evaluation of inner ear pathology in the average … › ... › uploads › 2012 › 12 ›...

1
Evaluation of inner ear pathology in Weddell seals B.A. BOHNE and D.C. BOZZAY Washington University School of Medicine Department of Otolaryngology St. Louis, Missouri 63110 J.A. THOMAS Naval Ocean Systems Center Hawaii Laboratory, Code 512 Kailua, Hawaii 96734-0997 Last year, it was reported that several noise sources, located in McMurdo Sound, are potentially damaging to the hearing of marine mammals. To determine whether or not the hearing organ (organ of Corti) of Weddell seals had evidence of perma- nent sensorineural damage, we processed for microscopic ex- amination, one temporal bone from each of 11 Weddell seals which were killed in January, 1985, as part of the New Zealand Antarctic Research Program. The techniques used to collect the seals and to fix and embed their temporal bones were described last year (Bohne et al. 1985). This report briefly describes the techniques used to ob- tain surface preparations of the organ of Corti and to analyze the specimens microscopically. The normal and pathological find- ings in the 11 Weddell seal cochleas are also summarized. The cochleas were fixed in osmium tetroxide, dehydrated in alcohol and embedded in plastic. Once the plastic had poly- merized, the cochlear bone which surrounds the soft tissue of the inner ear was removed with a sharpened steel pick. Pieces of razor blade were used to divide the cochlear duct into small segments which ranged in length from 0.6 to 4.9 millimeters. Each segment was then trimmed to remove most of the plastic filling scala typmani. The trimmed segments were re- embedded in a thin layer of plastic. After the layer polymerized, simplified images of the segments of the organs of Corti were made, their lengths were measured with a graphics tablet/ computer system, and the histological appearances of the sen- sory cells and eighth nerve fibers were determined using a phase contrast microscope. As noted in the previous report, all 11 temporal bones sus- tained some acute damage (e.g., detachment of the organ of Corti from the basilar membrane) due to the exploding bullets used to produce instant kills. The presence of acute damage prevented detailed analysis of the entire organ of Corti in each specimen. Nevertheless, in most specimens, a sufficient amount of tissue remained for the determination of some nor- mal cochlear parameters and for the assessment of the presence of pre-existing (i.e., prior to gunshot) cochlear pathology. The average length of the organ of Corti from the 11 Weddell seal cochleas was found to be 31.2 ± 1.1 millimeters. The aver- age density of inner and the three rows of outer hair cells per millimeter length of the organ of Corti were found to be 98 and 395, respectively. These values should be considered as rough approximations because the cell counts could be made in only a small portion of each of the 11 organs of Corti. However, it is interesting to note that these densities are similar to the inner and outer hair cell densities in several terrestrial mammals [human-109, 418 (Bredberg 1968); chinchilla-100, 405 (Bohne, Kenworthy, and Carr 1982); guinea pig-92, 354 (Thorne and Gavin 1984)]. Five of the 11 cochleas had no evidence of previous damage to the organ of Corti. Due to extensive acute damage, the organ of Corti was not visible in a sixth cochlea. In these six cochleas, the entire population of eight nerve fibers was intact. On this basis, it was concluded that none of these ears had sustained severe injuries to the organ of Corti prior to death. The remaining five cochleas had clear evidence of previous damage. These injuries ranged from scattered loss of outer hair cells to degeneration of an entire portion of the organ of Corti and its replacement by squamous epithelium. This latter lesion was accompanied by degeneration of the corresponding eighth nerve fibers. It should be noted that since only a small portion of the organ of Corti could be examined in each cochlea, additional sensory cells may have been missing but their losses would have been masked by the acute damage. Although the etiology of the cochlear damage in the five Weddell seal cochleas cannot be determined with certainty, noise is the one ototraumatic agent which is known to have been present in their environment. The effect these cochlear lesions had on the hearing ability of the seals is unknown. However, based on studies in terrestrial mammals in which hearing loss has been correlated with senso- ry cell loss (e.g., Bohne and Clark 1982), it is highly unlikely that any of the seals had a significant hearing impairment. The research was supported by National Science Foundation grant DPP 82-17708 and National Institutes of Health grant N5O1791. References Bohne, B.A., and W.W. Clark. 1982. Growth of hearing loss and cochlear lesion with increasing duration of noise exposure. In R.P. 1-lamernik, D. Henderson, and R. Salvi (Eds.), New perspectives On noise-induced hearing loss. New York: Raven Press. Bohne, BA., A. Kenworthy, and C.D. Carr. 1982. Density of myeli- nated nerve fivers in the chinchilla cochlea. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 72(1), 102-107. Bohne, BA., J.A. Thomas, E.R. Yohe, and S.H. Stone. 1985. Examina- tion of potential hearing damage in Weddell seals (Leptonychotes wed- dclii) in McMurdo Sound, Antarctica. Antarctic Journal of the U.S., 20(5), 174-176. Bredberg, C. 1968. Cellular pattern and nerve supply of the human organ of Corti. Acta Oto-laryngologica, (Supplement 236). Thorne, P.R., and J.B. Gavin. 1984. The accuracy of hair cell counts in determining distance and position along the organ of Corti. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 76(2), 440-442. 208 ANTARCTIC JOURNAL

Upload: others

Post on 31-May-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Evaluation of inner ear pathology in The average … › ... › uploads › 2012 › 12 › Bohne-B.A.2.pdfThe effect these cochlear lesions had on the hearing ability of the seals

Evaluation of inner ear pathology inWeddell seals

B.A. BOHNE and D.C. BOZZAY

Washington University School of MedicineDepartment of Otolaryngology

St. Louis, Missouri 63110

J.A. THOMAS

Naval Ocean Systems CenterHawaii Laboratory, Code 512Kailua, Hawaii 96734-0997

Last year, it was reported that several noise sources, located inMcMurdo Sound, are potentially damaging to the hearing ofmarine mammals. To determine whether or not the hearingorgan (organ of Corti) of Weddell seals had evidence of perma-nent sensorineural damage, we processed for microscopic ex-amination, one temporal bone from each of 11 Weddell sealswhich were killed in January, 1985, as part of the New ZealandAntarctic Research Program.

