frank c. gilmore, esq., sbn 283859 robison, sharp ... · 8/2/2019 · case 5:18-cv-01919-blf...
TRANSCRIPT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1 SUPPLEMENT TO JOINT STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THE PARTIES CROSS-MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AS TO PLAINTIFFS’ SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
Case No. 5:18-cv-01919-BLF
FRANK C. GILMORE, ESQ., SBN 283859 ROBISON, SHARP, SULLIVAN & LOW 71 Washington Street Reno, NV 89503 Telephone: (775) 329-3151 Facsimile: (775) 329-7941 Attorneys for Plaintiffs RICHARD DOYLE, City Attorney (88625) NORA FRIMANN, Assistant City Attorney (93249) MARGO LASKOWSKA, Sr. Deputy City Attorney (187252) WESLEY KLIMCZAK, Sr. Deputy City Attorney (294314) Office of the City Attorney 200 East Santa Clara Street, 16th Floor San José, California 95113-1905 Telephone Number: (408) 535-1900 Facsimile Number: (408) 998-3131 E-Mail Address: [email protected] Attorneys for CITY OF SAN JOSE
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
SAN JOSE DIVISION
CITIZENS FOR FREE SPEECH AND EQUAL JUSTICE, LLC; GTL ENTERPRISES, LLC; Plaintiffs, vs. CITY OF SAN JOSE, Defendant. AND RELATED COUNTERCLAIM
Case No.: 5:18-cv-01919-BLF SUPPLEMENT TO JOINT STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THE PARTIES’ CROSS-MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AS TO PLAINTIFFS’ SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT (Civil L.R. 56-2)
Pursuant to this Court’s Order Approving Jointly Submitted Case Status Report
and Proposed Briefing Schedule of April 23, 2019 (ECF 53), the parties hereby provide
the Court a Supplement to Joint Statement of Undisputed Facts in support of the
parties’ cross-motions for summary judgment as to Plaintiffs’ Second Amended
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 1 of 30
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
2 SUPPLEMENT TO JOINT STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THE PARTIES CROSS-MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AS TO PLAINTIFFS’ SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
Case No. 5:18-cv-01919-BLF
Complaint:
1. On or about July 1, 2019, Plaintiff GTL ENTERPRISES, LLC, obtained its
business tax certificate from the City. On or about July 5, 2019, Plaintiff CITIZENS FOR
FREE SPEECH AND EQUAL JUSTICE, LLC obtained its business tax certificate from
the City. Copies of documents evidencing when the Business Tax Certificates were
issued by the City of San Jose are attached hereto collectively as EXHIBIT 10.
2. Attached to the original Statement of Undisputed Facts as Exhibit 1 was
an incorrect version of the lease agreement between Citizens and GTL. Attached hereto
as EXHIBIT 11 is the correct version of the lease agreement referenced in the parties’
briefs.
Dated: August 2, 2019 ROBISON, SHARP, SULLIVAN & BRUST 71 Washington Street Reno, Nevada 89503 /s/ Frank C. Gilmore FRANK C. GILMORE, SBN 283859
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
Dated: August 2, 2019 RICHARD DOYLE, City Attorney /s/ Margo Laskowska MARGO LASKOWSKA, SBN 187252 Senior Deputy City Attorney
Attorneys for Defendant CITY OF SAN JOSE
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 2 of 30
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 3 of 30
7/30/2019 San Jose, CA - Official Website - Business Tax Lookup
www.sanjoseca.gov/index.aspx?nid=5313 1/1
200 E. Santa Clara St.San José, CA 95113408 535-3500 Main408 294-9337 TTYDirections
Select Language ▼
The City of San José is committed to open and honest government and strives toconsistently meet the community’s expectations by providing excellent service, in a positiveand timely manner, and in the full view of the public.
About sanjoseca.govNewsroomCareersMobile SitePrint FriendlySite MapContact Us
Code of EthicsOpen GovernmentWhistleblower HotlineAccessibility InstructionsMy ConnectionPowered by CIVICPLUS
For EmployeesAccess eWay from homeEmployee Web MailWebsite Administrators Login
Home > Government > Departments & Offices > Departments & Offices D-H > Finance > Business Tax &Registration > Business Tax Lookup
Business Tax Lookup
CSJ Business Directory Search Results
Business Name CITIZENS FOR FREE SPEECH & E Business Address 487 MISSOULA COURT Suite Zip 89511-6097 Business Owner CITIZENS FOR FREE SPEECH & E Mailing Address 487 MISSOULA CT, RENO CA 89511Business Start Date 07/05/2019 Expiration date 07/15/2020 Account# 6132124560 #Employees 1 #Units #Square Feet Nature of Business Advertising Business License Search
Register your Business
Make a Payment
Business Tax andRegulatory Permit Forms
Business Tax Lookup
Business Tax Rates
Exclusions, Exemptions &Other Requirements
Ballot Measure Changes
Residential LandlordUpdates
Search site
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 4 of 30
7/23/2019 San Jose, CA - Official Website - Business Tax Lookup
www.sanjoseca.gov/index.aspx?NID=5313 1/1
200 E. Santa Clara St.San José, CA 95113408 535-3500 Main408 294-9337 TTYDirections
Select Language ▼
The City of San José is committed to open and honest government and strives toconsistently meet the community’s expectations by providing excellent service, in a positiveand timely manner, and in the full view of the public.
About sanjoseca.govNewsroomCareersMobile SitePrint FriendlySite MapContact Us
Code of EthicsOpen GovernmentWhistleblower HotlineAccessibility InstructionsMy ConnectionPowered by CIVICPLUS
For EmployeesAccess eWay from homeEmployee Web MailWebsite Administrators Login
Home > Government > Departments & Offices > Departments & Offices D-H > Finance > Business Tax &Registration > Business Tax Lookup
Business Tax Lookup
CSJ Business Directory Search Results
Business Name GTL ENTERPRISES, LLC Business Address 300 E GISH RD Suite Zip 95112 Business Owner GTL ENTERPRISES Mailing Address 300 E GISH RD, SAN JOSE CA 95112Business Start Date 07/01/2019 Expiration date 07/15/2020 Account# 4841166640 #Employees 2 #Units #Square Feet Nature of Business Management Business License Search
Register your Business
Business Tax andRegulatory Permit Forms
Business Tax Lookup
Business Tax Rates
Exclusions, Exemptions &Other Requirements
Make a Payment
Ballot Measure Changes
Residential LandlordUpdates
Search site
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 5 of 30
7/23/2019 San Jose, CA - Official Website - Business Tax Lookup
www.sanjoseca.gov/index.aspx?NID=5313 1/1
200 E. Santa Clara St.San José, CA 95113408 535-3500 Main408 294-9337 TTYDirections
Select Language ▼
The City of San José is committed to open and honest government and strives toconsistently meet the community’s expectations by providing excellent service, in a positiveand timely manner, and in the full view of the public.
About sanjoseca.govNewsroomCareersMobile SitePrint FriendlySite MapContact Us
Code of EthicsOpen GovernmentWhistleblower HotlineAccessibility InstructionsMy ConnectionPowered by CIVICPLUS
For EmployeesAccess eWay from homeEmployee Web MailWebsite Administrators Login
Home > Government > Departments & Offices > Departments & Offices D-H > Finance > Business Tax &Registration > Business Tax Lookup
Business Tax Lookup
CSJ Business Directory Search Results
Business Name GTL ENTERPRISES, LLC Business Address 300 E GISH RD Suite Zip 95112 Business Owner GTL ENTERPRISES Mailing Address 300 E GISH RD, SAN JOSE CA 95112Business Start Date 07/01/2019 Expiration date 07/15/2020 Account# 4841166640 #Employees 2 #Units #Square Feet Nature of Business Management Business License Search
Register your Business
Business Tax andRegulatory Permit Forms
Business Tax Lookup
Business Tax Rates
Exclusions, Exemptions &Other Requirements
Make a Payment
Ballot Measure Changes
Residential LandlordUpdates
Search site
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 6 of 30
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 7 of 30
lNSI^3EU9V 3SV3t
ur.':'r'"';oJ;"'n:f :ri;il:i; 3o lueueelSe l'nlnu uodn'sru,el ree'{ (1) ouo u?ql sser ou roJ po,reuer eq ,(eru aseel oqr cr.uror rerrrur eqr3o uorlerrdxe eqt uodn 'requnc'oleroll
luens;ndpeleurlurelrerlreesselun'zruz --rlr.nont uoEur.rrdxe'rr""iiogl{urqlJopor.reduroJreueareql ontrrluoc lleqs pue'("atuo luouarueuuo3,, eql) /r0z'--;;;;tro rrurr*o, 11nq, *nr1 srqlJo r.urol eq1 ffibi 1.7
NOIIVNIhIUSI ONY hIUSI 'II
