errata to the kahler final eisa123.g.akamai.net/7/123/11558/abc123/forestservic... · 2016. 6....

Errata to the Kahler Final EIS Clarification to the Fisheries Section of the Final EIS The effects to fisheries were inadvertently omitted from the final EIS that was printed and distributed to interested and affected parties on February 5, 2016. Affects analysis was included in the Fisheries report that was also distributed at the time of publication of the final EIS. This report was available as Appendix C in Volume 2 of the final EIS. Because the Fisheries Report was circulated as part of an appendix to the final EIS and contains adequate information regarding direct, indirect, and cumulative effects the forest decided to republish Volume 1 of the final EIS to include this information to improve overall readability of the final EIS. The re-printed final EIS will have the same information that was presented in the Appendix C-Fisheries Report that was published in Volume 2 of the final EIS.

Clarification to Appendix M and Wildlife Section in the final EIS Table 3-10 in the Chapter 3 and Table W-32 in the Appendix M of the final EIS lists the Region 6 Sensitive Species with a potential to occur on the Umatilla National Forest and within the Kahler Analysis Area. In this table it is identified that the North America wolverine habitat occurs in the Kahler Analysis area. Although there is potential foraging habitat within the Kahler analysis area there is no potential natal denning habitat present in or near the analysis area. Contiguous subalpine forest types, backcountry (wilderness, Inventoried Roadless, Scenic Areas, and potential wilderness) habitat, open rocky slopes at high elevations, and sufficient snow cover for natal denning do not occur in the Kahler project area. Potential foraging habitat is present in the analysis area and was identified in Tables W-32 and 3-10. These stands are relatively small and disconnected from one another due to past activities and the broken nature (timbered draws and open ridges) of the analysis area. For these reasons, habitat quality is considered poor. The wolverine is not currently known to occur in the Kahler analysis area; there have been no sightings of this species in the area. Based on the quality and quantity of potential poor quality foraging habitat, the transportation system in the Kahler area, and the distance from suitable subalpine and backcountry habitats, it is very unlikely that wolverine would pass through the Kahler area. For the following reasons no further analysis of effects for the North American wolverine was included in the final EIS or Appendices:

- the wolverine was not on the preliminary species list provided by the US Fish and Wildlife Service identifying ESA listed, candidate, and proposed species;

- is not known to occur in the area; - there is no potential natal denning habitat; - no low disturbance higher-elevation backcountry habitat; and - only limited low quality foraging habitat is present in the analysis area

Re-Printing and Minor Changes Made to the Final EIS to Improve Readability During the Objection Response period the Forest and Regional Office agreed to re-print the final EIS with minor corrections to referencing the correct Appendix, Table, and page numbers; and punctuation, spelling, and grammar to improve readability. We copied the effects analysis from Appendix C into the Chapter 4 Fisheries section of the final EIS (see Fisheries Section, Chapter 4, pages 77 to 84) to correct an error in the previous EIS. No changes were made to Appendix C.

Missing Maps in Volume 2 of the Final EIS from Appendix J: Travel Action Plan Within the Travel Action Plan several maps did not print correctly, leaving blank pages with the map legend, but no map. These maps included:

- Map 2: Existing Transportation System (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 345) - Map 3: Kahler Access and Travel Management Alternative 2 (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 349) - Map 4: Kahler Access and Travel Management Alternative 3 (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 350) - Map 5: Kahler Access and Travel Management Alternative 4 (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 351) - Map 6: Value Risk Category (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 363) - Map 7: Haul Routes Alternative 2 (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 381) - Map 8: Haul Routes Alternative 3 (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 386) - Map 9: Haul Routes Alternative 4 (Appendix J, Volume 2 page 391)

These maps are included in Appendix A of this errata.

Clarification to Volume 4 of the Final EIS (Appendix P: Response to Comments) This appendix is a summary of public comments received on the Kahler draft EIS. The Umatilla National Forest published a legal notice of the draft EIS for review and public comment on October 10, 2014. Comments were requested within 45 days of publication of the legal notice. All comments received during the 45-day period have been reviewed and responses are included herein.

A total of 18 comment letters and emails were received from 17 interested and affected individuals. The letter numbers, names of respondents, and information on attachments to comments letters are displayed in Table 1.

Comment documents were tracked upon receipt using the Comment Analysis and Response Application (CARA) to assure all comments were captured. Individual comments from within each document were categorized based on the comment topic. The exact wording of comments were used to identify unique comments. Comments were then grouped based on comment subject and responded to.

Table 1: Concern Response by Letter Number and Commenter

Letter #

Date Received

Last Name Organization Comment Number

1 11/14/2014 Artley, Dick Individual 37, 38, 39, 41, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 119, 122, 132, 134, 135, 136, 137, 138, 144, 157, 158, 159, 160, 164, 166, 167, 168, 170, 186, 187, 190, 191, 192, 193, 194, 195, 196, 197, 199, 201, 202, 204, 208, 213, 244, 245, 263, 418, 419, 421, 422, 447, 457, 458, 461, 471, 472, 480, 482, 483, 484, 485, 486, 487, 488, 489, 490, 491, 492, 493, 494, 495, 496, 497, 498, 499, 512, 520, 521, 522, 523, 524, 525, 526, 527, 528, 529, 530, 531, 532, 533, 534, 535, 536, 537, 538, 539, 540, 541, 542, 543, 544, 545, 546, 547, 613

2 11/19/2014 Warness, Lindsay

Boise Cascade 4, 5, 7, 26, 54, 55, 57, 59, 64, 65, 66, 120, 127, 473, 479, 548

3 11/24/2014 St. Martin, Amanda

Individual 1, 10, 11, 67, 68, 116, 123, 173, 200, 203, 262, 549, 550, 551

Letter #

Date Received


4 11/18/2014 Coulter, Karen

Blue Mountains Diversity Project

3, 6, 14, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 27, 31, 32, 34, 35, 40, 56, 58, 78, 79, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 99, 100, 101, 102, 104, 107, 108, 113, 117, 118, 125, 126, 128, 133, 152, 162, 182, 189, 259, 265, 315, 415, 507, 508, 509, 552, 553, 554, 555, 556, 557, 558, 559, 560, 612

5 11/25/2014 Solomon, Laurie

Individual 1, 2, 11, 28, 29, 30, 124, 149, 561

6 11/25/2014 Vandehey, Roberta

Individual 8, 9, 60, 61, 62, 63, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 80, 94, 95, 97, 98, 121, 154, 156, 161, 205, 209, 214, 397, 469, 470, 562, 617, 618, 619, 620, 621, 622, 623, 635

