H. Thomas, Arun A. David, Ram Bharose and D. Venkat Reddy, School Of Forestry And Environment, Sam Higginbottom Institute Of Agriculture Technology & Sciences, (Formerly-Allahabad Agricultural Institute), Deemed-To-Be-University, Allahabad, 211 007, (U.P.), India
12. Department Of Applied Geology, Dr. H. S. G. Central University, Sagar, (M.P.) India
13. Department Of Civil Engineering, National Institute Of Technology, Surathkal (Nitk) Srinivasanagar-575025, Mangalore
Existing Studies
1. Forest Working Plan, Kashi Van Vibhagh
2. Turtle Conservation Plan, Kashi Van Vibhagh
Others
1. Site visits
2. Lab Analysis Report
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 51
3. LEGISLATIVE, REGULATION AND POLICY CONSIDERATION
3.1. Introduction
India has well defined institutional and legislative framework. The legislation covers all
components of environment viz. air, water, soil, terrestrial and aquatic flora and fauna,
natural resources, and sensitive habitats. India is also signatory to various international
conventions and protocols. The environmental legislations in India are framed to protect
the valued environmental components and comply with its commitment to international
community under various conventions and protocols. World Bank has also defined its
Environmental and Social Safeguard Operational Policies. This assessment is about the
applicability of above laws and regulations, conventions, protocols, and safeguards for
guidance purposes only. These applicability‟s should be re-confirmed from concerned
government agencies and concerned legal counsel.
The applicability of legislation to the navigational channel (waterway) improvement will
be assessed under separate EIA being carried out for waterways and NW-1 as a whole.
3.1.1. Overview of Indian Environmental Legislation and Administrative
Framework
The Government of India has framed various laws and regulations for protection and
conservation of natural environment. The legislations are broadly divided under following
categories.
Environmental Protection
Forests Conservation
Wild Life Protection
The umbrella legislation under each of above category is highlighted below:
The Environment (Protection) Act 1986 was enacted with the objective of providing for the protection and improvement of the environment. It empowers the Central Government to establish authorities charged with the mandate of preventing environmental pollution in all its forms and to tackle specific environmental problems that are peculiar to different parts of the country. Various rules are framed under this Act for grant of environmental clearance for any developmental project, resources conservation and waste management.
The Forest Conservation Act 1980 was enacted to help conserve the country's forests. It strictly restricts and regulates the de-reservation of forests or use of forest land for
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 52
non-forest purposes without the prior approval of Central Government. To this end the Act lays down the pre-requisites for the diversion of forest land for non-forest purposes.
Wild Life (Protection) Act 1972 amended 2003 was enacted with the objective of effectively protecting the wild life of this country and to control poaching, smuggling and illegal trade in wildlife and its derivatives. It defines rules for the protection of wild life and ecologically important protected areas.
The MoEF and the pollution control boards (CPCB - Central Pollution Control Board and
SPCBs - State Pollution Control Boards) together form the regulatory and administrative
core of the part. Other Ministries/Statutory Bodies/Departments responsible for ensuring
environmental compliance and granting various clearances includes state ministry /dept.
of environment, regional offices of MoEF and state forests/wildlife departments.
3.1.2. Applicable Environmental Legislation
As per the nature of the project, screening has been done to identify the legislations
applicable to the project. Legislations applicable to the project are further divided into the
legislations framed by Govt. of India and Regulations applicable for vessels plying in
inland waterways framed by IWAI and Ministry of Shipping, GoI. Regulations of Govt. of
India applicable to the project are given in Table 3.1 and legislations framed for vessels
plying in inland waterways framed by IWAI and Ministry of Shipping, GoI are given in
Table 3.2 below.
Table 3.1: Summary of Environmental and Other Legislation with Applicability Screening
Name Key Requirement
Applicability Type of permit and stage of applicability
Administrative Authority and indicative time frame for grant of permission
Responsibility
Environmental Protection Legislations
Environment Protection Act-1986 and Rules there under including EIA Notification 14th Sep 2006 and amendment till date
To protect and improve overall environment. Requires prior environmental clearance for new, modernization and expansion projects listed in schedule 1 of EIA Notification, 2006
Considered Applicable for certain activities like borrowing of earth if required (EIA Notification 2006 does not classify terminals on river or dredging in the river as a project requiring environmental clearance. The applicability of this legislation
Environment Clearance Construction stage for EC for borrowing earth
MoEF& CC & SEIAA/SEAC
Contractor for obtaining environmental clearances as applicable. Contractor shall also be responsible for EMP implementation and compliance to environmental clearance conditions.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 53
shall be re-confirm from the concerned authority).
Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981, 1987
An act to prevent and control Air pollution
Applicable. The applicability is due to emission from operation of construction equipment like batching plants, hot mix plants, DG sets, and similarly, during operation stage backup power generation, material handling related aspects.
Consent to Establish & Consent to Operate
SPCB Contractor, for setting up terminal, batching plant, hot-mix plant as prior to its establishment from SPCB CTO shall be taken by contractor for batching plant, hot-mix plant & quarry site as required prior to operation and it should be renewed before the expiry of permit. Contractor shall also obtain CTO for terminal site before its handover.
Water Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, 1988
An act to prevent and control water pollution.
Applicable. It is applicable for the projects having potential to generate effluent during any stage of the project. Effluents are expected to be generated during both the construction and operation phase of the project.
Consent to Establish & Consent to Operate
State Pollution Control Boards
CTE should be taken by contractor for disposal of sewage and construction of septic tank/soak pit prior to start of construction from SPCB CTE/CTO for terminal site shall also be obtained by Contractor along with CTE / CTO under Air
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 54
Act.
Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control Act) 2000 and amendment till date
Ambient Noise Standards for different areas and zones
Applicable due to generation of noise during construction and operation stage.
No permits issued under this act
SPCB & CPCB Contractor and IWAI to ensure compliance to Ambient Noise Level Standards.
Hazardous Wastes (Management Handling and Trans-boundary) Rules, 2008 .
Protection to general public against improper handling storage and disposal of hazardous waste. The rules prescribe the management requirement of hazardous wastes from its generation to final disposal.
Applicable. Project has potential to generate hazardous waste (Waste Oil) during both construction and operation phase.
Authorization for storage and handling hazardous waste
SPCB & MoEF& CC
Contractor shall obtain authorization for handling, storage and disposal of hazardous waste (Waste Oil) along with CTE/CTO under air and water act.
MSIHC Rules, 1989 Usage and storage of hazardous material
Applicable only for storage of highly inflammable liquids like HSD/LPG
No specific permit is required, however precautions defined under the material safety datasheets shall be followed. Safety audit and other requirements shall have to be complied if storage quantity exceeds the threshold limit
Chief Controller of Explosives, MoEFCC & DC
Contractor and IWAI
The Bio Medical Waste (Management and Handling rules)
To control storage, transportation
Applicable for the disposal of bio-medical waste
No specific permit is required.
Disposal through authorized
Contractor and IWAI
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 55
1998 and disposal of Bio Medical Waste.
from first aid centers and dispensaries
Just comply with the handling and disposal requirements of the rule
disposal agency
The Batteries (Management and Handling) Rules 2001
To regulate the disposal and recycling of lead acid batteries
Applicable for disposal of used led acid battery if likely to be used in any equipment during construction and operation stage.
No specific registration required. Compulsion to buy and sale through registered vendor only.
MoEF&CC
Contractor and IWAI
Coastal Zone Management Act 2011
To regulate development activities within the 500m of high tide line in coastal zone and 100 m of tidal influence rivers.
Not applicable CRZ Clearance
State Coastal Zone Management Authority and MoEF&CC
Not Applicable
Forest Conservation and Wildlife Protection Legislation
The Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980 and amendments The Forest (conversion) Rules 1981 and amendments till date
To protect forest by restricting conversion of forested areas into non- forested areas and deforestation
Not Applicable. No forest land is being diverted. No tree cutting is anticipated either. However, if any tree is required to be cut for access road than NOC from forest department is required.
Forest Clearance / Permission for tree cutting.
Forest Department, MoEFCC
NOC shall be obtained from forest department prior tree cutting if any involved by IWAI. Compensatory plantation shall be carried out in minimum ratio as per state forest policy. NOC shall be obtained by contractor.
Biological Diversity Act, 2002
conservation of biological diversity, sustainable use of its components
Not Applicable
No permit issued under this Act.
National Biodiversity Authority and State Biodiversity Board
NA
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 56
and fair and equitable sharing of the benefits arising out of the use of biological resources, knowledge and for matters connected therewith or incidental thereto
Wild Life Protection Act, 1972, 1993
To protect wildlife through notifying National Parks and Sanctuaries and buffer areas around these zones
Not Applicable though Kashi Turtle Sanctuary is located at 2.3 km d/s of the terminal site. However, as per the Guideline from MoEF&CC (Wildlife Division) dated 15th March 2011 this is not considered applicable as this project does not required environment clearance.
Wild life clearance
Chief Conservator Wildlife, Wildlife Wing, Forest Department, MoEFCC
Considered Not applicable
Safety and Other Related Legislations
Chemical Accidents
(Emergency
Planning,
Preparedness and
Response) Rules,
1996
Requirement
of preparation
of on-site and
off-site
Disaster
Management
Plans for
accident-
prone areas.
Not Applicable.
The project does
not involve
handling of any
hazardous
chemical during
both construction
and operation
phase which may
lead to
continuous,
intermittent or
repeated
exposure to
No permits
issued under
this act
Central, State
& District Crisis
Group
Not Applicable
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 57
death, or injury.
Public Liability and
Insurance Act 1991
Protection
from liability
arising due to
accidents from
handling of
hazardous
chemicals.
Not Applicable.
The project does
not involve
storage of any
chemicals (HSD)
beyond the
threshold limit
during
construction and
No permits
issued under
this act.
Owner of
project shall
take out
insurance
policies
providing for
contracts of
insurance so
as he is
insured
against
liability to
give relief,
before
handling any
such
hazardous
material
Collector of the
Area
Not applicable
Explosive Act 1884 &
Explosive Rules,
2008
Safe
transportation,
storage and
use of
explosive
material
Not Applicable
as no explosive
(as described in
act & rules) shall
be used in the
construction and
operation stage
of the project.
Permission
for storage
and usage of
explosive
Chief Controller
of Explosives
Not applicable
Petroleum Rules,
2002
Use and
Storage of
Petroleum
products
Applicable as
storage of
HSD/LPG or any
other petroleum
product may be
required for the
project purpose
License to
store
petroleum
beyond
prescribed
quantity.
Chief Controller
of
Explosives/DC
Contractor /
IWAI
Central Motor Vehicle Act 1988 and amendment
To minimize
the road
accidents,
Applicable, for all
the vehicles at
site during
No permit
issued under
this Act
Motor Vehicle
Department
(Licensing
Contractor to
follow Rules for
all the
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 58
Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989 and amendments till date
penalizing the
guilty,
provision of
compensation
to victim and
family and
check
vehicular air
and noise
pollution.
construction &
operation phase
authority,
registration
authority &
State Transport
Authorities)
construction
vehicles being
used at site
during
construction
purpose.
IWAI shall
follow the rules
for all its
vehicles at site
during
operation
phase and
should also
monitor that
loading &
unloading
vehicles also
comply with
these rules
The Gas Cylinder
Rules 2004
To regulate
the storage of
gas /
possession of
gas cylinder
more than the
exempted
quantity
Applicable if
contractor store
more than the
exempted
quantity of gas
cylinder.
License to
store gas
cylinder
more than
the regulated
quantity
Chief Controller
of explosives
Contractor
Ancient Monuments
and Archaeological
Sites and Remains
Act, 1958
Conservation of cultural and historical remains found in India. According to this Act, area within the radii of 100m and 300m from the “protected Property” are designated as “protected area” and
Not Applicable as
no notified ancient
monument is
located within 300
m of the project
site.
No objection
certificate
Archaeological
Dept. Gol,
Indian Heritage
Society and
Indian National
Trust for Art
and Culture
Heritage
(INTACH).
Not applicable
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 59
“controlled area” respectively. No development activity (including building, mining, excavating, blasting) is permitted in the “protected area” and development activities likely to damage the protected property is not permitted in the “controlled area” without prior permission of the Archaeological
Survey of
India (ASI).
Merchant Shipping
Act, 1958
To prevent
marine
pollution from
ships beyond
5 km of the
coastline and
to make the
transportation
safe.
Considered
Applicable as
these cargos are
also required to
register in India
under this act.
Registration
Certificate
National
Shipping Board
IWAI shall
ensure that all
the barges
plying in the
waterways are
complying with
the rule as
applicable
Guidelines for
evaluation of
proposals/requests
for ground water
abstraction for
drinking and
domestic purposes in
To regulate
extraction of
ground water
for drinking
and domestic
purpose
Applicable only if
bore well is done
for extracting
water for meeting
drinking/domestic
water needs of
terminal &
No objection
certificate
Central ground
Water
Authority/Board
& MoEFCC
Contractor/IWAI
shall obtain
NOC from
CGWA/CGWB
prior digging
any bore well
during
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 60
Notified areas and
Industry/Infrastructure
project proposals in
Non-notified areas,
2012
vessels construction &
operation
phase as
applicable.
Note: applicable social legislations are not listed here as these are covered under SIA
and RAP reports being prepared separately.
Table 3.2: Regulations Applicable on Vessels/Barges Plying in Inland Waterways (However, these will be applicable for operation stage only)
Name Key Requirement Applicability Administrative Authority
Prevention of Collision on national Waterways Regulations, 2002
Regard to precautions required by the ordinary practice of Seamen and limitation of the vessel
Applicable for development of the terminal at operation stage for all the vessel plying in National Waterway
IWAI
National Waterways, Safety of Navigation and Shipping Regulations, 2002
Ensuring safety of navigation and shipping on the national waterways
Applicable for development of the terminal at operation stage for all the vessel plying in National Waterway
IWAI
The National Waterway-1 Act, 1982
Provision for regulation and development of that river for purpose of shipping and navigation on the NW-1 and for the matters connected therewith or incidental thereto
Applicable for development of the terminal for operation stage for all the vessel plying in National Waterway
IWAI
New Inland Vessel Act, 2015 & Rules Under IV Act
Economical and safe transportation through inland waters
Applicable for development of the terminal for all the vessel plying in National Waterway
IWAI
3.2. International Best Practices & Guidelines
3.2.1. Operational Policies of World Bank
The project is being developed with the financial aid from World Bank. World Bank has
its operational policies, which safeguards the different environment and social
components. World Bank operational policies triggered for this project are listed in Table
3.3 below
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 61
Table 3.3: World Banks Operational Policies - Environmental & Social Safeguard
Name Key Requirement Applicability Remarks
OP 4.01 Environmental Assessment
Ensures sustainability and environmental feasibility of the project. Projects are classified into A, B & C category depending on the nature and extent of the impact.
Triggers Project classified as Category A considering nature of activities and impacts
OP 4.04 Natural habitats
Ensures conservation of natural habitats and discourages disturbance of nay natural habitat due to project development by recommending adoption of alternative method/route/approach or adopting management measures
Triggers Applicable for projects located in close vicinity to eco-sensitive zones like wildlife sanctuary, wetlands under Ramsar convention, national parks bird sanctuary, turtle breeding grounds etc. Kashi Turtle Sanctuary lies at 2.3 km at distance from d/s of the project site.
OP 4.36 Forests
Ensures that project activities does not disturbs/interfere with the forest, forest dwellers activities, fauna and flora of the forest. Prevents and discourages deforestation and impacts on rights of forest dependent people.
Triggers Neither diversion of forest land is involved nor any tree cutting is anticipated. However, tree cutting may be involved for access road. Permission will be required for felling any tree from forest department.
OP 4.12 Involuntary Resettlement
Ensures minimal involuntary resettlement by considering feasible alternatives project design, assisting displaced people to improve their former living standard.
Triggers Triggers for acquiring the private land.
OP 4.10 Indigenous people
Ensures protection of the dignity, right and cultural uniqueness of indigenous people and ensures they receive social and economic benefits
Not Triggers No indigenous group of people will be affected.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 62
OP 4.11 Physical Cultural Resources
Ensures preservation of property of cultural and religious importance, heritage and property of natural importance and enhancement of cultural properties
Not Triggers No property of Cultural and religious importance, heritage and property of natural importance located at project site and within 300m from project site. Ramnagar fort is located at a distance of more than 2km in north direction from terminal site.
World Bank‟s operational policy 4.01 (OP 4.01) categorize the project into Category A, B
& C on the basis of nature and extent of the impacts anticipated from the project. Scope
of Environmental assessment studies depends on the category in which the project falls
and is defined below.
Category A - Projects with significant environmental impacts and requiring a full
Environmental Assessment (EA),
Category B - Projects with moderate environmental impacts and requiring a lesser
level of environmental assessment,
Category C - Projects which require no environmental analysis.
Proposed Project involves development of the multimodal inland water terminal at River
Ganga at Ramnagar, Varanasi. Project development will impact both the environment
and social component. Components to be impacted due to project development are
quality of life, terrestrial and aquatic ecology, air quality, water quality, economy of the
country, noise levels etc. Thus the project is classified as Category A and a detailed
environment assessment study has been undertaken for the project.
3.2.2. Relevant International Environmental Convention
3.2.2.1. International Maritime Organization Conventions
India is member state of the International Maritime Organization (IMO). All the vessels
plying in marine environment are bound to follow these conventions. These conventions
are aimed at ensuring environmental protection and safety of seamen. These guidelines
shall also be followed by vessels/barges plying in inland water bodies to the extent
possible. IMO Conventions/ Protocols relevant to the project are given in Annexure 2.1.
Conventions which majorly are in environmental context include MARPOL Convention
1973/78 & Ballast Water Management, 2004.
MARPOL Convention, 1973/78
The MARPOL Convention, an international convention is responsible for the preventing
pollution of the marine environment by operational or accidental discharges from the
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 63
ships. It is a combination of two treaties adopted in 1973 and 1978 respectively and
updated by amendments through the years.
This international convention was adopted in 1973 at International Maritime Organization
(IMO) and covered pollution by oil, chemicals, and harmful substances in packaged
form, sewage and garbage. The Protocol of 1978 relating to the 1973 International
Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (1978 MARPOL Protocol) was
adopted at a Conference on Tanker Safety and Pollution Prevention in February 1978
held in response to a spate of tanker accidents in 1976-1977. Measures relating to
tanker design and operation were also incorporated into a Protocol of 1978 relating to
the 1974 Convention on the Safety of Life at Sea, 1974.
The MARPOL Convention includes regulations that are aimed at preventing and
minimizing pollution from ships - both accidental pollution and that from routine
operations – The convention currently includes six technical annexes delineate below:
Annex I: Regulations for the Prevention of Pollution by Oil
Annex II: Regulations for the Control of Pollution by Noxious Liquid Substances
in Bulk
Annex III: Prevention of Pollution by Harmful Substances Carried by Sea in
Packaged Form
Annex IV: Prevention of Pollution by Sewage from Ships
Annex V: Prevention of Pollution by Garbage from Ships
Annex VI: Prevention of Air Pollution from Ships (entry into force 19 May 2005)
Ballast Water Management, 2004
Under this heading, IMOs‟ setup “International Convention for the Control and
Management of Ship‟s Ballast Water and Sediments, 2004” for preventing the
introduction of unwanted organisms and pathogens from ship‟s ballast water and
sediment discharges. This is aimed to arrest the potentially devastating effects of the
spread of harmful aquatic organisms carried by ballast water. This convention will
require all ships to implement a Ballast Water Management Plan (BWMP) and
delineates the standards for the Ballast Water Exchange (BWE) and Ballast Water
Performance (BWP) under BWMP.
3.2.2.2. United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Montego Bay,
(1982):
This Convention was adopted by India on 10th December 1982 at Montego Bay,
Jamaica. Main objectives of the convention are:
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 64
• To set up a comprehensive new legal regime for the sea and oceans, as
far as environmental provisions are concerned, to establish material rules
concerning environmental standards as well as enforcement provisions
dealing with pollution of the marine environment; and
• To establish basic environmental protection principals and rules on global
and regional cooperation, technical assistance, monitoring, and
environmental assessment, and adoption and enforcement of
international rules and standards and national legislation with respect to
all sources of marine pollution.
Thus the convention can be referred to understand the environmental protection principals and
procedures to minimize the environmental pollution due to movement of vessels/barges and
related operations
3.2.2.3. International Maritime Dangerous Goods Code (IMDG-code)
The IMDG code relates to methods of safe transport of dangerous cargoes and related
activities. It sets out procedures for documentation, storage, segregation, packing,
marking and labelling of dangerous goods. This convention can also be referred to
understand the procedures followed by the vessels carrying the dangerous goods to
ensure safety and avoid spillage and accidents.
3.3. Environmental Standards & Guidelines
Project involves various activities, which may interfere with various environmental
components. Thus it is required to control those activities so as the concentration of
pollutant in environment shall not exceeds its assimilation capacity. CPCB has issued
some standards for disposal of effluents and quality of surface water body which should
be referred and adhered to with regards to prescribed discharge standards at any point
of time. India does not have any standard yet for disposal of dredged material, water
quality in and around harbour/ports/terminals, thus standards issued by other renowned
bodies are referred. Suggested list of standards are listed below and given in detail at
Annexure 2.2.
1. Standards for discharge of effluent in inland surface water bodies and Marine
Coastal Areas (Source: G.S.R 422 (E) dated 19.05.1993 and G.S.R 801 (E) dated
31.12.1993 issued under the provisions of E (P) Act 1986)
2. Classification of Surface water Bodies on basis of Quality (Source: Guidelines for
Water Quality Management-CPCB, 2008)
3. Water Quality Standards for Coastal Waters, SW-IV & V-Harbor and Navigation &
controlled waste disposal (EIA Guidance Manual for Ports & Harbours, MoEF, GoI)
4. Standards for permissible level of water quality indicators (Source: Assessment of
the Environment Impact of Port Development, United Nations, New York, 1992)
5. Permissible limit for off-shore dumping of dredged material (Source: Assessment of
the Environment Impact of Port Development, United Nations, New York, 1992)
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 65
6. Criteria for harmful bottom sediments (Source: Assessment of the Environment
Impact of Port Development, United Nations, New York, 1992)
7. Approximate Quantity of Suspended Sediments Generated by Dredging or Dumping
Operations (Source: Assessment of the Environment Impact of Port Development,
United Nations, New York, 1992).
3.3.1. Guideline, Standard and recommendations as published by
Environmental Committee of PIANC
PIANC- the World Association for Waterborne Transport Infrastructure is the forum
which provides expert advice on cost-effective, reliable and sustainable infrastructures to
facilitate the growth of waterborne transport. PIANC has published various guidelines for
ensuring the sustainable development of waterborne transport. Some of the guidelines
as applicable to the project are listed below. These guidelines can be referred to make
the Inland water transportation system sustainable and environmental friendly.
Dredging Management Practices for the Environment (WG 100-2009)
Dredging Material as a Resources (WG 104-2009)
Ecological and Engineering Guidelines for Wetland Restoration in relation
to the Development, Operation and Maintenance of Navigational
Infrastructure (WG 7-2003)
Management of Aquatic Disposal of dredged material (WG 1-1998)
Dredged Material Management Guide 1997.
Guidelines for sustainable Inland Waterways and Navigation WG 6-2003
.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 66
4. PROJECT DESCRIPTION
4.1. Introduction
This chapter describes project‟s location, layout, features of the project, its capacity and
details of cargo and other material handling capacity, estimated cost of the project
including cost of EMP, schedule for implementation, etc.
4.2. Location, Access and Layout of the Project
The proposed multimodal inland water terminal (stage 1) is located at Ramnagar,
Varanasi District, Uttar Pradesh. At present, proposed project site is accessible through
existing kachha road which connects to NH-7 through village road (pakka). For
transportation of men and material during construction phase, a temporary access road
of 600 m is proposed to be used. The proposed terminal will be developed in area of
5.685 ha (mention exact area) as a multimodal facility with road and rail network
connection. In future, an approach road will connect the site to NH-7 for which land
measuring 0.592 ha will be acquired. Internal road of 12 m width will be developed within
the terminal to facilitate smooth internal movement. Nearest railway station is
Jeonathpur which is at 4.0 kms distance from terminal site in SE direction. Connectivity
will be made from proposed terminal to existing IR track and proposed DFC track in
future.. Nearest airport is Lal Bahadur Shastri Airport located at a distance of app. 30 km
in NW direction.
Site is not a part of any forest land or any eco-sensitive/notified area. Project site is
surrounded by open land. No forest land, national park, migratory route of birds is
present within 10 km radius of terminal site. Kashi Turtle Sanctuary is located in
downstream direction from terminal site and is located at 2.3 km towards in North
direction from terminal site. Ramnagar fort is located at distance of 2.0 km from terminal
site in north direction.
The layout of the proposed terminal is given in figure 4.1 below. Plan of general
arrangement & schematic diagram of Jetty (Middle level) is given in figure 4.2 and figure
4.3 below.
Stone pitching works
Stone pitching works shall be carried out at the site to protect the river bank from current
& waves. A length of 200m behind the jetty shall be protected by the stone pitching
works. Stability of the slopes shall be carried out in accordance with the Indian standards
& guidelines. Details of stone pitching works is given in figure 4.4.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 67
4.3. Proposed Development
Facilities proposed at the site are 2 nos of berths for the cargo (100 m wide each),
loading & unloading bay, passenger jetty, Electrical sub-station (ESS), power back up
and sanitation facility.
Buildings
The following buildings cribbed ib Table 4.1 shall be constructed as part of Phase 1A:
Table 4.1: Details of building to be constructed
S. No.
Building Type Total Built up Area (Sqm)
1. Substation Building Single Storied Building 400 sqm
2. Toilet Block Single Storied Building 30 sqm
Pontoons
A steel pontoon deck of the size 20 m X 10 m shall be constructed at the location
Gangway
A gangway having walkway of 1.2 m width shall be provided to access the pontoon deck
from the shore.
Roads
Details of roads planned to be provided is given below in Table 4.2. Any culverts
required at the crossing of the drains and drainage system shall be provided.
Table 4.2: Details of Roads
Road Type
Overall Width
Carriageway Width
Width of Paved
Shoulders on either side of
Carriageway
Width of Treated
Shoulders on either side of Carriageway
Approximate length
Type R1
22 m 7.5 m 1 m 1 m 650 m
Type R2
12m 5 m 0.75 m 0.75 m 365 m
Resources and Utilities Demand for Off-Site Developments
Water supply
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 68
Water supply distribution system will be designed, installed and commissioned within the
project area including the supply of potable water to the buildings.
Power Requirement
Power requirement has been estimated to be 130 KV during construction phase. An
Electrical Sub-Station (ESS) and power back up system has been proposed for the
terminal.
