facility management - india
DESCRIPTION
Facility Management with reference to the Indian contectTRANSCRIPT
FACILITY MANAGEMENT – INDIA2009 - 2010
By Yogesh Kende
1
Meaning of Mall
• A large, often enclosed shopping complex containing various stores, businesses, and restaurants usually accessible by common passage ways.
• A street lined with shops and closed to vehicles.
• A shady public walk or promenade.
2
South China Mall
Location: Dongguan, ChinaYear Opened: 2005Gross Leasable Area: 7.1 millionsquare feet
3
Golden Resources Shopping Mall
Beijing, ChinaYear Opened: 2004Gross Leasable Area: 6 million square
4
SM Mall of Asia
Location: Pasay City, PhilippinesYear Opened: 2006Gross Leasable Area: 4.2 millionsquare fee
5
West Edmonton Mall
Location: Edmonton, Alberta, CanadaYear Opened: 1981Gross Leasable Area: 3.8 million square
6
King of Prussia Mall
Location: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania,USAYear Opened: 1962Gross Leasable Area: 2.8 millionsquare feet
7
Berjaya Times Square
Location: Kuala Lumpur, MalaysiaYear Opened: 2005Gross Leasable Area: 3.4 million
8
Mall Management - A Growing Phenomenon in Indian Retail Industry
9
Executive Summary• The Indian retail market is expected to continue its growth
trajectory into 2010.• Mall management has been identified as a critical factor for
the success of malls and the retail industry across the world.
• Mall management broadly includes mall positioning, zoning, tenant mix, promotions / marketing and facility/finance management.
• Currently, the Indian retail market lacks designated mall management firms. Large real estate developers and retail chains either have their own mall management arms operating as subsidiaries or have contractual agreements with international property consultants.
10
Cont…
• Till recently, mall management was limited to facility management by a majority of developers in India, leading to gaps in mall management practices.
• Given the high future supply of malls and increasing competitiveness within the Indian retail market
11
What is Mall Management?
Globally, mall management broadly includes:1. Positioning a mall (Location, Layout and design)2. Zoning – formulating the right tenant mix and its
placement in a mall3. Promotions and marketing4. Finance management5. Facility management – Infrastructure, Traffic and
Ambience management
12
The Single Purpose of RetailProperty Development
=Value Creation!
13
1) Positioning a Mall
Positioning a mall refers to defining the category of services offered based on demographics, psychographics, income levels, competition in neighboring areas and extensive market research of the catchment.
For example, if the market research indicates that the average number of households living in a particular area belongs to the upper middle class,
An example of this practice can be seen in the upcoming malls Select City Walk in Saket DLF’s Emporio in Vasant Kunj.
14
Cont…
• Positioning also refers to the location of the shopping mall. A good location defined in terms of factors like ease of access via roads, good visibility, etc. is considered as one of the prime prerequisites for a mall. Although other activities such as trade/tenant mix can be revisited or redefined, the location remains fixed, making it an imperative
15
Positioning Includes:
a) Locationb) Layoutc) Design
16
a) Location• The main objective of any industrial concern is to transform
raw materials into end products by utilizing all the required resources and serving them to the customers effectively, efficiently, economically, and quickly.
• This is possible when the plant is of the right size, right design, and at a place where all kinds of production economies are available.
• Facility Location and Layout play a key role in enhancing the plant efficiency and production effectiveness.
• The way in which inputs are obtained and outputs are distributed affects the location and layout decisions.
17
Factors Influencing Location Decisions:
Many factors - can be classified into three.a. Market Related Factorsb. Tangible or Cost Factorsc. Intangible or Qualitative Factors
18
Location Evaluation Methods:
• A number of diverse factors affect the location decisions
• Developing a formal, generic location model is very difficult.
• A complete study of all the sites available and identifying the optimal one is expensive and time consuming.
19
People generally go for satisfying decisions instead of optimum
decisions.
20
Entrepreneurs may choose to exercise their choice
• One choice is to have a single central plant that produces all the products of the company.
