equal treatment bench book (scotland) (2008)
TRANSCRIPT
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 1/206
CYSIB W_CIWNCEWOCEHL O@@K
ASDGIEHC
F@_ WLC JSGDHDI_T
Isasxw ?==< Jsgdhdib Xwsgdcx H`nndwwcc f`r Xh`wbieg
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 2/206
F@_CQ@_G w` wlc XCH@EG CGDWD@E
Ot
Wlc L`e B`rg Or`gdc"
Hlidrnie" Jsgdhdib Xwsgdcx H`nndwwcc
Wlcrc livc occe niet hlieacx ieg gcvcb`}ncewx de wlc biq xdehc wlc fdrxw cgdwd`e `f
wldx Ocehl O``k qix }r`gshcg de Gchcnocr ?==?% E`wiobt" wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 nigc rigdhib ibwcriwd`ex w` h`srw }r`hcgsrc% Wldx xch`eg cgdwd`e
iwwcn}wx w` deh`r}`riwc niet rchcew gcvcb`}ncewx" osw wlc `vcribb idn rcnidex ix
xwiwcg ot B`rg Qlciwbct de wlc f`rcq`rg w` wlc fdrxw cgdwd`e% Wlc Ocehl O``k rch`rgx
qliw dx segcrxw``g" ifwcr wlc h`exsbwiwd`e }r`hcgsrc gcwidbcg de I}}cegd| D" w` oc
hsrrcew ocxw }rihwdhc% Wlc grifwdea `f wlc Ocehl O``k qix segcrwikce ot ncnocrx `f
ie Cysib Wrciwncew Q`rkdea ]irwt cxwiobdxlcg ot wlc Jsgdhdib Xwsgdcx H`nndwwcc ieg
hlidrcg ot wlc _w L`e Bigt ]iw`e% D in vcrt ariwcfsb f`r wlc h`exdgcriobc q`rk }sw de
ot Bigt ]iw`e ieg lcr fcbb`q ncnocrx" ql`xc eincx hie oc f`seg de I}}cegd| DD% Din h`efdgcew wliw h`bbciascx ql` livc wlc `hhixd`e w` sxc wlc Ocehl O``k qdbb oc
vcrt ariwcfsb w``%
Ot dwx eiwsrc" i Ocehl O``k dx ibqitx `f wlc eiwsrc `f q`rk de }r`arcxx% Wlc Jsgdhdib
Xwsgdcx H`nndwwcc dx ibqitx rcigt w` rchcdvc ieg ihw `e iet xsaacxwd`ex nigc qdwl i
vdcq w` dn}r`vdea h`ewcew `r f`rniw%
]ldbd} L Or`gdc
Cgdeosral" Jsbt ?==<
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 3/206
H@EWCEWX
F`rcq`rg
Acecrib dewr`gshwd`e ieg `vcrvdcq
Cwledhdwt
Eincx ieg f`rnx `f iggrcxx
@iwlx
Dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx
Xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ieg acegcr dgcewdwt
]crx`ex qdwl gdxiodbdwdcx
Hldbgrce
G`ncxwdh iosxc
Dewdndgiwcg ieg `wlcr vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx
Vdhwdnx `f xc|sib hrdnc
]crx`ex qdwl`sw bcaib rc}rcxcewiwd`e
I}}cegd| D: H`exsbwiwd`e }r`hcxx f`r wlc xch`eg cgdwd`e
I}}cegd| DD: Ncnocrxld} `f Jsgdhdib Xwsgdcx Cysib Wrciwncew Q`rkdea
]irwt
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 4/206
GCWIDBCG H@EWCEWX
F@_CQ@_G
Hli}wcr 9 . ACEC_IB DEW_@GSHWD@E 9/9
Hli}wcr ? . CWLEDHDWT
Dewr`gshwd`e ?9
Wlc Bcaib H`ewc|w ?7
Wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9= ?/7
Wlc }r`wchwcg hlirihwcrdxwdhx ?/3
Wlc }sobdh xchw`r cysibdwt gswt ?/3
]`bdht ieg Ocxw ]rihwdhc ?1
]`bdht ?/1
Ocxw }rihwdhc ?/1
Asdgiehc ?<
Findbdirdxiwd`e qdwl h`srw }rd`r w` hixc ?/<
Irrieacncewx de h`srw ?/<
_cx}chw f`r rcbdad`sx }rihwdhcx ?/<
_cx}chw f`r wlc qdwecxx ?/4
Iggdwd`eib }`dewx ?/9=
I}}r`}rdiwc Bieasiac ?99
Obihk ?/99
Qcxw Degdie / Ifrdhie Hirdoocie / Ifrdhie ?/99
Ixdie ?/9?
Nd|cg rihc ?/9?
Cwledh nde`rdwdcx ?/98
]lrixcx w` oc iv`dgcg ?/98
Acecrib ]`dewx ?97
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 5/206
Hli}wcr 8 . EINCX IEG F@_NX @F IGG_CXX
A`bgce _sbc: Ixk Wlc Qdwecxx 89
C|in}bcx 8?
Ifrdhie eincx 8/?
Hirdoocie eincx 8/?
Hldecxc eincx 8/?
Crdwrcie ieg Cwld`}die eincx 8/8
Fdbd}de` eincx 8/8
Alieidie eincx 8/8
Arcck ieg Arcck Ht}rd`w eincx 8/8
Ldegs eincx 8/7
Driedie eincx 8/3
Jcqdxl eincx 8/3
Nsxbdn eincx 8/6
Edacrdie eincx 8/1
]`bdxl eincx 8/1
]`rwsascxc eincx 8/<
Xdkl eincx 8/<
X}iedxl eincx 8/4
Wsrkdxl eincx 8/9=
Wsrkdxl Ht}rd`w eincx 8/9=
Vdcweincxc eincx 8/9=
X`srhc Niwcrdib 899
Hli}wcr 7 . @IWLX IEG @IWL WIKDEA
Qdwecxxcx 79
]sr}`xc `f `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e 7/9
@iwlx Ihw 941< 7/9
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 6/206
Hldbgrce 7/?
]crx`ex qdwl bciredea gdxiodbdwdcx 7/?
F`rn `f `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e 7/?
Ividbiodbdwt `f l`bt o``kx de h`srw 7/8
H`n}bcwc rcfsxib w` wikc wlc `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e de hrdndeib
}r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?347/7
Gdffcrcew Wt}cx `f @iwl" ieg Qlcwlcr Iffdrniwd`e ]rcfcriobc 73
Qdwecxxcx 7/3
Dewcr}rcwcrx 7/6
Jsr`rx 7/1
Hsriw`rx ig bdwcn 7/1
I}}cegd|: Asdgiehc f`r H`srw Xwiff `e wlc Liegbdea ieg Xw`riac `f L`bt
O``kx ieg xhrd}wsrcx 7<
Hli}wcr 3 . DEWC_]_CWDEA XC_VDHCX
Dewr`gshwd`e 3/9
Eccg f`r jsgacx w` oc iqirc `f bdeasdxwdh gdffdhsbwdcx 3/9
Hrdndeib hixcx 3/?
Hdvdb hixcx 3/8
Dewcr}rcwcrx— ysibdfdhiwd`ex; h`gc `f h`egshw 3/8
Acegcr `f dewcr}rcwcr 3/7
Eccg f`r igj`srencewx 3/7
Eccg f`r jsgdhdib xs}crvdxd`e iw ibb wdncx 3/7
X`}ldxwdhiwcg cysd}ncew qdwl xdnsbwiec`sx dewcr}rcwiwd`e 3/3
Bieasiac Bdec 3/3
I}}cegd| I: Irrieacncewx f`r Dexwrshwd`e `f Dewcr}rcwcr f`r Ihhsxcg 36
I}}cegd| O: Dexwrshwd`e `f Dewcr}rcwcrx f`r Hrdndeib H`srw Gdcwx . ]r w`h`b dxxscg
ot Hr`qe @ffdhc
39?
I}}cegd| H: H`gc `f h`egshw f`r dewcr}rcwcrx ieg wriexbiw`rx 397
I}}cegd| G: Xwtbc Bcwwcr `f Dexwrshwd`e f`r F`rcdae Bieasiac Dewcr}rcwcr391
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 7/206
I}}cegd| C: XHX H`gc `f H`egshw f`r Dewcr}rcwcrx ieg Wriexbiw`rx 394
X`srhc Niwcrdib 3?8
Hli}wcr 6 . XC\SIB @_DCEWIWD@E IEG ACEGC_ DGCEWDWT
Gcfdedwd`ex 6/9
Esnocrx `f BAOW }c`}bc de Xh`wbieg 6/?
BAOW dgcewdwt 6/?
BAOW }ircewx 6/8
C|}crdcehcx `f }rcjsgdhc 6/7
H`nn`e ixxsn}wd`ex 6/7
Wlc Bcaib H`ewc|w 66
Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944< ieg Xh`wbieg Ihw 944< 6/6
]sobdh }`bdht 6/1
Acegcr rch`aedwd`e 6/<
Hrdndeib biq 6/<
Findbt biq 6/4
Iewd.gdxhrdndeiwd`e biq 6/9=
Dxxscx `f ]rihwdhc 699
H`egshw de h`srw 6/9?
Sxc `f bieasiac 6/97
_cx`srhcx ieg H`ewihwx 693
Hli}wcr 1 . ]C_X@EX QDWL GDXIODBDWDCX
Dewr`gshwd`e 19
Acecrib 1/9
Xwiwsw`rt gswdcx 1/9
Gswt w` nikc rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx 1/?
Gswt e`w w` wrciw bcxx fiv`sriobt 1/8
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 8/206
Wlc wcxw `f jsxwdfdhiwd`e 1/8
_cix`ex qldhl nit jsxwdft bcxx fiv`sriobc wrciwncew `r i fidbsrc w`
nikc rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx1/8
_cix`ex qldhl nit jsxwdft bcxx fiv`sriobc wrciwncew `ebt 1/7
Wlc gdxiodbdwt cysibdwt gswt 1/7
Lsnie _dalwx 1/7
Gcfdedwd`e ieg Wcrnx 17
Xwiwsw`rt gcfdedwd`ex 1/7
H`nn`e biq gcfdedwd`e 1/6
Wcrnx w` iv`dg; wcrnx w` sxc 1/6
]bieedea de Igviehc 11
@}}`rwsedwdcx f`r }bieedea 1/1
I}}`dewncew f hsriw`r ig bdwcn 1/<
Gswdcx `e }irwdcx w` }r`hccgdeax 1/<
Cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e ieg x}chdib ncixsrcx f`r wikdea cvdgcehc: hdvdb
}r`hccgdeax
1/4
X}chdib ncixsrcx f`r wlc wikdea `f cvdgcehc: hrdndeib hixcx 1/9=
Niwwcrx w` h`exdgcr 1/99
Irrieacncewx f`r wlc H`srw I}}ciriehc 199
Acecrib 1/99
Irrieacncewx w` oc h`exdgcrcg `e wlc git 1/9?
Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc 1/98
]r`obcnx f`r wl`xc qdwl ncewib lcibwl `r bciredea gdxiodbdwdcx 1/98
]r`obcnx f`r }`wcewdib jsr`rx 1/97
G`x ieg g`e—wx 1/97
Irrieacncewx de cncracehdcx 1/93
X`srhc Niwcrdib 196
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 9/206
Hli}wcr < . HLDBG_CE
Dewr`gshwd`e <9
I hldbg—x ie|dcwdcx </9
Findbdirdxiwd`e qdwl H`srw ieg H`srw ]r`hcgsrcx <9
Vdxdw w` h`srw </9
Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc </?
_cigdea niwcrdib </8
Hldbg—x Irrdvib iw" ]rcxcehc de" ieg Gc}irwsrc fr`n H`srw ]rcndxcx <8
L`xwdbc fihwd`ex iw h`srw </8
I x}chdib qidwdea r``n f`r hldbgrce </7
X}chdib Irrieacncewx de Hrdndeib ]r`hccgdeax <3Wlc vsbecriodbdwt `f i hldbg </3
Wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 </3
Hldbg ix vsbecriobc qdwecxx: x}chdib ncixsrcx de hrdndeib
}r`hccgdeax: xchwd`ex ?19I ieg ?19G
</6
Hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax </1
H`srwx h`exdgcriwd`e `f hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax <<
,9$ H`exdgcriwd`e de ioxcehc `f }irwdcx </<
,?$ H`srw lcirdea w` gdxhsxx Hldbg Qdwecxx E`wdhc </4
H`srw—x }`qcrx iw wlc hrdndeib lcirdea w` gdxhsxx Hldbg Qdwecxx
E`wdhc</9=
Fsrwlcr x}chdib ncixsrcx de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax f`r hldbgrce
segcr wlc iac `f 9?: xchwd`e ?19O </99
Hlieadea wlc x}chdib ncixsrcx iw iet wdnc
gsrdea hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19G </99
Cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19D <9?
Bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,HHWV$ de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19J </98
L`q w` `}criwc HHWV </97
Xhrccex de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19K </97
Xs}}`rwcr de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19B </97
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 10/206
]rd`r xwiwcncew w` h`exwdwswc cvdgcehc de hldcf de hrdndeib
}r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19N</93
Hldbg Qdwecxx ior`ig: xchwd`e ?18 </96
Ncwl`gx `f dgcewdftdea ie ihhsxcg de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax
dev`bvdea HHWV" xhrccex" `r cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e: </96
@wlcr ncwl`gx `f dgcewdfdhiwd`e `f ie ihhsxcg de hrdndeib
}r`hccgdeax dev`bvdea HHWV" xhrccex `r cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e</91
Hldbg qdwecxx rcfsxdea w` h`.`}criwc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax:
xchwd`e ?34 </9<
Hldbg ix ie ihhsxcg }crx`e: xchwd`e ?19f,?$ </9<
X}chdib Irrieacncewx De Hdvdb ]r`hccgdeax <94
H`srw—x }`qcrx iw h`nn`e biq de hdvdb }r`hccgdeax </94
H`srw—x xwiwsw`rt }`qcrx de hdvdb }r`hccgdeax </94
Ndxhcbbiec`sx X}chdib Irrieacncewx De Hrdndeib Ieg Hdvdb ]r`hccgdeax <?9
Hldbgrce segcr 9? tcirx e`w }sw `e `iwl </?9
Hldbg iacg 9? `r 98 tcirx nit oc }sw `e `iwl </?9
Hldbg iacg 97 `r `vcr }sw `e `iwl </??
Ndhr`}l`ecx de h`srw f`r xnibb v`dhcx </??
Xciwdea irrieacncewx: }`xdwd`e `f hldbg de h`srw </??
Hldbg iw i }irwt </??
Hldbg ix qdwecxx </??
Hldbg ix ihhsxcg </?8
]rcxcehc `f hldbg }xthldiwrdxw `r }xthl`b`adxw </?8
Frcyscew orcikx </?8
A`qex ieg qdax </?7
Hibbdea wlc hixc </?7
Hbcirdea wlc h`srw </?7
_cn`vib `f ie ihhsxcg ql` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf </?3
_cxwrdhwdea esnocrx de h`srw </?6
H`egshw Gsrdea Hixc <?6
Xs}}`rwdea Hldbg Qdwecxxcx Asdgiehc </?6
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 11/206
Xdn}bc bieasiac </?1
Gdxhb`xsrc f hldbg—x }crx`eib gcwidbx </?<
Gdxwrcxx gsrdea cvdgcehc </?<
]rcxx _c}`rwdea De Hixcx Dev`bvdea Hldbgrce <?4
Niegiw`rt }r`ldodwd`e de hrdndeib hixcx: </?4
Gdxhrcwd`eirt }r`ldodwd`e de hrdndeib hixcx </?4
Gdx}cexdea qdwl }r`ldodwd`e" qlcwlcr niegiw`rt `r gdxhrcwd`eirt"
de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax </?4
Acecrib }`qcrx de hdvdb ieg hrdndeib hixcx </8=
I}}`dewncew `f Hsriw`r ig Bdwcn Gsrdea H`srw Hixc </8?
I}}r`}rdiwc Igsbwx gsrdea h`srw }r`hccgdeax </88
Wlc Vdcqx `f Hldbgrce de Hdvdb ]r`hccgdeax <83
X`srhc Niwcrdib <86
I}}cegd| I: Ncn`riegsn ot B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx <8<
I}}cegd| O: Hldbg Qdwecxxcx Gdxhrcwd`eirt ]`qcrx <79
I}}cegd| H: Wikdea `f Cvdgcehc `f i Vsbecriobc Qdwecxx ot i H`nndxxd`ecr <77
Hli}wcr 4 . G@NCXWDH IOSXC
Dewr`gshwd`e 49
Gcfdedwd`e 4/9
H`excyscehcx 4/?
Gdffcrcew hsbwsrcx 4/?
G`ncxwdh Iosxc de wlc H`srw ]r`hcxx 48
Qlcrc wlc dxxsc nit irdxc 4/8
]`dewx w` ocir de ndeg 4/8
]r`wchwd`e Ncixsrcx 47
X}`sxcx `r }irwecrx 4/7
]r`wchwd`e acecribbt 4/7
E`e.lirixxncew rgcrx 4/3
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 12/206
Hldbgrce 4/3
Hldbgrce Degdrchwbt Iffchwcg ot G`ncxwdh Iosxc 46
_cxdgcehc ieg h`ewihw 4/6
Hli}wcr 9= . DEWDNDGIWCG IEG @WLC_ VSBEC_IOB
QDWECXXCX
Dewr`gshwd`e 9=9
Vsbecriodbdwt 9=/9
Wlc Dn}`rwiehc f Def`rniwd`e" Xs}}`rw" ieg Cevdr`encew 9=8
Def`rniwd`e 9=/8
Xs}}`rw 9=/7
]rcxcehc `f xs}}`rw fdasrc de h`srw 9=/7
Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc 9=/3
Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg Igvdhc 9=/3
Cevdr`encew 9=/6
Dewdndgiwcg Qdwecxxcx 9=6
Xchsrdwt irrieacncewx 9=/6
Gdxhb`xsrc f i qdwecxx—x }crx`eib gcwidbx 9=/1
_cn`vib `f hcrwide }crx`ex fr`n h`srw 9=/1
_cn`vib `f ie ihhsxcg ql` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf 9=/<
]rcvirdhiwdea qdwecxx" `r dewdndgiwcg" `r o`wl: rieac
i}}r`ihlcx
9=/<
HHWV" Xhrccex" Cvdgcehc e H`nndxxd`e" ieg ]rd`r Xwiwcncewx 9=4
H`nn`e biq }`qcrx: xhrccex 9=/4
I wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,HHWV$ `r xhrccex de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax:
xchwd`e ?19,3$ ieg ,6$ 9=/9=
Cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e
?19,9$
9=/99
Sxc `f i }rd`r xwiwcncew de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?34 9=/9?
X}chdib Ncixsrcx de Hdvdb ]r`hccgdeax 9=98
Hli}wcr 99 . VDHWDNX @F XC\SIB H_DNC
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 13/206
Acecrib 999
Dewr`gshwd`e 99/9
Def`rniwd`e f`r vdhwdnx 99/9
Findbdirdxiwd`e qdwl h`srw ieg h`srw }r`hcgsrcx 99/?
_c}rcxcewiwd`e f`r ie Ihhsxcg ]crx`e 99?
H`n}sbx`rt rc}rcxcewiwd`e f`r ie ihhsxcg hliracg qdwl
hcrwide xc|sib `ffcehcx
99/?
Irrieacncewx de H`srw 998
Hbcirdea wlc h`srw 99/8
]rcxcehc `f xs}}`rw fdasrc 99/8
_cn`vib `f ie ihhsxcg ql` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf 99/7
Gdxwrcxx gsrdea cvdgcehc 99/7
Wcbcvdxd`e Bdek ,HHWV$" Xhrccex" Cvdgcehc `e H`nndxxd`e" ]rd`r
Xwiwcncewx
993
H`nn`e biq }`qcrx: xhrccex 99/3
Xwiwsw`rt }r`wchwd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax 99/3
Qdwecxx rcfsxdea w` h`.`}criwc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax:
sxc `f }rd`r xwiwcncew: xchwd`e ?34 99/1
Qdwecxx seiobc w` rcncnocr de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax" osw qdbbdea w`
ig`}w }rd`r xwiwcncew: xchwd`e ?6=99/1
_cxwrdhwd`ex `e Hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e 99<
_cxwrdhwd`ex `e hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e f i vdhwdn `f i xc|sib hrdnc 99/<
X}chdib Ncixsrcx de Hdvdb ]r`hccgdeax 994
Hli}wcr 9? . ]C_X@EX QDWL@SW BCAIB _C]_CXCEWIWD@E" IEGBIT _C]_CXCEWIWDVCX
Acecrib Dewr`gshwd`e 9?9
Acecrib }`dewx 9?/9
]irwt Bdwdaiewx de Hdvdb ]r`hccgdeax 9??
Dewr`gshwd`e 9?/?
Acecrib gdffdhsbwdcx fihcg ot }irwt bdwdaiewx 9?/8
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 14/206
Xwiwsw`rt gdffdhsbwdcx fihcg ot }irwt bdwdaiewx 9?/3
,i$ H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9?/3
,o$ Xlcrdff h`srw 9?/6
Gcibdea qdwl wlc Gdffdhsbwdcx 9?/1
,9$ Qrdwwce asdgiehc 9?/1
,?$ H`exdgcr wlc degdvdgsib!x eccgx" cwh 9?/<
,8$ H`egshw `f lcirdeax" }r``fx" cwh% 9?/4
,7$ _cfcrcehc w` bcaib }rchcgcew ieg `wlcr iswl`rdwdcx 9?/99
,3$ Ixxdxwdea de wlc }rcxcewiwd`e `f i }irwt bdwdaiew—x hixc 9?/99
,6$ Wlc jsgancew `r gchdxd`e 9?/98
C|}cexcx Iqirgcg de Fiv`sr `f ]irwt Bdwdaiew 9?/98
Cef`rhcncew `f Gchrccx 9?/97
I}}cibx 9?/97
Vc|iwd`sx Bdwdaiewx 9?/93
Serc}rcxcewcg Ihhsxcg de Hrdndeib Hixcx 9?93
Acecrib 9?/93
C|}bieiwd`e w` serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg 9?/96
]r`wchwdea wlc dewcrcxwx `f wlc ihhsxcg 9?/91
Hrdndeib rch`rg `f ihhsxcg 9?/9<
]r`wchwdea wlc dewcrcxwx `f qdwecxxcx 9?/9<
Xc|sib `ffcehcx 9?/94
X`srhc Niwcrdib 9??=
I}}cegd| D . H@EXSBWIWD@E ]_@HCXX IEG BDXW @F H@EXSBWCCX
I}}cegd| DD . NCNOC_XLD] @F Q@_KDEA ]I_WT
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 15/206
Hli}wcr 9
ACEC_IB DEW_@GSHWD@E
9%9 Wlc fdrxw gchigc `f wlc wqcewt fdrxw hcewsrt lix qdwecxxcg ie ce`rn`sx f`hsx
`e cysibdwt ieg gdvcrxdwt `e ie dewcreiwd`eib ix qcbb ix g`ncxwdh oixdx% Wlc CS
Cysibdwt Gdrchwdvcx ieg _casbiwd`ex qcrc h`exdgcrcg ar`seg.orcikdea iw wlc wdnc `f
wlcdr sevcdbdea ieg livc h`ewdescg w` livc i }r`f`seg dn}ihw iaidexw gdxhrdndeiwd`e
de Xh`wbieg% Wlc _casbiwd`ex x}ie ihr`xx wlc x}chwrsn `f gdxhrdndeiwd`e dehbsgdea
rihc" rcbdad`e" acegcr" xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e" gdxiodbdwt ieg iac% Wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9= dx
e`q cffchwdvc ieg dw h`ewidex dn}`rwiew gswdcx `e }sobdh xchw`r iswl`rdwdcx de rcbiwd`e
w` fidr wrciwncew% Xh`wbieg lix gcvcb`}cg i n`rc r`osxw iewd.gdxhrdndeiwd`e xwiehc de
rchcew tcirx ieg wldx dx rcfbchwcg de wlc h`ewdesdea rcvdxd`e `f wlc Cysib Wrciwncew
Ocehl O``k%
9%? @vcr niet tcirx wlc }`}sbiwd`e `f Xh`wbieg lix arigsibbt hlieacg w` i }`dew
qlcrc dw dx e`q n`rc nsbwd.hsbwsrib ieg nsbwd.cwledh wlie lix cvcr }rcvd`sxbt occe
wlc hixc% Niet `f wl`xc ql`xc iehcxw`rx `rdadeibbt hinc fr`n Ifrdhie `r Hirdoocie
h`sewrdcx" fr`n wlc Degdie xso.h`ewdecew" `r fr`n cbxcqlcrc" irc e`q wldrg `r f`srwl
acecriwd`e Xh`wx: osw niet `f wlcn xwdbb }rcxcrvc wlcdr `rdadeib rcbdad`sx" hsbwsrib ieg
cwledh dgcewdwt" ieg niet `f wlcn xwdbb }rcfcr w` x}cik wlc bieasiac `f wlc h`sewrt
qlcrc wlcdr findbt `rdadeiwcg% N`rc`vcr" ix i h`sewrt rce`qecg f`r dwx cgshiwd`eib
fihdbdwdcx ieg f`r dwx w`srdxn" Xh`wbieg rcasbirbt iwwrihwx birac esnocrx `f }c`}bc fr`n
ir`seg wlc q`rbg ql` nit xwit lcrc f`r `ebt i xl`rw }crd`g `r" iw n`xw" i fcq tcirx%
Niet `f wlcn qdbb oc sefindbdir qdwl Xh`wwdxl dexwdwswd`ex xshl ix h`srwx `f biq" iegx`nc `f wlcn nit livc `ebt ie dn}crfchw ke`qbcgac `f wlc Ceabdxl bieasiac%
9%8 Ibb `f wlc }c`}bc jsxw ncewd`ecg h`sbg" qlcwlcr qdbbdeabt `r `wlcrqdxc" fdeg
wlcnxcbvcx dev`bvcg de wlc }r`hcxxcx `f wlc h`srwx% Wlct ndalw oc wlc vdhwdnx `f i
hrdnc" `r degccg ndalw oc ihhsxcg `f livdea h`nndwwcg i hrdnc% Cysibbt" wlct ndalw
oc hibbcg w` h`srw ix qdwecxxcx cdwlcr de i hrdndeib wrdib `r de hdvdb }r`hccgdeax% De
x`nc dexwiehcx wlct nit qdxl w` wikc `r w` gcfceg hdvdb }r`hccgdeax wlcnxcbvcx%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 16/206
9%7 Xh`wwdxl jsgacx livc ibqitx occe rdalwbt }r`sg `f wlc fihw wliw ibb ql` h`nc
ocf`rc wlc h`srwx irc wrciwcg qdwl rcx}chw ieg qdwl dn}irwdibdwt" ieg dw dx w` oc
xs}}`xcg wliw i Xh`wwdxl jsgac q`sbg ecvcr ke`qdeabt g` `r xit ietwldea wliw q`sbg
oc bdkcbt w` hisxc lsrw `r `ffcehc fir bcxx w` }bihc i }irwdhsbir }crx`e iw ie
seechcxxirt gdxigviewiac% Qlce fihcg qdwl i }crx`e fr`n i nde`rdwt oihkar`seg"
l`qcvcr" wlcrc irc niet hlibbceacx ieg }dwfibbx qldhl bdc de qidw cvce f`r wlc n`xw
hirdea ieg gdbdacew jsgac irdxdea fr`n wlc dehrcixdeabt gdvcrxc h`nnsedwt de qldhl
qc fsehwd`e% ]`xdwdvc xwc}x nsxw oc wikce w` cexsrc wliw wlcrc dx rcib cysibdwt ieg
fidrecxx f`r ibb de wlc jsxwdhc }r`hcxx% F`r jsgacx ql` irc ihhsxw`ncg w` wlc h`ehc}w
`f i fdrxw ,`r Hlrdxwdie$ einc ieg i xsreinc" dw nit oc gdffdhsbw w` ke`q l`q w`
iggrcxx i }crx`e fr`n i Nsxbdn oihkar`seg qdwl i Nsxbdn einc; ieg xdndbir
gdffdhsbwdcx nit irdxc df i jsgac dx rcysdrcg w` igndedxwcr wlc `iwl w` i qdwecxx ql` dx"
f`r c|in}bc" Ldegs `r Xdkl% Bdkcqdxc" ‒wrigdwd`eib„ degdhiw`rx `f l`ecxwt ieg rcx}chw"
xshl ix b``kdea i jsgac de wlc ctc qlce lc `r xlc dx x}cikdea" nit niedfcxw
wlcnxcbvcx de ysdwc gdffcrcew qitx in`ea wl`xc ql` h`nc fr`n Ixdie `r `wlcr
hsbwsrcx%
9%3 Wlc idn `f wldx Ocehl O``k dx e`w w` }rcihl `r }iwr`edxc" osw dwx fsehwd`e dx w`
`ffcr ixxdxwiehc ieg igvdhc w` jsgacx ql` irc gswt o`seg w` cexsrc wliw ibb ql` h`nc
ocf`rc wlc h`srwx irc gcibw qdwl de ie segcrxwiegdea ieg xcexdwdvc fixld`e" rcairgbcxx
`f wlcdr }crx`eib oihkar`segx% Ihh`rgdeabt" Hli}wcrx ? w` 3 gcib x}chdfdhibbt qdwl
niwwcrx rcbcview w` wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx jsxw gcxhrdocg%
9%6 I fciwsrc `f h`ewcn}`rirt bdfc qldhl dx e`q gcibw qdwl de i nshl n`rc `}ce
ieg se}rcjsgdhcg qit wlie qix f`rncrbt wlc hixc dx wliw `f xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ieg
acegcr dgcewdwt% Wldx dx xwdbb x`ncwldea qldhl dx hi}iobc `f ndxsegcrxwiegdea ieg
ndxh`ehc}wd`e" l`qcvcr" ieg dw dx wlcrcf`rc gcxdriobc wliw jsgacx xl`sbg livc ix hbcir
ie segcrxwiegdea `f wldx w`}dh ix dx }`xxdobc% Dw dx ihh`rgdeabt gcibw qdwl de Hli}wcr 6%
9%1 I}irw fr`n ibb `f wlc f`rca`dea wlcrc irc `wlcr hdrhsnxwiehcx" rcairgbcxx `f
yscxwd`ex `f cwledhdwt `r xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ieg acegcr dgcewdwt" de qldhl x`nc `f
wl`xc ql` h`nc ocf`rc wlc h`srwx nit oc iw i gdxigviewiac qlce h`n}ircg qdwl
`wlcr h`srw sxcrx% Wlct nit livc i }ltxdhib `r ncewib gdxiodbdwt; wlct nit oc
hldbgrce; wlct nit livc occe wlc vdhwdnx `f" `r livc occe ixx`hdiwcg qdwl" g`ncxwdh
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 17/206
iosxc; wlct nit oc qdwecxxcx ql`" f`r qliwcvcr rcix`e" irc i}}rclcexdvc io`sw wlc
}r`x}chw `f i}}cirdea de h`srw; `r wlct nit livc w`" `r nit hl``xc w`" h`egshw h`srw
}r`hccgdeax de }crx`e qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f bcaib rc}rcxcewiwd`e% Ibb rcysdrc w` oc
gcibw qdwl de i xcexdwdvc ieg segcrxwiegdea nieecr: ieg Hli}wcrx 1 w` 9? `f wlc Ocehl
O``k `ffcr x`nc igvdhc ix w` l`q wliw ndalw ocxw oc g`ec%
Gdxhrdndeiwd`e lix niet asdxcx ieg wlsx degdvdgsibx nit e`w oc h`n}irwncewibdxcg
de ihh`rgiehc qdwl wlc gdffcrcew hli}wcrx de wldx Ocehl O``k% Dexwcig" jsgacx nit
eccg w` h`exdgcr i esnocr `f hli}wcrx de `rgcr w` iggrcxx wlc dxxscx ridxcg ot i
}irwdhsbir xdwsiwd`e% Fsrwlcr" dw dx dn}`rwiew w` e wc wliw gdxhrdndeiwd`e g`cx e`w `ebt
irdxc qlce i xdndbir xdwsiwd`e dx wrciwcg gdffcrcewbt osw ibx` qlce gdffcrcew xdwsiwd`ex
irc wrciwcg de wlc xinc qit%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 18/206
Hli}wcr ?
CWLEDHDWT
DEW_@GSHWD@E
?%9 Giwi `e cwledhdwt `f wlc }`}sbiwd`e dx h`bbchwcg cvcrt 9= tcirx de wlc Xh`wbieg
Hcexsx" qldhl ocaie de 9449% Wlc n`xw rchcew hcexsx qix lcbg de ?=99" wlc fdrxw
rcxsbwx `f qldhl irc }bieecg f`r }sobdhiwd`e de Gchcnocr ?=9?% Xdehc wlc bixw hcexsx
9= tcirx ia`" ecq h`nnsedwdcx livc nigc Xh`wbieg wlcdr l`nc% Ibb cwledh nde`rdwt
ar`s}x bdvdea de Xh`wbieg `e ?1 Nirhl ?=99 qcrc dehbsgcg de wlc ?=99 hcexsx"
rcairgbcxx `f h`sewrt `f odrwl% Wlc hcexsx ixkcg yscxwd`ex `e o`wl eiwd`eib dgcewdwt
ieg `e cwledh ar`s} w` ibb`q }c`}bc w` n`rc fsbbt c|}rcxx gdffcrcew ix}chwx `f wlcdr
dgcewdwt%
?%? Wlc ?==9 hcexsx cxwdniwcg wliw Xh`wbieg—x w`wib nde`rdwt cwledh }`}sbiwd`e
qix 9=="=== }c`}bc" `r ?%=9 }cr hcew `f Xh`wbieg—x w`wib }`}sbiwd`e%9Dw xl`sbg oc
e`wcg" l`qcvcr" wliw ysdwc i}irw fr`n h`ehcre io`sw wlc hbixxdfdhiwd`e `f cwledh
nde`rdwdcx sxcg de wlc ?==9 hcexsx" Xh`wbieg lix lig `ec `f wlc fixwcxw ar`qdea
dnndariew }`}sbiwd`ex de wlc SK `vcr rchcew tcirx" qdwl }irwx `f Abixa`q ieg
Iocrgcce xl`qdea arciwcr hlieac de wlc h`n}`xdwd`e `f wlcdr }`}sbiwd`e wlie
B`eg`e%? Dw dx vcrt bdkcbt wliw wlc fdasrc `f ?%=9 }cr hcew qdbb oc xl`qe ot wlc ?=99
hcexsx w` oc ie segcrcxwdniwc `f wlc cwledh nde`rdwt }`}sbiwd`e de Xh`wbieg%
9 Wlc ?==9 hcexsx%? Wlc Dexwdwswc `f ]sobdh ]`bdht rcxcirhl ?==3 ‒Oct`eg Obihk ieg Qldwc: Ni}}dea Ecq Dnndariew
H`nnsedwdcx%„
?%8 Wlc ?==9 hcexsx }r`vdgcg lcb}fsb def`rniwd`e io`sw cwledh nde`rdwdcx de
Xh`wbieg% Qliw f`bb`qx dx xdn}bt ie dbbsxwriwd`e f x`nc `f wlc def`rniwd`e dw
}r`vdgcg% N`rc gcwidbx irc h`ewidecg de Xh wwdxl A`vcrencew rc}`rwx ieg ieibtxdx `f
wlc ?==9 hcexsx%9
F`r ibb ar`s}x de wlc ?==9 hcexsx" Xh`wbieg qix cdwlcr wlc n`xw
h`nn`e `r wlc xch`eg n`xw h`nn`e h`sewrt `f odrwl% Wlc hcexsx degdhiwcg wliw de
Xh`wbieg i nshl ldalcr }crhcewiac `f degdvdgsibx fr`n wlc nde`rdwt cwledh }`}sbiwd`e
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 19/206
bdvc de birac sroie ircix ,xcwwbcncewx `f `vcr 9?3"=== }c`}bc$ wlie Qldwc Xh`wwdxl
}c`}bc% Ihh`rgdea w` wlc hcexsx" `ebt 84# `f Qldwc Xh`wwdxl }c`}bc bdvc de wl`xc
ircix h`n}ircg qdwl 17# `f Degdie }c`}bc; <=# `f ]ikdxwied }c`}bc; 16# `f
Oieabigcxld }c`}bc; 13# `f `wlcr X`swl Ixdiex; ieg 17# `f Ifrdhiex% Wlc ?==9
hcexsx degdhiwcx wliw" `f wlc w`wib }`}sbiwd`e de Xh`wbieg" Qldwc Xh`wwdxl h`n}rdxcg
<<%4#; @wlcr Qldwc Ordwdxl 1%8<#; Qldwc Drdxl =%4<#; Iet @wlcr Qldwc Oihkar`seg
9%37#; Degdie =%8=#; ]ikdxwied =%68#; Oieabigcxld =%=7#; Hldecxc =%8?#; @wlcr
X`swl Ixdie =%9?#; Hirdoocie =%=7#; Ifrdhie =%9=#; Obihk Xh`wwdxl `r iet `wlcr
Obihk oihkar`seg =%=?#; Iet Nd|cg Oihkar`seg =%?3#; Iet @wlcr Oihkar`seg
=%94#%
9Ieibtxdx `f Cwledhdwt de wlc ?==9 Hcexsx Xsnnirt _c}`rw . @ffdhc `f wlc Hldcf Xwiwdxwdhdie Fcorsirt
?==7" ieg fsrwlcr ieibtxdx de E`vcnocr ?==6%
?%7 Wlc ?==9 hcexsx ibx` xl`qcg wliw wlcrc qix ie cwledh nde`rdwt }`}sbiwd`e de
cvcrt H`sehdb irci de Xh`wbieg" qdwl Abixa`q livdea wlc ldalcxw }crhcewiac ,iw 89#
`f wlc w`wib cwledh nde`rdwt }`}sbiwd`e `f Xh`wbieg$ f`bb`qcg ot Cgdeosral ,iw 9<#$%9
Wlc xdzc `f wlc nde`rdwt cwledh }`}sbiwd`e lix dehrcixcg xdehc wlc 9449 hcexsx" qlcedw qix cxwdniwcg w` oc 9%8# `f wlc w`wib `f Xh wbieg—x }`}sbiwd`e% Gsrdea wl`xc wce
tcirx wlc nde`rdwt cwledh }`}sbiwd`e dx cxwdniwcg w` livc dehrcixcg ot 6?%8#%
Hbcirbt" wlc ?==9 hcexsx h`efdrncg wliw Xh`wbieg lix i rdhl gdvcrxdwt `f cwledhdwdcx de
dwx }`}sbiwd`e%
9Ieibtxdx `f Cwledhdwt de wlc ?==9 Hcexsx Xsnnirt _c}`rw . @ffdhc `f wlc Hldcf Xwiwdxwdhdie Fcorsirt
?==7" ieg fsrwlcr ieibtxdx de E`vcnocr ?==6%
?%3 Wlc ?==9 hcexsx fsrwlcr degdhiwcg wliw wlc x`hdib ieg ch`e`ndh hdrhsnxwiehcx
`f Xh`wbieg—x cwledh nde`rdwt h`nnsedwdcx gdffcr nirkcgbt fr`n Xh`wbieg—x qldwc
h`nnsedwt% @e ivcriac" ibb `f wlc cwledh nde`rdwt h`nnsedwdcx irc t`seacr wlie wlc
Qldwc ar`s}x% Qdwl wlc c|hc}wd`e f wlc Hirdoocie ar`s}" ibb cwledh nde`rdwt ar`s}x
xl`qcg n`rc wlie ?=# de wlc hiwca`rt `f 96 tcirx `r t`seacr% Secn}b`tncew qix
ldalcr de ibb cwledh nde`rdwt ar`s}x% Wlc ar`s}x qldhl xl`qcg wlc ldalcxw
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 20/206
secn}b`tncew qcrc Ifrdhiex ,iw 93#$; Obihk Xh`wwdxl ,iw 93#$ ieg @wlcr X`swl
Ixdiex ,iw 97#$% Xcbf.cn}b`tncew qix ldalcxw in`eaxw wlc ]ikdxwied ar`s} ,iw 8?#$
ieg wlc Degdie ar`s} ,iw ??#$% Wlc Ifrdhie ar`s} xl`qcg wlc b`qcxw bcvcb `f xcbf.
cn}b`tncew iw <%7#%
?%6 Dw xl`sbg e`w oc f`ra`wwce wliw wlcrc dx i qdgc rieac `f degdvdgsibx fr`n niet
gdffcrcew rihdib ar`s}x ql` hie c|}crdcehc }rcjsgdhc ieg sebiqfsb rihc
gdxhrdndeiwd`e% F`r c|in}bc" de Xh`wbieg" h`n}bidewx `f rihdib gdxhrdndeiwd`e ot
Ceabdxl }c`}bc irc e`w seh`nn`e% Wlc bixw fcq tcirx lix xcce i ar`qdea o`gt `f
rcxcirhl degdhiwdea qdgcx}rcig gdxhrdndeiwd`e de Xh`wbieg iaidexw At}xdcxWrivcbbcrx"
dehbsgdea Xh`wwdxl At}xdcxWrivcbbcrx%9
_ihc gdxhrdndeiwd`e dx e`w rcxwrdhwcg w`
gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e wlc ar`segx `f h`b`sr" ibwl`sal dw dx x`ncwdncx xdn}bdxwdhibbt
vdcqcg de wldx qit% Ecdwlcr dx rihc gdxhrdndeiwd`e ibqitx ie dxxsc ocwqcce wlc
nij`rdwt ieg wlc nde`rdwt% Dw hie irdxc ocwqcce gdffcrcew nde`rdwt ar`s}x% Sebiqfsb
rihc gdxhrdndeiwd`e hie `hhsr `e wlc oixdx `f ie degdvdgsib—x `qe rihc `r `e wlc oixdx
`f ie`wlcr }crx`e—x rihc%
9‒Wlc _dalw w` _`in„" Xivc wlc Hldbgrce" 9441% At}xt/Wrivcbbcr dx wlc wcrn rch`nncegcg ot
wlc Xh`wwdxl ]irbdincew Cysib @}}`rwsedwdcx H`nndwwcc de dwx 9xw _c}`rw ?==9 ‘ Deysdrt dew`
At}xt Wrivcbbcrx ieg ]sobdh Xchw`r ]`bdhdcx ifwcr wikdea cvdgcehc fr`n At}xtWrivcbbcr
`raiedxiwd`ex ieg degdvdgsibx%
WLC BCAIB H@EWC\W
Wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9=?%1 Iewd.gdxhrdndeiwd`e biq dx i gteindh irci `f biq ieg dx h`exwiewbt cv`bvdea
ieg hlieadea" o`wl ix i rcxsbw `f g`ncxwdh bcadxbiwd`e ieg hixc biq" ieg ix i
h`excyscehc `f Csr`}cie Sed`e biq qldhl hie iffchw wlc dewcr}rcwiwd`e `f
g`ncxwdh biq ieg }r`vdgcx f`r gdrchwbt cffchwdvc rdalwx ieg `obdaiwd`ex de wlc SK%
Wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9= ,?=9= Ihw$ lix wq` nide }sr}`xcx" w` lirn`edxc
gdxhrdndeiwd`e biq ieg w` xwrceawlce wlc biq w` xs}}`rw }r`arcxx `e cysibdwt% Dw lix
rc}cibcg ieg rc}bihcg n`xw `f wlc c|dxwdea iewd.gdxhrdndeiwd`e bcadxbiwd`e" dehbsgdea:
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 21/206
Wlc _ihc _cbiwd`ex Ihw 9416
Wlc Xc| Gdxhrdndeiwd`e Ihw 9413
Wlc Gdxiodbdwt Gdxhrdndeiwd`e Ihw 9443
Cysib ]it Ihw 941= Wlc Gdxiodbdwt Gdxhrdndeiwd`e Ihw ?==3
?%< Wlc ?=9= Ihw rchcdvcg _`tib Ixxcew `e < I}rdb ?=9= ieg wlc nij`rdwt `f wlc
}r`vdxd`ex hinc dew` f`rhc `e 9 @hw`ocr ?=9=% Dwx nide }sr}`xcx irc w`:
‒nikc }r`vdxd`e w` rcysdrc Ndedxwcrx `f wlc Hr`qe ieg `wlcrx qlce nikdea
xwriwcadh gchdxd`ex io`sw wlc c|crhdxc `f wlcdr fsehwd`ex w` livc rcairg w` wlc
gcxdriodbdwt f rcgshdea x`hd`.ch`e`ndh decysibdwdcx; rcf`rn ieg lirn`edxc cysibdwt biq ieg rcxwiwc wlc arciwcr }irw `f wlc
ceihwncewx rcbiwdea w` gdxhrdndeiwd`e ieg lirixxncew rcbiwcg w` hcrwide
}crx`eib hlirihwcrdxwdhx;
ceiobc hcrwide cn}b`tcrx w` oc rcysdrcg w` }sobdxl def`rniwd`e io`sw wlc
gdffcrcehcx de }it ocwqcce nibc ieg fcnibc cn}b`tccx;
}r`ldodw vdhwdndxiwd`e de hcrwide hdrhsnxwiehcx; w` rcysdrc wlc c|crhdxc `f
hcrwide fsehwd`ex w` oc qdwl rcairg w` wlc eccg w` cbdndeiwc gdxhrdndeiwd`e ieg
`wlcr }r`ldodwcg h`egshw;
ceiobc gswdcx w` oc dn}`xcg de rcbiwd`e w` wlc c|crhdxc `f }sobdh }r`hsrcncew
fsehwd`ex;
dehrcixc cysibdwt `f `}}`rwsedwt; w` inceg wlc biq rcbiwdea w` rdalwx ieg
rcx}`exdodbdwdcx de findbt rcbiwd`exld}x; ieg f`r h`eechwcg }sr}`xcx%„9
9]rcinobc `f wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9=%
Wlc ]r`wchwcg Hlirihwcrdxwdhx
?%4 Wlc ?=9= Ihw h`ex`bdgiwcx ibb wlc }rcvd`sx iewd.gdxhrdndeiwd`e biqx ieg
rceincx wlc gdffcrcew ar`segx `f gdxhrdndeiwd`e ix ‒]r`wchwcg Hlirihwcrdxwdhx„9qldhl
irc ix f`bb`qx:
iac
gdxiodbdwt
acegcr rcixxdaencew
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 22/206
nirrdiac ieg hdvdb }irwecrxld}?
}rcaeieht ieg niwcrdwt
rihc
rcbdad`e `r ocbdcf acegcr
xc|sib rdcewiwd`e
9x%7" ?=9= Ihw%
? ‒Nirrdiac ieg hdvdb }irwecrxld}„ dx e`w i rcbcview }r`wchwcg hlirihwcrdxwdh f`r wlc }sr}`xcx `f
}iriari}lx ,o$ ieg ,h$ `f wlc }sobdh xchw`r cysibdwt gswt: x%974,1$" ?=9= Ihw%
Wlc ]sobdh Xchw`r Cysibdwt Gswt
?%9= Wlc }sobdh xchw`r cysibdwt gswt hinc dew` f`rhc `e 3 I}rdb ?=99 ieg dx gcfdecg
ix f`bb`qx:
‒I }sobdh iswl`rdwt nsxw" de wlc c|crhdxc `f dwx fsehwd`ex" livc gsc rcairg w` wlc eccg
w ‗
,i$ cbdndeiwc gdxhrdndeiwd`e" lirixxncew" vdhwdndxiwd`e ieg iet `wlcr h`egshw wliw dx
}r`ldodwcg ot `r segcr wldx Ihw;,o$ igviehc cysibdwt `f `}}`rwsedwt ocwqcce }crx`ex ql` xlirc i rcbcview }r`wchwcg
hlirihwcrdxwdh ieg }crx`ex ql` g` e`w xlirc dw;
,h$ f`xwcr a``g rcbiwd`ex ocwqcce }crx`ex ql` xlirc i rcbcview }r`wchwcg hlirihwcrdxwdh
ieg }crx`ex ql` g` e`w xlirc dw%„9
Niwwcrx ,o$ ieg ,h$ i}}bt w` wlc }r`wchwcg hlirihwcrdxwdhx `f iac" gdxiodbdwt" acegcr
rcixxdaencew" }rcaeieht ieg niwcredwt" rihc" rcbdad`e `r ocbdcf" xc| ieg xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e" osw wlct g` e`w i}}bt w` wlc }r`wchwcg hlirihwcrdxwdh `f nirrdiac ieg hdvdb
}irwecrxld}%?
H`srwx ieg wrdoseibx" de iggdwd`e osw e`w bdndwcg w` b`hib h`sehdbx ieg wlc }`bdhc" irc
h`exdgcrcg }sobdh iswl`rdwdcx f`r wlcxc }sr}`xcx" ibwl`sal wlc c|crhdxdea `f ‒jsgdhdib
fsehwd`ex„ `r fsehwd`ex c|crhdxcg `e oclibf `f" `r `e wlc dexwrshwd`ex `f" i }crx`e
c|crhdxdea i jsgdhdib fsehwd`e irc c|hbsgcg fr`n wlc gswt%8
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 23/206
Xchwd`e 974,?$ xwiwcx wliw i }crx`e ql` dx e`w i }sobdh iswl`rdwt osw ql` c|crhdxcx
}sobdh fsehwd`ex nsxw" de wlc c|crhdxc `f wl`xc fsehwd`ex" livc gsc rcairg w` ibb wlc
niwwcrx io`vc%7
Xchwd`e 974,6$ `f wlc ?=9= Ihw nikcx hbcir wliw h`n}btdea qdwl wlc gswt ndalw ncie
wrciwdea x`nc }c`}bc n`rc fiv`sriobt wlie `wlcrx% Wldx q`sbg dehbsgc wrciwdea
gdxiobcg }c`}bc n`rc fiv`sriobt wlie e`e.gdxiobcg }c`}bc ieg nikdea rcix`eiobc
igjsxwncewx f`r wlcn" nikdea sxc `f c|hc}wd`ex qldhl }crndw gdffcrcew wrciwncew" ieg
sxdea wlc }`xdwdvc ihwd`e }r`vdxd`ex de xchwd`ex 93< ieg 934 qlcrc wlct irc ividbiobc%
9 x%974,9$" ?=9= Ihw%
? x%974,1$" ?=9= Ihw%
8 Xhlcgsbc 94" ?=9= Ihw%
7 Xhlcgsbc 9<,8$" ?=9= Ihw%
3x%974,?$" ?=9= Ihw%
?%99 Wlc Cysibdwt ieg Lsnie _dalwx H`nndxxd`e ,CL_H$ ,f`rncrbt wlc
H`nndxxd`e f`r _ihdib Cysibdwt" wlc Gdxiodbdwt _dalwx H`nndxxd`e ieg wlc Cysib
@}}`rwsedwdcx H`nndxxd`e$ c|dxwx w` }r`n`wc wlc dn}`rwiehc `f cysibdwt ieg gdvcrxdwt
qdwl i vdcq w` cbdndeiwdea sebiqfsb gdxhrdndeiwd`e de x`hdcwt% Wlc CL_H ibx` lix
}`qcrx w` dedwdiwc }r`hccgdeax de dwx `qe einc ix qcbb ix dewcrvcec de rcbcview
bdwdaiwd`e%9
9 Fsrwlcr gcwidbx irc ividbiobc `e wlc Cysibdwt ieg Lsnie _dalwx H`nndxxd`e qcoxdwc:
lww}:qqq%cysibdwtlsnierdalwx%h`nigvdhc.ieg.asdgiehc}sobdh.xchw`r.cysibdwt.gswt
?%9? Wlc Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944< ibx` lix i xdaedfdhiew dn}ihw `e wlc c|wcew `f
}r`wchwd`e iaidexw gdxhrdndeiwd`e ot }sobdh o`gdcx de wlc Sedwcg Kdeag`n% Wlc 944<
Ihw advcx g`ncxwdh cffchw de }irwdhsbir w` Irwdhbcx < ,_dalw w` _cx}chw f`r ]rdviwc ieg
Findbt Bdfc$" Irwdhbc 4 ,_dalw w` _cbdad`sx Frccg`n$ ieg Irwdhbc 97 ,_dalw w` E`e.
Gdxhrdndeiwd`e de wlc cej`tncew `f wlc xsoxwiewdvc rdalwx$% Xchwd`e 6 `f wlc 944< Ihw
rcysdrcx wliw }sobdh iswl`rdwdcx" dehbsgdea wlc jsgdhdirt" h`n}bt qdwl wlc Csr`}cie
H`evcewd`e f`r wlc }r`wchwd`e `f Lsnie _dalwx ieg Fsegincewib Frccg`nx%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 24/206
]@BDHT IEG OCXW ]_IHWDHC
]`bdht
?%98 _cxcirhl lix dgcewdfdcg xdaedfdhiew oirrdcrx f`r }c`}bc fr`n nde`rdwt cwledhh`nnsedwdcx qlce dev`bvcg de wlc jsxwdhc xtxwcn% Wlcxc oirrdcrx" qldhl irc xlircg
ot niet birac `raiedxiwd`ex" livc occe gcfdecg de wlc Nih}lcrx`e _c}`rw ix ocdea
‒dexwdwswd`eib rihdxn„" wliw dx:
‒wlc h`bbchwdvc fidbsrc `f ie `raiedxiwd`e w` }r`vdgc ie i}}r`}rdiwc ieg
}r`fcxxd`eib xcrvdhc w` }c`}bc ochisxc `f wlcdr h`b`sr" hsbwsrc `r cwledh `rdade%
Dw hie oc xcce `r gcwchwcg de }r`hcxxcx" iwwdwsgcx" ieg oclivd`srx qldhl
in`sew w` gdxhrdndeiwd`e wlr`sal seqdwwdea }rcjsgdhc" dae`riehc"
wl`salwbcxxecxx ieg rihdxw xwcrc`wt}dea qldhl gdxigviewiacx nde`rdwt cwledh
}c`}bc„%9
9 Xwc}lce Biqrcehc Deysdrt _c}`rw" Xdr Qdbbdin Nih}lcrx`e" 9444" Hn 7?6?.D" }iri 6%87%
?%97 _cxcirhl }sobdxlcg de Fcorsirt ?==99
f`hsxcg f`r wlc fdrxw wdnc `e wlc c|wcew
`f }crhcdvcg gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e wlc ar`seg `f rcbdad`sx ocbdcf de Ceabieg ieg Qibcx"
dehbsgdea i xchwd`e `e gdxhrdndeiwd`e de wlc hrdndeib jsxwdhc xtxwcn% Wlc rc}`rw
degdhiwcx wliw wlc ioxcehc `f rcbdad`sx fihdbdwdcx" wlc gdxrcx}chwfsb wrciwncew `f
rcbdad`sx o``kx" ieg ie iwn`x}lcrc `f de.osdbw }rcjsgdhc bcg w` }crhc}wd`ex `f
gdxhrdndeiwd`e" ibwl`sal wlcxc qcrc gcxhrdocg ix ocdea `hhixd`eib riwlcr wlie r`swdec
`hhsrrcehcx%
9‒_cbdad`sx Gdxhrdndeiwd`e de Ceabieg ieg Qibcx„" L`nc @ffdhc _cxcirhl Xwsgt ??="
Fcorsirt ?==9%
Ocxw }rihwdhc
?%93 Wlc f`bb`qdea asdgiehc e`wcx irc }r`vdgcg w` ixxdxw jsgacx ieg h`srw xwiff w`
ig`}w ocxw }rihwdhc de nieiadea wlc gdvcrxdwt `f ‒qdwecxx cwledhdwt„ de h`srw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 25/206
ASDGIEHC
Findbdirdxiwd`e qdwl h`srw }rd`r w` hixc
?%96 H`srwx hiee`w ixxsnc wliw qdwecxxcx" `r ie ihhsxcg" irc findbdir qdwl h`srw}r`hcgsrcx% Dw dx wlcrcf`rc ocxw }rihwdhc w` cexsrc wliw wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r h`srw
findbdirdxiwd`e vdxdwx dx hbcirbt ibb`hiwcg ieg xl`sbg oc `ffcrcg de cvcrt hixc% Qlcrc i
qdwecxx xcrvdhc c|dxwx" wlct h`sbg }r`vdgc wldx xcrvdhc%9
9Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc dx e`q ividbiobc de cvcrt xlcrdff h`srw%
Irrieacncewx de h`srw
?%91 @iwlx:
@e wlc f`rn `f `iwl f`r }crx`ex `f gdffcrcew fidwlx" xcc Hli}wcr 7%
Ocf`rc i qdwecxx dx or`salw dew` h`srw" dw dx a``g }rihwdhc f`r wlc nihcr `r
h`srw `ffdhcr w` ixhcrwide fr`n wlc qdwecxx wliw lc `r xlc qdbb wikc wlc xwiegirg
`iwl% Df wlc qdwecxx qdxlcx w` iffdrn `r w` wikc wlc `iwl de ie`wlcr f`rn" wlc
nihcr `r h`srw `ffdhcr xl`sbg h`nnsedhiwc wliw }rcfcrcehc w` wlc jsgac% De wlc
hixc `f iffdrniwd`e" dw qdbb sxsibbt oc xsffdhdcew f`r wlc nihcr `r h`srw `ffdhcr
w` ordea wlc qdwecxx dew` h`srw ieg w` iee`sehc wliw wldx qdwecxx qdxlcx w`
iffdrn% Df wlc qdwecxx qdxlcx" f`r c|in}bc" w` xqcir `e wlc K`rie" wlc jsgac
xl`sbg oc igvdxcg ocf`rc wlc qdwecxx dx or`salw dew` h`srw ieg wlc l`bt o``k
xl`sbg oc nigc ividbiobc%
Qdwecxxcx xl`sbg oc ixkcg qliw `iwl wlct qdxl w` wikc% Ixxsn}wd`ex xl`sbg
e`w oc nigc%
?%9< _cx}chw f`r rcbdad`sx }rihwdhcx:
Jsgacx xl`sbg oc iqirc wliw rcbdad`sx }rihwdhcx nit nikc hcrwide gcniegx `f
i qdwecxx% Dw nit oc" f`r c|in}bc" wliw }ritcr wdncx qdbb livc w` oc
ihh`nn`giwcg%
Df }c`}bc irc fixwdea" c%a% i Nsxbdn gsrdea _inigie" wlct nit e`w oc iobc w`
xwieg f`r b`ea }crd`gx `f wdnc%
I }irwdhd}iew de h`srw }r`hccgdeax nit qcir i vcdb `r x`nc `wlcr airncew
ql`bbt `r }irwdibbt h`vcrdea wlc lcig ieg`r fihc% De xshl hdrhsnxwiehcx wlcrc
irc e` }rcxhrd}wdvc rsbcx" osw wlc dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc irc }irin`sew% Wlc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 26/206
yscxwd`e dx: qliw dx wlc xdaedfdhiehc `f xccdea wlc }crx`e—x fihc `r lcig gsrdea
wlc jsgdhdib }r`hccgdeax% Dw nit oc seechcxxirt w` xcc i h`srw `ffdhcr—x fihc
osw echcxxirt w` xcc i qdwecxx—x fihc qlce wlcrc irc dxxscx h`ehcredea
hrcgdodbdwt `r dgcewdfdhiwd`e% Dw nit oc wl`salw wliw de n`xw hdrhsnxwiehc dw
q`sbg oc dei}}r`}rdiwc f`r i jsr`r—x lcig w` oc h`vcrcg%9Dw dx xsaacxwcg wliw i
jsr`r ql` dx hlibbceacg ochisxc `f i vcdb `r x`nc `wlcr lcig h`vcrdea nit oc
c|hsxcg% I qdwecxx nit oc ixkcg w` rcn`vc wlc vcdb gsrdea cvdgcehc" `r
ibwcreiwdvcbt ixkcg qlcwlcr ncixsrcx xshl ix xhrccex" vdgc`.bdekx" `r hbcirdea
wlc }sobdh ocehlcx ndalw ixxdxw% ,Dw q`sbg oc }rcfcriobc w` livc wlc
i}}r`}rdiwc }r`hcgsrc rcx`bvcg iw ie cirbt xwiac" f`r c|in}bc" iw i }rcbdndeirt
lcirdea$% I biqtcr nit ibx` oc ixkcg w` rcn`vc i vcdb `r x`nc `wlcr lcig
h`vcrdea df wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx xsaacxw wliw wlc dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc irc ocdea
dn}cgcg ,f`r c|in}bc" df wlc biqtcr—x v`dhc hiee`w oc hbcirbt lcirg$% Iet `f
wlc f`rca`dea rcyscxwx xl`sbg oc nigc de i}}r`}rdiwc hdrhsnxwiehcx" f`r
c|in}bc iw ie cirbt xwiac" `r qlce wlc h`srw lix occe hbcircg `r igj`srecg"
wlsx ceiobdea wlc }crx`e i}}r`ihlcg w` livc wdnc w` h`exdgcr niwwcrx qdwl`sw
fccbdea }rcxxsrdxcg%?
9 F`r c|in}bc" de i nsrgcr wrdib de Obihkfrdirx Hr`qe H`srw" B`eg`e" i Nsxbdn jsr`r qix
ibbcacg w` livc sxcg lcr ldjio lcigxhirf w` ldgc cir}l`ecx w` ie N]8 }bitcr" ieg w` livc occe
bdxwcedea w` nsxdh riwlcr wlie w` vdwib cvdgcehc de wlc wrdib: Wlc Xh`wxnie 9= Jsbt ?==1%
? Asdgiehc advce de Hli}%8%8 `f wlc Cysib Wrciwncew Ocehl O``k f`r Ceabieg ieg Qibcx ieg
de i Ecqx _cbcixc giwcg ?7 I}rdb ?==1 fr`n wlc Jsgdhdib H`nnsedhiwd`ex @ffdhc f`r Ceabieg
ieg Qibcx% Xcc ibx` _% v% E%X%" ?==4 HieBDD ?9?=8 ,@E XH$ f`r sxcfsb asdgiehc ieg
gdxhsxxd`e% E`wc wldx hixc lix occe i}}cibcg w` wlc Hieigdie Xs}rcnc H`srw%
?%94 _cx}chw f`r wlc qdwecxxWlc f`bb`qdea }`dewx xl`sbg oc o`rec de ndeg%
Dw dx a``g }rihwdhc w` ixhcrwide wlc h`rrchw einc `f wlc qdwecxx ieg l`q lc `r
xlc }rcfcrx w` oc iggrcxxcg%9
@ec hiee`w ixxsnc wliw wlc qdwecxx lix iet ke`qbcgac `r }rcvd`sx c|}crdcehc
`f h`srw }r`hcgsrcx% Jsgacx xl`sbg oc rcigt w` igvdxc qdwecxxcx wliw df wlct g`
e`w segcrxwieg i yscxwd`e wlct xl`sbg xit" x` wliw dw hie oc rc}lrixcg% Dw dx
a``g }rihwdhc w` igvdxc i qdwecxx wliw grdekdea qiwcr dx ividbiobc df rcysdrcg%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 27/206
Xc| `ffcehcx: ochisxc `f hsbwsrib `r rcbdad`sx gdffcrcehcx" dw nit oc vcrt
gdffdhsbw f`r x`nc qdwecxxcx fr`n hcrwide nde`rdwt cwledh h`nnsedwdcx w` advc
cvdgcehc gsc w`" f`r c|in}bc" wlc eccg w` sxc hcrwide q`rgx% Xcexdwdvdwt w`
hsbwsrib e`rnx xl`sbg oc xl`qe%
_ihdibbt n`wdviwcg `ffcehcx: xcexdwdvdwt nit oc rcysdrcg df ieg qlce rihdxw
bieasiac dx rc}ciwcg de h`srw ix }irw `f wlc cvdgcehc%
X`nc }c`}bc nit oc `ffcegcg ot f`sb bieasiac% Wlc jsgac xl`sbg h`exdgcr
qlcwlcr `r e`w w` dewcrvcec ifwcr oibiehdea wlc dn}`rwiehc `f livdea rcairg w`
xcexdwdvdwdcx `f degdvdgsibx ieg wlc dn}`rwiehc `f ihldcvdea jsxwdhc%
X`nc }c`}bc nit e`w segcrxwieg wlc rcbcviehc `f dgcewdftdea wlc ihhsxcg de
h`srw% ]`dewdea nit oc h`exdgcrcg rsgc de x`nc hsbwsrcx" osw wlcrc irc `wlcr
qitx `f nikdea ie dgcewdfdhiwd`e%
9Xcc fsrwlcr" Hli}wcr 8 ,Eincx ieg f`rnx `f iggrcxx$%
Iggdwd`eib }`dewx
?%?= Ixxsn}wd`ex xl`sbg e`w oc nigc io`sw gdffcrcew hsbwsrib e`rnx% Dw nit oc
echcxxirt w` wikc ihh`sew `f rcbdad`sx `r hsbwsrib rcysdrcncewx f`r i }crx`e iwwcegdea
h`srw ix i qdwecxx%
I qdgc virdcwt `f gdffcrcew rihdib ar`s}x nit eccg w` oc hiwcrcg f`r% Wlcrc dx
ie cysib gdvcrxdwt `f eccg qdwlde wlc qldwc h`nnsedwt% F`r c|in}bc" w`srdxwx
nit oc hdwcg w` h`srw" ieg nit fdeg `sr hrdndeib jsxwdhc xtxwcn vcrt gdffcrcew
fr`n wlcdr `qe%
Wlcrc dx dehrcixdea rch`aedwd`e wliw wlc h`srwx xl`sbg osdbg a``g bdekx qdwl
b`hib vdhwdn" qdwecxx" ieg nde`rdwt cwledh igv`hiht ar`s}x ieg ceh`sriac
wlcdr findbdirdxiwd`e qdwl h`srw }r`hcgsrcx%
Ibwcreiwdvc o``kx f`r `iwlx xl`sbg oc rcigdbt ividbiobc de cvcrt h`srw%9
]rc.h`srw qrdwwce niwcrdibx xl`sbg oc ividbiobc de i rieac `f f`rniwx ieg de
gdffcrcew bieasiacx%?
I b`hib dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc qdbb oc iobc w` advc asdgiehc
`e wlc bieasiacx n`xw frcyscewbt x}`kce de t`sr b`hib h`nnsedwt%
9F`r `iwlx ieg `iwl wikdea" xcc Hli}wcr 7%
?F`r c|in}bc" wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc g`hsncew ‒A`dea w` H`srw„ dx ividbiobc de wldrwcce
gdffcrcew bieasiacx; wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew }sobdhiwd`e ‒Vdhwdnx `f Hrdnc„ def`rniwd`e
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 28/206
bcifbcw dx ividbiobc de Iriodh" Hldecxc" Srgs ieg Ldegd; ieg wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc }sobdhiwd`e
‒Ocdea i qdwecxx„ dx ividbiobc de xcvcrib gdffcrcew bieasiacx%
I]]_@]_DIWC BIEASIAC
?%?9 Wlc Ceabdxl bieasiac dx h`exwiewbt cv`bvdea" ieg ihhc}wiobc wcrnde`b`at
gcxhrdodea cwledh nde`rdwdcx lix gcvcb`}cg ix i qit `f iv`dgdea `ffcehc ieg
gcvcb`}dea xcexdwdvdwt% Dw dx dn}`rwiew wliw seihhc}wiobc bieasiac dx e`w sxcg% Wldx dx
e`w io`sw x` hibbcg ‒}`bdwdhib h`rrchwecxx„" riwlcr dw dx }irw `f x`hdcwt—x rcx}`exc w` wlc
eccg w` rch`aedxc ieg rcx}chw gdvcrxdwt ieg cysibdwt% Bieasiac wliw qix f`rncrbt
sxcg w` gcxhrdoc i }crx`e—x rihc dx x`ncwdncx e` b`eacr ihhc}wiobc% Dw xl`sbg oc e wcg
wliw wlcrc hie oc gdffcrcehcx de `}ded`e `vcr x`nc wcrnx" x` qldbxw x`nc q`rgx irc
hbcirbt seihhc}wiobc" f`r `wlcrx wlcrc nit e`w oc iet `ec h`rrchw iexqcr io`sw
qlcwlcr wlc wcrn dx rdalw `r qr`ea% E`wcg ocb`q dx x`nc oixdh asdgiehc%
Obihk
?%?? Dw dx e`q h`exdgcrcg ihhc}wiobc w` sxc wlc wcrn “obihk— w` gcxhrdoc }c`}bc `f
Hirdoocie r Ifrdhie gcxhcew%
Qcxw Degdie / Ifrdhie Hirdoocie / Ifrdhie
?%?8 Wlc wcrn ‒Qcxw Degdie„ qix f`rncrbt sxcg ix i }lrixc w` gcxhrdoc wlc fdrxw
acecriwd`e `f xcwwbcrx fr`n wlc Qcxw Degdcx% Qldbc wlc wcrn ‒Qcxw Degdie„ q`sbg e w
ibqitx advc `ffcehc" dw dx dei}}r`}rdiwc sebcxx wlc degdvdgsib h`ehcrecg dgcewdfdcx
ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf de wldx qit% Wlc wcrn ‒Ifrdhie Hirdoocie„ dx e`q nshl n`rc
qdgcbt sxcg" cx}chdibbt de `ffdhdib ieg ihigcndh g`hsncewx% Qlcrc i }crx`e—x cwledh
`rdade dx rcbcview" wliw wcrn dx o`wl i}}r`}rdiwc ieg ihhc}wiobc% Dw g`cx e`w" l`qcvcr"
rcfcr w` ibb }c`}bc `f Qcxw Degdie `rdade" x`nc `f ql`n irc Qldwc `r `f Ixdie
c|wrihwd`e%
?%?7 Wlc wcrn ‒Ifrdhie„ dx `fwce ihhc}wiobc ieg nit oc sxcg de xcbf .dgcewdfdhiwd`e"
ibwl`sal niet `f Ifrdhie `rdade qdbb rcfcr w` wlcdr h`sewrt `f `rdade de eiwd`eib wcrnx
xshl ix Edacrdie `r Alieidie%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 29/206
?%?3 T`sea }c`}bc o`re de Ordwide w`git nit hl``xc e`w w` sxc iet `f wlcxc
gcxdaeiwd`ex%
Ixdie
?%?6 ‒Ixdie„ dx i h`bbchwdvc wcrn qldhl lix occe i}}bdcg de Ordwide w` }c`}bc fr`n
wlc Degdie xso.h`ewdecew ieg `wlcr }irwx `f Ixdi" xshl ix Deg`ecxdi% De }rihwdhc"
}c`}bc fr`n wlc Degdie xso.h`ewdecew nit e`w h`exdgcr wlcnxcbvcx w` oc ‒Ixdie„%
]c`}bc wceg w` dgcewdft wlcnxcbvcx de wcrnx `f `ec `r n`rc `f wlc f`bb`qdea:
wlcdr eiwd`eib `rdade ,‒Degdie„" ‒]ikdxwied„" ‒Oieabigcxld„$;
wlcdr rcad`e `f `rdade ,‒Asjiriwd„" ‒]sejiod„" ‒Oceaibd„$;
wlcdr rcbdad`e ,‒Nsxbdn„" ‒Ldegs„" ‒Xdkl„$%
Wlc wcrn “Ixdie— hie oc i}}r`}rdiwc qlce wlc c|ihw cwledh `rdade `f wlc }crx`e dx
seke`qe% Wlc n`rc x}chdfdh wcrnx `f “X`swl Cixw Ixdie" Fir Cixw Ixdie `r X`swl
Ixdie nit oc }rcfcrrcg%
?%?1 Wlc wcrn ‒Ixdie„ dx ihhc}wiobc qlcrc wlc c|ihw cwledh `rdade `f wlc }crx`e dx
e`w ke`qe" `r ix i h`bbchwdvc rcfcrcehc w` }c`}bc fr`n wlc Degdie xso.h`ewdecew%
T`sea }c`}bc `f X`swl Ixdie `rdade o`re de Ordwide `fwce ihhc}w wlc xinc dgcewdwdcx
ieg gcxdaeiwd`ex ix wlcdr }ircewx% Wldx dx ot e` nciex ibqitx wlc hixc" ieg x`nc e`q
nit }rcfcr w` gcxhrdoc wlcnxcbvcx ix ‒Obihk„ `r ix ‒Ordwdxl Ixdie„%
Nd|cg rihc/Nd|cg lcrdwiac
?%?< Wlc wcrn ‒nd|cg rihc„ dx qdgcbt sxcg ieg dx h`exdgcrcg ihhc}wiobc ot x`nc
ieg e`w ot `wlcrx% Ie`wlcr wcrn qldhl nit oc ocwwcr dx ‒nd|cg lcrdwiac„% Wlc wcrn
‒nsbwd.rihdib„ nit `ebt oc sxcg de rcbiwd`e w` h`nnsedwdcx%
Cwledh nde`rdwdcx/Nde`rdwt cwledh
?%?4 Wlc wcrnx ‒cwledh nde`rdwt„ ieg ‒nde`rdwt cwledh„ irc qdgcbt sxcg ieg irc
acecribbt ihhc}wiobc ix wlc or`igcxw wcrnx w` ceh`n}ixx ibb wl`xc ar`s}x ql` xcc
wlcnxcbvcx w` oc gdxwdehw fr`n wlc nij`rdwt de wcrnx `f cwledh `r hsbwsrib dgcewdwt%
Wldx wcrn dx hbcirbt or`igcr wlie ‒Obihk nde`rdwt cwledh„ `r wlc }r`obcniwdhib ‒vdxdobc
nde`rdwdcx„ ,}r`obcniwdhib ix dw nit dn}bt wliw wlcrc irc devdxdobc nde`rdwdcx$" ieg
ordeax de xshl ar`s}x ix Arcck ieg Wsrkdxl Ht}rd`wx `r At}xt Wrivcbbcrx%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 30/206
]lrixcx w` oc iv`dgcg
?%8= Wlc segcre`wcg q`rgx irc seihhc}wiobc qlce rcfcrrdea w` }c`}bc" ix wlct irc
h`exdgcrcg w` oc `ffcexdvc de x`nc hixcx ieg }`xxdobt `ffcexdvc de `wlcrx%
@ffcexdvc:
H`b`srcg
]c`}bc `f h`b`sr
Vdxdobc nde`rdwdcx
Cwledhx
]ikd
Ecar`
Ecar`dg
@rdcewib
Ifr`.Hirdoocie
Libf.hixwc
Wdek
Hldekt
]r`obcniwdhib:
]c`}bc `f h`b`sr
Vdxdobc nde`rdwdcx
Obihk
De iggdwd`e" hircfsb sxc `f hcrwide `wlcr }crfchwbt ihhc}wiobc wcrnx qdbb oc rcysdrcg%
W` wikc x`nc xdn}bc c|in}bcx" ‒Ordwdxl„ ieg ‒Xh`wwdxl„ xl`sbg o`wl oc sxcg de ie
dehbsxdvc xcexc x` ix w` dehbsgc" ix dx i}}r`}rdiwc" ibb cwledh ar`s}x riwlcr wlie ocdea
sxcg dewcrhlieaciobt qdwl ‒Qldwc„% Wlc wcrnx ‒dnndariew„" ‒ixtbsn xcckcr„ ieg
‒rcfsacc„ xl`sbg `ebt sxcg qlcrc xshl wcrnx irc fihwsibbt h`rrchw de h`eechwd`e qdwl
wlc }irwdhsbir degdvdgsib de rcbiwd`e w` ql`n wlct irc sxcg%
?%89 Jsgacx nit ibx` qdxl w` h`exdgcr qlcwlcr iet rcfcrcehc w` i }crx`e—x rihc"
cwledh `r eiwd`eib `rdade dx rcbcview% Df dw lix e` ocirdea `e wlc }r`hccgdeax iw lieg"
qlt g`cx dw eccg w` oc rcfcrrcg w` iw ibb0
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 31/206
ACEC_IB ]@DEWX
?%8? Qldbxw niet jsgacx qdbb livc c|}crdcehc `f }rcxdgdea `vcr i gdvcrxc ieg nsbwd.