Construction Materials Sourcing
Construction material will be sourced from nearest authorized & licensed quarry and
dealers
Drainage
During construction phase, temporary drainage and pumping facilities will be provided to
keep the adjoining areas of work site free from water logging and flooding. A drainage
system for carrying the storm water run-off from the port area will be designed and
provided. The design rainfall intensity shall be taken as 50 mm/hr for the purpose of
design of drainage system at site.
Design Vessel Sizes
The design vessel sizes range and characteristics to be considered for design of jetty is given in Table 4.3.:
Table 4.3 : Design Vessel Sizes
Jetty Type DWT LOA (m) Beam (m) Loaded Draft (m)
Multi Modal Jetty
Maximum Ship Size 2000 80 11 3.5
Minimum Ship Size 200 18 5 1.0
The design bed level at the Jetty shall be taken as +3.5 m.
Earthing and Lightning Protection System
The complete earthing system shall conform to the provisions of Indian Electricity Rules, and applicable code of practice for earthing IS: 3043. All non-conducting structures shall be provided with Lightning protection consisting of Air termination network at the top and down conductors as per IS:2309. All structures made of conducting material shall be protected by adequate earthing arrangements and air terminations at the top as per IS:2309. Conductors shall be Galvanized Iron (GI) of suitable size as per IS:2309. Buried lightning grid conductors of 75mm x 8mm size shall be provided for interconnection of the lightning earth pits around individual building. The same shall also be connected with the main plant earth grid at places through isolating link installed in Earth pits.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 69
Lighting System
The nominal voltage of the distribution system shall be 3 phase 4 wire (415/240 ± 10% volts). All the equipment and materials shall be suitable for the system voltage. All materials and works shall comply with IS code of practices, Indian Electricity Rules and regulations. The lighting system of particular area whether indoor or outdoor shall be designed in such a way that uniform illumination is achieved. The type of lighting adopted shall provide adequate level of glare-free illumination, without creating undesirable shadows. Design of lighting layout shall be based on the minimum lighting intensities at the working plane and the type of luminaire specified in Table 4.4..
Table 4.4: Type of luminaires
Location Intensity of Illumination
Type of Luminaire
Substation/DG room/ Transformer Room / Pump House
200 Industrial type fluorescent fixture with SS reflector and 2x36 watt fluorescent lamp
High Mast 20 HPSV flood lighting fixtures on Raise / lowering high mast.
As required -- Fully vermin and weather proof integral street light fixture with die cast aluminium housing and 1 x 70 / 150 W HPSV lamp with integral control gear
Luminaires
All luminaires shall be of industrial/decorative type as specified. The number of different type of luminaires and their wattages shall be minimum consistent with the lighting requirements. While using discharge lamps, stroboscopic effect shall be minimized by various methods. All fluorescent fittings shall be of rapid start type and shall be so arranged that the power factor will be 90% or higher. All luminaries alongwith its terminal boxes shall have IP56 degree of enclosure protection for internal areas and IP65 degree of enclosure protection for external areas and battery room.
Emergency Lighting
For safety and protection of personnel and for shutdown of the equipment, battery operated lighting units shall be installed as a part of fixed wiring system. Battery operated lighting unit shall consist of compact fluorescent lamps. Sealed batteries, fully automatic solid state charger, transfer switch to automatically transfer from main supply to the battery and vice versa, fuses etc. shall also form part of the supply. The charger shall be capable of recharging fully in 12 hours. The incandescent fixtures shall be mounted on the box containing batteries and battery charger. The unit shall operate on 1 Ph 240 V 50 Hz.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 70
Greenbelt Development
Green buffer should be developed all along the terminal site and also compensatory plantation should be carried out as per state forest policy. Tree planted should be of
native type.
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 71
Figure 4.1: Layout of Ramnagar Terminal, Stage 1
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 72
Figure 4.2: general arrangement of Jetty (Middle level), Ramnagar
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 73
Figure 4.3: Typical section of jetty, Ramnagar
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 74
Figure 4.4: Details of stone pitching works
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 75
4.4 Capacity and features of the project
The terminal (Stage 1) is projected to handle projected cargo as 3.5 MTPA till 2018, and 18.7 MTPA in 2038. Dead Weight Tonnage
(DWT) is estimated be 2000 MT The cargo will mostly comprise coal, building materials, agriculture inputs, food grains and flour,
Edible oil, Local Handloom Silk products and Over-Dimensional Cargo. The details of type of commodity, volume estimated
preliminary growth projections, preliminary Turnover Volume per day and required storage capacity in 2038 is given in table 4.1
Table 4.1: Type of commodity, volume estimated preliminary growth projections, preliminary Turnover Volume per day and required storage capacity
Commodit
y
Prese
nt
Volu
me
(lakh
tonne
s/yea
r)
Direction
Incomi
ng /
Outgoi
ng
Preliminary Projection of the
Percentage Diverted to IWT in 2018
Preliminary
Growth Projection
for 2028
Preliminary Growth
Projection for 2038
Preliminary
Turnover Volume
per day
Required Storage
Capacity in 2038
mini
mum
in %
minim
um in
lakh
tons/y
ear
maxim
um in
%
maxim
um in
lakh
tons/ye
ar
minim
um in
lakh
tons/y
ear
maximu
m in
lakh
tons/yea
r
minimum
in lakh
tons/year
maximum
in lakh
tons/year
minimu
m in
tons
maximu
m in
tons
minimu
m in
tons
maxim
um in
tons
Coal days 1
Coal
(domestic)
8
.4
upstream incomin
g
30 2.5 70 5.9 3.4 11.6 4.6 22.8 1247.0 6233.9 1247.0 6233.9
Coal
Imported
24.0
Building
Materials
days 20.0
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 76
Cement
Bags
0
.9
upstream
(predomin
antly) /
downstrea
m
outgoin
g
30 0.3 60 0.5 0.4 1.1 0.5 2.1 133.6 572.5 2672.1 11450.
0
Cement
Bags
2
.3
downstrea
m
outgoin
g
30 0.7 60 1.4 0.9 2.7 1.2 5.3 341.4 1463.1 6828.6 29261.
2
Stone
Chips
17 downstrea
m
outgoin
g
30 5.1 40 6.8 6.9 13.4 9.2 26.3 2523.6 7209.3 50472.1 144185
.5
Sand 1.8 downstrea
m
outgoin
g
40 0.7 60 1.1 1.0 2.1 1.3 4.2 356.3 1145.0 7125.5 22900.
1
Agricultur
al Inputs
days 30.0
Fertilizer 1
2.0
upstream incomin
g
20 2.4 50 6.0 3.2 11.8 4.3 23.2 1187.6 6361.1 35627.4 190833
.8
Fertilizer down
stream
23.2
Food
grains and
flour
days 20.0
Wheat
bagged
4
.2
upstream outgoin
g
20 0.8 50 2.1 1.1 4.1 1.5 8.1 415.7 2226.4 8313.1 44527.
9
Rice
bagged
3
.3
upstream outgoin
g
20 0.7 50 1.7 0.9 3.2 1.2 6.4 326.6 1749.3 6531.7 34986.
2
EIA Report- Phase 1A of Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 77
Flour
bagged
1
.8
upstream
(predomin
antly) /
downstrea
m
outgoin
g
20 0.4 60 1.1 0.5 2.1 0.7 4.2 178.1 1145.0 3562.7 22900.
1
Flour
bagged
6
.6
downstrea
m
outgoin
g
20 1.3 60 4.0 1.8 7.8 2.4 15.3 653.2 4198.3 13063.4 83966.
9
Edible Oil days 1.0
Crude
Vegetable
Oil
5
.4
upstream incomin
g
100 5.4 100 5.4 7.3 10.6 9.8 20.9 2672.1 5725.0 2672.1 5725.0
Local
Handloom
Silk
products
days 1.0
Varanasi
Sarees
1
.0
downstrea
m
outgoin
g
0 0.0 0 0.0 0.5 0.5 0.7 1.0 184.1 269.5 184.1 269.5
Varanasi
Carpets
1
.3
downstrea
m
outgoin
g
0 0.0 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.5 0.5 137.0 137.0 137.0 137.0
Over-
Dimension
al Cargo
days 1.0
ODC 0
.004
upstream incomin
g
100 0.004 100 0.004 0.005 0.008 0.007 0.015 2.0 4.2 2.0 4.2
Totals 66.00
4
20.284 35.874 27.76 71.0695
88
37.80712 187.5046 10358.11 38439.6
26
138512.6
2
597381
.09
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 78
In the phase 1A, the terminal shall handle about 4,000 to 5,000T per day which is expected to
grow to 3.5 MTPA by 2018. Material to be handled will be coal, cement, stone chips, and
fertilizer and food grains”.
4.5 Material handling and other Facilities
The project provides for loading & unloading bay, passenger jetty. The terminal will have 2
berths of 200 metres. Mobile cranes and oil tankers for edible oil are proposed. The terminal in
Stage -1 will not have provisions of stack yard for storage of goods, vessel repair/maintenance
facility, workshop for material handling and fuel supply.
An Electrical Sub-Station (ESS), power back up and sanitation facility are proposed. Power
requirement is estimated to be 130 KV in construction phase.
To prevent bank erosion, embankment protection all along the length of the terminal will also be
made through stone pitching measures.
The access to the site will be developed under phase 1 B connecting national highway 7. For
transportation of men and material during construction phase, a temporary access road of 600
m is proposed to be used.
4.7 Waste management
Provision of septic tank is proposed onsite. Excavated earth, C&D waste will be reutilized to the
extent possible or disposed of in designated dumping site of concerned municipal body/PWD or
the site identified for debris disposal. Waste generated will be segregated into recyclable,
compostable and inert waste. Recyclable waste will be sold off to authorized dealer,
compostable waste will be composted within the site and inert waste will be sent for disposal in
designated dumping site of concerned municipal body/PWD or the site identified for debris
disposal.
4.8 Other features
About 100 people are estimated to be employed in the project. Estimated project cost will be
about 206 crores. Construction is estimated to be completed in 3 years in EPC mode. No cutting
or filling is proposed on the site. Construction materials will be procured from local markets,
stone quarries, etc. 100 trucks are estimated to be deployed. Provision for tubewell has been
made.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 79
5. : DESCRIPTION OF THE ENVIRONMENT
(EVIRONMENT AND SOCIAL BASELINE)
5.1. Prelude
The environmental status around the proposed project site is analyzed for valued environmental
components viz., air, water, land, noise, soil, ecology and socio-economic in a 10 km radius
around the proposed project site. The baseline provides the basis for assessment of impact
(likely changes in the baseline conditions) described in Chapter 6.
The baseline environmental quality has been collected during the month of June 2015 within the
10 km radius of the proposed terminal site. The present EIA Report has been prepared based
on the primary field investigations / assessment, and secondary data collected from different
department and published in journals, books, public consultations and site observations. Data
on meteorology, air quality, water quality and soil quality has been refers from secondary
sources (Indian Meteorological Department, UPPCB, CPCB publications and other sources).
Map showing environment-monitoring locations are provided in Figure 5.1.
Figure 5.1: Map Showing Environmental Monitoring Locations
Terminal Site
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 80
5.2. Site Description and Its Environs
The study area within a 10 KM radius around the proposed Terminal site has been considered
for baseline and impact assessment. The project activity areas are considered as core area and
remaining study area as buffer zone. Environment setting of 10 km radius area around terminal
site is given in Figure 5.1. Environmental profile of area is provided in Table 5.1.
Table 5.1: Environmental Setting Items Features within 10 km radius
Location Near Ralhupr village, Ramnagar, Varanasi
Connectivity National Highway (NH-2 about 380 m, North)
State Highway (NH-7 about 700 m, East)
Co-ordinates (Terminal Sites)
Corner Latitude: Longitude
A 25°14'59.78"N 83°01'51.27" E
B 25°14' 59.98"N 83°01'57.62" E
C 25°15' 11.75"N 83°01'54.62" E
D 25°15'12.72"N 83°01'48.90" E
Site Elevation Mainly flat with elevation of 77 m amsl
Water Body Ganga River passes along the eastern side of the Terminal
Nearest Airport Babatpur Airport about 28 km in NW
Nearest Railway Station Jeonathpur about 4.0 km in SE
Seismic Zone Zone III
Forests / National Parks None within 10 km study area
Wildlife Sanctuary Kashi Turtle Sanctuary about 2.3 km in North
Archaeologically important places/monuments
Ramnagar Fort 2.0 km in North
Industries Ramnagar Industrial Area about 3.5 km ESE
Site Photographs
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 81
Ramnagar Industrial Area: The industrial area of Ramnagar was established in 1978. The
total area of Ramnagar Industrial area is 305.54 acres. Ramnagar industrial area is located
on National Highway (NH-2), about 15 km from Varanasi city and about 3.5 km ESE of the
proposed Ramnagar Terminal. The Ramnagar industrial area has infrastructure facilities
like 33/11 KVA power sub-station, telephone exchange, post-office, bank, supervisory
hostel and shops. Due to poor infrastructure and pathetic condition of power supply, many
industrialists shifted business to other states. At present, only 120 units of 232 industrial
plots allotted to industrialists in Ramnagar industrial area are functioning.
5.3. Geology, Topography & Drainage, Hydrology,
Hydrogeology
Geology & Seismicity
Throughout Varanasi, the geological setting is quite similar i.e near surface are sandy lenses
surrounded by clay-silty deposits. These sandy lenses form the shallow aquifers (25-40 m depth
below surface, Shukla et al., 2008) with unconfined condition, which is the main water supply of
most part of the city. The lateral length of these lenses can be up to some 1000 m. Below the
clay-silty layer lie fine-coarse sand deposits, which represent the deeper aquifer (60-70 m depth
below surface, Shukla et al., 2008).The map is shown in Figure 5.2. The seismic zoning map of
India shows four distinct seismic zones.
Zone - II: This is said to be the least active seismic zone. Zone - III: It is included in the moderate seismic zone. Zone - IV: This is considered to be the high seismic zone. Zone - V: It is the highest seismic zone.
The proposed Terminal site falls in Zone –III, which fall in moderate risk zone.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 82
Figure 5.2 : Map Showing Plant Site & Seismic Zones .of India
Topography &Contour Map: Contour Map of the Study area showing site is shown in Figure
5.3. The range of elevation of this area varies from 55 – 95 m. The contours in Toposheet have
been digitized in the GIS environment and assigned the respective elevation values in meters
with reference to the mean sea level. Using the SRTM (Shuttle Radar Topography Mission)
data, the elevation values has been verified.
Proposed
Site
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 83
Figure 5.3 : Contour Map of Study Area
Digital Elevation Model (DEM): Based on the contour map, the Digital Elevation Model has
been prepared. The Nearest Neighbour method has been used to interpolate the elevation data
to develop the elevation model. This map gives clear picture that the eastern and western part
along the Ganga River having higher elevation. Center part of the area along the River has
lowest range of elevation. Digital Elevation Model for the area in 10 km radius from the
proposed site is shown in Figure 5.4.
Terminal Site
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 84
Figure 5.4 DEM of Study Area
Drainage: The study area, form a parts of Ganga river basin. The city of Varanasi is located in
the middle Ganges valley of North India, in the Eastern part of the state of Uttar Pradesh, along
the left crescent-shaped bank of the River Ganges. The river system consists of the mighty
Ganga highly revered by Hindus since ages. Varuna, Assi, Banganga, Chandra Prabha and
Karmnasa are tributaries of the Ganga, that drain the area. Being located in the Indo-Gangetic
Plains of North India, the land is very fertile because low level floods in the Ganges continually
replenish the soil. The drainage map of study area is given in Figure 5.5.
Terminal Site
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 85
Figure 5.5 Drainage Map of Study Area
Hydrology: Brief hydrological profile of river Ganga ha been described in the context of
Ramnagar Terminal. Bhagirathi is the source stream of Ganga. It emanates from Gangotri
Glacier at Gaumukh at an elevation of 3,892 m (12,770 feet). Many small streams comprise the
headwaters of Ganga. The Important among these are Alaknanda, Dhauliganga, Pindar,
Mandakini and Bhilangana. At Devprayag, where Alaknanda joins Bhagirathi, the river acquires
the name Ganga. It traverses a course of 2525 km before flowing into the Bay of Bengal. It has
a large number of tributaries joining it during this journey (Figure 5.6). In Uttarakhand, near
Tehri, a dam, has been built on Bhagirathi for hydropower generation resulting in regulated
additional water during the dry months. At Haridwar, Ganga opens to the Gangetic Plains,
where a barrage diverts a large quantity of its waters into the Upper Ganga Canal, to provide
water for irrigation. At Bijnore, another barrage diverts water into the Madhya Ganga Canal but
only during monsoon months. At Narora, there is further diversion of water into the Lower
Ganga Canal. Further down, River Ramganga joins Ganga near Kannauj, adding additional
water to the river. Yamuna confluences Ganga at the Sangam in Allahabad, making a major
contribution to the river flow. Beyond Allahabad, Ganga is joined by several tributaries, most of
which are from the north and a few from the south. In the stretch between Allahabad in U.P. and
Malda in West Bengal, Ganga, therefore, has considerable flow. The Farakka barrage in West
Terminal Site
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 86
Bengal regulates the flow of the river, diverting some of the water into a feeder canal linking
Hooghly to keep it relatively silt-free. Downstream of this barrage, River Ganga splits into two,
Bhagirathi (Hooghly) on the right and Padma on the left. Bhagirathi (Hooghly) meets the Bay of
Bengal about 150 km downstream of Kolkata. Padma enters Bangladesh and meets river
Brahmputra and Meghna before finally joining the Bay of Bengal. The main tributaries of the
Ganga river network (and some important flow and water quality measuring stations of CWC)
are shown in the line diagram Given in Figure 5.6.
Ramnagar Terminal fall in Varanasi district. Figure 5.6 indicates that Yamuna river contributes
to the flow of Ganga in a major way upstream, while river Gomti & Tons contribute to the flow
downstream of proposed terminal. Annual, dry & wet season flow contribution to Ganga
upstream and downstream of proposed terminal is shown in Figure 5.7, Figure 5.8 and Figure
5.9. Preliminary engineering assessment of flow conditions obtained from engineering
consultants indicate that adequate depth may be available at Ramnagar terminal.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 87
Figure 5.6: Line Diagram of Ganga River Network (with major dams/ barrages, canals, and flow and water quality measuring stations).
Figure 5.7: Annual Flow Contributions of Different Tributaries (sub-basins) to National
River Ganga under Present Flow Conditions and under Virgin Flow Conditions
Figure 5.8: Wet Season Flow Contributions of Different Tributaries (sub-basins) to
National River Ganga under Present Flow Conditions and under Virgin Flow Conditions
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 88
Figure 5.9: Dry Season Flow Contributions of Different Tributaries (sub-basins) to National River Ganga under Present Flow Conditions and under Virgin Flow Conditions Hydro-Geology
In the study aream subsurface stratigraphy is dominated by laterally persistent multi-storied
sand bodies capped by thick muddy succession near the top. The alternating sand and clay
layers have created a multi-tiered aquifer system. General slope of the water-table is from north
to south in Varanasi environs. The general water-table elevations (MSL) indicate that the Ganga
and Varuna rivers being deeply incised are gaining rivers. It is observed that some perched
water-table zones are also present where water level is very shallow. In the western part of
Varanasi city, water level is deep as compared to eastern part of the city. The shallow bore
wells (hand pumps) and dug wells puncturing unconfined aquifers at about 25–40 m depth have
water-level fluctuations from 8.51 m to 11.25 m. Such unconfined aquifers are made up of
recycled interfluves silt and silty sand forming lensoid units capped by relatively thin and
impersistent mud layers showing calcrete development. The deep wells penetrating below 60–
70 m have enormous yield of 45,000 lph to 220,500 lph. Good quality potable water is available
from coarse grained deep sandy aquifers. These aquifers are made up of craton derived pink
arkosic sand (sediment package 1) or the mixture sedimentary package 1 and 2 (Himalayan
gray sand). Because of thick cover of fine-grained material (sediment package 3) near the top,
these aquifers occur in semi-confined to confined conditions. Differential erosion of the sand
horizons by succeeding channel events within a sedimentary package may promote to semi-
confined conditions of the aquifers. The total thickness of the good water yielding sand strata
varies from 20 to 80 m or more in tube wells occurring at an average depth of about 100 m.
Because of intensive pumping of water due to fast urbanization, the water level in Varanasi
shows a lowering trend. The average fall of ground water level in last fifteen years is about 1.43
m (Sinha 2003). In general, the ground water of Varanasi city is of good quality.
5.4. Meteorology
Historical meteorological data were obtained from climatological tables pertaining to nearest
representative IMD station located at Varanasi and is presented in Table 5.3.
Table 5.3: Meteorological Conditions of Varanasi (30 years average)
Month Temperature (deg C) daily
Relative Humidity, %
Rainfall Wind speed
Pre-
dominant
wind
direction
Cloud
cover
Calm period
%
Max Min Max Min In mm Kmph From Octas Day Night
January 23.2 9.2 77 53 17.7 3.4 W, NW 2.2 35 41
February 26.4 11.6 67 42 17.1 4.3 W, NW 2.0 29 24
March 32.8 16.4 51 29 9.3 5.0 W, NW 1.8 21 17
April 38.5 22.1 42 25 5.4 5.4 W, NW 1.6 20 15
May 40.4 25.5 49 29 13.2 5.7 W,NW 1.8 17 16
June 38.5 27.2 62 47 91.3 5.7 W, NW 4.3 19 21
July 33.7 25.8 81 72 309.3 5.8 W, E, NE 6.6 24 30
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 89
August 32.9 25.4 84 76 286.5 5.0 W, E, NE 6.5 26 31
September
32.9 24.4 81 72 203.5 4.8 W, E 5.0 25 36
October 32.8 20.5 72 59 27.3 3.0 W, NW 2.0 34 43
November
29.5 14.3 68 54 13.8 2.3 W, NW 1.4 44 66
December
24.7 9.9 75 55 5.9 3.0 W, NW 1.7 36 54
(Source-IMD Varanasi)
The meteorological parameters play a vital role in transport and dispersion of pollutants in the
atmosphere.
Temperature – December and January constitutes winter months with daily mean minimum
temperature around 9.2oC and daily mean maximum temperature around 24.7oC. May is the
hottest month with daily mean maximum temperature around 40.4oC and daily mean minimum
temperature around 25.5oC.
Relative Humidity – The air is generally dry in the region except during monsoon. April and
May are driest with relative humidity between 25-49%. The maximum humidity during rainy
season is 84% and minimum was 72%. High humidity is found during daytime and low humidity
values during nighttime in all the months.
Rainfall – The annual total rainfall is 1000.3 mm. Over 80% of the total annual rainfall is
received during the monsoon period between June to September.
Wind Pattern
Wind Speed– The wind speed ranges between 2.3 – 5.8 km/hour for all the months. The wind
speed during summer season ranges between 5.0 - 5.7 km/hr while during rainy season, ranges
between 5.0–5.8 km/hr and in winter months wind speed ranges between 2.3 - 3.4 km/hr.
Wind Direction – The predominant wind direction during winter and summer season is from west
and Northwest direction. During Monsoon season the wind flows from West, NE and east
direction. Wind rose diagram is presented in Figure 5.6.
Special Weather Phenomena: The occurrence of thunderstorm is 21 days per year, mostly
spread across the months of June to September. On an annual average basis, 105 days have
visibility in the range of 1 - 4 km, 219 days have visibility in the range of 4 -10 km, 32 days
between 10 - 20 km and 1 days have visibility above 20 km. No thunderstorm or dust storm
occurred during the study period.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 90
Figure 5.6: Wind rose Diagram of IMD Varanasi (Summer Season)
Source: IMD Varanasi
5.5. Ambient Air Quality
CPCB guideline followed for selecting the appropriateness of monitoring locations. The location
and height of the stations were so selected (>5 m from base) to avoid the capture of re-
suspended road dust and fugitive domestic emissions. Ambient air quality monitoring was done
at six locations within the study area during 20th June 2015 to 5th July 2015. All the ambient air
analysis with respect to each parameter were analyzed as per CPCB guidelines. The AAQ
monitoring locations are provided in Table 5.5 and Figure 5.2. The Ambient Air Quality results
are presented in Table 5.6. Historical AAQ data of two monitoring location in Varanasi for period
March 2015 were also obtained from UPSPCB. AAQ Results of UPPCB monitoring locations is
presented in Table 5.7. Photographs of AAQ monitoring provided in Figure 5.7.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 91
Table 5.5: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Locations
Location Code
Name of Location
Distance & Direction from site
Characterstics/Terrain Features Coordinates
AAQ-1 Ralhupur 0.7 km N
Rural, flat terrain, Vehicular movements are usually of small private vehicle (Two and four-wheelers) close to the terminal site. Access road passes through this village.
25°15'31.46" N 83°01'55.59" E
AAQ-2 Tahirpur 1.2 km SE
Rural, flat terrain, Vehicular movements are usually of small private vehicle (Two and four-wheelers) located in downwind direction
25°14'45.77" N 83°02'34.29" E
AAQ-3 Bhitti 1.4 km NE
Rural, flat terrain, located close to NH-7, Small private vehicle movement. surrounded by agriculture, downwind direction.
25°15'38.83" N 83°02'34.29" E
AAQ-4 Madarwa 2.4 km NW Semi Urban, flat terrain, moderate traffic movement. located in upwind direction.
25°15'38.77" N 83°01'12.28" E
AAQ-5 Ramnagar 2.8 km NNE
Urban/commercial, populated area, flat terrain. Due to presence of restaurants and Shops it always remains crowded. NH-7 passes through the town (Heavy Traffic Movement).
25°16'48.19" N 83°01'48.12" E
AAQ-6 Milkipur 0.6 km SE Rural, flat terrain, surrounded by agriculture, downwind direction
25°16'48.19" N 83°01'48.12" E
UPPCB AAQ Monitoring Location
AAQ-1 Sigra 8.0 km NW Mixed use NA
AAQ-2 Jawahar Nagar
6.17 km NW Mixed use NA
Table 5.6: Ambient Air Quality Monitoring Results (24-hour average)
Location PM2.5, g/m3 PM10 (g/m3)
Min Max Mean Min Max Mean
Ralhupur 21 42 36 54 86 76
Tahirpur 22 45 38 58 90 78
Bhitti 20 48 37 53 88 74
Madarwa 25 50 41 61 96 84
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 92
Ramnagar 34 58 48 82 145 112
Milkipur 22 42 35 54 90 77
Source: EQMS
Location SO2, g/m3 NO2, g/m3
CO(mg/m3) 8 hour average
Min Max Mean Min Max Mean Avg.
