final report onreeep.sreda.gov.bd/...10-24...compositions-with-modified-machine_k… ·...
TRANSCRIPT
Final Report
On
Biomass Briquettes manufacturing with different compositions with Modified Machine
Period: 20 October 2018 to 31 October 2018
Submitted to
GFA Consulting Group GmbH
Date of Submission Date: 24 October 2018
Submitted by
Josna Ara
Executive Director
Khaya (Samaj Unnayan Sangstha)
Satkhira
Background: Biomass is the primary source of fuel for a large portion of the world’s
underdeveloped countries. Biomass is used for a variety of purposes in the
developing world, the primary of which is for cooking. Bangladesh is one of the most
energy starved countries of the world. The natural resources of the country are fast
depleting. Given this scenario, biomass is considered an important source of
renewable energy for the country. Biomass still accounts for over 50% of the total
energy supply of Bangladesh. It is the primary source of fuel for the rural
households. An average Bangladeshi household burns about 2.5 tonnes of biomass
a year, since only 6% of the total population of Bangladesh have access to natural
gas. In addition, businesses and institutions are also interested to use biomass for
cooking as well as other purposes.
More than 90% of the people of Bangladesh use traditional biomass such as non-
carbon neutral fuel wood, wood residue and leaves; agricultural residue such as rice
husk, rice straw, rice bran, wheat straw, maize stalk and maize cob, jute stalk, lentils
residue, sugarcane bagasse; and others like cow dung and poultry dropping for
cooking. Alternative fuels for cooking such as briquettes and pellets from biomass
are still at a very early stage of development in Bangladesh. However, in the
neighbouring countries such as Nepal and India, briquette and pellet manufacture
process and technology is at a much more developed stage. Though briquettes do
not enhance the heat value content of the used biomass, thermal efficiency is known
to be doubled compared to cooking with biomass in conventional way. Biomass
briquette production from refused and collected biomasses from open atmosphere
has an immense potential to be replicated in Bangladesh especially at rural and
semi-urban areas from waste stream. People in rural and slum areas along with
floating people of urban areas, may be engaged in handmade biomass briquette
production using tree leaves & twigs, agricultural and other biomass wastes.
Machine-made briquettes are already available in the market, as such the focus will
be to assess the current production processes and potential alternatives to it, as well
as potential other sources of raw material for briquettes, such as diverse agricultural
wastes, rice husk and water hyacinth or sugarcane bagasse at low cost. Currently
there is no mentionable market for briquettes in Bangladesh, yet there is an urgent
need to act on this considering the availability of raw materials and scarcity of dry
biomass during rainy season.
As an agricultural country along with a large population we have lots of biomass
waste.75% of energy comes from biomass in rural area are agricultural waste and
residues. These residues are used in a non-efficient and non-hygienic way. Mainly
this energy consumption is happened in rural area’s cooking system with only 8-12%
efficiency. The main problem with that biomass is low density and high moisture
content. By making briquette mixing a wide range different raw materials e.g Rice
husk, Saw dust, waste paper, cow dung, leaf etc. this problem can be solved. By
producing high efficiency briquette we can solve energy crisis, assuring hygiene in
rural
cooking and save the environment. Study in Kheya Samaj Unnayan Sangstha
conducted research on briquette to produce high burning efficiency briquette as well
as to mitigate fuel crisis in cooking system of Bangladesh.
Objective
Basic application of handmade briquettes is thinkable for domestic use and small businesses in rural
areas I\in order to develop the alternative fuel market in Bangladesh, it is essential to understand
different types and combinations of raw materials that can be used for production of briquettes,
Specifically, the study should identify and focus on the lowest cost options for briquette production
for the local market.
1. Select three different compositions of hand press Biomass Briquette as recommended by GFA
Advisor in Charge.
2. Identify local demand and target customer.
3. Provide designated areas for briquette manufacturing in an existing and new facility.
4. Manufacture and dissemination of 300 kg / month for selected composition of briquettes and
sales around 200 kg of briquettes in total during contract period.
