List of cases filed on grant of MACP on Promotional Hierarchy

GRANT OF MACP ON PROMOTIONAL HIERARCHY:

LIST OF CASES FILED

The list of cases filed on the subject is given below for your reference.

S

L

O.A.No.,

CWP.No. SLP

Civil (CC) No

PartiesDate of

Order

Name of

courtRemarks

RAJPAL Vs UoI & Others

1

OA

No.1038/CH/20

10 (Advocate :

Mr. V.K.Verma)

Raj Pal s/o Tilak

Ram, CAT,

Chandigarh

31.5.2011CAT,

Chandigarh.

OA is allowed for

grant of MACP in

the hierarchy of

Promotional post.

2 CWP No.19387

of (O&M)

(Advocate :

D.K.Bhisnoi)

Union of India

represented by

DoP&T and

others Vs. Raj

19.10.201

1

High Court of

Punjab and

Haryana at 

Chandigarh

Order dated 31-5-

2011 of Hon’ble

CAT, Chandigarh

is upheld. CWP

Pal and another.

filed by

Respondents

dismissed.

3

SLP No.cc-

7467 of 2013

against order

dated 19-10-

2011 of the

Hon’ble High

Court

Union of India

represented by

DoP&T and

others Vs. Raj

Pal and another.

15.4.2013Supreme

Court of India

SLP filed by the

Union of India is

dismissed

SANJAY KUMAR & Ors Vs UoI & Ors

4

OA

No.904/2012

(Mr.

M.K.Bhardwaj)

Sanjay Kumar,

UDC and 18

others Vs. UOI

nted byMinistry

of Defense and

others.

26.11.201

2

CAT,

Principal

Bench, New

Delhi.

OA is allowed for

grant of MACP in

next promotional

post i.e. Assistant

in PB-2+Grade

PayRs.4200.

5 W.P.(C)

4552/2013

UNION OF

INDIA Vs.

Delhi High Hearing Date

Court No. 5 Next

[PENDING]

(Mr. M.K.

Bhardwaj)

SANJAY

KUMAR & ORS.Court Date: 04/09/2014

M V Mahanan Nair Vs UoI & Ors

6 OA No.816/12

M.V.Mohanan

Nair, S/o

M.R.Vishwanath

an Nair,

Photocopier

CAT, Ernakulam

Bench & others

Vs Union of

India

29.1.2013

CAT,

PrincipalBenc

h Ernakulam

Bench

OA is allowed for

consideration of

MACP in the

hierarchy of

promotional post.

7

OP(CAT).

NO.2000 OF

2013 (Z)

UOI & 

ORS. .Vs. M.V. 

MOHANAN

NAIR

24.06.201

3

High court of

Kerala at

Ernakulam

In the result, this

original petition is

dismissed in

limine

8 Special Leave

Petition (Civil)

UOI &

ORS. .Vs. M.V.

Supreme PENDING

21803 OF 2014MOHANAN

NAIRCourt of India

9

OA No.1798 of

2014

Advocate : Shri

Yogesh

Sharma

Mahendra

Kumar Dubey,

S/o Sh. R.D.

Dubey, Working

as Programme

Executive, In

Doordarsan

Kendra, Delhi

VS UOI through

the Secretary,

Ministry of

lnformation &

Broadcastin

22.05.201

4Cat Delhi

OA is allowed for

consideration of

MACP in the

hierarchy of

promotional post

within a period of

one month

KISHAN SWARUP SHARMA Vs SECRETARY, MINISTRY OF

AGRICULTURE

10OA

No.2548/2014

Kishan Swarup

Sharma,

31.07.201CAT, New OA is allowed For

consider the case

MA

No.2167/2014

(Advocate :

Shri

M.K.Bhardwaj

working as

PPO(E), Meerut

& 28 others V/S

Secretary,

Ministry of

Agriculture,

4 Delhi

of the applicants in

the light of the

aforesaid orders

PRADEEP KUMAR Vs SECRETARY MIN. OF INFORMATION &

BROADCASTING

11OA No.988 of

2014 MA

No.872 of 2014

(Advocate :

Shri M.K.

Bhardwaj

Pradeep Kumar.

AE (C) Rohini,

Delhi & 20

others VS

Secretary,

Ministry of

Information &

Broadcasting,

Shastri Bhawan.

New Delhi

22.03.201

4

CAT. New

Delhi

in view of the

above position. we

dispose of this OA

at the admission

stage itself with

the direction to the

respondents to

consider the

representations of

the applicants in

the light of the

judgment of

Punjab and

Haryana High

Court in CWP

No.19387/2011

(supra) as upheld

by the Apex Court

in SLP (CC)

No.7467/2013(sup

ra) and decide

their cases under

intimation to them.

The aforesaid

exercise shall be

completed within a

period of one

month from the

date of receipt of a

copy of this order.

There shall be no

order as to costs.

12O.A. No.

1834/2014

Advocate: Shri

Yogesh

Sharma.