7 11/20/2014 Henning, Blake

Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation

33, 36, 448, 449, 450, 451

8 12/01/2014 McClure, Steve

Union County Board of Commissioners

4, 75, 76, 77, 96, 180, 183, 198, 434, 459, 466, 501, 563, 564, 565, 566

10 12/08/2014 Vandehey, Mike

Individual 155, 454

12 12/06/2014 Public, Jean

Individual 567

13 12/26/2014 Kelley, Brian

Hells Canyon Preservation Council (HCPC)

12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 21, 93, 103, 105, 106, 109, 110, 111, 112, 114, 115, 129, 130, 131, 150, 151, 184, 185, 313, 463, 464, 474, 481, 568, 569, 570, 571, 572, 573, 574, 575, 576

14 12/23/2014 Heiken, Doug

Oregon Wild 40, 145, 146, 147, 148, 153, 165, 171, 172, 173, 174, 175, 176, 177, 178, 179, 207, 215, 332, 398, 400, 401, 404, 416, 432, 433, 462, 465, 577, 578, 579, 580, 581, 582, 583, 627

15 12/29/2014 Jerome, Irene

American Forest Research Council

139, 140, 141, 142, 169, 188, 247, 328, 446, 455, 584, 585, 586, 587, 588, 589, 590, 591, 592, 593, 649

16 12/29/2014 Storm, Rex Associated Oregon Loggers

143, 163, 206, 246, 467, 468, 594, 595, 596, 597, 598, 599

17 11/28/2014 Davidson, Mark

Union County Board of Commissioners

18 12/26/2014 Reichgott, Christine

EPA 181, 236, 475, 600, 601

Letter #

Date Received


19 12/01/2014 Coulter, Karen

Blue Mountains Diversity Project

81, 210, 211, 212, 216, 217, 218, 219, 220, 221, 222, 223, 224, 225, 226, 227, 228, 229, 230, 231, 232, 233, 234, 235, 237, 238, 239, 240, 241, 242, 243, 248, 249, 250, 251, 252, 253, 254, 255, 256, 257, 258, 260, 261, 264, 266, 267, 268, 269, 270, 271, 272, 273, 274, 275, 276, 277, 278, 279, 280, 281, 282, 283, 284, 285, 286, 287, 288, 289, 290, 291, 292, 293, 294, 295, 296, 297, 298, 299, 300, 301, 302, 303, 304, 305, 306, 307, 308, 309, 310, 311, 312, 314, 316, 317, 318, 319, 320, 321, 322, 323, 324, 325, 326, 327, 329, 330, 331, 333, 334, 335, 336, 337, 338, 339, 340, 341, 342, 343, 344, 345, 346, 349, 350, 351, 352, 353, 354, 355, 356, 357, 358, 359, 360, 361, 362, 363, 364, 365, 366, 367, 368, 369, 370, 371, 372, 373, 374, 375, 376, 377, 378, 379, 380, 381, 382, 383, 384, 385, 386, 387, 388, 389, 390, 391, 392, 393, 394, 395, 396, 399, 402, 403, 405, 406, 407, 408, 409, 410, 411, 412, 413, 414, 417, 420, 423, 424, 425, 426, 427, 428, 429, 430, 431, 435, 436, 437, 438, 439, 440, 441, 442, 443, 444, 445, 452, 453, 456, 460, 476, 477, 478, 500, 502, 503, 504, 505, 506, 510, 511, 513, 514, 515, 516, 517, 518, 519, 602, 603, 604, 605, 606, 607, 608, 609, 610, 611, 614, 615, 616, 624, 625, 626, 628, 629, 630, 631, 632, 633, 634, 636, 637, 638, 639, 640, 641, 642, 643, 644, 645, 646, 647, 648, 650

Comments were grouped with similar comments and responses were based on the assigned codes or the general overall concern from the commenter. Each of these grouped concerns were given a Concern Response (CR) Number. Appendix P of the Volume 4 of the final EIS was sorted by the CR number. Topic codes were used to group like comments or identify overall theme of comment by the categories listed below in Table 2 in the Comment Code Topic column.

The response table in Appendix P used the following five response categories to respond to comments as per guidance provided by the Council of Environmental Quality (CEQ) regulations:

1. Modify alternatives, including the Proposed Action 2. Develop and evaluate alternatives not previously given consideration 3. Supplement, improve, or modify the analysis 4. Make factual corrections 5. Explain why the comments do not warrant further agency response

Table 2: List of Comment Codes for Associated Letter and Comment Number by CR Number