5. Arrange biomass briquettes sales at list 5 different sale center/ shops
6. Find out optimum manpower requirement for briquette manufacturing
7. Find out production capacity per day per person.
8. Calculate production cost (per kg) of briquette from raw materials local price (Rice husk, saw
dust, waste newspaper, agricultural waste and cow dung etc)
9. Identify willingness to use and acceptance criteria of the product from seller and user
perspectives
10. Maintain customer and production logbook as per prescribed format.
Primary Raw materials of Briquettes:
1. Saw Dust
2. Rice Husk
Binder materials:
1. Waste Paper
2. Cow dung
Raw materials Mixing with New Mixing Device:
Manufacturing Biomass Briquettes with Modified Machine:
Sun Drying
Selection of Composition:
GFA has Selected 04 no of Compositions for hand press Biomass Briquettes:
Composition ID Composition
Kheya 01
Saw Dust : 33 % Rice Husk: 33 % Waste Paper: 33%
Kheya 02
Saw Dust : 50% Waste Paper: 25% Cow dung : 25%
Kheya 03
Rice husk : 40% Paper : 60%
Kheya 04
Sawdust: 40% Leaf: 10% Waste paper: 30% Cowdung:20%
Biomass Briquettes sales
Production of Hand Press Biomass briquettes:
Composition ID
Composition Production Production time
Manpower Sun Drying Time
Remarks
Kheya 01 Saw Dust : 4 kg Rice Husk: 4 kg Waste Paper: 4 kg Total : 12 Kg
Day-1 213 pcs briquettes
8 hrs
2 persons
2-3 days (Rainey day)
02 persons can manufacture at least 200- 250 pcs biomass briquettes per day @ 100tk/ day/ person (Not the professional market labour )
Kheya 02 Saw Dust : 4 kg Waste Paper: 3 kg Cow dung : 04 kg Total : 10 Kg
Day-2 204 pcs briquettes
8 hrs 2 persons 2-3 days Sun drying
Kheya 03 Sawdust: 4 kg
Day-3 170 pcs
7 hrs 2 persons 2-3 days
Leaf: 1 kg Waste paper: 3 kg Cowdung: 2 kg Total: 10 kg
briquettes Sun drying
Kheya 04 Saw dust: 5 kg Waste paper: 5 kg
Day 1 213 pcs briquettes
8 Hrs 2 persons 3-4 days Sun drying
T- Stall Using Biomass Briquettes
Cost of raw Materials
Description Cost/ kg Purchase Quantity
Carrying cost
Unit price /kg Remarks
Rice Husk 6 Tk 80 kg 100 TK 7.25TK
Sawdust 4 Tk 80 kg 100 TK 5.25TK
Waste Paper 12 Tk 90 kg 100 TK 13 TK
Cow dung 2 tk 50 kg 100 4 kg
Composition ID: Kheya 01
Description Quantity
Unit Price Price
Total Price
Total no Briquette Manufacture
Labour Cost Total Manufacturing Cost for 12 KG
Manufacturing cost/kg
Rice Husk 4 kg 7.25 TK 29 TK Day 1 = 213
2x 100 TK (2 persons)
Raw materials = 102 TK Labour= 200 TK
Sawdust 4 kg 5.25 TK 21 TK
Waste Paper 4 kg 13 TK 52 TK
Total 12 kg 102 182 pcs 2x 100 TK 302 25 TK /kg
Composition ID: Kheya 02
Description Quantity Unit Price
Total Price Total no Briquette Manufacture
Labour Cost
Total Manufacturing Cost for 101 KG
Manufacturing cost/kg
Sawdust 4 kg 5.25 TK 21 TK Day 1 =204
2x100 TK (2 persons)
Raw materials = 76 TK Labour= 200 TK
Waste Paper 3 kg 13 TK 39 TK
Cow dung 4 kg 4 tk 16 tk
Total 11 kg 76 tk 204 pcs 2x100 TK
276 25 TK/kg
Composition ID: Kheya 03
Description Quantity Unit Price Price
Total Price
Total no Briquette Manufacture
Labour Cost
Total manufacturing Cost for 10 KG