rihdib h`srw" dw dx rch`aedxcg wliw f`r `wlcrx wlc }rcxcehc `f nde`rdwt cwledh }c`}bc dxbcxx h`nn`e% Wlc f`bb`qdea iggdwd`eib asdgiehc gcrdvcg fr`n wlc Jsgdhdib H`bbcac `f
Ceabieg ieg Qibcx9
nit oc lcb}fsb%
Wrciw cvcrt`ec ql` h`ncx w` wlc h`srw qdwl gdaedwt ieg rcx}chw ‘ ‒g` ix t`s
q`sbg oc g`ec ot„%
Cvcrt`ec lix }rcjsgdhcx% _ch`aedxc ieg asirg iaidexw t`sr `qe%
Cvcrt`ec ibx` vdcqx wlc q`rbg fr`n wlcdr `qe degdvdgsib }crx}chwdvc ieg
x`nc `f wlcxc vdcqx qdbb irdxc ochisxc `f hsbwsrib oihkar`seg%
Oc qcbb def`rncg ‘ ocdea degc}cegcew ieg dn}irwdib g`cx e`w ncie ocdea
dx`biwcg fr`n dxxscx qldhl iffchw }c`}bc fr`n nde`rdwt h`nnsedwdcx%
G` e`w ixxsnc wliw wrciwdea cvcrt`ec de wlc xinc qit dx wlc xinc wldea ix
wrciwdea cvcrt`ec fidrbt%
Oc ‒h`b`sr h`exhd`sx„" e`w ‒h`b`sr obdeg„% Fidr wrciwncew dev`bvcx wikdea
ihh`sew f gdffcrcehc%
G` e`w nikc ixxsn}wd`ex: ibb Qldwc }c`}bc irc e`w wlc xinc e`r irc ibb Ixdie
}c`}bc `r Hldecxc }c`}bc%
G` e`w }r jchw hsbwsrib xwcrc`wt}cx% N`xw t`sea cwledh nde`rdwt }c`}bc irc
xch`eg ieg wldrg acecriwd`e Ordwdxl o`re hdwdzcex ieg nit oc e` gdffcrcew fr`n
iet `wlcr wcceiacr qlce fihcg qdwl iswl`rdwt fdasrcx%
G` e`w }crhcdvc }c`}bc fr`n cwledh nde`rdwt h`nnsedwdcx ix ‒wlc }r`obcn„%
Df wlcrc dx iet }r`obcn" dw nit bdc de wlc q`rkdea ncwl`gx ieg wrigdwd`ex `f
x`nc dexwdwswd`ex qldhl nit }sw x`nc ar`s}x" xshl ix cwledh nde`rdwdcx" iw ie
sefidr gdxigviewiac%
Df de g`sow ‘ ixk% I }`bdwc ieg qcbb.dewcewd`ecg ceysdrt io`sw l`q w`
}r`e`sehc i einc `r io`sw i }irwdhsbir rcbdad`sx ocbdcf `r i bieasiac
rcysdrcncew qdbb e`w oc `ffcexdvc qlce }r`n}wcg ot i acesdec gcxdrc w` acw dw
rdalw% Ie ixxsn}wd`e" l`qcvcr" nit hisxc `ffcehc%
9 _ihc ieg wlc h`srwx" i xl`rw }rihwdhib asdgc f`r jsgacx" Jsgdhdib H`bbcac `f Ceabieg ieg
Qibcx" 9444%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 32/206
?%88 Ibb jsgacx sxc wlcdr ocxw cegciv`srx w` wrciw cvcrt`ec cysibbt ieg xl`q e` odix
`r }rcjsgdhc% Wlc jsgdhdib `iwl"9
wikce ot jsgacx `e i}}`dewncew" gdhwiwcx wlc nieecr
de qldhl wlct nsxw wrciw ibb wl`xc ql` h`nc ocf`rc wlcn% Wlcrc nsxw oc ie
iqircecxx" l`qcvcr" wliw qdwlde sx ibb wlcrc dx i }`wcewdib" seqdwwdeabt `r
seh`exhd`sxbt" w` nikc rcnirkx wliw ndalw oc }crhcdvcg ot x`nc w` oc }rcjsgdhdib"
`ffcexdvc r gdxh`srwc`sx cvce df e`wldea `f wlc x`rw qix dewcegcg% Wlc }`dewx de
}iriari}l ?%8? irc nigc xdn}bt w` ridxc iqircecxx% I nde`rdwt ar`s} nit fdeg
sedewcewd`eib }rcjsgdhc `r gdxhrdndeiwd`e" qldhl dx e`w rch`aedxcg ot wlc }cr}cwriw`r
ix xshl" jsxw ix `ffcexdvc ix df dw qcrc dewcewd`eib%
9 Wlc f`rn `f wlc jsgdhdib `iwl dx de x% 7 `f wlc ]r`ndxx`rt @iwlx Ihw 9<6< ieg dx de wlc
f`bb`qdea wcrnx:. ‒D" …" g` xqcir wliw D qdbb qcbb ieg wrsbt xcrvc `sr x`vcrcdae [Bigt" wlce
wlc einc `f wlc x`vcrcdae `f wldx kdeag`n f`r wlc wdnc ocdea ^" ieg qdbb g` rdalw w` ibb nieecr
`f }c`}bc ifwcr wlc biqx ieg sxiacx `f wldx rcibn" qdwl`sw fcir `r fiv`sr" iffchwd`e `r dbb.qdbb„%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 33/206
Hli}wcr 8
EINCX IEG F@_NX @F IGG_CXX
A@BGCE _SBC: IXK WLC QDWECXX
8%9 F`r niet" eincx ieg f`rnx `f iggrcxx irc dn}`rwiew ieg ix i rcxsbw }c`}bc hie
oc xcexdwdvc io`sw dw" c|}chwdea `wlcrx w` }r`e`sehc ieg x}cbb wlcdr einc h`rrchwbt ieg
w` acw wlc f`rn `f iggrcxx rdalw% Dw dx dn}`rwiew wliw de i gdvcrxc x`hdcwt" ibb ncnocrx
`f wliw x`hdcwt xl`sbg livc wldx rcbiwdvcbt xdn}bc c|}chwiwd`e fsbfdbbcg%% Dw dx ibx` ie
dn}`rwiew h`n}`ecew de dehrcixdea wlc h`efdgcehc de wlc h`srwx f`r wl`xc wliw h`nc
dew` h`ewihw qdwl wlc jsgdhdib }r`hcxx%
8%? Eiwsribbt" dw nit e`w oc }`xxdobc w` ke`q de igviehc l`q w` }r`e`sehc ibb
eincx `r w` rcncnocr cvcrt f`rn `f iggrcxx% Qlcrc i jsgac dx de iet g`sow" wlc
a`bgce rsbc dx w` ixk wlc qdwecxx ieg e`w w` nikc ixxsn}wd`ex% Wlc qdwecxx xl`sbg oc
ixkcg f`r ldx `r lcr fsbb einc" l`q dw dx x}cbw ieg }r`e`sehcg ieg l`q lc `r xlc
q`sbg bdkc w` oc iggrcxxcg% G` e`w rcfcr w` wlc fdrxw einc ix ‒Hlrdxwdie„" f`r `ovd`sx
rcix`ex" `r ixxsnc wliw wlc Ordwdxl findbt eindea xtxwcn qdbb i}}bt w` `wlcrx fr`n
gdffcrcew oihkar`segx%
8%8 Wlc def`rniwd`e ieg f`rnx `f iggrcxx e`wcg ocb`q9
irc dewcegcg ncrcbt ix
oihkar`seg def`rniwd`e% Eindea xtxwcnx fwce livc i h`eechwd`e qdwl wlc dewcr.}bit
ocwqcce h`nnsedwt ieg findbt bdfc% De Csr`}c f`r c|in}bc" }ircewib ieg }crx`eib
eincx irc wlc e`rn% L`qcvcr" de `wlcr hsbwsrcx qlcrc h`nnsedwt bdfc nit oc n`rc
xwrshwsrcg" eincx nit degdhiwc ncnocrxld} `f h`nnsedwt `r findbt ar`s}x%
Ncnocrx `f cwledh nde`rdwt h`nnsedwdcx de Xh`wbieg nit h`ewdesc w` sxc wrigdwd`eib
eindea xtxwcnx `r wlct ndalw igi}w wlcxc w` fdw qdwl bdvdea de Ordwide%
9
Igi}wcg fr`n ‒I asdgc w` hsbwsrib ieg rihdib iqircecxx„" }r`gshcg ot wlc Debieg _cvcesc"Hr`qe H`}trdalw" Isasxw ?=== ieg fr`n wlc B`wldie ieg O`rgcrx ]`bdhc Gdvcrxdwt Asdgc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 34/206
C\IN]BCX
Ifrdhie eincx
8%7 Wrigdwd`eibbt" ihr`xx xso.Xilirie Ifrdhi" eincx ndalw qcbb h`exdxw `f }crx`eib
eincx `ebt" ieg irc bdkcbt w` oc acegcr x}chdfdh% Xsreincx ieg findbt eincx,h`nn`e de Ordwide$ ndalw qcbb e`w oc sxcg% Eindea" acecribbt" rcfbchwx wlc niet
ieg gdvcrxc ar`s}x `f }c`}bc de wlc irci ieg wlc vird`sx cwledh ieg hsbwsrib
oihkar`segx% Wlc defbscehcx `f rcbdad`e ,Hlrdxwdie ieg Nsxbdn$ ieg h`b`edibdxn"
l`qcvcr" livc hlieacg eindea de wlc irci" ieg niet livc ig`}wcg Hlrdxwdie `r
Nsxbdn ieg findbt eincx%
Hirdoocie eincx
8%3 @bgcr acecriwd`ex fwce sxc Odobdhib eincx fr`n wlc @bg Wcxwincew% Gsc w` wlc
defbscehcx `f h`b`edibdxn l`qcvcr" wlc wrigdwd`eib qcxwcre eindea xtxwcn `f fdrxw ieg
bixw einc dx h`nn`e%
Hldecxc eincx
8%6 Wrigdwd`eibbt de Hldecxc eincx" wlc xsreinc h`ncx fdrxw" f`bb`qcg ot i }crx`eib
einc wliw nit h`exdxw `f `ec `r wq` ‒hlirihwcrx„% De Ceabdxl" wlcxc i}}cir ix wq`
xc}iriwc q rgx% Qlce q`nce nirrt" wlct nit kcc} wlcdr xsreinc `r ig`}w wlcdr
lsxoieg—x xsreinc% X`ncwdncx" i lsxoieg ieg qdfc ig`}w o`wl wlcdr }rc.nirrdiac
xsreincx ix i j`dew xsreinc% De wldx hixc" wlc lsxoieg—x xsreinc acecribbt h`ncx
fdrxw" osw wlc qdfc—x xsreinc h`ncx fdrxw df dw x`segx ocwwcr `r df wlct iarcc wliw dw qdbb%
Hldbgrce livc wlcdr fiwlcr—x xsreinc `r i j`dew xsreinc df wlcdr }ircewx sxc `ec% X`nc
Hldecxc }c`}bc livc ig`}wcg wlc }rihwdhc `f }swwdea wlcdr xsreinc bixw% Qdvcx nit
x`ncwdncx advc wlcdr einc ix ‒Nrx ,lsxoieg—x einc$„" ibwl`sal wlct ndalw de `wlcr
h`ewc|wx sxc wlcdr nidgce einc%
Niet Hldecxc }c`}bc bdvdea de Xh`wbieg livc ig`}wcg Qcxwcre eincx% Wldx nit
cewidb }bihdea wlc Qcxwcre einc ocf`rc wlc Hldecxc eincx" `r ibwcreiwdvcbt" gr`}}dea
wlc Hldecxc eincx ibw`acwlcr ieg xdn}bt advdea wlc Qcxwcre fdrxw ieg bixw eincx%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 35/206
Crdwrcie ieg Cwld`}die eincx
8%1 N`xw Crdwrcie ieg Cwld`}die eincx livc wq` }irwx" i }crx`eib einc f`bb`qcg
ot wlc fiwlcr—x }crx`eib einc sxcg ix i xsreinc% ]c`}bc nit ibx` sxc wlcdr
ariegfiwlcr—x }crx`eib einc ieg wlce wldx och`ncx wlc xsreinc% X`nc Crdwrciex ieg
Cwld`}diex livc ig`}wcg i ‒xwiwdh„ xsr einc wliw g`cx e`w hlieac qdwl cihl
acecriwd`e% Q`nce g` e`w wrigdwd`eibbt hlieac wlcdr bixw einc `e nirrdiac" ibwl`sal
x`nc livc ig`}wcg wldx hsxw`n% Hldbgrce livc wlcdr fiwlcr—x `r ariegfiwlcr—x fdrxw
einc ix wlcdr xsreinc%
Fdbd}de` eincx
8%< Fdbd}de`x livc wq` xsreincx: Wlc fdrxw dx wlcdr n`wlcr—x xsreinc ieg wlc xch`eg
dx wlcdr fiwlcr—x xsreinc% Qlce Fdbd}de` q`nce nirrt" wlct gr`} wlcdr n`wlcr—x
xsreinc ieg xsoxwdwswc wlcdr lsxoieg—x xch`eg xsreinc% Wlcrcf`rc" hldbgrce livc wlc
xinc xsreincx ix wlcdr n`wlcr xdehc lcr nirrdiac%
Alieidie eincx
8%4 Alieidiex" drrcx}chwdvc `f rcbdad`e" sxsibbt livc wlcdr `qe }crx`eib einc" i
ndggbc einc qldhl dx i wrdoib" hsxw`nirt" `r x`ncwdncx i rcbdad`sx einc" ieg i
xsreinc wliw dx i findbt einc% Wlct nit livc" cdwlcr ix wlcdr x`bc }crx`eib einc r
ix wlcdr ndggbc einc" i einc wliw gc}cegx `e wlc git `f wlc qcck `e qldhl wlct qcrc
o`re% Qlce q`nce nirrt de i hlsrhl `r hdvdb hcrcn`et" wlct ig`}w wlcdr lsxoieg—x
xsreinc% Df wlct irc nirrdcg ot hsxw`nirt biq" wlct acecribbt" ibwl`sal e`w ibqitx"
ibx` ig`}w wlcdr lsxoieg—x xsreinc% Hldbgrce wikc wlcdr fiwlcr—x xsreinc osw nit
ibx` igg wlcdr n`wlcr—x xsreinc" df wlcdr }ircewx x` gchdgc%
Arcck ieg Arcck Ht}rd`w eincx
8%9= De wlc wrigdwd`eib Arcck xtxwcn `f eindea" }c`}bc sxc i }crx`eib einc" qdwl
wlcdr fiwlcr—x `r ariegfiwlcr—x }crx`eib einc ix wlcdr xsreinc% Wlc cegdeax `f
}crx`eib eincx hlieac qlce sxcg ix xsreincx ieg nit gdffcr qlce i}}bdcg w` nce
ieg q`nce% @e nirrdiac i nie g`cx e`w hlieac ldx einc% I q`nie wikcx:
lcr lsxoieg—x }crx`eib einc ix lcr ndggbc einc; ieg
acecribbt" ldx fiwlcr—x }crx`eib einc ix lcr xsreinc% Xlc h`sbg" sesxsibbt"
sxc ldx ariegfiwlcr—x }crx`eib einc ix lcr xsreinc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 36/206
Df i nie dx sxdea ldx ariegfiwlcr—x }crx`eib einc ix i xsr einc" ldx qdfc qdbb
x`ncwdncx livc i gdffcrcew xsreinc% Niet Arcckx ieg Arcck Ht}rd`wx }crniecewbt
xcwwbcg de wlc SK livc ig`}wcg i xwiwdh xsreinc xtxwcn" qdwl wlc fiwlcr—x }crx`eib
einc dehbsgcg ix wlc ndggbc einc%
Ldegs eincx
8%99 Wlc oixdh }iwwcre f`r Ldegs eincx dx wliw wlcrc irc wlrcc }irwx:
}crx`eib ,fdrxw$ eincx: Bibdwi" _ij" Vdjit%
ndggbc eincx: Gcvd" Ksnir" Bib%
xsreincx: Xlirni , fcnibc$" Vixied ,nibc$" ]iwcb ,nibc$%
Wldx }iwwcre hie virt" ix wlc hlirihwcrdxwdhx `f Ldegs eincx ieg wdwbcx gc}ceg `e
gdibchwx ieg qlcrc i }crx`e h`ncx fr`n% F`r c|in}bc" eincx de X`swl Degdi nit
dehbsgc wlc vdbbiac ieg `hhs}iwd`e%
8%99%9 ]crx`eib ,fdrxw$ eincx: Findbt ieg frdcegx sxc wlc fdrxw einc `e dwx `qe%
Wlcrc irc i birac esnocr `f }`xxdobc eincx w` hl``xc fr`n% Wlc fdrxw einc `fwce
degdhiwcx acegcr% Wlc fdrxw ieg ndggbc eincx irc sxcg w`acwlcr ix i xdae `f f`rnibdwt
`r rcx}chw" f`r c|in}bc" Bibdwigcvd `r _ijksnir% De def`rnib h`ewc|wx wlc cegdea ‒jd„
nit dexwcig oc iggcg w` wlc }crx`eib einc w` xl`q rcx}chw%
8%99%? Ndggbc eincx: Wlcrc irc `ebt i fcq Ldegs ndggbc eincx% Wlct irc ecvcr
sxcg `e wlcdr `qe ieg irc e`w xsreincx ,osw xcc def`rniwd`e ocb`q segcr
‒Ie`nibdcx„$% Wlc ndggbc einc dx h`nn`ebt cdwlcr wlc fiwlcr—x `r lsxoieg—x einc%
8%99%8 Xsreincx: Wlc findbt einc dx sxcg ix i xsreinc" osw nit ibx` oc i ‒xso.
hixwc„ einc wliw degdhiwcx wlc findbt—x wrigdwd`eib xwiwsx ieg `hhs}iwd`e" ieg x` dx
xlircg ot i birac esnocr `f findbdcx" f r c|in}bc" ]iwcb% Wlc xsreinc dx xlircg ot
ibb ncnocrx `f `ec gdvdxd`e `f i hixwc de i }irwdhsbir irci% Wlc qdfc ieg hldbgrce sxc
wlc xinc xsreinc ix wlc lcig `f wlc findbt%
8%99%7 Ie`nibdcx: X`nc }c`}bc livc gr`}}cg wlc findbt einc w` degdhiwc rcjchwd`e
`f wlc hixwc xtxwcn% Qlce wldx li}}cex wlct sxc wlcdr ndggbc einc ix i xsreinc" ieg
cihl ncnocr `f wlc findbt lix i gdffcrcew ‒xsreinc„" f`r c|in}bc" Nrx Gcvd nit oc
wlc qdfc `f Nr Bib% @hhixd`eibbt" }c`}bc qdbb qr`eabt advc wlc ndggbc einc ix i
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 37/206
xsreinc ochisxc niet Degdie }c`}bc irc e`w ihhsxw`ncg w` advdea wlcdr xsreincx de
`ffdhdib xdwsiwd`ex% Df t`s wldek wldx nit livc li}}cecg" ixk f`r wlc findbt einc%
8%99%3 Iggrcxxdea Ldegsx: De f`rnib xdwsiwd`ex" ibqitx iggrcxx i Ldegs ot wdwbc ieg
fsbb einc" f`r c|in}bc" Nrx Bibdwigcvd Xlirni% Qlce iggrcxxdea i Ldegs
def`rnibbt" sxc wlc fdrxw einc" f`r c|in}bc" Bibdwi%
8%99%6 Asjiriwd Ldegs eincx: Asjiriwd Ldegs eincx h`exdxw `f:
i }crx`eib einc;
wlc fiwlcr—x fdrxw einc; ieg
i xsreinc%
Qlce q`nce nirrt" wlct igg wlcdr lsxoiegx— fdrxw einc ieg xsreinc w` wlcdr
}crx`eib einc% De findbdir sxc" wlc xsffd|:
‒olid„ ,or`wlcr$ nit oc iggcg w` nce—x }crx`eib eincx sxcg ib`ec; ieg
‒olid„ `r ‒oce„ w` q`nce—x eincx%
Driedie eincx
8%9? Driediex livc `ec `r n`rc }crx`eib eincx ieg i xsreinc% Driedie q`nce g`
e`w hlieac wlcdr xsreinc `e nirrdiac% Hldbgrce wikc wlcdr fiwlcr—x findbt einc%
N`xw Driediex irc Nsxbdnx" osw x`nc h`nn`e Driedie eincx irc e`e.Nsxbdn de
`rdade%
Jcqdxl eincx
8%98 Jcqdxl }c`}bc `fwce wikc wlc eindea xtxwcn `f wlc h`sewrt de qldhl wlct bdvc%
N`xw nirrdcg q`nce wikc wlcdr lsxoieg—x einc% Ix i acecrib asdgc" Jcqx sxc:
Ordwdxl eincx de git.w`.git xdwsiwd`ex qdwlde wlcdr `qe h`nnsedwt ieg de
wlcdr ihwdvdwdcx de wlc qdgcr h nnsedwt; ieg
wrigdwd`eib eincx f`r rcbdad`sx }sr}`xcx iw wlc wdnc `f odrwlx" nirrdiacx ieg
gciwlx%
Wlc wrigdwd`eib eincx irc i }iwr`e`ndhib xtxwcn de qldhl }c`}bc irc rcfcrrcg w` ot
wlcdr advce einc f`bb`qcg ot ‒x`e `f„ ieg wlc fiwlcr—x einc% F`r c|in}bc" f r
rcbdad`sx }sr}`xcx" i nie nit oc hibbcg Dxiih x`e `f Iorilin% Wlc rcbdad`sx einc dx
sxsibbt rcbiwcg w` wlc xchsbir einc% I findbt nit x`ncwdncx sxc wlc advce rcbdad`sx
einc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 38/206
Nsxbdn eincx
8%97 Vdrwsibbt ibb ]ikdxwiedx irc Nsxbdnx" ix irc n`xw Oieabigcxldx" ieg niet Cixw
Ifrdhie Ixdiex; ieg wlcrc dx i xsoxwiewdib Nsxbdn nde`rdwt de Degdi% Ochisxc Dxbin dx
wlc rcbdad`e `f }c`}bc fr`n vcrt niet h`sewrdcx ieg gdffcrcew hsbwsrcx wlcrc irc eincx
ieg einc }iwwcrex wliw" ibwl`sal oixdhibbt Nsxbdn" ibx` rcfbchw `wlcr b`hib" x`ncwdncx
}rc.Dxbindh" hsbwsrcx% Dw nit oc lcb}fsb w` ixk wlc }crx`e:
qliw wlct sxc ix wlcdr }crx`eib einc;
qliw wlct q`sbg h`exdgcr `r sxc ix wlcdr xsreinc;
qliw wlct qiew w` oc hibbcg%
8%97%9 _ch`rgdea Nsxbdn eincx: Qlce rch`rgdea Nsxbdn eincx" wlcrc irc i
esnocr `f }`dewx w` e`wc:
wlc `rgcr `f eincx dx e`w fd|cg `r xdaedfdhiew;
qlce Nsxbdnx nirrt" wlc q`nce g` e`w sxsibbt hlieac wlcdr eincx;
hldbgrce g` e`w echcxxirdbt livc wlcdr fiwlcr—x einc;
i xsreinc `r findbt einc nit e`w c|dxw%
]c`}bc `f ibb `rdadex nit igg hcrwide wdwbcx w` eincx w` xl`q rcx}chw% F`r c|in}bc"
Odod ieg Ocasn nit oc iggcg w` q`nce!x eincx" ieg nce ql` irc cx}chdibbt gcv`sw
nit livc c|wri rcbdad`sx wdwbcx% Wlc bixw einc dx e`w i xlircg findbt xsreinc% De
n`xw Nsxbdn findbdcx" cihl ncnocr lix i gdffcrcew einc" f`r c|in}bc:
lsxoieg N`linncg Lifdz
qdfc Jinccbi Kliw``e
x`ex N`linncg Xlirdf
Bdiysiw Ibd
gisalwcr Fiwdni Jie%
Wldx hie hisxc gdffdhsbwdcx" f`r c|in}bc:
t`s hiee`w ixxsnc Bdiysiw Ibd—x fiwlcr dx ibx` hibbcg Ibd;
x`nc findbdcx nit ig`}w wlc lsxoieg—x }crx`eib einc ix i ‒xsreinc„%
hldbgrce o`re w` }c`}bc `f ]ikdxwied `rdade de Xh`wbieg devirdiobt ig`}w wlcdr
fiwlcr—x ‒}crx`eib einc„ ix i xsreinc%
8%97%? Nibc Nsxbdn eincx: Nibc Nsxbdn eincx sxsibbt h`exdxw `f i }crx`eib einc
ieg i rcbdad`sx einc% Wlc }crx`eib einc nit h`nc:
fdrxw" ix de Alsbin N`linncg r Tsxcf Ibd; `r
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 39/206
xch`eg" ix de N`linncg Lifdz `r Ibbil Gdwwi%
Wlc rcbdad`sx einc dx h`exdgcrcg w` oc wlc n`xw dn}`rwiew }irw% Ecvcr sxc wlc
rcbdad`sx einc ib`ec% Dw dx vcrt gdffdhsbw f`r i e`e.Nsxbdn w` wcbb qldhl dx wlc
rcbdad`sx einc% Wlcrcf`rc" ibqitx sxc wlc wq`.}irw einc de fsbb w` iv`dg advdea
`ffcehc% Ix i asdgc:
Ibbil" Sbbil ieg N`linncg irc ibqitx rcbdad`sx eincx;
Ilncg" Ibd ieg Lsxxcde hie x`ncwdncx oc rcbdad`sx eincx%
8%97%8 Iggrcxxdea nibc Nsxbdnx: Qlce f`rnibbt iggrcxxdea i nibc Nsxbdn" ibqitx
sxc wlcdr wdwbc ieg fsbb einc" f`r c|in}bc" Nr Tsxcf Ibd ,e`w Nr Ibd$% Qlce
iggrcxxdea i nibc Nsxbdn def`rnibbt" sxc wlcdr fsbb einc" f`r c|in}bc" Tsxcf Ibd%
8%97%7 Fcnibc Nsxbdn eincx: Fcnibc Nsxbdnx ibx` livc i wq`.}irw einc" ibwl`sal
ecdwlcr lix iet rcbdad`sx xdaedfdhiehc% Wlc fdrxw einc dx ibqitx i }crx`eib einc% Wlc
xch`eg einc hie cdwlcr oc:
i wdwbc" f`r c|in}bc" Oie`" Ocasn" Od" Odod" Kliesn" Kliw``e" Xsbwiei; `r
ie`wlcr }crx`eib einc" f`r c|in}bc" Iklwir" Jie" Kisxir" Ecxi%
8%97%3 Iggrcxxdea fcnibc Nsxbdnx: Qlce iggrcxxdea i fcnibc Nsxbdn f`rnibbt"
ibqitx sxc lcr wdwbc ieg fsbb einc" f`r c|in}bc" Nrx Indei Ocasn `r Nrx Fiwdni
Jie% Qlce iggrcxxdea i fcnibc Nsxbdn def`rnibbt" sxc lcr fdrxw einc" f`r c|in}bc"
Indei `r Fiwdni%
Edacrdie eincx
8%93 Edacrdie eincx `}criwc de i xdndbir qit w` wlc Alieidie xtxwcn"9
ibwl`sal
wl`xc `f Nsxbdnx fr`n e`rwlcre Edacrdi nit oc gdffcrcew%
9Xcc }iri% 8%4" io`vc%
]`bdxl eincx
8%96 ]`bdxl }c`}bc livc `ec `r n`rc }crx`eib eincx" f`bb`qcg ot i xsreinc%
Q`nce nit livc i gdffcrcew ,fcndedec$ cegdea w` wlc xinc findbt einc" f`r
c|in}bc" ]d`wr Nibde`qxkd—x qdfc `r gisalwcr nit oc hibbcg Krtxwtei Nibde`qxki%
X`nc }c`}bc }crniecewbt xcwwbcg de wlc SK livc gr`}}cg wldx sxiac%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 40/206
]`rwsascxc eincx
8%91 Ibb ]`rwsascxc }c`}bc livc wq` xsreincx" wlc fdrxw ocdea wlcdr n`wlcr—x ieg
wlc xch`eg ocdea wlcdr fiwlcr—x% Wlct nit sxc o`wl `r `ebt wlcdr fiwlcr—x% I
]`rwsascxc q`nie hie wikc lcr lsxoieg—x xsreinc `e nirrdiac ot }crndxxd`e `f wlc
rcadxwrir% Wrigdwd`eibbt" q`nce gdg e`w g` x` ieg niet `bgcr q`nce fr`n rsrib ircix
xwdbb g` e`w% Hsxw`nx irc hlieadea" l`qcvcr" ieg niet q`nce e`q ig`}w wlcdr
lsxoieg—x xsreinc,x$" iggdea dw ,`r wlcn$ w` lcr `qe%
Xdkl eincx
8%9< Wlc oixdh }iwwcre f`r Xdkl eincx dx wliw wlcrc irc wlrcc }irwx:
fdrxw einc ,}crx`eib$: Oibjdw" _ivdegcr%
ndggbc einc ,rcbdad`sx$: Kisr ,fcnibc$" Xdeal ,nibc$%
xsreinc ,findbt$: Adbb" Xil`wi
F`r rcbdad`sx rcix`ex niet Xdklx g` e`w sxc wlc findbt einc%
8%9<%9 Fdrxw ,}crx`eib$ eincx: Qlce i hldbg dx eincg" wlc Xdkl L`bt O``k dx
`}cecg iw rieg`n% Wlc hldbg—x einc nsxw xwirw qdwl wlc fdrxw bcwwcr `f wlc fdrxw q`rg
`e wlc }iac `}cecg% Findbt ieg frdcegx sxc wlc fdrxw einc `e dwx `qe% Wlc cegdea ‒j„
nit oc iggcg w` wlc }crx`eib einc" de ie def`rnib h`ewc|w" w` gce`wc rcx}chw% Wlc
wrigdwd`eib f`rn `f iggrcxx dx w` sxc wlc fdrxw ieg ndggbc eincx w`acwlcr" f`r c|in}bc"
Oibjdw Kisr `r _ivdegcr Xdeal% N`xw Xdkl }crx`eib eincx g` e`w degdhiwc acegcr" ieg
nit oc advce w` o`wl nibcx ieg fcnibcx%
8%9<%? Ndggbc einc ,rcbdad`sx$: Wlc ndggbc einc Xdeal nciedea bd`e ,nibc$" `r
Kisr nciedea }rdehcxx ,fcnibc$" dx i rcbdad`sx einc degdhiwdea wliw wlc }crx`e dx i
Xdkl%
8%9<%8 Xsreinc ,findbt$: Wlc findbt einc dx i ‒xso.hixwc„ einc% Dw lix dwx `r dade de
Ldegs hixwc ar`s}dea" degdhiwdea `hhs}iwd`e ieg }bihc `f `rdade% Wlc Xdkl rcbdad`e dx
iewd.hixwc" x` Xdklx wrigdwd`eibbt ,ieg xwdbb wt}dhibbt de Degdi$ g` e`w sxc wlc findbt
einc% X`nc Xdklx de wlc Sedwcg Kdeag`n irc ecvcrwlcbcxx sxdea wlc findbt einc%
@hhixd`eibbt" wlc ql`bc findbt ig`}w ‒Xdeal„ ix wlc findbt xsreinc% @e nirrdiac" i
q`nie wikcx lcr lsxoieg—x xsreinc `ebt df lc sxcx dw" `wlcrqdxc xlc hibbx lcrxcbf
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 41/206
Nrx Kisr% Wlcrc irc ibx` x`nc nirrdcg Xdkl q`nce de wlc Sedwcg Kdeag`n ql` hibb
wlcnxcbvcx Nrx Xdeal%
8%9<%7 Ie`nibdcx: Wlcrc irc x`nc ie`nibdcx w` e`wc" f`r c|in}bc:
Nrx Kisr ocdea nirrdcg w` Nr Xdeal;
x`nc Xdkl findbdcx nit rcvcrw w` sxdea i findbt einc" qldbc wlcdr `rdadeib
rch`rgx irc segcr wlc einc Xdeal `r Kisr%
8%9<%3 Iggrcxxdea Xdklx: Qlce iggrcxxdea i Xdkl" ibqitx sxc wlcdr wdwbc" fdrxw ieg
ndggbc eincx" f`r c|in}bc Nr Givdegcr Xdeal `r Nrx Oibjdw Kisr% E`wc wliw sxdea
wdwbc ieg xsreinc" xshl ix ‒Nrx Adbb„ nit oc `ffcexdvc w` gcv`sw Xdklx ochisxc wlct
rcairg ‒Kisr„ ix wlc n`xw dn}`rwiew }irw `f wlcdr einc% Cysibbt" ‒Nrx Kisr„ nit
hisxc h`efsxd`e de x`nc xdwsiwd`ex ix n`rc wlie `ec ‒Nrx Kisr„ nit oc }rcxcew%
Qlce iggrcxxdea i Xdkl def`rnibbt" sxc wlcdr fdrxw einc" f`r c|in}bc" Oibjdw%
X}iedxl eincx
8%94 Iw `ec wdnc" wlc X}iedxl xtxwcn `f eindea qix sxcg de ibb h`sewrdcx wliw qcrc
`ehc }irw `f wlc X}iedxl Cn}drc" dehbsgdea n`xw `f Biwde Incrdhi% Xdehc
degc}cegcehc" l`qcvcr" niet h`sewrdcx livc hlieacg wlc sxiac" sxsibbt xdn}bdftdea
dw% Ibb X}iedxl }c`}bc livc wq` xsreincx" wlc fdrxw ocdea wlcdr fiwlcr—x xsreinc ieg
wlc xch`eg wlcdr n`wlcr—x xsreinc% Qlce X}iedxl }c`}bc nirrt" nce kcc} o`wl wlcdr
xsreincx qldbc q`nce gr`} wlcdr xch`eg xsreinc ,wlcdr n`wlcr—x$ ieg xsoxwdwswc
wlcdr lsxoieg—x fdrxw xsreinc% H`efsxd`e nit irdxc ochisxc:
wlc einc qrdwwce bixw dx `fwce ixxsncg w` oc wlc xsreinc osw" f`r ibb X}iedxl
}c`}bc `wlcr wlie nirrdcg q`nce" wlc nide xsreinc dx wlc }cesbwdniwc einc;
ocf`rc wlct nirrt" X}iedxl nce ieg q`nce nit sxc o`wl xsreincx `r `ebt
wlc fdrxw% Ifwcr wlct nirrt" X}iedxl q`nce nit sxc o`wl `r `ebt wlc xch`eg;
nirrdcg q`nce x`ncwdncx sxc `ebt wlcdr lsxoieg—x xsreinc ieg `ndw ‒gc„"
f`r c|in}bc" Nirdi Irr`t` gc A`ezibcx och`ncx xdn}bt Nirdi A`ezibcx;
`ffdhdib rch`rgx de wlc SK nit xl`q o`wl xsreincx `r cdwlcr" gcx}dwc qliw wlc
}crx`e sxcx%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 42/206
Wsrkdxl eincx
8%?= Wsrkdxl }c`}bc sxsibbt livc `ec `r n`rc }crx`eib eincx f`bb`qcg ot i
xsreinc" qldhl dx xlircg ot ibb ncnocrx `f ie dnncgdiwc findbt%
Wsrkdxl Ht}rd`w eincx
8%?9 Wsrkdxl Ht}rd`wx sxsibbt livc wq` eincx" i }crx`eib einc" ot qldhl wlct irc
iggrcxxcg" ieg i xch`eg einc% Qdvcx ieg hldbgrce hsxw`nirdbt ig`}w wlcdr lsxoieg
`r fiwlcr—x }crx`eib einc ix wlcdr xsreinc% Lcehc" n`xw nce g` e`w livc wlc xinc
xsreinc ix wlcdr qdvcx ieg hldbgrce%
Vdcweincxc eincx
8%?? Vdcweincxc }c`}bc `f e`e.Hldecxc `rdade livc wlrcc eincx% Wrigdwd`eibbt" wlc
oixdh }iwwcre dx:
xsreinc: Eastce
ndggbc einc: Ea`h
}crx`eib einc: Ndel
X`nc Vdcweincxc }sw wlcdr }crx`eib einc fdrxw" f`bb`qcg ot wlcdr ndggbc einc ieg
wlcdr xsreinc bixw% Wlcrc irc virdiwd`ex `e wldx" l`qcvcr" x` dw nit oc lcb}fsb w` ixk
wlc }crx`e qldhl einc dx qldhl% @e nirrdiac" wlc q`nie wrigdwd`eibbt kcc}x lcr
`qe einc% Hldbgrce irc ke`qe ot wlcdr fiwlcr—x xsreinc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 43/206
X@S_HC NIWC_DIB
‒I asdgc w` hsbwsrib ieg rihdib iqircecxx„" }r`gshcg ot wlc Debieg _cvcesc"
Hr`qe H`}trdalw" Isasxw ?===% Ividbiobc `e wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhcdewriecw ,Ibb }sobdh f`bgcrxgdvcrxdwthsbwsrib ieg rihdib iqircecxx asdgc$%
Gdvcrxdwt Iqircecxx Asdgc . B`wldie ieg O`rgcrx ]`bdhc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 44/206
Hli}wcr 7
@IWLX IEG @IWL WIKDEA
QDWECXXCX
]sr}`xc `f `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e
7%9 Wlc }sr}`xc `f igndedxwcrdea ie `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e w` i qdwecxx dx w` cexsrc
wliw wlc qdwecxx nikcx i x bcne gchbiriwd`e w` wcbb wlc wrswl% Xl`sbg wlc qdwecxx
wlcrcifwcr fidb w` wcbb wlc wrswl" lc `r xlc nit oc f`seg asdbwt `f }crjsrt" ieg hcrwide
h`excyscehcx nit f`bb`q%9 De w`git—x nsbwd.hsbwsrib x`hdcwt" wlcrc dx dehrcixdea
rch`aedwd`e wliw ie degdvdgsib nit qdxl w` wikc ie `iwl de wcrnx `f ldx `qe rcbdad`sx
`r hsbwsrib ocbdcfx%?
Qdwl wlc igvcew `f bcadxbiwd`e h`ehcredea lsnie rdalwx8" dw dx ibb
wlc n`rc dn}`rwiew wliw wlc h`srw dx iqirc `f wlc rcysdrcncewx `f wlc gdvcrxc rcbdad`sx
ieg hsbwsrib ocbdcfx `f qdwecxxcx ql` nit oc i}}cirdea de h`srw%
9Xcc" f`r c|in}bc" A`rg`e" Hrdndeib Biq ,8
rgcgdwd`e$" Hli}wcr 71%
?
Ibwl`sal x% 3,?$ `f wlc @iwlx Ihw 941< rch`aedzcx wliw i h`srw nit oc dbb.cysd}}cg w`
igndedxwcr x`nc `iwlx ,xcc gdffcrcew wt}cx `f `iwl de }iri% 7%9? ocb`q$" de qldhl hixc wlc
qdwecxx xl`sbg xdn}bt oc ixkcg w` iffdrn%
8 Wlc Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944<" qldhl hinc dew` cffchw `e ? @hw`ocr ?===%
@iwlx Ihw 941<
7%? ]irw DD `f wlc @iwlx Ihw 941< i}}bdcx w` Xh`wbieg" ieg }r`vdgcx:
‒8% Df iet }crx`e w` ql`n ie `iwl dx igndedxwcrcg gcxdrcx w` xqcir qdwl
s}bdfwcg lieg" de wlc f`rn ieg nieecr de qldhl ie `iwl dx sxsibbt igndedxwcrcg
de Xh`wbieg" lc xlibb oc }crndwwcg x` w` g`" ieg wlc `iwl xlibb oc igndedxwcrcg
w` ldn de xshl f`rn ieg nieecr qdwl`sw fsrwlcr yscxwd`e%
7%,9$ De iet hixc de qldhl ie `iwl nit biqfsbbt oc ieg lix occe igndedxwcrcg
w` iet }crx`e" df dw lix occe igndedxwcrcg de i f`rn ieg nieecr `wlcr wlie wliw
}rcxhrdocg ot biq" lc dx o`seg ot dw df dw lix occe igndedxwcrcg de xshl f`rn
ieg qdwl xshl hcrcn`edcx ix lc nit livc gchbircg w` oc odegdea%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 45/206
,?$ Qlcrc ie `iwl lix occe gsbt igndedxwcrcg ieg wikce" wlc fihw wliw wlc
}crx`e w` ql`n dw qix igndedxwcrcg lig" iw wlc wdnc `f wikdea dw" e` rcbdad`sx
ocbdcf" xlibb e`w f`r iet }sr}`xc iffchw wlc vibdgdwt `f wlc `iwl%
3%,9$ Iet }crx`e ql` `ojchwx w` ocdea xq`re xlibb oc }crndwwcg w` nikc ldx
x`bcne iffdrniwd`e dexwcig `f wikdea ie `iwl%
,?$ Xsoxchwd`e ,9$ io`vc xlibb i}}bt de rcbiwd`e w` i }crx`e w` ql`n dw dx e`w
rcix`eiobt }rihwdhiobc qdwl`sw deh`evcedcehc `r gcbit w` igndedxwcr ie `iwl de
wlc nieecr i}}r`}rdiwc w` ldx rcbdad`sx ocbdcf ix dw i}}bdcx w` i }crx`e `ojchwdea
w` oc xq`re%
,8$ I }crx`e ql` nit oc }crndwwcg segcr xsoxchwd`e ,?$ io`vc w` nikc ldx
x`bcne iffdrniwd`e nit ibx` oc rcysdrcg w` g` x`%
,7$ I x`bcne iffdrniwd`e xlibb oc f wlc xinc f`rhc ieg cffchw ix ie `iwl%„
7%8 Wlc 941< Ihw g`cx e`w xwiwc qldhl lieg xl`sbg oc s}bdfwcg% Wlc h`evcewd`e dx
wliw }c`}bc ridxc wlcdr rdalw lieg% Fsrwlcr" wlc Ihw g`cx e`w x}chdft de qldhl lieg i
l`bt o``k xl`sbg oc lcbg qlce wlc `iwl dx wikce%
Hldbgrce
7%7 Wlc `iwl dx e`w sxsibbt igndedxwcrcg w` i hldbg segcr wlc iac `f 9?% F`r
i}}r`}rdiwc }r`hcgsrcx rcbiwdea w` hldbgrce" xcc Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$" }iriari}l <%?4
cw xcy%
]crx`ex qdwl bciredea gdxiodbdwdcx
7%3 De x`nc hixcx" dw nit oc i}}r`}rdiwc w` ig`}w wlc xinc }r`hcgsrc ix f`r i
hldbg: xcc Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$" }iriari}l <%?4 cw xcy%
F`rn `f `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e
7%6 Wlc xwiegirg f`rn `f `iwl9
de o`wl hdvdb ieg hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax?
dx:
‒D xqcir ot Ibndalwt A`g wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl" ieg
e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%„
Wlc f`rn `f iffdrniwd`e de o`wl hdvdb ieg hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax8
dx:
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 46/206
‒D x`bcnebt" xdehcrcbt ieg wrsbt gchbirc ieg iffdrn wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl" wlc
ql`bc wrswl" ieg e`wldea osw wlc wrswl„%
9 Wlc f`rn `f `iwl nit oc virdcg ix hdrhsnxwiehcx rcysdrc ,xcc wlc rsbcx `f h`srw rcfcrrcg w` de
f``we`wc ?" ocb`q" ieg xcc c|in}bcx de }iri% 7%9?" ocb`q$% Wlc sxc `f wlc Odobc `r `wlcr l`bt
o``k dx e`w rcysdrcg%
? Qdwl rdalw lieg ridxcg" wlc qdwecxx xl`sbg rc}ciw wlc q`rgx ifwcr wlc jsgac% Dw dx `fwce
h`evcedcew w` gdvdgc wlc q`rgx dew` f`sr xchwd`ex ,w` ceiobc wlc qdwecxx w` f`bb`q ieg w` rc}ciw
ihhsriwcbt$ wlsx: ‒D xqcir ot Ibndalwt A`g / wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl / wlc ql`bc wrswl / ieg
e`wldea osw wlc wrswl„% Wlc x`srhcx f`r wlc f`rn `f q`rgx dehbsgc wlc _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f
Xcxxd`e 9447" F`rn 86%9=.I; wlc Xlcrdff H`srw @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx 9448" F`rn A97; ieg
wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx 9446" F`rn 97%3.I%
8
Dw dx e`w xwrdhwbt echcxxirt w` ridxc i lieg w` iffdrn ,ibwl sal x`nc g`$% Wlc x`srhcx f`r wlc
f`rn `f q`rgx dehbsgc wlc _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9447" F`rn 86%9=.O; wlc Xlcrdff
H`srw @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx 9448" F`rn A93; ieg wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx 9446" F`rn
97%3.O%
Ividbiodbdwt `f l`bt o``kx de h`srw
7%1 Dw dx a``g }rihwdhc w` livc i xcbchwd`e `f l`bt o``kx de wlc h`srw osdbgdea"
ividbiobc f`r qdwecxxcx ql` ndalw qdxl w` wikc wlc `iwl ihh`rgdea w` wlcdr rcbdad`sx
ocbdcfx% Ie i}}r`}rdiwc xcbchwd`e q`sbg oc:
Wlc L`bt Odobc
Wlc Lcorcq Odobc9
Wlc Oliaivig Adwi `r “Adwi— ,Ldegs$
Wlc Igd Ariewl ,Xdkl$
Wlc Ysr—ie `r “K`rie— ,Nsxbdn$
Wikdea wlc xwiegirg `iwl g`cx e`w rcysdrc wlc sxc `f wlc Odobc `r `wlcr l`bt o``k%
9d%c% wlc @bg Wcxwincew `ebt%
7%< Wlc bixw wlrcc o``kx nsxw e`w oc liegbcg `wlcr wlie ot wlc qdwecxx" ieg irc
sxsibbt xw`rcg qdwl i hb`wl h`vcrdea wlcn% Wldx dx ochisxc dw dx h`exdgcrcg ot x`nc
wliw wlc l`bt o``k xl`sbg oc w`shlcg `ebt ot i }crx`e ql` dx i ocbdcvcr ieg ql` lix
hbciexcg ldnxcbf% X`ncwdncx qdwecxxcx nit rcyscxw w` }crf`rn i rdwsib `r qixl wlcdr
liegx `r ie`wlcr }irw `f wlc o`gt ocf`rc w`shldea wlcdr l`bt o``k% Wldx rcyscxw xl`sbg
oc ihhcgcg w`" ibwl`sal dw dx l`}cg wliw xshl i rcyscxw q`sbg livc occe nigc ieg
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 47/206
ariewcg }rd`r w` wlc qdwecxx h`ndea dew` h`srw% Wlc }r`hcxx `ebt wikcx i fcq ndeswcx
qlce wlc qdwecxx hbciexcx ldx `r lcr liegx" f`rcirnx" fihc f`rclcig ieg echk qdwl
qiwcr%
Niet qdwecxxcx fr`n cwledh nde`rdwdcx wikc wlcdr rcbdad`e vcrt xcrd`sxbt" ieg h`exdgcr
wlcnxcbvcx o`seg w` wcbb wlc wrswl `ebt df wlct xqcir `e wlcdr l`bt o``k% @wlcr
qdwecxxcx nit }rcfcr w` iffdrn% X`nc Nsxbdn jsrdxwx livc xidg wliw Nsxbdnx eccg e`w
wikc wlc `iwl `e wlc Ysr—ie ix dw dx wlc sehrciwcg q`rg `f A`g% Ihh`rgdeabt" wlct irc
e`w ibb`qcg w` wikc wlc iwl `e wlc Ysr—ie% De wldx hixc" wlc qdwecxx xl`sbg oc `ffcrcg
ie `iwl wikce `e wlc ‒sehrciwcg gdvdec x}cchl `f Ibbil„ w` wcbb wlc wrswl" `r ie `iwl
‒ot Ibbil ql` dx ibb.ke`qdea ieg ibb.xccdea„ w` wcbb wlc wrswl% Wlc q`rgdea q`sbg
livc w` oc vcrt }rchdxc% Wlc h`srw xl`sbg oc iqirc `f ieg xcexdwdvc w` wlc eccgx `f wlc
qdwecxx% H`srw xwiff xl`sbg ixk i qdwecxx `r jsr`r ocf`rc h`ndea dew` h`srw df lc `r
xlc qdbb wikc wlc xwiegirg `iwl% Df wlc qdwecxx qdxlcx w` iffdrn `r wikc wlc `iwl de
ie`wlcr f`rn" wlc h`srw xwiff xl`sbg h`nnsedhiwc wliw }rcfcrcehc w` wlc jsgac% Df wlc
qdwecxx qdxlcx" f`r c|in}bc" w` xqcir `e wlc Ysr—ie" wlc jsgac xl`sbg oc igvdxcg
ocf`rc wlc qdwecxx dx or`salw w` h`srw ieg wlc l`bt o``k nigc ividbiobc ,qdwecxxcx
nit e`w oc iqirc wliw wlcdr `qe l`bt o``k dx ividbiobc de h`srw" ieg nit }rcfcr e`w w`
griq iwwcewd`e w` wlcnxcbvcx `r w` hisxc deh`evcedcehc ot ixkdea f`r dw$%
7%4 Df wlc Ysr—ie dx w` oc sxcg" dw nsxw oc or`salw w` h`srw qri}}cg de i hb`wl" ieg
}bihcg de ie cbcviwcg }`xdwd`e de wlc h`srw ‘ f`r c|in}bc" `e i r`xwrsn `e wlc jsgac—x
ocehl% Hirc xl`sbg oc wikce e`w w` }bihc dw `e i }biwf`rn `e qldhl }c`}bc qibk `r xdw%
Wlc Ysr—ie xl`sbg e`w oc hirrdcg ocb`q wlc qidxw% Qlce wlc qdwecxx dx rcigt w` wikc
wlc `iwl" wlc Ysr—ie ,xwdbb qri}}cg de hb`wl$ dx wikce fr`n dwx xwieg ieg }bihcg de fr`ew
`f wlc qdwecxx% Wlc hb`wl dx wlce hircfsbbt `}cecg ieg }sbbcg oihk ibwl`sal wlc
qdwecxx nit }rcfcr w` wikc wlc `iwl qdwl`sw seqri}}dea wlc Ysr—ie" ieg wldx xl`sbg
oc ibb`qcg" df rcyscxwcg% Wlc qdwecxx xl`sbg cdwlcr l`bg wlc Ysr—ie de wlcdr rdalw lieg
`r }bihc wlcdr rdalw lieg `e wlc Ysr—ie" de qldhl hixc wlc bcfw lieg q`sbg livc w` oc
ridxcg w` wikc wlc `iwl%9
Fsrwlcr asdgiehc advce w` nihcrx ieg oir `ffdhcrx h`ehcredea
wlc liegbdea ieg xw`riac `f l`bt o``kx ieg xhrd}wsrcx hie oc f`seg de wlc I}}cegd| w`
wldx Hli}wcr%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 48/206
9Wlc Ysr—ie eccg e`w oc lcbg iw ibb f`r ie @iwl de Dxbindh w` oc vibdg ochisxc wlc Nsxbdn
qdwecxx xqcirx !ot Ibbil! `r ot !wlc sehrciwcg q`rg `f Ibbil!% L`qcvcr" de `rgcr w` xiehwdft
wlc `hhixd`e ieg ix dw dx acecribbt rcairgcg ix hsxw`n de wlc SK" dw dx }crfchwbt vibdg w` g` x`%
F`r n`xw Nsxbdnx" l`bgdea i h`}t `f wlc Ysr—ie dx i }ltxdhib ieg `swqirg gcn`exwriwd`e w`
wl`xc }rcxcew wliw wlc degdvdgsib dewcegx" ot wldx ihwd`e `f l`bgdea wlc Ysr—ie" w` cn}lixdxc
wliw wlcdr `iwl dx xdehcrcbt ocdea wikce ieg dw dx x`bcne%
7%9= Ocxw }rihwdhc dx" f h`srxc" e`w ibqitx }`xxdobc% Ibb h`srw l`sxcx de Xh`wbieg
livc wlc nide L`bt O``kx `f wlc }rdehd}ib rcbdad`sx wrigdwd`ex% Jsgacx wlr`sal hbcrkx
xl`sbg rcyscxw rc}bihcncewx df wlcxc livc occe b`xw `r ndxbidg% Df wlc h`srw g`cx e`w
livc wlc echcxxirt l`bt o``k" wlc qdwecxx xl`sbg oc devdwcg w` iffdrn%9
9 Xcc x% 3,?$ `f wlc @iwlx Ihw 941<" ys`wcg de }iri% 7%?" io`vc%
H`n}bcwc rcfsxib w` wikc wlc `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e
?34
7%99 Qlcrc i }crx`e ‒dx hibbcg ix i qdwecxx ieg cdwlcr ‘ ,d$ rcfsxcx w` wikc wlc `iwl
`r iffdrniwd`e" `r ,dd$ livdea occe xq`re ix i qdwecxx ieg gdrchwcg ot wlc jsgac w` advc
cvdgcehc de h`eechwd`e qdwl wlc xsojchw niwwcr `f wlc xwiwcncew" rcfsxcx w` g` x`„"
xchwd`e ?34 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 }r`vdgcx wliw wlc qdwecxx—x
}rd`r xwiwcncew xlibb oc igndxxdobc ‒ix cvdgcehc `f iet niwwcr h`ewidecg de wlc
xwiwcncew„% Wldx dee`viwdvc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`e xl`sbg oc sxcg x}irdeabt" ocirdea de
ndeg wlc bihk `f `}}`rwsedwt w` hr`xx.c|indec `r `wlcrqdxc wcxw wlc cvdgcehc%9
9 Xcc `oxcrviwd`ex de NihG`eibg v% L%N%Igv`hiwc" 9444 X%H%H%_% 976% Wlc I}}cib H`srw
h`nncewcg `e wlc dee`viwdvc eiwsrc `f x% ?34" ieg cn}lixdzcg wliw" }rd`r w` rcx`rwdea w` i
xwiwcncew de wcrnx `f x% ?34" wlc qdwecxx nsxw fdrxwbt oc gdrchwcg w` iexqcr wlc yscxwd`ex" ieg
xch`egbt" ixkcg qlcwlcr lc `r xlc lig nigc i }rcvd`sx xwiwcncew% Wlce wlc wcrnx `f wlc
xwiwcncew xl`sbg oc }sw w` wlc qdwecxx% ]r`fcxx`r A`rg`e de ldx h`nncewirt iw }% 939"
`oxcrvcx wliw x% ?34 ridxcx h`ehcrex io`sw wlc sewcxwcg eiwsrc `f wlc xwiwcncew ieg ibx` wlc fihw
wliw i xdeabc qdwecxx ndalw oc rcairgcg ix xsffdhdcew w` }r`vc wlc xwiwcncew%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 49/206
GDFFC_CEW WT]CX @F @IWL" IEG QLCWLC_ IFFD_NIWD@E
]_CFC_IOBC
Qdwecxxcx
7%9?
Xwiegirg `iwl . Wlc qdwecxx w` ridxc rdalw lieg ieg rc}ciw ifwcr jsgac . D
xqcir ot Ibndalwt A`g wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl ieg e`wldea
osw wlc wrswl%
Xwiegirg iffdrniwd`e ‘ Wlc qdwecxx eccg e`w ridxc i lieg" osw xdn}bt
rc}ciwx ifwcr wlc jsgac ‘ D x`bcnebt" xdehcrcbt ieg wrsbt gchbirc ieg iffdrnwliw D qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl ieg e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%
Ifrdhie . Nshl gc}cegx `e wlc hsbwsrib wrigdwd`ex `f wlc qdwecxx" osw niet
qdbb iarcc w` wikc wlc `iwl `r w` iffdrn%
Osggldxw . @iwlx irc deh`n}iwdobc qdwl wlc }rihwdhc `f n`xw Osggldxwx" ql`
qdbb rcigdbt iffdrn%
Hldecxc . Sebcxx wlct irc Hlrdxwdie Hldecxc" wlct xl`sbg iffdrn%
Ldegs ,wikce `e wlc Adwi$ . D xqcir ot wlc Adwi wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl" wlc
ql`bc wrswl ieg e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%
Jcq ,wikce `e wlc Lcorcq Odobc9$ . D xqcir ot Ibndalwt A`g wliw D qdbb wcbb
wlc wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl ieg e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%
Nsxbdn / F`bb`qcrx `f Dxbin ,wikce `e wlc Ysr—ie$ . D xqcir ot Ibbil wliw D
qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl ieg e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%
_ixwifirdie . @fwce qdbbdea w` wikc wlc `iwl" osw nit hl``xc w` iffdrn%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 50/206
Xdkl ,wikce `e wlc Igd Ariewl$ . D xqcir ot Asrs Eieik wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc
wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl ieg e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%
Ysikcr `r N`rivdie Qdwecxx ,iffdrniwd`e$ . D" ocdea `ec `f wlc }c`}bc
hibbcg Ysikcrx ,wlc Sedwcg Orcwlrce hibbcg N`rivdiex$" g` x`bcnebt" xdehcrcbt
ieg wrsbt gchbirc ieg iffdrn wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl ieg
e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%
Jcl`vil—x Qdwecxx ‘ D xqcir ot Ibndalwt A`g Jcl`vil wliw D qdbb wcbb wlc
wrswl" wlc ql`bc wrswl ieg e`wldea osw wlc wrswl%
9 d%c% wlc @bg Wcxwincew `ebt%
Dewcr}rcwcrx
7%98
Dewcr}rcwcr—x `iwl ‘ @fwce ocxw igndedxwcrcg ot i yscxwd`e w` wlc dewcr}rcwcr"
cbdhdwdea wlc rcx}`exc ‒D g`„ ‘ G` t`s xqcir fidwlfsbbt w` }crf`rn wlc gswdcx `f
dewcr}rcwcr de wlcxc }r`hccgdeax0
Dewcr}rcwcr—x iffdrniwd`e ‘ G` t`s x`bcnebt" xdehcrcbt ieg wrsbt gchbirc ieg
iffdrn wliw t`s qdbb fidwlfsbbt }crf`rn wlc gswdcx `f dewcr}rcwcr de wlcxc
}r`hccgdeax0
Jsr`rx
7%97
Jsr`r—x `iwl . ixkcg ot hbcrk `f h`srw . G` t`s xqcir ot Ibndalwt A`g wliw
t`s qdbb qcbb ieg wrsbt wrt wlc ihhsxcg ieg advc i wrsc vcrgdhw ihh`rgdea w` wlc
cvdgcehc0 Jsr`rx rc}bt ‒D g`„%9
Jsr`r—x iffdrniwd`e ‘ wlc jsr`r w` rc}ciw ifwcr wlc hbcrk `f wlc h`srw . D
x`bcnebt" xdehcrcbt ieg wrsbt gchbirc ieg iffdrn wliw D qdbb qcbb ieg wrsbt wrt
wlc ihhsxcg ieg advc i wrsc vcrgdhw ihh`rgdea w` wlc cvdgcehc%?
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 51/206
9 Xcc F`rn 97%8.I de wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx 9446; ieg F`rn 86%9=.I de wlc _sbcx `f
wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9447%
? Xcc F`rn 97%8.O de wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx 9446; ieg F`rn 86%9=.O de wlc _sbcx `f
wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9447%
Hsriw`rx ig bdwcn
7%93
Hsriw`r ig bdwcn—x `iwl ‘ @fwce ocxw igndedxwcrcg ot i yscxwd`e w` wlc hsriw`r"
cbdhdwdea wlc rcx}`exc ‒D g`„ ‘ G` t`s xqcir fidwlfsbbt w` }crf`rn wlc gswdcx `f
hsriw`r ig bdwcn de wlcxc }r`hccgdeax0
Hsriw`r ig bdwcn—x iffdrniwd`e ‘ G` t`s x`bcnebt" xdehcrcbt ieg wrsbt gchbircieg iffdrn wliw t`s qdbb fidwlfsbbt }crf`rn wlc gswdcx `f hsriw`r ig bdwcn de
wlcxc }r`hccgdeax0
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 52/206
I]]CEGD\
ASDGIEHC F@_ H@S_W XWIFF @E WLC LIEGBDEA IEG XW@_IAC
@F L@BT O@@KX IEG XH_D]WS_CX
LIEGBDEA
Ibb L`bt o``kxxhrd}wsrcx xl`sbg oc wrciwcg qdwl rcx}chw ieg liegbcg qdwl hirc
iw ibb wdncx%
Wl`xc L`bt o``kxxhrd}wsrcx" qldhl nsxw oc kc}w de h`vcrx" xl`sbg rcnide x`
iw ibb wdncx c|hc}w qlce ocdea rcn`vcg ot i qdwecxx de h`srw ,xcc xw`riac$%
Xwiff xl`sbg oc iqirc f`bb`qcrx `f hcrwide fidwlx ,f`r c|in}bc Xdkldxn" Dxbin
ieg Ldegsdxn$ }bihc i arciw gcib `f dn}`rwiehc `e ltadcec ieg hbciebdecxx
qlce liegbdea L`bt o``kxxhrd}wsrcx% Dw dx h`nn`e }rihwdhc `f xshl f`bb`qcrx
w` qixl wlcdr liegx }rd`r w` liegbdea L`bt o``kxxhrd}wsrcx% Dw dx l`}cg wliw
qlcrc i qdwecxx rcyscxwx w` qixl wlcdr liegx" wldx hie oc g`ec ocf`rc wlc
qdwecxx h`ncx dew` wlc h`srwr``n%
Xsegir Aswki ‘ Xdkl
Liegx nsxw oc qixlcg ocf`rc liegbdea:
Iet }crx`e liegbdea wldx xl`sbg h`vcr wlcdr lcig qdwl wlc rinibx }r`vdgcg;
E`w oc segcr wlc defbscehc `f grdek `r grsax;
Wlc }crx`e wikdea wlc `iwl nsxw ibx` h`vcr wlcdr lcig qdwl i rinib ieg xl`sbg e`w
livc iet w`oihh` `r ibh`l`b de ldxlcr }`xxcxxd`e iw wliw wdnc%
Oliaivig Adwi ‘ Ldegs
E`wldea xl`sbg oc qrdwwce `e `r de dw: E`wldea }bihcg dexdgc dw;
E`wldea }sw `e w`} `f dw%
Ys—rie ‘ Nsxbdn
Xl`sbg ecvcr oc hirrdcg ocb`q wlc qidxw;
Lcbg ot wlc bcfw lieg;
Nsxw oc seqri}}cg ot i f`bb`qcr `f wlc fidwl%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 53/206
XW@_IAC
F`r wlc Ldegs" Nsxbdn ieg Xdkl rcbdad`ex" arciw dn}`rwiehc dx }bihcg `e wlc xw`riac
`f L`bto``kx xhrd}wsrcx% Wlc Adwi" Aswki ieg wlc Ys!rie xl`sbg wlcrcf`rc oc kc}w de
i h`vcr iw ibb wdncx%
Ibb rcbdad`sx o``kxxhrd}wsrcx xl`sbg" qlcrc }`xxdobc oc xw`rcg io`vc xl`sbgcr lcdalw"
`e i xlcbf `r de i hs}o`irg" osw iw ibb wdncx wlct nsxw oc io`vc ar`seg bcvcb ieg ecvcr
bcfw `e wlc fb``r%
Ibb L`bt o``kxxhrd}wsrcx de h`vcrx xl`sbg rcnide de wlcn iw ibb wdncx% L`qcvcr"
}rd`r w` wikdea wlcn dew` h`srw dw dx igvdxiobc w` hlchk wliw wlc h`rrchw L`bt
o``kxhrd}wsrc dx h`ewidecg qdwlde wlc h`vcr%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 54/206
Hli}wcr 3
DEWC_]_CWDEA XC_VDHCX
Dewr`gshwd`e
3%9 Ie dewcr}rcwcr nit oc rcysdrcg f`r dewcr}rcwdea de i f`rcdae bieasiac `r f`r
dewcr}rcwdea f`r }c`}bc qdwl bieasiac gdffdhsbwdcx% Wlcrc nit oc i eccg" f`r c|in}bc"
f`r xdae bieasiac" i bd}.x}cikcr9
`r }ibiewt}dxw?
f`r }c`}bc ql` irc gcif%8
Wlc q`rg
‒dewcr}rcwiwd`e„ dx wlc i}}r`}rdiwc wcrn f`r dewcr}rcwdea `rib cvdgcehc ieg ‒wriexbiwd`e„
dx wlc i}}r`}rdiwc wcrn f`r wriexbiwdea wlc qrdwwce q`rg% Ihh`rgdea w` wlc O`e`nt
_c}`rw7:
‒Wlcrc dx ie dehrcixdea eccg f`r wlc xcrvdhcx `f dewcr}rcwcrx% Xdehc I}rdb ?==?
rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r wlc }r`vdxd`e `f dewcr}rcwcrx" qlcrc `ec dx rcysdrcg f`r wlc ihhsxcg
de h`srw" lix bide qdwl wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc% I }r`w`h`b cewcrcg dew` ot wlc
Xcrvdhc qdwl wlc }`bdhc ieg wlc Hr`qe x}chdfdcx l`q wlc eccg f`r dewcr}rcwiwd`e
xl`sbg oc dewdniwcg w` wlc H`srw% Dewcr}rcwcrx irc ceaiacg wlr sal rch`aedxcg
dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx% Wlc dewcr}rcwcrx }r`vdgcg nsxw ibb oc ysibdfdcg ot l`bgdea wlc
Gd}b`ni de ]sobdh Xcrvdhc Dewcr}rcwdea ,G]XD$% Df dw dx e`w }`xxdobc w` dexwrshw ie
dewcr}rcwcr ql` lix wlc G]XD" wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc qdbb oc ixkcg w` rch`nnceg
`ec ql` dx xsdwiobc f`r wlc ixxdaencew h`ehcrecg" ieg w` }r`vdgc i qrdwwce ixxcxxncew
`f wliw dewcr}rcwcr de igviehc `f wlc h`srw lcirdea% Xdae bieasiac dewcr}rcwcrx rcysdrc
w` oc rcadxwcrcg qdwl wlc Xh`wwdxl Ixx`hdiwd`e `f Xdae Bieasiac Dewcr}rcwcrx ,XIXBD$%
Dw dx wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc Hr`qe w` irrieac f`r ie dewcr}rcwcr" qlcrc `ec dx
rcysdrcg w` wikc wlc cvdgcehc `f i Hr`qe qdwecxx% Dw dx wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc
gcfcehc w` ceaiac wlc dewcr}rcwcr" qlcrc echcxxirt f`r h`exsbwiwd`e qdwl wlc ihhsxcg
`r f`r wlc }rcxcewiwd`e `f wlc cvdgcehc `f i gcfcehc qdwecxx%„
9I bd}.x}cikcr dx i }crx`e ql` lix occe }r`fcxxd`eibbt wridecg w` sxc cixt.w`.rcig bd} }iwwcrex%
Bd}.x}cikcrx xdbcewbt rc}ciw wlc x}cikcr—x ncxxiac sxdea hbcir bd} xli}cx" wlc fb`q `f eiwsrib
x}cchl" fihdib c|}rcxxd`e ieg acxwsrc w` idg wlc bd}.rcigcr—x segcrxwiegdea% Bd}.x}cikcrx irc
wridecg w` advc i}}r`}rdiwc fdeacr.x}cbbdea xs}}`rw df rcyscxwcg w` g` x` ot wlc bd}.rcigcr%
? I }ibiewt}dxw sxcx i xnibb }l`ecwdh kcto`irg w` }r`gshc ie dexwiewiec`sx }l`ecwdh wc|w `f
qliw dx ocdea xidg% I h`n}swcr nit oc sxcg w` h`evcrw wlc }l`ecwdh de}sw dew` q`rgx qldhl
irc gdx}bitcg `e cdwlcr i WV xhrcce `r }r`jchwcg `ew` i biracr xhrcce%
8 @ebt <# `f }c`}bc ql` irc gcif sxc xdae bieasiac
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 55/206
7 !DN]_@VDEA ]_IHWDHC! . Wlc _cvdcq `f wlc ]rihwdhcx ieg ]r`hcgsrc `f wlc Ldal H`srw
`f Jsxwdhdirt ot wlc L`e`sriobc B`rg O`e`nt ?==? iw }iriari}l 96%?=
Eccg f`r jsgacx w` oc iqirc `f bdeasdxwdh gdffdhsbwdcx
3%? Ibwl`sal jsgacx irc e`w dev`bvcg de nikdea irrieacncewx f`r dewcr}rcwcrx" dw dx
dn}`rwiew wliw wlct irc fsbbt iqirc `f }`wcewdib gdffdhsbwdcx c|}crdcehcg ot qdwecxxcx
ql` nit livc `ebt i bdndwcg iodbdwt w` x}cik ieg segcrxwieg Ceabdxl% Qlce advdea
cvdgcehc" wlct nit e`w ibqitx fsbbt segcrxwieg qliw wlct irc ocdea ixkcg% Dw dx `ec
wldea w` ke`q wlc oixdhx `f i bieasiac ieg w` oc iobc w` h`nnsedhiwc qlce xl`}}dea
`r q`rkdea% Dw dx ysdwc ie`wlcr niwwcr livdea w` i}}cir de h`srw" segcrxwieg yscxwd`ex"
ieg advc cvdgcehc% Dw xl`sbg ibx` oc rcncnocrcg wliw niet cwledh nde rdwdcx }rcfcr
w` x}cik wlcdr n`wlcr w`easc iw l`nc% Jsgacx xl`sbg wlcrcf`rc oc ibcrw w` gdffcrcew
bieasiac eccgx" ieg xl`sbg e`w ixxsnc" xdn}bt ochisxc i qdwecxx lix bdvcg de
Xh`wbieg f`r niet tcirx" wliw lc `r xlc g`cx e`w rcysdrc ie dewcr}rcwcr%
3%8 Xdwsiwd`ex nit irdxc qlcrc wlc jsgac lix w` wikc i }r`ihwdvc r`bc" ieg nikc
x`nc cff`rw w` hbirdft ieg rcx`bvc wlc c|wcew `f iet bieasiac gdffdhsbwt fihcg ot i
qdwecxx% Dw dx }irw `f wlc jsgac—x fsehwd`e w` ixxcxx ie degdvdgsib—x fbsceht ieg
h`n}rclcexd`e% Df i jsgac lcirdea i hixc h`exdgcrx wliw ie dewcr}rcwcr dx rcysdrcg" ie
igj`srencew xl`sbg oc ariewcg f`r wliw }sr}`xc% Xshl ie igj`srencew qdbb e`w
echcxxirdbt rcxsbw de wlc b`xx `f wlc lcirdea `r wrdib gdcw" ix iacewx ieg }r`xchsw`rx livc
ihhcxx w` bdxwx `f i}}r`vcg dewcr}rcwcrx" ieg dw nit oc }`xxdobc w` nikc irrieacncewx
iw fidrbt xl`rw e`wdhc" sebcxx wlc bieasiac dx ie sesxsib `ec `r wlc h`srw dx de i rcn`wc
b`hiwd`e%
3%7 De acecrib" dw dx sxcfsb f`r i }irwt w` advc wlc hbcrk `f h`srw igviehc e`wdhcwliw ie dewcr}rcwcr qdbb oc dev bvcg% Wlc jsgac lix w` igndedxwcr wlc dewcr}rcwcr—x
`iwl%9
I jsgac nit ibx` qdxl w` livc wlc hbcrk `f h`srw hlchk qlcwlcr wlc dewcr}rcwcr
ieg wlc ihhsxcg `r qdwecxx irc degccg iobc w` h`nnsedhiwc" ieg w` h`efdrn wliw wlcrc
irc e` hsbwsrib gdibchw `r bieasiac gdffdhsbwdcx wliw q`sbg }rchbsgc wlc dewcr}rcwcr
fr`n dewcr}rcwdea%
9 Xcc }iri% 7%98 de Hli}wcr 7 ,@iwlx ieg `iwl wikdea$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 56/206
Hrdndeib hixcx
3%3 Hr`qe qdwecxxcx: De hrdndeib hixcx" wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc ieg wlc }r`hsriw`r
fdxhib xcrvdhc livc rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r dexwrshwdea dewcr}rcwcrx f`r Hr`qe qdwecxxcx% Dw dx
sxsibbt wlc }`bdhc ql` igvdxc wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib wliw i qdwecxx lix gdffcrcew
bieasiac eccgx" osw i }r`hsriw`r fdxhib `r ie igv`hiwc gc}swc nit ibx` dgcewdft i
eccg%
3%6 Ie ihhsxcg }crx`e: Dw dx wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc w`
nikc irrieacncewx f`r ie dewcr}rcwcr f`r ie ihhsxcg }crx`e%9
9 Xdehc 9 I}rdb ?==?" wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc" Xisalw`e L`sxc" Or``nl`sxc Grdvc
Cgdeosral" CL99 8\G" lix lig `vcribb rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r wlc }r`vdxd`e `f h`nnsedwt" f`rcdae
ieg xdae bieasiac dewcr}rcwcrx f`r ihhsxcg }crx`ex" o`wl }rc. ieg }`xw.h`evdhwd`e% Degdvdgsib
XHX hbcrkx iw b`hib h srwx gcib qdwl wlc git w` git irrieacncewx% Wldx f`bb`qcg rch`aedwd`e
wliw wlc dev`bvcncew `f wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc `r }r`xchsw`r de dexwrshwdea ie dewcr}rcwcr f`r ie
ihhsxcg ndalw oc i orcihl `f Irwdhbc 6 `f wlc Csr`}cie H`evcewd`e `e Lsnie _dalwx% I
h`}t `f wlc ‒Irrieacncewx f`r Dexwrshwd`e `f Dewcr}rcwcrx f`r Ihhsxcg„" dxxscg ot wlc
@}criwd`ex ieg ]`bdht Sedw ieg giwcg 9< Nirhl ?==?" hie oc f`seg de I}}cegd| I w` wldx
hli}wcr%
3%1 ]r`w`h`b ieg h`gc `f h`egshw: I }r`w`h`b f`r wlc dexwrshwd`e `f dewcr}rcwcrx
f`r hrdndeib h`srw gdcwx lix occe iarccg ocwqcce wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc ieg wlc Xh`wwdxl
H`srw Xcrvdhc%9
I h`gc `f h`egshw f`r dewcr}rcwcrx lix ibx` occe griqe s} ieg o`wl
g`hsncewx hie oc ihhcxxcg lcrc:
lww}:qqq%h`}fx%a`v%skxdwcxgcfisbwfdbcx]sobdhiwd`ex_cx`srhcG`h984?<====7
61%}gf ?
Wlc }irwt irrieadea f`r dewcr}rcwiwd`e xl`sbg cexsrc wliw wlc dewcr}rcwcr dx
xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg wliw wlc dewcr}rcwcr xdaex wlc h`gc `f h`egshw% Dw dx e`w
i}}r`}rdiwc w` sxc wlc xinc dewcr}rcwcr f`r `}}`xdea }irwdcx de hrdndeib h`srw hixcx%
F`r xdae bieasiac dewcr}rcwdea" wq` dewcr}rcwcrx nit oc rcysdrcg qlcrc }r`hccgdeax
irc bceawlt% Wldx qdbb ibb`q wlc dewcr}rcwcrx w` ibwcreiwc iw dewcrvibx `r ,xit$ ?=
ndeswcx% Wlc dewcr}rcwcr e`w xdaedea qdbb xwdbb f`bb`q wlc }r`hccgdeax%
9 I h`}t `f wlc ]r`w`h`b hie oc f`seg de I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr%
? Xcc I}}cegd| H w` wldx hli}wcr%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 57/206
Hdvdb hixcx
3%< De hdvdb hixcx" dw dx f`r wlc x`bdhdw`rx dev`bvcg de wlc bdwdaiwd`e w` nikc wlc
echcxxirt dewcr}rcwdea irrieacncewx" ibwl`sal dw dx igvdxiobc wliw wlc hbcrk `f h`srw oc
qirecg de igviehc `f wlc }r``f `r lcirdea% Serc}rcxcewcg }irwdcx ql` livc gdffcrcew
bieasiac eccgx irc bdkcbt w` h`nc w` wlc iwwcewd`e `f wlc hbcrk ql` xl`sbg ibcrw wlc
jsgac%
Dewcr}rcwcrx— ysibdfdhiwd`ex; h`gc `f h`egshw
3%4 Wlc xwiegirg `f dewcr}rcwcrx }r`vdgcg f`r h`srw q`rk lix xwcigdbt dn}r`vcg"
ieg ysibdfdhiwd`ex de dewcr}rcwdea irc e`q rcysdrcg% Ihh`rgdea w` wlc H`gc `f ]rihwdhc"
wlc dewcr}rcwcr xl`sbg:
l`bg i vibdg hcrwdfdhiwc fr`n Gdxhb`xsrc Xh`wbieg iw Xwiegirg bcvcb" `r" f`r
h`n}bc| `r xcexdwdvc hixcx" iw Celiehcg bcvcb% Wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib qdbb
igvdxc qlce Celiehcg Bcvcb Gdxhb`xsrc dx }rcfcrrcg% Xcexdwdvc hixcx nit
dehbsgc xc|sib `ffcehcx" `r hixcx dev`bvdea i hldbg qdwecxx `r xsx}chw;
ieg
l`bg wlc Gd}b`ni de ]sobdh Xcrvdhc Dewcr}rcwdea ,Xh`wwdxl Bcaib @}wd`e$ `r ie
cysdvibcew ysibdfdhiwd`e `f i xdndbir xwiegirg . f`r c|in}bc" i ysibdfdhiwd`e
ihhrcgdwcg ot wlc Hlirwcrcg Dexwdwswc `f Bdeasdxwx
`r
l`bg i rcbcview xdae bieasiac ysibdfdhiwd`e ieg dx rcadxwcrcg qdwl wlc Xh`wwdxl
Ixx`hdiwd`e f Xdae Bieasiac Dewcr}rcwcrx r cysdvibcew%
Ifwcr igndedxwcrdea wlc dewcr}rcwcr—x `iwl" dw nit oc lcb}fsb w` advc wlc dewcr}rcwcr
x`nc asdgiehc ix w` ldx `r lcr r`bc" ieg qliw lc `r xlc xl`sbg g` df iet gdffdhsbwt de
wlc qdwecxx—x h`n}rclcexd`e irdxcx% F`r c|in}bc" i jsgac ndalw cn}lixdxc wliw ‒dw dx
dn}`rwiew wliw qliw wlc qdwecxx xitx dx dewcr}rcwcg c|ihwbt" q`rg f`r q`rg" ieg dx e`w
ioorcvdiwcg `r }iri}lrixcg de iet qit% Df wlcrc dx gdffdhsbwt de advdea ie c|ihw
dewcr}rcwiwd`e `f cdwlcr wlc yscxwd`e `r wlc iexqcr" jsxw bcw nc ke`q%„ Wlc dewcr}rcwcr
xl`sbg ibx` wcbb wlc qdwecxx" }rd`r w` wlc yscxwd`ex ocdea }sw" w` iexqcr de xl`rw
}ixxiacx" w` ceiobc wlc dewcr}rcwcr w` dewcr}rcw f`r wlc h`srw% Wlc }r`hccgdeax xl`sbg
oc xb`qcg g`qe w` cexsrc wliw wlc dewcr}rcwcr hiwhlcx qliw dx ocdea xidg% Wlc h`gc `f
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 58/206
h`egshw }r`vdgcg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc qdbb ixxdxw dewcr}rcwcrx de wlc
}crf`rniehc `f wlcdr gswdcx%
? Xcc I}}cegd| H w` wldx hli}wcr%
Acegcr `f dewcr}rcwcr
3%9= De hcrwide xdwsiwd`ex wlc acegcr `f wlc dewcr}rcwcr nit oc dn}`rwiew% F`r
c|in}bc" i fcnibc qdwecxx livdea w` gcxhrdoc i xc|sib ixxisbw ndalw oc cnoirrixxcg
w` livc i nibc dewcr}rcwcr% Wlc iswl rdwt `r }irwt irrieadea dewcr}rcwiwd`e xl`sbg
h`exdgcr xshl xdwsiwd`ex ocf`rc dexwrshwdea wlc dewcr}rcwcr%
Eccg f`r igj`srencewx
3%99 Dw xl`sbg oc rcncnocrcg wliw wlc wixk `f ie dewcr}rcwcr hie oc i gcniegdea
`ec% Ie `hhixd`eib c|wri igj`srencew nit oc echcxxirt f`r wlc dewcr}rcwcr df wlcrc dx
i bceawlt c|indeiwd`e `f i qdwecxx%
Eccg f`r jsgdhdib xs}crvdxd`e iw ibb wdncx
3%9? Ibwl`sal i jsgac nit e`w oc findbdir qdwl wlc bieasiac `f wlc ihhsxcg `r wlc
qdwecxx" lc `r xlc xl`sbg oc ibcrw iw ibb wdncx w` }`wcewdib gdffdhsbwdcx de dewcr}rcwiwd`e%
F`r c|in}bc" df i qdwecxx advcx i bceawlt rcx}`exc w` i yscxwd`e" osw wlc dewcr}rcwcr
advcx i vcrt ordcf dewcr}rcwiwd`e" wliw ordcf dewcr}rcwiwd`e nit degdhiwc ie
dec|}crdcehcg dewcr}rcwcr ql` dx }iri}lrixdea riwlcr wlie dewcr}rcwdea% Dw dx vcrt
dn}`rwiew wliw wlc qdwecxx lix ldx `r lcr iexqcrx dewcr}rcwcg riwlcr wlie wlc
dewcr}rcwcr—x vdcq io`sw qliw wlc qdwecxx dx wrtdea w` xit%9
Ihh`rgdeabt wlc jsgac
xl`sbg h`ewdesibbt n`edw`r ieg ixxcxx wlc cvdgcehc%
9Wlc H`gc `f H`egshw f`r Dewcr}rcwcrx ieg Wriexbiw`rx bitx xwrcxx `e h`evctdea wlc c|ihw
nciedea `f qliw lix occe xidg qdwl`sw iggdea" `ndwwdea `r hlieadea ietwldea: xcc I}}cegd|
H w` wldx hli}wcr%
3%98 X`}ldxwdhiwcg cysd}ncew qdwl xdnsbwiec`sx dewcr}rcwiwd`e
Qldbc ndhr`}l`ecx" lcig}l`ecx" ieg xdnsbwiec`sx dewcr}rcwiwd`e }r`oiobt }r`vdgc
wlc ocxw qit `f dewcr}rcwdea qdwl`sw gcbitdea wlc }r`arcxx `f i hixc" xshl fihdbdwdcx irc
c|}cexdvc ieg wlcrcf`rc rcbiwdvcbt seh`nn`e%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 59/206
3%97 Bieasiac Bdec
Bieasiac Bdec lix occe dexwibbcg de wlc Xs}rcnc H`srwx `ffdhcx" xlcrdff hbcrkx— ieg
}r`hsriw`r fdxhibx— `ffdhcx% Df x`nc`ec i}}r`ihlcx i ncnocr `f h`srw xwiff ieg
i}}cirx seiobc w` x}cik Ceabdxl" wcbc}l`ec h`ewihw hie oc nigc qdwl ie dewcr}rcwcr de
iet `ec `f 97= bieasiacx% Wlc hbcrk `r }r`hsriw`r fdxhib wcbc}l`ecx wlc bdek ieg" ot
sxc f h`efcrcehc }l`ec fihdbdwdcx" wlrcc.qit h`nnsedhiwd`e hie oc cxwiobdxlcg%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 60/206
I]]CEGD\ I
Irrieacncewx f`r Dexwrshwd`e `f Dewcr}rcwcrx f`r Ihhsxcg" dxxscg ot wlc @}criwd`ex ieg
]`bdht Sedw `f wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc" 9< Nirhl ?==?%
Qdwl cffchw fr`n 9 I}rdb ?==?" qlce dw dx echcxxirt w` dexwrshw ie dewcr}rcwcr f`r iet h`srw
i}}ciriehc `f ie ihhsxcg }crx`e" rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r dexwrshwdea wliw dewcr}rcwcr qdbb bdc qdwl wlc
Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc ,XHX$% Asdgiehc `e wlc `}criwd`e `f wldx ecq }`bdht dx }r`vdgcg
ocb`q% Wlc asdgiehc h`vcrx wlc dexwrshwd`e `f h`nnsedwt" f`rcdae bieasiac ieg xdae
bieasiac dewcr}rcwcrx%
9% Oihkar`seg
]rd`r w` 9 I}rdb ?==? wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Xcrvdhc ,H@]FX$ lig rcx}`exdodbdwt
f`r dexwrshwdea dewcr}rcwcrx f`r ihhsxcg" fr`n wlcdr fdrxw i}}ciriehc de h`srw s} sewdb wlcdr
h`evdhwd`e% Wlc XHX lig rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r dexwrshwdea dewcr}rcwcrx f`r ibb h`srw i}}ciriehcx
f`bb`qdea h`evdhwd`e% Dw dx e`q h`exdgcrcg wliw wlc dev`bvcncew `f wlc }r`xchsw`r de dexwrshwdea
ie dewcr}rcwcr f`r wlc ihhsxcg nit oc de orcihl `f Irwdhbc 6 `f wlc CHL_" ieg dw lix"
wlcrcf`rc" occe iarccg wliw wlc XHX qdbb ixxsnc rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r wlc }r`vdxd`e `f dewcr}rcwcrx
f`r ibb h`srw i}}ciriehcx `f ihhsxcg }crx`ex% Wldx qdbb i}}bt w` ibb hixcx hibbdea de h`srw `e
`r ifwcr 9 I}rdb ?==?% Wlc H@]FX qdbb rcwide rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r dexwrshwdea dewcr}rcwcrx f`r
hr`qe qdwecxxcx%
Wlc XHX lix iarccg w` ig`}w wlc }`bdht dewr`gshcg bixw tcir ot wlc H@]FX qldhl dexdxwx `e
ndednsn bcvcbx `f ysibdfdhiwd`e ieg c|}crdcehc de dewcr}rcwcrx" de `rgcr w` iv`dg hlibbceacx `e
wlc oixdx `f deigcysiwc }r`vdxd`e `f dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx%
Dw lix occe rch`aedxcg wliw wlcrc dx bdndwcg wdnc ividbiobc ocwqcce irrcxw ieg wlc fdrxw
i}}ciriehc `f ie ihhsxcg de hsxw`gt" ieg dw lix occe iarccg" wlcrcf`rc" wliw qlce ieihhsxcg }crx`e dx i}}cirdea f`r wlc fdrxw wdnc fr`n hsxw`gt" wlc }`bdhc qdbb" x` fir ix }`xxdobc"
irrieac" `e oclibf `f wlc XHX" f`r i xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg c|}crdcehcg dewcr}rcwcr w` i}}cir
iw h`srw w` ixxdxw wlc ihhsxcg% Wlc fcc `f wlc dewcr}rcwcr de xshl hixcx qdbb oc }idg ot wlc
XHX%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 61/206
?% Dgcewdftdea wlc eccg f`r ie Dewcr}rcwcr
_cx}`exdodbdwt f`r dgcewdftdea qlcwlcr dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx irc rcysdrcg f`r ie ihhsxcg bdcx
qdwl wlc }`bdhc% Wlct qdbb igvdxc wlc ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib qlcrc xshl i eccg dx dgcewdfdcg% Wlc
]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib qdbb de wsre igvdxc wlc Hbcrk `f H`srw `f wlc eccg w` ceaiac ie dewcr}rcwcr ot
i }r` f`rni bcwwcr qldhl qdbb dgcewdft:
Einc `f ihhsxcg"
Wt}c `f h`srw gdcw" c%a% }bcigdeadewcrncgdiwcfdrxw gdcw"
Giwc `f gdcw"
Wt}c `f dewcr}rcwcr rcysdrcg" d%c% xdae bieasiac" `r bieasiac ieg gdibchw rcysdrcg"
Qlcwlcr wlcrc irc iet x}chdib hdrhsnxwiehcx" xshl ix wlc ividbiodbdwt `f ie iggdwd`eib
wchledhib ab`xxirt `f wcrnx" `r wlc eccg f`r i ordcfdea fr`n wlc }r`xchsw`r" `r wlc eccg w`
dex}chw hcrwide }r`gshwd`ex%
@ehc wlc eccg f`r ie dewcr}rcwcr lix occe dgcewdfdcg" t`s xl`sbg h`n}bt qdwl wlc f`bb`qdea
asdgiehc%
8% Dexwrshwdea ie Dewcr}rcwcr
T`s xl`sbg ibqitx dexwrshw dewcr}rcwcrx wlr`sal i rch`aedxcg dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc" w` cexsrc
wliw degdvdgsibx ql` rcysdrc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx irc }r`vdgcg qdwl i xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg
c|}crdcehcg dewcr}rcwcr% Dw dx wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc w` }r`vdgc ie
dewcr}rcwcr ql` lix occe ixxcxxcg ot wlcn ix xsdwiobc f`r wlc ixxdaencew" de ihh`rgiehc
qdwl wlc ndednsn rcysdrcncewx x}chdfdcg ot wlc XHX%
I bdxw `f wlc nide rcbcview dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx dx }r`vdgcg [ ^% Wlcxc irc" de wlc nide" b`hib
iswl`rdwt xcrvdhcx ibwl`sal i esnocr `f }rdviwc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx qldhl livc }r`vdgcg
h`exdgcriobc ixxdxwiehc w` wlc H@]FX de wlc }ixw irc ibx` bdxwcg%
7% Bcwwcr `f Dexwrshwd`e
T`s xl`sbg dexwrshw dewcr}rcwcrx sxdea wlc xwtbc bcwwcrx `f dexwrshwd`e }r`vdgcg [xcc I}}cegd|
G^% Xc}iriwc bcwwcrx irc }r`vdgcg f`r wlc dexwrshwd`e `f ,i$ xdae bieasiac" ieg ,o$ f`rcdae
bieasiac dewcr}rcwcrx%
T`s xl`sbg gdrchw wlc bcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e w` wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc ql` qdbb oc rcx}`exdobc f`r
dgcewdftdea ie i}}r`}rdiwc dewcr}rcwcr% Wlc bcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e qdbb wlce oc }ixxcg ot wlc
dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc w` wlc degdvdgsib dewcr}rcwcr dgcewdfdcg%
T`s xl`sbg cexsrc wliw dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx irc ibqitx dexwrshwcg de qrdwdea ieg wliw qrdwwce
rch`rgx irc kc}w `f gdxhsxxd`ex qdwl dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 62/206
Dw dx rch`aedxcg wliw dewcr}rcwcrx nit oc rcysdrcg iw xl`rw e`wdhc ieg wliw wlc dedwdib h`ewihw
qdwl ie dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc nit oc ot wcbc}l`ec% Cvce qlcrc wldx dx wlc hixc" wlc bcwwcr `f
dexwrshwd`e ieg cehb`xsrcx rcfcrrcg w` ocb`q xl`sbg oc sxcg" ieg xl`sbg oc }ixxcg ysdhkbt w`
wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc" w` cexsrc wliw wlc ndednsn rcysdrcncewx irc ke`qe ieg h`n}bdcg
qdwl%
Wlc bcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e rcfcrx w` i esnocr `f }i}crx qldhl xl`sbg ihh`n}iet dw" dehbsgdea:
H`gc `f H`egshw . wlc bcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e rcysdrcx wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc w` cexsrc wliw
wlc dgcewdfdcg dewcr}rcwcr xdaex wlc h`gc `f h`egshw ieg rcwsrex wlc `rdadeib w` wlc h`srw"
qdwl i h`}t ocdea rcwidecg ot wlc xcrvdhc" ieg ot wlc dewcr}rcwcr%
I h`}t `f wlc h`n}bidew `r hliracx `e wlc degdhwncew%
I h`}t `f wlc ordcfdea e`wc f`r dewcr}rcwcrx ieg xsnnirt `f h`nn`ebt sxcg wcrnx
C|}cexcx hbidn f`rn . xcc }iri% 4 ocb`q rcairgdea }itncew%
Wlc bcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e rcyscxwx wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc w` bdxw de qrdwdea wlc rch`nncegcg
dewcr}rcwcr!x ysibdfdhiwd`ex ieg c|}crdcehc ieg wlc oixdx `f wlc ixxcxxncew wliw wlc dewcr}rcwcr
dx xsdwiobc f`r wlc ixxdaencew% Wldx xl`sbg oc rcwidecg qdwl wlc h`srw }i}crx ix i rch`rg `f wlc
ixxcxxncew%
3% Ysibdfdhiwd`ex ieg C|}crdcehc `f Dewcr}rcwcrx
Qlce dexwrshwdea xdae bieasiac dewcr}rcwcrx t`s xl`sbg cexsrc wliw wlc dewcr}rcwcr dx i
ysibdfdcg xdae bieasiac dewcr}rcwcr ,ix `}}`xcg w` i wridecc$ ql` dx rcadxwcrcg qdwl wlcXh`wwdxl Ixx`hdiwd`e `f Xdae Bieasiac Dewcr}rcwcrx% Wlc i}}r`}rdiwc xwtbc bcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e
nikcx wldx rcysdrcncew hbcir%
Qlce i h`nnsedwt `r f`rcdae bieasiac dewcr}rcwcr dx rcysdrcg" t`s xl`sbg" de wlc fdrxw
dexwiehc" ixk wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc w` }r`vdgc ie dewcr}rcwcr ql` lix wlc Gd}b`ni de ]sobdh
Xcrvdhc Dewcr}rcwdea ,Xh`wwdxl bcaib `}wd`e$ `r dwx cysdvibcew ieg ql` lix rchcew c|}crdcehc `f
h`exchswdvc ieg xdnsbwiec`sx dewcr}rcwdea de wlc hrdndeib h`srw h`ewc|w%9
Wlcrc dx i xl`rwiac `f ysibdfdcg dewcr}rcwcrx de x`nc bieasiacx" ieg `e `hhixd`e wlc
dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc i}}r`ihlcg nit oc seiobc w` }r`vdgc ie dewcr}rcwcr ql` lix wlc Gd}b`ni
ieg rchcew c|}crdcehc `f dewcr}rcwdea de h`srw% Wlc Xh`wwdxl Wriexbiwd`e" Dewcr}rcwdea ieg
H`nnsedhiwd`e F`rsn lix advce ie ixxsriehc wliw dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx qdbb xlirc rcbcview
def`rniwd`e de rcbiwd`e w` ividbiobc dewcr}rcwcrx% Wlcrcf`rc" df wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc
i}}r`ihlcg dx seiobc w` }r`vdgc ie dewcr}rcwcr ql` lix wlc ysibdfdhiwd`ex ieg c|}crdcehc
rcysdrcg" wlc nieiacr `f wlc xcrvdhc xl`sbg def`rn t`s `f wldx% T`s xl`sbg wlce devdwc wliw
nieiacr w` bdidxc qdwl `wlcr dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx w` ixhcrwide df i xsdwiobc dewcr}rcwcr dx
ividbiobc cbxcqlcrc ,df wldx }r`hcxx lix e`w ibrcigt wikce }bihc$% Advce wlc ecq ndednsn
rcysdrcncewx dw nit oc wliw dewcr}rcwcrx qdbb livc w` oc or`salw fr`n `wlcr rcad`ex `r fr`n
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 63/206
`wlcr }irwx `f wlc Sedwcg Kdeag`n w` xiwdxft wlc ndednsn rcysdrcncewx ieg w` cexsrc wliw wlc
ihhsxcg lix i xsdwiobc dewcr}rcwcr de h`srw% Df ifwcr nikdea i}}r`}rdiwc cff`rwx wlc dewcr}rcwdea
xcrvdhc hiee`w xs}}bt ie dewcr}rcwcr ql` dx xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg c|}crdcehcg" i h`n}r`ndxc
qdbb livc w` oc rcihlcg% T`s xl`sbg cexsrc wliw wlc xcrvdhc `swbdecx wlc oixdx `f wlcdr
ixxcxxncew `f wlc rch`nncegcg dewcr}rcwcr de qrdwdea ieg wliw wlc def`rniwd`e }r`vdgcg w` wlch`srw dx kc}w qdwl wlc h`srw }i}crx%
Gdffdhsbwdcx de `owidedea xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg c|}crdcehcg dewcr}rcwcrx nit oc }irwdhsbirbt
ihswc de rcx}chw `f fdrxw i}}ciriehcx fr`n hsxw`gt; wlc }`bdhc livc segcrwikce w` nikc
irrieacncewx f`r dewcr}rcwcrx de rcx}chw `f fdrxw hsxw`gt i}}ciriehcx% Dw xl`sbg oc e`wcg"
l`qcvcr" wliw wldx dx ocdea g`ec ix i acxwsrc `f a``gqdbb" ieg wlcrc dx e` bcaib `obdaiwd`e s}`e
wlcn w` g` x`% De vdcq `f wlc gdffdhsbwdcx bdkcbt w` oc ceh`sewcrcg" fbc|dodbdwt qdbb oc rcysdrcg%
9Gcfdedwd`ex
Dewcr}rcwdea . x}`kce `r xdaecg" ix `}}`xcg w` qrdwwce" wriexfcr `f i ncxxiac fr`n
`ec bieasiac w` ie`wlcr%
Xdnsbwiec`sx `r qldx}crdea dewcr}rcwdea . ie dnncgdiwc dewcr}rcwiwd`e dew` wlc `wlcr
bieasiac `f cvcrtwldea ocdea xidg% Wlc dewcr}rcwcr sxsibbt xdwx hb`xc w` wlc e`e.
