feasibility study central african forest initiative incubator / accelerator · 2020-05-05 ·...
TRANSCRIPT
FEASIBILITY STUDY – CENTRAL AFRICAN FOREST INITIATIVE INCUBATOR / ACCELERATOR
December 2017
The Democratic Republic of Congo and Gabon
Executive Summary
3
SUMMARY OF KEY FINDINGS (1/2)
The demand assessments in both countries show that there is a real need and opportunity to put incubation mechanisms in place (both in terms of demand from SMEs and demand from ultimate off-takers / financiers looking for a pipeline of bankable businesses)
There is an impact story about how such mechanisms will ultimately support what CAFI is trying to achieve in terms of mitigating risks of deforestation via its support to countries in the region. In Gabon, sectors of interest have a direct link to forests; In the DRC, sectors with less direct link to the forest should be considered
The answers will look different in Gabon vs. the DRC
o In Gabon, the recommendation is to develop an incubation and acceleration program to boost value of natural and sustainable forest activities – essentially using mechanisms to help support the creation of eco- tourism and non-timber forestry sectors as well as driving formalization of the small scale industrial forestry sector. Here, the impact is about boosting value derived from forests in a sustainable way to support the country’s diversification efforts
o In the DRC, the recommendation is to develop an incubation program to drive SME development and promote employment in sectors that can divert people from activities that are acute deforestation drivers
Despite very different environments and needs, there is an incubation ecosystem that CAFI can build off in both countries, particularly in Gabon where incubation is key to the government’s entrepreneurship development strategy (included in the Gabon Emergent strategy). However, many gaps and challenges need to be taken into account and could be partly filled by CAFI’s intervention in both countries
Sources: Dalberg analysis
4
SUMMARY OF KEY FINDINGS (2/2)
In Gabon, one can build off JA Gabon and APJA for incubation activities, and from Entreprenariumfor acceleration programs. These entities already work with the government and donors (EU, AfDB). JA Gabon implemented the first working spaces and incubators in Gabon in partnership with the ministry of SMEs, and large private sector players such as Olam. APJA is a network of business people that have experience and expertise specific to the Gabonese context. Entreprenarium has trained and supported promising entrepreneurs, including women, develop innovative business models
In the DRC, a more nuanced approach need to be taken as there is less to build on in terms of existing incubation mechanisms. I&F, Tropenbos and Elan RDC could be considered. I&F is a local incubator part of the Afric’Innov program that aims to build capacity of incubators on the continent. Tropenbos is a research, capacity building and institutional development technical partner, running programs in several countries in South-East Asia, Latin America and Africa, including the DRC. ElanRDC is operating a broad private sector development program across the country, with several sector touch points including energy, agriculture and SME development
To move forward and capture these opportunities funding needs to be secured for design, set-up and 3-5 years of operations
o Based on high-level cost estimate the operational budget could be approximately US$750,000 per year for the DRC and US$850,000 per year for Gabon. Design and set-up costs being around US$500,000 per country
o The implementation road map for each country will have 3 phases: 1) define a clear business plan building on the feasibility study findings and detailed value chain analyses; 2) establish the pilot incubator and start creating impact by working with the first cohort of incubatees; 3) refine the model and focus on expanding, strengthening the ecosystem, having clear sight of impact measurement and of the handover plan for sustainability
Sources: Dalberg analysis
5
CONTENT
Project context
Feasibility in Gabon
Feasibility in the DRC
Incubator design options
CAFI Feasibility
study
Summary of the project objectives and methodology of the feasibility study
Project context
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in the DRC to determine market gaps
Feasibility in the DRC
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in Gabon to determine market gaps
Feasibility in Gabon
Proposed incubator benchmarking, design options and road map for implementation
Detailed incubator design options
6
The aim of the study is to appraise the feasibility of business incubators / accelerators in Gabon and the DRC to foster private sector development
Study Overview
• The study combines learning and analysis from four areas:
Enabling environment to review market conditions and broader context
Demand assessment to establish enterprise’s needs & potential market
Supply assessment to identify existing coverage & gaps
Benchmarking and Design options to establish design options for both countries based on best practices and findings on the ground
Background
• The Central African forest is the world’s second biggest tropical rainforest, covering 240 million ha. It is also home to 60 million people and feeds more than 40 million people in urban areas
• CAFI’s objectives are to recognize and preserve the value of the forests in the central African region to mitigate climate change, reduce poverty and contribute to sustainable development. It achieves this by both scaling-up international support to transformational reforms and by catalyzing investments on the ground
• Gabon and the DRC have given priority to forests and the environment in their vision statements and strategic plans, but currently the limited of private sector engagement is putting pressure on the forests considered as an economic asset
Sources: Dalberg analysis
7
Focus of this document
CONTENT
Project context
Feasibility in Gabon
Feasibility in the DRC
Incubator design options
CAFI Feasibility
study
Summary of the project objectives and methodology of the feasibility study
Project context
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in the DRC to determine market gaps
Feasibility in the DRC
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in Gabon to determine market gaps
Feasibility in Gabon
Proposed incubator benchmarking, design options and road map for implementation
Detailed incubator design options
8
In the DRC, the main driver of deforestation is attributed to populations depending on the forest for energy and food
Sources: The UN Collaborative Programme on Reducing Emissions from Deforestation and Forest Degradation in Developing Countries (UN-REDD), 2013
Forest covers at least 112 million hectares of the Democratic Republic of Congo (second-largest single block of forest in the world).
Tens of millions of people (40 to 60 million) in the DRC depend on the forest for their survival and the DRC has the largest area of deforested land in the Congo Basin.
