final report group 2 (mex section a)
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
1/45
COVERLETTER
BUSINESS COMMUNICATION
TERM REPORT (2011)
The Problems
Of
Professional Working Women
In
Pakistan
Presented To:
Mr. Shaikh Irfan Muhammad
Presented By:
Maria Aslam
Madiha Khan
Sana Ehsan
Aliya Bukhari
1
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
2/45
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all well like to give special thanks to our teacher Sir Irfan
Sheikh for helping and guiding us through thick and thins which we
faced while we were preparing our report. Secondly a special thanks to
all our working female professional colleagues who participated in our
survey and filled our questionnaire patiently and provided facts while
we were conducting our survey.
2
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
3/45
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL
20th
August 2011
Mr. Sheikh Irfan
Business Communication Teacher
Institute of Business Management
Karachi
Dear Sir,
We take pleasure in submitting for your consideration a report on The problems faced byprofessional working ladies in Pakistan'. This report is divided into four parts: Introduction,
Literature Review, Methodology and Conclusions and Results. The report aims to determine the
general opinion of the professional working women about the problems they face at work. The
report was authorized by you in August 2011. We have completed the report on schedule and met
all our proposed objectives.
The professional working ladies at our working places served as a sample for our study and
questionnaires were used as a research tool. The report provides different reasons the working
professional ladies in Pakistan face while they are at work and what are the circumstances which
are serving as a barrier in their way of success. We evaluated the results based on our survey andused them to test the hypotheses that we came up with.
Majority of the working ladies agreed that the social , cultural and religious orthodox thoughts are
the major hurdles in their working lives which are the barriers in their success.
We would like to express our gratitude to our professional working colleagues for bearing with our
questions and so patiently filling out our questionnaires. We commend this report to you.
Sincerely,
Maria Aslam
Madiha Khan
Sana Ehsan
Aliya Bukhari
3
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
4/45
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The purpose of the research study was to evaluate and identify the problems of
working women: the problems faced while they work for an organization and
manage between the work place and family life. For survey a questionnaire was
prepared and feedback from 40 working women from different
organizations/industry was collected and analyzed.
It is observed and inferred from the results that the working women are equally
potential employees as of men but are facing immense pressure which include
society, culture, work place and family pressures. In spite of her endeavors
towards the work place and her contribution to the family and growth of societyor economy her development as an employee is precluded at most.
There are a various number of factors contributing to the problems of working
women and the major reported issues and factors are discussed in this report.
The feedback received through questionnaire authenticate that the existence of
the mentioned problems are the upshot of gender biasness at work places. Our
culture and mind set nourishes these problems and throttles the potential and
capabilities of working women.
Fulfilling the necessities of working women flourishes her as an employee and
the organization too. Unbiased working environment creates healthy and
positive energy within the employees and increases the employee competencies.
4
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
5/45
TABLE OF CONTENTSCOVER LETTER............................................................................................................1
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT..................................................................................................2
LETTER OF TRANSMITTAL............................................................................................3
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY.................................................................................................4
TABLE OF CONTENTS..................................................................................................5
CHAPTER 01: INTRODUCTION......................................................................................8
1.1 PURPOSE STATEMENT.......................................................................................9
1.1.1.Population: ..................................................................................................9
1.1.2. Sample:.....................................................................................................10
1.1.3. Procedure and Method:.............................................................................10
1.1.4. Assumptions:............................................................................................10
1.1.5. Hypotheses:..............................................................................................10
CHAPTER 02: LITERATURE REVIEW............................................................................11
2.1 INTRODUCTION...............................................................................................11
2.2. SATISTICAL REVIEW OF WOMEN WORKFORCE IN PAKISTAN............................12
2.2.1. Demographic Trends and Developments in Labor Force Participation of
Females..............................................................................................................12
2.2.2. Female Employment by Sector..................................................................13
2.2.3. The Widening Wage Gap...........................................................................13
2.3. UNEMPLOYMENT AMONG WOMEN IN PAKISTAN:.............................................14
2.4. LEGAL, SOCIAL & CULTURAL BACKGROUND OF WOTKING WOMEN INPAKISTAN:..............................................................................................................14
2.4.1. Women Empowerment in Pakistan:...........................................................15
2.4.2. Role of Women in Freedom Movement:.....................................................15
2.4.3. Legal Status: ............................................................................................16
5
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
6/45
2.4.4. Suppression Based on Religious Issues:.....................................................16
2.4.5. Cultural & Social Standing of Women:.......................................................17
2.5. GENDER BIASNESS AT WORKPLACE:...............................................................18
2.5.1. Promotion and Pay Gap:............................................................................18
2.5.2. More Stress for Same Work:......................................................................18
2.5.3. Maternal Wall:...........................................................................................19
2.5.4. More Evidences of Skills:...........................................................................19
2.5.5. Behavior Curbs/Unspoken Norms:.............................................................19
2.5.6. Hidden Biasness:.......................................................................................19
2.6. WORKING WOMEN NEEDS AT WORK PLACE....................................................21
2.6.1. Practical Needs of Female Employees:......................................................21
2.6.2. Effect of Desirable Work Environment for Female:.....................................25
2.6.3. Outcomes of Exploitative Working Environment for Females:....................25
2.6.4. Recommendations for Women Friendly Work Environment:......................25
CHAPTER 03: METHODOLOGY....................................................................................27
3.1 PURPOSE STATEMENT:....................................................................................27
3.2 RESEARCH QUESTIONS:...................................................................................27
3.3 HYPOTHESES:..................................................................................................27
3.4 POPULATION:...................................................................................................28
3.5 SAMPLE:..........................................................................................................28
3.6 PROCEDURE AND METHOD:.............................................................................28
3.7 ASSUMPTIONS:................................................................................................28
CHAPTER 04: ANALYSIS.............................................................................................29
APPENDIX..................................................................................................................39
QUESTIONAIRE RESULTS IN TABULAR FORM..........................................................39
QUESTIONAIRE......................................................................................................40
6
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
7/45
Table 1: Population Distribution & Growth Rate as Estimated in 2008: .................41
Table 2: Labor Force Participation Rate (%) 2008:.................................................42
Table 3: Employment % by Sector:........................................................................43
Table 4: Gender inequalities in various indicators in a sample of countries (Male aspercent of Female).................................................................................................44
REFERANCES.............................................................................................................45
7
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
8/45
CHAPTER 01: INTRODUCTIONPakistan is a varied mixture of social classes and walks of life, and women can be found working
in a broad assortment of professions. There are highly qualified women working in white-collarmanagement, administrative, and creative and academic positions; women of the middle class have
entered the ranks of retail and restaurant workers, as well as other responsible positions. And then
there are women of lower class working at the lowest level, fighting for survival.