eq,ro qcee uo erroqc s,!r_o Bursrue^pu eo{ o1l_"J...", j;iJi:;ffi$'rfilqf ;::-;,ffjHH:TJ*-.;,:;#1,:l#::li; slql olul lelua ol lueuealSu s.plolpue.J roJ uotleteptsuoc rerreleu se reql seer8e,(;sse.rdxe eesser.Buro8e.ro3 aqt ol uorlrppe ul
leutErro rreqr or sesrruerd pes€er eqr erorse, pue sp*oqr,, "* :::;:':ltr:"'J::'l;"Jf::::J;.,Tfi:':::,:T ilI"[iit:,l:
Jo uorleurr.urol ,{1.ree.ro uor}errdxe eql uodp .spreoqllrg eql .rreder pue urpluretu ol {l!llqlsuodser elos a^eq lleqs eessel .aessel ,{qspr?oqllrE eqlJo uouellelsur oql 3ur'mo|1og 'eessa.I ot peurnrer ,(ltdruo.rd eq ileqs r;;;i ol eesso-r ,(q pred luer ,{ue uorreurr.urol qcns uodn pue.rosse,l olJoere$ ecrlou uellrr/r\ Burrrl8 iq rrn"l ,,,1, aleurr.urel ol tq8lr eql a^€q Ileqs eosse_l .rossel ,(q peno.rdde louarespleoqlllgeqlroJsuollecglcedspuesueJdeqlrospreoqlllgeqlJouorrpcor
eqruodneer8elouuecsergedeqtgl .sesruerd pese'l .ql uo rro^{ Sutcueruuoc lolcerluoc e o1 rorld'pe,(elep io p"uo,r,proc 'proqqlr,&r ,(Jqeuosee.run eq rou l'qs leno.rdde qcrqm 'lenordde roJ rossel ol eesso'l '{q pellruqns pue pe.rede.rd "q ilnqtrprnoqilrg oql roJ suorlecurceds pue suerd .eesser pu' losso.r '{q uodn pee,3e '(11en1nu sesluord peseol ot{l uo uorlecor e te pue'(o1e.req v ornpeqcs Burpnlcur) oseer srql qrr^{ ecu€procce ur ("spleoqllrg" eql) sp'reoq11rs lellElp t llelsur ol'esuedxe eros s!aesso'I te 1q8!r rqr rnnqltnqr'.eesso.I sluaura^orffiI aossa.t , r
penu,,uoc pue ,e'"o_, s q, repun ".,ilTJ'J"'"T:ii!::':ilfif:iff;:#:,:;':"xi'l1t;15"1"ffffi lI.TjI,r;:i,#:: '(ltuepuedepur 'ro3 elqrsuodsol sl eosse'I 1eq1 see.r8e puu seSpe;ltou1"" ,"rrr1 'rosser ,{q serlue:;e,tr pue suorreruaserde, Buro'a.ro3 eq1 Surpuelsqll'tloN 'uosred laqloueJo pe.rrnba.r srJoeroql leno.rdde ou'urereq peprnord rr,^r"qto se rdecxe cpue eseel srqr orul rolue ol fl,oqlne pue tq8l'r oql sell lossel (p) pue:secr^ros cr;qnd o1 pue s,{empeo.r ro sroerrs crlqnd Eururolpe uo.rj pue ol ssocce 0lqeuoseer e^eq sostruord paseel eq1 (c) luorlce ro 3utpeeco.td 'uor1e3l1;1 '1rns 'ure;c qcns roJ srseq ou sr eraqr .e8pe;mou1 s,rossa.I Jo lseq eq] ol'pue esn Jo/pu€ 'seslrueJd pesee'l eql ol saleler rcqt,$-red.reqlo ,(ue ro rossel liureae pouereerql .a3pel,vrou1 s,rossa,l Jo lseq eql 01 'ro Surpued uollce ro Surpeeco.rd 'uorreSltlr '1rns:rurelc ou sr eroql (q) lprocelgo se3e3gou, Burlsrxe Kue o1 lcefqns 'sastuel4 pesee'l eql ul lselelut dtqs:aurvro plJe^ ? seq lossel (e) ter{t eesse.I ol sluele,r pue slueserder rosse.I fi!ft!ffi 3. 1
'(,,sasrural4 pesue-L, eql) otereq peqcege V elnpeqcs uo u,ror{s ,{llecgrcads erou se '€luroJtleJ'oso[ ues 'peou qslc 'E 00e le pelecol ,,(1edor4 lcefqnS
"ql3o lrni n s, e"ed. peleuSrsep qcrq*r acedsSo 1ee3 e'renbs
- '{leleurxordde rosse'I ruou es€el ,(qe.req ,"op ,"rr"{pue eesse'I olun eseer ,(qe.req seop lossor ,peureruoc ulareq slueuee;8e pu? slueuo^oc eql pue p3^Jesol reueureroq luer eql Jo uorleroprsuoc ur pue roJ leql see.r3e rosse,I ;ftlfd!ffiaq
1 1
sssrhtsud ossva.I .r
',,Kuea,, e se fllenprrrrpur.ro.,.serged,, eql se Kle,rrtcelloc ol parreJer eg,(eu eossel pue rosse-l lueueer8y stql u1 '("aesse1") epene5l oueu 6unoJ elnosslt\ L8v p p'*)or sseursnqJo eceld ledrcurrd ,lt qrt^ .,(ueduo3 ,(tlllqett perru!.r epe^aN e "J'l-l'gJlrsnf 'Ivnos oNV Hf,sads asu.{ uo.{ sNszIrIJ pue '(,..rossa1,,) BruroJrJeJ .esof u€s ,peou
qslc 'a 06e le petecol sseursnq 3o eceld ledrcuud slr qlr^\ xuearuoc-&rttqen perrull'L,urog,1n3 e ,J.r-r,sgsluaustNlg 'IIC uoe,t\loq pue,{q'll0z'-Jsn6'--nv 3o,tepu- ,,q1 pr1n"r*e (,,esee1,, stqi) ir.raltsguCv gSVg_I S;HI
INflIAIgflUCV f,SVf,'I
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 8 of 30
6t lo zuoss3llN3/{33UCv 3sv3t
s''lltuluopul lsulu8e uerel uollce leSel leqlo 'ro '$1eued'uorlce,Jur ,(ue (g).ro'uosred ,(ue3o qleep ro,sseurr .,{.rnrur ,{ue (Z) .{uedoro
[:Tl"XTffi,:lHJ,'],1:i,f]ll::1,:"H:":,*i::i !::{;'"Ke's1soc rre pue ,rue isufe'u pus ,uo{ sserrureq ^,,ou,l ("see1ruurepul,, ''(;ezulce;;oc) {uedora lcetqns oquo srueuor-oc reqro ^* il:";,lirJ{"H I'Jj::hlT.rT#'"i#:::rjjl::il 'srecuJo'srequlotu's;euiledsll'rosselploqpunpueJep'4ruruepui 'rcelo.rd11nqr""Jo1 '*re1 fqpelllu.redluolxorsernJ eqro).2.v qde'r8e'le6 slqlJo uollelol^ ul ocueulpro Jo olnlers'uor1e1n8e.r'"1nr'^"1
recor ro orers cleropec fue selelorn oessoJ ruorxe elrr oJ
''(elr '(ue ul sosttueJd pes'el eqlJo uoruod,{uerequncue esr,rleqro lou Jreqs pu?.sesruerd p'seel aql uo sulolt '{ue elols lou lleqs eossel 'rosse'IJo luesuoc uerrr^\ sse:dxe ro,rd eql lnoqlt.r\ esodrnd.reqro ou pue sp*oql,g lelrBrp e 3ur,{eJdsrp reu'ereql pue Furlcn.rlsuor 3o ,roa-; ;;};;los sesrurerd pasee_l aql esn Il'r{s oesse.I Esffin_f rb
Af,NYdNJf,O ONY ASN 'AI
uotlero.td rolpue ruorursnfpe alerrdo.rdde ue ,esee1 srqrJo uorreururel ro uorlerrdxe3o el'p eql,ege ped ",
," ,r:l"f,rT"tJH::[:T eql eroJoq ued ur por,ed e ot oleler eseel slql repun eessa'I ,{q epeu eq or porrnba.r sluaru,{ed ,"q1o ,o 1ue, ,{ue y; miiEfoe 7 g
INSU .tlt
'J3e1 pue reel( erqeuos'oJ JoJ ldecxe uorlrpuoc pu' repro pooS ur pue ueerc ruoorq 'selcueuel-qns Jo eo{ 'seslruord poseol eql rosse.I olun dn pJer,( pue ,rprlrrn, 'rnn"t itt",nn pue ,,(lqeeceed ,esee1 srqr JouoIleuII'uJe1leIlleoeq1uodn;o.esea1Slt-l1JouJe1eqt3o,(eplSeleqlaJoJeqJouo.JleqSoesSe].@Zz
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 9 of 30
6r lo €:33SS3t
JNEI^]EIUDV 3SV3I
:i'T",,i:""Jr':l'#'ilJ1"#,Tl'i;jilll::H:Tl,;:l::1,ii"^r^:^'ly:l.rr1o' eq, q,r^\ pue '(lcv ,(lrlqesrq q,,^r su,c,reruv eqt se u/doul ,{Juor.uwoc ,trBJ eql .uorlelrurr
"," *j;r"";"^;':l";;""#J ij:,"::"]:'"11":..:""':., lelueuu.re,ro8 pun':r"rrnu,pro ,solnl'ls ,s^\et
llp qlrm ,{ldtuoc ,('duro.rrt orqrrrrfvr
["']",T;::l t::'9i;'o ""';;J;;;;;ffi'::il"]: ff:L $J:'#"fJ::::^i['[?:,;?::",1],:,^:T^:::"'t::.:u dee>1ro Bu,,q i1bu,,,.oq,";;;;J;;ili;;;;ffiffiil:;;:,i1?#;f;tl;T,ilTi;flii:,yi,Ti:l:l:: :iT:l_'",,f,;eY+ +rrwYb ru ur e uoP 0q ol dulqilue lluradllSul,{ou) ro op rou lleqs oosso-l .peleElnruord.ro
::i:i:,:: fff:1li::,u:11:.:"^::':J ,uf ^o' uoltrrnd",,o
"1n, lnru*ure,ro' ro ,ecueurpro .ornrers .rvrer ,{ue 'r^^ ,3r,,rn. rDM xue ur J'^ qctq'{ sesrruord eql rnoqe ro ur euop eq or Bulqilue r!u.,ed,"::1,"J"; ili:k'iiliiii:Jifjj{[4ry;;'sesruord eql lnoqe lo ,uo ,ur e1se,m ,(ue3o uorssrulrloc eql JeJJns ro l!ruruoc lou lleqs eesse'l .sesluold poseel eql lnoqe ro'uo'ut ecuestnu '(ue;ru'ued lo uteJuteu 'esnec eessel'11nq. rou'{u.dor4 tcerqng eqrJo uolrelnde.r eqr e.rnrur 11rm qcrq,n rauueu ,{ue ur ro esodlnd,{ue rog ro ,esodrnd
InJ^\elun ,(ue,o3 f"rn ,q ol sestuerd eql ,r\olle ro ,rn ,o ureql ,{ouue,{11erre1eu .ro elnlur ,(;1el.re1eu.r.ro,{uedor6 rcefqng aql3o sluedncro ro rrunu""r'reqloJo rlq8lr r,lt qll^ ".,r3r"ru,
,(11er.re1eu lo lcnrlsqo,{1Jer.re1eu KenfueutJIl,t\t'{clt{,t\SoStueldeql1noqeJouIeuopeqo13urqiluel-,uued,oop1ou11nqJ"",,"1@s'
uns e erorereqr uorreruouncop surlroddn, oun .,,on,,,u,1il:'iJ:::jt:]"iii:.r"i::T:lrf:{:lT;J:illf,Tffi[ff"{if1[::: pue uolllpuoc'leplo poo8 ul seslueld pesee-l aql tnd oip,n ltnqrq s.oesser uo suorle8rrqo qcns u.rogred ol sasruerd peseer eql uodn relue ol tq8r'r eql e^eq lleqs rosse.l'(e'rnc o1 peeco.rd rtlr.Bttip reueereqr pue porred Kep (oz),{1uem1 rrcns urqrr,r os op or ecueultuoc ol slleJ eessel pue s,{ep (g7) ,euertr1 ueql eroru e;rnbel 01 se ralcelpqc qcn ecrlou ou 'sec qcrq,r ur "(cue8;eueJo
os'c eql ur ldacxe) rosse-I [uo{JoeJaql ecll.r (67) '$ue"r'r1 urr{rrM uorlces srjl repun suorle'r;qo s,easso-I tu.ro3.red or srleJ eesserJl uolltpuoc'lep;o pooE ul 'spreoqlltg eql pue;enoc punor3,sfe,nqled,s,{errtanrp.secur 'asuedxe elos s,oesse-l le,ll?qs eesso.I i(uedo.rd lcelqng eqlJo lueuel .reqlo,{uego su tcelqng oqt uo sorlrnrtce ssaursnq srrossel .rredur,.ro'af,eOri Xn^ Xun r, 1o, lleqs suorteroclo s,eessal EmFj:bffiTrt y.y
pr'pusls e or lsoc olos s,eossa'I 1e dn 'de1 .q :,,:"rrrrjd paseor ;ir::,::iTff:ffi1,ilt'r:julil,;:;'Jr"r1'jffl'.":;; lleqs ''ssel 'sesluerd posue'l eqlJo eplslno '(uedo,d lcerqng ,qtyo ,jnJ., pue ecueualu,nru lnrera6 ro;,(111,q;suodsar s..rosse1 Surpuelsqlrltlop '{gado'r6 lcelqng eq1 uo s.'{1'reoo,a lr"hnjrql iun''Burlq8rr ,(ue pue sile/^ Jo socuoJ rorerur.red,(ue.eceJrns 1o1 3ur>1.red eql .ot polrrurl lou lnq.Eurpnlcur :rrr,.u"r4 peseel eql ur popnlcul lou sr VclVm {uedo.r4 nefqng eql3o uoruod eqt;o Iteder pue ocuPueluteu eql JoJ elqrsuodser eq lleqs Josse.l .seelrnur Jo se^rleluesolde.l ,slue8e .sae,{o1dr_ue s}l .oosso-lJo
lcnpuocsil.u loacue3r13auaqlo1Eur1e1aJJotUo{Eursr're',{gedordiueo1,,o1.roole3eruepro31decxE@e'
oq rreqs 7'p tqdenen4s,qrro r{ceerq e uou ,u,.1,:1u,0:,"0,o o.u"]X3ili;;'i'ilJ:l:i:ilil1:Xl;lT'#iill:i;:I;i]:; lesunoc '{q pe1191ng aq lreqs qde.r'e-red srqt repun suorle'rlqo "rr"3"p
