fstep webinar: beyond the funnel mentality
DESCRIPTION
Presented by Matt Dale and Jeremy Paynter on 2/6/10TRANSCRIPT
Copyright © 2008. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Beyond the Funnel Mentality: Transforming the Way Companies Engage Quality Candidates
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Agenda
Evolution and trends in recruiting A new role for Talent Acquisition Case Study: Premera The Science of Networking Leveraging the tools Q&A
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Evolution and trends in Recruiting
Recruiting has become a frantic attempt to create the largest funnel possible to manage an enormous amount of data
We are constantly in search of faster more productive recruiters
Systems are evolving in an attempt to make things easy while there are many features that are rarely used
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
The Fish Net Method
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Whale Watching
More aggressive recruiting tactics are being used in the corporate environment
Sometimes referred to as predatory recruiting
Poaching There is no value exchange,
only taking This is not a sustainable form
of networking
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Manager Involvement in the Process
Movement toward manager self service
Goal is to establish accountability for hiring
In what part of the hiring process do we really want the manager to be engaged?
Once you finish entering those requisitions, HR said we should have at least five top quality candidates to talk to in just 4 weeks!
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
The Quality Challenge
The tools and technologies offer the promise of higher quality
The speed of the competitive talent market is shortening the time we have to get to know a candidate
Assessments help, but we still do not know the true quality until after we see the person in action
Quality of hire measures can only take place post hire– Engagement survey– Manager survey, performance review– Peer review
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Stepping up to the challenge
Rather than attempting to improve the filtering process to increase the quality of the output
We should focus on putting higher quality candidates into the funnel
How?
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Building a Manager’s Network
Manager’s should be engaged in maintaining a network of talent
True networking is not aggressive
It is about establishing and leveraging relationships
There is value exchange in a relationship
A value based network becomes a sustainable source
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
A shift in thinking
Rather than building the biggest possible funnel
Establish a small network of talent to meet the hiring needs of a single manager
Create a network community by delivering value to the members
– Routine gatherings, online or in person
– Web portals for content and collaboration
– Turn acquaintances into relationships
– Engage in activities to get to know each other
Hiring people we know, increases quality
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
New Role for Talent Acquisition
Become a Talent Coach Assist the Hiring Manager in
developing and maintaining a network of ~ 20 – 35.– Identify prospects to be
introduced to the Manager– Provide the tools (e.g.
LinkedIn, Salesforce.com)– Attend industry events and
organize social events– Assist the manager maintain
periodic, systematic communication with network members
Create a Talent minded culture
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Establishing New Role for Talent Acquisition
Step I– Identify Managers who will be hiring critical talent– Determine the number of networks to be established and relative size
requirements based on hiring goals, and demographics– Establish criteria for inviting participants to the network– Educate managers on networking basics and protocol
Step II– Interview leaders who already operate as talent scouts– Determine the tools to be used for managing the information– Identify opportunities to provide relevant and meaningful content to participants
(news letters, press release, CE opportunities)– Develop a calendar of events (trade shows, ball games, association meetings,
etc.) Step III
– Establish goals for network production, number of hires and number of referrals– Identify method for data to be captured –different than source of hire– Monitor results and make adjustments
Better Health, Sustainable Costs
Talent Network Development Program
A Case Study
Better Health, Sustainable Costs
An Independent Licensee of theBlue Cross Blue Shield Association
14
About Premera• Health Benefits Provider: $3 Billion revenue, 1.7 million
members• Operations in Washington, Alaska, Oregon• 3,000 Employees, 6 recruiters• Our hiring includes IT, Nurses, Actuaries, Customer Service
& more• Our Business Environment
– Economic Pressures
– Industry Changes - Health Care Reform on the Horizon
– New Business Strategy
– Importance of Talent as Critical to Business Success
Better Health, Sustainable Costs
An Independent Licensee of theBlue Cross Blue Shield Association
15
Our Challenge: engage managers and create a more agile sourcing strategy
• Shift mindset from posting to sourcing • Use resources efficiently – more resumes doesn’t equal
better candidates• “Sourcing is Recruiting’s Job”• Need for flexibility and scalability• Build manager ownership and accountability for talent
Better Health, Sustainable Costs
An Independent Licensee of theBlue Cross Blue Shield Association
16
Innovative and simple approach• Objectives
– Improve manager attitude towards networking
– Increase manager ownership and accountability
– Build networks with capability to produce viable candidates
– Get better candidates into the pipeline to generate quality hires
• Talent Network Development Program Elements– Recruiters were “Talent Coaches” - provided 1:1 support, tools and
resources
– Piloted process across the business
– Established small, effective networks of talent to meet needs of a single manager
– Networking efforts focused on exchange of value vs. a specific recruiting effort
– Used surveys to measure results
Better Health, Sustainable Costs
An Independent Licensee of theBlue Cross Blue Shield Association
17
It worked!
• Program Results: – 30% improvement in attitudes towards effectiveness of
networking skills – 40% improvement in ratings of the value of networking as very
important or essential to managers’ professional success– 50% improvement in usage of online networking tools – 50% improvement in leveraging network for non-recruiting
purposes– 80% of respondents rated support from their Talent Coach as
very or extremely important– 100% of respondents are more comfortable with networking and
plan to take action to build their network
Better Health, Sustainable Costs
An Independent Licensee of theBlue Cross Blue Shield Association
18
And, managers liked it…
• Feedback:
“I think this is a great focus. Many people struggle in this area and I believe it has huge opportunity.”
“Recommend this to all managers. Tips provided by Recruiting Partner were invaluable.”
Better Health, Sustainable Costs
An Independent Licensee of theBlue Cross Blue Shield Association
19
What we learned
• Don’t apologize for asking managers to network – instead, make it part of “How we do things here” and our partnership
• Build simple, online tools. Example: “Linkedin Tip Sheet”• Teach them how. Example: “Getting Great Talent” workshop• Peer Pressure works. Recruiters recognize managers who do
it well• Difficult to measure ROI right away, it’s a shift in thinking
and takes time• Share the results you do have, early and often to build
adoption
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Taking it to the next level
It is widely accepted that the stronger the network the better results
How do we measure the strength of a person’s network today?– Number of entries in the rolodex– Contacts in the outlook folder– Number of connections on Linked-in
Anecdotal references– “She is really well connected”– “He knows everyone and their brother”
What if we apply the principles of Network Theory?
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Network Analysis
Closed NetworkOpen Network
Group 1
Group 2
Group 3
Group 4
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Filling structural holes
Group 1
Group 2
Group 3
Group 4
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Position in Network
The McKinsey Quarterly: Harnessing the power of informal employee networks, 2007
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Social Capital
"refers to the collective value of all 'social networks' and the inclinations that arise from these networks to do things for each other“
social capital can be measured by the amount of trust and "reciprocity" in a community or between individuals
Robert D. Putnam, Bowling Alone
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Software Enabled Analysis is Coming
www.touchgraph.com
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Visualizing the Network
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Twitalyzer
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Custom Private Community Portal
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Final comments
The tools are changing – we need to change the way we use them
Establishing value based networks is a sustainable source of quality candidates
Managers must participate in the networking to create the quality
Different model for investment of recruiting budget; Be selective in the application, where does it make the most sense
Measure, measure, measure
Copyright © 2010. Korn/Ferry International and Korn/Ferry International Futurestep, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
.
ACHIEVE TALENTMANAGEMENT SUCCESS
Thank you!
Matt Dale
Head of Consulting Australia
Jeremy Paynter
Head of Consulting New Zealand