finding common ground: operationalizing …...finding common ground: operationalizing conservation...

46
Orangutan Summit Houston Zoo October 2014 Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment.

Upload: others

Post on 23-Mar-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Orangutan Summit

Houston Zoo

October 2014

Finding common ground:

Operationalizing conservation in an oil

palm environment.

Page 2: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

“The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO. As of today, we are going to be sustainable”

THE END

Page 3: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

…and we are working with Farmers

Page 4: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

First Step:

Engaging the

Managers

Page 5: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Society

Economy Environment

Society

Sustainable Development

Environment

Society

Economy

“Sustainability” – Understanding the concept

This objective is NOT to find a win-win solution / it is to produce sustainable palm oil (whatever that takes) --- and maybe that results in win-win

situations too.

Page 6: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Society

Environment

This is the sustainability concept

Sustainable

Palm oil

production

Palm oil

production

Page 7: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Embracing the responsibility

Sustainable Palm Oil

Agriculture

Community

Environment

Page 8: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Understanding the responsibility

This means;

Society

Environment

Palm oil

production

EQUAL attention!!!

Page 9: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Palm oil

production

Society

Environment

Equal attention is NOT necessarily equal resources

Page 10: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Optimization and Intensification: BMP

Page 11: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Rainfall Variable

Topography Constant

Vegetation Variable

Land-use

ChangeVariable

Hydrology Constant

Fertilizer

ApplicationVariable

Harvest of

FFB - YieldVariable

Optimization and Intensification

Page 12: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Flora and Faunal Surveys: Baseline and Detailed

Identification, preservation and management of conservation areas.

Rehabilitation of suitable degraded areas

Advice on Integrating BioD into Estate Operations and Best Management Practices

Page 13: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 14: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

What’s an HCV?

The HCV areas are defined as follows:

HCV1: areas containing globally, regionally or nationally significant concentrations of biodiversity values (e.g., endemism, endangered species)

HCV2: areas containing globally, regionally or nationally significant large landscape natural habitats, contained within, or containing, the management unit, where viable populations of most if not all naturally occurring species exist in natural patterns of distribution and abundance.

HCV3: areas that are in or contain rare, threatened or endangered ecosystems.

HCV4: areas that provide basic services of nature in critical situations (e.g., watershed protection, erosion control).

HCV5: areas fundamental to meeting basic needs of local communities (e.g., subsistence, health).

HCV6: areas critical to local communities’ traditional cultural identity (areas of cultural, ecological, economic or religious significance identified in co-operation with such local communities).

:

Page 15: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 16: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 17: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 18: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Orangutan = 0 Sunbear = 0

False Gharial = 0 Gibbon = 0

Conservation Biologists = 2

Bule = 1

Let’s go fishing….

Page 19: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

47 Species of Fish

9 Endemic to Central Borneo

1 undescribed (new species?)

Page 20: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 21: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Camera Traps

Mist Nets (Understory Birds)

Standard Ecological Surveys compared to

“HCV Assessment”

Animal Species *Until May 2014

NO Species Common Name

IUCN

INDONESIAN LAW Endemic?

PP NO. 7 TAHUN 1999

265 Species 6 ~ 27

Page 22: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

RSPO compared to ISPO

HCV’s not recognized under ISPO

Indonesian Regulations:

Ijin Lokasi (Concession)

IUP (Plantation Permit)

Hak Guna Usaha --- HGU

No HGU for Conservation Areas!

Now what?

Alternative: Hak Guna /Hak Pakai (Special Permit based on Management Plan)

Page 23: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 24: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

“Monitoring and Managing Conservation Areas”

Page 25: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

SCB ASIA Conference

MELACCA, 2014

Biodiversity Division

UNITED PLANTATIONS BHD/PT. SURYA SAWIT SEJATI

Central Kalimantan

Page 26: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Ultimate IPM ?

RSPO ?

Page 27: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Rats are considered one of the most serious pests in oil palm estates.

Rats cause damage to fruit bunches resulting in significant economic loss.

