fourth quarter 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. this market consists of websites...

23
FOURTH QUARTER 2016 INTEGRITY • CONFIDENTIALITY • EXPERIENCE

Upload: others

Post on 17-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

FOURTH QUARTER 2016

INTEGRITY • CONFIDENTIALITY • EXPERIENCE

Page 2: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

The 2016 merger and acquisition (M&A) market in the U.S. outsourced businessservices (OBS) sector behaved as expected for most of the year. OBS includescompanies in the Accounts Receivable Management (ARM), Customer RelationshipManagement (CRM) and healthcare Revenue Cycle Management (RCM) industries.The OBS M&A market remained active throughout most of 2016 due to an ongoingconsolidation of smaller OBS companies into larger ones, and select platformacquisitions of larger OBS companies by financial buyers (mainly private equity firms)and strategic buyers seeking to expand into a new service offering and/or geographicregion.

2016 was also a year of significant events that affected the OBS sector: Wells Fargoreceiving a consent order from the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), theDepartment of Education announcing the winners and losers of the large businessagency contract, not-for-profit healthcare providers and their Revenue CycleManagement (RCM) vendors working to ensure they were in compliance with the final501(r) regulations, and of course, the nomination of Donald Trump as the nextPresident of the United States. Once it became clear that Donald Trump was going towin the election, the mindset of many sellers and buyers began to change. Somedeals that were already underway and intended to close by year-end were pushedinto 2017 with hopes of a lower capital gains tax. Other deals were put on hold assellers anticipated a reduction in regulatory requirements that would lead to betterfinancial performance, and greater business opportunities with current and pendingclients. Since his inauguration, President Trump has fueled these motivations withnew appointments for the heads of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and FederalCommunications Commission (FCC), and stated intentions of making changes at theConsumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) – although no announcements havebeen made to date. President Trump has also instituted a strict guideline for futureregulations, requiring two existing regulations to be recommended for terminationfor every new regulation proposed, and has his sights set on significantly modifyingDodd-Frank.

While it is difficult to predict exactly how much impact these changes will have onfuture business opportunities and performance within the OBS sector, we do expectthat President Trump will live up to his campaign promises of reducing the existingregulatory environment to make it more attractive for businesses. Owners of OBScompanies will want to maintain a close watch on these developments and make surethey know how these changes will impact their businesses, and their clients.

Here is a list of our 2017 predictions for the OBS sector:

Deal activity will match or exceed 2016 resultsThere will be an increase in M&A activity with larger OBS companiesU.S. companies will outsource more customer service and collections businessSales of debt portfolios should increase

Page 3: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

Healthcare providers will continue to consolidate, and smaller vendors willneed to continue to expand their client base and diversify their service offeringsto remain competitiveRichard Cordray will complete his term as head of the CFPB

We understand and appreciate that business owners may feel both motivated andconcerned about the future of their companies and industries, but we believe thatthings will be sorted out in the near future and are optimistic about the long-termpotential of the OBS sector.

We are grateful for your interest in our newsletter and the OBS sector, and appreciateany feedback or comments you may have.

Sincerely,

Mark RussellManaging Partner

2

CAS Transaction Summary

Johnson, Morgan & White Strategic Mergerwith Altus GTS Inc. – January 2017

One of the nations' leading debt recoveryfirms, Johnson, Morgan & White, completed astrategic merger with Altus GTS Inc., thelargest corporate collection agency in NorthAmerica, in January 2017. With offices coveringboth the U.S. and Canada, Altus,(www.TrustAltus.com) is North America's mostsophisticated commercial accounts receivablemanagement company.

Mark Russell, Managing Partner of CAS said “This transaction brings together twomarket leaders with complimentary skill setsand client bases. Together, they will be able toprovide their clients with even greater serviceand performance.â€

CAS served as the exclusive M&A advisor to JMW. Read full press release here.