Ralhupur 13.4 19.6 17.4 17.4 28.9 24.6 0.25
Tahirpur 14.3 21.6 18.6 18.2 31.6 26.3 0.26
Bhitti 15.2 24.4 19.6 17.8 30.2 25.6 0.30
Madarwa 14.4 23.8 18.8 18.4 32.4 27.2 0.28
Ramnagar 20.4 35.6 27.8 26.8 46.8 36.8 0.69
Milkipur 13.7 20.6 18.4 21.4 29.6 24.3 0.28
Source: EQMS
Table 5.7 Ambient Air Quality of Varanasi (March 2015)
Location Date PM10 g/m3 So2, g/m3 No2 g/m3
24hr Avg. 24hr Avg. 24hr Avg.
Jawahar Nagar Varanasi
2-3-2015 147.46 18.39 32.47
9-3-2015 146.49 18.83 32.89
12-3-2015 147.42 19.29 33.15
16-3-2015 146.10 18.81 33.28
19-3-2015 146.65 18.66 33.50
23-3-2015 143.99 18.77 32.90
26-3-2015 147.46 19.19 33.35
30-3-2015 146.49 19.32 32.93
Source: UPSPCB, Varanasi
Location Date PM10 g/m3 So2, g/m3 No2 g/m3
24hr Avg. 24hr Avg. 24hr Avg.
Sigra Varanasi
10-3-2015 144.90 19.92 33.10
13-3-2015 143.25 19.29 33.21
17-3-2015 140.95 19.96 32.24
20-3-2015 139.51 19.61 32.11
24-3-2015 144.05 18.51 32.15
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 93
27-3-2015 139.79 19.18 32.68
31-3-2015 141.49 19.02 32.13
Source: UPSPCB, Varanasi
5.5.1. Analysis of Ambient Air Quality
Particulate Matter (PM10)
Particulate Matter PM10 within study area varies from 53 to 145 µg/m3. Value of PM10 in all
location except Ramnagar is within the specified limit as per NAAQS. Highest level of PM10
i.e.145 µg/m3 is observed at Ramnagar area due to Heavy Traffic movement along the SH-7.
Particulate Matter (PM2.5)
PM2.5 levels were found ranging from 20 to 58 µg/m3. Value of PM2.5 is within the specified limits
as per NAAQS but high in Ramnagar site. The highest PM2.5 levels i.e. 58 µg/m3 were found at
Ramnagar area due to Heavy Traffic movement along the SH-7.
Sulphur Dioxide (SO2):
SO2 levels were found ranging from 13.4 to 35.6 µg/m3, which is found quite below the national
Ambient Air Quality Standard. The highest levels of SO2 were found at Ramanagr area. The
main source of SO2 emission is from vehicular pollution.
Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx):
NOx levels were found ranging from 17.4 to 46.8 µg/m3, which is found quite below the national
Ambient Air Quality Standard. The highest levels of NOx were found at Ramnagar Area. The
main source of SO2 emission is from vehicular pollution.
Carbon Monoxide (CO)
CO concentration ranges from 250 μg/m3 to 690 μg/m3. Higher concentration were observed at Ramnagar area.
Overall the ambient air quality of the study area is meeting the prescribed National Ambient Air
Quality Standard at all locations except Ramnagar, where the RSPM values are high in terms of
NAAQS. This is mainly due to the heavy traffic load on SH-7 and other commercial and
industrial activities in Ramnagar area.
Air Quality of Varanasi: The historical data of Varanasi shows that the concentration of the
particulate matter in the Varanasi city is exceeding the NAAQS. That is mainly due to the heavy
traffic movement in the city area. SO2 and NOx concentration is well within the National
Ambient Air Quality standard.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 94
Figure 5.7 : Photographs of Ambient Air Quality Monitoring
5.6. Ambient Noise Quality
Ambient noise measurements were taken at 8 locations. Measurements were noted at an
interval of 5 seconds over a period of 10 minutes per hour for 24-hours. Noise monitoring results
for daytime and night time is presented in Table 5.8.
Table 5.8 : Ambient Noise Quality in Study Area
Location Name
Category Day time Leq dB(A)
Standard Day time Leq; dB(A)
Night time Leq; dB(A)
Standard Night time Leq; dB(A)
Terminal Site Industrial 43.5 75 40.2 65
Ramnagar (NH-7)
Commercial 64.5 65 54.8 55
Ralhupur Residential 45.8 55 41.3 45
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 95
Tahirpur Residential 46.5 55 42.0 45
Bhitti Residential 46.8 55 42.5 45
Madarwa Residential 48.8 55 43.0 45
Sultanpur
(Mauaza Rastapur)
Residential 47.3 55 42.9 45
Milkipur Residential 46.4 55 42.5 45
(Source: EIA Team)
5.6.1. Analysis of Ambient Noise Quality
The ambient noise quality of the study area is meeting the prescribed National Ambient Noise
Quality Standard for respective residential and commercial category at all locations.
5.7. Traffic Assessment & Site Connectivity
The proposed Ramnagr Terminal is connected through NH-7 via a village road up to the
Ralhupur village. This village road is puckka up to the Ralhupur village. From Ralhupur village to
terminal site about 700 m stretch that connect terminal site to Rahlupur village need to be some
levelling and widening. This village road is approx. 3 m wide. Only the villagers of the Ralhupur
use this road for communication hence the traffic density on this road is very low. Two wheelers
and fourwheeler used by the villagers are the major vehicle counts on this road.
5.8. Surface and Ground Water Quality
Six ground water samples and three surface water samples were collected from different
locations during study period by following standard protocol. The water samples were examined
for physico-chemical parameters and bacteriological parameters. The samples were collected
and analysed as per the procedures specified in Standard Methods. Samples for chemical
analyses were collected in polyethylene carboys. Samples for bacteriological analyses were
collected in sterilized bottles. Surface water sample were analyzed for various parameters and
assessed using the CPCB‟s BDU Criteria. The name of sampling locations is presented in
Table 5.9. The analysis results of surface water and groundwater are presented in Table 5.10
and Table 5.11. Photographs of water sampling provided in Figure 5.8.
Table 5.9 Name of Water Sampling Locations
S.No. Ground Water Sampling Locations
Code Location Source
1 GW1 Terminal Site Borewell
2 GW2 Milkipur Handpump
3 GW3 Ralhupur Handpump
4 GW4 Tahirpur Handpump
5 GW5 Bhitti Handpump
6 GW6 Madarwa Handpump
Surface Water Sampling Locations
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 96
9 SW1 Gurha Nala Nala
10 SW2 Ganga River upstream of Gurha Nala River
11 SW3 Ganga River downstream of Gurha Nala River
Table 5.10: Surface Water Quality
Source: (Water analysis by MMITGM) Note All values in mg/l except pH
Table 5.11: Ground Water Quality
S.No. Parameters GW-1 GW-2 GW-3 Method
1 pH 7.40 7.14 7.17 APHA-4500
2 Turbidity (NTU) 0.5 0.5 0.6 APHA-2030B
3 Conductivity, mhos/cm 462 490 575 APHA-4500
4 Suspended solids 2 3 4 APHA-2540D
5 Dissolved solids 318 253 274 APHA-2540B
6 Total Hardness as CaCO3 272 212 220 APHA-2340C
7 Chloride as Cl 14 7 10 APHA-4500B
8 Sulphates as SO4 15 13 29 APHA-4500E
9 Nitrates as NO3 0.95 0.07 0.08 APHA-4500
10 Fluoride as F 0.40 0.03 0.31 APHA-4500D
11 Iron as Fe 0.12 0.020 0.11 APHA-3111B
12 Zinc as Zn 1.0 1.0 0.9 APHA-3111B
13 Calcium as Ca 32 39 35 APHA-3500B
14 Magnesium as Mg 47 27 32 APHA-3500B
15 Cadmium as Cd <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
16 Copper as Cu <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
17 Nickel as Ni <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
18 Lead as Pb <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
19 Mercury as Hg <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 APHA-3112
20 Chromium (Total as Cr) <0.05 <0.05 <0.05 APHA-3111B
21 Arsenic as As <0.025 <0.025 <0.025 APHA-3114
22 Oil and Grease Nil Nil Nil APHA-4500D
23 Total coliform MPN/100ml Nil Nil Nil APHA-9230B
Source: (Analysis Report by Kamal Laboratory) Note All values in mg/l except pH
Table 5.11 : continue… Ground Water Quality
Sl.No. Parameters Ganga River upstream of Gurha Nala
Ganga River downstream of Gurha Nala
Gurha Nala
1 pH 7.46 7.45 4.00
2 Conductivity, mhos/cm 509 499 426
3 Total Dissolved Solids (mg/liter) 339 335 277
4 Dissolved Oxygen (mg/liter) 7.43 6.85 4.0
5 Bio-chamical Oxygen demand (for 3 days at 270C) (mg/liter)
7.8 8.4 36
7 Fecal Coliform MPN/100 ml) 12300 15400 27200
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 97
S. No.
Parameters GW-4 GW-5 GW-6 Method
1 pH 7.25 7.50 7.40 APHA-4500
2 Turbidity (NTU) 0.8 1.8 1.6 APHA-2030B
3 Conductivity, mhos/cm 887 493 711 APHA-4500
4 Suspended solids 4 4 4 APHA-2540D
5 Dissolved solids 501 316 440 APHA-2540B
6 Total Hardness as CaCO3 284 172 312 APHA-2340C
7 Chloride as Cl 50 16 68 APHA-4500B
8 Sulphates as SO4 35 5.0 46 APHA-4500E
9 Nitrates as NO3 0.75 0.7 0.6 APHA-4500
10 Fluoride as F 0.64 0.34 0.13 APHA-4500D
11 Iron as Fe 0.012 0.12 0.12 APHA-3111B
12 Zinc as Zn 1.1 0.9 0.8 APHA-3111B
13 Calcium as Ca 37 44 50 APHA-3500B
14 Magnesium as Mg 47 12.2 46 APHA-3500B
15 Cadmium as Cd <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
16 Copper as Cu <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
17 Nickel as Ni <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
18 Lead as Pb <0.01 <0.01 <0.01 APHA-3111B
19 Mercury as Hg <0.001 <0.001 <0.001 APHA-3112
20 Chromium (Total as Cr) <0.05 <0.05 <0.05 APHA-3111B
21 Arsenic as As <0.025 <0.025 <0.025 APHA-3114
22 Oil and Grease Nil Nil Nil APHA-4500D
23 Total coliform MPN/100ml Nil Nil Nil APHA-9230B
Source: (Analysis Report by Kamal Laboratory) Note All values in mg/l except pH
Observation on Ground Water Quality: The pH value of ground water samples at all locations
varies from 7.14 – 7.50 and are within permissible limit. The conductivity values were found to
be in the range of 462 – 887 μmhos/cm. The chloride level was found to vary from 7 – 68 mg/l
within permissible limit. The total hardness values were found to vary from 172 – 284 mg/l;
within permissible limit. Calcium and Magnesium values were within the permissible limit. Zinc
and Fe levels were found to be within the permissible limit. All the parameters in ground water
sample were well within the permissible limit of Indian Standard IS: 10500-2012.
Average values of pH and DO in Ganga river in both the sampling location comply with the BDU
Criteria of CPCB. BOD does not comply with the standards at both the locations. An increasing
trend of BOD is observed in d/s of the river due to contamination. Faecal Coliform are observed
higher than the criteria at both the locations. Water quality of Graha nala is not meeting the BDU
Criteria of CPCB and overall the water quality of the Gurha nalla is polluted.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 98
Figure 5.8 : Photographs of Water Sampling
5.9. Soil Quality
Six soil samples were collected from agriculture fields and physico-chemical characteristics
were analysed. At each location, soil samples were collected from three different depths; 1-5
cm, 10-20 cm and 40-50 cm below the surface. The samples were homogenized and the
quantity was reduced using the coning and quartering method. The soil sampling location and
analysis results of soil samples are presented in Table 5.12 and 5.13.
Table 5.12: Soil Sampling Locations
Sr. No. Location Code Location Source Coordinates
1 S-1 Terminal site Site 25°15'06.72"N 83°01'52.83" E
2 S-2 Ralhupur Agricultural field 25°15'31.43"N 83°01'55.54" E
3 S-3 Tahirpur Agricultural field 25°14'45.70" N
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 99
83°02'34.30" E
4 S-4 Bhitti Agricultural field 25°15'38.80" N 83°02'34.32" E
5 S-5 Madarwa Agricultural field 25°15'38.72"N 83°01'12.25" E
6 S-6 Sultanpur Mauaza
Rastapur Agricultural field
25°15'39.05"N 83°02'12.49" E
Table 5.13: Physicochemical Characteristics of Soil
S. No.
Parameter
Unit
Sampling Locations
S-1 S-2 S-3 S-4 S-5 S-6
Physical Characteristics
1. Texture - Clay Loam
Sandy Loam
Sandy Loam
Clay Loam
Sandy Loam
Sandy Loam
2. Particle Size Distribution
i) Sand % 29 52 50 26 49 46
ii) Silt % 25 28 28 33 21 34
iii) Clay % 46 20 22 41 30 20
3. Porosity % 50.9 51.7 48.3 53.2 50.2 47.9
4. Bulk Density gm/cc 1.30 1.28 1.37 1.24 1.32 1.38
5. Water Holding Capacity
% 36 28 26 33 28 25
Chemical Characteristics
6. pH 20% Slurry
7.4 7.2 7.5 6.9 7.7 7.5
7. EC ds/m-1 0.36 0.40 0.37 0.32 0.30 0.34
8. CEC meq/100-gm
18 10 8 24 7 9
9. Available Nutrients
i) Nitrogen as N kg/ha 280.2 346.8 313.2 363.4 294.8 336.4
ii) Phosphorus as P kg/ha 16.2 11.5 13.8 14.2 15.5 12.9
iii) Potassium as K kg/ha 168.8 220.2 184.3 245.7 212.4 206.5
10. Organic Matter % 0.90 0.83 0.78 0.86 0.88 0.76
11. Organic Carbon % 0.52 0.48 0.45 0.50 0.51 0.44 Source: (Analysis Report by Kamal Laboratory)
Rating Chart for Soil Classification
S. No.
Test Parameters Classification
1 pH pH<4.5 Extremely Acidic 4.5-5.0 Very Strongly Acidic 5.1-5.5 Strongly Acidic 5.6-6.0 Moderately Acidic 6.1-6.5 Slightly Acidic 6.6-7.3 Neutral 7.4-7.8 Slightly Alkaline
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 100
7.9-8.4 Moderately Alkaline 8.5-9.0 Strongly Alkaline
2 Salinity Electrical Conductivity (µS/cm)
Up to 1.00 Average 1.01-2.00 Harmful to Germination 2.01-3.00 Harmful to Crops (Sensitive to Salts)
3 Organic Carbon % Low (below 0.50 %), Medium (0.50-0.75 %) and high (above 0.75 %)
4 Nitrogen, kg/ha low (<280-kg/ha-1), medium (280 to 560-kg/ha-1) and high (>560-kg/ha-1)
5 Phosphorus, kg/ha low (<10-kg/ha-1), medium (10 to 25-kg/ha-1) and high (>25-kg/ha-1)
6 Potassium, kg/ha low (<108-kg/ha-1), medium (108 to 280-kg/ha-1) and high (>280-kg/ha-1)
Source: Soil Survey Manual (IARI, 1970)
Observation on Soil Quality: pH of the soil samples ranges from 6.9 to 7.7 indicating the soils
are neutral to slightly alkaline in nature. Texturally, the soils of study area are observed as
Sandy Loam, & Clay Loam Soils. The organic Carbon content of soil ranges from 0.44 to 0.52 %
(as 0.76 to 0.90% Organic Matter), thereby implying that soils are medium in organic content.
Available Nitrogen content in the surface soils ranges between 193.4 to 262.8-kg/ha. Available
Phosphorus content ranges between 11.5 & 16.2-kg/ha. Available potassium content in these
soils ranges between 168.8 to 245.7-kg/ha. Overall the soil of the study area is moderately
fertile.
5.10. Land Use
Remote sensing data provides reliable accurate baseline information for land use mapping, as it
is a rapid method of acquiring up-to-date information of over a large geological area.
A systematic digital image interpretation approach was used to delineate the land use classes.
The present study was focused on demarcating boundaries of different land use/land cover
units from an analysis of different types of colour registrations of land use/land cover units from
satellite imagery.
Data used in the land use map preparation is the satellite Imagery of Indian Remote Sensing
Satellite (IRS- ID, sensor P6, LISS III) of 24 m resolution. The Swath of the imagery is 141 Km x
141 Km. Band used are 2, 3 4 and 5. LANDSAT imagery of 30-meter resolution and 185 x 185
km swath is also used for the comparative and overall analysis of the area. LISS III imagery and
LANDSAT 4-5 TM imagery were used for the complete coverage of the study area. Band used
are 2, 3 and 4.
As per the land use based on satellite image, about 57.87% of the land is under cultivation.
About 29.85% of the land is under settlement, about 6.2% land is under water bodies and rest of
the land is under other uses. Land use / land cover map of 10 km study area has been show in
Figure 5.9 and Table 5.14.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 101
Table 5.14 : Land use of the Study Area
Sl. No. Land use Category Area( Sq km) Area in %
1 Agricultural land 182.20 57.87
2 Settlement 93.96 29.85
3 Waterbody 19.52 6.20
4 Vegetation 10.96 3.48
5 Open land 3.41 1.08
6 Dry river bed 4.76 1.51
Total 314.81 100
(Source: EQMS)
Figure 5.9 Land use/ Land Cover Map of Study Area
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 102
5.11. Biological Environment
5.11.1. Flora
Flora refers to a systematic account of plants of any specific area and it provides keys and
descriptions of plants for their identification. Although, the primary aim of a flora is identification
of plant species, it also provides other useful data on plants such as their local / vernacular
names, distribution, correct names, uses, etc. The baseline ecological surveys were carried out,
based on various secondary sources (Forest Department Data, Scientific Studies and previous
similar studies) which are further validated from through field observations and interaction with
local people. Present biological assessment was carried out for core zone (at the economic
zone site and offsite facilities areas) and buffer zone (10 km surrounding the core zone area).
Core Zone –Ecological assessment (Terminal site)
The proposed site is devoid of any major plantation. Some agriculture activities were taken up
by nearby villagers within the land in the past but these activities have been discontinued now.
Now the land is categorized as current fallow land. There are about 12 small trees of Khajur
(Phoenix sylvestris) and 8 trees of Babool shrubs (Acacia spp.), which are present in the
identified land. Photographs of vegetation at site shown in Figure 5.10.
Figure 5.10 Vegetation at Site
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 103
Access Road to Terminal site
The proposed Ramnagr Terminal is connected through NH-7 via a village road up to the
Ralhupur village. This village road is puckka up to the Ralhupur village. Houses and shops also
exist along this village road. From Ralhupur village to terminal site about 700 m stretch that
connect terminal site to Rahlupur village need to be some leveling and widening.
Trees along the 700 m stretch: There are very few trees present in this road. Trees of Jamun,
Peepal, Pakad, Babul, Khajur and Sisham etc are present on both side of this 700 m stretch of
the road. The access road (700 m stretch that have to develop) is almost clear, only two to three
trees of Jamun, is present along the road alignment that may be removed. Small shrub of Babul
(Acacia spp.) and Khajur is also present on the acess road that needs to remove for passes.
One big Pakad tree is present along the acess road, which requires some chopping for clearing
the passes. The Type of Vegetation along approach Road is shown in Figure 5.11.
Figure 5.11: Type of Vegetation along approach Road
Buffer Zone –Ecological assessment
Buffer area of 10 km has been considered for studying the ecology around the p roject site.
Study area has terrestrial and aquatic ecosystem. The Ganga river is the main water body for
aquatic ecosystem in the study area. The river system of the area is rich in aquatic flora and
fauna. Substantial fishing and boating activities are also carried out in Ganga River.
Varanasi constitutes the representative part of the upper Gangetic plain of eastern Uttar
Pradesh. There is no forest present within the 10 km area of the study site. The vegetation
point of view the study area can be divided in to following two parts.
1. Urban area
2. Vegetation in BHU
3. Cultivated area
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 104
1. Urban Area: maximum part of the study area is in west, north and northeast side is
under the settlement. Most of the land is under urban development and vegetation is
restricted to road side only.
2. Vegetation in BHU: The entire campus of Banaras Hindu University (area 1300 acres)
is floristically very rich. It comprises of many plants of the eastern Uttar Pradesh. The
campus has huge Botanical and Ayurvedic gardens where plants of different regions of
India have been planted. The ground flora of these gardens are quite rich as a result of
favourable moisture conditions, high humidity and high humus conditions. A large
number of medicinal plants are also planted in the Ayurvedic garden. The University has
its own agriculture farm from where crop field weeds of different season may be
collected. The campus has many roadside trees. The avenues of trees and green plants
give a resort like atmosphere to the campus. Several weeds grow in different seasons
along these roads. It has many ponds and ditches which provide favourable conditions
for growth for many hydrophytes. Besides, there are many climbers and cultivated plants
in different lawns of the campus.
3. Rural area: Eastern and south-eastern part of the study area is rural and agricultural
activities are practiced. In this part of the study area, most of the land is under
cultivation. Further, the vegetation is sparse, which include timber, fruit, ornamental trees
and shrubs. Vegetation is restricted along the road side, agriculture field, along the pond
side and other open areas. The most characteristic tree is Accasia arabica, Bombax
ceiba, Dalbergia sissoo, Delbergia sisoo, Azdirachta indica, Mangifera indica, Ficus
benghalensis, Ficus religiosa and accacia spp are common. Ground vegetation covered
by dominant shrubs and herbs is Argemone mexicana, Vitex negundo, Chirchitta,
Xanthium strumarium Ipomea spp. Sida cardifolia, Zizyphus mauritiana, Achyranthus
aspera, Cyanodon dactylon, etc.
