everyone a leader
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Everyone a Leader
A Grassroots Model for the
New Workplace
Horst BergmannKathleen HursonDarlene Russ-Eft
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.New York ⢠Chichester ⢠Weinheim ⢠Brisbane ⢠Singapore ⢠Toronto
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page i
![Page 2: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
This book is printed on acid-free paper. âs
Copyright Š 1999 by AchieveGlobal, Inc. All rights reserved.
Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc.Published simultaneously in Canada.
No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval sys-tem or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical,photocopying, recording, scanning or otherwise, except as permittedunder Sections 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, with-out either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorizationthrough payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the CopyrightClearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, (978) 750-8400, fax (978) 750-4744. Requests to the Publisher for permissionshould be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons,Inc., 605 Third Avenue, New York, NY 10158-0012, (212) 850-6011, fax(212) 850-6008, E-Mail: PERMREQ @ WILEY.COM.
This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative infor-mation in regard to the subject matter covered. It is sold with the under-standing that the publisher is not engaged in rendering professionalservices. If legal, accounting, medical, psychological or any other expertassistance is required, the services of a competent professional personshould be sought.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data:Bergmann, Horst.
Everyone a leader: a grassroots model for the new workplace /Horst Bergmann, Kathleen Hurson, Darlene Russ-Eft.
p. cm.Includes bibliographical references (p. ) and index.ISBN 0-471-19763-7 (cloth: alk. paper)1. Leadership. 2. Management. 3. Supervision of employees.
4. Customer relations. I. Russ-Eft, Darlene F. II. Hurson,Kathleen. III. Title.HD57.7.B47 1999658.4'092âdc21 98-49084
CIP
Printed in the United States of America.
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page ii
![Page 3: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
To our clients, colleagues, and friends who strive to live asgrassroots leaders.
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page iii
![Page 4: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Blank Page iv
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page iv
![Page 5: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
v
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments vii
Foreword x
CHAPTER 1: Because If You Donât, No One Will 1
CHAPTER 2: Create a Compelling Future 19
CHAPTER 3: Let the Customer Drive the Organization 38
CHAPTER 4: Involve Every Mind 54
CHAPTER 5: Manage Work Horizontally 76
CHAPTER 6: Build Credibility and Trust 97
CHAPTER 7: The Emotional Labor of Grassroots Leadership 117
TOOLS: Grassroots Leadership Step by Step 127
TOOL 1: Look Inside: How Good a Leader Are You? 129
TOOL 2: Navigating Change 133
TOOL 3: The Big Picture 136
TOOL 4: Howâs It GoingâReally? 139
TOOL 5: Reframe It! 142
TOOL 6: Cycle of Service Analysis 144
TOOL 7: TACT Process 147
TOOL 8: Meeting Unspoken Customer Needs 151
TOOL 9: Proactive Listening 155
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page v
![Page 6: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
TOOL 10: CoachingâBringing Out the Best in Others 160
TOOL 11: Giving Recognition 164
TOOL 12: Managing Your Priorities 168
TOOL 13: Influencing for Win-Win Outcomes 173
TOOL 14: The âTeam Formation Checklistâ 179
TOOL 15: Raising Difficult Issues with Your Team 182
TOOL 16: Expressing Yourself: Presenting Your Thoughts and Ideas 188
TOOL 17:Moving from Conflict to Collaboration 193
TOOL 18: Handling Emotions under Pressure 199
APPENDIX A: Executive Leadership Study 204
APPENDIX B: Teams and Quality: A Blended Strategy Works Best 208
APPENDIX C: Validation of the Measurement of LeadershipCompetencies among Executives 212
APPENDIX D: Study to Define Leadership Competencies 215
APPENDIX E: Validation of Leadership Competencies among Individual Contributors 220
APPENDIX F: Leadership Training at All Levels 222
Notes 229
Bibliography 230
References 235
Index 236
About the Authors 243
About AchieveGlobal 244
vi CONTENTS
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page vi
![Page 7: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
vii
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
First and foremost, we want to thank Barry Schwenkmeyer forhis enormous contribution to this book. With the help of hisextraordinary intelligence and remarkable insights, we wereable to bring to life what could have been dry research find-ings. We feel blessed to have him as part of our team.
Many of our associates at AchieveGlobal provided us withinvaluable support. Amy Avergun deserves special recognitionfor her thorough review, critical commentary, and insightfulcomments on each page of this book.
The research efforts were accomplished through the capablehands of Lilanthi Ravishankar, Judith Richterman, and JulieWinkle.