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 1 #3-1 St. Martin, Amanda Timber Resource 1 #5-2 Solomon, Laurie Roles, Authorities 1 #5-2 Solomon, Laurie User Conflicts 1 #5-2 Solomon, Laurie Animal Species: TES, etc. 1 #5-2 Solomon, Laurie Biological Resources 1 #5-2 Solomon, Laurie Timber Resource 2 #5-7 Solomon, Laurie Fuel Treatment, Reduction 2 #5-7 Solomon, Laurie Soils Mgmt 2 #5-7 Solomon, Laurie Prescribed Burns 2 #5-7 Solomon, Laurie Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 3 #4-17 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 3 #4-17 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 4 #2-4 Warness, Lindsay Fuel Treatment, Reduction 4 #2-4 Warness, Lindsay Prescribed Burns 4 #8-12 McClure, Steve Fuel Treatment, Reduction 4 #8-12 McClure, Steve Cumulative Effects Analysis 5 #2-6 Warness, Lindsay Fuel Treatment, Reduction 5 #2-6 Warness, Lindsay Prescribed Burns 6 #4-42 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 7 #2-13 Warness, Lindsay Vegetation Mgmt 7 #2-13 Warness, Lindsay Timber Mgmt 8 #6-1 Vandehey, Roberta Position, No Rationale 9 #6-9 Vandehey, Roberta Fire and Fuels Mgmt 9 #6-9 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 10 #3-9 St.Martin, Amanda Timber Resource 11 #3-11 St.Martin, Amanda Harvest Levels (Actual) 11 #5-1 Solomon, Laurie Climate Change 11 #5-1 Solomon, Laurie Species: TES, etc. 11 #5-1 Solomon, Laurie User Conflicts 11 #5-1 Solomon, Laurie Timber Sales (Green) 12 #13-7 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 13 #13-8 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 14 #4-10 Coulter, Karen Harvest Levels (Actual) 14 #13-10 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 15 #13-27 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 15 #13-27 Kelley, Brian Domestic Livestock, Grazing Mgmt 16 #13-26 Kelley, Brian Effects Analysis 16 #13-26 Kelley, Brian Domestic Livestock, Grazing Mgmt 17 #13-14 Kelley, Brian Domestic Livestock, Grazing Mgmt 17 #13-14 Kelley, Brian Riparian Area Mgmt 18 #13-39 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 19 #13-6 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 19 #13-6 Kelley, Brian Water, Watershed Mgmt 19 #13-6 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 20 #4-2 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 20 #4-2 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 20 #4-2 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 21 #13-38 Kelley, Brian Fire and Fuels Mgmt 22 #4-18 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 22 #4-18 Coulter, Karen Trust, Credibility 23 #4-19 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 23 #4-19 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 24 #4-20 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 24 #4-20 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 24 #4-23 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 24 #4-23 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 25 #4-21 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 26 #2-5 Warness, Lindsay Prescribed Burns 26 #2-5 Warness, Lindsay Suppression 27 #4-36 Coulter, Karen Prescribed Burns 28 #5-3 Solomon, Laurie Ecosystem, Habitat Health 28 #5-3 Solomon, Laurie Laws, Policies 28 #5-3 Solomon, Laurie Roles, Authorities 28 #5-3 Solomon, Laurie Recreation 29 #5-6 Solomon, Laurie Road Closure, Decomm. 29 #5-6 Solomon, Laurie Road Construction, Maint. 29 #5-6 Solomon, Laurie Invasive Vegetation Treatment 30 #5-8 Solomon, Laurie Species: TES, etc. 30 #5-8 Solomon, Laurie Effects Analysis 31 #4-32 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 31 #4-32 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 32 #4-52 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 32 #4-29 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 33 #7-5 Henning, Blake Ecosystem, Habitat Health 33 #7-5 Henning, Blake Trust, Credibility 34 #4-33 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 36 #4-39 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 36 #4-39 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 36 #4-39 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 37 #7-6 Henning, Blake General Use of Science 37 #7-6 Henning, Blake Ecosystem, Habitat Health 38 #1-26 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 39 #1-27 Artley, Dick Effects Analysis 39 #1-27 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 40 #1-29 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 40 #1-29 Artley, Dick Effects Analysis 41 #4-40 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 41 #4-40 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 41 #14-28 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 41 #14-28 Heiken, Doug Riparian Area Mgmt 42 #1-9 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 43 #1-36 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 43 #1-36 Artley, Dick Biological Resources 44 #1-10 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 45 #1-12 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 46 #1-13 Artley, Dick Disturbance Regimes 46 #1-13 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 47 #1-11 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 48 #1-17 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 49 #1-18 Artley, Dick Disturbance Regimes 50 #1-19 Artley, Dick Biological Resources Mgmt 50 #1-19 Artley, Dick Prescribed Burns 50 #1-19 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 50 #1-19 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 51 #1-20 Artley, Dick Fuel Treatment, Reduction 51 #1-20 Artley, Dick Biological Resources Mgmt 51 #1-20 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 51 #1-20 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 52 #1-21 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 52 #1-21 Artley, Dick Fuel Treatment, Reduction 52 #1-21 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 53 #1-22 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 53 #1-22 Artley, Dick Fuel Treatment, Reduction 53 #1-22 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 54 #1-23 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 54 #1-23 Artley, Dick Fuel Treatment, Reduction 54 #1-23 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 55 #2-2 Warness, Lindsay Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 55 #2-2 Warness, Lindsay Vegetation Mgmt 56 #2-8 Warness, Lindsay Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 56 #2-8 Warness, Lindsay Road Closure, Decomm. 57 #4-26 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 58 #2-9 Warness, Lindsay Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 59 #4-1 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 59 #4-1 Coulter, Karen Timber Mgmt 60 #2-10 Warness, Lindsay Ecosystem, Habitat Health 61 #6-8 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 62 #6-18 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 63 #6-28 Vandehey, Roberta Roadless Areas 63 #6-28 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 63 #6-28 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 64 #6-13 Vandehey, Roberta Timber Mgmt 65 #2-11 Warness, Lindsay Animal Species: TES, etc. 65 #2-11 Warness, Lindsay Ecosystem, Habitat Health 66 #2-12 Warness, Lindsay Fuel Treatment, Reduction 66 #2-12 Warness, Lindsay Ecosystem, Habitat Health 66 #2-12 Warness, Lindsay Riparian Area Mgmt 67 #2-15 Warness, Lindsay Timber Sales (Green) 67 #2-15 Warness, Lindsay Suitability Determinations 67 #2-15 Warness, Lindsay Vegetation Mgmt 68 #3-5 St.Martin, Amanda Rec. Resource Usability 68 #3-5 St.Martin, Amanda User Conflicts 69 #3-6 St.Martin, Amanda Animal Species: TES, etc. 69 #3-6 St.Martin, Amanda Indicator Species 70 #6-16 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 71 #6-20 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 72 #6-21 Vandehey, Roberta Domestic Livestock, Grazing Mgmt 72 #6-21 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 72 #6-21 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 73 #6-22 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 74 #6-23 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 75 #6-29 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 76 #8-8 McClure, Steve Vegetation Mgmt 76 #8-8 McClure, Steve Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 77 #8-13 McClure, Steve Vegetation Mgmt 77 #8-13 McClure, Steve Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 78 #8-16 McClure, Steve Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 78 #8-16 McClure, Steve Effects Analysis 79 #4-5 Coulter, Karen Land Designations/Mgmt 80 #4-6 Coulter, Karen Campgrounds/Picnic Areas 80 #4-6 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Camping 80 #4-6 Coulter, Karen Visual Resource Mgmt 81 #6-5 Vandehey, Roberta Timber Mgmt 81 #6-5 Vandehey, Roberta Biological Resources Mgmt 81 #6-5 Vandehey, Roberta Water, Watershed Mgmt 82 #4-50 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 82 #19-244 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 82 #19-244 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 83 #4-67 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals 84 #4-7 Coulter, Karen Species: TES, etc. 84 #4-7 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 85 #4-8 Coulter, Karen Species: TES, etc. 86 #4-9 Coulter, Karen Transportation System 87 #4-11 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 89 #4-22 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 89 #4-22 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 90 #4-28 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 91 #4-30 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 91 #4-30 Coulter, Karen Purpose and Need 91 #4-30 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 92 #4-34 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 93 #4-53 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 94 #4-54 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 95 #13-35 Kelley, Brian Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 95 #13-35 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 96 #6-26 Vandehey, Roberta Roads Management

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 96 #6-26 Vandehey, Roberta Technical, Editorial 97 #6-27 Vandehey, Roberta Roads Management 98 #8-9 McClure, Steve Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 98 #8-9 McClure, Steve Roads Management 99 #6-24 Vandehey, Roberta Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access)