Fore
st lo
ss
Deforestation
Forest degradation
Subsistence farming
Collection of wood-fuel
Collection of wood-fuel
Industrial and artisanal forestry
Slash and burn agriculture in rural areas
Wood energy and charcoal production
Firewood used for household consumption
Lodging industry
Development of commercial agriculture
Expansion of arable land for food production
Illegal forestryLarge scale illegal logging in the Eastern Province
Main drivers of forest loss Examples
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dTh
e D
RC
1
1
2
3
2
3
9
The private sector, especially SMEs, could play a critical role in championing innovation to reduce deforestation
Reduce deforestation rates even with high population strains on forests through private sector development
Reduce reliance on unsustainable forestry practices
Reduce reliance on wood fuel use
Reduce slash and burn agriculture
prominence
INCUBATOR VISION
OUTCOMES
INCUBATOR SECTORS
ForestryEnergy Agriculture
Divert population from forest exploitation
OUTPUTSIntroduce energy
alternatives to wood fuel
Develop sustainable
commercial and subsistence
farming
Develop sustainable
forestry businesses
Diversify employment opportunities
Cross - sector
INCUBATOR MISSION
Provide support to startups & SMEs in targeted sectors that have the potential to reduce reliance and pressure on the forest
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dTh
e D
RC
Sources: Dalberg analysis
10
There is potential within these sectors to overcome the current status quo of deforesting activities, and to provide fresh employment opportunities
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dTh
e D
RC
Providing sustainable private sector models to move away from industrial and artisanal forestry along with employment opportunities to limit illegal forestry
Forestry
Given limited fuel options and grid supply, household technologies and clean tech could reduce reliance on wood-fuel and charcoal and change behaviors
Energy
Diversified employment could help reduce the reliance on the forest as an economic asset, being aware of the importance of proximity of activities to high deforestation areas
Cross-sector
AgricultureSustainable technologies to diversify methods of farming while improving crop productivity and reducing land take. Including improved inputs and extension services
Sources: Dalberg analysis
Theme
Impact Assessment
Forestry Agriculture
Energy
Cross-sector
11
In the DRC, small and medium enterprises face numerous barriers and significant constraints that can lead to failure
Unclear SME Policy - Specific support targeting SMEs can be unclear and complicated to apply for, as there are a range of public agencies defining the business landscape for SMEs (ANAPI, Ministry of SME, OPEC)
Taxation – The tax system is generally viewed as burdensome,with tax demands coming from multiple agencies. SMEs can becharged large penalties for mistakes in tax returns or delays
Protection – Strong networks are required to protect businessinterests, needing local leadership backing in challenging marketconditions, this complicates starting new initiatives/businesses
Political Risk & Investor Confidence - Investor confidence isworsened by the political environment, legal protections are in placeon paper but seldom tested in court, while financial risk (currency,inflation) increase costs of capital
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dTh
e D
RC
Sources: Dalberg interviews
12
When it comes to business development, early stage technical support and risk capital to grow and prove bankability are major constraints for SMEs
Ideation Early stage Growth
Suit
able
Fi
nan
cin
g
Financing at this stage is not a critical pinch point unless there is specific R&D requirements or technical expertise needs
There is a need for risk capital to prototype business and technical concepts. However, entrepreneurs can be wary to give up ownership
Entrepreneurs are having difficulty accessing credit as their businesses are not well formed and credit-worthy
Bu
sin
ess
Su
pp
ort
Entrepreneurs are struggling to fully develop commercial viability and business models
At this stage furtherbusiness management skills (rigorous accurate business planning and financial management) are needed as informal and university alike have poor business training
At this stage business services are available from banks, however investors are needed to make well-informed business decision
Tech
nic
al
Sup
po
rt
There is a lack of technical expertise near the start of projects with time wasted due to re-inventing the wheel
Where innovative ideas are being developed In the DRC, there is a lack of connection to technical experts
Technical mentorship could help increase potential to raise finance due to better managed risks
Shar
ed
Se
rvic
es
Entrepreneurs need more opportunities to share ideas and lessons learnt
Entrepreneurs need more opportunities to share services such as administrative function and tax advice
Entrepreneurs need more opportunities to connect with investor networks, to promote ideas and raise finance
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
em
and
The
DR
C
Not a constraint Minor Constraint Major Constraint
13
There is high potential demand for technical and financing support with nuances to guide incubator design
While the level of demand is clear, it will be important to establish how this is demand is currently being met and what ongoing initiatives exist
Component Exogenous Risks & Constraints
Idea Stage Financial support
• Startups lack particular robust commercial viability and business model setting at an early stage
• It will be important that the incubator has services at the ideation stage to prime for investment
Startup skills
support
• The financing provided must fill the gaps where entrepreneur’s cannot use their own funds to develop initial ideas
• Equity investments will need to be clearly discussed early and be part of selection criteria
• The incubator will need to be well placed within the enabling environment to ensure that investments are protected
• The incubator will need to a have a robust fiduciary process, while acknowledging the market conditions for business
Sector specific
technical knowledge
• Entrepreneurs will need regular input from domestic and overseas technical advisors as businesses progress
• The incubator will need to provide a platform to bring in this expertise
• Intellectual property and entrepreneurs unwillingness to share ideas may inhibit
• Potentially a lack of data will undermine robust market assessments in this stage
• DRC is perceived as a risky environment and access to technical expertise can be expensive
• The incubator will need to have an efficient way to leverage technical expertise through mentorship
Design Requirements
Sources: Dalberg Interviews
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
em
and
The
DR
C
14
Four main actor groups currently serve the entrepreneurs and small businesses, their service provision varies significantly within each group
Actors Description
Incubators
Commercial banks are currently the primary form of access to finance In the DRC for SMEs, there is a clear distinction between banks that provide services for SMEs such as RAWBank and Procredit Bank and those that don’t such as TMB. Outside of the banks there is a only a limited pool of investment funds (XSML) and private investors active In the DRC.