pue,eru.uepu, ,..rrrr1 .uorl€ur.urel qcns ol ,or;d Bu'lncco qleep ro sseuJlt "tnfur
'eaewep 'lue^a 'lueptcce,(ue o1 lcadse.r qri^ "rnr1
srr{rJo uorleururel ro uorlerrdxe oql e^r^rns Ir'qs pue lueulee'r8y slql ol lu'nsJnd eessel fq per.r'rec eq o1 pe.rrnbe, ,o p",rrn. e8e;enoc-ecuninru, "q1
,(q petlull eq rou lleqs uoures srql 3o suotsr,rord eql'Z.V qde;Bere4 srql repun suorle8rlqo sllJo fueJo qceolq s,eesse.I uor3 EurlJnser,tlllqe!l pu€ stulelc .se8er,uep 'sessol 'sesuedxe's1soc lle pue '(ue lsure8e pu€ tuo+ sselr.ureq seoiluuJepur proq pue pueJep ,,!ruuepur ,1ce1o.rd osre rleqs eesse.r '(seelltuuepu;3o
ecueErlSeu eq1 fq ged ut pesnec ueaq e^Bq lleqs qleep ro sseullr .,,ftnfur ,eEe']ep,ssol .urrelc.esuedxe,lsoc qcns uell^'\ 'uollellutl
lnoqlln' 63urpn;cur) seesuecll Jo soeltAur 'slsenF'sJeuorsno 'saefoldr-ue 'srocgJo .s;euped .slue^Jas ,sJolceJruoc 'slueSe s1r 'aesselJo lcnpuocslru lnJilr/r\ ro acueSrlSeu eqt,{q ued ur ro eroq^\ ur posnec eq ilBrrs ,Qtilqett ro ,.urelc .q*ap .sseuilr
"{lnfur 'e'eurup 'ssor 'esuedxe '1soc qcns ueq/h 'sesrurerd oql ueq}.req1o ,fuedo.r. lcefqng aqi:o uea ,{ue lnoqe ro .uo .ur Burlncco (q) pue :rosse'I Jo ]cnpuocslu lnJ[[t''' ro ecue8rlSau ssor8 eql 3o *sne, ,tq r1"1oi unqr i""qro ,rnrorrsq,,, osneJ ,{ue u,o.rg pue eutl '{uu 1e Sutsue Joeloql ued '{ue ro 'sestuer4 pesee'I eql tnoqe ro 'uo 'ur Bur.'ncco 1e; .uo,rr,*o ro uorJce s.eesser re^o*e[rs qderSe're4 slql lepun uorle8rlqo uotlecutu.'apu,-r,."rr"1 'eessa'I {q sasru;e.r4 pesee-I eqr uo percnpuoc sseursnq equo rrnser oqr s€
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 10 of 30
6IJO '
l?lcJetuuoc Jelluls Jo slosso'l- pelenlls '{1re1ru-'s '.req1o ,{q pe.rrnbe.l 6ureq ueqr ore ocuernsur
'lerJeL., oues oql ur serl-redold
;:?:Tff il?r1il""'"'""J"1t"r"ru*rg:.ff":^ *#;t*i,J;";ffi ,,,":",fr 1;'J#i,,*;H .cuernsur "(ue 'ro ee'e'uo4l ,{ue3o uo,uldo eql ur lr ..ree,{ qcee ,"uo unql i11u"nb"4-"ro; rN r(oo.ooo.o,r)
srelloq puesnoqJu'JJo ssocxo ul olqllcnpap e e^eq lou Ileqs"{cr1od rlltlqnlt ,,r.rr.1:rorrerJoJleqoq uo ro rog ecloJ ur ecuernsur elqecrlddepue Surlstxe '.plle^ loqlo '{ue q],'m i'"t"q1',*" JO
"re^o ssecxe,, tou prn ecueJnsur ,{.reLur.rd st lr leql epr,ro.rd Ireqs pue .(rossar ol elqeldecce u:'ro3 e ur) spornsut leuolllppe se (,,seru-ed pernsul 1"ro,11ppy, eqr,(;e,tr1ce,1o";
""rrr1 ol peqs!urnJ ueoq e^elr seueu
esoq^l slossel pue see'e'gol^1 's;e'eueu' '(ueio'o 'rr.pu.1 'r'otur*u: .srequreur .rrol""r1p 6srecuJo .sleuiled sl! ..rosseJ eureu j[x'"il"':"Hil"J:ffi;!i:liTiH::m*ii;l#1,"1",1'fllXJ,#r:,,ffi uil,;il;;;::;",:, ,,"u, uoilrn eerqJ pue ecuerrncco red (66.66e.eep.7g) s.re11oq uo!r1n o^l3ososruardru,o,^,",l.lJnl::Jll,lr%g:l$i_}n'|1fff qlri'l 'luele^rnbe ro'16963J :'.:'^:l'-"";';- ott prppuels eq1 Burzr;r1n 'esee'I srqr o'uensrnd
""r::l'l:""::ilii::t::ly:ro sesrurord eqt.4o ,(cuedncJo ro esn ,,r"rr.l lri^ ,o,rr"uuoc ur roJo lno Buis,rn ^r,,,o"ri,,n rr",:illXill;lf#ff:ffiirlll lpnlcerluoc Furpn;cur ,ecuernsur ,elilqell 1"r.u"d, lercroturloc u,n1ui", lleqs .tsoc s1r 1u .aesse1 .aruernsul {t!l!qel-| .e
ffilueuecelder llnJ eqlJo (%00 t) tuec.r"a prrpunq euoJo lunoue eql ul ecuernsur ,{gedord .XuJo, jfn^s.red
reqlo pun o.,nr*g "pnn
'su8rs'lueudrnbe,suorlerelJV.)JolA r,r"rrr13o ile uo ur'lureu Ileqs.lsoc slr le.oosso.l .oJuBrnsul ,{pado.r4 r,"rrrr', .O
,
Effil 1.eACVhIVO AIlVNSVJ qNV NOIIVJI.{INhISqNI 'gf,NYUNSNt .A
lNSt^tESdcv 3sv3t
lleqs 1""ff1;j;]'i?f',1ffii';n:ilTr"li:trffilrj::::-',:::ri'^:f i ssoccp rorluoc ro,,u,,r or'rB!, o* o^uq ",iilfi:rossel 'suortprolle.ro
se8ueqc qcns ,{uego Aur>1eu raql 3urj:lll::":"":_arq" ^"" "pLr"l,, ;ffi';;:ffi;ffi::':ffi:U'i:,1iil:lj:H1:11:l:,:1.T::::li:"",;;,;.;il;;;; elqeuos€er esn llsqs rosse.I .poleurutel
o^eq secueqrnlsrp
ffill"iJ::1,:lllliff:f:ilgTn:*:,:k:y::1i1:r:q",,"u,liliill^JuXi:Ti?"ilJ,HlXT:lHli::?:i"i.l:l ;xT"#l:{"Y1"':::::i::i,:.:::i,lfl seesse1 "' """ni*"li l:;l;:;:.i;il:ii:*i:qELlr druur roJ sls'l seslueld eql le sseulsnq s'eosso'l ol ecueqrnlslp r"qio ro uorlarqr^ r.np ."r,ouu.ur'Ji:ffitilnt^Tt:::*;:T
l:Tffi:'fr'"':lJ;H::li:"""^1:::':.'^.T111e-ro o^llcn4suoc e eq 01 paueep oq 10u neqs suorrerererososueucurnsn,rpQrrn,.D,^r'n;::Hn:,?,ff::"ffifii:r;f:;:f",::::*"'ri;*::;Tij::il'"":"':i':jlHfiri,"#,il:',.","ili:T::[iilK:][ lllT:fiii?:1HlffiJ:ii';:'il.il:"J#:j;lff:;:^::t:Y"1:::+il"::ffi'l'i;ffiTJ"':1tr;i',xl',[::Tl'"':,';:iill ::,'il:';,,;:H;::f:T[,Ji:ff'#ijiTff::.ji:::::::::--ffiff:T.':::ff:ff;n'''iT; ,(ue ol suorre.lerle.lo se8uerlc er'ru ot lq8!;
"u, *"u'ulur;;
"i,ols.rosse-I 4.t
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 11 of 30
6llo s
l.N3l,'\l33UDV 3SVEt
pue crosse'I '(q 3ur1r'rm r-rr pe'rordcle lasunoc '(q pettutry eq Ireqs qder8e.red srql .repun suorle8rlqo osroJop pue ,truuepur s.eesser 'uosred '(ue3o qteep lo ssaulll 'frnfut "{iledora
x* "r "s;;p
iun rog rr111q",1 ,o .rr,"1" ,rrrura*, .slsoc .se'eruep .sossor rle
lllf:HT:i?T";:ffi1ffiLH::H:*'j::: l"**: !il1a'";,i"p1oq",nq,',,o,,",,p.s,ocsro.srequ,ou.s,euued srr 'rosse-l ploq pue pueJep "{;ruuepur
'rcerord Jreqs oesser 't"'"irr"j ,* ; Ji;l;#';,::il:1ffi?ir"r':,"H,TJlH:: ql'ep ro sseu11t "('rnfur'e8eruep'lue^e'lueptcce '(ue ol lr.dr'qt1^
"rna1 srr{l Jo uorleururer;o uorlerrdxe eql e^r^rns,pqs pue luewee'r8v slql ol luens;nd eesso'l '{g perrrec oq ol perrnber ro'perrr?c a8erenoc ocu'rnsur eqt,(q pelru.rrr eq rou ,eqs uorrcos stql Jo suorsrrord eqJ 'seosuecrr ro seolr^ul 'slsen8 'sreruorsnc 'r""^o1a,..r. =rr;;";;;d .stue8e .sluenres ,s.rolcerluoc slr
'eessar '{q pesnec suels{s s,1r 'ro '{gedor4'lcefqnS eql o1 eSeuep ,(ue pue oseer srql repun suorleSrqo slr Jo ,{ue jo qcee.rq s,aesso-l tuo'r3 3ur11nsel'(tlllqell pue sullelc'se8eruep'sessor 'sesuedxa'$soc 1le pue,{ue lru,nan pun.uo4 rr"1u.req s,e8eueu,(gedo.rd pue
."i#:;T:liTillll':Hi:n;;J,Tli"ffi:'l;:*;;#i{,, ,o,,"', p,oq pue pu.:"p',(sruruapu .lce,o,d os,e,eqs
ued ur pasnec ueoq e^eq teq-s qreep ro sseurr ',(.rnfur 'a'eu?p ,ssol ;,;ir'.tJ#J:1iTi',f: jl'"'f i#:i11,il,,il:: l]:lrlTlf,3 se'suecll lo 'seell^ut 'slsen8 'sreuolsnc ,see,(o1du.La .sJecgJo .rrrurni-,urnnres ,s.ro1cer1uoc .slue'e slr .eesso_l Jo lcnpuocsr.u InJlll^\ ro ecueErlEeu eqt '{q ued ul ro eloq^ ut pesnac eq ileqs,firJrqer1 ro'urelc,qreep csseulrr .,{;nfur ,e'e.uep,sso; ,esuedxe 'lsoc qcns ueqi!\'soslueld eql uut{l leqlo '{yedor4 lcefqng ,qr.}o rniire rnoqe;o'uo'ur Burrncco (q) pue ls;e8euetu ,{iledo.rd.ro sae"{oldue slr 'rosse-tJo
lcnpuocsrtu rnJilr^\ ro ecue8rJFeu rro-,"8 "qlyo
uo*ri;,;rffij{r:ro^oosrerri\\ asnec,{ue uo{ pue eurl '{ue 1e Sutstle Soereql ued fue .,o :'",'t.r6 peseer oql lnoqp ro 'uo'ur Burlncco 1ey :uoued ,{ue3o qreep ro sseurr .,trnrur .ro ,{yedo.rd ,{ue o1 eEeuep ,{ue .ro; ,$tilqelt ,o .r*,ni, .se8euep,sassol .sesuedxe .rrro, lln pun fun l*,nan pug tuo{ sselurpq sre8eueu '{uedo'rd pue slue'e'see'(o1due 'sreproqereqs:rio'""r'p 'srecuJo 's.requeru .rr;;;i r;,'.;;;;:;;; pue puoJop .,{3ruuepur .rcero:d J|eqS0eSS0.l6se|ctilVSIt{lJoSuoISt^ordeqlo11ce|qni.1nq^Jixqp"ut'od,u,,",l,"11ry,q1"i.@zs
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 12 of 30
JN3IASSUCV 3SV3I
duISIJ3Jaqlaq,{.,(renoce.r3o1q3rr;1epue,{ueoSeolelpuee^Ie,{.(qe.reqJoSSe.]pueeoSSe]@9.s
lueuecuouuoc aql ol rotrd ut e,e't '{eqt uotlrpuoc aules oqr ,{Jlur1ue1sqns orrossor {q p:r"j;rT::iffl:il:ltfi;:ilr:ttl: ,(lldtuord eq o1 e'eurep qons osnec.esuedxe pue lsoc slr le,lleqs rosse.I ,&lensnc rqrgo."urrncco eqlJo et€p eql ruo.ry s,{ep (06) {tau'u ulqll'^' os op ol elq€ st pue e8euep qcns erorser or slcele rossor pepr^ord ueql ,ure.req rno 1es esod:nd eq1 .roy eessel ,(q perdncco puu posn eq Jllls uec lnq e8euep leJJns sesruerd peseer eql '.eosseJ ,(q uorssrruo.ro 1ce,,tue uorg Bulllnsar lou ,,{llensec e 3o uoseer '(q 3l peunsor seq Joorotll esn s,eosse'I pue pe.lreder ,{J1er1ue1sqns ueeq e^eq sesrtuerd peseer eql rrrun ,{lrensec eqlJo acu'rrncco oqlJo elep eql ruo{ ersqe lreqs ruer pue.esee.r srqlJo rue..,ecueul eq1 '{11er1ue1sqns ol rosseJ ,tq parolse.r t"ri*rr4 peseeJ eql pue perredar ,{lldurord eq ]e'lleqs losse'I ueql'peleuturol 1ou ,,
"rnr1 srql;1 .,{ged reqlo eql ol ectlou uoulr,4^ | aq ,{eu eseel srr{t uaql .,&;ensec .qt';o ,"u.rrncco eqt Jo elep oql uo.r3 s,{ep (96) , qcns arolseJ ol lcere lou seop Josse-I pue ,ure,eq
lno los esod,nd oql JoJ eessel ,(q upcJoareql uoruod e Jo sosrruold pesee.I eql leql luelxo qcns ol ,eessol Jo uorssrruo ro luaprcce elqepro^Bun .stueuele eqt ,eru ,{q pe8eruep eq lleqsJoereql uoruod e ro sesruord poseel oql .