Mohd Hamid 

Hussain,

Working as

APRO

(Defence),

Sr.Grade Group

B Officer In the

office of: DPR,

Ministry of

Defence New

Delhi- & 34

others VS UOI

through the

Secretary,

Ministry of

Information and

Broadcasting,

23.05.201

4

Central

Administrativ

e Tribunal

PrincipalBenc

h New Delhi

In view of the

aforesaid

submission made

by the applicants

and the

documents

available on

record. we

dispose of this OA

at the admission

stage itself with a

direction to the

respondents to

consider the case

of the applicants in

terms of the

aforesaid orders

within a period of

two months from

the date of receipt

of a copy of this

order. if the

applicants are

similarly placed,

they shall also be

treated alike

OM PRAKASH Vs SECRETARY, NCERT

13OA 864/2014

Advocate: Shri

M.K. Bhardwaj)

Shri Om

Prakash

NCERT, New

Delhi  VS

Secretary

(NCERT)  New

Delhi

12.3.2014Central

Administrativ

e Tribunal

PrincipalBenc

h, New Delhi

In view of the

above position. we

dispose of this OA

at the admission

stage itself with

the direction to the

respondents to

consider the

representations of

the applicants in

the light of the

judgment of

Punjab and

Haryana High

Court in CWP

No.19387/2011

(supra) as upheld

by the Apex Court

in SLP (CC)

No.7467/2013(sup

ra) and decide

their cases under

intimation to them.

The aforesaid

exercise shall be

completed within a

period of one

month from the

date of receipt of a

cop of this order.

14W.P.(C) NCERT,New 14.07.201High court of CWP filed by

3608/2014

Delhi VS Shri

Om Prakash &

others

4Delhi  at New

Delhi

Respondents

dismissed.

BABU RAM VS UoI

15O.A.

1281/CH/2012

ADVOCATE:

SHRI ROHIT

SETH

Sh. Babu Ram,

working as

Upper Division

Clerk, working in

the Central

Administrative

Tribunal,

opposite

Shivalik View

Hotel, Sector

17, Chandigarh

VS UOI

09.05.201

3

CAT

CHNDIGARH

BENCH

  allow this OA in

terms of the view

obtained in terms

of the view

obtained in the

OA.

1038/CH/11and

the judgments

(Annexures A-11

to A-13). The

compliance of the

order must ideally

come about within

two months from

the date a copy of

this order is

presented in the

office of the

competent

authority.

16CWP No.

24279 of 2013

U.O.I. .Vs.

BABU RAM &

ORS.

07.11.201

3

HIGH

COURT OF

PUNJAB &

HARYANA

see order of even

date passed in

CWP No.24278 of

2013 (UOI and

another versus

Smt.Reeta Devi

and another

17

Special Leave

to Petition

(Civil)10435 OF

2014

U.O.I. .Vs.

BABU RAM &

ORS

Supreme

Court of IndiaPending

DHIRENDER SINGH & Ors Vs UoI

18Civil Writ

Petition

U,O.I. .Vs.

DHIRENDER

07.11.201High Court Of

Punjab &

For orders, see

order of even date

No.24253 of

2013 Date of

Decision:

SINGH & ORS. 3Haryana At

Chandigarh

passed in CWP

No.24278 of 2013

(Union of India

and another

versus Smt. Reeta

Devi and another).

19

Special Leave

to Petition(Civil)

…. 10436 OF

2014

U.O.I. .Vs.

DHIRENDER

SINGH & ORS.

Supreme

Court of IndiaPending

20O.A.

12/CH/2013 By

Advocate:

Mr.Madan

Mohan

Smt. Reeta

Devi, Senior

Library

Attendant, CAT

Bench. 

Chandigarh.

Versus Union of

India

22.05.201

3

Cat

Chandigarh

Bench

After going

through the

judgment passed

in the case of Raj

Pal (supra), we

are in full

agreement with

the  learned

counsel for the

parties.

Accordingly, the

present original

application is

allowed in same

term as of Raj Pal

(supra). 

Consequently, we

quash the orders

at Annexures A-1

& A-2. The

respondents are

further directed to

grant the benefit of

2nd MACP in the

pay band of

Rs.9300-34800

with grade pay of

Rs.4600/- from

1.3.2009 (which is

the pay scale of

next post in the

hierarchy).  The

respondents are

directed to comply

with the judgment

within a period of

three months from

the date of receipt

of a copy of this

order.

21CWP No.

24278 of 2013

Union of India

VS Smt. Reeta

Devi, & and

others

07.11.201

4

High Court Of

Punjab

&Haryana

CWP filed by

Respondents

dismissed

22

Special Leave

Petition(Civil)

22181 OF 2014

U.O.I. & ORS.

Vs. REETA

DEVI

Supreme

Court of Indiapending

NARAYAN KALITA Vs UoI

23O.A. No. Narayan Kalita Date of  CAT OA is allowed. for

040/00052/201

4

CPWD

Guwahati VS

UOI

Represented by

Secretary GOI,

Ministry of

Urban and

Develoment

order

25.06.201

4 Date of

Delivery

of Order

7.8.2014

Guwahati

Bench

grant of MACP in

the hierarchy of

Promotional post. 

Respondent is

directed to grant

scale of pay (PB-

3) of Rs. 15600-

39100 + Grade

pay 6600/-

24

OA( 1727/2014

)  was filed by

CPWD

Engineers‘

Association in

regarding

MACP as per

promotional

hierarchy on

19.5.2014

CAT,

Principal

Bench, New

Delhi on

next date of its

hearing has been

fixed by CAT on

24/09/2014

25

case filed by

the Junior

Clerks of 

Railway -OA

No. 1509 of

2013

CAT Kolkata

next date of its

hearing has been

fixed by CAT on

8th Dec. 2014