equivocation, accent, distinction without a difference, quoting out of context ambiguity fallacies

8
Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Upload: claire-carroll

Post on 02-Jan-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Equivocation,Accent,

Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context

Ambiguity fallacies

Page 2: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Equivocation

• The fallacy of equivocation is committed when a term is used in two or more different senses within a single argument.

• Also know as: homonym

Page 3: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Example

• All banks are beside rivers. • Therefore, the financial institution where I

deposit my money is beside a river.

Page 4: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Distinction without a difference

• The assertion that a position is different from another position based on the language when, in fact, both positions are exactly the same -- at least in practice or practical terms.

• Exception: sometimes there can be minute differences with degrees of meaning or measurement

Page 5: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

• Bre: What is the difference between a dodge challenger and a Chevy corvette?

• Chandler: Six and one half- dozen.

Page 6: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Accent

• fallacies that depend on where the stress is placed in a word or sentence.

• AKA: sarcasm• Mr. Trubitt’s opinion: Sarcasm is not a bad

thing; except when it is overdone.

Page 7: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Example

• John: I heard Ethan jumped off a bridge• Mr. Trubitt: Yeah I could imagine Ethan

jumping off a bridge.

Page 8: Equivocation, Accent, Distinction Without a Difference, Quoting out of Context Ambiguity fallacies

Quote out of Context