21
Central Plant
Advantages:• Economies of Scale• Reduced unit cost by
better utilization of equipment
• Dispersion of fixed costs over more units
Disadvantages:• Highly Dispersed
Suppliers• Highly Dispersed
Customers• Transportation Costs• Strike• Disaster - Fire / Flood
22
b) Layout:• Physical Disposition of a Facility and its Various Parts. • Layout Decisions also have a Long-term Consequence
on Costs and Ability of the Firm to Serve the Market.• A Layout is a Physical Configuration of Departments,
Workstations, and Equipment in the Conversion Process.
• It is the Spatial Arrangement of Physical Resources used to Create the Product
Objective: To provide a smooth workflow of material through the workplace.
23
Criteria for a Good Layout: 1. Maximum Flexibility2. Maximum Coordination3. Maximum Visibility4. Maximum Accessibility5. Minimum Distance6. Minimum Handling7. Minimum Discomfort8. Inherent Safety9. Efficient Process Flow10. Easy Identification
24
Types of Layouts:
Broadly, there are 3 Types of Layouts:1.Process Oriented Layout2.Product Oriented Layout3.Fixed Position Layout
25
Developing Layouts:
1. Mathematical Models – to Analyze and Conceptualize
2. Computer Models – to Arrive at a Quick Approximation
3. Physical Models – to Visualize
26
Japanese Approaches to Layout:
• Japanese Culture Encourages Teamwork.• When an equipment breaks down, they do not wait for management or maintenance people.• Main idea is work simplification and continuous improvement Japanese changed both the physical layout and managerial system.• They use U – shaped assembly lines
27
c) Design:OBJECTIVES: • To get the inputs (material, supplies, etc) into through and out of each
facility in the shortest time practicable, at acceptable cost.
• Design deals with the design and arrangement of physical elements of an activity/s related to the manufacturing industry, whose drawing represents a plant layout.
• Design analyzes, conceptualizes, designs and implements systems for the production of goods or services.
• Design is represented as a floor plan, or an arrangement of physical facilities (equipment, land, buildings, utilities, etc.)
28
Enterprise Design Process
29
2) Zoning:
• Formulating the Right Tenant Mix and Its Placement in a Mall.
• Tenant mix refers to the combination of retail shops occupying space in a mall. A right tenant mix would form an assemblage that produces optimum sales, rents, service to the community and financial ability of the shopping mall venture.
30
Zoning refers to the division of mall – Forum Mall
31
Forum Mall
• The Forum Mall is designed in a ‘dog bone’ fashion, an anchor tenant at each end and vanilla retailers in the middle.
• Landmark and Westside are the anchor tenants of this mall, and the food court is positioned on the top floor to attract consumers vertically up.
• Forum Mall was built in 2003 and was the first mall in Bangalore City. Since then, six new malls have been constructed in the city and yet the Forum Mall
• Continues to command the highest foot traffic, continuing to
32
3) Promotions and Marketing:• Promotional activities and events in a mall form an integral
part of mall management.• Activities like food festivals, handicraft exhibitions and
celebrity visits increase foot traffic and in turn sales volumes.
• Organizing cultural events has time and again proved vital in attracting consumers to a mall.
• Such activities may also act as a differentiator for a mall.• Developers can work on drafting marketing• strategies• for individual malls to meet the needs of the local• consumer base and the challenges of local.
33
Promotion and Marketing atAnsal Plaza
34
Cont…
• Regular promotional activities at Ansal Plaza, including cultural events have ensured a steady foot traffic in the mall since its inception in 1999.
• The mall also has an amphitheatre dedicated to these promotional activities.
• This has been one of the driving factors behind the success of the mall, despite having a less optimal mall design and tenant mix compared with some recent
35
4) Finance Management:
• Professional financial management of a mall as a business venture is a must.
• Mall Management also covers financial management, which involves monitoring and controlling of various issues such as:
• Cash receipts and collection of income including rentals, service charges, car park receipts,
• Electricity and other utility income• Developing accounting systems to track the ageing of
debts, payment delay patterns, bad debts.36
5) Facility Management:
• Facility management refers to the integration of people, place, process and technology in a building 5 Vanilla retailers refer to single-brand shops.
• It also means optimal utilization of resources to meet organizational needs.
• It broadly includes Infrastructure, Ambience and Traffic management.