JI Eft.u_EE_Tmfr.u-, g S
ro es'e'r srql repun suorleEr;qo srosse.r ,,,oru:..:, j1li, ,",iiljtxf:f:fr1: ffj::: :iliJHl:i:::li:r.'::::l[:jjlff; slesse ro '{uedo,d oql ol^rool lou Ilel]s oossel pue '{uejo.r4 icefqng'eqt ur lsorelur s,rosse-I ol pollru1 eq lr'rrs pup peecxe lou leqs ase'lslqllapun suotle8tlqos'losselloJrosso'IJo'ttttqntt eqr'JatuearossoreqlJo,{uersureEesa8euep,{ueleesloureqspuerepuner0q suotl,Erlqo s'rossel ocloJue ol rosse-l,ol ,tleJos 1oo1 J1eq, ,rrr"1 'es'e-I srrrl repun suorre8lrqo s,rosso.r jo acueurograd eql loJ 'lqell eq ;leqs (,,seriled rossel" eqt ',{Je,r!tce1lot;
auloa.rog eqt 3o ,(ue go see,{oldrue lo srueEe .srecgJo .srolcerp .sJepJoqeJeqs.SJeq[Ueu.s:euiledeqtrloU.JoSSe]3ulstldtuoc,,,q,",'ros.reuuedeqlleqlloN@'s
,{uu.ro3 orqe,r eq rou rreqs rossor ,uo,r,ppe u1 .s.re'eueu ^l"jff:::iil"r" "*",?;i;l[i:jJ;r:j:ffiT,Hi::il#1:H[inil
'slequeu s1t ',ossel Jo lcnpuocsltu lnJlll^\ lo ecue8rlSeu ssor8 eql ,(q ,(11oq,tt pesnec s,-iu,o8ero3 eqt;o ,(ue luolxe eql ol ldecxe i,{pedo:6 nefqng eql uo uosred .lo luednccg ,eassel ,{ue ,{q euop eq 01 pepluo ro euop Burqfue ,(q .ro .ued e erp sestuerd pesee-l eql qclq/v\Jo '(uado':d lcefqn5 eql 3o yed '{uego uotlererre'.ro'uorlcnlrsuoc'ecueuelureru .rreder qEno.rry esr,e,{eLu qcrq,r,r 'Juelu'Auocut lo eEeulep '(ue ,o3 'lo
"Qr'roq1ne.ro,(poq Jelueuu.reno8go rrpro ro ,o;r;r; ,+ro unoc .re,{ ,uorlcerrnsur .orrrls 'lol't ''{uleue crlqnd eq1 3o slce'ocuarlncco lernr'u,(q'sesrruel4 "ql.Io
uno,{ue oluiEu,^og ro au,nrr, .6ur1eeJ sacuplsqns rorlro lo uler'rele^\'se8'uee1s '{q 'ecrn'res lo,{1r1r1n crlqnd xue'*rlri, *,"rnq,u'p-r;qec euoqdelel ,{ue3o uorldnrrelur eqr,(q .aSuure.rp elenbepe '{1ddns ol esnec '(ue ,o3 t.'n1te3 ,{q :surr1i,{, Su,qrnlo ro e8eurap 're;1ur.rds ,tq .ebe>1ee.rq ro ueql ,erg ,uorsoldxe fq pesnec '(uedo'rd 'ro suos;ed ol re^eos1nr{'on ernleu '(ueJo se8eruep.ro eEeuep iun.,o3 orqerr eq lou Ireqs rosso.r .Euro6ero3 eq13o ,(lrJereua' eql Surlrur; lnoqll1ys;e8eueul ,(uedold .ro sfue8e .see,{o1due ,srocgJo ,s.rolcerrp ,s:eugeJ .r.,"pJoq"rnq, .sreq1ueu slr .rosse_I
Jo lcnpuocsltu lnJlll^\ lo ecueErlEeu ssor8 eql ,(q ,(1eJos posnec sr e8euep ro ssol 'funlur .qleop qcns:rrrJun .uos;ad reqlo fue;o srsen3 'seell^ul 'seosuocll 'sreuolsnc 's1ue3e 'see'(o1due slt Jo eesso'r o1 BurFuoleq sosrtuoJd pesee-I eqr urqlr/( ro eplslno ,,g.rodord ,(ue ol '{;nlut 'to e8er"uep lo ssol '{ue JoJ lo :lo^eosleq^ sesnec,(ue uo.r3'uosred.reqlo,{ue io'r"rr"1 3o r"rorrn".ro lua3e.lsen'.eelrnur 'eesuecll 'ee'(o1dua '(ue lo aessel xq peurelsns ro peroJJns eq ,(eur reql re^oosleq/rr ernleu,{ue3o,(.rnfur ,(ue.ro qleep,(ue :3o 1no Sutstre ro o1 lcedser qlm s.reSeuetu .{uedorO pue sl'e8e s:e,{oldure .rr.ag3o ,sJolcoJtp .s.reuged .sleploqeJ'qs .slequloru sll .rosse.l1sute3esulelc[JPse^Ie/\\,,(qeleqeeSSe]pue6JoJ,{e,t.(ueure1q'suodse".rloe|qeI|eqlou|IeqSloSSel@ss
eq rr?qs 7'v rqdene"-4s*ilro qceerq e ruo{ Furs'e Eurpued," or"ri:Iil;;'fiil#:il:jffilJ:,""X'j}lT'ffi#:i;::;jff; lasunoc {q paltglru oq ll€gs qde'r8e'red stql repun suorle8rlqo esueJep pue 6,utuepui s.eesser .ruosuoc uerrr^r,o'd s..rosse1 lnoqlr/v\ pasruroldtuoc ro perilos oq lleqs 7'y qdet1erc4,,q13o qrn".,"q e ulou Eursrre Buriued r; o;;;;u;#;: ffi;res ou
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 13 of 30
6r co /uoss3lINsIA3sUDV 3SV3I
slql l.pun suol*Bllqo sll tuJoJJed 01 eJnlteJ s'eessel ,{q pesnec ,(1aleru1xord ruo.urrlop oql 1e JoJ Josso.r elesueduroc o1 xresseceu:ilfi,#i::rti]rll: J,'i':ii,i';;fffi:,:1i'::^'.,'::;1-'^T;'l ':q,.:*r ,ueu qcns ro lunoue oq, speecxo pre,re ro
.uotlnc0xe
r.Invdso .IA
'ssoulsnq s'aosse'lJo uotldnr.lelut ol enp eessel ,{q pe.reg;ns ssol ,{ue (rr) ilueLudrnbelo s3urqsrurnJ ,seln}xu eperl 'suollerellv 'rlolA s'oessel o1 e8euep (r) ro3 elqrsuodsa.r aq 1ou 11nqr'pun'uo ecuernsur ,tlec 1ou lluqs rosso.l (e) 1nql se6pel,r<,ru1ce eessel 'SuroEeroJ eq1 Surpuelsql!'tuoN 'lslxe esr^\Jeqto tq8ru qcrqrvr uorle8orqns Jo lq8r.r ,(ue e^re^\ ol sB r.uJoJ qrns ur penssl selcllod ecuelnsut Jleqt o^eq qcee Il'qs oesser pue rosseTas?er srql ur peuleluoc eseeler Jo re^re,u\ .req1o ,{ue or uorrrppe ul sl ls^I?'t\ lenlnu stql'1ued e qcns Kq pesnec se8euep Jo ssol uror;3ur11nsar srual Jo s8uru:ueJo ssol rro{ sesre,fue,rocergo lq8r'r qcrq"n ro '(e3eruep Jo ssol eql seJnsut-Jlos Jo ocuernsur qcns repun sJe^oceJ 'ecuernsur qcns se,rec ,{11en1ce e3euep:o ssol eqr Eu'e3;ns '{ued eql lou ro reqleq^\) .repune.reql serqrFnpep Eurpnlcui 'e8ere,ro3 u.rog lercedg-sso.I Jo sesn'J osl eqr repun lsure3e pornsur eq plnoc leql slrrad eql uo{J sesrre e8eurep ro ssol qclq,!\ .fuedord pahng ,qljoued n*Au,lnt,truo" ro urqlr^\ pelecol ,(uedo.rd '{ue o1 eEeruep ro ssol Il3 pue '{ue .ro3 luroJ eq] Suirnp Sursr.re jslueSe
pue- sae,(oldrue Eurpnlcur .reqlo eql lsurege ,uol ro lcerluoc ul
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 14 of 30
6I JO 833SS
JNEI,^,IA3UDV 3SV3I
elll EutlcorrB suorlerelrv roc'osuodxo s'eesso'r 11,fiioora,j;i;;s 'q;r_"':;j;,^il# #j:Tf;filf;:;fi,'fij,J:iTtr
'leJnlcnrls eql lJeJJe qclq^\ suollerellv eqlJo suorgod q'* .,ogo;":rnt or lcere,(etu.rossel .,{gedo.r4
lcerqng eqrJo sruers,(s '&oJes eJll .ro Surqrunld 'ilecrrlcola .1n",u"qrJ* ,1e.rn1cnr1s or{1 lcaJJe suorlelellV eqlgr .renervroq .peprnord lsesrue.r6 peseel eqt le )Jo'4 ol Jossal '(q Surlrrrvr ur pe'r'o'rdde '{lqeuosee.r ueeq ,{lsnorrrJid ,nq oq^ a.,,es eql ereu or rorcerluoc e Jo secr^Jos eq1 e'e'ue lleqs e'ssel pue esuedxe pue lsoc elos s'oessel le eesse.' ,(q epeu-r eq ,eqs eues eqr .suor1e.re1ly ,{uego Burleru eqr ol sluesuoc lossel JI '("eec suollerellv'eq1) suorle're1lv eqlJo uotlcntlsuoc eql Buuolruour ur perlncur srsoc e^rlerlsrurrupe reuorrrppe roJ
iJ,;'il:lffilffi1fjff:H ;:jj:"r:un ^"1,n'3o rro. ,q'os',o*a1 elesueduoc or suorrerelrv eqrro rsoc uorlcnrrsuoc eqr
petncexo aql 3o,{doc e pue 1ru.red,{gedo.r. "H ' qs eesse'I'su:lT^r^e-1v11e Surleroc lc€rluoc uorlrnrtsuoc
lueuecueuuocol .ror.rd pue luesuoc s,Josse, s eessol 'suolleJellv
eqlJo uoucnJlsuocJoqstulnJ lleqs oesso'l 'luesuoc qcns ,{ue.rog F
ep eql roJ suotlecgtceds pue suepd eleldruoclcefqng eqrgo,{1e3es ro slueuero rernrcnrls eql rceJJe ,riy\ suorrerorly pasodo.rd ^""r, ,;,1:.,t:,rtl;lll i, f:ff:,;,';ljl,fili:,; rossel 'le^e'''oq'papr'ro'rd
ipexe;ep ro peuotltpuoc '.pleqqlr^\,t1qeuosea.,un eq rou tri\{ ruesuoc qcrq^\ .rosserJo
ruesuoc ue'rr^\ lotrd eql lnoqll/t\Jooreql ued '(ue 'ro seslLuerd peseel oqlJo uoruod,{ue or ro uo'ur(,,suor1erelrv,, ^leAlrcaJloc)e1rJ eqr ro sernlrnrls spmoqllrg 'slueuleno:drul lecrJlcele ,Bur.trnr Bur;qec elepTuorlel unuuoceleuo uouellelsut uoqqrunlnoqrr,,r Burpnlcut ,slueue,roldrul JoSuoutppe.suol]eJe1le,(ueeper-ue9olesneclouo)eu]Jeq1tOu|JeL|saeSse.].
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 15 of 30
6t lo 6
pue lsoc eqlJo Sulrncul ro luou^ed eqlJo Sutreul s'losso'l Jo selep e^rlcedser eql uo{ ,sseJ sr ro^eqcrq^\ .peil!ured ,{J1e'e,:fi:iTi:H:ll:J:,,I'#:,,1".1,1t::]i,:::i:1"':l-::li:lT.:y,'olu, ,n uo,,,u,,sora,ur q,r,tr reqre'or ,q,r,r\o,eq, uorlceuuor ur
6r",ffi;:,T1,;Tj*J:; eeSSe]JoUoI]coJ|poqtleJo,(qeuop1.ro,rt,(uero3,{1tduo.rd,(ed11eqs,",,.1..,
IN3}\J33dDV 3SV3I
v'L
xlalerpeurur perr?q eq rl?qs uo,r,{cns,e,^"",'r:',:'i#":"I,ffjIJ#I"['r'""J,il,':,ffj1Tffiffi;IT;"#rg:,.;i::]j? ,(q ses[ue.r6 pesee'l eqlJo uorlerocop ro lueue,rorduu ,rotrippn ,uo,rnr"rln .uorlcnrlsuoc ,{ue plnoqg 51o_iru*joq_€- f /
,u ueuu^\:or.rd,s,{ep (g1) uaegg lwel lp rossel enrS llnqr r.rrr1'peldecxe uorleuuapuoc pue Jeol pue J?e,r\ elqpuoseel .uorlrpr
lsoc olos slr te pue,ecue8r;rp enp ll" qttm pue qlr^ quoJ lleqse( Onp ll3 qlri\\ pue qll/v\qiloJ .esuedxe pu? lsoc elos s,oosso.l lB ,
plnoqS 'suorlerellV fuu3o uorlcnrlsuoc eq1 onulluocsrp ol .Jo^o
ro p0uorlrpuoc .pleqqlr,^^ ,,{Jqeuosee.lun eq ollou .luosuoc uegrrly\lssel fq uolsrn.ledns o1 lcefqns eq Ileqs pue joereql uorlcrpsunlr8er .sacueurplo .sme1 .se1n1e1s e;qecrldde lle qrr^{ ,(ldruoc l1eqsrossel,(q penordde suorlecgrceds pue sueld eql qlra ecueprocce
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 16 of 30
6tlo0l
rNSt^l33UCV 3SV3t
,i,*:iil:::1T:n::,fl'J:lni'::H::::::"'"","*:i':::: y:rq^{ 'ecu',su, qc'e u! ,uosuoc ueilrr,!\,orrd s,.,osso-r ,noq,,M,li]l11l,l:j:":ll:j,:fl ul','q :1 lce qcns q'n.y ."""1 ;;;;;#;il;;'peroncco eq ol sestuor6 eql lru.r.red roJooteql y,, un,n r ;",;r';il;;;;;';;';:,i, il:ffiffiTi S0Sl[UelJ ettt rorrpd .f,rro rn,,- ^16^^,,.^rr..,^ --
;:":,"'" :l:*::1,fTj::':"1'::11"*:: *:u"" "1^"q'o ';;t;;;:il;J;:;;ffif i:iil:,]:X':LlTl""tfi:: i;?-"il jl ..{11celrpur.rof11cerrp,|l3qSeeSS3'lJo""u3,,,n,o,J,,liil;;;;"""J:,';l*^iil
DNIIISISNS T INShICISSV'XI
'uollelueuncop Suruoddns qlr,rr JoJereql oJroAUl s,rossal se^leoer eesse-l rege s'(ep (og) ̂utqr utqll/t\ lsoc elqeuoseer qcns rosse'I ,{ed 1leqs eosser .rue^e reqrre ul Joerew lsoc erqeuoseer eql JoJ ''sseJ a8reqc puesJuqoq s,oessel uo srtede; pte,
"rJn* inr pue secuels.uncrrJ or.rr ur erqeuoseeJ sr ecrlou ro^eleq,n eessel e,rrF Ilst{s losso'l 1nq 'pert nbe'r eq lleqs ecllou ,s'(ep (6g),{ilr qlror.rd ou 'ueq1 ',{:esseceu ,{J"p,p"rr, ,rn s;rede: qcns,(ue ,uorurdo e;qeuosee.r s'rossa'I ut
"{cue8rerue uB ul 3l's'{ep (69) '{u1q1 urqrr/h pelerduoc eq flqeuosee, lourn, tg .r'ude, BJo ernleu eql ol enp,ereq/h 'popuelxe eq 1;eqs por,ed '{Bp 0e pres 'uortelduoc or eues Surlnc"roro rrruld,r; r;;;;, o* *^ro ror),{urqr pres urqrr,r .rrude.r ol pocueuuoc seq eesso'l leql pepl^old Jooreql lsoc elqeuoseer eqt roJ eesse'I eS.reqc pueJleqeq s,oesse.l uo s;reder pres eleu ,{eu 'repunareq eneq '(etu 1r slq8l'r 'reqlo '{ue ol uolltppe ut 'rosser 'roJareqr peau eqr Jo rosser uo{ ecrrou uerlrr,ruo ldrace.r .rege s,{pp (0i) '(1'rr q1 ur qlrnr elcluv sl t{l repun eesse'l '(q epeu aq or pelr nbe.r ,r,nd' eqt 3o ,{ue e>1eur ol ileJ 1lnq.
