exhausting academia

8/13/2019 Exhausting Academia

1/11

!"#$%&'")*+

,-"$'./%*+$"0"'"12

3,*4"$567789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

AB+C*D%1 &E&.,FD&25

EXHAUSTING ACADEMIA: IN DEFENCE OF

ANTHROPOLOGY, IN SEARCH OF TIME1

Eeva Berglund

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

V22 0-=9 !)>/ "!/8( .--: ),: =): #-8,"9' X,8>/(98"8/9A )" "!/8( =/9"A )(/ !)>/,9 -B 2/)(,8,.A;(/)"8>8"? ),: /S;8"/*/,"' O/-#2/ ;), ;-**8" "- 2-,.+"/(* 8,"/22/;"1)2 #(-0/;"9 &8"!-1" /S#/(8/,;8,. "!//,"(/#(/,/1(P9 ,//: "- 9/22 -( "!/ ;-,91*/(P9 )::8;"8-, "- B)9!8-,' X,B-("1,)"/2?A "!/9/ ;-,:8"8-,9 )(/ )"(89< )9 .->/(,*/," #-28;8/9 !)>/ 8,;(/)9/: =1(/)1;();? &8"!8, 1,8>/(98"8/9 &!82/ )" "!/ 9)*/ "8*/ #(/991(8,.);):/*8;9 "- #(->/ "!/8( 19/B12,/99' W !)>/ =/;-*/ #/(91):/: "!)" ;-,9")," #/(B-(*),;/ *-,8"-(8,. -()1:8" 89 )" "!/ !/)(" -B );):/*8;9P ;-*#2)8,"9 H/'.' G!)""-;< IJJQA G"()"!/(, QRRR /:'A Y--:2): QRRQA

Z(8-(? 6-&/(9 #(-"/;"8,. ) 1,8B8/: ;-**1,8"? -B !1*=2/ "(1"! 9///(98"8/9 =/2-,. "- "!/ ;2)99 -B "!8,.9 &!-9/ 98.,8B8;),;/ ;),,-" =/ */)91(/:HZ(8/(A )=2/ "- ;-,98:/( *? 98"1)"8-, &8"!8, "!/ ;-,"/S" -B ) 9?*#-981* -,T-(2: V,"!(-#-2-.8/9 -(.),89/: =? "!/ T/,,/( Y(/, a-1,:)"8-, 8, QRRL' W #(/#)(/: ), ),)2?989 -B "!/


2/11

!"#$%&'")*+,-"

$'./

%*+$"0"'"123,*4"$5

67789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

68 G,$1'#%.

;!),.8,. ;-,:8"8-,9 -B &-(< 8, ](8"89! ),"!(-#-2-.?'QF? ;-,"(8=1"8-, /,:/: 1# 9?*=-2898,. #(-=2/*9"!)" )22 "!/ #)("8;8#),"9A &-(8/& ,-& 89 "!)" c"!/ (-"P89 B)( ://#/(A *-(/ &8:/9#(/): ),: *-(/ B(8.!"/,8,. "!), W !): (/)289/:'

!"#$%&'#() +,'#"%''

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

6!/ 9#(/): ),: 8,9"8"1"8-,)289)"8-, -B )1:8" 89 -,/ )9#/;" -B "!/ "/,:/,;? "- "(/)" />/(?"!8,.A8,;21:8,. 2/)(,8,.A )9 ) =198,/99 /,"/(#(89/' ]? )1:8" W (/B/( "- ;-,9")," )##()89)2' W" 89 );;-*#),8/: =? )

;12"1(/ "!)" ,-(*)289/9 c"(),9#)(/,;?P ),: c);;-1,")=828"?P ),: 19/9 "!/ 2),.1)./ -B "!/ c*)(/ "8*/ -( 8,;28,)"8-, "- (/):' V9 G"()"!/(, #1" 8"A )=->/A "!/(/ 89 ,-"8*/ B-( "8*/ 8, "!/ 1,8>/(98"8/9' 6!/ (/)9-,9 B-( "!89 !)>/ )2(/):? =//, :/=)"/: &8:/2? H/'.' G!829 IJJQAG"()"!/(, /:' QRRRA Z(8/(98"8/9' W =/.8, B(-* #/(9-,)2 /S#/(8/,;/'

@,;/ W !): *):/ "!/ 9!8B" B(-* #-9"+:-;"-()2 (/9/)(;!/( "- 1,8>/(98"? 2/;"1(/(A "!/ *-9" :()8,8,.