37
a) Infrastructure Management:
• Infrastructure management refers to the management of facilities provided to the tenants within the mall.
• This includes provision of adequate power supply, safety issues in case of emergency and miscellaneous issues related to signage, water supply, sanitation, etc.
38
Make sure that every bit of the mall has enough infrastructure
39
Cont…
• Infrastructure management refers to the management of facilities provided to the tenants within the mall.
• This includes provision of adequate power supply, safety issues in case of emergency and miscellaneous issues related to signage, water supply, sanitation, etc. Infrastructure management also includes risk management issues such as essential safety measure asset liability and
40
Cont…INFRASTRUCUTRE REQUIRED:
• Uninterrupted Power Supply with 100% power backup
• HVAC with adequate redundancy• Fire Fighting & Detection System• Dedicated Security System• ETP Plant• Proper Sewage System• Water Softening & Purification System• P. A. System with Channeled Music• Emergency Lighting in all areas• Toilets - separate for customers & staff• Building & Floor Directories• Signages directing customers towards
elevators, toilets, fire exits, etc.
OCCUPANT MANAGEMENT:• Help desk• Periodic feedback• Coordinate construction of shops• Billing• Collections• Attending to grievances & complaints• Ensure observance of rules &
regulations of the mall
41
B) Traffic Management:
• Traffic management includes managing foot traffic into the mall and parking facilities.
• Foot traffic management involves crowd management inside the operational area of a mall.
• The flow of people is related to the design of the mall and the spatial
42
A shopping mall underground parking
43
C) Ambience Management:
• The overall shopping experience provided for consumers becomes an important factor for the success of any mall.
• Ambience management includes management of parks, fountains and overall look of the mall.
In favorable, lush green landscaping with seating facilities and the presence of food and beverage inside or outside the mall can increase foot.
44
Facility Management In The Indian Context
45
‘FM Is About Managing People
and Places to Achieve Best Value
for Money by Balancing Between
User Needs and Business Needs to Achieve Optimum
Organizational Effectiveness’
‘FM Is About Managing People
and Places to Achieve Best Value
for Money by Balancing Between
User Needs and Business Needs to Achieve Optimum
Organizational Effectiveness’
Occupant Perceptions
OrganizationNeeds
Cost
Productivity
Infrastructure
Micro-environ
CWO
RKIN
G
EN
VIR
ON
MEN
T
Value ForValue ForMoneyMoney
Value ForValue ForMoneyMoney
Facilities Management’sEffectiveness is Measured
Through
… helping Clients attract and retain good employees by providing an excellent working environment
Understand FM …….
46
47
Sector Overview in India:
New Delhi & NCR ( 20%)
Mumbai(10%)
Pune(10%)
Bangalore(35%) Chennai
(10%)
Hyderabad(5%)
Others(10%)
Others include Chandigarh, BBSR, Indore, Jaipur, Vizag, TVM, Calcutta etc
Total FM Market : Rs.1225 Crores
48
Future Growth Prospects:
FY 2007-2008
FY 2008-2009
FY 2009-2010
Foreign systems in Indian Context- do they work??- Issues
• FM companies are brought in at a late stage of the project. Cost of fixing an error rises dramatically, with highest cost during the operations phase.
• Large organization should focus on Strategic Asset Management-Property performance, planning tools, delivery methods etc.
• Capacity to pay to service providers is limited. Only rich projects make use of technology /hi-tech equipments.
• Environment, health and safety issues given less importance.
49
Facility Management - Indian Context
• Growing Market, limited trained manpower hence prone to poaching.
• No training institute with a focus to FM.• Acute manpower shortage foreseen in future.• Vendors as business partners.• Most facilities are over manned.• Performance based Management fee with a fair fixed
fee.• Develop applicability of FM to all types of
infrastructure like township, factory, hospitals, airports, STPI parks, Govt. establishments etc.