In in this research we assess the major problems these working women face as they aim to break
traditional rules and restrictions on their employment and how they deal with such problems.
Through a the questionnaire, working women explained how and why they are facing problems at
work, which are giving them more confidence to strive for better .
The history of womens employment tells us that the very first jobs for educated women were
teaching or nursing, jobs which were considered as the extension of the household duties and
where the contact with the males was minimal. These are still referred to as traditional jobs. Things
are beginning to change: there is now a social and cultural expectation for young women to
achieve a certain level of education, even for their chances in the marriage market.
Now women have begun working at nontraditional jobs as well: many respondents in categories
two and three worked in jobs considered only a few years ago to be exclusively male employment
Culturally, household work is considered a womans primary role. Due to the increase of economic
pressures on families in the past few decades, the traditional restrictions on women have lessened
and large numbers of women have taken on paid employment; but domestic work remains a
womans principal duty.
Seventy-five percent of the women included are reported that they are physically tired out by
managing both their work at home and at their place of employment. The largest percentage of
working women across Pakistan has concentrated on occupations such as health workers,
educational professionals and clerical workers. They have entered into professions that are less
attractive to men because of poor working conditions, lower pay, lack of control, monotony, and
lack of opportunity for advancement. Women feel discriminated against in terms of their salaries
and promotions.
8
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
9/45
A very strong factor negatively influencing the participation of women in the work force is the
practice of seclusion traditionally seclusion means wearing an over-garment that covers the whole
body, including the head and face. Women from moderately educated and/or religious
backgrounds are often found working in traditional jobs, and women from well-educated and
socially advanced families have the opportunity to pursue non-traditional jobs and careers, where
they compete with males.
Parents encouragement plays a very important role for girls pursuing male-dominated
occupations. It was found that parental support was one of the strongest predictors of young
womens career aspirations and motivations: those who were career oriented girls faced less
pressure from their parents to marry early and have children.
Women are still earning less than the male counterparts. They either feel theyre neglecting their
children. Or theyve decided to remain childless in order to focus on their careers. This could be
why were starting to see more and more professional women telecommuting, working flex time or
even getting off the job track for a few years to be stay-at-home moms. They want to do one thing
well and for many that means choosing to be with their children.
Women CEOs are still in the minority, which means fewer mentors for the younger women on the
way up. And, of course, many whove made it to the top are all too often labeled tough, hard,
difficult, cold. In other words, possessing the same skills as their successful male counterparts.
1.1 PURPOSE STATEMENT
To determine the perception of different working women about what the professional working
ladies face problems at work in Pakistan.
1.1.1.Population:
Our working places which include Beacon-house School System, Siemens Pakistan, Al-karam
textiles and Ferguson were chosen as a survey place. The sample population which we targeted
was the professional working women in these working places.
9
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
10/45
1.1.2. Sample:
The size of our sample is 40 with 10 from each firm. 10 questioners were distributed to each firm.
In this way we came to know the opinion of the working professional ladies in the age group of 25-
40.
1.1.3. Procedure and Method:
The research took 3 days to complete. We asked our participants to take out time for us as we
explained our purpose of research and explained them the questioners which they filled. It took an
average 5 to 6 minutes to fill up the questionnaire by the participants. After the collection of data
from our respective working places one of our group members compiled the data and results.
1.1.4. Assumptions:
Questions have been answered honestly
The participants are knowledgeable and aware of the research topic.
There were no bias views from the participants.
The questionnaire is valid according to our research.
1.1.5. Hypotheses:
The salaries earned by the women are lower as compared to men in the same position.
They need flexible work arrangements to successfully manage work and family life.
They are provided less work based support for family responsibilities.
It is a generic thought that mothers cant be both good mothers and good workers.
