epim i concise senior executive preview this slide show is a condensed summary of artf electronic...
TRANSCRIPT
ePIM I Concise Senior executive preview
This slide show is a condensed summary of ARTF Electronic Public Information Manual (ePIM) nbr I.
Please have your managers study the relevant full ePIM’s on www.artf-scrace.com (Library Section).
This preview is issued and used subject to the terms and usage notes of the original full ePIM’s, and the full ARTF-SCRACE etc. terms and conditions as listed on www.artf-scrace.com/terms
1
ARTF research findings:
On the broad scale African continental building , structure and roof asset damage and financial loss crisis.
Including widespread and dangerousSHE, fire, flood, leak and building illegality concerns.
Summary of practical remedies - for Owners, Tenants, Roofing professionals, Inspectors, Engineers, Architects, Stakeholders and Finance managers etc.
PART I of V – Issued january 2010
BASED ON ARTF/S.A.B.S./CSIR/HDGASA ET AL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT STUDIES (1994 – 2010)
THE ADVANCED ROOF TECHNOLOGY FOUNDATION
ARTF2
Copyright and usage termsBy opening and reading this file, the reader acknowledges and accepts that these materials are copyrighted to and are the intellectual property of RNA consultants (RNA), who have sole authority re the usage of these materials, which may not be altered, abbreviated, or issued under any other names than RNA. Usage reserved at RNA’s sole discretion.
3ARTFCopyright © January 2010 – RNA Consultants, all rights reserved
Walter Gordon Steward BarnettSecond Chairman of ARTF
Walter Barnett was the founder and an honorary lifetime member of the Hot Dip Galvanizers Association of Southern Africa. He has had a long and illustrious career in the corrosion control field, having acquired a number of honorary titles and awards for his achievements.
Mr. Barnett has twice served as President of the Corrosion Institute, and was Executive Director of the Hot Dip Galvanizers Association of Southern Africa (HDGASA). He was a gold and silver medal award winner of the Corrosion Institute, and was appointed as their Vice Chairman in 2003. He remained very active as a senior advanced technical consultant in the fields of corrosion protection, coatings and galvanizing, up until his passing on March 16, 2009.ARTF 4
5
“This vast pool of knowledge and experience, together with access to the S.A.B.S., CSIR, ISO and other international authorities, is available to industry through the services of ARTF and its members”.Mr. Gordon Munro - Internationally renowned veteran chemical, coatings and waterproofing authority. Manager of the S.A.B.S. Paints and Sealants Division (1988 to 1997). International S.A.B.S. and ISO spokesperson.
3rd ARTF Chairman and Custodian - 2005-2006
ARTF
6
“Overall costs which can be attributed to corrosion amount to several billion Rand annually in South Africa alone.
Corrosion damage to roofing contributes significantly to this costly situation”.
Editorial - Volume 4 Issue 1 2007 - Hot Dip Galvanizing Today
ARTF
7
Long-term neglect, and incorrect ventilation, material and corrosion control specifications, caused this Wadeville factory structure to fail very
dangerously, less than halfway through its projected lifespan.
8ARTF
“… the bill to replace a long neglected and weather/ corrosion damaged factory or warehouse roof, frequently costs between five and twelve million Rand”.(ARTF Roof Users’ Manual).
9ARTF
“In most cases, these extreme costs, losses and risks could have been reduced by 40% or more...”
(Based on CSIR roof cost study bulletin – ref #B1 104/002 5663 – 12 April 2000)
10
Extensive roof rust – Bloemfontein – per the CSIR and many other experts, roofs should be coated before rust occurs – this can reduce maintenance costs by half or more.
11ARTF
the long-term cost of not having correctly designed, constructed, repaired and maintained these very valuable assets, could run into the …
12ARTF
Hundreds of millions, or even …
13ARTF
BILLIONS OF RANDS IN DAMAGES AND LOSSES!!!
14
It does also appear to be true that when things do go wrong, it is mainly with the roof area”
Gordon H Munro - ISO and S.A.B.S. senior authority
ARTF
15
“…roofing, as an industry, is neither
regulated nor governed formally…”.
ARTF
Billy PerrinOwner/ publisher, SA Roofing Magazine
ARTF
HUNDREDS OF ROOFS RIPPED OFF BY WIND!
It has for some time been assumed that modern “clip system roofs”, as used on most new buildings today, are a more stable and secure alternative to older forms of roof sheeting … but …
16
17ARTF
… many hundreds of these roofs have been ripped up or damaged extensively by high winds!!!
18New roof sheets ripped loose by heavy winds - Johannesburg
19ARTF
EXTENSIVE FLOODING OCCURS IN MANY BUILDINGS!!!
Many years of careful study have shown that a very large percentage of buildings constructed in Southern Africa over the past 120 years …
20
have been dangerously under-designed etc. and are subject to …
ARTF
…extensive and severe internal flooding through gutters, stormwater drains, downpipes etc.