Manufacturing cost/kg
Day 1 = 170 2x100 Raw materials
Sawdust 4 kg 5.25 TK 21 TK TK (2 persons)
=71 TK Labour= 200 TK
Waste Paper
3 kg 13 TK 42 TK
Leaf Cow Dung
1 kg 2 kg
- 4
- 8tk
Total 10 kg 71 170 pcs 200 TK 271 TK 27TK/kg
Biomass briquettes user list
Sl no Name and Address Biomass
Briquettes (Kg)
01 Khasu Billah
T- stall
Bash Gatha, Satkhira
Mobile: 01998624407
40
02 Mohiful Islam
T-Stall
Bashgatha, Satkhira
Mobile: 01913741439
50
03 Hena Begum
T-Stall
Bashgatha, Satkhira
Mobile: 01902748173
50
04 Md Faruq
T-stall
Bashgatha, Satkhira
Mobile: 01956637455
30
05 Md Mizanur
T-Stall, Bashgatha
Mobile: 01797877366
40
Total 200
Feedback on Local fuel seller:
1. It should be good for tea-stall and restaurant.
2. Can they manufacture briquette by shop owners.
Conclusion:
There is significant effect on binding materials. If use less than 40 % binding
materials, production of briquette goes slow because of broken finished product. For
production of briquette we need at least two person. And two person can produce
maximum 250-300 pcs briquettes per day higher than previous machine. If can use
semi-automatic machine production cost will be less. It’s not user friendly for single
people. For cooking it is good for Improved cook stove because of its great. Fuel
concussion is almost same compare to CRH. Presently its production cost is 25-27
Tk/ kg. it’s too high. Because of high labour cost and slow production. In the local
market Compressed Rice husk(CRH) cost is around 09.30 TK/kg. In this condition I
recommend hand press biomass briquette price should not more than 9-10 tk/Kg .
Composition ID
Composition Test Result Remarks
NACOM 01 Saw Dust :5 kg Waste Paper: 3 kg Cow dung : 2 kg
Calorific Value : 2331.59 k cal/kg Volatile matter(w/w): 60.68%
NACOM 02 Saw Dust : 4kg Waste Paper: 3 kg Cow dung : 3 kg
Calorific value: 3598 k cal/kg Volatile Mater w/w: 54.15 (%)
Recommended Composition
Kheya 03 Rice husk: 3 kg Sawdust: 3 kg Waste paper: 4 kg
Calorific value: 3088.97 k cal/kg Volatile Mater w/w: 57.19 (%)
Recommended Composition
Kheya 04 Saw dust : 4 kg Waste paper: 4 kg Rice husk : 1 kg
Calorifie value: 2698.07 k cal/kg Volatile Mater w/w (%): 51.26
Kheya 05 Rice Husk : 4 kg Waste paper: 5 kg Cow dung: 1 kg
Calorifie value: 2288.71 k cal/kg Volatile Mater w/w (%): 47.42
Kheya 06
Rice husk: 2.5 kg Sawdust: 2.5 kg Leaf: 0.5 kg Waste paper: 3.5 kg Cowdung: 0.5 kg
Calorifie value: 3229.27 k cal/kg Volatile Mater w/w (%): 60.29
Recommended Composition
As per test result we have found that Best Composition of Briquettes is
Saw dust : Wastepaper: Cow dung: 4:3:3
2nd best composition is ,
Sawdust: rice husk: waste paper: leaf: cow dung: 2.5: 2.5: 0.5: 3.5: 0.5
3rd best composition is
Rice husk: sawdust: waste paper: 3:3:4
For using Modified Hand Press machine production rate has increased almost
double. And manufacturer can easily remove briquettes from the machine. For using
sawdust , cow dung and waste paper compaction is high and increase calorific
value and also increase volatile mater.