Page 4: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

CAS Conference and Event Activity

Please connect with us at one of the upcoming conferences/seminars that will beattended by CAS team members:

February 14–17 – Committee of 100March 3–7 – LendITMarch 13–15 – ACA Spring ForumMarch 27th - Institute for Collection Leadership (ICL), New Orleans, LA

We hope that you find our newsletter a useful insight into the OBS sector andwelcome any discussion of business interests or feedback you may have. Our contactinformation can be found at the end of this report.

Members of Corporate Advisory Solutions, LLC are Registered Representatives of, andsecurities transactions are conducted through, StillPoint Capital LLC; MemberFINRA/SIPC. StillPoint Capital is not affiliated with Corporate Advisory Solutions, LLC.

Page 5: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 6: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 8: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

Within the publicly traded ARM sector,there were three deals that wereannounced in the fourth quarter of 2016which will most likely close in Q1 2017. Intrum Justitia (STO:IJ) announced theirintention to combine with European creditmanagement service provider Lindoff. Ifthe transaction is approved, it will createone of the largest providers of creditmanagement services.  Intrum Justitia(STO:IJ)  have also entered into a definiteagreement to acquire the UK debtpurchaser 1st Credit. The deal will allowIntrum Justitia to widen their client baseand strengthen its position in theEuropean market. Additionally, PRA Group(NASADQ:PRAA) has sold off it governmentservices business unit to Millstein & Co.

All of the deals above are expected to, orhave already closed in Q1 2017 and arenot accounted for in our enterprise valuecalculations. Â Below are some additionalnoteworthy transactions that took place inthe ARM sector in Q4 2016:

Radius Global Solutions merged withNorthland Group to enhance theirservice offerings and expand theircapabilitiesGeneral Credit Services, Inc. acquiredSKYLINK Receivables in order toprovide diversification in theircollections strategy

Page 9: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

The new entity will be called GovernmentRevenue Solutions. This allows PRA tofocus on their core strategies and create anew player in the government servicesmarketplace. Millstein & Co. believe thatthat is a high demand for the governmentrevenue services going forward.

Page 10: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 11: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

Within the publicly traded RCM sector,there was one transaction that closed andone transaction has reached a definiteagreement in Q4 2016. MedicalTranscription Billing (NASDAQ:MTBC)acquired MediGain to enhance theircustomer base as well as improve theirservice offerings. Team Heath Holdings(NYSE:THM) is in a definite agreement tobe acquired by Blackstone Group. The dealis expected to close in Q1 2017 and hasnot been included in the total enterprisevalue for Q4 2016.

Below are some additional noteworthytransactions that took place in the RCMsector in Q4 2016:

nThrive, a subsidiary of MedAssets,has acquired revenue cyclemanagement firm Adreima. Thisenhances nThrive’s strategiccapabilities and provide patientadvocacy and self-pay collections.EqualizeRCM acquired MedicalManagement Solutions, a companythat specializes in physician revenuecycle management.  This is effortsto expand EqualizeRCM’spractice management services.

Page 12: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 13: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

Within the publicly traded CRM sectorthere were three deals in the fourthquarter of 2016. TeleTech Holdings(NASDAQ:TTEC) acquired Atelka, a Canadabased CRM company. West Corporation(NASDAQ:WSTC) has acquired 911 ETC, Inc,a provider of enhanced 911 services. NICESystems (NASDAQ:NICE) has acquiredinContact. This acquisition creates a morecomprehensive and fully integrated set ofsolution offerings for NICE Systems.

Below is an additional noteworthytransaction that took place in the CRMsector in Q4 2016:

Everstone Capital partnered withSunrise BPO to acquire C3(CustomerContactChannels) who is aglobal provider of CRM solutions.

The section below features additional articles from CAS team members David Lavine and ElaineRowley. David Lavine, discusses how the new tax laws proposed by President Trump laws will affectcapital gains taxes. Elaine Rowley, provides an ARM Regulatory Update detailing the latestgovernment news, regulation and compliance activities in the ARM sector.