21
Costs set-aside for roof etc. replacements & repairs
(neglect/ unplanned scenario)
Disposable Income
These and other graphs, charts and calculations used in this slide-showare empirical approximations, not based on virtual models or formal accounting.
DISPOSABLE INCOME vs. DEPRECIATION
ROOFS & BUILDINGS
1963 1978 2009
22
INLAND METAL ROOF DEPRECIATION & MAINTENANCE PLANNING CHARTThis chart shows typical deterioration and loss of value and functionality of a large galvanized steel roof in Gauteng.
This projection assumes typical neglect and lack of suitable maintenance etc.Deprecation and maintenance/ repair rates are usually 30-300% higher at the coast, for common steel materials
23
“Death Valley Curve” Mechanical damage
and loss of asset value become somewhat
exponential from this point onwards
Decay curve of correctly designed, constructed and well maintained roof. Each Rand correctly spent saves three Rand later. SHE & legal issues reduced by 80% or more
24
CHART 2 METAL ROOF DEPRECIATION– MULTIPLE ROOFS, VARIOUS AGESThis chart shows typical deterioration and loss of value and functionality of a large galvanized steel roof in Gauteng
This projection assumes prolonged neglect and lack of suitable maintenance etc.
Deprecation and maintenance/ repair rates are usually 30-300% higher at the coast, for common steel materials
Value of A. B. C. D. E. F. G. H. I. J.a Phase Approximate Condition Typical Faults, Overall roof Potential Potential Success Investment Costs to
10000 m sq Age of Roof deterioration performance, success of serviceable life of value of rehabilitateroof of Roof leak expectancy maintenance, of a well-constructed coating ISO/ and (after after maintenance roof coating roof if correctly and SABS/ maintain
deprec- coating and repairs and repairs rehabilitated, regularly repair CSIR etc roofiation) maintained and methods style
correctly repaired maintenanceRATES OUT OF DATE
R5 800 000 Phase 1 Phase 1 0-5 years Excellent condition
R5 080 000 Phase 2 Phase 2 5-10 years Good condition.
Some damage
R4 350 000 Phase 3 Phase 3 11-14 years Fair condition.
Significant damage
R3 650 000 Phase 4 Phase 4 15-18 years Poor condition.Seriously damaged
R2 900 000
R2 200 000
Phase 5 Phase 5 19-25 years Very poorR1 450 000 condition,
very severely damaged
R 500 000 May needneed full
re-R 0 placement
No ValueAGE OF ROOF : 5 YEARS 10 YEARS 15 YEARS 20 YEARS 25 YEARS BEYOND 25 YEARS (NB: Graph line became condensed and distorted when chart was re-sized - we will correct in next edition.) PC File Ref: Chart - Roof maintenance.May 2005
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80TIME IN YEARS
Feb 2009
Repl
ace
incr
emen
tally
Full
SCRA
CE C
are
Prog
ram
me
Swea
t the
Ass
etPr
eser
ve &
Upg
rade
B Very expensive! Roof to be replaced
C Mid-age roof – seriously damaged.
D New roof - valuable protective galvanizing being stripped due to prolonged exposure and neglect.
E
Decay curve of correctly designed, constructed and well maintained roof. Each Rand correctly spent saves three Rand later. SHE & legal issues reduced by 80% or more
A Current date line
F The Rubicon Line – this is the line below which a roof is not reliably and securely salvageable using standard repair and maintenance practices.
SA ROOFING JOURNAL– AUGUST 2008 ROOF DEPRECIATION TABLE
AGRAPP - “ARTF Global Roof Asset Protection Plan” – now known as the “SCRACE system”. 25
26
Serious Fire, SHE, and Legal Violations and Risks are Very Common
A number of intensive site surveys also showed that SHE, fire, legal and other risks and violations, are…… a great deal more widespread, dangerous, and legally non-compliant nationally, than was previously realized!!!
ARTF
27
FIRE!
ARTF
“In recent years, two very well known large wholesale warehouse buildings have been gutted by fire in Gauteng, and their stock and equipment destroyed – this was due to the flammability of the roof insulation”.
Highly flammable, extremely bio-hazardous insulation media in use at a Butterworth warehouse– this product
releases deadly hydrogen-cyanide gas during combustion
In cases like this, insurance claims may be declined.
28
29
Illegal and very dangerous structural non-compliances and weaknesses are often a major issue in buildings.
ARTF
Structural risks and failures
Very unsafe, failed roof and structure – East London
30
31
The purpose of these laws, related by-laws and national standards (SANS 10400 etc.), is to ensure that buildings, equipment, structures, utilities etc. are …
... maintained in a safe and functional condition by the owners.
ARTF
... and that the building is able to resist the penetration of rainwater or moisture.