50
TOWNSHIP - FM COMPONENTS
• MUNCIPAL SERVICES• ZONAL SEVICES
51
MUNICIPAL SEVICES• Landscaping / Turf Management• Lake Maintenance• Maintenance of Utilities• Street lighting / signage• Street repair• Street cleaning• Potholes• Sidewalk repairs• Traffic Management and Parking Mgt• Refuse collections• Sanitary enforcements• Illegal dumping• Dead animal pickups
52
ZONAL SERVICES
• Grass Mowing• Housekeeping• Pest and Rodent Control• Security• Electrical and Mechanical Services
53
STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE
Delivery Systems• Performance Plan• Develop process improvement plan• Restructuring delivery relationships
Maintenance Mgt• Preventive maintenance• Condition monitoring• Corrective maintenance
Service Quality Measures• Management Systems• Health and Safety• Staff Professional development
Call Center/Help Desk• Forward complaints/reports/orders to appropriate person• Monitor performance• Maintain database of all calls
54
55b a c k n e x th o m e
Strategic Assets & Facilities Audit ---Technical Evaluation of Building state and services
Facilities Management Incorporating quality controls, vendor development, sub-contract management, house-
keeping services and systems management
Activity AGENCY TOP PERFORMANCE
ZONE PERFORMANCE
OBSERVATION
Grass & weed Mowing
Trash Collection `
Rodent Abatement
Abandoned Vehicles
Sanitation Enforcement
Parking Enforcement
Street/ Sidewalk Repair
Street Cleaning
Landscaping
Dead Animal Pick Up
SYSTEM OF MONITORING MUNICIPAL SERVICES
56
b a c k n e x th o m e
Strategic Asset & Facilities AuditModern Techniques
S.no Service Item Functions Benefits Remarks
1. PropertyManagement
ComputerAided FacitlitiesManagement
ProvidesCentralisedexpertise for allmatter
Call Center can beestablished
2. FinancialManagement
FinancialSoftwareintegrated withCAFM
7 Levels ofHierarchy
Single SeatInterface
3. UtilitiesManagement
BuildingAutomationSystem
InteroperabilityViz HVAC,Lighting, BuildingAccess, Security,Fire Fighting,WorkManagement
EnergyManagementEfficiency ofsystem, CostReduction, BetterinformationManagement, CostReduction, BetterControl Actions
4. TrashCollection &recyclingCollection
Large Supercans (96gallons)
Collection on aperiodic basis. Alltrash is baggedand put in a supercan.Bags outside thecan are allowedonly for grassclipper & leaves.
Systematic methodof Trash collection
Recyclingcollection-newspaper,corrugatedcupboards, food &beverages, cans,glass bottle,metals, plastic etc.
57b a c k n e x th o m e
S .n o S e r v ic e I te m F u n c t io n s B e n e f its R e m a r k s
5 . S tre e t C le a n in g M e c h a n ic a l S tre e t C le a n in g
C le a n in g S tre e t fo r m u d a n d l i t te r
R e g u la r is e c le a n in g o n a p e r io d ic b a s is
6 . O p e n A re a C le a n in g
P re s s u re C le a n e r , F lo o r S c ru b b e rs , D r ie rs
S w e e p in g & c le a n in g o f la rg e o p e n a re a s
E f f ic ie n t a n d m o d e r n m e th o d s o f c le a n in g
7 . S e c u r i ty E le c tro n ic & a c c e s s c o n tro l s y s te m , D ig i ta l v id e o T e c h n o lo g y
A c e n tra l is e d s e c u r i ty s y s te m
8 . T u r f M a n a g e m e n t
M o w in g E q u ip m e n t; B la d e T y p e , R e e l T y p e , F la il & R o ta ry ty p e S p r a y e r s S e e d e rs
C o m m o n ly u s e d fo r m o w in g la rg e o p e n a re a s C h e m ic a l S p ra y e rs a n d S p re a d e r
H ig h P ro d u c t iv i ty & Q u a l i ty p e r fo rm a n c e . E n v i ro n m e n ta l C o n c e r n , A d v a n c e d T e c h n o lo g y , C o m p u te r is e d S p ra y e rs . L a rg e c o v e ra g e a re a .
FOR A SUCCESSFUL MALL ……
A Carefully Conceived Design and A Good Management Team, managing the functioning of the Mall.
Modern, Convenient, Technologically Well-Equipped, Well - Maintained / Managed and Promoted – Today’s Malls…..