Ceabdxl x}cikcr% De nsbwd.ihhsxcg hixcx" ndhr`}l`ecx ieg lcig}l`ecx nit oc
echcxxirt%
H`exchswdvc dewcr}rcwdea . wlc dewcr}rcwcr qidwx f`r wlc ncxxiac wlce rc}ciwx dw de wlc
`wlcr bieasiac% Wlc dewcr}rcwcr ndalw wikc e`wcx w` lcb} qdwl gcwidbx c%a% giwcx"
eincx" esnocrx%
Xsnnirdxdea dewcr}rcwdea . f`r c|in}bc" xsnnirdxdea bcaib irasncewx `r }r`hcgsrcx%
Ndalw oc sxcg w` c|}bide bcaib h`ehc}wx}r`hcgsrcx qdwl qldhl wlc }crx`e dx e`w
findbdir%
E@WC: De wlc hrdndeib h`srw `ebt xdnsbwiec`sx `r h`exchswdvc dewcr}rcwdea dx cvcr
bdkcbt w` oc i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc ihhsxcg ieg qdwecxxcx%
6% Ordcfdea `f Dewcr}rcwcrx
T`s xl`sbg cexsrc wliw i}}r`}rdiwc ordcfdea dx advce w` wlc dewcr}rcwcr de igviehc `f wlc h`srw
lcirdea% De n`xw hixcx wldx xl`sbg xdn}bt ncie h`}tdea wlc h`n}bidew" `r wlc hliracx `e wlc
degdhwncew" w` wlc dewcr}rcwcr de igviehc `f h`srw" ieg }r`vdgdea wlc dewcr}rcwcr qdwl i h`}t `f
wlc ab`xxirt `f wcrnx [xcc I}}cegd| C^% Wlcxc xl`sbg oc }r`vdgcg qdwl wlc bcwwcr `f
dexwrshwd`e ieg wlc H`gc `f H`egshw w` oc }ixxcg w` wlc dewcr}rcwcr ot wlc dewcr}rcwdea
xcrvdhc%
De hixcx qlcrc wchledhib `r sesxsib wcrnde`b`at dx bdkcbt w` oc sxcg ,Lcibwl ieg Xifcwt hixcx
irc ie `ovd`sx c|in}bc$ wldx qdbb oc dgcewdfdcg de wlc dedwdib bcwwcr fr`n wlc ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib w`
wlc Hbcrk `f H`srw" ieg nit dev`bvc i fsrwlcr qrdwwce `r vcroib ordcfdea ot wlc ]r`hsriw`r
Fdxhib%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 64/206
Df iet `ojchwd`e dx ridxcg ot wlc gcfcehc w` iet ordcfdea `f wlc dewcr}rcwcr h`exdxwcew qdwl wldx
asdgiehc" wlc ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib qdbb c|}bide w` wlc h`srw wliw wlc dewcr}rcwcr dx ie degc}cegcew
degdvdgsib }r`vdgdea c|}crw ixxdxwiehc w` wlc h`srw% Wlc xdaecg H`gc `f H`egshw nit oc
rcfcrrcg w` ieg xl`sbg" wlcrcf`rc" oc ividbiobc de h`srw% Wlc ordcfdea dx }r`vdgcg w` cexsrc wliwwlc dewcr}rcwcr dx de i }`xdwd`e w` ixxdxw wlc h`srw n`rc cffchwdvcbt" ieg hiee`w oc xidg w` advc
rdxc w` iet }rcjsgdhc w` iet }irwt w` wlc }r`hccgdeax%
1% H`nnsedhiwd`ex ocwqcce X`bdhdw`r ieg Hbdcew
Dewcr}rcwcrx dexwrshwcg w` }r`vdgc xcrvdhcx f`r wlc ihhsxcg irc x`ncwdncx ixkcg ot gcfcehc
x`bdhdw`rx w` fihdbdwiwc h`nnsedhiwd`ex ocwqcce x`bdhdw`r ieg hbdcew iw h`srw% Wlc dewcr}rcwcr dx
segcr e` `obdaiwd`e w` ixxdxw wlc h`nnsedhiwd`ex `f x`bdhdw`r ieg hbdcew" ieg xl`sbg e`w oc
}rcxxsrdxcg w` g` x`% Ie dewcr}rcwcr ceaiacg ot wlc XHX xl`sbg e`w ihhc}w xshl q`rk
qdwl`sw fdrxw `owidedea }crndxxd`e fr`n wlc Hbcrk `f H`srw% Xshl }crndxxd`e xl`sbg e`rnibbt
oc advce qlce wlc dewcr}rcwcr dx h`ewcew w` ixxdxw% Wlc wcrnx `f wlc H`gc `f H`egshw xl`sbg
oc e`wcg%
<% Iwwcegiehc iw H`srw
Qlcrcvcr }`xxdobc Hbcrkx `f H`srw xl`sbg irrieac w` nccw dewcr}rcwcrx ceaiacg ot wlc XHX
}rd`r w` h`nncehcncew `f wlc h`srw" w` cexsrc wliw wlct irc }rcxcew" iqirc `f wlc h`srw
bit`sw" ieg igvdxcg `f wlc bdkcbt `rgcr `f osxdecxx% Qlce wlc dewcr}rcwcr lix occe ceaiacg
ot wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc" wlc Hbcrk `f wlc H`srw xl`sbg rchcdvc i h`}t `f wlc “H`gc `f
H`egshw— xdaecg ot wlc Dewcr}rcwcr ,I}}cegd| H$%
4% ]itncew `f Dewcr}rcwcrx
Wlc XHX dx rcx}`exdobc f`r }itncew `f wlc dewcr}rcwcr—x fcc% Ie c|}cexcx hbidn f`rn xl`sbg
oc cehb`xcg qdwl wlc Bcwwcr `f Dexwrshwd`e% Wlc c|}cexcx qldhl nit oc hbidncg irc dwcndxcg
`e wlc c|}cexcx hbidn f`rn% Wlc Hbcrk `f H`srw xl`sbg h`sewcrxdae wlc f`rn w` h`efdrn wlc
dewcr}rcwcr—x iwwcegiehc% Wlcrcifwcr" ie `ffdhcr ,e`w wlc hixldcr$ xl`sbg hlchk wliw wlc hbidn
lix occe }r`}crbt hibhsbiwcg% Wlce wlc `ffdhc nieiacr `r ldxlcr i}}`dewcg gc}swc xl`sbg
iswl`rdxc ieg }ixx wlc hbidn f`r }itncew%
9=% N`edw`rdea `f ecq irrieacncewx
T`s xl`sbg cexsrc wliw wlcxc ecq irrieacncewx irc gdxhsxxcg qdwlde t`sr `ffdhc% B`hib
ibb`hiwd`e `f gswdcx xl`sbg oc iarccg" ieg t`s xl`sbg cexsrc wliw ibb rcbcview xwiff hbcirbt
segcrxwieg wlcdr rcx}`exdodbdwdcx de wlc ecq }r`hcxx%
T`s xl`sbg igvdxc @}criwd`ex ieg ]`bdht Sedw `f iet xdaedfdhiew gdffdhsbwdcx c|}crdcehcg qdwl
cdwlcr }irwdhsbir dewcr}rcwcrx" `r wlc xwiegirg `f xcrvdhc acecribbt }r`vdgcg ot dewcr}rcwdea
xcrvdhcx" x` wliw wldx def`rniwd`e hie oc fcg oihk w` wlc xcrvdhcx ieg w` wlc Xh`wwdxl
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 65/206
Wriexbiwd`e" Dewcr}rcwdea ieg H`nnsedhiwd`e F`rsn% T`s xl`sbg ibx` igvdxc @}criwd`ex ieg
]`bdht Sedw `f iet acecrib rchsrrdea }r`obcnx qldhl irc c|}crdcehcg ix i rcxsbw `f wlc ecq
irrieacncewx%
99% H`ehbsxd`e Iet yscrdcx `r vdcqx de rcbiwd`e w` wlc h`ewcew `f wldx hdrhsbir xl`sbg oc rcfcrrcg w` @}criwd`ex
ieg ]`bdht Sedw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 66/206
I]]CEGD\ O
DEXW_SHWD@E @F DEWC_]_CWC_X
F@_ H_DNDEIB H@S_W GDCWX ]_@W@H@B
Wldx }r`w`h`b xcwx `sw iarccg irrieacncewx ocwqcce Hr`qe @ffdhc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw
Xcrvdhc ieg wlc Ixx`hdiwd`e `f Hldcf ]`bdhc @ffdhcrx de Xh`wbieg ,IH]@X$ f`r wlc
dexwrshwd`e `f dewcr}rcwcrx f`r hrdndeib h`srw gdcwx% Dw dx dewcegcg w` h`vcr wlc
dexwrshwd`e `f h`nnsedwt" f`rcdae ieg xdae bieasiac dewcr}rcwcrx ieg ,dewcr}rcwcrx
rcysdrcg w` ixxdxw }c`}bc qdwl xcex`rt dn}idrncew$%
Dw dx wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc }`bdhc w` igvdxc wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib de wlc }`bdhc rc}`rwqlcwlcr wlc ihhsxcg `r iet }r`}`xcg }r`xchswd`e qdwecxx rcysdrcx wlc xcrvdhcx `f ie
dewcr}rcwcr w` advc cvdgcehc de h`srw% Wlc rc}`rwdea `ffdhcr xl`sbg x}chdft wlc bieasiac
ieg gdibchw rcysdrcg de wlc }`bdhc rc}`rw ieg xl`sbg ibx` }r`vdgc wlc einc" gcxdaeiwd`e
ieg ysibdfdhiwd`ex `f iet dewcr}rcwcr sxcg iw wlc devcxwdaiwdvc xwiac x` wliw wlc
}r`hsriw`r fdxhib ieg wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc nit cexsrc wliw" x` fir ix }`xxdobc"
wlc xinc dewcr}rcwcr dx e`w sxcg iw iet h`srw gdcw%
Dw dx wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib w` ceaiac i xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg
c|}crdcehcg dewcr}rcwcr" xkdbbcg de wlc bieasiac ieg gdibchw x}chdfdcg de wlc }`bdhc
rc}`rw" w` ixxdxw }r`xchswd`e qdwecxxcx de advdea wlcdr cvdgcehc% Dw dx rch`aedxcg wliw
wlcrc dx bdndwcg wdnc ividbiobc ocwqcce irrcxw ieg wlc fdrxw i}}ciriehc `f ie ihhsxcg
}crx`e de hsxw`gt%
De ibb hixcx wlcrcf`rc qlcrc ihhsxcg }crx`ex irc i}}cirdea f`r wlc fdrxw wdnc fr`n
hsxw`gt wlc }`bdhc qdbb" x` fir ix }`xxdobc" irrieac" `e oclibf `f wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw
Xcrvdhc" f`r i xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg c|}crdcehcg dewcr}rcwcr w` i}}cir iw h`srw w` ixxdxw
wlc ihhsxcg% Wlc dewcr}rcwcr ceaiacg f`r h`srw xl`sbg e`w oc wlc xinc dewcr}rcwcr ql`
ixxdxwcg wlc ihhsxcg gsrdea wlc devcxwdaiwd`e xwiac ibwl`sal dw dx rch`aedxcg wliw dw
nit e`w ibqitx oc }`xxdobc w` xchsrc wlc xcrvdhcx `f i gdffcrcew dewcr}rcwcr ql` lix
i}}r`}rdiwc ysibdfdhiwd`ex ieg c|}crdcehc advce wlc bdndwcg wdnc ividbiobc% Wlc fihw
wliw wlc }`bdhc livc ceaiacg ie dewcr}rcwcr f`r wlc ihhsxcg—x fdrxw i}}ciriehc fr`n
hsxw`gt xl`sbg oc xcw `sw de wlc }`bdhc rc}`rw w` wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib% Df gdffdhsbwdcx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 67/206
irdxc de xchsrdea wlc xcrvdhcx `f ie dewcr}rcwcr wlc }`bdhc xl`sbg nikc cirbt h`ewihw
qdwl wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib% Wlc fcc `f wlc dewcr}rcwcr de xshl hixcx qdbb oc }idg ot
Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc ieg wlct qdbb dexwrshw wlc dewcr}rcwcr f`r wlc ihhsxcg f`r iet
h`ewdescg gdcwx de wlc hixc%
De rcx}chw `f ibb `wlcr hrdndeib h`srw gdcwx" o`wl }rc.wrdib ieg wrdib gdcwx" dw dx wlc
rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc w` ceaiac i xsdwiobt ysibdfdcg ieg
c|}crdcehcg dewcr}rcwcr" xkdbbcg de wlc bieasiac ieg gdibchw rcysdrcg w` ixxdxw wlc
ihhsxcg% De rcx}chw `f ibb `wlcr gdcwx wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib qdbb igvdxc wlc xlcrdff hbcrk
,`r de ldal h`srw hixcx wlc gc}swt }rdehd}ib hbcrk `f jsxwdhdirt$ de qrdwdea `f wlc
bieasiac eccgx `f wlc ihhsxcg" eincbt wlc bieasiac ieg gdibchw ix xcw `sw de wlc
}`bdhc rc}`rw" iw bcixw 97 gitx ocf`rc wlc xhlcgsbcg gdcw%
Dw dx rch`aedxcg wliw wlc r`bc `f wlc dewcr}rcwcr de wlc hrdndeib h`srw dx hrshdib% Wlc
}r`hsriw`r fdxhib" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc ieg wlc }`bdhc qdbb cexsrc" x` fir ix }`xxdobc"
wliw dewcr}rcwcrx irc ceaiacg wlr`sal rch`aedxcg dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx ieg wliw
dewcr}rcwcrx ceaiacg livc i}}r`}rdiwc ysibdfdhiwd`ex ieg c|}crdcehc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 68/206
I]]CEGD\ H
H@GC @F H@EGSHW F@_ DEWC_]_CWC_X
Wldx H`gc `f H`egshw xcwx `sw wlc xwiegirgx qldhl irc c|}chwcg `f t`s qlce
ihhc}wdea ixxdaencewx fr`n Xh`wwdxl ]`bdhc Xcrvdhc" x`bdhdw`rx" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
`r wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc ieg ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Xcrvdhc%
,9$ H`n}cwcehc ‘ T`s irc c|}chwcg w`:
livc i qrdwwce ieg x}`kce h`nnieg `f o`wl bieasiacx" dehbsgdea iet x}ch dibdxw
wcrnde`b`at" hsrrcew dgd`nx ieg gdibchw
oc findbdir qdwl iet hsbwsrib oihkar`segx rcbcview w` wlc ixxdaencew
segcrxwieg }`bdhc xwiwd`e ieg h`srw }r`hcgsrcx%
,?$ ]r`hcgsrc ‘ t`s qdbb:
h`evct wlc c|ihw nciedea `f qliw lix occe xidg qdwl`sw iggdea" `ndwwdea `r
hlieadea ietwldea; nikdea c|}bieiwd`e `ebt qlcrc i hsbwsrib ndxsegcrxwiegdea nit
oc `hhsrrdea" `r qlcrc wlcrc dx e` gdrchw cysdvibcew f`r i }irwdhsbir wcrn% @ebt de
c|hc}wd`eib hdrhsnxwiehcx xl`sbg i xsnnirt oc advce ,df wldx dx h`excewcg w` ot ibb
}irwdcx$ }r`vdgcg wlc nciedea `f qliw dx ocdea xsnnirdxcg dx e`w gdxw`rwcg
gchbirc iet gdffdhsbwdcx t`s livc qdwl gdibchw `r wchledhib wcrnx ieg df wlcxc hiee`w oc
xiwdxfihw`rdbt rcncgdcg" qdwlgriq fr`n wlc ixxdaencew
e`w advc igvdhc" bcaib `r `wlcrqdxc" w` ie ihhsxcg }crx`e `r qdwecxx de wlc hixc" e`r
cewcr dew` gdxhsxxd`e qdwl wlcn ,`wlcr wlie w` h`efdrn bieasiac/gdibchw niwhl$
e`w gcbcaiwc q`rk" e`r ihhc}w gcbcaiwcg q`rk ,`r q`rk f`r ie`wlcr }irwt de wlc
}r`hccgdeax$ qdwl`sw wlc }rd`r h`excew `f wlc }irwt ceaiadea t`s/wlc `wlcr
dewcr}rcwcr—x xcrvdhcx
oc rcbdiobc ieg }sehwsib iw ibb wdncx
gchbirc dnncgdiwcbt iet }rcvd`sx dev`bvcncew de wlc ixxdaencew ieg iet
dev`bvcncew `r rcbiwd`exld} qdwl wlc ihhsxcg `r iet qdwecxx de wlc hixc
dewcrr s}w wlc dewcrvdcq/}r`hccgdeax `ebt ,9$ w` ixk f`r hbirdfdhiwd`e ,?$ w` }`dew `sw wliw
i }irwt nit e`w livc segcrxw``g x`ncwldea ,8$ w` ibcrw wlc }irwdcx w` i ndxxcg hsbwsrib
rcfcrcehc ,7$ w` igvdxc wliw wlcrc dx e` cysdvibcew wcrn de wlc bieasiac h`ehcrecg w`
wlc wcrn ocdea sxcg ieg ,3$ w` igvdxc wliw t`s rcysdrc i orcik gsc w` wlc }`wcewdib f`r
bi}xcx de h`ehcewriwd`e w` `hhsr gsrdea bceawlt }crd`gx `f xdnsbwiec`sx `r
h`exchswdvc dewcr}rcwdea%
,8$ Cwldhib ieg ]r`fcxxd`eib Dxxscx ‘ t`s qdbb:
rcx}chw h`ef dgcewdibdwt iw ibb wdncx ieg e`w xcck w` wikc igviewiac `f iet def`rniwd`e
gdxhb`xcg gsrdea t`sr q`rk
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 69/206
ihw de ie dn}irwdib ieg }r`fcxxd`eib nieecr
e`w gdxhrdndeiwc ocwqcce }irwdcx ,w` wlcdr igviewiac `r gdxigviewiac$ cdwlcr gdrchwbt
`r degdrchwbt `e wlc ar`segx `f rihc" h`b`sr" cwledh `rdade" iac" eiwd`eibdwt" rcbdad`e `r
ocbdcf" acegcr" xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `r gdxiodbdwt
gdxhb`xc iet def`rniwd`e" dehbsgdea iet hrdndeib rch`rg" qldhl nit nikc t`ssexsdwiobc f`r iet }irwdhsbir ixxdaencew
gdxhb`xc dnncgdiwcbt df wlc }crx`e f`r ql`n t`s irc dewcr}rcwdea" `r wlcdr dnncgdiwc
findbt dx ke`qe `r rcbiwcg w` t`s
gchbirc iet osxdecxx" fdeiehdib" findbt `r `wlcr dewcrcxwx qldhl t`s ndalw livc de wlc
niwwcr ocdea liegbcg
e`w ihhc}w iet f`rn `f rcqirg ,qlcwlcr de hixl `r `wlcrqdxc$ f`r dewcr}rcwdea q`rk"
`wlcr wlie }itncew ot wlc }irwt ceaiadea t`sr xcrvdhcx%
,7$ H`efdgcewdibdwt ‘ Iet def`rniwd`e t`s `owide de wlc h`srxc `f t`sr ixxdaencew dx
h`efdgcewdib ieg dx e`w w` oc advce ot t`s w` iet`ec `wlcr wlie wlc }irwt ql`
dexwrshwcg t`s" qlcwlcr gsrdea wlc ixxdaencew `r ifwcr dw lix fdedxlcg" sebcxx t`s irc
advce qrdwwce }crndxxd`e w` g` x`% T`s nsxw ibx` h`n}bt qdwl wlc hsrrcew Giwi
]r`wchwd`e Ihw bcadxbiwd`e%
T`s qdbb e`w sxc iet def`rniwd`e t`s `owide de wlc h`srxc `f t`sr ixxdaencew f`r iet
}sr}`xc `wlcr wlie ix iswl`rdxcg ot wlc }irwt dexwrshwdea t`s% Wlc rdalw w` ibb xshl
def`rniwd`e rcxwx qdwl wlc }irwt dexwrshwdea t`s ieg }crndxxd`e w` ihhcxx ieg sxc wldx
def`rniwd`e hie `ebt oc advce ot wliw }irwt% Df t`s fccb wliw t`s nit rcysdrc w` gdxhb`xc
def`rniwd`e `owidecg de wlc ixxdaencew gsc w` i eccg f`r iggdwd`eib xs}}`rw `r
asdgiehc" t`s xl`sbg qrdwc w` wlc }irwt ql` dexwrshwcg t`s f`r }crndxxd`e w` gdxhb`xc
xshl def`rniwd`e%
T`s nsxw kcc} xifc iet g`hsncewx }r`vdgcg w` t`s de wlc h`srxc `f ie ixxdaencew;
t`s nsxw nikc xsrc wlct irc e`w h`}dcg" de ql`bc `r de }irw" ieg t`s nsxw rcwsre wlcn
w` wlc }irwt ql` dexwrshwcg t`s iw wlc ceg `f wlc ixxdaencew%
,3$ Dexsriehc ‘ T`s xl`sbg oc h`vcrcg ot }r`fcxxd`eib degcnedwt dexsriehc ,cdwlcr
t`sr `qe `r ix }r`vdgcg ot wlc dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc$% Wlc }irwt dexwrshwdea t`s qdbb e`w
oc rcx}`exdobc f`r iet hbidnx nigc iaidexw dw" `r iaidexw t`s" `e wlc ar`segx" f`r
c|in}bc" `f deh`n}cwcew dewcr}rcwdea `r se}r`fcxxd`eib h`egshw%
D ihhc}w wldx ixxdaencew" livdea rcig ieg segcrxw``g wlc wcrnx ieg h`egdwd`ex xcw `sw
io`vc% D segcrxwieg wliw df D orcihl iet `f wlcxc wcrnx ieg h`egdwd`ex" }irwdhsbirbt
wl`xc rcbiwdea w` h`efdgcewdibdwt" hrdndeib `r hdvdb }r`hccgdeax nit rcxsbw%
Xdaecg: PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
]rdew Einc: PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
Giwc: PPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPPP
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 70/206
I}}cegd| G
Xwtbc Bcwwcr `f Dexwrshwd`e f`r F`rcdae Bieasiac Dewcr}rcwcrx
Gcir Xdr/Nigin
HIXC IAIDEXW [dexcrw einc `f ihhsxcg^
[dexcrw hixc rcfcrcehc esnocr^
[dexcrw einc ieg iggrcxx `f h`srw^
[dexcrw giwc ieg wdnc `f lcirdea^
[dexcrw eiwsrc `f gdcw c%a% Wrdib Gdcw" ]bcigdea Gdcw" Hsxw`gt Gdcw" ]cwdwd`e Gdcw^
D xl`sbg oc ariwcfsb df t`s q`sbg xs}}bt i [dexcrw einc `f bieasiac rcysdrcg ieg
gdibchw df i}}r`}rdiwc^ dewcr}rcwcr w` ixxdxw wlc ihhsxcg de wlc io`vc hixc `e wlc giwc,x$
rcfcrrcg w`%
Wlc dewcr}rcwcr xl`sbg livc wlc Gd}b`ni de ]sobdh Xcrvdhc Dewcr}rcwdea ,Xh`wwdxl
Bcaib @}wd`e$ ieg rchcew c|}crdcehc `f o`wl h`exchswdvc ieg xdnsbwiec`sxdewcr}rcwdea de wlc h`srw h`ewc|w% Df t`s irc seiobc w` nccw wlcxc rcysdrcncewx D xl`sbg
oc ariwcfsb df t`s q`sbg h`ewihw wldx `ffdhc w` gdxhsxx wlc niwwcr ix x``e ix }`xxdobc%
De wlc cvcew wliw t`s g` rch`nnceg ie dewcr}rcwcr" D qdbb rcysdrc i qrdwwce xwiwcncew
fr`n t`s gcwidbdea:
wlc ysibdfdhiwd`ex ieg c|}crdcehc f wlc dewcr}rcwcr rch`nncegcg"
wlc oixdx `f t`sr ixxcxxncew `f wlc dewcr}rcwcr" ieg
qlt t`s h`exdgcr wlc dewcr}rcwcr w` oc xsdwiobc f`r wldx ixxdaencew%
D xl`sbg oc ariwcfsb df t`s q`sbg:
}ixx wldx bcwwcr w` wlc dewcr}rcwcr dgcewdfdcg ot t`s . dw xl`sbg wlce oc wrciwcg ix ibcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e;
ixk wlc dewcr}rcwcr w` h`exdgcr ieg xdae wlc H`gc `f H`egshw;
rcwsre wlc xdaecg H`gc `f H`egshw w` wldx `ffdhc qdwl iet rcx}`excx rcysdrcg otwlc H`gc ‘ wldx dx echcxxirt ocf`rc wlc dewcr}rcwcr nit wikc s} wlc ixxdaencew;
rcwide i h`}t `f wlc H`gc `f H`egshw f`r t`sr rch`rgx%
Wlc segcre`wcg g`hsncewx irc ibx` cehb`xcg% ]bcixc }ixx wlcxc w` wlc dewcr}rcwcr:
i h`}t `f wlc h`n}bidewdegdhwncew [gcbcwc ix i}}r`}rdiwc^;
i acecrib ordcfdea e`wc ieg i bdxw `f h`nn`ebt sxcg bcaib wcrnx ieg wlcdr Ceabdxlnciedeax w` ixxdxw de }rc}iriwd`ex;
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 71/206
ie c|}cexcx f`rn%
D in ariwcfsb w` t`s f`r t`sr ixxdxwiehc% ]bcixc g` e`w lcxdwiwc w` h`ewihw nc df t`s
livc iet yscrdcx de rcbiwd`e w` wldx niwwcr%
T`srx fidwlfsbbt
Xlcrdff Hbcrk Gc}swc/
Gc}swc Hbcrk `f Jsxwdhdirt
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 72/206
I]]CEGD\ C
XH@WWDXL H@S_W XC_VDHC
Dewcr}rcwdea de wlc Hrdndeib H`srw
H@EWCEWX
Acecrib ordcfdea f`r dewcr}rcwcrx
Ab`xxirt `f wcrnx . ]c`}bc ieg ]bihcxBcaib Wcrnx & ]r`hcgsrcWt}cx `f H`srwWt}c `f Xcewcehc
ACEC_IB O_DCFDEA F@_ DEWC_]_CWC_X
Df t`s livc ecvcr dewcr}rcwcg de h`srw ocf`rc }bcixc igvdxc wlcdewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhc% Dw nit oc }`xxdobc w` irrieac i vdxdw w` wlc h`srw f`r t`s ieg ie c|}bieiwd`e `f wlc bdkcbt }r`hcgsrc fr`n i ncnocr `f wlch`srw xwiff%
_cncnocr wliw ix ie dewcr}rcwcr de wlc hrdndeib h`srw t`s irc cewdrcbtdegc}cegcew `f wlc }irwdcx% T`s nsxw }crf`rn t`sr r`bc de i ql`bbtdegc}cegcew ieg dn}irwdib nieecr%
Oc h`efdgcew% T`s r`bc dx cxxcewdib w` cexsrc wliw wlc }r`hccgdeax ircfidr% Df wl`xc x}cikdea irc a`dea w`` ysdhkbt w` ibb`q t`s w` dewcr}rcw}r`}crbt bcw wlc jsgac ke`q%
De h`nnsedwt" f`rcdae ieg xdae bieasiacx" wlcrc nit oc e` cysdvibcewwcrn w` wlc Ceabdxl wcrn `r }lrixc ocdea sxcg% Dw dx hrshdibbt dn}`rwiewwliw t`s dewcr}rcw ix hb`xcbt ix }`xxdobc wlc nciedea `f wlc wcrnx ocdeasxcg% G` e`w ascxx% Igvdxc wlc h`srw `f wlc gdffdhsbwt iw wlc wdnc% Dw dxbdkcbt wliw dw qdbb oc }`xxdobc f`r wlc degdvdgsib sxdea wlc gdffdhsbw wcrn w`/xit dw de i gdffcrcew qit/%
]bcixc cexsrc wliw t`s h`exdgcr" xdae ieg rcwsre wlc H`gc `f H`egshw
}r`vdgcg qdwl wlc bcwwcr `f dexwrshwd`e ocf`rc ihhc}wdea ie ixxdaencewfr`n wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc%
_cncnocr wliw t`sr h`ehcewriwd`e hie bi}xc de b`ea }crd`gx `f xdnsbwiec`sx `r h`exchswdvc dewcr}rcwdea% Oc xsrc w` ibcrw wlc h`srw w`wldx ieg w` wlc eccg f`r rcasbir orcikx ,cvcrt 8= ndeswcx `r x`$%
AB@XXI_T @F WC_NX
]c`}bc ieg ]bihcx
LDAL H@S_W @F JSXWDHDI_T: Ix i wrdib h`srw dw lix x`bc jsrdxgdhwd`e w` lcir wlc n`xw arivc h`nn`e biq hrdncx xshl ix nsrgcr ieg ri}c% Dw gcibx qdwl
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 73/206
wlc n`xw xcrd`sx hrdncx% Dw hie dn}`xc s} w` bdfc dn}rdx`encew ieg wlcrc dx e`bdndw `e wlc n`ecwirt }ceibwt dw hie dn}`xc% Ix ie i}}cib h`srw `f 8 `r n`rc jsgacx dw lcirx i}}cibx fr`n ibb `wlcr h`srwx dehbsgdea i}}cibx fr`n dwxcbf ix iwrdib h`srw% Sxcx `ebt x`bcne }r`hcgsrc%
Xlcrdff H`srw: Sxcx o`wl xsnnirt ieg x`bcne }r`hcgsrc% De xsnnirt`ffcehcx wlc xlcrdff hie fdec s} w` ¨3=== ieg dn}rdx`e i fdrxw `ffcegcr f`r 8n`ewlx% Hcrwide rc}ciw `ffcegcrx hie oc dn}rdx`ecg s} w` 6 n`ewlx% Qlcesxdea x`bcne }r`hcgsrc wlc xlcrdff hie dn}rdx`e f`r s} w` 8 tcirx" dn}`xc iesebdndwcg fdec" `r df wlc xlcrdff wldekx wlc hixc dx xcrd`sx ce`sal hie rcndw wlcihhsxcg w` wlc ldal h`srw f`r xcewcehdea%
Gdxwrdhw H`srw: Bit }crx`ex xdw ix jsxwdhcx `f wlc }cihc qdwl i bcaibbt ysibdfdcgixxcxx`r% I jsxwdhc nit xdw ib`ec `r n`rc wlie `ec hie xdw w`acwlcr% Hiedn}rdx`e f`r s} w` 6= gitx `r dn}`xc i fdec e`w c|hccgdea ¨?"3==% Gcibx `ebtqdwl xsnnirt }r`hcgsrc" ieg n`rc nde`r `ffcehcx% Lix i }`qcr w` rcndw i
hixc w` wlc Xlcrdff h`srw osw wldx }`qcr dx xcbg`n c|crhdxcg%
B`rg Igv`hiwc: Wlc lcig `f wlc }r`xchswd`e xcrvdhc de Xh`wbieg% Dxxscxdexwrshwd`ex ieg asdgiehc w` ]r`hsriw`rx Fdxhib ieg w` wlc }`bdhc% I ndedxwcr dewlc Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc" ldxlcr gc}swt dx ke`qe ix wlc X`bdhdw`r Acecrib% Wlctirc ixxdxwcg ot igv`hiwcx gc}swc% Wlc B`rg Igv`hiwc" `r n`rc sxsibbtigv`hiwcx gc}swc qdbb h`egshw wrdibx de wlc Ldal H`srw%
]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib: B`hib }r`xchsw`rx wlr`sal`sw Xh`wbieg" ixxdxwcg ot `ec`r n`rc ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Gc}swcx ql` h`egshw }r`xchswd`ex de wlc Xlcrdff ieg Gdxwrdhw H`srwx ieg }rc}irc xcrd`sx hixcx ot qit `f ]rch`aedwd`e%
Ihhsxcg: Wlc }crx`e ql` xdwx de wlc g`hk ihhsxcg `f h`nndwwdea wlc hrdnc`e wlc degdhwncew `r h`n}bidew% Wlc ihhsxcg dx x`ncwdncx hibbcg wlc /}iecb/de x`bcne }r`hcgsrc%
Gcfcehc Iacew: Wldx wcrn dehbsgcx wlc biqtcrx" i x`bdhdw`r `r igv`hiwc" ql`qdbb ihw `e oclibf `f ie ihhsxcg%
Hbcrk: Cihl h`srw qdbb livc i hbcrk ql` qdbb e`rnibbt xdw de fr`ew `f wlc jsgacieg rch`rg wlc }r`hccgdeax%
Bcaib Wcrnx & ]r`hcgsrc
X`bcne ]r`hcgsrc: Sxcx i jsrt ,`f 93$ w` lcir n`rc xcrd`sx hixcx%E`wdfdhiwd`e `f wlc hliracx dx h`ewidecg de ie degdhwncew wliw rsex de wlc einc`f wlc B`rg Igv`hiwc%
Xsnnirt ]r`hcgsrc: E` jsrt" lcirx n`rc nde`r hixcx% E`wdfdhiwd`e `f wlchliracx dx h`ewidecg de i h`n}bidew wliw rsex de wlc einc `f wlc b`hib]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 74/206
H`nn`e Biq: Lix osdbw s} `vcr wdnc wlr`sal hsxw`n ieg }rihwdhc ieggchdxd`ex `f wlc h`srwx% N`xw hrdncx irc hrdncx iw h`nn`e biq" c%a% nsrgcr"ri}c" ixxisbw" wlcfw%
Xwiwsw`rt Biq: ]irbdincew cdwlcr de Qcxwndexwcr `r Cgdeosral hie bcadxbiwc
w` nikc hcrwide ihwd`ex hrdndeib% Xshl bcadxbiwd`e nit ibx` ibwcr wlc }`qcrx `f xcewcehdea% C|in}bcx dehbsgc _`ig Wriffdh Ihw 94<< ieg Ndxsxc `f Grsax Ihw9419%
]sobdh Dewcrcxw: Ibb hrdncx irc }r`xchswcg de wlc }sobdh dewcrcxw% I}r`xchswd`e hie wikc }bihc cvce qlcrc wlc }irwdcx dev`bvcg livc h`nc w`x`nc f`rn `f }rdviwc iarccncew% Wlc B`rg Igv`hiwc ieg ]r`hsriw`rx Fdxhibgchdgc qlcwlcr w` }r`xchswc%
]rch`aedwd`e: Wlc }r`hcxx ot qldhl i ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib }rc}ircx i hixcsegcr x`bcne }r`hcgsrc% Wldx qdbb dehbsgc dewcrvdcqdea qdwecxxcx iw ldxlcr
`ffdhc%
Oidb: Ie ihhsxcg }crx`e nit oc rcbcixcg fr`n hsxw`gt `e oidb% H`egdwd`exirc iwwihlcg ieg c|wri h`egdwd`ex" xshl ix e`w w` cewcr i x}chdfdcg irci `r h`ewihw i eincg degdvdgsib" nit oc dn}`xcg% @ebt i h`srw hie ibwcr i oidb`rgcr" rcairgbcxx `f qliw i qdwecxx nit xit% Ie ihhsxcg hie oc irrcxwcg ieg jidbcg f`r orcihldea i oidb `rgcr%
X`hdib Ceysdrt _c}`rw: ]rc}ircg ot i x`hdib q`rkcr ql` rc}`rwx w` wlc h`srw`e ie ihhsxcg!x }crx`eib hdrhsnxwiehcx ieg wlcdr xsdwiodbdwt f`r wlc vird`sxwt}cx `f xcewcehc%
Wt}cx `f H`srw
Hsxw`gt H`srw: Qlcrc }c`}bc i}}cirdea fr`n hsxw`gt fdrxw i}}cir% Segcr x`bcne }r`hcgsrc ie ihhsxcg qdbb i}}cir `e }cwdwd`e ieg nit oc h`nndwwcgf`r fsrwlcr c|indeiwd`e `r fsbbt h`nndwwcg sewdb bdocriwcg de gsc h`srxc `f biq%Wlc ihhsxcg dx e`w ixkcg w` }bcig asdbwt `r e`w asdbwt% Segcr xsnnirt}r`hcgsrc wlc ihhsxcg dx ixkcg w` }bcig asdbwt `r e`w asdbwt% De o`wl f`rnx `f }r`hcgsrc wlc ihhsxcg nit ixk wlc h`srw w` oc rcbcixcg `e oidb" ieg wlc
]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib nit degdhiwc qlcwlcr lcxlc `}}`xcx wldx% Df `}}`xcg wlcXlcrdff `r Jsxwdhc qdbb gchdgc df ie ihhsxcg dx rcbcixcg `e oidb%
Gdcw H`srw `r ]bcix H`srw: Segcr xsnnirt }r`hcgsrc wlc fdrxw hibbdea `f e`e.hsxw`gt hixcx" qlce wlc ihhsxcg dx ixkcg w` }bcig asdbwt `r e`w asdbwt%
Dewcrncgdiwc Gdcw H`srw: F`r xsnnirt hixcx" i qcck `r wq` ocf`rc wlc wrdib"iw qldhl wlc ihhsxcg nsxw i}}cir ieg xwiwc ldxlcr }bci ieg }rc}ircgecxxf`r wrdib%
Fdrxw Gdcw H`srw: F`r x`bcne hixcx" i qcck `r wq` ocf`rc wlc wrdib iw qldhl
wlc ihhsxcg nsxw i}}cir ieg xwiwc ldxlcr }bci ieg }rc}ircgecxx f`r wrdib%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 75/206
Wrdib H`srw: Qlcrc wrdibx wikc }bihc" hie `fwce oc n`rc wlie `ec de osxdcr h`srwx%
_cnieg H`srw: Gcib qdwl h`ewdescg osxdecxx xshl ix gcfcrrcg xcewcehcx%
Fdecx Ceysdrt H`srw: Qlcrc wlc h`srw qdbb ixk ie ihhsxcg qlt wlct livc e`w}idg wlcdr fdec% Hie advc wlcn n`rc wdnc w` }it" i xs}crvdxcg iwwcegiehc`rgcr `r `rgcr dn}rdx`encew%
Wt}c `f Xcewcehc
Iox`bswc Gdxhlirac: I h`srw nit de c|hc}wd`eib hdrhsnxwiehcx ariew ieiox`bswc gdxhlirac; qldbxw wlc ihhsxcg lix occe h`evdhwcg" e` hrdndeibh`evdhwd`e dx rch`rgcg iaidexw wlcdr einc ieg wlct irc frcc w` a`%
Ign`edxlcg: Qirecg ot wlc h`srw w` oclivc%
H`nnsedwt Xcrvdhc @rgcr: Se}idg q`rk f`r wlc h`nnsedwt" igndedxwcrcg otwlc X`hdib Q`rk Gc}irwncew%
Gcfcrrcg Xcewcehc: H`srw nit gcfcr xcewcehc f`r i esnocr `f rcix`ex% Dwnit gcfcr f`r s} w` i tcir w` xcc df ie ihhsxcg }crx`e lix occe `f a``goclivd`sr%
Gdxysibdfdhiwd`e: H`srw nit gdxysibdft ie ihhsxcg fr`n grdvdea f`r i x}chdfdcg}crd`g%
Grsa Wrciwncew ieg Wcxwdea @rgcr: Dewcexdvc f`rn `f }r`oiwd`e de qldhl ieihhsxcg segcrwikcx h`n}sbx`rt grsa wrciwncew ieg wcxwdea%
Ceg`rxcncew: De grdvdea `ffcehcx }ceibwt }`dewx nit oc ceg`rxcg `e igrdvdea bdhcehc%
Fdec: Hie oc }idg ot dexwibncewx% ]itncewx irc w` wlc hbcrk%
Dn}rdx`encew: Xcew w` jidb%
]r`oiwd`e: Hie dev`bvc iggdwd`eib h`egdwd`ex" xshl ix w` segcra` ncgdhibwrciwncew" osw qdbb dev`bvc h`n}sbx`rt nccwdeax qdwl i x`hdib q`rkcr w`gdxhsxx wlc }r`obcnx de ie ihhsxcg—x bdfc" c%a% ibh`l`bdxn" grsa iggdhwd`e%
Xs}crvdxcg Iwwcegiehc @rgcr: Df i fdec dx se}idg h`srw nit dn}`xc xshl ie`rgcr rcysdrdea ie ihhsxcg w` iwwceg iw i xhlcnc rse ot wlc x`hdib q`rkgc}irwncew%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 76/206
Hli}wcr 6
XC\SIB @_DCEWIWD@E IEG ACEGC_ DGCEWDWT
GCFDEDWD@EX
6%9 Wlc f`bb`qdea irc x`nc lcb}fsb gcfdedwd`ex% ]c`}bc nit hl``xc w` dgcewdft
wlcnxcbvcx sxdea iet `f wlcxc biocbx" `r e`ec%
Bcxodie: i q`nie ql` dx cn`wd`eibbt ieg }ltxdhibbt iwwrihwcg w` `wlcr q`nce%
Ait: x`nc`ec ql` dx cn`wd`eibbt ieg }ltxdhibbt iwwrihwcg w` ncnocrx `f wlc
xinc xc|% Sxsibbt i}}bdcg `ebt w` nce" osw x`ncwdncx w` q`nce%
Odxc|sib: i }crx`e ql` dx cn`wd`eibbt ieg }ltxdhibbt iwwrihwcg w` ncnocrx `f
o`wl xc|cx%
Wriexxc|sib: i }crx`e ql` bdvcx `r qiewx w` bdvc ix i ncnocr `f wlc xc| gdffcrcew
w` wliw `e ldx `r lcr odrwl hcrwdfdhiwc% X`nc wriexxc|sib }c`}bc xcck ncgdhib
dewcrvcewd`e" dehbsgdea l`rn`ec wrciwncew ieg xsracrt% @wlcrx" f`r ncgdhib `r
`wlcr rcix`ex" g` e`w%
Wriexvcxwdwc: i }crx`e ql`" ot wlcdr hb`wldea `r `wlcrqdxc" hl``xcx w` wikc `e
ix}chwx `f wlc i}}ciriehc `f wlc acegcr e`w xl`qe `e ldx `r lcr odrwl hcrwdfdhiwc"
cdwlcr ibb `r }irw `f wlc wdnc% Wriexvcxwdwc }c`}bc g` e`w sxsibbt dgcewdft ix i
ncnocr `f wlc `wlcr xc|%
Wriexacegcr: ie `vcribb wcrn f`r wriexvcxwdwc ieg wriexxc|sib }c`}bc" ieg `wlcrx
ql`xc acegcr dgcewdwt dx de h`efbdhw qdwl wlc n`gcb }rcxcewcg ot x`hdcwt%
BAOW: bcxodie" ait" odxc|sib `r wriexacegcr% Wldx dx wlc wcrn de dehrcixdeabt
acecrib sxc ot" f`r c|in}bc" wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew ieg `wlcr }sobdh iswl`rdwdcx"w` rcfcr w` }c`}bc de `ec `r n`rc `f wlc io`vc hiwca`rdcx%
6%? Qldbc BAOW }c`}bc `fwce xlirc h`nn`e c|}crdcehcx" dw dx dn}`rwiew w` e`wc
wliw" de `wlcr qitx" wlct irc ix gdvcrxc ix iet `wlcr h`nnsedwt% Wlc rieac `f
`hhs}iwd`ex" iacx" rihdib oihkar`segx" fdeiehdib xdwsiwd`ex" findbt xdwsiwd`ex"
bdfcxwtbcx" ieg rcbdad`sx ieg }`bdwdhib ocbdcfx dx ix arciw in`ea BAOW }c`}bc ix in`ea
wlc }`}sbiwd`e ix i ql`bc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 77/206
Hrdndeib Jsxwdhc ieg Liwc Hrdnc
6%8 Dw dx cxwdniwcg wliw ix nshl ix 4= }cr hcew `f l`n`}l`odh hrdnc a`cx
serc}`rwcg ochisxc vdhwdnx irc w`` frdalwcecg `r cnoirrixxcg w` rc}`rw wlc hrdnc%9
F`r n`xw hiwca`rdcx `f liwc hrdnc wlcrc irc e` xtxwcniwdhibbt h`bbchwcg eiwd`eib
xwiwdxwdhx" ibwl`sal wlcrc livc occe x`nc dn}r`vcncewx de rchcew tcirx%?
Ihh`rgdea
w` i rc}`rw fr`n ?==8" x`nc BAOW degdvdgsibx fcir dewcrihwd`e qdwl wlc hrdndeib
jsxwdhc xtxwcn: ‒@f wl`xc dxxscx ridxcg rcbiwdea w` hrdnc `r jsxwdhc" n`xw qcrc oixcg `e
i }crhc}wd`e wliw wlc Xh`wwdxl bcaib ieg hrdndeib jsxwdhc xtxwcn qix" de wlc nide"
dew`bcriew `f BAOW degdvdgsibx% Wldx qix fcbw w` bcig w` h`exdgcriobc gdx}irdwt de wlc
qit wliw BAOW dxxscx qcrc gcibw qdwl ot wlc }`bdhc ieg wlc h`srwx" ieg qdwl l`q
BAOW }c`}bc qcrc vdcqcg ot xshl iswl`rdwdcx" qlce h`n}ircg qdwl l`q
lcwcr`xc|sib }c`}bc fircg%„8Ihh`rgdea w` i Xw`ecqibb _c}`rw" ecirbt i ysirwcr `f
bcxodie ieg ait }c`}bc wldek wlct q`sbg oc wrciwcg q`rxc df wlct i}}circg ocf`rc i
jsgac f`r i nij`r `ffcehc% Xd| de wce ait nce" ieg libf `f q`nce" wldek wlct q`sbg
oc wrciwcg q`rxc ot i }rdx`e `ffdhcr df dw qix ke`qe wlct qcrc bcxodie `r ait%7
BAOW irc `fwce vdhwdnx `f hrdnc ochisxc `f wlcdr xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e% Ihh`rgdea w` i
Xw`ecqibb rc}`rw" `ec de cdalw ait nce" bcxodiex ieg odxc|sibx c|}crdcehcg x`nc x`rw
`f l`n`}l`odi ‘ qlcwlcr “cvcrtgit— `r c|wrcnc de ?=9=% Nshl `f wlcxc hrdncx a`
serc}`rwcg% 3
9 lww}:qqq%l`nc`ffdhc%a`v%skhrdncliwc.hrdnc
? Fidrecxx ieg Frccg`n: Wlc Fdeib _c}`rw `f wlc Cysibdwdcx _cvdcq ?==1 } <9
8? ‒XC\SIB @_DCEWIWD@E _CXCI_HL ]LIXC ?:
WLC FSWS_C @F BAOW _CXCI_HL ‘ ]C_X]CHWDVCX @F H@NNSEDWT
@_AIEDXIWD@EX„ Hirb NhBcie ieg Qdbbdin @!H`ee`r" Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc X`hdib
_cxcirhl" ?==8 > lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%sk_cx`srhcG`h71=87==98<36%}gf
7 ‒Xcrvcx T`s _dalw" Bcxodie ieg Ait ]c`}bc—x C|}chwiwd`ex `f Gdxhrdndeiwd`e„ ?==<:
lww}:qqq%xw`ecqibb%`ra%skg`hsncewxxcrvcxt`srdalw%}gf
3Ob`q wlc qldxwbc `e ait liwc: I }bide Ceabdxl asdgc `e ait liwc hrdnc f`r bcxodie" ait ieg
odxc|sib }c`}bc ,?=9=$
BAOW dgcewdwt
6%7 N`xw }c`}bc ql` irc BAOW och`nc iqirc `f wlcdr xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `r
acegcr dgcewdwt vcrt cirbt de bdfc% Ihh`rgdea w` wlc Ordwdxl Ncgdhib Ixx`hdiwd`e"
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 78/206
“n`xw rcxcirhlcrx ocbdcvc wliw igsbw xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e dx sxsibbt cxwiobdxlcg ocf`rc wlc
iac `f }socrwt—%9
Niet wriexacegcr }c`}bc irc iqirc `f wlcdr dgcewdwt ix hldbgrce%
9 Iac `f h`excew f`r l`n`xc|sib nce ‘ i xhdcewdfdh ieg ncgdhib }crx}chwdvc" Ordwdxl Ncgdhib
Ixx`hdiwd`e" 9448%
6%3 Dw nsxw oc o`rec de ndeg wliw niet }c`}bc h`exdgcr xc|sibdwt i x}chwrsn
riwlcr wlie dgcewdftdea wlcnxcbvcx ix l`n`xc|sib `r lcwcr`xc|sib% X`nc degdvdgsibx
rcjchw x}chdfdh biocbx hiwca`rdxdea wlcdr xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e%
6%6 Qldbc dw xccnx wliw n`rc }c`}bc irc dgcewdftdea ix BAOW iw i t`seacr iac" wlc
dxxsc `f qlce ieg l`q w` oc `}ce io`sw xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `r acegcr dgcewdwt dx xwdbb i
xdaedfdhiew `ec f`r niet BAOW }c`}bc% De wlc xwsgt ot ]biew ieg ]biew9
`f BAOW
}c`}bc de Cgdeosral" }c`}bc segcr wlc iac `f ?9 qcrc bcxx `}ce io`sw wlcdr xc|sib
dgcewdwdcx" ieg wl`xc iacg 89.7= qcrc n`rc `}ce qdwl frdcegx wlie wl`xc cdwlcr `bgcr
`r t`seacr% Wldx q`sbg xccn w` degdhiwc o`wl wliw t`sea BAOW }c`}bc xwdbb gcbit
‒h`ndea `sw„" ieg wliw wlcrc dx i wrceg w`qirgx arciwcr `}ceecxx e`q h`n}ircg w` wq`
gchigcx `r n rc ia`% Dw dx ibx` dn}`rwiew w` e`wc wliw }c`}bc—x `}ceecxx io`sw wlcdr
xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e r acegcr dgcewdwt hie virt ihr`xx gdffcrcew xdwsiwd`ex% ]c`}bc irc
nshl bcxx bdkcbt w` oc ‒`sw„ de q`rk xdwsiwd`ex wlie qdwl frdcegx" ieg irc n`rc `}ce
qdwl frdcegx wlie qdwl findbt ncnocrx%
9‒C|}crdcehcx ieg }crhc}wd`ex `f vd`bcehc ieg dewdndgiwd`e `f wlc bcxodie" ait" odxc|sib" ieg
wriexacegcr h`nnsedwdcx de Cgdeosral% I _c}`rw f`r wlc Hdwt `f Cgdeosral H`sehdb!x
H`nnsedwt Xifcwt Sedw„" 9444" N`dri ]biew" Nirwde ]biew" Odbb Nix`e" Hlrdxwdec Wl`rew`e"
Ibh`l`b & Lcibwl _cxcirhl Hcewrc" Cgdeosral%
BAOW }ircewx
6%1 Findbdcx wliw g` e`w xwrdhwbt h`ef`rn w` wlc wrigdwd`eib n`gcb irc ie
dehrcixdeabt h`nn`e x`hdib rcibdwt% BAOW }c`}bc hie oc }ircewx wlr`sal i nd|cg.
xc| rcbiwd`exld}" `r nit hl``xc w` och`nc }ircewx cdwlcr ix }irw `f i xinc.xc| h`s}bc
,}crli}x wlr`sal irwdfdhdib dexcndeiwd`e `r ig`}wd`e$" `r de `wlcr irrieacncewx"
dehbsgdea xdeabc }ircewl``g `r h`.}ircewdea qdwl frdcegx" `r ot wikdea `e }ircewib
rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r }irwecrx— hldbgrce%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 79/206
6%< Wlcrc dx e` cvdgcehc wliw wlc hldbgrce `f BAOW }c`}bc c|}crdcehc }r`obcnx
ixx`hdiwcg qdwl wlcdr }ircewx— xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `r acegcr dgcewdwt" ibwl`sal x`nc
nit c|}crdcehc x`nc }rcjsgdhc" f`r c|in}bc de wlc xhl``b cevdr`encew% H`efdgcehc
w` gcib qdwl wlc q`rbg x}rdeax fr`n i b`vdea" xs}}`rwdvc ieg xchsrc l`nc" qldhl
cysd}x hldbgrce w` gcib qdwl iedn`xdwt ieg wlc s}x ieg g`qex `f bdfc% Wlcrc dx x`nc
cvdgcehc wliw hldbgrce—x c|}crdcehc `f bdvdea de ie BAOW findbt lcb}x wlcn w`
gcvcb`} e`e.gdxhrdndeiw`rt iwwdwsgcx%
C|}crdcehcx `f }rcjsgdhc
6%4 Xcvcrib xwsgdcx livc f`seg wliw wlc c|}crdcehc `f vd`bcehc ieg gdxhrdndeiwd`e
dx qdgcx}rcig in`ea BAOW }c`}bc" ieg wliw wlcdr fcir `f ocdea vdhwdnx `f hrdnc ieg
gdxhrdndeiwd`e dx ldalcr wlie wliw `f wlc acecrib }`}sbiwd`e% De ?==<" Xw`ecqibb
h`nndxxd`ecg T`sA`v w` h`egshw i xsrvct dew` wlc c|}crdcehcx `f vdhwdnx `f
l`n`}l`odh hrdncx% I kct fdegdea qix wliw `ec de fdvc bcxodie ieg ait }c`}bc livc
c|}crdcehcg i l`n`}l`odh liwc hrdnc `r dehdgcew de wlc bixw wlrcc tcirx% @ec de cdalw
livc occe i vdhwdn de wlc bixw tcir% @ec de f`sr `f wl`xc c|}crdcehdea liwc hrdncx `r
dehdgcewx rc}`rwcg wlcn w` wlc }`bdhc" qldbc `ebt xd| }cr hcew rc}`rwcg wlcn w` wldrg
}irwdcx%9
L`n`}l`odh liwc hrdnc% Wlc Ait Ordwdxl Hrdnc Xsrvct ?==< ihhcxxcg vdi:
lww}:qqq%xw`ecqibb%`ra%skg`hsncewxrcvdxcgPliwcPhrdncP}gfPjiecP?=99P9%}gf
6%9= Wldx xwsgt ieg `wlcrx livc ibx` f`seg wliw BAOW }c`}bc frcyscewbt
c|}crdcehc gdxhrdndeiwd`e `r dbb wrciwncew de cn}b`tncew ieg wlc }r`vdxd`e `f
xcrvdhcx% Fr`n osbbtdea iw xhl``b" w` }``r wrciwncew ot lcibwl }r`fcxxd`eibx" wlc
}`bdhc" l`sxdea ixx`hdiwd`ex ieg dexsriehc }r`vdgcrx" niet BAOW }c`}bc livc rcix`e
w` ocbdcvc wliw wlct livc e`w c|}crdcehcg cysib wrciwncew" ieg h`nc w` c|}chw wliw
wlct qdbb c|}crdcehc fsrwlcr gdxhrdndeiwd`e ieg iosxc% Wlcxc c|}crdcehcx ieg
c|}chwiwd`ex hie livc ie cffchw `e wlc qit de qldhl BAOW }c`}bc rcihw de hcrwide
xdwsiwd`ex% Wlct nit oc seqdbbdea w` gdxhb`xc wlcdr xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `r acegcr
dgcewdwt" ieg nit ldgc fihwx qldhl q`sbg nikc dw hbcir% Wlct nit oc seqdbbdea w`
rc}`rw iwwihkx w` wlc }`bdhc" ix wlct g` e`w c|}chw wlcn w` oc wikce xcrd`sxbt" `r fcir
gdxhrdndeiw`rt wrciwncew fr`n wlc }`bdhc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 80/206
H`nn`e ixxsn}wd`ex
6%99 Dw dx e`w wlc hixc wliw BAOW }c`}bc irc iet n`rc bdkcbt w` oc }r`ndxhs`sx wlie
wlcdr lcwcr`xc|sib h`sewcr}irwx% X`nc BAOW }c`}bc irc }r`ndxhs`sx" `wlcr BAOW
nce ieg q`nce qdbb oc de b`ea.wcrn rcbiwd`exld}x" ieg `wlcrx irc hcbdoiwc%
6%9? Xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e dx e w xdn}bt gcfdecg ot i }crx`e—x xc|sib oclivd`sr% I
}crx`e nit dgcewdft ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf ix ait `r bcxodie qdwl`sw livdea lig iet xinc.
xc| xc|sib c|}crdcehc% Odxc|sib }c`}bc" de }irwdhsbir" nit oc de b`ea.wcrn
rcbiwd`exld}x qdwl i ncnocr `f wlc xinc `r wlc `wlcr xc|" ieg xwdbb rcwide wlcdr odxc|sib
dgcewdwt%
6%98 Dw dx ndxasdgcg w` iwwrdoswc fcndedec hlirihwcrdxwdhx w` ait nce" `r nixhsbdec
hlirihwcrdxwdhx w` bcxodiex% Xshl iwwrdoswd`ex irc e`w `ebt `ffcexdvc osw hie bcig w`
fsrwlcr deh`rrchw ixxsn}wd`ex" f`r c|in}bc wliw i bcxodie nit oc ocwwcr iobc w` gcfceg
lcrxcbf de i l`xwdbc xdwsiwd`e" nit oc n`rc iobc w` fdalw `ff xc|sib iwwihk `r qdbb oc
n`rc rcxdbdcew w` lirixxncew wlie i lcwcr`xc|sib h`sewcr}irw%
6%97 Wlcrc dx e` xwr`ea h`eechwd`e ocwqcce wriexacegcr xwiwsx ieg xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e% Wriexxc|sib" wriexvcxwdwc ieg `wlcr wriexacegcr }c`}bc hie oc xwridalw"
ait" bcxodie r odxc|sib%
6%93 De hixcx `f ri}c `f i nibc ot i nibc" deh`rrchw ixxsn}wd`ex nit oc nigc
io`sw wlc xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `f o`wl vdhwdn ieg }cr}cwriw`r% I xwsgt de wlc Sedwcg
Xwiwcx9
f`seg wliw libf `f ibb }cr}cwriw`rx `f ri}c `f nce livc lig h`excexsib xc|sib
ceh`sewcrx `ebt qdwl q`nce" ieg ie iggdwd`eib 8<# qdwl o`wl nce ieg q`nce% Iw
bcixw libf `f ibb rc}`rwdea vdhwdnx `f nibc ri}c dgcewdft wlcnxcbvcx ix h`n}bcwcbt
lcwcr`xc|sib%
9Ar`wl" I%" cw ib" Nibc _i}c: @ffcegcrx ieg Vdhwdnx" Incrdhie J`sreib f ]xthldiwrt" 981,1$"
}}%<=6.<9=" 94<=%
6%96 Wlcrc dx e` cvdgcehc wliw ocdea ait dn}bdcx i }r`}cexdwt w` h`nndw iet
}irwdhsbir wt}c `f hrdnc% I h`nn`e ieg c|wrcncbt ffcexdvc" xwcrc`wt}c bdekx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 81/206
l`n`xc|sibdwt qdwl i }icg`}ldbc `rdcewiwd`e% Nshl xc|sib iosxc f hldbgrce li}}cex
de wlc l`nc" dx h`nndwwcg ot x`nc`ec wlc hldbg ke`qx qcbb" ieg dx e`w acegcr.
x}chdfdh% Wlcrc dx e` cvdgcehc wliw ait nce irc n`rc bdkcbt w` iosxc hldbgrce wlie
lcwcr`xc|sib nce%
6%91 LDV dx x}rcig ot se}r`wchwcg xc| ieg ob``g.w`.ob``g h`ewihw ,c%a%
wriexfsxd`ex" xlirdea eccgbcx$% Qldbc niet dedwdib hixcx `f LDV de Ordwide qcrc
in`ea ait nce" xc| ocwqcce i nie ieg i q`nie dx e`q wlc fixwcxw ar`qdea hisxc `f
ecq defchwd`ex de Xh`wbieg" ieg q`rbgqdgc" wlc vixw nij`rdwt `f LDV defchwd`ex irc
wriexndwwcg wlr`sal xc| ocwqcce i nie ieg i q`nie%
6%9< I h`nn`ebt.lcbg xwcrc`wt}c dx wliw l`n`xc|sib rcbiwd`exld}x bihk
h`nndwncew ieg fdgcbdwt% Wldx xwcrc`wt}c dx deihhsriwc ix hie oc xcce ot wlc
dehrcixdea esnocrx `f gdv`rhc ocwqcce lcwcr`xc|sib h`s}bcx ieg wlc dehrcixdea
esnocrx `f hdvdb }irwecrxld}x% Livdea xidg wliw" x`nc l`n`xc|sib rcbiwd`exld}x g` e`w
cnsbiwc wlc h`nn`e fciwsrcx `f i lcwcr`xc|sib }irwecrxld}% Jsgacx xl`sbg oc ndegfsb
`f wldx ieg xl`sbg rcfride fr`n isw`niwdhibbt iwwrdoswdea }rdehd}bcx h`nn`ebt fciwsrcg
de lcwcr`xc|sib nirrdiacx%
WLC BCAIB H@EWC\W
Wlc biq rcbiwdea w` xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ieg acegcr dgcewdwt dx hlieadea ri}dgbt% Wldx
xchwd`e }r`vdgcx i xei}xl`w iw wlc wdnc `f qrdwdea" qdwl degdhiwd`ex `f }`xxdobc
gcvcb`}ncewx%
6%?= Wlc SK A`vcrencew!x Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9= dehbsgcx wlc }r`wchwcg
hlirihwcrdxwdhx `f acegcr rcixxdaencew" hdvdb }irwecrxld} ieg xc| ieg xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e% Dw xcwx `sw wlc rdalwx wliw }c`}bc qdwl wlcxc hlirihwcrdxwdhx livc w` oc
}r`wchwcg fr`n gdxhrdndeiwd`e de ircix xshl ix cn}b`tncew" cgshiwd`e" }r`vdxd`e `f
a``gx ieg xcrvdhcx ieg wlc c|crhdxc `f }sobdh fsehwd`ex% Dw rc}bihcx }rcvd`sx BAOW
cysibdwt bcadxbiwd`e dehbsgdea wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ,Xc|sib @rdcewiwd`e$ _casbiwd`ex ?==1
ieg wlc Cn}b`tncew Cysibdwt ,Xc|sib @rdcewiwd`e$ _casbiwd`ex ?==8%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 82/206
Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944< ieg Xh`wbieg Ihw 944<
6%?9 Segcr wlc Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944<" }sobdh iswl`rdwdcx nsxw e`w ihw de i nieecr
qldhl dx deh`n}iwdobc qdwl wlc Csr`}cie H`evcewd`e `e Lsnie _dalwx9" sebcxx" ix i
rcxsbw `f `ec `r n`rc }r`vdxd`ex `f }rdnirt bcadxbiwd`e" wlc iswl`rdwt h`sbg e`w livc
ihwcg gdffcrcewbt%?
]rdnirt bcadxbiwd`e nsxw oc dewcr}rcwcg" df }`xxdobc" de i qit qldhl
dx h`n}iwdobc qdwl wlc H`evcewd`e%8
Segcr wlc Xh`wbieg Ihw 944<" Xh`wwdxl
]irbdincew bcadxbiwd`e dx e`w biq de x` fir ix dw dx deh`n}iwdobc qdwl wlc H`evcewd`e%7
9Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944<" x% 6,9$%
? Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944<" x% 6,?$%
8 Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944<" x% 8,9$%7 Xh`wbieg Ihw 944<" x% ?4,?$,g$%
6%?? Irwdhbc 97 `f wlc H`evcewd`e }r`ldodwx gdxhrdndeiwd`e de wlc cej`tncew `f wlc
`wlcr H`evcewd`e rdalwx% Ibwl`sal xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e dx e`w c|}bdhdwbt dehbsgcg de
irwdhbc 97" wlc Csr`}cie H`srw `f Lsnie _dalwx lix rsbcg wliw wlc irwdhbc g`cx i}}bt
w` gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e ar`segx `f xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e%9
Xibasdcr` gi Xdbvi N`swi v ]`rwsaib ,?==9$ Fin B_ ?%
6%?8 Xinc xc| h`s}bcx e`q livc ie cegsrdea rdalw w` rcx}chw f`r findbt bdfc segcr
g`ncxwdh biq ix qcbb ix Irwdhbc < ieg }rcvd`sx hixcx oixcg `e wldx irwdhbc iwwihkdea
biqx h`ehcredea wlc xihkdea `f ait ieg bcxodie irncg f`rhcx }crx`eecb9
ieg w` biqx
wrciwdea xinc xc| ieg nd|cg xc| h`liodwdea h`s}bcx gdffcrcewbt?" irc e`q biracbt
ldxw`rdhib" ibocdw `f arciw xdaedfdhiehc% Wlc xwiwc lix i }`xdwdvc gswt w` xs}}`rw ieg
}r`n`wc findbt bdfc de ibb dwx gdvcrxc f`rnx%
89Xndwl ieg Arigt v SK ,9444$ ?4 C%L%_%_% 748%
? Kirecr v Isxwrdi ,?==7$ 8< C%L%_%_% ?7%
6%?7 Irwdhbcx < ieg 9? ,wlc rdalw w` nirrt$ `f wlc H`evcewd`e f`rncg wlc oixdx `f i
xshhcxxfsb hlibbceac iw wlc Csr`}cie H`srw `f Lsnie _dalwx `e wlc bcaib }`xdwd`e `f
wriexxc|sib }c`}bc de wlc SK%9
W` advc cffchw w` wlcxc jsgancewx" wlc Acegcr
_ch`aedwd`e Ihw ?==7 qix ceihwcg ot wlc SK ]irbdincew%?
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 83/206
9 A``gqde v SK ,?==?$ 83 C%L%_%_% 9< ieg D v SK ,?==8$ 86 C%L%_%_% 38%
?xcc }irix 6%?7 w` 6%?6%
]sobdh }`bdht
6%?3 ]sobdh }`bdht qdwl rcx}chw w` BAOW }c`}bc de Xh wbieg dx hlieadea% Wlc
Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew ieg `wlcr }sobdh o`gdcx livc rch`aedxcg wlc eccg w` iv`dg
gdxhrdndeiwd`e de }sobdh xcrvdhcx iaidexw BAOW }c`}bc"9
ieg xshl gdxhrdndeiwd`e dx
e`q sebiqfsb%?
9F`r c|in}bc" x% 3,?$ `f wlc Xwiegirgx de Xh`wbieg—x Xhl``bx cwh% Ihw ?===; xx% 9 ieg 78 `f wlc
_casbiwd`e `f Hirc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==9; x% 9=6 `f wlc L`sxdea ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==9%
?Cysibdwt Ihw ,Xc|sib @rdcewiwd`e$ _casbiwd`ex ?==1 ,X%D% ?==19?68$
Acegcr rch`aedwd`e
6%?6 Wlc Acegcr _ch`aedwd`e Ihw ?==7 }r`vdgcx i }r`hcxx w` ibb`q i wriexxc|sib
}crx`e w` `owide bcaib rch`aedwd`e `f ldx `r lcr xcbf.}crhcdvcg acegcr ,wlc `}}`xdwc w`
wlc }crx`e—x `rdadeib odrwl hcrwdfdhiwc acegcr$% Acegcr rch`aedwd`e dx ividbiobc w` i
}crx`e ql` lix i ncgdhib gdiae`xdx `f wriexxc|sibdwt ,acegcr gtx}l`rdi$" ieg ql` lix
bdvcg ix wlcdr xcbf.}crhcdvcg acegcr f`r iw bcixw wq` tcirx ieg dewcegx w` g` x`
}crniecewbt% Wt}dhibbt" i wriexxc|sib }crx`e qdbb iw x`nc } dew de ldx `r lcr bdfc wikc
wlc gchdxd`e w` nikc wlc ‒wriexdwd`e„ ‘ wliw dx" w` xwirw w` bdvc }crniecewbt de wlc xcbf.