32
This includes ensuring that the building, structure etc. is able to withstand any foreseeable weather or event…
National Building Regulations, Pg. 54-55
ARTF
33
“Any company that owns or manages a large portfolio of … properties, is very probably in the middle of a massive asset damage, SHE risk, legal compliance and financial loss crisis, without realizing that anything is seriously wrong”.
ARTF Public Information Bulletin 2009
ARTF
THE LONG AND THE SHORT OF IT …
34
This situation has, from a company profitability and sustainability point of view, reached critical proportions”.
The Star
ARTF
35
“The roofing industry has
become a minefield”
ARTF
Comment by a senior CSIR Scientific Research authority – circa 2000
36
What affordable, realistic resource do building owners, managers or tenants have to protect themselves, their staff, equipment, assets, and their companies from such severe abuses, losses, liabilities and risks?
ARTF
Is there an affordable solution?
37ARTF
The ARTF-SCRACE building and roof remedial and maintenance system!
Answer
38
Advanced Level Corrosion Control
Services
Engineering Services
SCRACE CUSTODIAN &
CO-ORDINATOR FUNCTIONS
Special Corporate ServicesS
C
R
A
C
E
Specialised Roofing Services
Architectural Services
Construction Services
SCRACE
CUSTODIAN
SCRACE
CO-ORDINATOR
WORKS PROJECT
(Optimal & most economical
outcome and best investment return
ensured)
OWNER
/ TENANT
ARTF
39ARTF
SCRACE Definition:SCRACE derives its name from the first letters of the following:
Special corporate services; Corrosion control; Roofing; Architecture; Construction; Engineering.
SCRACE is an operations, structures and hard asset care and services portfolio that is scientifically developed to address building, property, client and employee needs in the field of roof and building technology, etc..
SCRACE is highly beneficial, as it is an advanced, holistic, synergistic and comprehensive science and system…
40ARTF
…carefully interlaced and balanced, to ensure maximum asset protection/ development; cost control; staff wellness; statutory, engineering and SHE compliance…
… building and function optimization; risk and loss control; green building and infrastructure development; energy efficiency optimization etc.
SCRACE Definition Contd.:
41ARTF
Use of 12-year SMP’s
SCRACE utilizes 12-year Strategic Maintenance Plans (SMP's), and cleverly paces and optimizes cost and works allocations, for maximal investment value, ongoing economy, and owner benefits.
42ARTF
A VETERAN SCIENTIFIC EXPERT COMMENTS ON SCRACE
“Although roofing project failures and sub-performance are (very) common in the local roofing industry, cases of such that have been reported to myself, the CSIR, ARTF or their senior members, regarding projects undertaken by ARTF approved specialist applicators, using the (SCRACE) specifications and application/ QA etc. systems, have decreased to zero”.M.S. Smit, Chief Research Officer (now retired), Division of Building and Construction Technology, CSIR. ( ) = editors changes
43ARTF
“The ARTF-SCRACE system probably achieves more asset salvation, stabilization, protection and optimization per Rand input, then any other method in use continentally.
It is a true, exceptional and very secure investment”.
ARTF Bulletin - 2009
44
The PSAR is a concise, broad-spectrum preliminary assessment of various key engineering, architectural, corrosion, SHE, fire, roofing etc. items, which provides recommendations regarding high priority works to be done over the following 3 years.It also includes advice regarding reliable expert professional resources, ideal specifications and materials to be used etc.
The SCRACE PSAR
45
PSAR COSTS:Micro PSAR - For a concise general overview R 13,980.00
Midi PSAR - Includes Fire Audit, Natural Ventilation Assessment, Safety and Health (S&H) Audit, more comprehensive Building and Roof Assessment*
R 24,980.00
ARTF
46
Full PSAR (Highly recommended):Includes: OHS etc. related Structural Engineer’s Assessment and Report Fire Audit Basic Natural Ventilation Assessment Building and Roof Assessment Safety and Health (S & H) Audit plus a Green Building/ Energy efficiency review*
R48,850.00
(All prices VAT Excl)
The full PSAR also includes a light preliminary review of your building’s “Green” and Energy Efficiency statuses, and feasible level-1 initiatives for the improvement and statutory / national standards compliance to same.
47
GREEN, LEAN AND CLEAN
ARTF
48
Your company’s next step:
to arrange for a PSAR (Preliminary SCRACE Assessment and Report) to be undertaken by an ARTF listed professional team, at one or more of your properties (see contact details on slide 117).
Contact ARTF now
ARTF
Executive Workshops
To help greatly improve your company’s understanding, safe practice, statutory compliance and due diligence in the areas covered by this slide show, ARTF highly recommends that all staff and executives attend the related mobile SCRACE workshops – cost R6,890.00 per workshop.
49ARTF (All prices VAT Excl)
Contact ARTF on +27 (0)11 605 2837; (0)71 343 9194
orLog on to www.artf-scrace.com
orContact your nearest ARTF-SCRACE listed
Consultant, Architect or Engineer
ARTF 50