Financiers
There are a number of independent private incubators which focus on business services rather than financing, some are regionally focused such as I&F Entrepreneriat in Bas Congo. And other are either recent (MIME Incubator) or in development (Delions Incubator). Incubators typically serve cross-sector markets rather than having individual specialisms.
Public Sector & Associations
There are a number of public sector actors setting the policy environment and business landscape for SMEs, including OPEC and the Ministry of Industry. While there is a broad acknowledgement of the need to improve the SME eco-system, overlaps between agencies can cause confusion for private actors.
Technical / Development Organizations
Several development actors have incorporated private sector development into their activities with IITA being an institutional example and UKAID’s Elan RDC being a programmatic example.
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dTh
e D
RC
1
2
3
4
Sources: Dalberg Interviews
15
The service coverage for early stage companies is mixed, with opportunities for CAFI to scale up activities and fill gaps
Ideation Early Growth
Suit
able
Fi
nan
cin
g
Friends & family arecurrently filling this gap, which works for commerce & services but not for business with high set up or R&D costs
There is a lack of risk capital to make the investments necessary to grow the business, in part driven by poorly perceived minority protections
There are only a limited number of instruments targeting SME’s but a pipeline of viable businesses is missing also
Bu
sin
ess
Se
rvic
e
Sup
po
rt
There is a lack of business support to review the commercial viability of ideas even before getting business plans sorted
Some small entrepreneurs can access business and financial management training only if successful in gaining bank debt
Banks are pressing forwardwith business support services to established SMEs but not necessarily those with potential for growth
Tech
nic
al
Sup
po
rt
Entrepreneurs appear to lack connections to research institutes or with SMEs overseas to explore ideas to import in the DRC market
There are a large number of developmentactors In the DRC, but their expertise does not always reach early stage companies with the potential to grow
There are a large number of development actors In the DRC, but their expertise is not in reach of growth stage companies
Shar
ed
Se
rvic
es
& N
etw
ork
s
There is little to no shared space in major urban centers where entrepreneurs can collaborate. Plus, access to investors is limited
There are no examplesof shared services for administrative functions such as accountancy and tax
Companies like COPAMECOand FEC are reliable forums for networking, although not necessarily helping to reach investors
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dTh
e D
RC
Well provided Partially provided Poorly/Not provided
16
There are several supply-side gaps where the CAFI incubator could step in with nuances to define the value proposition and subsequent design principles
While the gaps in the supply are clear, the incubator design will need to acknowledge the trade off between control over stand-alone service and partnering to enhance current capacity
Function 1 -Risk Capital
Area of Gap Design Requirements
• Services need to intervene to help test commercial viability, just training on how to write a business plan won’t work
• Partnering with organizations that have relevant expertise will ensure both training content and delivery are high quality and targeted to a specific audience or sector group
Function 2 -Early-stage business &
Technical skills
• A clear process to protect investor interested, likely needs an offshore fund for currency protection and skills development to ensure robust business modelling and financial management
• Incubator will need to have a strong but independent governance structure and an embedded tax support function to help protect firms
• Long game so needs significant commitment from CAFI
Function 3 -Shared space and network opportunities
throughout
• Location is key and clarity of objective/target organizations given the broad range and backgrounds of entrepreneurs that could be attracted
• Outreach networks and events could cater to companies outside the incubator cohort to ensure the broader ecosystem moves forward
• Provide mechanisms for old cohorts to mentor new cohorts
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dTh
e D
RC
Sources: Dalberg Analysis
17
18
Focus of this document
CONTENT
Project context
Feasibility in Gabon
Feasibility in the DRC
Incubator design options
CAFI Feasibility
study
Summary of the project objectives and methodology of the feasibility study
Project context
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in the DRC to determine market gaps
Feasibility in the DRC
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in Gabon to determine market gaps
Feasibility in Gabon
Proposed incubator benchmarking, design options and road map for implementation
Detailed incubator design options
19
The Gabonese forest is one of the best preserved in the world offering considerable potential to help in the country’s development efforts
Sources: Hosonuma and Al. An assessment of deforestation and forest degradation drivers in developing countries , 2012
13 %88 % 50 %
Forest coverage Protected lands
0,04 %
Exploited landsDeforestation rate
Fore
st lo
ss
Deforestation
Forest degradation
Commercial agriculture
Industrial forestry
Infrastructure and urban expansion
Collection of wood-fuel
Rise of palm oil plantations
Timber industry
Libreville’s growth encroaching the Mondah Forest
Charcoal production
MiningBelinga iron ore mine, planned inside the Ivindo National Park
Main drivers of forest loss Examples
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dG
abo
n
1
2
2
1
3
20
An incubator could play a critical role in leveraging the economic potential of forests sustainably, promoting business creation in non-oil sectors
Improve forest sustainability and support the country’s economic diversification strategy through a sustainable exploitation of forests
Reduce reliance on timber
production and logging
Maintain forest protected areas
Reduce deforestation due
to commercial agriculture
INCUBATOR VISION
OUTCOMES
INCUBATOR SECTORS
Forestry/Wood processing
Tourism Agriculture
Increase the valuation of the
non wood products
OUTPUTS
Develop financially self
sustainable national parks
Develop sustainable commercial agriculture
Promote sustainable
forestry and local wood
transformation
Develop the NTFPs industry to mitigate reliance
on timber
Non Timber Forest Products
(NTFP)
INCUBATOR MISSION
Provide support to startups and SMEs in sectors linked to forests that have the potential to develop and scale-up sustainable business models
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dG
abo
n
Sources: Dalberg Analysis
21
To prevent forest loss and degradation in Gabon, sustainable business models linked to forest exploitation can be developed
Source : Economic and Sector Work Private Sector Development, Stakeholders interviews, Dalberg analysis, 2017
