formate brines - reservoir drilling and well completion fluids since 1993
DESCRIPTION
Formate brines as reservoir drilling and well completion fluids since 1993. Presentation made to OMV in Vienna in September 2014.TRANSCRIPT
FORMATE BRINES DRILL-IN AND COMPLETION FLUIDS SINCE 1993
John Downs
Formate Brine Ltd
www.formatebrine.com
Formate brines
Sodium formate
Potassium formate
Cesium formate
Solubility in water
47 %wt 77 %wt 83 %wt
Density 1.33 g/cm3
11.1 lb/gal1.59 g/cm3
13.2 lb/gal2.30 g/cm3
19.2 lb/gal
Formates are also soluble in some non-aqueous solvents
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 2
LATEST FORMATE SUCCESS – Unconventional shale drilling – Formates cut drilling times in half
Oil companies in Canada are exploiting a discovery from 1996 – formates are VERY fast in shale vs weighted muds
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 3
Potassium formate brines excelling in Canada as solids-free and polymer-free shale drilling fluid
118 shale wells drilled with DMK’s potassium formate drilling fluid since mid-2013 Quote from Encana : “ The fluid is inhibitive, after drilling caliper logs displayed the same response as invert (oil) drilled caliper logs. The ROP improvement has allowed us to cut our lateral drilling time in half! “
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 4
New explanation for shale drilling success with potassium formate – Osmosis
ROP Enhancement in Shales through Osmotic Processes
Eric van Oort, SPE, and Muneeb Ahmad, The University of Texas at Austin, and
Reed Spencer, SPE, Baker Hughes
“It will be shown that the mechanism responsible for the Deeptrek ROP results
with formate mud is chemical osmosis …..”
Potassium formate brine use in unconventional shale drilling may become widespread
Paper to be presented to the 2015 SPE/IADC Drilling conference :
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 5
The traditional use for formate brines is in High-Pressure High-Temperature gas wells
Low-solids heavy fluids for deep HPHT gas well constructions
• Reservoir drill-in
• Completion
• Workover
• Packer fluids
• Well suspension
• Fracking
Used in hundreds of HPHT wells since 1995, including some of
Europe’s deepest, hottest and highly-pressured gas reservoirs
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 6
42 deep HPHT gas fields developed using formate brines , 1995-2011. Now probably > 50 fields *
Country Fields Reservoir Description
Matrix
type
Depth, TVD
(metres)
Permeability
(mD)
Temperature
(oC)
Germany Walsrode,Sohlingen
Voelkersen, Idsingen,
Kalle, Weissenmoor,
Simonswolde
Sandstone 4,450-6,500 0.1-150 150-165
Hungary Mako , Vetyem Sandstone 5,692 - 235
Kazakhstan Kashagan Carbonate 4,595-5,088 - 100
Norway Huldra ,Njord
Kristin,Kvitebjoern
Tune, Valemon
Victoria, Morvin,
Vega, Asgard
Sandstone 4,090-7,380 50-1,000 121-200
Pakistan Miano, Sawan Sandstone 3,400 10-5,000 175
Saudi Arabia
Andar,Shedgum
Uthmaniyah
Hawiyah,Haradh
Tinat, Midrikah
Sandstone
and
carbonate
3,963-4,572 0.1-40 132-154
UK Braemar,Devenick
Dunbar,Elgin
Franklin,Glenelg
Judy, Jura, Kessog
Rhum, Shearwater
West Franklin
Sandstone 4,500-7,353 0.01-1,000 123-207
USA High Island Sandstone 4,833 - 177
* More HPHT fields developed in Kuwait, India and Malaysia during 2012-2013
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 7
Almost every HPHT gas field in northern North Sea in Norway drilled and/or completed in formate brine
More than 400 well construction jobs in Europe with high density formate brines since 1995
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 8
OPERATOR LOCATION Packer Fluid(ppg)
BHT (°C)
BHT (°F)
Start Date
End Date Comments
Devon WC 165 A-7 8.6 KFo 149 300 1/2005
Devon WC 165 A-8 8.6 KFo 149 300 1/2006
DevonWC 575 A-3
ST29.5 KFo 132 270 5/2005
WOG/Devon MO 862 #1 12.0 NaKFo 215 420 4/2005 5/2006Well P&A – H2O production – G-3 in excellent condition
BP/Apache HI A-5 #1 11.5 NaKFo 164 350 2/2002 4/2008Well P&A - Natural depletion – S13Cr in excellent condition
ExxonMobil MO 822 #7 12.0 NaKFo 215 420 2001
EPL ST 42 #1 11.5 NaKFo 133 272 2006
EPL ST 41 #F1 13.0 NaKFo 105 222 2006
EPL EC 109 A-5 11.5 NaKFo 121 250 2006
EPL ST 42 #2 12.8 NaKFo 132 270 2006
DominionWC 72 #3
BP110.0 NaFo 121 250 2006
EPLWC 98 A-3
ST112.7 NaKFo 153 307 2006
EPL WC 98 A-3 10.8 NaKFo 154 310 2007
Formate brines as packer fluids in USA (GOM)
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 9
• 177ºC, 14,000 psi
• S13Cr tubing failed from CaCl2 packer fluid
• Well worked over and re-completed with Cs formate
• 1.4 g/cm3 Na/K formate used as packer fluid
• Tubing retrieved 6 years later
• Tubing was in excellent condition.