The techniques used to collect the seals and to fix and embedtheir temporal bones were described last year (Bohne et al.1985). This report briefly describes the techniques used to ob-tain surface preparations of the organ of Corti and to analyze thespecimens microscopically. The normal and pathological find-ings in the 11 Weddell seal cochleas are also summarized.

The cochleas were fixed in osmium tetroxide, dehydrated inalcohol and embedded in plastic. Once the plastic had poly-merized, the cochlear bone which surrounds the soft tissue ofthe inner ear was removed with a sharpened steel pick. Pieces ofrazor blade were used to divide the cochlear duct into smallsegments which ranged in length from 0.6 to 4.9 millimeters.Each segment was then trimmed to remove most of the plasticfilling scala typmani. The trimmed segments were re-embedded in a thin layer of plastic. After the layer polymerized,simplified images of the segments of the organs of Corti weremade, their lengths were measured with a graphics tablet/computer system, and the histological appearances of the sen-sory cells and eighth nerve fibers were determined using aphase contrast microscope.

As noted in the previous report, all 11 temporal bones sus-tained some acute damage (e.g., detachment of the organ ofCorti from the basilar membrane) due to the exploding bulletsused to produce instant kills. The presence of acute damageprevented detailed analysis of the entire organ of Corti in eachspecimen. Nevertheless, in most specimens, a sufficientamount of tissue remained for the determination of some nor-mal cochlear parameters and for the assessment of the presenceof pre-existing (i.e., prior to gunshot) cochlear pathology.

The average length of the organ of Corti from the 11 Weddellseal cochleas was found to be 31.2 ± 1.1 millimeters. The aver-age density of inner and the three rows of outer hair cells permillimeter length of the organ of Corti were found to be 98 and395, respectively. These values should be considered as roughapproximations because the cell counts could be made in only asmall portion of each of the 11 organs of Corti. However, it isinteresting to note that these densities are similar to the innerand outer hair cell densities in several terrestrial mammals[human-109, 418 (Bredberg 1968); chinchilla-100, 405(Bohne, Kenworthy, and Carr 1982); guinea pig-92, 354(Thorne and Gavin 1984)].

Five of the 11 cochleas had no evidence of previous damage tothe organ of Corti. Due to extensive acute damage, the organ ofCorti was not visible in a sixth cochlea. In these six cochleas, theentire population of eight nerve fibers was intact. On this basis,it was concluded that none of these ears had sustained severeinjuries to the organ of Corti prior to death.

The remaining five cochleas had clear evidence of previousdamage. These injuries ranged from scattered loss of outer haircells to degeneration of an entire portion of the organ of Cortiand its replacement by squamous epithelium. This latter lesionwas accompanied by degeneration of the corresponding eighthnerve fibers. It should be noted that since only a small portion ofthe organ of Corti could be examined in each cochlea, additionalsensory cells may have been missing but their losses wouldhave been masked by the acute damage.

Although the etiology of the cochlear damage in the fiveWeddell seal cochleas cannot be determined with certainty,noise is the one ototraumatic agent which is known to have beenpresent in their environment.

The effect these cochlear lesions had on the hearing ability ofthe seals is unknown. However, based on studies in terrestrialmammals in which hearing loss has been correlated with senso-ry cell loss (e.g., Bohne and Clark 1982), it is highly unlikely thatany of the seals had a significant hearing impairment.

The research was supported by National Science Foundationgrant DPP 82-17708 and National Institutes of Health grantN5O1791.

References

Bohne, B.A., and W.W. Clark. 1982. Growth of hearing loss andcochlear lesion with increasing duration of noise exposure. In R.P.1-lamernik, D. Henderson, and R. Salvi (Eds.), New perspectives Onnoise-induced hearing loss. New York: Raven Press.

Bohne, BA., A. Kenworthy, and C.D. Carr. 1982. Density of myeli-nated nerve fivers in the chinchilla cochlea. Journal of the AcousticalSociety of America, 72(1), 102-107.

Bohne, BA., J.A. Thomas, E.R. Yohe, and S.H. Stone. 1985. Examina-tion of potential hearing damage in Weddell seals (Leptonychotes wed-dclii) in McMurdo Sound, Antarctica. Antarctic Journal of the U.S.,20(5), 174-176.

Bredberg, C. 1968. Cellular pattern and nerve supply of the humanorgan of Corti. Acta Oto-laryngologica, (Supplement 236).

Thorne, P.R., and J.B. Gavin. 1984. The accuracy of hair cell counts indetermining distance and position along the organ of Corti. Journal ofthe Acoustical Society of America, 76(2), 440-442.

208 ANTARCTIC JOURNAL