We are also very grateful for the review and feedback onthe materials provided by Todd Warren Beck, ConstanceBentley, Jennifer Berkley, Caryl Berrey, Joseph Boschi, KarenBrennan, Camille M. Busette, Martha L. Chamberlain, DarleneCoker, Marcia Corbett, Ed Del Gaizo, Audrey Ellison, RandieGuest, Juan F. Gutierrez, Howard Kamens, Maureen Kelly,
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page vii
![Page 8: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Alexandra Lang, John LaVeck, J. J. Martin, John Mulholland,Craig Perrin, Lynn Piecuch, Cornelien Posada, Susan Muttart,Bill Silberman, and Joyce Thompsen. Nan Lyon, Roz Madden,and Michelle Soto provided stellar administrative support.
The research efforts received assistance or critical review bythe researchers at the American Institutes for Research: KristiAndes, Donald McLaughlin, Jeanne Moulton, and Roger Levine.
Our international colleagues were invaluable in helping usto gain entry to organizations in their respective countries:Colin Duncan of AchieveGlobal UK, Pat Sheridan of Achieve-Global Ireland Training & Development Ltd., and Rod Smartof AchieveGlobal Australia.
We received additional critical commentary from our col-leagues in other Times Mirror Companies: Jeanne Hartley ofthe Los Angeles Times, and Durrie Monsma and William C.Lockwood of Jeppesen Sanderson.
We also want to thank John Harrison and Jan Stiles for help-ing us with early drafts of the book, and Margaret McGuan andLilia Schwartz for helping with needed administrative support.
Most of all, we are indebted to the numerous unnamedpeople who contributed their insights on leadership throughthe critical incidents. We can, however, recognize the follow-ing individuals who agreed to participate in lengthy tele-phone or in-person interviews: Major Greg Balzer, U.S. MarineCorps Recruiting Command; Michelle Bauman, UnitedExpress, Atlantic Coast Airlines; Des Byrne, Wavin Ireland,Ltd.; Jerry Carr, Rochester Telephone; Janet H. Clement,Office of Management Excellence, U.S. Mint; LorraineCosgrove, Intel Ireland Ltd.; Jack Crouch, Prime Tanning;Peter Dean, The Wharton School and The University ofTennessee; John Eft, Office of Counsel, U.S. Army Corps ofEngineers; Steven B. Falk, San Francisco Newspaper Agency;Kenneth Farrell, The Farrell Group; Monica Gleeson, SigmaWireless Communications; Judy Goetz, Fidelity and DepositCompany of Maryland; Jordan Goldstein, Gensler Architec-ture Design Planning Worldwide; Merry Goodenough, Officeof Counsel, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers; Colm Gorman,Intel Ireland Ltd.; Jeremy Hay, Cendant PHH; Greg Hense,EPCOR Utilities Inc.; Jo Dee Hughes, Honeywell Avionics;Tina Kannapel, U.S. Marshals Service; Gary J. Kral, Cessna
viii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page viii
![Page 9: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Aircraft Company; Max Lil, Industrial Incineration; MaryLucas, Cort Furniture Rental; Christopher Lydon, consultant;Judy McTighe, U.S. Census Bureau; Gil Murdoch, LafargeConstruction Materials; Anthony OâDowd, COREL Corpo-ration Ltd.; Timothy Olson, U.S. Census Bureau; LieutenantColonel Jack Pharris, U.S. Marine Corps Recruiting Com-mand; Angie Risley, Whitbread PLC; Colonel Clyde Slick, U.S.Marine Corps; Rex Smitherman, Department of Commerce;Olga Vives, BT Office Products International; Robert Wasley,Raychem Corporation.
Acknowledgments ix
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page ix
![Page 10: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
x
COMPETITIVE EXCELLENCE REQUIRES STRONG LEADERSHIP. PEOPLE IN
organizations need and respond to leadership. Yet often, lead-ership seems in short supply. This book aims to help.
Leaders need to create exciting visions of a better future,which are then made concrete through ambitious and measur-able goals that galvanize people and get them moving in thesame direction. Far too few individuals within organizationsknow how to do this. Fewer still are prepared for the daily,grassroots give-and-take required of anyone who is seriousabout turning visions and goals into results. These are chal-lenges men and women at every level in the organization needto accept. The world is so complex and moving so fast that it isnot possible for a few executives âat the topâ to make all of thedecisions necessary to keep their organizations competitivelysharp. Organizations need people at every level with thecourage and the skill to step up to leadership opportunities,whether theyâre formally designated leaders or not.