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dG
abo
n
Gabonese legislation requires companies in the timber sector to set up local processing units raising the timber processing target to 100%. This obligation would bring about the redistribution of value added for the benefit of Gabon
Wood processing
Eco tourism
NTFPs provide a wealth of resources including foods, medicines, construction materials, cosmetics, as well as resources of spiritual and cultural significance. However, much of this value and the livelihood security that NTFPs can provide is little researched and understood
Non timber forest products (NTFP)
Gabon has assets for tourism, in particular its rich biodiversity that can be made profitable by economically enhancing its thirteen national parks. However, road infrastructure remain a constraint and the country’s image as a tourist destination is to be built
Impact Assessment
Woodprocessing
Eco tourism
Non Timber Forest Products
22
Leveraging specific opportunities in forest related sectors would create economic and environmental value addition
Source: Economic and Sector Work Private Sector Development, Stakeholders interviews, Dalberg analysis, 2017
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dG
abo
n
• Long distances between the logging and processing areas and poor quality of road
• High transportation costs (by railway)• Inadequate skills of the local labor• Lack of competitivity under the global
market of the locally processed timber
• Markets in NTFPs are often hampered by poor infrastructure and storage and by lack of market information
• The scientific knowledge base and understanding of economic opportunities is poorly documented
• The value chain is fragmented and informal
• Technical challenges of doing eco tourism in tropical forest covered countries and lack of local expertise
• Lack of good infrastructure (accommodation, roads) in the country and high cost of transportation (by air & road)
• Weak country image as a tourist destination
Relevant Constraints Opportunity Areas
• New legislation aiming at developing local transformation can be an incentives for investors
• Set-up of the Nkok Economic Zone• Several players in the 3rd
transformation stage but still informal
• Potential for disruptive innovation in the food and beverage (such as acai) or pharmaceutical (example of Ibogai) industry
• Potential implication of local communities
• Ongoing sector reforms as part of the national strategy (e.g. e-visa)
• New sources of financing and business models possible for the national parks
• Former oil companies staff investing and working in the tourism sector (highly skilled labor pool)
Forestry & Wood processing
Eco tourism
Non timber products
23
To become strong players in the private sector and drive strong and diversified economic growth, entrepreneurs need to overcome a various set of constraints
Comments
• Slow and complex administrative procedures:entrepreneurs report facing major delays when setting upa business (which can take up to two months due to thelack of a one-stop shop for business registration) orperforming regular administrative tasks partly due to thecentralization of institutions and decisions in Libreville
• Little institutional coordination, especially for SMEssupport: the private sector support ecosystem is verypoorly coordinated and responsibilities are fragmentedwhich hamper effectiveness
•Non reinforcement of the tax exemption provision forSMEs: the government has implemented tax incentivesfor SMEs but the actors are not well informed, henceconstraining SMEs performance
• Failure of the government in paying VAT credit causesserious stress in the companies' finances
• The dependence on imports for raw materials makesproduction costs very high and local productionuncompetitive compared to imported products
162
177
139
175
96
161
118
158
Gettin
g C
redit
184
Starting a
Bu
sine
ss
139
190
152
Gettin
g Electricity
Pro
tecting
Min
ority
Investo
r 145
158
Paying Taxes 187
The DRC CAR*Gabon
Gabon’s performance on selected Doing Business indicators (rank out of 190)
Note: *Central African Republic
Source: World Bank, Doing Business Report, 2017; DRC 2017 Economic outlook, Dalberg analysis
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dG
abo
n
24
Access to finance Technical knowledge
NetworkBusiness services
Entrepreneur persona
Unless they start a business intheir sector of expertise, newentrepreneurs are likely toenter the services or retailsector for the lack of adequatetechnical knowledge
Because they had previouswork experience, the youngentrepreneur could usehis/her savings or access anetwork of angel investors tostart their business
Networking is critical to get freeservices and business support,hence the entrepreneurs at allstage seek help from theirpeers. Business owners inGabon gather in severalassociations
Entrepreneurs might haveexperience of a certain sectorbut don’t necessarily knowhow to start and run abusiness hence they needbusiness development support
The typical entrepreneurs in Gabon differs from what can be observed in other countries. They are generally older and have had previous work experience
It is observed in Gabon that most entrepreneurs are adults, aged over 35, who quit or lose theiremployment and decide to start their own business
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
em
and
Gab
on
Source: Dalberg analysis
25
Depending on the stage of their business, entrepreneurs in Gabon have various needs to thrive; mainly technical, financial and advanced business support
Ideation Early stage Growth
Suit
able
Fi
nan
cin
g
Entrepreneurs need seed capital to launch their businesses and cover initial costs but the typical entrepreneurs in Gabon has had previous employment and some savings to start
As the company grows personal funding is no longer suitable. Entrepreneurs often turn to local banks for loans but struggle to present strong creditworthy accounts
Attracting funds to grow is often a critical step of the SMEs’ growth but a strong network can help to overcome this challenge
Bu
sin
ess
Su
pp
ort
Entrepreneurs need support to strengthen entrepreneurial mindset, mature business ideas and assess technical feasibility
SMEs at this stage need support to professionalize their operations and prepare for growth. They also need affordable working space
Enterprises need business support to international standards to overcome a stage where there is limited national benchmarking
Tech
nic
al
Sup
po
rt
There is a need for technical support to prototype and test products or services. Failure to test is a problem for entrepreneurs currently
SMEs in this stage mostly operate in service sectors, creating intense competition and the companies in more innovative or technical sectors lack support
Medium enterprises with a strong network can access resources while others struggle to make the right connections
Shar
ed
Se
rvic
es
Entrepreneurs need support to formalize ideas and write business plans intended to shareholders. They also need working space.