/S#/(8/,;/ =/;)*/ "!/ :8BB8;12"? -B B8""8,. 8, ):/C1)"/ (/9/)(;!' 6!/(/ &)9 ,/>/( ,/)(2? /,-1.! "8*/ B-((/):8,.A :89;1998-,A B-( #(-#/( B8/2:&-(/(? 9-;8)2 9;8/,"89"W -2>/:#)("8/9 &/(/ "-- ->/(/S"/,:/: )29- "- B-;19 -, "!/* #(-#/(2?' a(-* *),)./*/," "!/ */99)./ &/(/;/8>/: &)9 "!)" 9")BB ;-12:A 8,://: *19"A =/ />/, *-(/ ;-**8""/:A *-(/ #(-:1;"8>/' T/ &/(/ ,-"A 9-W &)9 "-2:A 8, ) #-98"8-, "- 9)? c,-PU "!/(/ 89 ,- :-&,"8*/ 8, );):/*8)'

@,/ -B "!/ "!8,.9 W *899 *-9" 8, *? ;1((/," 28B/ -1"98:/ "!/ 1,8>/(98"? 89 "!/ 9"1:/,"9' W ")1.!"9-*/ >/(? =(8.!" ),: *-"8>)"/: #/-#2/' `/(")8,2? *),? &/(/ "!/(/ "- .8>/ "!/*9/2>/9 "8*/ "- :89;->/("!/8( #)998-, -( "- 8*#(->/ "!/8( /)(,8,. #-"/,"8)2' W, ](8")8, 1,8>/(98"? 2/;"1(/(9 )(/ -B"/, :89#)()./: )928>8,. 9-*/&!/(/ -"!/( "!), (/)28"?A =1" "!/ 9"1:/,"9 ,/>/( 2/" */ B-(./" "!)" W &)9 );"1)22? #)(" -B ) >/(?(/)2 &-(2: -B "(1/ 8*#-("),;/A "!/ &-(2: -B 2/)(,8,. ),: !1*), .(-&"!' e1(8,. "!/ B-1( ?/)(9 W &-(/( 9"-##/: =/8,. )*)f/: )" *? 9"1:/,"9P -(*? -&, ;)#);8"? ),: &822 "- 2/)(,' 6!/ 1,8>/(98"8/9 )(/ ) 28"/()22? 8,>)21)=2/ )(/,) B-( ,-1(89!8,. "!-9/!1*), C1)28"8/9'

]/?-,: ) ;/(")8, #-8,"A "!/9/ ;),,-" =/ (/:1;/: "- */)91()=2/ 8*#(->/*/,"9 8, (/912"9' ^-()(/ "!/? ,/;/99)(82? B1("!/(/: =? "!/ ](8"89! .->/(,*/,"P9 8,989"/,;/ -, 8,;(/)98,. 9"1:/," 8,")


3/11


4/11

!"#$%&'")*+,-"

$'./

%*+$"0"'"123,*4"$5

67789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

6J G,$1'#%.

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hN .-/9 9- B)( )9 "- ;2)8* "!)" "-:)?P9 9"1:/,"9 )(/ 91BB/(8,. ) */,")2

!/)2"! ;(8989' W" 89 *):/ &-(9/ =? "!/ B);" "!)" "!/(/ "!/ (/9-1(;/9 "- )""/,: "- "!/8( /*-"8-,)2 ),:#!?98;)2 &/22=/8,. )(/ *-(/ -B"/, =/8,. /(-:/: "!), 9"(/,."!/,/:' Xb 9"1:/,"9 )(/ )29- )" (89/,"!/ #(/991(/9 &8"!8, "!/ 1,8>/(98"? 9?9"/*A =1" )29- "!/ "/,:/,;? 8, "!/ Xb )9 ) &!-2/ "- &-(< 2-,.!-1(9 HW_@ QRRhN' V,/;:-")2 ),: *)99 */:8) (/#-("9 B(-* a8,2),: 91../9" .(-1,:9 B-( ;-,;/(, !/(/)29- H/'.' ^1(*8,/, QRRhN'