".rr"1 g; .peldecxe uorreuruepuoc pu? r'el pue reo^ olqeuoseor 'eessel ,{q peldecce ueq/y\ sp .rrede.r pue ,l,1,puo, pooE se ui i"r;{;;;":i;J;
";;;;lrn, .rrn"-, slqlJo uotleululel eql le 6ll€tls eosso'l pue'eesso'l ,(q.ro3 pred oq lleqs',uor1e1nur s,eesso.I ln ro ru"ruo" s,eessel q'^\ sesrtueJd pes'e'I eq1 uodn lo ul eq '(eu oqlt uoslad '{ue,(q .ro eessel ,{q sesrurel6 pesee-I eql ol euop,(rnfur ro a8er-uep Irv
.sosruerd peseo-l eql Eurseel roJ uollereplsuoc eq13o ged se poreplsuoc oq lreqs pue 'eesse'rJo esuedxe eqr r€'eq Ireqs sesruerd eqr qrr/r\ uorrceuuoc ur perrncur sesuedxe ocuuueluleu loTpue slreder'sluerue,ro.rdur ile 'rpeorsu,'pun ,"po3
;,n,3 r,rro3,1nJ eqlJo zv6I pue ft61 ,(r)T,t6L suollcesJo suotstnold eql lepun esuedxe s'Jossel 1e sltedel tlnt ol rqa,, 11e se^re^{,(qereq ,rro1 .peleururer seq uorldnr.relur aql Jtlun '(ep ssoulsnq o^llncesuoc (uu) vunog et'|l ulo{ ropunoreq ereq? ileqs lueu rua^s qcrq^\ ur ,s,{ep sseursnq e^rlncesuoc (t) earql u?ql eJolu JoJ lsPJ llBt{s sesltueJd oql utqll'{\ sseulsnq s'eesse'lJo lcnpuoc aql qlt^'\ ocueJoJJelur Jo IroA\.rreder eql sselun ureroql lueudrnbe lo sacueuoilndde'se'rn1xg eql ol ro ur -ro {gedor6 rceiqng oql_ro seerv uor.uruoJ eql .sesruerd posee.r aqrJo uoruod '(ue o1 'ro ut lueue'rordul Jo uolleJolle 'ecueuelureru 'srreder ,{ue uorg Fursre ssaursnq ,,rrrr"r qrrA\ ocueloJJolur Jo o1 ,{lnfur '{ue 'ol lcedse, qlt^ luerJo lue.,ol€qp ou eq lleqs eroql pue 'roJ olqprl oq lou ilBr{s rosso.r .repuneroq sesn poillr.urad ueqt reqro.ro3 uosled qcns '{ue lo eessel ,{q sesr ue.r6 pesesl eqlJo ,(cuedncco.ro'rrn;o ,ruunr .ro ,{cuedncco Jo osn eql ,(q ro ,seesuacrl Jo srolrsr^ 'slue8e 'sJolseJluoc 'see'{o1due 'slue^l's JleqlJo ,{ue lo 'eessel ,"pu"n ,o q8no.rql Bururrelc uos;ed ,{ue ro eessel3o acua'rlBeu.ro suolssl.uo'slceeql'{q peuolseccoro pol'llsseceu slueuecelde.rrosrreder rernlcnrrs ile pue xuego lsoc eql roJ .pu?uep uodn ,.rossa1 esrnqruler ll?qs eossel 'uourppe ul 'roJorotll ecro^ul ue3o ldrece.r3o sxep (6g) ,{utqi ,iqrt^ ruJx lnuo,1,ppe sB eesso.l ,{q.rog pred oq lleqs lossel '{q peu,o3,ed rlo'nn lle'lue^e qcns ul -eesse-lJo lunocce eqlroJ pueJoJrprroq uo ecueuolureu qcns u.ro3.red ro slrede.r qcns ')Btu o1 'uotlelduoc ol eues eql elnceso.rd fllueEgJlp ol slleJ..ues Eu,cu"ruro" i"gn eesso.rgr ro,por:ed,{ep (ot) ue} qcns Sullnp ecueueluleu qcns uroJ,ed 'roTpue srredeJ qcns ereul or ecueuuoc lou seop eosse'rJr 6os op ol uorlcore srr Jo ecrrou ue,rr/n 's'{ep (9 1) uol oesse'l 3ur'rl3 uodn 'lqErr eqt e^eq Ileqs rosser 'esea'r srql repun suorle8rJqo s,oesse.r o1 luensrnd Joereql ued,{ue ro 'sesl.'oJd pos€e-l eql uleluteu 'loTpue slteder ereu o1 slce;8au ,o ,"rn;r, easse.l JI
'uorrrpuoc eJes pue ,{relrues ,upolc € ur pue ''rtedel pue 'rep'ro poo8 ul sosttuord pes'oJ eqtgo syed 11e deel 'asuedxe ,]""rr"1 re .1eqs eesser .sesruerd poseor eqrJo uorrrpuoc aq1 Sutlcedsel eesso'l ol epBru ueeq e^€q 'uoeleq pesropue lo urereq peureluoc se ldecxe ,suorleluese.lde: o51 T.r..rffi[ l.g
SUIVdSU'UIA
'peqslulnJ set;ddns lo sletloleul ro'peru.rog.red roqel 'euop rro^r qcns o^eq or uorssrured s,losso.l peurelqo eesse.l lou lo reqleq^\
"(uedo'r4 lcefqn5 oql lo s€erv uotu.'oc eql 'sesru:ar4 pesee-I eql uo eesso-IJo runocce eqr roJ euop 'orn ,{ue3o ecueulo3lad qll^\ uollceuuoc ul lo oesseJJo lsenber
"q in ,o o, 'p"'q'urn3 sarlddns ,o ,1n,r"pr ro .peur.rog.red roqel Jo rlo^{ JoJ sulelc ol poleler '{e'tt xue ul roJo 1no Sutstre asuedxe pue,(.lnfur 'e8euep'1soc 'sso1
11e pue ,(ue lsure8e sseltur€q rosso.l ploq pue pueJop "{3ruuepur
llsqs eessel 'lueu leuolllppe se '.pueuepgo sfep (og),futql ulql;^.,orrr1 ol oesso.r ,{q pred eq lleqs
,esuadxe
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 17 of 30
uossStINE'\ISEUDV ESVSI
repro unoc eql qclq,r uo olep oql ol loltd eurl ,(ue le ue^r8 oossel ol ocrlou ̂q posrJJOXe eq ol .uolldo pue lqBF .ror.rd eqt a,reqHfi::'#:'#:l','"T"ffi:l?j,iTj'JjJ:i::":i,':i:':j: i:-"^I,l:1'ne ror uorc!psrrnr ,ue,edruooro ilnoc e o1 serldde eosse.r qcrtr'r\ uo elep eql ol.roud s,(ep (61) uel ueql reler lue^o ou ur lnq ,rrr" ur"r"o:il5;;;;#;:#H::lj|,i:|]:il:il] ueql lelel ou eesso-l ,{q rossel o1 ueirr8 eq lJeqs
.osee-I eql ,.pun ""u"..ro3red
eln1n; sll Jo eeu8rsse pasodord oq ,{q peqsru.rn3 eq 01 .rusrnsse elunbepe eqt (c) pue '1ueu,u3rsse pesodo;d pue reJJo eqtJo suorlrpuoc pu' surel eqlJo Ile (q) ,eeuSrsse pesodo;d eqlJo sserppe pue ou€u eqt (e) quo3 Burges rueruu'rsse p"rouor;"qr3o ecrrou ueql .oesser 01 erqeldecce surrel uo eseeJ srql 3o lueuuEtsse ue ldecce ol leJJo apu euoq e peldecce 'o eppu seq oq^ir1rrr.,o uorrro xun oi "io3
,trlonrlueg eqlJo suorsrnord eql ol luensJnd eseel srql 'uSrsse pu' eunsse ol sesodord .,o 'u8rsse o1 sesodord pue seunsse'(uorssessod ur lorqep se eessa., lo aelsnrl e reqloq''' "(ctdnrlueq
ul rosseccns s,eesse'l uorlces srql 3o sesod.rnd.roj Burpnlcul) eessel pue ,(,,epo3,(c1dn.r1ueg,, eql) pepueue se'epoc sel€ls pellun eqlJo ll ellrr repunJorler roJ oessa-l lsureSe ro rq'pe1g sr uorlrled e31 T-clrlnrit@. 1,6
uorleuruJel qcns lou to leqloq/y\Jo sselpreSer ,eseel stqlJo "",r"",r;::T;;":J;"# seseelqns requnJ lJe pue) es€elqns qcns leql (q) pue .asee_l slqlJo suorsrnord aql ot e€ eql roJ Surlrrrvr ur eerSe 'eseeJqns qcns ol uo,ripuo, e se 6il3rrs sesruord e{lJo uorfor peuroJ;ed eq o1 ged s,sesser uo peureluoc ureJeq srueueerEe pue'suoq-rpuoc.srueue/ 'lueuJo
lueu'(ed oqlroJ oessel qlrlt '(11ulenes pue,{11urof alqni1 ,rn.,,"r'pue eq ileqs pue eseer srqlrepun eesse.IJo suorle'rlqo 1;e e[UnSS3J[3qs.JoSSolueq1Jeq1o..repuneleqlSeJe1uIS'3eSSa.][email protected]
'(oo'oos,zs) srelloc perpunH e^rJ puesnoqJ o,ru paecxe 01 lou tuosuoc s,rossel Eurrrnba.l eseelqns ro lueuu'rssy pesodo.rdK;ene3urssecord3o1socS.JoSSo.l,rorunoueeJqeuoS3eJoqlloSSo.lot,{edIIeqsoeSSe-J@s6
o1 uorle'rlqo oql ruo{ eesserro rosseccns ^*,::::,r-J:;:ilT?,H:',',X,;Jl"l"l,tjH:::;lTJ,;;::::l'^'ffi::lJ,:r;; 'ewe.l srtll repun eosso-l '(q peuroS,ed eq o1 uorleSr;qo rue go eesse.I'e^orre, ;";; ;;";;;* ," ,""r"trssy ,{ue ereu ol s,eassa.r 3o 1q3r'r eJo esBo'I sltll ul uollscgrceds ou pup ;."rr"'1 ,(q esealqng ro lueuu8rssy xue oi ,lrr"1 ,(q luesuoc op E355ffi o111 7.6
,(lquuosee.r uo,r?rurorur 11eso ldlecer .rage s,(ep,(sr),eeuu uru.,,t .;T;1ff:rJ;^:li::,::Xr:J:i:r#fft:J,ffilff::"r"r'Jll'tls lossel 'ssaulsnq s1t 'to luedncco ro eesselqns 'aeu8rsse
l.soiora aql Bu1u.recuo" rr"ni", rtqn*rn"r,(eu .rossel se uolreurroJur reqlo qcns pu? uolleuloJul lercueuU qcns (p) pue '.oseelqns ro tueuru8rssy pesodo.rd "qr:o
^oo" e (c) ,sesruerd eqr ur uo pelrrec eq ol sseulsnq s'luedncco lo s'eosselqns s,eeu8tsse pesodora eqrJo ernleu eq1 (q) 'luedncco ro oesserqns ,eeu'rsse pesodo,d eqlJo Oueu eqt (u) epnlcut lleqs oseelqng 'ro lueuu8rssy cgrceds n'Jl tu.ruo, s,rosse-I roJ eessel ,(q lsenbe.r,(uy E5lib[ 9.6
eSeolqnsJolOJSu?Jl.,""n,ojil:,#:;ilif,l;Hnr",L"ffi,ii""'ll.Ji'ii
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 18 of 30
INEI^I33UCV ESVEI
'eesse.lxqsestue,4eqlul pellelsut suotleJelrvrorro^A s,eesse-l erorserrorrede; ol uorl€Frrqoou e^Pq lleqs lossel l,lll'ro^e/\\oq 'peprno'rd los op o1 ,{1lue811!p peecoru rl"r..rs pup aues eql prrnqel o1 pele8r;qo eq ,eqs rosser ueql 'uollcnrlsep 'ro e8euep3o olep oLll tno{ st{luou (9) xrs urqtrm pe.rreder ,(l1er1ue1sqns eaeuep' j1e'qtr,*' erqeseer epeu eq uec sesrueld peseel eql pue sesluerd pes'e'I eql o1 '(1eJos pell.ull st pu€ acuernsur s,rossel ,{q pe,enoc sr e3eruep eql3; (e)
SCYhIV( T NOIIJNUISSq'IX
SSXVI'X
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 19 of 30
.LN3t 33UCV 3SV3-t
secu'lsqns snoplezeq ou uleJuoc 'yede en soslruerd peseol ot{l qctt{^\Jo xuedord lcelqng eqr'e8peJ,uoLr) s.oosso.rJo lsoq eqr ol 'pu€ sesltuord pos,e'I eq1 'eleg luatueJuetuuoJ eqlJo se'leqr oesse-l ol sluerre/( pue slueserde, xqe,eq rosse.I Tossdfft. 7.71'tee'{(1)euoSopor'rederoJoseolstqlJouolleutuilelrouorle;rdxeoqro^r^rnsil?qsuorrcessrqlrepunsuorp8rlqos,eosse.I
.osee.r slqlJo I'u'lol eq1 8ur'tnp s,noco l,tll uollces slql ropun suotle8rlqo sr! Jo qc€erq pe8elle ro qceerq's,oesso.r or Eurle;e.r ro uo{ Eursr.re (slueuresrnqsrp pue seeJ s,,{euroge elqpuosear EurpnJcui; r.rura*, pul slsoc.se8euep:r"rroJ .sorlrlrqerl .slrns.spueruep.sr.urelc 'suollce 11e pue '{ue lsute8e pue ruo{ sselulleq rosse.l proq pue puoJep ',!ruruepur o1 see.r3e pun s"Breqcs,p ,seseerer ,(qereq eesser