BP High Island, Gulf of Mexico – Formate brine used as a packer fluid for 6 years
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 10
The economic benefits provided by formate brines in HPHT gas field developments
Formate brines improve the economics of HPHT gas field developments by :
Reducing well delivery time and costs
Improving operational safety and reducing risk
Delivering production rates that exceed expectations
Providing more precise reservoir definition
Detailed explanation and evidence later in this presentation
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 11
Formate brines used by OMV in Pakistan in 2005-6 for drill-in and completions in HPHT gas wells
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 12
Formate brines used by OMV in Pakistan in 2005-6 for drill-in and completion in HPHT gas wells
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 13
www.formatebrines.com Source of all the latest formate information
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 14
Useful reference material
The Formate Technical Manual - 26 chapters
- > 400 pages
- Available in English, Spanish and Chinese
- Updated and expanded every month
Recent SPE papers
SPE 130376 (2010): “A Review of the Impact of the Use of Formate Brines on the Economics of Deep Gas Field Development Projects”
SPE 145562 (2011): “Life Without Barite: Ten Years of Drilling Deep HPHT Gas Wells With Cesium Formate Brine”
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 15
Another source of formate information The Formate Brines group on LinkedIn – www.linkedin.com
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 16
And another source of formate information....
The Formate Brines newsletter – Issue #9 out this week
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 17
Formate brines – Discovery and qualification by Shell Research
1987 1988 1989 1990 1991 1992
Shell patent the use of formates as
polymer stabilisers
Shell discover cesium formate
brine
Shell R&D in UK study the effect of sodium and potassium formates on the thermal stability of drilling polymers
Shell R&D in The Netherlands carry out qualification work on formate brines as deep slim-hole (HPHT) drilling fluids
Shell publish first SPE papers on formate brines
Start of Shell’s deep slim-hole drilling
R&D programme
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 18
Formate Brines – Properties that make them excellent drilling and completion fluids
•Density up to 2.3 g/cm3 and pH 9-10
• Only monovalent ions (Na+, K+, Cs+, HCOO-)
• Stabilise shales (K, Cs and low water activity)
•Protect polymers at high temperature
•Less corrosive than other brines
•Good lubricity
•Non-toxic and readily biodegradableJohn Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 19
Benefits of formate brines – Compatible with polymers, so can be used as drilling fluids
Component Function Concentration
Formate brine
DensityLubricity
Polymer protectionBiocide
1 bbl
XanthanViscosity
Fluid loss control0.75 – 1 ppb
Lo- Vis PAC and modified starch
Fluid loss control 4 ppb each
Sized calcium carbonate Filter cake agent 10 – 15 ppb
K2CO3/KHCO3
BufferAcid gas corrosion
control2 – 8 ppb
A traditional low-solids formate drilling fluid formulation
This simple formulation has been in field use since 1993 – good to 160o C
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 20
Formate brines launched as low-solids drilling fluids in mid-1990’s
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd
Property Typical values
pH 9 – 10.5
PV [cP] 15 - 20
YP [lb/100ft2] 8 - 15
10” gel 2 - 5
10’ gel 3 - 6
HPHT fluid loss [mL] < 10
API fluid loss < 3
Service company brand names:
Baker Hughes : CLEAR-DRILL (1994)M-I : FLOPRO (1995) Baroid : BRINEDRIL
Filter cake on aloxite disc
21
Benefits of formate brines - they raise the thermal stability ceiling of polymers
150 200 250 300 350 400
Temperature [deg F]
66 116 166
Temperature [deg C]
Starch
PAC
Xanthan
Potassium formate(1.59 sg 13.25 ppg)
Sodium formate(1.32 sg 11.05 ppg)Potassium chloride(1.16 sg 9.66 ppg)
Sodium bromide(1.53 sg 12.75 ppg)
Calcium chloride(1.39 sg 11.58 ppg)
Freshwater
Sodium chloride(1.19 sg 9.91 ppg)
Bar graph showing the temperature at which polymers lose 50% of their viscosity after 16 hours hot rolling
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 22
Benefits of formate brines - ROP enhancement
Low-solids formate brines increase drilling ROP by >100% compared to OBM (in carbonates and shale)
Data from DOE Deep Trek project , see SPE paper 112731