T/ )(/ );;19"-*/: "- "!8,/(A &/ :- ,-" #1(91/ "!/9/ "!-1.!"9 "-- B)(A 98,;/ "- )(.1/ "!)" "!8,.9A 8,./,/()2 "!)" 89A )(/ ./""8,. &-(9/A 89 "- )""();" "!/ ;!)(./ -B :--*+*-,./(8,.A -B =/8,. ) !)=8"1)2

#/998*89" -( ) ,/-+;-, 91##-("/( )&)8"8,. V(*)./::-,' W" 89 #-998=2/A !-&/>/(A "- )("8;12)"/ )2"/(,)"8>/>8/&9 ),: &8"!-1" :89;-1,"8,. -,/P9 -&, /S#/(8/,;/ -B (/)28"?'

W ")/ ),)2?989 -B "!//S!)19"8-, ),: ;-,B28;" "!)" ;!)();"/(89/ &-(< "-:)?' G!/ :8: 9- =? :()&8,. -, F)(S89" #-28"8;)2 /;-,-*8;"!/-(? ),: #9?;!-),)2?"8; "!-1.!"A ),: *)(9!)22/: ) =(/):"! -B /*#8(8;)2 82219"()"8-,9 "- 91##-(" !/()(.1*/,"' G8*82)( >8/&9 !)>/ =//, )("8;12)"/: /29/&!/(/A B-( /S)*#2/ =? ])(=)() V:)* HIJJMN ),: j-),F)("8,/f+V28/( HQRRQN' ](/,,),P9 &-(< 89 (/*)(8:/,;/A ,-" -,2? -B "!/ =),/(9 &)9"/ ),: B/)(' Z>/, 8, "!/ *8:9" -B "!/

#2/,"? ;!82: ;)(/A /:1;)"8-, ),: !/)2"! ;)(/ )(/ )22 =/8,. :-,/ &8"! B/&/( ),: B/&/( (/9-1(;/9' W, B);" 8"89 #-998=2/ ,-& "- ")2< -B "!/ 4#(-!8=8"8>/ ;-9" -B 28B/E 98,;/ )B"/( )22A B(-* "!/ #-8," -B >8/& -B 9#//:?#(-B8"9A (/#(-:1;8,. "!/ ,/S" ./,/()"8-, -B &-(/ *8,:9 -B !1*), =/8,.9'

Z>/, &!82/ 9-;8/"? )##)(/,"2? ;/2/=()"/9 c;(/)"8>/ ;2)99/9P "!/ 9"),:)(:89/: */)91(/9 (/C18(/:=? )1:8" #1" =-"! =-:8/9 ),: *8,:9 )" (89< Hb8,*), ),: j-,/9 QRRhA b):89-, QRRhN' 6!/ ;(8"8;9 -B "!/,/& );):/*8; (/.8*/ "/,: "- ).(// "!)" "8*/ B-( (/B2/;"8-, !)9 =/;-*/ ) 21S1(?' O/(!)#9 -,/ :)? 8" &822=/ )>)82)=2/ -,2? "- "!-9/ &!- ;), )BB-(: "- =1? "8*/ B-( 8"' k/" 28/(98"? &-(< (/C18(/9 "8*/ ),: 9-;8)2 8,"/();"8-,A ),: 8" (/C18(/9 "!)" #/-#2/ =/ 28"/()22?#(/9/," "- /);! -"!/( HG8#82l QRR[N'