FOREWORD
Leadership Counts
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page x
![Page 11: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
LeadershipâOr Empowerment?The most successful organizations I know are chock-full of prin-cipled, committed people who have been encouraged and pre-pared to do whatever it takes to help their organizations reachtheir goalsâchallenge accepted wisdom, if need be, make inde-pendent decisions based on their own assessments, take risks,and continuously be on the alert for those moments whensomeone needs to step in and keep things moving forward.
Isnât this really just empowerment? I donât think so. To methis is leadership. In fact, itâs what any formally designatedleader does every day of his or her life. If you allow for issues ofscope and scale, itâs what every employee in an organizationshould be able to do. When we call this empowerment, I thinkweâre selling people short. Weâre saying, in effect, âItâs nice toshow some initiative. Everybodyâs overworked these days, andwe need people to pitch in and help out. But of course youcanât be expected to have the judgment of someone like asupervisor or manager who is in an official position of leader-ship. So donât go too far. Donât push too hard. Donât care toomuch.â
To Be a LeaderThis book is written for those of you who want to make a dif-ference in your organizations regardless of your job title. It willhelp you understand that:
⢠Your organization will operate most effectively when itsgoals are clear, ambitious, and measurable. If theyâre not,donât sit back and complain. In such circumstances, yourgreatest leadership opportunity may be to push for clarity.
⢠Successful leaders tune in to where their organization isgoing, look around to see what needs to be done to getthere, and move quickly to do it. They have a bias forresults.
⢠As a leader, you need a healthy dose of self-confidence.The going will get tough, so you need the inner strengthto push ahead.
Foreword: Leadership Counts xi
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page xi
![Page 12: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
In other words, this book provides the perspective and theskills people at any level of the organization can use to becomemore effective leaders. It will help you make a difference.
âMark WillesChairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer,
Times Mirror, andPublisher, Los Angeles Times
xii FOREWORD: LEADERSHIP COUNTS
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page xii
![Page 13: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
1
CHAPTER
1
Because If You Donât,No One Will
BEING A LEADER IN TODAYâS CHANGE-SATURATED ORGANIZATIONS
often feels more like picking your way through a torn-up landsprawl full of half-finished construction projects, where free-ways end abruptly in midspan, and billboards advertisingbright futures compete for your attention with road signs longout of date. As you go along, you see problems that need fixingand people who could possibly use some assistance. You won-der if you should keep moving or if you should stop and help.But then you ask yourself, âIf I were to stop, what could I do?What should I do?â
This book provides a road map for people who aspire toleadership success in this new world. It describes a break-through model of grassroots leadership based on an analysis ofhundreds of observed experiences of what people actually dowhen they lead. Made up of specific behaviors that you canlearn, this grassroots model applies equally to those in formalmanagement positions and to individual contributors with nopositional authorityâpeople who donât really think of them-
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 1
![Page 14: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
selves as leaders, yet who nevertheless seem to have leader-ship challenges forced upon them on almost a daily basis. Bestobserved and most effective in one-on-one and small-groupinteractions, this kind of leadership is nevertheless not for thefaint of heart. It calls for someone with the skills of a salesper-son, the credibility of a trusted friend, and occasionally thecourage of a freedom fighter.
. . .At 2:30 in the afternoon Tony is facing a challenge he is notsure he is up for.
Tony used to think he was a product development engineer,but now he seems to be âattachedâ to the Customer SupportCenter pretty much full-time. Heâs been there on the phone allday answering customersâ questions about one of the sophisti-cated monitoring systems his company manufactures. Itâs actu-ally the system he helped design six years agoâthe one thatgot handed off to another manufacturing line last year as partof a big cost-cutting consolidation, where it occupies a low-priority position in the new lineâs list of products. Not surpris-ingly, this product now has one of the poorest yield rates ofany product in the company. It sometimes seems to Tony thateveryone wishes the product would just go away.