Business advisory services are critical at this stage to allow SMEs to operate formally and interact with the public administration stakeholders
SMEs at this stage can usually afford their own facilities and other business development support and the need for shared services is less critical
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
em
and
Gab
on
Not a constraint Minor Constraint Major Constraint
26
In Gabon as well, there is high potential demand for an incubator to support early stage and growth businesses and provide various set of services
Source: Dalberg analysis
Component Design Requirements Exogenous Risks & Constraints
Financial support
• As the entrepreneurial culture is not widespread in Gabon, business skills building should start from the basics to develop the business mindset and provide financial literacy
Business skills support
• The incubator should connect the entrepreneurs to a mix of financial actors providing seed capital, risk capital and equity to cover different needs at different stage
• The incubator should provide support in financial documents preparation
• It is necessary to do a careful screeningof the entrepreneurs to make sure appetite and foundations are solid and maximize chances of success
Sector specific
technical knowledge
• Such support should bring together international players with local established businesses to share their experience with SMEs but also serve as mentors
• If the incubator does not have a clear curriculum, gaps may arise as entrepreneurs are unlikely to self-assess what support they need
• To attract technical corporate partners, the business case for Gabon needs to be strong, showcasing clear pathways and attractive competitive advantage compared to other countries in the region
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
em
and
Gab
on
27
There are four main actor groups that serve the entrepreneurs and small businesses, their service provision varies significantly within each group
Note: 1 Association pour la Promotion de la Jeunesse; 2 Private Investment Promotion Agency 3 Gabonese National Confederation of Employers’ Associations
Source: Stakeholders interviews, Dalberg analysis, 2017
Actors Description
Incubators
• Three out of ten banks in Gabon are publicly owned entities. In general, commercial banks in Gabon mainly work with government entities or big private players. Micro finance is in a very early stage (BGFI launched LOXIA as it’s MFI branch) and equity investors are timidly entering the market with a limited reach (e.g., Moringa fund invest in commercial agriculture, I&P in BTP, etc.)
Financiers
• The government has recently signed several agreements with private sector players to launch sector-focused incubators to support economic diversification and private sector development. There are also private player and NGOs supported incubators such as Entrepneuriam, Espace PME, JA and APJA1
Public Sector & Associations
• An examination of the private sector institutional support reveals public players such as APIP2, the SME direction, Promo Gabon, etc. and private association such as the Chamber of Commerce, APJA, CPG3, etc. They provide high level assistance to both aspiring entrepreneurs and well-established SMEs. However institutional changes often occur
Technical / Development Organizations
•Many development agency present in Gabon have private sector support as part of their programs, working to enable the environment and spur economic growth. AfDB supported APJA to set an incubator and AFD with its ARIZ program has established a guarantee fund
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
dG
abo
n
1
2
3
4
28
Actors are mostly providing business development and shared services to enterprises at the ideation stage
Ideation Early Growth
Suit
able
Fi
nan
cin
g
Money from family, friend and savings is available at this stage and entrepreneurs often have network that can ease more formal loans
Banks in Gabon target large private company and few financial institutions are willing or have the ability to work with SMEs
Barring few exceptions, the financing of long-term investments is beyond the scope of commercial banks and few PE firms are present in Gabon
Bu
sin
ess
Se
rvic
e
Sup
po
rt
Some private players provide business services to SMEs and the content is adapted to the very early stage or pre-launch of the company
Business service providers don’t target this category of SMEs and their pricing is often unaffordable. Existing incubators and business associations working with them have only a limited reach
Professional serviceproviders target SMEs of this size or larger but their provision is still limited and the quality is not always adjusted to international standards
Tech
nic
al
Sup
po
rt
Entrepreneurs engaging in sectors requiring technical innovation often fail to find the necessary supportor have trouble in seeking international assistance
Passed the prototyping stage, entrepreneurs have no access to technical assistance and government institutions such as IRET1 don’t get enough funding to scale up their support
Technical support needed atthis stage is not available locally and entrepreneurs need to establish international partnerships
Shar
ed
Se
rvic
es
&
Net
wo
rks Entrepreneurs at this
stage can easily get connected to business association and share services with their peers
This stage is the main target of working spaces and service sharing entities present in Libreville but the pricing still high
Needs are more specific at this stage and companies are growing in size. Finding common services and spaces suitable for different sectors is challenging
Well provided Partially provided Poorly/Not provided
Gab
on
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
d
29
An incubator in Gabon could play a critical role in matching the missing supply of technical and financial assistance needed by the SMEs
Function 1 -Financing
Area of Gap Design Requirements
• For each sector, the technical partner needs to have experience in a context similar to Gabon
• The country is experimenting economic diversification and experience has shown that the level of complexity of the Gabonese business environment requires granular understanding
• A multi-sectorial incubator should outsource technical support to ensure coverage
Function 2 -Technical assistance
• Financial support should prioritize businesses that don’t heavily rely on the government to mitigate political and regulatory risk
• Fro early stage companies, the incubator should play a role in facilitating relationships between local financiers and businesses