The list of the plant species observed in the study area is given Table 5.15
Table 5.15 : List of Common Plant Species Present in Study Area
Sl. No. Botanical Name Vernacular Name Family
1. Acacia auriculiformis A.Cunn. Australian Babool Mimosaceae
2. A.catechu Willd. Kattha, khair Mimosaceae
3. A.nilotica Linn. Babool Mimosaceae
4. Aegle marmelos (Linn.) Correa Bel, Shreephal Rutaceae
5. Albizia lebbeck Linn. Siris Mimosaceae
6. A.procera Roxb. Safed siris Mimosaceae
7. Annona squamosa Linn. Sharifa Annonaceae
8. Anogeissus pardula Edgew. Dhav Combretaceae
9. Anthocephalus chinensis (Lam.) A.Rich. Kadamb Rubiaceae
10. Artocarpus heterophyllus Lam. Kathar Moraceae
11. Azadirachta indica Juss. Neem Meliaceae
12. Bauhinia variegata Linn. Kachnar Caesalpiniaceae
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 105
Sl. No. Botanical Name Vernacular Name Family
13. Bombax ceiba linn. Semal Bombacaceae
14. Borassus flabellifer Linn. Tad Arecaceae
15. Boswellia serrata Roxb. Shalki Burseraceae
16. Buchnania latifolia Roxb. Chiraunji Anacardiaceae
17. Butea monosperma (Linn.) DC. Dhak, palas Papilionaceae
18. Callistemon lanceolatus DC Bottlebrush Myrtaceae
19. Calotropis gigentea (Linn.) R.Br. Madar Asclepiadaceae
20. C. procera (Ait.) R.Br. Madar Asclepiadaceae
21. Caryota urens Linn. Fish tail palm Arecaceae
22. Cassia fistula Linn. Amaltas Caesalpiniaceae
23. Casurina equisetifolia J.R. Vilayati Jhau Casurinaceae
24. Cinnamomum.tamala Fr. Tejpat Lauraceae
25. Citrus aurantifolia (Christ.) Swingle. Kagzinimboo Rutaceae
26. C.limon(Linn.) Burm. Jamerinimboo Rutaceae
27. C.maxima(Burm.) Merr. Chakodra Rutaceae
28. Dalbergia sissoo Roxb. Sheesham Papilionaceae
29. Delonix regia (Boj.) Rafin. Gulmohar Caesalpiniaceae
30. Emblica officinalis Gaertn. Amla Euphorbiaceae
31. Eryobotrya japonica (Thumb.) Lindle. Lukat Rosaceae
32. Erythrina suberosa Roxb. Dhavaldhak Papilionaceae
33. Eucalyptus citriodora Hooker Eucalyptus Myrtaceae
34. Ficus benghalensis Linn. Bargad Moraceae
35. F. hispida Linn. Kathgular Moraceae
36. F.racemosa Linn. Gular Moraceae
37. F. religiosa Linn. Peepal Moraceae
38. F. virens Ait. Pakar Moraceae
39. Grewia hainesiana Hole. Phalsa Teliaceae
40. Gmelia arborea Roxb. Gambhar Verbenaceae
41. Leucaena leucocephala (Lamk.)Wt. Shoobabool Mimosaceae
42. Madhuca indica Gmel Mahua Sapotaceae
43. Melia azedirach linn. Bakain Meliaceae
44. Mallotus philippinensis Lamk. Kampilak Euphorbiaceae
45. Mangifera indica Linn. Am Anacardiaceae
46. Moringa oleifera Lamk. Sahjan Moringaceae
47. Morus alba Linn. Shehtoot Moraceae
48. Pithocellobium dulce (Roxb.)Benth. jangal jilebi Mimosaceae
49. Phoenix sylvestris (L.)Roxb. Khajur Arecaceae
50. Prunus persica (L.)Stokes. Aru Rosaceae
51. Prosopis cineraria (L.)Mac. Shammi Mimosaceae
52. Psidium guajava Linn. Amrood Myrtaceae
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 106
Sl. No. Botanical Name Vernacular Name Family
53. Punica granatum Linn. Anar Punicaceae
54. Pongamia pinnata Karanj Papileonacaea
55. Sapindus emarginatus Vahl. Rithi Sapindaceae
56. S.mukorossi Gaertn. Ritha Sapindaceae
57. Saraca asoka (Roxb.) ashok, sita ashok Caesalpiniaceae
58. Schleichera oleosa (Lour.) Oken. Kusum Sapindaceae
59. Syzygium cumini (L.)Skeels. Jamun Myrtaceae
60. Tamarindus indica Linn. Imli Caesalpiniaceae
61. Tectona grandis Linn. Sagun Verbenaceae
62. Terminalia slata Heyne Asna Combretaceae
63. T.arjuna Roxb. Arjun Combretaceae
64. T.belerica Gaertn. Bahera Combretaceae
65. T.catappa Linn. desi badam Combretaceae
66. T.chebula Retz. Hara Combretaceae
67. Zizyphus mauritiana Lamk. Ber Rhamnaceae
68. Z.nummularis (burm.f.)Wt.&Arn. kanta ber Rhamnaceae
Shrubs/ Herbs
Sl. No. Botanical Name Vernacular Name Family
1. Achyranthes aspera Linn. Chirchida Amaranthaceae
2. Adhatoda zealanica Medik. Arus, Vasak Acanthaceae
3. Argemone mexicana Linn. Bharbhar Papaveraceae
4. Artabotrys hexapetalus Linn. Kateli Champa Annonaceae
5. Asparagus racemosus Willd. Satawari Liliaceae
6. Cannabis sativa Linn. Bhang Cannabinaceae
7. Canscora decussata (Roxb.) Roem. Sankhphuli Gentianaceae
8. Carissa carundas linn. Karaunda Apocynaceae
9. Cassia.occidentalis Linn. Bara Chakwar Caesalpiniaceae
10. Cassia.tora Linn. Chhota Chakwar Caesalpiniaceae
11. Catharanthus roseus (Linn.) G.Don Sadabahar Apocynaceae
12. Centella asiatica (Linn.) Urban Brahmi Apiaceae
13. Cestrum diurnum Linn. Din ka Raja Solanaceae
14. C.nocturnum Linn. Rat ki rani Solanaceae
15. Chenopodium album Linn. Bathua Chenopodiaceae
16. Curculago orchioides Gaet. kali musli Hypoxidaceae
17. Datura metel Linn. Dhatura Solanaceae
18. Euphorbia hirta Linn. Dudhia Euphorbiaceae
19. H. rosa-chinensis Linn. gurhal, arhul Malvaceae
20. Holoptelia integrifolia (Roxb.) Planch. Chilbil Ulmaceae
21. Ipomea. cairica (L.)Sweet railway creeper Convolvulaceae
22. Ipomea. carnea Mart Bahaya Convolvulaceae
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 107
23. J. grandiflorum Linn. Chameli Oleaceae
24. Lawsonia inermis Linn. Mehandi Lythraceae
25. Leucas aspera Willd. Gum Lamiaceae
26. Linum usitattissimum Linn. tisi, alsi Linaceae
27. Mimosa pudica Linn. chui mui Mimosaceae
28. Murraya koenigii (L.)Spreng. Meethineem Rutaceae
29. Nerium indicum Mill. Kaner Apocynaceae
30. Nyctanthes arbor-tristis Linn. Harsingar Oleaceae
31. Ocimum americanum Linn. Bantulsi Lamiaceae
32. O.sanctum linn. Tulsi Lamiaceae
33. Oxalis corniculata linn. Khatmithi Oxalidaceae
34. Phalaris minor Retz. gehun ka mama Poaceae
35. Pothos aureus Hort. money plant Araceae
36. Pterospermum acerifolium Willd. kanak champa Sterculiaceae
37. Rauvolfia serpentina (L.)Benth. Sarpgandha Apocynaceae
38. S. nigrum Linn. Makoy Solanaceae
39. S.verginianum Linn. bengani, bhatkataya Solanaceae
40. Thevetia peruviana (Pers.)K.Schum. pila kaner Apocynaceae
41. Trichosanthes anguina Linn. Chichida Cucurbitaceae
42. Tribulus terrestris Linn. Gokhru Zygophyllaceae
43. Xanthium strumarium Linn. Gokhru Asteraceae Source: (Feild Survey)
Climber/grasses
Sl. No. Botanical Name Vernacular Name Family
1. Alysicarpus monilifer (Linn.) DC Juhighas Papilionaceae
2. Bambusa arundinacea (Retz.) Willd. Bans Poaceae
3. Cuscuta reflexa Roxb. amarbel, akashbel Cuscutaceae
4. Cynodon dactylon (L.) pers. Doob Poaceae
5. Cyperus rotundus Linn. Motha Poaceae
6. I. cairica (L.)Sweet railway creeper Convolvulaceae
7. Macuna pruriens Baker Kawanch Papilionaceae
8. Millingtonia hortensis Linn. akash neem Bignoniaceae
9. Sachharum officinarum Linn. Ikh Poaceae
10. Sachharum.spontaneum Linn. Kaas Poaceae
11. Vetiveria zizanioides (L.)Nash Khas Poaceae
Cultivated Plants
Sl. No. Botanical Name Vernacular Name Family
1. Abelmoschus esculentus (L) Moen. Bhindi Malvaceae
2. Allium cepa Linn. Pyaj Liliaceae
3. A.sativum Linn. Lahsun Liliaceae
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 108
4. Amaranthus tricolor Linn. Lalsag Amaranthaceae
5. A. viridis Linn. Chaurai Amaranthaceae
6. Brassica compestris Linn. Sarson Brassicaceae
7. Cajanus cajan (Linn.) Mill. Arhar Papilionaceae
8. Capsicum annuum Linn. Mirch Solanaceae
9. Carica papaya Linn. Papita Caricaceae
10. Coccinia cordifolia (Linn.) Cogn. Kundra Cucurbitaceae
11. Coriandrum sativum Linn. Dhaniya Apiaceae
12. Cuminum cyminum linn. Jeera Apiaceae
13. Cucumis melo Linn. Kakri Cucurbitaceae
14. Cucurbita maxima Dutch. Kaddu Cucurbitaceae
15. Daucus carota Linn. Gajar Apiaceae
16. Dolichos lablab Linn. Sem Papilionaceae
17. Lagenaria leucantha duch. Lauki Cucurbitaceae
18. lens culinaris Medik. Masur Papilionaceae
19. L. cylindrica Linn. ghia taroi Cucurbitaceae
20. Lycopersicon esculentum Mill. Tamatar Solanaceae
21. Mentha spicata Linn. Pudina Lamiaceae
22. Momordica charantia Linn. Karela Cucurbitaceae
23. Oryza sativa Linn. Dhan Poaceae
24. Pennisetum tphoides (Burm.)Stapf. Bajra Poaceae
25. Phaseolus aureus Roxb. Moong Papilionaceae
26. P.mungo Linn. Urd Papilionaceae
27. Pisum sativum Linn. Matar Papilionaceae
28. Raphanus sativus Linn. Mooli Brassicaceae
29. Solanum melongena Linn. Baigan Solanaceae
30. Spinacia oleracia Linn. Palak Chenopodiaceae
31. Trachyspermumammi (L.) Sprague. Ajwain Apiaceae
32. trigonella foenum-graecum Linn. Methi Papilionaceae
33. Triticum aestivum Linn. Gehun Poaceae
34. Zea mays Linn. Makka Poaceae
35. Zingiber officinale Rosc. Adarak Zingiberaceae Source: (Feild Survey)
Vegetation of aquatic and marshy habitat: the plants of aquatic and wetland habitat found in
the BHU campus can be classified as follows:
1. Free-floating hydrophytes: These are in contact with water and air only. In the
stagnant water of these ponds some free floating hydrophytes are found. These are
commonly represented by Eichhornia crassipes (Mart.) Solms, Lemna paucicostata.
Hegel, Pistia stratiotes Linn and Wolfia arrhiza (Linn.) Horkel.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 109
2. Attached submerged hydrophytes: Eleocharis dulcis (Burm.f.) Trinius, Hrdrilla
verticillata (Linn.f.) Royle. And Vallisneria spiralis Linn. are the common attached
submerged hydrophytes. These hydrophytes make large patches on the substratum and
under surface of the pond water.
3. Attached hydrophytes with free floating leaves: these are in contact with oil, water as
well as air. Aponogeton natans(linn.) Eng., Nelumbo nucifera Gaertn. and Nymphaea
nouchali Burm. are the common species in ditches and ponds of the campus.
4. Weeds along roadsides: Places along the roads are occupied by different herbaceous
plant species. Some of the common weeds growing along roadsides in the study area
are: Cassia occidentalis Linn., C.tora Linn.,Argemone mexicana, Chirchitta, Xanthium
strumarium Ipomea spp. Parthenium hysterophorus Linn., Sida cordifolia Linn., Sida
rhombifolia Linn. etc.,
Road Side Trees: A few common trees planted along road-side are: Albizia lebbeck Linn.,
Alstonia scholaris (Linn.) R.Br., Anthocephalus chinensis (Lam.) Rich., Azadirachta indica Juss.,
Bauhinia purpurea Linn., B.variegata Linn., Bombax ceiba Linn., Callistemon lanceolatus DC.,
Cassia fistula Linn., Dalbergia sissoo Roxb., Delonix regia (Boj.) Raf., Eucalyptus citriodora
Hook., Ficus benghalensis Linn. F. religiosa Linn., Syzygium cumini (Linn.) Skeels, Tectona
grandis Linn. and terminalia arjua Roxb..Rare and Endangered Plant Species in the Study Area:
In the study area, no rare and endangered plant species was observed (Source: Red Data Book
of Indian Plants, N.P Nayar and A. P. K. Sastry, B.S.I. 1988).
5.11.2. Fauna
There is no protected and reserved forest present in the study area (10 km radius). The study
area has no forest land as evident from the topography map and land use records. The only
vegetation is scanty scrub-land that too in patches. The vegetation is dominated by acacia
species. Such scanty vegetation coupled by speedy industrial development and residential
development has left the area devoid of any significant faunal species or wildlife. List of flora
and fauna found in the study area has been obtained from the Working Plan of Forest
Department. The list has been be validated during the field visit and / or interviewing the
Zoology and Botany Professors of Banaras Hindu University, Local people or by cross checking
with other published documents / books.
The terrestrial fauna includes common invertebrates and vertebrates. 44 birds species, 10
species of reptiles and amphibians and 11 species of mammals are recorded in the study area.
Peacock is the only schedule-I species present in the study area. No other schedule-I species of
Wildlife (Protection) Act.,972 is present in the study area. The list of faunal species is given in
Table 5.15.
Table 5.15: List of Wildlife Found in Study Area
Mammals
S.No. Local name English name Zoological name Status (WLP Act.1972) Schedule
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 110
1. Siyar Jackal Canisa ureus II
2. Kharghosh Common Indian hare Lepus ruficaudatus IV
3. Gilhari Five stripped squirrel Funambuluspennant IV
4. Chamgadad Short nosed fruit bat Cynopterus sphinx V
5. Chooha Field rat Bandicota benghalensis V
6. Lomadi Indian fox Vulpus benghalensis II
7. Bandar Monkey Macaca mulatta III
8. Neola Mangoose Herpetes edwardsi IV
9. Jangli billi Jungle cat Felis chaus II
10. Shahi Indian porcupine Hystrix indica IV
11 Neel gai Blue bull Boselaphus tragocamelus
III
Source: (Feild Survey)
Amphibia and Reptiles
S.N. Common /English name
Zoological name Status (WLP Act.1972) Schedule
1. Common Karait Bungarus caeruleus IV
2. Dhaman/Indian Rat snake Ptyas mucosus II
3. Dhondwa/Water sanke Enhydris enhydris IV
4. Girgit (Garden lizard) Calotes versicolor -
5. Nag/Cobra Naja naja II
6. Russel viper Vipera ruselli II
8. Common toads Duttaphrynus melanostictus V
9. Small frog Microhyla ornata V Source: (Feild Survey)
Avifaunal: Avifauna is an important part of the ecosystem playing the various roles as
scavengers, pollinators, predators of insect, pest, etc. They are also one of the bio indicators of
different status of environment and affected by urbanization, industrialization and human
interference. They can be used as sensitive indicators of pollution and malfunction of
ecosystem.
The area is inhibited by residents forms of a large numbers of raptors like the Brahmini kite
(Haliasur Indus) and Hawk Eagle (Nasiaetus fasciatus) The nocturnal birds found in the area
are Bat (Pteropus giganteus) Owl (Bobo bobo), Bee-Eaters, Swallows (Hirundo rustica),
Shrikes, Fairy Birds and Wegtails. All the birds are found near fresh waters and wet irrigated
fields feeding actively on insects. List of bird species observed in the study area are given in
Table 5.16.
Table 5.16 : List of the Birds Surveyed / Recorded in the Study Area
Sl No Common Name Scientific Name
1 Blue Rock Pigeon Columbia livia
2. Bank Myna Acridotheres ginginianus
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 111
3. Baya Weaver Ploceus philippinus
4. Black Drongo Dicrurus adsimilis
5. Blossom headed Parakeet Psittacula Cyanocephala
6. Bleu throated Barbet Megalaima asiatica
7. Brown Shrike Lanius Cristatus
8. Brahmini Kite Haliasur Indus
9. Cattle Egret Bubukus ibis
10. Crow Pheasant Centropus sinensis
11. Crimson breasted Barbet Megalaima haemacephala
12. Common Swallow Hirundo rustica
13. Common Tailorbird Orthotomus sutorius
14. Common Kingfisher Alcedo atthis
15. Dove Streptopelia decaocto
16. Coppersmith Barbet Megalaima haemacephala
17. Greater cookoo Centropus sinensis
18. Grey backed shrike Lanius tephronotus
19. Golden Back Woodpecker Dinopium benghalense
20. Hawk Eagle Nasiaetus fasciatus
21. House Crow Corvus splendens
22. House Swift Apus affinis
23. Hoopoe Upupa spops
24. House Sparrow Passer domesticus
25. Indian Roller Coracias benghalensis
26. India Tree Pie Dendocitta vagabunda
27. Indian Ring Dove Streptopelia decapctp
28. Jungle crow Corvus macrorthynchos
29. Jungle Babler Turdoides striatus
30. Koel Eudynamys scolopacea
31. Kingfisher - Common Alcedo atthis
32. Little Brown Dove Streptopelia senegalensis
33. Large Pied Wagtail Motacilla maderaspatensis
34. Magpie Robin Copsychus saularis
35. Mayna - Brahminy Sturnus pagodarum
36. Mayna - Common Acridotheres tristis
37. Owl Bobo bobo
38. Peacock Pavao cristatus
39. Pariah Kite Milvus migrans
40. Pond Heron Ardeala grayii
41. Redwattled Lapwing Vanellus indicus
42. Red Turtle Dove Streptopelia tranquebarica
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 112
43. Rose ringed Parakeet Psittacula krameri
44. Redvented bulbul Pycnonotus cafer
44. Spotted Dove Streptopelia chinensis
Source: (Feild Survey)
Endangered, Rare and threatened,vulnerable Species- With reference to the list of endangered
species prepared by Zoological Survey of India (ZSI), Ministry of Environment and Forests,
Government of India, none of the terrestrial faunal species present in the study area belonged to
the 'endangered' category except turtle species like Chitra Indica, Geoclamis haniltonii. Dolphins
are reported in Ganga river however it has not been sited in the study area.
Schedule-I Fauna: With reference to the list of schedule-I fauna listing of wildlife Protection Act
1972, No schedule-I terrestrial fauna (except peacock which is of least concern category of
Wildlife Protection) is present within 10 km area of the proposed terminal site.
5.11.3. Kashi Turtle Sanctuary
Location: Kashi Turtle Sanctuary is located about 2.27 km in north direction from the proposed
Ramnagar terminal. Map showing proposed terminal, Ramnagar fort and location of the turtle
sanctuary is given in Figure 5.12.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 113
Figure 5.12 : Location of Turtle Sanctuary and Other Environment Features
Establishment of Turtle Wild Life Sanctuary (Legal Status)
To safeguard the released turtles and their natural habitat in the Ganga River, under the U.P.
State Administration Forests Act, Section-3, Part-4170/14-3-62, dated 21-12-1989 the area of
the mid-section of the Ganga River, Flowing through Varanasi city and measuring around 7-km
has been declared as the Turtle Wild Life Sanctuary under which, the area between Ramnagar
Fort to Malviya Rail/Road Bridge (Raj Ghat Bridge) has been declared as the Turtle Wild Life
Sanctuary, Varanasi, Along with the turtles, other species of aquatic animals which inhabit this
area are also being provided complete protection. The Sanctuary forms the part of Ganga
Action Plan.
History
According to a mention in the religious scriptures of the Hindu it is believed that if a person dies
in the Holy city of Kashi or his funeral rites are performed at Kashi, the person will have access
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 114
to the heaven and will be free from the cycle of birth and rebirth. In pursuance of this belief
people from far and near bring dead to city of Varanasi for performing the last rites at the
numerous Ghats on the bank of River Ganga. Brunt and and half brunt corpuses are immersed
in the river and are a major reason for the increased pollution level with waste garbage dumping
in the Ganga. With this in mind the Ganga Action Plan support the organic removal of dead
bodies by supporting the breeding and release of turtles in the river water.
The basic idea to setup the sanctuary was to club the dwindling of turtle population which is on
the verge of extension and also by releasing carnivorous turtles, that would feed on the remains
of the corpses and would help in reducing the organic and harmful waste emanating from the
corpses and also in the process providing for food to the diminishing population of turtles and
help them survive, grow and breed and increase their number. Under the Turtle Rehabilitation
Plan Turtle Breeding Center were set up in Sarnath.
This in turn leads to further addition to river pollution. In order to check this biological pollution
and to make River Ganges free of pollutants, Ganga Action Plan (GAP) Phase I, has started in
the year 1986 by the Govt. of India, with a tortoise breeding project with its breeding center at
Sarnath where tortoise (both herbivores &Carnivores) are hatched and reared for one to one
and half year and then are left into River Ganges to remove the bio-pollutants like partly
cremated and dead bodies directly thrown in the river. The eggs of these turtles are specially
procured from river Chambal.
Tortoise were released annually in the Ganga River. To protect these tortoise and secure their
habitat Kachhua Sanctuary, spreading over seven km. from Rajghat (Malviya Rail Road Bridge)
to Ramnagar Fort, was declared Wildlife Protection Zone, under U.P. Govt. Order (No. 4170/04-
3-62/89 dated 21-12-1989) under the provisions of the Wildlife Protection Act 1972, after
launching the Ganga Action Plan (GAP). The existence of motor boats and sand mining in the
protected zone of the Sanctuary is prohibited, as tortoise lay eggs in the sand of the river banks.
Tortoise Sanctuary has its own importance to clean the water. In the Kachhua (tortoise)
Sanctuary mainly Aspederites Gangetic (self-shell turtles), Geoclamis, Hamiltonai, Chitra Indica
& Lasimous which are carnivorous species and hard shelled herbivorous tortoise- Pechra,
Kachhua, Sundri Kachhua, Kachhua Tentoria, Kachhua Tongoka are in abundance. The year
wise details of turtle released in the sanctuary is provided in following Table 5.17.
Table 5.17 Year wise details of Turtle Released in the Sanctuary
S. No. Turtle eggs Collection yr.
No. of eggs brought to the department
No. of turtles from the eggs
No. of turtles dispatched by the
department
1 1987 5290 3126 100
2 1988 9402 4271 -
3 1989 12006 6928 2554
4 1990 13879 6845 3677
5 1991 9997 5386 6773
6 1992 5116 3535 8224
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 115
7 1993 - - 7592
From year 1994 to 2003 due to unavailability of the funds, turtle rehabilitation work was stopped. Again in year 2002-2003, fund were granted to Turtle Rehabilitation Centre, Sarnath and the work of turtle rehabilitation was started again. Details given below:
3 2005-06 3000 1520 -
4 2006-07 3000 1777 -
5 2007-08 2000 1110 1549
6 2008-09 2000 1154 1777
7 2009-10 2000 1028 1110
8 2010-11 2000 1042 1154
9 2011-12 2000 1333 1028
10 2012-13 2000 831 1042
11 2013-14 2000 0 1333
Source: (Office of Kashi Turtle Sanctuary)
Sarnath Turtle Breeding Center
At the Sarnath center, the eggs of the carnivorous species of turtles (the “Kathawa”-Aspadiritis
Gangatic) were brought from the Chambal River-and the new-borns were brought up at the
breeding center under controlled conditions. One hatching room and three artificial ponds has
been created in the center where these turtle where tortoise (both herbivores & Carnivores) are
hatched and reared for one to one and half year. Once they reached the right age they were
released in the waters of the Ganga River.
Under this plan, during the period 1987-1992, 55690 turtle eggs were brought to the Sarnath
Breeding Centre from the Chambal River, out of which 30091 new borns were reared, of these
28920 were released in the Ganga River. In the period 2005-2006, eggs were again brought
from the Chambal River and 3297 new borns were reared and in March 2009 and of these,
1549 were released in the Ganga River. Photographs of Turtle breeding center is provided in
Figure 5.13.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 116
Figure 5.13: Turtle Breeding Centre Sarnath
5.11.4. Aquatic Ecosystem
The aquatic eco-biology is highly dependent on the type of Aquatic ecosystem, The running
water ecosystem is called as lotic Aquatic system. This means it is the running freshwater
(limnotic) eco- system. The volume of water and its velocity are among the basic factors along
with the physico-chemical attributes of an aquatic ecosystem, which govern and impact the
biotic communities in that area. This biotic community composition in turn is highly sensitive to
seasonal and climatic changes round the year. However, any given ecosystem under reference
becomes seasonally static, unless any unforeseen or sudden geo-climatic situations do not take
place, after few years of its existence in that particular geographic area. Here below are given
our observations related to the ecologically, economically naturally occurring important biotic
constituents of Ganga river system around Ramnagar area.
The freshwater ecosystems are live, highly dynamic but equally very sensitive and fragile
environments. A freshwater ecosystem is normally rich in biodiversity. No other group of
organisms is believed to be more at risk than freshwater animals. As a result the riverine
ecosystems are among the most productive life support systems in the world and are of
immense socio-economic, ecological, commercial and bio-esthetic importance to mankind.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 117
With reference to the Gangetic riverine ecosystem along with its major and minor tributaries and
their secondary and tertiary contributing tributaries the whole system forms a web of life of its
own creation and sustenance. The reasons of this status have been the undisturbed ecological
flows of this river web system since millenniums. However, last five-six decades have seen
tremendous changes in the behavior and the quality of this gangetic riverine ecosystem, mainly
on account of anthropogenic interventions. Therefore, it becomes highly imperative to
understand the behavior of the existing eco-system and its components before embarking on
to any new multi-pronged project which would be totally dependent on the course of the
existing riverine ecosystem, its constituents and the anticipated impacts of initiating,
establishing and running a totally hitherto unknown physical system over and along the river
body, including its riparian appendages. It is most important under the prevailing
circumstances of our conservation and restoration policies for a sustained healthy freshwater
environment. It becomes greatly critical and vulnerable when we come across the ganga river
ecology, on account of our sentiments attached to it.
Sampling Location: Sample for the phytoplankton and zooplankton monitoring were collected
from following two locations. Sampling site is located in upstream and downstream of the
proposed inland water terminal. Details of sampling location is given in Table 5.18.
Table -5.18: Details of Aquatic Sampling Locations
Code Locations Remarks
A-1 Ganga River, u/s of proposed Terminal Fresh water
A-2 Ganga River, d/s of Proposed Terminal Fresh water
Biotic Resources of River Ganga at Varanasi: To be precise we are here concerned with
the major bioti component of river system which is commercially (primarily) and eco-
environmentally important to the riparian human population, their economic status ( through self
employment and secondary market stake holders acting at short time intervals and impacting
long time policies. In that light Gangariver and its surrounding landin the study area is used
largely for fisheries and boating purposes. The fishery resources of the Ganga river system are
of tremendous economic and nutritional sustenance to fisherman of the study area, Ganga
River being the main source of water body in the reference area.
Plankton: Phyto-plankton & Zoo-plankton:
Like any other aquatic ecosystem the ecology of the Ganga River depends on the primary
producers. And primary producers are those micro- floristic communities called Phyto-plankton,
which convert the solar energy with the raw material from earth & atmosphere to organic form,
which in turn in the food chain of nature is consumed by the primary, secondary and sometimes
by the tertiary consumers of the ecosystem at various trophic levels.
Phytoplankton are most important, because these are the first food of new born fishes. Not only
this, but many fishes depended for their nutritional requirements on these micro-phytoplankton,
throughout their life.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 118
Two sampling locations were identified for sampling. Surface water samples were collected,
counted and identified by using the APHA method. The water samples were collected in sterile
glass bottles. The phytoplankton‟s were collected after filtering the water through a plankton net
made up of bolting silk cloth No.25. 5% formalin solution was added for preservation of
phytoplankton and zooplanktons. The systematic identification of phytoplankton and
zooplanktons was made by standard keys of APHA.
Phytoplankton: Phytoplankton forms the basis of food chain in any aquatic water body. The
diversity and abundance of phytoplankton mainly depends on the region, type of water body,
either lentic or lotic, the nutrient flux in the system and the sunlight available for photosynthesis.
These factors together form the dynamics of phytoplankton productivity over the seasons. The
phytoplankton of given water body determines the zooplankton populations and the fish
productivity of the ecosystem. Phytoplankton group reported from the sampled locations are
Basillariophyceae, Chlorophyceae, Cyanophyceae, Xanthophyceae and Euglenophyceae
members. Dominance of Bacillariophyceae members followed by Chrophyceae and
Cyanophyceae was observed in studied samples. The list of phytoplankton recorded in Ganga
River during study period is presented in Table 5.19.
Table 5.19: List of Phytoplankton’s Observed in Sampling Locations
Sr. No.
Phytoplankton Group
Phytoplankton Ganga River upstream of Terminal Site
Ganga River downstream of Terminal Site
1 Bacillariophyceae
Amphora sp. + -
2 Asterionella sp. + +
3 Biddulphia sp. + +
4 Chaetoceros sp. - +
5 Cyclotella sp. + -
6 Cymbella sp. - +
7 Diatoma sp. + +
8 Fragilaria sp. + +
9 Gomphonema sp. + +
10 Gyrosigma sp. + +
11 Melosira sp. + -
12 Navicula sp. + +
13 Nitzschia sp. + -
14 Pinnularia sp. + +
15 Pleurosigma sp. + +
16
Chlorophyceae
Actinastrum sp. - +
17 Chlorella sp. + +
18 Closterium sp. + -
19 Coelastrum sp. + =
20 Conococcus sp. + -
21 Eudorina sp. + +
22 Gonium sp. + +
23 Hormidium sp. + -
24 Microspora sp. + +
25 Pandorina sp. + +
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 119
26 Pediastrum sp. - +
27 Spirogyra sp. + +
28 Ulothrix sp. + +
29 Anabeana sp. + +
30 Calothrix sp. + +
31 Nostoc sp. + +
32 Oscillatoria sp. + +
33 Phormidium sp. + +
34 Rivularia sp. + -
35 Schizothrix sp. - +
36 Spirulina sp., etc. + +
37 Xanthophyceae
Bumillaria sp. + +
38 Chlorobotrys sp. + -
39
Euglenophyceae
Astasis sp. + -
40 Euglena sp. + +
41 Peronia sp. + +
42 Phacus sp. - +
Note: + denote present and – denotes absent
Zooplankton: The zooplankton of the aquatic water body are the primary consumers and also
in cases secondary producers which play an important role for the fisheries of that system. The
diversity and abundance of zooplankton also depends on whether the water body is eutrophic or
oligotrophic. They also are good representation of the ecosystem health. The amount and type
of pollutants in the water body impacts and determines the type of zooplankton species, in any
particular habitat / niche. Among the zooplankton group, Brachionoussps.(Rotifera) had highest
percentage composition and the lowest percentage composition was of Asplanchana sps. In the
total zooplankton Cyprissps and Gastrocypris sp., also occurred in the sampled water bodies.