Everyone except the customers. At the moment, Tonyâs onthe phone with a salesman whoâs complaining that heâs got sixhot orders and canât get Manufacturing to commit to a firmship date. âCome on, Tony,â he wheedles. âGo over there andsee if you canât light a fire under somebody.â
âLike who? I donât even know half those guys any more.ââBut they know you! Youâre the expert on this product!ââLook,â Tony replies, âas far as theyâre concerned, all this
product has ever done is make them look bad. Iâve got no timeto get in the middle of another fight with them.â
âBut I got six orders here! Youâve got to do something!ââMe!? Why me?ââBecause if you donât,â the salesman says, âthereâs no one
who will.âAs Tony trudges across the plant to the other line, he is not
looking forward to the reception heâll get. He doesnât even
2 EVERYONE A LEADER
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 2
![Page 15: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
know if this is something he should be spending his time on.Maybe he simply feels sorry for the salesman. Maybe heâs gottoo much of himself invested in this product. Maybe the com-pany is phasing it out. Tony has asked his boss in ProductDevelopment about the possibility but hasnât gotten a straightanswer. Besides, Tony now spends so much time in theSupport Center he hardly sees his boss any more.. . .New Opportunities for Leadership
Although the specifics may differ, the dilemma the salesmanhas dropped in Tonyâs lap is very much like the leadershipchallenges faced by all those men and women who are strug-gling today to make sense out of new ways of working, often inlooser corporate configurations that have undefined, but notnecessarily redefined, their jobs. They care about the organiza-tion, often very deeply. Theyâve gotten the message about notresisting change, but how do they translate this into action? Itâsnot that they donât see situations where their help seemsneeded; they see all too many. What they donât see is the sup-port or the authority to intervene. Often, in fact, they run intojust the opposite: inertia, covert (and overt) resistance, andmessy interpersonal issues, none of which they feel equippedto handle.
The research on which this book is based cuts through thisconfusion by focusing on the concrete behaviors that wereobserved to produce leadership. It highlights what leadershipactually looks like as it is practiced today, who the real leadersare, and where to concentrate your efforts to be a successfulleader yourself. It was written for managers, nonmanagers, teamleaders, project managers, and human resource professionals.
Seizing opportunities for grassroots leadership is not a risk-free proposition. Often ambiguous and poorly defined, suchopportunities donât come with either a set of instructions fromthe boss or a promise of absolution if things turn out badly. Tobe successful, people often have to go outside their depart-ments, as well as their comfort zones. They may need to callpolicies and procedures into question and force the people
Because If You Donât, No One Will 3
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 3
![Page 16: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
higher up in the organization to provide more information, toclarify issues, and to make difficult decisions.
If those opportunities are so challenging, why, then, are peo-ple pursuing them? Because they want to make their jobs, andother peopleâs jobs, easier? Feel a strong sense of ownership?Need recognition? Seek advancement? Want to make an impact?Our research indicates itâs for all of these reasons, and more.Sometimes, itâs out of a heartfelt conviction that itâs simply theright thing to do. And sometimes, as for Tony, itâs because of acomplex interplay of unexamined reasons that the salesmantapped into when he said, âBecause if you donât, thereâs no onewho will.â
. . .Thinking as he walks along about what heâs going to say to theoperators, Tony knows that his strongest argument is the con-tinuing customer demand for this product. After all, why is thecompany in business, if not to provide customers what theywant and need? At the same time he realizes that the situationisnât quite so simple. For one thing, âhisâproduct (which is stillhow he thinks of it) hasnât generated anything like the sales ofits three companion monitoring systems, and it probably neverwill. So maybe moving the product to the new line was notsimply to cut costs. Maybe thereâs a message there. Maybe thesalesmanâs inability to interest anybody in filling his six ordersis further handwriting on the wall. On the other hand, the salesforce has always maintained that customers prefer to buy allfour systems from one vendor, and that if the company discon-tinued this one system, it would lose sales of the other three.This being the case, as Tony would like to believe, it makes nosense to deep-six his product . . . does it?
Not for the first time Tony considers how much easier hislife would be if the companyâs overall plans and goals werecomplete and consistentâand cascaded down (as the head ofthe plant is always saying) to his level. Instead of trying to readthe corporate tea leaves, heâd know exactly where he stood,and how he should be spending his time. He remembers aperiod in the past when his boss could have guided him onthese matters, but sheâs so overloaded these days she doesnât
4 EVERYONE A LEADER
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 4
![Page 17: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
have the time. In fact, Tony has begun to wonder if, even withall the time in the world, she could help him.
In the back of his mind the suspicion is growing that the onlyway heâs going to get answers is to force the issue in somewayâalthough heâs not sure how, or with whom. Who knows,this meeting heâs about to have could be a step in that direction.. . .What Has Created These Grassroots Leadership Opportunities?
These opportunities have emerged as the result of far-reachingchanges taking place in organizations throughout the world.
Increased Competition and More Demanding Customers
Better, faster, cheaper, newer. These are the standards organiza-tions must meet to be competitive todayânot just one or twoor three of them, but all four. This is a tall order, and in the lastdecade, organizations have turned themselves inside out tryingto reach these goals. Pity the organization that canât figure outhow to simultaneously (1) stay ahead of the competition; (2)give its customers not only what they want, but also what theyneedâplus what they never thought of but will be totally daz-zled by once they get it; and oh yes, also (3) make a profit.