Effect of Mud on Rate of PenetrationCarthage Marble with 7 Blade PDC Bit
0
10
20
30
40
50
0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000 30,000
Weight on Bit (lbf)
Ra
te o
f P
en
etr
ati
on
(ft
/hr)
Water
16ppg OBM
16ppg CsFm
16ppg OBM + Mn
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 23
Benefits of formate brines - ROP enhancement
Zero-solids formate brines can increase drilling ROP by 200-300% vs WBM
Zero-solids potassium formate brines are now breaking records as drilling fluids in the Montney and Duvernay shales in Canada
Data from SPE paper 36425 (1996) John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 24
Benefits of formate brines - ROP enhancement
Ramsey et al found correlation between Fann 600 reading of drilling fluids and ROP in sandstone
Note the effect of the calcium carbonate (solids) concentration on Fann 600 reading and ROP with formate brine
Data from SPE paper 36396 (1996) John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 25
Benefits of formate brines – Zero/low solids gives better hydraulics
•Lower Surge and Swab Pressures- Faster tripping times- Reduced risk of hole instability or well control incidents
•Lower System Pressure Losses-More power to motor
• Lower ECD - Drill in narrower window between pore and fracture pressure gradients- Less chance of fracturing well and causing lost circulation
•Higher Annular Flow Rates- Better hole cleaning
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 26
Benefits of formate brines – Natural lubricity
Potassium Formate - Mild Steel
0.00
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.40
0.50
0.60
0.70
1 1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6
Specific Density
CoF
31 kg side load 21 kg side load 11 kg side load
WBM
OBM
pure water
Steel-steel coefficient of friction in potassium formate brine (BP test)
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 27
Benefits of formate brines – Low methane solubility
•Low methane solubility and diffusion rates - Easier kick detection
- Low rate of static influx
• Mud properties not degraded by gas influx
Solubility of methane in drilling fluids: T = 300°F (149°C), P = 10,000 psi (690 bar)
Fluid Solubility (kg/m3)Diffusion coefficient
(m2/sec x 108)Diffusion flux (kg/m2s x 106)
OBM 164 1.15 53.30
WBM 5 2.92 3.98
Formate brine 1 0.80 0.25
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 28
Finnish Environment Institute recommends the use of potassium formate in sensitive groundwater areas
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 29
Extracts from summary of Finnish Environment Institute report on potassium formate
“In Finland, potassium formate is currently the sole de-icing agent used on nine roads crossing valuable groundwater areas…. For the follow-up study, data on groundwater quality was collected from three of the groundwater areas. No negative impacts were observed on groundwater quality, due to the use of potassium formate, at any of the three areas in question”
“Potassium formate is already widely used in Finnish airports. According to a recently completed follow-up study conducted over several years, formate biodegrades rapidly in the ground, even at low temperatures. This prevents its infiltration into groundwater”
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 30
Extracts from abstracts of Finnish Environment Institute reports on potassium formate Alternative deicing agents and ground water protection. Final report of MIDAS2-
project (published 2010)
This report summarizes….. novel data from a 7-year follow-up study on the ground water quality at three areas (Kauriansalmi, Taavetti, and Jaamankangas aquifers) where potassium formate has been used as a sole de-icing chemical.
On highway 13, running along Kauriansalmi aquifer (Suomenniemi municipality), potassium formate was used as a sole de-icer from 2002 until the end of 2009. During that period, no formate was found in the ground water at the area. The average chloride concentration in the formation has decreased on average by 3,3 % a year since sodium chloride application came to an end in 2002.
At Taavetti municipal water intake, chloride concentration decreased sharply after 2004 when potassium formate was introduced in de-icing at the area.
This study shows that potassium formate can be applied in winter road maintenance in particular at sensitive ground water areas, and at airports to minimize the adverse impacts on ground and surface water resulting from de-icing.
