expense planning: understanding the sensibility of cash
TRANSCRIPT
Expense Planning: Understanding the Sensibility of
CashJosh Tabin & Ted Leitch
vcfo: What We Do
Finance
Interim or Permanent Finance
Support
M&A
Cash Flow Management
Exit Strategy
Transaction Support
Business Process Outsourcing
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary2
HR
HR Audits
Employee Development
and Training
Payroll
Strategic HR Plans
Policies and Procedures
Benefits
Recruiting
Finance and AccountingProfessionals
Operations and HRProfessionals
IT and Technology Professionals
C-Suite Executives
Technology
System Implementation
Operational Assessment
Project and Program Management
Business and Technology Integration
Strategy Development
Expense Reduction Analysts: What We Do
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary3
Expense Reduction Analysts (ERA) helps organizations put additional cash flow to work by further lowering supplier costs, without any compromise to quality and
service.
With 700+ consultants and analysts who specialize in specific expense category industries, ERA brings intimate "insider” knowledge of supplier industries not available to many internal procurement resources.
Armed with the right knowledge and tools, ERA helps, CEOs, CFOs and their procurement teams get better value from supplier relationships without any sacrifices in quality and service.
4
Today’s Panelists
Josh Tabin
Managing Directorvcfo Houston
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
Ted Leitch
DirectorExpense Reduction Analysts
5
Today’s Moderator
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
Mike Wilfley
Executive Vice Presidentvcfo
6
Agenda
Frameworks for Expense Planning
Expense Planning Challenges & Opportunities
Q&A
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
7
Poll Question 1
How does your organization budget?
(Multiple responses accepted)
a) Top down revenue based planning
b) Bottoms up, cost based planning
c) Iterative model incorporating both a top down and bottoms up approach
d) Don’t know, our accounting team gives us a budget
e) We don’t need no stinkin’ budget
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
8
Budgeting in Context
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
9
Expense Planning ModelsA Comparison
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
10
Expense Classifications
It’s expected that every business endeavors to minimize expenses wherever possible and at all times. However, the cost structure that a business operates within can vary depending on their business model.
There are two that exist at opposite ends of the spectrum:
• Cost Driven businesses look to keep costs as low as possible and attempt to be capital efficient, whether it is achieved through automation, outsourcing or the like.
• Value Driven businesses are less focused on the cost to deliver services and more focused on the value received by their clients. Luxury service business would be an example of this.
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
11
Poll Question 2
What cost structure does your business operate under?
(Multiple responses accepted)
a) Cost driven
b) Value driven
c) Somewhere in between cost and value driven
d) Can you go back to that slide?
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
12
Expense Characteristics
Regardless of the cost structure that a company operates within, all expenses have the following characteristics:
• Fixed costs
• Variable costs
• Mixed costs
• Economies of scale
• Economies of scope
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
13
Expense Types for Planning
Expenses come in two categories for planning purposes: cash and accrual.
• Cash expenses are real dollars that will be paid out at some future period either within the reporting period as cash or in a future reporting period through accounts payable.
• Accruals are expenses recorded for GAAP purposes that are not associated with any cash payments. These items may represent reserves for bad debt, inventory or depreciation/amortization of capitalized assets.
Both expense types are important for planning purposes: cash expenses represent costs of the business that need cash flow to support while accrued expenses show true accounting profits which feed balance sheet items for lenders to calculate spreads from.
The use of accrued expense in your budgeting process is a byproduct of what the intended use of the projections are. Management should understand the cash impact of plans as well as the accounting impact on earnings and ratios.© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
14
Company Expenses
A business will have expenses in the following areas of the financials:
• Cost of goods
• Operating expenses
• Non-operating expenses
• Capital expenses
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
15
Planning Methodologies
For most companies, planning starts with revenue. Sometimes, revenue planning is a function of costs. Here’s a recap from our revenue planning webinar:
The methods for planning revenue fall into two primary categories:
• “Resource” based projecting
• “Market” based projecting
Leverage both models in parallel and use the lower of the two forecasts to generate the most effective revenue targets.
• Revenue likely won't exceed the level justified by your resources or the level justified by your market potential.
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
16
Resource Based Expense Planning
The first step in preparing a resource-based projection is to identify key resource factors that will produce or limit revenue for your business. This means that you are effectively setting your revenue targets by first setting the capacity constraints of your expense levels.
These expenses may include the following:
• Labor costs (production driven model)
• Facilities rent and costs
• Sales costs (quota driven model)
These costs are usually predicated on historical and current levels.
• For example, your company adds a salesperson who has a quota of $X, and by adding that resource and expense, you drive additional sales volume. Or, your company adds a production line in the form of capital expenditures which adds the ability to double or triple production capacity, hence driving revenue upward.