A Loosening-Up of the Formal Organizational Structure
It has been clear for several years that the traditional organiza-tional structureâthe standard org chart (see Figure 1.1); the top-down chain of command; the well-defined responsibilities forexecutives, managers, and supervisorsâdoesnât work very well.
As the competitive need for âbetter, faster, cheaper, newerâpushed performance to its limits, a discrepancy was revealedbetween the traditional structure and how work actually getsdone. Under such pressure, the traditional structure began tobreak down (Figure 1.2).
This push probably marked the moment at which your job,whether managerial or not, began to feel out of control. No
Because If You Donât, No One Will 5
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 5
![Page 18: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
longer did authority cascade down from the top until itreached you in a compact package of responsibilities that tiedneatly into both the level above and the level below yours.
Today, more and more organizations have evolved into struc-tures that resemble a fishnet (see Figure 1.3)âstrong, resilient,structured in its way, but flexible enough to drastically changeshape depending on the forces applied to it, and the changinggoals and directions of the organization.1
While you may appreciate the organizational need for suchflexibility, if you are in a fishnet organization it is precisely this
6 EVERYONE A LEADER
Figure 1.1 The traditional organizational structure.
Figure 1.2 The traditional organizational structure under pressure.
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 6
![Page 19: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
flexibility that can drive you crazy. Fishnet organizations stillhave relationships and hierarchies, but they are temporary,lasting only as long as a task requires them. The structure isconstantly being redraped, so to speak, so that exactly theright components can come together to respond to specificand fast-changing business needs. Boundaries between theorganization and the rest of the world are deliberately blurredso the organization can get as close as possible to customers,and also enter into outside partnerships and alliances.Although such flexibility may be necessary for business rea-sons, it can play havoc with your roles and responsibilities,and it offers little guidance about how to structure your contri-bution to the organization.
Fewer and Busier Managers
Another factor creating new leadership opportunities is thereduction in managerial ranks. Today, there are fewer man-agers and supervisors than there used to be, and those who areleft have been given so many extra responsibilities and peopleto manage that they canât always carry out their traditionalleadership duties. Besides, in todayâs organizations, there areso many cross-functional teams, so many off-site and out-
Because If You Donât, No One Will 7
Figure 1.3 The âfishnetâ organization.
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 7
![Page 20: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
sourced activities, that managers donât have nearly the knowl-edge of or control over events they once did.
One duty that has fallen victim to this trend is the annualperformance evaluation. Never a favorite among managers, intodayâs cross-functional, long-distance organization this man-dated activity can seem truly anachronistic. Take the experi-ence of a research manager, whom we can call Wendy, at amultidivision corporation. One of her direct reports, letâs callhim Leon, is a research analyst who works in another city. Hehas spent the last year on a cross-functional team developingstandards and software guidelines for certain procedures com-mon to all company divisions. Because Wendy is not involvedwith this project, she has virtually no direct information aboutthe quality of his work. Yet, the company requires her to con-duct an annual evaluation of his performance; Leon, for hispart, wants and expects feedback on how heâs doing.
In this dilemma lie the seeds of a leadership opportunity formembers of Leonâs team. Why shouldnât they step in and givehim feedback about his performance? In fact, some peoplewould say that feedback about Leon from his peers wouldprobably be more accurate than Wendyâs, even if she weremanaging this project from the office next door to his.
The Predominance of the Knowledge Worker
Information is one of an organizationâs most valuable assets;knowledge workers are the people who create, analyze, anduse it. Knowledge workers are sometimes defined as peoplewho donât make anything tangible. These days, however,even workers on the factory floor often use computers andother information-processing equipment. Knowledge workerstoday are everywhereâin manufacturing, design, finance,information services, customer service, and technical sup-port. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, be-tween 1986 and 1996 the number of âprofessional specialtyâworkers increased by 34 percent, compared with a 19percent increase in the number of workers in all occupations.Between 1996 and 2006, growth in this category is expected
8 EVERYONE A LEADER
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 8
![Page 21: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
to outstrip total growth in all occupational areas by more than15 percent.2
As a knowledge worker, to some degree you probably shareseveral common characteristics and patterns of work, whichhave contributed to the creation of new leadership opportuni-ties. Often you work on your own. The work you do and thevalue you add can be hard to observe, because they involvethought and judgment. You may know more about your workthan your manager does. You may feel a stronger allegiance toyour academic discipline or field of expertise than to yourorganization. Finally, although you donât necessarily value man-agement skills or want to move up to a management position,you may become involved in projects and project teams thatrequire you to do management work.