The list of zooplanktons recorded in fresh water bodies in study area during study Table 5.20:
Table-5.20 List of Zooplanktons Observed in Ganga River: At Ramnagar site
Sr. No.
Family Phytoplankton Ganga River upstream of Terminal Site
Ganga River downstream of Terminal Site
1
Protozoa
Arcella sp. - +
2 Chilodonella sp. + -
3 Difflugia sp. - +
4 Globigerina sp. + +
5 Holophyra sp. + +
6 Noctiluca sp. + +
7 Spathidium sp. - +
8 Sphenoderia sp. + -
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 120
9 Tintinnopsis sp. + +
16
Rotifers
Anura sp. - +
17 Asplanchna sp. + +
18 Brachionus sp. + -
19 Filinia sp. - +
20 Horaelle sp. + -
21 Keratella sp. + +
22 Notholca sp. - +
23 Rotaria sp. + -
29 Copepoda Cyclops sp. - +
30 Diaptomus sp. + +
37 Cladocera
Bosmina sp. - +
Ceriodaphnia sp. + -
38 Cydorus sp. + +
39
Euglenophyceae
Cypris sp. - +
40 Gastrocypris sp., etc.
+ +
Note: + denote present and – denotes absent
Zoo- benthos:
Benthos is the community of organisms which live on, in, or near the riverbed, also known as
the benthic zone. This community lives in or near sedimentary environments, Many organisms
adapted to deep-water pressure cannot survive in the upper parts of the water column. Because
light does not penetrate very deep water, the energy source for deep benthic ecosystems is
often organic matter from higher up in the water column which drifts down to the depths. This
dead and decaying matter sustains the benthic food chain; most organisms in the benthic zone
are scavengers or detritivores. The zoo-benthos observed in the river water is listed below in
Table 3.21
Table-3.21: Zoo-benthic fauna at Ramnagar.
Sl. No. Gastropoda Annelids Insects
1 Bellamya sp. Oligochaetes Argia sp.
2 Gabbia sp. Polychaetes, etc. Caenis sp.
3 Lymnaea sp.
Cloeon sp.
4 Thiaria sp., etc. Enallagma sp., etc.
Fisher Man Says: Among the first rate stake-holders to these water produces of fishes,
Fisherman community is at the base of the pyramid of economy here. As per our discussion
with fisherman the fishes have suffered serious decline in the Ganga River stretch of Varanasi
due to overfishing, sewage water pollution and construction of reservoirs, barrages and
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 121
abstraction of riverine water along the riparian areas. The loss of fish fauna is not in terms
quality ( that is body size / body wt. ), but also in terms their species diversity. According to older
reports the area had around 50-60 species of fishes in this region, which has come down to
around 25 to 36 species, presently. For example according to fishermen the famous illesh fish
Hilsas ps. are no more visible around, which used to migrate up to Allahabad only about a
decade back. It is because of the construction of barrages on Ganga river at Farakka, coupled
with a high rate of pollution along its course..
The fishing boats used by the fisherman are mostly indigenous and non-mechanized. The boats
are designed to suit local conditions. The simplest and most primitive types of boats used for
fishing in the river are the rafts and dongas, operated in calm water. As per the discussion with
the fisherman of the study area the average fish production (catch) is 5 to 10 kg/day.
Various type of fishing gears are in operation in the riverine system. They are designed to suit
the local condition such as depth of water, water current, desired fish to catch etc. some of them
selective to the particular species. The most common gears used by the fisherman are chanta,
Mahajal, Ghanali, Bhanwarjal, Gochail, Dodandi etc.
Fish Fauna of River ganga at Ramnagar area: Fishes are the consumers in River ecosystem.
The fish population of Ganga is largely dependent on the micro-flora and fauna produced by the
river system including phytoplankton, zooplankton, periphyton and zoobenthos which
establishes itself in the form of food chain. Among the preferred freshwater food fishes are
include species of major carps like, Rohu (Labeorohita) mrigal (cirrhinusmrigala), katla(
catlacatla) , kalbasu ( labeocalbasu ), and cat fishes like padhan ( wallagoattu ) ) tengras (
Mystusteengara, ) and Magur ( Clariasbatrachus ), Singhi ( Heteropneutesfossilis ), Tilapia (
Oreocromissps. ),Kavai ( anabas testudineus ), Mahfish ( Barbussps. ), to name a few, around
the Ramnagar area of Ganga river. Common fishes identified during the field visit are provided
in following Table 5.22.
Table-5.22 List of Fishes observed in Study Area during Study Period
S. No. Genus, species Common Name
1 Sperataseenghala Tengra
2 Cyprinuscarpio Common carp
3 Labeobata (Hamilton) Bata
4 Oreochromisniloticusniloticus Tilapia
5 Rita buchnani Bail gagra
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 122
6 Labeorohita (Hamilton) Rohu
7 Clariasbatrachus (Linnaeus) Mangur
8 Anabas testudineus (Bloch) Kavai or sumha
9 Cirrhinusmrigala (Hamilton) Nain
10 Catlacatla Katla
11 Wallagoattu Padhni
12 Heteropneustes fossils Singhi
13 Labeocalbasu Kalabasa
14 Barbus tor Mahasir
15 Mastacembelusarmatus Balm
Source: (Feild Survey)
Chelonian Fauna (Ganga Turtle) Among the important reptilian fauna turtles had been in abundance along the course of river
Ganga, till few decades back. [These were / are regarded as the scavengers of the river along with
scavenger carnivore fishes like Wallaoattu, Bagariussps. Mystussps. And few other minor cat fishes like
Clarias, Mystusvittatus etc.]
Therefore the existing species of freshwater turtles (the group is known as Chelonians: order
Chelonia, class - Reptilia) in Ganga river are also ecologically very important . We visited the
Kashi turtle sanctuary, which is located about 2.7 km to the north of the proposed terminal at
Ramnagar .Details of the sanctuary are already discussed in the above sections. In the
Kachhua (tortoise) Sanctuary mainly Aspederites Gangetic (self shell turtles), Geoclamis,
Hamiltonai, ChitraIndica & Lasimous which are carnivorous species and hard shelled
herbivorous tortoise- Pechra, Kachhua, SundriKachhua, Kachhua Tentoria, KachhuaTongoka
are in abundance. Photographs of fishes observed in the study area is provided in Figure 5.15.
Labeorohita (Hamilton) – (Rohu) Clariasbatrachus (Linnaeus) – (Mangur)
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 123
Anabas testudineus (Bloch) – (Kavai) Rita buchnani (Belgagra)
CyprinusCarpio ( Common Carp) Oreochromisniloticusniloticus (Tilapia)
Labeobata Sperataseenghala(Tengra)
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 124
Figure 5.15 Photographs of Fishes Observed during Study Period
5.12. Social Impact Assessment
The social impact assessment included gathering information on the socio-economic profile of
the project area which was compiled through secondary sources which is the published data of
the Government of India. Secondly, in order to understand the socioeconomic profile of the
affected families a primary census socio-economic survey (SES) is will be carried out as
necessary. The information from secondary sources enabled the project team to understand the
general socio-economic issues if any in the project area and the primary information enabled
the project to understand the following issues:
The socio-economic profile of the affected families;
The category and extent of loss due to the project development; and
The demography, literacy level, the occupation pattern, etc. about the project affected
families.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 125
The ensuing section provides the analysis of the secondary and the primary information thus
gathered
Published information analysis on the socio-economic profile of the project area
The Ramnagar terminal will be location in Varanasi (Banaras) of the state of Uttar Pradesh.
Uttar Pradesh is the largest state in India. The administrative and legislative capital is Lucknow
and the judicial capital is Allahabad. Other notable cities include Agra, Aligarh, Ayodhya,
Varanasi (also known as Benares and Kashi), Etawah, Kanpur, Mirzapur and Deoband.
Neighbouring states are Uttaranchal, Himachal Pradesh, Haryana, Delhi, Rajasthan, Madhya
Pradesh, Chhattisgarh, Jharkhand and Bihar. Uttar Pradesh also shares its border with Nepal.
The published information included the websites of the Government of India the Census of India
data 2011, which was utilized to enlist the socio-economic profile of the project area. The
analysis of the data is provided in the sections below.
Table 5.23 shows the population of Uttar Pradesh. Out of the total population of 19.99 crore,
10.04 crore people are males and remaining 9.53 crore people are females. Out of the total
population, around 78% people are residing in rural areas and remaining in urban areas.
Table 5.23: Uttar Pradesh State Population
State TRU No. of HH Total
Population
Total Male Total Female
Uttar Pradesh
Total 33448035 199812341 104480510 95331831
Rural 25685942 155317278 80992995 74324283
Urban 7762093 44495063 23487515 21007548
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.24 shows the literacy population of Uttar Pradesh. Out of the total literate population of
11.43 crore, 6.83 crore males are literate and remaining 4.61 crores are female literates. Nearly
75% of the total literate populations are in rural areas.
Table 5.24: Uttar Pradesh State Literacy Level
State TRU Population
Literate Male Literate Female Literate
Uttar Pradesh
Total 114397555 68234964 46162591
Rural 85284680 51793688 33490992
Urban 29112875 16441276 12671599
Source: Census of India, 2011
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 126
Table 5.25 shows the SC and ST population of Uttar Pradesh. Out of the total population of
19.99 crores,4.13 crore (21%) population belongs to Schedule Cast and 11.34 lakhs belongs to
Schedule Tribes, which is nearly 0.57% of the total population.
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.26 shows the Worker population of Uttar Pradesh. Out of the total population of 19.99
crore, 6.58 crores are working population. Out of these 4.98 crores are male worker and
remaining 1.59 crores are female workers. Out of these only 21% (1.38 crores) are working in
urban areas.
Table 5.26: Uttar Pradesh State Worker Population
State TRU Total Work
Population
Total Male
Worker
Total Female
Worker
Uttar Pradesh
Total 65814715 49846762 15967953
Rural 51950980 38352879 13598101
Urban 13863735 11493883 2369852
Source: Census of India, 2011
District Varanasi, Uttar Pradesh
About Varanasi
Varanasi, one of world's oldest living cities, is rightly called the religious capital of India. Also
known as Banaras or Benaras, this holy city is located in the south-eastern part of the state of
Uttar Pradesh in northern India. It rests on the left bank of the holy river Ganga (Ganges), and is
one of the seven sacred spots for Hindus. Varanasi a place for pilgrimage, and also known as a
great center of learning, and a place known for its heritage in music, literature, art and craft.
It is a cherished name in the art of silk weaving. The Banarasi silk sarees and brocades are
prized all over the world. The classical musical styles or 'gharanas' are woven into the lifestyle
of the people and are accompanied by musical instruments that are manufactured in Varanasi.
The ancient city of Varanasi was not built in a day. The city has two remnants of a holy past: the
first being Rajghat plateau, where the archeological findings of wares date back to the period of
Table 5.25: Uttar Pradesh State Population SC and ST
State TRU Population SC Population ST
Uttar Pradesh
Total 41357608 1134273
Rural 35685227 1031076
Urban 5672381 103197
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 127
very existence of urban settlement and the second being Sarnath, where Buddha gave his first
sermon, “Turning the wheel of law” in 528 BC. Later during 3rd century King Ashoka built a
monastery township there, which continued its existence till 12th century and was later
destroyed.
Since ancient times the natural and cultural landscapes of the city have retained an active social
role in contemporary society closely associated with the traditional way of life. The city is a place
of pilgrimage and a holy site for sacred baths in the Ganga River, to have a good death, to get
relief from transmigration, to learn and receive spiritual merit, etc. The city has still maintained
its traditions. In spite of several downfalls and upheavals, traditions are fully alive even today8.
Being the holiest city of Hinduism, the impact of the religion is found everywhere in the city – the
chanting bells and the monotonous, but oddly soothing, chant of Sanskrit hymns, in the fragrant
flower offerings, and the colored powders that are sold in a myriad roadside shops which
decorate the foreheads of the devout, in the tens of thousands of worshippers and the
thousands who offer them salvation or services.
Ghats with stairways along the Ganga with presence of “dying homes”, charitable homes,
pilgrims‟ rest houses, are some of the city‟s unique characteristics. Apart from that, silk weaving
and sari making, metal, wood and terracotta handicrafts, toy making, particular painting forms,
etc., comprise the continuity of historical and cultural tradition. Varanasi is famous for its fairs
and festivals with respect to variety, distinction, time, sacred sites, performers, viewers and
sideshows.
Varanasi town lies between the 25015‟ to 25022‟ North latitude and 82057‟ to 83001‟ East
longitude. The River Ganga only here flows South to North having the world famous ghats on
the left bank of the river. The highest flood level of river Ganga was 73.90m (1978) and the
lowest river water level is approximately 58m. It is at an elevation of 80.71 metres above mean
sea level.
Linkages and Connectivity
Varanasi is well connected by road, rail and air with other parts of the country. The distance
from the major cities are Delhi-750 km, Lucknow-286 km and 125 km from Allahabad. There are
three national highways i.e. NH-2, NH-56 and NH-29 and four state highways i.e. SH-87, SH-73,
SH-74 and SH-98 passing through the heart of the city. The linkages provided by the National
highways are, NH 2- G.T. Road from Mughal Sarai to Allahabad; NH 29- Varanasi to
Gorakhpur, Kushinagar; and NH 56- Varanasi to Jaunpur Lucknow.
These National Highways and state highways have high passenger traffic as these roads
provide a good connectivity to the surrounding areas in the U.P. state as well as to metropolitan
cities like Delhi and Kolkata. The Grand trunk road or NH2 forms the main transportation spine
of the city.
8 Prof. Rana B P Singh (2005), “Life in Historic Urban Landscape of Varanasi, a Heritage City of India”, Geography
Department, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi, UP
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 128
A bypass is being constructed along the Eastern edge of the city to relieve the burden off NH-2.
Another ring road is under consideration along the Western edge of the city to divert the traffic
and provide better connectivity to the newer developments coming up in the Trans Varuna
Region.
Varanasi is well connected by railways with broad gauge. There are three rail lines entering to
the city from Lucknow, Bhadoi and Allahabad and is diverted in two lines to Gorakhpur and
Mughal Sarai. The city lies on Delhi-Kolkata rail route of North Eastern Railways, which is the
broad gauge. A rail line connects the town with Sarnath. The other cities having good
connectivity through railways are Patna, Guwahati, Chennai, Mumbai, Gwalior, Meerut,
Lucknow, Kanpur and Allahabad.
The town also has an airport at a distance of about 24 km away from the city. There are flights
to Varanasi from Agra, Bhubaneshwar, Kolkata, Delhi, Gorakhpur, Khajuraho, Lucknow, Raipur
and Kathmandu (Nepal). It is on a regular aviation route of Delhi to Kolkata and Bhuvaneshwar.
It is also the aviation gateway to Nepal.
Basic issues in Varanasi
There are several issues facing the millions of people who live and visit the city of Varanasi. By
the time the Ganga reaches the end of the city, Ganga is polluted–her waters are grey, stinking,
and a breeding ground for water-borne diseases such as dysentery, cholera, and typhoid,
among others. An estimated 66% of the local population of Varanasi faces some sort of water-
borne disease each year.
The infrastructure of Varanasi has never been properly developed to fit the booming population.
The sewage lines that exist today were created by the British for a population of 200,000.
Many residents do not have access to any sort of toilet, and thus use the river. No proper solid
waste disposal has ever been created for the city. Many residents do not have access to any
sort of clean, purified drinking water. Thus they use the polluted Ganga for their everyday
needs, such as drinking, bathing, cooking, and doing laundry. Further, the sewer lines and
sewage treatment plants that are present in Varanasi do not work, as they rely heavily on
electricity (and electricity does not work in the city for many hours each day). During monsoon
season, the floods force these facilities to cease their function entirely. Thus, raw untreated
sewage is directly dumped every day into the Ganga, Varuna, and Assi rivers at approximately
thirty sources. This accounts for 95% of the pollution in Ganga at Varanasi, and it is making
people sick.
The other 5% of the pollution in the Ganga at Varanasi comes from non-point sources, such as
cremation grounds. Thousands of cremations happen along the banks of the river in Varanasi,
and the river simply is filled with ash and half-burnt bodies
Varanasi district demographics
The demography, occupation pattern and the other socio-economic features of Varansi is
provided in this section of the report.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 129
Table 5.27 shows the population of affected Varanasi district. Total population of Varanasi
district is 36.76 lakhs (1.84% of UP). Out of which 19.21 lakhs are males and 17.54 are females.
Out of these 15.59 lakh population resides in Urban areas.
Table 5.27: Population of the District
State District TRU No. of HH Total
Population
Total
Male
Total
Female
Uttar Pradesh Varanasi
Total 560162 3676841 1921857 1754984
Rural 306978 2079790 1076526 1003264
Urban 253184 1597051 845331 751720
Source: Census of India, 2011
The growth rate of population in Varanasi District declined between 1991 – 2001 from 33% to
17.15%, however in the past decade the growth rate has been about 25.16%.
Table 5.28 shows the literacy population of Varanasi district. Total literate population of
Varanasi district is 24.03 lakhs. Out of which 13.89 lakhs are males and 10.01 lakhs are
females. Literate population are more in rural areas (54.14%) than urban areas.
Table 5.28: Literacy in the District
State District TRU Population Literate Male
Literate
Female
Literate
Uttar Pradesh Varanasi
Total 2403903 1389116 1014787
Rural 1301232 769456 531776
Urban 1102671 619660 483011
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.29 shows the SC and ST population of Varanasi district. Out of the total population of
36.76 lakhs,4.86 lakhs belongs to schedule caste and only 0.28 lakhs (5.88%) belongs to
schedule tribes. Out of these 73.64% of SC and 67% of ST are in rural area.
Table 5.29: SC and ST population of the District
State District TRU Population SC Population ST
Uttar Pradesh Varanasi
Total 486958 28617
Rural 358612 19144
Urban 128346 9473
Source: Census of India, 2011
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 130
Table 5.30 shows the worker population of Varanasi district. Total 12.20 lakhs people belongs
to working class. Out of which 9.21 lakhs are males and 2.99 are females.
Table 5.30: Work population of the District
State District TRU Total Worker
Population
Total Male
Worker
Total Female
Worker
Uttar Pradesh Varanasi
Total 1220708 921234 299474
Rural 695418 496488 198930
Urban 525290 424746 100544
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.32 shows the Tehsil population of Varanasi Tehsil. Total population of Varanasi Tehsil
was 30.49 lakh, out of which 16.03 lakhs are males and 14.45 lakhs are females.
Table 5.31: Tehsil Wise Population of district
District Tehsil TRU No. of HH Total
Population
Total
Male
Total
Female
Varanasi Varanasi
Total 467569 3049543 1603805 1445738
Rural 216031 1463875 764427 699448
Urban 251538 1585668 839378 746290
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.30 shows the literacy of Varanasi Tehsil. Total 20.07 lakhs people are literate in
Varanasi Tehsil. Out of which 11.57 are males and 8.50 are females.
Table 5.32: Tehsil wise literacy population of District
District Tehsil TRU Population
Literate
Male
Literate
Female
Literate
Varanasi Varanasi
Total 2007746 1157401 850345
Rural 912382 542025 370357
Urban 1095364 615376 479988
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.33 shows the SC and ST population of Varanasi Tehsil. Total 3.69 lakhs are SC and
0.24 lakhs are females.
Table 5.33: Tehsil wise SC and ST population of District
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 131
District Tehsil TRU Population SC Population ST
Varanasi Varanasi
Total 369361 24012
Rural 243343 14630
Urban 126018 9382
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.34 shows the work population of Varanasi Tehsil. Total 10.01 lakhs population are
working, out of which 7.76 lakhs are males and 2.24 are females.
Table 5.34: Tehsil wise work population of District
District Tehsil TRU Total Worker
Population
Total Male
Worker
Total Female
Worker
Varanasi Varanasi
Total 1001113 776204 224909
Rural 480279 354383 125896
Urban 520834 421821 99013
Source: Census of India, 2011
Ramnagar – location of the multi-modal IWAI terminal
Ramnagar is a city and a municipal board in Varanasi district in the Indian state of Uttar
Pradesh. Ramnagar has a fort known as Ramnagar Fort which is still the residence of King of
Varanasi (Benares).
The demographics of Ramnagar is detailed in the ensuing section of this report.
Table 5.35 shows the population in the proposed terminal area in Ramnagar town. Total
population of Ramnagar town is 49132.
Table 5.35 : Town where the Terminal is to be located along NW-1 - Population
District and Tehsil Village/Town No. of
HH
Total
Population Total Male
Total
Female
District: Varanasi
Tehsil: Varanasi Ramnagar
7729 49132 26071 23061
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.36 shows the SC and ST population in the proposed terminal area in Ramnagar town.
Table 5.36: Town where the Terminal is to be located along NW-1- SC and ST population
Tehsil Village/Town Population SC Population ST
District: Varanasi Ramnagar 5340 191
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 132
Table 5.36: Town where the Terminal is to be located along NW-1- SC and ST population
Tehsil Village/Town Population SC Population ST
Tehsil: Varanasi
Source: Census of India, 2011
Table 5.37 shows the Literate and work population in the proposed terminal area in Ramnagar
town. 70% of the total Ramnagar town population is literate and 30% of the total population are
working.
Table 5.37: Town where the Terminal is to be located along NW-1 - Literacy and work population
Tehsil Village/Town
Populati
on
Literate
Male
Literat
e
Femal
e
Literat
e
Total
Worker
Populati
on
Total
Male
Worke
r
Total
Femal
e
Worke
r
District:
Varanasi
Tehsil:
Varanasi
Ramnagar
34400 19484 14916 14895 12794 2101
Source: Census of India, 2011
This location has a population of about 49000 and about 7700 households. However there is a
an insignificant population being affected adversely due to this project development. The details
of the adversely affected population is discussed in the section below.
5.12.1. Tourism and Heritage
The ancient city of Varanasi is believed to have existed since beginning of the earth and finds its
mention in the Arthavedas6. Varanasi, owing to its rich traditional fabric and ghats, attracts more
than 30 lakh domestic and international tourists each year. The city, an important centre for
religious tourism in India is also a gateway to the Buddhist circuit; with significant foreign tourist
coming from Japan, China, Malaysia, etc. Being the holiest city of Hinduism, the impact of the
religion is found everywhere in the city. The city of Varanasi is unique in the architectural, artistic
and religious expressions of traditional Indian culture and is, even today, a living example of this
culture.
Tourism
Ghats
Varanasi is famous for its Ghats. Ghats are steps that lead down to River Ganga. The crescent
shaped bank of river Ganges houses 84 ghats on the western bank spread over a distance of
6.8 km. Several rituals and religious ceremonies are associated with these ghats and pilgrims
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 133
travel from all over the country for prayers, holy dip in the river Ganga, cremation, religious
offerings, etc. The most important ghats are Dasaswamedh, Harish Chandra, Manikarnika,
Panchaganga, and Assi ghat. Map showing Location of Ghats along Ganga River and other
sensitive features is provided in Figure 5.12.
Dasaswamedh Ghat: It is one of the most important ghats of Varanasi. It is located near „Kashi
Vishwanath Temple’. It is belived that on this very Ghat ten horses were sacrifised by Lord
Brahma to allow Lord Shiva to return from a period of banishment. In spite of the fact that
Dasaswamedh is one of the oldest ghats of Varanasi, dating back to many thousand years, the
ghat has remained unspoilt and clean. Dasaswamedh provides a beautiful and colourful
riverfront view. A large number of Sadhus can be seen performing religious rites on this ghat.
Devotees must not miss the opportunity of visiting this ghat in the evening when the Aarti is
performed. During Dipawali festival, thousands of earthen lamps are immersed in the waters of
the holy Ganges and the floating lamps give a divine look to the river at dusk.
Harish Chandra Ghat: Harish Chandra Ghat is name after a mythological King Harish
Chandra, who once worked at the cremation ground here for the perseverance of truth and
charity. It is believed that the Gods rewarded him for his resolve, charity and truthfulness and
restored his lost throne and his dead son to him. Harish Chandra Ghat is one of the two
cremation Ghats (the other being Manikarnika Ghat) and is some times referred as Adi
Manikarnika (the original creation ground). Hindus from distant places bring the dead bodies of
their near and dear ones to the Harish Chandra Ghat for cremation. In Hindu mythology it is
believed that if a person is cremated at the Harish Chandra Ghat, that person gets salvation or
"moksha". The Harish Chandra Ghat was somewhat modernized in late 1980's, when an electric
crematorium was opened here.
Manikarnika Ghat: It is one of the oldest and most sacred Ghats of Varanasi. People belive
that being burned here provides an instant gateway to liberlisation from the cycle of births and
rebirths. Lying at the centre of five tirthas, ghat symbolises both creation and destruction. At
Manikarnika Ghat, the mortal remains are consigned to flames with the prayers that the souls
rest in eternal peace. It is also believed that fire does not extinguish at this Ghat. There is a
sacred well at the Manikarnika Ghat, called the Manikarnika Kund. Manikarnika Kund is said to
be dug by Lord Vishnu at the time of creation while the hot ashes of the burnt bodies makes one
remember the inevitable destruction of everything in the world.
Panchaganga Ghat: As the name suggests, it is belived that five rivers Kirana, Ganga,
Yamuna, Saraswati and Dhuta-papa converge here. Dominating the ghat is Auangazeb's
smaller mosque, also known as the Alamgir Mosque, which he built on the site of large Vishnu
temple erected by the Maratha chieftain Beni Madhav Rao Scindia.
Assi Ghat: This Ghat marks the confluence of the Assi canal with the River Ganga. It is
believed that when Lord Durga killed the demons Shunga and Nishunga, her sword fell in
Varanasi creating a depression in the form of Assi canal. Out of these ghats Manikarnika,
Panchganga, Adi Kesava, Dasaswamedha and Assi Ghat comprise the “Pancha Jala Tirthas”.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 134
Figure 5.16 : Map Showing Location of Ghats Along Ganga River
Apart from the Ghats, there are around 2000 temples, small, medium and big in size throughout
the city. Many important temples are located along the ghats of Ganga River, adding to the
religious value to the holey river. Some of the important temples are Kashi Vishwanath, the
Sankat Mochan temple, The Tulsi Manas temple, the Durga temple, the Kal Bhairav temple and
the Mritunjaya temple.
Kashi Vishwanath Temple: Located almost centrally on the west bank of River Ganga, this is
the most important temple in the city. It is also known as the Golden Temple dedicated to Lord
Shiva, the founder of the city. It is believed that Aurangzeb destroyed the original temple and
the stones were used to build a mosque next to the temple. The rear wall of the temple was left
untouched by Aurangzeb and Queen Ahilya later on built a new temple close to the old one.