Page 14: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

Please feel free to contact the authors to further discuss the information they have detailed in theirrespective pieces below.

Page 15: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 16: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 18: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

Consumer Financial ProtectionBureau (CFPB)

CFPB Notices of ProposedRegulation Open for Comment:

Request for Information RegardingConsumer Access to FinancialRecords The Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reformand Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank Act) provides for consumerrights to access financial account andaccount-related data in usableelectronic form. The Bureau ofConsumer Financial Protection (Bureauor CFPB) is seeking comments from thepublic about consumer access to suchinformation, including access byentities acting with consumerpermission, in connection with theprovision of products or services thatmake use of that information.

CFPB Reports and Updates:

Consumer Experiences With DebtCollection: Findings From the CFPB’s Survey on Consumer Views onDebt This report presents the resultsof the

Survey of Consumer Views on Debtwhich was conducted by the CFPBbetween December 2014 and March2015. The survey results substantiallyexpand the understanding of debtcollection in the United States byproviding the first comprehensive andnationally representative data onconsumers’ experiences andpreferences related to debt collection.

Market Snapshot: Online Debt SalesThis report provides an introduction tothe online marketplace for charged-offdebt. This market consists of websitesand in at least one case, a Facebookpage, where portfolios of charged-offconsumer debt are listed for sale.

Snapshot of older consumers andstudent loan debt The number of consumers age 60 andolder with student loan debt hasquadrupled over the last decade in theUnited States, and the average amountthey owe has also dramaticallyincreased.Â

Consumer Financial ProtectionBureau Independent Audit ofSelected Operations and Budget,Fiscal Year 2016In accordance with the Dodd-Frank Act,the CFPB orders an annualindependent audit of the operationsand budget of the Bureau.

Republican members of HouseFinancial Services Committeerelease new report on CFPB’sauto finance actions Republican members of the HouseFinancial Services Committee recentlyreleased a report, prepared by theRepublican Staff of the Committee,titled “Unsafe at Any Bureaucracy,Part III: The CFPB’s Vitiated LegalCase Against Auto Lenders.â€Â

Department of Labor (DOL)

Agency Rule Lists

14

CAS Resource Links:

CFPB, January, 2017, Report of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau pursuant to section1017(e)(4) of the Dodd-Frank Act

CFPB, January 2017,  Consumer Experiences With Debt Collection: Findings From the CFPB’sSurvey on Consumer Views on Debt

CFPB, January 2017, Market Snapshot: Online Debt Sales

CFPB, January 2017, Monthly Complaint Report, Vol. 18

Page 19: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

CFPB, January 2017, Fall-Winter Regulatory Agenda

CFPB, October, 2016 Annual Report of the CFPB Student Loan Ombudsman.

CFPB, October 2016, Guide to Loan Estimate and Closing Disclosure Forms.

CFPB, October 2016, Small Entity Compliance Guide

CFPB, September 2016, Monthly Complaint Report, Vol. 15

CFPB, April 2016 Online Payday Loan Payments

CFPB, April 2016, Student Loan 'Payback Playbook'

CFPB, March 2016, Winter Supervisory Highlights

DOL, Overtime Final Rule, May 2016

FTC, EU-U.S. Privacy Shield Framework, July 2016

FTC, Fair Debt Collection Practices Act

FTC, Memorandum of Understanding between the CFPB and the FTC, March 2015.

IRS, Internal Revenue Service Affordable Care Act

Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Risk Management Guidance

Protecting Personal Information: A Guide for Business.

Page 20: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 21: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer
Page 23: FOURTH QUARTER 2016...the online marketplace for charged-off debt. This market consists of websites and in at least one case, a Facebook page, where portfolios of charged-off consumer

CAS – Corporate Advisory Solutions © 2017 Chevy Chase, MD 20815