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 31
Formate brines – Production and first field use - Milestones
1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998
First field use of sodium formate: Shell drills and completes first
Draugen oil wells
Start of deep HPHT gas well
drilling with formates in Germany
(Mobil, RWE, Shell)
Sodium formate powder available. Draugen wells each produce 48,000 bbl oil /day
1994 - Potassium formate brine becomes available from Norsk Hydro (now Addcon)
Potassium formate brines used in USA,
Canada, Mexico,
Venezuela, Brazil,
Ecuador
First field use of potassium formate (with Micromax) : Statoil drills and
completes Gullfaks oil well
1997 - Cesium formate brine becomes available from Cabot
First use of formate brine
as packer fluid: Shell Dunlin
A-14
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 32
W-Cluster
15000'
14800'
Z2
Z6
Z5Z7
Z4
5000'
10000'
15000'
18000'
Potassium formate brine has been used to drill deep HPHT gas wells since 1995
First use : ExxonMobil’s Walsrode field, onshore northern Germany - high-angle deep HPHT slim hole low perm gas wells
TVD : 4,450-5,547 metres Reservoir: Sandstone 0.1-125 mDBHST : 157o C Section length: 345-650 mDrilling fluid: SG 1.45-1.55 K formate brine
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 33
Potassium formate from Addcon used in 15 deep
HPHT gas well constructions in Germany ,1995-99
Well Name Application Fluid Type Density s.g. (ppg)Horizontal Length(m)
Angle (°) BHST (°F) BHCT (°F) TVD (metres) MD (metres)Permeability
(mD)
Walsrode Z5 W/C K Formate 1.55 (12.93) 345 26 315 na 4450 - 4632 4815 - 5151 0.1 - 125 mD
Wasrode Z6 W/C K Formate 1.55 (12.93) 420 40 315 na 4450 - 4632 4815 - 5151 0.1 - 125 mD
Walsrode Z7 Drill-In K Formate 1.53 (12.77) 690 59 315 295 4541 - 4777 5136 - 5547 0.1 - 125 mD
Söhlingen Z3A Drill-In Formix 1.38 (11.52) 855 89 300 270 4908 5600 na
Söhlingen Z3a Drill-In Na Formate 1.30 (10.85) 855 89 300 270 4908 5600 na
Volkersen Z3 W/C Formix 1.40 (11.68) 512 52 320 na na na na
Kalle S108 Drill-In Formix 1.45 (12.10) 431 60 220 na 6000-6500 6200-6600 na
Weißenmoor Z1 W/C Formix 1.35 (11.27) 634 31 300 na na na na
Idsingen Z1a Drill-In K Formate 1.55 (12.93) 645 61 321 290 4632 - 4800 5257 - 5821 0.1 - 125 mD
Söhlingen Z12 Drill-InNa
Formate/Formix1.35 (11.27) 452 28 313 285 4736 - 4937 4846 - 5166 1.0 - 75 mD
Simonswolde Z1 Drill-In K Formate/Formix 1.52 (12.68) 567 35 293 275 4267 - 4572 4236 - 4648 0.1 - 25 mD
Walsrode NZ1 Drill-In Formix 1.51 (12.60) 460 34 290 265 4632 - 4815 4541 - 4693 0.1 - 125 mD
Idzingen Z2 W/C Formix 1.40 (11.68) na na 320 na 4632 - 4800 5257 - 5821 0.1 - 125 mD
Voelkersen NZ2 W/C Formix 1.40 (11.680 na na 320 na na na na
Söhlingen Z13 Drill-In/Frac K Formate/Formix 1.30 (-1.56)(10.85) 1200 90 300 285 4724 5486 - 6400 0,1 - 150 mD
Fluids service provided by M-I and Baroid
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 34
Summary of potassium formate brine use in HPHT gas wells in Germany,1995-99
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 35
Addcon’s potassium formate plant in Norway has been supplying the oil industry since 1994
Production Site ADDCON NORDIC AS
Storage tanks for raw materials
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 36
Potassium formate production by Addcon
• The first and largest producer of potassium formate
- Brine production capacity : 800,000 bbl/year
- Non-caking powder capacity: 8,400 MT/year
• Direct production from HCOOH and KOH
• High purity product
• Large stocks on quayside location
• Fast service – by truck, rail and sea
• Supplier to the oil industry since 1994
50 % KOH4,500 m3
6,300 MT
94 % Formic acid5,000 m3
Feedstock storage tanks in Norway
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 37
Addcon’s new potassium formate plant in Bitterfeld, Germany
Only 7 hours drive from Bitterfeld to Vienna area
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 38
Potassium formate brine – Methods of shipment
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 39
Typical potassium brine grades
% w/w Density TCT* SG oC 75 1.57 7
71 1.53 2
63 1.46 -13
* Crystals of potassium formate added to encourage crystallisation
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 40
Formate brines – Some important milestones : 1999-2004
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
First production of non-caking
crystalline K formate by
Addcon
First drilling jobs with
K/Cs formate brine:
Huldra and Devenick HPHT
Formate brines used as packer fluids for HPHT wells in GOM. First well : ExxonMobil’s MO 822#7 (215oC BHST) in 2001
Use of Cs-weighted oil-based completion fluids for oil reservoirs : Visund, Statfjord, Njord, Gullfaks, Snorre , Oseberg, Rimfaks 2001 – present
First use of Cs-weighted LSOBM as perforating completion