10
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
11/45
CHAPTER 02: LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 INTRODUCTION
The women of Pakistan have always experienced disadvantage relative to men of the same class.
Social, cultural and religious factors have reduced the number of women entering the job market.
Along with Pakistan, gender bias is a thorn in the flesh of more or less every social system, in one
or other way. It has been always realized that women has been exploited, whatever they do get the
jobs or not. There is a general perception that after getting job all the financial and social problems
are solved , however this has been exactly opposite in case of women. When Men get jobs their
problems are solved and when women get jobs their problems start.
In Pakistan there is social environment that never allows Pakistani women to come out and face the
society bravely, women remain restricted to houses. There is small ratio of the working women in
Pakistan, either they dont prefer to work or they dont have access to the opportunities.
On the other hand there is a serious need to consider why mostly women do not want to work as to
play a vital role in the countrys economic growth and why Pakistans half of the population is
sitting sluggish in the homes.
The major reason behind all is that hardships of working women are multiplied. They are supposed
to work double or sometimes triple to prove themselves as good workers at their workplaces, good
mothers for children and good care taker of homes. Despite of all, usually people dont see them
with honor and make them face even more problems instead.
This chapter describes briefly about religious, cultural & social backgrounds of working women inPakistan. Problems faced by women during their work tenure, like gender biasness, family
restrictions, lack of opportunities etc are also discussed in brief.
This chapter also includes genuine needs of working women at work place.
11
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
12/45
2.2. SATISTICAL REVIEW OF WOMEN WORKFORCE
IN PAKISTAN
Pakistan is a federation of four provinces conjoined with the federal capital area, the Federally
Administered Tribal Areas (FATA), the Federally Administered Northern Areas (FANA), and
Azad Jammu and Kashmir.
2.2.1. Demographic Trends and Developments in Labor Force Participation of
Females
Pakistans female population was estimated at 78 million out of the national population of 161
million in the year 2008 and is gradually increasing with an average annual growth rate of 2.1
percent since 2000 (Table 1 Appendix).
Approximately 45.9 million women in the country were at working age (15 years and above)
compared to 47.2 million men, in 2008. In line with the increases in the female population, the
number of women in working age is constantly growing with the largest increases in rural areas. In
2008, almost two thirds of working age women (29.8 million) was living in rural areas and just
16.1 per cent in urban areas (Table 2 Appendix).
In accordance with a increasing female working population, the female labor force participation
rate increased over time. Yet, it was with 21.8 percent in 2008 still very low if considered from an
international or regional point of view. Globally, 52.6 percent of women in working age were
economically active in 2007.
Furthermore, the regional average labor force participation of women in South Asia was with 35.6
percent, much higher than Pakistans labor force participation rate for women (Table 2 Appendix).
12
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
13/45
2.2.2. Female Employment by Sector
Out of approximately 46 million people that were employed in the country in 2008, just 9 million
were women (19.4 per cent). Still a very small proportion of females worked in industry (12.2 per
cent in 2008 compared to 22.6 of males) and service sectors (13.9 per cent in 2008, as compared to
42.2 of males) (Table 1 Appendix).
Agriculture continues to provide the vast majority of jobs for women: 7 out of 10 women (73.8
percent in 2008) worked in the agricultural sector mainly as contributing family workers under
tough working conditions with little or no economic security. This share has frequently increased
over the last couple of years (from 64.5 percent in 2002 to 73.8 per cent in 2008), refer Table 3
Appendix.
2.2.3. The Widening Wage Gap
Wages comprise a large share of total domestic income in Pakistan. Therefore, wage inequalities
can be held responsible for much of the disparity that exists in wealth, expenditure, healthcare and
other well-being indicators associated with income. Since households with low wages and earning
are often among the poorest households in the country, weakening wages could deteriorate theiralready weak economic situations.
The review of wage data available in the Labor Force Survey shows enormous wage discrepancies
for male and female employees in average real wages. In 2008, women generally earned almost
one third less than their male counterparts. In addition, the wage gap significantly widened since
the beginning of the decade, in particular during the most recent survey years. Between 2007 and
2008, real wages for female employees decreased from 3607 to 3419 Pakistani Rupees in average
per month whereby they increased from 4878 to 4917 Pakistani Rupees for male employees,
during the same period.
13
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
14/45
Wage gap in average real wages of employees (PKR)
2.3. UNEMPLOYMENT AMONG WOMEN IN
PAKISTAN:
In 2008, women in Pakistan had a much higher probability of being unemployed compared to men.
The female unemployment rate stood at 8.7 percent, which was more than double as high as the
male rate of 4.0 per cent. Nevertheless, female unemployment could be halved during the last
decade from 15.8 per cent to 8.7 per cent (Table 1 Appendix).
2.4. LEGAL, SOCIAL & CULTURAL BACKGROUND
OF WOTKING WOMEN IN PAKISTAN:
The social and cultural context of Pakistani society is predominantly patriarchal. Men and women
are conceptually divided into two separate worlds. Home is defined as a womans legitimate
ideological and physical space, while a man dominates the world outside the home.
14
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
15/45
Pakistani family life is based on the traditional roles and values of family members. The husband is
the breadwinner, major decision maker and head of the family. The wifes role is to bring up
children, take care of the household and to provide emotional nurturance to her husband. If any
family member fails to behave properly as demanded by the tradition, that person brings
disharmony and shame to the family.