• Investors into SMEs should have an appetite for risk as private activity in some sectors still experimental, with instable performance
Function 3 -Shared
business support services
mentoring
• Real estate and renting prices are expensive and limit SMEs capacity. Ashared space should make sure to have affordable pricing and collaborate with the existing industrial areas to provide adequate facilities to businesses depending on the sector
• Gabonese entrepreneurs report a lack of role model in their immediate environment. The incubator should pool a global network of mentor to support the nascent ecosystem
• Business support services should be aligned with international standards
Source: Dalberg analysis
Gab
on
Co
nte
xt &
En
ablin
gSu
pp
lyD
eman
d
30
31
Focus of this document
CONTENT
Project context
Feasibility in Gabon
Feasibility in the DRC
Incubator design options
CAFI Feasibility
study
Summary of the project objectives and methodology of the feasibility study
Project context
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in the DRC to determine market gaps
Feasibility in the DRC
Assessment of the entrepreneurial environment (demand and supply) in Gabon to determine market gaps
Feasibility in Gabon
Proposed incubator benchmarking, design options and road map for implementation
Detailed incubator design options
32
The analysis shows that sector-targeted incubators are feasible in both countries, with operational specificities for each context
• Feasibility: There is a lack of early entrepreneurial support and businessmanagement support especially in target sectors. Additionally a number of SMEsshow promise for growth but have limited technical and financial support
• Value proposition: An incubator-accelerator program will leverage CAFI’stechnical networks to support a select number of entrepreneurs in potentialtarget sectors while leveraging impact investor networks to help existing SMEsconnect with international organizations in supply chain development andfunding
• Target sectors: Sustainable Forestry, Eco-Tourism, Non-Timber Forest Products• Operational budget: ~US$ 850,000 per year• Timeline: Pilot in Q3 2018
Feasibility & Outline
Design
• Feasibility: There are gaps in the existing ecosystem, especially for early stageenterprises and entrepreneurs. Sectors’ potential seem compelling, however, theenabling environment is challenging
• Value Proposition: An incubator program that leverages CAFI’s technicalnetworks to allow entrepreneurs and early stage enterprises to build on bothdomestic or regional innovations in target sectors. Helping startups to form andbecome ready for downstream investment (from local financial institutions andinvestors) and expanded market activity
• Target sectors: Sustainable Forestry, Energy & Agriculture• Operational budget: ~US$ 750,000 per year• Timeline: Pilot in Q2 2019
Feasibility & Outline
Design
Bo
t h
Co
un
trie
sB
ench
mar
kin
gO
utl
ine
Des
ign
Op
tio
n S
elec
tio
n
Source: Dalberg analysis
33
14 organizations from a range of geographies were analyzed in the benchmarking exercise, comprising of incubators and investment funds
South Africa
Sub Saharan Africa
2Scale
Latin America
Ethiopia
DRC
Zambia
France
India
USA
Ghana
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
Be
nch
mar
kin
gO
utl
ine
Des
ign
Op
tio
n S
elec
tio
n
*Full benchmarking profiles are included in Appendix A
Sources: Dalberg analysis
34
The benchmarking revealed several characteristics that were considered in the incubator’s design
Description
Clear placement between public and
private sectors
Leverage the business expertise of the privatesector and adequate policy support from thepublic sector to design successful initiatives.
Use a value chain approach
Take into account all challenges in value chainsfrom the production to the commercializationphases and focus on developing acomprehensive support system
Build linkages between SMEs and
large businesses
Grow the domestic economy by developing localsourcing, with a focus on increasing the country’scompetitiveness and capacity
Integrate an advisory board
An advisory board composed of technical expertscan be critical to ensure the businesses needs interms of sectorial expertise are met
Offer an office space and shared services
Reduce the operational costs of starting abusiness by providing rentable space andadministrative services
1
2
3
4
5
2Scale
2Scale
Examples Characteristic
Be
nch
mar
kin
gO
utl
ine
Des
ign
Op
tio
n S
elec
tio
nB
oth
Co
un
trie
s
Sources: Dalberg analysis
35
Based on the country assessments and benchmarking there are three distinct options, which would be adapted operationally to suit each country’s context
Start-up Incubation Program
A
Start-up InvestmentPlatform
B
SME Accelerator for Growth Program
Value Proposition
• To improve the focus on the commercial viability of business models and need for disruptive intervention in target sectors CAFI could target ideation & early stage companies
• Business development and technical support would be provided to either strong country startups in target sectors or to strong local entrepreneurs coupling them with regional proven business models to transfer ideas into the DRC/Gabon context
Target Stage
Ideation
& Early
Early
Growth
• To address the limited pipeline of established SME’s viable for growth investment, CAFI could provide bespoke training to selected established SME’s leveraging connections with multinational partners interested in knowledge sharing
• CAFI would also link strong SMEs to international partners for investments or as off-taker i.e. integrated supply chain solutions
• To address the lack of appetite and mistrust of entrepreneurs in risk capital investment and facilitate investment in early stage companies CAFI could provide a platform to facilitate the matching of existing SMEs to risk capital investors
• CAFI would mainly govern the processes of establishing an angel investor network with clear processes and a legal team to provide confidence on both sides
Option
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esig
nO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
Sources: Dalberg analysis
C
36
Option A – Start-up Incubation Program
Operational Profile
Mobilization Timeframe 9-12 Months
Impact Timeframe 5-10 Years
Level of Complexity Medium
Organizations Processed 10-20 / year
1. Key Selection Criteria: Start-ups with both strong entrepreneur candidates and ideas in the right sectors and/or having activities in selected high risk deforestation regions.