6!89 89 9- :/9#8"/ "!/ #-8," W *):/ )=-1" );):/*8; 28B/ =/8,. 28>/: c8, "!/ !/):P' a);/+"-+B);/8,"/();"8-, &8"! ;-22/).1/9 ),: 9"1:/,"9 !)9 )2&)?9 =//, #-"/,"8)22? !1./2? 9"8*12)"8,. ),: 9)"89B?8,.'6!-9/ &!- .(/& 8,"- ),"!(-#-2-.89"9 8, "!/ (/2)"8>/2? ;-,B8,/: ;-,"/S" -B "!/ ](8"89! 8,9"8"1"8-,9 :/9;(8=/:=? G#/,;/( HQRRIN )(/ C18;< "- *)8=()," ;-22/;"8>/


5/11

!"#$%&'")*+

,-"$'./%*+$"0"'"12

3,*4"$567789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

AB+C*D%1 &E&.,FD&29

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

-./+0.#'0(#/" 0"1 0"(2&/3/./4)

a-( "!/ *-*/," 8" 9//*9 1,28/,/99 -B )##(-);!/9 ),: "!/ :/28.!" 8, 8,+:/#"! 2/)(,8,. )(/ 8, 9/(8-19 :),./( =/;)19/ 8" 89 ,-"-=>8-19 !-& -,/ &-12: *)/ (/9#-,:/: "- "!/ ,/&;8(;1*9"),;/9 =? ;-,;/,"()"8,. -, !-,8,. 98:/: 8,"- "!-9/ B-( c,1*=/(9P #/-#2/ ),: "!-9/ B-( c&-(:P #/-#2/'a)228,. 8,"- "!/ 2)""/( ;)"/.-(?A "!/ #(-").-,89" /,"/(9 ) ;-22/./ -BB/(8,. T/=.)*/ e?,)*8;9A W*)./O(/9/,")"8-,A O8;"-()2 ),: O2)9"8; V("9 ),: O(-=2/*)"8;9A ,8;)21)=2/ 9/(>8;/9 "- "!/ ;12"1(/ 8,:19"(8/9 -( "- ):*8,89"()"8-,9 ),: ;-(#-()"8-,9 &),"8,. :)") -, =/!)>8-1(']1" (/,:/(8,. 9/(>8;/9 89 ) >/(? 8*#->/(89!/: :/B8,8"8-, -B &!)" 1,8>/(98"8/9 :-'

W,9"8"1"8-,)22? "!/ !1*), 9;8/,;/9 )(/ "(?8,. "- *8*8; "!/ ,)"1()2 ),: /,.8,//(8,. 9;8/,;/9 "!)")(/ *-(/ !8.!2? >)21/: =? ;-**/(;/' Z,.8,//(9 ),: 2)=-()"-(? 9;8/,"89"9 &-(< )9 "/)*9 ),: ./,/()22?(/C18(/ #();"8;)2 )9 &/22 )9 "!/-(/"8;)2 /,.)./*/," &8"! /);! -"!/(' 6!89 !)9 =/;-*/ ) 9"),:)(: "- &!8;!

"!/ !1*),8"8/9 ),: 9-;8)2 9;8/,;/9 )(/ =/8,. )9/, "!-1.! "!/ =/,/B8"9 -B :-8,. 9- )(/ ,-"-=>8-19A 1,2/99 -,/ );;/#"9 "!)" =8. #(-0/;"9 1,:/(")898=828"? -B ), 8,9"8"1"8-, -( );;1*12)"/ .2-(?A),: 9- "!/? )(/ :89;-1()./: -( ->/(2--/(,*/,")29- (/.12)(2? 19/9 8" ), /S#2),)"8-, B-( 9-;8)2 #(-=2/*9 H) ;12"1(/ -B *89*),)./*/," ;), );;-1," B-()828,. 9;!--29A /"!,8; ;12"1(/9 )(/ );;/#")=2/ /S#2),)"8-,9 B-( 1,:/(+);!8/>/*/,"A >8-2/,;/ ),: #->/("?N'^- &-,:/( 98,;/ "- 8,>--21,")(? 28B/9"?2/ ;!-8;/ ),: "- *)8)2 /S/(;89/ 8, :/9;(8=8,. !1*), :8>/(98"? -( )9 ) 98,89"/( "--2 B-( *),8#12)"8,.9-;8/"? H]/(.21,: QRRmN'

`12"1(/ 89 "!19 #/(!)#9 -,/ -B "!-9/ &-(:9A 28)82)=2/ 8, ) 2),.1)./"!)" &-12: *)


6/11

!"#$%&'")*+,-"

$'./

%*+$"0"'"123,*4"$5

67789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

@7 G,$1'#%.