Pakistani women rarely leave their home towns on their own to look for employment: they usually
move as a part of their fathers, brothers, or husbands families.
In recent years opportunities for women to attend school have increased, and as a result women
have gained higher standards in self esteem, personal goals and ideals, but most of the women
must still bury their expectations, sacrificing the opportunity to be the individuals they had set out
to be, especially after marriage.
2.4.1. Women Empowerment in Pakistan:
The position Pakistani women have achieved was not granted to them voluntarily or out of any
kindness. Pakistani women struggled hard for the rights to education and freedom of work and
earning. They went through painful experiences, sacrificing many natural rights. They have come a
long way, but they have not yet won: they still have a long way to go and must continue to struggle
in order to achieve the status they deserve.
2.4.2. Role of Women in Freedom Movement:
The Islamic Republic of Pakistan came into existence in 1947. Many Muslim women actively
contributed in this freedom fight and worked side by side with men, creating new openings for
themselves as well as for other women. They discovered and participated in new fields of
education and work, thus stirring new hopes and ideas to women of the newly-formed Pakistan.
15
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
16/45
2.4.3. Legal Status:
New rights were given to women in the inclusion of the family law ordinance in Pakistans
Constitution in 1973. Article 27 of the Fundamental Rights stated that:
There should be no discrimination on the basis of race, religion, caste or sex for appointment inthe services of Pakistan.
This gave positive support to women to enter and take part in different fields of education and
work.
2.4.4. Suppression Based on Religious Issues:
Because of misconceptions the Muslim women of Pakistan have suffered a great deal of
unnecessary restriction. Most are required to stay within the confines of their homes and forbiddento come in contact with any male outside their family.
In 1977 (when martial law was imposed in Pakistan) the countrys women, Muslim and otherwise,
faced complete social regression. The chief martial law administrator General Zia-ul-Haq
announced that Islam would be imposed in the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, stressing the isolation
for women. In the name of Islam new laws and policies were designed and the legitimate family
law ordinance was suspended.
The extremist Muslim priests, who were themselves ignorant of Islamic laws which condemn
discrimination against women, persuaded people to think that modesty for women means they
should be veiled from head to foot in public or better yet, stay home. In order to practice this law,
barriers were instituted to discourage and prevent womens education, employment and
professional careers, even their taking part in activities outside their homes (particularly those
activities which involved competing with men).
Women were mostly assigned subordinate roles in the civil, political and managerial hierarchies. In
1988, when the martial law period ended, the anti-Islamic ways preached by the extremist Muslim
clerics during Martial Law remained, few people changed their minds.
16
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
17/45
However, as democracy took hold, so did gradual changes which encouraged women to enter new
fields of education as well as professional careers. Today there are an increasing number of women
in traditional as well as non-traditional services and professions.
2.4.5. Cultural & Social Standing of Women:
For Pakistani women, their domestic, parental, and conjugal roles have the highest priority,
whereas the professional and society roles are secondary. A married womans primary role is to
maintain her marriage, she is held responsible for its quality, whether it is considered successful.
As a wife and mother she is expected to be selfless, ever-nurturing and unflagging.
A Pakistani woman is usually perceived as existing as a member of a kin group rather than as an
individual: a typical Pakistani woman grows up in a sheltered environment, with most decisions
affecting her life made for her by others. She learns moral and social codes of behavior early in
life. After certain age, usually during or after high school, fathers become responsible for their
sons, whereas mothers are responsible for their daughters upbringing and training.
Mothers teach their daughters household chores and have high expectations from them in terms of
domestic responsibilities and child care. Older daughters are given the responsibilities of raising
their younger brothers and sisters as if they are their own sons and daughters, and if money is
scarce then the son and the daughter are also sent to work outside the home to provide additional
income as well as taking care of their younger siblings. A married woman faces the same
responsibilities, earning money if required and taking care of her children.
But all these women are subject to the same degrading and discriminatory laws, customs and
prejudices against women prevailing in the country. Due to the male breadwinner ideology,
women are persistently undervalued as wage earners, their abilities to conduct themselves in aprofessional capacity and make decisions for themselves regularly under-appreciated. The ability
to earn income has helped some women increase their independence and maintain self esteem, but
if her familys economic condition requires her to work, then she has to work double days,
performing multiple roles.
17
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
18/45
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
19/45
2.5.3. Maternal Wall:
The strongest and most explicit bias in todays workplace is against mothers. Generally, maternal
wall bias is triggered when motherhood becomes obvious to managers and colleagues. This
typically occurs when a woman announces that she is pregnant, returns from maternity leave, or
adopts a part-time or flexible schedule.
Maternal wall bias stems from assumptions that mothers are not as competent as others, not as
committed to their jobs and fit in at home because they cannot be both good mothers and good
workers simultaneously. Fathers may run up against a comparable set of assumptions when they
take an active role in caring for their families.
2.5.4. More Evidences of Skills:
The truth of the common saying women must try twice as hard to achieve half as much is
documented by more than a quarter century of social science. Women need to provide more
evidence of job-related skills than their male counterparts before they are viewed as competent.