100 #6-25 Vandehey, Roberta Roadless Areas 100 #6-25 Vandehey, Roberta Position, No Rationale 101 #4-55 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 102 #4-56 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 102 #4-56 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 103 #4-57 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 104 #4-63 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 104 #4-63 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 104 #4-63 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 105 #13-3 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 107 #4-37 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 107 #4-37 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 109 #13-9 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 110 #13-16 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 110 #13-16 Kelley, Brian Riparian Area Mgmt 111 #4-64 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 111 #4-64 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 112 #4-48 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 112 #4-48 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 113 #13-21 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 114 #13-22 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 114 #13-22 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 115 #13-23 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 116 #13-25 Kelley, Brian Climate Change 116 #13-25 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 117 #4-62 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 117 #4-62 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 118 #13-28 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 118 #13-28 Kelley, Brian Land Designations/Mgmt 119 #13-29 Kelley, Brian Fire and Fuels Mgmt 119 #13-29 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 120 #3-7 St.Martin, Amanda Prescribed Burns 120 #3-7 St.Martin, Amanda Ecosystem, Habitat Health 120 #3-7 St.Martin, Amanda Fuel Treatment, Reduction 120 #3-7 St.Martin, Amanda Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 121 #4-12 Coulter, Karen Prescribed Burns 121 #4-12 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 122 #4-35 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 122 #4-35 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 123 #1-45 Artley, Dick Timber Mgmt 124 #2-7 Warness, Lindsay Biological Resources Mgmt 124 #2-7 Warness, Lindsay Riparian Area Mgmt 124 #2-7 Warness, Lindsay Soils Mgmt 124 #2-7 Warness, Lindsay Fuel Treatment, Reduction 125 #6-10 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 125 #6-10 Vandehey, Roberta Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 125 #6-10 Vandehey, Roberta Fire and Fuels Mgmt 126 #1-79 Artley, Dick Tribal Lands 126 #1-79 Artley, Dick Proposed Action, Decision 126 #1-79 Artley, Dick Technical, Editorial 127 #3-2 St.Martin, Amanda Timber Resource 127 #3-2 St.Martin, Amanda Riparian Areas, Wetlands 128 #5-4 Solomon, Laurie Timber Sales (Green)

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 128 #5-4 Solomon, Laurie Riparian Area Mgmt 128 #5-4 Solomon, Laurie Ecosystem, Habitat Health 128 #5-4 Solomon, Laurie Species: TES, etc. 129 #4-15 Coulter, Karen General Use of Science 129 #4-15 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 129 #4-15 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 130 #4-58 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 130 #4-58 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 131 #2-16 Warness, Lindsay Vegetation Mgmt 131 #2-16 Warness, Lindsay Timber Resource 132 #4-59 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 133 #13-32 Kelley, Brian Soils 133 #13-32 Kelley, Brian Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 133 #13-32 Kelley, Brian Vegetation 133 #13-32 Kelley, Brian Timber Resource 133 #13-32 Kelley, Brian Fire and Fuels Mgmt 134 #13-33 Kelley, Brian Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 135 #13-34 Kelley, Brian Water, Watershed Mgmt 135 #13-34 Kelley, Brian Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 136 #1-76 Artley, Dick Slope or Erosion Control 136 #1-76 Artley, Dick Road Closure, Decomm. 137 #4-61 Coulter, Karen Visual Resource Mgmt 138 #1-94 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 139 #1-95 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 140 #1-101 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 141 #1-102 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 142 #1-103 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 143 #15-3 Jerome, Irene Timber Resource 144 #15-9 Jerome, Irene Timber Resource 145 #15-12 Jerome, Irene Clearings, Canopy 145 #15-12 Jerome, Irene Disturbance Regimes 145 #15-12 Jerome, Irene Fragmentation, Connectivity 146 #15-13 Jerome, Irene Ecosystem, Habitat Health 147 #16-5 Storm, Rex Harvest Levels (Actual) 148 #1-69 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 148 #1-69 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 149 #14-11 Heiken, Doug Ecosystem, Habitat Health 149 #14-11 Heiken, Doug Fuel Treatment, Reduction 150 #14-32 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 150 #14-32 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 151 #14-33 Heiken, Doug Animal Species: TES, etc. 151 #14-33 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 152 #14-34 Heiken, Doug Ecosystem, Habitat Health 153 #5-5 Solomon, Laurie Visual Resource Mgmt 153 #5-5 Solomon, Laurie Rec. Resource Usability 154 #13-31 Kelley, Brian Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 155 #13-24 Kelley, Brian Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 155 #13-24 Kelley, Brian Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 156 #4-65 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 156 #4-65 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 157 #14-24 Heiken, Doug General Use of Science 157 #14-24 Heiken, Doug Roadless Areas 158 #6-4 Vandehey, Roberta Water, Watershed Mgmt 159 #10-2 Vandehey, Mike Water, Watershed Mgmt 160 #6-15 Vandehey, Roberta Water, Watershed Mgmt 160 #6-15 Vandehey, Roberta Riparian Area Mgmt 160 #6-15 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 161 #1-55 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 162 #1-72 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 163 #1-61 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 164 #1-74 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 164 #1-74 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 165 #6-14 Vandehey, Roberta Water, Watershed Mgmt 165 #6-14 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 166 #4-60 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 166 #4-60 Coulter, Karen Visual Resource Mgmt 167 #16-9 Storm, Rex Fuel Treatment, Reduction 168 #1-5 Artley, Dick Riparian Areas, Wetlands 168 #1-5 Artley, Dick Water Resources 169 #14-36 Heiken, Doug Prescribed Burns 170 #1-44 Artley, Dick Timber Resource 170 #1-44 Artley, Dick Vegetation 170 #1-44 Artley, Dick Fire and Fuels Mgmt 171 #1-43 Artley, Dick Fire and Fuels Mgmt 172 #1-75 Artley, Dick Climate Change 173 #15-11 Jerome, Irene Introduction, Planting, Seeding 174 #1-96 Artley, Dick Timber Mgmt 175 #14-7 Heiken, Doug Timber Mgmt 176 #14-10 Heiken, Doug Timber Mgmt 176 #14-10 Heiken, Doug Biological Resources Mgmt 177 #3-12 St.Martin, Amanda Harvest Levels (Actual) 177 #14-4 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 177 #14-12 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 177 #14-12 Heiken, Doug Timber Resource 178 #14-13 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 178 #14-13 Heiken, Doug Timber Resource 179 #14-14 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 179 #14-14 Heiken, Doug Ecosystem, Habitat Health 180 #14-15 Heiken, Doug Ecosystem, Habitat Health 180 #14-15 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 181 #14-16 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 182 #14-30 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 182 #14-30 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 183 #14-25 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 184 #8-11 McClure, Steve Cumulative Effects Analysis 184 #8-11 McClure, Steve Riparian Area Mgmt 185 #18-3 Reichgott, Christine Technical, Editorial 185 #18-3 Reichgott, Christine Riparian Area Mgmt 186 #4-4 Coulter, Karen Riparian Area Mgmt 187 #8-10 McClure, Steve Riparian Area Mgmt 188 #13-4 Kelley, Brian Riparian Area Mgmt 189 #13-13 Kelley, Brian Riparian Area Mgmt 190 #1-57 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 191 #1-58 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 192 #15-2 Jerome, Irene Timber Resource 193 #4-14 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 193 #4-14 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 194 #1-59 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 195 #1-62 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 196 #1-63 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 197 #1-64 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 198 #1-71 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 199 #1-66 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 200 #1-67 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 201 #1-68 Artley, Dick Chemical Veg. Treatment 202 #8-5 McClure, Steve Effects Analysis