Y2-=)289)"8-, !)9 */)," "!)" ),"!(-#-2-.89"9 !)>/ =//, ;-,B(-,"/: =? "&- =(-): /*#8(8;)2;!)22/,./9 "- "!/8( &-(/9 (89/ "- "!/ 8/&9 )=-1" &!)" /(?-,/ &822 / );;/#"/:A "!/? )(/ )29- ), )99/"'

6!89 :-/9 ,-" ;-*/ /)982? "- ),"!(-#-2-.89"9' a(-* :/=)"/9 )=-1" &(8"8,. ;12"1(/ 8, "!/ IJMR9

),: 9;8/,;/ &)(9 8, "!/ IJJR9A "- &!)" j-!, d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b1#/( IJMMA \-9)2:- IJMJN'

WB 8" ;-,"8,1/9 "- B-;19 -, C1/9"8-,8,. 8"9 -&, #(/*89/9 ),"!(-#-2-.? 89 8, :),./( -B =/;-*8,.) #)(-:? -B #-9"*-:/(, ),S8/"?' W" (89/(? B(19"()"8,. B-( 9"1:/,"9A #)("8;12)(2? 8B "!/?)(/ #(8*)(82? 2--


7/11

!"#$%&'")*+

,-"$'./%*+$"0"'"12

3,*4"$567789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

AB+C*D%1 &E&.,FD&31

]1" &!/(/ )""/,"8-, 9#),9 )(/ 9!-(" ),: &!/(/ =182"+8, -=9-2/9;/,;/ 89 );"1)22? ) .--: "!8,.A )9"!/? )(/ 8, *)(/, !?#/: 1# c8,"/(>/,"8-,9P =? 9")( 9;!-2)(9A )9 ),?-,/ &!- !)9 /S#/(8/,;/: ) 9")*#/:/ B-( #2/,)(? )""!/ VVV .8>/, =? 9-*/ ;/2/=(8"? );):/*8;A &822 /(98"? 9")BB -, =-"! 98:/9 -B "!/ V"2),"8;' 6!/ *)8, #-8," 89 "!)"&!)" 2--/ 8*#(->/*/,"' V;;-(:8,. "- O(-B/99-( \8;!)(:]1228/" -B `-21*=8) X,8>/(98"?A 8,"/(>8/&/: 8, "!/ -21*=8) G#/;")"-( HV(-,)1/( QRR[NA 9")( );):/*8;9Pc-BB+;)*#19 >898=828"?P !)(*9 c-,+;)*#19 >)21/9PA #)("8;12)(2? "!-9/ )9#/;"9 -B (1,,8,. ) :/#)("*/,"

"!)" )(/ ,-" ;-,>/("8=2/ 8,"- *-,/")(? >)21/9'

6!/? :-A -B ;-1(9/A -BB/( "!/ #(-*89/ -B 8,"/22/;"1)2 /S;8"/*/," ),: !/2# "- :()& 8, "!/ =/9"9"1:/,"9' ]1" B(-* "!/ #/(9#/;"8>/ -B *),)./(9A 8, "!/ Xb )" 2/)9"A "!/8( >)21/ 28/9 8, "!/8( )=828"? "- !8/ &-(898=828"? -B 9- *1;! &-(< 89 *-(/ "!), ), /"!8;)2 8991/' 6!/ B2-1(89!8,. -B "!/ 1,8>/(98"8/9)9 ) B/)"1(/ -B 9-;8/"? :/#/,:9 ;(1;8)22? -, "!/ "8*/+;-,91*8,. &-(< "!)" .-/9 -, 8, "!/ 9!):-&9A -B-(.),898,.A -B :/)28,. &8"! #/(8-:8; ;(89/9 )*-,. 9"1:/,"9 -( :/*-()289/: 9")BBA -B 9"(1..28,. "- !-2:-,"- (/9-1(;/9 ),:A -B ;-1(9/A -B 8"? B-( "!/*9/2>/9&!82/ (/#(-:1;8,. "!/ 9"(1;"1()2 ;-,9"()8,"9 "!)" B(19"()"/ "!/ ;(/)"8>8"? -B -"!/(9'