}crhcdvcg acegcr% Ir`seg wlc xinc wdnc" wlc }crx`e nit xwirw i h`srxc `f ncgdhib
wrciwncew ke`qe ix acegcr rcixxdaencew" qldhl nit dehbsgc l`rn`ec wrciwncew ieg
xsracrt" w` ibwcr }ltxdhib hlirihwcrdxwdhx `f xc|% I ndednsn f wq` tcirx ifwcr
nikdea wlc wriexdwd`e" wlc }crx`e nit i}}bt f`r acegcr rch`aedwd`e ieg" `e wlc dxxsdea
`f i acegcr rch`aedwd`e hcrwdfdhiwc" wlc }crx`e—x bcaib acegcr hlieacx f`r ibb }sr}`xcx%
I rc}bihcncew odrwl hcrwdfdhiwc dx dxxscg" de wlc ecq einc ieg acegcr% Dw dx e`w
echcxxirt f`r i }crx`e w` livc segcra`ec iet acegcr rcixxdaencew wrciwncew w`
ysibdft f`r acegcr rch`aedwd`e" x` wlc }crx`e—x }ltxdhib hlirihwcrdxwdhx nit e`w
h`rrcx}`eg fsbbt qdwl ldx `r lcr ecqbt rch`aedxcg acegcr%
6%?1 @ehc i wriexxc|sib }crx`e lix nigc wlc wriexdwd`e" lc `r xlc hie `owide
g`hsncewx xshl ix i grdvdea bdhcehc ieg }ixx}`rw de wlc ecq einc ieg acegcr" cvce
wl`sal" iw wliw xwiac" wlc }crx`e—x bcaib acegcr rcnidex wlc `rdadeibbt rcadxwcrcg
acegcr% Dw dx a``g }rihwdhc w` wrciw xshl i }crx`e ix ocdea `f wlc hlieacg acegcr
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 84/206
c|hc}w qlcrc wlc biq rcysdrcx `wlcrqdxc% Ifwcr acegcr rch`aedwd`e dx `owidecg" wlc
}crx`e xl`sbg oc wrciwcg ix wlcdr ecqbt rch`aedxcg acegcr" f`r ibb }sr}`xcx%
Hrdndeib biq
6%?< F`bb`qdea rchcew hlieacx w` xc|sib `ffcehcx biq" xchwd`e 9 `f wlc Xc|sib
@ffcehcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==4 qdgcex wlc gcfdedwd`e `f ri}c w` dehbsgc }cecwriwd`e `f
wlc }cedx dew` wlc viadei" iesx `r n`swl `f ie`wlcr }crx`e% Wldx xchwd`e rc}bihcx wlc
h`nn`e biq `ffcehc `f ri}c" qldhl dx rcxwrdhwcg w` viadeib }cecwriwd`e" qdwl i qdgcr
`ffcehc h`vcrdea viadeib" ieib ieg `rib }cecwriwd`e% Ix xshl" dw h`vcrx h`egshw qldhl
q`sbg }rcvd`sxbt livc occe }r`xchswcg sxdea wlc h`nn`e biq `ffcehcx `f degchcew
ixxisbw ieg x`g`nt ieg" sebdkc wlc h`nn`e biq `ffcehc `f ri}c" h`vcrx o`wl fcnibc
ieg nibc vdhwdnx% Dw xl`sbg oc rch`aedxcg wliw niet `f wlc cffchwx `f wlc e`e.
h`excexsib }cecwriwd`e `f i nie `r i wriexxc|sib q`nie irc ix wrisniwdxdea ix wlc
ri}c `f i fcnibc vdhwdn% Wlcrc nit oc x}chdfdh gdffdhsbwdcx f`r BAOW vdhwdnx `f
xc|sib iwwihkx rcbiwdea w` wlcdr ieg `wlcrx— }crhc}wd`e `f wlcdr xc|sibdwt%
6%?4 Dxxscx `f xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `r acegcr dgcewdwt nit ibx` irdxc de hrdndeib
}r`hccgdeax qlce ie BAOW }crx`e dx wlc wiracw `f hrdnc ochisxc `f wlcdr `rdcewiwd`e
`r dgcewdwt% Iewd.x`hdib oclivd`sr ieg lirixxncew irc h`nn`e" ieg hrdncx `f liwrcg
iaidexw BAOW }c`}bc rieac fr`n vcroib iwwihkx" wlr`sal xc|sib `r `wlcr ixxisbw" w`
nsrgcr%9
Wlc @ffcehcx ,Iaariviwd`e ot ]rcjsgdhc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==4 hinc dew`
cffchw `e ?7 Nirhl ?=9=" ieg c|wcegx }r`wchwd`e ibrcigt de }bihc f`r vdhwdnx `f hrdnc
n`wdviwcg ot rihdib `r rcbdad`sx }rcjsgdhc w` h`vcr BAOW ieg gdxiobcg }c`}bc oixcg
`e wlc vdhwdn!x ihwsib `r }rcxsncg xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ,qlcwlcr l`n`xc|sib" odxc|sib
`r lcwcr`xc|sib$" wriexacegcr dgcewdwt `r gdxiodbdwt%
9‒C|}crdcehcx ieg }crhc}wd`ex `f vd`bcehc ieg dewdndgiwd`e `f wlc bcxodie" ait" odxc|sib" ieg
wriexacegcr h`nnsedwdcx de Cgdeosral% I _c}`rw f`r wlc Hdwt `f Cgdeosral H`sehdb!x
H`nnsedwt Xifcwt Sedw„" 9444" N`dri ]biew" Nirwde ]biew" Odbb Nix`e" Hlrdxwdec Wl`rew `e"
Ibh`l`b & Lcibwl _cxcirhl Hcewrc" Cgdeosral%
6%8= Xchwd`e ? xwiwcx wliw Ie `ffcehc dx iaariviwcg ot }rcjsgdhc rcbiwdea w` xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e `r wriexacegcr dgcewdwt df ‗
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 85/206
,i$ iw wlc wdnc `f h`nndwwdea wlc `ffcehc `r dnncgdiwcbt ocf`rc `r ifwcr g`dea
x`" wlc `ffcegcr cvdehcx w`qirgx wlc vdhwdn ,df iet$ `f wlc `ffcehc nibdhc ieg
dbb.qdbb rcbiwdea w ‗
,d$ wlc xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ,`r }rcxsncg xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e$ `f wlc vdhwdn" `r
,dd$ wlc wriexacegcr dgcewdwt ,`r }rcxsncg wriexacegcr dgcewdwt$ `f wlc vdhwdn
Findbt biq
6%89 Sewdb rchcewbt" wlc biq gdg e`w rch`aedxc wliw wq` }c`}bc `f wlc xinc xc| nit
f`rn b`ea.wcrn rcbiwd`exld}x ieg findbt sedwx" qdwl r qdwl`sw hldbgrce% Wlc Hdvdb
]irwecrxld} Ihw ?==7 lix rigdhibbt ibwcrcg wlc bcaib }`xdwd`e" f`r xinc xc| h`s}bcx%
E`q xinc.xc| h`s}bcx hie rcadxwcr i hdvdb }irwecrxld}" wlr`sal i }r`hcxx cffchwdvcbt
dgcewdhib w` hdvdb rcadxwriwd`e `f i nirrdiac% Wlc bcaib cffchwx f hdvdb }irwecrxld} irc
cffchwdvcbt dgcewdhib w` wl`xc `f nirrdiac% De iggdwd`e" ibb xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex f`r
nd|cg.xc| h`liodwiewx" bdvdea w`acwlcr ix lsxoieg ieg qdfc" livc e`q occe c|wcegcg
w` i}}bt ibx` w` h`s}bcx `f wlc xinc xc| bdvdea w`acwlcr ix df wlct qcrc hdvdb }irwecrx%
Dw }r`vdgcx f`r gdv`rhc sxdea wlc wcrn “gdxx`bswd`e— de i xdndbir qit ix nirrdiac%
6%8? Wlc Lsnie Fcrwdbdxiwd`e ieg Cnort`b`at Ihw ?==< i}}bdcx w` o`wl
l`n`xc|sib ieg lcwcr`xc|sib h`s}bcx ql` h`ehcdvc qdwl wlc lcb} `f g`e`r x}crn `r
cnort`x% E`q" hdvdb }irwecrx irc advce wlc xinc rdalwx ix nirrdcg h`s}bcx ieg xinc
xc| h`liodwiewx livc wlc xinc rdalwx ix lcwcr`xc|sib h`liodwiewx% Wlsx fr`n wlc
n`ncew `f h`ehc}wd`e" xinc xc| h`s}bcx ,dehbsgdea hdvdb }irwecrx$ irc bcaibbt
rch`aedxcg ix }ircewx `f i hldbg h`ehcdvcg gsrdea wlcdr rcbiwd`exld}%
6%88 I wriexxc|sib }crx`e ql` lix `owidecg acegcr rch`aedwd`e dx frcc w` nirrt i
}crx`e `f wlc `}}`xdwc xc|" `r w` cewcr i hdvdb }irwecrxld} qdwl i }crx`e `f wlc xinc
xc|" ix wlcdr ecqbt rch`aedxcg xc|% I wriexxc|sib }crx`e ql` dx nirrdcg `r de i hdvdb
}irwecrxld} iw wlc wdnc `f i}}bdhiwd`e f`r acegcr rch`aedwd`e nsxw gdxx`bvc wliw
nirrdiac `r hdvdb }irwecrxld} ocf`rc i fsbb acegcr rch`aedwd`e hcrwdfdhiwc hie oc dxxscg%
Wlc }crx`e nit wlce cewcr i ecq hdvdb }irwecrxld} `r nirrdiac qdwl ldx `r lcr f`rncr
x}`sxc `r hdvdb }irwecr%
6%87 I xdaedfdhiew nde`rdwt `f BAOW }c`}bc livc hldbgrce ieg wldx lig occe nigc
cixdcr ot wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc Ig`}wd`e ieg Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==1% E`q
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 86/206
h`liodwdea xinc.xc| h`s}bcx ql` irc de /ie cegsrdea findbt rcbiwd`exld}/ qdbb oc iobc
w` i}}bt w` j`dewbt ig`}w i hldbg%9
Wlc biq rcairgx wlc hdvdb }irwecr `f i }ircew `f i
hldbg ix wlc xwc}.}ircew `f wlc hldbg"?
ieg segcr wlc ?==1 Ihw" wlc hdvdb }irwecr `r
h`liodwdea xinc.xc| }irwecr `f i }ircew `f i hldbg hie i}}bt w` ig`}w wliw hldbg%8
Ibwcreiwdvcbt" i xinc.xc| }irwecr `f i }ircew nit i}}bt w` h`srw f`r }ircewib rdalwx
ieg rcx}`exdodbdwdcx f`r wliw }ircew—x hldbgrce% ]ircewib dxxscx dev`bvdea BAOW }c`}bc
ibx` irdxc de rcbiwd`e w` orcikg`qe `f hdvdb }irwecrxld}" nirrdiac `r `wlcr rcbiwd`exld}%
Wlc Xibascdr` gi Xdbvi N`swi7
hixc xsaacxwx wliw irwdhbcx < ieg 97 `f wlc Csr`}cie
H`evcewd`e nit oc dev`kcg w` }rcvcew gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e ar`segx `f xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e de h`srw `rgcrx rcbiwdea w` }ircewib rcx}`exdodbdwdcx ieg rdalwx" rcxdgcehc
ieg h`ewihw%3
9 Ig`}wd`e ieg Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==1" x% ?4%
? Hdvdb ]irwecrxld} Ihw ?==7" x% ?76%
8 Ig`}wd`e ieg Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==1" x% 8=,8$%
?7 ,?==9$ Fin B_ ?%
8 3 Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" x% 99%
6%83 Wlc }r`wchwd`ex fr`n g`ncxwdh iosxc }r`vdgcg w` nirrdcg }crx`ex ieg wlcdr
hldbgrce ot wlc Niwrdn`edib L`ncx ,Findbt ]r`wchwd`e$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 94<9 irc
rc}bdhiwcg f`r hdvdb }irwecrxld} ot wlc Hdvdb ]irwecrxld} Ihw ?==7%9
Wlc Findbt Biq
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==6 }r`vdgcx wliw wlc }r`wchwd`ex f`r i h`liodwdea }irwecrx ieg wlcdr
hldbgrce" segcr wlc Niwrdn`edib L`ncx Ihw" i}}bt w` xinc.xc| ieg nd|cg.xc|
h`liodwiwd`e%?
9Hdvdb ]irwecrxld} Ihw ?==7" xx% 9=9 w` 998%
? Findbt Biq ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==6" xx% 89 ieg 87%
Iewd.gdxhrdndeiwd`e biq
6%86 Wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9= oiex gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e wlc ar`segx `f xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e de cn}b`tncew ieg v`hiwd`eib wridedea% Wldx bcadxbiwd`e x}chdfdhibbt oiex
gdrchw ieg degdrchw gdxhrdndeiwd`e" lirixxncew ieg vdhwdndxiwd`e ochisxc `f xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e% Ihh`rgdea w` wlc Cysibdwt Ihw" wrciwdea }c`}bc bcxx fiv`sriobt wlie `wlcrx
`e ar`segx `f xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e h`exwdwswcx gdrchw gdxhrdndeiwd`e ieg degdrchwgdxhrdndeiwd`e nciex i}}btdea i }r`vdxd`e" hrdwcrd`e `r }rihwdhc qldhl gdxigviewiacx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 87/206
}c`}bc `f i }irwdhsbir xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ieg qldhl dx e`w jsxwdfdcg ix i }r`}`rwd`eiwc
nciex `f ihldcvdea i bcadwdniwc a`ib%
Lirixxncew dx gcfdecg ix seqiewcg h`egshw wliw vd`biwcx }c`}bc—x gdaedwt `r hrciwcx
ie dewdndgiwdea" l`xwdbc" gcarigdea" lsndbdiwdea `r `ffcexdvc cevdr`encew%
Ecq bcadxbiwd`e }r`vdgcx }r`wchwd`e w` bcxodie" ait ieg odxc|sib q`rkcrx wlr`sal`sw
wlc cewdrc cn}b`tncew rcbiwd`exld} ‘ fr`n rchrsdwncew w` gdxndxxib wlr`sal`sw wlc
SK% Wlc oie `e xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e gdxhrdndeiwd`e i}}bdcx w` wcrnx ieg h`egdwd`ex"
}it" }r`n`wd`ex" wriexfcrx" wridedea ieg gdxndxxib%
Wlc Cysibdwt Ihw }r`wchwd`e c|wcegx w` gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e wlc ar`segx `f xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e rcairgbcxx `f qlcwlcr i }crx`e—x xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e dx w`qirgx }c`}bc `f
wlc xinc xc|" wlc `}}`xdwc xc| `r o`wl xc|cx% Wlc biq }r`wchwx ibb }c`}bc fr`n xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e gdxhrdndeiwd`e: bcxodiex" ait nce" odxc|sibx ieg lcwcr`xc|sibxxwridalw
}c`}bc%
Wlc ecq bcadxbiwd`e g`cxe—w `ebt }r`wchw }c`}bc fr`n gdxhrdndeiwd`e oixcg `e wlcdr
ihwsib xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e% Gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e wlc ar`segx `f ixxsncg `r }crhcdvcg
xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e dx ibx` oieecg ieg dw dx e`w dn}`rwiew qlcwlcr i }crx`e—x xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e dx ixxsncg h`rrchwbt `r deh`rrchwbt%
Wlc biq ibx` }r`wchwx wl`xc }c`}bc ql` irc gdxhrdndeiwcg iaidexw ochisxc `f wlc
xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e `f wlc }c`}bc qdwl ql`n wlct ixx`hdiwc ‘ wlcdr findbt ncnocrx ieg
frdcegx%
DXXSCX @F ]_IHWDHC
6%81 Cysib wrciwncew rcysdrcx wliw h`srwx ieg wrdoseibx i}}bt }rdehd}bcx `f cysibdwt
ieg fidrecxx qlcrcvcr }`xxdobc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 88/206
6%8< BAOW }c`}bc fihc i gidbt gdbcnni ‘ qlcwlcr w` oc `}ce io`sw wlcdr xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e `r acegcr dgcewdwt" ieg rdxk }rcjsgdhc" gdxhrdndeiwd`e ieg wlc igvcrxc
jsgacncewx `f `wlcrx" `r w` kcc} wlc dxxsc ldggce ieg fihc ihhsxiwd`ex `f h`vcr.s}"
gdxl`ecxwt" ieg i bihk `f hieg`sr% Niet BAOW }c`}bc irc gcc}bt fcirfsb f wlc
h`excyscehcx `f ‒h`ndea `sw„% Jsgacx xl`sbg oc iqirc wliw wlcxc fihw`rx nit }bihc
iggdwd`eib osrgcex e BAOW qdwecxxcx" h`n}bidecrx ieg ihhsxcg" ieg xl`sbg h`exdgcr
qliw ncixsrcx ndalw oc ividbiobc w` h`sewcrihw wlcn%
6%84 Dw dx e`w ibqitx cixt w` dgcewdft ieg iv`dg xwcrc`wt}dhib ixxsn}wd`ex% I
xwcrc`wt}c dx e`wldea n`rc wlie i ncewib xl`rw.hsw" bcigdea w` acecribdxcg c|}chwiwd`ex
io`sw hlirihwcr" ieg }rcgdhwd`ex io`sw oclivd`sr" qdwl`sw wlc cff`rw `f `owidedea ieg
ixxcxxdea ihhsriwc ieg gdrchw def`rniwd`e io`sw wlc }crx`e" }c`}bc `r xdwsiwd`e% Dw dx
`fwce xcbf.xsxwidedea ieg rdadg% Dw dx rcxdxwiew w` h`ewrirt cvdgcehc% Dw hie defbscehc
jsgacncew ieg hisxc dejsxwdhcx% W` oc xwcrc`wt}cg `e wlc oixdx `f xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e
`r acegcr dgcewdwt dx jsxw ix `ffcexdvc ix w` oc xwcrc`wt}cg `e wlc oixdx `f h`b`sr%
H`excyscewbt" jsgacx nsxw oc iqirc `f wlc lirn g`ec w` }c`}bc" ieg w` wlc rc}swiwd`e
`f wlc jsgdhdib xtxwcn" ot xwcrc`wt}dhib ixxsn}wd`ex ieg l`ncx}se wlc`rdcx ir`seg wlc
dxxscx `f xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ieg acegcr dgcewdwt%
6%7= Dw dx }irwdhsbirbt dn}`rwiew w` oc qirt `f ixxsn}wd`ex io`sw i }crx`e—x xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e `r acegcr dgcewdwt oixcg `e wlcdr i}}ciriehc `r oclivd`sr% F`r c|in}bc"
xc|sib ihwdvdwt `f i }irwdhsbir kdeg dx e`w ie degdhiw`r `f i }crx`e—x xcbf .}crhcdvcg
xc|sib rdcewiwd`e%
6%79 Wlc bcaib rch`aedwd`e `f ibwcreiwdvc findbt f`rnx" f`r c|in}bc findbdcx lcigcg
ot i xinc.xc| h`s}bc" g`cx e`w segcrndec wlc dexwdwswd`e `f nirrdiac% Wlc xsaacxwd`e
wliw dw g`cx gc}cegx `e ihhc}wiehc `f wlc }r`}`xdwd`e wliw w` }r`n`wc wlc rdalwx `f `ec
hiwca`rt f hdwdzce echcxxirdbt segcrndecx wl`xc `f ie`wlcr% Wliw irasncew q`sbg
xccn hsrd`sx df i}}bdcg w` wlc rdalwx `f q`nce vcrxsx nce" `r w` wlc rdalwx `f i rihdib
nde`rdwt vcrxsx wlc nij`rdwt% De }r`n`wdea x`hdib xwiodbdwt" wlc h`srwx irc dehrcixdeabt
ixkcg w` rch`aedxc gdvcrxdwt% Wlc `ec g`cx e`w }rchbsgc wlc `wlcr%
6%7? Qlce h`srwx h`nc dew` h`ewihw qdwl wriexxc|sib `r wriexvcxwdwc }c`}bc" wlc
rcysdrcncewx `f wlc biq nit h`efbdhw qdwl wlc eccgx ieg dewcrcxwx `f wlc }crx`e
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 89/206
dev`bvcg% Qlcrcvcr }`xxdobc" l`qcvcr" i wriexacegcr }crx`e xl`sbg oc wrciwcg"
dgcewdfdcg ieg iggrcxxcg de ihh`rgiehc qdwl wlcdr xcbf.dgcewdfdcg acegcr%
6%78 ]rdx`e ihh`nn`giwd`e ridxcx x}chdfdh dxxscx f`r wriexacegcr }c`}bc%
Wriexxc|sib }c`}bc ql` livc `owidecg acegcr rch`aedwd`e qdbb oc }bihcg de i }rdx`e
i}}r`}rdiwc w` wlcdr rch`aedxcg acegcr% Wriexxc|sib }c`}bc ql` livc nigc wlc
wriexdwd`e" osw livc e`w tcw `owidecg acegcr rch`aedwd`e" nit oc }bihcg de i }rdx`e
i}}r`}rdiwc w` wlcdr `rdadeibbt rcadxwcrcg acegcr% O`wl xdwsiwd`ex hie bcig w` }r`obcnx
rcbiwcg w` wlc rcihwd`ex `f `wlcr }rdx`ecrx" qldbc de wlc biwwcr hixc" }r`obcnx f`r wlc
}rdx`ecr qdbb oc h`n}`segcg ot ocdea wrciwcg ix wlc `}}`xdwc acegcr w` wlcdr
}crhcdvcg dgcewdwt%
H`egshw de h`srw
6%77 Jsgacx xl`sbg oc ibcrw w` rcxwride iet dewrsxdvc yscxwd`edea `f wlc xc|sib
`rdcewiwd`e `r acegcr dgcewdwt `f i qdwecxx" i bdwdaiew `r ie ihhsxcg }crx`e sebcxx dw dx
xwrdhwbt rcbcview w` rcib dxxscx de wlc hixc% Jsgacx xl`sbg ibx` oc qdbbdea w` sxc wlcdr
}`qcrx w` rcxwrdhw rc}`rwdea `f eincx ieg iggrcxxcx% De hrdndeib hixcx" iggrcxxcx nit
oc advce ix hirc `f wlc }`bdhc de `rgcr w` }r`wchw wlc dgcewdwt `f qdwecxxcx% De hdvdb
hixcx" iggrcxxcx nit oc advce ix hirc `f i x`bdhdw`r% De cihl wt}c `f hixc" ie iggrcxx
nit oc qrdwwce `e i }dchc `f }i}cr qldhl dx liegcg w` wlc ocehl%
6%73 Qlce gcibdea qdwl i}}ircew bihk `f hieg`sr" jsgacx xl`sbg rcncnocr wliw
ocdea BAOW dx ie degdvdgsib c|}crdcehc wliw nit livc bcg w` fcir `r h`ehcibncew% Dw
dx dn}`rwiew w` dgcewdft ieg rcjchw xwcrc wt}dea ix ie cvdgcewdib xl`rwhsw% Jsgacx
xl`sbg oc ibcrw w` x}`w wlc hixcx qlcrc sefidr wrciwncew nit irdxc" qdwl i vdcq w`
s}l`bgdea wlc rc}swiwd`e `f wlc jsxwdhc xtxwcn%
6%76 Wriexxc|sib }c`}bc qdbb sxsibbt i}}cir de h`srw ix wlcdr xcbf.dgcewdfdcg acegcr%
De x`nc hixcx" gdxhb`xsrc `f odrwl acegcr nit oc cxxcewdib f`r cvdgcewdib rcix`ex%
Wlcrc qdbb oc vcrt niet hixcx" l`qcvcr" qlcrc xshl gdxhb`xsrc dx e`w iox`bswcbt
echcxxirt" ieg" de iet cvcew" dw xl`sbg oc }`xxdobc w` ihhc}w wlc }crx`e—x i}}ircew
dgcewdwt f`r ecirbt ibb h`srw }sr}`xcx%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 90/206
6%71 Segcr xchwd`e ?? `f wlc Acegcr _ch`aedwd`e Ihw ?==7" dw dx ie `ffcehc f`r i
}crx`e ql` lix ihysdrcg def`rniwd`e de ie `ffdhdib hi}ihdwt" w` gdxhb`xc def`rniwd`e
io`sw ie i}}bdhiwd`e f`r acegcr rch`aedwd`e `r io`sw i }crx`e—x acegcr ocf`rc acegcr
rch`aedwd`e% Wlcrc dx ie c|hc}wd`e qlcrc wlc }crx e iarccx w` gdxhb`xsrc" `r qlcrc
gdxhb`xsrc dx f`r wlc }sr}`xcx f }r`hccgdeax ocf`rc wlc h`srw% Wlcrc nit oc
hdrhsnxwiehcx de qldhl dw dx echcxxirt w` h`exdgcr wlc nikdea `f ie `rgcr `f xchwd`e
7,?$ `f wlc H`ewcn}w `f H`srw Ihw 94<9 w` }rcxcrvc wlc ie`etndwt `f wlc h`n}bidecr
`r qdwecxx ql` f`r vird`sx rcix`ex g`cx e`w qdxl ldx `r lcr xc|sibdwt `r acegcr `r
xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e w` oc rc}`rwcg ot wlc ncgdi%
6%7< Dw dx sebdkcbt wliw i wriexvcxwdwc ql` hr`xx.grcxxcx de }rdviwc ieg x`ncwdncx de
}sobdh" qdbb hr`xx.grcxx de h`srw% Wldx nit e`w ibqitx oc wlc hixc" l`qcvcr% I gcxdrc
`r eccg w` hr`xx.grcxx nit oc i rcbcview ieg dn}`rwiew dxxsc" f`r c|in}bc de gdv`rhc
`r findbt }r`hccgdeax" `r ix wlc oihkar`seg w` ie `ffcehc `f vd`bcehc iaidexw wliw
}crx`e% F`r niet wriexvcxwdwcx" hr`xx.grcxxdea dx ie decxhi}iobc cn`wd`eib eccg"
qldhl" }irwdhsbirbt de }sobdh }bihcx" acecriwcx rdxk `f h`efbdhw `r rdgdhsbc% Jsgacx
xl`sbg cexsrc wliw ecaiwdvc defcrcehcx irc e`w griqe fr`n oclivd`sr wliw dx }crhcdvcg
ot `wlcrx ix }r`v`hiwdvc `r ldal.rdxk%
Sxc `f bieasiac
6%74 Sxc `f bieasiac dx i }irwdhsbirbt dn}`rwiew dxxsc% E` `ec lix wlc rdalw w` sxc
wlc h`srw ix i f`rsn f`r iosxc% Ix de `wlcr ircix `f }`wcewdib gdxhrdndeiwd`e" }c`}bc
dev`bvcg de wlc bcaib }r`hcxx xl`sbg" ix fir ix }`xxdobc" oc }r`wchwcg fr`n `ffcexdvc `r
hbsnxt biocbx" ieg xl`sbg oc ibb`qcg w` hl``xc wlcdr `qe bieasiac f`r gcxhrdodea
wlcdr xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e ieg acegcr dgcewdwt" ieg wlc eiwsrc `f wlcdr rcbiwd`exld} `r
g`ncxwdh irrieacncewx% Ie c|hc}wd`e w` wldx xl`sbg oc qlcrc `ec `f wlc dxxscx de wlc
hixc h`ehcrex wlc c|dxwcehc `f }rcjsgdhc ,f`r c|in}bc" qlcrc wlc h`srw h`exdgcrx wliw
wlc qdwecxx—x hl`dhc `f bieasiac dx rcbcview de ixxcxxdea wlc qdwecxx$%
6%3= Ix i oixdh }rdehd}bc" bieasiac sxcg w` `r io`sw BAOW }c`}bc xl`sbg rcfbchw
l`q wlct wlcnxcbvcx qdxl w` oc iggrcxxcg `r rcfcrrcg w`% Wldx i}}bdcx }irwdhsbirbt w`
wlc wdwbc ,c%a% Nr" Nx" cwh%$ ieg fdrxw ieg `wlcr eincx `f wriexacegcr }c`}bc" ix qcbb ix
wlc }crx`eib }r`e`se sxcg w` rcfcr w` wlcn% De wlc vixw nij`rdwt `f hdrhsnxwiehcx"
wlcrc qdbb oc e` eccg w` gdxhsxx wlc wriexacegcr xwiwsx `r iet f`rncr einc `f i
wriexacegcr }crx`e% Wlc }rdehd}bc `f ‒sxc }rcfcrrcg bieasiac„ ibx` i}}bdcx w` wlc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 91/206
q`rgx sxcg w` gcxhrdoc x`nc`ec—x xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e" ieg wlcdr rcbiwd`exld}x ieg
}irwecrx% @ovd`sxbt" df wlc hixc h`ehcrex wlc c|dxwcehc `f i }rcjsgdhcg iwwdwsgc" dw qdbb
oc echcxxirt w` iggrcxx wlc wcrnx de qldhl wldx iwwdwsgc qix c|}rcxxcg% Iet sxc `f
xshl bieasiac de ietwldea `wlcr wlie wldx h`ewc|w" ot iet`ec de h`srw" xl`sbg oc
rcxwridecg%
_CX@S_HCX IEG H@EWIHWX
: lww}:qqq%xw`ecqibb%`ra%sk
lww}:qqq%cysibdwt.ecwq`rk%`ra
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 92/206
Hli}wcr 1
]C_X@EX QDWL GDXIODBDWDCX
DEW_@GSHWD@E
Acecrib
1%9 Wldx hli}wcr gcibx qdwl }crx`ex h`ndea w` h`srw ql` livc i gdxiodbdwt% Wlc
wcrn “gdxiodbdwt— dx gcfdecg ot wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9= xchwd`e 6 ,9$ qldhl xwiwcx wliw i
}crx`e lix i gdxiodbdwt df wlc }crx`e lix i }ltxdhib `r ncewib dn}idrncew ieg wlc
dn}idrncew lix i xsoxwiewdib ieg b`ea.wcrn igvcrxc cffchw `e wlcdr iodbdwt w` hirrt `sw
e`rnib git.w`.git ihwdvdwdcx%
1%? _chcew fdasrcx }sobdxlcg degdhiwc wliw ecirbt `ec de fdvc }c`}bc `f q`rkdea iac
,9 ndbbd`e" `r 94#$ de Xh`wbieg irc gdxiobcg9
Dw dx dn}`rwiew" wlcrcf`rc" w` livc rcairg
w` wlc eccgx ieg h`ehcrex `f ncnocrx `f wldx ar`s} ql` livc w` h`nc w` h`srw%
9 Xcc lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%skW`}dhx]c`}bcCysibdwtgdxiodbdwt;
1%8 Acecribbt" yscxwd`ex c|}b`rdea i }crx`e—x gdxiodbdwt irc e`w i}}r`}rdiwc sebcxx
dw dx w` h`exdgcr qliw rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx xl`sbg oc nigc" `r dw dx rcbcview w` ie
dxxsc de wlc hixc%
Xwiwsw`rt gswdcx
1%7 Wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc ,XHX$ lix i xwiwsw`rt gswt w` h`n}bt qdwl wlcCysibdwt Ihw ?=9= qldhl rcysdrcx h`srwx w` wikc ihh`sew `f wlc eccgx `f }crx`ex qdwl
gdxiodbdwdcx de }r`vdgdea fihdbdwdcx ieg xcrvdhcx% Wlc XHX lix gswdcx de wcrnx `f ]irw DDD
`f wlc Ihw cewdwbcg “Xcrvdhcx ieg ]sobdh Fsehwd`ex—% Wlsx" wlcrc dx i gswt `e wlc XHX
w` iewdhd}iwc wlc eccgx `f gdxiobcg }c`}bc ieg nikc i}}r`}rdiwc rcix`eiobc
igjsxwncewx% F`r c|in}bc" df i qdwecxx dx gcif" wlc qdwecxx xl`sbg oc }r`vdgcg qdwl i
Ordwdxl Xdae Bieasiac Ceabdxl dewcr}rcwcr f`r wlcdr h`srw i}}ciriehc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 93/206
Gdxhrdndeiwd`e irdxdea fr`n Gdxiodbdwt
1%3 Xchwd`e 93 ,9$ `f wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9= xwiwcx wliw ,i$ wrciwdea i gdxiobcg
}crx`e bcxx fiv`sriobt ochisxc `f x`ncwldea irdxdea ix i h`excyscehc `f wliw
gdxiodbdwt dx gdxhrdndeiwd`e df ,o$ wlc }crx`e h`ehcrecg hiee`w xl`q wliw wlc wrciwncew
dx i }r`}`rwd`eiwc nciex `f ihldcvdea i bcadwdniwc idn% I rcx}`exc w` xchwd`e 93,9$,i$
dx wliw wlc }crx`e gdg e`w ieg h`sbg e`w rcix`eiobt livc occe c|}chwcg w` ke`q wliw
wlc }crx`e lig wlc gdxiodbdwt% Wlsx" wlc Ihw }bihcx i gswt `e wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw
Xcrvdhc w` cexsrc wliw wlc eccgx `f gdxiobcg degdvdgsibx irc h`exdgcrcg de igviehc%
Wlc jsgac nsxw h`exdgcr wlc eccgx `f cihl gdxiobcg }crx`e degdvdgsibbt% Gdxiobcg
}crx`ex dev`bvcg de wlc h`srw }r`hcxx nsxw oc ixxdxwcg w` ceaiac fsbbt de wlc }r`hcxx
`f ihldcvdea jsxwdhc% Cihl }crx`e ql` i}}cirx ocf`rc wlc h`srw qdwl i gdxiodbdwt nsxw
wlcrcf`rc oc wrciwcg ix ie degdvdgsib" qdwl x}chdfdh eccgx wliw irc }irwdhsbir w` wlcn%
Qlce ceysdrdea" wlc Jsgac xl`sbg ixk io`sw wlc eiwsrc `f wlc x}chdib eccg riwlcr wlie
wlc c|wcew `f wlc gdxiodbdwt% F`r c|in}bc" “Hie t`s lcir qliw dx ocdea xidg0— _iwlcr
wlie" “Irc t`s lirg `f lcirdea0—
Wlc jsgac xl`sbg `oxcrvc wl`xc xdwwdea de wlc h`srw w` cexsrc wliw wl`xc }irwdhd}iwdea de
wlc }r`hccgdeax irc iobc w` g` x` w` wlc fsbbcxw c|wcew% F`r c|in}bc" ie cbgcrbt }crx`e
nit eccg w` rcnide xciwcg qlce advdea cvdgcehc `r i lcirdea b``} xl`sbg oc `ffcrcg
qlcrc wlc }irwdhd}iew dx lirg `f lcirdea% Wlc jsgac xl`sbg c|}bdhdwbt xwiwc wliw df i
}r`obcn irdxcx gsrdea wlc }r`hccgdeax" wlce dw xl`sbg oc or`salw w` ldx `r lcr iwwcewd`e
ix x``e ix }`xxdobc%
Gswt w` nikc rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx
1%6 Segcr ]irw DDD `f wlc ?=9= Ihw dw dx sebiqfsb w` gdxhrdndeiwc iaidexw }crx`ex
qdwl i gdxiodbdwt de wlc }r`vdxd`e `f ihhcxx w` h`srwx% Wlc Ihw dn}`xcx i }`xdwdvc gswt
`e xcrvdhc }r`vdgcrx" xshl ix wlc XHX" w` nikc rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx w` nikc
fihdbdwdcx n`rc ihhcxxdobc w` gdxiobcg }c`}bc" qlcrc dw q`sbg `wlcrqdxc oc dn}`xxdobc
`r sercix`eiobt gdffdhsbw f`r wlc gdxiobcg }crx`e w` nikc sxc `f wlc xcrvdhc% Wlc gswt
dx `qcg w` gdxiobcg }crx`ex iw birac ieg e`w jsxw degdvdgsib gdxiobcg }crx`ex% Dw dx ie
iewdhd}iw`rt gswt" wlsx x}chdib irrieacncewx xl`sbg oc h`exdgcrcg de igviehc w` xivc
wdnc ieg cnoirrixxncew iw wlc lcirdea% Iacewx xl`sbg oc ceh`sriacg w` wcbb wlc h`srw
df wlcdr hbdcew `r i qdwecxx lix x}chdib eccgx% Dw dx i h`ewdesdea gswt ieg nit rcysdrc
n`rc wlie `ec igjsxwncew% Wlc XHX nsxw wikc rcix`eiobc xwc}x w` hlieac }rihwdhcx"
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 94/206
}`bdhdcx `r }r`hcgsrcx wliw nikc dw dn}`xxdobc `r sercix`eiobt gdffdhsbw f`r }crx`ex
qdwl gdxiodbdwdcx w` sxc wlc H`srw Xcrvdhc9
qlcrc i }ltxdhib fciwsrc }swx i gdxiobcg
}crx`e iw i xsoxwiewdib gdxigviewiac de rcbiwd`e w` i rcbcview niwwcr de h`n}irdx`e
qdwl }crx`ex ql` irc e`w gdxiobcg% Xhlcgsbc ? `f wlc ?=9= Ihw c|}bidex l`q wlc gswt
w` nikc rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx de x% ?= i}}bdcx w` i xcrvdhc }r`vdgcr `r }crx`e
c|crhdxdea i }sobdh fsehwd`e" qlcrc i gdxiobcg }crx`e dx }bihcg iw i xsoxwiewdib
gdxigviewiac?% Dw dehbsgcx gcfdedwd`ex `f “xsoxwiewdib gdxigviewiac— ieg “}ltxdhib
fciwsrcx— ieg xwd}sbiwcx wliw wlc gswt g`cx e`w rcysdrc fsegincewib hlieacx w` wlc
eiwsrc `f wlc xcrvdhc%
Wlc }ltxdhib fciwsrcx `f i h`srw osdbgdea nit" wlcrcf`rc" livc w` oc igjsxwcg w`
`vcrh`nc }ltxdhib oirrdcrx w` ihhcxx w` dw" ix }cr x% ?=%X% ?=,4$ xwiwcx wliw wldx
dehbsgcx:
,i$ rcn`vdea wlc }ltxdhib fciwsrc de yscxwd`e"
,o$ ibwcrdea dw" `r
,h$ }r`vdgdea i rcix`eiobc nciex `f iv`dgdea dw%
9 F`r c|in}bc: dehbsgdea i yscxwd`e de ibb h`nnsedhiwd`ex w` }crx`ex rcysdrcg w` iwwceg h`srw"
ixkdea qlcwlcr wlct ndalw rcysdrc iet rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx w` iwwceg%
? F`r c|in}bc: wlc }r`vdxd`e `f i b``} xtxwcn%
Fidbsrc w` nikc rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx
1%1 Xchwd`e ?9 `f wlc Cysibdwt Ihw xwiwcx wliw fidbsrc w` h`n}bt qdwl iet `ec `f wlc
rcix`eiobc igjsxwncew rcysdrcncewx in`sewx w` gdxhrdndeiwd`e iaidexw i gdxiobcg
}crx`e w` ql`n wlc gswt dx `qcg%
Lsnie rdalwx
1%< H`srwx qdbb ibx` livc w` livc rcairg w` wlc lsnie rdalwx `f }crx`ex qdwl
gdxiodbdwdcx segcr wlc Csr`}cie H`evcewd`e `e Lsnie _dalwx% Dw dx sebiqfsb f r i
h`srw" ix i }sobdh iswl`rdwt" w` ihw de i qit wliw dx deh`n}iwdobc qdwl wlc H`evcewd`e:
Lsnie _dalwx Ihw 944<" xchwd`e 6% Irwdhbc 97" qldhl h`ewidex wlc }r`ldodwd`e iaidexw
gdxhrdndeiwd`e" hie `}criwc `ebt qlce ie`wlcr irwdhbc" f`r c|in}bc Irwdhbc < wlc rdalw
w` rcx}chw f`r findbt bdfc" dx ibx` ceaiacg% Irwdhbc 97 }r`ldodwx gdxhrdndeiwd`e `e iet
ar`seg xshl ix xc|" rihc" h`b`sr" bieasiac" rcbdad`e" }`bdwdhib `r `wlcr `}ded`e"
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 95/206
eiwd`eib `r x`hdib `rdade" ixx`hdiwd`e qdwl i eiwd`eib nde`rdwt" }r`}crwt" odrwl `r `wlcr
xwiwsx% Wldx dehbsgcx gdxiodbdwt%
Gcfdedwd`ex ieg Wcrnx
1%4 ‒Vsbecriobc qdwecxx„: ]r`vdxd`e dx nigc ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,‒wlc ?==7 Ihw„$ f`r x}chdib ncixsrcx f`r wlc wikdea ieg advdea
`f cvdgcehc `f vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx% I vsbecriobc qdwecxx dx gcfdecg ix dehbsgdea i
}crx`e qdwl i ncewib gdx rgcr% Wlc gcfdedwd`e `f i vsbecriobc qdwecxx f`r wlc }sr}`xcx
`f hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax dx de xchwd`e ?19 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw
9443 ix xsoxwdwswcg ot x% 9 `f wlc ?==7 Ihw; ieg f`r wlc }sr}`xcx `f hdvdb }r`hccgdeax
dx de xchwd`e 99 `f wlc ?==7 Ihw% Wlc gcfdedwd`e dx wlc xinc f`r hrdndeib ieg hdvdb
}r`hccgdeax ieg dx ix f`bb`qx: I }crx`e ql` dx advdea `r dx w` advc cvdgcehc dx i
vsbecriobc qdwecxx df ,i$ lc `r xlc dx segcr wlc iac `f 96 `e wlc giwc `f
h`nncehcncew `f wlc }r`hccgdeax ,hibbcg i ‒hldbg qdwecxx„$; `r ,o$ qlcrc e`w i hldbg
qdwecxx" wlcrc dx xdaedfdhiew rdxk wliw wlc ysibdwt `f wlc cvdgcehc w` oc advce ot wliw
}crx`e qdbb oc gdndedxlcg ot rcix`e `f ncewib gdx`rgcr ix gcfdecg ot xchwd`e 8?< `f
wlc Ncewib Lcibwl ,Hirc ieg Wrciwncew$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==8" `r fcir `r gdxwrcxx de
h`eechwd`e qdwl advdea cvdgcehc% De gcwcrndedea qlcwlcr i }crx`e dx vsbecriobc" wlc
h`srw lix w` wikc dew` ihh`sew vird`sx fihw`rx ncewd`ecg de xchwd`e ?19,?$ `f wlc 9443
Ihw ,f`r hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax$ ieg xchwd`e 99,?$ ,f`r hdvdb }r`hccgdeax$%
H`nn`e biq gcfdedwd`e
1%9= Sebdkc wlc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex rcbiwdea w` i vsbecriobc qdwecxx" iw h`nn`e
biq wlcrc dx e` rcxwrdhwdvc gcfdedwd`e `f /vsbecriobc qdwecxx/% De Lin}x`e v L%N%
Igv`hiwc"9 wlc B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib ,Hsbbce$ xidg: ‒[D^w dx qcbb rch`aedxcg wliw wlcrc
irc qdwecxxcx ql` q`sbg oc }bihcg iw ie sefidr gdxigviewiac ot wlc e`rnib
}r`hcgsrc" ieg `e wliw ihh`sew irc rcairgcg ix vsbecriobc ieg de eccg `f x}chdib
ncixsrcx w` }r`wchw wlcn% Xshl qdwecxxcx nit e`rnibbt oc f`seg qdwlde `ec r n`rc
`f wlc f`bb`qdea ar`s}x `f }crx`e" eincbt" fdrxw hldbgrce; xch`egbt" }crx`ex ql`xc
iodbdwt w` lcir" xcc `r h`nnsedhiwc dx dn}idrcg" `r ql` livc i }r`obcn qdwl wlcdr
lcibwl" qlcwlcr }ltxdhib `r ncewib; ieg wldrgbt" }crx`ex ql` irc vsbecriobc w` iwwihk"
`r fcir `f iwwihk" `r dewdndgiwd`e irdxdea `sw `f wlcdr advdea cvdgcehc% Qc livc xidg
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 96/206
‒qdwlde„ xshl i ar`s} `r ar`s}x" xdehc qlcwlcr ie degdvdgsib qdwecxx xl`sbg oc advce
xshl }r`wchwd`e gc}cegx e" dewcr ibdi" wlc gcarcc `f ldx `r lcr vsbecriodbdwt%„
9 ?==8 XHH_ 98" }iri% [1^%
Wcrnx w` iv`dg; wcrnx w` sxc
1%99 Dw dx igvdxiobc w` iv`dg wcrnx wliw i}}cir w` f`hsx `e wlc gdxiodbdwt riwlcr wlie
wlc }crx`e% X`nc wcrnx w` iv`dg" ieg n`rc ihhc}wiobc }lrixcx" irc ix f`bb`qx:.
‒wlc obdeg„; dexwcig sxc ‒xdalw dn}idrcg„ `r ‒}c`}bc ql` irc obdeg„%
‒hrd}}bc„" ‒hrd}}bcg ot„" ‒xsffcrdea fr`n„" ‒vdhwdn `f„; dexwcig sxc ‒}crx`e
ql` lix…„" `r ‒}crx`e qdwl…„
‒wlc gcif„; dexwcig sxc ‒lcirdea dn}idrcg„ `r ‒}c`}bc ql` irc gcif„%
‒gcif ieg gsno„; dexwcig sxc ‒gcif qdwl`sw x}cchl„%
‒c}dbc}wdh„; dexwcig sxc ‒}crx`e qdwl c}dbc}xt„%
‒liegdhi}}cg }crx`e„; dexwcig sxc ‒gdxiobcg }crx`e„ `r ‒}crx`e qdwl i
gdxiodbdwt„%
‒ncewibbt liegdhi}}cg }crx`e„; dexwcig sxc ‒}crx`e qdwl bciredea gdxiodbdwt„%
‒x}ixwdh„; dexwcig sxc ‒}crx`e qdwl hcrcorib }ibxt„% ‒qlccbhlidr o`seg„ `r ‒h`efdecg w` i qlccbhlidr„; dexwcig sxc ‒qlccbhlidr
sxcr„%
Wlc wcrnx ‒gdxiobcg }crx`e„ ieg ‒}crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt„ irc o`wl de sxc% ]c`}bc
virt de wlcdr }rcfcrcehcx%
]BIEEDEA DE IGVIEHC
@}}`rwsedwdcx f`r }bieedea
1%9? O`wl wlc iewdhd}iw`rt eiwsrc `f wlc rcix`eiobc igjsxwncew gswt9
rcysdrcx wlc
XHX w` advc cirbt h`exdgcriwd`e w` qliw xwc}x hie oc wikce w` dn}r`vc ihhcxx f`r
gdxiobcg }c`}bc?% Dw dx sexiwdxfihw`rt df dw dx `ebt qlce wlc }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt
h`ncx w` wlc h`srw wliw iet }r`obcn de rcbiwd`e w` wliw }crx`e—x h`evcedcehc och`ncx
i}}ircew w` wlc h`srw xwiff `r wlc jsgac% Qlcrc x`nc fihdbdwt dx rcysdrcg `wlcr wlie‒x}chdib ncixsrcx„" dw dx dn}`rwiew f`r wlc }irwdcx de }r`hccgdeax w` ordea iet eccg w`
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 97/206
wlc iwwcewd`e `f wlc h`srw ix x``e ix }`xxdobc% Wlcrc irc `}}`rwsedwdcx f`r
h`exdgcriwd`e `f x}chdib ncixsrcx w` oc nigc ot wlc h`srw w` oc or`salw ot
i}}bdhiwd`e w` wlc h`srw de rcbiwd`e w` vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx8% Wldx nit oc g`ec iw
h`nn`e biq `r ot vdrwsc `f }r`vdxd`ex nigc ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$
Ihw ?==7 xshl ix iw }rcbdndeirt" fdrxw `r dewcrncgdiwc gdcwx de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax `r
iw }rc.}r``f lcirdeax `r n`wd`ex de hdvdb }r`hccgdeax%7
9Xcc }iri% 1%6 io`vc%
?Wlc XHX lix i gswt ihwdvcbt w` h`exdgcr l`q w` dn}r`vc ihhcxx f`r gdxiobcg }crx`ex:
qlcwlcr }rcndxcx `r `wlcr }ltxdhib fciwsrcx rcysdrc ibwcriwd`e" qlcwlcr }rihwdhcx" }`bdhdcx ieg
}r`hcgsrcx rcysdrc igjsxwncew ieg qlcwlcr iet is|dbdirt idgx ieg xcrvdhcx irc rcysdrcg% Xcc
wlc c|in}bc iw }iriari}l 1%6
8F`r wlc gcfdedwd`e `f i vsbecriobc qdwecxx dewr`gshcg ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$
Ihw ?==7" xcc }iri% 1%4 io`vc; f`r wlc gcfdedwd`e iw h`nn`e biq" xcc }iri% 1%9= io`vc%
7 Wlc }r`vdxd`ex f`r x}chdib ncixsrcx f`r vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx irc gcibw qdwl de }iriari}lx de
Hli}wcr 9=%
I}}`dewncew `f hsriw`r ig bdwcn9
1%98 Wlc h`srw nit i}}`dew i hsriw`r ig bdwcn w` i }irwt de i hixc iw dwx `qe
dexwiehc `r `e wlc n`wd`e `f ie dewcrcxwcg }irwt%
?
Xshl i hsriw`r nit oc i}}`dewcg w`i }crx`e `f xshl ncewib gdx`rgcr wliw lc `r xlc dx seiobc w` dexwrshw i x`bdhdw`r `r" de
hcrwide hdrhsnxwiehcx" w` i hldbg%
9 Xcc acecribbt" Nih}lidb `e Xlcrdff H`srw ]rihwdhc" 8rg cgdwd`e" }irix% 7%?8.7%?<%
? Grsnn`eg—x Wrsxwccx v ]ccb—x Wrsxwccx 94?4 X%H% 7<7" 394 }cr B`rg N`ehrdcff%
1%97 De ie ihwd`e `f gdv`rhc `r xc}iriwd`e" wlc h`srw nsxw i}}`dew i hsriw`r ig bdwcn
w` i gcfcegcr ql` lix i ncewib gdx`rgcr% De iet `wlcr hixc dw dx de wlc gdxhrcwd`e `f wlc
h`srw w` gcwcrndec qlcwlcr xshl ie i}}`dewncew xl`sbg oc nigc% Wlc hsriw`r ig
bdwcn ihwx de wlc dewcrcxwx `f wlc }irwt w` ql`n lc `r xlc lix occe i}}`dewcg% Lc `r
xlc dx ie `ffdhcr `f wlc h`srw i}}`dewcg w` cexsrc wliw wlc hixc dx }r`}crbt h`egshwcg
ieg w` }r`wchw ieg xifcasirg wlc dewcrcxwx `f wlc qirg%9
Dw xl`sbg oc i}}rchdiwcg wliw i
hsriw`r ig bdwcn dx cewdwbcg w` oc }idg%
9 F`r wlc `iwl wikce ot i hsriw`r ig bdwcn" xcc Hli}wcr 7 ,@iwlx ieg `iwl wikdea$" }iri% 7%93%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 98/206
Gswdcx `e }irwdcx w` }r`hccgdeax
1%93 Wlc XHX lix ie iewdhd}iw`rt gswt w` nikc }r`vdxd`e f`r }c`}bc qdwl i
gdxiodbdwt ix xcw `sw de }iriari}l 1%6% ]irwdcx ieg wlcdr bcaib igvdxcrx xl`sbg ibx` oc
ixkcg w` def`rn h`srw xwiff de igviehc `f iet }irwdhsbir eccgx `f }crx`ex h`ndea w`
h`srw% Wldx dx dn}`rwiew f`r iet x}chdib irrieacncewx wliw livc w` oc nigc `r
h`exdgcriwd`ex `f qldhl h`srw xwiff ieg wlc jsgac xl`sbg oc iqirc%
1%96 De i hrdndeib hixc" qlce i }crx`e dx hdwcg w` advc cvdgcehc f`r wlc Hr`qe" lc
`r xlc dx xcew i bcifbcw ‒Ocdea i qdwecxx„ wliw advcx acecrib def`rniwd`e io`sw
iwwcegdea h`srw ieg advdea cvdgcehc9% I }crx`e dgcewdfdcg ix i vsbecriobc qdwecxx dx
xcew" ot wlc Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg Igvdhc xcrvdhc" i h`}t `f i asdgc f`r vsbecriobc
qdwecxxcx `e ocdea i qdwecxx% Wlc asdgc ixkx wlc qdwecxx w` igvdxc wlc Hr`qe `f iet
x}chdib eccgx ieg devdwcx wlc qdwecxx w` h`ewihw wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib io`sw iet
h`ehcrex `r x}chdib eccgx% Wlc bcifbcw h`ewidex b`hib def`rniwd`e io`sw ihhcxx w` wlc
h`srw osdbgdea f`r qdwecxxcx qdwl i gdxiodbdwt w`acwlcr qdwl i h`ewihw esnocr f`r wlc
xlcrdff hbcrk—x `ffdhc ,qldhl dx rcx}`exdobc f`r xshl irrieacncewx$% Wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc
ieg ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Xcrvdhc ,‒H@]FX„$ ieg wlc XHX livc }sobdxlcg i J`dew
Xwiwcncew `e Hr`qe Qdwecxxcx% Wlcrc dx i xlircg rcx}`exdodbdwt `e }r`xchsw`rx ieg
hbcrkx `f h`srw w` ‒h`.`}criwc de rcbiwd`e w` xcexdwdvc hixcx ieg qdwecxxcx qdwl x}chdib
eccgx qlcrc x}chdib irrieacncewx nit oc rcysdrcg„%
9 Ividbiobc `ebdec iw qqq%h`}fx%a`v%skQdwecxxcxQdwecxxcxiwwcegdeah`srw%
1%91 Cihl xlcrdff h`srw lix dwx `qe h`gc `f }rihwdhc" griqe s} ot wlc xlcrdff hbcrk
ieg }r`hsriw`r fdxhib" wliw xcwx `sw l`q wlc h`nndwncewx de wlc Xwiwcncew qdbb oc
ihldcvcg de }rihwdhc% H@]FX lix cxwiobdxlcg i Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg Igvdhc
xcrvdhc f`r ibb h`srwx wlr`sal`sw Xh`wbieg de b`hib }r`hsriw`r fdxhib `ffdhcx%9
9Fsrwlcr def`rniwd`e nit oc f`seg iw qqq%hr`qe`ffdhc%a`v%skVdhwdnx
1%9< De i hdvdb hixc" wlcrc dx e` cysdvibcew bcifbcw w` ‒Ocdea i Qdwecxx„% Dw dx
dehsnocew" wlcrcf`rc" `e }irwdcx ieg wlcdr igvdxcrx w` def`rn h`srw xwiff de igviehc `f
iet eccgx `f }crx`ex h`ndea w` h`srw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 99/206
Cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e ieg x}chdib ncixsrcx f`r wikdea cvdgcehc: hdvdb
}r`hccgdeax
1%94 De hdvdb ihwd`ex iw h`nn`e biq" i h`nndxxd`e ieg gdbdacehc f`r wlc wikdea `f
cvdgcehc f i qdwecxx `wlcr wlie de h`srw nit oc `owidecg% Xshl cvdgcehc nit oc
`owidecg" in`ea `wlcr rcix`ex" ,i$ w` bdc de rcwcewdx ,wliw dx" kc}w ixdgc de hixc dw dx
eccgcg dexwcig `f cvdgcehc iw i }r``f$ ochisxc wlc cvdgcehc dx de gieacr `f ocdea b`xw"
sxsibbt ochisxc `f iac `r gieacr`sx xdhkecxx" `r ,o$ ochisxc wlc qdwecxx dx seiobc w`
iwwceg h`srw ochisxc `f iac" defdrndwt `r xdhkecxx%9
F`bb`qdea qliw qix gchdgcg de
Lin}x`e v% LN Igv`hiwc?" dw nit oc xidg wliw de hdvdb hixcx" iw h`nn`e biq" x}chdib
ncixsrcx h`sbg oc nigc f`r iet vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx%
9 F`r i gdxhsxxd`e `f wlcxc" xcc Arccex Iee`wiwcg _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e" e`wcx 83%99%?
ieg 83%99%8; ieg Nih}lidb `e Xlcrdff H`srw ]rihwdhc" 8rg cg%" }irix% 93%9<.93%84%
? ?==8 XHH_ 98" }iri [1^% Xcc fsrwlcr `e wliw hixc" }iri% 1%98%
1%?= Segcr ]irw ? `f wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7" wlcrc irc
xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex f`r x}chdib ncixsrcx f`r wlc wikdea `f cvdgcehc de hdvdb
}r`hccgdeax `f vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx qdwlde wlc nciedea `f wliw Ihw9% Wlcxc
}r`vdxd`ex irc cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e de ihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e 94" bdvc WV bdek deihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e ?=" sxc `f i xhrcce de ihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e ?9" sxc `f i
xs}}`rwcr de ihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e ??" ieg xshl `wlcr ncixsrcx ix Xh`wwdxl
Ndedxwcrx nit }rcxhrdoc segcr xchwd`e 9<?%
9 Xcc }iri% 1%4 io`vc f`r gcfdedwd`e `f vsbecriobc qdwecxx segcr wlc ?==7 Ihw%
?Wlc }r`vdxd`ex f`r x}chdib ncixsrcx irc n`rc fsbbt h`exdgcrcg de Hli}wcr 9= ,dewdndgiwcg ieg
`wlcr vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx$%
X}chdib ncixsrcx f`r wlc wikdea `f cvdgcehc: hrdndeib hixcx
1%?9 Iw h`nn`e biq" f`bb`qdea qliw qix gchdgcg de Lin}x`e v% LN Igv`hiwc9"
i}}r`}rdiwc x}chdib ncixsrcx h`sbg oc nigc f`r wlc wikdea `f cvdgcehc `f iet
vsbecriobc }crx`e% Sebdkc wlc xwiwsw`rt gcfdedwd`e `f vsbecriobc qdwecxx?
de xchwd`e
?19 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 xsoxwdwswcg ot xchwd`e 9 `f wlc
Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7" wlcrc dx e` rcxwrdhwdvc gcfdedwd`e `f
vsbecriobc qdwecxx iw h`nn`e biq8
%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 100/206
9 ?==8 XHH_ 98% Xcc fsrwlcr Hli}wcr 9= ,dewdndgiwcg ieg `wlcr vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx$" }iri%
9=%93%
? Xcc }iri% 1%4 io`vc f`r wlc xwiwsw`rt gcfdedwd`e `f vsbecriobc qdwecxx%
8 F`r wlc gcfdedwd`e iw h`nn`e biq" xcc }iri% 1%9= io`vc%
1%?7 Segcr xchwd`e ?19 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" ix dexcrwcg
ot xchwd`e 9 `f wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7" cbio`riwc }r`vdxd`e dx
nigc f`r x}chdib ncixsrcx f`r wikdea wlc cvdgcehc `f vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx9
dehbsgdea
ihhsxcg }crx`ex de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax% Wlc x}chdib ncixsrcx irc wlc wikdea `f
cvdgcehc ot i h`nndxxd`ecr de ihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e ?19D `f wlc 9443 Ihw" sxc `f i
bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek de ihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e ?19J" sxc `f i xhrcce de ihh`rgiehc
qdwl xchwd`e ?19K" sxc `f i xs}}`rwcr de ihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e ?19B" wlc advdea `f cvdgcehc de hldcf ot }rd`r xwiwcncew de ihh`rgiehc qdwl xchwd`e ?19N" ieg xshl `wlcr
ncixsrcx ix Xh`wwdxl Ndedxwcrx nit }rcxhrdoc segcr xchwd`e ?19L%?
9Xcc }iri% 1%4 io`vc f`r wlc xwiwsw`rt gcfdedwd`e `f vsbecriobc qdwecxx%
? Wlcxc x}chdib ncixsrcx irc n`rc fsbbt h`exdgcrcg de Hli}wcr 9= ,Dewdndgiwcg ieg `wlcr
vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx$%
Niwwcrx w` h`exdgcr
1%?3 De }bieedea de igviehc" h`exdgcriwd`e nit livc w` oc advce" f`r c|in}bc" w`.
ixkdea io`sw wlc eccgx `f iet }irwt qdwl i gdxiodbdwt ,qlcwlcr advdea cvdgcehc
ix i qdwecxx `r e`w$ `r iet qdwecxx qdwl i gdxiodbdwt;
irrieadea f`r wlc cvdgcehc `f i qdwecxx qdwl i gdxiodbdwt w` oc wikce cbxcqlcrc
wlie de wlc h`srwr``n: f`r c|in}bc" de wlc l`nc `f wlc qdwecxx qdwl i
gdxiodbdwt;
hlchkdea qlcwlcr iet h`srw de wlc osdbgdea lix occe fdwwcg qdwl ie degshwd`e
b``} ,qldhl ixxdxwx }crx`ex ql`xc lcirdea dx dn}idrcg$;
hlchkdea wliw irrieacncewx livc occe nigc f`r ie dewcr}rcwcr" i xdaecr" bd}.
x}cikcr `r }ibiewt}dxw f`r i }crx`e ql`xc lcirdea dx dn}idrcg" `r i x}cchl ieg
bieasiac wlcri}dxw;9
irrieadea f`r wlc }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt w` oc xl`qe
r`seg wlc h`srw ieg livc }r`hcgsrcx c|}bidecg ocf`rclieg;
}crndwwdea ie igsbw iswl`rdxcg ot wlc h`srw w` xs}}`rw i qdwecxx qdwl i
gdxiodbdwt de wlc qdwecxx o`|;
ibb`hiwdea xsffdhdcew h`srw wdnc w` ibb`q f`r wlcri}cswdh orcikx f`r i }irwt `rqdwecxx" xdaecr `r dewcr}rcwcr;
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 101/206
}crndwwdea i qdwecxx qdwl i gdxiodbdwt w` advc cvdgcehc iw i wdnc qlce lc `r xlc
dx iw ldx `r lcr ocxw?;
nikdea c|wri wdnc ividbiobc f`r wlc hixc w` oc lcirg%
9 Xcc fsrwlcr" Hli}wcr 3 ,Dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx$" }iri% 3%9%
? Xcc ie c|in}bc de Ceabieg" _ v Dxbcq`rwl Hr`qe H`srw C| }% Kdea [?==9^ C%L%B%_% 97;
[?==9^ I%H%G% 39 ,i}}cbbiew de }crx`e qdwl i ncgdhib gdxiodbdwt lig e`w lig i fidr wrdib ochisxc
i jsgac lig e`w wikce wliw gdxiodbdwt dew` ihh`sew qlce rcysdrdea ldn w` h`egshw ldx hixc biwc
dew` wlc ifwcre``e$%
I__IEACNCEWX F@_ WLC H@S_W I]]CI_IEHC
Acecrib
1%?6 Dw nit `ebt oc qlce wlc }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt h`ncx w` wlc h`srw wliw iet
eccg f`r rcix`eiobc igjsxwncew och`ncx i}}ircew w` wlc h`srw xwiff `r wlc jsgac%
]r`oiobt wlc fdrxw }crx`e w` oc w`bg qdbb oc wlc nihcr `r h`srw `ffdhcr; ieg lc `r xlc
qdbb def`rn wlc hbcrk `f h`srw% Wlce wlc jsgac qdbb oc def`rncg%
NhKcezdc Frdcegx
1%?1 Dw dx `}ce w` wlc jsgac w` ibb`q iet serc}rcxcewcg }irwt dehbsgdea `ec ql` dx
cbgcrbt" defdrn `r }crli}x deirwdhsbiwc" w` livc i frdceg `r findbt ncnocr ihh`n}iet
wlcn gsrdea i h`srw lcirdea% Wldx “frdceg— nit wikc e`wcx ieg advc igvdhc osw nit e`w
ihw `e oclibf `f wlc }crx`e ocdea xs}}`rwcg%
Irrieacncewx w` oc h`exdgcrcg `e wlc git
1%?< Wlc i}}ciriehc iw h`srw `f wlc }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt nit" wlcrcf`rc" oc wlc
fdrxw `}}`rwsedwt iw qldhl dw qdbb livc w` oc h`exdgcrcg qlcwlcr f`r c|in}bc.
}irwdhsbir irrieacncewx livc w` oc nigc f`r dn}r`vdea ihhcxx;
wlc hixc lix w` oc wriexfcrrcg w` ie`wlcr h`srwr``n;
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 102/206
irrieacncewx livc w` oc nigc f`r lcirdea wlc cvdgcehc `f i qdwecxx
x`ncqlcrc `wlcr wlie de wlc h`srwr``n" xshl ix wlc qdwecxx—x l`nc `r de
hlinocrx;
irrieacncewx livc w` oc nigc f`r ie dewcr}rcwcr" i xdaecr" bd}.x}cikcr `r
}ibiewt}dxw f`r }c`}bc ql` irc gcif 9" `r i x}cchl ieg bieasiac wlcri}dxw;
h`exdgcriwd`e lix w` oc advce w` livdea xl`rw orcikx f`r wlc h`evcedcehc `f wlc
}crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt" wlc xdaecr `r `wlcr dewcr}rcwcr;
xsffdhdcew h`srw wdnc dx nigc w` ibb`q f`r orcikx f`r i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt"
xdaecr `r dewcr}rcwcr;
irrieacncewx livc w` oc nigc f`r i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt w` oc xl`qe r`seg
wlc h`srw ieg livc }r`hcgsrcx c|}bidecg ocf`rclieg;
ie iswl`rdxcg igsbw xl`sbg oc ibb`qcg w` xs}}`rw wlc qdwecxx de wlc qdwecxx
o`|;
irrieacncewx hie oc nigc f`r wlc }crx`e w` advc cvdgcehc iw i wdnc qlce wlct
irc iw wlcdr ocxw" c%a%" fdrxw wldea de wlc n`redea?;
nikdea c|wri wdnc ividbiobc f`r wlc hixc w` oc lcirg;
qlcrc wlc h`srw lix ie degshwd`e b``} f`r }c`}bc ql`xc lcirdea dx dn}idrcg"
nikdea xsrc wlc x`seg b``} dx xqdwhlcg `e" wlc }crx`e—x lcirdea idg dx wsecg de
ieg wliw oihkar`seg e`dxc dx cbdndeiwcg% Dw xl`sbg oc hlchkcg wliw i }crx`e
qdwl dn}idrcg lcirdea ql` dx de i qdwecxx r``n `r wlc jsrt r``n hiee`w lcir
qliw dx a`dea `e de wlc h`srwr``n%
9Xcc fsrwlcr" Hli}wcr 3 ,Dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx$" }iri% 3%9%
?Xcc ie Ceabdxl c|in}bc" _ v Dxbcq`rwl Hr`qe H`srw C| }% Kdea [?==9^ C%L%B%_% 97; [?==9^
I%H%G% 39 ,gcwidbx de f``we`wc ? w` }iri% 1%?3" io`vc$%
Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc
1%?4 _c}rcxcewiwdvcx `f wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc irc e`q ividbiobc de wlc Ldal H`srw
ieg ibb xlcrdff h`srwx% Wridecg xwiff ieg v`bsewccrx qdbb `e rcyscxw.
xl`q i qdwecxx wlc h`srw r``n ocf`rc i hixc"
advc def`rniwd`e io`sw h`srw cwdyscwwc" }r`hcgsrcx ieg h`srw }crx`eecb"
advc cn`wd`eib xs}}`rw rcairgdea ie|dcwdcx io`sw i}}cirdea de h`srw"
irrieac f`r i}}r`}rdiwc qidwdea ihh`nn`giwd`e df wlcrc irc h`ehcrex io`sw
h`ewihw qdwl `wlcr }c`}bc"
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 103/206
advc }rihwdhib igvdhc `e niwwcrx xshl ix }irkdea ieg c|}cexcx" ieg
nikc ie ixxcxxncew `f iet eccg f`r rcfcrrib w` `wlcr iacehdcx ifwcr wlc hixc%
Wlct irc }rc}ircg w` ihh`n}iet i qdwecxx dew` h`srw df eccg oc% Wlct g` e`w gdxhsxx
wlc cvdgcehc qdwl wlc qdwecxx%
]r`obcnx f`r wl`xc qdwl ncewib lcibwl `r bciredea gdxiodbdwdcx
1%8= I }crx`e qdwl i bciredea gdxiodbdwt qdbb livc ie DY segcr 1= ieg qdbb livc
occe gdiae`xcg ocf`rc wlc iac `f 9<% Wlc eiwsrc `f i }crx`e—x gdxiodbdwt qdbb virt ieg
qdbb" wlcrcf`rc" iffchw wlc kdeg `f xs}}`rw lc `r xlc qdbb rcysdrc de h`srw% I }crx`e
qdwl i bciredea gdxiodbdwt nit livc gdffdhsbwt segcrxwiegdea ecq `r h`n}bc|
def`rniwd`e ieg nit" wlcrcf`rc" wikc b`eacr w` rcx}`eg w` i yscxwd`e dehbsgdea xshl
def`rniwd`e% Xshl i }crx`e nit livc gdffdhsbwt c|}bidedea wldeax" nit livc i bdndwcg
v`hiosbirt ieg nit ibx` oc cixdbt h`efsxcg% De iggdwd`e" lc `r xlc nit livc i
bdndwcg xcexc `f wdnc `r giwc%
1%89 Dw dx q`rwl ocirdea de ndeg wliw i }crx`e qdwl i bciredea gdxiodbdwt hie oc
ihysdcxhcew df e`w segcrxwiegdea i yscxwd`e fsbbt `r qdxldea w` i}}cir n`rc
ke`qbcgaciobc% Oc }rc}ircg w` c|}bide wldeax n rc wlie `ehc" de gdffcrcew qitx"
kcc} bieasiac xdn}bc ieg cexsrc gdxwrihwd`ex irc w` i ndednsn%
1%8? Ncewib dbbecxx hie oc ihswc `r hlr`edh" fb`rdg `r n`rc xsowbc" h`exwiew `r
ixx`hdiwcg qdwl virdiwd`ex de }rcxcewiwd`e% I }crx`e qdwl i b`ea wcrn ncewib dbbecxx
nit e`w i}}cir w` livc iet xtn}w`nx% Qlce seqcbb" l`qcvcr" xshl i }crx`e nit
xsffcr fr`n gdxw`rwd`ex `r }crhc}wd`e ieg wldekdea% Wldx nit iffchw ldx `r lcr iodbdwt
w` h`nnsedhiwc ieg" wlcrcf`rc" w` advc rcbdiobc `r h`lcrcew cvdgcehc%
]r`obcnx f`r }`wcewdib jsr`rx
1%88 I }`wcewdib jsr`r nit livc i gdxiodbdwt% X`nc n`gcre jsrt o`|cx hie
ihh`nn`giwc i qlccbhlidr ieg livc degshwd`e b``}x f`r wl`xc ql`xc lcirdea dx
dn}idrcg% De `bgcr h`srwx" wlc }ltxdhib cevdr`encew `f wlc osdbgdea nit nikc dw
gdffdhsbw w` ihh`nn`giwc i }irwdhsbir gdxiodbdwt" osw h`exdgcriwd`e lix w` oc advce de
cihl degdvdgsib hixc w` qliw rcix`eiobc igjsxwncewx xl`sbg oc nigc% H`exdgcriwd`ex
livc w` a` oct`eg wlc jsrt o`| ieg dehbsgc wlc jsrt r``n" biviw`rdcx ieg gdedea ircix%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 104/206
G`x ieg g`e—wx
1%87 Lcrc irc i esnocr `f }`dewx w` ocir de ndeg%
Wlcrc nit oc e` `swqirg xdaex `f i gdxiodbdwt sewdb wlc }crx`e dx ixkcg i
yscxwd`e%
B``k gdrchwbt iw wlc }crx`e qdwl wlc gdxiodbdwt qlce t`s irc x}cikdea w` ldn `r
lcr" cvce qlce i xdae bieasiac `r `wlcr dewcr}rcwcr" `r }crx`e ihh`n}ietdea
ldn `r lcr" dx }rcxcew" riwlcr wlie iw wlc dewcr}rcwcr `r ihh`n}ietdea }crx`e%
Wrciw i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt ql` dx ie igsbw ix ie igsbw%
Wrciw wlc gdxiodbdwt de i niwwcr `f fihw qit%
_cncnocr wliw i }crx`e—x ie|dcwt hie nikc ldx `r lcr h`nnsedhiwd`e
gdffdhsbwdcx q`rxc%
E`g `hhixd`eibbt `r sxc ie ceh`sriadea }lrixc% Wldx ceh`sriacx wlc }crx`e w`
x}cik ix dw xl`qx wliw t`s irc bdxwcedea ieg wikdea ie dewcrcxw de qliw wliw
}crx`e dx xitdea% Kcc} yscxwd`ex xdn}bc ieg e`e.wlrciwcedea% I }crx`e qdwl i
bciredea gdxiodbdwt nit oc xcexdwdvc w` ecaiwdvc cn`wd`ex%
X}cik xb`qbt" sxdea xdn}bc q`rgx ieg xl`rw xcewcehcx qlce x}cikdea w` i
}crx`e qdwl i bciredea gdxiodbdwt%
Ibb`q i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt wdnc w` rc}bt w` i yscxwd`e%
Oc }iwdcew qdwl i }crx`e ql` lix i x}cchl dn}idrncew `r bciredea gdxiodbdwt
qldbc qidwdea f`r `r bdxwcedea w` ie iexqcr w` i yscxwd`e%
Oc }rc}ircg w` rc.}lrixc yscxwd`ex `r w` ixk `wlcrx w` g` wlc xinc%
H`exdgcr qlcwlcr xl`rw orcikx iw rcasbir dewcrvibx nit oc rcysdrcg f`r wlc
h`evcedcehc `f wlc }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt%
G` e`w xwirc iw i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt% ]c`}bc qdwl gdxiodbdwdcx hie fdeg wldx
dewdndgiwdea `r wlrciwcedea% Dw hie }sw wlcn `ff% H`ehcewriwc `e qliw wlc
}crx`e dx xitdea" e`w `e wlc qit lc `r xlc b``kx%
G` e`w }iwr`edxc% Ochisxc x nc`ec lix i xcvcrc }ltxdhib gdxiodbdwt" dw g`cx
e`w f`bb`q wliw lc `r xlc dx dewcbbchwsibbt dn}idrcg%
G` e`w ibb`q i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt fccb wliw lc `r xlc dx iw i gdxigviewiac%
G` e`w nikc ixxsn}wd`ex io`sw qliw i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt hie `r hiee`w
g`% ]crx`ex qdwl gdxiodbdwdcx `fwce gcvcb`} wlcdr `qe hrciwdvc x`bswd`ex w`
}r`obcnx%
G` e`w xl`q iet gdxh`nfdwsrc wliw t`s nit fccb io`sw i gdxiodbdwt%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 105/206
Irrieacncewx de cncracehdcx
1%83 De wlc cvcew `f i }crx`e eccgdea ncgdhib iwwcewd`e" cihl h`srw lix iw bcixw `ec
ncnocr `f xwiff ql` dx e`ndeiwcg ix wlc fdrxw idg `ffdhcr%
1%86 De wlc cvcew `f i h`srw osdbgdea livdea w` oc cvihsiwcg ochisxc `f ie
cncraceht" xshl ix i fdrc ibirn" i ncnocr `f wlc h`srw xwiff dx e`ndeiwcg ieg wridecg
w` wikc i }crx`e qdwl i gdxiodbdwt ql` rcysdrcx ixxdxwiehc `sw `f wlc osdbgdea%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 106/206
X@S_HC NIWC_DIB
Ocdea i Qdwecxx ,g`hsncew iwwihlcg ot }r`hsriw`r fdxhib w` qdwecxx hdwiwd`e$%
Ocdea i Qdwecxx asdgcx" de o``kbcw `r }gf f`rniw }sobdxlcg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl
A`vcrencew iw
lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%sk_cx`srhcG`h93?7?3==7=441%}gf
Obihk—x Ncgdhib Gdhwd`eirt%
H`gc `f }rihwdhc f`r b`hib xlcrdff h`srw%
Wlc Cysibdwt ieg Lsnie _dalwx H`nndxxd`e:
lww}:qqq%cysibdwtlsnierdalwx%h`nio`sw.sxcysibdwt.ieg.gdvcrxdwt
Vdhwdnx Def`rniwd`e ]ihk qldhl dehbsgcx wlc H`srw Sxcrx Hlirwcr" }sobdxlcg
ot wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc%
A`dea w` H`srw0 Bcifbcw }sobdxlcg ot wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc `f Vdhwdn Xs}}`rw
Xh`wbieg" 93?8 Lirgqcbb Hb`xc" Cgdeosral CL< 4_\%
Wlc f`bb`qdea dx i bdek w` wlc bdxw `f }sobdhiwd`ex ividbiobc de rcbiwd`e w`
xcrvdhcx ieg h`gcx `f }rihwdhc de rcbiwd`e w` wlc Cysibdwt Ihw ?=9=
lww}:qqq%cysibdwtlsnierdalwx%h`nbcaib.ieg.}`bdhtcysibdwt.ihwcysibdwt.
ihw.h`gcx.`f.}rihwdhc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 107/206
Hli}wcr <
HLDBG_CE
DEW_@GSHWD@E
I hldbg—x ie|dcwdcx
<%9 Hldbgrce nit oc i}}rclcexdvc io`sw h`ndea w` h`srw f`r i virdcwt `f rcix`ex%
Wlc sefindbdir xsrr`segdeax" wlc f`rnibdwt `f wlc }r`hccgdeax" wlc xsojchw.niwwcr `f
wlc h`srw hixc" wlc }rcxcehc `f i fcircg }crx`e `r }crx`ex" i h`efbdhw `f b`tibwdcx" ieg
wlc wixk `f livdea w` iexqcr yscxwd`ex }sw ot igsbwx de }sobdh9" irc jsxw x`nc `f wlc
fihw`rx bdkcbt w` hisxc i}}rclcexd`e% Qliw f`bb`qx irc qitx de qldhl xshl
i}}rclcexd`e nit oc rcgshcg%
9 ]irwdhsbirbt gsrdea hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e" ieg }irwdhsbirbt df ie ihhsxcg }crx`e hl``xcx w`
rc}rcxcew ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf% Xcbf.rc}rcxcewiwd`e dx e`w }`xxdobc de xc|sib `ffcehc hixcx: x%
?<<H,9$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" dexcrwcg ot x% 9 `f wlc Xc|sib
@ffcehcx ,]r`hcgsrc ieg Cvdgcehc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==? ifwcr 9 E`vcnocr ?==?%
FINDBDI_DXIWD@E QDWL H@S_W IEG H@S_W ]_@HCGS_CX
Vdxdw w` h`srw
<%? Ocxw }rihwdhc dx w` xl`q i hldbg qdwecxx wlc h`srw }rcndxcx ieg wlc h`srw r``n
ocf`rc wlc hixc ocadex% Wlc ‒Asdgiehc `e Hldbg Qdwecxx H`srw Findbdirdxiwd`e
Vdxdwx„9
xwiwcx wliw h`srw vdxdwx irc i vcldhbc f`r rcbdcvdea ie|dcwt ieg irc ie cxxcewdib
}irw `f rcgshdea xwrcxx% Wlc }sr}`xc f wlc vdxdw dx ‘
f`r wlc hldbg w` xcc wlc h`srwr``n `r i xdndbir r``n w` wliw qlcrc wlc hldbg
qdbb advc cvdgcehc;
f`r wlc }`xxdodbdwdcx `f l`q wlc hldbg qdbb advc cvdgcehc de wliw r``n w` oc
c|}bidecg w` wlc hldbg; ieg
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 108/206
w` dgcewdft ieg iwwcn}w w` rcx`bvc ncixsrcx `f xs}}`rw e`w ibrcigt
dgcewdfdcg ieg w` cexsrc wliw fswsrc irrieacncewx irc hbcir w` wlc hldbg%
Wlc }irwt hdwdea wlc hldbg ix i qdwecxx dx rcx}`exdobc f`r irrieadea i h`srw vdxdw de
ihh`rgiehc qdwl wlc Asdgiehc% Wliw }irwt xl`sbg h`ewihw wlc xlcrdff hbcrk ,f`r xlcrdff
h`srw hixcx$" wlc Jsxwdhdirt @ffdhc ,f`r Ldal H`srw hixcx$ `r wlc Kcc}cr `f wlc _`bbx
,f`r H`srw `f Xcxxd`e hixcx$% Qlcrc i bcaib rc}rcxcewiwdvc dx h`egshwdea wlc vdxdw" dw
q`sbg oc h`ewrirt w` wlc }sr}`xc `f wlc vdxdw w` livc `wlcr bcaib rc}rcxcewiwdvcx
}rcxcew `oxcrvdea wlc vdxdw% Df wlc }crx`e h`egshwdea wlc vdxdw dx e`w wlc bcaib
rc}rcxcewiwdvc" wliw }crx`e qdbb livc w` livc x`nc gdxhsxxd`e qdwl wlc }crx`e hdwdea
wlc hldbg qdwecxx de `rgcr w` oc iqirc `f wlc hldbg—x eccgx ieg iet ncixsrcx `r
irrieacncewx w` oc sxcg% I }crx`e nit livc occe dgcewdfdcg ix wlc }crx`e ql` qdbb
xs}}`rw wlc hldbg qldbc advdea cvdgcehc% Wliw }crx`e xl`sbg ibx` oc dehbsgcg de wlc
h`srw vdxdw%
9Dxxscg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew ix }irw `f wlc ‒Xs}}`rwdea Hldbg Qdwecxxcx asdgiehc
}ihk„ de ?==8%
Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc
<%8 I qcbh`nc gcvcb`}ncew de wldx h`ewc|w dx wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc xhlcnc9"
xsaacxwcg ot Vdhwdn Xs}}`rw% Fsegdea ochinc ividbiobc de 944<" ieg }db`w xwsgdcx
qcrc xcw s} de hcrwide xlcrdff h`srwx%?
Wridecg xwiff ieg v`bsewccrx e`q gcbdvcr wlc
xcrvdhc de cvcrt xlcrdff h`srw ieg de wlc Ldal H`srw% Iet qdwecxx qdxldea w` ixk
yscxwd`ex io`sw h`srw }r`hcgsrcx nit xcck wlc ixxdxwiehc `f wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc
v`bsewccrx% Ie `rdcewiwd`e vdxdw nit oc irrieacg% ]crx`eib }r`obcnx hisxdea wlc
qdwecxx ie|dcwt hie oc gdxhsxxcg qcbb de igviehc `f wlc h`srw lcirdea" ieg i}}r`}rdiwc
irrieacncewx nigc%8
Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc hie ibx` }r`vdgc xs}}`rw de h`srw" xl`sbg dw oc
rcysdrcg7%
9 Xcc wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc Ieesib _c}`rw ?===.?==9 }%8=: ‒Wldx v`bsewirt xcrvdhc dx
gcxdaecg w` `ffcr qdwecxxcx ieg vdhwdnx `f hrdnc }rihwdhib ieg cn`wd`eib xs}}`rw% Dw dx ie
dewcarib ieg vibscg }irw `f wlc h`nndwncew qc livc nigc w` }r`vdgc cvcr dn}r`vdea bcvcbx `f
xcrvdhc w` ibb h`srw sxcrx ieg w` q`rk de }irwecrxld} qdwl `wlcr iacehdcx de wlc jsxwdhc xtxwcn%„
?Dedwdibbt Kdrkhibgt" Lindbw`e ieg Itr%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 109/206
8 Hf% wlc degdvdgsibdxwdh i}}r`ihl rch`nncegcg de }iriari}l 7,c$ `f wlc Ncn`riegsn `e
Hldbg Qdwecxxcx ot B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c Jsbt 944=" ,xs}crxcgcg ot }iriari}l 6,f$ `f
]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$$ xcw `sw de wlc iggcegsn w` wldx Hli}wcr: ‒Ibb hldbgrce irc
gdffcrcew" ieg jsgacx xl`sbg wikc cihl hldbg—x }irwdhsbir hdrhsnxwiehcx dew` ihh`sew ocf`rc
gchdgdea qliw xwc}x" df iet" xl`sbg oc wikce w` ndedndxc ie|dcwt `r gdxwrcxx%„ 7 Xcc }iri <%?= ocb`q%
_cigdea niwcrdib
<%7 Sxcfsb rcigdea niwcrdib f`r i hldbg c|}chwcg w` advc cvdgcehc dx }r`vdgcg ot ie
dbbsxwriwcg bcifbcw cewdwbcg ‒A`dea w` H`srw ix i Qdwecxx0„ }r`gshcg ot wlc Hr`qe
@ffdhc" Cgdeosral ,s}giwcg ?==3$% Wlcrc irc wq` vcrxd`ex" `ec f`r hldbgrce iacg 3 w`
9? tcirx" ieg `ec f`r hldbgrce iacg 9? w` 96 tcirx% 9 Wlc bcifbcw c|}bidex de xdn}bc
bieasiac qliw dx dev`bvcg de a`dea w` h`srw w` advc cvdgcehc% I fsrwlcr xcrdcx `f
dbbsxwriwcg o``kbcwx cewdwbcg ‒Ocdea i Qdwecxx„ }r`gshcg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew
,Jsec ?==3$ advcx hldbgrce" t`sea }crx`ex" ieg hircrx x`nc asdgiehc de rcbiwd`e w`
hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax ieg hldbgrce—x lcirdeax%?