Although knowledge workers tend to be self-managing, atleast to the extent that they donât want or need daily supervi-sion, theyâre not necessarily self-leading. They still need theleadership their managers once provided, even if they canât getit from their busy managers any more. They may need coach-ing to improve their performance. They may need periodicupdates to understand how their work fits into changing orga-nizational objectives.
A Growing Focus on Projects and Teams
Youâve probably noticed a shift in your organization away frommanaging routine, day-to-day activities toward managing pro-jects. Projects present a raft of leadership challenges: projectmembers from different departments, resources seldom underthe direct control of a project manager, and reporting relation-ships that can create conflicts between project and departmen-tal goals. In addition to project teams, many organizationstoday have reconfigured departments and work groups intopermanent teams, ranging from hierarchical, business-as-usualgroups to totally self-managed entities. These new configura-tions present opportunities for leadership within teams,between teams and the rest of the organization, and betweenteams and customers and the rest of the outside world.
Because If You Donât, No One Will 9
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 9
![Page 22: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
. . .As Tony drives home that evening after his meeting with theoperators on the other line, he realizes that although he stilldoesnât have answers to any of his big questions, at least a lot oflittle roadblocks came to light. He wrote them all down. One,the materials arenât being stored properly; no wonder theydonât perform up to spec. Two, the line supervisor, who alwaysgets so argumentative about having to change over the line forsuch a âpiddling little run,â doesnât really understand theprocess but has been too embarrassed to admit it. Three, sev-eral pallets sat on the receiving dock for two days before anyonenoticed them. And so forth. Tony is surprised by the positivereception he got from the operators. Maybe he shouldnât havetaken notes. Now they probably think heâs going to get thingsstraightened out for them.. . .What Does Leadership Look Like?
As more employees at every level find themselves, like Tony,almost forced to exercise leadershipâthe if-you-donât-no-one-will scenarioâwe at AchieveGlobal have sought to learn moreabout the skills and behaviors required in such cases, andabout current patterns of leadership in general. As a world-wide training and consulting company, we provide training inthe skills that help people lead more effectively at all organi-zational levels. We therefore asked, âHow do the skills andbehaviors required of people like Tony differ from thoserequired of executives, managers, and other nominal leaders?Furthermore, what training will best prepare employees atevery level to make the most of these emerging leadershipopportunities?â
Before we raised these questions in 1995, most of our lead-ership research focused on formal leaders at the supervisory,managerial, and executive levels. In the early 1990s, for exam-ple, we undertook a study to identify the factors that promotedorganizational change. We asked a cross section of executives
10 EVERYONE A LEADER
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 10
![Page 23: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
in both successful and less successful U.S. and Canadian orga-nizations to describe and rate their own success on 15 dimen-sions of organizational improvement, including productivity,cycle time, customer loyalty, profitability, employee retention,and market share. We compared responses from the successfulwith the less successful organizations. What emerged was aclear picture of what the successful executives did that madethe difference.
We summarized these findings in five key strategies wecalled the CLIMB⢠model of executive effectiveness, whichbecame the basis for much of our consulting work with execu-tive teams. The CLIMB model describes the five leadershipstrategies that outstanding executives follow to ensure the suc-cess of an organizational change initiative:
Create a compelling future.
Let the customer drive the organization.
Involve every mind.
Manage work horizontally.
Build personal credibility.
Then, in 1995, we began the search for skills and behaviorsthat might help nonmanagers like Tony meet the less-structuredleadership challenges of todayâs organization. We launched thiswider search by analyzing over 100 leadership studies andscores of books on leadership. Our initial findings were, at best,inconclusive.
⢠All the studies examined leadership in formal leadersâexecutives and managersânot in technical workers, non-management professionals, project leaders, team leaders,and frontline employees. Yet, in todayâs pared-down orga-nizations, these employees are not only increasing in num-ber, in the absence of traditional managers they areprecisely the men and women who have leadership virtu-ally foisted on them.
⢠We found no consensus on what makes a good leader.Lists of skills and attributes differed from study to study. It
Because If You Donât, No One Will 11
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 11
![Page 24: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
seemed that every professor, management guru, andstrategist had his or her view, and agreement on findingswas relatively rare.
⢠The opinions of survey respondents tended to reflect the-ories in vogue at the time of a particular study. For exam-ple, when Peters and Watermanâs best-seller, In Search ofExcellence, was scoring points in executive boardrooms,over 30 percent of respondents in studies of that periodcited âmanagement by walking aroundâas a desirable lead-ership behavior. In earlier and later studies, that advicerarely appeared.
⢠Most studies described leadership in general terms. Forinstance, although a study might mention integrity as anattribute of effective leaders, researchers rarely exploredthe day-to-day behaviors or skills that embody or commu-nicate that attribute.