6!89 =8B1(;)"8-, 8,"- 9")(9 ),: 8,>898=2/ ,-=-:8/9 89 ,-"A -B ;-1(9/A 1,8C1/ "- );):/*8)A =1" ,-(89 8" 98*#2? ), 8*#-(" B(-* "!/ &-(2: -B */:8) ;/2/=(8"?' W*)./ *),)./*/," !)9 =/;-*/ 9"),:)(:);(-99 ;-(#-()"/ 28B/ ),: )22 "!/ &!8"/ ;-22)( 0-=9 "!)" )(/ *-:/22/: -, 8"A ) B);" "!)" 89 !)>8,. )(.1)=2?#(-B-1,: 9-;8-+#9?;!-2-.8;)2 /BB/;"9' G-;8-2-.89" \8;!)(: G/,,/"" HIJJMN ),: 0-1(,)289" ])(=)() Z!(/,(/8;!


8/11

!"#$%&'")*+,-"

$'./

%*+$"0"'"123,*4"$5

67789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

@6 G,$1'#%.

HQRR[N !)>/ :/9;(8=/: "!/ #(/991(/9 -B &-(/:/9;(8=/: ) 9-;8)2 /,>8(-,*/," &!/(/ ;(/)"8,. ), 8*#(/998-, -B 91;;/99 89 B1,:)*/,")2 "- 91(>8>8,. 2/"

)2-,/ B2-1(89!8,. 8, "!/ 8,;/99),"2? )1:8"/: ),: (/2/,"2/992? ;-*#/"8"8>/ &-(2: -B &-(/(98"8/9 )29- */),9 /*=();8,. ) 9-12+:/9"(-?8,. ;12" -B

;/2/=(8"? &!-9/ 918")=828"? "- );):/*8) 89 !8.!2? :/=)")=2/'

]/8,. B)*-19 !)9A !-&/>/(A =/;-*/ ), /S#28;8" )9#8()"8-, 8, "!/ T/9" )9 !)9 *)/9' V;):/*8;9 !)>/A !-&/>/(A

);C18/9;/: "- ) 9?9"/* -B &-(/ /()./A )B"/( )22A 89,/>/( .--: /,-1.!N'

W !)>/ )(.1/: "!)" &!)" .-/9 -, 8,98:/ 1,8>/(98"8/9 89 ,-" 1,8C1/' k/" "!/ B);" "!)" 1,8>/(98"8/9

9!-12: !)>/ B-1,: "!/*9/2>/9 9"(1..28,. &8"! 91;! 1,918")=2/ &-(/(A 89 ,-&

),: "!/ 9)*/ .-/9 B-( &-(8-19 "- -,/ &!- 89 ,-& ), -1"98:/(A ), -;;)98-,)2

>898"-( -=9/(>8,. &!)" !)9 ;!),./: ),: &!)" !)9 9")?/: "!/ 9)*/' ]/98:/9 *? #/(9-,)2 8*#(/998-,9 "!)"

#/-#2/ )(/ 2/99 9)"89B8/: &8"! 9-;8)2 "(/,:9A (/;/," a8,,89!+2),.1)./ 28"/()"1(/ H/'.' G82")2) QRRhA G/##l,/,

QRRhN -BB/(9 91##-(" B-( *? )99/99*/," "!)" a8,2),: 89 ) 9-;8/"? 1,:/( .(-&8,. 9"()8, =1"A )9 "!/ 98.,8B8;),;/

-B 8*)./+*),)./*/," &-12: 2/): 19 "- /S#/;"A #1""8,. ) =()>/ B);/ -, "!8,.9' a8,2),: ),: a8,,9 #/(989"8, #(-0/;"8,. ), 8*)./ -B !)##8,/99 ),: 91;;/99' 6!/ /;-,-*? 9//*9 B8,/A "!/ ;-1,"(? 9"822 ./"9 "-

