evolution of bands in solids - universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-dos.pdfthe...

36
P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids http://folk.uio.no/ravi/MENA9520-15 Prof.P. Ravindran, Department of Physics, Central University of Tamil Nadu, India & Center for Materials Science and Nanotechnology, University of Oslo, Norway Evolution of Bands in Solids 1

Upload: others

Post on 11-Aug-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

http://folk.uio.no/ravi/MENA9520-15

Prof.P. Ravindran, Department of Physics, Central University of Tamil

Nadu, India

&Center for Materials Science and Nanotechnology,

University of Oslo, Norway

Evolution of Bands in Solids

1

Page 2: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Band Structure: KCl

We first depict the band structure of an ionic crystal, KCl. The bands are very

narrow, almost like atomic ones. The band gap is large around 9 eV. For alkali

halides they are generally in the range 7-14 eV.

Page 3: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Band Structure: silver (fcc)

Page 4: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Band Structure: tungsten (bcc)

Page 5: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Empirical pseudopotential method

Energy band of Si, Ge and Sn

Empirical pseudopotential

method

Si Ge Sn

Page 6: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

6Band structure of semiconductor

Calculated energy band structure of

Silicon

Calculated energy band structure of

GaAs

- Interband transitions : The excitation or relaxation of electrons between

subbands

- Indirect gap : The bottom of the conduction band and the top of the

valence band do not occur at the same k

- Direct gap : The bottom of the conduction band and the top of the

valence band occur at the same k

Page 7: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

DOS is Nanomaterials

In bulk (a), layered (b) and wire (c) materials, there are always states populated which do not contribute to gain. These are parasitic states and contribute to inefficiency.

In quantum dot (d) materials, the DOS is a set of discrete states. Theory predicts this type of material is ideal for the gain region of a laser because fewer parasitic states are occupied.

Page 8: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

8

First Brillouin zone E vs. k band

diagram of zincblende semiconductors

One relevant conduction band is

formed from s- like atomic orbitals“unit cell” part of wavefunction is

approximately spherically symmetric.

The three upper valence bands are

formed from (three) p- like orbitalsand the spin-orbit interaction splits off

lowest, “split-off” hole (i. e., valence)

band. The remaining two hole bands

have the same energy (“degenerate”)at zone center, but their curvature is

different, forming a “heavy hole” (hh)

band (broad), and a “light hole” (lh)band (narrower)

Page 9: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

SnO2: band structure

VBM

CBM

Density of States

Page 10: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

10

Page 11: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

11

How to get conduction in Si?

Page 12: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

12

Doping Silicon with Donors (n-type)

Page 13: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

13

Doping Silicon with Acceptors (p-type)

Page 14: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

14

Atomic Density

for Si

Page 15: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

15

Summary of n- and p-type Silicon

Page 16: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

16

Page 17: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

17

Page 18: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Introduction to Silicon

6

The appearance of Band Gap, separating CB and VB

The 6 CB minima are not located at the center of 1st

Brillouin zone, INDIRECT GAP

CB VB-H VB-L

1st Brillouin zone of Diamond

lattice

CB

VB

Anisotropy in surface of E

Page 19: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

19

Page 20: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

20

The Bandgap Problem of DFT

Page 21: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

21

The Bandgap problem [Sham,Schluter, PRL, 51, 1888 (1983).

Page 22: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

22

Baandgap Error in Semiconductors from LDA

Page 23: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

23Calculated Badgap values of Si from various level of Calculation

Page 24: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

24GWA calculation of Bandgap of Semiconductors

Page 25: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

25

Graphite band structure (Semi Metal)

Page 26: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 03 June 2013 Various Aspects of Energy Issues

Fermi level

As Fermions are added to an energy band, they will fill the

available states in an energy band just like water fills a

bucket.

The states with the lowest energy are filled first, followed by

the next higher ones.

At absolute zero temperature (T = 0 K), the energy levels are

all filled up to a maximum energy, which we call the Fermi

level. No states above the Fermi level are filled.