9 I qcoxdwc x}chdfdhibbt gcxdaecg f`r hldbgrce hie oc f`seg iw
lww}://qqq%hrdnciegt`sea}c`}bc%ecw% ? Wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew lix ibx` }r`gshcg i GVG f`r hldbg qdwecxxcx ividbiobc fr`n
x`srhcx xshl ix Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc" Vdhwdn Xs}}`rw" wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc" ieg wlc Xh`wwdxl
A`vcrencew%
HLDBG—X I__DVIB IW" ]_CXCEHC DE" IEG GC]I_WS_C F_@N H@S_W
]_CNDXCX
L`xwdbc fihwd`ex iw h`srw
<%3 O`wl hdvdb ieg hrdndeib hixcx nit ordea w`acwlcr }c`}bc ql` irc iewia`edxwdh
w`qirgx cihl wlcr% F`r c|in}bc" i hdvdb hixc dev`bvdea gdx}swcg rcxdgcehc `r h`ewihw
nit rcxsbw de wq` qcbb.gcfdecg ‒xdgcx„% Ie ihhsxcg de i hrdndeib hixc" ieg ldx `r lcr
frdcegx ieg xs}}`rwcrx" nit oc iaarcxxdvc w`qirgx }r`xchswd`e qdwecxxcx%9
Ncnocrx
`f wlc }rcxx dewcrcxwcg de wlc hixc nit ibx` oc qidwdea de `r `swxdgc wlc osdbgdea% Dw dx
}irwdhsbirbt dn}`rwiew wliw i hldbg qdwecxx xl`sbg e`w oc xsojchwcg w` i wrisniwdh
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 110/206
c|}crdcehc ot livdea w` qibk }ixw l`xwdbc }crx`ex `r wlr`sal birac hr`qgx" `r ot
livdea w` qidw de i qdwecxx.r``n cdwlcr qdwl `r ecir l`xwdbc }crx`ex% Xshl }r`obcnx
nit oc c|ihcroiwcg de xnibb h`srw osdbgdeax% Jsgacx" h`srw xwiff" }ircewx" asirgdiex"
}`bdhc ieg }rdx`e `ffdhcrx xl`sbg" df }`xxdobc" h`nnsedhiwc ieg }bie de igviehc" x`
wliw i}}r`}rdiwc irrieacncewx hie oc nigc w` iv`dg xsojchwdea i hldbg w` ie
se}bcixiew h`efr`ewiwd`e `r c|}crdcehc% De wlc hixc `f i hldbg ihhsxcg de i hrdndeib
hixc" dw nit oc echcxxirt w` nikc x}chdib irrieacncewx w` cewcr ieg bcivc wlc h`srw
osdbgdea ot i xchsrc `r xdgc cewriehc" f`r rcix`ex `f xifcwt ieg ie`etndwt `r w`
irrieac f`r wlc hldbg w` advc cvdgcehc fr`n ie`wlcr osdbgdea ot HHWV bdek" wlsx
iv`dgdea iet }`xxdodbdwt `f livdea w` ‒rse wlc aisewbcw„?% De ibb hrdndeib hixcx fr`n
?==1 x}chdib ncixsrcx hie oc x`salw x` ix w` ceiobc hldbgrce w` advc cvdgcehc vdi
HHWV bdekx fr`n i b`hiwd`e `wlcr wlie wlc osdbgdea qlcrc wlc wrdib dx ocdea lcbg%
9De Lteg v% NhAbceeie" ?=== X%H%H%_% ?89" iw }% ?8?" B`rg Xswlcrbieg h`nncewcg `e wlc
dn}`rwiehc `f xcarcaiwd`e ieg h`ewr`b `f qdwecxxcx: ‒Wlc gcfcehc qdwecxxcx xl`sbg e`w oc de
wlc xinc r``n ix Hr`qe qdwecxxcx" ieg wlc qdwecxxcx xl`sbg de fihw oc de wlc qdwecxx r``n
ieg h`efdecg wlcrc ieg e`w qiegcrdea io`sw wlc h`rrdg`rx% Fsrwlcrn`rc" dw xl`sbg livc occe
nigc hbcir w` Hr`qe qdwecxxcx `r degccg w` iet gcfcehc qdwecxxcx wliw `ehc wlct lig advce
cvdgcehc" wlct xl`sbg e`w rcwsre w` wlc qdwecxx r``n%„
? Xcc wlc irrieacncewx nigc de wlc wrdib rcfcrrcg w` de ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg
Frdcegbt H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" iw }% 9<9" ieg xcc ibx` }irix% <%99
ieg <%91 ocb`q ,hldbg iobc w` advc cvdgcehc ot HHWV bdek fr`n i b`hiwd`e `wlcr wlie wlc h`srw
osdbgdea$%
I x}chdib qidwdea r``n f`r hldbgrce
<%6 Hldbgrce" qlcwlcr dev`bvcg de hdvdb `r hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax" nit livc w`
x}ceg x`nc wdnc de i h`srw osdbgdea% I r``n cysd}}cg qdwl o``kx ieg w`tx rcgshcx
xwrcxx ieg lcb}x hldbgrce w` qidw n`rc }iwdcewbt%9
Wlc b`hiwd`e `f wlc r``n nit oc
dn}`rwiew" f`r" ix degdhiwcg io`vc" i hldbg xl`sbg e`w oc f`rhcg w` qidw cdwlcr qdwl `r
ecir l`xwdbc fihwd`ex% Df wlc h`srw }rcndxcx irc bdndwcg" wcn}`rirt irrieacncewx nit
livc w` oc nigc w` ihh`nn`giwc }irwdhsbir hixcx" f`r c|in}bc" sxdea }rcndxcx
ecirot%
9‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$
914" iw }}% 9<= ieg 9<8%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 111/206
X]CHDIB I__IEACNCEWX DE H_DNDEIB ]_@HCCGDEAX
Wlc vsbecriodbdwt `f i hldbg
<%1 Wlc vsbecriodbdwt `f i hldbg dx n`rc `fwce rcbiwcg w` wlc r`bc qldhl wlc hldbglix }bitcg de wlc hixc" riwlcr wlie w` iac `r xc|% _cbiwdvcbt t`sea hldbgrce nit oc
li}}t w` advc cvdgcehc fr`n wlc qdwecxx o`| xsrr`segcg ot biqtcrx ieg `ffdhdibx
qcirdea a`qex ieg qdax" }r`vdgcg wliw wlcdr }crx`eib xcexc `f devsbecriodbdwt lix e`w
occe giniacg%9
De xshl hdrhsnxwiehcx" x}chdib irrieacncewx nit e`w oc echcxxirt%
Qlcrc" l`qcvcr" i hldbg dx ie ihhsxcg }crx`e" `r ie ibbcacg vdhwdn ,f`r c|in}bc `f ie
ixxisbw" `r xc|sib iosxc" `r i findbt orcikg`qe$" lc `r xlc dx bdkcbt w` oc }irwdhsbirbt
vsbecriobc" ieg bcxx iobc w` h`}c qdwl e`rnib h`srw irrieacncewx% Cirbt ixxcxxncew
`f wlc hldbg ot" f`r c|in}bc" i biqtcr" `r }rch`ae`xhcr" `r ie`wlcr }r`fcxxd`eib"
w`acwlcr qdwl a``g h`nnsedhiwd`e de igviehc `f wlc h`srw lcirdea" dx igvdxiobc%
9 Wlsx de `ec hixc" ie <.tcir.`bg o`t ql` lig qdwecxxcg }irw `f ie irncg r`oocrt" osw ql`
lig e`w fcbw }irwdhsbirbt gdxwsrocg `r wlrciwcecg ot qliw lc lig xcce" }r`vcg i h`efdgcew
qdwecxx de `}ce h`srw" rcysdrdea e` x}chdib irrieacncewx%
Wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7<%< Qldbc wlcrc lig occe dehrcixdea rch`aedwd`e wliw x`nc hldbgrce segcr wlc iac
`f 96 ndalw oc vsbecriobc" ieg wliw x`nc q`sbg rcysdrc x}chdib irrieacncewx de
h`srw"9 wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7? dewr`gshcg ie ixxsn}wd`e wliw
ibb hldbgrce irc vsbecriobc ieg irc isw`niwdhibbt cewdwbcg w` x}chdib irrieacncewx de
h`srw sebcxx i jsgac h`exdgcrx xshl irrieacncewx seechcxxirt%8
Fsrwlcr x}chdib
}r`vdxd`e dx nigc f`r hldbg qdwecxxcx segcr wlc iac `f 9?%7 Asdgiehc }ihkx livc occe
}r`vdgcg f`r }rihwdwd`ecrx"3 ieg c|}bieiw`rt o``kx f`r hldbg qdwecxxcx ieg wlcdr
hircrx6%
9Wlsx cirbdcr xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex }crndwwcg wlc sxc `f HHWV" xhrccex" ieg cvdgcehc `e
h`nndxxd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax" }r`vdgcg wliw wlc h`srw qix }crxsigcg wliw xshl
ncixsrcx qcrc i}}r`}rdiwc: f`r c|in}bc" xx% 36.34 `f wlc Biq _cf`rn ,Ndxhcbbiec`sx
]r`vdxd`ex$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 944=; xx% 88.83 `f wlc ]rdx`ecrx ieg Hrdndeib ]r`hccgdeax
Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9448; x% ?19 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ix xsoxwdwswcg ot x%
?4 `f wlc Hrdnc ieg ]sedxlncew ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9441 ieg ix dw xw``g }rd`r w` wlc h`ndea dew`
f`rhc `f wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7; wlc Ncn`riegsn ot B`rg Jsxwdhc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 112/206
Acecrib L`}c `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx" Jsbt 944= ,e`q rc}bihcg ot ]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$
Hldbg Qdwecxxcx: Gdxhrcwd`eirt ]`qcrx: xcc wlc I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr$; ‒Hldbgrce de
H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" 9<9%
? Ceihwcg f`bb`qdea qdgcx}rcig h`exsbwiwd`e: xcc f`r c|in}bc: _c}`rw `e wlc Cvdgcehc `f
Hldbgrce ieg @wlcr ]`wcewdibbt Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`w% Biq H`n% 9?3$; ieg i
h`exsbwiwd`e }i}cr dxxscg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew de Nit ?==? cewdwbcg ‒Vdwib V`dhcx:
Lcb}dea Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx Advc Cvdgcehc„%
8 x%?19I,3$,o$ Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ix incegcg ot wlc Vsbecriobc
Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7%
7Xcc }iri <%97 ocb`q%
3 ‒X}chdib Ncixsrcx f`r Vsbecriobc Igsbw ieg Hldbg Qdwecxxcx: I Asdgiehc ]ihk„ ,Xh`wwdxl
A`vcrencew" Cgdeosral" ?==3" s}giwcg ?==<$" ividbiobc iw:
lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%sk]sobdhiwd`ex?==<=7?997?97=8=%
6 Wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew lix }sobdxlcg i xcrdcx `f o``kbcwx cewdwbcg ‒Ocdea i Qdwecxx„
,rcvdxcg ?==1$ idncg iw hldbgrce" t`sea }c`}bc" ieg hircrx% Wlc Xh`wwdxl Hldbg Biq Hcewrc
,lww}:qqq%xhbh%`ra%sk $ livc }sobdxlcg i bcifbcw `e Hldbgrce ix Qdwecxxcx de G`ncxwdh
Iosxc Hixcx Qldhl hie oc ihhcxxcg lcrc:
lww}:qqq%xh`wwdxlq`ncexidg%`ra%skixxcwxfdbcxwridedeaPiegPcvcewxH`efcrcehc#?=?=9=?
#?=.NGrdxh`bb#?=XHBH#?=HT]#?=Qdewcxxcx%}gf
Hldbg ix vsbecriobc qdwecxx: x}chdib ncixsrcx de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`ex
?19I ieg ?19G
<%4 I hldbg segcr wlc iac `f 969
dx gccncg w` oc i vsbecriobc qdwecxx cewdwbcg w`
hcrwide x}chdib ncixsrcx qlce advdea cvdgcehc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax%? Wlc x}chdib
ncixsrcx dehbsgc8
,i$ cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e: xchwd`e ?19D `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443;
,o$ i bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,HHWV$: xchwd`e ?19J;
,h$ i xhrcce: xchwd`e ?19K;,g$ i xs}}`rwcr: xchwd`e ?19B;
,c$ i }rd`r xwiwcncew sxcg ix wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc de hldcf: xchwd`e ?19N;
ieg
,f$ xshl `wlcr ncixsrcx ix wlc Xh`wwdxl Ndedxwcrx nit }rcxhrdoc ot xwiwsw`rt
dexwrsncew:7
I h`srw—x h`nn`e biq }`qcrx w` nikc `r iswl`rdxc x}chdib irrieacncewx f`r
vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx livc e`w occe rcn`vcg ot wlc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex%3
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 113/206
9 D%c% segcr wlc iac `f 96 `e wlc giwc `f h`nncehcncew `f wlc }r`hccgdeax de qldhl wlc wrdib dx
ocdea `r w` oc lcbg" eincbt `e wlc giwc qlce wlc degdhwncew `r h`n}bidew dx xcrvcg `e wlc
ihhsxcg: x% ?19,9$,i$ ieg ,8$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443% E`wc wliw i
hldbg ihhsxcg dx ibx` cewdwbcg w` x}chdib ncixsrcx ,qdwl wlc c|hc}wd`e `f xhrccex$: x% ?19F%
?
xx% ?19,9$ ieg ?19I,9$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw ix xsoxwdwswcg ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix} 8$ ieg fsrwlcr incegcg ot wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Incegncew$
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix} 3$ qdwl cffchw fr`n 9 I}rdb ?==3: XXD ?==77=3 Irw% ? ieg Xhlcg% ?;
XXD ?==396< Irw% ? ieg Xhlcg ?% I hldbg ihhsxcg dx ibx` cewdwbcg w` hcrwide x}chdib ncixsrcx:
x %?19F ,xcc }iri%<%?6 ocb`q$%
8Xchwd`e ?19 L `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
7 Xchwd`e ?19 L,9$,f$%
3Xchwd`e ?19A `f wlc 9443 Ihw iggcg ot Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix} 8$ ]w
9 x%9,9$; ieg xcc ]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$ Hldbg Qdwecxxcx: Gdxhrcwd`eirt ]`qcrx" xcw `sw
de I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr% Ie dbbsxwriwd`e `f wlc c|crhdxc `f h`nn`e biq }`qcrx hie oc
f`seg de Lin}x`e v L%N% Igv`hiwc" ?==8 X%B%W% 47" qlcrc }crndxxd`e w` advc cvdgcehc fr`n
ocldeg i xhrcce qix advce w` i vsbecriobc igsbw ql` gdg e`w ysibdft de wcrnx `f wlc wlce
c|dxwdea xwiwsw`rt hiwca rdcx% H`nn`e biq }`qcrx irc ibx` c|crhdxcg qlce wlc h`srw `rgcrx
wliw a`qex ieg qdax oc rcn`vcg%
Hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax
<%9= I }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc i hldbg qdwecxx de i hrdndeib hixc nsxw b`gac
i hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc" dewdniwdea qlcwlcr x}chdib ncixsrcx irc h`exdgcrcg
i}}r`}rdiwc" ieg df x`" qliw%9 Wlc e`wdhc xl`sbg h`ewide `r oc ihh`n}iedcg ot ,d$ i
xsnnirt `f iet vdcqx c|}rcxxcg ot wlc hldbg qdwecxx?
ieg ldx `r lcr }ircew ,c|hc}w
qlcrc wlc }ircew dx wlc ihhsxcg$;8
ieg ,dd$ xshl `wlcr def`rniwd`e ix nit oc
}rcxhrdocg ot Ihw `f Igj`sreib%7 Wlc e`wdhc nsxw oc b`gacg ot wlc rcysdrcg wdnc%3
I E`wdhc nit oc b`gacg biwc `e hisxc xl`qe%6
9
Xchwd`e ?19I ,?$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw% Df e` x}chdib ncixsrcx irc x`salw" wlc e`wdhc xl`sbg xwiwcwliw fihw: x% ?19 I,?$,o$% Wlc }irwt b`gadea wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc nsxw dewdniwc wlc e`wdhc
w` wlc `wlcr }irwdcx w` wlc }r`hccgdeax: x% ?19I,98$% Qlcrc cvdgcehc dx w` oc wikce ot
h`nndxxd`e" wlc e`wdhc xl`sbg h`ewide hcrwide niwwcrx x}chdfdcg de }iriari}l 1 `f ]rihwdhc
E`wc ,E`%8 `f ?==3$ Wikdea `f Cvdgcehc `f i Vsbecriobc Qdwecxx ot i H`nndxxd`ecr: xcc
}iri% <%96 ocb`q" ieg I}}cegd| H w` wldx hli}wcr%
? Livdea rcairg w` wlc hldbg—x iac ieg niwsrdwt: x% ?19C,?$,o$% I hldbg iacg 9? `r `bgcr dx
}rcxsncg w` oc `f xsffdhdcew iac ieg niwsrdwt w` f`rn i vdcq: x% ?19 C,8$,i$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 114/206
8 Xchwd`ex ?19I,8$ ieg ?19C,?$,o$: osw qlcrc wlc }ircewx— vdcqx irc deh`exdxwcew qdwl wlc
hldbg qdwecxx—x vdcqx" wlc vdcqx `f wlc hldbg qdwecxx qdbb oc advce arciwcr qcdalw: x%
?19C,8$,o$%
7 Wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx 9446 ,XD 9446398$ livc occe incegcg ot wlc Ihw `f
Igj`sreib ,Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx Incegncew E`%8$ ,Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$
Ihw ?==7$ ?==3 ,XXD ?==39<<$ ieg wlc Ihw `f Igj`sreib ,Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc Incegncew
E`%6$ ,Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7$ ,Cvdgcehc `e H`nndxxd`e$ ?==3 ,XXD
?==3317$%
3Xchwd`e ?19I,?$ ieg ,98I$: de wlc Ldal H`srw" e` biwcr wlie 97 hbcir gitx ocf`rc wlc
}rcbdndeirt lcirdea; de }r`hccgdeax `e degdhwncew de wlc xlcrdff h`srw" e` biwcr wlie 1 hbcir
gitx ocf`rc wlc fdrxw gdcw; ieg de iet `wlcr hixc" e` biwcr wlie 97 hbcir gitx ocf`rc wlc wrdib gdcw%
6Xchwd`e ?19I,7$%
H`srw—x h`exdgcriwd`e f hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax
,9$ H`exdgcriwd`e de ioxcehc `f }irwdcx ,de hlinocrx$
<%99 Wlc h`srw dedwdibbt h`exdgcrx wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc de wlc ioxcehc `f wlc
}irwdcx%9
9 Wlc h`srw—x h`exdgcriwd`e xl`sbg wikc }bihc e`w biwcr wlie 1 gitx ifwcr wlc e`wdhc dx b`gacg:
x% ?19I,3$%
<%99%9 X}chdib ncixsrc: Df i xwiegirg x}chdib ncixsrc9 dx x}chdfdcg de wlc e`wdhc" wlc
h`srw xlibb" xsojchw w` xchwd`e ?19O,8$" nikc ie `rgcr iswl`rdxdea wliw ncixsrc%?
Xchwd`e ?19O,8$ }r`vdgcx wliw wlc jsgac xlibb e`w iswl`rdxc i x}chdib ncixsrc qldhl
rcysdrcx wlc hldbg w` oc }rcxcew de wlc h`srw.r``n `r iet }irw `f wlc h`srw osdbgdea de
qldhl wlc h`srw.r``n dx b`hiwcg sebcxx wlc jsgac dx xiwdxfdcg:
,i$ wliw xshl i }rcxcehc ,d$ ihh`rgx qdwl wlc hldbg—x c|}rcxxcg qdxl" ieg ,dd$ dxi}}r`}rdiwc; r
,o$ wlc bihk `f xshl i }rcxcehc q`sbg advc rdxc w` i xdaedfdhiew rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc
w` wlc fidrecxx `f wlc wrdib `r `wlcrqdxc w` wlc dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc" ieg wliw rdxk
xdaedfdhiewbt `swqcdalx iet rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc dewcrcxwx `f wlc hldbg
qdwecxx%
Df i ncixsrc `wlcr wlie i xwiegirg ncixsrc dx x}chdfdcg de wlc e`wdhc" ieg df wlc h`srw
dx xiwdxfdcg8
`e wlc oixdx `f wlc e`wdhc wliw dw dx i}}r`}rdiwc w` g` x`" wlc h`srw xlibb
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 115/206
nikc ie `rgcr iswl`rdxdea wlc sxc `f wliw x}chdib ncixsrc" qldhl nit oc iggdwd`eib
w` wlc xwiegirg x}chdib ncixsrcx%7
9 De wcrnx `f x% ?19I,97$" wlc ‒xwiegirg„ x}chdib ncixsrcx irc: ,i$ HHWV qlcrc wlc hldbg dx de
wlc xinc osdbgdea ix wlc h`srw; ,o$ xhrccex; ,h$ i xs}}`rw }crx`e de h`ejsehwd`e qdwl wlc sxc `f
cdwlcr HHWV `r xhrccex%
? Xchwd`e ?19 I,3$,i$,d$%
8 F`r }r`hcgsrc qlcrc wlc h`srw dx e`w xiwdxfdcg" xcc }iri% <%9? ocb`q%
7 Xchwd`e ?19 I ,3$,i$,dd$%
<%99%? E` x}chdib ncixsrc,x$: Df ,d$ wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc xwiwcx wliw wlc }irwt
hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc wlc hldbg qdwecxx h`exdgcrx wliw wlc hldbg qdwecxx xl`sbg
advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib ncixsrcx" ,dd$ wlc xsnnirt `f vdcqx
ihh`n}ietdea wlc e`wdhc degdhiwcx wliw wlc hldbg lix c|}rcxxcg i qdxl w` advc
cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f i x}chdib ncixsrc" ieg ,ddd$ wlc h`srw dx xiwdxfdcg9
`e
wlc oixdx `f wlc e`wdhc wliw dw dx i}}r`}rdiwc w` g` x`" wlc h`srw xlibb nikc ie `rgcr
iswl`rdxdea wlc advdea `f cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc%?
9 F`r }r`hcgsrc qlcrc wlc h`srw dx e`w xiwdxfdcg" xcc }iri <%9? ocb`q%
? Xchwd`e ?19 I,3$,o$% Dw lix occe e`wcg wliw wlc sxc `f x}chdib ncixsrcx nit livc x`ncgdxigviewiacx% F`r c|in}bc" df i HHWV bdek dx sxcg" wlc jsrt nit oc seiobc }r`}crbt w` ixxcxx
jsxw l`q t`sea ieg dnniwsrc wlc hldbg wrsbt dx% Wlc biqtcrx ixkdea yscxwd`ex nit oc bcxx
iobc w` ihldcvc i ri}}`rw qdwl wlc hldbg% @e `hhixd`ex wlcrc nit oc wchledhib gdffdhsbwdcx
f`hsxdea wlc hincri x` wliw wlc x}cikcr dx hcewrcg `e.xhrcce%
,?$ H`srw lcirdea w` gdxhsxx hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc
<%9? Qlcrc i h`srw dx e`w xiwdxfdcg wliw i e`e.xwiegirg ncixsrc dx i}}r`}rdiwc"9
`r dx
e`w xiwdxfdcg wliw dw q`sbg oc i}}r`}rdiwc w` livc e` x}chdib ncixsrc"?
`r qlcrc wlc
hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc xwiwcx wliw e` x}chdib ncixsrcx irc x`salw8
osw wlc xsnnirt `f
vdcqx degdhiwcx wliw wlc hldbg lix e`w c|}rcxxcg i qdxl w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc
ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc"7
wlc h`srw nit ‘
i}}`dew wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc w` oc gdxhsxxcg iw i f`rwlh`ndea }rcbdndeirt
lcirdea de wlc Ldal H`srw ,`r i f`rwlh`ndea fdrxw gdcw de wlc xlcrdff h`srw$;3
`r
df e` xshl lcirdea `r gdcw dx ividbiobc" i}}`dew i gdcw w` oc lcbg ocf`rc wlc wrdib
gdcw" ieg rcysdrc }irwdcx w` iwwceg wliw gdcw%6
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 116/206
Xshl i lcirdea nit wikc }bihc de hlinocrx df wlc }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc wlc
hldbg qdwecxx x` rcyscxwx" `r df wlc h`srw x` `rgcrx `e dwx `qe n`wd`e%1
Fsrwlcrn`rc"
qlcrc dw i}}cirx w` wlc h`srw wliw i }irwt dewcegx w` hibb i hldbg qdwecxx" tcw e` hldbg
qdwecxx e`wdhc lix occe b`gacg ieg e` biwc bcivc f`r b`gadea lix occe ibb`qcg" wlc
h`srw xlibb `rgcr wlc }irwt w` b`gac i e`wdhc qdwlde i x}chdfdcg wdnc%<
Ibwcreiwdvcbt wlc
h`srw nit ridxc wlc yscxwd`e `f x}chdib ncixsrcx iw i f`rwlh`ndea }rcbdndeirt lcirdea
`r fdrxw gdcw4
,`r qlcrc e`ec dx ividbiobc" iw i x}chdibbt i}}`dewcg gdcw$"9=
ieg nit"
livdea lcirg }irwdcx" cdwlcr iswl`rdxc wlc sxc `f xshl x}chdib ncixsrc,x$ ix wlc h`srw
h`exdgcrx n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc" `r `rgcr wliw wlc hldbg—x cvdgcehc oc advce qdwl`sw wlc
ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc% Iaide xshl lcirdeax nit wikc }bihc de hlinocrx%
9 Xchwd`e ?19I,3$,i$,dd$%
? Xchwd`e ?19I,3$,o$%
8 Xchwd`e ?19I,?$,o$%
7Xchwd`e ?19I,3$,h$,dd$%
3Xchwd`e ?19I,3I$,i$ ieg ,o$%
6Xchwd`e ?19I,3I$,h$% De xshl hdrhsnxwiehcx" wlc h srw nit }`xw}`ec wlc wrdib gdcw: x% ?19 I
,<$% Wlc gdcw i}}`dewcg f`r wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc nit oc h`ej`decg qdwl iet `wlcr gdcw w` oc
lcirg ocf`rc wlc wrdib gdcw: x% ?19 I,9?$%
1
Xchwd`e ?19I,9?$%<Xchwd`e ?19I,6$ ieg ,1$,i$%
4Xchwd`e ?19I,1$,o$,d$%
9=Xchwd`e ?19I,1$,o$,dd$% De xshl hdrhsnxwiehcx" wlc h`srw nit }`xw}`ec wlc wrdib gdcw:
x% ?19I,<$% Wlc gdcw i}}`dewcg f`r wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc nit oc h`ej`decg qdwl iet `wlcr
gdcw w` oc lcirg ocf`rc wlc wrdib gdcw: x% ?19I,9?$%
H`srw—x }`qcrx iw wlc hrdndeib lcirdea w` gdxhsxx hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc
<%98 Iw wlc }rcbdndeirt lcirdea" fdrxw gdcw" `r x}chdib gdcw rcfcrrcg w` de }iriari}l
<%9? io`vc" wlc h`srw" livdea advce }irwdcx ie `}}`rwsedwt w` oc lcirg" ,i$ nit"
qlcrc xwiegirg x}chdib ncixsrcx livc ibrcigt occe iswl`rdxcg" iswl`rdxc wlc
sxc `f fsrwlcr x}chdib ncixsrcx9
ieg ,o$ xlibb" de iet `wlcr hixc" iswl`rdxc
x}chdib ncixsrc,x$" qldhl wlc h`srw h`exdgcrx w` oc wlc n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc
}sr}`xc `f wikdea wlc hldbg—x cvdgcehc"?
`r ibwcreiwdvcbt xlibb nikc ie `rgcr
wliw wlc qdwecxx dx w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc%8
9 Xchwd`e ?19I,4$,i$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 117/206
? Xchwd`e ?19I,4$,o$,d$%
8 Xchwd`e ?19I,4$,o$,dd$% Wlc h`srw nit nikc xshl ie `rgcr `ebt df xiwdxfdcg ,i$ qlcrc wlc
hldbg qdwecxx lix c|}rcxxcg i qdxl w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib
ncixsrc" wliw dw dx i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc hldbg qdwecxx x` w` advc cvdgcehc" `r ,o$ de iet `wlcr
hixc" wliw ,d$ wlc sxc `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f wikdea wlc cvdgcehc `f wlc hldbg
qdwecxx q`sbg advc rdxc w` i xdaedfdhiew rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc fidrecxx `f wlc wrdib `r `wlcrqdxc
w` wlc dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc" ieg ,dd$ wliw rdxk xdaedfdhiewbt `swqcdalx iet rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc
dewcrcxwx `f wlc hldbg qdwecxx df wlc `rgcr dx nigc: x% ?19I,9=$%
Fsrwlcr x}chdib ncixsrcx de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax f`r hldbgrce segcr wlc iac `f
9?: xchwd`e ?19O
<%97 De hcrwide wt}cx `f hixc"9
i hldbg segcr wlc iac `f 9??
xl`sbg e`w oc rcysdrcg w`
advc cvdgcehc de wcrnx `f i x}chdib ncixsrc `rgcr qldhl lix wlc cffchw `f rcysdrdea wlc
hldbg w` oc }rcxcew de wlc h`srw.r``n `r de iet }irw `f wlc h`srw osdbgdea de qldhl wlc
h`srw.r``n dx b`hiwcg sebcxx wlc jsgac dx xiwdxfdcg.
,i$ qlcrc wlc hldbg qdwecxx lix c|}rcxxcg i qdxl w` oc x` }rcxcew" ieg wliw
}rcxcehc dx i}}r`}rdiwc" `r
,o$ de iet wlcr hixc" wliw.
,d$ bihk `f wlc hldbg—x }rcxcehc q`sbg advc rdxc w` i xdaedfdhiew rdxk
`f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc fidrecxx `f wlc wrdib `r `wlcrqdxc w` wlc
dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc"
ieg
,dd$ wliw rdxk xdaedfdhiewbt `swqcdalx iet rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc
dewcrcxwx `f wlc hldbg qdwecxx df wlc `rgcr dx nigc%8
9Xcc xchwd`e ?19O,9$%
?D%c% segcr wlc iac `f 9? `e wlc giwc `f h`nncehcncew `f }r`hccgdeax de qldhl wlc wrdib dx
ocdea `r w` oc lcbg: x% ?19O,9$,o$%
8Xchwd`e ?19O" dexcrwcg ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix}8$ ieg or`salw
dew` f`rhc `e 9 I}rdb ?==3 ,XXD ?==396< Irw%? ieg Xhlcg%$%
Hlieadea wlc x}chdib ncixsrcx iw iet wdnc gsrdea hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e
?19G
<%93 Xchwd`e ?19G `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ceiobcx wlc h`srw
w` ibwcr c|dxwdea x}chdib ncixsrcx ‒iw iet xwiac de wlc }r`hccgdeax ,qlcwlcr ocf`rc `r
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 118/206
ifwcr wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc wrdib `r ocf`rc `r ifwcr wlc qdwecxx lix ocase w` advc
cvdgcehc$„%9
Wlc h`srw nit.
`rgcr x}chdib ncixsrcx qlcrc e`ec lig }rcvd`sxbt occe rgcrcg;?
virt x}chdib ncixsrcx ibrcigt rgcrcg;8
rcv`kc x}chdib ncixsrcx ibrcigt rgcrcg%7
Wldx dn}`rwiew ecq }`qcr nit oc dev`kcg ot wlc }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc wlc
qdwecxx `r ot wlc h`srw `f dwx `qe n`wd`e3% Wlc h`srw nsxw advc wlc }irwdcx ie
`}}`rwsedwt w` oc lcirg" ieg nit wlce nikc ie `rgcr de wcrnx `f x% ?19G,?$%6
9Xchwd`e ?19G,9$: dexcrwcg ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix}8$ ieg
or`salw dew` f`rhc de rcbiwd`e w` hldbg qdwecxxcx `e 9 I}rdb ?==3 ,XXD ?==396< Irw%? ieg
Xhlcg%$
? D%c% ‒xshl x}chdib ncixsrc `r ncixsrcx ix wlc h`srw h`exdgcrx n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc
}sr}`xc `f wikdea wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc„: x% ?19G,?$,o$%
8Xchwd`e ?19G ,?$,i$% Ie `rgcr virtdea ie cirbdcr `rgcr nit igg w`" `r xsoxwdwswc" xshl
x}chdib ncixsrc ix wlc h`srw h`exdgcrx n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f wikdea wlc qdwecxx—x
cvdgcehc%
7 Wlc h`srw nit rcv`kc ie cirbdcr `rgcr `ebt df xiwdxfdcg ,i$ qlcrc wlc qdwecxx lix c|}rcxxcg i
qdxl w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw x}chdib ncixsrcx" wliw dw dx i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc qdwecxx x` w` advccvdgcehc; `r ,o$ de iet `wlcr hixc" wliw wlc sxc" `r h`ewdescg sxc" `f wlc x}chdib ncixsrc,x$
q`sbg advc rdxc w` i xdaedfdhiew rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc fidrecxx `f wlc wrdib `r `wlcrqdxc w` wlc
dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc" ieg ,dd$ wliw rdxk xdaedfdhiewbt `swqcdalx iet rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc
dewcrcxwx `f wlc qdwecxx df wlc `rgcr dx nigc%
3 Xchwd`e ?19G,9$,i$ `r ,o$%
6 Xchwd`e ?19 G,9$%
Cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19D
<%96 Qlcrc cvdgcehc dx w` oc wikce ot i h`nndxxd`ecr" wlc h`srw i}}`dewx cdwlcr i
Ldal H`srw jsgac ,de i Ldal H`srw wrdib$" `r i xlcrdff" ix i h`nndxxd`ecr9% Wlc
qdwecxx nit advc cvdgcehc ot HHWV bdek ?% ]r`hccgdeax irc rch`rgcg ot vdgc`.
rch`rgcr% Wlc ihhsxcg dx e`w }rcxcew de wlc r``n qlcrc wlc cvdgcehc dx ocdea wikce" `r
de wlc qdwecxx HHWV r``n8" osw dx cewdwbcg w` qiwhl ieg lcir wlc }r`hccgdeax ot xshl
nciex ix xccn xsdwiobc w` wlc h`srw%7
Iw wlc wrdib" wlc rch`rgdea `f wlc cvdgcehc wikce
`e h`nndxxd`e dx rchcdvcg de cvdgcehc qdwl`sw ocdea xq`re w` ot qdwecxxcx%3
Wlc
}r`hccgdeax ocf`rc wlc h`nndxxd`ecr irc w` oc wrciwcg ix df wlct qcrc }r`hccgdeax de
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 119/206
h`srw6% I ]rihwdhc E`wc lix occe dxxscg advdea gcwidbcg asdgiehc ix w` }r`hcgsrcx w`
oc f`bb`qcg qlce xcckdea wlc x}chdib ncixsrc `f cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e1%
9 Xchwd`e ?19D,1$ ieg ,<$" dexcrwcg ot xchwd`e 83 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hccgdeax cwh ,_cf`rn$
Xh`wbieg Ihw ?==1% De LN Igv`hiwc v T`seix" Abixa`q Ldal H`srw" Gchcnocr ?==1.Jiesirt
?==<" B`rg Lirgdc i}}`dewcg ldnxcbf ix i h`nndxxd`ecr w` wikc wlc cvdgcehc `f i f`sr.tcir.
`bg o`t de i hixc dev`bvdea wlc gciwl `f i oiot% Ix qix rc}`rwcg de Wlc Lcribg" ?3 Jiesirt
?==<: ‒Wlc }r`xchswd`e rcbdcg lcivdbt `e i vdgc`cg dewcrvdcq h`egsh wcg ot wlc jsgac" B`rg
Lirgdc" n`ewlx cirbdcr qdwl i f`sr.tcir.`bg o`t" qldhl dw qix hbidncg qix cvdgcehc `f ixxisbw
`e Ibdxloi%„
? Xchwd`e ?19D,9I$" dexcrwcg ot xchwd`e 83 `f wlc ?==1 Ihw%
8 Xchwd`e ?19D,8$,i$ ix incegcg ot wlc ?==1 Ihw% Wlc ihhsxcg nit `ebt oc }rcxcew `e x}chdib
hisxc xl`qe" qdwl wlc bcivc `f wlc h`srw%7
Xchwd`e ?19D,8$,o$
3Xchwd`e ?19D,7$
6Xchwd`e ?19D,3$" dexcrwcg ot wlc ?==1 Ihw%
1]rihwdhc E`wc E`%8 `f ?==3 Wikdea `f Cvdgcehc `f i Vsbecriobc Qdwecxx ot i H`nndxxd`ecr
,xcc I}}cegd| H w` wldx hli}wcr$% F`r c|in}bc" wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc xl`sbg advc fsbb
gcwidbx `f wlc }r`}`xcg vcesc ,irrieacg df echcxxirt qdwl wlc ixxdxwiehc `f wlc Cbchwr`edh
Xcrvdhc Gcbdvcrt Sedw qdwlde wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc$" wt}c `f h`nndxxd`ecr" wdncx xsdwiobc
w` wlc qdwecxx" dev`bvcncew `f HHWV ,df iet$" wlc eccg f`r orcikx" wlc eccg f`r gdxiobcg
ihhcxx" l`q wlc yscxwd`e `f dgcewdfdhiwd`e dx w` oc gcibw qdwl" qliw }r`gshwd`ex `r biocbx nit
oc }sw w` wlc qdwecxx" qlcwlcr ie dewcr}rcwcr dx rcysdrcg" ieg qlcwlcr iet `ojchwd`ex w`
}irwdhsbir }irwx `f cvdgcehc irc bdkcbt: }irix%1 ieg < `f wlc ]rihwdhc E`wc%
Bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,HHWV$ de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19J
<%91 Qlcrc cvdgcehc dx w` oc wikce ot bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,hb`xcg hdrhsdw wcbcvdxd`e
`r ‒HHWV„$" wlc h`srw nikcx xshl irrieacncewx ix irc i}}r`}rdiwc w` ceiobc wlc hldbg
w` advc cvdgcehc fr`n i }bihc `swxdgc wlc h`srw.r``n%9
Wlc }bihc nit oc qdwlde wlc
h`srw osdbgdea" `r iet `wlcr xsdwiobc }bihc%?
Wlc }bihc dx wrciwcg ix }irw `f wlc h`srw.
r``n qldbxw wlc qdwecxx advcx cvdgcehc"8
ieg wlc }r`hccgdeax irc wrciwcg ix wikdea
}bihc de wlc }rcxcehc `f wlc ihhsxcg%7
I hixc nit df echcxxirt oc wriexfcrrcg fr`n
`ec xlcrdff h`srw osdbgdea w` ie`wlcr qldhl lix wlc echcxxirt ihh`nn`giwd`e ieg
cysd}ncew%3
9 Xchwd`e ?19J,9$%
? Xchwd`e ?19J,?$,i$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 120/206
8 Xchwd`e ?19J,?$,o$%
7 Xchwd`e ?19J,8$%
3Xchwd`e ?19J,7$% Xshl i wriexfcr nit oc `rgcrcg iw iet xwiac `f wlc }r`hccgdeax" qlcwlcr
ocf`rc `r ifwcr wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc wrdib: x% ?19J,3$,i$% I wriexfcr nit ibx` oc `rgcrcg
de rcbiwd`e w` iet }irw `f wlc }r`hccgdeax: x% ?19J,3$,o$%
L`q w` `}criwc HHWV
<%9< De h`srw" wlc jsgac lix wq` WV xhrccex% Wlc fdrxw xhrcce xl`qx wlc hldbg xdwwdea
de wlc bdek r``n% I xnibb dexcw `e wliw xhrcce ibx` xl`qx wlc dniacx ocdea xcce ot
wlc hldbg `e wlc WV xhrcce de wlc bdek r``n% Wlc jsgac—x xch`eg xhrcce advcx ie
`vcrvdcq `f wlc bdek r``n" x` wliw ibb ihwdvdwt ,f`r c|in}bc" dei}}r`}rdiwc }r`n}wdea
fr`n i xs}}`rw }crx`e$ hie oc n`edw`rcg ieg df echcxxirt h`ewr`bbcg% Wlc
}r`xchswd`e" wlc gcfcehc" ieg wlc jsrt" livc xhrccex xl`qdea wlc hldbg `ebt% Wlct g`
e`w livc ie `vcrvdcq `f wlc bdek r``n% Wlc jsgac lix wlc h`ewr`b }iecb f`r wlc ql`bc
xtxwcn" qdwl osww`ex nirkcg ‒`e/`ff„" J ,jsgac$" ] ,}r`xchswd`e$" ieg G ,gcfcehc$% Dw
dx f`r wlc jsgac w` }rcxx wlc i}}r`}rdiwc osww`e w` ordea wlc dniac `f jsgac"
}r`xchswd`e `r gcfcehc" ix rcysdrcg" w` wlc hldbg—x xhrcce; osw wlc dniac `e wlc xhrccex
vdcqcg ot }r`xchswd`e" gcfcehc ieg jsrt dx devirdiobt wliw f wlc hldbg% Df" de wlc
h`srxc `f cvdgcehc" ie `ojchwd`e dx ridxcg" wlc jsgac xl`sbg c|}bide w` wlc hldbg wliw i
bcaib }`dew lix w` oc gdxhsxxcg" ieg wliw wlc wcbcvdxd`e qdbb oc xqdwhlcg `ff f`r i fcq
ndeswcx% Wlc jsgac xl`sbg wrt w` iv`dg advdea wlc dn}rcxxd`e wliw wlc hldbg lix g`ec
x`ncwldea oig" `r dx iw fisbw de x`nc qit" hisxdea wlc dewcrrs}wd`e%
Xhrccex de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19K
<%94 Wldx x}chdib ncixsrc dev`bvcx }`xdwd`edea i xhrcce de h`srw xshl wliw wlc
ihhsxcg dx h`ehcibcg fr`n wlc xdalw `f wlc hldbg qdwecxx%9 L`qcvcr wlc h`srw nsxw
nikc irrieacncewx w` cexsrc wliw wlc ihhsxcg dx iobc w` qiwhl ieg lcir wlc hldbg
qdwecxx advc cvdgcehc%?
9Xchwd`e ?19K,9$% Wlc xhrcce dx sxsibbt nigc `f x`nc x`bdg niwcrdib" xshl ix q``g%
?Xchwd`e ?19K,?$% De }rihwdhc" i HHWV hincri dx f`hsxcg `e wlc hldbg qdwecxx" }r`jchwdea ie
dniac `ew` i vdxsib gdx}bit sedw ,VGS$ vdcqcg ot wlc ihhsxcg% Wlc q``gce xhrcce
h`ehcibdea wlc ihhsxcg fr`n wlc xdalw `f wlc hldbg qdwecxx g`cx e`w iffchw wlc jsgac ieg jsrt"
ql` livc i fsbb vdcq `f o`wl ihhsxcg ieg hldbg%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 121/206
Xs}}`rwcr de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19B
<%?= I xs}}`rw }crx`e ,‒xs}}`rwcr„$ nit oc e`ndeiwcg ot `r `e oclibf `f i hldbg
qdwecxx" w` oc ‒}rcxcew ib`eaxdgc wlc qdwecxx w` xs}}`rw wlc qdwecxx qldbc wlc biwwcr dx
advdea cvdgcehc„%9 Df wlc }crx`e e`ndeiwcg dx w` advc cvdgcehc iw wlc wrdib" wliw }crx`e
nit e`w ihw ix xs}}`rwcr iw iet wdnc ocf`rc advdea cvdgcehc%? Wlc xs}}`rwcr nsxw e`w
}r`n}w `r `wlcrqdxc xcck w` defbscehc wlc qdwecxx de wlc h`srxc `f advdea cvdgcehc"8
ieg wlc h`srw nit qdxl w` qire wlc xs}}`rwcr ihh`rgdeabt%7 Wlc xciwdea irrieacncew
xl`sbg oc xshl wliw wlc xs}}`rwcr dx xsffdhdcewbt hb`xc w` wlc hldbg" osw g`cx e`w
dewcrfcrc" cdwlcr }ltxdhibbt `r vcroibbt" qdwl wlc hldbg—x cvdgcehc%
9Xchwd`e ?19B%
? Xchwd`e ?19B,?$%
8Xchwd`e ?19B,8$%
7Xcc }iri%6 `f B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c—x Ncn`riegsn `f Jsbt 944= ,xcw `sw de I}}cegd|
I" dec|}bdhiobt `ndwwcg fr`n ]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$$% De NhAdebct v L%N% Igv`hiwc"
?==9 X%H%H%_% 71" qlcrc ie igsbw h`n}bidecr de i hixc dev`bvdea ibbcacg xc|sib iosxc
rcyscxwcg wlc }rcxcehc `f lcr o`tfrdceg ix i xs}}`rw }crx`e" dw qix lcbg echcxxirt f`r wlc
xlcrdff w` advc gdrchwd`ex xwrcxxdea wlc bdndwcg r`bc `f wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e" ieg w` qire ldn e`w
w` dewcrfcrc qdwl wlc qdwecxx—x iexqcrx%
]rd`r xwiwcncew w` h`exwdwswc cvdgcehc de hldcf de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e
?19N
<%?9 Xchwd`e ?19N }crndwx wlc }rd`r xwiwcncew9 `f i hldbg qdwecxx ,f`r c|in}bc" i
xwiwcncew advce w` i }`bdhc `ffdhcr$ w` oc sxcg ix wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc de hldcf% Wlc
}rcvd`sx xwiwcncew dx b`gacg" ieg qdbb oc igndxxdobc ix wlc ql`bc `r }irw `f wlc
qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc de hldcf% Wlc qdwecxx g`cx e`w livc w` ig`}w wlc xwiwcncew r
`wlcrqdxc x}cik w` dw qlce advdea cvdgcehc de h`srw%? Xchwd`e ?6= i}}bdcx w` wlc }rd`r
xwiwcncew" qdwl x`nc n`gdfdhiwd`ex%8 Xchwd`e ?19N g`cx e`w iffchw wlc igndxxdodbdwt
`f iet xwiwcncew igndxxdobc `wlcr wlie ot vdrwsc `f xchwd`e ?19N%7
9De wcrnx `f x% ?19N,3$" ‒xwiwcncew„ lix wlc nciedea advce de x% ?6?,9$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw"
eincbt: ‒ i xwiwcncew dehbsgcx ‘
,i$ iet rc}rcxcewiwd`e" l`qcvcr nigc `r c|}rcxxcg" `f fihw `r `}ded`e; ieg
,o$ iet }irw `f i xwiwcncew" osw g`cx e`w dehbsgc i xwiwcncew de i }rch`aedwd`e
`wlcr wlie i }rch`aedwd`e `e `iwl„%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 122/206
I xwiwcncew dx ‒h`ewidecg de i g`hsncew qlcrc wlc }crx`e ql` nikcx dw ‘ ,i$ nikcx wlc
xwiwcncew de wlc g`hsncew }crx`eibbt; ,o$ nikcx i xwiwcncew qldhl dx" qdwl `r qdwl`sw ldx
ke`qbcgac" cno`gdcg de i g`hsncew ot qliwcvcr nciex `r ot iet }crx`e ql` lix gdrchw
}crx`eib ke`qbcgac `f wlc nikdea `f wlc xwiwcncew; `r ,h$ i}}r`vcx i g`hsncew ix cno`gtdea
wlc xwiwcncew„: x% ?6?,?$% ?
Xchwd`e ?19N,?$%
8Xchwd`e ?19N,8$% F`r c|in}bc" wlc xwiwcncew nsxw oc h`ewidecg de i g`hsncew; ieg wlcrc dx
x}chdib }r`vdxd`e f`r }rch`aedwd`ex `e `iwl ieg xwiwcncewx nigc de `wlcr }r`hccgdeax: x%
?6=,?$ w` ,7$ ix n`gdfdcg%
7Xchwd`e ?19N,7$%
Hldbg qdwecxx ior`ig: xchwd`e ?18
<%?? Df i hldbg qdwecxx lix w` advc cvdgcehc de i hrdndeib wrdib" osw dx ior`ig" ie
i}}bdhiwd`e f`r i bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek nit oc nigc ot bcwwcrx `f rcyscxw de wcrnx `f
xchwd`e ?18 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443%
Ncwl`gx `f dgcewdftdea ie ihhsxcg de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax dev`bvdea HHWV"
xhrccex `r cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e: xchwd`e ?<9I
<%?8 Xchwd`e ?<9I,9$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 }r`vdgcx;
‒,9$ Qlcrc de i wrdib wlc }r`xchsw`r b`gacx ix i }r`gshwd`e i rc}`rw eindea ‘
,i$ i }crx`e dgcewdfdcg de ie dgcewdfdhiwd`e }irigc `r `wlcr dgcewdfdhiwd`e
}r`hcgsrc ot i qdwecxx" ieg
,o$ wliw qdwecxx"
dw xlibb oc }rcxsncg" xsojchw w` xsoxchwd`e ,?$ ocb`q" wliw wlc }crx`e eincg de
wlc rc}`rw ix livdea occe dgcewdfdcg ot wlc qdwecxx dx wlc }crx`e `f wlc xinc
einc ql` i}}cirx de iexqcr w` wlc degdhwncew `r h`n}bidew%
,?$ Wliw }rcxsn}wd`e xlibb e`w i}}bt ‘
,i$ sebcxx wlc }r`xchsw`r lix" ot wlc rcysdrcg wdnc" xcrvcg `e wlc ihhsxcg i
h`}t `f wlc rc}`rw ieg i e`wdhc wliw lc dewcegx w` rcbt `e wlc }rcxsn}wd`e" `r
,o$ df wlc ihhsxcg.
,d$ e`w n`rc wlie 1 gitx ifwcr wlc giwc `f xcrvdhc `f wlc h`}t `f wlc
rc}`rw" `r
,dd$ ot xshl biwcr wdnc ix wlc h`srw nit de x}chdib hdrhsnxwiehcx ibb`q"
lix xcrvcg e`wdhc `e wlc }r`xchsw`r wliw lc dewcegx w` hlibbceac wlc
fihwx xwiwcg de wlc rc}`rw%
,8$ De xsoxchwd`e ,?$,i$ io`vc" ‒wlc rcysdrcg wdnc„ nciex.
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 123/206
,i$ de wlc hixc `f }r`hccgdeax de wlc Ldal H`srw ‘
,d$ e`w bcxx wlie 97 hbcir gitx ocf`rc wlc }rcbdndeirt lcirdea; `r
,dd$ xshl biwcr wdnc" ocdea e`w bcxx wlie 97 hbcir gitx ocf`rc wlc wrdib" ix
wlc h`srw nit" de x}chdib hdrhsnxwiehcx" ibb`q;
,o$ de iet `wlcr hixc" e`w bcxx wlie 97 gitx ocf`rc wlc wrdib%„
@wlcr ncwl`gx `f dgcewdfdhiwd`e `f ie ihhsxcg de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax dev`bvdea
HHWV" xhrccex `r cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e
<%?7 @wlcr ncwl`gx f dgcewdfdhiwd`e irc ibx` ividbiobc% F`r c|in}bc ‘
J`dew ndeswc%
Qlcrc ie `ffcehc dx ibbcacg w` livc occe h`nndwwcg de iet x}chdib hi}ihdwt
xshl ix wlc fiwlcr `f i hldbg" ieg wlc hldbg rcfcrx w` ldx `r lcr fiwlcr qldbc
ie`wlcr igsbw advcx cvdgcehc wliw wlc ihhsxcg dx wlc hldbg—x fiwlcr: x% ?33 `f
wlc 9443 Ihw" ieg ] v Qdbbdinx" ?==3 X%B%W% 3=<%
Nsbg``e v Lcrr`e" 941= J%H% 8=: }rcxsniobt df wlc }r`xchsw`r lix fidbcg w`
xcrvc wlc echcxxirt e`wdhc de wcrnx `f x% ?<9I" dw dx xwdbb }`xxdobc w` bcig wlc
cvdgcehc `f }`bdhc `ffdhcrx ql` xiq wlc hldbg qdwecxx dgcewdft wlc ihhsxcg ix
wlc }cr}cwriw`r iw ie dgcewdfdhiwd`e }irigc%
Dw dx ibx` irasiobc wliw" qlcrc wlcrc lix occe fidbsrc w` xcrvc wlc echcxxirt
e`wdhc de wcrnx `f x% ?<9I" dw dx `}ce w` wlc }r`xchsw`r w` xcck i virdiwd`e `f
wlc x}chdib ncixsrcx de wcrnx `f x% ?19G f`r wlc bdndwcg }sr}`xc `f ibb`qdea
wlc hldbg w` cewcr wlc h`srw.r``n w` iwwcn}w w` dgcewdft wlc }cr}cwriw`r%
L`qcvcr xshl ie i}}r`ihl nit livc gdxigviewiacx: f`r c|in}bc" wlc hldbg
xwdbb lix cvdgcehc w` advc de hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e ieg rc.c|indeiwd`e" tcw wlc
}rcxcehc `f wlc ibbcacg }cr}cwriw`r nit hisxc wlc hldbg w` och`nc gdxwrcxxcg
ieg seiobc w` h`ewdesc: hf% `oxcrviwd`ex de Or`wlcrxw`e v L%N% Igv`hiwc"
9443 X%H%H%_% 698%
Qldbc dw dx de wlc`rt }`xxdobc f`r wlc hldbg w` rcnide de wlc bdek r``n qldbc
wlc hincri rcbitdea wlc h`srw.r``n dniac w` wlc hldbg dx }ieecg ir`seg wlc
h`srw.r``n ieg wlc hldbg dx wlce ixkcg w` xit df wlc }cr}cwriw`r dx wlcrc" wliw
}irwdhsbir i}}r`ihl lix e`w occe wcxwcg de }rihwdhc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 124/206
Hldbg qdwecxx rcfsxdea w` h`.`}criwc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?34
<%?3 Xchwd`e ?34 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 }crndwx wlc }rd`r
xwiwcncew `f" dewcr ibd`x" i hldbg qdwecxx w` oc igndwwcg de cvdgcehc qlcrc wlc jsgac dx
xiwdxfdcg wliw wlc hldbg lix:
rcfsxcg w` ihhc}w wlc jsgac—x ign`edwd`e w` wcbb wlc wrswl ,`r" livdea occe x`
ign`edxlcg" rcfsxcg w` advc cvdgcehc$; `r
rcfsxcg w` wikc wlc `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e ,`r" livdea occe xq`re `r livdea
iffdrncg ieg livdea occe gdrchwcg ot wlc jsgac w` advc cvdgcehc de h`eechwd`e
qdwl wlc xsojchw.niwwcr `f wlc xwiwcncew" rcfsxcg w` g` x`$%
Wldx dee`viwdvc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`e xl`sbg oc sxcg x}irdeabt" ocirdea de ndeg wlc bihk
`f `}}`rwsedwt w` hr`xx.c|indec `r `wlcrqdxc wcxw wlc cvdgcehc%9
9 Xcc wlc `oxcrviwd`ex de NihG`eibg v L%N% Igv`hiwc" 9444 X%H%H%_% 976" qlcrc wlc ihhsxcg
qix hliracg qdwl xlincbcxx degchceht" ieg wlrcc <.tcir.`bg qdwecxxcx ochinc gdxwrcxxcg ieg
rcfsxcg w` iexqcr yscxwd`ex% Wlc I}}cib H`srw h`nncewcg `e wlc dee`viwdvc eiwsrc `f x% ?34"
ieg cn}lixdxcg wliw" }rd`r w` rcx`rwdea w` i xwiwcncew ib`ec de wcrnx `f x% ?34" wlc qdwecxx
nsxw fdrxwbt oc gdrchwcg w` iexqcr wlc yscxwd`ex" ieg xch`egbt" ixkcg qlcwlcr lc `r xlc lig
nigc i }rcvd`sx xwiwcncew% Wlce wlc wcrnx `f wlc xwiwcncew xl`sbg oc }sw w` wlc qdwecxx%
]r`fcxx`r A`rg`e de ldx h`nncewirt" iw }% 939" `oxcrvcx wliw x% ?34 ridxcx h`ehcrex io`sw wlc
sewcxwcg eiwsrc `f wlc xwiwcncew ieg ibx` wlc fihw wliw i xdeabc qdwecxx ndalw oc rcairgcg ix
xsffdhdcew w` }r`vc wlc xwiwcncew%
Hldbg ix ihhsxcg }crx`e: xchwd`e ?19F,?$
<%?6 De wcrnx `f xchwd`e ?19F,?$" ie ihhsxcg }crx`e segcr wlc iac `f 96 dx cewdwbcg
w` hcrwide x}chdib irrieacncewx de h`srw% L`qcvcr lc dx e`w cewdwbcg w` wlc sxc `f
xhrccex%9 N`rc`vcr df ldx cvdgcehc dx w` oc wikce ot h`nndxxd`e" xchwd`e ?19D,8$ g`cx
e`w i}}bt%?
9Xchwd`e ?19F,<$,i$%
?Ioxcehc `f ihhsxcg fr`n r``n qlcrc cvdgcehc dx ocdea wikce ocf`rc wlc h`nndxxd`ecr:
x% ?19F,<$,o$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 125/206
X]CHDIB I__IEACNCEWX DE HDVDB ]_@HCCGDEAX
H`srw—x }`qcrx iw h`nn`e biq de hdvdb }r`hccgdeax
<%?1 Iw h`nn`e biq" i jsgac lix }`qcr w` rcasbiwc }r`hccgdeax ieg de }irwdhsbirwlc nieecr de qldhl qdwecxxcx nit advc wlcdr cvdgcehc%
9 F`r c|in}bc" i jsgac lix wlc
}`qcr iw h`nn`e biq w` }crndw i hldbg qdwecxx w` advc cvdgcehc xciwcg de wlc qcbb `f
wlc h`srw riwlcr xwiegdea `r xdwwdea de wlc qdwecxx o`|% I jsgac ibx` lix }`qcr w`
ibb`q i hldbg qdwecxx w` xdw ocldeg i xhrcce; w` `rgcr biqtcrx w` rcn`vc a`qex ieg
qdax df wliw dx wl`salw w` oc lcb}fsb de }swwdea i hldbg qdwecxx iw cixc; w` }crndw i
xs}}`rw }crx`e w` xdw ecir i hldbg qdwecxx; }r`oiobt w` ariew ie i}}bdhiwd`e w` wikc i
hldbg qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e; ieg }`xxdobt cvce w` hbcir wlc h`srw w` iv`dg
segsc ie|dcwt `r gdxwrcxx w` wlc hldbg qdwecxx%? Dw dx wl`salw wliw wlc jsgac—x h`nn`e
biq }`qcrx g` e`w c|wceg w` `rgcrdea i HHWV bdek de i hdvdb hixc" `r }crndwwdea wlc
sxc `f i hldbg qdwecxx—x }rd`r xwiwcncew w` oc sxcg ix cvdgcehc de hldcf%
9 Lin}x`e v L%N% Igv`hiwc" ?==8 X%H%H%_% 98" B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib Hsbbce iw }iri%[4^: ‒Dw dx
}bide wliw wlc h`srw lix wlc }`qcr" ieg degccg wlc gswt" w` [rcasbiwc dwx }r`hccgdeax dehbsgdea
wlc nieecr de qldhl qdwecxxcx nit advc wlcdr cvdgcehc^ qlce wldx dx echcxxirt de `rgcr w`
nccw wlc rcysdrcncewx `f jsxwdhc de wlc }irwdhsbir hixc%„
? Lin}x`e hdw% xs}% ieg Ncn`riegsn `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx ot B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c
giwcg Jsbt 944= }iri% 8,g$ ,xcc I}}cegd| I w` wldx hli}wcr$; ]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$
}iri%3,h$ ,xcc I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr$%
H`srw—x xwiwsw`rt }`qcrx de hdvdb }r`hccgdeax
<%?< Hdvdb }r`hccgdeax9
irc a`vcrecg ot xchwd`ex 99 w` ?8 ,]irw ?$ `f wlc Vsbecriobc
Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7? ix incegcg ot xchwd`e 916 `f wlc Hldbgrce—x
Lcirdeax ,Xh wbieg$ Ihw ?=99% De h`ewrixw qdwl hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax ,qlcrc wlcrc dx
ie ixxsn}wd`e wliw i hldbg qdwecxx rcysdrcx x}chdib irrieacncewx de h`srw8$" de hdvdb
}r`hccgdeax wlc h`srw—x gswt dx w` nikc ie rgcr:
‒,i$ iswl`rdxdea wlc sxc `f xshl x}chdib ncixsrc `r ncixsrcx ix wlc h`srw
h`exdgcrx w` oc n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f wikdea wlc hldbg qdwecxx—x
cvdgcehc" `r
,o$ wliw wlc hldbg qdwecxx dx w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib
ncixsrc%„7
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 126/206
Wlc }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc i hldbg qdwecxx nsxw b`gac i hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc"
x}chdftdea wlc i}}r`}rdiwc x}chdib ncixsrcx x`salw" `r ibwcreiwdvcbt xwiwdea wliw e`
x}chdib ncixsrcx irc rcysdrcg3% X}chdib ncixsrcx de wldx h`ewc|w irc i HHWV bdek" i
xhrcce" wlc wikdea `f cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e" ieg i xs}}`rwcr6% Qlce h`exdgcrdea i
hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc" wlc h`srw xl`sbg livc rcairg w` wlc ocxw dewcrcxwx `f wlc hldbg
qdwecxx" ieg xl`sbg wikc dew` ihh`sew wlc vdcqx `f wlc hldbg ,gc}cegdea `e iac ieg
niwsrdwt$ ieg wlc }ircew,x$1% Wlc h`srw xl`sbg `rgcr e` x}chdib ncixsrcx df xiwdxfdcg
wliw wlc hldbg lix c|}rcxxcg i qdxl w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib
ncixsrc" ieg wliw dw dx i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc hldbg w` g` x`<% Ibwcreiwdvcbt wlc h`srw nsxw
oc xiwdxfdcg wliw wlc sxc `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc q`sbg advc rdxc w` i ‒xdaedfdhiew rdxk `f
}rcjsgdhc w` wlc fidrecxx `f wlc }r`hccgdeax `r `wlcrqdxc w` wlc dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc"
ieg…wliw rdxk xdaedfdhiewbt `swqcdalx iet rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc dewcrcxwx `f wlc
hldbg qdwecxx df wlc `rgcr dx nigc%„4
Wlc irrieacncewx f`r wlc hldbg nit oc rcvdcqcg
iw iet xwiac de wlc }r`hccgdeax9=
% Wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx
i}}bdhiwd`e nsxw oc b`gacg `r nigc ocf`rc wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc lcirdea iw
qldhl wlc hldbg `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx dx w` advc cvdgcehc osw" `e hisxc xl`qe" nit oc
b`gacg `r nigc ifwcr wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc lcirdea%99
Wlcxc }r`vdxd`ex i}}bt ibx`
w` i hldbg ql` dx }irwt w` hdvdb bdwdaiwd`e%9?
Wlc ]rdehd}ib _c}`rwcr nit b`gac i hldbg
qdwecxx e`wdhc `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx i}}bdhiwd`e `r nikc ie i}}bdhiwd`e w` rcvdcq wlc
hsrrcew irrieacncewx f`r wikdea i qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc%98
9 ‒Hdvdb }r`hccgdeax„ dehbsgcx hdvdb }r`hccgdeax de wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e ieg wlc xlcrdff h`srw"
fiwib ihhdgcew deysdrdcx" ieg i}}bdhiwd`ex w` wlc xlcrdff h`srw segcr ]irw DD `f wlc Hldbgrce
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ,f`r c|in}bc" ie i}}bdhiwd`e w` cxwiobdxl ar`segx `f rcfcrrib$% Hl%83I `f
wlc _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e xcwx `sw wlc i}}r`}rdiwc f`rnx ieg }r`hcgsrcx i}}bdhiobc
fr`n 9 E`vcnocr ?==1 ,XXD ?==1/73=$%
? Xcc h`nncehcncew `rgcrx XXD ?==3/96<; ?==3/34=; ?==6/34; ieg ?==1/771%8
Xcc }iri%<%< cw xcy% io`vc%
7Xchwd`ex 99,9$ ieg 9?,9$%
3Xchwd`e 9?,?$%
6Xchwd`e 9?,8$ ieg 9<% De wcrnx `f x% 9?,8$" df i hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc x}chdfdcx i HHWV bdek" `r
i xhrcce `r i xs}}`rwcr" ‒wliw x}chdib ncixsrc dx … w` oc wikce w` oc wlc n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc
[ncixsrc^ f`r wlc }sr}`xcx `f wikdea wlc hldbg qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc„%
1Xchwd`e 93,?$.,7$% Arciwcr qcdalw dx w` oc advce w` wlc hldbg—x vdcqx qlcrc deh`exdxwcehdcx
irdxc ocwqcce }ircew ieg hldbg%
<Xchwd`e 9?,7$,i$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 127/206
4Xchwd`e 9?,7$,o$%
9=Xchwd`e 98,9$% Wlc h`srw nit rcvdcq wlc irrieacncewx `e wlc i}}bdhiwd`e `f wlc }irwt hdwdea
wlc qdwecxx" `r `f dwx `qe n`wd`e% Ie cirbdcr `rgcr nit oc virdcg `r rcv`kcg" `r i ecq x}chdib
ncixsrc iswl`rdxcg%
99
Xchwd`e 9?,<$ dexcrwcg ot x%916 Hldbgrce—x Lcirdeax ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?=99% 9?
Xchwd`e 96%
98Xchwd`e 96I dexcrwcg ot x%916 Hldbgrce—x Lcirdeax ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?=99%
NDXHCBBIEC@SX X]CHDIB I__IEACNCEWX DE H_DNDEIB IEG
HDVDB ]_@HCCGDEAX
Hldbg segcr 9? tcirx e`w }sw `e `iwl
<%?4 I hldbg iacg segcr 9? tcirx dx e`w }sw `e `iwl" osw dx xdn}bt ign`edxlcg w` wcbb
wlc wrswl%9 Xdehc 9 I}rdb ?==3"? dw dx e` b`eacr wlc fsehwd`e `f wlc jsgac w` h`egshw i
}rcbdndeirt c|indeiwd`e `f wlc hldbg w` ixxcxx qlcwlcr lc `r xlc dx h`n}cwcew w` advc
cvdgcehc%8 Xchwd`e ?7 `f wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix}8$
}r`vdgcx:
‒,9$ Wlc cvdgcehc `f iet }crx`e hibbcg ix i qdwecxx ,rcfcrrcg w` de wldx xchwd`e
ix ‒wlc qdwecxx„$ de hrdndeib `r hdvdb }r`hccgdeax dx e`w deigndxxdobc
x`bcbt ochisxc wlc qdwecxx g`cx e`w segcrxwieg .
,i$ wlc eiwsrc `f wlc gswt `f i qdwecxx w` advc wrswlfsb cvdgcehc" `r
,o$ wlc gdffcrcehc ocwqcce wrswl ieg bdcx%
,?$ Ihh`rgdeabt" wlc h`srw nsxw e`w" iw iet wdnc ocf`rc wlc qdwecxx advcx
cvdgcehc" wikc iet xwc} dewcegcg w` cxwiobdxl qlcwlcr wlc qdwecxx
segcrxwiegx wl`xc niwwcrx%„
9Hf% Ysdee v Bccx" 9447 X%H%H%_% 934%
?Qlce x% ?7 `f wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix}8$ hinc dew` cffchw ,XXD
?==3/96< Irw%? ieg Xhlcg%$ f`bb`qdea s}`e i Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew h`exsbwiwd`e }i}cr ‒Vdwib
V`dhcx: Lcb}dea Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx Advc Cvdgcehc„ ,Nit ?==?$%
8De wlc xcexc `f ocdea hi}iobc `f segcrxwiegdea wlc yscxwd`e" ieg `f rcx}`egdea qdwl ie
i}}rchdiwd`e `f wlc gdffcrcehc ocwqcce wrswl ieg bdcx: hf% gdhwi `f B`rg Lindbw`e de B v B"
9446 X%B%W% 161%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 128/206
Hldbg iacg 9? `r 98 tcirx nit oc }sw `e `iwl
<%8= Wlc h`srw lix w` hlchk wliw wlc hldbg segcrxwiegx wlc }r`hcgsrc `f wikdea ie
`iwl de h`srw w` wcbb wlc wrswl% Df wlc h`srw dx xiwdxfdcg" wlc `iwl9
nit oc igndedxwcrcg%
@wlcrqdxc wlc h`srw lix w` `owide wlc hldbg—x }r`ndxc w` wcbb wlc wrswl%?
9 @r iffdrniwd`e%
? Ysdee v Bccx 9447 X%H%H%_% 934%
Hldbg iacg 97 `r `vcr }sw `e `iwl
<%89 Wlc h`srw xl`sbg e`rnibbt igndedxwcr wlc `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e% E` }rcbdndeirt
devcxwdaiwd`e dx sxsibbt echcxxirt%9
9 Ysdee v Bccx 9447 X%H%H%_% 934%
Ndhr`}l`ecx de h`srw f`r xnibb v`dhcx
<%8? Hldbgrce `fwce livc gdffdhsbwt }r`jchwdea wlcdr v`dhcx" ieg jsgacx ieg jsrdcx
hie och`nc frsxwriwcg qlce wlct hiee`w lcir% Irrieacncewx f`r cbchwr`edh
in}bdfdhiwd`e ,e`q xwiegirg de niet h`srw osdbgdeax$ hie iv`dg `r rcgshc wldx
}r`obcn%
9
X`nc h`srwx `ffcr ‒bi}cb„ ndhr`}l`ecx" iwwihlcg w` wlc qdwecxx—x hb`wldea%
?
9 Hf% }iri% 7 ,f$ `f B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c—x Ncn`riegsn `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx" Jsbt 944=
,xcc I}}cegd| I w` wldx hli}wcr$% Xcc e`q }iri% 6,a$ `f ]rihwdhc E`wc E` ? `f ?==3 ,Hldbg
Qdwecxxcx: Gdxhrcwd`eirt ]`qcrx$ ,xcc I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr$%
?F`r c|in}bc" wlc Ldal H`srw de Abixa`q: xcc ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt
H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" iw }%9<=%
Xciwdea irrieacncewx: }`xdwd`e `f hldbg de h`srw
<%88 Hldbg ix }irwt: Qlcrc i hldbg dx i }irwt w` i hdvdb hixc" lc `r xlc xl`sbg
}r`oiobt xdw ocxdgc `r ocldeg ldx `r lcr biqtcr" df wlc h`srw.r``n bit`sw }crndwx%
<%87 Hldbg ix qdwecxx: Df i hldbg dx advdea cvdgcehc de h`srw" wlc jsgac ndalw
h`exdgcr h`ndea g`qe fr`n wlc ocehl ieg xdwwdea iw wlc xinc bcvcb ix wlc hldbg%9
De i
hrdndeib wrdib" i vsbecriobc hldbg qdwecxx dx `fwce ocxw xciwcg de wlc qcbb `f wlc h`srw"
gdrchwbt de fr`ew `f wlc jsrt" fihdea wlc jsgac" qdwl ldx `r lcr oihk w` wlc ihhsxcg%?
Ibwcreiwdvcbt" df i hldbg q`sbg }rcfcr w` rcnide de wlc qdwecxx o`|" wlc yscxwd`ecr
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 129/206
,qlcwlcr h`sexcb" x`bdhdw`r" `r x`bdhdw`r.igv`hiwc$ ndalw oc ocxw }`xdwd`ecg ecir wlc
ocehl" x` wliw wlc hldbg dx iobc w` fihc w`qirgx wlc jsgac ,ieg jsrt" df iet$ ieg iqit
fr`n wlc ihhsxcg%
9 Dw nit" l`qcvcr" oc fcbw wliw wlc jsgac xl`sbg rcnide `e wlc ocehl ,i$ w` nidewide ie
`vcrvdcq `f }r`hccgdeax acecribbt; ,o$ w` oc iobc w` `oxcrvc wlc oclivd`sr ieg gcncie`sr `f
ibb h`ehcrecg; ieg ,h$ w` iv`dg deigvcrwcewbt `vcrlcirdea dexwrshwd`ex `r h`nncewx }ixxdea
ocwqcce wlc hldbg ieg ldx `r lcr biqtcrx: xcc ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt
H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" iw }% 9<?%
? Xcc }iri% 8,o$ `f wlc Ncn`riegsn ot B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx" Jsbt
944= ,xcc I}}cegd| I w` wldx hli}wcr$; ieg }iri%3,o$ `f ]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$ ,xcc
I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr$%
<%83 Hldbg ix ihhsxcg: Qlcrc i hldbg dx ie ihhsxcg de i hrdndeib wrdib" wlcrc dx
`fwce i }rcbdndeirt lcirdea ocf`rc wlc wrdib jsgac" w` h`exdgcr qliw x}chdib
irrieacncewx xl`sbg oc nigc f`r wlc hldbg%9
Xshl irrieacncewx nit oc nigc
qlcwlcr `r e w wlcrc irc igsbw h`.ihhsxcg% Wlc hldbg nit oc }crndwwcg w` xdw ocxdgc
ldx `r lcr biqtcr" riwlcr wlie de wlc g`hk" ieg nit xdn}bt n`vc w` ie`wlcr }`xdwd`e
,xwdbb iw fb``r bcvcb$ qlce advdea cvdgcehc%?
Wlc h`srw nsxw livc rcairg w` wlc qcbfirc
`f wlc hldbg ihhsxcg ieg w` wlc yscxwd`e qlcwlcr lc xl`sbg oc rcn`vcg fr`nsegcxdriobc xsrr`segdeax
8%
9 Hf% wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx gcxhrdocg de ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„"
G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" iw }% 9<9%
?]iac 9<? `f ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw„% De wlc wrdib gcxhrdocg de wliw irwdhbc" de Abixa`q Ldal
H`srw" i wiobc qix }bihcg de fr`ew `f wlc g`hk% Wlc wq` ihhsxcg iacg segcr 96 tcirx xiw iw wlc
wiobc" ihh`n}iedcg ot wlcdr x`bdhdw`rx% Wlc jsgac ieg jsrt lig i hbcir vdcq `f wlc hldbgrce%
Wlc hldbgrce—x x`bdhdw`rx qcrc iobc w` lcb} wlcn w` f`bb`q }r`hccgdeax% Wlc hldbgrce—x h`sexcb
xiw xc}iriwcbt" iw wlc oir `f wlc h`srw% Ibb wlc hldbg qdwecxxcx ,dehbsgdea wlc wq` ihhsxcg
hldbgrce$ aivc cvdgcehc xciwcg iw ie`wlcr wiobc b`hiwcg de fr`ew `f wlc jsrt o`|%
8Xcc xchwd`e 3=,6$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443%
]rcxcehc `f hldbg }xthldiwrdxw `r }xthl`b`adxw
<%86 Dw nit oc i}}r`}rdiwc w` ariew ie i}}bdhiwd`e w` livc i hldbg }xthldiwrdxw `r
hldbg }xthl`b`adxw }rcxcew de h`srw w` n`edw`r wlc qcbb.ocdea `f i hldbg advdea
cvdgcehc%
9
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 130/206
9 ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$
914" iw }%9<=%
Frcyscew orcikx
<%81 Wlc jsgac xl`sbg ixk wlc hldbg w` degdhiwc df `r qlce lc `r xlc rcysdrcx i
orcik% Ibwcreiwdvcbt" wlc h`srw nit iarcc iw wlc `swxcw w` igj`sre cvcrt l`sr `r x`%9
9 De wlc wrdib gcxhrdocg de wlc irwdhbc ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„"
G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" iw }%9<?" hldbg }xthl`b`adxwx— rch`nncegiwd`ex w`
xdw f`r e` b`eacr wlie 7= ndeswcx iw i wdnc" qdwl ?= ndeswc orcikx" qcrc ig`}wcg% Ibwl`sal
e`w i}}bdhiobc de Xh`wbieg" i ]rihwdhc Gdrchwd`e dxxscg ot wlc B`rg Hldcf Jsxwdhc f`r Ceabieg
ieg Qibcx" B`rg Odealin de ?=== f`bb`qdea s}`e wlc Wl`nx`e ieg Vceiobcx hixcx W v
Sedwcg Kdeag`n" V v Sedwcg Kdeag`n ,944=$ 8= C%L%_%_% 9?9% xsaacxwx: ‒9?% Wlc wrdibxl`sbg oc h`egshwcg ihh`rgdea w` i wdncwiobc qldhl [wikcx^ fsbb ihh`sew `f i t`sea
gcfcegiew—x deiodbdwt w` h`ehcewriwc f`r b`ea }crd`gx% Frcyscew ieg rcasbir orcikx [qdbb^ `fwce
oc i}}r`}rdiwc%„ Wlc ]rihwdhc Gdrchwd`e hie oc f`seg iw [?===^ 9 Q%B%_% 634; [?===^ ? Ibb
C%_% ?<3%
A`qex ieg qdax
<%8< Niet hldbgrce irc findbdir qdwl a`qex ieg qdax" livdea qiwhlcg wcbcvdxd`e
ieg fdbnx% De x`nc hixcx" wlcrcf`rc" wlcrc nit oc bdwwbc w` oc aidecg ot `rgcrdea wliw
a`qex ieg qdax oc rcn`vcg% De hcrwide hixcx" l`qcvcr" i vsbecriobc hldbg nit fdeg
wlc a`qex" r`ocx ieg qdax dewdndgiwdea% Cirbt ixxcxxncew `f wlc hldbg dx igvdxiobc
,ot" f`r c|in}bc" wlc }rch`aedwd`e `ffdhcr" `r i }`bdhc `ffdhcr" `r i h`srw `ffdhdib ql`
lix xs}crvdxd`e `f wlc hldbg gsrdea h`srw }r`hccgdeax$% Wlcrcifwcr a``g
h`nnsedhiwd`e dx cxxcewdib" ieg wlc h`srw lix gdxhrcwd`e w` }crndw a`qex ieg qdax w`
oc rcn`vcg gsrdea wlc hldbg—x cvdgcehc%9
9]iri% 8,i$ `f B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c—x Ncn`riegsn `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx" Jsbt 944=
xs}crxcgcg ot }iri 3,i$ `f ]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$ ,xcc I}}cegdhcx I ieg O w` wldx
hli}wcr$% De wlc wrdib rcfcrrcg w` de wlc irwdhbc ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt
H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" iw }%9<?" wlc jsgac" hbcrk" nihcr" h`sexcb"
ieg }`bdhc qcrc ibb def`rnibbt grcxxcg%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 131/206
Hibbdea wlc hixc
<%84 De i hrdndeib wrdib" df i hldbg dx ie ihhsxcg }crx`e" dw nit oc igvdxiobc w`
irrieac w` livc wlc hixc hibbcg `vcr wlc wiee`t qdwl`sw sxdea wlc einc `f wlc hldbg
ihhsxcg" wlsx }rcxcrvdea ldx r lcr ie`etndwt%9
9 ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„" G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$
914" iw }%9<7: ‒Wlc hibbdea `f wlc hixc `vcr wlc h`srw wiee`t qix igi}wcg w` c|hbsgc wlc einc
`f wlc hldbg ihhsxcg" wlc f`rniw sxcg ocdea ‒H`ewdescg wrdib ocf`rc B`rg Hirb`qit h`srw 6„%
Hbcirdea wlc h`srw
<%7= De wcrnx `f xchwd`e 3=,8$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443"
qlcrc i hldbg dx hibbcg ix i qdwecxx de i hixc rcbiwdea w` ‒ie `ffcehc iaidexw gchceht `r n`ribdwt„" wlc h`srw nit" gsrdea wlc hldbg—x cvdgcehc" c|hbsgc fr`n wlc h`srw r``n
cvcrt`ec c|hc}w ‘
,i$ ncnocrx `r `ffdhcrx `f h`srw"
,o$ }irwdcx w` wlc hixc" wlcdr h`sexcb `r x`bdhdw`rx" `r }crx`ex `wlcrqdxc
gdrchwbt h`ehcrecg de wlc hixc"
,h$ o`ei fdgc rc}`rwcrx }rcxcew f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f }rc}irdea i
h`ewcn}`riec`sx rc}`rw `f wlc }r`hccgdeax" r
,g$ iet`ec x}chdibbt iswl`rdxcg ot wlc h`srw w` oc }rcxcew ,f`r c|in}bc" i
xs}}`rw }crx`e$%
<%79 De wcrnx `f xchwd`e 4?,8$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw" ‒Fr`n wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc
bcigdea `f cvdgcehc de i wrdib f`r ri}c `r wlc bdkc wlc jsgac nit" df lc wldekx fdw" hisxc
ibb }crx`ex `wlcr wlie wlc ihhsxcg ieg h`sexcb ieg x`bdhdw`rx w` oc rcn`vcg fr`n wlc
h`srw.r``n%„
<%7? De iet `wlcr hixc" wlc jsgac nit hbcir wlc h`srw w` iv`dg segsc ie|dcwt `r
gdxwrcxx w` wlc hldbg%9
9]iri% 1 `f wlc Ncn`riegsn ot B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx" Jsbt 944=
,xcw `sw de I}}cegd| I w` wldx hli}wcr$" xs}crxcgcg ot }iri% 3,h$ `f ]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f
9443$ ,xcc I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr$%
<%78 _cx}`exdobc ncnocrx `f wlc }rcxx irc e`w e`rnibbt c|hbsgcg%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 132/206
_cn`vib `f ie ihhsxcg ql` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf
<%77 Df ie ihhsxcg x` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf gsrdea wlc h`srxc `f i wrdib wliw wlc jsgac
f`rnx wlc vdcq wliw i }r`}cr wrdib hiee`w wikc }bihc sebcxx wlc ihhsxcg dx rcn`vcg" wlc
jsgac nit `rgcr wliw lc `r xlc dx rcn`vcg fr`n wlc h`srw f`r x` b`ea ix wliw h`egshw
nikcx dw echcxxirt" ieg wliw wlc wrdib }r`hccg de wlc ihhsxcg—x ioxcehc%9
Df wlc
ihhsxcg dx e`w bcaibbt rc}rcxcewcg" wlc jsgac nsxw i}}`dew h`sexcb `r i x`bdhdw`r w`
rc}rcxcew ldx `r lcr dewcrcxwx gsrdea xshl ie ioxcehc%
9X`bcne }r`hccgdeax: x% 4?,?$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443; xsnnirt
}r`hccgdeax: x% 938,?$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
_cxwrdhwdea esnocrx de h`srw
<%73 De Xh`wbieg" dw dx rirc f`r xwc}x w` oc wikce w` rcxwrdhw esnocrx de h`srw9
,ix
gdxwdehw fr`n hbcirdea wlc h`srw?$%
9 De Ceabieg ieg Qibcx" l`qcvcr" B`rg Hldcf Jsxwdhc Odealin—x ]rihwdhc Gdrchwd`e de ?===
xsaacxwx: ‒97% Wlc h`srw xl`sbg oc }rc}ircg w` rcxwrdhw iwwcegiehc iw [i wrdib dev`bvdea i hldbg
ihhsxcg^ w` i xnibb esnocr" }crli}x bdndwcg w` x`nc `f wl`xc qdwl ie dnncgdiwc ieg gdrchw
dewcrcxw de wlc `swh`nc `f wlc wrdib% Wlc h`srw xl`sbg rsbc `e iet hlibbceacg hbidn w` iwwceg%
93% …Wlc h`srw ndalw rcxwrdhw wlc esnocr `f wl`xc iwwcegdea de wlc h`srw .r``n f`r wlc }sr}`xc`f rc}`rwdea wlc wrdib…qlcrc ihhcxx w` wlc h`srw.r``n ot rc}`rwcrx qix rcxwrdhwcg"
irrieacncewx xl`sbg oc nigc f`r wlc }r`hccgdeax w` oc rcbcixcg" isgdobt ieg df }`xxdobc
vdxsibbt" w` ie`wlcr r``n de wlc xinc h`srw h`n}bc| w` qldhl wlc ncgdi [lix^ frcc ihhcxx%„
[?===^ 9 Q%B%_% 634; [?===^ ? Ibb C%_% ?<3%
? Xcc }irix% <%7= ‘ <%78" io`vc%
H@EGSHW GS_DEA HIXC
Xs}}`rwdea Hldbg Qdwecxxcx Asdgiehc
<%76 Wlc ‒Asdgiehc `e wlc Yscxwd`edea `f Hldbgrce de H`srw„9
h`ewidex xsaacxwd`ex
f`r wlc h`egshw `f wlc hixc% Fdrxw" dw dgcewdfdcx wlc dn}`rwiehc `f }rc.lcirdea
}rc}iriwd`e f`r dgcewdftdea wlc dxxscx de wlc hixc% Wldx dx dn}`rwiew x` wliw wlc h`srw
ieg wlc }irwdcx irc iqirc `f wlc rcx}chwdvc }`xdwd`ex `f wlc }irwdcx de rcbiwd`e w` wlc
cvdgcehc wliw wlc hldbg nit advc" wlsx iv`dgdea gs}bdhiwd`e `f yscxwd`ex%H`exdgcriwd`e `f echcxxirt irrieacncewx" ix gdxhsxxcg de }iriari}lx <%1 `eqirgx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 133/206
io`vc" xl`sbg livc occe gcibw qdwl iw wlc }rc}iriwd`e xwiac% Wlc Asdgiehc a`cx `e w`
advc igvdhc io`sw h`egshw `f wlc c|indeiwd`e `f wlc hldbg qdwecxx%
9Dxxscg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew ix }irw `f wlc ‒Xs}}`rwdea Hldbg Qdwecxx asdgiehc }ihk„
de ?==8 ,s}giwcg de ?==6$%
<%71 Wlc Asdgiehc9
xwiwcx wliw dw dx wlc gswt `f wlc h`srw w` cexsrc i fidr lcirdea" osw
w` }r`wchw wlc dewcrcxwx `f i hldbg qdwecxx h`exdxwcew qdwl wliw gswt% Dw xsaacxwx?
wliw
wlc h`srw qdbb oc xcexdwdvc w` wlc eccg w` cexsrc wliw hldbgrce irc yscxwd`ecg
i}}r`}rdiwcbt% Wlc h`srw lix }`qcr w` gdxibb`q yscxwd`edea wliw ,9$ dx drrcbcview w` wlc
dxxsc" ,?$ lix e` `ojchw `wlcr wlie w` dexsbw wlc qdwecxx" ,8$ dx dewcegcg w` `r lix wlc
cffchw `f lirixxdea wlc qdwecxx" ,7$ lix ix dwx }sr}`xc wlc nikdea `f i h`nncew riwlcr
wlie cbdhdwdea i fihw ieg ,3$ dev`bvcx rc}cwdwd`e `f i yscxwd`e ibrcigt iexqcrcg%
9Asdgiehc `e wlc Yscxwd`edea `f Hldbgrce de H`srw" }iri% 3%
?Asdgiehc" }iri% 1%
<%7< Wlc Asdgiehc9
xwiwcx wliw dw dx wlc gswt `f wlc }rihwdwd`ecr i}}cirdea ocf`rc wlc
h`srw w` cexsrc wliw hldbgrce advdea cvdgcehc irc hisxcg ix bdwwbc ie|dcwt ieg gdxwrcxx
ix }`xxdobc% Asdgiehc dx advce io`sw wlc h`egshw `f c|indeiwd`e" hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e
ieg rc.c|indeiwd`e?% Wlc Asdgc w` ]r`fcxxd`eib H`egshw f Igv`hiwcx
8ieg wlc
X`bdhdw`rx ,Xh`wbieg$ _sbcx `f H`egshw f`r X`bdhdw`r Igv`hiwcx ?==?7
}r`vdgc wliw de
wlc c|indeiwd`e ieg hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e `f qdwecxxcx" wlc }rihwdwd`ecr dx de i }rdvdbcacg
}`xdwd`e qldhl lc `r xlc xl`sbg e`w iosxc%
9
Asdgiehc `e wlc Yscxwd`edea `f Hldbgrce de H`srw" }iri 6%
?Asdgiehc" }irix 91 w` ?=%
8Fdfwl cgdwd`e" @hw`ocr ?==<" iw }iri 6%7%?%
7_sbc <,?$; ividbiobc iw: lww}:qqq%biqxh`w%`ra%skncnocrxncnocr.xcrvdhcxi.w`.z.
rsbcx..asdgiehcx...zx`bdhdw`r.igv`hiwc.rsbcxacecrib.rsbcx
Xdn}bc bieasiac
<%74 Xdn}bc bieasiac ieg hbcir dexwrshwd`ex qdbb ixxdxw de }swwdea i hldbg qdwecxx iw
cixc%9
I jsgac xl`sbg oc rcigt w` c|}bide }r`hcgsrib xwc}x de xdn}bc q`rgx% Df ie
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 134/206
`ojchwd`e dx wikce de wlc h`srxc `f cvdgcehc echcxxdwiwdea xsondxxd`ex `swqdwl wlc
}rcxcehc `f wlc jsrt `r wlc hldbg qdwecxx" ieg wlc hldbg lix w` bcivc h`srw ,`r rcnide de
wlc HHWV bdek r``n qdwl i obiek WV xhrcce$" wlc hldbg xl`sbg e`w oc nigc w` fccb iw
fisbw de iet qit% Dw xl`sbg oc c|}bidecg wliw i }`dew `f biq lix w` oc gdxhsxxcg" ieg
wliw wlc hldbg qdbb livc w` bcivc h`srw ,`r qidw de wlc HHWV bdek r``n$ f`r i xl`rw
}crd`g% Df" de wlc h`srxc `f cvdgcehc" i hldbg `ovd`sxbt g`cx e`w segcrxwieg i q`rg r
i yscxwd`e" tcw xccnx w`` xlt w` igndw dw" wlc jsgac ndalw qdxl w` dewcrvcec qdwl ie
c|}bieiwd`e `f wlc q`rg" `r ie ibwcreiwdvc }lrixc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 135/206
9Ie Ceabdxl ]rihwdhc Gdrchwd`e ,xcc [?===^ 9 Q%B%_% 634; [?===^ ? Ibb C%_% ?<3$ xsaacxwx de
}iriari}l 99 wliw wlc h`srw ‒xl`sbg cexsrc" x` fir ix }rihwdhiobc" wliw wlc [hixc dx^ h`egshwcg
de bieasiac qldhl wlc [hldbg hie^ segcrxwieg%„
Gdxhb`xsrc f hldbg—x }crx`eib gcwidbx
<%3= I hldbg nit oc vcrt h`ehcrecg io`sw livdea w` xwiwc de `}ce h`srw }crx`eib
gcwidbx xshl ix l`nc iggrcxx `r xhl``b% Xshl fcirx xl`sbg livc occe cbdhdwcg" e`wcg"
ieg ihwcg s}`e gsrdea }rc}iriwd`e f`r wlc wrdib" ieg wlc yscxwd`ecr xl`sbg" ix i rcxsbw"
ixk i}}r`}rdiwcbt n`gdfdcg yscxwd`ex% F`r c|in}bc" de hrdndeib wrdibx" i }r`xchsw`r
nit ixk i hldbg qdwecxx df ldx `r lcr iggrcxx f`r wlc }sr}`xcx `f wlc wrdib dx ‒hirc `f
[wlc b`hib }`bdhc^„% Ecvcrwlcbcxx wlcrc nit oc hixcx qlcrc }rc.wrdib }rc}iriwd`e lix
fidbcg w` dgcewdft i qdwecxx—x fcirx% Jsgacx xl`sbg wlcrcf`rc oc ibcrw f`r xdaex `f
gdxwrcxx `r gdxh`nf`rw `e wlc }irw `f i hldbg qdwecxx qlce ocdea ixkcg io`sw }crx`eib
gcwidbx% Df echcxxirt" wlc jsgac xl`sbg dewcrvcec% De niet hixcx" i q`rkiobc x`bswd`e
dx w` xsaacxw wliw wlc def`rniwd`e oc qrdwwce `e i }dchc `f }i}cr qldhl dx liegcg w` wlc
jsgac%
Gdxwrcxx gsrdea cvdgcehc<%39 Df i hldbg qdwecxx och`ncx gdxwrcxxcg" ie igj`srencew nit oc i}}r`}rdiwc%
9
Wlc c|wcew w` qldhl i jsgac nit }crx`eibbt dewcrvcec `r `ffcr rcixxsriehc w` i hldbg dx
i gdffdhsbw ieg `fwce h`ewcewd`sx irci%?