(8"1)22? ;/2/=()"/ 8"9 B8(9"9 -( ,/)(2? B8(9"9 8, 8,"/(,)"8-,)2 (),


9/11

!"#$%&'")*+

,-"$'./%*+$"0"'"12

3,*4"$567789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

AB+C*D%1 &E&.,FD&33

V" 2/)9" #)(" -B "!/ (/)9-, !)9 "- :- &8"! "!/ 98*#2/ =1" 1,1""/()=2/ B);" "!)" /*#8(8;)22?9#/)8:1)29 -( ;-**1,8"8/9 "- =/28/>/ "!)" !)(: &-(< ),: B-(&)(: #2),,8,. *8.!"?8/2: 9)"89B?8,. (/&)(:9' T!)" 89 #/(!)#9 *-9" 98.,8B8;)," 89 "!)" ),? ;-((/2)"8-, =/"&//, /BB-(" ),:

(/&)(: 89 #/(;/8>/: "- !)>/ =(-8"? HG82")2) QRRh$ QmLN' T!)" 91(#(89/9 89"!)" "!/(/ 89 ,-" *-(/ )2)(* ->/( "!/ B);" "!)" />/, "!/ ;(/)"8>/ ;2)99/9A 28/9"/: 8, (/#(-:1;"8-, o ;!82:;)(/A 9-;8)2 (/2)"8-,9A (/;1#/()"8-, B(-* /S/("8-, o !)9 =//,:8>/("/: 8,"- "!/ .(-&"! -B ;)#8")2p ZS!-("8,. )22 &-(/(?-,/ "-/9A &!)" ])(=)() V:)* ;)229 c*--,28.!"8,.P HIJJMNA !)9 "- 21(< 8, "!/ 9!):-&9A "!/ 1,:/(.(-&"!'W, "!-9/ 1,/,>8)=2/ ;-,:8"8-,9 8" "(8/9 "- #)";! 1# "!/ */99 2/B" =? "!/ -BB8;8)2 /;-,-*?' 6!/ &)9"/ 8,/,/(.? 89 #!/,-*/,)2A ),: "!/ :),./(9 &!82/ 9-;8/"? (/B19/9 "- );;/#" "!/ ;-9" -B 8"9 .(-&"! B),")98/9*)? =/ :/>)9")"8,.'

V;):/*8;9A #)("8;12)(2? 8, "!/ !1*),8"8/9 ),: "!/ 9-;8)2 9;8/,;/9A *19" (/.)8, "!/8( ;-,B8:/,;/'6!/ *),)./(9 -B "!/ 1"828")(8), 1,8>/(98"? )(/ ,-" .-8,. "- 9/;1(/ "!/ ;-,:8"8-,9 B-( 92-& ),: ;)(/B12

9;!-2)(9!8# -( ,1("1(8,. /:1;)"8-,' 6!/8( )991*#"8-,9 *19" =/ ;!)22/,./:' 6- =/.8, "!/ ")9/ =--/ ^1./," B-(/,;-1()./*/," ),: 91../9"8-,9 B-( 9-1(;/9'

QV("1(- Z9;-=)( ),: Y19")>- _8,9 \8=/8(- ;-,>/,/: "!/ 9?*#-981*' ]/98:/9 /:8"8,. ) >-21*/ B-(#1=28;)"8-, "!/? !)>/ /9")=289!/: ), 8,"/(,)"8-,)2 ,/"&-(< -B ),"!(-#-2-.89"9A "!/ T-(2: V,"!(-#-2-.8/9^/"&-(< HTV^NA !""#$%%&&&'()*+&),'-(.%!"*2%!-*/'!"*

L6!/ Xb */:8) B(/C1/,"2? -BB/(9 1# 9"-(8/9 -B "!/ c"8*/ =-*=9P "8;


10/11

!"#$%&'")*+,-"

$'./

%*+$"0"'"123,*4"$5

67789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

@T G,$1'#%.