fluid (Visund)
First use of K/Cs formate
brine : Completion
job in Shearwater well (Shell
UK)
Cs-weighted LSOBM used as OH screen completion
fluid (Statfjord)
First use of K/Cs
formate brine as
HPHT well suspension
fluid (Elgin)
Individual Draugen oil wells (1993) and Visund oil wells (2003) have similar flow rates of around 50,000 bbl oil/day
First of 14 Kvitebjørn HPHT wells drilled and completed with K/Cs formate brines
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 41
Cesium formate produced by Cabot in Canada from pollucite ore
Pollucite ore
Cs0.7Na0.2Rb0.04Al0.9Si2.1O6·(H20)
• Mined at Bernic Lake, Manitoba
• Processed on site to Cs formate brine
• Cs formate brine production 700 bbl/month
• Cs formate stock built up to 30,000 bbl
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 42
The first sustained use of K/Cs formate brine was in the
world’s largest HPHT gas field development
190oC1100bar
5300m
Water Depth 90m
SIWHPFWHT
830bar180oC
::
GASCONDENSATE
3-4% C0230-40 ppm H2S
320barDEWPOINT
30% O1 Darcy K
Cesium formate brine used by TOTAL in 34 well construction operations in 8 deep gas fields in period 1999-2010
Elgin/Franklin field – UK North Sea
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 43
Formate brines – Some published milestones 2005 -2010
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
OMV Pakistan
start using K formate to drill and
complete (with ESS) in
HPHT gas wells
K/Cs formate brines used as well perforating fluids in 11 HPHT gas fields in UK North Sea : Dunbar, Shearwater, Elgin, Devenick , Braemar , Rhum, Judy , Glenelg , Kessog , Jura and West Franklin1999-2011
Saudi Aramco start using K
formate to drill and complete (with ESS) in
HPHT gas wells
Gravel pack with K
formate brine in
Statfjord B
First MPD operation in Kvitebjørn with K/Cs formate
“designer fluid”
First of 12 completions
in the Kashagan field with
K/Cs formate
Total’s West Franklin F9 well (204oC) perforated in K/Cs formate
brine
Petrobras use K
formate brine for
open hole gravel packs
in Manati field
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 44
Saudi Aramco have been drilling HPHT gas wells with potassium formate brine since 2003
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 45
Saudi Aramco use of formate brines, 2003-2009
• 7 deep gas fields
• 44 HPHT wells drilled
• 70,000 ft of reservoir drilled at high angle
• 90,000 bbl of brine recovered and re-used
• Good synergy with ESS, also OHMS fracturing
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 46
Summary from Aramco’s OTC paper 19801
Aramco consume around 300 m3/month of K formate brine
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 47
SPE 132151 (2010) “Successful HPHT Application of Potassium Formate/Manganese Tetra-Oxide Fluid Helps Improve Drilling Characteristics and Imaging Log Quality”
SPE/IADC 147983 (2011) “Utilization of Non-damaging Drilling Fluid Composed of Potassium Formate Brine and Manganese Tetra Oxide to Drill Sandstone Formation in Tight Gas Reservoir
SPE 163301 (2012) “Paradigm Shift in Reducing Formation Damage: Application of Potassium Formate Water Based Mud in Deep HPHT Exploratory Well”
Potassium formate brine weighted with Micromax® in Kuwait and Saudi Arabia
Good results in first 9 HPHT wells – could become the standard HPHT fluid for KOC
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 48
Potassium formate brine weighted with Micromax for drilling deep HPHT fractured carbonate wells 10,000 psi, 140oC, H2S = 4-12%, CO2 = 1-6%
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 49
Potassium formate brine weighted with Micromax for drilling deep HPHT fractured carbonate wells “The results were extraordinary when compared to wells
drilled with ..OBM” – Production rates x 3 higher
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 50
Pakistan - OMV use potassium formate brine for HPHT deep gas well drilling and completions
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 51
Extracts from OMV’s SPE papers and SPE presentations – note 1,700 psi overbalance, and 350oF
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 52
OMV drills and completes using ESS in potassium formate brine – Pakistan, 2006/7
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 53
Norway, 2002 - Perforating in solids-free oil-based kill pill weighted with formate brine
•Visund field - BHST: 118o C
- Fluid density: SG 1.65
- 13 wells – 1000- 2000 metre horizontal sections
- Drilled with OBM ,completed with perforated liners
•Justification for use: - First 3 wells badly damaged by CaBr2 kill pill
- PI only 60-90 m3/bar/day
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 54
Perforating Visund wells in solids-free oil-based kill pill weighted with formate brine
•Visund – Change to formate kill