Sankat Mochan Temple: Sankat Mochan temple is one of the sacred temples of Varanasi. It is
located in the southern part of Varanasi, near the Banaras Hindu University. It is dedicated to
the Hindu God, Hanuman. The word "Sankat Mochan" means one who helps in removing
sufferings i. e. Lord Hanuman. Tulsidas, the author of the famous Hindu epic
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 135
Ramacharitamanasa, founded the Sankat Mochan temple. According to Hindu mythology, one
who visits the Sankat Mochan temple regularly, his wishes get fulfilled. Every Tuesday and
Saturday, thousands of devotees queue up in front of the Sankat Mochan temple to offer
prayers to Lord Hanuman. According to Vedic Astrology, Hanuman protects human beings from
the anger of planet Saturn and those who have ill placed Saturn in their horoscope visit the
Sankat Mochan temple to get remedy. People put "Sindoor" on the statue and offer "laddoos" to
Lord Hanuman. The "Sindoor", from the statue of Lord Hanuman is put on the foreheads of
devotees.
Tulsi Manas Temple: Tulsi Manas temple is one of the most famous temples of Varanasi. It is
also an important tourist attraction of the holy city. The Tulsi Manas temple is located near the
famous Durga temple. It was built in white marble in the year 1964. The temple has been made
more harming by the magnificent landscaping around it. The Tulsi Manas temple is dedicated to
lord Ram. It is believed that temple is built at the same place where Tulsidas wrote the famous
Indian epic,
Archeological Importantant Place: (Ramnagar)
Ramnagar fort is located about 14 km from Varanasi city and 2.7 km in north of the proposed
terminal site. The Ramnagar fort houses a museum displaying the Royal collection of old silver
and brocade palanquins for the use of the ladies of the court, elephant howdahs made of silver
brocades, a replica of the royal bed and an armoury of swords and guns, vintage cars, royal
palkies, an armory of swords and old guns, ivory work and antique clocks.
Fairs and Festivals
Varanasi, the sacred corridor (tirtha) is the embodiment of living sacred heritage and hosts a
large number of fairs and festivals throughout the year. The importance of these festivals can be
seen from the number of pilgrims arriving and attending the fairs. During the greatest festivals
when more than 2500 people arrive per hour, the self-organization of the Varanasi pilgrimage
system intensifies partially due to increased mutual interaction of pilgrims who arrive in informal
groups of family and
friends or various kinds of pilgrimage tours. The fares and festivals that take place in Varanasi,
with their venue and period during which they occur is given in Table 5.36:
Table 5.36: Important festivals and the venue in Varanasi city
Festivals Venue Period of Occurrence
Paush Poornima Ghats January
Makar Sankranti Ghats January
Mauni Amavasya Ghats January/February
Magh Poornima Ghats/Ravidas Mandir February
Ganga Water Rally Ghats February
Dhrupad Mela Tulsighat March
Mahashivaratri Ghats & temples March
Navratra (Chaitra) Ghats / Temples April
Ram Navami Tulsi Manas Mandir & April
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 136
Ghats
Sankat Mochan Music Festival
Sankat Mochan Mandir April
Buddha Poornima Sarnath May
Ganga Dussehra Ghats June
Ramlila, Ramnagar Ramnagar September-October
Dhanush Yagya Ramnagar September
Ram Vivah Ramnagar September
Nakkataiya Ramnagar September
Pitra Visarjan Ghats September
Navaratra(Ashwin) Ghats & Temples October
Vijaya Dashmi / Dussehra
Ramnagar D.L.W Vidyapeeth
October
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 137
6. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS
6.1. Introduction
Environmental impacts assessment was carried out considering present environmental setting
of the project area, and nature and extent of the proposed activities. Proposed project involves
development of multimodal inland water terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P. Potential
environmental impacts associated with the project is classified as: (i) impacts during design and
construction phase and ii) impacts during operation phase/Post-construction phase. Sensitive
environmental and social components were identified during the site visits and qualitative and
quantitative techniques have been applied for direct and indirect assessment of impacts on the
identified environmental and social sensitive components. Impacts are classified as being
insignificant, minor, moderate and major.
Some of the important impacts associated with the proposed multimodal inland water terminal
will be associated with land use (land acquisition), land stability (soil erosion), soil compaction
and contamination, water availability, water quality of river/stream/canal, ground water
contamination, waste and wastewater disposal, ambient air quality, ambient noise levels,
vegetation, tree cutting (including social forestry tree), fauna ( terrestrial and aquatic), drainage
pattern, hydrology, socio economic, places of social/cultural importance (religious structures,
community structure), construction material sourcing and occupational health and safety.
Adequate mitigation measures are devised to mitigate/minimize all likely environmental impacts
and the same have been presented along with the impacts.
During the field study, consultations were also held within study area including local people and
Govt. authorities like PHED, Jal Nigam, Jalkal Vibhag, Ganga Pollution Unit etc. Outcome of
these consultations were used in impact assessment and devising mitigation measures.
6.2. Impact Identification
During the site visit, various environment and socially sensitive features were identified which
may potentially be impacted by the project at various stages. Identified impacts of the project
activities on the environment and social components are given below along with the activities
associated.
Table 6.1: Impact Matrix for Proposed Off-site Infrastructure
S.
No.
Activities Impacts Negative
Impact
Positive
Impact
Not
Applicable
Short
Term
Long
Term
Short
Term
Long
Term
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 138
A Pre-Construction Phase
i Land Acquisition for
access road and
railway connectivity
Diversion of
agricultural land
(ROW purpose only)
Impact on livelihood
ii Site Clearance &
Preparation
Removal of
Vegetation. Loss of
tree cover and
Impact on aesthetic
aspects
B Construction Phase
i
Construction of
Terminal
Loss of Top soil
Soil contamination
due to spillage of
material
Surface water
contamination
Air pollution
Noise pollution
Increase in traffic
Un pleasant view
Impact on Health &
safety
Social impact
Aquatic Ecology
Felling of Trees
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 139
C Operational Phase
i
Movement of
Vessels/Barges,
loading and
unloading activity,
storage of material,
transportation of
unloaded material
via road & railway,
running DG sets,
plantation of trees
Air Quality
Economic
Development
&Generation of
Employment
Infrastructural
development
Increased Run-off
Natural drainage
pattern
Noise Pollution
Surface Water
Pollution
Health & Safety
Soil Erosion and
Contamination
Terrestrial Ecology
Aquatic Ecology
Aesthetics
6.3. Impact on Climate
Project is unlikely to cause negative effect on climate. However, project can contribute positively
for climate. Further measures are proposed to improve the climate of the region
Mitigation Measures
Avoid cutting any tree standing on the proposed terminal site or temporary accesses
area of 600m length.
Prior permission shall be taken for cutting any tree.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 140
Compensatory tree planation shall be carried out for any tree cut as per state forest
policy
Addition plantation of local variety of tree (200 no one row of tree on three side of the
terminal land) shall be carried out along boundary of the terminal site
6.4. Impact Due to Natural Disaster
Project site lies in seismic zone III as per the BIS Seismoc zone map of India. Thus hazard
associated is moderate. Adoption of Relevant IS codes while designing the civil structures to
sustain the earthquake of moderate to high magnitude. High water & low water levels with
reference to the India Naval Hydrographic Chart Datum of river Ganga at site are RL+73.90 m &
RL + 58.22 m. Terminal site is above HFL of the river.
6.5. Impact on Air Environment
Pre-construction Phase
Pre-construction phase of development of phase 1A of proposed multimodal inland water
terminal will involve site clearance and leveling. There is no significant vegetation at the terminal
site & proposed temporary access road except few trees. Trees may be required to cut and trim
for construction of proposed facility. Temporary access road will connect terminal site to NH-7
through village road. At present terminal site is covered with municipal solid waste which has
been collected from city and is being dumped over the years on site.
Site clearance and leveling activities and will lead to dust generation. But these emissions will
be limited to the site only and have impact for short duration only during clearance activity.
Mitigation Measures
To minimize the dust generation, water should be sprinkled regularly at the site
Low sulphur diesel should be used in land levelling equipments to control the SO2 emissions.
Site should be cleaned regularly
If landfill site is not present nearby then a site should be identified for waste disposal. Site should not be agriculture land, should be away from residential and sensitive areas like school, temples and hospitals. Low lying areas should preferably be selected.
Debris & MSW disposal Site should be closed and rehabilitated after completion of the construction activities
Plantation should be carried out on the closed site to stabilize the soil in the area.
Trees should be fell only after obtaining permission from forest department
Construction Phase
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 141
Impact Due to Construction activities and material handling
The proposed project involves construction activities like onshore & offshore civil construction,
construction material handling and stocking, and construction vehicle movement etc, which will
generate fugitive dust and vehicular emissions. However, these emissions will be limited to the
construction area and the impact will be short duration, i.e during construction phase only. The
likely emission from construction vehicle, machinery, and generators is likely to be insignificant
as the pollutant emission activities (point and area sources) will be limited within the project
boundary and the activities will be short term (only for construction period). However, this impact
may further be minimized by adopting following mitigation measures.
Mitigation Measures
Sprinkling of water at construction site and haul roads
Covering the scaffolding to reduce the dust emission in outside environment
Provision of face mask to workers to minimize inhalation of dust particles
Construction vehicles and machinery should be regularly serviced and check for
pollution control and should carry PUC certificate
Low sulphur diesel should be used for running construction equipment and vehicles
Adequate parking space should be provided for the construction vehicles so as to
prevent idling of the vehicles and the emissions generating from them
Vehicles carrying construction material and debris should be covered with tarpaulin
cover
Raw materials, excavated soil and other debris should be stored under covered sheds
Green buffer should be developed all along the terminal site
Plantation should be carried out along both side of the access road
DG sets, hot mix plant, batching plant, if any should be provided with the stack of
adequate height as per CPCB norms and should be regularly maintained
Air quality monitoring should be carried out throught out the construction phase,
quarterly
All maintenance facilities, hot mix plant and concrete missing plant shall be established
with prior consent to establish to be obtained from SPCB. All such equipment/plant shall
be fitted with air pollution control system and shall comply with condition of consent to
establish.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 142
Periodic ambient air quality monitoring & stack monitoring shall be carried as per
consent conditions
Power shall be sourced from national/state grid. DG sets shall be used only during
power failure.
Back-up power shall be set up with all provisions of containment for fuel leakages, air
pollution control (stack height as per regulation), and with acoustic enclosure.
Solar energy shall be used in common lighting area on 1:2 basis.
Buildings designed should have green infrastructure. Measures should be taken to
conserve energy as per ECBC norms as applicable.
Traffic regulators ( Guard) shall be posted in habitat area and at key junction areas to
avoid congestion and the increased emissions due to traffic congestion
Impacts Due to Material Sourcing
Required construction material shall be sourced from nearest licensed and authorized
quarry/agency only so as to minimize the emissions in transportation of material to the site and
to discourage illegal quarrying and minming activities. Measures to be taken for effective
consruction material sopurcing are listed below
Material Sourcing
Aggregates required for embankment stone pitching and roads shall be procured from
licensed quarries.
It shall be ensures that selected quarries are having requisite environment clearance,
and comply with Air Pollution Control and Noise level requirements as per the law.
Copy of Environmental Clearance letter and Consent to Operate and shall Be obtained
and submitted to IWAI.
Material shall be transported under covered trucks only.
No new quarry shall be opened without due permissions.
Each Quarry shall be visited prior to its selection to ensure its compliance with lease
conditions, EC and consent conditions.
Stone crushers, if required, shall be set up only after consent from SPCB and taking
adequate measures for air pollution control
Operation Phase
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 143
Development of paved surfaces will reduce the dust generation at the site. Since the project will
not be operationalize in phase 1A stage thus impact during operation of terminal will be covered
under Phase 1B.
Inland waterways are green way of transportation. Water transportation consume much less
energy as compared to road and rail transportation and dust emissions due to vehicular
movement will also not generate in water transportation. Development of inland waterway will
enhance water transportation reducing burden on rail & road transportation thus the will improve
the air quality of the area. Emissions from tow boat, train and truck carrying one ton of cargo for
1000 miles is given in table below for comparison.
Table 6.2: Emissions produced in movement of 1 ton of Cargo for 1000 miles by tow boat, truck and train
Mode Hydrocarbon (pounds)
Carbon monoxide (pounds)
Nitrous oxide (pounds)
Tow boat 0.09 0.20 0.53
Train 0.46 0.64 1.83
Truck 0.63 1.90 10.17
Source: EPA, Emission Control Lab
Mitigation Measures
Trees should be planted all along the terminal boundary
Tree plantation should start in construction stage only
Geo-textiles and mulching should be carried out to reduce soil erosion by wind and thus
the dust generation
6.6. Impact on Noise Environment
Pre-construction and Construction Phase
Pre-construction phase will involve site clearance activity for development of terminal and
temporary access road. Clearance of site will involve removal of vegetation and land leveling
activities. Operation of different machineries and equipments for construction activities, running
of heavy load traffic for construction materials transportation, and regular traffic movement may
generate noise during construction period. The produced noise may have impact on existing
acoustic environment of the area. There is no habitation area within 500 m of the terminal site
thus the impact of noise during construction phase will be insignificant on the residents of the
area. Noise generation during construction phase will also disturb the terrestrial and aquatic
flora & fauna.
Mitigation Measures
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 144
Machinery to be used should comply with the noise standards prescribed by CPCB
DG set shall be enclosed in acoustic enclosure
Workers shall be given ear plugs if working in high noise area. Job rotations should be
practiced for workers working in high noise zone
No noise generating activity shall be carried out in the night time
No construction activity should be carried out during the breeding and spawning season
of turtles
Temporary noise barriers should be provided near the high noise generating areas
Periodic noise level monitoring shall be carried out during construction phase
Speed control shall be enforced in habitat areas. Operation Phase
Since after construction of phase 1A of the terminal, terminal will not be operationalized thus the
impact during operation stage of the terminal will be discussed in phase 1B in detail.
However water transportation generates minimum noise if compared to road and rail traffic.
After operationalizing the terminal, noise generation in the area may increase due to
loading/unloading activity but overall noise generation in region will reduce as water
transportation will reduce the burden on rail and road traffic which generate higher level of noise
than water transportation.
6.7. Impacts on Water Resources
Pre-Construction and Construction Phase
Impacts on Ground & Surface Water Resources:
Water will be required for various construction activities & domestic purpose. Source of water for
these activities will be the surface water from river. Water should be withdrawn only after
obtaining permission from irrigation department. Measures should be taken to minimize the
water extraction by reducing water consumption and wastage. Mitigation measures are given
below.
Mitigation Measures
Best management practices will be required to be adopted to minimize water wastage and water
loss. Best management practices to be adopted are given below:
Water for curing can be saved by carrying out curing in early morning or late evening
and covering structures with gunny bag so as the moisture can be restored for longer
time.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 145
Regular inspections at site to monitor leakages in water storage tanks
Creating awareness among construction workers about the importance of water
conservation
Adoption of the advance technologies and machinery which helps in minimizing water
requirement for construction
Storing the curing run-off and waste from other construction activity and using the same
for sprinkling.
Covering the water storage tanks at site to prevent evaporation losses.
The Area is under safe category as per Central Ground Water Board. However,
necessary permission shall be taken from district authorities as applicable before digging
the bore well, if any.
Staff and visitors should be made aware about water conservation by displaying posters
and signage
Preference shall be given to source water from rivers wherever feasible in the project
area with due permission from authorities. .
Augmentation through incorporating water harvesting structures if technically feasible.
Construction of check dams in consultation with community to reduce burden on ground
water resources.
Efforts to restrict water intensive activities during summer period (April, May, June)
Impact on Surface Water Quality
Run-off from the construction site may carry the higher quantity of sediments and oil which may
pollute the surface water and impact the aquatic life. Also construction activity like pilling within
water body will increase the sediment load and turbidity in the water. Increased sediment load in
water may make water unfit for aquatic flora and fauna. But the impacts are short term and
confined to construction stage only. With following measures impacts on surface water quality
can be minimized
Mitigation Measures
Restoration of changes in the stream, if any, made during construction to its original
level.
Precautions shall be made that no nala or canal is clogged.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 146
Substructure construction should be limited to the dry season and cofferdams may be
constructed and utilized to lift the spoil directly out of it and carried to the riverbank for
land disposal.
The piling work shall be undertaken during low flow period.
Turbidity traps/curtains should be provide or Geo-Textile synthetic sheet curtain shall be
placed around pilling and construction area to prevent movement of sediments and
construction waste.
Provision shall be made for geo Synthetic Screen for arresting silt flowing down stream.
Water from dewatering (if any) should pass through sediment bags before discharge into
the river
Excavated area should be covered with tarpaulin during rains
To prevent piling up of excavated soil, raw material and construction debris at site by
proper management and disposal
Minimize run-off by using sprays for curing
Maintaining appropriate flow of water sprinklers at site to prevent water ponding at site
Collection & Reusing of curing over flow, tyre wash water etc within the site
Construction of adequate nos. of toilets and proper sanitation system to prevent open
defecation along the river banks/water supply lines
Construction of soak pits/septic tanks to dispose-off the domestic waste water generated
from labour camps to prevent disposal of sewage in surface water bodies
Proper collection, management and disposal of construction and municipal waste from
site to prevent mixing of the waste in run-off and entering the water bodies
No debris/construction material should enter the aquaculture ponds and other water
body in the area
Construction of storm water drains along with sedimentation tanks with sand bags
partition as barrier for direct flow of run off to river.
Storm water drains should be provided at the terminal facility to drain the storm water
during operation phase into the river. Storm water drains should be provided with oil &
grease trap
All washing and maintenance effluent from the workshop area of vehicle maintenance
area should darin to separate collection areas fitted with oil and grease trap and de-
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 147
siltation chamber. The treated water shall be used for dust suppression and green belt
development. This water shall not be discharged to river at all.
Periodic water quality monitoring shall be carried out during construction phase
Provision shall be made for collection and draining of water for the piling earth. It shall be
used for embankment protection or road construction depending on its suitability.
Natural Drainage pattern of area around shall be maintained.
No waste shall be allowed to dumped to industrial effluent Nala flowing adjacent to the
terminal site. Its opening to river shall not be obstructed in any manner.
Impacts on Ground Water Quality
Ground water level at the river bank is shallow. Thus while construction of the terminal; it may
be required to dewater the groundwater for construction. This water should be used for
construction purpose. If this water is discharged into the river then it should pass through
sediments bags. Only the shallow water aquifer will be disturbed and disturbance will be
confined to project site. No significant impact of terminal construction is anticipated on ground.
Impacts on Drainage Pattern & Hydrology
Terminal site is located along the River Ganga. A drain surrounding the proposed terminal site
flows from inland towards River Ganga. Construction of the paved surfaces like roads, loading
and unloading bay, and other terminal facilities will increase the run-off from the area.
Construction activities will obstruct the flow of the river in that area. Terminal site constructed is
above the HFL level of the River in that stretch. Stone pitching will be carried out both in
upstream and downstream to protect the embankment from erosion. A riverside subsurface
artificial embankment should be constructed to protect the terminal structure/foundation from
collapsing due to push of water.
Following measures should be taken to minimize the impact on drainage and hydrology of the
area.
.Mitigation Measures
Storm water drains should be provided at the terminal facility to drain the storm water
from the site during operation phase into the river.
Provision of side drain shall be made in access road if required to prevent water logging.
Operation Phase
Impacts on Ground & Surface Water Resources:
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 148
Since project will not be operationalize after completion of phase 1A construction, impacts
during operation phase has not been discussed here and will be dealt in EIA study of phase 1B
of the terminal.
However construction of terminal and berth will impact on water flow in the area and thus will
affect the quality of water due to poor circulation. In case if untreated effluent from terminal
facility and from ships/barges is disposed off is discharged into the river, it will result into
stagnation of wastewater. This condition may deteriorate through increase of phytoplankton and
decrease of dissolve oxygen, resulting from eutrophication of water, caused by effluents
containing nutrient salts. Thus sewage generated should not be discharge into river.
Impacts on Surface & Ground Water Quality
Due to construction of paved surfaces, run-off will increase but will carry less sediment load.
Since project will not be operationalize after construction of phase 1A thus the impacts on
surface and ground water quality during operation stage of the terminal are not discussed here
and will be dealt with EIA study of phase 1B.
6.8. Impact on Land Environment
Pre-Construction and Construction Phase
Impacts due to Land acquistion
Private land of 5.685 ha has been acquired for construction of phase 1A of the proposed
terminal site. Acquired land is agriculture fallow land. Land acquisition process has been
completed and compensation has been given to the land owners as per law of land. Following
measures should be taken to minimize loss due to land acquistion
Mitigation Measures
Fuel storage Further for borrow area and debris disposal, agriculture land should not be
identified but waste land should preferably be selected
Land for borrow area and debris disposal should be taken only after consent of land
owner
Proper closure of borrow are and debris disposal site should be carried out
Provision shall be made for collection and draining of water for the piling earth. It shall be used for embankment protection or road construction depending on its suitability rather than using the sand/soil from borrow pits
Impacts due to Change in Land Use Pattern
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 149
At present the site is open land with sparse vegetation. After construction of terminal, paved
areas will be constructed. This will increase the run-off and will obstruct the recharge of the
storm water.
Impact on Topography & Geology
No impact on topography & Geology is anticipated due to development of terminal site as the
terminal site is flat land. Site is above HFL of Ganga River. Excavation will be carried out for
laying the foundation of the proposed facilities but these activities will be confined to project site
only.
Impact on Top Soil and Soil Quality
Development of the structures and construction of the road may disturb the soil profile of the
area. Top soil will be removed from the site for construction of proposed facilities. This top soil
should be excavated upto 15 cm and should be stored under covered sheds till construction
phase and should be used for landscaping in later stage.
Sand may also be required for filling purpose for road construction and construction of off-shore
structure. The sand should be purchased from authorized dealers only. If borrow pits are
required then environment clearance & consent of land owner shall be obtained prior
excavation. Area identified for borrow pits should not be agriculture land, waste land should be
used preferably. Borrow area should be selected towards the river side as it will eventually be
filled naturally in due course of time due to deposition action of river. Borrow areas should not
be selected near residential areas and sensitive zones like school, temples and hospitals.
Storage of raw material, fuel and construction debris may contaminate the soil thus measures
should be taken to prevent the soil pollution. Mitigation measures to be adopted are mentioned
below. Contractors are required to take all the proposed mitigation measures. IWAI will ensure
that all the proposed mitigation measures are being incorporated in the bid document issued to
the contractor and the implementation of the same during construction.
Mitigation Measures
Top soil from site, borrow area, debris disposal site should be excavated and stored
separately and should be relayed in case of borrow area and debris disposal site at time
of closure and top soil from terminal site should be used for landscaping in later stage
No piling of raw material at site
Raw material will be stored under covered sheds and paved surface
Fuel storage area should be paved with gentle slope to a corner and connected with a
chamber to collect any spills of the oils
Provision of “oil interceptors” at wash-down and re-fuelling areas.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 150
Adoption of best management practices to prevent any spillage of raw materials
Construction debris should be stored under covered sheds and paved surface and
should be disposed off regularly to designated sites
Waste from labour camps can be segregated at site. Food waste/wet waste should be
composted in pits within the camp site. Recyclable waste should be sold to the
authorized dealers and the remaining should be disposed off at designated sites through
local agencies responsible for waste management in the area.
Oil and grease spill and oil soaked materials are to be collected and stored in labelled
containers (Labelled: WASTE OIL; and hazardous sign be displayed) and sold off to
SPCB/ MoEF authorized vendors.
Movement of construction vehicles, machinery and equipment shall be restricted to the
designated haulage route.
Impacts due to soil erosion on River bank
Construction activity, excavation activity etc enhances the soil erosion in the area. Construction
of onshore structure also leads to unstability of the banks which will lead to enhanced soil
erosion. Construction of terminal facility may enhance erosion of embankment in upstream and
downstream of proposed terminal site. Following measures should be taken to prevent soil
erosion:
Mitigations Measures
Provision of cross drainage structure shall be made in the access road if required to
maintain the natural drainage pattern.
Provision of side drain shall be made in access road if required to prevent water logging.
Measures like building of scouring protection structures, protection by geo-textiles
matting etc shall be made, if river bank erosion is found around the terminal area.
Bio-turfing of embankments shall be made enhance the slop stabilization.
Embankment protection measures (stone pitching) shall be made in both upstream and
downstream to the extent that erosion is minimized.
Erosion monitoring shall be carried out periodically downstream as well.
The earth stockpiles to be provided with gentle slopes to prevent soil erosion.
Impact on landscape and scenic beauty
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 151
Project site is fallow land. Construction activities and machinery will also provide unpleasant
view but proper up keeping of site and provision of adequate sewage and waste management
facility at site will maintain the hygiene and cleanliness at site.
Impact due to solid waste management
Construction activities involve generation of construction debris like bricks, mortar, dried
cement/concrete, metal pieces etc. from construction activities, municipal waste from the labour
camps and hazardous waste like used oil from cleaning, servicing and lubrication of machinery,
equipment, vehicles and DG sets. These wastes should be properly managed and handled as
they have potential to contaminate air, soil & water quality. Following measures should be taken
to prevent environment pollution due to solid waste generated:
Different color bins should be provided at construction site and labour camps for
segregation of waste at source
Awareness should be spread amongst the staff/labours to use dustbins and not to litter
Housekeeping staff should be appointed to ensure clean site conditions
Recyclable waste should be sold to authorized dealers, compostable waste should be pit
composted so as it can be used as manure for carrying out plantation and remaining
waste should be send for landfilling through authorized agency in area responsible for
waste management
Construction debris should be re-used within site for construction of roads etc to the
extent possible. These debris can also be used in borrow area closure but should not be
contaminated with any hazardous waste.
A site should be identified for construction debris disposal. This site should be min. 1000
m away from residential areas and sensitive location like schools. Agriculture land
should not be selected for this purpose. Debris disposal site should properly be closed
and rehabilitated at end of construction by covering it with layer of soil and carrying out
plantation
Survival rate of plantation at closed debris disposal site should be monitored for atleast 1
year.
No waste should be dumped in identified borrow area site or any other area outside
project site.
Hazardous waste like used oil shall be stored in HDPE containers and should be stored
in isolated area at site. After accumulation of sufficient quantity, it should be sold to
authorized dealers (every 3 months)
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 152
River Bed material shall be tested for contaminants before its use or disposal for land fill
site. If any level of heavy metal contamination is found than it shall be disposed off in a
secure manner.
Operation Phase
Impact on Land Use & Soil quality
Since project will not be operationalize after construction of phase 1A thus the impacts on land
environment during operation phase are not discussed here and will be dealt in detail in EIA
study of phase 1B.
However operation of terminal will lead to increased traffic movement, loading and unloading
activities, storage of fuel for running cranes, DG sets during power failure, cleaning of
machinery & site and etc. Thus the storm water from site and waste water generated from
cleaning site and roads should not be disposed on land. Proper storm water should be provided
with oil & grase trap and the storm water should then be discharged into river. Also wastewater
generated during operation phase should be disposed off properly through septic tank/soak pit.