These early efforts helped us see that if we wanted to find aleadership model expressing todayâs realities, we would haveto conduct our own research. We wanted to isolate a set ofcompetencies closely associated with effective leadership,regardless of the level or role of the employee who mastersthem. To clarify those competencies, we chose the critical-incident methodology, an approach validated in literally thou-sands of studies since the early 1940s.3
Using this methodology, AchieveGlobal researchers askedpeople at all organizational levels to describe specific recentoccurrences of both good and poor leadership that they hadobserved directly. Incidents could involve managers (supervi-sors, middle management, and executives) or nonmanagers(e.g., technical workers, nonmanagement professionals, pro-ject leaders, team leaders, and frontline employees).
What We Asked
Think of a time within the past month when a person in yourorganization showed good (or poor) leadership. What didthat person do that showed good (or poor) leadership? Whatwas the result of this behavior? What was the personâs posi-tion in your organization?
12 EVERYONE A LEADER
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 12
![Page 25: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
We simply asked our respondents to recall an incident anddescribe what happened as clearly as possible. Later, we sortedthe incidents into categories based on the central behavior,purpose, or result described in each incident.
Our study engaged the full organizational hierarchy, fromcorporate executive officers (CEOs) and government execu-tives to frontline employees in over 450 organizations (ran-domly chosen from growth sectors like manufacturing,high-tech, service, government, and education) in all majorregions of the United States and Canada. Organizations rangedin size from fewer than 250 employees to over 10,000. Thestudy produced 1,871 critical incidentsâverbal snapshots, asit wereâof what individuals in a range of roles and industriesregarded as examples of leadership, or its absence.Researchers then analyzed the incidents for commonalities,sorted them into 120 larger categories of behavior, and com-bined closely related categories into 17 leadership competen-cies. Figure 1.4 illustrates that process.
A New Grassroots Model of Leadership
We believe that the leadership competencies we identified addup to a new grassroots model of leadership, derived from andappropriate to a range of roles at all organizational levels. Thecritical-incident approach allows us to define leadership basedon the day-to-day actions of individuals, as described by otherindividuals, at every level of the organization. In that respect,this model differs from leadership models resting solely on theexperiences and opinions of designated leaders, or on what
Because If You Donât, No One Will 13
Figure 1.4 Example: from critical incidents to competency.
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 13
![Page 26: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
experts say leaders should do. We call it a grassroots model ofleadership because itâs rooted in behaviors that can be per-formed by anyone regardless of position.
The following 17 competencies in the model add up to whatleadership looks like:
1. Create and describe a vision.
2. Manage changes required to realize a vision.
3. Respond to identified customer needs.
4. Support individual effort.
5. Support team effort.
6. Share information.
7. Make decisions that solve problems.
8. Manage cross-functional processes.
9. Display technical skills.
10. Manage projects.
11. Manage time and resources.
12. Take initiative beyond job requirements.
13. Take responsibility for your own actions and the actionsof your group.
14. Handle emotions in yourself and others.
15. Display professional ethics.
16. Show compassion.
17. Make credible presentations.
These competencies define leadership as behaviorsânot astraits such as tenacity, for example, or integrity, which are oftenheld to be key characteristics of effective leaders. The distinc-tion between a behavior and a trait is important to anyone whowants to become a better leader. Itâs possible through study andpractice to learn specific behaviors, like âshare information,âbutacquiring a trait like âopenness,â for example, or âhonestyâ is afar more daunting task. We have found that the best way toacquire a trait is to learn the behaviors that express it. For thisreason, the grassroots model is not only more reality-based thanmore theoretical constructs, itâs also more learnable.
14 EVERYONE A LEADER
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 14
![Page 27: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
The Leader in Each of Us
Still, our research prompted a key question: Do we need a newsummary model of leadership for nonmanagement staff, or willthe CLIMB model serve to guide this group as well as execu-tives? To answer that question, we enlisted both Achieve-Global and outside researchers to review the critical incidentsand the competencies through the lens of the CLIMB strate-gies. With strong agreement among independent researchers,we were able to associate each of the incidents and competen-cies with one of the five CLIMB strategies as follows:
CLIMB STRATEGIES COMPETENCIES
Create a compelling future. Create and describe a vision.Manage changes required to realize a vision.
Let the customer drive the Respond to identified customer organization. needs.Involve every mind. Support individual effort.
Support team effort.Share information.Make decisions that solve problems.
Manage work horizontally. Manage cross-functional processes.Display technical skills.Manage projects.Manage time and resources.