pill (see SPE 73709, 58758 and 84910)- Next 3 wells perforated in formate fluid -Also used new perforating guns, in dynamic
underbalance
•Results : - Eliminated formation damage problem - PI increased up to 900 m3/bar/day - 300-600% PI improvement - Best well : 53,000 bbl/day
Visund well productivity
60 70 50
220
620
900
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
1000
Well
m3
oil
/ba
r/d
ay
Formate brine
Bromide brine
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 55
Formate brines used as HPHT cased well completion fluids after drilling with OBM
Formate brines have been used as (perforating) completion fluids for cased wells in 9 HPHT gas fields in the North Sea
•Shearwater •Elgin/Franklin •Braemar •Rhum •Judy •Glenelg •Kessog • Jura •West Franklin
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 56
Managed Pressure Drilling and completion of fractured carbonates with formate brine
SPE 165761 (2012) “ Experience with Formate Fluids for Managed Pressure Drilling and Completion of Sub-Sea Carbonate Gas Development Wells”
• Petronas - Kanowit field – 2 sub-sea gas wells
• Managed Pressure Drilling in fractured carbonate
with K formate brine improved economics by:
- Minimising fluid losses
- Reducing fluid cost (by using K formate)
- Improving production by 50%
- Eliminating need for stimulation (no acidising)
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 57
Kanowit SS-1 : Production profile from start-up - natural clean-up – no stimulation . Carbonate reservoir
• 100 MMscfd gas and 4,000 bpd condensate after 5 hours
• >150 MMscfd gas and > 6,000 bpd condensate after 9 hours
Kanowit SS-1 : Multi-rate well test results from carbonate
Both wells can produce > 150 MMscfd gas and > 6,000 bpd condensate
The maximum potential flow rate figures are 50% higher than the technical potential predicted in the original field development plan.
MRT measurements on well SS-1 before acidizing (Mahadi et al, 2013)
MRT Test Choke size
(/64)
Well Head
Pressure
(psi)
Gas Flow rate
Choke correlation
(MMscfd)
Gas Flow rate
Sonar
(MMscfd)
PDG Pressure
(psi)
PDG Temp
(oF)
1 112 2874.4 159.16 147.61 3857.0 252
2 88 3273.0 111.85 108.76 3932.2 252
3 64 3476.8 63.46 64.51 3978.5 251.7
4 40 3560.5 25.84 28.01 3998.8 250.1
North Sea - Formate brines used as combined HPHT drill-in and completion fluids
33 development* wells drilled and completed in 7 HPHT offshore gas fields
•Huldra (6 ) •Tune (4) •Devenick (2) •Kvitebjoern (8 O/B and 5 MPD) •Valemon (1) •Kristin (2) – Drilled only •Vega (5)
* Except Valemon (appraisal well)
Mostly open hole stand-alone sand screen completions
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 60
Tune field – HP/HT gas condensate reservoir drilled and completed with K formate brine, 2002
4 wells : 350-900 m horizontal reservoir sections. Open hole screen completions. Suspended for 6-12 months in formate brine after completion
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 61
Tune wells - Initial Clean-up – Operator’s view (direct
copy of slide) June 2003
• Wells left for 6-12 months before clean-up• Clean-up : 10 - 24 hours per well • Well performance
•Qgas 1.2 – 3.6 MSm3/d•PI 35 – 200 kSm3/d/bar•Well length sensitive
•No indication of formation damage•Match to ideal well flow simulations (Prosper) - no skin
• Indications of successful clean-up•Shut-in pressures •Water samples during clean-up
•Formate and CaCO3 particles•Registered high-density liquid in separator•Tracer results
•A-12 T2H non detectable•A-13 H tracer indicating flow from lower reservoir first detected 5 sd after
initial clean-up <-> doubled well productivity compared to initial flow data•No processing problems Oseberg Field Center
SIWHP SIDHP SIWHP SIDHPbara bara bara bara
A-11 AH 169 - 388 -
A-12 T2H 175 487 414 510
A-13 H 395 514 412 512
A-14 H 192 492 406 509
Before After
3350
3400
3450
3500
3550
3600
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000
Well length [m MD]
Dep
th [
m T
VD
MS
L]
A-11AH
A-12HT2
A-13H
A-14H
A-11 AH plugged back
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 62
Tune – Production of recoverable gas and condensate
reserves since 2003 (NPD data)
Good early production from the 4 wells - No skin (no damage)
- 12.4 million m3 gas /day - 23,000 bbl/day condensate
Good sustained production - 90% of recoverable hydrocarbon reserves produced by end of Year 7
NPD current estimate of RR: - 18.3 billion m3 gas - 3.3 million bbl condensate
Rapid and efficient drainage of the reservoir
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 63
• 6 production wells
• 1-2 Darcy sandstone
• BHST: 147oC
• TVD : 3,900 m
• Hole angle : 45-55o
• Fluid density: SG1.89-1.96
• 230-343 m x 81/2” reservoir sections
• Open hole completions, 65/8” wire wrapped
screens
• Lower completion in formate drilling fluid and
upper completions in clear brine