Leakage of wastewater pipelines should be checked through regular inspection so as to prevent
contamination of soil.
Also after construction & operationalization of the terminal in this area further developments are
expected to occur in nearby area which will affect the land use pattern of the area.
6.9. Impacts on Biological Environment
Pre-construction and construction Phase
Impact on terrestrial flora & Fauna
The proposed site is devoid of any major plantation. Some agriculture activities were taken up
by nearby villagers within the land in the past but these activities have been discontinued now.
Now the land is categorized as fallow land. There are about 12 small trees of Khajur (Phoenix
sylvestris) and 8 trees of Babool shrubs (Acacia spp.) are present in the identified land. These
trees may require to be removed.
The access road to connect site crosses through the Ralhupur villages. This road is pucca upto
the Rahlpur village. About 700 m stretch that connect terminal site to Rahlupur village levelling
and widening. Trees of Jamun, Peepal, Babul and Sisham etc are present along this road.
Houses and shops also exist along the access road. The access road (700 m stretch that have
to develop) is almost clear, only one or two trees of Jamun, is present along the road alignment
that may require to be removed. One big tree also requires some chopping for clearing the
passes. Nilgai are also observed at the site.
No significant impacts are anticipated on the terrestrial flora & fauna. However Following
measures are required to be taken to prevent any damage to flora and fauna
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 153
Mitigation Measures
Only trees essential and marked should be fell for construction purpose. Permission
from forest department should be taken for felling any tree
No construction activity should be carried during night time as it may disturb the animals
in the area
All workers should be instructed not to kill any animal in any circumstance observed at or
outside the site
Twice the nos. of tree fell should be planted as compensator afforestation.
Terminal site should be provided with peripheral green belt.
Construction site should be barricaded to prevent trespassing of any animal
Green belt plantation and afforestation should be started in construction phase in ratio
as per state forest policy
Tree plantation shall be made as feasible at site and around the site depending on land
availability.
Survival rate of tree shall be regularly monitored. It is shall be minimum 70%.
Caution sign shall be placed to prevent hunting of wild animal and birds. Heavy fines
should be imposed if any such activity is reported at site
Provision of LPG shall be made in construction site camp and labour camp as fuel source to avoid tree cutting.
Impact on aquatic flora & Fauna
Tortoise Sanctuary is located at about 2.0 Km from site. Necessary permission shall be
obtained from National Board of Wild Life prior to start of construction. No movement of tortoise
is reported upward to the site. No harm shall be caused to this tortoise. No breeding ground is
noticed around the project site. However construction activity shall be restricted during
spawning period of June to August.
Run-off from the construction site will carry high sediment load and also the construction
activities within water for pilling may lead to generation of high turbidity levels. High turbidity
may reduce the primary productivity by killing the planktons and affect submerged aquatic flora
by reducing the penetration level of sunlight. High turbid water also impact the fishes as it enters
into fish gills and may lead to fish kill. But these activities are short term and confined for the
construction phase only thus the impact anticipated are temporary and short term. Higher
turbidity also may impact the turtle sanctuary downstream
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 154
Leakage of oils, oily wastes and mixtures from construction activity may directly cause damage
to fishery resources and aquatic biota. Biodegradation of oil also generates polymerizedoil
particles and toxic aromatic fractions using dissolved oxygen in the water, which indirectly cause
damages to bottom biota and habitat. Both effects may affect aquatic ecology. Mitigation
measures are required to be taken for prevention of any impacts on flora and fauna.
Mitigation Measures
Piling should not be carried out during breeding and spawning season and also to be
carried out in low water season, i.e. pre-monsoon
Concrete and wood piling should be carried out in place of wood piling
Maintaining equipment in good condition to prevent leaks or spills of potentially
hazardous materials like hydraulic fluid, diesel, gasoline and other petroleum products
Recovering waste or any miscellaneous unused materials for disposal in an
appropriately certified facility or placed in storage Maintaining emergency spill equipment
available whenever working near or on the water
Positioning water borne equipment in a manner that will minimize damage to fish
habitat.
Fish exclusion devices may be installed in the water column around the pile
driving area to prevent fish access. The need for exclusion would be determined
on the basis of installation timing, mitigation measures, the success of mitigation
measures in the field etc
Bubble curtains (with frames acceptable to DFO) over the wetted length of the
pile may be required to mitigate impacts on aquatic life
Turbidity traps/curtains should be provide or Geo-Textile synthetic sheet curtain shall be
placed around pilling and construction area to prevent movement of sediments and
construction waste.
Visual and hydrophone monitoring will be conducted during pile driving, at a
range of depths in the water column and at varying distances and directions from
the pile being driven, to measure sound waves and determine if temporary work
stoppages and / or additional mitigation strategies are required to maintain levels
below 30 kPa
Hydrophone monitoring shall be carried out throughout the pile driving from
beginning to end and particularly during periods of pile driving resistance or
refusal
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 155
Using lightning as per need basis only especially during night time as lighting
during night time may disturb the flora and fauna. Lighting should be oriented in a
way tthat illumination of water body is avoided
No excavation on shore shall be carried out during monsoon
Run-off from the construction site & dewatered water should pass through the
sediment bags prior disposal in river
Workers should be trained to handle the equipment and material at site so as to
minimize the spillage of materials and contamination of water
All workers should be made aware of not throwing any waste in the river or any
drain
No construction debris/ already accumulated solid waste at site or waste
generated from labour camp should be thrown in river or any drain
Sewage generated from labour camp should not be directed into river but should
be disposed off through septic tank/soak pit
In case any tortoise is sited, necessary caution notice shall be displaced and conveyed
to all construction workers and officers.
Operation Phase
Since project will not be operationalize after construction of phase 1A thus the impacts on
biological environment during operation phase are not discussed here and will be dealt in detail
in EIA study of phase 1B.
However operation phase will involve movement of barges in the river which will increase the
chances of polluting water making water unfit for aquatic like due to oil spillage, discharge of
wastewater/waste etc. Also run-off from terminal site specially loading and unloading bay,
roads, parking area may contain oil & grease which again may deteriorate water quality. All
these impacts will be discussed in detail in EIA to be carried out for phase 1 B of the terminal
facility
6.10. Impacts on Socio-Economy
Pre-construction and construction Phase
Loss of livelihood and land
Fishing activities are seen in the river close to site. Construction activity may disturb the fishing
activity in the area. Disturbance to the fishermen should be minimized. Fishermen should be pre
intimated of the hazards associated to fishing equipment and life if entered in construction zone.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 156
Arrangement shall be made to provide free access to river and undisturbed safe movement of
the fishermen.
Land of 5.685 ha has been acquired for constructing phase 1A of terminal facility. Acquired land
is agriculture fallow land. No agriculture activity has been reported during site visit at site. Also
during discussion in FGDs, it was learned that land is no long used for agriculture purpose by
land holders. Compensation has been given to all the land holders as per law of land. Thus no
impact on livelihood is anticipated for people losing land.
Impacts on Land Due to Borrow Area
Further agriculture land should not be acquired for purpose of borrow area, debris disposal and
location of construction labour camps. Land to be taken for above purpose should be taken only
after consent of land owner. Following measures should be taken for identification, maintaining
and closure of borrow areas:
Mitigation Measures- For Management of borrow Areas
Non-productive lands, barren lands, raised lands; wastelands shall be used for
borrowing earth with the necessary permissions/consents.
Agricultural areas not to be used as borrow areas unless requested by the
landowner for lowering the land for making it cultivable.
Excavation depth should not exceed 1.5 m bgl
Environmental Clearance from State Environmental Impact Assessment
Authority and required permission from District Magistrate shall be obtained
prior to excavation. Copy of this permission shall be submitted to IWAI before
start of excavation.
Record of location, area, accessibility to the location and photograph of borrow
area should be maintained prior to excavation
Site selected for borrow area should be approved by PMC & IWAI expert prior to
excavation
Ridges of not less than 8m width will be left at intervals not exceeding 300m.
Small drains will be cut through the ridges, if necessary, to facilitate drainage.
The slope of the edges will be maintained not steeper than 1:4 (vertical:
Horizontal).
Topsoil to be stockpiled and protected for use at the rehabilitation stage.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 157
Rehabilitation shall be satisfactorily undertaken immediately after the use has
ceased and at least three weeks prior to monsoon.
Unpaved surfaces used for the haulage of borrow materials to be maintained.
Transportation of earth materials shall be through covered vehicles.
Impact on Health, Aesthetics and Hygiene due to occupational health hazard
Construction activities lead to generation of dust, unpleasant view, hazardous working
conditions, obstruction in fishing activity in that area etc which may impact the society
significantly. Adequate safety management plan, waste management plan, air, soil, noise and
water pollution controls are required to be adopted during construction phase to prevent any
impact on society. Measures to prevent any damage to health, aesthetic and hygiene are as
follows:
Mitigation Measures
Contractors to adopt and maintain safe working practices.
Training workers to handle the equipment so as to prevent accidents
Training workers to handle emergency situation like fire, earth quake and flood
Pre-joining medical checkup of workers and periodic six monthly medical
checkup for workers should be carried out
First aid facilities including ambulance should be provided at the site. Also tie-ups
with local hospital should be done to handle emergency case, if any
Labour camps should be located at neat and clean location with no water logging issues
and should be well ventilated with adequate illumination, kitchen and safe drinking water
facility
Construction labour camps and site should be properly cleaned and hygiene
should be maintained
Proper sanitation facility like toilet and bathing facility should be provided at site
and labour camps. Wastewater generated from these facilities should be
disposed off through septic tanks and soak pit
LPG should be provided as fuel for cooking to workers and open burning of fuel
should not be allowed
Wastewater from construction site should not be allowed to accumulate at site as
standing water may lead to breeding of mosquitoes
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 158
Temporary storm water drainage system should also be provided at camp site and
construction site so as to drain the storm water and prevent accumulation of storm water
at site and thus breeding of mosquitoes/flies
Workers should be trained to handle the materials so as to prevent spillage and
any other accident
Safety officers should be appointed at site so as to ensure all safety measures
are taken at the site
All construction workers shall be provided with personal protective equipments
and fines should be imposed if found not wearing
Job rotation should be carried out for workers exposed to high noise and dust areas
Activity like smoking and consuming liquor should be prohibited at the site
Traffic manager should be present at the site all the time to manage incoming
and outgoing traffic to prevent accidents
Crèche facility should be provided for kids if female workers are employed
Regular inspection for hygiene and safety in labour camps should be done
Provision of cautionary and guiding signage in local and English language indicating the
hazard associated with the site & activities. Usage of fluorescent signage, in local
language at the construction sites
Speed limit of vehicles should be restricted at site to prevent any accidents and
fines should be imposed on vehicles if same is not maintained
Employment should be provided preferable to local & affected people
Entry to the fuel storage area and construction equipment rooms should be restricted
and should be allowed for trained personnel
Dustbins should be provided at labour camps for collection of waste and waste should
be regularly disposed off through the concerned agency
Arrangement of fire-fighting should be made at site and workers should be trained to use
the system in case of fire
Entrance to any road/structure should not be blocked for construction of terminal
Site should be barricaded and entrance of outsiders should strictly be prohibited
All proposed environmental pollution measures should be taken during construction of
phase 1A to prevent harm to existing environmental quality of the area, which is being
enjoyed by the residents of that area
Impact on Infrastructure& Utilities
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 159
No sensitive feature like religious structures, school, hospital etc and any other utility is located
at the terminal site. To provide access to terminal a temporary access road will be constructed
which will be connected to NH-7 through village road which will increase the burden and traffic
movement on village road. Following measures should be taken to prevent impact on existing
facilities
Mitigation Measures
Maintenance and repair of the village road should be carried out both before and end of
construction by contractor.
Sprinkling of water should be carried out in village road also, so as to minimize dust
generation due to movement of construction vehicles.
Construction vehicle movement should be restricted to non-peak hours, i.e late evening
(7-12:00 pm) only. Villagers should also be given intimation of these timings.
All construction vehicles should follow the designated rout and restricted speed limits.
All construction vehicles should be regularly serviced and maintained and carry pollution
under control certificate
Construction labour camp, plant site, debris disposal site and borrow areas shall
belocated minimum 500 m distance from habitations and 1000 m from forest area to
prevent damage to existing environmental quality and resources
No cultural resources & utilities are located at the site which is required to be removed from the
site.
Generation of Employment
Employment will be generated during construction phase. Unskilled jobs can be provided to
local people. Skilled jobs will be provided on the basis of skill assessment.
Further, the construction labour force will be requiring food and other items, which is expected
to be supplied by the local eateries, retail shops and the local community. The local community
members can take advantage of these opportunities. Employment generation benefits improve
the quality of life of the labourers and enhance their productivity and living standards.
Mitigation Measures
Child labour should be strictly prohibited
Women should also be provided equal job opportunity as per suitability
Preferably local people should be given employment
Operation Phase
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 160
Since project will not be operationalize after construction of phase 1A thus the impacts on
biological environment during operation phase are not discussed here and will be dealt in detail
in EIA study of phase 1B.
However operation of the terminal facility will have significant impact on socio-economy.
Terminal facility will help in enhancing the internal trade thereby improving the economy of the
area. Also the project will lead to generation of employment for both skilled and unskilled labour.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 161
7. PUBLIC CONSULTATIONS AND DISCLOSURE
Public consultations are important for any investment in infrastructure development project. This
is an important tool to ensure peoples‟ participation in the planning and implementation phase of
the project. The aim of the public consultation is to make the people aware about the
developmental activities being undertaken in their locality and to incorporate their views for
making a sustainable plan during the design to the successful completion of the project.
In this project various consultations with stakeholders at different stages of the project
preparation were undertaken and issues related to local needs, problem and prospects of
resettlement, compensation options etc. were discussed. The project will therefore ensure that
the affected people and other stakeholders are informed, consulted, and allowed to participate
actively in the planning and development process. This will be done throughout the course of
the project, both during preparation, implementation, and monitoring of project results and
impacts.
The need for public consultation for this kind of an intervention is many folds. Following points
were considered while conducting the public consultations as major objectives.
I. Informing people about the project, its objectives and potential impacts.
II. Understand the views of the people affected, with reference to use of land.
III. Understand views of people on resettlement options, if any.
IV. Identify and assess major economic and social characteristics of the villages to enable
effective planning and implementation of rehabilitation.
V. Resolve issues related to impacts on community property and their relocation, if any.
VI. Identify levels and extent of community participation in project implementation and
monitoring.
VII. To establish an understanding for identification of overall developmental goals and
benefits of the project.
VIII. To develop a thorough coordination between the stakeholders for the successful
implementation of the project.
7.1. Methods of Public Consultation
Public consultations in the project area were held on 24.6.2015 at Balwa Ghat under Rampur
town near the proposed terminal location. The following methodology has been adopted for
carrying out public consultations in this project:
- Disseminating information on the project development and the general consultations that
were being held.
- Walk over survey and discussion with people within the affected area.
- Individual interviews with affected people.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 162
- Sharing the opinions and preferences of the affected persons/ family.
The methodology adopted included providing information to the affected families (fishermen,
boatman and squatters), the Village Revenue officials and the members of the affected families
through the field team of the consultant. The appropriate date, time and the venue were also
finalized in consultation with the affected people and conducted at a convenient location in
concurrence. The invitation was given through individual contacts at the site. The extensive
discussions at individual levels during the field survey facilitated in finalizing the issues to be
discussed during the Public Consultations. Thus the Public Consultations were extensive and
effective.
The contacts and the target stakeholders’ during the Public consultations
Institutional Consultations:
- Special Land Acquisition Officer
- IWAI
- Banaras Development Authority
- Health Department
- District Statistical Department
- PWD Rural and Urban
- PMGSY
- Agriculture Department
- Irrigation Department (Sigra)
- BHU
- Jal Nigam
- UPSIDC
- DIC
Community Consultations:
- Village elders and leaders
- Affected families
- Vulnerable groups
In addition to the above consultations the project team provided information to the affected
population and the communities about the project developments. All suggestions about the
alignment.
However, at the implementation stage the executive summary of this RP will be translated in the
local language and distributed amongst the affected population. A copy of the Detailed RP will
be available with the respective local administration and the Implementing agency at the field
level for access to the affected population. The land acquisition details is as per the Land
Acquisition Act will be published in the local papers in local language for the easy access and
understanding of the local population. The detail of the contacts during the Stakeholder
Consultations is detailed below in the Table 7.1:
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 163
Table 7.1: Detail of the contacts during the Stakeholder Consultations
Sl. No. Stakeholders Name and designation
1 IWAI-Varanasi Mr AK Misra(Deputy Director) Mr. Brijesh(Land acquisition In charge)
2. Special Land Acquisition officer
Mr. Rajinder Prasad(Special Land Acquisition officer )
3. Health Department Dr. MP Chaurasia, Chief Medical Officer Varanasi
4. Varanasi VikasParadhikaran Banaras Development Authority
Mr. TejPratap, (City Planner) Mr. Gopal Krishan (Executive Engineer –VDA)
5 District Statics department Varanasi (VikashBhawan)
Rapesh Kumar, (DESTO) 541 525214
4 PWD Satya Prakash Chief Engineer (Varanasi Circle)
5 PMGSY Mr. MP Singh Administration Office (9621626963)
6 Agriculture department DISTRICT Agriculture office Varanasi VikasBhawan
7 Irrigation Department (Sigra)
RaghuveerSarev, (S.E) OP Srivastava Chief Engineer
8 Ramnagar (BalauvaGhat) Fishermen, Boatmen and Squatters at Ghat
9 Banaras Hindu University Prof N.K Dubey (FNASC) (9838602197) Prof B D Tripathy (UGC-BSR Faculty fellow BHU, Ganga Pollution Research ) (94152 25011)
10 Jal Nigam Mr. SP Srivastava (Chief Engineer)
11 PWD Urban Part Mr. RapeshRajvanshi
12 UPSIDC Varanasi Mr. SubhashTripathy 9935757014
13 District Industries Centre Mr. Umesh Kumar Singh Joint Commissioner Industries
14 Ganga Pollution Mr. Ramesh Chaudhary, GM
15 BHU Ms. UshaKumari Senior Research Fellowship Zoology Department
The key findings of the stakeholder consultation details have been provided below:
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 164
7.2. Institutional Consultation
Consultations at the institutional level was to understand the proposed infrastructure
development projects around the proposed NW-1 project. It came out with the discussion that
no infrastructure development project will cause any adverse impact on the NW-1 project. The
planned projects will facilitate the NW-1 project; i.e. road connectivity with the terminal, sewage
treatment for clean ganga. The environment issues discussed with stockholders is provided in
Table 7.2:
Table 7.2: Environment Issues discussed with stockholders
Date Location and Concern
Person
Environmental Issues
20.06.2015 A.K.Mishra
Deputy Director
IWAI,Varanasi
According to him site location is suitable for
development of terminal from HFL prospective. Other
points he added are
Economic Feasible Reduce Air and noise pollution, Increased Employment
21.06.2015 Fisherman and Boatman,
Balua Ghat,Varanasi
Discussion was carried out with Fishermen and
boatman regarding the impact of this project. Most of
them are educated till Higher secondary level. People
are well aware about the project. The main issues of
the fisherman and boatman are:
Negative impact on fish due to pollution Suspected Reduction in fish catch due to
pollution Suspect their boats running business and
which will affect their daily income. Construction will cause siltation due to which
fish will dies Some of them wants this project because
more job opportunity will create in the area.
22.06.2015 Ralhupur Village Discussion was carried out with Farmers, students
and PAF regarding the impact of this project. People
are well aware about the project. The main issues of
the villagers are:
Not satisfied with the Compensation given to them by Govt.
Most of them want this project because more job opportunity will create in the area.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 165
People were expecting permanent job in this project.
Majority of people have positive attitude towards the project.
People also expect infrastructure development such as good roads, water supply, power supply in their area after coming up of proposed terminal.
People expects that the upcoming project is of less polluting industries so as no pollution related problems will observed in the area.
23.06.2015 Ajay roy,DFO,
Kashi Van Mandal
Kacchua sanctuary
Varanasi
Discussion was carried out to identify environmental
issues may associate with Turtle Sanctuary.
Following are the main concerns of the officer:
There turtle will get impacted due to regular movement of ships and vessels in river.
Because the Turtle is very shy in nature the noise generated from the waterway transport will affect them.
Siltation during the construction period will create a problem to aquatic fauna.
Chance of oil spillage from the ships will contaminate the Ganga water quality.
Solid waste generation management shall be done in scientific manner.
24.06.2015
Dr.B.D. Tripathi
UGC-BSR,BHU
Ganga pollution Research,
NMCGA
Discussion was carried out with him regarding this
project. Following are the main concerns of Dr.
Tripathi was:
Ganga River has anti bacterial quality on itself. Execution of this project, Ganga will lose its anti bacterial property.
Aquatic flora and fauna will disturbs Religious point of view he was not satisfied. Overall he is not in favor of this project.
24.06.2015 E.S.P.Srivastava,
Sacchiv,Jal Nigam
Irrigiation Department
Varanasi
He is concerned about the vibration generated due to
heavy traffic movement can disturb the strata of
pump wells located in Ganga river for drinking water
purposes.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 166
26.06.2015
Dr. G.S. Dharbari
President of U.P chamber of
commerece
Output of the discussion is as below
There is very less water in many stretches along the Ganga. How is it feasible?
There is huge siltation in Ganga River. How the waterways will maintain.
Construction and dredging will lead to siltation and create problem to aquatic fauana.
7.3. Affected Person’s (Land Acquisition) Consultation
Land Acquisition for the terminal was carried out earlier and the affected families have
approached the court for higher compensation. Points discussed with them as follows :
Consultation with Affected families in Rahalupur, Ramnagar, Varanasi
As per PAFs, a consultation were held in 1991 for their land acquisition but they got compensation in 2004 of Rs.22000/- per Biswa that was very less because the circle rate in 1991 was Rs.1.90 lakhs per Biswa.
As per PAFs, they lost their land in 1991 due to construction of the terminal and did not get compensation at 2004 circle rate.
They wished and expect from authority that their compensation should be on current market price.
They got notification from government before acquisition of their land.
As per villagers, officers from block/anchal never talked to them regarding compensation and land acquisition.
They have been growing crops like Jau, Pulse, Arhar, Masoor for a long time on their landbut now they have been gradually losing their irrigation land.
Villagers are requesting that compensation of their land should be as per prevailing market rate, if it is not feasible at least compensation should be disbursed to them on circle rate.
Some Project affected families have filed petitions in the court for higher compensation.
Sl.No. Name of the Affected Persons
1 Dinesh Singh
2 Ashok Singh
3 Santosh Kumar Singh
4 Alok Kumar Singh
5 Gopal Singh
6 Narender Bahadur Singh
7 Laxami Prasad Rai and family
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 167
7.4. Direct/Indirect Affected Person’s Consultation
Four Consultations sessions were carried out with the fishermen, boatmen and Squatters at the
Balwa Ghat near the proposed terminal. The outcome of the consultations are as follows:
People were happy with the NW-1 project.
As per fisherman it is their ancestor livelihood, forefather involved in this profession
As per these fisherman, area of the Sanctuary is around 7 km starting from Ram Nagar Fort to Malvipur.
They extract upto five kg fish from Ganga river and sells these fishes from Rs.60/- to Rs.200/- per kg.
Fishermen sell their catch near the ghatin the evening and the provision to continue the same should be ensure.
Ghat is also used for various religious activities, which give them livelihood and are looking for continued livelihood activities during project work phase.
Squatters are happy and looking for new livelihood/ business opportunities.
Villagers informed that forest department is not allowing their boats for fishing, which is affecting their livelihood and government should allow fishing or provide them work in project as per their skill and education background.
Some awareness program should be run by the Government agencies to update the project activities on regular basis.
7.5. Conclusion:
Social Assessment (SA) has been carried out as part of the entire study. Under the study, basic
social investigations were carried out to collect views and opinions of different stakeholders of
the project area. The main objective of the SA under this project was to carry out an
assessment on prevailing socio-economic condition and likely impacts of the project and
prospects in connection with the proposed structures and interventions of the project.
A further study in detail (if required) will be carried out once the land acquisition and related
activities are complete to identify the project-affected household, their socio-economic condition
and assessment of their land and properties to be affected under the project. A resettlement and
rehabilitation plan will be prepared considering due attention about the socio-economic
condition of the PAFs, and other vulnerable and indigenous group of people likely to be affected
due to the implementation of project.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 168
Baluva Ghat Photos
Session 1: Consultation with Boatmen and Fishing community
Session 2: Consultation with Boatmen, Sqatters and Fishing community
Session 3: Consultation with Boatmen and Fishing
community Photograph of Baluva Ghat
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 169
Consultation with affected Families at Rahalupur Fish Mandi at Baluwa ghat Ramnagar
Session 3: Consultation with Boatmen and Fishing community
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 170
8. ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN AND MONITORING INDICATORS
8.1. Introduction
The Environmental Management Plan (EMP) is the synthesis of all proposed mitigation and
monitoring actions, set to a time frame with specific responsibility assigned and follow-up
actions defined. EMP is a plan of actions for avoidance, mitigation and management of the
negative impacts of the project. Environmental enhancement is also an important component of
EMP. A detailed set of mitigation measures have been compiled in view of the likely impacts
associated with the proposed phase 1A of multimodal inland water terminal at Varanasi
8.2. The Environmental Management Plan
The EMP consists of a set of mitigation, monitoring and institutional measures to be taken
during the design, construction and operation (post-construction) stages of the project. The
EMP has been designed keeping in view the regulatory and other requirements to ensure the
following:
Minimum disturbance to the native flora and fauna
Compliance with the air, water, soil and noise quality norms.
Conservation of water to the extent possible through rain water harvesting,
wastewater recycling
Considering all the impacts identified for construction phase of terminal 1A, during the EIA
study, mitigation measures are proposed to prevent pollution. Impacts associated with operation
phase are not discussed here as the project will not be operationalized after construction of
phase 1A and same will be discussed in EIA study of phase 1B. Detailed EMP is given below
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 171
Table 8.1: Environment Management Plan
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
1. Climate
1. Project is
unlikely
to cause
negative
effect on
climate.
However,
project
can
contribute
positively
for
climate
Avoid cutting any tree standing on the proposed terminal site or temporary accesses area of 600m length.
Prior permission shall be taken for cutting any tree.
Compensatory tree planation shall be carried out for any tree cut (as per state forest policy)
Addition plantation of local variety of tree ( 200 no one row of tree on three side of the terminal land) shall be carried out along boundary of the terminal site
Forest Conservation Act, 1980
Access road area and proposed terminal area
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Compensatory /Additional Plantation ( @ Rs 500 per tree for 200 tree) ) Rs 100000
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC9
2. Natural Hazard
2. Earthqua
ke-
Seismic
Zone III
i.e.,
Adoption of Relevant IS codes while designing the civil structures to sustain the earthquake of moderate to high magnitude.