Build personal credibility. Take initiative beyond job requirements.Take responsibility for your own actions and the actions of your group.Handle emotions in yourself and others.Display professional ethics.Show compassion.Make credible presentations.
Because If You Donât, No One Will 15
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 15
![Page 28: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Because the critical incidents describe people at every level,the CLIMB model defines leadership not just for executives,but for every employee. Using CLIMB, itâs possible to evaluateleadership using the very same criteria for the executive as forthe frontline worker. More important, itâs possible to improveleadership at all levels by training people in the competenciessummarized in CLIMB.
In other words, there is a leader in each of usâif we masterand apply the CLIMB strategiesâwhether weâre president,sales manager, technician, or staff support person.
Other Key Findings
In addition to identifying the competencies of leadership,the critical-incident study produced the following key find-ingsâsome new, and some important affirmations of earlierthinking.
Organizations today cannot survive if leadership is lim-ited to the CEOs, executives, and managers. Life movestoo quickly, and top management is too removed from theaction. As the incidents demonstrated, leadership opportuni-ties can arise at any moment:
⢠On a busy loading dock when a foreman switches carriersbecause he reads of an impending strike
⢠During a heated team meeting when one of the memberstakes it upon him- or herself to mediate the dispute
⢠When a harried administrative assistant volunteers to pullin extra people to get a proposal out on time
People define leaders by what they doâor donât doâinâsmallâ moments. Respondents in the study talked aboutpeople who took a moment to coach, to bolster confidence, toresolve a dispute, or to go after a resource. This is in markedcontrast to the commonly held belief that leaders define them-selves through heroic, high-profile actions.
16 EVERYONE A LEADER
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 16
![Page 29: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
The instant that people experience you as a leader,they start keeping score. Itâs not clear why, but the studyfound that if you step up to a leadership challenge, peoplewill judge you as a leader not only in that situation, but fromthat point on. Their criteria: how well you perform the 17competencies.
For people to see you as a leader, you need the completeset of leadership skills. Just as strength in one or two acad-emic subjects does not make a good student, in the eyes of therespondents strength in a few leadership competencies doesnot make a good leader.
How the Book Is Organized
Each of the five main chapters of the book focuses on one ofthe five CLIMB strategies and covers:
1. Why itâs important
2. Symptoms to watch for in your work group or organiza-tion that indicate the strategy is being badly executed orunderexecuted
3. What you can do to carry it out successfully
4. Examples of how leaders at all organizational levels haveapplied it
5. Reference to specific tools and techniques to help youperform this strategy (see Tools: Grassroots LeadershipStep by Step and the appendices)
The appendices also contain additional background on theAchieveGlobal research supporting this book, and in additionyouâll find a bibliography of pertinent books and articles.
. . .The clock next to the bed says 2:00 A.M. Tony turns over andtries to go back to sleep, but his mind refuses to slow down.Forget about it, he tells himself. Thereâs no way you can take
Because If You Donât, No One Will 17
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 17
![Page 30: Everyone a Leader](https://reader031.vdocument.in/reader031/viewer/2022012101/61db887bb984c9495038cc4b/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
those operators under your wing, absolutely no way. Five min-utes later he gives up on sleeping and pads downstairs to seewhatâs in the refrigerator. With considerable misgivings, herealizes heâs in too far to back out now. Nobody cares as muchas he does. Itâs not fair, he thinks. If work keeps you fromsleeping, at least it ought to be your own work.. . .Grassroots Leadership Step by Step
Look Inside: How Good a Leader Are You? In the tools sec-tion on pages 129â132, you will find a leadership profile basedon the five CLIMB strategies. Completing this self-evaluationwill give you an idea of how you rate your own performance asa leader according to the criteria that the critical-incident studyshowed others will use to judge you.
From breakthrough research, AchieveGlobal hasdeveloped a new model of leadership that appliesequally to managers and nonmanagers. The modelemerges from, and is geared to, changes that haveswept across organizations in the last decade: a loos-ening of structure, fewer and busier managers, moreknowledge workers, and a growing focus on pro-jects and teams. What makes it a grassroots model isthe fact that itâs based on a collection of hundreds ofactual incidentsâverbal snapshotsâin which peo-ple at all organizational levels demonstrated behaviorthat was described by direct observers as leadership.From this research emerged a series of 17 leadershipcompetenciesâspecific behaviors that anyone canlearn to become a more effective leader at any levelof the organization. Furthermore, these were foundto correlate closely with AchieveGlobalâs five CLIMBstrategies for executive effectiveness.
18 EVERYONE A LEADER
>
0-471-19763-7 2/10/99 6:51 PM Page 18