2. Programme-based services: Three-part programme of: 1) General - basics of business management & business plan review; 2) Specific -commercial and technical mentoring; 3) Grant –grant funding for top incubatees & monitoring
3. Location: Pilot physical space in one major economic center, with programme for two additional during expansion phases
4. Revenue model: Mainly donor backed, with small incubatee contribution for services in initial years of operation and success fees for arranged financing
5. Governance & Partners: Programme formed under existing CAFI entity. Partners could include: management partner to operate, and leveraging CAFI’s technical partner networks in target value chains to provide technical mentorship
Initial Design Considerations
Resource Profile (Illustrative)
Full Time Equivalents (FTEs) 8
Annual Operational Costs $ 450k-750k
Annual Grant Support $ 50k-100k
Direct Financing None Proposed
PR
OC
ESS
TARGETED
SELECTIONGRANT &
NETWORK SUPPORTBespoke – Tech &
Commercial MentoringGeneral BD Skills
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esig
nO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
Sources: Dalberg analysis
37
Option B – Start-up Investment Platform
Operational Profile
Mobilization Timeframe 6-12 Months
Impact Timeframe 4-7 Years
Level of Complexity Medium
Organizations Processed 5- 10 / year
1. Location: Office space in major center and regular investment events in key geographies in shared partner office space
2. Key Selection Criteria: Early-stage companies active in the market showing strong leadership and potential to grow further in the right sectors and/or having activities in selected high risk deforestation regions.
3. Bespoke-based services: Three part services: 1) mentorship and technical training through a hybrid approach; 2) Investor matching forums; 3) Ongoing operational and external technical support
4. Revenue model: Donor support, arrangement fees & equity exits
5. Governance & Partners: 1) In country non-CAFI entity with unique board; 2) Offshore investment vehicle; 3) Light touch government involvement
Initial Design Considerations
Resource Profile (Illustrative)
Full Time Equivalents (FTEs) 3
Annual Operational Costs $ 250-450k
Annual Grant Support None Proposed
Annual Direct Financing None Proposed
TARGETED
SELECTIONNETWORK
SUPPORTInvestor Matching
ProcessCoaching &
Priming
PR
OC
ESS
Ongoing Support
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esig
nO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
Sources: Dalberg analysis
38
Option C – SME Accelerator for Growth Program
Operational Profile
Mobilization Timeframe 1 Year +
Impact Timeframe 3-4 Years
Level of Complexity High
Organizations Processed 5-10 / year
1. Location: Pilot physical space in one major economic center, with programmes in two additional regions/areas
2. Key Selection Criteria: Established SMEs with strong leadership credentials and significant potential to grow in the right sectors and/or having activities in selected high risk deforestation regions. Time based exits
3. Bespoke services: 1) Growth business planning & promote technical linkage with global corporate partners; 2) Impact investment Mobilization with guarantees to support; 3) Ongoing shared support services (tax etc.)
4. Revenue model: Some attendee fee recovery, but mainly revenue from arrangement fees charged to downstream debt/equity finance providers
5. Governance & Partners: 1) In country non-CAFI entity with unique board; 2) Only light touch government and public body involvement
Initial Design Considerations
Resource Profile (Illustrative)
Full Time Equivalents (FTEs) 7
Annual Operational Costs $ 450-650k
Annual Grant Support $ 50k-150k
Annual Direct Financing $ 2-10M
PR
OC
ESS
TARGETED
SELECTIONGUARANTEE
TERM ENDSConnection with global partners
Ongoing shared Services
Impact investment support by guarantees
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esig
nO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
Sources: Dalberg analysis
39
In the DRC, targeting early stage companies is most viable given the need to build a stronger pipeline of companies that are innovating in target sectors
• Option A is preferred as there is an overarching need to build early pipeline andbring in fresh ideas to innovate in existing sectors and potentially disrupt thestatus quo
• The enabling environment also hinders the development of Option B which willrequired significant confidence in political stability and institutions to encourageinvestment
• Option B & C could yield some short term benefits but might not be sustaineddue to a lack of bankable pipeline
Option SelectionRationale
• The incubator will: leverage CAFI’s technical networks to allow entrepreneurs tobuild on both domestic or regional innovations in target sectors, helping startupto form and become ready for downstream investment and expanded marketactivity
• Sector Focus: Energy, Agriculture, Forestry (non-timber products), Eco-tourism,Services (e.g., ICT)
• In 5 years, what does success look like? The incubator will have helped between15-20+ viable businesses form, that receive downstream financing to grow.Proven innovation will also champion new entrants into target markets. Theincubator will have strengthened the entrepreneurial ecosystem and itself actedas a model for other organizations to replicate in other sectors and geographies
Value Proposition & Success
The
DR
CB
ench
mar
kin
gO
utl
ine
Des
ign
Op
tio
n S
elec
tio
n
Sources: Dalberg analysis
40
In Gabon, an incubator is needed for entrepreneurs to develop early skills and innovate in new sectors, but also assist some SMEs ready for growth
Option SelectionRationale
• Option A is preferred, combined with some elements of Option C. There is aneed to embed entrepreneurial culture within target value chains starting withbasic training and providing a platform for startups to develop from ideas
• However, there are some existing SMEs that could be grown, therefore aprogram focused on early stage companies but with some room for those at agrowth stage is required. Option B would not provide the necessary sharingspace and business management skills that are gaps in the supply-side currently
Value Proposition & Success
• The incubator will: leverage CAFI’s technical networks to support a selectnumber of entrepreneurs with potential target sectors while leveraging CAFI’stechnical networks to link existing SMEs and owners to internationalorganizations for supply chain development, as recommended by thebenchmarking exercise
• Sector Focus: Eco-tourism, Forestry/Wood processing, Non Timber ForestProducts, Agriculture
• In 5 years, what does success look like? The incubator will have generatedbetween 10-15 functional startups that receive downstream financing to grow.These will act as a precedent to encourage Gabonese to enter target sectorsproactively. Coupled with this the accelerator function will successfully couple 5-10 existing SMEs/owners with international technical support to expand to newmarkets or scale in current ones
Gab
on
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esig
nO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Sources: Dalberg analysis
41
Three entry points should be considered to ensure appropriate gender mainstreaming into the functions of the incubators in both countries
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esi
gnO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
• In the target sectors, prioritize value chains or steps of the value chainwhere gender participation is higher or can be enhanced (distribution of clean cooking energy in the DRC; harvesting of non timber products in Gabon)
• Formalize informal value chains where women’s participation is already high in both countries
Target sectors and value chains to enhance
women’s participation
• Consider a gender lens in the selection criteria, in addition to assessing the entrepreneur, the business/idea and it’s impact potential
• Foster women’s entrepreneurship through specific events (e.g. prominent women entrepreneurs as keynote speakers and / or mentors for entrepreneurs)
Promote women entrepreneurship through
incubators’ selection processes
• Track impact of incubation program on women’s participation in specific sectors or on women’s economic empowerment (e.g., number of female entrepreneurs, number of female employees in the businesses that are being supported or in their ecosystem, etc.)
