esa 2016 filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

33
The effect of consumer pressure and abiotic stress on positive plant- interactions is mediated by drought Alessandro Filazzola, Amanda Liczner, Michael Westphal, & Christopher J. Lortie

Upload: alex-filazzola

Post on 15-Jan-2017

874 views

Category:

Environment


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

The effect of consumer pressure and abiotic stress on positive plant-interactions is mediated by droughtAlessandro Filazzola, Amanda Liczner, Michael Westphal, & Christopher J. Lortie

Page 2: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert
Page 3: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

mechanisms of positive plant-interactions

Filazzola & Lortie 2014

Page 4: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

Gómez Aparicio,‐ et al. 2005

shrubs ameliorate abiotic stress

Page 5: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

shrubs reduce consumer pressure

Barbosa et al. 2009

insect abundance mammalian herbivory

Page 6: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

most studies only examine one stressor

Filazzola & Lortie 2014

Page 7: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

additional stressors change predictions

Smit et al. 2009

No herbivoresWith herbivores

Page 8: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

additional stressors change predictions

Crain et al. 2008

Page 9: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

RII 0

-1

+1

local gradients alter microscale association among plants

-1+1

Page 10: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

Shrubs facilitate the annual community by concurrently reducing consumer pressure through associational resistance and ameliorate abiotic stress by increasing soil moisture

hypothesis and predictions

RII 0

-1

+1

-1+1

?

Page 11: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

study site and extreme drought

2014 2016

Page 12: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert
Page 13: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert
Page 14: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert
Page 15: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

1 - 6X 15

Design Water level

1 - 6X 5

Replication

Experimental design for 2014

Plots/sample size (N/n)

60 / 5

180 / 15

Page 16: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

0/1X 15

Design Water level

0/1X 15

Replication

Experimental design for 2016

Plots/sample size (N/n)

60 / 15

60 / 15

Page 17: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

E. californica ameliorates abiotic stress

Page 18: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

Effect Biomass 2014 Biomass 2016

Soil moisture + +Microsite + +

Consumer pressure -Microsite * soil moisture

Microsite * consumer pressure +Microsite * consumer pressure *

soil moisture

Page 19: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

E. californica reduces consumer pressure

Page 20: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

facilitation had a greater effect than water addition or consumer pressure

Page 21: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

an invasive species was facilitated more strongly than subordinates

Page 22: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

RII 0

-1

+1

-1+1

E. californica facilitates regardless of soil moisture or consumer pressure

Page 23: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert
Page 24: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

precipitation can increase phytophagous insects and attract non-resident herbivores

Patten 1998; Augustine & McNaughton 2006; Retzer & Miehe 2005

Page 25: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

precipitation mediates mechanism of facilitation

drought above average rainfall

Page 26: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

precipitation increases relative difference among shrub and open microsites

Page 27: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

Augustine & McNaughton 2006

herbivory does not affect productivity when rainfall and soil fertility are high

Page 28: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

species specificity changes predictions

Maestre et al. 2009

Page 29: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

dominant-mediated distribution of invasives

Survival of experimentally planted seedlings of Taraxacum officinale within and outside Azorella monantha cushions at 3200 m a.s.l.

Cavieres et al. 2007

Page 30: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

invasive beneficiaries negative affect benefactors

Rodrıguez-Buritica & Miriti 2009

Page 31: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

loss of invasive and native species

Page 32: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

implications

Interacting stressors alter predictions on positive plant interactions

Precipitation mediates stressors and mechanisms of facilitation in desert environments

The life strategy of beneficiary species relates to the facilitation effects

Shrubs in arid environments may be support non-native invasion

Page 33: Esa 2016   filazzola - water limitation and consumer pressure in the desert

Thank youDr. Chris LortieDr. Sapna SharmaDr. Bridget StutchburyDr. Michael WestphalDr. Diego SotomayorThe Ecoblender LabBLM: Central Coast Field Office

filazzola.info

@alex_filazzola

afilazzola