Additionally, women are allowed fewer mistakes than men before they are judged incompetent.
2.5.5. Behavior Curbs/Unspoken Norms:
Behavior that is acceptable in men often is considered unacceptable in women. A woman in a
traditionally masculine job may be called a witch, hard to work with or too ambitious for the
same behavior that helps a man establish himself as assertive and having leadership potential.
The unspoken view in such situations is that women should be helpful, warm, understanding, and
kind. In some workplaces, women are seen either as likable, dependent traditional women who
are nice but incompetent or as dominant, nontraditional women who are competent, but are
disliked for violating unspoken norms that women should be inclusive and nurturing.
2.5.6. Hidden Biasness:
19
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
20/45
Most gender bias is understated rather than explicit like policies and procedures that appear to be a
facially neutral but objective to may be applied in ways that lead to fewer hiring and promotion
opportunities, lower compensation, poor performance evaluations, more frequent disciplinary
actions, and greater termination rates among women. These patterns result when managers base
their employment decisions on biases rather than job performance.
20
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
21/45
2.6. WORKING WOMEN NEEDS AT WORK PLACE
As societies become more advanced technologically, women depend increasingly on their
individual talent and inventiveness for their progress and development. While inflation is
compelling women to join the work force, its the unfavorable social and work place conditions
that handicap them at many instances.
Although the number of female students graduating from Pakistani universities keeps increasing9
each year but due to adverse social conditions they are hesitant in working outside of the home.
As conventional gender roles dictate that females perform all chores related to household and
dependent care without any help from the male family members, but women have to undertake
paid employment at the peril of carrying triple burden of professional, domestic and reproductive
work. The dual roles of the working women can lead to additional stress in their lives.
Conflict arising out of performance of divergent roles can affect a workers mental and physical
health limiting her ability to perform her duties efficiently especially when her work environment
is not supportive of her needs.
With this context, working women needs can be identified quite differently and somewhat more
than men doing the same work.
2.6.1. Practical Needs of Female Employees:
In this report work place needs for women are figured out on the basis of problems that a working
woman faced while performing job tasks. Most important of these are mentioned below:
Transport Facility
Baby care facilities & Facilitation in balancing work with family responsibilities
Remedial measures for resolving specific female problems
Protection from sexual harassment at the workplace
Better maternity leave benefits
21
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
22/45
Shorter/Flexible working hours & less stressful work
2.6.1.1. Transport Facility:
When a female gets into the job, transport is the first need that should be addresses immediately.
Especially females from middle and lower class who cannot afford personal cars to reach theirwork place and get back to home late in evening.
Public transport in this regard is not considered as reliable. As there are too many barriers and
issues to women using public transport. This includes cost, expediency, and most considerably,
terror of physical abuse, predominantly at night.
It must also be recognize that many women must walk through, or wait in, unsafe areas in order to
access public transit. Moreover, at odd times of day and in isolated places, public transit may be
unreliable.
Despite all women who has none other option except using public transport have to face mental
torture twice a day. They have to face physical & mental harassment, run for a seat in the bus or
van, in the rush often get pushed and bumped, and more often do not get a seat and left standing at
the bus stop waiting for the next bus or van.
Mirrors are a must in every public van. It is extremely annoying for women to have a driver staring
at them all the time through the mirrors fixed at places convenient to him in different sections of a
bus. The traffic police are heedless to women's complaints against a bus or van driver, a conductor
or even the general public.
A safe transport provided by employer can reduce an immense stress from female employees in
terms of getting into work place without any fears of harassment and all physical & mental
tortures.
Yet generally transport facility is not provided by the companies especially for female employees
having low salaries.
22
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
23/45
2.6.1.2.Day Care & Facilitation in Balancing Work with Family Responsibilities:
In particular working women who are married and those who have young children are at risk of
facing job-burnout and employment disruptions. Most of the time, these working women returning
to work are increasingly becoming less efficient and reliable. They are unable to find adequatechildcare or any responsible person to take care of their children during their working hours,
causing lowered productivity at work. Their job satisfaction is also affected. Some mothers
consistently arrive at work late and leave early in order to drop-off and pick-up their children at
day-cares or to any relative. Arriving and leaving work at irregular hours poses a threat to their job
security and lowers possibilities for promotions and bonuses.
Among such women perceptions of family-friendly organizational environment and Day Care
facility can lower absenteeism, reduce intention to turnover, increase job satisfaction, improve
affective commitment and enhance job involvement.
While if current scenario is taken mostly females workers are not provided with day care facilities
and feasible environment at a work place that immensely impacts their performance. Instead they
have to work as tough as male employees or even more as they have to do their work well before
time to get back to home on time.
2.6.1.3.Remedial Measures for Resolving Specific Female Problems:
There should be trained medical staff such as a nurse to first aid female workers in case of
emergencies.
Currently medical facilities provided are not sufficient and usually factories are having male
nurses/doctors to whom female workers hesitate to consult.
2.6.1.4.Protection from Sexual Harassment at Workplace:Sexual harassment is a form of discrimination as well it happens when one employee makes
continued, unwelcome sexual advances, requests for sexual favors, and other verbal or physical
conduct of a sexual nature, to another employee, against his or her wishes.
23
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
24/45
Incidents of sexual harassment at work place are most often committed by people in authority who
are perceived to have the power to influence womens job security in the institution.