"{'rerluoc eql ol eseel slqt u1 3u1qilun Suipuel'qt,^roN ,,'secuelsqns snoprezeq,, sp pegrsserc ere (ure.reql sluerper8ur ro) suelr pres lou ro leqlaq''' secuJo ut esn '{reuolsnc roJ peldecce ,{11e.reue8 suell Jo selrlruenb
"1q"1,"n" {lJercreuuoc qcns or ,{1dde lou ;leqs pelelndrls e^oqeuleJeq se ecuelsqns snoplezuq '{ue ,,e.ro1s,, or rou ,o,r,"nord aq1 '(.,smn-l'lnrur*uorr,,ru3,, ,,{;enrlcolloc) suor:eln'e.r ro s^{EI leluoruuorrnue elels ro lerepal r{cns roqlo .ro ..bes
le I096:"", .3.g.1 ZV ro icy,{ttilqen pue uorlesueduo3 ,esuodseg
lelu'l'uuolt^ug entsueqerduoc eql "bes 'e t069'cas'J's'n zt) 1cy,(.renocag uollnnr"ruo3 secrnoseu eql ropun,{lrttqert ro'$leued ol esr'r 3uJnl8 ols€'nn lo secuetsqns rnoprnrnq rue.+o se,i,luenb elqeiloJer sesrtuerd pes'er eql uo{ ro uo eseerer ro e8'reqcsrp "{Jnq'e'ro1s'e1eJeue3
lou lleqs ".rrr1
'sosruold p"rr"1 eql uo suorlerado sseuisnq sil Surlcnpuoc u1 ,56ssEfffi- 1.71
SJNYI'IdhIOJ -IVJNSWNOUIANS'II X
or rr{Fr.r eqr e^eq reqs oesse-l pup rurer eqr11rea,( rspr eq} u",r"o,;r';":1""1r"r,.;::j'f::":ri'ifijlfflL:,T"T,:t:;IJ#1: 1u0^e 'ql ul sostruerd pesee-l eqt pllnqer o1 uorle8rlqo o, tnnq 11"qi rossa1 'Buro8e:og eqlBurpuelsqlr.&uoN (r{)
'pe;rq Eurqlequo uorlcnrlsep uodn Bur.rrqSo uorleuruJrelroJ Eurprno,d (Dttot pue (dzE6[ suotlces apoJ Ir^rJ eruroJrreJJo rgeueq eql se^re^ eesso.r (E)
reqlo ro oru PJo llnser eql se lued leuolllppeJo sulolt ro seS.reqc.reqlo ro lueu Jo lueuel?qe ,(ue eq e.reql ,,"Ur r:"r':;:;H::ffi: es'.l slql ''{lerluoc aql o1 pepr'tord {1sse,dxe uroteq se ldecxE 'uorrrnrrr"p .ro eEeuep slr or roud persrxo qcrq^{ leqr or renbe rseor le uolllpuoc e ol pue rouuetu e ur lueudrnbe pue s8urqsrulnJ'sernlxrJ eperr'suorlerolrv'rro^A s,eosse.r ecelde.r puerreder ,€qs eosse,r ueql'sesluerd poseo'l eql spllnqer lo s:tedel losse'I pue <e^oqe pepr,lord se pelpurrurel lou sr espe.I srqrJJ 0)
lsnruopeep'(uesoaercgeueq '(ue3o slq8t.r eql or Fefqns rosso'I or pled aq pue o1Buo1eq,,"u:11:::;T;?T:ilti:::iltl$ '{uu ro xiledo,d lcafqng eqlJo uollcnrlsep ro ol a8euepJo uosee.r fq pred ecuelnsur,(ue uo.r; speeco.rd eq1 (e)'see'(o1due'rosluaSeslr'eassa13os1ce
lnJllr/rlroocua8rl3eu eqt uo{ pollnser uor}cnrlsep;o e8euep eqlJr luaueleqe qcns ou eq lleqs orol{l 'raqunJ 'pepra'o'rd pue '(gedo.r6 lcefqng "ql
,o r"r,*'d pos'e-I oql .espo.I srql or rcedser qlri'' rosse-l '{q peurelureu ocu?rnsul etuocul sseutsnqJo speecord "qr
rog "]q"rlnor.,
pu' roJ pelesuedruoc sr Joeroql lunoue eql reql ruelxe eql ol ldecxe luouel?q? qcns ou oq lleqs eraql lnql pepr,rord lernldecer luenbesqns-o1 lcefqns eq Ileqs poreq? os lueu eqlJo uoruod ou puP 'olqeseel operu or€ sesltuord eqlse outl qcns lllun 'rosse'I ,{q peururelep flqeuosee.r se'',tleleuorpodord apqe Ileqs rueu 'uotlcnllsep ro e8euep '(q pepege ,{JluecgruErs sr sesruerd eql Jo esn sreosse-1 ueq,tr porred ,{ue Burrnq (p)
tt€r.ts easso'r pue porred,(ep (os),gxrs qcns urqrr,r oesser ,!1rou l1eqs rosse.r ,".^r";::ff'Ji:l:ifi::Tl::i1"fffi:JHr:;r: lcefqnS eql lcnrlsuocer ot rcele ol tqEr-r eql a^eq rleqs rosse-r leq1 're^e,r\oq .peprno.rd :ec40u qcnsJo epp eql rege s,{ep (og) ,futql ulqllA\ J'qlo eql ol ecllou ueDtJ'n^ Surnr8 '(q es,ol stql eleururor,{eu rossel ro oosse'I Jeqlre pue uorlcnJlsep ro eEeruep qcnsJo 01ep aql leue s'{ep (69) '(1xts utqlt,o' eesse'I ,(gr1ou 11eqs .rossel 'serldde e^oqe (q) .rou (e) qder3ered reqlreuJl (c)
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 20 of 30
JNEt^{33UCV 3SV31
UOSSS'I AS S]VS'AIX
t{lr1'. uortceuuocurspr€^,\e pu'luer.euocur .soa?u,,€p,uotrpsuoduoc ,p pu: (ue o1 peJ1r1u.
"1 ,,"ulttJfiif ffi::;Jillt:T?,il,j ul uleuel llPqs esPel slql'stlluotu (t) eerql usql ssalJo porred e.ro3 icuedncco lnru"rurrnoE n ,{q u"rlnrro peuuepuoc ,{;r.re.rodure1 eqlleL|Ss3sIueldeq13oped,{ue.ro11e3r..(tel1uoceqlo1JoeJeqsuotstnoldeqt3o,{ue3urpue1sq]r,[email protected]
lal Ileqs esea.1 srr{l ,ureuop lueurtueJo remod eq13o esrclexe eql
uerd posee-l eq13o ped,{ue ro 11eg1 .ffiiru5{ilo__g-@E
t.f l
NIVhIO(I INSNII IS'IIIX
'esea'lln suorle8rlqo flruuepur s,Jossel .,euelre,tt pue uorlelueselde.rrrsue (slueuesrnqslp pue saoJ s,feuJo11e olqeuospe.r Surpnlcur)rrelc .suorlce
ll3 pu? fue lsureEe puB ruo{ ssoluleq eosse,I ploqJeJluoc eql ol osee.I srql ur Burqilue Eurpuelsqlrmlou .pue ,s,,ne1pleeq ol pJezeqe eleetc pl noc lo seleelc ecuesa.ld esoq^\ else,v\ Jo
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 21 of 30
6l lo 9l
INShI3EUCV 3SV3I
'uoll?ulproqns'{usolenlceJJe 01 losso'l lo eose8uor^ ,{ue ,{q perrnber ,(lqeuosuar eq {eu leqt srueunrrsur ro srueuncop '(ue:enrleppuporncoxorosse'luo.glsenbergos,(epsseursnqio,r""ri,ir,^"r,roreurrr.uo+reqseessel
(q) r,/yr durt u1 etull tuo+ leqs eessel (q)
ro ecue^\olle luouqslqrnJer 'ecuennolle luerue^ordut eesso'I pepunJun ,{ue go luaru,(ed eqr roJ alqell 1,rrfolln8ttcolelluls
ro:rosser rosseccns qcns ol pere^rlep,(11en1ce sr 1!percJo rorer qcns ro pred sr ,(1.en1ce lrsodep,{t!rncas qcns lllun pue sselun 'llpercJo .lepeJ ,(ue;o repuorlns ro lrsodep ,qirncas ,(ueJo tueu,{ede; aql loJ elqetl (,r)
iluesuoc s,Josselrosseccns qcns lnoqlt^\ epeuJ eseel srqlJo len{euel Jo lueupueue.uorlecurporu ,{ue,{q punoq (,rt)
rossoccns qcns ol elqelre^e epeur {11en1ce ,,{lenllcedsar ,spJe,r\e uorleuuepuoc lo ocur ,(;qeuoseer uec s;reder qcns leq'uelxa eql ",
r1"" i"f .rll';,;;;.;",r,no.rd eql ol J'.{lo Jo e;g ,{q eSeuepJo lrnsor e se sesrtuoJd eql o1 srreder pue .eseal srr{1 repun ros srreder 'ro3 rdecxe sosrtueJd or.r1 01 slueuenordrur ereu 01 JO 1.ro,,n ,{ue u.ro3.red ol uorlei
:lossel lsure8e eneq '(euaessol qctq/y\ slesJJo roJJo-les 'ur€rcrelunoc .r.ure1c .asuegep ,{ue o1 lcerqns (tt)
i(uorssruo ro lce qcns Jo ecrlou sanrB eessal pue lsoJelur s,Josso.l 01 spoeccns Jossel rosseccns qcns uaqiv\ elep eqt puo'{eq senulluoc uolssltuo lo lce qcns tuelxo eqt o1 ldecxa)'.rosso-rJo uorssr.uo ro lc?,{ue.rog elqer; (r)
suo,rrpuoc 'sruror oqrro ;1e uodn oesser o* ,":,:i:i:HfiilJ::::,"i'F[ l:l],f:"J,::ffJ:'J:Jff"jil:ffi:::i,il: esee'I srt{llueuuJoDe qcns uodl .lcedsel letJel€ut,{ue ur eseal ,,q1 ,rpun slq8rr s,eessa.l 1ceg3e{les,enpelolcedsel Jerreleu,{ue ur ese'l slql lepun suorleEr;qo s,eosse.l es'ercut '6oseo.l srqlropun a1qe,{ed luou eqr es'Orcur rou op suorlrpuoc pue.surel qcns pepr,to.rd 'rossa'I .ro ae'e'po6l qcns,(q pernbel aq ̂eu se suorlrpuoc pue s.urel Jeqlo qcns Burureluoc pue luor.uurolle qcns Eurcueprne lsanbe'r '{Jqeuosee; '(eu ,ossel rossoccns qcns l'ql ruetunJrsur erqeuos'eJ ,{lJurcreu*uoc ,(ue .renrlep pue elncexe {;1druo.rd ll'qs ''ssel 13ql '.Je^e^{ot{'peprno'rd
lole'req tce3ge anr8 o1 ,1u"tn4rur rorrunJ ou errnbe.l pue e,rrlelado-JJes erp I.sr uorrcos srr.rl go suorsrnord eqJ .esge"I srql ropun rossol ,n rorrrl rorrrrrn, qrn, f"r,uaorer pue ol pauroDe e^eq 01 poueep oq lleqs oesso.l <os€ol stql lopun lselelul s'eosse.l eztuSocal ol pu'lueuuJoile s,eesse'I rdacce o1 iua*""rgn uolrrr/r\ s,rosse.I Josseccns qcns uodn pue ross''l rossoccns eq13o lsenbe, oql lP uaql 'e3e8ilol ,nnou ro pr"p n3o ,{.rerJ1ap eqt ro uorlce ernsorceroJ.ro uorssessod q'no.rqt leqleqih '.eseeJ slt{lrepun rosso'lJo slq8r'r eqt ol pooccns 11eqs,Qr1ue.ro uosred rrqlo iun ro rosse.-, ,ee8e8go6l eJt (p)
sueeu "(s)'rosse'I" pue es'3fuoru eJo reptoq roqlo ro oelsnrl 'ea'e'poru fue suueu ,,tr)r.anauoi,ilil,l:fir r::J.fiH,'r:iljr,::; ro slueupueue'slueuelddns'suotsualxe'slenneuer lle pue',(qereqt peleerJlserorur proqeseer eql pup,,Q-redor4 lcefqngeqrBurlces,e pelncexe eq JeueoJeq '{eu qcrq'tr 'ro Sutlstxe '(1lue;.rnc esueJ 3ur,(lrepun Jo oseor punorE ,{ue sueeru ,,ewe-J ro,edng,, :JopunoJorrl 'peu s'cue^pe pue 'loJeJeql suollnlllsqns 'oleJeql Jo Joereql slueuecelde, pue suorr'prrosuoc .suorlecgrporu ,slueLupueue 'slueuelddns 'suotsuelxa 'sle'''euel