Applicable BIS Standards
Project area
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
9 It is proposed to set up Social and Environmental Management Unit (SEMU) in IWAI to manager social and environmental aspect of NW1 augmentation. PMC
( Project Management Consultants) anticipated to be appointed for project management and quality check.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 172
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Moderate
damage
risk
zone10
3. Site Preparation : Access road, Construction Camp, Construction Site
3. Improve
ment of
Access
road :
pavement
of the
road,
Disposal
of
accumula
Improvement of Access Road:
Access road route and alignment (for unpaved area) shall be finalized and submitted to PMC and IWAI for their concurrence.
Tree shall not be cut. Alignment shall be suitable adjusted to avoid cutting of the tree. If unavoidable, than tree shall be cut with due permission from concerned district/forests authorities.
Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000,
Social Impact Assessment requirements
Juncture of Access road and Entrance phase 1A terminal site
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
10
IS:1893 (Part 1): 2002 Indian Standard Criteria for Earthquake Resistant Design of Structures Part 1 General Provisions and Buildings Fifth Revision divides
the Indian subcontinent into five seismic zones ( II to V) depending on the magnitude and damage intensity of seismic activity.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 173
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
ted
Municipal
Solid
Waste11 :
Loss of
Agricultur
al land,
loss of
tree, air
and noise
pollution
Trimming of the large tree standing close to the site shall be done as minimum as possible.
Provision shall be made for dust suppression during its use.
Provision shall be made (safety boards, speed control, traffic guards) to prevent accident.
Survival rate of tree shall be regularly monitored. It is shall be minimum 70%.
Municipal Solid Waste Management :
Arrangement shall be made for identifying the area for disposal of construction debris and notify to
11
Substantial municipal solid waste is disposed at the entrance and around the proposed terminal site requiring proper management of the same.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 174
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
IWAI. The site should be minimum 1000 m distance from the river bank, residential area and sensitive areas like hospitals, school and temples.
Arrangement shall be made for segregation of waste generated from construction site into recyclable, compostable and non-compostable waste.
Resalable/recyclable waste shall be sold off to authorized agencies. Compostable waste will be composted in pits at site and non-compostable waste shall be disposed off to designated landfill site. If designated landfill site not available, then debris disposal site shall be identified
4. Setting of
Labor
Camps :
Loss of
agricultur
e land,
contamin
ation of
land and
Location of Camp:
Agriculture land should not be used for development of construction labour camps. Barren/waste land should be used
Site identified by contractor should be approved by the engineers of PMC/IWAI
Proper closure, stabilization and rehabilitation of the area should be
The Building and Other Construction workers (Regulation of Employment and Conditions of Service) Act 1996 and Cess Act of 1996 and
Labour Camp Locations
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Approximate Rs 500,000/- per camp for sanitation an health facilities.
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 175
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
water
resources
from
municipal
waste
from
Camps,
worker‟s
health,
Pressure
on
natural
resources
due to
establish
ment of
labour
camps
carried out as soon as the activity is completed
No land should be used for above purpose without consent of land owner. Sanitation and Worker’s Health :
Camp shall be well ventilated. It should have adequate provision for illumination, kitchen and safe drinking water facility shall be provided at the camp
Adequate bathing and sanitation facilities to be provided at labour camp. Mobile Toilets shall be provided. Soak Pits can be provided only if labour camp is located away from river.
Proper drainage to be maintained around the sites to avoid water logging leading to disease
Preventive medical care to be provided to workers- six monthly medical check-up should be organized
Waste will be collected & segregated within site into recyclable, compostable and inert waste. Recyclable waste will be sold
The Water (Prevention & Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and amendments thereof. Municipal Solid Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 2000
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 176
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
off to authorized dealers. Compostable waste shall be pit composted and inert waste shall be sent for disposal to landfill or site identified for debris disposal.
Provision shall be made for essential material supply like cooking fuel ( only LPG gas should be used, open burning of fuel should not be allowed)
Provision shall be made for day crèche for children
5. Setting
up
constructi
on Camp:
Concert
Mix Plant,
Hot Mix
Plant,
Mechanic
al
Worksho
p, Fuel
storages,
Lubricant
storages
All these facilities shall be installed at proposed terminal site itself. In case these are to be set up away from site than these shall be located at minimum distance of 500 m from habitation, water bodies and 1000 m from forest areas.
All maintenance facilities, hot mix plant and concrete missing plant shall be established with prior consent to establish to be obtained from SPCB.
All such equipment/plant shall be fitted with air pollution control system and shall comply with condition of consent to establish.
Periodic monitoring shall be carried
Air (Prevention and Control of Water Pollution) Act, 1981 and Water (Prevention and Control of Water Pollution) Act, 1972
Site construction Camp
During design and Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Approximate Rs 500,000/- per camp for sanitation an health facilities.
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 177
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
as per consent conditions.
4. Site Preparation : Power supply, Water Supply, Drainage and disposal of muck and debris
6. Power
supply
and
Energy
Conserva
tion: Air
Pollution ,
energy
loss
Power shall be sourced from national/state grid. DG sets shall be used only during power failure.
Back-up power shall be set up with all provisions of containment for fuel leakages, air pollution control (stack height as per regulation), and with acoustic enclosure.
Solar energy shall be used in common lighting area on 1:2 basis.
Buildings designed should have green infrastructure. Measures should be taken to conserve energy as per ECBC norms as applicable.
Energy Conservation Building Code 200733
Construction Sites, Access road, and Labour Camp Locations
During design, Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
7. Water
Supply,
Drainage
and
effluent
discharge
The Area is under safe category as per Central Ground Water Board. However, necessary permission shall be taken from district authorities as applicable before digging the bore well.
Staff and visitors should be made
Central Ground Water Board, Local regulations.
Construction Sites, and Labour Camp Locations
Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Approx. Rs 300,000 for construction of grease traps and
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 178
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
aware about water conservation by displaying posters and signage
Garland storm water temporary drains shall be developed around the site to prevent any direct discharge of contaminated or soiled water to river. It shall be pass through di-siltation chamber and water collection pit. Collected water shall be used for construction purposes.
All washing and maintenance effluent from the workshop area of vehicle maintenance area should darin to separate collection areas fitted with oil and grease trap and de- siltation chamber. The treated water shall be used for dust suppression and green belt development. This water shall not be discharged to river at all.
de-siltation chambers
8. Disposal
of piling
earth,
muck and
debris:
uncontroll
Provision shall be made for collection and draining of water for the piling earth. It shall be used for embankment protection or road construction depending on its suitability.
Provision shall be made for geo
Terminal area River Bank along the terminal site
Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 179
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
ed
disposal
may
leads to
increased
sediment
ation of
the river.
Synthetic Screen for arresting silt flowing down stream.
5. Embankment Design and Construction, Drainage Pattern and Fishermen’s Access to River.
9. River
Bank
Erosion
Protectio
n:
Construct
ion of
Embank
ment
and
constructi
on of jetty
: may
lead to
accumula
tion of
Embankment protection measures (stone pitching) shall be made in both upstream and downstream to the extent that erosion is minimized.
Erosion monitoring shall be carried out periodically downstream as well.
River Bed material shall be tested for contaminants before its use or disposal for land fill site. If any level of heavy metal contamination is found than it shall be disposed off in a secure manner.
River Bank along the terminal site
During design, Pre-Construction and construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 180
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
sediment
s on the
updrift
side and
erosion of
the
downdrift
side .
Contamin
ation of
river
water
quality
and land
may
happen
due to
river bed
material
10. Drainage
Pattern
Natural Drainage pattern of area around shall be maintained. No waste shall be allowed to dumped to industrial effluent Nala flowing adjacent to the terminal site. Its opening to river shall not be obstructed in any manner.
Construction Sites, Access road, and Labour Camp Locations
Pre-Construction Stage and construction stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 181
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
11. Access to
river :
restricted
movemen
t of
fisherman12
Fishing activities are seen in the river close to site. Arrangement shall be made to provide free access to river and undisturbed safe movement of the fishermen.
Terminal site and area around
Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor.
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
6. Construction Material Sourcing
12. Borrow
areas for
sourcing
earth for
filling as
required
(erosion,
loss of
productiv
e land,
Non-productive lands, barren lands, raised lands; wastelands shall be used for borrowing earth with the necessary permissions/consents.
Agricultural areas not to be used as borrow areas unless requested by the landowner for lowering the land for making it cultivable.
Excavation depth should not exceed 1.5 m bgl
IRC Guidelines on borrow areas and for quarries. EIA Notification 2006( under Environmental Protection Act and Rules, 1986; )
All Identified Borrow sites
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
12
Fishing activities are seen. Local fisherman are seen fishing close to river areas. They access the river from small temporary access around the site.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 182
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
land
degradati
on, air
pollution)
Environmental Clearance from State Environmental Impact Assessment Authority and required permission from District Magistrate shall be obtained prior to excavation. Copy of this permission shall be submitted to IWAI before start of excavation.
Record of location, area, accessibility to the location and photograph of borrow area should be maintained prior to excavation
Site selected for borrow area should be approved by PMC & IWAI expert prior to excavation
Ridges of not less than 8m width will be left at intervals not exceeding 300m. Small drains will be cut through the ridges, if necessary, to facilitate drainage.
The slope of the edges will be maintained not steeper than 1:4 (vertical: Horizontal).
Topsoil to be stockpiled and protected for use at the rehabilitation stage.
Rehabilitation shall be satisfactorily undertaken immediately after the use has ceased and at least three
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 183
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
weeks prior to monsoon.
Unpaved surfaces used for the haulage of borrow materials to be maintained.
Transportation of earth materials shall be through covered vehicles.
Quarries for sourcing stone and aggregates (loss of productive land, land degradation, air pollution. Any illegal quarrying may lead to land use change, unstable rock formation)
Aggregates required for embankment stone pitching and roads shall be procured from licensed quarries.
It shall be ensures that selected quarries are having requisite environment clearance, and comply with Air Pollution Control and Noise level requirements as per the law.
Copy of Environmental Clearance letter and Consent to Operate and shall Be obtained and submitted to IWAI.
Material shall be transported under covered trucks only.
No new quarry shall be opened without due permissions.
Each Quarry shall be visited prior to its selection to ensure its compliance with lease conditions, EC and consent conditions.
EIA Notification 2006( under Environmental Protection Act and Rules, 1986; )
Quarry Site
During design and Pre-Construction Stage
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 184
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Stone crushers, if required, shall be set up only after consent from SPCB and taking adequate measures for air pollution control
7. Protection of Flora and Fauna
13. Protectio
n of
Tortoise :
Increased
sediment
ation
downstre
am of
constructi
on site
Tortoise Sanctuary is located at about 2.3 Km from site.
No movement of tortoise is reported upward to the site. No harm shall be caused to these tortoise in case any tortoise is sited. Necessary caution notice shall be displaced and conveyed to all construction workers and officers.
Geo-Textile synthetic sheet curtain shall be placed around pilling and construction area to prevent movement of sediments and construction waste.
Wild Life ( Protection ) Act, 1972
In and Around Project Site
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project costs
SEMU through DFO
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
14. Terrestria
l Fauna:
increase
in hunt
Caution sign shall be placed to prevent hunting of wild animal and birds.
Provision shall be made for strict penalty for hunting these animals.
Wild Life ( Protection ) Act, 1972
In and Around Project Site
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project costs
Contractor
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 185
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
tendency13
High noise construction work shall not be made in night.
15. Vegetation loss due to site preparation and construction activities
Tree shall not be cut as much as possible. Any tree cut shall be compensated with compensatory tree plantation as per state forest policy.
Tree plantation shall be made as feasible at site and around the site depending on land availability.
Provision of LPG shall be made in construction site camp and labour camp as fuel source to avoid tree cutting.
Proper arrangement of lighting should be made at site and construction labour camp
Open burning of fuel for any purpose should not be allowed at the site
Forest Conservation Act, 1980
In and Around Project Site and labour camp
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
13Peacock and Wild Neel Gai are sited next to project site.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 186
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
16. Effect on
Aquatic
life such
as Fish,
Plankton14
No breeding ground is noticed around the project site. However construction activity shall be restricted during spawning period of June to August.
Sedimentation and siltation shall be prevented/ controlled to maintain productivity of aquatic ecosystem and ensure availability of food for aquatic fauna & flora.
Terminal construction site
During the design and Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
8. Air Quality
17. Fugitive Dust
Generation
due to
construction
activities
Transport of loose and fine materials through covered vehicles.
Loading and unloading of construction materials in covered area.
Approach roads shall be paved and widened.
Water spraying on earthworks, unpaved haulage roads, other dust prone areas and construction yard.
Make Provision of PPEs like face mask to workers.
Environmental Protection Act, 1986 and amendments thereof; The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 and amendments thereof
Construction sites, Loading areas, storage areas,
During the Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
18. Exhaust gas
emissions
Regular maintenance shall be carried out of machinery and
Environmental Protection Act,
Construction camps
During the Constructio
Part of project
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
14
The floodplain fisheries are dominated by major and minor carps viz, Labio rohita, Catla catla, Cirrhinus mrigala, L. bata, Puntius sps. and catfishes viz. H.
fossilis, Mystus sps, etc. and fishes of family Clupeidae, Notopteridae and a mix of many other families.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 187
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
from
machinery and
vehicular
traffic.
equipment.
Periodic Ambient air quality monitoring shall be carried out.
DG sets to be fitted with stacks of adequate height and low sulphur diesel to be used in DG sets as well as in machineries.
Monitoring of air quality for PM10, PM2.5, SOx, NOx, and CO shall be carried out quarterly at construction site. Stack monitoring shall be carried out every month at the site.
1986 and amendments thereof; The Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1981 and amendments thereof
and sites, concrete mixing plant, DG sets locations
n stage Costs
19. Emissions at
access road :
avoidance of
traffic Jams15
Efforts shall be made to move construction material early morning and late evening period.
Traffic regulators ( Guard) shall be posted in habitat area and at key junction areas to avoid congestion
-do- Access road
During the Construction stage
- Do - Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
9. Noise and Vibration
15
The roads connecting the proposed sites is narrow and also passes through habitat area. Traffic remains heavy.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 188
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
20. Noise from
construction
vehicle,
equipment
and
machinery.
All equipment to be timely serviced and properly maintained to minimize its operational noise.
Construction equipment and machinery to be fitted with silencers and maintained properly.
Provision of temporary noise barrier near habitat areas during construction phase.
Protection devices (ear plugs or ear muffs) will be provided to the workers operating in the vicinity of high noise generating machines.
Speed control shall be enforced in habitat areas.
The ambient noise level as per CPCB standard is 55 dB(A) and 45 db(A). Current noise level at habitat area meets the standard
Noise monitoring day and night at site, labour camp and access road area shall be carried quarterly to ensure the effectiveness of mitigation measures.
Noise Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 and amendments thereof
Construction Site and accesses road.
During the Construction stage
Part of project Costs
Contractor
IWAI/SEMU/PMC
10. Land-use and Landscape
21. Land use
Change and
Loss of
Efforts shall be made to improve the aesthetic of the area. No construction waste or other wastes
Design requirement
Around project site area and
During construction Stage
Approximately Rs 25000 for
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 189
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
productive/top
soil
shall be dumped at unidentified areas. Caution board in local language shall be placed at different locations to prevent dumping of waste generated from construction site in the river and nearby areas
Compensatory tree plantation for loss of trees.
Top soil shall be preserved and laid over either on the embankment slope for growing vegetation to protect soil erosion or spread over in the proposed plantation areas.
Land earmarked for dumping of construction waste shall be free from any social and R&R issue and away from settlements.
borrow area
five caution boards @ Rs 5000 per board
22. Soil erosion
due to
construction
activities,
earthwork
Provision of cross drainage
structure shall be made in the
access road if required to maintain
the natural drainage pattern.
Provision of side drain shall be made in access road if required to prevent water logging.
Measures like building of scouring protection structures, protection by
Access road and river bank
Construction stage
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 190
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
geo-textiles matting etc shall be made, if river bank erosion is found around the terminal area.
Bio-turfing of embankments shall be made enhance the slop stabilization.
23. Soil erosion
at earth
stockpiles
The earth stockpiles to be provided with gentle slopes to prevent soil erosion.
At earth stockpiles
Construction stage
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
24. Compaction
and
contamination
of soil due to
movement of
vehicles and
equipment
Fuel and lubricants to be stored at the predefined storage location.
Storage area shall be paved with gentle slope to a corner and connected with a chamber to collect any spills of the oils.
Provision of “oil interceptors” at wash-down and re-fuelling areas.
Oil and grease spill and oil soaked materials are to be collected and stored in labelled containers (Labelled: WASTE OIL; and hazardous sign be displayed) and sold off to SPCB/ MoEF authorized vendors.
Movement of construction vehicles, machinery and equipment shall be restricted to the designated haulage route.
Terminal site
Pre construction and construction stage.
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 191
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
11. Water Resources
25. Depletion of
Groundwater
resources due
to unregulated
abstraction for
construction
purpose
Preference shall be given to source water from rivers wherever feasible in the project area with due permission from authorities. .
Augmentation through incorporating water harvesting structures if technically feasible.
Construction of check dams in consultation with community to reduce burden on ground water resources.
Efforts to restrict water intensive activities during summer period (April, May, June)
During
Constructio
n stage
Part of
project
costs
Contractor, IWAI/SEMU/PMC
26. Increase in
water Siltation
levels due to
construction of
terminal and
contamination
due to
disposal of
domestic
waste
The piling work shall be undertaken during low flow period.
Restoration of changes in the stream, if any, made during construction to its original level.
Precautions shall be made that no nala or canal is clogged.
Substructure construction should be limited to the dry season and cofferdams may be constructed and utilized to lift the spoil directly out of it and carried to the riverbank for land disposal.
Terminal
Site
During
Constructio
n stage
Part of
project
costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 192
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Mobiel toilets with anaerobic digestion facility shall be fixed at construction site. No domestic waste shall be discharged to river.
12. Accident and Safety Risks
27. Accident risk
from
construction
activities
Contractors to adopt and maintain safe working practices.
Usage of fluorescent signage, in local language at the construction sites
Training shall be provided to workers, especially machinery operators, on safety procedures and precautions.
The contractors to appoint a safety officer mandatory.
At every work place, a readily available first aid unit including an adequate supply of dressing materials, a mode of transport (ambulance), nursing staff, and doctor to be provided.
Required PPE shall be provided to workers.
Half yearly medical check-up shall be carried of the workers and summary report shall be submitted to PMC
Central Motor
and Vehicle
Act 1988
EP Act 1986
Noise Rules 2002
Construction sites
Construction period
Part of project costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 193
Environmental Issue/ Component
Remedial Measure Reference to laws and Contract
Documents
Approximate Location
Time Frame
Indicative /
Mitigation Cost
Institutional
Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
13. Shifting of Common Property Resources and other Utilities
Shifting of community properties and utilities
As per assessment, no such shifting is involved. However if any shifting is involved it shall done at suitable location with the concurrence from local authorities and community.
Project Area
Pre- Construction
Part of Project Costs
Contractor IWAI/SEMU/PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 194
8.3. Institutional Arrangement
IWAIwill develop Environmental Management Framework with the help of World Bank. The
institutional arrangement shall align as per this framework. IWAI will have an Environmental and
social cell which will coordinate with site engineers and PMC.
8.3.1. Environmental Management Cell
Apart from having an Environmental Management Plan, it is also necessary to have apermanent
organizational set up charged with the task of ensuring its effectiveimplementation of mitigation
measures and to conduct environmental monitoring.
Highly qualified and experienced persons in the field of Environmental Management ofTerminal
shall be considered for the positions ofGeneral Manager (GM) and Managers for overall
Environmental management for proposed project. The majorduties and responsibilities of
Environment Management Cell are:
To implement the environmental management plan
To assure regulatory compliance with all relevant rules and regulations
To ensure regular operation and maintenance of pollution control devices
To minimize environmental impacts of operations as by strict adherence to the EMP
To initiate environmental monitoring as per approved schedule
Review and interpretation of monitoring as per approved schedule
Review and interpretation of monitoring results and corrective measures in case monitored
results are above the specified limit
Maintain documentation of good environmental practices and applicable environmentallaws
as ready reference
Maintain environmental related records
Coordination with regulatory agencies, external consultant, monitoring laboratories
Maintain log of public complain and the action taken
Efforts shall be made for setting up of common conservation cell consisting of one
marinebiologist, and ecologist, a sociologist and a fishery expert
The proposed environmental management cell should have all basic record keeping
facilitiessuch as hard w are/software facilities, adequate space, vehicle (transport) and basic
furnitureand all simple instruments such as GPS, Digital camera, Hand held noise metre etc.
The cellshould have all basic environmental management data of the project that includes but
notlimited to the following:
Environmental Impact Assessment Report (both well preserved soft and hard copy)
All valid and up to date environmental clearance and consent papers
All latest Environmental legislations, policies, codes and manuals for ready references
A list of consultants on environmental management need to be kept with yearly revision of
the list. This will help to receive proper advice in case of an emergency or arequirement and
also to implement day to day environmental management activities.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 195
Over a period of time a system to understand and absorb the new revisions and changes inthe
environmental requirements and practices are to be established. This can only beachieved by
regular training and genuine capacity building initiatives. Institutional framework for the project is
given in figure 8.1
Figure 8.1: Institutional Framework
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 196
8.4. Environmental Standards
Environmental standards to be followed for disposal of waste, emissions, disposal of dredged
soil etc is attached as appendix I.
8.5. Environment Monitoring Plan
The objective of environmental monitoring during the construction and operation phases is to
compare the monitored data against the baseline condition collected during the study period to
assess the effectiveness of the mitigation measures and the protection of the ambient
environment based on national standards. The following are the main objectives of the
environmental monitoring program:
Provides information for documentation of monitoring of mitigation measures and
impacts
Tool for the statutory authority of unanticipated adverse impacts or sudden changes
inthe environmental condition due to the proposed project
Provides information that could be used for evaluating the effectiveness of
implementedmitigation measures
Provides information that could be used to verify predicted impacts and thus
validateimpact prediction techniques
The effectiveness of the mitigation measures being followed during construction
andoperational phases can be assessed and the measures can be revised, made
morestringent and reinforced based on the monitoring results
Environmental Monitoring can also serve a basic component of a periodic
environmentalregulatory auditing program for the proposed project
A monitoring schedule has been sketched based on the environmental components that may be
affected during the construction phase of the project. Environmental monitoring plan for
operation stage will be discussed in EIA study to bae carried out for phase 1B of terminal.
Environment monitoring indicators identified are listed below
Monitoring Indicators
Air quality- ambient air quality levels & stack emissions
Surface Water quality
Drinking water quality- for construction labours
Noise levels- ambient noise level and work zone noise levels
Soil quality- dredged sand quality and soil quality
Solid & Hazardous Waste Management
Wastewater disposal
Re-plantation success / survival rate
Soil Erosion
Aquatic ecology– plankton and benthic communities
Integrity of embankment
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 197
These indicators will evaluated periodically based on the monitoring results, baseline conditions,
predicted impacts and mitigation measures.
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 198
Table 8.2: Environment Monitoring Plan
S. No.
Aspect Parameters to be monitored
No of sampling locations & frequency
Standard methods for smapling and analysis
Role & Responsibility
Implementation
Supervision
Construction Period
1 Air Quality (Ambient & Stack)
PM10, PM2.5, SO2, NO2, HC and CO
Four Sites including project site and 3 other sites within 2 km of terminal site Once in a month
Fine Particulate Samplers for PM2.5
Respirable Dust Sampler fitted PM10
Respirable Dust Sampler fitted with Gaseous sampling arrangements for SO2 and NO2, CO analyser /portable CO meter for CO portable HC meter or tubes for HC; TO-14A, TO-15, USEPA method for sampling and analysis of VOCs in ambient air
Contractor IWAI & PMC
2 Surface Water Quality
Physical, chemical and biological
River Ganga & Gurha Nallah Once a month
Grab sampling and analysis by using standard methods
Contractor IWAI & PMC
3 Drinking water Quality
Physical, chemical and biological
Drinking water fro labour camps Once a month
Grab sampling and analysis by using standard methods
Contractor IWAI & PMC
4 Noise Level Day time and night time noise level (max, min & Leq levels)
Construction labour camp, construction site and 2 locations within 2 km of terminal site Once a month
Noise meter Contractor IWAI & PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 199
5 Soil Quality Soil texture, type, Electrical conductivity, pH, infiltration, porosity, etc.,
Construction site, labour camps and debris disposal site Once in 6 months
Collection and analysis of samples as per IS 2720
Contractor IWAI & PMC
6 Soild & Hazardous Waste Management
Physical & Chemical characteristics
Construction site, labour camps and debris disposal site Daily
MSW Rules, 2000, Hazardous Waste & Management Rules, 2008
Contractor IWAI & PMC
7 Wastewater Management
Physical, chemical and biological
Construction site & labour camps Once a month
-- Contractor IWAI & PMC
8 Plantation Plantation survival rate
At plantation site (terminal site & afforestation site)
Survey, counting, recording & reporting
Contractor IWAI & PMC
9 Soil Erosion --- Upstream & downstream of terminal site
Survey & observation; Extent and degree of erosion; Structures for controlling soil erosion
Contractor IWAI & PMC
10 Aquatic ecology Phytoplankton, Zooplankton
River Ganga & Gurha Nallah Once a month
Plankton net of diameter of 0.35 m, No.25 mesh size 63 and analysis by using standard methods.
Contractor IWAI & PMC
11 Integrity of embankment
--- Upstream & downstream of terminal site
Survey & observation; Extent and degree of erosion; Structures for controlling soil erosion
Contractor IWAI & PMC
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 200
8.6. Reporting Requirement
It is required that contractor will submit quarterly compliance report to Project Management
Consultants (PMC) as well as to SEMU ( social and environmental Management Unit) of IWAI.
PMC will analyze the report and notify the corrective action if any required to contractor under
intimation to IWAI.
8.7. Grievance Redress Mechanism
The concern/grievances from local/affected people may come up related to inappropriate
implementation of various components of EMP. These issues can be easily addressed through
acknowledgement, evaluation and corrective action and response approach. To resolve
grievance from public or stakeholders concerning the project will be directed to the
SPMU/Director concerned. Firstly, it will be assessed if the grievances are genuine or
suggestion is acceptable. Accordingly, response will be given within 15-30 days by the SEMU in
consultation with PMC and Director concerned. In case the SEMU is unable to resolve the
issue, the matter will be forwarded to Project Director at Head Quarter. The corrective action
will be started as per the response or action plan indicated to the stakeholder. The outcome
shall also form part of quarterly report to World Bank. (Figure 8.2)
ESIA Report-Multimodal River Water Terminal at Ramnagar, Varanasi, U.P., India
EQMS – IRGSSA – AIAID JV 201
Figure 8.2: Grievance Redressal Cell