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 202 #8-5 McClure, Steve Air and Climate 202 #8-5 McClure, Steve Climate Change 202 #8-5 McClure, Steve Issues, Alternatives 203 #1-89 Artley, Dick Soils Mgmt 203 #1-89 Artley, Dick Roads Management 203 #1-89 Artley, Dick Water, Watershed Mgmt 203 #1-89 Artley, Dick Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 205 #3-14 St.Martin, Amanda Roads Management 206 #1-91 Artley, Dick Issues, Alternatives 206 #1-91 Artley, Dick Road Construction, Maint. 207 #1-90 Artley, Dick Alts. Not Analyzed In Detail 207 #1-90 Artley, Dick Road Construction, Maint. 209 #3-8 St.Martin, Amanda Road Construction, Maint. 210 #1-14 Artley, Dick Fire, Fire Risk 210 #1-14 Artley, Dick Fuel Load 210 #1-14 Artley, Dick Disturbance Regimes 211 #6-32 Vandehey, Roberta Road Construction, Maint. 212 #16-6 Storm, Rex Road Construction, Maint. 213 #14-31 Heiken, Doug Ecosystem, Habitat Health 213 #14-31 Heiken, Doug Road Construction, Maint. 214 #1-77 Artley, Dick Road Closure, Decomm. 214 #1-77 Artley, Dick Slope or Erosion Control 215 #6-33 Vandehey, Roberta Domestic Livestock, Grazing Mgmt 216 #19-99 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 216 #19-99 Coulter, Karen Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 217 #19-98 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 217 #19-98 Coulter, Karen Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 218 #19-100 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 218 #19-100 Coulter, Karen Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 219 #1-65 Artley, Dick Laws, Policies 220 #6-19 Vandehey, Roberta Beyond Scope 221 #14-26 Heiken, Doug Slope or Erosion Control 221 #14-26 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 221 #14-26 Heiken, Doug Riparian Area Mgmt 222 #19-6 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 223 #19-7 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 224 #19-8 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 224 #19-8 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 225 #19-9 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 225 #19-9 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 226 #19-10 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 227 #19-11 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 228 #19-12 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 230 #19-13 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 231 #19-14 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 232 #19-15 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 233 #19-16 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 234 #19-17 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 235 #19-19 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 236 #19-18 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 237 #19-71 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 237 #19-71 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 237 #19-71 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 237 #19-71 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 237 #19-71 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 238 #19-28 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 238 #19-28 Coulter, Karen Land Mgmt Emphasis 239 #19-1 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 239 #19-1 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 240 #19-221 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 241 #19-3 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 241 #19-3 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 242 #19-21 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 243 #18-2 Reichgott, Christine Riparian Area Mgmt 243 #18-2 Reichgott, Christine Soils Mgmt 244 #19-22 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 245 #19-23 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 245 #19-23 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 245 #19-23 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 246 #19-83 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 246 #19-83 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 246 #19-83 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 247 #19-26 Coulter, Karen Land Mgmt Emphasis 247 #19-26 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 247 #19-26 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 247 #19-26 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 248 #19-2 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 249 #19-117 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 251 #19-115 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 251 #19-115 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 251 #19-115 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 251 #19-115 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 251 #19-115 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 251 #19-115 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 252 #1-35 Artley, Dick Vegetation Mgmt 252 #1-35 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 253 #1-56 Artley, Dick Laws, Policies 253 #1-56 Artley, Dick Roles, Authorities 254 #16-3 Storm, Rex No Action Alternative 255 #15-18 Jerome, Irene Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 255 #15-18 Jerome, Irene Prescribed Burns 256 #19-134 Coulter, Karen Land Designations/Mgmt 256 #19-134 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 257 #19-135 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 258 #19-136 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 259 #19-137 Coulter, Karen Purpose and Need 259 #19-137 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 259 #19-137 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 260 #19-138 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 260 #19-138 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 261 #19-139 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 261 #19-139 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 262 #19-140 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 262 #19-140 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 263 #19-141 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 263 #19-141 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 264 #19-142 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 264 #19-142 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 265 #19-143 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 265 #19-143 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 266 #19-187 Coulter, Karen Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 266 #19-187 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 267 #4-47 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 267 #4-47 Coulter, Karen Air and Climate 268 #19-111 Coulter, Karen Wildland/Urban Interface 269 #19-164 Coulter, Karen Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access)