H`exdgcriwd`e nit livc w` oc advce w` wlc
yscxwd`e qlcwlcr `r e`w w` dewcrvcec w` }rcvcew l`xwdbc `r iaarcxxdvc yscxwd`edea%
9 F`r c|in}bc" de wlc wrdib rcfcrrcg w` de ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„"
G`qdc ieg @aa" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" iw }% 9<9" i 93.ndeswc igj`srencew qix rcysdrcg f`r
i gdxwrcxxcg hldbg ihhsxcg%? Obihk v _s|w`e" 944< X%H%H%_% 77= ,xsnnirt wrdib: xlcrdff igvdxdea i gdxwrcxxcg hldbg
qdwecxx qlce xlc rcwsrecg w` h`srw wliw lc qix wlcrc w` }r`wchw lcr ieg q`sbg xw`} wlc gcfcehc
x`bdhdw`r ixkdea iet gdxwrcxxdea yscxwd`ex; lcbg dewcr ibdi wliw dw dx wlc gswt `f wlc h`srw w`
}r`wchw qdwecxxcx iaidexw lirixxdea yscxwd`ex qldbc iw wlc xinc wdnc ibb`qdea wlc gcfcehc
}r`}crbt w` gcvcb`} iet i}}r`}rdiwc bdec `f hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e; wliw dw qix x`ncwdncx i fdec
bdec w` griq" osw wliw wlcrc qix e`wldea qr`ea de wlc h`srw wcbbdea i qdwecxx xlc q`sbg oc
}r`wchwcg de wliw qit; ieg fsrwlcr" wliw" b``kdea iw wlc niwwcr `ojchwdvcbt" i rcix`eiobc
`oxcrvcr q`sbg e`w wikc wlc vdcq wliw wlc xlcrdff lig }rc.jsgacg wlc dxxsc de iet qit; ieg
i}}cib rcfsxcg$; NhKdc v L%N% Igv`hiwc" 9441 X%B%W% 9=9<; 9441 X%H%H%_% 8= ,jsrt wrdib:
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 136/206
xlcrdff h`nf`rwdea i wcirfsb 4.tcir.`bg qdwecxx; wlc i}}cib h`srw `oxcrvcg ‒… dw dx }crli}x
sef`rwseiwc wliw [wlc xlcrdff^ lig e`w acxwsrcg w` wlc hircr w` dewcrvcec iw wlc ocadeedea dexwcig
`f dewcrvcedea ldnxcbf …„
]_CXX _C]@_WDEA DE HIXCX DEV@BVDEA HLDBG_CE
Niegiw`rt }r`ldodwd`e de hrdndeib hixcx
<%3? Xchwd`e 71,9$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 }r`vdgcx:
‒Xsojchw w` xsoxchwd`e ,8$ ocb`q9" e` ecqx}i}cr rc}`rw `f iet }r`hccgdeax de i
h`srw xlibb rcvcib wlc einc" iggrcxx `r xhl``b" `r dehbsgc iet }irwdhsbirx
hibhsbiwcg w` bcig w` wlc dgcewdfdhiwd`e" `f iet }crx`e segcr wlc iac `f 96 tcirxh`ehcrecg de wlc }r`hccgdeax" cdwlcr ‘ ,i$ ix ocdea i }crx`e iaidexw `r de
rcx}chw `f ql`n wlc }r`hccgdeax irc wikce; `r ,o$ ix ocdea i qdwecxx de wlc
}r`hccgdeax%„?
E` }dhwsrc `f `r dehbsgdea wlc hldbg hie oc }sobdxlcg de i h`ewc|w rcbcview w` xshl
}r`hccgdeax%
9Xcc }irix% <%38 ieg <%37 ocb`q%
?Xcc" f`r c|in}bc" Frinc v Iocrgcce J`sreibx Bwg" ?==3 X%B%W% 474%
Gdxhrcwd`eirt }r`ldodwd`e de hrdndeib hixcx
<%38 De wcrnx `f xchwd`e 71,8$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw" wlc rcxwrdhwd`ex g` e`w i}}bt qlcrc
wlc hldbg dx h`ehcrecg `ebt ix i qdwecxx ieg e`.`ec iaidexw ql`n wlc }r`hccgdeax irc
wikce dx segcr 96% Wlc h`srw nit" l`qcvcr" gdrchw wliw wlc rcxwrdhwd`ex i}}bt% Df wlc
h`srw hl``xcx w` g` x`" wlc h`srw nsxw x}chdft wlc hldbg de rcx}chw `f ql`n wlc
gdrchwd`e dx nigc% Wldx xl`sbg oc g`ec de `}ce h`srw" gsbt rch`rgcg de iet rch`rg `f
}r`hccgdeax" ieg iswlcewdhiwcg ot wlc hbcrk—x xdaeiwsrc%9
9Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx 9446" r% 6%1%
Gdx}cexdea qdwl }r`ldodwd`e" qlcwlcr niegiw`rt `r gdxhrcwd`eirt" de hrdndeib
}r`hccgdeax
<%37 Xchwd`e 71,8$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw }r`vdgcx wliw wlc h`srw nit" iw iet xwiac `f wlc
}r`hccgdeax" df xiwdxfdcg wliw dw dx de wlc }sobdh dewcrcxw w` g` x`" gdx}cexc qdwl wlc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 137/206
rcxwrdhwd`ex de ql`bc `r de }irw% Df wlc h`srw g`cx x " dw nsxw x}chdft wlc hldbg de
rcx}chw `f ql`n wlc gdrchwd`e dx nigc" ieg wlc c|wcew w` qldhl wlc rcxwrdhwd`ex irc
gdx}cexcg qdwl% Iaide wlc yscxwd`e xl`sbg oc gcibw qdwl de `}ce h`srw" gsbt rch`rgcg
de iet rch`rg `f }r`hccgdeax" ieg iswlcewdhiwcg ot wlc hbcrk—x xdaeiwsrc%9
Hircfsb
h`exdgcriwd`e xl`sbg oc advce ocf`rc wikdea wldx xwc}%
9 Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx 9446" r% 6%1,8$%
Acecrib }`qcrx de hdvdb ieg hrdndeib hixcx
<%33 De wcrnx `f xchwd`e 7,?$ `f wlc H`ewcn}w `f H`srw Ihw 94<9" wlc h`srw nit
‒qlcrc dw i}}cirx w` oc echcxxirt f`r iv`dgdea i xsoxwiewdib rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc
igndedxwriwd`e `f jsxwdhc de [bcaib }r`hccgdeax ocdea lcbg de }sobdh^" `r de iet `wlcr
}r`hccgdeax }cegdea `r dnndecew" `rgcr wliw wlc }sobdhiwd`e `f iet rc}`rw `f wlc
}r`hccgdeax" `r iet }irw `f wlc }r`hccgdeax" oc }`xw}`ecg f`r xshl }crd`g ix wlc h`srw
wldekx echcxxirt f`r wliw }sr}`xc„%
<%36 Xchwd`e 76 `f wlc Hldbgrce ieg T`sea ]crx`ex ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9481 ix
incegcg ieg c|wcegcg ,w` wcbcvdxd`e ieg rigd` or`ighixwx$ ot Xhlcgsbc ?= w` wlc
Or`ighixwdea Ihw 944= }r`vdgcx:
‒,9$ De rcbiwd`e w` iet }r`hccgdeax de iet h`srw … wlc h`srw nit gdrchw wliw ‘
e` ecqx}i}cr rc}`rw `f wlc }r`hccgdeax xlibb rcvcib wlc einc" iggrcxx" `r
xhl``b" `r dehbsgc iet }irwdhsbirx hibhsbiwcg w` bcig w` wlc
dgcewdfdhiwd`e `f i }crx`e segcr wlc iac `f xcvcewcce tcirx
h`ehcrecg de wlc }r`hccgdeax" cdwlcr ix ocdea wlc }crx`e ot `r
iaidexw `r de rcx}chw `f ql`n wlc }r`hccgdeax irc wikce" `r ixocdea i qdwecxx wlcrcde;
,i$ e` }dhwsrc xlibb oc }sobdxlcg de iet ecqx}i}cr ix ocdea `r
dehbsgdea i }dhwsrc `f i }crx`e segcr wlc iac `f xcvcewcce tcirx x`
h`ehcrecg de wlc }r`hccgdeax ix if`rcxidg;
c|hc}w de x` fir ,df iw ibb$ ix nit oc }crndwwcg ot wlc gdrchwd`e `f wlc h`srw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 138/206
,?$ Iet }crx`e ql` }sobdxlcx iet niwwcr de h`ewrivcewd`e `f iet xshl
gdrchwd`e xlibb `e xsnnirt h`evdhwd`e oc bdiobc de rcx}chw `f cihl `ffcehc w` i
fdec …„
<%31 Dw dx ibx` q`rwl e`wdea wliw xchwd`e 9 `f wlc Jsgdhdib ]r`hccgdeax ,_casbiwd`e `f
_c}`rwx$ Ihw 94?6 }r`vdgcx:
‒,9$ Dw xlibb e`w oc biqfsb w` }rdew `r }sobdxl" `r w` hisxc `r }r`hsrc w` oc
}rdewcg `r }sobdxlcg ‘
,i$ de rcbiwd`e w` iet jsgdhdib }r`hccgdeax iet degchcew niwwcr `r degchcew
ncgdhib" xsradhib `r }ltxd`b`adhib gcwidbx ocdea niwwcr `r gcwidbx wlc
}sobdhiwd`e `f qldhl q`sbg oc hibhsbiwcg w` dejsrc }sobdh n`ribx;
,o$ de rcbiwd`e w` iet jsgdhdib }r`hccgdeax f`r gdxx`bswd`e `f nirrdiac" f`r
esbbdwt `f nirrdiac" `r f`r jsgdhdib xc}iriwd`e" [`r f`r wlc gdxx`bswd`e `r
ieesbncew `f i hdvdb }irwecrxld} `r f`r wlc xc}iriwd`e `f hdvdb }irwecrx^9"
iet }irwdhsbirx `wlcr wlie wlc f`bb`qdea" wliw dx w` xit:.
,d$ wlc eincx" iggrcxxcx ieg `hhs}iwd`ex `f wlc }irwdcx ieg
qdwecxxcx;
,dd$ i h`ehdxc xwiwcncew f wlc hliracx" gcfcehcx ieg h`sewcrhliracx
de xs}}`rw `f qldhl cvdgcehc lix occe advce;
,ddd$ xsondxxd`ex `e iet }`dew `f biq irdxdea de wlc h`srxc `f wlc
}r`hccgdeax" ieg wlc gchdxd`e `f wlc h`srw wlcrc`e;
,dv$ wlc xsnndea.s} `f wlc jsgac ieg wlc fdegdea `f wlc jsrt ,df iet$
ieg wlc jsgancew `f wlc h`srw ieg `oxcrviwd`ex nigc ot wlc
jsgac de advdea jsgancew:
]r`vdgcg wliw e`wldea de wldx }irw `f wldx xsoxchwd`e xlibb oc lcbg w`
}crndw wlc }sobdhiwd`e `f ietwldea h`ewrirt w` wlc }r`vdxd`ex `f
}iriari}l ,i$ `f wldx xsoxchwd`e…„
9 Q`rgx xsoxwdwswcg ot Hdvdb ]irwecrxld} Ihw ?==7 h% 88 Xhl%?1 }iri%<,?$ ,Gchcnocr 3" ?==3$
<%3< E` }crx`e nit }sobdxl iet niwwcr de rcx}chw `f }r`hccgdeax ocf`rc i xlcrdff
de rcbiwd`e w` i hldbg }r`wchwd`e `rgcr" ie c|hbsxd`e `rgcr" rcvdcq `f ar`segx `f rcfcrrib `r ie i}}cib segcr ]irw DD `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 qldhl dx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 139/206
dewcegcg `r bdkcbt w` dgcewdft i hldbg de wl`xc }r`hccgdeax `r wlc hldbg—x iggrcxx `r
xhl``b%9
Segcr xchwd`e 77,?$ dw dx ie `ffcehc w` }sobdxl xshl niwcrdib%?
9xchwd`e 77,9$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
? xchwd`e 77 `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 dx gsc w` oc rc}cibcg ot Xhlcgsbc 6,9$ `f wlc
Hldbgrce—x Lcirdeax ,Xh`w$ Ihw ?=99%
I]]@DEWNCEW @F HS_IW@_ IG BDWCN & XIFCASI_GC_ GS_DEA
H@S_W HIXC
]r`wchwd`e `f hldbg—x dewcrcxwx gsrdea h`srw }r`hccgdeax
<%34 I hsriw`r ig bdwcn dx i asirgdie i}}`dewcg ot wlc h`srw w` }r`wchw wlc dewcrcxwx
`f i }irwt bihkdea fsbb hi}ihdwt de i bdwdaiwd`e% Xshl ie i}}`dewncew nit oc nigc iw
wlc h`srw—x gdxhrcwd`e9" ieg nit oc nigc ot wlc h`srw `f dwx `qe n`wd`e%
?
9Kdrk v% Xh`wwdxl Aix O`irg " 946< X%H% 8?<; Ordiehl`e v @hhdgcewib ]cwr`bcsn ,Hibcg`edi$
Bwg 944= X%B%W% 8??%
? Grsnn`eg—x Wrx% v% ]ccb—x Wrx%" 94?4 X%H% 7<9" iw }%39<: xcc acecribbt h`nncewirt de wlc
Iee`wiwcg _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e" e`wc 98%?%?,O$,7$%
<%6= I xifcasirgcr dx i }crx`e" e`rnibbt qdwl i rcbcview }r`fcxxd`eib oihkar`seg de
biq" x`hdib q`rk `r wcihldea" i}}`dewcg ot wlc h`srw w` xifcasirg wlc dewcrcxwx `f i
hldbg de }r`hccgdeax%
I]]_@]_DIWC IGSBWX GS_DEA H@S_W HIXC
<%69 Wldx asdgiehc dx dewcegcg f`r sxc ot ie i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw qlce iwwcegdea h`srw
f`r i bdvc lcirdea `r wrdib de wlc }rcxcehc `f i jsgac" xlcrdff `r J] ,wlc jsgac$% Wlc
asdgiehc g`cx e`w i}}bt w` ie i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw iwwcegdea h`srw ix i qdwecxx% Wlc
asdgiehc dx e`w dewcegcg w` h`vcr wlc xdwsiwd`e qlce wlc jsgac dx `ff wlc ocehl ,}rc.
wrdib `r gsrdea ie igj`srencew$" wl`sal dw nit dehdgcewibbt w`shl `e wldx dxxsc% Wldx
asdgiehc rcbiwcx `ebt w` ocxw }rihwdhc" de i bdvc h`srw xdwsiwd`e" qdwl i vsbecriobc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 140/206
ihhsxcg ql` lix i ncewib gdx`rgcr ,dehbsgdea }c`}bc qdwl i bciredea gdxiodbdwt$ ieg
h`nnsedhiwd`e gdffdhsbwdcx%
<%6? Wlc jsgac dx segcr i vcrt dn}`rwiew bcaib `obdaiwd`e w` cexsrc wliw wlc ihhsxcg
rchcdvcx i fidr wrdib% Wldx dehbsgcx ocdea xiwdxfdcg wliw wlc ihhsxcg segcrxwiegx ieg
f`bb`qx qliw li}}cex iw ibb xwiacx `f wlc lcirdea `r wrdib }r`hcgsrc% W` fihdbdwiwc wldx
segcrxwiegdea wlc jsgac nit iswl`rdxc xwc}x wliw dehbsgc wlc f`bb`qdea:.
9% Wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw xl`sbg }r`vdgc rcixxsriehc w` wlc ihhsxcg gsrdea wlc
}r`hccgdeax%
?% De igviehc `f wlc wrdib" wlc jsgac" gcfcehc wcin ieg i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw nit
iarcc irrieacncewx dehbsgdea wlc bceawl `f cvdgcehc xcxxd`ex ieg wlc
frcysceht ieg gsriwd`e `f iet orcikx%
8% Wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw xl`sbg xdw hb`xc w` wlc ihhsxcg ql` qdbb oc de wlc g`hk
ieg c|}bide qlce echcxxirt" ix ysdcwbt ix }`xxdobc" qliw dx li}}cedea ieg
ocdea xidg gsrdea wlc }r`hccgdeax% Df wlc ihhsxcg g`cx e`w segcrxwieg ie
ix}chw `f wlc }r`hccgdeax wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw xl`sbg c|}bide wldx w` ldn `r
lcr% Wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw xl`sbg e`w }r`vdgc i rseedea h`nncewirt `e wlc
cvdgcehc% Wldx h`sbg gdxwrihw wlc jsrt ,df }rcxcew$" `wlcr qdwecxxcx ieg wlc
ihhsxcg%
7% Wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw xl`sbg rc}`rw w` wlc gcfcehc wcin ,x`bdhdw`r" x`bdhdw`r
igv`hiwc ieg`r h`sexcb$" iet gdffdhsbwt `r gdxwrcxx wlc ihhsxcg dx c|}crdcehdea
gsrdea wlc }r`hccgdeax% Wldx nit ocxw oc g`ec gsrdea ie igj`srencew `r df
sracew ot }ixxdea i xl`rw qrdwwce e`wc w` wlc ihhsxcg—x x`bdhdw`r% Dw dx wlc
rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc gcfcehc wcin w` ixxcxx ieg h`evct wlc h`ewcew `f wldx e`wc
w` wlc jsgac" df i}}r`}rdiwc% Iet gdxwrcxx nit oc `ovd`sx de qldhl hixc wlc
jsgac qdbb gcib qdwl dw gdrchwbt ot deysdrt `f wlc gcfcehc wcin ieg`r
igj`srencew%
3% Df wlc ihhsxcg cbchwx w` advc cvdgcehc" ,i gchdxd`e nigc ot wlc gcfcehc bcaib
wcin de h`ejsehwd`e qdwl wlc ihhsxcg$" wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw }bitx e` ihwdvc
r`bc qldbc wlc ihhsxcg dx de wlc qdwecxx o`| advdea cvdgcehc% _cx}`exdodbdwt
f`r cexsrdea wliw wlc ihhsxcg segcrxwiegx wlc yscxwd`edea qldbc lc `r xlc dx
advdea cvdgcehc dx cewdrcbt f`r wlc jsgac%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 141/206
6% Df wlc cvdgcehc `f wlc ihhsxcg dx dewcrrs}wcg ot ie igj`srencew" wlc
i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw hiee`w gdxhsxx qdwl wlc ihhsxcg wlc cvdgcehc wlc ihhsxcg lix
advce `r qdbb advc w` wlc h`srw" ocf`rc `r ifwcr wlc igj`srencew% E` qdwecxx"
dehbsgdea ie ihhsxcg" hie gdxhsxx ldx `r lcr cvdgcehc qdwl iet `wlcr }crx`e
gsrdea ie igj`srencew%
1% Df wlc ihhsxcg" ix i vsbecriobc qdwecxx" rcysdrcx x}chdib ncixsrcx w` fihdbdwiwc
advdea cvdgcehc" wlc gcfcehc wcin qdbb i}}bt w` wlc h`srw f`r wlcxc de wlc sxsib
qit" ocf`rc wrdib% Wlc gchdxd`e w` ariew wlcxc" `r e`w" dx wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc
jsgac ql` lcirx wlc i}}bdhiwd`e%
<% Wlcrc dx e` rsbc wliw }rcvcewx ie i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw ocdea i xs}}`rwcr" ot qit `f
i x}chdib ncixsrc" qldbc wlc ihhsxcg advcx cvdgcehc% Cysibbt wlc xs}}`rwcr
nit oc x`nc`ec `wlcr wlie wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw% Df wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw g`cx
fsbfdb wlc r`bc `f xs}}`rwcr" wlc i}}r`}rdiwc igsbw hiee`w h`nnsedhiwc" de iet
qit" qdwl wlc ihhsxcg qldbc lc `r xlc dx advdea cvdgcehc de hldcf" gsrdea hr`xx
c|indeiwd`e `r rc.c|indeiwd`e% Gsrdea wldx xwiac `f wlc wrdib wlc ihhsxcg dx
ib`ec ocf`rc wlc jsgac ieg`r jsrt bdkc iet `wlcr qdwecxx% W` dewcrvcec gsrdea
wlc cvdgcehc `f wlc ihhsxcg de iet qit q`sbg rcxsbw de i qiredea fr`n wlc wrdib
jsgac e`w w` g` wldx ieg" df qdbfsbbt }crxdxwcg de" q`sbg rdxk h`exwdwswdea i
h`ewcn}w `f h`srw%
<%68 Df wlc jsgac nikcx i rsbdea wliw n`gdfdcx `r h`ewrigdhwx wldx asdgiehc wliw
rsbdea nsxw oc `octcg% F`r fsrwlcr asdgiehc" }bcixc h`ewihw wlc Xh`wwdxl I}}r`}rdiwc
Igsbw Ecwq`rk iw lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%skW`}dhxJsxwdhcbiqvdhwdnx.
qdwecxxcxI}}r`}rdiwc.Igsbwi}}r`}rdiwcigsbwecwq`rkxncnocrxld}
WLC VDCQX @F HLDBG_CE DE HDVDB ]_@HCCGDEAX
<%67 X}chdib }r`vdxd`e lix occe nigc de rcbiwd`e w` ihwd`ex qldhl nit iffchw
hldbgrce" ceiobdea wlcdr vdcqx w` oc wikce dew` ihh`sew de hcrwide hdrhsnxwiehcx"
qlcwlcr `r e`w wlct irc hdwcg ix qdwecxxcx% Xchwd`e 99,1$ `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$
Ihw 9443 ,h%86$ }r`vdgcx:
‒Xsojchw w` xsoxchwd`e ,<$ ocb`q9de h`exdgcrdea qlcwlcr `r e`w w` nikc ie
`rgcr? segcr xsoxchwd`e 9 io`vc" ieg qliw `rgcr w` nikc" wlc h`srw…,o$
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 142/206
wikdea ihh`sew `f wlc hldbg—x iac ieg niwsrdwt" xlibb x` fir ix }rihwdhiobc ‘ ,d$
advc ldn ie `}}`rwsedwt w` degdhiwc qlcwlcr lc qdxlcx w` c|}rcxx ldx vdcqx;
,dd$ df lc g`cx x` qdxl" advc ldn ie `}}`rwsedwt w` c|}rcxx wlcn; ieg ,ddd$
livc rcairg w` xshl vdcqx ix lc nit c|}rcxx%„
9 Qldhl h`ehcrex rdalwx ieg dewcrcxwx de wlc }r`}crwt `f i hldbg" ihysdrcg de a``g fidwl%
? Qldhl rcbiwcx w` }ircewib rcx}`exdodbdwdcx" }ircewib rdalwx" asirgdiexld}" `r wlc igndedxwriwd`e
`f i hldbg—x }r`}crwt%
<%63 I}}r`}rdiwc }r`vdxd`e f`r dewdniwd`e w` hldbgrce lix occe nigc ot rsbcx `f
h`srw%9
Wlc h`srw nit gdx}cexc qdwl dewdniwd`e qlcrc wlc hldbg dx w`` t`sea%?
Qlcrc
i jsgac rchcdvcx i qrdwwce h`nnsedhiwd`e fr`n i hldbg" wliw h`nnsedhiwd`e nit" iw
wlc jsgac—x gdxhrcwd`e" oc kc}w h`efdgcewdib" ieg nit oc }bihcg de ie cevcb`}c e`w
f`rndea }irw `f wlc }r`hcxx% Qlcrc i jsgac dewcrvdcqx i hldbg dw nit oc echcxxirt w`
c|}bide wlc gdffdhsbwdcx `f h`efdgcewdibdwt" xl`sbg wlc hldbg e`w qdxl ldx `r lcr vdcqx w`
oc ke`qe w` `wlcr }irwdcx%
9Wlc _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9447" rr% 74%<,9$,l$" 74%<,1$" ieg F`rn 74%<.E; ieg xcc wlc
xlcrdff h`srw @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx 9448" rr% 88%1,9$,l$" 88%1,1$" ieg F`rn F4%
? Wlcrc dx i xwiwsw`rt }rcxsn}wd`e wliw i hldbg iacg 9? `r `vcr dx `f xsffdhdcew iac ieg niwsrdwt
w` f`rn i vdcq: x% 99,9=$ `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443%
X@S_HC NIWC_DIB
Ncn`riegsn ot B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx" Jsbt 944= ,fsbb
wc|w de I}}cegd| I w` wldx hli}wcr$%
]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$ ,fsbb wc|w de I}}cegd| O w` wldx hli}wcr$%
]rihwdhc E`wc E`%8 `f ?==3 ,fsbb wc|w de I}}cegd| H w` wldx hli}wcr$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 143/206
_c}`rw `e wlc Cvdgcehc `f Hldbgrce ieg @wlcr ]`wcewdibbt Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx:
Xh`wwdxl Biq H`nndxxd`e rc}`rw e`%9?3 ,944=$
Irwdhbc ‒Wlc Cvdgcehc `f Hldbgrce„" Frixcr Givdgx`e" 9449 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 9<9
Irwdhbc ‒Hldbgrce de H`srw: W`qirgx i Hldbg Frdcegbt H`srw„" E`rnie G`qdc"
Xced`r Hbcrk `f Jsxwdhdirt" ieg Gcrck @aa Y%H%" ?==9 X%B%W% ,Ecqx$ 914" 9<9
_cew`e & Or`qe" Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc
Xlcrdff H`srw Hrdndeib Ocehl O``k" Hli}wcr 7 ,Cvdgcehc$
H`exsbwiwd`e ]i}cr ‒Vdwib V`dhcx: Lcb}dea Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx Advc cvdgcehc„
,Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew" Nit ?==?$
Xs}}`rwdea Hldbg Qdwecxxcx asdgiehc }ihk ,Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew" ?==8$
‒Ocdea i Qdwecxx„ ,Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew" Jsec ?==3$
‒X}chdib Ncixsrcx f`r Vsbecriobc Igsbw ieg Hldbg Qdwecxxcx: I Asdgiehc ]ihk„
,Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew" ?==3$
X`bdhdw`rx ,Xh`wbieg$ _sbcx `f H`egshw f`r X`bdhdw`r Igv`hiwcx ?==?
Asdgc w` ]r`fcxxd`eib H`egshw `f Igv`hiwcx ,3wl
cgdwd`e" @hw`ocr ?==<$
Xh`wwdxl I}}r`}rdiwc Igsbw Ecwq`rk
lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%skW`}dhxJsxwdhcbiqvdhwdnx.qdwecxxcxI}}r`}rdiwc.
Igsbwi}}r`}rdiwcigsbwecwq`rkxncnocrxld}
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 144/206
I}}cegd| I
Ncn`riegsn ot B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib L`}c `e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx" Jsbt 944=
9% Wlc f`bb`qdea ncn`riegsn `f asdgiehc lix occe }rc}ircg iw wlc xsaacxwd`e `f wlc
Xh`wwdxl Biq H`nndxxd`e: xcc _c}`rw `e wlc Cvdgcehc `f Hldbgrce ieg @wlcr
]`wcewdibbt Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`w% Biq H`n% E`% 9?3$% Dwx }sr}`xc dx w`
}r`vdgc ixxdxwiehc w` jsgacx de wlc c|crhdxc `f wlcdr gdxhrcwd`eirt }`qcrx" qlcrc i
hldbg dx w` advc cvdgcehc ot h`evcewd`eib nciex de `}ce h`srw" w` }sw wlc hldbg iw cixc
qldbc advdea cvdgcehc ieg w` hbcir wlc h`srw `f }crx`ex e`w livdea i gdrchw
dev`bvcncew de wlc }r`hccgdeax%
?% Wlc acecrib `ojchwdvc dx w` cexsrc" x` fir ix dx rcix`eiobt }rihwdhiobc" wliw wlc
c|}crdcehc `f advdea cvdgcehc ot ibb hldbgrce segcr wlc iac `f 96 hisxcx ix bdwwbc
ie|dcwt ieg gdxwrcxx w` wlc hldbg ix }`xxdobc de wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx%
8% Wlc f`bb`qdea irc c|in}bcx `f wlc ncixsrcx qldhl nit oc wikce" iw wlc gdxhrcwd`e `f
wlc }rcxdgdea jsgac" qdwl i vdcq w` ihldcvdea wliw `ojchwdvc:
,i$ Wlc rcn`vib `f qdax ieg a`qex ot wlc jsgac" h`sexcb ieg x`bdhdw`rx;
,o$ Wlc }`xdwd`edea `f wlc hldbg iw i wiobc de wlc qcbb `f wlc h`srw ib`ea qdwl
wlc jsgac" h`sexcb ieg x`bdhdw`rx" riwlcr wlie rcysdrdea wlc hldbg w` advc
cvdgcehc fr`n wlc qdwecxx o`|;
,h$ ]crndwwdea i rcbiwdvc `r `wlcr xs}}`rwdea }crx`e w` xdw ib`eaxdgc wlc hldbg
qldbc lc `r xlc dx advdea cvdgcehc;
,g$ Wlc hbcirdea fr`n wlc h`srw r``n `f ibb }crx`ex e`w livdea i gdrchw
dev`bvcncew de wlc }r`hccgdeax%
7% De gchdgdea qlcwlcr `r e`w w` wikc wlcxc `r xdndbir ncixsrcx" `r iet `f wlcn" wlc
}rcxdgdea jsgac xl`sbg livc rcairg w` wlc f`bb`qdea fihw`rx ‘
,i$ Wlc iac ieg niwsrdwt `f wlc hldbg
De acecrib wlc t`seacr wlc hldbg wlc n`rc gcxdriobc dw dx wliw xwc}x xl`sbg oc
wikce w` rcgshc f`rnibdwt ieg w` }sw wlc hldbg iw cixc qldbc advdea cvdgcehc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 145/206
,o$ Wlc eiwsrc `f wlc hlirac `r hliracx" ieg wlc eiwsrc `f wlc cvdgcehc
qldhl wlc hldbg dx bdkcbt w` oc hibbcg s}`e w` advc
]irwdhsbir hirc xl`sbg oc wikce de hixcx qdwl i xc|sib cbcncew `r dev`bvdea
ibbcaiwd`ex `f hldbg iosxc cx}chdibbt qlcrc wlc hldbg dx wlc h`n}bidecr `r ie
ctc qdwecxx% Hldbgrce gdrchwbt dev`bvcg de xshl hixcx irc bdkcbt w` occx}chdibbt vsbecriobc w` wrisni qlce hibbcg s}`e w` advc cvdgcehc de wlc
}rcxcehc `f wlc ihhsxcg% Wlc advdea `f cvdgcehc `f i rcbiwdvcbt f`rnib
eiwsrc" cx}chdibbt de wlc hixc `f ie `bgcr hldbg" dx sebdkcbt w` hisxc ie|dcwt `r
gdxwrcxx ieg de xshl hixcx dw qdbb rircbt oc echcxxirt w` wikc x}chdib
ncixsrcx de wlc dewcrcxwx `f wlc hldbg%
,h$ Wlc rcbiwd`exld}" df iet" ocwqcce wlc hldbg ieg wlc ihhsxcg
I hldbg ql` dx advdea cvdgcehc iw wlc wrdib `f i hb`xc rcbiwdvc nit oc
cx}chdibbt c|}`xcg w` i}}rclcexd`e `r cnoirrixxncew" drrcx}chwdvc `f wlc
eiwsrc `f wlc hlirac% Wlc }`xdwd`edea `f wlc hldbg ieg wlc xs}}`rw `f i }crx`e
xdwwdea ib`eaxdgc wlc hldbg qldbc advdea cvdgcehc irc bdkcbt w` oc `f }irwdhsbir
dn}`rwiehc de wlcxc hixcx%
,g$ Qlcwlcr wlc wrdib dx xsnnirt `r `e degdhwncew
Qldbc def`rnibdwt nit oc cixdcr w` ihldcvc de xsnnirt hixcx" wlc }rcxcehc
`f i jsrt de hixcx wikce `e degdhwncew dx bdkcbt w` }rcxcew ie ie|d`sx `r
gdxwrcxxcg hldbg qdwl ie iggdwd`eib hisxc f`r ie|dcwt `r gdxwrcxx% Wldx nikcx
dw ibb wlc n`rc echcxxirt segcr x`bcne }r`hcgsrc wliw xwc}x xl`sbg oc wikce
w` }sw wlc hldbg iw cixc%
,c$ Iet x}chdib fihw`rx }bihcg ocf`rc wlc h`srw h`ehcredea wlc gdx}`xdwd`e"
lcibwl `r }ltxdysc `f wlc hldbg
Ibb hldbgrce irc gdffcrcew" ieg jsgacx xl`sbg wikc cihl hldbg—x }irwdhsbir
hdrhsnxwiehcx dew` ihh`sew ocf`rc gchdgdea qliw xwc}x" df iet" xl`sbg oc
wikce w` ndedndxc ie|dcwt `r gdxwrcxx%
,f$ Wlc }rihwdhiodbdwt `f gc}irwdea fr`n e`rnib }r`hcgsrc" dehbsgdea wlc
xdzc ieg bit`sw `f wlc h`srw ieg wlc ividbiodbdwt `f in}bdfdhiwd`e
cysd}ncew
Qliwcvcr xwc}x irc wikce" i hldbg qdwecxx ql` advcx cvdgcehc ot
h`evcewd`eib nciex nsxw rcnide vdxdobc ieg isgdobc w` ibb wl`xc ql` livc w`
lcir ieg ixxcxx wlc cvdgcehc" dehbsgdea wlc jsrt ieg wlc ihhsxcg%
3% De ibb hixcx ocf`rc i qdwecxx segcr 96 tcirx dx bcg de cvdgcehc ie `}}`rwsedwt xl`sbg
oc advce w` wl`xc rc}rcxcewdea wlc Hr`qe ieg wlc gcfcehc w` iggrcxx wlc jsgac ix w`
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 146/206
qliw x}chdib irrieacncewx" df iet" irc i}}r`}rdiwc% Segcr x`bcne }r`hcgsrc xshl
rc}rcxcewiwd`ex xl`sbg oc nigc `swqdwl wlc }rcxcehc `f wlc jsrt ieg }rcfcriobt
ocf`rc wlc jsrt dx cn}iecbbcg `r iw bcixw ocf`rc wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc cvdgcehc%
6% Df i rcbiwdvc `r `wlcr xs}}`rwdea }crx`e dx w` xdw ib`eaxdgc wlc hldbg" wliw }crx`e xl`sbge`w oc i qdwecxx de wlc hixc ieg lc `r xlc xl`sbg oc qirecg ot wlc jsgac iw wlc
`swxcw e`w w` }r`n}w `r xcck w` defbscehc wlc hldbg de iet qit de wlc h`srxc `f wlc
cvdgcehc%
1% Wlc hbcirdea `f wlc h`srw qldbc i hldbg dx advdea cvdgcehc qdbb e`rnibbt oc i}}r`}rdiwc
de ibb hixcx qldhl dev`bvc ie `ffcehc iaidexw" `r h`egshw h`ewrirt w`" gchceht `r
n`ribdwt: xcc xchwd`e 966 ieg xchwd`e 86? `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw
9413 ,e`q xchwd`e 3= `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443$% De `wlcr hixcx
wldx xl`sbg `ebt oc g`ec df wlc jsgac dx xiwdxfdcg wliw wldx dx echcxxirt de `rgcr w`
iv`dg segsc ie|dcwt `r gdxwrcxx w` wlc hldbg% Wlc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex wliw o`ei fdgc
rc}rcxcewiwdvcx `f i ecqx}i}cr `r ecqx iaceht xl`sbg e`w oc c|hbsgcg xl`sbg oc
i}}bdcg de ibb hixcx%
<% Qlce wikdea iet `f wlc ncixsrcx gcxhrdocg io`vc wlc jsgac xl`sbg livc rcairg w`
wlc h`srw—x acecrib gswt w` cexsrc wliw wlc ihhsxcg rchcdvcx i fidr wrdib ieg d x advce i
}r`}cr `}}`rwsedwt w` }rcxcew ldx gcfcehc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 147/206
I]]CEGD\ O
]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%? `f ?==3$
Hldbg Qdwecxxcx: Gdxhrcwd`eirt ]`qcrx
9% Wldx }rihwdhc e`wc lix cffchw fr`n 9xw
I}rdb ?==3 ieg xs}crxcgcx wlc Ncn`riegsn
`e Hldbg Qdwecxxcx `f ?6 Jsbt 944=%
?% Wlc }sr}`xc `f wldx }rihwdhc e`wc dx w` }r`vdgc ixxdxwiehc w` jsgacx de wlc c|crhdxc
`f wlcdr gdxhrcwd`eirt }`qcrx" qlcrc i hldbg dx w` advc cvdgcehc ot h`evcewd`eib nciex
de `}ce h`srw" w` }sw wlc hldbg iw cixc qldbc advdea cvdgcehc ieg w` hbcir wlc h`srw `f
}crx`ex e`w livdea i gdrchw dev`bvcncew de wlc }r`hccgdeax% Wldx }rihwdhc e`wc g`cx
e`w h`ehcre wlc sxc `f iet xwiwsw`rt x}chdib ncixsrcx wliw nit oc iswl`rdxcg f`r wlc
advdea `f cvdgcehc ot hldbgrce segcr wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443
,‒wlc 9443 Ihw„$ ix incegcg ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7%
8% Wlc gdxhrcwd`eirt }`qcrx hie oc c|crhdxcg ot jsgacx de iggdwd`e w` iet xwiwsw`rt
x}chdib ncixsrcx wliw nit oc iswl`rdxcg f`r hldbg qdwecxxcx segcr wlc 9443 Ihw" `r
nit oc sxcg qlcrc wlc h`srw lix `rgcrcg wliw i hldbg qdwecxx nit advc cvdgcehc
qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet xwiwsw`rt x}chdib ncixsrc%
7% Wlc acecrib `ojchwdvc dx w` cexsrc" x` fir ix dx rcix`eiobt }rihwdhiobc" wliw wlc
c|}crdcehc `f advdea cvdgcehc ot ibb hldbgrce segcr wlc iac `f 96 hisxcx ix bdwwbc
ie|dcwt ieg gdxwrcxx w` wlc hldbg ix }`xxdobc de wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx%
3% Wlc f`bb`qdea irc c|in}bcx f wlc ncixsrcx qldhl nit oc wikce" iw wlc gdxhrcwd`e
`f wlc }rcxdgdea jsgac" qdwl i vdcq w` ihldcvdea wliw `ojchwdvc ‘
,i$ wlc rcn`vib `f qdax ieg a`qex ot wlc jsgac" h`sexcb ieg x`bdhdw`rx;
,o$ wlc }`xdwd`edea `f wlc hldbg iw i wiobc de wlc qcbb `f wlc h`srw ib`ea qdwl
wlc jsgac" h`sexcb ieg x`bdhdw`rx" riwlcr wlie rcysdrdea wlc hldbg w` advc
cvdgcehc fr`n wlc qdwecxx o`|;
,h$ wlc hbcirdea fr`n wlc h`srw r``n `f ibb }crx`ex e`w livdea i gdrchw
dev`bvcncew de wlc }r`hccgdeax%
6% De gchdgdea qlcwlcr `r e`w w` wikc wlcxc r xdndbir gdxhrcwd`eirt ncixsrcx" `r iet
`f wlcn" wlc }rcxdgdea jsgac xl`sbg livc rcairg w` wlc f`bb`qdea fihw`rx ‘
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 148/206
,i$ Wlc x}chdib ncixsrcx" df iet" x`salw ot wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc `r
`wlcrqdxc iswl`rdxcg ot wlc h`srw%
,o$ Wlc iac ieg niwsrdwt `f wlc hldbg% De acecrib" wlc t`seacr wlc hldbg wlc
n`rc gcxdriobc dw dx wliw xwc}x xl`sbg oc wikce w` rcgshc f`rnibdwt ieg
w` }sw wlc hldbg iw cixc qldbc advdea cvdgcehc%
,h$ Wlc eiwsrc `f wlc hlirac `r hliracx" ieg wlc eiwsrc `f wlc cvdgcehc
qldhl wlc hldbg dx bdkcbt w` oc hibbcg s}`e w` advc%
]irwdhsbir hirc xl`sbg oc wikce de hixcx qdwl i xc|sib cbcncew `r
dev`bvdea ibbcaiwd`ex `f hldbg iosxc cx}chdibbt qlcrc wlc hldbg dx wlc
h`n}bidecr `r ie ctc qdwecxx% Hldbgrce gdrchwbt dev`bvcg de xshl hixcx
irc bdkcbt w` oc cx}chdibbt vsbecriobc w` wrisni qlce hibbcg s}`e w`
advc cvdgcehc de wlc }rcxcehc `f wlc ihhsxcg% Wlc advdea `f cvdgcehc
`f i f`rnib eiwsrc" cx}chdibbt de wlc hixc `f ie `bgcr hldbg" nit e`w
rcysdrc iggdwd`eib gdxhrcwd`eirt ncixsrcx w` oc wikce de iggdwd`e w` wlc
xwiwsw`rt x}chdib ncixsrcx wliw nit livc occe iswl`rdxcg%
,g$ Wlc rcbiwd`exld}" df iet" ocwqcce wlc hldbg ieg wlc ihhsxcg% I hldbg
ql` dx advdea cvdgcehc iw wlc wrdib `f i hb`xc rcbiwdvc nit oc cx}chdibbt
c|}`xcg w` i}}rclcexd`e `r cnoirrixxncew" drrcx}chwdvc `f wlc eiwsrc
`f wlc hlirac%
,c$ Qlcwlcr wlc wrdib dx xsnnirt r `e degdhwncew% Qldbc def`rnibdwt nit
oc cixdcr w` ihldcvc de xsnnirt hixcx" wlc }rcxcehc `f i jsrt de hixcx
wikce `e degdhwncew dx bdkcbt w` }rcxcew ie ie|d`sx `r gdxwrcxxcg hldbg
qdwl ie iggdwd`eib hisxc f`r ie|dcwt `r gdxwrcxx% Wldx nikcx dw ibb wlc
n`rc echcxxirt segcr x`bcne }r`hcgsrc wliw xwc}x xl`sbg oc wikce w`
}sw wlc hldbg iw cixc%
,f$ Iet x}chdib fihw`rx }bihcg ocf`rc wlc h`srw h`ehcredea wlc gdx}`xdwd`e"
lcibwl `r }ltxdysc `f wlc hldbg%
,a$ Wlc }rihwdhiodbdwt `f gc}irwdea fr`n e`rnib }r`hcgsrc" c|hc}w ix fir ix
dx echcxxirt f`r iet iswl`rdxcg xwiwsw`rt x}chdib ncixsrc" dehbsgdea wlc
xdzc ieg bit`sw `f wlc h`srw ieg wlc ividbiodbdwt `f iet in}bdfdhiwd`e
cysd}ncew% Qliwcvcr xwc}x irc wikce" i hldbg qdwecxx ql` advcx
cvdgcehc ot h`evcewd`eib nciex nsxw rcnide vdxdobc ieg isgdobc w` ibb
wl`xc ql` livc w` lcir ieg ixxcxx wlc cvdgcehc" dehbsgdea wlc jsrt ieg
wlc ihhsxcg%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 149/206
1% De ibb hixcx qlcrc xwiwsw`rt x}chdib ncixsrcx livc e`w occe iswl`rdxcg ot wlc h`srw"
ocf`rc i qdwecxx segcr 96 tcirx dx bcg de cvdgcehc ie `}}`rwsedwt xl`sbg oc advce w`
wl`xc rc}rcxcewdea wlc Hr`qe ieg wlc gcfcehc w` iggrcxx wlc jsgac ix w` qlcwlcr iet
iggdwd`eib gdxhrcwd`eirt x}chdib ncixsrcx irc i}}r`}rdiwc% Segcr x`bcne }r`hcgsrc
xshl rc}rcxcewiwd`ex xl`sbg oc nigc `swqdwl wlc }rcxcehc `f wlc jsrt ieg }rcfcriobt
ocf`rc wlc jsrt dx cn}iecbbcg `r iw bcixw ocf`rc wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc cvdgcehc%
<% Wlc hbcirdea `f wlc h`srw qldbc i hldbg dx advdea cvdgcehc qdbb e`rnibbt oc
i}}r`}rdiwc de ibb hixcx qldhl dev`bvc ie `ffcehc iaidexw" `r h`egshw h`ewrirt w`"
gchceht ieg n`ribdwt: xcc xchwd`e 3= `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh wbieg$ Ihw 9443%
De `wlcr hixcx wldx xl`sbg `ebt oc g`ec df wlc jsgac dx xiwdxfdcg wliw wldx dx echcxxirt de
`rgcr w` iv dg segsc ie|dcwt `r gdxwrcxx w` wlc hldbg% Wlc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex wliw
o`ei fdgc rc}rcxcewiwdvcx `f i ecqx}i}cr `r ecqx iaceht xl`sbg e`w oc c|hbsgcg
xl`sbg oc i}}bdcg de ibb hixcx%
4% Qlce wikdea iet `f wlc iggdwd`eib gdxhrcwd`eirt ncixsrcx gcxhrdocg io`vc wlc
jsgac xl`sbg livc rcairg w` wlc h`srw—x acecr ib gswt w` cexsrc wliw wlc ihhsxcg
rchcdvcx i fidr wrdib ieg dx advce i }r`}cr `}}`rwsedwt w` }rcxcew ldx gcfcehc%
Nirhl ?7" ?==3
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 150/206
I]]CEGD\ H
]rihwdhc E`wc ,E`%8 `f ?==3$
Wikdea `f Cvdgcehc `f i Vsbecriobc Qdwecxx ot i H`nndxxd`ecr
Dewr`gshwd`e
9% Wldx }rihwdhc e`wc qdbb h`nc dew` cffchw `e 8=wl
E`vcnocr ?==3%
?% Hcrwide incegncewx w` wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ,h%76$ ,‒wlc
9443 Ihw„$ qcrc dewr`gshcg ot wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix} 8$
,‒wlc ?==7 Ihw„$% Ix i rcxsbw" wlc 9443 Ihw e`q }r`vdgcx f`r wlc h`srw w` ibb`q
hcrwide vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx w` advc cvdgcehc sxdea x}chdib ncixsrcx% @ec `f wlcxc
x}chdib ncixsrcx dx f`r wlcdr cvdgcehc w` oc wikce ot i h`nndxxd`ecr ,9443 Ihw"
x% ?19L,9$,i$$% I}}r`}rdiwc incegncewx livc ibx` occe nigc w` wlc Ihw `f
Igj`sreib ,Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx$ 9446 ,‒H]_„$ ,XD 9446/398$% Wlcxc qcrc
dewr`gshcg ot wlc Ihw `f Igj`sreib ,Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc _sbcx Incegncew E`%8$
,Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7$ ?==3,XXD ?==39<<$ ieg Ihw `f
Igj`sreib ,Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc Incegncew E`%6$ ,Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$
Ihw ?==7$ ,Cvdgcehc `e H`nndxxd`e$ ?==3% Wlc ?==7 Ihw `ebt i}}bdcx iw }rcxcew w`
hldbg qdwecxxcx de x`bcne }r`hccgdeax de qldhl wlc rc}`rw `f wlc hixc lix occe
rchcdvcg ot wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib ifwcr 9 I}rdb ?==3% Dw qdbb oc dn}bcncewcg de gsc
h`srxc w` i}}bt w` vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx de ibb hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax%
8% Wlc }sr}`xc f wldx }rihwdhc e wc dx w` advc asdgiehc ix w` ‘
,i$ qliw }rihwdwd`ecrx nsxw g` de }rc}iriwd`e f`r xcckdea wlc iswl`rdxiwd`e
`f wlc x}chdib ncixsrc `f wikdea wlc cvdgcehc `f i vsbecriobc qdwecxx
ot i h`nndxxd`ecr;
,o$ qliw dxxscx wlc h`srw qdbb c|}chw }rihwdwd`ecrx w` iggrcxx de i hldbg
qdwecxx e`wdhc `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx i}}bdhiwd`e de rcbiwd`e w` wlc
x}chdib ncixsrc `f wikdea cvdgcehc ot i h`nndxxd`ecr;
,h$ l`q wlc h`nndxxd`e qdbb oc h`egshwcg;
,g$ l`q iet dxxscx irdxdea fr`n wlc h`nndxxd`e qdbb oc gcibw qdwl%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 151/206
]rc}iriwd`e f`r xcckdea wlc x}chdib ncixsrc `f wikdea cvdgcehc ot i
h`nndxxd`ecr
7% I }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc i hldbg qdwecxx xlibb b`gac qdwl wlc h`srw i hldbg
qdwecxx e`wdhc ,9443 Ihw" x% ?19I,?$$% I }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc i }crx`e"
`wlcr wlie i hldbg qdwecxx" ql` wlc }irwt h`exdgcrx w` oc i vsbecriobc qdwecxx segcr
xchwd`e ?19H,9$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw" xlibb b`gac qdwl wlc h`srw i vsbecriobc qdwecxx
i}}bdhiwd`e ,9443 Ihw" x% ?19H,?$$%
3% I hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx i}}bdhiwd`e nsxw xcw `sw qliw x}chdib
ncixsrcx wlc }irwt hdwdea wlc vsbecriobc qdwecxx h`exdgcrx w` oc wlc n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc
f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f wikdea wlc cvdgcehc `f wliw qdwecxx%
6% Qlcrc i hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx i}}bdhiwd`e xcckx wlc iswl`rdwt
`f wlc h`srw w` wikc wlc cvdgcehc `f wlc qdwecxx ot i h`nndxxd`ecr wlc }irwt hdwdea wlc
qdwecxx xl`sbg h`exdgcr xcvcrib niwwcrx ocf`rclieg%
1% Wlc h`srw qdbb c|}chw wliw de }rc}irdea i hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx
i}}bdhiwd`e i }rihwdwd`ecr qdbb ‘
,i$ h`ewihw wlc Cbchwr`edh Xcrvdhc Gcbdvcrt Sedw qdwlde wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw
Xcrvdhc w` igvdxc `f wlc dewcewd`e w` xcck iswl`rdwt w` livc wlc cvdgcehc
`f i vsbecriobc qdwecxx wikce ot i h`nndxxd`ecr ieg hlchk wlc
ividbiodbdwt `f xsdwiobc vcescx;
,o$ h`exdgcr qlcwlcr iet }irwdhsbir h`nndxxd`ecr `r wt}c `f h`nndxxd`ecr
q`sbg oc wlc n`xw i}}r`}rdiwc de wlc }irwdhsbir hdrhsnxwiehcx `f wlc
hixc ,f`r c|in}bc" i jsgac `f wlc Ldal H`srw$;
,h$ h`exdgcr df wlcrc dx iet }irwdhsbir }bihc wliw i h`nndxxd`e rcysdrcx w`
oc lcbg gsc w` wlc b`hiwd`e `f wlc qdwecxx `r iet }irwdhsbir
vsbecriodbdwdcx lc `r xlc nit livc" dehbsgdea qlcwlcr wlc h`nndxxd`e
nit oc qdwlde i h`srw osdbgdea `r rcysdrcx w` oc de i b`hiwd`e rcn`wc
fr`n i h`srw osdbgdea;
,g$ h`exdgcr df wlc qdwecxx dx rcxwrdhwcg ix w` iet wdncx `f wlc git" `r
}irwdhsbir gitx `r giwcx wliw lc `r xlc hie iwwceg i h`nndxxd`e ix i
rcxsbw `f ldx `r lcr vsbecriodbdwt;
,c$ h`exdgcr qlcwlcr wlc h`nndxxd`e rcysdrcx w` oc lcbg qdwl iet x}chdib
h`egdwd`ex xshl ix wlc qdwecxx advdea cvdgcehc w` wlc h`nndxxd`e ot
qit `f HHWV bdek fr`n ie`wlcr b`hiwd`e;
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 152/206
,f$ h`exdgcr qlcwlcr wlc qdwecxx dx bdkcbt w` eccg frcyscew orcikx `r iet
`wlcr x}chdib rcysdrcncewx" xshl ix gdxiobcg ihhcxx;
,a$ h`exdgcr l`q iet yscxwd`e `f dgcewdfdhiwd`e dx a`dea w` oc gcibw qdwl;
,l$ dgcewdft iet }r`gshwd`ex `r biocbx wliw qdbb rcysdrc w` oc }sw w` wlc
qdwecxx;
,d$ dgcewdft qlcwlcr ie dewcr}rcwcr dx eccgcg;
,j$ h`exdgcr df dw dx bdkcbt wliw wlcrc qdbb oc iet `ojchwd`ex w` }irwdhsbir
}irwx `f wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc%
<% Wlc h`srw qdbb c|}chw wliw wlc hldbg qdwecxx e`wdhc `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx
i}}bdhiwd`e qdbb advc fsbb gcwidbx `f iet `f wlc niwwcrx wliw irc dgcewdfdcg de }iriari}l
1%
4% Iw iet }rcbdndeirt lcirdea iw qldhl wlc x}chdib ncixsrc `f wikdea cvdgcehc ot i
h`nndxxd`ecr dx iswl`rdxcg `r" df wlc x}chdib ncixsrc lix ibrcigt occe iswl`rdxcg" dw dx
dewdniwcg w` wlc h`srw wliw i h`nndxxd`e dx w` wikc }bihc" wlc h`srw qdbb h`exdgcr fd|dea
i fsrwlcr gdcw ,9443 Ihw" x% 1?,4$$% Wldx fsrwlcr gdcw h`sbg ibb`q wlc h`srw w` gcib qdwl
iet niwwcrx wliw ndalw irdxc fr`n wlc h`nndxxd`e ,f`r c|in}bc" yscxwd`ex `f
igndxxdodbdwt wliw nit livc occe rcxcrvcg" wlc ysibdwt `f wlc rch`rgdea `f wlc
h`nndxxd`e }r`hccgdeax ieg wlc eccg f`r iet cgdwdea `f wlc rch`rgdea$%
9=% Wlc h`srw qdbb ibx` wikc e`wc `f iet `wlcr dxxsc ridxcg de wlc qrdwwce rch`rg `f
}rc}iriwd`e ,9443 Ihw" x% 1?C,?$,i$$ wliw ndalw iffchw wlc h`nndxxd`e }r`hccgdeax ieg
nikc iet `rgcrx `r advc xshl gdrchwd`ex ix nit oc echcxxirt f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f
irrieadea wlc h`nndxxd`e cffchwdvcbt ,f`r c|in}bc gcibdea qdwl iet i}}bdhiwd`e `e
oclibf `f wlc ihhsxcg w` oc }rcxcew de wlc r``n qlcrc wlc h`nndxxd`e }r`hccgdeax irc
wikdea }bihc ,9443 Ihw" x% ?19D,8$,i$$%
H`egshw `f wlc h`nndxxd`e
99% Wlc h`nndxxd`ecr lix wlc iswl`rdwt `f wlc h`srw w` wikc cvdgcehc fr`n i x}chdfdcg
qdwecxx `r qdwecxxcx% Lc `r xlc lix wlc iswl`rdwt w` rcysdrc wlc }irwdcx w` xl`q rcx}chw
f`r wlc }r`hccgdeax ieg wlc }`qcr w` h`ewr`b wlc }r`hccgdeax w` ibb`q wlc h`nndxxd`e
w` oc h`n}bcwcg cffchwdvcbt% Df wlc h`egshw `f iet }irwt w` wlc }r`hccgdeax }rcvcewx
wlc h`nndxxd`e ocdea h`egshwcg cffchwdvcbt" wlc h`nndxxd`ecr qdbb rc}`rw wldx w` wlc
h`srw% Df wlc h`nndxxd`ecr dx i jsgac `f wlc Ldal H`srw" lc `r xlc lix ibb wlc }`qcrx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 153/206
w` h`ewr`b wlc h`egshw `f }r`hccgdeax wliw lc `r xlc q`sbg `wlcrqdxc livc qldbc
xdwwdea ix i jsgac%
9?% Wlc h`nndxxd`ecr qdbb gcwcrndec iet }irwdhsbir niwwcrx echcxxirt f`r wlc
cffchwdvc h`egshw `f wlc h`nndxxd`e }r`hccgdeax ,f`r c|in}bc" qlcwlcr iet
igj`srencewx irc echcxxirt f`r wlc h`nf`rw `f wlc qdwecxx `r w` ibb`q wlc ihhsxcg w`
h`exsbw qdwl wlcdr rc}rcxcewiwdvcx$%
Fsrwlcr lcirdea ifwcr wlc h`nndxxd`e
98% Iw iet fsrwlcr lcirdea wliw lix occe fd|cg w` gcwcrndec niwwcrx irdxdea fr`n wlc
h`nndxxd`e wlc h`srw qdbb .
,i$ gcwcrndec iet yscxwd`e `f igndxxdodbdwt `f cvdgcehc wliw nit livc
occe rcxcrvcg iw wlc h`nndxxd`e;
,o$ nikc gdrchwd`ex de rcx}chw `f iet cvdgcehc rch`rgcg gsrdea wlc
h`nndxxd`e }r`hccgdeax wliw dx w` oc cgdwcg `r `wlcrqdxc rcn`vcg
fr`n wlc rch`rgdea w` oc }bitcg w` wlc jsrt iw wlc wrdib gdcw;
,h$ h`exdgcr iet xsondxxd`ex fr`n }irwdcx de rcx}chw `f wlc ysibdwt `f wlc
rch`rgdea `r iet rcyscxwx f`r i wriexhrd}w `f iet }irw `f wlc rch`rgdeax
wliw nit oc `f }``r ysibdwt ,}irwdcx nit rcyscxw wliw wlc hbcrk ibb`q wlc
rch`rgdea w` oc vdcqcg }rd`r w` wlc fsrwlcr lcirdea w` ixxcxx wlc ysibdwt
`f wlc rch`rgdea$;
,g$ nikc iet gdrchwd`e echcxxirt w` ibb`q }irwdcx w` vdcq wlc fdeib vcrxd`e
`f wlc rch`rgdea xsoxcyscew w` iet rcn`vib `f }irwx `f wlc rch`rgdea
wliw irc e`w w` oc }bitcg w` wlc jsrt gsrdea wlc wrdib%
97% Wlc h`srw c|}chwx wliw df }irwdcx dewceg w` nikc xsondxxd`ex `e wlc cgdwcg vcrxd`e
`f wlc rch`rgdea wliw dx w` oc }bitcg w` wlc jsrt iw wlc wrdib" wldx xl`sbg oc dewdniwcg w`
wlc hbcrk }rd`r w` wlc wrdib gdcw%
Dewr`gshwd`e `f rch`rgdea gsrdea wlc wrdib
93% Wlc rch`rgdea `f wlc h`nndxxd`e }r`hccgdeax qdbb oc }bitcg w` wlc jsrt iw wlc
wdnc de wlc wrdib wlc qdwecxx advdea cvdgcehc w` wlc h`nndxxd`ecr q`sbg `wlcrqdxc
livc occe hibbcg w` advc cvdgcehc gsrdea wlc wrdib }r`hccgdeax%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 154/206
_cvdcq `f ]rihwdhc E`wc
96% Wldx ]rihwdhc E`wc qdbb oc kc}w segcr rcvdcq" ieg dwx wcrnx nit oc n`gdfdcg fr`n
wdnc w` wdnc de bdalw `f c|}crdcehc%
E`vcnocr 4" ?==3
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 155/206
Hli}wcr 4
G@NCXWDH IOSXC
DEW_@GSHWD@E
Gcfdedwd`e
4%9 “‒G`ncxwdh iosxc„ dx iet f`rn `f }ltxdhib" e`e.}ltxdhib" `r xc|sib iosxc
qldhl wikcx }bihc qdwlde wlc h`ewc|w `f i rcbiwd`exld}" h`nndwwcg cdwlcr de wlc
l`nc `r cbxcqlcrc% Wldx rcbiwd`exld} qdbb oc ocwqcce }irwecrx ,nirrdcg" h`.
liodwdea `r `wlcrqdxc$ `r c|. }irwecrx—%9 Wlc iosxc nit dev`bvc }ltxdhib vd`bcehc
`r dw nit dev`bvc iosxc `f i xc|sib" cn`wd`eib r fdeiehdib kdeg% @fwce wlc vdhwdn
`f iosxc dx xsojchwcg w` iosxc `f n`rc wlie i xdeabc kdeg; ieg `e `hhixd`ex wlc
iosxc `f i }irwecr dx ihh`n}iedcg ot wlc iosxc `f `ec `r n rc hldbgrce% Qldbc
n`xw g`ncxwdh iosxc dx }cr}cwriwcg ot nce iaidexw fcnibc }irwecrx?
`r hldbgrce" dw
dx e`w seke`qe f`r dw w` oc hirrdcg `sw ot q`nce% Dw nit ibx` `hhsr ocwqcce
}irwecrx `f wlc xinc xc|%8
De rcbiwd`e w` iosxc `f hldbgrce" wldx dx gcfdecg ix
dehbsgdea vd`bcehc" lirixxncew" wlrciwcedea h`egshw ieg iet `wlcr h`egshw advc
rdxc" `r bdkcbt w` advc rdxc" w` }ltxdhib `r ncewib dejsrt" fcir" ibirn `r gdxwrcxx; ieg
iosxc `f i }crx`e `wlcr wlie wlc hldbg qldhl iffchwx" `r ndalw iffchw wlc hldbg%
Xshl h`egshw dehbsgcx x}cchl ieg }rcxcehc de i x}chdfdcg irci%7
9Wlc gcfdedwd`e iarccg ot wlc g`ncxwdh vd`bcehc q`rkdea ar`s} `f wlc Xh`wwdxl Hrdndeib
Xwiwdxwdhx H`nndwwcc dev`bvdea IH]@,X$ ,Ixx`hdiwd`e `f Hldcf ]`bdhc @ffdhcrx de Xh`wbieg$
e`ndeiwcg rc}rcxcewiwdvcx qldhl iarccg wlc gcfdedwd`e%
?Xwiwdxwdhib Osbbcwde HrJ?==999: G`ncxwdh iosxc rch`rgcg ot wlc }`bdhc de Xh`wbieg" 9
Jiesirt w` 89 Gchcnocr ?===" }sobdxlcg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc" Gchcnocr ?==9%
8 Wldx lix occe h`efdrncg ot rcxcirhl hirrdcg `sw ot wlc Hcewrib _cxcirhl Sedw `f wlc Xh`wwdxl
C|chswdvc" wl`sal wliw rcxcirhl degdhiwcx wliw wlc bcvcb `f iosxc iaidexw nce dx b`q: G`ncxwdh
iosxc iaidexw nce de Xh`wbieg" }sobdxlcg 7 Xc}wcnocr ?==?%
7Xcc x% 99 `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ix incegcg ot x% ?7 `f wlc Findbt Biq
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==6%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 156/206
H`excyscehcx
4%? Ysdwc i}irw fr`n wlc dnncgdiwc cffchwx `f }ltxdhib `r xc|sib iosxc"
g`ncxwdh iosxc acecribbt hie bcig" }irwdhsbirbt f`r q`nce" w` xdaedfdhiew ieg
qdgc.rieadea h`excyscehcx qldhl xl`sbg e`w oc segcr.cxwdniwcg% Wl`xc
h`excyscehcx hie dehbsgc ncewib lcibwl }r`obcnx" ibh`l`b `r grsa iosxc"
l`ncbcxxecxx" }`vcrwt ieg rcgshcg cn}b`tncew `}}`rwsedwdcx% Dw dx x`ncwdncx
nidewidecg wliw i q`nie ql` dx ocdea iosxcg lix wlc rcncgt de lcr `qe liegx:
xlc hie xdn}bt bcivc lcr iosxdea }irwecr% Osw wliw dae`rcx wlc fihw wliw de x`nc
dexwiehcx wlc n`xw xcrd`sx bcvcbx `f vd`bcehc `hhsr qlce i q`nie bcivcx" `r
iwwcn}wx w` bcivc" lcr }irwecr% Dw ibx` dae`rcx wlc fihw wliw ie iosxcg q`nie nit
xdn}bt livc e`qlcrc cbxc w` a`% Xlc nit livc e` findbt ncnocrx bdvdea ecirot"
ieg xlc nit e`w livc wlc fdeiehdib rcx`srhcx w` xcw s} i l`nc f lcr `qe% Xlc
nit ibx` oc fcirfsb wliw" df xlc n`vcx x`ncqlcrc cbxc" lcr iosxdea }irwecr qdbb
xdn}bt f`bb`q lcr ieg wrt w` rcxsnc wlc }iwwcre `f vd`bcehc% Ibb `f wlc f`rca`dea
}r`obcnx qdbb" `f h`srxc" oc c|ihcroiwcg qlcrc wlc q`nie dx rcx}`exdobc f`r wlc
hldbgrce `f wlc rcbiwd`exld}% I bdndwcg in`sew `f rcbdcf dx ividbiobc w` x`nc
q`nce ql` qdxl w` bcivc iosxdea }irwecrx ot wlc }r`vdxd`e `f rcfsacx `}criwcg
ot `raiedxiwd`ex xshl ix Xh`wwdxl Q`nce—x Idg% X`nc ncixsrcx irc ividbiobc w`
ceiobc i q`nie w` rcnide de lcr `qe l`nc%9 Wlc Abixa`q G`ncxwdh Iosxc
H`srw lix wlc idg `f IXXDXW" ql`xc q`rkcrx h`ewihw ibbcacg vdhwdnx `f g`ncxwdh
iosxc ieg `ffcr hl`dhcx ieg igvdhc qldhl ibb`q wlc vdhwdn w` gchdgc qlcwlcr w`
rcwsre l`nc `r e`w%
9 Xcc fsrwlcr }irix% 4%1 w` 4%9= ocb`q%
Gdffcrcew hsbwsrcx
4%8 Dw dx x`ncwdncx xidg wliw cwledh nde`rdwt h`nnsedwdcx }r`vdgc i arciwcr
c|wcegcg findbt ieg x`hdib h`nnsedwt wlie dx w` oc f`seg de `wlcr }irwx `f
x`hdcwt% Wldx dx i h`exdgcriwd`e qldhl nit oc `f xdaedfdhiehc de x`nc hixcx% Dw
q`sbg oc qr`ea" l`qcvcr" f`r i jsgac w` }r`hccg `e wlc oixdx wliw ie iosxcg
q`nie fr`n ie cwledh nde`rdwt h`nnsedwt dx o`seg w` livc findbt ieg
h`nnsedwt xs}} rw% Dw q`sbg ibx` oc ysdwc qr`ea f`r i jsgac w` }r`hccg `e wlc
oixdx wliw de x`nc h`nnsedwdcx g`ncxwdh vd`bcehc ieg iosxc irc" `r nit oc"hsbwsribbt ihhc}wiobc% Ie igsbw `r hldbg ql` lix occe iosxcg dx cewdwbcg w` wlc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 157/206
fsbb }r`wchwd`e iff`rgcg ot wlc biq rcairgbcxx `f ldx `r lcr cwledh `r hsbwsrib
oihkar`seg%
G@NCXWDH IOSXC DE WLC H@S_W ]_@HCXX
Qlcrc wlc dxxsc nit irdxc
4%7 G`ncxwdh iosxc hie niedfcxw dwxcbf de wlc h`srw }r`hcxx de vird`sx qitx% Dw
nit oc wlc xsojchw `f i hlirac `r hliracx de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax; dw nit f`rn
wlc xsojchw.niwwcr" `r iw bcixw wlc oihkar`seg" w` findbt }r`hccgdeax; ieg dw nit
f`rn wlc xsojchw. niwwcr" `r wlc oihkar`seg" w` }r`hccgdeax ocf`rc i hldbgrce—x
lcirdea qldhl nit wlce }r`arcxx" ot `ec nciex `r ie`wlcr" dew` wlc xlcrdff h`srw
ieg oct`eg%
]`dewx w` ocir de ndeg
4%3 Qlcrc ibbcaiwd`ex `f g`ncxwdh iosxc irc w` oc c|}b`rcg de iet kdeg `f h`srw
}r`hccgdeax" dw qdbb oc }irwdhsbirbt dn}`rwiew f`r jsgacx ieg hbcrkx `f h`srw w` ocir de
ndeg wlc xwride ieg fcir qldhl wldx dx bdkcbt w` hisxc wlc h`n}bidecr% Hircfsb
irrieacncewx xl`sbg oc nigc w` kcc} wlc h`n}bidecr ieg ibbcacg }cr}cwriw`r xc}iriwc
fr`n cihl `wlcr o`wl ocf`rc ieg gsrdea wlc }r`hccgdeax% De i}}r`}rdiwc hixcx"
cvdgcehc nit oc advce de i nieecr qldhl iff`rgx x`nc }r`wchwd`e w` wlc qdwecxx%9
9Xcc x}chdib ncixsrcx f`r vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx" gcwidbcg de }iri%9=%?= ocb`q%
4%6 Dw dx e`w seke`qe" }irwdhsbirbt de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax" f`r i vdhwdn `f ibbcacg
g`ncxwdh iosxc w` oc rcbshwiew w` advc cvdgcehc de xs}}`rw `f wlc hlirac `r hliracx" `r
iw bcixw w` xcck w` gdndedxl xsoxwiewdibbt wlc xcrd`sxecxx `f qliwcvcr `hhsrrcg% Wldx
hie oc drrdwiwdea iw wdncx f`r jsgacx ieg }r`xchsw`rx" osw wlcrc hie oc xcvcrib rcix`ex
f`r dw% De bcxx xcrd`sx hixcx dw dx bdkcbt wliw wlc ihhsxcg qdbb livc occe ibb`qcg oidb
f`bb`qdea ldx fdrxw i}}ciriehc de h`srw" ieg ix i h`excyscehc lc ieg ldx }irwecr nit
livc h`ewdescg w` h`liodw gsrdea wlc }crd`g sewdb wlc giwc `f wlc wrdib% De xshl i
xdwsiwd`e dw dx }crfchwbt }`xxdobc wliw wlct nit ihwsibbt livc ihldcvcg x`ncwldea `f i
rch`ehdbdiwd`e qdwl wlc rcxsbw wliw wlc iosxcg }irwecr dx seqdbbdea w` xit ietwldea wliw
ndalw rcxsbw de wlc `wlcr ocdea }sedxlcg f`r qliw lc gdg" }`xxdobt niet n`ewlx
cirbdcr% Ie cysibbt }`xxdobc c|}bieiwd`e f`r i fidbsrc ot i vdhwdn w` x}cik s} de h`srw
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 158/206
dx wliw i ldxw`rt `f iosxc" `r wlrciwx w` lcr `r lcr hldbgrce io`sw advdea cvdgcehc" lix
bcfw lcr x` wcrrdfdcg wliw xlc fcirx wlc h`excyscehcx df xlc x}cikx s} iaidexw lcr
iosxdea }irwecr% Wldx dx xcbg`n bdkcbt w` cncrac ix i hcrwidewt de wlc h`srxc `f i wrdib"
osw dw dx i gdxwdehw }`xxdodbdwt de niet hixcx; ieg dw xl`sbg e`w wlcrcf`rc oc ixxsncg
wliw i qdwecxx ql` g`cx e`w advc cvdgcehc xs}}`rwdvc `f i hlirac or`salw iaidexw lcr
}irwecr dx xdn}bt ocdea gdffdhsbw `r `oxwrshwdvc% Wlc f`rca`dea gdffdhsbwdcx irc bcxx
bdkcbt w` oc ceh`sewcrcg de" f`r c|in}bc" gdv`rhc }r`hccgdeax qlcrc wlc oclivd`sr `f
`ec x}`sxc dx ocdea f`segcg `e ot wlc `wlcr ix jsxwdftdea i gchrcc `f gdv`rhc: ot wlc
wdnc i gdv`rhdea x}`sxc lix wikce }r`hccgdeax w` wlc xwiac `f i }r``f xlc lix sxsibbt
rcihlcg i }`dew qlcrc xlc dx qdbbdea ieg iobc w` advc ibb `f wlc cvdgcehc qldhl nit oc
rcysdrcg% Dw xl`sbg oc rch`aedxcg" l`qcvcr" wliw q`nce nit oc fsrwlcr iosxcg ieg
dewdndgiwcg gsrdea h`ewihw irrieacncewx f`r hldbgrce" ieg gsrdea gdv`rhc }r`hccgdeax%
]_@WCHWD@E NCIXS_CX
X}`sxcx `r }irwecrx
4%1 De hixcx `f vd`bcehc `r iosxc dev`bvdea i x}`sxc `r }irwecr x`nc wcn}`rirt
}r`wchwd`e dx }r`vdgcg ot wlc Niwrdn`edib L`ncx ,Findbt ]r`wchwd`e$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw
94<99
ieg wlc Hdvdb ]irwecrxld} Ihw ?==7% Wlc wcrnx `f wlc rcbcview }r`vdxd`ex de
wl`xc Ihwx irc fsbbt c|}bidecg ieg h`nncewcg `e cbxcqlcrc%?
H`nn`e biq dewcrgdhwx
nit ibx` oc i}}r`}rdiwc de hcrwide hdrhsnxwiehcx%
9 Wlc 94<9 Ihw }r`vdxd`ex qcrc c|wcegcg w` h`vcr h`liodwdea h`s}bcx `f wlc xinc xc| ot x%87
`f wlc Findbt Biq ,Xh`wbieg $ Ihw ?==6 qldhl incegx x%9< `f wlc Niwrdn`edib L`ncx
,Findbt ]r`wchwd`e$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 94<9%
? Xcc" f`r c|in}bc" Hbdvc" Lsxoieg ieg Qdfc ,7wl cg%$" Hli}wcr 93; Oceecww" Gdv`rhc ieg
Gdxx`bswd`e `f Hdvdb ]irwecrxld} de wlc xlcrdff h`srw ,<wl cg%$ hli}wcr 7%
]r`wchwd`e acecribbt
4%< Wlc ]r`wchwd`e fr`n Iosxc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==9 }r`vdgcx wliw iet }crx`e9
ql`
dx i}}btdea f`r" `r ql` lix `owidecg" ie dewcrgdhw f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f }r`wchwd`e iaidexw
iosxc" nit livc i }`qcr `f irrcxw iwwihlcg w` wlc dewcrgdhw%? ‒Iosxc„ dx gcfdecg f`r
wldx }sr}`xc ix dehbsgdea ‒vd`bcehc" lirixxncew" wlrciwcedea h`egshw" ieg iet `wlcr
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 159/206
h`egshw advdea rdxc" `r bdkcbt w` advc rdxc" w` }ltxdhib `r ncewib dejsrt" fcir" ibirn `r
gdxwrcxx„" ieg ‒h`egshw„ dx gcfdecg ix dehbsgdea ,i$ x}cchl" ieg ,o$ }rcxcehc de i
x}chdfdcg }bihc `r irci% W` iv`dg gdffdhsbwdcx qldhl livc irdxce de rcbiwd`e w` `rgcrx
segcr wlc ]r`wchwd`e fr`n Lirixxncew Ihw 9441 ,xcc }iriari}l 4%4" ocb`q$" dw dx
c|}rcxxbt }r`vdgcg wliw ‒dewcrgdhw„ dehbsgcx dewcrdn dewcrgdhw%
9 Wlc }r`wchwd`e `ffcrcg ot wlc xwiwswc dx e`w rcxwrdhwcg w` x}`sxcx `r }irwecrx%
? Xcc Xchwd`e 9I `f wlc ]r`wchwd`e fr`n Iosxc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==9 ix incegcg ot xchwd`e 8?