-, =-"! 98:/9 -B "!/ V"2),"8;A />/, )*-,. ;!82:(/,A 91../9"9 "!)" #9?;!-2-.8;)2 #(-=2/*9 )(/ )29-&8:/9#(/):'

h6!),- _8,9 \8=/8(- ),: V("1(- Z9;-=)(' -"$'. /%*+$"0"'"1D,C= VDCED0'D%&$2K$&%C)"$F&*D"%C -D*+D% M2C*,FC ") S"4,$' @SB-(:$ ]/(.'

]2)8(A 6-,?' QRR[' G#//;! "- "!/ _)=-1( O)("? `-,B/(/,;/' ](8.!"-,' HQJ%JN'

]1;898-,8,. `)#8")2$ O-28"8;)2 Z;-,-*? -, e89#2)?' H$D*DE&' W%X#D$2' HQIN$hLh+hmK'

`-!/,A G),:/' IJJL'/E&.,FD& &%. *+, Y#C*,$ ") H&0D*&'RF8,,/)#-289$ F8,,/9-") X,8>/(98"? O(/99'

Z!(/,(/8;!A ])(=)()' QRR[' G&D* &%. M4D*E+= K+, ;)#*D',< 0#$C#D* ") *+, /F,$DE&% V$,&F' ^/& k-(/(98"? a8" B-( `(8"8;)2 W,"/22/;"1)29$ (/;->/(8,. B(-* "!/ ()>)./9 -B

"!/ #-9"*-:/(, ;-,:8"8-,' G$D*DC+ A.#E&*D"%&' Z,C,&$E+ !"#$%&'A Q[H[N$ [ML+[J['

a122/(A G"/>/ QRR[' K+, W%*,'',E*#&'= K+, 0"CD*DU, 0"4,$ ") %,1&*DU, *+D%5D%1' `)*=(8:./A Xb$ W;-, ]--


11/11

!"#$%&'")*+

,-"$'./%*+$"0"'"12

3,*4"$567789:;6?@>

!""

#$%

%&&&

'()

*+&

),

'-(.

%/

+0-1(,)

2

AB+C*D%1 &E&.,FD&35

_8#9/""A V,"!/) ),: e/*-#-12-9A b)"!/(8,/' G")( 9")BB ;-99/"/: 8, =8: "- 1# \VZ ()"8,.' KLAM`KDF,C LD1+,$ A.#E&*D"% M#00',F,%*IL'R['QRR[$ IAm'

F)("8,/f+V28/(A j-),' QRRQ' K+, A%UD$"%F,%*&'DCF ") *+, S""$= / M*#.2 ") AE"'"1DE&' H"%)'DE*C &%. [&'#&*D"%'`!/2"/,!)*A XbA ^-("!)*#"-, FV$ Z:&)(: Z2.)('

F8";!/22A 68*-"!?' IJJM' a8S8,. "!/ Z;-,-*?' H#'*#$&' M*#.D,CA IQHIN$ MQ+IRI'

^1(*8,/,A 6)#8-' QRRh cG"(/998 >)8>)) -#89)'

G*?"!A j-!, ),: d)"")*A \-=/("' QRRR' W,"/22/;"1)2 )9 d19"2/($ (/9/)(;!8,. ).)8,9" "!/ .()8, -B "!/*)()./A F)(?2),:$ \-&2),:),: _8""2/B8/2:'

G"()"!/(,A F)(82?,' IJJK' 4W*#(->8,. ()"8,.9E$ V1:8" 8, "!/ ](8"89! X,8>/(98"? G?9"/*'A#$"0,&% Z,UD,4'[HLN$ LR[+QI'

G"()"!/(,A F)(82?, H/:'N' QRRR'/#.D* H#'*#$,C= /%*+$"0"'"1DE&' M*#.D,C D% &EE"#%*&OD'D*29 ,*+DEC &%. *+, &E&.,F2'_-,:-, ),: /& k-(

exhausting academia

Documents