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 270 #3-4 St.Martin, Amanda Position, No Rationale 270 #3-4 St.Martin, Amanda Road Construction, Maint. 270 #3-4 St.Martin, Amanda Timber Resource 271 #1-88 Artley, Dick Alts. Not Analyzed In Detail 272 #19-260 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 273 #4-66 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 273 #4-66 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 273 #4-66 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 274 #19-262 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 275 #19-261 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 276 #19-144 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 276 #19-144 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 276 #19-144 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 277 #19-145 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 278 #19-146 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 278 #19-146 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 279 #19-148 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 279 #19-148 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 280 #19-149 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 280 #19-149 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 281 #19-150 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 281 #19-150 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 282 #19-263 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 283 #19-152 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 283 #19-152 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 284 #19-153 Coulter, Karen Decision Process 285 #19-156 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 286 #19-158 Coulter, Karen Effects Analysis 286 #19-158 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 287 #19-159 Coulter, Karen Decision Process 287 #19-159 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 287 #19-159 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 287 #19-159 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 288 #19-160 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 288 #19-160 Coulter, Karen Effects Analysis 288 #19-160 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 288 #19-160 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 289 #19-161 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 290 #19-31 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 291 #19-165 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 292 #19-166 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 292 #19-166 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 293 #19-167 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 293 #19-167 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 293 #19-167 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 294 #19-168 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 294 #19-168 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 295 #19-169 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 296 #19-170 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 297 #19-171 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 297 #19-171 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 298 #19-27 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 298 #19-27 Coulter, Karen Issues, Alternatives 299 #19-29 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 300 #19-30 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 300 #19-30 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 301 #19-34 Coulter, Karen Effects Analysis 301 #19-34 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 302 #19-37 Coulter, Karen Timber Mgmt 302 #19-265 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 302 #19-37 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 302 #19-265 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt 302 #19-265 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 303 #19-172 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 303 #19-172 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 304 #19-173 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 304 #19-173 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 305 #19-174 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 306 #19-175 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 306 #19-175 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 307 #19-176 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 308 #19-177 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 309 #19-178 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 310 #19-179 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 311 #19-180 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 312 #19-181 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 312 #19-181 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 313 #19-182 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 313 #19-182 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 314 #19-184 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 315 #19-185 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 315 #19-185 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 316 #19-186 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 317 #19-188 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 317 #19-188 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 318 #19-189 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 319 #19-191 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 319 #19-191 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 320 #19-192 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 321 #13-5 Kelley, Brian Effects Analysis 321 #13-5 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 322 #19-193 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 322 #19-193 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 323 #4-3 Coulter, Karen Purpose and Need 324 #19-5 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 325 #19-24 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 326 #19-194 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 327 #19-195 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 328 #19-196 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 328 #19-196 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 329 #19-108 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 330 #19-110 Coulter, Karen Suppression 330 #19-110 Coulter, Karen Soils 330 #19-110 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 331 #19-118 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 331 #19-119 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 332 #19-197 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 333 #19-198 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 334 #19-121 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 334 #19-123 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 335 #19-199 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 336 #15-8 Jerome, Irene Riparian Area Mgmt 337 #19-200 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 338 #19-122 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 339 #19-201 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 340 #14-27 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 340 #14-27 Heiken, Doug Riparian Area Mgmt 341 #19-124 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 342 #19-202 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 342 #19-202 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 343 #19-125 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 343 #19-125 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 344 #19-203 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 344 #19-203 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 345 #19-126 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 346 #19-127 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 347 #19-128 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 348 #19-204 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 349 #19-130 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 350 #19-131 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 351 #19-205 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 352 #19-206 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 353 #19-87 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 353 #19-87 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 354 #19-132 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 354 #19-132 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 357 #19-133 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 358 #19-207 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 359 #19-89 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 359 #19-89 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 360 #19-79 Coulter, Karen Issues, Alternatives 360 #19-79 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 361 #19-147 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 362 #19-84 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 362 #19-84 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 363 #19-151 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 364 #19-208 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 365 #19-209 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 366 #19-210 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 366 #19-210 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 367 #19-162 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 368 #19-211 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 368 #19-211 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 368 #19-211 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 369 #19-212 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 370 #19-214 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 371 #19-215 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 372 #19-232 Coulter, Karen Purpose and Need 372 #19-232 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 373 #19-239 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 373 #19-239 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 374 #19-216 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 375 #19-217 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 375 #19-217 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 376 #19-218 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 377 #19-219 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 378 #19-93 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 378 #19-93 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 379 #19-95 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 379 #19-95 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 380 #19-101 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 380 #19-101 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 381 #19-94 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 381 #19-94 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 381 #19-94 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 382 #19-96 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 382 #19-96 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 383 #19-105 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 383 #19-105 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 384 #19-4 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 385 #19-88 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 386 #19-90 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 387 #19-91 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 388 #19-92 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 389 #19-97 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 390 #19-103 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 391 #19-104 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 392 #19-106 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 393 #19-107 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 394 #19-112 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 395 #19-113 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 396 #19-114 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 397 #19-220 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 397 #19-220 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 398 #19-223 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 399 #19-238 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 399 #19-238 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 399 #19-238 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 400 #19-234 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 400 #19-234 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 401 #19-224 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 402 #19-225 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 402 #19-225 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 403 #19-226 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 404 #19-227 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 405 #6-31 Vandehey, Roberta Multiple Use Mgmt 405 #6-31 Vandehey, Roberta Recreation Mgmt 406 #14-29 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 406 #14-29 Heiken, Doug Ecosystem, Habitat Health 407 #19-228 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 408 #14-20 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 408 #14-20 Heiken, Doug Lands, Condition, Designation 409 #14-37 Heiken, Doug Climate Change 410 #19-229 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 411 #19-25 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 412 #14-9 Heiken, Doug Biological Resources 413 #19-109 Coulter, Karen Suppression 413 #19-109 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 414 #19-230 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 415 #19-231 Coulter, Karen Alternatives (comparing, range) 415 #19-231 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 416 #19-233 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 417 #19-235 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 418 #19-67 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 418 #19-67 Coulter, Karen Watershed Condition 418 #19-67 Coulter, Karen Water Quality 418 #19-67 Coulter, Karen Disturbance, Erosion, etc. 419 #19-236 Coulter, Karen Animal Species: TES, etc. 419 #19-236 Coulter, Karen Indicator Species 419 #19-236 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 420 #19-85 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 420 #19-85 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 420 #19-85 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 421 #19-48 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 421 #19-48 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 422 #19-237 Coulter, Karen Alternatives (comparing, range) 422 #19-237 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 423 #4-25 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 423 #4-25 Coulter, Karen Issues, Alternatives 424 #14-17 Heiken, Doug Land Designations/Mgmt 424 #14-17 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 424 #14-17 Heiken, Doug Timber Sales (Green) 425 #19-86 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 425 #19-86 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 426 #1-1 Artley, Dick Soils 427 #1-2 Artley, Dick Soils 428 #19-240 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 429 #1-3 Artley, Dick Soils 430 #1-4 Artley, Dick Soils 431 #19-241 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 432 #19-242 Coulter, Karen Econ. Actions, Analyses 432 #19-242 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 433 #19-243 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 434 #19-245 Coulter, Karen Issues, Alternatives 435 #19-246 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 436 #19-247 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 437 #19-248 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 438 #19-251 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 439 #19-252 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 440 #14-18 Heiken, Doug Lands, Condition, Designation 440 #14-18 Heiken, Doug Clearings, Canopy 441 #14-23 Heiken, Doug Technical, Editorial 442 #8-4 McClure, Steve Issues, Alternatives 442 #8-4 McClure, Steve Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 443 #19-249 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 444 #19-250 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 445 #19-253 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 446 #19-254 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 447 #19-255 Coulter, Karen Trans. Sys. Mgmt (& non-rec. access) 447 #19-255 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 448 #19-256 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 449 #19-257 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 450 #19-258 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 451 #19-259 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 451 #19-259 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 452 #19-267 Coulter, Karen Fire and Fuels Mgmt 452 #19-267 Coulter, Karen Vegetation 452 #19-267 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 453 #19-266 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 454 #15-5 Jerome, Irene Purpose and Need 455 #1-82 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 455 #1-82 Artley, Dick Biological Resources Mgmt 455 #1-82 Artley, Dick Effects Analysis 455 #1-82 Artley, Dick Timber Mgmt 456 #7-1 Henning, Blake Alternative X 457 #7-2 Henning, Blake Alternative X 457 #7-2 Henning, Blake Ecosystem, Habitat Health 458 #7-3 Henning, Blake Alternative X 458 #7-3 Henning, Blake Ecosystem, Habitat Health 459 #7-4 Henning, Blake Ecosystem, Habitat Health