Huldra field – HPHT gas condensate reservoir drilled and completed with formate brine, 2001
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 64
65
Comments from Huldra project manager
TROND JUSTADManager-Huldra ProjectBergen, Norway
“CESIUM FORMATE HAS PLAYED A KEY ROLE in the development of the Huldra field (a high-
temperature, high-pressure gas field being developed by Statoil in the North Sea). Without it Statoil
could not have developed the field without major consequences on our plans, including the very
expensive redesign of all wells. The need to use a cesium formate-based drilling fluid became clear
after we experienced severe operational limitations when we drilled the first reservoir section with a
different product. Also, quite early in the process, we found that good synergies could be achieved
when using the same fluid for the drilling and completion phases.
“Cesium formate has significantly improved the safety and well control aspects of the project. It has
demonstrated good drillability with good hole cleaning, faster tripping speeds and absolutely no sag.
During flow checks, the fluid is completely stable after only 20 minutes, compared to 45 to 60 minutes
when using another product. This results in significant savings on every trip, as several flow checks
must be done each time the drill string is run in and out of a high-temperature, high-pressure well.
“For the specific conditions of the Huldra field, there is no realistic fluid alternative for successfully
drilling and completing the wells” - TROND JUSTAD
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd
Huldra – Production of recoverable gas and condensate
reserves since Nov 2001 (NPD data)
Plateau production from first 3 wells - 10 million m3 gas /day - 30,000 bbl/day condensate
Good sustained production - 78% of recoverable gas and 89% of condensate produced by end of Year 7 - Despite rapid pressure decline.....
NPD current estimate of RR: - 17.5 billion m3 gas - 5.1 million bbl condensate
Rapid and efficient drainage of the reservoir
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 66
• 13 wells to date – 8 O/B, 5 in MPD mode
• 100 mD sandstone
• BHST: 155oC
• TVD : 4,000 m
• Hole angle : 20-40o
• Fluid density: SG 2.02 for O/B
• 279-583 m x 81/2” reservoir sections
• 6 wells completed in open hole : 300-micron single wire-wrapped
screens.
• Remainder of wells cased and perforated
Kvitebjørn field – HPHT gas condensate reservoir drilled and completed with K/Cs formate brine, 2004-2013
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 67
A few of the highlights from Kvitebjoern
Kvitebjoern well
Completion time
(days)
A-4 17.5
A-5 17.8
A-15 14.8
A-10 15.9
A-6 12.7 *
* Fastest HPHT well completion in the North Sea
“The target well PI was 51,000 Sm3/day/bar This target would have had a skin of 7”
“A skin of 0 would have given a PI of 100,000”
“THE WELL A-04 GAVE A PI OF 90,000 Sm3/day/bar (ANOTHER FANTASTIC PI)”
Operator comments after well testing (Q3 2004 )
The Well PI was almost double the target
Fast completions and high well productivity
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 68
Kvitebjørn– Production of recoverable gas and
condensate reserves since Oct 2004 (NPD data)
Good production reported from first 7 wells in 2006 - 20 million m3 gas /day
- 48,000 bbl/day condensate
Good sustained production (end Y8) - 37 billion m3 gas - 17 million m3 of condensate - Produced 70% of original est. RR by end of 8th year
NPD : Est. RR have been upgraded - 89 billion m3 gas (from 55) - 27 million m3 condensate (from 22)
Note : Shut down 15 months, Y3-5 - To slow reservoir pressure depletion - Repairs to export pipeline
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 69
Economic benefits of using formate brines
• SPE 130376 (2010): “A Review of the Impact of the Use of Formate Brines on the Economics of Deep Gas Field Development Projects”
• SPE 145562 (2011): “Life Without Barite: Ten Years of Drilling Deep HPHT
Gas Wells With Cesium Formate Brine”
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 70
Economic benefits from using formate brines - Latest paper
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 71
Economic benefits from using formate brines - Good well performance and recovery of reserves
• “High production rates with low skin” *
• “ We selected formate brine to minimise well control problems
and maximise well productivity”*
* Quotes by Statoil relating to Kvitebjoern wells (SPE 105733)
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 72
Economic benefits from using formate brines
- More efficient and safer drilling
“ a remarkable record of zero well control incidents in all 15
HPHT drilling operations and 20 HPHT completion operations”
Better/safer drilling environment saves rig-time costs • Stable hole: see LWD vs. WL calipers in shale