Female workers are usually reluctant to share such issues with anyone as they fear that their
families will get to know about it, their morality will be questioned, if the girl is unmarried then it
will be difficult to get her married. Generally when women, after all hurdles, take step to complaint
against sexual harassment, face victimization in the workplace. Such women are disrupted through
different tactics by other colleagues.
There is strong need to protect female worker from sexual harassment and convince them to break
the silence without any fears.
Government needs to explicitly identify the procedures and practices to solve the issue of sexual
harassment for women at work. There is a dire need for a legal framework to check the practice
and ensure a safe working environment for half of the countrys population.
An organization also has the responsibility to take each complaint of sexual harassment seriously
and investigate.
2.6.1.5.Maternity/Parental Leave Benefit:
Female workers must be provided with maternity paid leaves. But most of the time females have to
sacrifice from their jobs.
2.6.1.6.Shorter/Flexible Working Hours & Less Stressful Work:
Woman needs to find a comfortable balance between the kitchen and boardroom. The challenge of
balancing the demands and stress of a working life and family requirements is at best tricky. For
women the situation gets even trickier as their responsibilities include having to be homemakers,
wives and professionals all rolled into one, as well.
Therefore female employees should be facilitated with shorter/flexible working hours so they can
have margin to deal with both family and work. But unfortunately this not the case in real world
which is one major problem being faced by working women.
24
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
25/45
2.6.2. Effect of Desirable Work Environment for Female:
Besides positive individual employee outcomes, perceptions of a desirable work environment for
female employees help in gender mainstreaming.
Advantages of gender mainstreaming for an organization include more gender diversity which in
turn improves competitiveness in acquisition of a skilled workforce and increases the
organizations internal capacity and ability to manage change.
Work attitudes of male and female employees are better in gender-balanced work environments
than in environments where gender parity is skewed in either direction.
2.6.3. Outcomes of Exploitative Working Environment for Females:
Inability to deal with gender diversity issues can produce many negative consequences for an
organization such as:
Losing competent female employees and having to sustain high cost to recruit and train their
replacements
Creating a reputation that the organization is not a good place to work;
An organizational climate in which effort digresses away from work performance toward politics
of how to attain justice
Inability of the management to create a good bond with female employees
2.6.4. Recommendations for Women Friendly Work Environment:
One should not assume that all women want to work; it is safe to say that women want to be given
the same freedom as men to choose to work if they want to and if they do choose to work, they
should have the same chance of finding decent jobs than men.
General guidelines for maintaining gender equity should be adapted according to specific needs of
each organization. However, provision of services such as separate toilets for male and female
staff, transport and daycare facilities should be made mandatory.
25
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
26/45
Not only should there be wider broadcasting of information regarding opportunities for career
development of female employees, but the organizations should also actively encourage females to
take up these opportunities by facilitating them.
Gender sensitization training which aims to make workers more understanding and responsive of
womens need
Educated women with should be encouraged to work professionally.
Employers should promote equal treatment of men and women in the workplace in respect of
employment, remuneration, training and promotional opportunities in order to discourage risky
behavior amongst women workers who may be disadvantaged by any form of social exclusion
26
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
27/45
CHAPTER 03: METHODOLOGY
3.1 PURPOSE STATEMENT:
To determine the perception of different working women about what the professional working ladies face
problems at work in Pakistan.
3.2 RESEARCH QUESTIONS:
Do the salaries earned by women are lower as compared to men in the same position?
Do they need flexible work arrangements to successfully manage work and family life?
Are they provided little work-based support for family responsibilities?
Do the strongest and most explicit bias in todays workplace is against mothers, because it is believed that
they cant be both good mothers and good workers?
Do they need to provide more evidence of job related skills than the male counterparts before they are
viewed as competent?
In addition to being employed do they find their selves performing the majority of house hold
responsibilities?
3.3 HYPOTHESES:
The salaries earned by the women are lower as compared to men in the same position.
They need flexible work arrangements to successfully manage work and family life.
They are provided less work based support for family responsibilities.
It is a generic thought that mothers cant be both good mothers and good workers.
They need to provide more evidence of job related skills than the male counterparts before they are
viewed as competent.
The employed women in addition to their jobs perform the majority of house hold responsibilities.
27
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
28/45
3.4 POPULATION:
Population is basically the sum of all the people inhabiting a specified area. It was too difficult for us to
attempt to survey all the members as all of us are working. So we choose a small, but carefully selected
sample that can be used to represent the population as the result reflects the characteristics of the
population on which our report is based on.
Our working places which includes Beaconhouse School System, Simens Pakistan, Al-karam textiles and
Ferguson where chosen as a survey place. The sample population which we targeted was the professional
working women in these working places.
3.5 SAMPLE:
The size of our sample is 40 with 10 from each firm. 10 questioners were distributed to each firm. In this
way we came to know the opinion of the working professional ladies in the age group of 25- 40.
3.6 PROCEDURE AND METHOD:
The research took 3 days to complete. We asked our participants to take out time for us as we explained
our purpose of research and explained them the questioners which they filled. It took an average 5 to 6
minutes to fill up the questionnaire by the participants. After the collection of data from our respective
working places one of our group members compiled the data and results.
