Existential Psychotherapy

in the PTS

A qualitative and quantitative exploration of

goals and goal attainment

Introduction

Existential psychotherapy The NHS climate

Evidence-based psychotherapies Different types of evidence

Evidence-based practice and practice-based evidence

Qualitative and quantitative research Goals in psychotherapy

Research questions

What are the goals of clients receiving Existential Psychotherapy in the Psychological Therapies Service (now the Complex Care Team)?

Is clients’ level of psychological distress any different after therapy?

To what extent do clients feel that each of their goals has been met after being offered approximately 16 sessions of existential psychotherapy?

Is the level of goal attainment linked with levels of psychological distress, or with number of sessions attended?

Method Participants

n = 30, 21 women, 8 men, 1 unrecorded gender. Aged 19-60 years (µ = 43) 30% white European or white other, 70% no data

Measures CORE goal attainment form:

At start of therapy: clients write down up to 4 goals/difficulties they want help with.

At end of therapy: rate extent to which therapy helped with each difficulty/goal

CORE-OM: 34 items, 4 domains, overall score of psychological distress.

Other measures not studied here – CORE-5

Results

Descriptive statistics: Average 4.5m in therapy, attended 12 sessions

(ranging from 1 to 24 sessions). 20 participants attended a full course of therapy,

for 8 therapy ended early and no data for 2.

CORE-OM

75% of clients completed at start, 62.5% at end of therapy. Clients had significantly lower scores at the end of therapy

than at the start, showing a reduction in their distress. Before (M = 22, SE = 1.4), After (M = 16.50, SE = 1.5), t(19) = 3.45, p = .003;

CI (95%) = 2.16 – 8.84. Medium to large effect, d = .77 or r = .63.

Reliable change (Jacobson & Truax, 1991) for 20 clients: reliable change, less distress: 11 clients (55%). reliable change, more distress: 1 client (5%). no reliable change: 8 clients (40%).

No link between post-therapy CORE-OM scores and Level of goal attainment (for both mean and best level of goal attainment per client)

But there is a link between post-therapy CORE-OM scores and goal attainment for Goal 1 (Spearman’s Rho = -.586, p = .028) Goal 1 is probably a client’s most important goal

No link between post-therapy CORE-OM scores and number of sessions attended (r = .27, p = .26).

Goals: Thematic analysis

25 participants wrote down a total of 77 goals (5 participants had no goal forms).

60% of participants wrote down 3 or more goals.

Length: 1 to 74 words (µ = 11 words). 6 themes, some goals in more than one

theme.

Themes and sub-themes

1. Self Acceptance Respect

2. Relationships Family Attitude Roles Independence Relating

3. Acceptance Past Present Future

4. Making changes Building a future Embrace life Behaviour

5. Feelings More positive feelings Fewer negative feelings

6. Miscellaneous

Goals: quantitative analysis

Of all 30 clients: 83% wrote at least one difficulty at the start, 60% (20

clients) rated a total of 57 goals at the end of therapy (20 goals unrated), on this scale:

How much did therapy help you with this difficulty?

0 1 2 3 4 Not at all A little bit Moderately Quite a bit Extremely

Of these 20 clients: most (78%) wrote down three or more goals for therapy.

Goal attainment: All goals

Goal attainment - all goals

2

8

17 16 14

27

2016

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Level of goal attainment

Number of goals number of goals

Goal attainment per client: Goal 1

0

2

5

6

5

1

7

4

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

0 1 2 3 4 no goal notrated

noform

Goal rating

Number of clients

Highest level of goal attainment per client

01

3

6

8

1

7

4

0123456789

not a

t all

a litt

le b

it

mod

erate

ly

quite

a b

it

extre

mely

no g

oal

goal

not

rate

d

miss

ing

Level of goal attainment

Number of clients Number of goals

Mean level of goal attainment per client

0

2

8

4 4

1

7

4

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

not a

t all

a litt

le bit

mod

erat

ely

quite

a b

it

extre

mely

no g

oal

goal

not

rate

d

miss

ing

Level of goal attainment

Number of clients

Number of goals

Discussion Strengths:

Combined quantitative and qualitative data High ecological validity Important time to gather this data

Limitations: No control group Incomplete data Small sample size Some goals not very detailed Difficulty separating themes - all interlinked My inexperience with Existential Psychotherapy

Recommendations: Good outcomes, pat on the back! Continue to help clients achieve their goals,

through Existential Psychotherapy, particularly their main goal (Goal 1).

Therapists to value data collection - integrate more in therapy, not just tick-box exercise.

Thorough – goals at start, re-rate at end.