final netflix response to comm. pai 12.11.14 (1)

2
  December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

Upload: jbrodkin2000

Post on 08-Oct-2015

1.033 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Response to Pai's accusations

TRANSCRIPT

  • December 11, 2014 The$Honorable$Ajit$Pai$Commissioner$Federal$Communications$Commission$$445$12th$Street,$SW$$Washington,$DC$20554$$$Dear$Commissioner$Pai:$$Thank$you$for$your$December$2nd$letter$and$for$your$questions$regarding$Netflixs$Open$Connect$technology.$$Netflix$offers$the$following$response.$$$With$respect$to$open$Internet$policy,$Netflix$supported$the$FCCs$use$of$section$706$to$promulgate$its$2010$Open$Internet$Order.$The$courts$decision$in$Verizons$lawsuit$invalidated$Section$706$as$the$sole$basis$of$Open$Internet$rules.$This$has$left$you$and$your$colleagues$at$the$FCC$with$little$alternative$but$to$consider$other$enforcement$tools,$such$as$industry$standards,$codes$of$conduct$and$Title$II$of$the$Communications$Act$to$protect$consumers$and$innovation.$While$we$may$differ$on$precisely$what$alternatives$the$Commission$should$use,$our$goal$is$to$rest$Open$Internet$policy$on$a$solid$legal$foundation.$$$Netflix$designed$the$Open$Connect$content$delivery$network$(CDN)$to$provide$consumers$with$a$highVquality$video$experience$that$enables$ISPs$to$manage$their$networks$in$an$efficient$and$cost$effective$way.$Through$Open$Connect,$Netflix$brings$data$to$the$location(s)$of$an$ISPs$choice,$usually$at$common$Internet$exchange$points$or$through$localized$caches.$This$is$how$most$CDNs$interconnect.$Under$the$Open$Connect$program,$Netflix$bears$all$of$the$costs$of$providing$Open$Connect$equipment$to$any$ISP$that$chooses$to$participate$in$Open$Connect.$$$Open$Connect$is$not$a$fast$lane.$$Since$the$beginning$of$this$proceeding,$Netflix$has$consistently$opposed$the$Commission$permitting$fast$lanes$in$consumer$Internet$connections.$$Open$Connect$does$not$prioritize$Netflix$data.$Open$Connect$uses$best$efforts$Internet$services$into$and$out$of$its$content$caches.$When$an$ISP$asks$Netflix$to$localize$an$Open$Connect$cache$within$its$network,$it$does$not$disadvantage$other$Internet$content.$To$the$contrary,$Open$Connect$helps$ISPs$reduce$costs$and$better$manage$congestion,$which$results$in$a$better$Internet$experience$for$all$end$users.$$

  • $Only$ISPs$can$speed$up$or$slow$down$data$that$flow$over$their$last$mile.$When$Netflix$directly$interconnects$with$an$ISP,$Netflix$data$does$not$travel$faster$than$other$Internet$content$VV$unless$an$ISP$is$artificially$constraining$capacity$to$other$data$sources.$$$$Open$Connect$uses$openVsource$software$and$readilyVavailable$hardware$components.$Because$these$designs$may$be$helpful$for$other$providers$of$large$media$files$and$are$very$cost$efficient,$Netflix$has$published$that$information$online$for$use$freely$by$others.1$Netflix$is$also$active$in$efforts$to$develop$open$standards$for$streaming$video.$All$truly$open$Internet$Protocol$Standards,$including$those$used$for$streaming$video$delivery,$are$coordinated$through$the$World$Wide$Web$Consortium2$(W3C)$and$the$Internet$Engineering$Task$Force3$(IETF).$Netflix$is$an$active$participant$in$both.$$Others$in$the$industry$are$exploring$the$use$of$open$or$proxy$caching$for$streaming$video$content.$$It$is$good$that$others$are$thinking$about$ways$to$improve$streaming$video$quality.$However,$Netflix$has$focused$its$efforts$and$resources$on$Open$Connect$because$we$have$found$that$it$is$more$efficient$and$results$in$fewer$service$outages$and$customer$complaints$than$these$other$options.$$$Netflix$has$not$impeded$the$use$of$proxy$caches$by$changing$protocols.$Netflix$has$obscured$certain$URL$structures$to$protect$our$members$from$deep$packet$inspection$tools$deployed$to$gather$data$about$what$they$watch$online.$Netflix$is$committed$to,$and$will$continue$to$ensure,$the$privacy$of$our$members$viewing.$$We$hope$that$these$responses$have$been$helpful.$$Please$do$not$hesitate$to$reach$out$if$you$have$additional$questions.$$$

    Sincerely,$$$$

    Christopher$Libertelli$Vice$President$|$Global$Public$Policy$$Netflix$Inc.$

    $$

    1 See https://openconnect.itp.netflix.com/openconnect/index.html. 2 http://www.w3.org/Consortium/. 3 https://www.ietf.org/.