3.7 ASSUMPTIONS:
Questions have been answered honestly
The participants are knowledgeable and aware of the research topic.
There were no bias views from the participants.
The questionnaire is valid according to our research.
28
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
29/45
CHAPTER 04: ANALYSISQ1:
The salaries earned by women are lower as compared to men in the same
position.
Q1 Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly
Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores 0 1 3 10 26 4.525
INTERPRETATION:
Average rate of 4.525 indicates it clearly that the most of the working women are in strong
agreement with the statement that their salaries are lower than the men in the same position.Our survey included multi nationals and local industries however the reply is same and
confirms the salary disparity among the men and women
29
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
StronglyDisagree
Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 1
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
30/45
Q2:
Women employees need flexible work arrangements to successfully manage
work and family life.
Q1 Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly
Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores0 1 4 14 21 4.375
INTERPRETATION:
The response to this question is in agreement to the given statement. Our survey included
women professionals however for Pakistani women her family is indeed a priority even if she
is a working women. Our religion and culture both have taught the life time lesson and has
built this quality among the woman that they manage their family life and their work life too.
Flexible working hours enable women to maintain the work life balance.
30
0
5
10
15
20
25
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 2
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
31/45
Q3:
You are provided little work-based support for family responsibilities.
Responses Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly
Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores 0 2 1 12 25 4.50
INTERPRETATION:
It is evident from the average rate of 4.5 that women under go immense pressure for keeping
the balance between their profession and family responsibilities. They have a hard time as
they are not given provided with the support. Due to pressure her family life and professional
life may suffer and result in decreased output or low quality work.
Behavioral Sciences indicate that employees work efficiency can be increased by facilitating
them and accommodating their human requirements and responsibilities.
31
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 3
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
32/45
Q4:
The strongest and most explicit bias in todays workplace is against mothers,
because it is believed that they cant be both good mothers and good workers.
Responses
StronglyDisagre
e
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
StronglyAgree
(5)
AverageRate
Scores 0 1 9 16 14 4.075
INTERPRETATION:
The vote in strong agreement and agreement is evenly distributed. Results in neutral
category may infer that the responses are due to inexperienced situation. Still the average
score mentions that the women face problems against this natural fact that they can be a
mother at the same time they are a working women.
32
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
Strongly
Disagree
Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 4
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
33/45
Q5:
You have to provide more evidence of job related skills than your male
counterparts before you are viewed as competent.
Responses Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores 1 6 5 20 8 3.70
INTERPRETATION:
The average rate shows that more than 50% of women are in agreement and
authenticate the problem that they have to justify their existence in the
organization by providing evidence of skills as compared to the male
colleagues. The responses in disagreement are most likely due to the industryor sector these women work in such as in education sector this may not be the
case.
33
0
5
10
15
20
25
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 5
Responses
0
5
10
15
20
25
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 5
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
34/45
Q6:
In addition to being employed women has to perform the majority of house
hold responsibilities.
Responses
StronglyDisagre
e
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
StronglyAgree
(5)
AverageRate
Scores 4 7 4 14 11 3.525
INTERPRETATION:
The result is not completely in agreement with the stated problem. This indicates towards thefact that in present era a number of working women has trend of keeping maids to perform
their house hold jobs. This also indicate the women empowerment that they are not only
there to perform house hold jobs once they are earning they may afford or contribute to their
family in difernt ways.
34
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 6
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
35/45
Q7:
Family restrictions are the main reason behind females not doing jobs.
Responses Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores 6 9 1 11 13 3.40
INTERPRETATION:
The result shows that the problem stated is not equally applicable to the complete women
working class. Our survey includes professional coming from different type of families and
back grounds. Karachi is a modern city with educated families, which understand the
importance of education and are in agreement with women employment and carrying out
their professions.
35
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 7
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
36/45
Q8:
Females have less job opportunities then equally educated males.
Responses Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores 1 2 0 9 28 4.525
INTERPRETATION:
The result indicates that all the sectors and industries have same situation for women
employment. However education is a sector where women are encouraged and employed but
gain for professional institutes and universities the competition becomes tough and the statedproblem is faced by women.
36
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 8
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
37/45
Q9:
Females do not prefer to work because of work place environment.
Responses Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores 5 9 1 14 11 3.425
INTERPRETATION:
The result may be interpreted that the work place environment is not only the issue for
women not working. Votes in agreement and strong are still on the higher side. Our
population is from one of the biggest city of Pakistan where we have various multi nationals
working. Good Work place environment is one of the focus of organization and this
decreases the stated problem. However still there is a large number of organizations where
the stated problem is encountered by female employees.
37
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 9
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
38/45
Q10:
Our society accepts and respects working women
Responses Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly Agree
(5)
Average
Rate
Scores 10 12 1 11 6 2.775
INTERPRETATION:
We belong to the culture where working women were not accepted in history. Over the
period of time the acceptance level has improved but the results still indicates that the
women worker still undergo this problem and mental pressure that she is not accepted and
respected for her efforts.