`f wlc Findbt Biq ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==6%
E`e.lirixxncew `rgcrx
4%4 X`nc fsrwlcr }r`wchwd`e nit oc }r`vdgcg ot wlc ]r`wchwd`e fr`n LirixxncewIhw 9441% In`ea wlcr wldeax" wliw Ihw }crndwx wlc nikdea `f ‒e`e.lirixxncew
`rgcrx"„ wlc orcihl `f qldhl dx }sedxliobc qdwl dn}rdx`encew% Wlcrc irc h`efbdhwdea
gchdxd`ex ix w` wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx de qldhl e`e.lirixxncew `rgcrx nit" ieg nit e`w"
oc nigc9% I }rch`egdwd`e f`r i e`e.lirixxncew `rgcr dx wliw wlc ihhsxcg lix occe
h`evdhwcg `f ie `ffcehc dev`bvdea rcbcview h`egshw `e iw bcixw wq` `hhixd`ex?%
Wlc
Hrdndeib Jsxwdhc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==8 incegcg wlc 9441 Ihw w` ibb`q i }`bdhc `ffdhcr
w` irrcxw qdwl`sw i qirriew i }crx`e lc `r xlc rcix`eiobt ocbdcvcx w` oc de orcihl `f i
e`e.lirixxncew `rgcr" dn}`xcg de cdwlcr hrdndeib `r hdvdb }r`hccgdeax8%
9 _`ocrwx`e v% Vieecw 944< X%H%H%_% 66<; Fsrocr v% Fsrocr 9444 X%H%B%_% 973" ieg 993?;
Lcceie v% Gdbb`e 9444 X%H%B%_% 371; Ibc|iegri v% Nsr}lt ?=== X%H%B%_% ?==%
? NhAbceeie v NhKdee`e 944< X%B%W% 747%
8 Xchwd`e 4,8$ `f wlc ]r`wchwd`e fr`n Lirixxncew Ihw 9441 ix dexcrwcg ot x% 74 wlc Hrdndeib
Jsxwdhc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==8%
Hldbgrce
4%9= Hldbgrce ql` irc wlc vdhwdnx `f ibbcacg iosxc nit oc iff`rgcg }r`wchwd`e
segcr wlc hldbgrce—x lcirdea xtxwcn% @e i wcn}`rirt" `r cncraceht" oixdx wlc h`srwx
livc }`qcr segcr wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 w` nikc hcrwide dewcrdn `rgcrx de
`rgcr w` }r`vdgc }r`wchwd`e% Wlcxc dehbsgc" segcr xchwd`e 31" hldbg }r`wchwd`e rgcrx"
ieg" segcr xchwd`ex 16 w` <=" c|hbsxd`e `rgcrx%9 Fsrwlcrn`rc" qlce nikdea iet h`srw
`rgcrx rcbiwdea w` }ircewib rcx}`exdodbdwdcx" wlc h`srw nsxw livc rcairg w` .
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 160/206
,i$ wlc eccg w` }r`wchw wlc hldbg fr`n iet iosxc `r wlc rdxk `f iosxc qldhl
iffchwx" `r ndalw iffchw wlc hldbg;
,o$ wlc cffchw xshl iosxc" `r wlc rdxk `f xshl iosxc" ndalw livc `e wlc hldbg;
,h$ wlc iodbdwt `f i }crx`e ,ql` lix hirrdcg `sw iosxc qldhl iffchwx `r ndalw
iffchw wlc hldbg; `r ql` ndalw hirrt `sw xshl iosxc$ w` hirc f`r" `r `wlcrqdxc
nccw wlc eccgx `f" wlc hldbg" ieg
,g$ wlc cffchw iet iosxc" `r wlc rdxk `f iet iosxc" ndalw livc `e wlc hirrtdea
`sw `f rcx}`exdodbdwdcx de h`eechwd`e qdwl wlc qcbfirc `f wlc hldbg ot i }crx`e
ql` lix ,`r q`sbg ‘ segcr i h`srw `rgcr ‘ livc$ wlcxc rcx}`exdodbdwdcx?%
9Wlcxc `rgcrx irc fsbbt gcxhrdocg de" f`r c|in}bc" E`rrdc" Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443"
rcvdxcg cgdwd`e" Arccex Iee`wiwcg Ihwx 944<; Qdbkdex`e ieg E`rrdc" ]ircew ieg Hldbg" ?eg cg%
?Xcc x% 99 ,1I.C$ `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ix incegcg ot x% ?7 `f wlc Findbt Biq
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==6%
HLDBG_CE DEGD_CHWBT IFFCHWCG OT G@NCXWDH IOSXC
_cxdgcehc ieg h`ewihw
4%99 Gdffdhsbw yscxwd`ex nit irdxc de hixcx qlcrc `ec }ircew ibbcacx wliw xlc lix
occe iosxcg ot wlc `wlcr }ircew" ieg wlc jsgac lix w` gcwcrndec rcxdgcehc `r h`ewihw
qlcrc dw dx e`w ibbcacg wliw wlcrc lix occe iet gdrchw iosxc iaidexw wlc hldbg `r
hldbgrce wlcnxcbvcx% H`exdgcriwd`e xl`sbg oc advce w` wlc cffchw `e i hldbg `f
qdwecxxdea iosxc `f `ec }ircew ot wlc `wlcr }ircew% Ibx` `ec }ircew nit sxc h`ewihw
w` iosxc wlc `wlcr }ircew fsrwlcr" ieg nit wrt w` dev`bvc wlc hldbg de wliw iosxc% Vcrt
`fwce yscxwd`ex `f rcxdgcehc `r h`ewihw irdxc iw ie cirbt xwiac ocf`rc wlcrc lix occe
iet `}}`rwsedwt w` c|}b`rc de cvdgcehc wlc c|dxwcehc" `r ioxcehc" `f dewcr.}ircewib
iosxc% Dw dx vdrwsibbt dn}`xxdobc w` `ffcr iet acecrib asdgiehc de xshl hixcx" ix x`
nshl qdbb decvdwiobt wsre `e wlc }irwdhsbir fihwx ieg hdrhsnxwiehcx% I fsbb ieg
dewcrcxwdea gdxhsxxd`e `f wlc acecrib dxxscx hie oc f`seg de ie Ceabdxl iswl`rdwt _c B
,i hldbg$%9
9 [?==9^ Fin% ?6=; [?===^ 7 Ibb C%_% 6=4% Xcc ibx` }iri 4%9= io`vc ieg wlc rcfcrcehc w` x%99
,1I.C$ `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ix incegcg ot x%?7 `f wlc Findbt Biq ,Xh`wbieg$
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 161/206
Ihw ?==6" qlcrc wlc h`srw dx rcysdrcg w` wikc wldx def`rniwd`e dew` ihh`sew qlce nikdea
`rgcrx iffchwdea i hldbg—x rcxdgcehc ieg h`ewihw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 162/206
Hli}wcr 9=
DEWDNDGIWCG IEG @WLC_ VSBEC_IOBC
QDWECXXCX
DEW_@GSHWD@E
Vsbecriodbdwt
9=%9 Niet qdwecxxcx irc i}}rclcexdvc io`sw advdea cvdgcehc de h`srw" qlcwlcr de i
hdvdb `r i hrdndeib hixc%
9
X`nc qdwecxxcx irc n`rc vsbecriobc ieg n`rc i}}rclcexdvcwlie `wlcrx% Wlc gcarcc `f vsbecriodbdwt nit rcbiwc w` i virdcwt `f fihw`rx" dehbsgdea
}crx`eib hlirihwcrdxwdhx?" }crx`eib hdrhsnxwiehcx
8" ieg wlc eiwsrc `f wlc gdx}swc `r
`ffcehc%7 Wlc wcrn “vsbecriobc qdwecxx— dehbsgcx hldbgrce ieg }crx`ex `vcr 96 qlcrc
wlcrc dx i xdaedfdhiew rdxk wliw wlc ysibdwt `f wlcdr cvdgcehc qdbb oc gdndedxlcg ot
rcix`e `f wlcdr ncewib gdx`rgcr `r fcir ieg gdxwrcxx de h`eechwd`e qdwl advdea cvdgcehc
iw wlc wrdib%3
9 Xcc" f`r c|in}bc `oxcrviwd`ex de W`qirgx i Jsxw H`ehbsxd`e" }sobdxlcg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl
@ffdhc de 944<: ‒Qldbc qdwecxxcx nit oc rcbshwiew w` h`nc f`rqirg ochisxc wlct irc
i}}rclcexdvc `f dev`bvcncew de wlc ql`bc hrdndeib jsxwdhc }r`hcxx" fr`n devcxwdaiwd`e w` wrdib"
dw dx wlc wrdib dwxcbf qldhl hisxcx n`xw i}}rclcexd`e% Wldx dx wrsc f`r ibn`xw iet qdwecxx: cvce
c|}crdcehcg }`bdhc `ffdhcrx fdeg dw gisewdea w` advc cvdgcehc% ]irwdhsbirbt gisewdea dx wlc
}r`x}chw `f ie ihwdvc ieg }crxdxwcew hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e ot wlc gcfcehc% Wlc ldal xwiegirg `f
}r``f" qldhl dx rcysdrcg w` `owide i hrdndeib h`evdhwd`e" nciex wliw qdwecxxcx f`r wlc
}r`xchswd`e nit oc xsojchwcg w` hr`xx c|indeiwd`e gcxdaecg w` wcxw wlc hrcgdodbdwt `f wlcdr
cvdgcehc%„ Xh`wbieg nsxw h`n}bt qdwl wlc CS Frincq`rk Gchdxd`e `e wlc Xwiegdea `f Vdhwdnx de Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc: f`r gcwidbx" xcc Vdhwdnx de wlc Hrdndeib Jsxwdhc Xtxwcn
}sobdxlcg ot wlc Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc de E`vcnocr ?==?
,lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%skbdorirt3jsxwdhcvhjx.==%ix}$% Xcc ibx` Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc
asdgiehc }ihk f`r Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx }sobdxlcg de ?==3
,lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%sk]sobdhiwd`ex?==6=889=4879=9=$%
?Xshl ix gdxiodbdwt" `r iac: xcc Hli}wcrx 1 ,]crx`ex qdwl gdxiodbdwdcx$ ieg < ,Hldbgrce$%
8Irdxdea" f`r c|in}bc" fr`n i rcbiwd`exld} qdwl i qdwecxx `r ie ihhsxcg: xcc dewcr ibdi Hli}wcr
4 ,G`ncxwdh iosxc$%
7 Vdhwdnx `f ixxisbw `r xc|sib hrdnc irc `fwce wrisniwdxcg" ieg fdeg dw vcrt gdffdhsbw w` advc
cvdgcehc de h`srw de wlc }rcxcehc `f wlc ihhsxcg: xcc Hli}wcr 99 ,Vdhwdnx `f xc|sib hrdnc$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 163/206
3 Xcc xchwd`e ?19 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ix xsoxwdwswcg ot xchwd`e 9 `f
wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7%
9=%? Hli}wcrx 1" <" 4" ieg 99 `f wldx Ocehl O``k f`hsx `e }crx`ex qdwl gdxiodbdwdcx"
hldbgrce" g`ncxwdh iosxc" ieg vdhwdnx `f xc|sib hrdnc% Wldx hli}wcr dx h`ehcrecg qdwl
i}}rclcexdvc qdwecxxcx de acecrib" ieg qdwl dewdndgiwcg qdwecxxcx%9
I fdeib xchwd`e"
rcbcview `ebt de hrdndeib wrdibx" `swbdecx ibwcreiwdvc qitx `f bcigdea cvdgcehc fr`n
vsbecriobc }crx`ex ieg }crx`ex sefdw w` advc cvdgcehc de h`srw de wlc e`rnib qit%?
9Ie dewdndgiwcg qdwecxx lix occe gcfdecg ix x`nc`ec ql` ‒ix i rcxsbw `f ihwsib dewdndgiwd`e"
`r i }crhcdvcg wlrciw `f dewdndgiwd`e" nit oc de acesdec fcir `f a`dea w` h`srw w` advc
cvdgcehc„: W`qirgx i Jsxw H`ehbsxd`e" Xh`wwdxl @ffdhc" 944<%
?Wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,HHWV$" xhrccex" cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e" ieg wlc sxc `f }rd`r xwiwcncewx"
irc ncwl`gx ividbiobc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax%
9=%8 De hrdndeib hixcx" wlc h`ehc}w `f i ‒vsbecriobc }crx`e„ lix occe xwiwsw`rdbt
gcfdecg de wlc h`ewc|w `f i}}bdhiwd`ex f`r cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e" f`r wlc sxc `f
HHWV `r xhrccex" `r wlc sxc `f i xs}}`rwcr%9 De }irwdhsbir" ‒vsbecriobc }crx`e„
dehbsgcx i }crx`e `f `r `vcr wlc iac `f 96 tcirx qlcrc wlcrc dx i xdaedfdhiew rdxk wliw
wlc ysibdwt `f cvdgcehc w` oc advce ot wlc }crx`e qdbb oc gdndedxlcg ot ncewib
gdx`rgcr `r fcir `r gdxwrcxx de h`eechwd`e qdwl advdea cvdgcehc iw wlc wrdib%?
Wlc h`srw
ibx` lix i h`nn`e biq }`qcr w` }r`wchw iet vsbecriobc qdwecxx ql` q`sbg oc }bihcg
iw i gdxigviewiac ot livdea w` advc cvdgcehc de wlc e`rnib qit%8
De }irwdhsbir" wlc
h`srw lix }`qcr iw h`nn`e biq w` }crndw xshl i qdwecxx w` advc cvdgcehc fr`n
ocldeg i xhrcce%7
9Xcc }irix% 9=%96 cw xcy% ocb`q ieg xchwd`e ?19H ieg L `f wlc 9443 Ihw ix xsoxwdwswcg ot
xchwd`e 9 `f wlc ?==3 Ihw%
? Xcc xchwd`e ?19,9$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ix xsoxwdwswcg ot xchwd`e 9
`f wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7%
8 Iw h`nn`e biq" wlcrc dx e` rcxwrdhwdvc gcfdedwd`e `f ‒vsbecriobc qdwecxx„% Wlc H`srw `f
Hrdndeib I}}cib lix rch`aedxcg wliw ‒}crx`ex ql` irc vsbecriobc w` iwwihk" `r fcir `f iwwihk"
`r dewdndgiwd`e irdxdea `sw `f wlcdr advdea cvdgcehc„ nit }r`}crbt oc rcairgcg ix ‒vsbecriobc
qdwecxxcx„: xcc Lin}x`e v L%N% Igv`hiwc" ?==8 XHH_ 98" iw }iri% [1^%
7 Lin}x`e v L%N% Igv`hiwc" io`vc" iw }iri% [<^ ,qlcrc i vsbecriobc ieg ie|d`sx q`nie iacg
?4" wcrrdfdcg `f ocdea c|}`xcg w` wlc aizc `f wlc wlrcc nce ihhsxcg `f rivdxldea lcr" qix
}crndwwcg w` advc lcr cvdgcehc fr`n ocldeg i xhrcce$; Xndwl v L%N% Igv`hiwc ?=== X%H%H%_%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 164/206
49= ,qlcrc segcrh`vcr }`bdhc `ffdhcrx qcrc }crndwwcg w` advc wlcdr cvdgcehc qdwl`sw rcvcibdea
wlcdr wrsc dgcewdwdcx ieg qldbc rcnidedea h`ehcibcg fr`n wlc }sobdh ieg wlc }rcxx ot xhrccex$%
WLC DN]@_WIEHC @F DEF@_NIWD@E" XS]]@_W" IEG CEVD_@ENCEW
Def`rniwd`e
9=%7 Wlc xwrcxx ieg fccbdeax `f gdxcn}`qcrncew c|}crdcehcg ot i qdwecxx qidwdea
w` advc cvdgcehc hiee`w oc `vcrcn}lixdxcg% I qdwecxx `obdacg w` iwwceg i xwrieac
osdbgdea" ieg w` xdw f`r b`ea }crd`gx qdwl`sw h`ewihw `r def`rniwd`e" dx sebdkcbt w` rcihw
qcbb% Wlc ysibdwt `f wlc cvdgcehc sbwdniwcbt advce" ieg wlc iwwcewd`e }idg w` wlc hixc"nit oc igvcrxcbt iffchwcg% Dw dx dn}`rwiew" wlcrcf`rc" wliw i qdwecxx oc advce rcasbir
def`rniwd`e io`sw ldx `r lcr i}}ciriehc de h`srw%9
Qdwecxxcx i}}rchdiwc ocdea w`bg
l`q b`ea wlct irc bdkcbt w` livc w` qidw" ieg qlce wlct irc bdkcbt w` oc hibbcg w` advc
cvdgcehc% Wlct ibx` i}}rchdiwc ocdea w`bg io`sw niwwcrx qldhl nit xccn r`swdec w`
h`srw xwiff" osw qldhl irc `f wlc swn`xw dn}`rwiehc w` wlc qdwecxx ‘ f`r c|in}bc" wliw
wlc wrdib lix occe gcbitcg ieg wlc rcix`e f`r wlc gcbit" `r wliw wlc ihhsxcg lix }bcg
asdbwt% De wlc biwwcr hixc" qdwecxxcx nit i}}rchdiwc ie `}}`rwsedwt w` oc de h`srw qlce
wlc }bci dx wcegcrcg ieg gcibw qdwl% F`bb`q.s} def`rniwd`e f r vdhwdnx `f hrdnc dx
cysibbt dn}`rwiew%?
Qldbxw nshl `f wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r }r`vdgdea def`rniwd`e bdcx
qdwl `wlcrx8" jsgacx xl`sbg ecvcr ixxsnc wliw qdwecxxcx fsbbt segcrxwieg wlc jsgdhdib
}r`hcxx" `r wlcdr r÷bc de dw% De h`srw" jsgacx xl`sbg wrt qlcrcvcr }`xxdobc w` cexsrc wliw
qdwecxxcx irc nigc iqirc `f qliw dx li}}cedea" f`r c|in}bc" df ie igj`srencew dx
rcysdrcg% Jsgacx nit ibx` livc `}}`rwsedwdcx w` rcndeg h`srw xwiff ieg igndedxwriwdvc
xwiff io`sw wlc eccg w` advc qdwecxxcx def`rniwd`e" f`r c|in}bc" ot hlchkdea qdwl wlc
hbcrk `f h`srw wliw def`rniwd`e io`sw i gcbit lix occe h`nnsedhiwcg w` qidwdea
qdwecxxcx% Qlcrcvcr }`xxdobc" jsgacx xl`sbg ceh`sriac h`srw ieg igndedxwriwdvc xwiff
w` bdidxc qdwl iacehdcx ql` hie ixxdxw qdwecxxcx" xshl ix wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc7" ieg
Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg Igvdhc%3
9 Dw dx g`sobt dn}`rwiew de wlc hixc `f ie dewdndgiwcg `r vsbecriobc qdwecxx" `r i h`n}bidecr de
i hixc: xcc acecribbt ‒Xh`wwdxl Xwriwcat f`r Vdhwdnx„" Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc" ?==9%
? Wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc ieg ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Xcrvdhc lix cxwiobdxlcg i Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg
Igvdhc xcrvdhc oixcg de irci fdxhibx `ffdhcx wlr`sal`sw Xh`wbieg: xcc }iri% 9=%< ocb`q%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 165/206
8 F`r c|in}bc" wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc dx h`exhd`sx `f wlc eccg w` kcc} wlc }sobdh qcbb.
def`rncg% Ie cvcr.dehrcixdea esnocr `f def`rniwd`e bcifbcwx irc ividbiobc de Hdwdzcex Igvdhc
Osrcis|" biqtcrx— `ffdhcx" iacehdcx xshl ix Vdhwdn Xs}}`rw ieg Q`nce—x Idg" h`srw qidwdea
r``nx ieg }sobdh ircix" ieg fr`n wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc ieg ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Xcrvdhc%
7
Xcc }iri% 9=%1" ocb`q%3 Xcc }iri% 9=%<" ocb`q%
Xs}}`rw
9=%3 Niet qdwecxxcx livc x`srhcx `f xs}}`rw" ieg irc ihh`n}iedcg w` h`srw ot
findbt `r frdcegx% @wlcrx livc bdwwbc xs}}`rw% Iaide" qldbc xshl bihk f xs}}`rw dx
biracbt oct`eg wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt `f wlc jsgac" dw dx sxcfsb df ncnocrx `f wlc jsgdhdirt
findbdirdxc wlcnxcbvcx qdwl wlc r÷bc ieg fsehwd`e `f h`srw x`hdib q`rkcrx" Vdhwdn
Xs}}`rw" Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc" ieg `wlcr x}chdibdxw iacehdcx xshl ix Q`nce!x Idg" ieg
_i}c Hrdxdx% Ibb livc i vibsiobc h`ewrdoswd`e w` nikc%
]rcxcehc `f xs}}`rw fdasrc de h`srw
9=%6 Ocf`rc ariewdea iet rcyscxw wliw i rcbiwdvc `r x`hdib q`rkcr `r `wlcr xs}}`rw
}crx`e oc }crndwwcg w` xdw ecir wlc qdwecxx qldbc lc `r xlc dx advdea cvdgcehc" dw dx
xsaacxwcg wliw ,i$ wlc vdcqx `f `wlcr }irwdcx xl`sbg oc ixhcrwidecg; ,o$ h`efdrniwd`e
xl`sbg oc `owidecg wliw wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e dx e`w w` oc i qdwecxx de wlc hixc; ,h$ i
xciwdea irrieacncew xl`sbg oc nigc xshl wliw wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e dx xsffdhdcewbt hb`xc
w` wlc qdwecxx" osw g`cx e`w dewcrfcrc ‘ cdwlcr }ltxdhibbt `r vcroibbt ‘ qdwl wlc
cvdgcehc; ,g$ wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e xl`sbg oc qirecg ot wlc h`srw e`w w` }r`n}w `r xcck
w` defbscehc wlc qdwecxx de iet qit%9
I vsbecriobc qdwecxx i}}bdhiwd`e xl`sbg oc
nigc w` wlc h`srw ot wlc }irwt dewcegdea w` hibb ie igsbw qdwecxx wl`salw w` oc
vsbecriobc% Wlc i}}bdhiwd`e xl`sbg dehbsgc wlc x}chdib ncixsrcx x salw w` fihdbdwiwc
wlc qdwecxx advdea cvdgcehc%?
9 De NhAdebct v L%N% Igv`hiwc" ?==9 X%H%H%_% 71" qlcrc ie igsbw h`n}bidecr de i hixc
dev`bvdea ibbcacg xc|sib iosxc rcyscxwcg wlc }rcxcehc `f lcr o`tfrdceg ix i xs}}`rw }crx`e" dw
qix lcbg echcxxirt f`r wlc xlcrdff w` advc gdrchwd`ex xwrcxxdea wlc bdndwcg r`bc `f wlc xs}}`rw
}crx`e" ieg qiredea ldn e`w w` dewcrfcrc qdwl wlc qdwecxx—x iexqcrx%
? Xcc xchwd`e ?19H `f wlc 9443 Ihw ix xsoxwdwswcg ot xchwd`e 9 `f wlc ?==7 Ihw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 166/206
Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc
9=%1 F`bb`qdea }db`w }r`jchwx de Itr" Lindbw`e ieg Kdrkhibgt xlcrdff h`srwx" wlc
Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc dx e`q ividbiobc de cvcrt xlcrdff h`srw% H`.`rgdeiw`rx livc occe
i}}`dewcg de cbcvce ‒h`rc h`srwx„ ieg wlct irc rcx}`exdobc f`r rseedea wlc Qdwecxx
Xcrvdhc de wliw h`srw ieg `wlcrx de wlc ixx`hdiwcg hbsxwcr% Wlc xcrvdhc dx }r`vdgcg ot
wridecg v`bsewccrx% Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc }r`vdgcx }rihwdhib ieg cn wd`eib xs}}`rw w`
qdwecxxcx iwwcegdea h`srw f`r hrdndeib wrdibx% Wlc Xcrvdhc qdbb" l`qcvcr" }r`vdgc
xs}}`rw w` qdwecxxcx de hdvdb hixcx df ixkcg% Wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc `ffcrx i virdcwt `f
xcrvdhcx dehbsgdea:
}rc.wrdib h`srwr``n vdxdwx;
def`rniwd`e io`sw h`srw cwdyscwwc" }r`hcgsrcx" ieg }crx`eecb;
cn`wd`eib xs}}`rw rcairgdea iet ie|dcwdcx wlc h`srw i}}ciriehc nit degshc;
irrieacncewx f`r qidwdea ihh`nn`giwd`e df wlcrc irc h`ehcrex rcairgdea h`ewihw
qdwl hcrwide }crx`ex ,xshl ix ixx`hdiwcx `f ie ihhsxcg$;
}rihwdhib igvdhc `e dxxscx xshl ix }irkdea" c|}cexcx cwh%;
ie ixxcxxncew `f wlc qdwecxx—x eccgx f`bb`qdea wlc hixc" dehbsgdea rcfcrrib w` `wlcr
iacehdcx ix rcysdrcg%
Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg Igvdhc
9=%< Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg Igvdhc ,VDI$ dx wlc gcgdhiwcg vdhwdn def`rniwd`e ieg
igvdhc xcrvdhc qdwlde wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc ieg ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Xcrvdhc% @ffdhcx livc
occe cxwiobdxlcg wlr`sal`sw Xh wbieg de irci }r`hsriw`r fdxhib `ffdhcx% VDI idnx w`
}r`vdgc acecrib def`rniwd`e io`sw wlc hrdndeib jsxwdhc }r`hcxx" ieg w` kcc}
degdvdgsibx def`rncg io`sw wlc }r`arcxx `f wlc hixc wliw iffchwx wlcn% Dw ibx` igvdxcx
`e ieg fihdbdwiwcx rcfcrribx w` `wlcr iacehdcx f`r x}chdibdxw xs}}`rw ieg h`sexcbbdea ix
rcysdrcg% X}chdibbt wridecg xwiff fr`n i virdcwt `f rcbiwcg oihkar`segx" rieadea fr`n
x`hdib q`rkcrx w` c|.}`bdhc `ffdhcrx" cexsrc wliw i qcbb.def`rncg" xcexdwdvc ieg
degdvdgsib i}}r`ihl dx wikce qdwl vdhwdnx% VDI }r`vdgcx def`rniwd`e `ebt `e hixcx
rc}`rwcg w` wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib% VDI q`rkx hb`xcbt qdwl `wlcr xwiwsw`rt iacehdcx ,f`r
c|in}bc" wlc }`bdhc ieg wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc$ ieg ibx` qdwl v`bsewirt
`raiedxiwd`ex ,xshl ix wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc" Q`nce—x Idg ieg Vdhwdn Xs}}`rw
Xh`wbieg$% Wlc xcrvdhc dx }r`vdgcg w` degdvdgsib vdhwdnx `r w` ar`s}x `f vdhwdnx% VDI
hsrrcewbt gcibx qdwl wlc f`bb`qdea hiwca`rdcx:
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 167/206
Vdhwdnx de ibb xcrd`sx hixcx" qlcrc wlc eiwsrc `f wlc hlirac,x$ dx degdhiwdvc `f
x`bcne }r`hccgdeax;
Wlc ec|w `f kde de hixcx dev`bvdea gciwlx qlcrc hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax irc }`xxdobc
`r qlcrc i fiwib ihhdgcew deysdrt dx w` oc lcbg;
Wlc ec|w `f kde de iet hixc qlcrc wlct livc occe devdwcg ot wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib
w` gdxhsxx wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx `f wlc gciwl;
Vdhwdnx de hixcx `f g`ncxwdh iosxc;
Vdhwdnx de hixcx qdwl i rihdib iaariviwd`e ieg hixcx qlcrc dw dx ke`qe w` wlc
}r`hsriw`r fdxhib wliw wlc vdhwdn }crhcdvcx wlc `ffcehc w` oc rihdibbt n`wdviwcg;
Hixcx dev`bvdea hldbg qdwecxxcx;
Vdhwdnx de hixcx dev`bvdea xc|sib ffcehcx;
Iet `wlcr vdhwdn" ec|w `f kde `r qdwecxx qlcrc wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib ieg wlc VDI
`ffdhcr iarcc wliw ochisxc `f }irwdhsbir vsbecriodbdwt wlc }r`vdxd`e `f xcrvdhcx
q`sbg oc ocecfdhdib%
Cevdr`encew
9=%4 Wlcrc dx dehrcixdea rch`aedwd`e wliw }ltxdhib cevdr`encew dx dn}`rwiew w` wl`xc
ql` och`nc dev`bvcg de wlc jsxwdhc xtxwcn% Qdwecxxcx" jsr`rx" ieg `wlcr ncnocrx `f
wlc }sobdh `fwce livc w` x}ceg wdnc de i h`srw osdbgdea" cdwlcr ihwdvcbt dev`bvcg de i
hixc" r xdn}bt qidwdea% Wlc Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc dx wikdea xwc}x w` n`gcredxc
osdbgdeax ieg dn}r`vc fihdbdwdcx" wlsx }r`vdgdea xsdwiobc cevdr`encewx% Niet
iacehdcx `ffcr }rc.h`srw vdxdwx w` ceiobc qdwecxxcx w` findbdirdxc wlcnxcbvcx qdwl wlc
h`srw ieg dwx fihdbdwdcx%9
9 F`r c|in}bc" wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc%
DEWDNDGIWCG QDWECXXCX
Xchsrdwt irrieacncewx
9=%9= Wlc }`bdhc f`rhc dx wlc n`xw bdkcbt iaceht w` och`nc iqirc wliw i qdwecxx dx
fihdea `r dx bdkcbt w` fihc dewdndgiwd`e }rd`r w`" gsrdea" `r ifwcr i h`srw i}}ciriehc% Dw
dx dn}`rwiew wlcrcf`rc wliw wlcrc dx a``g h`nnsedhiwd`e ocwqcce }`bdhc" }r`xchswd`e"ieg h`srw xcrvdhcx" x` wliw rcbcview def`rniwd`e rcairgdea i qdwecxx—x eccgx dx nigc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 168/206
ividbiobc ix cirbt ix }`xxdobc w` cexsrc cffchwdvc }bieedea% Ie dewdndgiwcg qdwecxx
nit livc w` qidw de i xc}iriwc qdwecxx r``n" `r oc cxh`rwcg w` `r fr`n wlc h`srw
osdbgdea ,sxdea i xdgc `r oihk cewriehc$" `r wlc qdwecxx nit rcysdrc iggdwd`eib xchsrdwt
o`wl `swxdgc ieg dexdgc wlc h`srw osdbgdea" ieg }`xxdobt de wlc h`srw dwxcbf%
Irrieacncewx xshl ix x}chdib wriex}`rw" }`bdhc }r`wchwd`e" ieg qdwecxx }r`wchwd`e
xhlcncx" qdbb e`w echcxxirdbt h`nc w` wlc e`wdhc `f wlc jsgac% Ecvcrwlcbcxx jsgacx
xl`sbg ixhcrwide qliw }r`hcgsrcx irc ividbiobc de wlcdr h`srw osdbgdea f`r wlc
}r`wchwd`e `f dewdndgiwcg qdwecxxcx `r jsr`rx% Fsrwlcr" ix `swbdecg ocb`q" i jsgac
xl`sbg oc ibcrw w` dewdndgiwdea `r wlrciwcedea }rcxcehcx de h`srw%
Gdxhb`xsrc f i qdwecxx—x }crx`eib gcwidbx
9=%99 Qdwecxxcx" ieg }irwdhsbirbt qdwecxxcx ql` fcir rc}rdxibx ifwcr advdea cvdgcehc"
irc bdkcbt w` oc vcrt h`ehcrecg io`sw livdea w` xwiwc de `}ce h`srw }crx`eib gcwidbx
xshl ix wlcdr l`nc iggrcxx" }bihc `f q`rk" r xhl``b% Dgcibbt" xshl fcirx xl`sbg livc
occe cbdhdwcg" e`wcg" ieg ihwcg s}`e gsrdea }rc}iriwd`e f`r wlc wrdib" ieg wlc yscxwd`ecr
xl`sbg" ix i rcxsbw" ixk i}}r`}rdiwcbt n`gdfdcg yscxwd`ex% F`r c|in}bc" de hrdndeib
wrdibx" i }r`xchsw`r nit ixk i qdwecxx df wlc qdwecxx—x iggrcxx f`r wlc }sr}`xcx `f wlc
wrdib dx ‒hirc `f [wlc b`hib }`bdhc^„; `r wlc qdwecxx ndalw oc ixkcg w` qrdwc ie iggrcxx
`e i }dchc `f }i}cr" qldhl dx wlce liegcg s} w` wlc jsgac% Ecvcrwlcbcxx wlcrc nit oc
hixcx qlcrc }rc.wrdib }rc}iriwd`e lix fidbcg w` dgcewdft i qdwecxx—x fcirx% Jsgacx
xl`sbg wlcrcf`rc oc ibcrw f`r xdaex `f gdxwrcxx `r gdxh`nf`rw `e wlc }irw `f i qdwecxx
qlce ocdea ixkcg io`sw }crx`eib gcwidbx% Df echcxxirt" wlc jsgac xl`sbg dewcrvcec% De
niet hixcx" wlc cixdcxw x`bswd`e dx w` livc wlc def`rniwd`e oc qrdwwce `e i }dchc `f
}i}cr qldhl dx liegcg w` wlc jsgac%
_cn`vib `f hcrwide }crx`ex fr`n h`srw
9=%9? I jsgac lix hcrwide }`qcrx w` hbcir wlc h`srw%9
Qlcrc i hldbg dx hibbcg ix i
qdwecxx de iet }r`hccgdeax rcbiwdea w` h`egshw rcbiwdea w` gchceht `r n`ribdwt" wlc
h`srw nit gdrchw wliw iet`ec `wlcr wlie ncnocrx `r `ffdhcrx `f h`srw" }irwdcx ieg wlcdr
h`sexcb `r x`bdhdw`rx" }crx`ex `wlcrqdxc gdrchwbt h`ehcrecg de wlc hixc ieg o`ei fdgc
j`sreibdxwx oc c|hbsgcg fr`n wlc h`srw gsrdea wlc hldbg—x cvdgcehc% Acecribbt" df dw
och`ncx hbcir wliw }crx`ex de h`srw i}}cir w` oc ihwdea de i wlrciwcedea" dewdndgiwdea
`r gdxwrihwdea nieecr qdwl i vdcq w` defbscehdea qdwecxxcx `r jsr`rx" i jsgac nit
h`exdgcr dw i}}r`}rdiwc w` dexwrshw h`srw xwiff w` livc wl xc }crx`ex rcn`vcg% Niwwcrx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 169/206
nit oc n`rc gdffdhsbw qlcrc wlc ncrc }rcxcehc `f i }crx`e `r }crx`ex" qdwl`sw iet
`vcrw oclivd`sr" i}}cirx w` oc iffchwdea i qdwecxx% Wlc `vcr.rdgdea }rdehd}bc dx wliw i
jsgac dx rcx}`exdobc f`r cexsrdea wliw i hixc }r`hccgx qdwl`sw wlrciwcedea `r
dewdndgiwdea oclivd`sr `e wlc }irw f iet`ec de h srw% I jsgac xl`sbg wlcrcf`rc oc
rcigt w` wikc i}}r`}rdiwc xwc}x qlcrc echcxxirt%
9 Xcc" f`r c|in}bc" Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$" }iri% <%7= cw xcy% ieg LN Igv`hiwc v N`bi ?==1
XHH_ 9?7%
_cn`vib `f ie ihhsxcg ql` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf
9=%98 Df ie ihhsxcg }crx`e x` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf `r lcrxcbf gsrdea wlc h`srxc `f wlc
wrdib wliw wlc h`srw f`rnx wlc vdcq wliw i }r`}cr wrdib hiee`w wikc }bihc sebcxx wlc
ihhsxcg dx rcn`vcg" wlc h`srw nit `rgcr wliw lc `r xlc dx rcn`vcg fr`n wlc h`srw f`r
x` b`ea ix wliw h`egshw nikcx dw echcxxirt" ieg wliw wlc wrdib }r`hccg de wlc ihhsxcg—x
ioxcehc% Df wlc ihhsxcg dx e`w bcaibbt rc}rcxcewcg" wlc h`srw nsxw i}}`dew h`sexcb `r i
x`bdhdw`r w` rc}rcxcew ldx `r lcr dewcrcxwx gsrdea xshl ie ioxcehc%9
9 X`bcne }r`hccgdeax: x% 4?,?$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443; xsnnirt
}r`hccgdeax: x% 938,?$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
]rcvirdhiwdea qdwecxx" `r dewdndgiwcg" `r o`wl: rieac `f i}}r`ihlcx
9=%97 Wlcrc nit" fr`n wdnc w` wdnc" oc hdrhsnxwiehcx qlcrc i jsgac h`exdgcrx dw
echcxxirt w` ig`}w i fidrbt xwcre i}}r`ihl qdwl i rcbshwiew qdwecxx%9
Dw nit oc
echcxxirt w` wikc hcrwide xwc}x" xshl ix rcfsxdea w` rcbcixc wlc qdwecxx fr`n ldx `r lcr
hdwiwd`e% Dw dx wl`salw w` oc ocxw }rihwdhc w` gcbdvcrt iet qiredea io`sw wlc }`xxdobc
h`excyscehcx `f }crjsrt `r }rcvirdhiwd`e `swqdwl wlc }rcxcehc `f i jsrt%?
Xshl i
}rchiswd`e iv`dgx advdea wlc jsrt qliw nit i}}cir w` oc ie dexdalw dew` wlc jsgac—x
ixxcxxncew `f wlc qdwecxx—x hrcgdodbdwt ieg" `r" rcbdiodbdwt% Dw ibx` iv`dgx wlc
}`xxdodbdwt wliw wlc jsrt ndalw oc dei}}r`}rdiwcbt defbscehcg xdn}bt ix i h`excyscehc
`f wlc jsgac!x nieecr w`qirgx wlc qdwecxx% De `wlcr xdwsiwd`ex" l`qcvcr" qlcrc i
qdwecxx i}}cirx e`w w` oc xdn}bt }rcvirdhiwdea" osw i}}cirx w` livc occe dewdndgiwcg
`r w` livc occe xcrd`sxbt iffchwcg ot i hrdnc" dw nit oc i}}r`}rdiwc w` wrt w` fdeg qitx
de qldhl wlc qdwecxx nit oc xcw n`rc iw cixc%8
Wlc c|wcew w` qldhl i jsgac nit
}crx`eibbt dewcrvcec ieg `ffcr rcixxsriehc dx i gdffdhsbw irci%7
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 170/206
9Xcc Xlcrdff H`srw Hrdndeib Ocehl O``k" Hli}wcr < ,H`ewcn}w `f h`srw$% Xcc ibx`
NhEcdbiac" ]cwdwd`ecr " 9444 X%H%H%_% 719 ,qdwecxx hlieadea cvdgcehc ix dw xsdwcg ldn"
iv`dgdea iexqcrdea yscxwd`ex" ieg nikdea ariwsdw`sxbt igvcrxc h`nncewx io`sw wlc
h`n}bidecr: lcbg wliw wlc acecrib dgci h`evctcg ot wlc wcrn ‒}rcvirdhiwd`e„ qix `f i niedfcxw
seqdbbdeaecxx hiegdgbt w` wcbb wlc ql`bc wrswl" fcehdea qdwl yscxwd`ex de xshl i nieecr ix w`
xl`q rcbshwiehc w` gdxhb xc wlc wrswl" ieg i gdx}`xdwd`e w` h`ehcib `r qdwll`bg wlc wrswl; ieg
xcewcehc `f wlrcc n`ewlx dn}rdx`encew f`r h`ewcn}w `f h`srw h`efdrncg$%
? Xcc Lswhldx`e v% LN Igv`hiwc" 9447 X%B%W ?88%
8 Ysicrc qlcwlcr xshl ie i}}r`ihl ndalw livc occe n`rc i}}r`}rdiwc de wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx
`swbdecg de B`aie v% NhAbceeie" 9444 X%H%H%_% 3<3 ,fcnibc qdwecxx dewdndgiwcg ot wlc
ihhsxcg `e lcr qit w` h`srw" advdea wq` deh`exdxwcew xw`rdcx de wlc qdwecxx o`|" ieg wlce
fidewdea de wlc qdwecxx o`|$%
7 Xcc wq` rc}`rwcg hixcx dev`bvdea hldbgrce: Obihk v% _s|w`e" 944< X%H%H%_% 77=; NhKdc v%
L%N% Igv`hiwc" 9441 X%B%W% 9=9<; 9441 X%H%H%_% 8=: f`r fsrwlcr gcwidbx rcbiwdea w` wlcxc hixcx"
xcc Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$ }iri% <%84%
HHWV" XH_CCEX" CVDGCEHC @E H@NNDXXD@E" IEG ]_D@_ XWIWCNCEWX
H`nn`e biq }`qcrx: xhrccex
9=%93 ‒De iggdwd`e w` wlc xwiwsw`rt }`qcrx ncewd`ecg io`vc" wlc h`srw lix }`qcr iw
h`nn`e biq w` }r`wchw iet vsbecriobc qdwecxx ql` q`sbg oc }bihcg iw ie sefidr
gdxigviewiac ot livdea w` advc cvdgcehc de wlc e`rnib qit%9
De }irwdhsbir" wlc h`srw
lix }`qcr w` }crndw xshl i qdwecxx w` advc cvdgcehc fr`n ocldeg i xhrcce%?
Sebdkc
wlc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex ,xcc }iriari}lx 9=%96 cw xcy% ocb`q$" wlcrc dx iw h`nn`e biq
e` rcxwrdhwdvc gcfdedwd`e `f ‒vsbecriobc qdwecxx„% Ix B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib Hsbbce
`oxcrvcg de Lin}x`e v% L%N% Igv`hiwc8 ‒[D^w dx qcbb rch`aedxcg wliw wlcrc irc
qdwecxxcx ql` q`sbg oc }bihcg iw ie sefidr gdxigviewiac ot wlc e`rnib }r`hcgsrc"
ieg `e wliw ihh`sew irc rcairgcg ix vsbecriobc ieg de eccg `f x}chdib ncixsrcx w`
}r`wchw wlcn% Xshl qdwecxxcx nit e`rnibbt oc f`seg qdwlde `ec `r n`rc `f wlc
f`bb`qdea ar`s}x `f }crx`e" eincbt" fdrxw" hldbgrce; xch`egbt" }crx`ex ql`xc iodbdwt w`
lcir" xcc `r h`nnsedhiwc dx dn}idrcg" `r ql` livc i }r`obcn qdwl wlcdr lcibwl"
qlcwlcr }ltxdhib `r ncewib; ieg wldrgbt" }crx`ex ql` irc vsbecriobc w` iwwihk" `r fcir
`f iwwihl" `r dewdndgiwd`e irdxdea `sw `f wlcdr advdea cvdgcehc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 171/206
Qc livc xidg ‒qdwlde„ xshl i ar`s} `r ar`s}x" xdehc qlcwlcr ie degdvdgsib qdwecxx
xl`sbg oc advce xshl }r`wchwd`e gc}cegx `e" dewcr ibdi" wlc gcarcc `f ldx `r lcr
vsbecriodbdwt…Wlcrc nit oc hdrhsnxwiehcx de qldhl" l`qcvcr c|hc}wd`eibbt" i
qdwecxx nit oc cewdwbcg w` advc cvdgcehc ie`etn`sxbt ieg ocldeg xhrccex f`r rcix`ex
rcbiwcg w` ldx xifcwt„%7
9% Lin}x`e v LN Igv`hiwc" ?==8 X%H%H%_ 98%
? Lin}x`e" io`vc" iw }iri% [<^% De wliw hixc i vsbecriobc ieg ie|d`sx q`nie iacg ?4" wcrrdfdcg
`f ocdea c|}`xcg w` wlc aizc ieg vdcq `f wlc wlrcc nce ihhsxcg `f rivdxldea lcr" qix
}crndwwcg w` advc lcr cvdgcehc fr`n ocldeg i xhrcce%
8 Lin}x`e" io`vc" iw }iri% [1^%
7 Xndwl v L%N% Igv`hiwc" ?=== X%H%H%_% 49= ,de qldhl segcrh`vcr }`bdhc `ffdhcrx qcrc
}crndwwcg w` advc wlcdr cvdgcehc qdwl`sw rcvcibdea wlcdr wrsc dgcewdwdcx ieg qldbc h`ehcibcg
fr`n wlc }sobdh ieg wlc }rcxx ot xhrccex$%
I wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,HHWV$ `r xhrccex de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19,3$ ieg
,6$
9=%96 Xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex }crndw wlc sxc `f HHWV `r xhrccex qlce wikdea wlc
cvdgcehc `f i ‒vsbecriobc qdwecxx„" ix gcfdecg ot xchwd`e ?19 `f wlc Hrdndeib
]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 ,ix xsoxwdwswcg ot xchwd`e 9 `f wlc Vsbecriobc
Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7$%9
Xchwd`e ?19H }r`vdgcx wliw ie i}}bdhiwd`e nit oc
nigc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax w` wlc Ldal H`srw `f Jsxwdhdirt" `r wlc xlcrdff h`srw" w`
iswl`rdxc dewcr ibdi wlc sxc `f HHWV `r xhrccex f`r xshl i qdwecxx% Wlc h`srw nit
ariew xshl ie i}}bdhiwd`e `e hisxc xl`qe" livdea rcairg de }irwdhsbir w` ,i$ wlc
}`xxdobc cffchw `e wlc qdwecxx df rcysdrcg w` advc cvdgcehc de wlc e`rnib qit; ,o$
qlcwlcr dw dx bdkcbt wliw wlc qdwecxx q`sbg oc ocwwcr iobc w` advc cvdgcehc df xshl ie
i}}bdhiwd`e qcrc ariewcg; ieg ,h$ wlc acecrib hdrhsnxwiehcx `f wlc hixc%
?
Xchwd`e ?19}crndwx wlc h`srw w` wikc dew` ihh`sew wlc eiwsrc ieg hdrhsnxwiehcx `f wlc ibbcacg
`ffcehc w` qldhl wlc }r`hccgdeax rcbiwc" wlc eiwsrc `f wlc cvdgcehc qldhl wlc }crx`e dx
bdkcbt w` advc" wlc rcbiwd`exld} ,df iet$ ocwqcce wlc }crx`e ieg wlc ihhsxcg" ieg wlc
}crx`e!x iac ieg niwsrdwt% Wliw bdxw dx e`w" l`qcvcr" c|lisxwdvc" ieg wlc h`srw nit
livc rcairg w` iet fihw`r qldhl i}}cirx rcbcview de i }irwdhsbir hixc% Qlcrc i bdvc
wcbcvdxd`e bdek dx w` oc sxcg de }r`hccgdeax de i xlcrdff h`srw" osw wliw h`srw bihkx
ihh`nn`giwd`e `r cysd}ncew echcxxirt f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f rchcdvdea xshl i bdek" wlc
xlcrdff nit ot `rgcr wriexfcr wlc }r`hccgdeax w` iet `wlcr xlcrdff h`srw de wlc xinc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 172/206
xlcrdffg`n qldhl lix xshl ihh`nn`giwd`e `r cysd}ncew ividbiobc: xchwd`e ?19J%
Fsrwlcr gcwidbx io`sw HHWV ieg xhrccex i}}bdhiwd`ex" dehbsgdea ncwl`gx `f
dgcewdftdea wlc ihhsxcg" ieg jsgdhdib h`ewr`b `f wlc HHWV cysd}ncew" irc h`ewidecg de
Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$" }iriari}l <%< cw xcy%
9 ‒vsbecriobc }crx`e„ nciex ‘
,i$ iet hldbg;
,o$ iet }crx`e `f `r `vcr wlc iac `f 96 tcirx ‘
,d$ ql` dx xsojchw w` ie `rgcr nigc de h`excyscehc `f i fdegdea `f i h`srw
de iet }irw `f wlc Sedwcg Kdeag`n wliw lc dx xsffcrdea fr`n ncewib gdx`rgcr
qdwlde wlc nciedea `f xchwd`e 9,?$ `f wlc Ncewib Lcibwl ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw
94<7" xchwd`e 9,?$ `f wlc Ncewib Lcibwl Ihw 94<8" `r Irwdhbc 8,9$ `f wlc
Ncewib Lcibwl ,E`rwlcre Drcbieg$ @rgcr 94<6 ,i}}bdhiwd`e `f ceihwncew$; `r
,dd$ ql` dx xsojchw w` i wriexfcr gdrchwd`e segcr xchwd`e 19,9$ `f wlc 94<7
Ihw" xchwd`e 71 `f wlc 94<8 Ihw" `r Irwdhbc 38 `f wlc 94<6 `rgcr ,wriexfcr
gdrchwd`ex$; `r
,ddd$ ql` `wlcrqdxc i}}cirx w` wlc h`srw w` xsffcr fr`n xdaedfdhiew
dn}idrncew `f dewcbbdacehc ieg x`hdib fsehwd`edea%„
? 9443 Ihw" x% ?19,?$,i$ ‘ ,f$%
Cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`e ?19D9=%91 Xchwd`e ?19D `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 }r`vdgcx wliw de
ie i}}bdhiwd`e nit oc nigc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax w` wlc Ldal H`srw `f Jsxwdhdirt
`r wlc xlcrdff h`srw w` livc i vsbecriobc }crx`e—x cvdgcehc wikce `e h`nndxxd`e"
riwlcr wlie de h`srw% Wlc h`nndxxd`ecr nsxw oc i Ldal H`srw jsgac de Ldal H`srw
}r`hccgdeax `r i xlcrdff de iet `wlcr }r`hccgdeax%9
Wlc }rcrcysdxdwcx ieg
h`exdgcriwd`ex f`r cvdgcehc w` oc wikce `e h`nndxxd`e irc wlc xinc ix f`r i HHWV
bdek `r xhrccex i}}bdhiwd`e%?
]r`hccgdeax ocf`rc i h`nndxxd`ecr i}}`dewcg xlibb" df
wlc h`srw x` gdrchwcg qlce iswl`rdxdea xshl }r`hccgdeax" wikc }bihc ot nciex `f i
bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek ocwqcce wlc }bihc qlcrc wlc h`nndxxd`ecr dx wikdea" ieg wlc
}bihc fr`n qldhl wlc qdwecxx dx advdea" cvdgcehc% ]r`hccgdeax ocf`rc i
h`nndxxd`ecr nsxw oc rch`rgcg ot vdgc` rch`rgcr% Ie ihhsxcg nsxw e`w" c|hc}w ot
bcivc `f wlc h`srw `e x}chdib hisxc xl`qe" oc }rcxcew de wlc r``n qlcrc xshl
}r`hccgdeax irc wikdea }bihc; `r df xshl }r`hccgdeax irc wikdea }bihc ot nciex `f i
bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek" de wlc xinc r``n ix wlc qdwecxx" osw dx cewdwbcg ot xshl nciex ix
xccn xsdwiobc w` wlc h`srw w` qiwhl ieg lcir wlc }r`hccgdeax% Wlc rch`rgdea `f wlc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 173/206
}r`hccgdeax dx rchcdvcg de cvdgcehc qdwl`sw ocdea xq`re w` ot qdwecxxcx% Wlc
h`nndxxd`e nit oc lcbg iw wlc qdwecxx—x l`nc `r x`nc `wlcr xsdwiobc vcesc% Wlc
qdwecxx dx xq`re" c|indecg" hr`xx.c|indecg" ieg rc.c|indecg" ix echcxxirt% Wlc
ncwl`gx `f dgcewdftdea wlc ihhsxcg qlce cvdgcehc dx wikce `e h`nndxxd`e irc
xsnnirdxcg de Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$" }iriari}lx <%?8 ieg <%?7%
9Xcc xchwd`e ?19D,<$ dexcrwcg ot wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hccgdeax cwh ,_cf`rn$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==1%
? Xcc xchwd`e ?19H ieg ?19L `f wlc 9443 Ihw ieg }iriari}l 9=%96" io`vc%
Sxc `f i }rd`r xwiwcncew de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax: xchwd`ex ?34" ?6= ieg ?19N
9=%9< Xchwd`e ?19N i}}bdcx qlcrc wlc x}chdib ncixsrc w` oc sxcg de rcx}chw `f i
vsbecriobc qdwecxx dx advdea cvdgcehc de hldcf de wlc f`rn `f i }rd`r xwiwcncew% ]rd`r
xwiwcncewx hie oc sxcg ix wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc de hldcf de ql`bc `r }irw% Xchwd`e
?19N }r`vdgcx wliw i xwiwcncew ot i vsbecriobc qdwecxx b`gacg de cvdgcehc dx
igndxxdobc ix" `r ix }irw `f" wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc de hldcf" qdwl`sw wlc qdwecxx ocdea
rcyscxwcg w` ig`}w `r `wlcrqdxc x}cik w` dw% Xchwd`e ?6=" qldhl h`ehcrex wlc
igndxxdodbdwt `f }rd`r xwiwcncewx" i}}bdcx w` xshl i xwiwcncew%9
De wcrnx `f xchwd`e ?34
`f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" ‒cvdgcehc `f i xwiwcncew nigc ot i
}crx`e `wlcrqdxc wlie qldbc advdea `rib cvdgcehc de h`srw de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax
xlibb oc igndxxdobc de wl`xc }r`hccgdeax ix cvdgcehc `f iet niwwcr h`ewidecg de wlc
xwiwcncew qlcrc wlc jsgac dx xiwdxfdcg [dewcr ibdi^ wliw wlc }crx`e ql` nigc wlc
xwiwcncew dx…ot rcix`e `f ldx o`gdbt `r ncewib h`egdwd`e" sefdw `r seiobc w` advc
cvdgcehc de iet h`n}cwcew nieecr„% Xshl i xwiwcncew dx ibx` igndxxdobc qlcrc wlc
}crx`e ql` aivc wlc xwiwcncew ‒dx hibbcg ix i qdwecxx ieg cdwlcr ‘ ,d$ rcfsxcx w` wikc
wlc `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e" `r ,dd$ livdea occe xq`re ix i qdwecxx ieg gdrchwcg ot wlc
jsgac w` advc cvdgcehc de h`eechwd`e qdwl wlc xsojchw niwwcr `f wlc xwiwcncew" rcfsxcx
w` g` x`„% Wldx dee`viwdvc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`e xl`sbg oc x}irdeabt sxcg" ocirdea de
ndeg wlc bihk `f `}}`rwsedwt w` hr`xx.c|indec `r `wlcrqdxc wcxw wlc cvdgcehc%?
9Xcc }iri%9=%94 ocb`q%
?Xcc `oxcrviwd`ex de NihG`eibg v% L%N% Igv`hiwc" 9444 X%H%H%_% 976" qlcrc wlc ihhsxcg
qix hliracg qdwl xlincbcxx degchceht" ieg wlrcc <.tcir.`bg qdwecxxcx ochinc gdxwrcxxcg ieg
rcfsxcg w` iexqcr yscxwd`ex% Wlc I}}cib H`srw h`nncewcg `e wlc dee`viwdvc eiwsrc `f
xchwd`e ?34" ieg cn}lixdxcg wliw" }rd`r w` rcx`rwdea w` i xwiwcncew ib`ec de wcrnx `f xchwd`e
?34" wlc qdwecxx nsxw fdrxwbt oc gdrchwcg w` iexqcr wlc yscxwd`ex" ieg xch`egbt" ixkcg qlcwlcr
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 174/206
lc `r xlc lig nigc i }rcvd`sx xwiwcncew% Wlce wlc wcrnx `f wlc xwiwcncew xl sbg oc }sw w` wlc
qdwecxx% ]r`fcxx`r A`rg`e de ldx h`nncewirt `oxcrvcx" iw }% 939" wliw xchwd`e ?34 ridxcx
h`ehcrex io`sw wlc sewcxwcg eiwsrc `f wlc xwiwcncew ieg ibx` wlc fihw wliw i xdeabc qdwecxx
ndalw oc rcairgcg ix xsffdhdcew w` }r`vc wlc xwiwcncew%
9=%94 Segcr xchwd`e ?6= `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" i }rd`r
xwiwcncew" qldhl q`sbg e`w `wlcrqdxc oc igndxxdobc ix cvdgcehc" nigc ot i qdwecxx dx
igndxxdobc ix cvdgcehc `f iet niwwcr xwiwcg de dw `f qldhl gdrchw `rib cvdgcehc ot ldn
q`sbg oc igndxxdobc df advce de wlc h`srxc `f wl`xc }r`hccgdeax% Wlc xwiwcncew dx e`w
igndxxdobc sebcxx.
,i$ wlc xwiwcncew dx h`ewidecg de i g`hsncew;
,o$ wlc qdwecxx" de wlc h`srxc `f ldx cvdgcehc" degdhiwcx wliw wlc xwiwcncewqix nigc ot ldn ieg wliw lc ig`}wx dw ix ldx cvdgcehc; ieg
,h$ iw wlc wdnc wlc xwiwcncew qix nigc" wlc }crx`e ql` nigc dw q`sbg
livc occe i h`n}cwcew qdwecxx de wlc }r`hccgdeax%
Wlc rcxwrdhwd`ex `e igndxxdodbdwt e`wcg io`vc g` e`w i}}bt w` i }rch`aedwd`e `e `iwl `r
i xwiwcncew nigc de `wlcr hdvdb `r hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax de wlc SK `r cbxcqlcrc9% Wlc
igndxxdodbdwt `f }rd`r xwiwcncewx segcr xchwd`e ?6= `f wlc 9443 Ihw g`cx e`w i}}bt w` i
}rd`r xwiwcncew ot ie ihhsxcg }crx`e?%
99443 Ihw xchwd`e ?6=,7$%
?9443 Ihw xchwd`e ?69,9$%
X]CHDIB NCIXS_CX DE HDVDB ]_@HCCGDEAX
9=%?= Hdvdb }r`hccgdeax9 irc a`vcrecg ot xchwd`ex 99 w` ?8 ,]irw ?$ `f wlc Vsbecriobc
Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7% Ie igsbw ysibdfdcx ix i ‒vsbecriobc qdwecxx„ df:
‒…%wlcrc dx i xdaedfdhiew rdxk wliw wlc ysibdwt `f wlc cvdgcehc w` oc advce ot wlc
}crx`e qdbb oc gdndedxlcg ot rcix`e `f .
,d$ ncewib gdx`rgcr ,qdwlde wlc nciedea `f xchwd`e 8?< `f wlc Ncewib
Lcibwl ,Hirc ieg Wrciwncew$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==8 ,ix}98$" `r
,dd$ fcir `r gdxwrcxx de h`eechwd`e qdwl advdea cvdgcehc de wlc
}r`hccgdeax%„?
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 175/206
Wlc }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc wlc qdwecxx xl`sbg nikc i vsbecriobc qdwecxx
i}}bdhiwd`e8% Wlc h`srw" qlce h`exdgcrdea qlcwlcr `r e`w i }crx`e dx i vsbecriobc
qdwecxx" nsxw wikc dew` ihh`sew:
‒,i$ wlc eiwsrc ieg hdrhsnxwiehcx `f wlc ibbcacg niwwcr w` qldhl wlc
}r`hccgdeax rcbiwc"
,o$ wlc eiwsrc `f wlc cvdgcehc qldhl wlc }crx`e dx bdkcbt w` advc"
,h$ wlc rcbiwd`exld} ,df iet$ ocwqcce wlc }crx`e ieg iet }irwt w` wlc
}r`hccgdeax"
,g$ wlc }crx`e—x iac ieg niwsrdwt"
,c$ iet oclivd`sr w`qirgx wlc }crx`e `e wlc }irw `f .
,d$ iet }irwt w` wlc }r`hccgdeax"
,dd$ ncnocrx `f wlc findbt `r ixx`hdiwcx `f iet xshl }irwt"
,ddd$ iet `wlcr }crx`e ql` dx bdkcbt w` oc i }irwt w` wlc }r`hccgdeax `r i
qdwecxx de wlc }r`hccgdeax" ieg
,f$ xshl `wlcr niwwcrx" dehbsgdea ‘
,d$ wlc x`hdib ieg hsbwsrib oihkar`seg ieg cwledh `rdadex `f wlc }crx`e"
,dd$ wlc }crx`e—x xc|sib `rdcewiwd`e"
,ddd$ wlc g`ncxwdh ieg cn}b`tncew hdrhsnxwiehcx `f wlc }crx`e"
,dv$ iet rcbdad`sx ocbdcfx `r }`bdwdhib `}ded`ex `f wlc }crx`e" ieg
,v$ iet }ltxdhib gdxiodbdwt `r `wlcr }ltxdhib dn}idrncew qldhl wlc }crx`e
lix" ix i}}cirx w` wlc h`srw w` oc rcbcview%„7
Qlce ixxcxxdea qliw x}chdib ncixsrc,x$ ndalw oc i}}r`}rdiwc" wlc h`srw nsxw livc
rcairg w` ,d$ wlc ocxw dewcrcxwx `f wlc qdwecxx ,wikdea dew` ihh`sew iet vdcqx c|}rcxxcg
ot wlc qdwecxx3$; ,dd$ wlc }`xxdobc cffchw `e wlc qdwecxx df rcysdrcg w` advc cvdgcehc
qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc: ieg ,ddd$ qlcwlcr dw dx bdkcbt wliw wlc
qdwecxx q`sbg oc ocwwcr iobc w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl wlc ocecfdw `f i x}chdib ncixsrc6%
Wlc }r`vdxd`ex ibx` i}}bt w` ie igsbw ql` dx i }irwt w` wlc hdvdb bdwdaiwd`e1%
9 ‒Hdvdb }r`hccgdeax„ dehbsgc hdvdb }r`hccgdeax de wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e ieg wlc xlcrdff h`srw"
fiwib ihhdgcew deysdrdcx" ieg i}}bdhiwd`ex w` wlc xlcrdff h`srw segcr ]irw DD `f wlc Hldbgrce
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443%
?Xchwd`e 99,9$ `f wlc ?==7 Ihw%
8Xchwd`e 9?,6$ De wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e" rsbcx xcwwdea `sw i}}r`}rdiwc f`rnx ieg }r`hcgsrcx
hinc dew` cffchw `e 9 E`vcnocr ?==1 ,Hl%83I" XXD ?==163=$% F`r c|in}bc" qlce
h`exdgcrdea i vsbecriobc qdwecxx i}}bdhiwd`e" wlc h`srw nit nikc ie `rgcr qdwl`sw l`bgdea i
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 176/206
lcirdea; `r nit rcysdrc fsrwlcr def`rniwd`e fr`n iet `f wlc }irwdcx; `r nit fd| i giwc f`r i
lcirdea `f wlc i}}bdhiwd`e; rsbc 83I%3,9$%
7 Xchwd`e 99,?$%
3 Xchwd`e 93,?$%
6
Xchwd`e 9?,1$%1 Xchwd`e 96%
9=%?9 Df xiwdxfdcg wliw wlc igsbw qdwecxx dx vsbecriobc ieg wliw dw q`sbg oc i}}r`}rdiwc
w` ariew i x}chdib ncixsrc" wlc h`srw nit" de wcrnx `f xchwd`e 9?,6$" nikc ie `rgcr
iswl`rdxdea i x}chdib ncixsrc" xshl ix cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e" HHWV" xhrccex" `r i
xs}}`rwcr9% Wlc irrieacncewx nit oc rcvdcqcg iw iet xwiac de wlc }r`hccgdeax
?% Ie
`rgcr iswl`rdxdea i x}chdib ncixsrc nit oc rcv`kcg `ebt df wlc h`srw dx xiwdxfdcg wliw:
‒,i$ wlc qdwecxx lix c|}rcxxcg i qdxl w` advc `r" ix wlc hixc nit oc" h`ewdesc
w` advc cvdgcehc qdwl`sw wlc ocecfdw `f iet x}chdib ncixsrc ieg wliw dw dx
i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc qdwecxx x` w` advc cvdgcehc" `r
,o$ wliw .
,d$ wlc sxc" `r h`ewdescg sxc" `f wlc x}chdib ncixsrc f`r wlc }sr}`xcx `f
wikdea wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc q`sbg advc rdxc w` i xdaedfdhiew rdxk `f
}rcjsgdhc w` wlc fidrecxx `f wlc }r`hccgdeax `r `wlcrqdxc w` wlc dewcrcxwx
`f jsxwdhc" ieg
,dd$ wliw rdxk xdaedfdhiewbt `swqcdalx iet rdxk `f }rcjsgdhc w` wlc
dewcrcxwx `f wlc qdwecxx df wlc `rgcr dx nigc%„8
9 Xchwd`ex 9?,6$ ieg 9< w` ?? `f wlc ?==7 Ihw%
? Xchwd`e 98
8%Xchwd`e 98,7$
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 177/206
Hli}wcr 99
VDHWDNX @F XC\SIB H_DNC
ACEC_IB
Dewr`gshwd`e
99%9 Vdhwdnx `f xc|sib hrdnc irc `fwce wrisniwdxcg" ieg fdeg dw gdffdhsbw w` advc
cvdgcehc de h`srw% _cxcirhl xsaacxwx wliw wlc h`srw i}}ciriehc nit oc ix gdxwrcxxdea
ieg gdxcn}`qcrdea ix wlc `rdadeib hrdnc%9
X`nc `f wlc ncixsrcx e`wcg ocb`q nit
ixxdxw de gdndedxldea i}}rclcexd`e ieg s}xcw%?
9 X`ncwdncx rcfcrrcg w` ix ‒xch`egirt vdhwdndxiwd`e„: xcc _cgrcxxdea wlc Oibiehc" Xh`wwdxl
C|chswdvc" ?===%
? Xh`wbieg nsxw h`n}bt qdwl wlc CS Frincq`rk Gchdxd`e `e wlc Xwiegdea `f Vdhwdnx de
Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc: f`r gcwidbx" xcc Vdhwdnx de wlc Hrdndeib Jsxwdhc Xtxwcn }sobdxlcg ot wlc
Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc de E`vcnocr ?==?% ,lww}:qqq%xh`wbieg%a`v%skbdorirt3jsxwdhcvhjx.
==%ix}$%
Def`rniwd`e f`r vdhwdnx
99%? Qldbc dw dx dn}`rwiew wliw iet qdwecxx oc advce def`rniwd`e io`sw ldx `r lcr
i}}ciriehc de h`srw" dw dx g`sobt dn}`rwiew wliw i h`n}bidecr de i hixc dev`bvdea
ibbcaiwd`ex `f xc|sib hrdnc oc advce ix nshl def`rniwd`e ix }`xxdobc" ix rcasbirbt ix
}`xxdobc% Def`rniwd`e w` oc h`nnsedhiwcg dehbsgcx qlcwlcr `r e`w ie ihhsxcg dx w` oc
}r`xchswcg" qlce ieg qlcrc i wrdib dx bdkcbt w` wikc }bihc" qlce i h`n}bidecr dx bdkcbt
w` oc hibbcg w` advc cvdgcehc" ieg sbwdniwcbt wlc `swh`nc `f wlc wrdib% Df i wrdib dx
}`xw}`ecg" `r df wlcrc dx w` oc i rc.wrdib" i fsbb c|}bieiwd`e xl`sbg oc advce w` wlc
h`n}bidecr% Df i }bci `f asdbwt dx w` oc wcegcrcg" wlc vdhwdn `f wlc hrdnc nit qdxl w`
oc }rcxcew de h`srw w` lcir wlc }bci gcibw qdwl% Qldbc nshl `f wlc rcx}`exdodbdwt f`r
}r`vdgdea def`rniwd`e bdcx qdwl `wlcrx" jsgacx xl`sbg oc iqirc `f wlc }r`obcnx fihdea
vdhwdnx" ieg ibx` `f wlc wt}c `f iaceht iobc w` ixxdxw%9
Fsrwlcr" jsgacx xl`sbg wrt
qlcrcvcr }`xxdobc w` cexsrc wliw i h`n}bidecr dx nigc iqirc `f qliw dx li}}cedea%
F`r c|in}bc" ocf`rc igndedxwcrdea wlc `iwl" i jsgac ndalw qdxl w` c|}bide w` i
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 178/206
h`n}bidecr wliw wlc h`srw lix occe hbcircg `f cvcrt`ec c|hc}w wl`xc qdwl `ffdhdib
osxdecxx%?
9 Vdhwdn Def`rniwd`e ieg Igvdhc sedw `f wlc Hr`qe @ffdhc ieg ]r`hsriw`r Fdxhib Xcrvdhc
,H@]FX$ }r`vdgc wldx wt}c `f def`rniwd`e w` vdhwdnx `f xc|sib: xcc }iri% 9=%<" io`vc% Vdhwdn
Xs}}`rw Xh`wbieg" _i}c Hrdxdx Ecwq`rk ieg Xh`wwdxl Q`nce—x Idg irc `wlcr `raiedxiwd`ex
qldhl qdbb oc iobc w` ixxdxw%
? Xcc }iri% 99%3" ocb`q%
Findbdirdxiwd`e qdwl h`srw ieg h`srw }r`hcgsrcx
99%8 I h`n}bidecr nit ocecfdw fr`n i }rc.wrdib vdxdw w` h`srw }rcndxcx ocf`rc wlc
hixc ocadex% Xshl vdxdwx irc e rnibbt irrieacg ot wlc }r`xchswd`e" osw i qcbh`nc
gcvcb`}ncew de wldx h`ewc|w dx wlc Qdwecxx Xcrvdhc" qldhl `ffcrx vdxdwx" acecrib
asdgiehc ieg ixxdxwiehc%9
9 Xcc }iri% 9=%1" io`vc%
_C]_CXCEWIWD@E F@_ IE IHHSXCG ]C_X@E
H`n}sbx`rt rc}rcxcewiwd`e f`r ie ihhsxcg hliracg qdwl hcrwide xc|sib `ffcehcx
99%7 Wlc Xc|sib @ffcehcx ,]r`hcgsrc ieg Cvdgcehc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==? dexcrwx
xchwd`e ?<<H,9$ de wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" }r`ldodwdea ie
ihhsxcg }crx`e hliracg qdwl hcrwide xc|sib `ffcehcx9
fr`n h`egshwdea ldx `r lcr
gcfcehc de }crx`e iw wlc wrdib% Qlcrc ie ihhsxcg g`cx e`w livc i x`bdhdw`r" xchwd`e
?<<G?
`f wlc 9443 Ihw }r`vdgcx nihldecrt f`r wlc h`srw w` i}}`dew i x`bdhdw`r" ql`
nsxw ihw de wlc ocxw dewcrcxwx `f wlc ihhsxcg% Wlc x`bdhdw`r lix }`qcr w` dexwrshw
h`sexcb% Xchwd`e 7 `f wlc ?==? Ihw incegx xchwd`e ?49 `f wlc 9443 Ihw w` }rcvcew i
}crx`e ihhsxcg `f i xc|sib `ffcehc fr`n }rch`ae`xhdea wlc h`n}bidecr `e `iwl% Wlc
?==? Ihw rcfbchwx i rcibdxiwd`e wliw ie ihhsxcg }crx`e qdwl`sw bcaib rc}rcxcewiwd`e
nit iosxc wlc rdalw w` hr`xx.c|indec wlc vdhwdn%8
9Xcc xx% ?<<H,?$ ieg ,7$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw" dexcrwcg ot x% 9 `f wlc Xc|sib @ffcehcx ,]r`hcgsrc
ieg Cvdgcehc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==?%
?Dexcrwcg ot x% ? `f wlc ?==? Ihw%
8 Xcc _cgrcxxdea wlc Oibiehc" Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc" ?===%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 179/206
I__IEACNCEWX DE H@S_W
Hbcirdea wlc h`srw
99%3 De wcrnx `f xchwd`e 4?,8$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443"
‒[f^r`n wlc h`nncehcncew `f wlc bcigdea `f cvdgcehc de i wrdib f`r ri}c `r wlc bdkc wlc
jsgac nit" df lc wldekx fdw" hisxc ibb }crx`ex `wlcr wlie wlc ihhsxcg ieg h`sexcb ieg
x`bdhdw`rx w` oc rcn`vcg fr`n wlc h`srw.r``n„%9 Dw dx xwiegirg }rihwdhc w` hbcir i h`srw
qlcrc i h`n}bidecr dx io`sw w` advc cvdgcehc io`sw ri}c" ixxisbw qdwl dewcew w` ri}c"
ixxisbw qdwl dewcew w` rivdxl" degchcew ixxisbw" }sobdh degchceht" dehcxw" x`g`nt" ieg
`wlcr xc|sib `ffcehcx ,dehbsgdea iwwcn}wx iw wlcxc `ffcehcx$% Qlce wlc h`n}bidecr
h`ncx dew` h`srw" i jsgac xl`sbg" ocf`rc igndedxwcrdea wlc `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e" igvdxcwlc h`n}bidecr wliw wlc h`srw lix occe hbcircg `f cvcrto`gt c|hc}w wl`xc qdwl `ffdhdib
osxdecxx% Ix rcx}`exdobc ncnocrx `f wlc }rcxx irc e`w e`rnibbt c|hbsgcg" dw nit oc
i}}r`}rdiwc ibx` w` igvdxc wlc h`n}bidecr wliw wlc }rcxx" df rc}`rwdea wlc hixc" irc
seiobc w` rc}`rw wlc h`n}bidecr—x einc" `r w` dgcewdft ldn `r lcr de iet qit%
9 E`wc wliw qlcrc i hldbg dx hibbcg ix i qdwecxx de iet }r`hccgdeax de rcbiwd`e w` ie `ffcehc
iaidexw" `r iet h`egshw h`ewrirt w`" gchceht `r n`ribdwt" wlc h`srw lix wlc iggdwd`eib }`qcr de
wcrnx `f x% 3=,8$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 w` gdrchw wliw ibb }crx`ex
`wlcr wlie ncnocrx `r `ffdhcrx `f wlc h`srw" }irwdcx w` wlc hixc" wlcdr h`sexcb `r x`bdhdw`rx `r
}crx`ex `wlcrqdxc gdrchwbt h`ehcrecg de wlc hixc" ieg o`ei fdgc rc}rcxcewiwdvcx `f wlc }rcxx"
xl`sbg oc c|hbsgcg fr`n h`srw gsrdea wlc wikdea `f wlc cvdgcehc fr`n wlc hldbg: xcc Hli}wcr <
,Hldbgrce$" }iri% <%7= cw xcy%
]rcxcehc `f xs}}`rw fdasrc
99%6 Ocf`rc ariewdea iet rcyscxw wliw i rcbiwdvc `r x`hdib q`rkcr `r `wlcr xs}}`rw
}crx`e oc }crndwwcg w` xdw ecir wlc qdwecxx" dw dx xsaacxwcg wliw:
wlc h`srw ixhcrwidex wlc rcbiwd`exld} ocwqcce wlc qdwecxx ieg wlc xs}}`rw
}crx`e;
wlc vdcqx `f `wlcr }irwdcx xl`sbg oc ixhcrwidecg;
h`efdrniwd`e xl`sbg oc `owidecg wliw wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e dx e`w w` oc i qdwecxx
de wlc hixc;
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 180/206
i xciwdea irrieacncew xl`sbg oc nigc xshl wliw wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e dx
xsffdhdcewbt hb`xc w` wlc qdwecxx" osw g`cx e`w dewcrfcrc ‘ cdwlcr }ltxdhibbt `r
vcroibbt ‘ qdwl wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc;
wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e xl`sbg df echcxxirt oc qirecg ot wlc h`srw e`w w` }r`n}w `rxcck w` defbscehc wlc qdwecxx de iet qit
9%
9 Xcc" f`r c|in}bc" NhAdebct v% L%N% Igv`hiwc" ?==9 X%H%H%_% 71" qlcrc ie igsbw
h`n}bidecr de i hixc dev`bvdea ibbcacg xc|sib iosxc rcyscxwcg wlc }rcxcehc `f lcr o`tfrdceg
ix i xs}}`rw }crx`e: dw qix lcbg echcxxirt f`r wlc xlcrdff w` advc gdrchwd`ex xwrcxxdea wlc
bdndwcg r`bc `f wlc xs}}`rw }crx`e" ieg w` qire ldn e`w w` dewcrfcr c qdwl wlc qdwecxx—x
iexqcrx%
_cn`vib `f ie ihhsxcg ql` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf
99%1 Df ie ihhsxcg x` ndxh`egshwx ldnxcbf gsrdea wlc h`srxc `f wlc wrdib wliw wlc
h`srw f`rnx wlc vdcq wliw i }r`}cr wrdib hiee`w wikc }bihc sebcxx wlc ihhsxcg dx
rcn`vcg" wlc h`srw nit `rgcr wliw lc `r xlc dx rcn`vcg fr`n wlc h`srw f`r x` b`ea ix
wliw h`egshw nikcx dw echcxxirt" ieg wliw wlc wrdib }r`hccg de wlc ihhsxcg—x ioxcehc%9
Df wlc ihhsxcg dx e`w bcaibbt rc}rcxcewcg" wlc h`srw nsxw i}}`dew h`sexcb `r i x`bdhdw`r
w` rc}rcxcew ldx `r lcr dewcrcxwx gsrdea xshl ie ioxcehc%
9 X`bcne }r`hccgdeax: x% 4?,9$ `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443; xsnnirt
}r`hccgdeax: x% 938,?$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
Gdxwrcxx gsrdea cvdgcehc
99%< I}irw fr`n wlc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex de xchwd`ex ?17 ieg ?13 `f wlc Hrdndeib
]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" wlc c|wcew w` qldhl i jsgac nit dewcrvcec `r `ffcr
rcixxsriehc w` i gdxwrcxxcg qdwecxx dx i gdffdhsbw ieg `fwce h`ewcewd`sx irci
9
%
9 Obihk v _s|w`e" 944< X%H%H%_% 877= ,xsnnirt wrdib: xlcrdff igvdxdea i gdxwrcxxcg hldbg
qdwecxx qlce xlc rcwsrecg w` h`srw wliw lc qix wlcrc w` }r`wchw lcr ieg q`sbg xw`} wlc gcfcehc
x`bdhdw`r ixkdea iet gdxwrcxxdea yscxwd`ex$; NhKdc v L%N% Igv`hiwc" 9441 X%B%W% 9=9<; 9441
X%H%H%_% 8= ,jsrt wrdib: xlcrdff h`nf`rwdea i wcirfsb 4.tcir.`bg qdwecxx$% F`r fsrwlcr gcwidbx `f
wlcxc hixcx" xcc Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$" }iri% <%39 f``we`wc ?%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 181/206
WCBCVDXD@E BDEK ,HHWV$" XH_CCEX" CVDGCEHC @E H@NNDXXD@E"
]_D@_ XWIWCNCEWX
H`nn`e biq }`qcrx: xhrccex
99%4 ‒Wlc h`srw lix }`qcr iw h`nn`e biq w` }r`wchw iet vsbecriobc qdwecxx ql`
q`sbg oc }bihcg iw ie sefidr gdxigviewiac ot livdea w` advc cvdgcehc de wlc e`rnib
qit„%9 De }irwdhsbir" wlc h`srw lix }`qcr w` }crndw xshl i qdwecxx w` advc cvdgcehc
fr`n ocldeg i xhrcce%?
Sebdkc wlc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex ,xcc }iriari}lx 99%9= cw xcy
ocb`q$" wlcrc dx iw h`nn`e biq e` rcxwrdhwdvc gcfdedwd`e `f ‒vsbecriobc qdwecxx„% Ix
B`rg Jsxwdhc Acecrib Hsbbce `oxcrvcg de Lin}x`e v% L%N% Igv`hiwc8 ‒[D^w dx qcbb
rch`aedxcg wliw wlcrc irc qdwecxxcx ql` q`sbg oc }bihcg iw ie sefidr gdxigviewiac otwlc e`rnib }r`hcgsrc" ieg `e wliw ihh`sew irc rcairgcg ix vsbecriobc ieg de eccg `f
x}chdib ncixsrcx w` }r`wchw wlcn% Xshl qdwecxxcx nit e`rnibbt oc f`seg qdwlde `ec
`r n`rc `f wlc f`bb`qdea ar`s}x `f }crx`e" eincbt" fdrxw" hldbgrce; xch`egbt }crx`ex
ql`xc iodbdwt w` lcir" xcc `r h`nnsedhiwc dx dn}idrcg" `r ql` livc i }r`obcn qdwl
wlcdr lcibwl" qlcwlcr }ltxdhib `r ncewib; ieg wldrgbt" }crx`ex ql` irc vsbecriobc w`
iwwihk" `r fcir f iwwihk" `r dewdndgiwd`e irdxdea sw `f wlcdr advdea cvdgcehc% Qc livc
xidg /qdwlde/ xshl i ar`s} `r ar`s}x" xdehc qlcwlcr ie degdvdgsib qdwecxx xl`sbg oc
advce xshl }r`wchwd`e gc}cegx e" dewcr ibdi" wlc gcarcc `f ldx `r lcr vsbecriodbdwt%„
9 Lin}x`e v L%N% Igv`hiwc" ?==8 X%B%W% 47" ?==8 X%H%H%_% 98%
? Lin}x`e" io`vc" iw }iri% [<^% De wliw hixc i vsbecriobc ieg ie|d`sx q`nie iacg ?4"
wcrrdfdcg `f ocdea c|}`xcg w` wlc aizc `f wlc wlrcc nce ihhsxcg `f rivdxldea lcr" qix }crndwwcg
w` advc lcr cvdgcehc fr`n ocldeg i xhrcce%
8 Lin}x`e" io`vc" iw }iri%
[1^%
Xwiwsw`rt }r`wchwd`e de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax
99%9= Wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==79
gcfdecx i vsbecriobc qdwecxx
ix x`nc`ec iacg segcr 96 ,i hldbg qdwecxx$?