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 459 #7-4 Henning, Blake Alternative X 460 #19-38 Coulter, Karen Slope or Erosion Control 461 #19-39 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 462 #10-1 Vandehey, Mike Issues, Alternatives 463 #15-4 Jerome, Irene Purpose and Need 464 #19-41 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 465 #1-47 Artley, Dick Technical, Editorial 466 #1-40 Artley, Dick Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 467 #8-3 McClure, Steve Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 468 #19-20 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 469 #1-80 Artley, Dick Cultural, Hist., Anthro. Mgmt 469 #1-80 Artley, Dick Coordination, Consultation 470 #14-19 Heiken, Doug Harvest Levels (Actual) 470 #14-19 Heiken, Doug Lands, Condition, Designation 471 #13-36 Kelley, Brian Effects Analysis 471 #13-36 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 471 #13-36 Kelley, Brian Laws, Policies, Courts 472 #13-40 Kelley, Brian Laws, Policies 472 #13-40 Kelley, Brian Technical, Editorial 473 #14-1 Heiken, Doug Public Involvement 474 #8-14 McClure, Steve Econ. Actions, Analyses 474 #8-14 McClure, Steve Issues, Alternatives 474 #8-14 McClure, Steve Community Econ. Effects Analysis 475 #16-7 Storm, Rex Technical, Editorial 475 #16-7 Storm, Rex Harvest Methods 476 #16-12 Storm, Rex Estimating Costs/Values 476 #16-12 Storm, Rex Harvest Methods 477 #6-17 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 478 #6-2 Vandehey, Roberta Road Closure, Decomm. 478 #6-2 Vandehey, Roberta Road Construction, Maint. 478 #6-2 Vandehey, Roberta Vegetation Mgmt 479 #1-46 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 480 #1-48 Artley, Dick Multiple Use Mgmt 481 #2-1 Warness, Lindsay Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 482 #13-37 Kelley, Brian Decision Process 482 #13-37 Kelley, Brian Timber Mgmt 483 #18-4 Reichgott, Christine Harvest Levels (Actual) 483 #18-4 Reichgott, Christine Monitoring 484 #19-81 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 484 #19-81 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 485 #19-82 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 485 #19-82 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 486 #19-116 Coulter, Karen Biological Resources Mgmt 486 #19-116 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 487 #2-3 Warness, Lindsay Soils Mgmt 487 #2-3 Warness, Lindsay Vegetation Mgmt 488 #1-108 Artley, Dick Proposed Action, Decision 489 #13-1 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 490 #1-7 Artley, Dick Heritage Laws 491 #1-81 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 492 #1-83 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 493 #1-84 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 493 #1-84 Artley, Dick Multiple Use Mgmt 494 #1-85 Artley, Dick Laws, Policies 495 #1-86 Artley, Dick Technical, Editorial 496 #1-87 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 497 #1-92 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 498 #1-93 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 499 #1-104 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 500 #1-105 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 501 #1-106 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 502 #1-107 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 503 #1-109 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 504 #1-110 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 505 #1-111 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 506 #1-112 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 507 #1-113 Artley, Dick No Further Response Required 508 #19-70 Coulter, Karen Issues, Alternatives 508 #19-70 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 509 #8-6 McClure, Steve Water, Watershed Mgmt 509 #8-6 McClure, Steve Alternatives (comparing, range) 509 #8-6 McClure, Steve Vegetation Mgmt 510 #19-63 Coulter, Karen Effects Analysis 510 #19-63 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 511 #19-68 Coulter, Karen Effects Analysis 511 #19-68 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 512 #19-73 Coulter, Karen Effects Analysis 512 #19-73 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 513 #19-47 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 513 #19-47 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 514 #19-76 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 514 #19-76 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 515 #4-13 Coulter, Karen Purpose and Need 515 #4-13 Coulter, Karen Issues, Alternatives 516 #4-31 Coulter, Karen Issues, Alternatives 517 #4-49 Coulter, Karen Alternatives (comparing, range) 518 #19-42 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 519 #19-44 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 520 #1-28 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 520 #1-28 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 520 #1-28 Artley, Dick Fire and Fuels Mgmt 521 #19-51 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 522 #19-59 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 523 #19-60 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 524 #19-61 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 525 #19-62 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 526 #19-64 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 527 #19-65 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 528 #1-15 Artley, Dick Wildland/Urban Interface Cond. 528 #1-15 Artley, Dick Fire, Fire Risk 529 #1-6 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 530 #1-8 Artley, Dick Heritage Laws 530 #1-8 Artley, Dick Cultural, Hist., Anthro. Resources 531 #1-24 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 532 #1-25 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 533 #1-30 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 533 #1-30 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 534 #1-31 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 535 #1-32 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 535 #1-32 Artley, Dick Effects Analysis 536 #1-33 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 537 #1-34 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 538 #1-37 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 539 #1-38 Artley, Dick No Further Response Required 541 #1-41 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 542 #1-42 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 542 #1-42 Artley, Dick General Use of Science 543 #1-49 Artley, Dick Technical, Editorial 544 #1-50 Artley, Dick Community Econ. Effects Analysis 545 #1-51 Artley, Dick Community Econ. Effects Analysis 546 #1-52 Artley, Dick Purpose and Need 547 #1-53 Artley, Dick Decision Process 548 #1-54 Artley, Dick Technical, Editorial 549 #1-60 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 550 #1-70 Artley, Dick Technical, Editorial 551 #1-73 Artley, Dick Laws, Policies 552 #1-78 Artley, Dick Technical, Editorial 553 #1-97 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 554 #1-98 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 555 #1-100 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 556 #1-99 Artley, Dick Position, No Rationale 557 #2-14 Warness, Lindsay Community Econ. Effects 557 #2-14 Warness, Lindsay Cost/Benefit Outcome 557 #2-14 Warness, Lindsay Resource Value 558 #3-3 St.Martin, Amanda Forest Service Directives 559 #3-10 St.Martin, Amanda Purpose and Need 560 #3-13 St.Martin, Amanda No Further Response Required 561 #4-16 Coulter, Karen Purpose and Need 562 #4-27 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 563 #4-38 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 563 #4-38 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 563 #4-38 Coulter, Karen Water, Watershed Mgmt 564 #4-41 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 565 #4-43 Coulter, Karen Vegetation 565 #4-43 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 566 #4-44 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 566 #4-44 Coulter, Karen Vegetation 567 #4-45 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 568 #4-46 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 569 #4-51 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 570 #5-9 Solomon, Laurie No Further Response Required 572 #6-3 Vandehey, Roberta No Further Response Required 573 #8-1 McClure, Steve Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 574 #8-2 McClure, Steve Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 575 #8-7 McClure, Steve Vegetation Mgmt 576 #8-15 McClure, Steve Issues, Alternatives 577 #12-1 Public, Jean Position, No Rationale 578 #13-2 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 579 #13-11 Kelley, Brian Technical, Editorial 580 #13-15 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 581 #13-12 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 582 #13-17 Kelley, Brian Technical, Editorial 582 #13-17 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 583 #13-18 Kelley, Brian Technical, Editorial 584 #13-19 Kelley, Brian Technical, Editorial 585 #13-20 Kelley, Brian Technical, Editorial 586 #13-30 Kelley, Brian Fire and Fuels Mgmt 586 #13-30 Kelley, Brian Vegetation Mgmt 586 #13-30 Kelley, Brian Issues, Alternatives 587 #14-2 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 587 #14-2 Heiken, Doug Technical, Editorial 588 #14-3 Heiken, Doug Technical, Editorial 589 #14-5 Heiken, Doug Resource & Area Mgmt 590 #14-6 Heiken, Doug Resource & Area Mgmt