38
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
StronglyDisagree
Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree
QUESTION 10
Responses
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
39/45
APPENDIX
QUESTIONAIRE RESULTS IN TABULAR FORM
Question
Number
Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly
Agree
(5)
Total
Average
10 1 3 10 26 4.525
20 1 4 14 21 4.375
30 2 1 12 25 4.5
40 1 9 16 14 4.075
5
1 6 5 20 8 3.7
64 7 4 14 11 3.525
76 9 1 11 13 3.4
81 2 0 9 28 4.525
95 9 1 14 11 3.425
10 10 12 1 11 6 2.775
39
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
40/45
QUESTIONAIRE
QUESTIONAIRE
Name:
Age:
Years of Professional Work Experience:
Industry:
Strongly
Disagree
(1)
Disagree
(2)
Neutral
(3)
Agree
(4)
Strongly
Agree
(5)
Total
Average
1The salaries earned by women arelower as compared to men in the same
position.
2
Women employees need flexible work
arrangements to successfully managework and family life.
3You are provided little work-basedsupport for family responsibilities.
4
The strongest and most explicit bias in
todays workplace is against mothers,because it is believed that they cant be
both good mothers and good workers.
5
You have to provide more evidence of
job related skills than your malecounterparts before you are viewed as
competent.
6
In addition to being employed women
has to perform the majority of house
hold responsibilities.
7Family restrictions are the main reason
behind females not doing jobs.
8Females have less job opportunities thenequally educated males.
9Females do not prefer to work because
of work place environment.
10
Our society accepts and respects
working women
40
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
41/45
Table 1: Population Distribution & Growth Rate as
Estimated in 2008:
Source: FBS, various years, Pakistan labour force survey.
41
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
42/45
Table 2: Labor Force Participation Rate (%) 2008:
Source: FBS, various years, Pakistan labor force survey.
42
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
43/45
Table 3: Employment % by Sector:
43
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
44/45
Table 4: Gender inequalities in various indicators in a
sample of countries (Male as percent of Female)
Source: World Bank, Social indicators
44
-
8/2/2019 Final Report Group 2 (MEX Section a)
45/45
REFERANCES
http://www.businessknowhow.com/growth/womenchal.htm
http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ASearch&search=working+women+problems
http://cws.emu.edu.tr/en/conferences/2nd_int/pdf/Iffat%20Hussain.pdf
http://www.policyproject.com/pubs/countryreports/ARH_Pakistan.pdf
http://www.c-s-p.org/flyers/9781847189165-sample.pdf
http://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/victorians/womens_work_01.shtml
http://blogs.payscale.com/content/2008/09/working-girl-a.html
http://www.bos.frb.org/economic/nerr/rr2005/q1/section3e.pdf
http://www.adb.org/Documents/Books/Country_Briefing_Papers/Women_in_Pakistan/chap01.pdf
http://www.lmis.gov.pk/publications/PETFW.pdf
http://www.finance.gov.pk/survey/chapter_10/16_Population.pdf
http://pu.edu.pk/images/journal/pesr/PDF-FILES/8%20FARIDA%20Perceptions%20of%20Work
%20Environment.pdf
http://www.businessknowhow.com/growth/womenchal.htmhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ASearch&search=working+women+problemshttp://cws.emu.edu.tr/en/conferences/2nd_int/pdf/Iffat%20Hussain.pdfhttp://www.policyproject.com/pubs/countryreports/ARH_Pakistan.pdfhttp://www.c-s-p.org/flyers/9781847189165-sample.pdfhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/victorians/womens_work_01.shtmlhttp://blogs.payscale.com/content/2008/09/working-girl-a.htmlhttp://www.bos.frb.org/economic/nerr/rr2005/q1/section3e.pdfhttp://www.adb.org/Documents/Books/Country_Briefing_Papers/Women_in_Pakistan/chap01.pdfhttp://www.lmis.gov.pk/publications/PETFW.pdfhttp://www.finance.gov.pk/survey/chapter_10/16_Population.pdfhttp://pu.edu.pk/images/journal/pesr/PDF-FILES/8%20FARIDA%20Perceptions%20of%20Work%20Environment.pdfhttp://pu.edu.pk/images/journal/pesr/PDF-FILES/8%20FARIDA%20Perceptions%20of%20Work%20Environment.pdfhttp://www.businessknowhow.com/growth/womenchal.htmhttp://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Special%3ASearch&search=working+women+problemshttp://cws.emu.edu.tr/en/conferences/2nd_int/pdf/Iffat%20Hussain.pdfhttp://www.policyproject.com/pubs/countryreports/ARH_Pakistan.pdfhttp://www.c-s-p.org/flyers/9781847189165-sample.pdfhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/history/british/victorians/womens_work_01.shtmlhttp://blogs.payscale.com/content/2008/09/working-girl-a.htmlhttp://www.bos.frb.org/economic/nerr/rr2005/q1/section3e.pdfhttp://www.adb.org/Documents/Books/Country_Briefing_Papers/Women_in_Pakistan/chap01.pdfhttp://www.lmis.gov.pk/publications/PETFW.pdfhttp://www.finance.gov.pk/survey/chapter_10/16_Population.pdfhttp://pu.edu.pk/images/journal/pesr/PDF-FILES/8%20FARIDA%20Perceptions%20of%20Work%20Environment.pdfhttp://pu.edu.pk/images/journal/pesr/PDF-FILES/8%20FARIDA%20Perceptions%20of%20Work%20Environment.pdf