Efficient Management requires: Integration of the Owner and The Mall Management Team
58
Mall management : planning and strategy
PROPER PLANNING INCLUDES :
• VISITORS MANAGEMENT• OCCUPANTS MANAGEMENT• SOUND INFRASTRUCTURE• CREATION OF AN AMBIENCE
59
Scope of ServicesUtilities Management Service Management Management Functions Minor Repairs
• Fire Detection and fire fighting system
• HVAC• Lifts & Elevator • Water and Fire Pumps• Closed Circuit Television
System• Access Control System• Vertical Elevation Systems • Water & Fire Fighting
Pumps• Backup Power Supply
• Security• Electrical & Mechanical• DG & HVAC Operations• House Keeping• Sanitary & Plumbing• Pest Control• Landscaping• Office Support Staff• Water Effluent Treatment
Plant Maintenance• Parking Area Management
• Quality Control• Health and Fire Safety• Preventive Management• Energy Management• Help Desk• Vendor Management &
Procurements • Tender Processing• Inventory Control• Budgeting
• Equipments• Civil works• Carpentry• Masonry work• Furniture• Painting • Trouble shooting• Project Work
60
61
MALL MANAGEMENT : Typical Organization Structure
62
MALL MANAGEMENT : TYPICAL MALL OPERATION SCHEDULE
Description of Timings Duration Remarks
Mall Timings 9 AM - 9 PM 12 Hrs.
Cleaning Time 6 AM - 9 AM 3 Hrs.
Major cleaning carried out before opening of Mall for customers, in presence of security staff.
Diesel Delivery 7 AM - 9 AM 2 Hrs.
Escalator / Lift Repairs 11 PM - 7 AM 8 Hrs.
Escalators generally require 5-6 hrs time for maintenance work, in the presence of security staff.
Garbage Disposal 7 AM - 8 AM 1 Hr.To be carried out in the presence of security staff.
Emergency Lighting - -Required by Inverters and/or emergency lights in all common areas and shops.
Electrical Breakdown 24 Hrs. 24 Hrs.Typical minor electrical faults in shops require 10mins to 40mins to repair.Recommendation - Have ample number of electricians at all times.
Air Conditioning Maintenance Works 7AM - 10 AM 2-3 Hrs.
Normal maintenance of AHU's etc. installed in shops and common areas. Cleaning of filters etc. of AHU's, in the presence of security staff for common areas and in the presence of shop owners for the shop.
Plumbing Work 11 PM - 7 AM 8 Hrs.All plumbing work to be done at night in the presence of the security staff.
OPERATION SCHEDULE
INORBIT MALL Mumbai is an example of a successful mall led by good facility management
63
Inorbit Mall in Mumbai
By K Raheja Corp is a good example of facility management in a mall. It has two anchor stores placed at the two corners of the mall. There are three entry points, one each from the two anchor stores and another entry directly to the mall atrium. With three entry points, traffic management within the mall is better organized.
64
Cont…
• The mall also provides ample parking space and superior infrastructure management. The Inorbit Mall commands higher rental values of INR 175 per sq ft per month compared with other malls in the north-western suburbs of Mumbai with average rental values of INR 135 per sq ft per month in 4Q06, indicating it’s success story. The low vacancy rates at Inorbit Mall.
65
Indian Scenario for MallManagement
• large Indian conglomerates such as Reliance Industries and Aditya Birla Group are commencing their foray into retailing across India.
• Currently, there are very few designated mall management companies in India.
• However, big retail chains such as Future Group and some large developers have set up their own mall management divisions that operate as their subsidiary companies.
• Some developers such as DLF have also recently entered into contractual arrangements with retailers.
66
Future trends…• The building industry is recognizing the benefits of an integrated Facility
Management Services and the trends are:– the increased availability of industry specific software packages that
can provide for a wide range of FM requirements; – data on assets such as buildings and equipment is being viewed as
corporate information that is best managed by the FM department – increasing interest in web based access to the FM services for
improved access to information by the FM staff and others in the organization;
– more emphasis on business process re-engineering and staff training in order to maximize the use and benefits of the system;
– future interfaces with building automation systems in order to achieve further operating efficiencies.
67
In India, retail is an emerging market having immense potential in terms of opportunities.
68