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 591 #14-8 Heiken, Doug Ecosystem, Habitat Health 592 #14-21 Heiken, Doug Wilderness, Roadless Character 593 #14-22 Heiken, Doug Wilderness, Roadless Character 594 #15-6 Jerome, Irene Purpose and Need 595 #15-7 Jerome, Irene Purpose and Need 596 #15-10 Jerome, Irene Econ. Actions, Analyses 597 #15-14 Jerome, Irene Transportation System 598 #15-15 Jerome, Irene Econ. Actions, Analyses 599 #15-16 Jerome, Irene Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 600 #15-17 Jerome, Irene Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 601 #15-19 Jerome, Irene Technical, Editorial 602 #15-20 Jerome, Irene Alternative X 603 #15-21 Jerome, Irene Technical, Editorial 604 #16-1 Storm, Rex No Further Response Required 605 #16-2 Storm, Rex Preferred Alternative 606 #16-4 Storm, Rex Laws, Policies 607 #16-8 Storm, Rex Estimating Costs/Values 607 #16-8 Storm, Rex Harvest Methods 608 #16-10 Storm, Rex Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 609 #16-11 Storm, Rex Econ. & Soc. Actions, Analyses 610 #18-1 Reichgott, Christine No Further Response Required 611 #18-5 Reichgott, Christine No Further Response Required 612 #19-32 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 612 #19-32 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 613 #19-33 Coulter, Karen Dispersed Recreation Mgmt 614 #19-35 Coulter, Karen Econ. Actions, Analyses 615 #19-36 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 616 #19-53 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 617 #19-74 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 618 #19-75 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 619 #19-72 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 620 #19-80 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 621 #19-78 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 622 #4-24 Coulter, Karen FOIA 623 #1-16 Artley, Dick Ecosystem, Habitat Health 623 #1-16 Artley, Dick Animal Species: TES, etc. 624 #19-40 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 625 #19-154 Coulter, Karen Public Involvement 625 #19-154 Coulter, Karen Decision Process 626 #19-190 Coulter, Karen Laws, Policies 627 #6-6 Vandehey, Roberta Beyond Scope 628 #6-7 Vandehey, Roberta Beyond Scope 629 #6-11 Vandehey, Roberta Beyond Scope 630 #6-30 Vandehey, Roberta Multiple Use Mgmt 631 #6-34 Vandehey, Roberta Position, No Rationale 632 #6-35 Vandehey, Roberta Position, No Rationale 633 #6-36 Vandehey, Roberta Beyond Scope 634 #19-129 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 634 #19-129 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 635 #19-155 Coulter, Karen Cumulative Effects Analysis 635 #19-155 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 635 #19-155 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 636 #19-120 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 637 #14-35 Heiken, Doug Harvest Methods 638 #19-157 Coulter, Karen Vegetation Mgmt 638 #19-157 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 638 #19-157 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 639 #19-54 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale

CR Number Letter-Comment # Commenter Comment Topic Code 639 #19-54 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 640 #19-163 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 640 #19-163 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 641 #19-183 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 642 #19-213 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 643 #19-222 Coulter, Karen Wildlife/Animals Mgmt 644 #19-43 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 645 #6-12 Vandehey, Roberta Beyond Scope 647 #19-45 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 648 #19-46 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 648 #19-46 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 649 #19-49 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 649 #19-49 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 650 #19-50 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 650 #19-50 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 651 #19-52 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 651 #19-52 Coulter, Karen Effects Analysis 651 #19-52 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 652 #19-55 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 653 #19-56 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 654 #19-57 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 654 #19-57 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 655 #19-58 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 656 #19-66 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 656 #19-66 Coulter, Karen Technical, Editorial 657 #19-69 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 658 #19-77 Coulter, Karen Soils Mgmt 659 #19-102 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 660 #15-1 Jerome, Irene Technical, Editorial 661 #19-264 Coulter, Karen Position, No Rationale 661 #19-264 Coulter, Karen Recreation Mgmt

Appendix A: Travel Action Plan Maps

The maps below replace the missing maps from Volume 2 of the Final EIS from Appendix J: Travel Action Plan.

Map 1: Existing Transportation System (replaces Map 2 in Appendix J, Volume 2 page 345)

Map 2: Kahler Access and Travel Management Alternative 2 (replaces Map 3 in Appendix J, Volume 2 page 349)

Map 3: Kahler Access and Travel Management Alternative 3 (replaces Map 4 in Appendix J, Volume 2 page 350)

Map 4: Kahler Access and Travel Management Alternative 4 (replaces Map 5 Appendix J, Volume 2 page 351)

Map 5: Value Risk Category (replaces Map 6 Appendix J, Volume 2 page 363)

Map 6: Haul Routes Alternative 2 (replaces Map 7 Appendix J, Volume 2 page 381)



KAHLER TRANSPORTATION PLAN Kahler

24


25


26


27


29


31


32

errata to the kahler final eisa123.g.akamai.net/7/123/11558/abc123/forestservic... · 2016. 6....

Documents