Gender differentiated tracking of impact
Sources: Dalberg analysis
42
The implementation road map for each country will have 3 phases, to define a clear business plan, pilot the incubator and expand before a handover process
Phase 1 – Design Development:
Assess incubatees’
opportunities
Draft business plan
Reach out to Partners & sign
MoUs
Develop Business Plan and financial
model
Business plan
Decision: Progress on basis of feasibility study?
Phase 2 – Launch Pilot:
Register legal entity
Hire staff & set-up office
Secure funding & SMEs
Progress with initial cohort
Interim evaluation
Decision: Progress on basis of business plan?
Phase 3 – Refine, Grow & Handover:
Establish refined
structure
Expand to new location or
larger cohort
Repeat cohorts and build network
Handover planning
Close-out evaluation
Decision: Is the potential to grow there?
Decision: Does CAFI want tolengthen it’s involvement?
Outputs
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esi
gnO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
Sources: Dalberg analysis
43
Based on a high level appraisal of services and operational requirements the combined cost of running both incubators could be over $1.5M a year
Annual Operational Costs Breakdown*
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esi
gnO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Phase 1Design
Phase 2 Setup
Phase 3Operational
5-Year Total
Combined operational
costs
$ 250k
Expenditure GabonThe DRC
$ 3.75M
$ 750k**
$ 200k
$ 250k
$ 4.25M
$ 850k**
$ 230k
$ 8.0 M
Expenditure Estimates
Staffing is likely to contribute over 70% while other expenditure, including direct programming
support to incubatees could be around 20% of each incubator’s costs, Grant size could vary
significantly by business need
Gabon’s higher operating costs are driven by the need to have a larger team to manage the
accelerator function, though this is partially offset by a lower number of early stage firms
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
53%
18%6% 6%
18%
Trai
nin
g St
aff
Mgm
t St
aff
Gra
nts
Eve
nts
Oth
er
Exp
en
dit
ure
Tota
l
100%
*Estimates for Gabon; **including small grants
Sources: Dalberg analysis
44
Funders and financiers will be interested to understand both the incubators’ impact and the potential for pipeline generation downstream
Entrepreneurs Trained – all incubatees regardless of downstreamsuccess will grow the capacity of the local business ecosystemwhich would create private sector development outside of theincubator’s direct influence. Potential KPI: Number of incubatees,outreach event attendance per annum, client satisfaction
Jobs Created – It will be relatively easy to monitor the size ofincoming businesses and their growth both during and in the yearsafter incubation. Potential KPI: Aggregate number of employmentopportunities created
Viable businesses formed – Not all incubation processes will yieldviable businesses a measure could be to rate successful businessformation on the ability to raise significant further financing post-incubation. Potential KPI: Number of incubated businessesreceiving downstream financing, SME survival rate
Investment pipeline– Related to the above point investors will beinterested in the potential pipeline of investment opportunitiescreated, either to grow bank SME loan portfolios or to improvedeal flow for investment funds and impact investors. Potential KPI:Volume of transactions in incubation companies and sectors
Potential impact within 5 years
Early: 10
Growth: 10
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esi
gnO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
DRC Gabon
Early: 20
Growth: 0
$ 1M to 5M
$ 2.5M to $ 15M
150 –1,000
Early: 50
Growth: 20
Early: 100
Growth: 0
200 –5,000
Sources: Dalberg analysis
45
The potential log-frame for the incubation activities will also include indicators related to CAFI’s environmental objectives
Ben
chm
arki
ng
Ou
tlin
e D
esi
gnO
pti
on
Sel
ecti
on
Bo
th C
ou
ntr
ies
• Number of enterprises in the targetedsectors
• Volumes of national and international sales• Price index of non-timber products
• Increase value of forest – Creation of viablemarkets for non timber forest products
(e.g., honey, Ibogai, etc.) and eco-tourism
Examples of indicatorsObjectives
• % of deforestation attributed to subsistencefarming
• % of deforestation attributed to collectionof wood-fuel
• Cultivated land expansion in highdeforestation areas
• Reduce reliance on forest – Creation ofsustainable business models andtechnologies to reduce slash and burnagriculture and reliance on wood-fuel
• Number of sustainable forestry plantations• Acre of land reforested• Number of certified “green” enterprises• Volumes of wood from illegal logging
• Promote sustainable forestry practices –Development of sustainable private sectormodels to move away from artisanalforestry
Sources: Dalberg analysis
46
THANK YOU