llB pue 'esee'I -rorredng ,{ue ro 'ureJeql elelso ro lserelur s,rosse.I .ro .Burplrng errr lceJJp reuealeq Jo 'nnou '{eru qcrqa'r luouncop Surcueug Jeqlo Jo ernluepur rsn.rr 'e8e8uou ,(ue sueeru ,,(s)e8e8go61,, .spored ernc pue ecrrou eJqect;dde reue pelncun st qclq'{\ oesseJ '{q tlne3ep eJo asec eql ur rdecxe osee-r srqr (q peleerc ,(cueuel eqr qrnrsrp ol rou Furrr.r,r ut peerSe eABq lleqs lsolelul ul Jossoccns sll ro tosser qcns 01'eJqecr;dde se 'ro eres ernsorceroJ e ur Jeseqclnd,{ue.ro rseJelur ur losseccns s1t 'ee8e31'ro14 qcns leql peprnord lselolul ur rosseccns slr lo Josser qcns ol 'eJqecrldde sB.Jo eres ernsorcoJoJ B ur reseqc;nd fue ro lserelur ur srosseccns sll 'eeEeEuor qcns oi ,roun ttnqr;;;;;"rr1dde se ,o.r.1 .ro ee6e3yo6l fue3o lsenbe.r oqr' .pu€ .esee1rotradn5,,(uepuese3e3go61lleo1eleuIpJoqnSpuB1ca|qns,,".n"1.,,q1IsI
NOIIVNI(IIIOSNS 'AX
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 22 of 30
INEIA3EUCV 3SV3I
or cNlrv'If,u ssrndslo ''v do Norrnrgsau *"'Jrti8i+Il_1"l,'#$l$Hil $t:'r?3iiifJ#l ONV S.UOSSS"I dO USAIVA\ V SSINIIISNOf, ASNV'IJ NOII\'UUSUV SIHI IVHI (INY NOIIVUilSUV cNloNIs or (''roNacv srvrs uo'lYusqs-{ v do NorrJr(srunf g^rsnrJxa sHr NIHrr/t\ gs or grnryrs AS OSflldJSOdd ugrrYt^l ANY Or ouvSsu Hrra rascxs) r*r^rroiy srHr .{o NorrvNrhrusr uo HJYaug 'gf,NYl^Iuo'{usd 'NoIJJnursNoJ 'Artoltv^ 'nto'orsur-"ir*, sHr uo ,rtrtgtnggucv sIHr H,I^' Notrf,gNNof, NI uo 'or SNlrv'lgu'-{o rno cNIsIuv swrv.lf, gunrn,{ ANv Jrl,rsns or xsdcv sssss'I oNV uossst 'trttgt'ugaucv
sIHr cNtNcIS Ag rvHr aNvrsugoNn sssssr oNy uossa-r.NOIIYUUSUV
SSSSNf,SIC Hf,IH^\ 9I NOIIJSS SIHI ANVISUSCNN ANY OVSd SAYH SgSSg.I qNV UOSSS'I
"'neJ elqectldde repun pe/dolle ro rol'rllqre eql ,{q pe.rep.ro osrihreqro se ldecxe ,ecueprne3o uorleluesard
ffr:1'ffHir:ti"ililifi1l}r'X||*]o,,"uno" u,r\o sl, 3o esuedxe ,q, ,nrq rrnq, iuno q,ng .,orer,qre eq13o s,e,trod
.r o' u o r rc u n l u r r,n u,,, I ", o .;-;il;;;, ;:i:i:iffi ]' ::j: #lill l?:llfi ,fl::: pelrnber ro rolerttqle eql ,{q peleplo est,rloqlo ssolun ,slsoc uorl€rlrqre IIB lllds,(11enbe I {g peuoddns aq ol seurrurotep rol€rlrqr€ aql qcrq/K pue serued eql ,(q pelsenbe.r sr q pre^\E ol pegrulad eq ll?qs lolerltqle aq1 .uorurdo eqtgo ued qcee Eurpoddns IcBJJ Ileqs pu? paDrr.uqns senssr ll€ eptcep IIsrls trsnssr lleqs rolerlrqre eql .rotgrlrqre
"qifq 1' )q llBqs qclq'a^ 'prelv\e pue uorurdo ueltrr,r e
ul qUoJ les sB Suorlelrr.ull Jo selnlels elqecrl loslruerd l€sPe'I ereq^\ elels eqlJo s^\€l aql
e qcrq^i repun slrr.url eurl oqJ .uorleJlrqJr Eno'rq eq '(eu,(s'renorluocJo utelc'elndsrps!qJ 'rueuee.r'y srqr Jo^qceerq rueurur.ur ro peuereerqr 6r'nrce sserppe o1 uorlcunru, ?il:H:!::ffill,i:ru"t","J,,Hlil:; Sututellsel '{,erodulel e-Sutnsst *o.,g uo'l,iprr.rnf rueledruocJo unoc n iu,lrrn.ro se penJlsuoJ oq prnoqs elerlrqre o1 lueruae,'e srql lnoqeBurqlop'ssaco,duollelllqJe"ql3ouollnrlrn{roasnqeJoJSuorlcuesJouorlrsoduraqlro.suorrcunfurlueuerured.roleug3o.cuensst 'se8eLuepSo
lueu'(ed pue 'ecuerulog,ed cgrceds '1ue*ipnt"ilnrrn, 'uorrpl*urr
rnoqrr^\ .EurpnJcur 1ue.r' ro repro prnoJ pelmol ere saslueld pes'el eql eleq''' etnls eqlJo unoc € l?qlJallor 'ro ,(petue;,{ue pre,ne ol &troqlnn eq} e^eq ilBqs rolerltcrre eqJ 'uollelcossv
uollelltqlv uectrotrlv aql Jo solnr eql qll^\ ecueprocce ut rorerlrqre rqt,(q p"ptrrp eq lleqs slsenbar,te,rocsrp qlr,,rl ecuet;dtuocFurpre8a'rsensslllv'ornpacotdll^!f,JosernueruroJlre3eql ,(qp"ur"no'B"qir",rr,trenocs,plly.suorlrsodep3oFur>1e1 eql pue slueuncop.ro uorlcnpo.rd 'seroleS0rrelurroJ
peDrrrlJed eq 11eqs ,{rerocsrp lrrrr; uorreooJ crqderEoeS reqro ro,(1rc e ur preq oq 11eqs Surpeecora uo,rnrilqrn eq1 .serped aq1 Sur,req pnoc ,(ue ul perelue eq {eu ,oln.,i,qrl eqt ,(q pe.repuer pre,re eql uo tueu erq?rr'^e er' sornr vvv eqJ 'uorlercossv uorl?rilqrv uecrourv eql ,(q peleSlnuord se r solnu leuorlsN aql qlr,r\ acueprocce ut pelcnpuoc eq lleqs uotlerlrqre eqJ .uorlerlrq.re 3l€JepeJ eJo uollclpsl;nf e'rtsnlcxe eqt utqlt,^^ regeru ,{uego uorrdecxe aqr qllrrr) JepuneJeq acueu:og.led s,.rosse-I .ro s,eesse.rJo lno Sutstre ensst '{ue ro'1ueue-er8y tlqtgo uo!lnulrlrJolro qceerq '.ocueuroJred-luo,tcnrrrro, ,irrpilnn :uo,1n1".,drrrur eqr .luoueer'y srql qll'n' uollceuuoc ul lo'o1 3ur1e1e'r Jo 1no Sutstre xsrerro:1uoc ro elndlp,tue ier{t ee:Be eessel pue rosso.I eq1 tb.!J711iq1" 1.91
NOIIYUIIAUY'IAX
'eEe8go61 eqlgo Bur procel pue f.le,rr 1ap, uorlncexa aq1 o1 'totrd peprocor Jooleql .'npueJouleul € pue 'porncexe uoeq peq eseoJ srql Jr pelslxe e^eq prno,r se es'eJ srql o1 lcedser tlllm s1qfi1, eules eqt o^eq lleqs e8e8po141 q"n, ;1u"*nrop qcns ul qiloJ res luorxe oqr 01 .rue^e reql u; .Burp.locor rolpup ,{.ra,rr;ep 'uotlncexe
Jo selep enllcedse'r rleql ol pre8e, lnoqlrrvr luotlrncop qcns ur quoJ res ruelxe eql o1 e6e6gol4 qcns ol .rorrd perueep eq Ileqs osee'] stql uodne'leql pue luerrlncop qcns ut quoJ les ruolxe oqr ol esee-I srql o1 e8eEgor^l qcns Furleurproqns tuounrop uellll''' eJo uouncoxe fq 'luesuoc s'oessel ulelQo ol peeu xue lnoqlr,r\:iled u1 roeroq^r ur esee-l'srqr o1 e8e8go;41 srr eleulproqns eut1fue1e,{eruee3e3uoJ^,(ue.e,roqequoJloS,(;er1uoceqtotEu,q1tue3urpue1sq1|[email protected]
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 23 of 30
lN3n33UDV 3SV3t
J'lJ 'sosrrdroluS -lJC
:rossel olJJ
er^ ro (persenbe'r rdrece.r urnler'prederd aaelsod '.r'ru solers perrun r.,illi"i,::'r:ffi::"iil;"111';:i:rT;'.XT:1fffi:ffi:; eqJ|eqSpuu3ut1tlrr,rutuent3oqlJBqSeSee']Stql.repunpe.rrnbeJSeclloupues1ueu,{ed]uaJI|V@s./l
)axe lleqs eessel pue rosso.l Jo qcee ,,(ged .raqlo eq1 ,{q lsenbe.r| ''r'urr ol eurl uo{ pue eurrl ,(ue lv Sjucutrilemrraldiq' 7.11
'selcueuet-qns ro seseelqns qcnsJo 11e ro {uego rosso.l o1 lueuu8tsse ue se eleredo ro'solcueuol-qns lo saseerqns Surlsrxe 11e ro {ue eleur.uJer.rossa-lJo uorldo aq1 1?,r'qs pue.ra3reu e )ro/Y\ lou lleqs Soereql uollellecuec lentnu e ro 'eesse'l ,(q eseal srql Jo repuerrns roqlo .ro ,(.re1un1on eq1 T5ffibfl E.1 1
ecueldecce3o eutl oql l3 qcee,q Eurpecerd qcnsgo e8pelntou>1 s,rossa-l Jo ssaJp.re8e.r ,peldecce os luex .relncrped "u,
^"4':i:l:fr j:OrnllBJ eql u?tll reqlo os€o'l sltiuo uolllpuoc lo lu?uo^oc 'Lure1 ,(ue 3o eosse'l ,,(q qcee.rq Burpaca.rd ,(ue jo renrerrr e eq ol peureep eq lou ll'qs rosso-l '{q repune'req luexJo ecueldeccu luenbesqns .q1 'f"u,n1uoc uraroq uorlrpuoc ro rueue^oc .r.urol roqlo r{ue lo erues oqlJo qc?erq luenbesqns '{uu 'ro uotllpuoc lo lueue^oc'ura1 qcnsJo Jenre/v\ e eq or peueep eq lou lluqs peureluoc uroreq uorlrpuoc ro lueuo^oc'rurel ,{ueJo uolleror^ ro qceerq xue qlrr'r uorlcouuoc u! stqSlr slr esrcrexa ol rosse.rJo eJnrreJ eq1 T5- 7.11
'me1 '(q penlured luelxe lsellnJ oql ol elq€ocroJue pue prle^ eq lleqs uorsl^ord Burureuer qceo pue,,(qe.reql pelceJJ€ eqloulleqseseolslqlJoropuleruereql'elqeecroJuaunroptle^utpleqeqlleqsesee.1srqtJouorsr^ord,{ueg1 .I1@g
1.11
SNOISIAOUd SNOANV'I-ISJSIhI'IIAX
. aassa.IJOSSaT
'uo td uot1o4tqn sI puD ,luawaatBy
aassaT puo rossaT 'TuautaatBy slt'lt olu! &ur.ta\ua (q wry arottv sr q)oa pqt $i1.tac aassaT pu, ,orru7 ,qdot*o.tod stt,l 8u11o111u1 4g
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 24 of 30
6l lo 8luossS-IJNSIA93dCV 3SV3I
':ffiIJ:j.i,JITJ11::,n:l:":il:'j";'"1::::j1'^::::::..^::':: :r!rr" uo,,ncoxs ,{1redor6 rcefqns aq, uodn pa,en,,s ssel ,(q ,rrr"ru, ̂"" "t"arr'
. u r-"-"uoue^leseJ e elnlrlsuoc lou lleqs pu? lou seop pue .,{1uo sesod.rnj uo,lnu,run*e rol oq lleus oossel ()r eqptn qrrrl rn rr^r.-rr os'or s'Iquo,{docpelncex"';";"';;;rili"';;;,:,il,*ff.#il'rl:ffi1'ji,[l':,Ti:i""^T:]:i,:'i:::i:y.T::11 r v+ verei r'rdv J6q rubrs'r rcql durpuBlsqlr.ruou .esee-r srr{r peronrlep pue pelncoxo e^eq q10q luun sesrueJd pesee-l oql ol toodseJ r{1r,4^ eosse.I pue lossoJ uoo^uoq lsrxe Jleqs slq8lr.reqlo Jo lgnlcelluoo or\r tldlJ Joqlo JO l€nlcelluoc oN __rrtr _m l l.LI
'osee.] srquo uoueurulelro/puB uotle,peuoep eq lleqs il elcluv srql repun enp suns llv .tlneJep peLseullou Jo uorlce eAucelJoc selel .por.rsd ecrlou elqecrldde aql ureesse.I 'uor1e8r1r1go ecuesqe oql ur ,peprrrord ipecueuruoc lou sr E
pes'el oql ereq/{ elels eqlJo s^1el eql '(q pau,e^o8 eq lleqsJoeroql suorsrno.rd pu€ surel oql pue esee.I srr1J ##"-r.,,"^""tgtllf.serged eq1 ,{q pauErs pue Euril.rm ur ldecxe pepueue .ro pe8ueqc .perolle eq 1ou ,{eu esee_l stqJ frAurp[b6p g.1 1
lteqlo1pueo1olaqseruedeqlJo1geUeqeqlolelnul||eqSpue":::?:ilffiHT:",',"ffl.lll,T'ffii
reqto eqt ot sluerlE,4r pue slueselde.r ,tUed qcq Ta4b.rl[ 9.1 1'ecl^resJo ol?p oql elnltlsuoc [[t^\ ect^ros retJnoc eql ,(q pecueprna se,{re,rrlapJo elep ew .1eu