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
17
Poll Question
What could your company do with an additional 20% added back into your budgets?
a) Hire more people or prevent layoffs
b) Make capital improvements, such as purchases
c) Fund projects that previously missed the budget
d) Take a company cruise to the Bahamas
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
Poll Question 3
18
Hidden Cash Flow: The Opportunity
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
19
How is That Possible?
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
20
Procurement Best Practices10 Common Misconceptions
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
ONESuppliers give similar pricing to similar clients and customers
01 TWOYour strategy and expertise in purchasing in one cost category will produce similar results in another
02
THREENational pricing agreements are always better than local or regional agreements with the same supplier
03 FOURSupplier loyalty translates to best pricing and service
04
21
Procurement Best Practices10 Common Misconceptions
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
FIVEMore volume always gets you a better deal
05 SIXGetting three bids will get you the best price
06
SEVENYou’re asking the right questions in your RFPs
07 EIGHTGroup purchasing will always get you the lowest cost
08
22
Procurement Best Practices10 Common Misconceptions
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
NINELower price means lower quality and service
09
TENLowest price is the same as lowest cost
10
IS YOUR ORGANIZATION
LIMITEDBY SOME OF
THESE
BELIEFS?
23
You Can Recover More Cash Flow
Top 10 Best Practices in the Path to Exceptional
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
GOOD
BETTER
GREAT
EXCEPTIONAL
24
Recover More Cash FlowThe Path to Exceptional: Getting Started
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
01
COMMITDevelop a strategy and plan
02
ANALYZEAnalyze your actual purchasing history
25
Recover More Cash FlowThe Path to Exceptional: Understand Yourself
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
03
DEFINE QUALITATIVE NEEDSUnderstand the qualitative requirements for each cost category. It’s NOT all about price.
04UNDERSTAND YOUR ASSUMPTIONSMany of the assumptions & processes that drive supplier requirements are no longer valid, appropriate or necessary. Improvement and flexibility here often lead to lower supplier pricing.
26
Recover More Cash FlowThe Path to Exceptional: Understand Suppliers
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
05SUPPLIERS & THEIR INDUSTRIESUnderstand each of your suppliers’ businesses and their industries like you understand your own
• Market trends, pressures & cycles
• Terminology & jargon
• Business practices & unique ways to contract
• Cost & price drivers
• Pricing benchmarks for similar companies, with similar spends, in other geographies
• Their true differentiation among their competitors
27
Recover More Cash FlowThe Path to Exceptional: Re-evaluate
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
06
RE-EVALUATERe-evaluate your current supplier relationships with these new insights 07
GO TO MARKETGo to market with written bids and proper frequency, and ask the right questions
28
Recover More Cash FlowThe Path to Exceptional: Structure the Deal
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
08
NEGOTIATENegotiate more effectively• Leverage all your new insights• Separate negotiator and
relationship owner• Use pricing behavior
benchmarks• Help the supplier save money• Know all the contracting
options
09DECIDE, IMPLEMENT, MONITORImplement quickly• This is equivalent to a cash
leak!
Fight price creep• Many mistakes: many line
items and human error• Processes: e.g., off-contract
purchasing• Publish pricing & SKU changes• Rebates, incentives, credits,
etc.
Suppliers have many methods to recover margins
29
Recover More Cash FlowThe Path to Exceptional: Maintain It
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
10
CHANGE THE CULTUREEmbed a real expense control mindset into the company culture• Mindset first - techniques, policies and
procedures second
• No cost is sacred
• Are they spending money like it’s their own?
• Do they understand the impact on the company (e.g., $1 saved = $5-$10 in sales)?
• Have you ensured that changes are implemented on both sides?
• Are cost-saving suggestions encouraged and pursued?
• Are they integrated into the penalty/reward systems?
30
How to Recover More Cash Flow
© 2014 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
31
Key Takeaways
• Expense planning is typically based on historical trends or existing business constraints (i.e. what you can afford to spend). This may or may not drive your revenue projections.
• Understanding your business model is critical to developing a budget for expenses: cost- or value-based business models.
• Expenses can be cash or non-cash and knowing the difference helps plan for cash and accounting requirements.
• Take the time to discover if some of the common misconceptions are present at your company and negatively impacting your company’s procurement efforts.
• Gain knowledge about the specific expense from your company’s key stakeholders as well as “insider knowledge” of your vendor’s industry. This will provide valuable leverage and result in greater savings.
• Commit to a plan, prioritize, implement and audit on an ongoing basis. Expense management is on ongoing process, not a once-a-year exercise.
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
32
Q&A
© 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary
Thank youWe will be following up with you by email shortly to
provide more details on receiving CPE credit.
Happy expense planning!
33 © 2015 vcfo | confidential and proprietary