• Elimination of well control* and stuck pipe incidents • Good hydraulics, low ECD
• Good ROP in hard abrasive rocks
* See next slide for details
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 73
Formate Brines : Allow fast solids-free drilling
Solids-free formate brines drill deep horizontal well sections much faster than muds like OBM – and cause less formation damage
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 74
Economic benefits from using formate brines - Improved well control and safety
• Elimination of barite and its sagging problems
• Elimination of oil-based fluids and their gas solubility problem
• Low solids brine Low ECD (SG 0.04-0.06) and swab pressures
• Inhibition of hydrates
• Ready/rapid surface detection of well influx
• Elimination of hazardous zinc bromide brine
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 75
- Drill-in and completing with formate brine allows open hole completion with screens
- Clean well bores mean no tool/seal failures or blocked screens
- Completion time 50% lower than wells drilled with OBM
“ fastest HPHT completion operation ever performed in North Sea (12.7 days)”
Economic benefits from using formate brines
- More efficient/faster completions
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 76
• No differential sticking
• Pipe and casing running speeds are fast
• Mud conditioning and flow-check times are short
• Displacements simplified, sometimes eliminated
Duration of flow back(minutes)
Fluid Gain (bbl)
30 0.8
15 0.56
20 0.44
30 0.56
Flow check fingerprint for a Huldra well
Economic benefits from using formate brines - Operational efficiencies
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 77
Economic benefits from using formate brines - Good reservoir definition if Cs present in fluid
• High density filtrate and no barite
• Filtrate Pe up to 259 barns/electron
• Unique Cs feature - makes filtrate invasion highly visible against formation Pe of 2-3 b/e
• LWD can “see” the filtrate moving (e.g. see the resistivity log on far right – drill vs ream
• Good for defining permeable sands (see SAND-Flag on log right )
• Consistent and reliable net reservoir definition
from LWD and wireline
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 78
Economic benefits from using formate brines - Good reservoir imaging
• Highly conductive fluid
• Clear resistivity images
• Information provided: - structural dip - depositional environment - geological correlations
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 79
Formate brines – Summary of economic benefits provided to users
Formate brines improve oil and gas field development economics by :
Reducing well delivery time and costs
Improving well/operational safety and reducing risk
Maximising well performance
Providing more precise reservoir definition
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 80
Formate brines enable open-hole screen completions in high-angle HPHT wells
Formate brines are low-solids drill-in and completion fluid systems
that provide massive benefits in open-hole screen completions in HPHT
wells
• Generally non-damaging to reservoir and screens
• Clean-up naturally during start-up (10-20 hours)
• Low skins
• No well stimulation required
• Good with expandable screens (Saudi, Pakistan)
Formates are perhaps the only high-density fluids that routinely deliver
unimpaired open hole screen completions in HPHT wells
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd
Finnish Environment Institute recommends the use of potassium formate in sensitive groundwater areas Environ Sci Technol. 2005 Jul 1;39(13):5095-100.Use of potassium formate in road winter deicing can reduce groundwater deterioration.Hellstén PP1, Salminen JM, Jørgensen KS, Nystén TH.
“Potassium formate was used to de-ice a stretch of a highway in Finland. The fate of the formate was examined by monitoring the groundwater chemistry in the underlying aquifer of which a conceptual model was constructed. In addition, we determined aerobic and anaerobic biodegradation rates of formate at low temperatures (-2 to +6 degrees C) in soil microcosms.
Our results show that the formate did not enter the saturated zone through the thin vadose zone; thus, no undesirable changes in the groundwater chemistry were observed. We recorded mineralization potential up to 97% and up to 17% within 24 h under aerobic and anaerobic conditions, respectively, in the soil and subsurface samples obtained from the site. This demonstrates that biodegradation in the topsoil layers was responsible for the removal of the formate.
We conclude that the use of potassium formate can potentially help diminish the negative impacts of road winter deicing on groundwater without jeopardizing traffic safety.”
John Downs - Formate Brine Ltd 82