Page 28: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Use baits/poison to keep rat populations low

Barn owls (Tyto alba) as biological pest control

Barn owls not native to Borneo…. and not very common

Page 29: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Leopard cat (Prionailurus bengalensis) are common in many palm oil estate

Very little is known about leopard cats as rat predators in oil palm plantations

Page 30: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Methodology

Trap 10 leopard cats in purpose-made cage-traps

Fit them with VHF radio-transmitters

Deploy 20 camera traps in a 2000m x2500m trapping grid

Estimate rat population cat study sites using 100 small mammals traps. Use Capture-Mark-Recapture

Page 31: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

Leopard Cat

DomesticCat

Activity pattern of leopard cat and domestic cat

in an oil palm landscape

(Silmi, et al 2013)

Page 32: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Code: LC B

Caught: July 16, 2014.

Code: LC A

Caught: July 02, 2014 .

Page 33: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Home Range (Ha)

ID Species

Sex 95 % MCP

LC A M 61.77

LC B M 23.35

Movement LC A

Day 1 (m) Day 2 (m)

Daily Movemen

t

2018.63 923.26

Page 34: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Shrub Species Compositions

No. Species Habit

1 Ageratum conyzoides Herb

2 Eupatorium odoratum shrubs

3 Ficus aurata shrubs

4 Lycopodium sp. Fern

5 Lygodium microphyllum Liana

6 Melastoma malabathricum shrubs

7 Mikania sp. Liana

8 Mucuna sp. Liana

9 Nephrolepis sp. Fern

10 Pseuderanthemum polyanthum Herb

11 Sida acuta shrubs

12 Stenochlaena sp Fern

13 Uncaria sp. Liana

Page 35: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 36: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 37: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Comprehensive understanding of habitat use and dispersal of leopard cat in the oil palm landscape.

Alternative native species for Integrated Pest Management.

Page 38: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO
Page 39: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

IMPLEMENTATION OF SMART SOFTWARE FOR PATROLING CONSERVATION AREA IN PT SSS

1. Login

2. Map of conservation area

1

Page 40: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

3. Employee List

4. Agency and Rank List

2

Page 41: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

5. Patrol 5a. Patrol type and transportation list

5b. Patrol Mandates list

3

Page 42: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

5c. Patrol Teams List

5d. Patrol Stations List

4

Page 43: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

6. Creating and selecting member for new patrol plan

5

Page 44: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

8. Data Input

8a. Updating Track from GPS

7

Page 45: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

16 Apr 2013 15.01

PATROL REPORT APRIL 2013

1

Patrol ID Type Patrol

Start Date

Patrol

End Date

Station Team Objective Mandate Armed Patrol

Leg ID

Leader Patrol

Transport BIOD_000 Ground 11 Apr

2013

30 Apr

2013

Patrol Station Runtu Estate

Runtu

Team

Patrol for Illegal Logging

Logging

Control

false 1 Mislan Mislan [19740001

Motorbike

BIOD_000 Ground 13 Apr

2013

13 Apr

2013

BIOD HQ Lada

Team

Patrol to check the condition HCV area in Lada Estate April 2013

Law

Enforceme

false 1 Sakti Anggara Bayu Murti [19850001

Truck

BIOD_000 Ground 16 Apr

2013

30 Apr

2013

BIOD HQ Water Quality Team

To check water quality and sampling

Water

Sampling

false 1 Sakti Anggara Bayu Murti [19850001

Truck

BIOD_000 Ground 16 Apr

2013

16 Apr

2013

BIOD HQ Lada

Team

To patrol HCV area in Lada Estate

Law

Enforceme

false 1 Muhamma Silmi [19820001

Truck

Page 46: Finding common ground: Operationalizing …...Finding common ground: Operationalizing conservation in an oil palm environment. “The Executive Committee has subscribed to the RSPO

Bjorn Dahlen [email protected] Green Harvest Environmental www.greenharvestconsulting.com Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, Malaysia