ethical issue: social american factory justice
TRANSCRIPT
RaceandCultureinAmericanFactory:ACaseStudyEmilyA.Callam
Advisor:Dr.ChadPainter
AbstractThiscasestudyfocusesonthe2019documentary AmericanFactory andexaminestheissuesofraceandculturethroughtheethicallensofsocialjustice.ThedocumentarydirectedbyJuliaReichertandStevenBognar introducesviewerstothetransitionofalargefactoryinDayton,Ohio,fromGeneralMotorsCompanytoFuyaoGlassAmerica,aChinesecompany.
SummaryThefilmattemptstocaptureanall-encompassingviewofthistransitionasitdepictstheeffectsithasoneveryonefromtheCEOofthecompanytobothAmericanandChineseworkersonthefactoryfloor.LifestylesandworkplaceculturesclashastheproductivitylevelsofthoseintheUnitedStatesdoesnotnearlyreachthatofChina.
American Transition• Lowerwages,noabilitytounionize,
unstableemployment• Mostwhoheldmanagementpositions
were quicklyreplaced.• Adaptingtoforeignleadership.
Chinese Transition• Learnandadapttoanewcultureand
language.• Mostifnotallawayfromtheirfamilies.
Ethical Issue: Social Justice RaceandEthnicity
•Twoculturesemerge;AmericanandChinese.WithintheAmericanculturearemanysubculturesthatrepresentdifferentraces;white,black,Hispanic,Asian.Didthesesubculturesfacedifferentchallengesandobstacles?
Class•Thereisnotmuchcontextforclass.ManyChineseworkerslivedtogether,withouttheirfamilies.WhatdoesthelifeofaChineseworkerinamanagerialrolelooklike?
Gender•HowdogenderrolesinChinatranslateintheAmericancontext?WerethejobsofAmericanwomenworkinginthefactoryaffectedbythechangeinmanagement?
Geography•Wouldthenarrativebedifferentifthefactorywereinadifferentpartofthecountryorclosertoamajorcity?
Generation•Americansweretypicallyintheir40s-60s.Chineseworkersweretypicallyyoungerintheirmid-20sormid-30s.Whatdoesthismean?