lq3rureno ,(q31 'lesnJer gsnsJo olsp eql 'pesnJerJI 'to ldtecer unler ecuJo lsod selets pollun eql ,tq acueprne'se'1d,ece.rgo elep eql eq lreqs ecrlou qcns '{ue3o ect^JosJo elep eqJ 'reqlo aql ol ecrrou uelrrr^\,(q eurl ol eulr ruo.rg eleuErsep,{eru.reqlre sB ssolpp' reqro qcns ro- :euoqd
20969 n N .oueu
unoJ elnosstl^ /gtuosleHJJef :uuv
311 'ecrtsnl;enbg
pue qcaedg oerC loJ suozltlJ:eesse.I 01 JI
0069-966 (967) :euoq6z t I s6 VJ 'osof ues
pBou rlsrc.E 06tseq)rrr.uv uv :uilv
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 25 of 30
INANSAUDV 3SV3I
J'I'I .SJIISNf .IYNOS ANY HJSgds gSU.{ USNSZIIIJ :ggSSg'I
@-:es1to?l-'t :erueN luud
'pel€lsO^oqBuleroq lsr1;t ercp oql uo pelncexe eq 01 eseol Jo lueuee.rSy srr{l pesnec e^?Lr oloreq serued eql ..{ogugHA\
SSgNrr/K NI
puolxo ol popuelut lou sr pue ola.req serued oqlJo lgoueq oqlrlero qloq .slueueel8e pue s8urpuelsJopun ,suorleluese;dal loeql ueeilueq luaruaerEe olrlue oql selnltlsuoc 6oleleq peqceDl
''see'l slqlrepun pepl^o'rd se sprepuels {rlllqlssecce pel'lor-uorrcnrlsuocJo ecuurldruoc roJ serrr|qrsuodser errrlcedser s,eesse.I ro s,rosse-l lceJJp lou saop ernsolcsrp Buro8roj oqJ (dSVJ) lsrlercedg sseccv peuruef, e ,(q uortcedsur auo8:apun JON SVH eS€a]Stt{1Jepunpelu9lJopeS8e[3ureq,{gedo.rdeqt.e3pe1mouIlen1ce,.,o,,,1o171a1
ro srueuesee's1q'r.r ou pue ,urereq qilor res ,{lsse.rdxe ,, ilfi:t::Jil:[?:fTi,ff:T],i:.,t:1iffT]i;fii,"':il:::,""'l JoSuotlelueSerder,(ueop3ue^eqs,{aurojeros1ue3eS'loSSe"I,ou,o,,"1JeqlleN'l'/l
,eseor s,,,, o,ur re,ueo,^*d;;1,"1.,?rii:Jfi::ilrfi,::"ffff:3;ll:HffijrTx,j;ffix1;:1,:,1'il,x.ffi;i.T,ff: Sutlstxe pu' pezlroqlne 't1np e sl J'l-I ro uotlerodroc aw p.|t ,uni*^ipun lu'ue^oc ,{qereq seop ,gr1ue plps Jo Jleqeq uo aseo.l stql Eutlncexa suosled eqlJo qcee '(.,c.Ir,') ,'(ueduoc rllirqnli pallurll e ,o uorlnrodroc e se su8rs ,{ged reqileJI Tilfbqlil-v 71.a 1
ugINs .lJ,c :uoss3.I
eessaTolesee'I srql pere^rlep pw petncexe lcBJ ur seq rosse.I |llun ,len.relur eurl ,(ue Eurpuelsqilluou
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 26 of 30
zJo IHSrD's 008 JNsnEEucv ssvs-, ,.nor"r3i /'lJC OJ I 'ON JNg^tCNgt\tV/r^{nAf.faCAV
'Lfleap'sseulJI
"{'lnfut 'a8euep'sso1 'esuadxe'lsoc
qJns ueq^\'saslLuor6 eql ueqr;aqro,{iledo"r4 tcelqng 3qlJo Ued Aue lnoqe Jo,Lro.ur Eur.r.rno:lo fo) nrrrz.crren,,-,,, r..^r^-r
pue rosseJ s3 .|ESCCJ pu? .lJc uee^ueq tc:esee'l aql ul suorle8tlqo pue sallrJrqrsuodse.reql '-lJc ot svH)UInv r,o{ drqs;eurvro Jo roJsuerl lnJ^ul eql peurruuoc 3urne11
'oleJeLse'8102' ql8,i"y\ lnoqe ro uo pelunlceJJeplPs 'lJD ol svH)Ulhlv ruo{ parrsJsuerl,(1Jn1 e;our se) ,{l-tador4 lcelqng aql pue .sesrL
Jo alep eArlceJe oqlJo sV .,{1.rado_rd ,(trunuur
Jrr.uv Jnolv sJoumo .ror.rd uro.r3 .lJC) Jo eueu
I tou peq ,(asee1 orurrd oqt ur pouuep ,{J1n3 a.roureql .{q pelncexo se,{\ esee.I eunrd eql elep aql
;3e pue a8pelzlroulce sorupd er.{J .l
:s,{\oJJoJ se aa;Fe 1ESJCJ pue IID 'quo3
les reueuroreq suollrpuoc pue suuot aqt ot luens.rnd .gXggEUAHJ .AON
'ureraq qUoJ los elu se suotlrpuoc pue stuJel rqcns uodn puu'esee1 eullJd otll ul pouuep '{11n3 oJotu se sostuoJd pes?al ureuec osoqrJo drqsreu^o eql o1 preSe; ur oseor erurrd eqt ,(3r:e1c or errsep fESCCJ pue rJD .[ .oN runpueppv srr.{1 r,B
S'IVIIf,gU.,,,,(ye6,, e se XllenplAlpul lo,,.set1Jp4,, oql se,{lanrlJOlJoc ol paJreJel eq,{eur fgSCCJ pue'rJD 'luauee;3y
srql u|pueq raqlo srrl uo '(,,fESCJJ,,) epenell ,oueg ,r.,no3 ernossrn
LgV w petecol sseursnq jo aceld ledrcurrd sll qtl^\ .,{ueduro3 ,(illqett O"rl*,.1 epe^oN e 'Jr'I 'SJIJSnf 'rvnOE CNV HJASdS SEUC UOC SNEZITTJ pu, ,pueq auo eql uo"(,,-rJD.,) sruroJIleJ'sso1 ueS'peou qslD'E 06tw perecoJ sseursnq jo eceld ledrcur.rd sll r{l!^\.riueduo3 '(tlllqelt polltu!'I eluroJlleJ e'J-I-l 'sasluduS1NS -lJD uea,\rteq pue ,{q ,(,,1 .oN unpuappy..)
9167'-x"a .;o,{ep qrel. slqf olul paJaluo pue opeu sl ,(,,asee1 aul.r6,,) Ll1Z,_ ,,,1}0,trr6.Vpotep tuetuee;Fy aseal urerec leqt ol I
.oN tuorupueuv/unpuappv srrlJ
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 27 of 30
ZJOEHSrD'g 00t JNgr\gsuDV gsvE.r ,r"r"r:i/tJD OJ ION JNEt^tcN3r\V/nncrvEcav
IVNOE CNV HJEEdS SEUJ
:A'INO IAUOC OI SV CENOUddV
J'I'] .SESIUdU:tJN3'IJD
UOSSf,'I
J']']'EJIJSNf
UOC SNEZIIIJ
gflSSg.I
'peuorlueuls.tl;.rue,{ pue Kep aql .spueq rno les oluneraq o^ELlo^, ,COEU3HA
SSANJIA\ NI
e^rlceJJo aq rleqs Joereq urel ,{ue ," #:f:jJo Je^r?nt .lueupuorue
o11 .Burpuelsqlr,mlou ,{.ra
aql ,{.run ol pleq eq JJeqs lueutee:Be uenuM rreneu lcefqns aql ot lcedser qtlm 1ESJCJ purpuu lustuee;3e '{;ena 1o uotlerBalur elalduroc B sr uroJeq pele;od;ocur es'o.r ourrd eql Jo suorrrpuoc pue srurel 1e ql!/v\ SuoJe'J 'oN unpuappv siqJ
'r;!;;";;;r;;r;;;J .z
'luosuoc uelllJ^^ loud s,119lnoql!^\ pestuorduroc Jo par]los eq lleqs uorsrnord srqrJo qceerq e uo{ Sursre Surpued ro peuels'Jgl ,{ue Jo luouellros ou pue ..]JC ,(q 8ur1r.r,r,r, ur penordduresunos '{q pe11g1n3 eq rle.{s uorsrnord srqr ropun suorluSrlqo asueJep pue ,{lruruapur ,fESCCJ 'uolleultuJel qcns o1 'totld 3ut'uncco .Jleep Jo sseuilr 'rurelc ',tnl-uJ ,a8eurep .lue^e .lueprcce'{ue o1 lcedse', qll^ eseo'I autJd aql Jo uorleur[rrJa];o uorlerrdxe eql e^r^Jns ,eqs pue aseor erurJd eql 0l luenslnd fasccJ ,{q pel.r.rec 3q ol psJtnner to perJJec e3e;enoc ecuplnsur aqt,{q pellull oq lou llPl'.ls uollces slql Jo suolsl^o-rd aq1 ''IJc ol sesrurord pesea-I eVt pue ,(uedo.rd lceiqng eql Jo re-+suerl Je8el ur '{e1ep aq1 Jo rlnsar eqr se rurelc ,{ue ur svH)ur;41y alecrldurr Jo opnlcul o1 sldutepe '(yed p'rrqt,{ue 1ua1xe aqr ol'soesuacrl Jo searr^ur .slsen3 ,sJeluolsnc 'see,{oJdrue 'stecg.;o .slauyed ,slue8e .sluenJes ,s.ro1ce:luoc sll .fESCCJ ,{q pesneo suels'{s s'll Jo '{pedo"rd lceiqng eql ol e8euep,{ue pue eseal er.urrd eqr Jepun suorl,Brlqo s1r
3o '{ueJo qceoJq,fgSCCl ruo.r3 3ur11nsel ,{ilFqer1 pue sutelc,se3euep,sessol ,sosuedxe,slsoclre pu? '{ue lsureSe pue uo{ sseJ*req s1ua8e rreql pue ,svH)urhrv proq pue puoJop ,,{;ruruepur '1ce1o'rd ol saelSe,{11euor1lppe fasccf,'(s.ra8euer-u,{uado.rd.ro srueuel reqro.saa,{o1dua s1t ''lossel
-;o acue8rlSeu eql '{q ued ut posnec ueeq e^eq Jleqs qreep ro ssoullr .,{.lnful ,e3eurep 'sso1 'rulelc 'esuedxo '1soc qcns uaqrrt 'uot1e1,r,y 1noqt,^ ,Fu,pnlrur) seasuecrl Jo .seorrAur 'slsenB 's''eLuolsnc 'seef oldure 'sracggo 's.leuged 's1uen;es ,slolce;1uoc ,slue8e s' .oessal
Jo lcnpuocsl'u lnJlll,&\ ;o ecue8rlSau eqr {q ued ur ro eloq,{ ur posnec oq lleqs ,(tl[qell _ro ,ure1c
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 28 of 30
zJoeHSrc's 00r JNirhrs:rucv Esva'fr"r:i/.IJC OJ I
'ON JNEhICNAhIV/hINCNACCV
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 29 of 30
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Robison, Sharp, Sullivan & Brust 71 Washington St. Reno, NV 89503 (775) 329-3151
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
Pursuant to FRCP 5(b), I certify that I am an employee of Robison, Sharp,
Sullivan & Brust, and that on this date I caused to be served a true copy of
SUPPLEMENT TO JOINT STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED FACTS IN SUPPORT OF
THE PARTIES’ CROSS-MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AS TO
PLAINTIFFS’ SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT on all parties to this action by the
method(s) indicated below:
____ by placing an original or true copy thereof in a sealed envelope, with sufficient postage affixed thereto, in the United States mail at Reno, Nevada, addressed to:
RICHARD DOYLE, City Attorney NORA FRIMANN, Assistant City Attorney MARGO LASKOWSKA, Sr. Deputy City Attorney Office of the City Attorney 200 East Santa Clara Street, 16th Floor San José, California 95113-1905
X by using the Court’s CM/ECF Electronic Notification System addressed to:
RICHARD DOYLE, City Attorney NORA FRIMANN, Assistant City Attorney MARGO LASKOWSKA, Sr. Deputy City Attorney E-Mail Address: [email protected]
____ by placing an original or true copy thereof in a sealed envelope for personal delivery/hand delivery of original addressed to:
____ by facsimile (fax) addressed to: ____ by Federal Express/UPS or other overnight delivery addressed to: DATED: This 2nd day of August, 2019. /s/ Mary Carroll Davis Employee of Robison, Sharp, Sullivan & Brust
Case 5:18-cv-01919-BLF Document 61 Filed 08/02/19 Page 30 of 30