Page 27: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 03 June 2013 Various Aspects of Energy Issues

22/3

2

( ) 3( )

8F

hc NE

mc V

FERMI ENERGY

Page 28: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Fermi surface sampling for metallic systems

The determination of the Fermi level might be delicate for metallic systems

Slightly different choices of k-points can lead to bands

entering or exiting the sum, depending if a given

eigenvalue is above or below the Fermi level.

Band structure of bulk Al

For this k-point, three

bands are occupied

For this k-point, two

bands are occupied

For this k-point, one

band is occupied

For a sufficiently dense Brillouin zone sampling, this should not be a problem

Page 29: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

For the k-points close to the Fermi surface, the

highest occupied bands can enter or exit the sums

from one iterative step to the next, just because the

adjustement of the Fermi energy

Difficulties in the convergence of the self-consistence procedure

with metals: smearing the Fermi surface

Instability of the self-consistent procedure

Solution 1: Use small self-consistent mixing coefficients

Solution 2: Smear the Fermi surface introducing a distribution of occupation number

The occupations are not any longer 1 (if below EF) or 0 (if above EF)

Gaussians

Fermi functions

C. –L. Fu and K. –M. Ho, Phys. Rev. B 28, 5480 (1989)

Page 30: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Smearing the Fermi surface: the Electronic Temperature

is a broadening energy parameter that is adjusted to avoid instabilities

in the convergence of the self-consistent procedure. It is a technical

issue. Due to its analogy with the Fermi distribution, this parameter is

called the Electronic Temperature

For a finite , the BZ integrals converge faster but to incorrect values. After

self-consistency has been obtained for a relatively large value of Tc , this has to

be reduced until the energy becomes independent of it.

Page 31: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Comparing energies of structures having

different symmetries: take care of BZ samplings

The BZ sampling of all the structures must be sampled

with the same accuracy

Since for unit cells of different shapes it is not possible to

choose exactly the same k-point sampling, a usual strategy is

to try and maintain the same density of k-points

Page 32: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 03 June 2013 Various Aspects of Energy Issues

CONTACT POTENTIAL

1 2contactV

e

Page 33: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 03 June 2013 Various Aspects of Energy Issues

Page 34: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 03 June 2013 Various Aspects of Energy Issues

BZ integration, “FERMI”-methods Replace the “integral” of the BZ by a finite summation on a mesh of “k-points”

weights wk,n depend on k and bandindex n (occupation)

– for full “bands” the weight is given by “symmetry”

w(G)=1, w(x)=2, w(D)=4, w(k)=8

shifted “Monkhorst-Pack” mesh

– for partially filled bands (metals) one must find the

Fermi-energy (integration up to NE) and determine

the weights for each state Ek,n

linear tetrahedron method (TETRA, eval=999)

linear tetrahedron method + “Bloechl” corrections (TETRA)

“broadening methods”

– gauss-broadening (GAUSS 0.005)

– temperature broadening (TEMP/TEMPS 0.005)

– broadening useful to damp scf oszillations, but dangerous (magnetic moment)

kk

nk

nknknk

EE

n

wkdrFn

*

,

,

3

,

*

,)(

G D X

Page 35: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Relativistic treatment

Valence states

– Scalar relativistic

mass-velocity

Darwin s-shift

– Spin orbit coupling on demand by

second variational treatment

Semi-core states

– Scalar relativistic

– on demand

spin orbit coupling by second

variational treatment

Additional local orbital (see Th-6p1/2)

Core states

– Fully relativistic

Dirac equation

For example: Ti

Page 36: Evolution of Bands in Solids - Universitetet i oslofolk.uio.no/ravi/cutn/ccmp/4b-bandstr-DOS.pdfThe remaining two hole bands have the same energy (“degenerate”) at zone center,

P.Ravindran, FME-course on Ab initio Modelling of solar cell Materials 19 June 2015 Evolution of Band structure of Solids

Relativistic semi-core states in fcc Th

additional local orbitals for

6p1/2 orbital in Th

Spin-orbit (2nd variational method)

J.Kuneš, P.Novak, R.Schmid, P.Blaha, K.Schwarz,

Phys.Rev.B. 64, 153102 (2001)