`r:
‒,o$ qlcrc wlc }crx`e dx e`w i hldbg qdwecxx" wlcrc dx i xdaedfdhiew rdxk wliw wlc ysibdwt
`f wlc cvdgcehc w` oc advce ot wlc }crx`e qdbb oc gdndedxlcg ot rcix`e `f ‘
,d$ ncewib gdx`rgcr ,qdwlde wlc nciedea `f xchwd`e 8?< `f wlc Ncewib Lcibwl
,Hirc ieg Wrciwncew$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==8 ,ix} 98$$" `r
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 182/206
,dd$ fcir `r gdxwrcxx de h`eechwd`e qdwl advdea cvdgcehc iw wlc wrdib8%„
Wlc h`srw nsxw wikc dew` ihh`sew vird`sx fihw`rx qlce ixxcxxdea qlcwlcr i }crx`e dx
i vsbecriobc qdwecxx7% Df i qdwecxx dx gccncg vsbecriobc" lc `r xlc dx cewdwbcg w`
hcrwide x}chdib ncixsrcx qlce advdea cvdgcehc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax% Wlc
x}chdib ncixsrcx dehbsgc3:
,i$ cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e: xchwd`e ?19b `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443;
,o$ i bdvc wcbcvdxd`e bdek ,HHWV$: xchwd`e ?19J;
,h$ i xhrcce: xchwd`e ?19K;
,g$ i xs}}`rwcr: xchwd`e ?19B;
,c$ i }rd`r xwiwcncew sxcg ix wlc qdwecxx—x cvdgcehc de hldcf: xchwd`e ?19N;
ieg
,f$ xshl `wlcr ncixsrcx ix wlc Xh`wwdxl Ndedxwcrx nit }rcxhrdoc ot xwiwsw`rt
dexwrsncew: xchwd`e ?19,9$,f$%
]r`hcgsrib gcwidbx rcbiwdea w` wlc x}chdib ncixsrcx hie oc f`seg de Hli}wcr <"
,Hldbgrce$ io`vc% I }irwt hdwdea `r dewcegdea w` hdwc i vsbecriobc qdwecxx de i
hrdndeib hixc nsxw nikc i vsbecriobc qdwecxx i}}bdhiwd`e e`w biwcr wlie 97 hbcir gitx
ocf`rc wlc wrdib gdcw6% De wlc h`srxc `f i wrdib" wlc h`srw nit ibwcr c|dxwdea x}chdib
ncixsrcx cvce df wlc qdwecxx lix ocase w` advc cvdgcehc1% Xshl ibwcriwd`e nit
h`n}rdxc `rgcrdea x}chdib ncixsrcx qlce e`ec c|dxw; `r virtdea `r rcv`kdea ncixsrcx
ibrcigt de }bihc<% Qlce sxdea x}chdib ncixsrcx xshl ix HHWV" xhrccex" `r cvdgcehc
`e h`nndxxd`e" h`exdgcriwd`e xl`sbg oc advce w` wlc ocxw nciex `f }r`vdgdea wlc
qdwecxx qdwl ie `}}`rwsedwt w` dgcewdft ie ihhsxcg4%
9 ix} 8" incegdea wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443% Fsrwlcr incegncewx qcrc
nigc ot wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Incegncew$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7 ,ix} 3$ ieg ot wlcHrdndeib ]r`hccgdeax cwh ,_cf`rn$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==1 ,ix} 6$% Wlc }r`vdxd`ex hsrrcewbt
i}}bt w` igsbwx de x`bcne hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax% Fr`n 9 I}rdb ?==< wlc }r`vdxd`ex qdbb ibx`
i}}bt w` igsbwx de xsnnirt }r`hccgdeax%
? Xcc Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$%
8 Xchwd`e ?19,9$ df wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" ix xsoxwdwswcg ot wlc
Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7%
7 Xchwd`e ?19,?$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw
3 Xchwd`e ?19L `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
6 Xchwd`e ?19H `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 183/206
1 Xchwd`e ?19G,9$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
< Xchwd`e ?19G,?$ `f wlc 9443 Ihw%
4 Xchwd`e ?<9I `f wlc 9443 Ihw% Hf Hli}wcr < ,Hldbgrce$ }iriari}lx <%?8 ieg <%?7%
Qdwecxx rcfsxdea w` h`.`}criwc de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax ieg sxc `f }rd`r
xwiwcncewx: xchwd`e ?34
99%99 Xchwd`e ?34 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 }crndwx wlc }rd`r
xwiwcncew `f i qdwecxx w` oc igndwwcg de cvdgcehc qlcrc wlc jsgac dx xiwdxfdcg wliw wlc
qdwecxx lix:
rcfsxcg w` wikc wlc `iwl `r iffdrniwd`e; `r
livdea occe xq`re ix i qdwecxx ieg gdrchwcg ot wlc jsgac w` advc cvdgcehc
de h`eechwd`e qdwl wlc xsojchw niwwcr `f wlc xwiwcncew rcfsxcx w` g` x`%
Wldx dee`viwdvc xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`e xl`sbg oc sxcg x}irdeabt" ocirdea de ndeg wlc bihk
`f `}}`rwsedwt w` hr`xx.c|indec `r `wlcrqdxc wcxw wlc cvdgcehc%9
9 Xcc wlc I}}cib H`srw—x `oxcrviwd`ex de NihG`eibg v L%N% Igv`hiwc" 9444 X%H%H%_% 976"
qlcrc wlc ihhsxcg qix hliracg qdwl xlincbcxx degchceht" ieg wlrcc <.tcir `bg qdwecxxcx
ochinc gdxwrcxxcg ieg rcfsxcg w` iexqcr yscxwd`ex% Wlc I}}cib H`srw h`nncewcg `e wlc
dee`viwdvc eiwsrc `f xchwd`e ?34" ieg cn}lixdxcg wliw" }rd`r w` rcx`rwdea w` i xwiwcncew ib`ec
de wcrnx `f xchwd`e ?34" wlc qdwecxx nsxw fdrxwbt oc gdrchwcg w` iexqcr wlc yscxwd`ex" ieg
xch`egbt" ixkcg qlcwlcr lc `r xlc lig nigc i }rcvd`sx xwiwcncew% Wlce wlc wcrnx `f wlc
xwiwcncew xl`sbg oc }sw w` wlc qdwecxx% Xdr Acribg A`rg`e de ldx h`nncewirt" iw }%939"
`oxcrvcx wliw x% ?34 ridxcx h`ehcrex io`sw wlc sewcxwcg eiwsrc `f wlc xwiwcncew ieg ibx` wlc fihw
wliw i xdeabc qdwecxx ndalw oc rcairgcg ix xsffdhdcew w` }r`vc wlc xwiwcncew%
Qdwecxx seiobc w` rcncnocr de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax" osw qdbbdea w` ig`}w }rd`r
xwiwcncew: xchwd`e ?6=
99%9? Segcr xchwd`e ?6= `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" i }rd`r
xwiwcncew nigc ot i qdwecxx" qldhl q`sbg e`w `wlcrqdxc oc igndxxdobc ix cvdgcehc" dx
igndxxdobc ix cvdgcehc `f iet niwwcr xwiwcg de dw `f qldhl gdrchw `rib cvdgcehc ot ldn
q`sbg oc igndxxdobc df advce de wlc h`srxc `f wl`xc }r`hccgdeax% Wlc xwiwcncew dx e`w
igndxxdobc sebcxx.
,i$ wlc xwiwcncew dx h`ewidecg de i g`hsncew;
,o$ wlc qdwecxx" de wlc h`srxc `f ldx cvdgcehc" degdhiwcx wliw wlc xwiwcncew
qix nigc ot ldn ieg wliw lc ig`}wx dw ix ldx cvdgcehc; ieg
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 184/206
,h$ iw wlc wdnc wlc xwiwcncew qix nigc" wlc }crx`e ql` nigc dw q`sbg
livc occe i h`n}cwcew%
Wlc rcxwrdhwd`ex `e igndxxdodbdwt e`wcg io`vc g` e`w i}}bt w` i }rch`aedwd`e `e `iwl `r
i xwiwcncew nigc de `wlcr hdvdb `r hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax de wlc SK `r cbxcqlcrc9% Wlc
igndxxdodbdwt `f }rd`r xwiwcncewx segcr xchwd`e ?6= `f wlc 9443 Ihw g`cx e`w i}}bt w` i
}rd`r xwiwcncew ot ie ihhsxcg }crx`e?%
99443 Ihw xchwd`e ?6=,7$%
?9443 Ihw xchwd`e ?69,9$
_CXW_DHWD@EX @E [email protected]\INDEIWD@E
_cxwrdhwd`ex `e hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e `f i vdhwdn `f i xc|sib hrdnc9
99%98Xchwd`e 1 `f wlc Xc|sib @ffcehcx ,]r`hcgsrc ieg Cvdgcehc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==?
xsoxwdwswcx i ecq xchwd`e ?17 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443 w` c|wceg
wlc }rcvd`sx rcxwrdhwd`ex `e wlc cvdgcehc ibb`qcg `r yscxwd`ex wliw nit oc ixkcg
rcbiwdea w` wlc hlirihwcr `r xc|sib `r `wlcr oclivd`sr `f i h`n}bidecr% Df dw i}}cirx w`
wlc gcfcehc echcxxirt w` ixk xshl yscxwd`ex" ie i}}bdhiwd`e lix w` oc nigc w` wlc h`srw
,ieg de x`bcne hixcx" irascg `swqdwl wlc }rcxcehc `f wlc jsrt$%
9 Wldx irci `f wlc biq dx n`rc fsbbt gcibw qdwl de wlc JXH ordcfdea }i}cr ‒Xc|sib @ffcehcx
,]r`hcgsrc ieg Cvdgcehc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==?„%
99%97 Wlc h`srw lix gdxhrcwd`e segcr xchwd`e ?13 `f wlc 9443 Ihw9
w` ibb`q i bdec `f
yscxwd`edea r w` igndw cvdgcehc% Ie cbio`riwc }r`hcgsrc dx xcw `sw f`r xshl ie
i}}bdhiwd`e% Ie i}}bdhiwd`e lix w` oc nigc e`w bcxx wlie 97 gitx ocf`rc wlc wrdib gdcw
sebcxx x}chdib hisxc dx xl`qe%?
Qlcrc wlc h`srw ibb`qx xshl yscxwd`edea `r igndwx
xshl cvdgcehc" wlc }r`xchsw`r nsxw }bihc ocf`rc wlc h`srw iet rcbcview }rcvd`sx
h`evdhwd`ex f wlc ihhsxcg%8
9Ix xsoxwdwswcg ot x% < `f wlc ?==? Ihw%
? 9443 Ihw" x% ?13O" dexcrwcg ot x% < `f wlc ?==? Ihw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 185/206
8 9443 Ihw" x% ?13I" dexcrwcg ot x% < `f wlc ?==? Ihw; ieg xcc X v L%N% Igv`hiwc ?==1 X%H%
,]%H%$ 9" ?==1 XBW 9=?6" }irix% 37 ieg <1 f`r asdgiehc `e rcbcview gdrchwd`ex w` wlc jsrt%
X]CHDIB NCIXS_CX DE HDVDB ]_@HCCGDEAX
99%93 Wlc dxxsc `f xc|sib hrdnc nit irdxc de hdvdb }r`hccgdeax% Wlc ibbcacg vdhwdn
nit ysibdft ix i vsbecriobc qdwecxx"9 ieg oc cewdwbcg w` x}chdib ncixsrcx xshl ix
xhrccex" HHWV" cvdgcehc `e h`nndxxd`e" ieg i xs}}`rwcr%? Dw xl`sbg oc e`wcg wliw de
rcfcrribx w` wlc xlcrdff h`srw fr`n hldbgrce—x lcirdeax" wlcrc irc rcxwrdhwd`ex `e wlc
hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e f i hldbg ibbcadea xc|sib iosxc%8
9Xchwd`e 99,9$ `f wlc Vsbecriobc Qdwecxxcx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==7%
? Xchwd`ex 99 w` ?8 ,]irw ?$ `f wlc ?==7 Ihw: gcwidbx w` wlcxc }r`hcgsrcx hie oc f`seg de Hli}wcrx < w`
9=" io`vc%
8Xchwd`ex 6<I ieg 6<O `f wlc Hldbgrce ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" dexcrwcg ot x% ?8 `f wlc ?==7 Ihw% De
}irwdhsbir wlcrc irc rcxwrdhwd`ex xdndbir w` wl`xc h`ewidecg de xx% ?17 ieg ?13 `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc
,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443: xcc }irix% 99%98 ieg 99%97 io`vc%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 186/206
Hli}wcr 9?
]C_X@EX QDWL@SW BCAIB _C]_CXCEWIWD@E" IEG
BIT _C]_CXCEWIWDVCX
ACEC_IB DEW_@GSHWD@E
Wlc h`ehcrex `f wldx hli}wcr
9?%9 ]crx`ex nit h`egshw wlcdr `qe hixcx de o`wl wlc hdvdb h`srwx ieg wlc hrdndeib
h`srwx% Wlct nit g` x` cdwlcr ot hl`dhc `r ochisxc wlct livc e`w occe ariewcg bcaibidg% Xshl }crx ex fihc }irwdhsbir gdffdhsbwdcx%
9?%? Nshl `f wldx hli}wcr dx i}}bdhiobc w` bit rc}rcxcewiwdvcx%9
9D%c% }crx`ex ql` ihw `e oclibf `f bdwdaiewx osw ql` g` e`w livc bcaib ysibdfdhiwd`ex% Bit
rc}rcxcewiwdvcx nit i}}cir de xsnnirt hisxcx ot vdrwsc `f r% ?%9,9$ `f wlc Xsnnirt Hisxc
_sbcx ?==? ,X%X%D% ?==? 98?$; xnibb hbidnx ot vdrwsc `f r% ?%9,9$ `f wlc Xnibb Hbidnx _sbcx
?==? ,X%X%D% ?==?988$; ieg de }r`hccgdeax segcr wlc Gcow`rx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 94<1 ot vdrwsc `f
r% 1= `f wlc Ihw `f Xcgcrsew ,]r`hccgdeax de wlc Xlcrdff H`srw segcr wlc Gcow`rx ,Xh`wbieg$
Ihw 94<1$ 94<< ,X%D% 94<<?=98$%
Acecrib }`dewx
9?%8 Ocir wlc f`bb`qdea acecrib }`dewx de ndeg" qlcrc i}}r`}rdiwc:
]sw wlc serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e iw cixc%
Oc }iwdcew iw ibb wdncx%
Oc segcrxwiegdea% Ie serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e nit oc q`rrdcg" ocqdbgcrcg"
ecrv`sx `r fcirfsb de ie ibdce cevdr`encew% Wldx nit niedfcxw dwxcbf de
i}}ircewbt l`xwdbc" ocbbdacrcew `r cvce rsgc oclivd`sr%
Oc xcexdwdvc w` bdwcriht }r`obcnx% X`nc }c`}bc nit livc gdffdhsbwt qdwl
rcigdea" qrdwdea `r x}cbbdea%
I}}rchdiwc wliw ie serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e nit e`w segcrxwieg qliw dx a`dea `e%
Cexsrc wliw wlc serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e lix xidg qliw lc `r xlc eccgx w` xit%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 187/206
C|}bide qliw dx w` li}}ce" dx li}}cedea" lix li}}cecg ieg qlt%
C|}bide qliw dw dx wliw wlc serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e lix w` g`" qlt ieg qlce%
_cncnocr wlie ie serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e nit e`w livc wlc fihdbdwdcx ividbiobc
w` i }crx`e de ie `ffdhc `r livc rcigt ihhcxx w` bcaib o``kx%
Advc ie serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e cvcrt rcix`eiobc `}}`rwsedwt w` nikc ldx `r lcr
hixc qdwl" df echcxxirt" i}}r`}rdiwc igj`srencewx%
Wrt w` acw wlc serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e w` dgcewdft wlc dxxsc,x$%
Iv`dg bcaib jira`e `r" df echcxxirt" c|}bide dw%
Df echcxxirt" lcb} ie serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e w` }sw i }`dew w` i qdwecxx de wlc
f`rn `f i yscxwd`e%
C|}bide wlc rcix`ex f`r iet gchdxd`e t`s nikc ieg iet rdalwx `f i}}cib%
De hdvdb hixcx" c|}bide io`sw c|}cexcx%
Def`rn ie serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e `f wlc ividbiodbdwt `f igvdhc iacehdcx qldhl
ndalw oc iobc w` lcb} ldn `r lcr%9
Nidewide i fidr oibiehc: ibwl`sal ie serc}rcxcewcg }crx`e dx cewdwbcg w`
ixxdxwiehc ieg i fidr lcirdea" lc `r xlc xl`sbg e`w oc }crndwwcg w` c|}b`dw `r
iosxc bihk `f rc}rcxcewiwd`e w` wlc }rcjsgdhc `f `wlcrx%
9 F`r c|in}bc" Xh`wwdxl Ixx`hdiwd`e `f Biq Hcewrcx" Hdwdzcex Igvdhc Osrcis|" H`exsncr
Igvdhc hcewrcx" H`exsncr ]r`wchwd`e gc}irwncewx" De.H`srw Igvdxcr ]r`jchwx" N`ect Igvdhc
Xh`wbieg ieg wrigdea xwiegirgx gc}irwncewx%
]I_WT BDWDAIEWX DE HDVDB ]_@HCCGDEAX
Dewr`gshwd`e9?%7 Iet eiwsrib }crx`ex `wlcr wlie hldbgrce" hcrwide }crx`ex qdwl ncewib
dehi}ihdwt" `r }crx`ex v`bsewirdbt rcxdgcew `r hirrtdea `e osxdecxx de l`xwdbc wcrrdw`rt
nit h`egshw wlcdr `qe hisxc de cdwlcr wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e `r wlc xlcrdff h`srw% Xshl
}crx`ex irc ke`qe ix }irwt bdwdaiewx%9
Dw lix occe lcbg" l`qcvcr" wliw" qlce i
}rihwdxdea x`bdhdw`r rc}rcxcewx cdwlcr ldnxcbf `r ldx fdrn" lc g`cx e`w fibb w` oc rcairgcg
ix i }irwt bdwdaiew f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f iet c|}cexcx qldhl nit oc iqirgcg de ldx
fiv`sr%?
9Xcc Nih}lidb" Xlcrdff H`srw ]rihwdhc" 8rg cg%" }iri% 7%99<%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 188/206
? Nihocwl" Hsrrdc & H` v Niwwlcq 94<3 X%B%W% ,Xl Hw$ 77; ieg xcc C|}cexcx iqirgcg de
fiv`sr `f }irwt bdwdaiewx" }iri% 9?%?1" ocb`q%
9?%3 X`nc }irwt bdwdaiewx livc i gcarcc `f xcbf.h`efdgcehc" ieg x`nc ke`qbcgac `f
biq ieg }r`hcgsrc% F`r n`xw }irwt bdwdaiewx" l`qcvcr" wlc }r`x}chw `f livdea w`
i}}cir de h`srw" ieg `f livdea w` }rcxcew i hixc ocf`rc i jsgac" hie oc gisewdea ieg
frdalwcedea% Ysdwc i}irw fr`n livdea ie segcrxwiegiobc i}}rclcexd`e ix w` qliw dx
a`dea w` li}}ce" xshl bdwdaiewx irc bdkcbt w` xsffcr xcrd`sx gdxigviewiacx h`n}ircg
qdwl }irwdcx ql` irc rc}rcxcewcg ot h`sexcb `r ot i x`bdhdw`r% Dw dx dn}`rwiew wliw wl`xc
gdxigviewiacx xl`sbg oc qcbb segcrxw``g" ieg wliw ibb rcix`eiobc xwc}x xl`sbg oc wikce
de `rgcr w` ndedndxc wlcdr h`excyscehcx x` fir ix dx }rihwdhiobc%
Acecrib gdffdhsbwdcx fihcg ot }irwt bdwdaiewx
9?%6 N`xw }irwt bdwdaiewx hiee`w oc c|}chwcg w` livc nshl" `r degccg iet"
ke`qbcgac `f biq `r }r`hcgsrc% X`nc ixxdxwiehc `e niwwcrx `f }r`hcgsrc hie oc
advce ot hbcrkx `f h`srw" osw wlct irc e`w cn}`qcrcg w` `ffcr bcaib igvdhc `r w` kcc}
}irwt bdwdaiewx igvdxcg `e wlc }r`arcxx `f wlcdr hixcx% Xbdalwbt n`rc ixxdxwiehc ieg
igvdhc nit oc ividbiobc w` i }irwt bdwdaiew de h`srwx qlcrc ie de.h`srw igvdhc xcrvdhc dx
ividbiobc%9
Osw wliw x`rw `f xcrvdhc dx acecribbt ividbiobc `ebt de rcx}chw `f xnibb
hbidn ieg xsnnirt hisxc hixcx; ieg de iet cvcew dwx xh`}c fibbx fir xl`rw `f h`n}bcwc
rc}rcxcewiwd`e%
9 I xcrvdhc `f wldx kdeg lix occe de c|dxwcehc iw Cgdeosral Xlcrdff H`srw f`r x`nc tcirx%
@rdadeibbt xs}}`rwcg ot fsegdea fr`n wlc Csr`}cie H`nndxxd`e" dw dx e`q fsegcg ot wlc
Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew% Dw h`exdxwx `f i xibirdcg igvdxcr" ql dx bcaibbt ysibdfdcg" ieg x`nc
xs}}`rw xwiff% Wlc igvdxcr lix ie ffdhc de wlc h`srw osdbgdea ieg dx ividbiobc w` `ffcr igvdhc w`
}irwt bdwdaiewx de xnibb hbidn ieg xsnnirt hisxc hixcx% Hsrrcewbt wlc igvdxcr gcibx qdwl
i}}r`|dniwcbt 8== deysdrdcx cihl n`ewl% I xdndbir xcrvdhc dx ividbiobc de x`nc `wlcr xlcrdff
h`srwx%
9?%1 ]irwt bdwdaiewx irc ibx` bdkcbt w` livc e` c|}crdcehc w` asdgc wlcn de rcbiwd`e w`
qliw }r`fcxxd`eib h`srw sxcrx q`sbg rcairg ix vcrt `rgdeirt" }rihwdhib" niwwcrx ‘
qlcrc w` xdw de h`srw; qlce w` xdw ieg qlce w` xwieg; l`q w` iggrcxx wlc jsgac; ieg x`
`e% Wlct nit e`w oc xkdbbcg iw c|}rcxxdea wlcnxcbvcx cdwlcr `ribbt `r de qrdwdea; ieg
wlct irc sebdkcbt w` livc iet segcrxwiegdea `f l`q w` }rcxcew cvdgcehc ot wlc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 189/206
c|indeiwd`e ieg hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e `f qdwecxxcx% Degccg" c|}crdcehc xl`qx wliw
niet }irwt bdwdaiewx xcck w` gcib qdwl xshl niwwcrx ot wlc nikdea `f xwiwcncewx riwlcr
wlie ot ixkdea yscxwd`ex% X`nc }irwt bdwdaiewx nit e`w segcrxwieg wlc echcxxdwt `f
livdea dn}`rwiew fihwx x}`kce w` ot wlc cvdgcehc `f `wlcr qdwecxxcx" ieg nit oc
xsr}rdxcg qlce wlct irc w`bg wliw dw dx e`w a``g ce`sal f`r wlcn xdn}bt w` xit: ‒Df t`s
}l`ec s} Nr Xndwl lc qdbb h`efdrn qliw D livc occe xitdea„% X`ncwdncx wlc
gcxdriodbdwt `f livdea c|}crw wcxwdn`et qdbb e`w oc segcrxw``g; ieg `e `wlcr `hhixd`ex
wlc eccg w` livc g`hsncewirt ieg `wlcr }r`gshwd`ex de h`srw qdbb e`w oc i}}rchdiwcg%
9?%< N`rc fsegincewibbt" `f h`srxc" i nij`r }r`obcn fihcg ot n`xw }irwt bdwdaiewx
dx wliw wlct xdn}bt g` e`w livc wlc bcaib ke`qbcgac w` ceiobc wlcn w` f`rnsbiwc i
hbidn `r i gcfcehc de i qit qldhl ndalw cewdwbc wlcn w` wlc rcncgt qldhl wlct xcck%
W` wikc i xdn}bc c|in}bc" i }irwt bdwdaiew nit oc xcckdea giniacx de rcx}chw `f
ibbcacgbt fisbwt a``gx osw nit e`w rcfcr w` iet }irwdhsbir xchwd`e `f wlc Xibc `f A``gx
Ihw 9414" ieg degccg nit e`w cvce rcfcr w` wliw" `r iet `wlcr" xwiwswc%9
Ibb `f wldx hie
advc rdxc w` i fsrwlcr }r`obcn de wliw x`nc }irwt bdwdaiewx livc wlc dn}rcxxd`e wliw" ot
wikdea i hixc w` h`srw" wlct qdbb oc asiriewccg i git `e qldhl wlct hie }rcxcew
cvdgcehc de xs}}`rw `f wlcdr hixc ieg `owide i jsgancew `e wliw cvdgcehc% Wlct g` e`w
segcrxwieg wliw i hixc nit oc gdxndxxcg ix deh`n}cwcew" drrcbcview" `r bihkdea de
x}chdfdhiwd`e qdwl`sw i xdeabc q`rg `f cvdgcehc livdea occe lcirg; ieg i fcq }irwt
bdwdaiewx e`q xcck w` nidewide wliw xshl i gdx}`xib h`exwdwswcx ie defrdeacncew `f wlcdr
rdalwx segcr irwdhbc 6 `f wlc Csr`}cie H`evcewd`e `e Lsnie _dalwx%
9 Xcc" f`r c|in}bc" Nieedfdcbg v Qibkcr 944= X%H%B%_% 864%
Xwiwsw`rt gdffdhsbwdcx fihcg ot }irwt bdwdaiewx
9?%4 Ysdwc i}irw fr`n wlc acecrib gdffdhsbwdcx qldhl livc occe `swbdecg io`vc" }irwt
bdwdaiewx irc ibx` xsojchw w` i esnocr `f xwiwsw`rt rcxwrdhwd`ex segcr wlc _sbcx `f wlc
H`srw `f Xcxxd`e" ieg wlc @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx ieg `wlcr _sbcx qldhl i}}bt de wlc
xlcrdff h`srw% X`nc `f wl`xc rcxwrdhwd`ex irc cxxcewdibbt wlc xinc o`wl de wlc H`srw `f
Xcxxd`e ieg de wlc xlcrdff h`srw" osw wlct irc e`w h`n}bcwcbt sedf`rn% Wlct irc ix
f`bb`qx:
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 190/206
,i$ H`srw `f Xcxxd`e
9?%9= Niet dedwdiwdea g`hsncewx de wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e xshl ix i xsnn`ex" i
}cwdwd`e" i e`wc" ie i}}bdhiwd`e `r i ndeswc nit `ebt oc xdaecg ot h`sexcb" i }crx`e
livdea i rdalw `f isgdcehc `r ot ie iacew" ieg nit e`w oc xdaecg ot i }irwt bdwdaiew%
Qlcrc i }irwt bdwdaiew hiee`w `owide wlc xdaeiwsrc `f h`sexcb `r `wlcr iswl`rdxcg
}crx`e" lc nit rcyscxw wlc Gc}swt ]rdehd}ib Hbcrk w` }bihc wlc g`hsncew ocf`rc wlc
B`rg @rgdeirt f`r bcivc w` }r`hccg; ieg wlc B`rg @rgdeirt—x gchdxd`e ix w` qlcwlcr `r
e`w w` ariew bcivc dx fdeib ieg e`w xsojchw w` rcvdcq% Qlcrc bcivc dx ariewcg wlc }irwt
bdwdaiew dx wlce }crndwwcg w` xdae wlc g`hsncew%9
9_sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9447" r% 7%?,9$" ,?$" ,8$" ,3$" ,6$%
9?%99 De rcbiwd`e w` wlc rch`vcrt `f g`hsncewx ot h`nndxxd`e ieg gdbdacehc" x}chdib
}r`vdxd`e dx nigc qlcrc wliw }r`hcgsrc dx dexwdaiwcg ot i }irwt bdwdaiew%9
9 _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9447" rr% 83%8I" 83%7,6$" ieg 83%99,1$%
9?%9? Qlcrc qdwecxxcx irc w` oc hdwcg f`r i }r``f `r jsrt wrdib i }irwt bdwdaiew nsxw"
e`w biwcr wlie 9? qcckx ocf`rc wlc ixxdaecg gdcw" i}}bt w` wlc h`srw w` fd| hiswd`e f`r
wlc c|}cexcx `f qdwecxxcx de iexqcrdea i hdwiwd`e de xshl xsn ix wlc h`srw h`exdgcrx
rcix`eiobc; ieg wlc }irwt bdwdaiew dx" de wlc fdrxw dexwiehc" }crx`eibbt bdiobc f`r wlc fccx
ieg c|}cexcx `f i qdwecxx x` hdwcg%9
Hdwiwd`e `f i qdwecxx w` oc hibbcg ot i }irwt
bdwdaiew nit `ebt oc cffchwcg ot i ncxxceacr.iw.irnx ieg" ocf`rc iet xshl ncxxceacr
dx dexwrshwcg" wlc hiswd`e fd|cg ot wlc h`srw nsxw livc occe f`seg ot wlc }irwt bdwdaiew%
9 _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e 9447" r% 86%?,7$ ieg ,3$ ,}r``fx$; ieg r% 81%7 ,jsrt wrdibx$%
,o$ Xlcrdff h`srw
9?%98 De `rgdeirt hisxc }r`hccgdeax de wlc xlcrdff h`srw wlcrc dx e` rcxwrdhwd`e `e ie
dedwdib qrdw ocdea xdaecg ot i }irwt bdwdaiew% Wlc @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx 9448 c|}rcxxbt
}r`vdgc wliw i }irwt nit xdae ie dedwdib qrdw%9
Wl`xc rsbcx" l`qcvcr" }r`vdgc i
rcxwrdhwd`e" qldhl dx ioxcew de wlc _sbcx `f wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e" `e wlc o`rr`qdea `f
}irwx `f }r`hcxx ot i }irwt bdwdaiew% De `rgdeirt hisxc }r`hccgdeax wl`xc }irwx `f
}r`hcxx qldhl irc hi}iobc `f ocdea o`rr`qcg nit oc o`rr`qcg ot i }irwt bdwdaiew
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 191/206
`ebt qdwl bcivc `f wlc xlcrdff ieg xsojchw w` xshl h`egdwd`ex ix wlc xlcrdff nit
dn}`xc%?
Ecvcrwlcbcxx" i }irwt bdwdaiew nit dex}chw i }r`hcxx iw iet wdnc ieg nit
`owide h`}dcx" qlcrc }rihwdhiobc" fr`n wlc xlcrdff hbcrk%8
Wlc rsbcx g` e`w xit ql`
xl`sbg ocir wlc h`xw `f iet xshl h`}tdea% De }rihwdhc" h`}dcx irc `fwce nigc ividbiobc
w` }irwt bdwdaiewx iw e` h`xw qlcrc wlc in`sew `f h`}tdea dx rcbiwdvcbt xnibb% Dw dx
wl`salw" l`qcvcr" wliw wlc ‒qlcrc }rihwdhiobc„ }r`vdxd`e de wlc rsbc q`sbg }r`oiobt
cewdwbc i xlcrdff hbcrk w` rcysdrc x`nc }itncew df i }irwt bdwdaiew x`salw h`}dcx `f i
vcrt birac esnocr `f }irwx `f }r`hcxx%
9@rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx 9448" r% 8%9,1$%
? Dodg% r% 99%8,8$,i$%
8 Dodg % r% 99%8,8$,o$% Xdndbir }r`vdxd`ex c|dxw de rcbiwd`e w` xsnnirt hisxcx ieg xnibb hbidnx:
Xsnnirt Hisxc _sbcx ?==?" r% 91%8,7$ ieg ,3$; Xnibb Hbidnx _sbcx ?==?" r% 96%?,7$ ieg ,3$%
9?%97 X` fir ix wlc hdwiwd`e `f qdwecxxcx dx h`ehcrecg wlc @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx 9448
nikc xdndbir" wl`sal e`w dgcewdhib" }r`vdxd`e w` wliw h`ewidecg de wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e
_sbcx f`r }irwt bdwdaiewx% De wlc xlcrdff h`srw wlc i}}bdhiwd`e w` wlc xlcrdff w` fd|
hiswd`e nsxw oc nigc e`w biwcr wlie f`sr qcckx ocf`rc wlc gdcw `f }r``f; ieg hdwiwd`e
rcysdrcx w` oc cffchwcg ot i xlcrdff `ffdhcr%9
Wlc @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx g` e`w h`ewide
iet }r`vdxd`ex de rcbiwd`e w` wlc rch`vcrt `f g`hsncewx segcr h`nndxxd`e ieg
gdbdacehc h`n}iriobc w` wl`xc i}}btdea de wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e%
9 @rgdeirt Hisxc _sbcx 9448" r% ?4%<%
9?%93 Xsnnirt hisxc ieg xnibb hbidn }r`hcgsrcx de wlc xlcrdff h`srw irc w` x`nc
c|wcew gcxdaecg f`r sxc ot }irwt bdwdaiewx" ieg ix i h`excyscehc wlct g` e`w" qdwl wlc
c|hc}wd`e `f wlc o`rr`qdea `f }r`gshwd`ex `r }irwx `f }r`hcxx" dn}`xc `e }irwt
bdwdaiewx iet rcxwrdhwd`ex qldhl irc e`w dn}`xcg `e wl`xc rc}rcxcewcg ot h`sexcb `r i
x`bdhdw`r% Wlsx" f`r c|in}bc" wlc xsnn`ex de i xsnnirt hisxc dx w` oc iswlcewdhiwcg
ot wlc xlcrdff hbcrk `r" de hcrwide hdrhsnxwiehcx" wlc xlcrdff%9
Xdaeiwsrc ot wlc bdwdaiew
dx e`w rcysdrcg%
9 Xsnnirt Hisxc _sbcx ?==?" r% 7%7,9$ ieg ,?$%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 192/206
Gcibdea qdwl wlc gdffdhsbwdcx
9?%96 Dw lix b`ea occe ihhc}wcg de wlc h`srwx `f Xh`wbieg wliw" ochisxc `f wlc
gdffdhsbwdcx qldhl livc jsxw occe xsnnirdxcg" i }irwt bdwdaiew qdbb acecribbt oc
ibb`qcg h`exdgcriobc biwdwsgc `r degsbacehc de wlc }rcxcewiwd`e `f ldx `r lcr hixc"
}r`vdgcg wliw wlcrc dx e` }rcjsgdhc w` wlc `}}`ecew%9
Wldx xl`sbg e`w ncie wliw jsgacx
qdbb ibb`q drrcbcview xsondxxd`ex qldhl q`sbg e`w oc }crndwwcg de wlc hixc `f h`sexcb
`r i x`bdhdw`r% N`rc }`xdwdvc xwc}x xl`sbg oc wikce de `rgcr w` cexsrc" x` fir ix dx
}rihwdhiobc" wliw i }irwt bdwdaiew hie `vcrh`nc iw bcixw x`nc `f wlc gdffdhsbwdcx qldhl
bdc de ldx `r lcr }iwl" ieg wliw i fidr ieg i}}r`}rdiwc lcirdea hie oc advce iw ibb wdncx%?
Wlcrc irc vird`sx qitx de qldhl xshl }`xdwdvc xwc}x hie" ieg xl`sbg" oc wikce% Wlcxc
irc xcw `sw ocb`q%
9 Xcc" f`r c|in}bc" N``rc v Xchrcwirt `f Xwiwc f`r Xh wbieg 94<3 X%B%W% 8<" 84%
? Xcc irw% 6,9$ `f wlc Csr`}cie H`evcewd`e `e Lsnie _dalwx%
,9$ Qrdwwce asdgiehc
9?%91 X`nc bcifbcwx ieg o``kbcwx" qrdwwce de rcbiwdvcbt xdn}bc bieasiac" ibrcigt c|dxw
de `rgcr w` `ffcr i}}r`}rdiwc asdgiehc w` }irwt bdwdaiewx ceaiacg de n`xw f`rnx `f hdvdb
}r`hcgsrc%9
Wlc c|dxwcehc `f xshl qrdwwce asdgiehc" l`qcvcr" g`cx e`w rcbdcvc jsgacx
ieg hbcrkx `f h`srw `f i gswt w` ixxdxw }irwt bdwdaiewx qlcecvcr dw dx i}}r`}rdiwc ieg
rcix`eiobc w` g` x`%
9 Gcwidbx `f x`nc `f wl`xc bcifbcwx ieg o``kbcwx irc advce iw wlc ceg `f wldx Hli}wcr%
,?$ H`exdgcr wlc degdvdgsib—x eccgx
9?%9< Ix de wlc hixc `f iet }crx`e i}}cirdea de h`srw" hirc nsxw oc wikce w` cexsrc
wliw e` gdxigviewiac dx xsffcrcg ot i }irwt bdwdaiew `e ihh`sew `f i gdxiodbdwt" bieasiac
`r `wlcr gdffdhsbwt%9
Wlsx" f`r c|in}bc" df i }irwt bdwdaiew dx i qlccbhlidr sxcr" ieg
x`nc h`srwr``nx `r `ffdhcx irc e`w rcigdbt ihhcxxdobc f`r i qlccbhlidr" irrieacncewx
xl`sbg oc nigc f`r h`srw }r`hccgdeax ieg iet dewcrvdcqx qdwl h`srw xwiff w` wikc }bihc
de i h`srwr``n `r `wlcr }bihc qldhl dx x` ihhcxxdobc% Bdkcqdxc" df i bdwdaiew lix i
lcirdea dn}idrncew" i}}r`}rdiwc irrieacncewx xl`sbg oc nigc w` cexsrc wliw wliw g`cx
e`w rcxsbw de gdxigviewiac?% Iaide i bdwdaiew ndalw livc i ncewib gdx`rgcr ,xshl ix i
}crx`eibdwt gdx`rgcr `r xhldz`}lrcedi `r bciredea gdxiodbdwt$% De xshl hdrhsnxwiehcx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 193/206
wlc h`srw ndalw qdxl w` h`exdgcr i}}`dewdea ,c| }r`}rd` n`ws$ i hsriw`r ig bdwcn ql`
nit rch`nnceg wliw ie i}}bdhiwd`e nit oc nigc f`r i asirgdie w` oc i}}`dewcg
segcr wlc Igsbwx qdwl Dehi}ihdwt ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?===% X`nc bdwdaiewx nit livc
ibrcigt lig i asirgdie i}}`dewcg w` wlcn segcr wliw Ihw% Segcr xchwd`e 67,8$ wlc
asirgdie lix }`qcr w` ihw ix wlc bcaib rc}rcxcewiwdvc de rcbiwd`e qdwlde wlc xh`}c `f wlc
}`qcr h`efcrrcg ot wlc asirgdiexld} `rgcr%
9Xcc" acecribbt" Hli}wcrx 3 ,Dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx$" 1 ,]crx`ex qdwl gdxiodbdwdcx$" 9=
,Dewdndgiwcg ieg `wlcr vsbecriobc qdwecxxcx$ ieg 99 ,Vdhwdnx `f xc|sib hrdnc$%
?Wlcxc" ieg xdndbir" niwwcrx irc fsbbt gcibw qdwl de Hli}wcr 1 ,]crx`ex qdwl gdxiodbdwt$%
9?%94 I }irwt bdwdaiew nit livc bdwwbc" `r ie dn}crfchw" segcrxwiegdea `f Ceabdxl%
Xshl i }crx`e nsxw oc iff`rgcg wlc `}}`rwsedwt w` livc g`hsncewx wriexbiwcg ieg w`
livc wlc xcrvdhcx `f ie dewcr}rcwcr gsrdea iet }r`hccgdeax de h`srw%9
Dw qdbb oc f`r wlc
}irwt w` ceaiac wlc xcrvdhcx `f ie dewcr}rcwcr ieg w` nccw wliw }crx`e—x fccx ieg
c|}cexcx ,wl`sal wlcxc nit sbwdniwcbt oc rch`vcriobc fr`n wlc `wlcr }irwt df wliw
}irwt dx sexshhcxxfsb$% Qlcrc Ceabdxl dx e`w i }irwt bdwdaiew—x eiwdvc w`easc" ie
dewcr}rcwcr xl`sbg e`w oc dexdxwcg s}`e df dw dx hbcir wliw wlc }irwt bdwdaiew de yscxwd`e
lix i a``g segcrxwiegdea `f Ceabdxl ieg hie x}cik dw qcbb%
?
@e wlc `wlcr lieg" hircxl`sbg oc wikce e`w w` f`rn ie `vcr.`}wdndxwdh vdcq `f i }crx`e—x bdeasdxwdh iodbdwt:
findbdirdwt qdwl xdn}bc" h`evcrxiwd`eib" x}cchl nit e`w ncie wliw wlc }crx`e de
yscxwd`e qdbb oc iobc w` h`}c qdwl gcwidbcg yscxwd`edea ieg hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e"
}`xxdobt `e niwwcrx qldhl irc h`n}bc| ieg wchledhib%8
9F`r ie ihhsxcg }crx`e rc}rcxcewdea ldnxcbf de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax" xcc Hli}wcr 3
,Dewcr}rcwdea xcrvdhcx$" }iri% 3%6%
? Fsrelcdn v Qiwx`e" 9476 X%B%W% ?41" }cr B%J%H% H``}cr iw }% 8==%8
De hrdndeib hixcx" qlcrc ie ihhsxcg—x `r i qdwecxx—x eiwdvc w`easc dx e`w Ceabdxl" dw dx n`rc
sxsib w` h`exdgcr sxdea ie dewcr}rcwcr wlie e`w% Xcc f`r c|in}bc Ibc|cd Ibc|iegr`vdh
Ndklidbdehlcek` v Iegrcq Hlrdxwdc E`rnieg 9448 X%H%H%_% 36%
,8$ H`egshw `f lcirdeax" }r``fx" cwh%
9?%?= De xnibb hbidnx ieg xsnnirt hisxcx i }irwt bdwdaiew dx bdkcbt w` h`nc ocf`rc i
xlcrdff iw wlc fdrxw hibbdea `f wlc hixc% Segcr `rgdeirt hisxc }r`hcgsrc de wlc xlcrdff
h`srw" wlc xlcrdff qdbb }r`oiobt ceh`sewcr xshl i }crx`e f`r wlc fdrxw wdnc iw ie `}wd`ex
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 194/206
lcirdea% De `wlcr hdrhsnxwiehcx i jsgac nit e w ceh`sewcr wlc }irwt bdwdaiew sewdb wlc
xwiac `f i gcoiwc `r }r`hcgsrc r`bb lcirdea r iw wlc ocadeedea `f i }r``f% Qlcrc i
}irwt bdwdaiew i}}cirx iw ie cirbt xwiac de wlc }r`hccgdeax" wliw nit qcbb oc i xsdwiobc
`}}`rwsedwt f`r i jsgac w` .
advc x`nc c|}bieiwd`e io`sw wlc lcirdea qldhl dx w` wikc }bihc" ieg
`ffcr x`nc acecrib def`rniwd`e ieg igvdhc rcairgdea wlc ec|w xwiac `r xwiacx
`f wlc hixc%
F`r c|in}bc" iw ie cirbt lcirdea qldhl dx xsoxcyscewbt w` oc f`bb`qcg ot i }r``f" dw dx
bdkcbt w` oc lcb}fsb df wlc jsgac qcrc w` `ffcr x`nc c|}bieiwd`e io`sw wlc eccg w` ordea
qdwecxxcx w` wlc }r``f ieg w` b`gac iet g`hsncewirt `r `wlcr }r`gshwd`ex qldhl irc
bdkcbt w` oc rcysdrcg iw wliw xwiac% I jsgac ndalw qdxl w` h`exdgcr wi}c rch`rgdea
}r`hccgdeax dev`bvdea i }irwt bdwdaiew qldhl q`sbg e`w e`rnibbt oc wi}c rch`rgcg%
Wldx h`sbg ixxdxw o`wl }irwdcx ieg wlc jsgac%
9?%?9 Wlc f`bb`qdea irc x`nc `f wlc wldeax qldhl i jsgac xl`sbg livc de ndeg iw ibb
wdncx% H`exdgcriwd`e xl`sbg oc advce w` c|}bidedea wlcxc niwwcrx de xdn}bc ieg
cvcrtgit bieasiac%
Ql` wlc jsgac dx" ieg l`q lc `r xlc xl`sbg oc iggrcxxcg%
Ql` wlc `wlcr }crx`ex de h`srw irc" ieg qliw irc wlcdr rcx}chwdvc fsehwd`ex%
Wliw" sebcxx xsffcrdea fr`n x`nc }ltxdhib gdxiodbdwt" wlc }irwt bdwdaiew xl`sbg
xwieg qlce iggrcxxdea wlc h`srw `r yscxwd`edea i qdwecxx%
Wliw" df wlc }irwt bdwdaiew g`cx e`w segcrxwieg x`ncwldea" `r lix i }r`obcn de
rcbiwd`e w` iet ix}chw `f wlc hixc" wlc jsgac xl`sbg oc w`bg iw `ehc x` wliw wlc
}r`obcn hie oc iggrcxxcg%
Wlc }sr}`xc `f wlc }irwdhsbir lcirdea ieg qliw dwx h`excyscehcx nit oc%
Wliw ibb }irwdcx qdbb livc i fsbb `}}`rwsedwt w` }rcxcew wlcdr hixc" ieg wliw wlc
}irwt bdwdaiew xl`sbg e`w dewcrrs}w qlce x nc`ec cbxc dx x}cikdea% Dexwcig" i
e`wc xl`sbg oc nigc x` wliw wlc }irwdhsbir }`dew hie oc gcibw qdwl qlce wlc
}irwt bdwdaiew dx hibbcg `e w` x}cik%
Wliw wlc }irwt bdwdaiew hie nikc e`wcx%
Wliw wlc }irwt bdwdaiew nit livc i frdceg `r h`bbciasc xdwwdea ib`eaxdgc w` nikc
e`wcx `r ixxdxw de wlc }rcxcewiwd`e f wlc hixc% Xshl i }crx`e nit igvdxc r
ixxdxw wlc }irwt bdwdaiew" osw nit e`w iggrcxx wlc h`srw%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 195/206
Wliw" df wlc }irwt bdwdaiew q`sbg bdkc i xl`rw orcik de wlc }r`hccgdeax f`r
}crx`eib rcix`ex" wliw dx bdkcbt w` oc ariewcg `e rcyscxw%
Wliw iet fswsrc lcirdea dx ie dn}`rwiew cvcew" ieg wliw wlc giwc fd|cg f`r dw
hiee`w oc hlieacg c|hc}w f`r vcrt a``g rcix`e xshl ix sec|}chwcg dbbecxx% Dw
xl`sbg oc c|}bidecg wliw de wliw cvcew ix nshl e`wdhc ix }`xxdobc xl`sbg oc
advce ieg wliw" df dbbecxx dx wlc rcix`e f`r xcckdea ie igj`srencew" dw nit oc
echcxxirt f`r wlc }irwt bdwdaiew w` `owide i ‒x`sb ieg h`exhdcehc„ hcrwdfdhiwc
fr`n i g`hw`r" ieg w` xceg wliw w` wlc h`srw%
9?%?? Fsrwlcr ixxdxwiehc" ieg h`exdgcriwd`e f`r wlc }`xdwd`e `f i }irwt bdwdaiew" nit
oc rcysdrcg" ieg nit oc i}}r`}rdiwc" ix i }irwdhsbir lcirdea gcvcb`}x% F`r c|in}bc"
ie seiewdhd}iwcg }r`obcn nit irdxc" ieg wl`xc ihwdea f`r i rc}rcxcewcg }irwt nit
`ffcr xsaacxwd`ex ix w` l`q dw xl`sbg oc gcibw qdwl% Wldx dx bdkcbt w` }rcxcew
gdffdhsbwdcx f`r i }irwt bdwdaiew% De xshl i xdwsiwd`e i jsgac nit qdxl w` cexsrc wliw wlc
}irwt bdwdaiew }r`}crbt segcrxwiegx wlc eiwsrc `f wlc }r`obcn `e qldhl ldx `r lcr
vdcqx irc rcysdrcg ‘ c|}bidedea dw" df echcxxirt" de xdn}bc wcrnx ‘ ieg nit wlce gchdgc
w` ibb`q i xl`rw igj`srencew x` wliw wlc }irwt bdwdaiew hie h`exdgcr ldx `r lcr }`xdwd`e%
De i hixc qlcrc i }irwt bdwdaiew dx ihh`n}iedcg ot i frdceg `r h`bbciasc" xshl i h`srxc
nit oc }irwdhsbirbt i}}r`}rdiwc de wliw dw qdbb }r`vdgc wlcn qdwl ie `}}`rwsedwt w`
gdxhsxx wlc niwwcr de }rdviwc ocf`rc wlc }irwt bdwdaiew dx rcysdrcg w` rcx}`eg f`rnibbt de
h`srw%
,7$ _cfcrcehc w` bcaib }rchcgcew ieg `wlcr iswl`rdwdcx
9?%?8 ]irwt bdwdaiewx irc `fwce h`efsxcg" ieg fccb wlcnxcbvcx iw i xcrd`sx
gdxigviewiac" qlce h`sexcb `r i x`bdhdw`r f`r ie`wlcr }irwt rcfcrx w` gchdgcg hixcx `r
w` xwiwsw`rt }r`vdxd`ex% ]irwt bdwdaiewx nit livc gdffdhsbwt de segcrxwiegdea qlt wlcdr
hixc xl`sbg oc gchdgcg `e wlc oixdx `f qliw li}}cecg de x`nc `wlcr }crx`e—x hixc"
ieg dw nit oc echcxxirt w` c|}bide" iaide de ix xdn}bc bieasiac ix dx }`xxdobc" wlc
xdaedfdhiehc `f gchdgcg hixcx ix xcwwdea `sw wlc qit de qldhl i }irwdhsbir }`dew `f biq
xl`sbg oc dewcr}rcwcg `r i}}bdcg% De x`nc dexwiehcx dw nit ibx oc echcxxirt w`
h`exdgcr ibb`qdea i xl`rw igj`srencew x` wliw wlc }irwt bdwdaiew hie b``k iw wlc hixc `r
xwiwswc de yscxwd`e `r x` wliw h`}dcx `f wlc rcbcview iswl`rdwdcx hie oc nigc ividbiobc
f`r wlc }irwt bdwdaiew% Qlcwlcr `r e`w w` ibb`q xshl ie igj`srencew qdbb oc vcrt nshl
i niwwcr f`r wlc gdxhrcwd`e `f wlc jsgac iw wlc wdnc% Df wlc hixc `r xwiwswc dx }bidebt `f
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 196/206
rcbcviehc w` wlc hixc" wlc dewcrcxwx `f jsxwdhc irc bdkcbt w` rcysdrc wliw ie i}}r`}rdiwc
igj`srencew xl`sbg oc ibb`qcg%
,3$ Ixxdxwdea de wlc }rcxcewiwd`e `f i }irwt bdwdaiew—x hixc
9?%?7 Acecribbt" dw qdbb oc o`wl i}}r`}rdiwc ieg lcb}fsb f`r i jsgac w` `ffcr }irwt
bdwdaiewx x`nc ixxdxwiehc de wlc }rcxcewiwd`e `f wlcdr hixcx% Ibwl`sal dw dx `fwce ocwwcr
e`w w` dewcrrs}w i }irwt bdwdaiew ql` dx nikdea xsondxxd`ex `r yscxwd`edea i qdwecxx"
xdehc wliw nit nikc wlc bdwdaiew n`rc ecrv`sx ieg dexchsrc" dw nit x`ncwdncx oc
i}}r`}rdiwc w` g` x` w` cexsrc wliw i xsondxxd`e" qldhl nit e`w livc occe vcrt qcbb
irwdhsbiwcg" dx }r`}crbt c|}bidecg ieg segcrxw``g% Dw nit ibx` oc i}}r`}rdiwc" qlcrc
wlc }irwt bdwdaiew dx e`w i}}r`ihldea wlc yscxwd`edea `f i qdwecxx de ie i}}r`}rdiwc `r
cffchwdvc qit" f`r wlc jsgac w` cn}lixdxc w` wlc }irwt bdwdaiew wlc dn}`rwiehc `f
f`rnsbiwdea i yscxwd`e ieg `owidedea ie iexqcr w` wliw yscxwd`e% Wlc jsgac ndalw
ibx` sxcfsbbt }sw x`nc yscxwd`ex w` wlc qdwecxx de `rgcr w` cbdhdw cvdgcehc `e i
}irwdhsbir }`dew% I}irw fr`n iet ixxdxwiehc qldhl wldx nit advc w` wlc }irwt bdwdaiew" dw
nit ibx` oc fidr w` wlc qdwecxx ot cexsrdea wliw cvdgcehc dx advce hbcirbt ieg de i
nieecr qldhl hiee`w xsoxcyscewbt oc ndxrc}rcxcewcg% @hhixd`eibbt dw nit oc
echcxxirt f`r i jsgac w` dewcrvcec de `rgcr w` h`ewr`b `r w` xw`} yscxwd`edea `f i
qdwecxx qldhl dx dei}}r`}rdiwcbt iaarcxxdvc `r `ffcexdvc%
9?%?3 I nshl n`rc gdffdhsbw yscxwd`e irdxcx" l`qcvcr" de hdrhsnxwiehcx ,qldhl irc
e`w seh`nn`e$ qlcrc dw i}}cirx wliw i }irwt bdwdaiew nit livc x`nc x`rw `f xwiwciobc
hixc" osw lix fidbcg w` c|}rcxx dw de wlc }bcigdeax% Wlc yscxwd`e de xshl hdrhsnxwiehcx
dx qlcwlcr i jsgac lix i gswt" `r dx cvce cewdwbcg" w` ixxdxw wlc }irwt bdwdaiew w` gcvcb`}
ieg w` c|}rcxx ldx `r lcr hixc% Wlc decvdwiobc" wl`sal x`ncqliw sexiwdxfihw`rt"
iexqcr w` wliw yscxwd`e dx wliw dw qdbb oc i niwwcr `f gcarcc" ieg qdbb gc}ceg `e wlc
hdrhsnxwiehcx `f wlc }irwdhsbir hixc% Dw ibx` lix w` oc xidg wliw wldx dx ie irci qlcrc
gdffcrcew jsgacx irc bdkcbt w` l`bg gdffcrcew vdcqx% De i xdn}bc xdwsiwd`e" xshl ix wlc
`ec hdwcg de }iriari}l 9?%<" io`vc" qlcrc i }irwt bdwdaiew g`cx e`w nikc iet rcfcrcehc
w` wlc Xibc `f A``gx Ihw 9414" dw nit oc i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc jsgac w` gchdgc wlc hixc
ot rcfcrcehc w` wliw xwiwswc e`wqdwlxwiegdea wliw dw lig e`w occe x}chdfdhibbt ncewd`ecg
ot wlc }irwt bdwdaiew% Dw dx xsaacxwcg" l`qcvcr" wliw i jsgac xl`sbg wikc xshl i h`srxc
`ebt qlcrc dw dx }crfchwbt hbcir wliw wlc hixc nsxw oc a`vcrecg ot i }irwdhsbir xwiwsw`rt
}r`vdxd`e% De xshl i xdwsiwd`e" n`rc`vcr" wlc jsgac xl`sbg ridxc wliw niwwcr de `}ce
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 197/206
h`srw" ieg xl`sbg asirg iaidexw iet }`xxdodbdwt `f gchdgdea `e i }`dew `f qldhl wlc
`wlcr xdgc lix lig e` e`wdhc%9
@e wlc `wlcr lieg" df i }irwt bdwdaiew lix i hixc qldhl
i}}cirx w` oc }bidebt drrcbcview" dw dx wl`salw wliw wlcrc dx e` gswt `e i jsgac w` `ffcr
iet xsaacxwd`ex ix w` l`q dw ndalw oc nigc rcbcview% Wlc }irwt bdwdaiew nsxw xdn}bt
fihc wlc h`excyscehcx `f i fidbsrc w` xwiwc i rcbcview hixc% Wliw dx wlc `swh`nc `f ie
igvcrxirdib xtxwcn `f bdwdaiwd`e; ieg wlcrc dx e` rcix`e qlt i }irwt bdwdaiew xl`sbg oc
advce igviewiacx qldhl q`sbg e`w oc ividbiobc w` i bdwdaiew ql` qix }r`fcxxd`eibbt
rc}rcxcewcg%
9 Kit—x Wsw`r v Itrxldrc ieg Irrie Lcibwl O`irg 94<3 X%B%W% 783" 77=%
,6$ Wlc jsgancew `r gchdxd`e
Qlcrc i jsgancew `r gchdxd`e dx advce iw wlc ceg `f i lcirdea" de wlc }rcxcehc `f i
}irwt bdwdaiew" wlc jsgac xl`sbg wikc }irwdhsbir hirc w` c|}rcxx dw de xdn}bc" cvcrtgit"
bieasiac; ieg" df dw dx echcxxirt w` sxc wchledhib bcaib wcrnx" wlc nciedea `f wlcn
xl`sbg oc hbcirbt c|}bidecg w` wlc }irwt bdwdaiew% Df wlc gchdxd`e rcysdrcx wlc }irwt
bdwdaiew w` g` x`ncwldea ,f`r c|in}bc" w` fdeg hiswd`e f`r fswsrc c|}cexcx$ wlc
xdaedfdhiehc `f wliw xl`sbg oc fsbbt c|}bidecg" ieg wlc }irwt bdwdaiew xl`sbg oc qirecg
`f wlc bdkcbt h`excyscehcx `f fidbsrc w` h`n}bt qdwl qliw lix occe `rgcrcg ot wlc
h`srw% Df wlc gchdxd`e de i hixc dev`bvdea i }irwt bdwdaiew dx w` oc wikce w` ivdziegsn"
wlc jsgac xl`sbg c|}bide de xdn}bc wcrnx wliw i qrdwwce jsgancew qdbb oc dxxscg iw i
biwcr xwiac h`ewidedea wlc gchdxd`e ieg wlc rcix`ex f`r dw% Dw dx ibx` bdkcbt w` oc lcb}fsb
f`r i }irwt bdwdaiew df wlc jsgac hie advc x`nc degdhiwd`e iw wliw xwiac `f wlc giwc qlce
wlc qrdwwce jsgancew dx bdkcbt w` oc dxxscg% Sebcxx `wlcrqdxc `rgcrcg" H`srw `f
Xcxxd`e jsgancewx irc dxxscg qdwl`sw wlc echcxxdwt `f wlc iwwcegiehc `f h`sexcb" `r i
x`bdhdw`r" `r i }irwt% I hbcrk `f xcxxd`e qdbb" qlcrc }`xxdobc" advc e`wdhc `f wlc giwcqlce ie `}ded`e dx w` oc dxxscg ,sxsibbt wq` gitx de igviehc$" ieg i h`}t `f wlc
`}ded`e nit oc h`bbchwcg `e `r ifwcr wlc giwc `f dxxsc fr`n wlc @}ded`ex gcxk gsrdea
`ffdhc l`srx" `e }itncew `f wlc }rcxhrdocg fcc% Df }`xxdobc" ie cbchwr`edh h`}t `f wlc
`}ded`e qdbb oc c.nidbcg w` }irwdcx `e wlc giwc `f dxxsc% De wlc xlcrdff h`srw i h`}t `f i
jsgancew dx isw`niwdhibbt xcew w` i }irwt" frcc `f hlirac" `e wlc giwc qlce dw dx dxxscg%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 198/206
C|}cexcx iqirgcg de fiv`sr `f }irwt bdwdaiewx
9?%?1 Qlcrc i }irwt bdwdaiew dx xshhcxxfsb de wlc h`srxc `f bdwdaiwd`e" ie iqirg `f
c|}cexcx nit oc nigc de ldx `r lcr fiv`sr de wlc xinc qit ix df wlcrc lig occe bcaib
rc}rcxcewiwd`e% De xshl i hixc" l`qcvcr" qdwl i }`xxdobc c|hc}wd`e `f i }rihwdxdea
x`bdhdw`r ql` lix i}}circg `e ldx `qe oclibf `r `e oclibf `f ldx fdrn9" iet xshl
iqirg `f c|}cexcx qdbb oc a`vcrecg ot wlc }r`vdxd`ex `f wlc Bdwdaiewx de ]crx`e
,H`xwx ieg C|}cexcx$ Ihw 9413%?
Cxxcewdibbt" qliw wliw Ihw" ieg wlc rcbcview Ihw `f
Xcgcrsew" }r`vdgc dx wliw" de iggdwd`e w` `swbitx" i }irwt bdwdaiew nit oc cewdwbcg w`
c|}cexcx s} w` i ni|dnsn `f wq` wldrgx `f wlc xsn ibb`qiobc w` i x`bdhdw`r f`r wlc
q`rk de yscxwd`e segcr wlc i}}r`}rdiwc wiobc `f fccx% Wliw g`cx e`w i}}bt" l`qcvcr" de
wlc hixc `f i xnibb hbidn ihwd`e sebcxx ie `rgcr lix occe nigc f`r c|}cexcx w` oc
ixxcxxcg e wlc xhibc i}}r`}rdiwc w` xsnnirt hisxc ihwd`ex%8
9 Xcc }iri% 9?%7" f``we`wc ?" io`vc%
? Xcc" ibx`" Ihw `f Xcgcrsew ,C|}cexcx `f ]irwt Bdwdaiewx$ 9416 ,X%D% 941696=6$" incegcg ot
Ihw `f Xcgcrsew ,C|}cexcx `f ]irwt Bdwdaiewx$ 94<8 ,X%D% 94<8978<$%
8 E`rnibbt e` c|}cexcx nit oc iqirgcg de i xnibb hbidn de qldhl wlc vibsc `f wlc hbidn g`cx
e`w c|hccg ¨?==" ieg de iet `wlcr hixc c|}cexcx irc e`w w` c|hccg ¨13 ,Xnibb Hbidnx
,Xh`wbieg$ @rgcr 94<< ,X%D% 94<<9444$" }iri% 7$% De hcrwide bdndwcg hdrhsnxwiehcx" l`qcvcr"
c|}cexcx `e wlc xsnnirt hisxc xhibc nit oc iqirgcg ,Xlcrdff H`srwx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9419" x%
86O,8$$%
9?%?< I }irwt bdwdaiew" ql` lix `owidecg i gchrcc `r `wlcr `rgcr de ldx `r lcr fiv`sr"
nit e`w rcibdxc wliw lc dx cewdwbcg w` nikc i f`rnib n`wd`e f`r c|}cexcx% Dw dx wl`salw
wliw de xshl hdrhsnxwiehcx dw q`sbg oc }crfchwbt }r`}cr f`r wlc jsgac w` igvdxc wlc
}irwt bdwdaiew `f wlc cewdwbcncew w` xcck ie iqirg `f c|}cexcx" ieg w` ixk df xshl ieiqirg dx x`salw% De xshl i xdwsiwd`e wlc jsgac q`sbg oc g`dea e` n`rc wlie }r`vdgdea
wlc }irwt bdwdaiew qdwl def`rniwd`e qldhl q`sbg oc qcbb ke`qe w` cdwlcr h`sexcb `r i
x`bdhdw`r%
Cef`rhcncew `f gchrccx
9?%?4 ]irwt bdwdaiewx ql` livc `owidecg i gchrcc de wlcdr fiv`sr" f`r c|in}bc f`r
}itncew `f i xsn `f n`ect" irc `fwce xsr}rdxcg w` gdxh`vcr wliw" df }itncew segcr wlc
gchrcc dx e`w nigc v`bsewirdbt ot wlc `wlcr }irwt" dw qdbb oc f`r wlcn w` dexwdwswc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 199/206
cef`rhcncew }r`hcgsrcx wlcnxcbvcx" ieg iw wlcdr `qe c|}cexc% Dw dx wl`salw wliw dw dx
seechcxxirt f`r jsgacx w` }`dew wldx `sw iw wlc xwiac `f ariewdea gchrcc" osw hbcrkx `f
h`srw xl`sbg oc }rc}ircg w` advc wldx def`rniwd`e `e rcyscxw%
I}}cibx
9?%8= Qlcrc i hixc lix occe gchdgcg iaidexw i }irwt bdwdaiew ot fdeib gchrcc `r
jsgancew" ie i}}cib dx e`rnibbt ividbiobc" ieg wlc }irwt bdwdaiew qdbb oc iobc w` `owide
def`rniwd`e io`sw l`q w` i}}cib fr`n wlc hbcrk `f h`srw%
Df i gchdxd`e dx advce iaidexw i }irwt bdwdaiew" l`qcvcr" `e x`nc dehdgcewib `r
dewcrb`hsw`rt niwwcr" de rcx}chw `f qldhl bcivc w` i}}cib dx rcysdrcg" wlc }irwt bdwdaiew
nit e`w och`nc iqirc `f wlc eccg w` xcck bcivc sewdb wlc wdnc f`r xcckdea bcivc lix
c|}drcg% Dw dx wlcrcf`rc xsaacxwcg wliw" df xshl i gchdxd`e dx advce" ieg df wlc }irwt
bdwdaiew dx `ovd`sxbt seli}}t qdwl wlc gchdxd`e" wlc jsgac xl`sbg wlcrc ieg wlce
degdhiwc wliw ie i}}cib iaidexw wliw gchdxd`e nit `ebt oc wikce qdwl bcivc" ieg ixk wlc
}irwt bdwdaiew df bcivc w` i}}cib dx ocdea x`salw% De xshl i xdwsiwd`e wlc jsgac qdbb e`
g`sow qdxl w` nikc dw hbcir wliw wlc advdea `f wliw def`rniwd`e g`cx e`w dn}bt wliw
bcivc w` i}}cib qdbb decvdwiobt oc ariewcg: wlc }irwt bdwdaiew dx ncrcbt ocdea igvdxcg
`f wlc cewdwbcncew w` xcck bcivc%
Vc|iwd`sx bdwdaiewx
9?%89 Segcr xchwd`e 9 `f wlc Vc|iwd`sx Bdwdaiewx ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9<4<" i Gdvdxd`e `f
wlc H`srw `f Xcxxd`e" `e ie i}}bdhiwd`e nigc ot wlc B`rg Igv`hiwc" nit gchbirc i
}crx`e w` oc i vc|iwd`sx bdwdaiew `e wlc ar`seg wliw wliw }crx`e lix liodwsibbt ieg
}crxdxwcewbt dexwdwswcg vc|iwd`sx bcaib }r`hccgdeax qdwl`sw iet rcix`eiobc ar`segx f`r
g`dea x`% Qlce xshl i gchbiriwd`e lix occe nigc" wlc }crx`e h`ehcrecg nit e`w
wlcrcifwcr ridxc iet bcaib }r`hccgdeax sebcxx bcivc lix occe `owidecg fr`n i jsgac
xdwwdea de wlc @swcr L`sxc% Xshl gchbiriwd`ex irc nigc `ebt defrcyscewbt% Wlcrc dx e`
nciex `f }r`ldodwdea i }crx`e fr`n gcfcegdea ie ihwd`e qldhl lix occe ridxcg iaidexw
ldn `r lcr%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 200/206
SE_C]_CXCEWCG IHHSXCG DE H_DNDEIB HIXCX
Acecrib
9?%8? Ochisxc `f wlc ividbiodbdwt `f hrdndeib bcaib idg dw dx rcbiwdvcbt seh`nn`e f`r}crx`ex w` rc}rcxcew wlcnxcbvcx de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax `wlcr wlie de rcx}chw `f vcrt
nde`r `ffcehcx; osw `hhixd`eibbt jsgacx nit ceh`sewcr ihhsxcg }crx`ex ql`" f`r
qliwcvcr rcix`e" cbchw w` rc}rcxcew wlcnxcbvcx%9
De x`nc dexwiehcx ie ihhsxcg nit oc rc}rcxcewcg iw wlc ocadeedea `f i wrdib osw nit
qdwlgriq dexwrshwd`ex fr`n ldx h`sexcb `r x`bdhdw`r de wlc h`srxc `f wlc wrdib%
E`rnibbt" de xshl i xdwsiwd`e" i ordcf igj`srencew xl`sbg oc ibb`qcg de `rgcr w`
ceiobc wlc ihhsxcg w` xchsrc ecq rc}rcxcewiwd`e% Dw dx e`w seke`qe" l`qcvcr" f`r ie
ihhsxcg }crx`e w` ‒ldrc ieg fdrc„ i xshhcxxd`e `f rc}rcxcewiwdvcx" ieg dw dx wlcrcf`rc
xsaacxwcg wliw wlcrc nsxw h`nc i }`dew qlce i jsgac dx fsbbt cewdwbcg w` xit wliw
ce`sal dx ce`sal" ieg wliw wlcrcifwcr wlc ihhsxcg nsxw }r`hccg qdwl`sw
rc}rcxcewiwd`e%?
Nshl `f qliw lix ibrcigt occe xidg de rcbiwd`e w` }irwt bdwdaiewx de
hdvdb }r`hccgdeax i}}bdcx cysibbt de wlc hixc `f wl`xc }crx`ex ql`" f`r qliwcvcr
rcix`e" hl` xc w` gcfceg wlcnxcbvcx de hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax% Wlcrc irc x`nc x}chdib
fciwsrcx `f hrdndeib }r`hccgdeax qldhl rcysdrc }irwdhsbir ncewd`e%
9I }crx`e hliracg qdwl i xc|sib `ffcehc nit e`w" l`qcvcr" rc}rcxcew ldnxcbf: xcc }iri%
9?%8<" ocb`q%
? De xshl i xdwsiwd`e" `f h`srxc" gsc rcairg nsxw oc lig w` CHL_" irw% 6,8$,h$% Dw dx wl`salw"
l`qcvcr" wliw wlcrc dx sebdkcbt w` oc iet orcihl `f wliw irwdhbc }r`vdgcg wliw ie ihhsxcg }crx`e
lix occe advce i rcix`eiobc `}}`rwsedwt w` xchsrc bcaib rc}rcxcewiwd`e `f ldx `qe hl``xdea%
C|}bieiwd`e w` serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg
9?%88 Iw wlc vcrt ocadeedea `f i wrdib dw q`sbg oc i}}r`}rdiwc w` gcxhrdoc w` wlc
serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg wlc }r`hcgsrc wliw qdbb oc f`bb`qcg dehbsgdea:
wlc e`rnib `rgcr `f c|indeiwd`e de hldcf" hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e ieg rc.
c|indeiwd`e;
wliw lc nit oc iobc w` `ojchw w` wlc igndxxd`e `f iet cvdgcehc; ieg
n`xw `f wlc niwwcrx h`vcrcg de }iriari}l 9?%?9" io`vc%
Iw wlc hb`xc `f wlc Hr`qe hixc" wlc serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg xl`sbg oc ixkcg:
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 201/206
qlcwlcr lc qdxlcx w` nikc i xsondxxd`e `f e` hixc w` iexqcr;
qlcwlcr lc qdxlcx w` advc cvdgcehc }crx`eibbt" de qldhl hixc lc nit oc hr`xx.
c|indecg; ieg
qlcwlcr lc qdxlcx w` hibb iet gcfcehc qdwecxxcx%
Qlce ibb cvdgcehc lix occe bcg" lc xl`sbg oc rcndegcg wliw lc qdbb oc advce ie
`}}`rwsedwt w` iggrcxx wlc jsgac" de i xsnnirt wrdib" `e wlc cvdgcehc" `r wlc jsrt de
x`bcne }r`hccgdeax%
]r`wchwdea wlc dewcrcxwx `f wlc ihhsxcg
9?%87 ]r`oiobt wlc n`xw dn}`rwiew fciwsrc irdxcx fr`n wlc fihw wliw" de hrdndeib
}r`hccgdeax" ie ihhsxcg }crx`e dx }rcxsncg w` oc dee`hcew sebcxx ieg sewdb asdbw lix
occe }r`vcg oct`eg rcix`eiobc g`sow `e wlc oixdx `f xsffdhdcew" h`rr`o`riwcg"
cvdgcehc% Ihh`rgdeabt" qlcrc ie serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg wcegcrx i }bci `f asdbwt" i
jsgac nsxw wikc xwc}x w` cexsrc wliw wlcrc dx i fsbb segcrxwiegdea `f wlc hlirac `r
hliracx" ieg wliw wlc ihhsxcg dx frccbt ieg wrsbt ihke`qbcgadea asdbw% N`rc`vcr"
qlcrc i hixc a`cx w` wrdib" dw dx xsaacxwcg wliw wlc jsgac nsxw wikc ihwdvc xwc}x w` ixxdxw
wlc ihhsxcg de }rcxcewdea ldx `r lcr gcfcehc% Wliw qdbb }irwdhsbirbt oc x` de i jsrt
wrdib" qlcrc dw qdbb oc wlc gswt `f wlc wrdib jsgac w` cexsrc wliw ie serc}rcxcewcg
ihhsxcg—x }`xdwd`e de rcbiwd`e w` wlc cvdgcehc ieg wlc hliracx" de x` fir ix wliw hie oc
gcwcrndecg" lix occe fidrbt ieg igcysiwcbt }sw ocf`rc wlc jsrt% Wliw nit livc w` oc
gcibw qdwl de wlc jsgac—x hlirac w` wlc jsrt%
9?%83 Wlc jsgac lix i gswt segcr Irwdhbc 6 `f wlc CHL_ w` cexsrc `vcribb wliw wlc
wrdib dx h`egshwcg fidrbt% Dw dx xsaacxwcg" l`qcvcr" wliw dw dx e` }irw `f i jsgac—x gswt"
de i wrdib qlcrc ie ihhsxcg dx serc}rcxcewcg" w` dewcrvcec de wlc h`srxc `f wlc cvdgcehc
de `rgcr w` wikc }`dewx `r `ojchwd`ex qldhl ndalw livc occe wikce lig wlc ihhsxcg
occe rc}rcxcewcg ot h`sexcb `r ot i x`bdhdw`r% Df cvdgcehc dx advce de wlc h`srxc `f i
wrdib `e i niwwcr qldhl" df `ojchwcg w`" ndalw rcysdrc wlcrc w` oc i wrdib qdwlde i wrdib"9
wlc jsgac xl`sbg h`exdgcr qlcwlcr w` dewcrrs}w wlc }r`hccgdeax de `rgcr w` ixhcrwide
qlcwlcr `r e`w hdrhsnxwiehcx c|dxw qldhl q`sbg nikc xshl i }r`hcgsrc echcxxirt% De
wlc xinc qit" df ie serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg g`cx e`w nikc iet n`wd`e `f e` hixc w`
iexqcr iw wlc h`ehbsxd`e `f wlc Hr`qe hixc qlcrc dw ndalw oc i}}r`}rdiwc w` g` x`" dw
q`sbg" dw dx wl`salw" oc i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc wrdib jsgac w` h`exdgcr qlcwlcr w` devdwc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 202/206
ldn w` g` x` ieg w` ridxc qdwl Hr`qe H`sexcb `r wlc }r`hsriw`r fdxhib yscxwd`e `f wlc
xsffdhdceht f wlc Hr`qe cvdgcehc%
9 Wl`n}x`e v Hr`qc ?=== J%H% 918%
Hrdndeib rch`rg `f ihhsxcg
9?%86 Dw dx }r`oiobt seechcxxirt" ieg nit degccg oc segcxdriobc" wliw wlc jsgac
xl`sbg iw iet xwiac `f wlc }r`hccgdeax igvdxc wlc ihhsxcg `f wlc hdrhsnxwiehcx de
qldhl wlc }r`xchsw`r ndalw oc }crndwwcg w` gdxhb`xc wlc ihhsxcg—x `qe hrdndeib
rch`rg" df iet%9
Df ie serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg" l`qcvcr" ocadex" gsrdea wlc h`srxc `f i
wrdib" w` ixk yscxwd`ex" `r w` bcig cvdgcehc" `f i kdeg qldhl ndalw }crndw wlc
}r`xchsw`r w` xcck bcivc w` gdxhb`xc wlc ihhsxcg—x rch`rg" dw dx xsaacxwcg wliw wlc jsgac
xl`sbg dewcrvcec iw wliw xwiac de `rgcr w` igvdxc wlc ihhsxcg `f wlc }`xxdobc
h`excyscehcx `f h`ewdesdea wliw bdec `f yscxwd`edea `r cvdgcehc%
9 Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" x% ?1=% Acecribbt" wldx xchwd`e i}}bdcx qlcrc
cvdgcehc dx bcg ot wlc gcfcehc" `r wlc gcfcehc ixkx yscxwd`ex `f i qdwecxx f`r wlc }r`xchswd`e"
qdwl i vdcq w` cxwiobdxldea wlc ihhsxcg—x a``g hlirihwcr `r dn}saedea wlc hlirihwcr `f wlc
}r`xchsw`r" `f iet qdwecxx f`r wlc }r`xchswd`e `r `f wlc h n}bidecr% Dw ibx` i}}bdcx qlcrc wlc
eiwsrc `r h`egshw `f wlc gcfcehc dx xshl ix w` wceg w` cxwiobdxl iet `f wlc f`rca`dea% Qlcrc
wlc xchwd`e i}}bdcx wlc h`srw nit" `e wlc i}}bdhiwd`e `f wlc }r`xchsw`r" }crndw wlc }r`xchsw`r w`
bcig cvdgcehc wliw wlc ihhsxcg lix h`nndwwcg" `r lix occe h`evdhwcg `f" `r lix occe hliracg
qdwl" `ffcehcx `wlcr wlie wliw f`r qldhl lc dx ocdea wrdcg" `r dx `f oig hlirihwcr% De
}r`hccgdeax `e degdhwncew ie i}}bdhiwd`e ot wlc }r`xchsw`r nsxw oc nigc de wlc ioxcehc `f
wlc jsrt%
]r`wchwdea wlc dewcrcxwx `f qdwecxxcx
9?%81 Dw dx e`w seke`qe f`r serc}rcxcewcg ihhsxcg w` i}}r`ihl wlc yscxwd`edea `f
qdwecxxcx9" ieg }irwdhsbirbt h`n}bidecrx" de ie iaarcxxdvc ieg `ffcexdvc qit qldhl dx
ysdwc seqirriewcg ieg qldhl dx ncrcbt dewcegcg w` lsndbdiwc ieg w` wrisniwdxc wlc
qdwecxx% I jsgac nsxw" `f h`srxc" oc ndegfsb `f ie ihhsxcg }crx`e—x cewdwbcncew w`
wcxw wlc cvdgcehc ot nciex `f hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e" ieg ihh`rgdeabt hirc nsxw oc wikce
wliw iet dewcrvcewd`e dx e`w bdkcbt w` bcig w` wlc }`xxdodbdwt `f i xsoxcyscew h`evdhwd`e
ocdea wlcrcifwcr ysixlcg `e i}}cib% @e wlc `wlcr lieg" i jsgac lix i gswt w` }r`wchw
h`n}bidecrx ieg `wlcr qdwecxxcx fr`n yscxwd`edea qldhl a`cx qcbb oct`eg qliw dx
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 203/206
i}}r`}rdiwc f`r wlc }sr}`xc `f wcxwdea `r hlibbceadea wlcdr cvdgcehc% Wldx dx i
}irwdhsbirbt gdffdhsbw irci" osw jsgacx nsxw g` wlcdr ocxw w` ihw de i advce hixc de i
nieecr qldhl qdbb cexsrc wliw wlct g` e`w }rcjsgdhc ie ihhsxcg }crx`e—x rdalw w` i fidr
wrdib qldbc xwdbb ocdea }rc}ircg w` dewcrvcec ix echcxxirt de wlc dewcrcxwx `f i
h`n}bidecr `r `wlcr qdwecxx%
9 Osw xcc wlc }r`ldodwd`e de xc|sib `ffcehc hixcx: gcibw qdwl de }iri% 9?%8<" ocb`q%
Xc|sib `ffcehcx
9?%8< ]irwbt ochisxc `f xcrd`sx h`ehcrex de rcbiwd`e w` hixcx qlcrc serc}rcxcewcg
ihhsxcg }crx`ex wlcnxcbvcx h`egshwcg wlc hr`xx.c|indeiwd`e `f h`n}bidecrx ieg
`wlcr qdwecxxcx de xc|sib `ffcehc hixcx" wlc Xh`wwdxl ]irbdincew }ixxcg wlc Xc|sib
@ffcehcx ,]r`hcgsrc ieg Cvdgcehc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==?% Wlc cffchw `f wliw
bcadxbiwd`e dx wliw ie ihhsxcg nit e`w }crx`eibbt h`egshw ldx gcfcehc `r iet }irw `f dw
de rcbiwd`e w` i hlirac `f i xc|sib `ffcehc%9
Wlc h`srw nsxw i}}`dew i x`bdhdw`r qlcrc
wlc ihhsxcg lix e`w ceaiacg `ec" gdxndxxcg i x`bdhdw`r" `r wlc x`bdhdw`r lix qdwlgriqe"
sebcxx wlc ihhsxcg dewcegx w` ceaiac ie`wlcr x`bdhdw`r% I x`bdhdw`r i}}`dewcg ot wlc
h`srw nit e`w oc gdxndxxcg ot wlc ihhsxcg" ieg dx e`w `obdacg w` h`n}bt qdwl ie
dexwrshwd`e w` gdxndxx h`sexcb%?
9Xchwd`e ?<<H `f wlc Hrdndeib ]r`hcgsrc ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw 9443" dexcrwcg ot x% ? `f wlc ?==?
Ihw%
?9443 Ihw" x% ?<<G" dexcrwcg ot x% ? `f wlc ?==? Ihw% Xcc ibx` }iri% 99%9?" io`vc" ieg JXH
ordcfdea }i}cr ‒Xc|sib @ffcehcx ,]r`hcgsrc ieg Cvdgcehc$ ,Xh`wbieg$ Ihw ?==?„%
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 204/206
X@S_HC NIWC_DIB
Xnibb Hbidnx
Qliw dx i Xnibb Hbidn ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
Wikdea i Hbidn w` H`srw ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
_cx}`egdea w` i Hbidn ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
A`dea w` H`srw ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
Xsnnirt Hisxcx
Qliw dx i Xsnnirt Hisxc ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
_idxdea ie Ihwd`e ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc_cx}`egdea w` i Xsnn`ex ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
A`dea w` H`srw ‘ def`rniwd`e ieg }r`hcgsrib asdgc" Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 205/206
I}}cegd| D
H@EXSBWIWD@E ]_@HCXX f`r wlc XCH@EG CGDWD@E
Iw vird`sx xwiacx de wlc h`srxc `f grifwdea wlc xch`eg cgdwd`e" wlc segcre`wcg qcrc
h`exsbwcg:
Hr`qe @ffdhc
Vdhwdn Xs}}`rw Xh`wbieg
Cysibdwt Ecwq`rk
H`nndxxd`e f`r Cysibdwt ieg Lsnie _dalwx
H`nndxxd`e f`r _ihdib Cysibdwt
Xh`wwdxl H`srw Xcrvdhc
Wlc Xh`wwdxl C|chswdvc ieg wlc Xh`wwdxl A`vcrencew
7/30/2019 Equal Treatment Bench Book (Scotland) (2008)
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/equal-treatment-bench-book-scotland-2008 206/206
I}}cegd| DD
NCNOC_XLD] @F Q@_KDEA ]I_WT
Ncnocrxld} `f wlc Jsgdhdib Xwsgdcx H`nndwwcc f`r Xh`wbieg—x Q`rkdea ]irwt `e
Cysib Wrciwncew ‘ Xch`eg cgdwd`e
,de ib}liocwdhib `rgcr $:
Xlcrdff F% _% Hr`qc" Cgdeosral ,Gdrchw`r `f Jsgdhdib Xwsgdcx$